Upload
center-for-american-progress
View
214
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
1/128
Abe~bgcd Jgdbdai Hbsq Jbghbq Alv~lvbpi Eldiw Jhll`q
Ky`gagbh VbaiqFghhw Alvvgoiv Kbdybvw 6>21
SSS$BEIVGABD^VLCVIQQ$L
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
2/128
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
3/128
Abe~bgcd Jgdbdai Hbsq Jbghbq Alv~lvbpi Eldiw Jhll`qKy`gagbh Vbaiq
Fghhw Alvvgoiv Kbdybvw 6>21
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
4/128
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
5/128
2 Gdpvl`yapgld bd` qyeebvw
1 Poi Eghhgld @lhhbv Ky`ciq lj 6>26
7 Fgc Fyqgdiqq Pbmgdc lziv Qpbpi Qy~viei Alyvpq
09 @gqahlqyvi Hbsq Dii`i` pl Idqyvi Pvbdq~bvidaw gd Ky`ga
Ihiapgldq
97 ^bvpgqbd Ky`gagbh Ihiapgldq bd` poi @gqplvpgdc Gdjhyidai
Abe~bgcd Abqo
32 Eivgp Qihiapgld bd` Vipidpgld Ihiapgldq Mii~ Ky`ciq Ly
^lhgpgaq
72 Qpvldc Viayqbh Vyhiq Bvi Avyagbh pl Ky`gagbh Gdpicvgpw
2>1 ^yfhga Jgdbdagdc lj Ky`gagbh Vbaiq Abd Cgzi Qebhh @ldlv
@iagqgzi Vlhi
227 Bflyp poi Bypolv bd` bamdlshi`cieidpq
Aldpidpq
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
6/128
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
7/128
Gdpvl`yapgld bd` qyeebvw sssbeivgabd~vlcviqq
Gdpvl`yapgld bd` qyeebvw
Pi qii~ vgqi gd abe~bgcd aldvgfygldq lv ky`gagbh ihiagldq obq fiid sihh
`layeidi` Abd`g`biq gd qbi qy~viei alyv vbaiq vbgqi` bvlyd` $622 eghhgld
vle 6>>> l 6>>7sl bd` b obh geiq elvi obd gd oi ~vizglyq `iab`i Fy
oi 6>26 ihiagldq qbs q~id`gdc vialv`q qobpivi` bq oi ydhgegi` abe~bgcd abqo
ydhibqoi` fwAgg{idq Ydgi` bd` loiv i`ivbh alyv abqiq yd`i` fghhgldq l `lh%
hbvq gd gd`i~id`id ix~id`gyviq B vialv` $673 eghhgld sbq q~id ld ihizgqgld
b`q gd qbi qy~viei alyv vbaiq ogq wibv( bd` elvi obd obh l ogq eldiw abei
gd oi lve l gd`i~id`id ix~id`gyviq( baalv`gdc l Kyqgai b Qbmi bd` oiFviddbd Aidiv lv Kyqgai( sl cvly~q ob vbam eldiw gd ky`gagbh ihiagldq2
Pgq ll` l abe~bgcd abqo abei vle alv~lvbgldq( hbswivq( bd` loivq sgo b
qbmi gd ols oiqi alyvq vyhi Izid gd lqidqgfhw dld~bvgqbd vbaiq( ~lhggabh ~bvgiq
q~id eghhgldq l `lhhbvq ld abd`g`biq lv alyvq ayvvidhw aldqg`ivgdc hbsqygq lziv
vi`gqvgagdc eb~q Piqi ~ivaigzi` aldgaq l gdiviq sghh yvoiv ivl`i ~yfhga
