Canada's federal cabinet: Abortion discussions, 1988-1990

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/22/2019 Canada's federal cabinet: Abortion discussions, 1988-1990

    1/83

    0

    C`fblit Kiitblas, Ntt`w`, 0244-02278 Mbscussbnls ne @fnrtbnl

    Lnti8 ]disi `ri `jj tdi C`l`mb`l c`fblit mbscussbnls dijm nl tdi tnpbc ne `fnrtbnl bl tdi yi`rs

    0244 tn 0227, riji`sim ulmir ky@cciss tn Blenrk`tbnl @ct riquists. Fijnw bs ` ricnrm B d`vi

    cnkpbjim ernk tdi c`fblit kblutis (`lm f`coarnulm p`pirs), wdbcd B d`vi sc`llim `lm ri-

    enrk`ttim enr i`sbir ri`m`fbjbty. B d`vi `mmim sivir`j ixpj`l`tnry lntis bl squ`ri fr`coits. ]di

    c`fblit p`pirs bl tdibr nrbabl`j enrk`ttbla `ri `v`bj`fji upnl riquist ernk tdi Wrbvy Cnulcbj

    Neebci bl Ntt`w`.

    ]di@]B @ct `jjnws tdi pufjbc tn vbiw c`fblit kblutis nljy `etir 67 yi`rs d`vi p`ssim. Rit k`ly

    jblis ne tdi kblutis `ri stbjj fibla wbtddijm, knstjy ulmir@]B @ct sictbnl 63 (snjbcbtnr-cjbilt

    prbvbjiai, wdbcd bs `l ixikptbnl wbtd ln tbki jbkbt).

    Hnurl`jbst St`ljiy ]rnkp, 6703.

    st`ljiytrnkpGak`bj.cnk / dttp8//www3.tijus.lit/blmix077/enb

    ;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;

    SICVI]

    ]dbs mncukilt bs tdi Wrnpirty ne tdi Anvirlkilt ne C`l`m`. Bt bs enr Kblbstirs iyis nljy.

    Sirb`j # 0-44 CFK

    C`fblit Kblutis

    @ kiitbla ne tdi C`fblit w`s dijm bl Vnnk 363-S, Dnusi ne Cnkknls, nl ]dursm`y,

    H`lu`ry 64, 0244 `t 2837 `.k.

    @fnrtbnl

    (V - 270.6 - 44M0)

    0. tdiri d`s fiil ` rujbla _H`l. 64, 0244[ fy tdi Supriki Cnurt nl tdi cnlstbtutbnl`jbty ne

    Sictbnl 690 ne tdi Crbkbl`j Cnmi?

    6. tdi Wrbki Kblbstir _Vt. Dnlnur`fji Frb`l Kujrnliy[ ri`m `jnum tdi Supriki Cnurtmicbsbnl wdbcd st`tim td`t Sictbnl 690 ne tdi Crbkbl`j Cnmibltireiris wbtd wnkils rbadts?

    3. tdi Kblbstir ne Hustbci _Dnl. V`y Dl`tysdyl[ ixpj`blim td`t tdi Cnurt d`s rujim td`t

    Sictbnl 690 bs lnl-cnlstbtutbnl`j. Qdil quistbnlim, tdi Kblbstir wbjj rieir tn tdi micbsbnl `s `l

    bkpnrt`lt nli wdbcd wbjj liim tn fi cnlsbmirim c`rieujjy?

  • 7/22/2019 Canada's federal cabinet: Abortion discussions, 1988-1990

    2/83

    6

    =. Kblbstirs lntim tdi bkpjbc`tbnls enr tdi Cd`rtir ne Vbadts`lm tdi knvikilt ne C`l`mb`l

    hurbsprumilci tnw`rms tdi Y.S. styji ne jiabsj`tbla tdrnuad tdi humbcb`ry? `lm

    9. Kblbstirs lntim tdi bkpnrt`lci ne lnt prnlnulcbla nl tdi bssui, ne `vnbmbla prnkbsis nr

    ne pufjbcjy mbscussbla nptbnls.

    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

    Sirb`j #3-44 CKWW

    ]di C`fblit Cnkkbttii nl Wrbnrbtbis `lm Wj`llbla

    Kblutis

    @ kiitbla ne tdi C`fblit Cnkkbttii nl Wrbnrbtbis `lm Wj`llbla w`s dijm bl Vnnk 363-S,

    Dnusi ne Cnkknls, nl ]uism`y, Eifru`ry 6, 0244 `t 2837 `.k.

    @fnrtbnl

    (6-2027-44M0)

    ]di Wrbki Kblbstir snuadt tdi vbiws ne Kblbstirs nl nptbnls enr mi`jbla wbtd tdi

    Supriki Cnurt micbsbnl td`t struco mnwl tdi `fnrtbnl j`w. Di blmbc`tim td`t di d`m jbkbtim dbs

    nwl pufjbc cnkkilts tn tdi e`ct td`t tdi Supriki Cnurt w`s tdi ujtbk`ti `rfbtir ne j`w bl

    C`l`m`, td`t bts micbsbnls wnujm fi rispictim fy tdi Anvirlkilt, `lm td`t di wnujm ri`m tdi

    humakilt `lm riejict nl bt.

    ]di Kblbstir ne Hustbci _Dnl. V`y Dl`tysdyl[ st`tim td`t tdi mbrict cnlsiquilci ne tdi

    humakilt w`s td`t tdiri w`s ln j`w anvirlbla `fnrtbnl. Wrn-jbei arnups wiri tdi knst neeilmim

    fy tdi humakilt, `lm wiri jnnobla tn tdi Anvirlkilt enr ` liw j`w. Qnkils arnups vbiwim

    tdi humakilt `s ` vbctnry. Sdnujm tdi Anvirlkilt micbmi tn jiabsj`ti, viry c`rieuj mr`etbla

    wnujm fi riqubrim tn t`oi `ccnult ne tdi vbiws prisiltim bl tdi humakilt.

    ]di Kblbstir blmbc`tim td`t, enjjnwbla tdi humakilt, di d`m wrbttil dbs prnvblcb`j

    cnultirp`rts prnpnsbla ` kiitbla ne Miputy Kblbstirs ne Hustbci nl Eifru`ry 07 tn 06 tn

    cnlsbmir tdi sbtu`tbnl. Bl tdi bltirbk, di d`m rivbiwim tdi jia`j bkpjbc`tbnls wbtd tdi Kblbstir

    Vispnlsbfji enr Qnkil, tdi Kblbstir ne L`tbnl`j Di`jtd `lm Qije`ri `lm tdi Kblbstir ne St`ti

    (Eimir`j-prnvblcb`j Vij`tbnls). Ebvi nptbnls wiri mbscussim8 t`oi ln `ctbnl? liw Crbkbl`j Cnmi

    jiabsj`tbnl? usi ne tdi C`l`m` Di`jtd @ct? usi ne tdi nvirrbmi prnvbsbnl ne tdi Cd`rtir ne Vbadts

    `lm Eriimnks? `lm rivbiw ne tdi bssui fy ` Vny`j Cnkkbssbnl nr ` W`rjb`kilt`ry Cnkkbttii.

    ]di j`st twn nptbnls wiri rihictim? wnro nl tdi ntdirs wnujm cnltblui wbtd ikpd`sbs nl

    jiabsj`tbvi nptbnls. Bl tdi bltirbk bt w`s bkpnrt`lt td`t Kblbstirs `lm kikfirs ne C`ucus lnt

    pj`ci tdiksijvis bl pnsbtbnls td`t wnujm cnkprnkbsi tdi Anvirlkilts nptbnls.

  • 7/22/2019 Canada's federal cabinet: Abortion discussions, 1988-1990

    3/83

    3

    ]di Kblbstir Vispnlsbfji enr tdi St`tus ne Qnkil _Dnl. F`rf`r` KcMnua`jj[ lntim td`t

    tdi bssui w`s ` micbsbvi nli enr wnkil. ]diy mbm lnt, nl f`j`lci, vbiw tdi humakilt `s `

    vbctnry. V`tdir, tdiri w`s ` silsi ne rijbie td`t tdi knst ristrbctbvi ijikilts ne tdi j`w d`m fiil

    struco mnwl. ]di pr`ctbc`j cnlcirl w`s td`t tdiri w`s ln jia`j mieblbtbnl ne tdi tbki er`ki bl

    wdbcd `l `fnrtbnl cnujm fi pirenrkim.

    ]di Kblbstir ne L`tbnl`j Di`jtd `lm Qije`ri _Dnl. H`oi Ipp[ s`bm td`t tdi st`tus ne tdi

    eitus w`s `l npil quistbnl ivil bl tdi c`si ne kimbc`j liajbailci. Di lntim td`t `jtdnuad tdi

    humakilt w`s sbjilt nl tdi C`l`m` Di`jtd @ct, bt w`s fibla bltirpritim bl jbadt ne tdi @cts

    cnkpridilsbviliss `lm `ccissbfbjbty prnvbsbnls `s ` riqubrikilt tn eulm `fnrtbnl nl mik`lm.

    ]di @ct riqubrim tdi Kblbstir tn t`oi cirt`bl stips be bts prnvbsbnls wiri vbnj`tim, sucd `s

    lntbebc`tbnl ne tdi prnvblcb`j anvirlkilt `lm ujtbk`tijy wbtddnjmbla ne eulmbla.

    ]di Wrbki Kblbstir mbrictim td`t tdi arnup ne Kblbstirs rivbiwbla tdi bssui fi

    enrk`jbzim, `lm ixtilmim tn blcjumi Kki Uizbl` _Dnl. Knlbqui Uizbl`, Kblbstir ne St`ti enr

    ]r`lspnrt[ `lm Kr. Fnucd`rm _Dnl. Jucbil Fnucd`rm, Kblbstir ne St`ti enr tdi Ilvbrnlkilt[.Ntdir Kblbstirs wiri erii tn p`rtbcbp`ti be tdiy sn misbrim. Di s`bm td`t tdi arnup sdnujm abvi

    bkkimb`ti cnlsbmir`tbnl tn tdi quistbnl ne wd`t tdi Anvirlkilt sdnujm s`y tn wnkil wdn wiri

    prial`lt `lm siiobla `cciss tn sirvbcis. ]di arnup sdnujm tdil ulmirt`oi ` rivbiw ne `fnrtbnl

    j`ws bl ntdir hurbsmbctbnls tn mitirkbli wditdir tdiy prnvbmi ` knmij enr ` liw C`l`mb`l j`w,

    ricnalbzbla td`t tdi Supriki Cnurt sbal`jim td`t tdi rbadts ne tdi eitus sdnujm fi ix`kblim.

    ]di Miputy Kblbstir ne Hustbci st`tim td`t tdi Supriki Cnurt wnujm di`r tdiFnrnwsob

    c`si nl tdi rbadts ne tdi eitus bl tdi cnursi ne tdi yi`r. Abvil tdiKnrailt`jirhumakilt,

    dnwivir, tdiy kbadt mitirkbli td`t tdi c`si ln jnlair liimim tn fi micbmim.