ald`idai gd bd ge~bvgbh ky`gagbvw( sogao gq bhvib`w b bd bhbvegdc hls6
Pi Aidiv lv Beivgabd ^vlcviqq obq ale~ghi` gq viaid vi~lvq `iqavgfgdc oi
`gqlvgdc gdyidai l abe~bgcd abqo bd` qycciqgdc ~lhgaw qlhygldq l eggcbi
oiqi ~vlfhieq Pi vq vi~lv( Eghhgld @lhhbv Ky`ciq( ogcohgcoq qizivbh 6>26
ky`gagbh ihiagldq ghhyqvbgdc ols abe~bgcd dbdai hbsq obzi fvlmid `lsd gd oi
bai l ydhgegi` gd`i~id`id q~id`gdc Pi dix vi~lv( Fgc Fyqgdiqq bmgdc
Lziv Qbi Qy~viei Alyvq( bmiq b fvlb`iv zgis bd` ghhyqvbiq ols abe~bgcd
abqo obq biai` ky`ciq bd` oi hbs lziv oi ~bq sl `iab`iq Pgq ale~ghbgld
gdahy`iq oi ix l oi hbpiv vi~lv bd` b qyeebvw l oi `bb vle gq b~~id`gx
Pi ale~ghbgld aldahy`iq sgo b qivgiq l vi~lvq ld `givid ~lhgagiq ob alyh`
oih~ eggcbi oi gdyidai l alv~lvbi abe~bgcd abqo gd ky`gagbh ihiagldq Piqivi~lvq bvi gdid`i` lv b`zlabiq lv hicgqhblvq sol sbd l idqyvi ob lyv kyq%
gai qwqie slvmq lv izivwldi( dl kyq lv olqi sgo idlyco eldiw l `ldbi
Ibao vi~lv gq ~vibai` fw b ldi%~bci qyeebvw Id`dliq bd` agbgldq bvi bzbgh%
bfhi gd oi hldciv zivqgldq ob lhhls oi qyeebvgiq
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
8/128
6 Aidpiv lv Beivgabd vlcviqq Abe~bgcd Jgdbdai Hbsq Jbgh bq Alv~lvbpi Eldiw Jhll`q Ky`gagbh Vbaiq
Id`dlpiq
2 Fviddbd Aidpiv lv Kyqpgai bd` Kyqpgai bp Qpbmi( Dis@bpb Qolsq Ky`gagbh Ihiapgld B` Q~id`gdc Fvibmq Vi%alv` bp $673 eghhgld( viqq vihibqi( @iaiefiv 23( 6>26(bzbghbfhi bp opp~;,,sssfviddbdaidpivlvc,aldpidp,vi%qlyvai,dis\`bpb\qolsq\ky`gagbh\ihiapgld\b`\q~id`%gdc\fvibmq\vialv`\bp\673\eghhgld
6 B 6>2> ~lhh vle Kyqpgai bp Qpbmi lyd` pobp 32 ~ivaidp
l viq~ld`idpq qbg` pobp poiw fihgizi abe~bgcdix~id`gpyviq obzi b qgcdgabdp ge~bap ld alyvpvlle`iagqgldq Kyqpgai bp Qpbmi( Qlhg` Fg~bvpgqbd EbklvgpgiqFihgizi Ky`ciq Gdyidai` fw Abe~bgcd Aldpvgfypgldq(
^viqq vihibqi( Qi~piefiv ?( 6>2>( bzbghbfhi bp opp~;,,ssskyqpgaibpqpbmilvc,disqvlle,~viqq\vihibqiqae,7?2>\qlhg`\fg~bvpgqbd\ebklvgpgiq\fihgizi\ky`c%iq\gdyidai`\fw\abe~bgcd\aldpvgfypgldq>7 Cbhhy~,YQB Pl`bw~lhhlyd` pobp ?7 ~ivaidp l viq~ld`idpq qbg` poiw fihgizipoi gdyidai l abe~bgcd aldpvgfypgldq ld ky`ciqvyhgdcq gq b ~vlfhie Klbd Fgqmy~ga( Qy~viei Alyvp
Abqi sgpo poi iih l b fiqp qihhiv( YQB Pl`bw( Jifvybvw2:( 6>>7( bzbghbfhi bp opp~;,,sssyqbpl`bwale,disq,sbqogdcpld,6>>7%>6%2:%cvgqobe%alyvp\Dope
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
9/128
@gqahlqyvi Hbsq Dii`i` pl Idqyvi Pvbdq~bvidaw gd Ky`gagbh Ihiapgldq sssbeivgabd~vlcviqq
Poi Eghhgld @lhhbv Ky`ciq lj 6>26
Lvgcgdbhhw ~yfhgqoi`; Kbdybvw 29( 6>21
Qyeebvw
Gd`i~id`id q~id`gdc svibmi` obzla ld ky`gagbh ihiagldq bd` iqi` abe~bgcd
dbdai hbsq gd 6>26( bq gdiviq cvly~q izb`i` aldvgfygld hgegq bd` q~id egh%
hgldq l ihia oigv ~viivvi` ky`ciq Pi Aidiv lv Beivgabd ^vlcviqq alhhiai`
gdlvebgld ld bhh ky`ciq sol sld ihiagldq gd 6>26 soghi vbgqgdc vlycohw $2 egh%
hgld lv elvi( bq sihh bq olqi sol ob` elvi obd $2 eghhgld q~id ld oigv fiobh fwgd`i~id`id cvly~q2 Pi abe~bgcdq l oi eghhgld `lhhbv ky`ciq l 6>26 `ie%
ldqvbi ob gd`i~id`id q~id`gdc ~hbwq bd gdavibqgdchw avyagbh vlhi Ydhiqq qbiq
ge~hieid vilveq( izid elvi eldiw sghh ll` ky`gagbh vbaiq( bd` oi gdyidai
ob alv~lvbgldq bd` q~iagbh gdiviqq ixivagqi lziv ky`ciq sghh aldgdyi ydbfbi`
Kyqpgai ^byh Disfw( Dlvpo Abvlhgdb Qy~viei Alyvp
Dlvo Abvlhgdb Qy~viei Alyv Kyqgai ^byh Disfw sbq vi%ihiai` sgo oi oih~
l elvi obd $69 eghhgld gd gd`i~id`id q~id`gdc6 Pi qbiq ~yfhga dbda%
gdc ~vlcvbehldc b el`ih lv qbiq qiimgdc l mii~ eldiw ly l ky`gagbh
vbaiqsbq lzivsoihei` fw eldiw vle gdiviq cvly~q hgmi oi qbi Aobefiv
l Aleeivai bd` Beivgabdq lv ^vlq~ivgw( b cvly~ bhgbi` sgo oi fghhgldbgvi
gd`yqvgbhgq Mlao fvloivq Dlvo Abvlhgdb lfbaal ale~bdgiq aog~~i` gd oyd%
`vi`q l olyqbd`q l `lhhbvq bjiv oiw fidii` vle b 6>>7 vyhgdc(1 byolvi` fw
Disfw( gd b `gq~yi sgo lfbaal bveivq
Pi hbvciq `ldbgld fw bv sbq oi elvi obd $2 eghhgld vle oi Vi~yfhgabd Qbi
Hib`ivqog~ Aleegpii( b cvly~ ob oih~i` oi qbiq Vi~yfhgabd hicgqhbyvi vbjgq viaid vi`gqvgagdc eb~q0 Agzgh vgcoq cvly~q hi` b hbsqyg bhhicgdc ob oi eb~
`gqidvbdaogqiq egdlvgw zlivq( bd` oi abqi gq ayvvidhw filvi oi qbi qy~viei
alyv9 Pgq eldiw sbq gdqvyeidbh gd mii~gdc b 0%1 aldqivzbgzi ebklvgw ld oi
fidao Dlvo Abvlhgdbq iogaq vyhiq qbw ob b ky`ci qolyh` dl oibv b abqi g ogq lv
Disfw
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
10/128
0 Aidpiv lv Beivgabd vlcviqq Abe~bgcd Jgdbdai Hbsq Jbgh bq Alv~lvbpi Eldiw Jhll`q Ky`gagbh Vbaiq
oiv ge~bvgbhgw egco vibqldbfhw fi ryiqgldi`(: fy Kyqgai Disfw sghh oibv oi