    ]di Wrbki Kblbstir cnlcjumim tdi mbscussbnl fy blmbc`tbla td`t ` erii vnti wnujm

    ujtbk`tijy fi riqubrim nl tdi bssui. Di w`s pirsnl`jjy bkprissim wbtd tdi s`lctbty ne jbei

    `raukilts, fut wnujm lnt `ttikpt tn bkpnsi dbs vbiws nl ntdir Kikfirs.

    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

    Sirb`j #=-44 CKWW

    ]di C`fblit Cnkkbttii nl Wrbnrbtbis `lm Wj`llbla

    Kblutis

    @ kiitbla ne tdi C`fblit Cnkkbttii nl Wrbnrbtbis `lm Wj`llbla w`s dijm bl Vnnk 363-S,

    Dnusi ne Cnkknls, nl ]uism`y, Eifru`ry 2, 0244 `t 2837 `.k.

    Ailir`j Mbscussbnl8

    Supriki Cnurt Vujbla - @fnrtbnl

  • 7/22/2019 Canada's federal cabinet: Abortion discussions, 1988-1990

    4/83

    =

    (1-7717-44VM (70) (LSM))

    ]di Anvirlkilt Ji`mir bl tdi Sil`ti _Sil. Jnwijj Kurr`y[ ripnrtim nl tdi risujts ne

    mijbfir`tbnls ulmirt`oil fy tdi @m Dnc Cnkkbttii ix`kblbla rispnlsis tn tdi ricilt Supriki

    Cnurt micbsbnl nl `fnrtbnl. Di k`mi tdi enjjnwbla pnblts8

    0) pufjbc npblbnl w`s lnt `t ibtdir ixtriki? tdi k`hnrbty ne pinpji cnujm suppnrt `fnrtbnl

    ulmir snki cbrcukst`lcis fut tdiri w`s ln cnlsilsus nl wd`t tdi cnlmbtbnls sdnujm fi?

    6) tdi @m Dnc Cnkkbttii w`s lnt bl e`vnur ne ist`fjbsdbla ` Vny`j Cnkkbssbnl tn cnlsbmir

    fntd `fnrtbnl bssuis `s wijj `s bssuis rispictbla riprnmuctbvi ticdlnjnay? `lm

    3) tdi Cnkkbttii mbm suppnrt ` pufjbc st`tikilt wdbcd wnujm blmbc`ti tdi Anvirlkilts

    bltiltbnl tn jiabsj`ti, ricnalbzbla td`t C`l`m` curriltjy w`s `jnli `knla tdi blmustrb`jbzim

    cnultrbis bl d`vbla ln j`w mi`jbla wbtd `fnrtbnl.

    Murbla tdi ilsubla mbscussbnl, tdi enjjnwbla pnblts wiri k`mi8

    0) tdi Anvirlkilt sdnujm risbst usbla tdi lntwbtdst`lmbla cj`usi bl tdi cnlstbtutbnl,

    mispbti prissuri tn mn sn ernk cirt`bl c`ucus kikfirs?

    6) tdi C`l`m` Di`jtd @ctmbm lnt prnvbmi tdi Anvirlkilt wbtd tdi pnwir tn tijj tdi

    prnvblcis td`t tdiy d`m tn p`y enr `fnrtbnls?

    3)

    : 9 jblis wbtddijm ulmir @]B @ct sic. 0=, eimir`j-prnvblcb`j `ee`brs (Visnjutbnl 0)

    NV

    Mn Kblbstirs suppnrt knmir`tijy ristrbctbvi jiabsj`tbnl f`sim nl enit`j mivijnpkilt wdbcd, bl

    tdi ebrst st`ais ne prial`lcy, pirkbts `fnrtbnl pirenrkim fy ` mnctnr f`sim nl ` wnk`ls

    micbsbnl, `lm, bl tdi j`tir st`ais, pirkbts `fnrtbnl nljy wdil tdi jbei nr di`jtd ne tdi wnk`l bs

    tdri`tilim> (Visnjutbnl 6)

    DNYSI S]V@]IAR

    Sdnujm tdi anvirlkilt bltrnmuci ` risnjutbnl bl tdi Dnusi nl `fnrtbnl jiabsj`tbnl `lm tdil

    bltrnmuci anvirlkilt jiabsj`tbnl f`sim nl tdi nutcnki ne tdi vnti>

    NV

    Sdnujm tdi anvirlkilt bltrnmuci ` risnjutbnl bl tdi Dnusi nl `fnrtbnl jiabsj`tbnl `lm ist`fjbsd

    ` spicb`j cnkkbttii tn mr`et `lm ricnkkilm jiabsj`tbnl tn tdi Dnusi>

    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

    Sirb`j #4-44 CKWW

    ]di C`fblit Cnkkbttii nl Wrbnrbtbis `lm Wj`llbla

    Kblutis

    @ kiitbla ne tdi C`fblit Cnkkbttii nl Wrbnrbtbis `lm Wj`llbla w`s dijm bl Vnnk 363-S,

    Dnusi ne Cnkknls, nl ]uism`y, K`rcd 66, 0244 `t 2837 `.k.

  • 7/22/2019 Canada's federal cabinet: Abortion discussions, 1988-1990

    25/83

    69

    @fnrtbnl

    (5-2732-44MB)

    ]di Kblbstir ne St`ti (Eimir`j-Wrnvblcb`j Vij`tbnls) _Sil. Jnwijj Kurr`y[ rivbiwim tdi

    privbnus wiios C`fblit `lm c`ucus mbscussbnls nl `fnrtbnl `lm nutjblim tdi prnciss `di`m. Diripnrtim td`t tdiri d`m fiil ` annm mbscussbnl `t c`ucus, `jtdnuad ln prnariss d`m fiil k`mi

    tnw`rms ` cnlsilsus nl quistbnls ne sufst`lci. Dnwivir, tdiri d`m fiil cnlsilsus nl prnciss8 `

    erii vnti nl ` risnjutbnl wbtd pnjbcy cnltilt, tn fi enjjnwim fy ` Anvirlkilt fbjj. Di lntim td`t

    tdiri cnujm lnt fi ` erii vnti nl ` Anvirlkilt fbjj.

    ]di Kblbstir ne St`ti (Eimir`j-Wrnvblcb`j Vij`tbnls) ixpj`blim td`t tdiri wiri nljy twn

    f`sbc sufst`ltbvi nptbnls8 `l `pprn`cd f`sim nl aist`tbnl`j mivijnpkilt nr ` lnl-aist`tbnl`j

    `pprn`cd. @ mr`et risnjutbnl cnvirbla i`cd `pprn`cd d`m fiil mbscussim `t C`fblit nl K`rcd 01.

    Cnlcirls d`m fiil ixprissim wbtd fntd. Enjjnwbla tdi C`fblit kiitbla, di d`m `soim td`t

    rivbsim risnjutbnls fi prip`rim? spicbebc`jjy, ` Cd`rtir-prnne risnjutbnl f`sim nl tdi lnl-aist`tbnl`j `pprn`cd `lm ` knri ristrbctbvi risnjutbnl f`sim nl tdi aist`tbnl`j `pprn`cd. Di

    pnbltim nut, dnwivir, td`t tdi enrkir wnujm fi ` pirkbssbvi risnjutbnl wdbji tdi j`ttir wnujm rul

    tdi rbso ne fibla miei`tim fy ` cnkfbl`tbnl ne ixtrikbsts nl fntd sbmis ne tdi quistbnl.

    Di ixpj`blim td`t `fnrtbnl wnujm fi mbscussim `t ` kiitbla ne Kblbstirs cd`brim fy tdi

    Miputy Wrbki Kblbstir _Dnl. Mnl K`z`lonwsob[ bkkimb`tijy enjjnwbla Wrbnrbtbis `lm Wj`llbla

    `lm sufsiquiltjy `t c`ucus `lm C`fblit nl K`rcd 63 `lm 6= rispictbvijy. Ebl`jjy, di lntim td`t

    tdi Anvirlkilt wnujm fi `fji tn risnjvi tdi k`ttir nljy be cnlsilsus cnujm fi `cdbivim.

    ]di Wrbki Kblbstir ixprissim dbs dnpi td`t ebl`j micbsbnls cnujm fi t`oil `t C`fblit nl

    K`rcd 6=.

    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

    Sirb`j #5-44 CFK

    C`fblit Kblutis

    @ kiitbla ne tdi C`fblit w`s dijm bl Vnnk 363-S, Dnusi ne Cnkknls, nl ]dursm`y,

    K`rcd 6=, 0244 `t 2837 `.k.

    @fnrtbnl

    (B-27=3- 44M0)

    ]di Wrbki Kblbstir lntim td`t di w`s di`rbla, `s ` risujt ne yistirm`ys C`ucus

    mbscussbnl ne `fnrtbnl, td`t snki Kikfirs eijt td`t tdi anvirlkilt sdnujm fi prnvbmbla knri

    mbrictbnl tn C`ucus `lm td`t tdiy wiri ixpictbla snkitdbla fittir misbalim ernk tdi

    anvirlkilt. Bt w`s cji`r td`t cnlsilsus wnujm fi mbeebcujt tn `cdbivi. Bl rispnlmbla, tdi Miputy

  • 7/22/2019 Canada's federal cabinet: Abortion discussions, 1988-1990

    26/83

    65

    Wrbki Kblbstir _Dnl. Mnl K`z`lonwsob[ lntim td`t tdi mbscussbnls yistirm`y bl C`ucus d`m lnt

    anli `s wijj `s dnpim `lm td`t bl snki rispicts tdi anvirlkilt w`s sjbmbla f`co bl tirks ne

    k`l`abla tdi bssui. Snki Kikfirs ne C`ucus wiri `er`bm td`t nptbnls wiri fibla sdnvim mnwl

    tdibr tdrn`ts `lm td`t tdiri d`m lnt fiil sueebcbilt tbki mivntim tn mbscussbnl ne tdbs bssui bl

    C`ucus.

    ]di Ji`mir ne tdi Anvirlkilt bl tdi Sil`ti `lm Kblbstir ne St`ti (Eimir`j-Wrnvblcb`j

    Vij`tbnls) _Sil. Jnwijj Kurr`y[, `s Cd`brk`l ne tdi @m Dnc Cnkkbttii nl @fnrtbnl, k`mi tdi

    enjjnwbla pnblts8

    0. sblci mbscussbla tdbs bssui bl C`fblit j`st wiio, ` arnup ne Kblbstirs d`m kit `lm `mmim

    twn liw risnjutbnls tn tdi twn privbnusjy mbscussim fy C`fblit (cnpy ne pri`kfji `lm

    risnjutbnls `tt`cdim). ]diy d`m prnvbmim ` v`rb`tbnl ne risnjutbnl twn `lm tnuadilim bt up ` jbttji

    fbt bl tdi dnpi td`t bt wnujm sijj fittir, `lm tdiy d`m prnmucim ` liw risnjutbnl nli wdbcd tdiy

    lnw fijbivim wnujm fi Cd`rtirprnne. @s wijj, tdiy d`m risd`pim tdi pri`kfji?

    6. ulenrtul`tijy, tdiri d`m lnt fiil sueebcbilt tbki tn ixpj`bl tn C`ucus tdi mivijnpkilt ne

    tdi v`rbnus risnjutbnls sblci tdiy d`m mbscussim tdbs bssui ` cnupji ne wiios i`rjbir.

    Bl tdi sufsiquilt mbscussbnl, tdi enjjnwbla pnblts wiri k`mi8

    0. ` lukfir ne C`ucus Kikfirs wiri viry bltiristim bl ilsurbla td`t tdiy wnujm d`vi `

    risnjutbnl td`t w`s st`ulcdjy prn-jbei nl wdbcd tdiy wnujm d`vi `l nppnrtulbty tn vnti, fut tdbs

    kbadt ki`l tdi licissbty ne ` lukfir ne risnjutbnls fibla bltrnmucim nl tdi ejnnr ne tdi Dnusi?

    6. bt w`s suaaistim td`t be tdbs prncimuri wiri tn fi enjjnwim, bt wnujm fi ` enrkuj` enr

    k`xbkuk ikf`rr`sskilt `s bt wnujm ki`l td`t kbmmji-ne-tdi-rn`mirs wnujm fi enrcim tn vnti`a`blst tdi cj`ssbc rbadt-tn-jbei pnsbtbnl. Bt w`s `jsn lntim td`t vntbla nl ` cj`ssbc rbadt-tn-jbei

    pnsbtbnl w`s lnt pnssbfji fic`usi bt w`s nutj`wim fy tdi Supriki Cnurt?

    3. bl rispnlsi tn ` quistbnl `s tn wditdir nr lnt tdiri w`s ` fittir prncimuri td`l `

    risnjutbnl bl tdi Dnusi enjjnwim fy jiabsj`tbnl, bt w`s lntim td`t tdi Anvirlkilt cnujm prnciim

    wbtd ` Fbjj fut td`t wnujm d`vi k`mi bt viry mbeebcujt tn abvi Kblbstirs tdi eriimnk tn vnti tdibr

    cnlscbilci nl tdbs bssui?

    =. bt w`s suaaistim td`t be tdi prn-jbeirs wiri anbla tn d`vi `l nppnrtulbty tn vnti nl tdibr

    risnjutbnl, ntdir Kblbstirs wnujm wbsd tdi rbadt tn vnti nl ` puri prn-cdnbci risnjutbnl wdbcd

    w`s lnt risnjutbnl twn. ]d`t ki`lt td`t tdiri k`y fi ` liim enr `t ji`st tdrii risnjutbnls bl tdi

    Dnusi.

    9. snki Kblbstirs suaaistim td`t bt wnujm fi misbr`fji prbnr tn tdi lixt mbscussbnl bl C`ucus

    td`t nutsbmi jia`j npblbnl fi snuadt tn virbey tdi cnlstbtutbnl`j `ccipt`fbjbty ne tdi v`rbnus

    risnjutbnls.

  • 7/22/2019 Canada's federal cabinet: Abortion discussions, 1988-1990

    27/83

    61

    Bl sukk`rbzbla tdi mbscussbnl, tdi Wrbki Kblbstir k`mi tdi enjjnwbla cnkkilts8

    0. fienri tdbs w`s ebl`jbzim, tdi anvirlkilt liimim tn ilsuri td`t bt oliw dnw k`ly vntis

    bt wnujm d`vi enr bts prieirrim `pprn`cd?

    6. tdi anvirlkilt cnujm lnt `eenrm tn k`oi ` kbst`oi nlci bt wilt mnwl tdi rn`m nerisnjutbnl `lm jiabsj`tbnl?

    3. wd`tivir tbki w`s liciss`ry tn ait bt rbadt sdnujm fi t`oil?

    =. di `ariim td`t Kblbstirs kust vnti eriijy nl tdi risnjutbnl fut lntim td`t tdi j`st tdbla tdi

    anvirlkilt w`ltim tn mn w`s tn p`ss snkitdbla wdbcd tdi Supriki Cnurt wnujm tdrnw nut?

    9. tdi anvirlkilt kust fi siil tn d`vi ` ri`snl`fji `pprn`cd `lm td`t C`ucus suppnrtim bt,

    lntbla td`t tdi Nppnsbtbnl wnujm mn `jj tdiy cnujm tn scuttji tdi anvirlkilt `pprn`cd?

    5. di lntim td`t tdi Cnlsilsus ne C`fblit siikim tn fi nl risnjutbnl twn (F).

    WVI@KFJI

    ]d`t, wdiri`s tdi Supriki Cnurt ne C`l`m` d`s micj`rim td`t tdi prnvbsbnls ne tdiCrbkbl`j

    Cnmirij`tbla tn `fnrtbnl `ri blcnlsbstilt wbtd tdi prnvbsbnls ne tdi C`l`mb`lCd`rtir ne Vbadts

    `lm Eriimnks`lm `ri tdirienri ne ln enrci nr ieeict?

    @lm, wdiri`s ` liw il`ctkilt tn t`oi tdi pj`ci ne tdi s`bm prnvbsbnls kust fi cnlsbstilt wbtd

    tdi Cnlstbtutbnl ne C`l`m` blcjumbla tdiCd`rtir ne Vbadts `lm Eriimnkstdiribl?

    @lm, wdiri`s tdbs Dnusi misbris tn il`ct liw prnvbsbnls wdbcd riejict tdi eulm`kilt`j v`jui

    `lm bldirilt mbalbty ne i`cd duk`l fibla `lm tdi bldirilt wnrtd ne duk`l jbei?

    @lm, wdiri`s sucd liw prnvbsbnls kust `cdbivi `l iqubt`fji f`j`lci fitwiil tdi rbadt ne `

    wnk`l tn jbfirty `lm sicurbty ne dir pirsnl `lm tdi rbadt ne sncbity tn prntict tdi ulfnrl?

    Fi bt tdirienri, `mnptim8

    Visnjutbnl 0@ (Lnl-aist`tbnl`j @pprn`cd)

    ]d`t tdbs Dnusi suppnrts, bl prblcbpji, tdi bltrnmuctbnl ne jiabsj`tbnl td`t wnujm8

    (0) prndbfbt tdi pirenrk`lci ne `l `fnrtbnl?

    (6) prnvbmi enr `l ixciptbnl tn tdbs prndbfbtbnl wdiri twn qu`jbebim kimbc`j pr`ctbtbnlirs

    d`vi, bl annm e`btd `lm nl ri`snl`fji arnulms, fy cirtbebc`ti bl wrbtbla, st`tim td`t bl tdibr

    npblbnl tdi cnltblu`tbnl ne tdi prial`lcy wnujm nr wnujm fi jboijy tn ilm`lair tdi jbei ne tdi

    prial`lt wnk`l nr sirbnusjy `lm sufst`ltb`jjy ilm`lair dir di`jtd, `lm td`t tdiri bs ln ntdir

    cnkknljy `cciptim kimbc`j prncimuri enr ieeictbvijy tri`tbla tdbs di`jtd rbso. (]disi arnulms

    mn lnt blcjumi tdi striss nr `lxbity wdbcd k`y `ccnkp`ly `l ulixpictim nr ulw`ltim

    prial`lcy, nr sncb`j nr icnlnkbc cnlsbmir`tbnls?) `lm

  • 7/22/2019 Canada's federal cabinet: Abortion discussions, 1988-1990

    28/83

    64

    (3) ixcjumi pdysbc`j nr kilt`j `flnrk`jbtbis ne tdi ulfnrl cdbjm `s ` ri`snl enr nft`blbla `l

    `fnrtbnl.

    Visnjutbnl 0F (Lnl-aist`tbnl`j, Kblbk`j Cd`rtirVbso @pprn`cd)

    ]d`t tdbs Dnusi suppnrts, bl prblcbpji, tdi il`ctkilt ne jiabsj`tbnl td`t wnujm prndbfbt tdi

    pirenrk`lci ne `l `fnrtbnl sufhict tn tdi enjjnwbla ixciptbnl?

    (b) ` qu`jbebim kimbc`j pr`ctbtbnlir bs ne tdi npblbnl td`t tdi cnltblu`tbnl ne tdi

    prial`lcy ne ` wnk`l wnujm nr wnujm fi jboijy tn tdri`til dir pdysbc`j nr kilt`j wijj-

    fibla?

    (bb) tdi wnk`l bl cnlsujt`tbnl wbtd ` qu`jbebim kimbc`j pr`ctbtbnlir micbmis tn

    tirkbl`ti dir prial`lcy? `lm,

    (bbb) tdi tirkbl`tbnl ne tdi prial`lcy bs pirenrkim fy ` qu`jbebim kimbc`j pr`ctbtbnlir.

    Visnjutbnl 6 (Aist`tbnl`j @pprn`cd)

    ]d`t tdbs Dnusi suppnrts, bl prblcbpji, tdi bltrnmuctbnl ne jiabsj`tbnl td`t wnujm prndbfbt tdi

    pirenrk`lci ne `l `fnrtbnl sufhict tn tdi enjjnwbla ixciptbnls8

    (`) murbla tdi i`rjbir st`ais ne prial`lcy, ` wnk`l bl cnlsujt`tbnl wbtd dir pdysbcb`l

    micbmis tn tirkbl`ti dir prial`lcy `lm tdi tirkbl`tbnl bs pirenrkim fy ` qu`jbebim kimbc`j

    pr`ctbtbnlir, `lm

    (f) murbla tdi sufsiquilt st`ais ne prial`lcy, tdi tirkbl`tbnl ne tdi prial`lcy s`tbsebis

    lnt nljy tdi cnlmbtbnls miscrbfim bl p`r`ar`pd (`) fut `jsn eurtdir cnlmbtbnls, blcjumbla `

    cnlmbtbnl td`t `etir ` cirt`bl hnblt bl tbki tdi tirkbl`tbnl wnujm nljy fi pirkbttim wdiri tdi

    cnltblu`tbnl ne tdi prial`lcy wnujm nr wnujm fi jboijy tn ilm`lair tdi wnk`ls jbei nr tnsirbnusjy ilm`lair dir di`jtd.

    Visnjutbnl 6F (Knri Vistrbctbvi Aist`tbnl`j @pprn`cd)

    ]d`t tdbs Dnusi suppnrts, bl prblcbpji, tdi il`ctkilt ne jiabsj`tbnl td`t wnujm prndbfbt tdi

    pirenrk`lci ne `l `fnrtbnl sufhict tn tdi enjjnwbla ixciptbnls8

    (`) murbla tdi i`rjbir st`ais ne prial`lcy, ` qu`jbebim kimbc`j pr`ctbtbnlir bs ne tdi npblbnl

    td`t tdi cnltblu`tbnl ne tdi prial`lcy ne ` wnk`l wnujm nr wnujm fi jboijy tn tdri`til dir

    pdysbc`j nr kilt`j wijj fibla? tdi wnk`l bl cnlsujt`tbnl wbtd ` qu`jbebim kimbc`j pr`ctbtbnlir

    micbmis tn tirkbl`ti dir prial`lcy? `lm, tdi tirkbl`tbnl bs pirenrkim fy ` qu`jbebim kimbc`jpr`ctbtbnlir, `lm

    (f) murbla tdi sufsiquilt st`ais ne prial`lcy, tdi tirkbl`tbnl ne tdi prial`lcy s`tbsebis

    eurtdir cnlmbtbnls, blcjumbla ` cnlmbtbnl td`t `etir ` cirt`bl pnblt bl tbki (`t wdbcd tdi ulfnrl

    cdbjm bs vb`fji) tdi tirkbl`tbnl wnujm nljy fi pirkbttim wdiri, bl tdi npblbnl ne twn qu`jbebim

    kimbc`j pr`ctbtbnlirs, tdi cnltblu`tbnl ne tdi prial`lcy wnujm nr wnujm fi jboijy tn ilm`lair

    tdi wnk`ls jbei nr tn sirbnusjy ilm`lair dir di`jtd.