vi`gqvgagdc abqi `iq~gi oi ba ob oi sbq vi%ihiai` obdmq l eghhgldq l `lhhbvq
vle Vi~yfhgabd cvly~q ob obzi b qbmi gd oi lyalei3
Kyqpgaiq Qpi~oid Ebvmebd( Fvgbd [bovb( bd` Fvg`cip EaAlvebam(Egaogcbd Qy~viei Alyvp
Kyqgaiq Qi~oid Ebvmebd bd` Fvgbd [bovb( flo aldqivzbgziq( ibao vbgqi`
bvlyd` $?>>(>>> lv oigv vi%ihiagld fg`q( fy baalv`gdc l oi Egaogcbd
Abe~bgcd Jgdbdai Dislvm( oi yd`gqahlqi` gd`i~id`id q~id`gdc sbq qizivbh
geiq ob cyvi Pi qbi Vi~yfhgabd ^bvw q~id $09 eghhgld ld b`q lv Kyqgaiq
Ebvmebd bd` [bovb( bq sihh bq bd ydqyaaiqqyh ogco alyv abd`g`bi( sgoly
`gqahlqgdc oi qlyvai l bdw l ob eldiw? L oi q~id`gdc sogao sbq vi~lvi`(
oi Egaogcbd Bqqlagbgld l Vibhlvq q~id $0>>(>>> ld b`q lv oi aldqivzbgzi
abd`g`biq bjiv oiw klgdi` b 6>22 l~gdgld ob eb`i g ibqgiv lv elvcbci ale%~bdgiq l lviahlqi ld oleilsdivq7
Kyqgai Fvg`ci Ebvw EaAlvebam sld b qib ld oi Egaogcbd Qy~viei Alyv
bjiv oi @ielavbga ^bvw q~id $9 eghhgld gd yd`gqahlqi` q~id`gdc ld b`q
qy~~lvgdc oiv bd` sl loiv abd`g`biq2> Oiv abe~bgcd alhhiai` elvi obd
$:>>(>>> sgo oi oih~ l hbvci `ldbgldq vle ydgldq22
Kyqpgai @ld Sghhipp( Pixbq Qy~viei Alyvp
Pi ixbq Qy~viei Alyv gq ale~lqi` idgvihw l aldqivzbgzi Vi~yfhgabdq( bd`
Kyqgai @ld Sghhip avygqi` l vi%ihiagld( vbgqgdc $23 eghhgld lv b ~vgebvw ald%
iq Pgq oijw qye gdahy`iq bhelq $2>>(>>> vle idivcw ale~bdgiq bd` hbvci
aldvgfygldq vle oi gd`yqvwq l~ hbs veq26 Kyqgai Sghhip obq viaigzi` elvi
obd $69>(>>> vle idivcw ale~bdgiq lziv oi wibvq( baalv`gdc l oi Dbgldbh
Gdqgyi ld Eldiw gd Qbi lhggaq 21
Kyqgai Sghhip obq diziv ei bd lgh ale~bdw hggcbd ob oi `g` dl hgmi Pi
ixbq Qy~viei Alyv vyhi` gd 6>>3 ob aldvba ie~hlwiiq( qyao bq lgh%vgc slvm%ivq( abddl qyi oigv ie~hlwivq lv ld%oi%klf gdkyvgiq20 Jlv wibvq oi idivcw
gd`yqvw ob` ydqyaaiqqyhhw hlffgi` oi qbi hicgqhbyvi lv qyao b aobdci29 Gd b
6>>? hbsqyg gdzlhzgdc ow`vbyhga vbayvgdc( lv vbamgdc( Kyqgai Sghhip fhbbdhw
gdzlmi` ~lhgaw vibqldq gd vyhgdc lv oi idivcw ale~bdw; L~id%id`i` hgbfghgw
Ebvmebd
[bovb
EaAlvebam
Sghhipp
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
11/128
@gqahlqyvi Hbsq Dii`i` pl Idqyvi Pvbdq~bvidaw gd Ky`gagbh Ihiapgldq sssbeivgabd~vlcviqq
Alhiebd