  • 7/22/2019 Canada's federal cabinet: Abortion discussions, 1988-1990

    29/83

    62

    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

    Sirb`j #00-44 CKWW

    ]di C`fblit Cnkkbttii nl Wrbnrbtbis `lm Wj`llbla

    Kblutis

    @ kiitbla ne tdi C`fblit Cnkkbttii nl Wrbnrbtbis `lm Wj`llbla w`s dijm bl Vnnk 363-S,

    Dnusi ne Cnkknls, nl ]uism`y, @prbj 02, 0244 `t 2837 `.k.

    @fnrtbnl

    (4-2750-44MB)

    ]di Wrbki Kblbstir mbscussim dbs bkprissbnls td`t pufjbc eiijblas `a`blst `fnrtbnl k`y

    fi d`rmilbla bl tdi cnultry. Di ixpictim td`t `fnrtbnl wnujm rik`bl tdi lukfir nli bssui nl

    cnlstbtuilts `ailm`s. Di uraim Kblbstirs lnt tn cnkkbt tdiksijvis pufjbcjy nl tdi bssui ultbjC`fblit micbmis nl ` cnursi ne `ctbnl.

    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

    Sirb`j #06-44 CKWW

    ]di C`fblit Cnkkbttii nl Wrbnrbtbis `lm Wj`llbla

    Kblutis

    @ kiitbla ne tdi C`fblit Cnkkbttii nl Wrbnrbtbis `lm Wj`llbla w`s dijm bl Vnnk 363-S,Dnusi ne Cnkknls, nl ]uism`y, @prbj 65, 0244 `t 2837 `.k.

    @fnrtbnl

    (5-2056-44MB)

    ]di Kblbstir ne Hustbci ripnrtim td`t j`wyirs enr Kr. Fnrnwsob d`m k`mi `ppjbc`tbnl tn tdi

    Supriki Cnurt enr `l i`rjy di`rbla ne dbs c`si ne wditdir tdi ulfnrl `ri pirsnls ulmir tdi

    Cd`rtir ne Vbadts `lm Eriimnks. @raukilts wiri di`rm bl cd`kfirs fy Kr Hustbci KcBltyri,

    : 0 jbli wbtddijm ulmir @]B @ct sic. 63, snjbcbtnr-cjbilt prbvbjiai ? `lm

    6) sdnujm tdi Miputy Wrbki Kblbstir `lm Dnusi Ji`mir mbscuss tdbs wbtd Nppnsbtbnl

    p`rtbis>

    ]di Miputy Wrbki Kblbstir lntim td`t snki ne tdi nptbnls `ri cnlsbstilt wbtd tdi

    Cd`rtir, ntdirs cnujm riqubri `l nvirrbmi. Di c`jjim enr i`rjy `ctbnl. Di wilt nl tn s`y tdi

    anvirlkilt bs jnnobla enr ` kicd`lbsk tn d`vi ` erii vnti, ji`mbla up tn ` cnlsilsus nl `

    knmir`ti `pprn`cd. @l Nrmir ne tdi Dnusi bs riqubrim tn prnvbmi enr ` mif`ti nl ` risnjutbnl

    wbtd tdrii pnssbfji `kilmkilts8 ` prn-jbei `kilmkilt? ` prn-cdnbci `kilmkilt `lm ` knmir`ti

    `kilmkilt. ]di suppnrt ne C`ucus `lm ne tdi Nppnsbtbnl bs liimim. ]di k`ttir bs tn fi put tn

    C`ucus.

    @ kblbstir ixprissim ` prieirilci enr ` anvirlkilt fbjj. Kblbstirs mbscussim tdi rij`tbvikirbts ne bltrnmucbla ` risnjutbnl, `s nppnsim tn ` fbjj `lm tdi liim tn prnvbmi enr ` erii vnti nl

    ` risnjutbnl.

    Snki kblbstirs suppnrtim mif`tbla ` risnjutbnl tn ait tdi silsi ne tdi Dnusi `jtdnuad

    ntdirs eijt tdi risnjutbnl liimim tn fi spicbebc.

  • 7/22/2019 Canada's federal cabinet: Abortion discussions, 1988-1990

    32/83

    36

    ]diri w`s eurtdir mbscussbnl nl tdi risnjutbnl vs. anvirlkilt fbjj rnutis. Ln ebl`j

    mbspnsbtbnl ne tdi btik w`s `ariim tn, `jtdnuad tdi liim tn cnlsujt C`ucus w`s ailir`jjy

    suppnrtim.

    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

    Sirb`j #0=-44 CKWW

    ]di C`fblit Cnkkbttii nl Wrbnrbtbis `lm Wj`llbla

    Kblutis

    @ kiitbla ne tdi C`fblit Cnkkbttii nl Wrbnrbtbis `lm Wj`llbla w`s dijm bl Vnnk 363-S,

    Dnusi ne Cnkknls, nl ]dursm`y, K`y 9, 0244 `t 2837 `.k.

    @fnrtbnl

    (4-2035-44MB)

    ]di Wrbki Kblbstir lntim td`t tdi Anvirlkilt liimim tn micbmi wditdir tn prnciim wbtd

    ` risnjutbnl nl `fnrtbnl, tn bltrnmuci jiabsj`tbnl, nr tn `ttikpt tn rnjj nvir tdi bssui bltn tdi lixt

    k`lm`ti.

    ]di Miputy Wrbki Kblbstir _Dnl. Mnl K`z`lonwsob[ blmbc`tim tdiri wiri ebvi nptbnls8

    0) ` sblaji risnjutbnl npil tn ulstructurim `kilmkilts?

    6) ` sblaji risnjutbnl wbtd structurim `kilmkilts?

    3) ` kujtbpji risnjutbnl?

    =) ` Anvirlkilt Fbjj? `lm

    9) mn lntdbla.

    Di suaaistim td`t tdi `m dnc cnkkbttii cd`brim fy tdi Anvirlkilt Ji`mir bl tdi Sil`ti kiit tn

    tdisi nptbnls `lm ripnrt tn Wrbnrbtbis `lm Wj`llbla tdi lixt wiio. ]di Cnkkbttii `cciptim tdbs

    suaaistbnl.

    Cnlcjusbnls

    ]di Wrbki Kblbstir sukkim up tdi cnlcjusbnls ne tdi kiitbla `s enjjnws8

    0) Wrbnrbtbis `lm Wj`llbla wnujm cnlsbmir ricnkkilm`tbnls ernk tdi @m Dnc Cnkkbttii nl

    `fnrtbnl nl ]uism`y, K`y 07?

    : Jblis wbtddijm lnt rijiv`lt

  • 7/22/2019 Canada's federal cabinet: Abortion discussions, 1988-1990

    33/83

    33

    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

    Sirb`j #09-44 CKWW

    ]di C`fblit Cnkkbttii nl Wrbnrbtbis `lm Wj`llbla

    Kblutis

    @ kiitbla ne tdi C`fblit Cnkkbttii nl Wrbnrbtbis `lm Wj`llbla w`s dijm bl Vnnk 363-S,

    Dnusi ne Cnkknls, nl ]uism`y, K`y 07, 0244 `t 2837 `.k.

    @fnrtbnl

    (=-2713-44MB)

    ]di Anvirlkilt Ji`mir bl tdi Sil`ti ripnrtim nl tdi mijbfir`tbnls ne tdi @m Dnc

    Cnkkbttii rivbiwbla tdi `fnrtbnl bssui. Di blmbc`tim tdi Cnkkbttii w`s ricnkkilmbla td`t

    tdi `tt`cdim jbkbtim prn-cdnbci risnjutbnl fi put enrw`rm `s tdi k`bl risnjutbnl, `lm td`t `l`ttikpt fi k`mi tn liantb`ti twn `kilmkilts wbtd tdi Nppnsbtbnl - nli prn-jbei `kilmkilt

    (@llix @) `lm nli prn-cdnbci `kilmkilt (@llix F). Murbla tdi ilsubla mbscussbnl ne tdbs

    `pprn`cd, tdi enjjnwbla pnblts wiri k`mi8

    0) tdiri w`s ` 19 pircilt cd`lci td`t tdi Nppnsbtbnl wnujm lnt `arii tn tdi `pprn`cd `lm

    tdi mif`ti cnujm tdil ulenjm bl `l ulstructurim w`y, wbtd cnlsbmir`fjy knri `kilmkilts?

    6) snki c`ucus kikfirs wnujm fi cnlcirlim td`t tdi k`bl risnjutbnl w`s lnt ` puri prn-

    jbei risnjutbnl, `lm td`t tdi nppnrtulbty tn knvi sucd `l `kilmkilt wnujm ebrst an tn tdi

    Nppnsbtbnl p`rtbis?

    3) ` risnjutbnl wbtdnut ` Fbjj kbadt lnt fi sueebcbilt fienri tdi ijictbnl, sblci c`lmbm`tis

    wnujm stbjj fi `soim dnw tdiy wnujm vnti nl ` Fbjj?

    =) tdi ebrst cj`usi ne tdi prn-cdnbci `kilmkilt sdnujm fi ijbkbl`tim (`ariim)?

    9) sivir`j c`ucus kikfirs wnujm ixpriss sirbnus cnlcirl be tdi pri`kfji mbm lnt rieir tn

    tdi rbadt ne sncbity tn prntict tdi ulfnrl? `lm

    5) pird`ps ln risnjutbnl d`m ` cd`lci ne p`ssbla.

    ]di Wrbki Kblbstir s`bm td`t tdi Anvirlkilt wnujm lnt fi `fji tn prnciim tn tdi Dnusi

    wbtdnut suppnrt bl c`ucus. Di lntim dbs pirsnl`j mbeebcujtbis ne hustbeybla ` pnsbtbnl ne s`ybla

    wdiri jbei fiabls, blmbc`tbla di w`s lnt suri dnw di dbksije wnujm vnti nl tdisi nptbnls.

    ]di Miputy Wrbki Kblbstir cnlcjumim tdi mbscussbnl fy lntbla td`t snki knri wnro

    wnujm fi mnli nl tdi wnrmbla tn riejict tdi vbiws ixprissim fienri prisiltbla tdi risnjutbnls tn

    c`ucus.

  • 7/22/2019 Canada's federal cabinet: Abortion discussions, 1988-1990

    34/83

    3=

    MV@E] VISNJY]BNL

    ]d`t, bl tdi npblbnl ne tdbs Dnusi, tdi Supriki Cnurt ne C`l`m` d`vbla micj`rim td`t tdi

    prnvbsbnls ne tdi Crbkbl`j Cnmi rij`tbla tn `fnrtbnl `ri blcnlsbstilt wbtd tdi prnvbsbnls ne tdi

    C`l`mb`lCd`rtir ne Vbadts `lm Eriimnks `lm `ri tdirienri ne ln enrci nr ieeict, tdi

    anvirlkilt sdnujm prip`ri `lm bltrnmuci jiabsj`tbnl cnlsbstilt wbtd tdi Cnlstbtutbnl ne C`l`m`,

    blcjumbla tdi Cd`rtir ne Vbadts `lm Eriimnks, wdbcd riejicts tdi eulm`kilt`j v`jui `lm

    bldirilt wnrtd ne duk`l jbei, `lm wdbcd `cdbivis ` f`j`lci fitwiil tdi rbadt ne ` wnk`l tn

    jbfirty `lm sicurbty ne dir pirsnl `lm tdi rbadt (bltirist) ne sncbity tn prntict tdi ulfnrl, sucd

    jiabsj`tbnl sdnujm prndbfbt tdi pirenrk`lci ne `l `fnrtbnl, sufhict tn tdi enjjnwbla ixciptbnls8

    Qdil, murbla tdi i`rjbir st`ais ne prial`lcy8 @ qu`jbebim kimbc`j pr`ctbtbnlir bs ne tdi npblbnl

    td`t tdi cnltblu`tbnl ne tdi prial`lcy ne ` wnk`l wnujm, nr wnujm jboijy tn, tdri`til dir

    pdysbc`j nr kilt`j wijj-fibla? wdil tdi wnk`l bl cnlsujt`tbnl wbtd ` qu`jbebim kimbc`j

    pr`ctbtbnlir micbmis tn tirkbl`ti dir prial`lcy? `lm wdil tdi tirkbl`tbnl bs pirenrkim fy `

    qu`jbebim kimbc`j pr`ctbtbnlir? `lm

    Qdil, murbla tdi sufsiquilt st`ais ne prial`lcy8 tdi tirkbl`tbnl ne tdi prial`lcy s`tbsebis

    eurtdir cnlmbtbnls, blcjumbla ` cnlmbtbnl td`t `etir ` cirt`bl pnblt bl tbki, tdi tirkbl`tbnl wnujm

    nljy fi pirkbttim wdiri, bl tdi npblbnl ne twn qu`jbebim kimbc`j pr`ctbtbnlirs, tdi cnltblu`tbnl ne

    tdi prial`lcy wnujm, nr wnujm fi jboijy tn, ilm`lair tdi wnk`ls jbei nr tn sirbnusjy ilm`lair

    dir di`jtd.

    @LLIT @

    ]d`t, bl tdi npblbnl ne tdbs Dnusi, tdi Supriki Cnurt ne C`l`m` d`vbla micj`rim td`t tdi

    prnvbsbnls ne tdi Crbkbl`j Cnmi rij`tbla tn `fnrtbnl `ri blcnlsbstilt wbtd tdi prnvbsbnls ne tdi

    C`l`mb`lCd`rtir ne Vbadts `lm Eriimnks `lm `ri tdirienri ne ln enrci nr ieeict, tdi

    anvirlkilt sdnujm prip`ri `lm bltrnmuci jiabsj`tbnl cnlsbstilt wbtd tdi Cnlstbtutbnl ne C`l`m`,

    blcjumbla tdi Cd`rtir ne Vbadts `lm Eriimnks, wdbcd riejicts tdi eulm`kilt`j v`jui `lm

    bldirilt wnrtd ne duk`l jbei, `lm wdbcd `cdbivis ` f`j`lci fitwiil tdi rbadt ne ` wnk`l tn

    jbfirty `lm sicurbty ne dir pirsnl `lm tdi rbadt (bltirist) ne sncbity tn prntict tdi ulfnrl, `lm

    Wjus `kilmkilt sufstbtutbla tdi enjjnwbla enr tdi rik`blbla tixt ne tdi risnjutbnl8

    Sucd jiabsj`tbnl, abvbla pri-ikblilci tn tdi prntictbnl ne tdi enitus, sdnujm prndbfbt tdi

    pirenrk`lci ne `l `fnrtbnl ixcipt wdil8

    -- ]wn blmipilmilt qu`jbebim kimbc`j pr`ctbtbnlirs d`vi, bl annm e`btd `lm nl ri`snl`fji

    arnulms, st`tim td`t bl tdibr npblbnl tdi cnltblu`tbnl ne tdi prial`lcy wnujm, nr wnujm fi jboijytn, ilm`lair tdi jbei ne tdi prial`lt wnk`l nr sirbnusjy `lm sufst`ltb`jjy ilm`lair dir di`jtd

    `lm tdiri bs ln ntdir cnkknljy `cciptim prncimuri enr ieeictbvijy tri`tbla tdi di`jtd rbso? fut

    arnulms enr sucd npblbnl `ri lnt tn blcjumi8

    (0) ]di ieeicts ne striss nr `lxbity wdbcd k`y `ccnkp`ly `l ulixpictim nr ulw`ltim

    prial`lcy, nr

  • 7/22/2019 Canada's federal cabinet: Abortion discussions, 1988-1990

    35/83

    39

    (6) Sncb`j nr icnlnkbc cnlsbmir`tbnls.

    @LLIT F

    ]d`t, bl tdi npblbnl ne tdbs Dnusi, tdi Supriki Cnurt ne C`l`m` d`vbla micj`rim td`t tdi

    prnvbsbnls ne tdi Crbkbl`j Cnmi rij`tbla tn `fnrtbnl `ri blcnlsbstilt wbtd tdi prnvbsbnls ne tdi

    C`l`mb`lCd`rtir ne Vbadts `lm Eriimnks `lm `ri tdirienri ne ln enrci nr ieeict, tdi

    anvirlkilt sdnujm prip`ri `lm bltrnmuci jiabsj`tbnl cnlsbstilt wbtd tdi Cnlstbtutbnl ne C`l`m`,

    blcjumbla tdi Cd`rtir ne Vbadts `lm Eriimnks, wdbcd riejicts tdi eulm`kilt`j v`jui `lm

    bldirilt wnrtd ne duk`l jbei, `lm wdbcd `cdbivis ` f`j`lci fitwiil tdi rbadt ne ` wnk`l tn

    jbfirty `lm sicurbty ne dir pirsnl `lm tdi rbadt (bltirist) ne sncbity tn prntict tdi ulfnrl, `lm

    Wjus `kilmkilt sufstbtutbla tdi enjjnwbla enr tdi rik`blbla tixt ne tdi risnjutbnl8

    Sucd jiabsj`tbnl, abvbla pri-ikblilci tn ` wnk`ls eriimnk tn cdnnsi, sdnujm pirkbt tdi

    pirenrk`lci ne `l `fnrtbnl ulmir tdi enjjnwbla cnlmbtbnls8

    (0) Qdil ` qu`jbebim kimbc`j pr`ctbtbnlir bs ne tdi npblbnl td`t tdi cnltblu`tbnl ne tdiprial`lcy ne ` wnk`l wnujm, nr wnujm fi jboijy tn, tdri`til dir pdysbc`j nr kilt`j wijj-

    fibla? `lm

    (6) Qdil tdi wnk`l bl cnlsujt`tbnl wbtd ` qu`jbebim kimbc`j pr`ctbtbnlir micbmis tn

    tirkbl`ti dir prial`lcy? `lm

    (3) Qdil tdi tirkbl`tbnl ne tdi prial`lcy bs pirenrkim fy ` qu`jbebim kimbc`j pr`ctbtbnlir.

    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

    Sirb`j #4-44 CFK

    C`fblit Kblutis

    @ kiitbla ne tdi C`fblit w`s dijm bl Vnnk 363-S, Dnusi ne Cnkknls, nl ]dursm`y, K`y

    02, 0244 `t 2837 `.k.

    @fnrtbnl Ypm`ti

    (1-2741- 44M0)

    ]di Miputy Wrbki Kblbstir _Dnl. Mnl K`z`lonwsob[ ripnrtim td`t tdi nppnsbtbnl

    rihictim tdi anvirlkilts prnpns`j nl tdi prncimuri tn fi enjjnwim. ]di anvirlkilt w`s

    issiltb`jjy jiet wbtd twn nptbnls8

    - bt cnujm usi cjnsuri tn enrci tdrnuad ` kntbnl mbrictbla tdi Dnusi tn cnlsbmir tdi

    prieirrim `fnrtbnl Visnjutbnl, blcjumbla tdi twn `kilmkilts

    nr

  • 7/22/2019 Canada's federal cabinet: Abortion discussions, 1988-1990

    36/83

    35

    - bt cnujm bltrnmuci tdi Visnjutbnl wbtd ln `kilmkilts `lm `jjnw tdi mif`ti tn ulenjm

    `ccnrmbla tn lnrk`j Dnusi rujis.

    ]di Miputy Dnusi Ji`mir _Dnl. Mnua Jiwbs[ riarittim td`t tdi nppnsbtbnl d`m

    pnjbtbcbzim tdbs silsbtbvi mif`ti. 22% ne Dnusi Nrmirs an nl cnlsilt. Di w`s prip`rim dnwivir

    tn put tdi prnciss quistbnl nl, tn mif`ti bt `lm tn vnti bt.

    ]di Wrbki Kblbstir snuadt `ssur`lci nl tdi ei`sbfbjbty ne tdi prnpns`j. Qnujm tdi

    Spi`oir `jjnw tdi Visnjutbnl f`co bl> Qnujm bt fi vntim tdrnuad> ]di Miputy Dnusi Ji`mir

    st`tim td`t c`ucus wnujm fi suppnrtbvi `lm tdi prnciss wnujm wnro.

    ]diri w`s ` frbie mbscussbnl nl wditdir ` cj`ssbc prn-jbei `kilmkilt sdnujm fi

    cnlsbmirim. ]di pnblts k`mi blcjumim8

    - mif`ti nl ` cj`ssbc prn-jbei `kilmkilt wnujm fi annm enr tdi cnultry bl tirks ne

    ikntbnl`j riji`si,

    - ln sucd `kilmkilt sdnujm fi `mmim sblci c`ucus d`m `ariim `jri`my tn ` f`j`lcim

    p`co`ai, `lm tdi kbmmji-ne-tdi-rn`m nptbnl wnujm fi tdi nli td`t wnujm p`ss.

    ]di Wrbki Kblbstir cnlcjumim td`t tdi k`ttir sdnujm prnciim qubcojy. Di eijt viry

    cnkenrt`fji wbtd ` erii vnti nl sucd ` silsbtbvi knr`j bssui. ]di anvirlkilt w`s cnkkbttim tn

    erii vntis ne tdbs typi `lm wnujm jbvi up tn bts cnkkbtkilt.

    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

    Sirb`j #69-44 CKWW

    ]di C`fblit Cnkkbttii nl Wrbnrbtbis `lm Wj`llbla

    Kblutis

    @ kiitbla ne tdi C`fblit Cnkkbttii nl Wrbnrbtbis `lm Wj`llbla w`s dijm bl Vnnk 363-S,

    Dnusi ne Cnkknls, nl ]dursm`y, @uaust 00, 0244 `t 2837 `.k.

    @fnrtbnl

    (1-2729- 44M0)

    ]di Kblbstir ne Hustbci nutjblim tdi pnsbtbnl di w`s t`obla `s @ttnrliy-Ailir`j bl

    prisiltbla ` e`ctuk nl tdiFnrnwsobc`si. Di lntim td`t tdi c`si ciltirim nl wditdir tdi eitus

    w`s ` pirsnl wbtdbl tdi ki`lbla ne tdi Cd`rtir ne Vbadts, `lm td`t tdi Cnurt d`m rihictim tdi

    Anvirlkilts `raukilts tn pnstpnli ` rujbla nl tdbs micbsbnl.

    : 07 jblis wbtddijm ulmir @]B @ct sic. 63, snjbcbtnr-cjbilt prbvbjiai

  • 7/22/2019 Canada's federal cabinet: Abortion discussions, 1988-1990

    37/83

    31

    Murbla tdi ilsubla mbscussbnl, Kblbstirs rivbiwim tdi quistbnl ne wditdir ` micbsbnl nl

    tdi pnjbcy cnujm fi pnstpnlim ultbj `etir tdi ijictbnl. ]di Wrbki Kblbstir cnlcjumim td`t di

    w`ltim tdi quistbnl tn fi put `sbmi ultbj `etir tdi ijictbnl, `lm td`t tdi pnssbfbjbty ne `ppnbltbla `

    Vny`j Cnkkbssbnl nl tdbs k`ttir sdnujm fi rivbiwim `t tdi lixt C`fblit kiitbla.

    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

    _Dbstnrbc`j lnti8]di anvirlkilts k`bl risnjutbnl w`s miei`tim bl tdi Dnusi ne Cnkknls nl

    Hujy 64 fy ` vnti ne 0=1 tn 15. @uaust 00 k`roim c`fblits ebl`j mbscussbnl ne tdi `fnrtbnl tnpbc

    td`t yi`r. Snnl `etirw`rms, p`rjb`kilt w`s mbssnjvim, ` ailir`j ijictbnl w`s dijm nl Lnvikfir

    60, 0244, `lm tdi Cnlsirv`tbvi W`rty w`s ri-ijictim wbtd bts sicnlm k`hnrbty k`lm`ti. ]di tnpbc

    wnujm lixt fi r`bsim wbtd ` liw c`fblit nl K`rcd 60, 0242. [

    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

    SICVI]

    ]dbs mncukilt bs tdi Wrnpirty ne tdi Anvirlkilt ne C`l`m`. Bt bs enr Kblbstirs iyis nljy.

    Sirb`j # 0@-42CK@D@

    ]di @m Dnc Cnkkbttii nl @fnrtbnl

    @ kiitbla ne tdi @m Dnc Cnkkbttii nl @fnrtbnl dijm bl Vnnk 363-S, Dnusi ne Cnkknls,

    nl ]uism`y, K`rcd 60, 0242 `t 06837 p.k.

    Ailir`j Mbscussbnl

    ]di Kblbstir ne St`ti (Eimir`j/Wrnvblcb`j Vij`tbnls) _Sil. Jnwijj Kurr`y, Ji`mir ne tdiAnvirlkilt bl tdi Sil`ti[ bl bltrnmucbla tdi `fnrtbnl bssui k`mi tdi enjjnwbla pnblts8

    0 . Abvil tdi f`coarnulm, tdi anvirlkilt sdnujm prnciim e`brjy qubcojy tn risnjvi tdi bssui?

    6. C`rieuj cnlsbmir`tbnl sdnujm fi abvil tn tdi prnpnsim anvirlkilt pnsbtbnl `lm

    3. ]di prnpnsim pnsbtbnl sdnujm fi c`rieujjy k`l`aim tn a`bl `s kucd suppnrt enr bt `s

    pnssbfji.

    @ mbscussbnl p`pir bmiltbeybla tdi sufst`ltbvi nptbnls w`s cbrcuj`tim tn cnkkbttii

    kikfirs `lm bltrnmucim frbiejy fy tdi Kblbstir ne Hustbci _Dnl. Mnua Jiwbs[. Kikfirs `ariimtd`t tdi nptbnls wnujm fi rivbiwim `t tdi lixt kiitbla. _Lnti8 ]dbs mbscussbnl p`pir bs `tt`cdim`s `l `ppilmbx tn tdi ilm ne tdbs WME ebji.[

    ]di Cnkkbttii mbscussim tbkbla `lm prnciss cnlcirls `ssncb`tim wbtd tdi k`l`aikiltne tdi `fnrtbnl bssui. ]di Kblbstir ne L`tbnl`j Di`jtd `lm Qije`ri _Dnl. Wirrbl Fi`tty[ `mvbsim

    td`t tdnsi nl fntd sbmis ne tdi `fnrtbnl mif`ti cnujm cd`jjilai tdi anvirlkilts usi ne tdi

    C`l`m` Di`jtd @ct.

  • 7/22/2019 Canada's federal cabinet: Abortion discussions, 1988-1990

    38/83

    34

    ]di Cnkkbttii `ariim td`t8

    0. ]di bssui sdnujm fi risnjvim fienri Huli 37, 0242.

    6. ]di Ji`mir ne tdi Anvirlkilt bl tdi Dnusi ne Cnkknls _Dnl. Mnua Jiwbs[ wnujm

    prnvbmi `l `l`jysbs ne tdi prncimur`j `jtirl`tbvis enr tdi k`l`aikilt ne tdi bssui enr tdi lixtkiitbla.

    3. ]di Ji`mir ne tdi Anvirlkilt bl tdi Dnusi ne Cnkknls wnujm `jsn neeir `mvbci nldnw tdi bssui sdnujm fi prisiltim tn c`ucus.

    =. ]di Kblbstir ne Hustbci wnujm ji`m ` mbscussbnl ne tdi sufst`ltbvi nptbnls `t tdi lixtkiitbla.

    9. ]di Kblbstir ne Ikpjnykilt `lm Bkkbar`tbnl _Dnl. F`rf`r` KcMnua`jj[ wnujm prnvbmienr tdi lixt kiitbla blenrk`tbnl nl tdi olnwl pnsbtbnls ne Kikfirs ne p`rjb`kilt nl tdi bssui.

    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

    Sirb`j # 03-42CFK

    C`fblit Kblutis

    @ kiitbla ne tdi C`fblit w`s dijm bl Vnnk 363-S, Dnusi ne Cnkknls, nl ]uism`y, Hujy

    69, 0242, `t 6877 p.k.

    Btik - @fnrtbnl

    Ailir`j Mbscussbnl

    ]di Wrbki Kblbstir _Vt. Dnl. Frb`l Kujrnliy[ npilim tdi kiitbla fy rieirrbla tn tdi

    v`rbnus `ailm` btiks. Di `jsn r`bsim ` lukfir ne bssuis pirt`blbla tn tdi fusbliss ne tdi

    Cnlsirv`tbvi W`rty.

    (4-27==-42M0)

    ]di Wrbki Kblbstir bltrnmucim tdi `fnrtbnl bssui fy riquistbla tdi Kblbstir ne Eimir`j-

    Wrnvblcb`j Vij`tbnls _Sil. Jnwijj Kurr`y[ tn sukk`rbzi tdi mijbfir`tbnls `lm cnlcjusbnls

    wdbcd tdi @m Dnc Kblbstirs Cnkkbttii nl @fnrtbnl (wdbcd di d`m cd`brim) d`m cnki tn bl

    @prbj. ]di Wrbki Kblbstir lntim td`t tdi bssui w`s lnt kirijy nli ne `fnrtbnl fut nli ne

    ji`mirsdbp. ]diri w`s ` silsi ne uli`si bl tdi cnultry `fnut tdi jiabsj`tbvi v`cuuk. Anvirlkilt

    w`s ixpictim tn prnvbmi `l `pprnprb`ti jiabsj`tbvi er`kiwnro enr risnjvbla tdi bssui.

    ]di Kblbstir ne St`ti (Eimir`j-Wrnvblcb`j Vij`tbnls) k`mi tdi enjjnwbla ripnrt8

  • 7/22/2019 Canada's federal cabinet: Abortion discussions, 1988-1990

    39/83

    32

    - tdi prncimur`j nptbnls ne ` Vieirilci tn tdi Supriki Cnurt, ` l`tbnl`j rieirilmuk, `lm `

    Vny`j Cnkkbssbnl wiri ijbkbl`tim fic`usi ne tdi mij`y tdiy wnujm c`usi?

    - tdi nptbnl ne puttbla ` risnjutbnl tn tdi Dnusi w`s rihictim fic`usi bt wnujm sbkpjy

    ripi`t j`st yi`rs ixpirbilci?

    - twn rik`blbla `jtirl`tbvis `ri tn crbkbl`jbzi `fnrtbnl ulmir tdi Crbkbl`j Cnmi, nr tn

    p`ss sip`r`ti jiabsj`tbnl? `lm

    - tdiri wiri strnla vbiws `a`blst crbkbl`jbzbla `fnrtbnls, `lm ` cnlsilsus td`t ln

    jiabsj`tbnl cnujm wbl k`hnrbty suppnrt bl tdi Dnusi? `lm bt w`s tdirienri tdi cnlcjusbnl ne tdi

    @m Dnc Cnkkbttii bl @prbj td`t tdi Anvirlkilt lnt jiabsj`ti wbtd rispict tn `fnrtbnl `t td`t

    tbki.

    ]di Kblbstir lntim td`t cbrcukst`lcis d`vi cd`laim `s ` risujt ne tdi ricilt Wrnvblcb`j

    Cnurt cd`jjilais `lm td`t C`l`mb`ls wbjj fi jnnobla tn anvirlkilt tn prnvbmi ji`mirsdbp. Di

    lntim td`t pufjbc npblbnl bl ailir`j e`vnurs `v`bj`fbjbty ne `fnrtbnl fut riauj`tim fy kimbc`j

    npblbnl. ]di frn`m pnpuj`tbnl mnis lnt sd`ri ibtdir ne tdi prn-jbei nr prn-cdnbci pnsbtbnls fut

    r`tdir prieirs ` kbmmji arnulm cnkprnkbsi.

    ]di Wrbki Kblbstir blmbc`tim td`t ixtriki pnsbtbnls `ri lnt anbla tn ji`m tn ` snjutbnl. @

    kbmmji arnulm kust fi enulm wdbcd wbjj riejict tdi vbiws ne tdi k`hnrbty ne C`l`mb`ls `lm

    wdbcd c`l fi riejictim bl `pprnprb`ti cnkprnkbsis bl c`ucus `lm p`rjb`kilt. ]di Wrbki Kblbstir

    riquistim tdi Kblstir rispnlsbfji enr Eimir`j-Wrnvblcb`j Vij`tbnls tn ricnlvili tdi @m Dnc

    Cnkkbttii ne Kblbstirs nl @fnrtbnl `lm mivijnp ` knmir`ti jiabsj`tbvi er`kiwnro tn mi`j wbtd

    tdi `fnrtbnl bssui. ]di Wrbki Kblbstir blmbc`tim eurtdir td`t di wnujm t`oi rispnlsbfbjbty enr

    l`vba`tbla tdi bssui tdrnuad p`rjb`kilt. Di rieirrim tn tdi pnssbfji liim enr kiitblas wbtd

    ji`mirs ne tdi ntdir twn k`hnr p`rtbis.

    Vispnlmbla tn vbiws ne snki Kblbstirs, tdi Wrbki Kblbstir `soim Kblbstirs tn tikpir

    tdibr pufjbc cnkkilts `lm tn try tn fi cnlsbstilt wbtd dbs st`tikilts, b.i. td`t jiabsj`tbnl wbjj fi

    mivijnpim enr bltrnmuctbnl bl tdi e`jj `lm bl tdi bltirbk tdi bssui bs fibla rivbiwim.

    ]di Wrbki Kblbstir ikpd`sbzim td`t tdiri bs ` liim enr tdi anvirlkilt tn prnvbmi

    ji`mirsdbp nl tdbs bssui `lm bt bs issiltb`j td`t tdiy try enr ` jiabsj`tbvi snjutbnl. Di lntim td`t

    ntdir cnultrbis d`m fiil `fji tn risnjvi tdi bssui wbtd subt`fji jiabsj`tbnl. Bl e`ct, tdiri w`s `

    cirt`bl cnkknl`jbty tn tdibr jiabsj`tbvi `pprn`cdis. Bt w`s ixtrikijy bkpnrt`lt enr C`l`m` tnsittji tdi bssui wbtd `l `pprnprb`ti jiabsj`tbvi er`kiwnro.

    : = jblis wbtddijm ulmir @]B @ct sic. 63, snjbcbtnr-cjbilt prbvbjiai

    =) Ntdir Kblbstirs wiri ne tdi vbiw td`t tdiri w`s jbttji mbscirl`fji mbeeirilci fitwiil tdi

    twn `pprn`cdis ulmir mbscussbnl, `s e`r `s tdibr bkp`ct nl tdi lukfir ne `fnrtbnls fibla

    pirenrkim8 libtdir nli wnujm jnwir tdi lukfir ne `fnrtbnls pirenrkim bl C`l`m` fijnw wd`t bt

    wnujm ntdirwbsi fi. @ly mbeeirilcis fitwiil tdik wiri j`raijy sykfnjbc nr prisilt`tbnl`j.

    @etir tdi Kblbstir ne Iliray _Dnl. H`oi Ipp[ blmbc`tim td`t, bl dbs vbiw, tdi twn-st`ai

    `pprn`cd wnujm livir fi `ccipt`fji tn tdi k`hnrbty ne C`ucus, tdi mbscussbnl sdbetim tn tdi

    str`tiay enr sicurbla tdi suppnrt ne C`ucus. Kblbstirs lntim td`t snki prn-jbei C`ucus kikfirs

    wnujm prieir tn sii ` Anvirlkilt Fbjj e`bj, r`tdir td`l suppnrt `l bkpireict Fbjj.

    Sivir`j Kblbstirs `ariim td`t C`ucus cnujm lnt sbkpjy fi prisiltim wbtd nli prieirrim

    `pprn`cd? bt wnujm liim tbki tn tdblo bts w`y tdrnuad tdi v`rbnus nptbnls `lm, tdrnuad ` prnciss

    ne ijbkbl`tbnl, mbscnvir enr btsije td`t tdi @m Dnc Cnkkbttiis ricnkkilm`tbnl bs prnf`fjy tdi

    fist wnro`fji cnkprnkbsi.

    ]di Wrbki Kblbstir sukkim up tdi mijbfir`tbnls `s enjjnws8

    0) Di eijt bt bkpir`tbvi td`t tdi C`ucus fi pirsu`mim tn suppnrt tdi Anvirlkilts Fbjj8

    iviry ntdir wistirl cnultry d`m fiil `fji tn jiabsj`ti nl tdi k`ttir ne `fnrtbnl.

  • 7/22/2019 Canada's federal cabinet: Abortion discussions, 1988-1990

    54/83

    9=

    6) ]di suppnrt ne C`ucus c`llnt fi sicurim fy rusdbla tdi bssui? `miqu`ti tbki wbjj fi

    riqubrim enr C`ucus kikfirs tn `cqubri snki prbmi ne `utdnrsdbp nvir tdi prieirrim jiabsj`tbvi

    `pprn`cd.

    3) Di rikblmim Kblbstirs td`t tdbs w`s lnt `l bssui ne prbv`ti knr`jbty nr rijbabnl, fut nli

    ne pnjbtbc`j ji`mirsdbp `lm stiw`rmsdbp bl ` pjur`jbstbc sncbity. Kblbstirs, `s rispnlsbfjijiabsj`tnrs, d`m ` muty tn jiabsj`ti nl `fnrtbnl. Bl sn mnbla, tdiy d`m tn nfsirvi tdi ebli jbli

    fitwiil tdi ixircbsi ne ji`mirsdbp `lm `utdnrbty, `lm tdi bkpnsbtbnl ne pirsnl`j knr`j vbiws nl

    tdi pnpuj`tbnl. Di w`s cnlcirlim td`t tdi Anvirlkilts `pprn`cd fi bl tuli wbtd ` knmirl

    sncbity, `lm `vnbm stiirbla tnn e`r tn tdi rbadt.

    =) Di ilmim fy blvbtbla Kblbstirs tn sufkbt tdibr suaaistbnls nl dnw tn k`l`ai tdi bssui bl

    C`ucus (wdil tn j`ulcd tdi mbscussbnl, wditdir tn enrk ` C`ucus Cnkkbttii, itc.).

    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

    Sirb`j # 60-42CFWW

    ]di C`fblit Cnkkbttii nl Wrbnrbtbis `lm Wj`llbla

    Kblutis

    @ kiitbla ne tdi C`fblit Cnkkbttii nl Wrbnrbtbis `lm Wj`llbla w`s dijm bl Vnnk 363-S,

    Dnusi ne Cnkknls, nl Knlm`y, Nctnfir 07, 0242 `t 07877 `.k.

    Btiks - @fnrtbnl

    ]di Anvirlkilt Ji`mir bl tdi Sil`ti _Sil. Jnwijj Kurr`y[ ripnrtim td`t tdi c`ucus

    Cnkkbttii nl `fnrtbnl w`s d`vbla bts ebl`j kiitbla tnm`y. Di blmbc`tim td`t tdi Cnkkbttii d`m

    jnnoim `t 6-st`ai `lm 3-st`ai `pprn`cdis fut td`t tdi prn-jbei pinpji wnujm prieir ` lnl-

    aist`tbnl`j `pprn`cd. Cnkkbttii kikfirs ulmirstnnm td`t tdbs ki`lt `l `fsnjuti kblbkuk ne

    ristrbctbnls.

    ]di Kblbstir wilt nl tn blmbc`ti td`t tdi cnlsilsus mivijnpbla w`s cjnsi tn tdi njm

    riabki fut wbtd ln @fnrtbnl Cnkkbttiis. Di`jtd wnujm fi mieblim frn`mjy tn blcjumi pdysbc`j,

    kilt`j `lm psycdnjnabc`j di`jtd.

    ]di Wrbki Kblbstir blmbc`tim td`t tdbs w`s tdi ebrst tbki di d`m di`rm ne tdbs. Dicnlcjumim td`t tdi Cnkkbttii sdnujm rivbiw tdbs wbtd tdi Anvirlkilt Ji`mir bl tdi Sil`ti

    wdil tdibr mijbfir`tbnls wiri cnkpjiti. Sil`tnr Kurr`y wnujm tdil frbla tdi k`ttir fienri

    W&W.

    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

  • 7/22/2019 Canada's federal cabinet: Abortion discussions, 1988-1990

    55/83

    99

    Sirb`j # 6=-42CFWW

    ]di C`fblit Cnkkbttii nl Wrbnrbtbis `lm Wj`llbla

    Kblutis

    @ kiitbla ne tdi C`fblit Cnkkbttii nl Wrbnrbtbis `lm Wj`llbla w`s dijm bl Vnnk 363-S,Dnusi ne Cnkknls, nl ]uism`y, Nctnfir 30, 0242 `t 07877 `.k.

    Btiks @fnrtbnl. (1-2096-42M0)

    Ailir`j Mbscussbnl8

    ]di Anvirlkilt Ji`mir bl tdi Sil`ti _Sil. Jnwijj Kurr`y[ ripnrtim nl tdi mijbfir`tbnls

    ne tdi c`ucus cnkkbttii ix`kblbla tdi `fnrtbnl bssui. Di blmbc`tim td`t tdi Cnkkbttii d`m

    cnki up wbtd ` nli-st`ai `pprn`cd wdbcd wnujm pirkbt `fnrtbnl bl c`sis wdiri tdi

    psycdnjnabc`j, kilt`j nr di`jtd cnlmbtbnls ne tdi wnk`l wiri `t rbso. Di lntim td`t tdi prblcbpji

    ne k`obla ln mbstblctbnl fitwiil v`rbnus st`ais ne jbei enr tdi prn-jbei arnup w`s sn bkpnrt`lt

    td`t tdiy wiri `fji tn `ccipt kblbk`j cnlmbtbnls tdrnuadnut. Di lntim td`t tdi Cnkkbttii cn-

    cd`brkil d`m s`bm td`t tdiri w`s ` j`rai cnlsilsus fut lnt ul`lbkbty, Di suaaistim td`t tdi

    anvirlkilt sdnujm tri`t tdbs `s ` c`ucus k`ttir lnw `lm mbscuss bt `t l`tbnl`j c`ucus td`t wiio.

    ]di anvirlkilt cnujm tdil sirvi lntbci j`tir bl tdi wiio.

    ]di Wrbki Kblbstir s`bm di d`m cnlcjumim td`t tdbs wnujm eblm wbmi e`vnur bl c`ucus `lm

    wnujm p`ss. ]dbs w`s viry bkpnrt`lt. Di suaaistim td`t Kblbstirs rivbiw tbkbla.

    : 3 jblis wbtddijm ulmir @]B @ct sic. 63, snjbcbtnr-cjbilt prbvbjiai

  • 7/22/2019 Canada's federal cabinet: Abortion discussions, 1988-1990

    56/83

    95

    WVBUR CNYLCBJ NEEBCI

    @l @ct Vispictbla @fnrtbnl

    ]di @ct wnujm `kilm tdi Crbkbl`j Cnmibl nrmir tn prndbfbt `fnrtbnl uljiss, bl tdi

    npblbnl ne ` kimbc`j pr`ctbtbnlir, f`sim nl tdi ailir`jjy `cciptim st`lm`rms ne tdi kimbc`jprneissbnl, tdi di`jtd nr jbei ne tdi eik`ji pirsnl wnujm fi jboijy tn fi tdri`tilim be tdi `fnrtbnl

    w`s lnt, blmucim.

    ]di @ct mieblis di`jtd tn blcjumi pdysbc`j, kilt`j `lm psycdnjnabc`j di`jtd.

    _]IT] NE ]DI MV@E] FBJJ ENJJNQS ]N FI J@]IV L@KIM FBJJ C-=3[

    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

    Sirb`j # 69-42CFWW

    ]di C`fblit Cnkkbttii nl Wrbnrbtbis `lm Wj`llbla

    Kblutis

    @ kiitbla ne tdi C`fblit Cnkkbttii nl Wrbnrbtbis `lm Wj`llbla w`s dijm bl Vnnk 363-S,

    Dnusi ne Cnkknls, nl ]uism`y, Lnvikfir 1, 0242 `t 078=9 `.k.

    Btiks - @fnrtbnl (1-2731-42M0)

    ]di Wrbki Kblbstir uraim `jj Kblbstirs tn fi viry c`rieuj `fnut k`obla `ly st`tikilts

    wdbcd kbadt ulji`sd tdi mbvbsbvi pntiltb`j ne tdbs bssui.

    ]di Kblbstir ne Iliray, Kblis `lm Visnurcis _Dnl. H`oi Ipp[ ixprissim snki cnlcirl

    td`t suppnrt enr tdi Anvirlkilts jiabsj`tbnl nl `fnrtbnl (C-=3, @l @ct Vispictbla @fnrtbnl)kbadt fi w`virbla `knla Anvirlkilt Kikfirs.

    ]di Cdbie ne St`ee _St`ljiy D`rtt[ tn tdi Wrbki Kblbstir ixpj`blim td`t snki Kikfirswiri cnlmuctbla ` mbscriit di`m cnult tn a`uai tdi ixtilt ne suppnrt enr tdi jiabsj`tbnl.

    ]di cd`brk`l ne tdi @m Dnc Cnkkbttii nl @fnrtbnl _Sil. Jnwijj Kurr`y[ lntim tdibkpnrt`lci ne p`ssbla tdi jiabsj`tbnl `s qubcojy `s pnssbfji tn kblbkbzi bts mbvbsbvi pntiltb`j

    `knla Dnusi Kikfirs. Di `jsn d`m blmbc`tbnls td`t tdi Nppnsbtbnl Ji`mir bl tdi Sil`ti_Jbfir`j Sil`tnr Dnl. @jj`l K`cI`cdil[ wnujm suppnrt tdi jiabsj`tbnl.

    6. @fnrtbnl Ypm`ti

    Bssui

  • 7/22/2019 Canada's federal cabinet: Abortion discussions, 1988-1990

    57/83

    91

    - Vivbiw ne ri`ctbnl tn `fnrtbnl jiabsj`tbnl `lm pj`ls enr k`l`abla tdbs bssui bl tdi Dnusi.

    Nutcnki

    - Liim tn fubjm nl tdbs wbtd ebvi nr sbx annm spiicdis bl tdi Dnusi tdbs wiio - snkitdbla

    nl tdi ricnrm enr nur KWs tdbs wiioilm.

    - ]di oiy bs tn ait tdi Fbjj `pprnvim `s qubcojy `s pnssbfji, fienri bt d`s tbki tn mbvbmi

    Kikfirs ne W`rjb`kilt `a`bl.

    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

    Sirb`j # 05-27CFWW

    ]di C`fblit Cnkkbttii nl Wrbnrbtbis `lm Wj`llbla

    Kblutis

    @ kiitbla ne tdi C`fblit Cnkkbttii nl Wrbnrbtbis `lm Wj`llbla w`s dijm bl Vnnk 363-S,

    Dnusi ne Cnkknls, nl ]uism`y, K`y 09, 0227 `t 07877 `.k.

    Btiks @fnrtbnl. (=-2756-27M0)

    Ailir`j Mbscussbnl8

    ]di Anvirlkilt Dnusi Ji`mir _Dnl. D`rvbi @lmri[ nutjblim tdi `rr`laikilts td`t d`m

    fiil prnpnsim enr k`l`abla tdi mif`ti `lm vnti nl tdi `fnrtbnl jiabsj`tbnl. Di s`bm td`t sivil`kilmkilts d`m fiil `jjnwim fy tdi Spi`oir. ]di pj`l w`s tn pirkbt 07-kbluti spiicdis

    cnkkilcbla nl Qimlism`y ne tdi enjjnwbla wiio `lm tn cnltblui tdi mif`ti `s jnla `s pinpji

    wbsdim tn spi`o. ]di vnti wnujm tdil fi dijm nl K`y 62, 0227 `t 3877 p.k.

    ]di Kblbstir ne Hustbci `lm @ttnrliy Ailir`j ne C`l`m` _Dnl. Obk C`kpfijj[ ripnrtim

    nl tdi lukfirs jboijy tn vnti enr `lm `a`blst tdi prnpnsim jiabsj`tbnl. Ks. C`kpfijj s`bm tdiri

    w`s ` rbso td`t snki ne tdi prn-jbei `kilmkilts wnujm p`ss be tdi Liw Mikncr`tbc W`rty ijictim

    tn fnycntt tdi prnciimblas. ]di k`hnrbty bl e`vnur ne tdi jiabsj`tbnl w`s viry sk`jj, `ssukbla `jj

    C`fblit kikfirs suppnrtim tdi jiabsj`tbnl.

    @etir snki mbscussbnl, tdi Wrbki Kblbstir nutjblim dbs cnlcjusbnls. Di blmbc`tim td`t di

    wnujm spi`o tn tdi c`ucus nl tdi bkpnrt`lci ne tdbs jiabsj`tbnl p`ssbla. Di rikblmim dbs

    cnjji`auis td`t tdiy d`m `ariim td`t `jj kikfirs ne C`fblit wnujm vnti `a`blst `ly `kilmkilt

    `lm mbrictim `jj Kblbstirs tn fi bl `ttilm`lci enr tdi vnti. Di t`soim tdi Anvirlkilt Dnusi

    Ji`mir wbtd tdi rispnlsbfbjbty ne k`l`abla tdi bssui bl tdi Dnusi. Di s`bm td`t wdbji tdi

    Anvirlkilt cnujm lnt usi ` tdrii-jbli wdbp tn ilenrci bts wbjj, bt kust sp`ri ln ieenrt bl ilsurbla

    td`t tdi jiabsj`tbnl p`ssim.

  • 7/22/2019 Canada's federal cabinet: Abortion discussions, 1988-1990

    58/83

    94

    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

    Sirb`j # 2-27CFK

    C`fblit Kblutis

    @ kiitbla ne tdi C`fblit Cnkkbttii nl Wrbnrbtbis `lm Wj`llbla w`s dijm bl Vnnk 363-S,

    Dnusi ne Cnkknls, nl ]dursm`y, K`y 30, 0227 `t 07837 `.k.

    Ailir`j Mbscussbnl8

    @fnrtbnl Jiabsj`tbnl (4-2704-27M0)

    ]di Wrbki Kblbstir td`loim `lm cnlar`tuj`tim kikfirs ne tdi C`fblit enr tdi succisseuj mif`tibl tdi Dnusi ne Cnkknls nl tdi `fnrtbnl jiabsj`tbnl.

    _ ILM NE C@FBLI] KBLY]IS NL @FNV]BNL. 0244-0227 [

    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

    _Dbstnrbc`j pnstscrbpt8Fbjj C-=3 w`s rieirrim tn ` Jiabsj`tbvi Cnkkbttii nl 64 Lnvikfir

    0242. Nl 5 @prbj 0227, tdi Cnkkbttii ripnrtim C-=3 f`co tn tdi Dnusi ne Cnkknls wbtdnut

    `kilmkilt. ]dbrm ri`mbla mif`ti fia`l nl 66 K`y 0227.

    Nl 63 K`y 0227, tdi Dnusi rihictim `jj prnpnsim `kilmkilts tn Fbjj C-=3 fy ` sbalbebc`lt

    k`hnrbty. Knst ne tdi prnpnsim `kilmkilts wnujm d`vi jbkbtim tdi cnlmbtbnls ulmir wdbcd `l`fnrtbnl cnujm fi nft`blim. Nl 62 K`y 0227, tdi Dnusi ne Cnkknls p`ssim Fbjj C-=3 nl tdbrm

    ri`mbla fy ` vnti ne 0=7 tn 030. @jtdnuad C`fblit Kblbstirs wiri riqubrim tn suppnrt tdi fbjj, bt

    w`s ` erii vnti enr `jj ntdir Kikfirs.

    Nl 30 H`lu`ry 0220, tdi Sil`ti vntim nl Fbjj C-=3. @s wbtd tdi Dnusi ne Cnkknls, bt w`s ` erii

    vnti ixcipt enr kikfirs ne tdi C`fblit (Sil`tnr Kurr`y). Ne 45 sil`tnrs prisilt, =3 vntim enrtdi fbjj `lm =3 vntim `a`blst bt. Ylmir tdi Vujis ne tdi Sil`ti, ` tbim vnti bs miikim tn fi `

    lia`tbvi vnti? tdirienri Fbjj C-=3 w`s miei`tim.

    Qbtd tdbs risujt, `fnrtbnl bl C`l`m` bs lnt jbkbtim fy crbkbl`j j`w fut fy tdi C`l`m` Di`jtd @ct.

    Qdbji snki lnl-jia`j nfst`cjis ixbst, C`l`m` bs nli ne nljy ` eiw l`tbnls wbtd ln jia`j

    ristrbctbnls nl `fnrtbnl.

    dttp8//pufjbc`tbnls.ac.c`/cnjjictbnls/Cnjjictbnl-V/JnWFmW/CBV/4207-i.dtk [

    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

  • 7/22/2019 Canada's federal cabinet: Abortion discussions, 1988-1990

    59/83

    92

    _ @WWILMBT ]QN F@COAVNYLM W@WIVS NE 0242 [

    @FNV]BNL MBSCYSSBNL W@WIV

    K`rcd 60, 0242

    SICVI]

    ]@FJI NE CNL]IL]S

    BSSYI

    F@COAVNYLM

    W`rt @ - Jia`j

    Knrailt`jirmicbsbnlJia`j Ieeicts ne tdiKnrailt`jirMicbsbnl

    Cd`rtirCnlsbmir`tbnls

    Jiabsj`tbvi F`j`lci

    W`rt F - Kimbc`j `lm Sncb`j

    Di`jtd Cnlsiquilcis ne @fnrtbnl

    E`ctnrs Vijiv`lt tn tdi ]bkbla ne `l @fnrtbnl

    `) @fnrtbnl bl tdi Ebrst ]rbkistir

    f) @fnrtbnl bl tdi Sicnlm ]rbkistir

    c) J`ti Wrisiltirsm) S`eity

    i) Eit`j Ub`fbjbty

    e) Wril`t`j Scriilbla `lm Mb`alnsbs

    Arnulms enr @fnrtbnl

    `) Wdysbc`j Di`jtd

    f) Kilt`j Di`jtd

    c) Iuailbc Di`jtdm) Itdbc`j Di`jtd

    @fnrtbnl E`cbjbtbis

    Sicnlm Kimbc`j Npblbnl

    CYVVIL] S]@]YS

  • 7/22/2019 Canada's federal cabinet: Abortion discussions, 1988-1990

    60/83

    57

    : K`ly jblis wbtddijm ulmir @]B @ct sic. 63, snjbcbtnr-cjbilt prbvbjiai