ovibidq l gdga cvbzi bd` ydeggcbfhi obve( idqyvgdc ob eyao l lyv Qbiq
yd`izihl~i` idivcw qy~~hgiq slyh` qbw ob sbwyd`izihl~i`Beg` qlbvgdc
`iebd` bd` qbccgdc qy~~hw( ixbq aleeld hbs eyq baaleel`bi aypgdc%i`ci
iaodlhlcgiq bfhi l ixvba ydlh` viqivziq vle ydaldzidgldbh ih`q2:
Kyqpgai Ebvw Kbdi Poigq( Ghhgdlgq Qy~viei Alyvp
Kyqgai Ebvw Kbdi Pigq l oi Ghhgdlgq Qy~viei Alyv ibqghw sld oi vbai lv aogi
kyqgai gd oi cidivbh ihiagld Hgmi Kyqgai Sghhip gd ixbq( olsiziv( qoi bai` b
~vgebvw aobhhidci bd` vbgqi` bvlyd` $29 eghhgld( sgo elvi obd $0>>(>>> l oiv
abe~bgcd yd`q alegdc vle hbswivq23 Kyqgai Pigq bhql viaigzi` $2?(9>> vle
~yfhga%qialv ydgldq(2? gdahy`gdc b aob~iv l oi Beivgabd Ji`ivbgld l Qbi(
Alydw( bd` Eydgag~bh Ie~hlwiiq( sogao lyco oi ahlqyvi l aivbgd qbi baghg%
giq gd b abqi filvi oi ogco alyv Kyqgai Pigq `gqqidi` vle b viaid Ghhgdlgq
Qy~viei Alyv vyhgdc bcbgdq oi ydgld27 Oiv ~vgebvw abe~bgcd bhql fidii`vle dibvhw $6>>(>>> gd gd`i~id`id q~id`gdc vle ^ivqldbh ^BA( Gda( b cvly~
qy~~lvgdc vi~vl`yagzi oibho abvi lv sleid6>
Kyqpgai Klqgbo Alhiebd( Egqqgqqg~~g Qy~viei Alyvp
Kyqgai Klqgbo Alhiebd sld b qib ld oi Egqqgqqg~~g Qy~viei Alyv sgo vlycohw
$2 eghhgld gd gd`i~id`id q~id`gdc Dibvhw obh l ob eldiw abei vle b qob`%
lsw Zgvcgdgb%fbqi` lvcbdg{bgld( oi Hbs Idlvaieid Bhhgbdai l Beivgab62 Pi
cvly~ obq fiid bagzi gd ky`gagbh vbaiq bavlqq oi alydvw( bd` bholyco g viyqiq
l `gqahlqi gq `ldlvq(66 g obq fiid bqqlagbi` sgo oi Dbgldbh Vgi Bqqlagbgld
bd` oi YQ Aobefiv l Aleeivai61 Pi viebgd`iv l oi gd`i~id`id q~id`%
gdc abei vle Ge~vlzi Egqqgqqg~~g BA( sogao viaigzi` hbvci ldbgldq vle
alv~lvbi%yd`i` cvly~q( gdahy`gdc dbgldbh lv vilve b`zlabiq bd` ~lhggabh
bagld aleegpiiq vi~viqidgdc oi gdqyvbdai( dbdai( bd` idivcw gd`yqvgiq60
Kyqpgai Qobvld Middi`w( Logl Qy~viei Alyvp
@iq~gi b vbvi dl vialeeid`i` vbgdc fw oi Logl Qbi Fbv Bqqlagbgld(69
Kyqgai Qobvld Middi`w `iibi` bd gdayefid kyqgai lv b qib ld oi qbi
qy~viei alyv Middi`w sbq bg`i` fw abe~bgcd `ldbgldq vle idivcw ale%
~bdgiq bd` oi gdqyvbdai gd`yqvw( bq sihh bq gd`i~id`id q~id`gdc fw oi Logl
Poigq
Middi`w
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
12/128
: Aidpiv lv Beivgabd vlcviqq Abe~bgcd Jgdbdai Hbsq Jbgh bq Alv~lvbpi Eldiw Jhll`q Ky`gagbh Vbaiq
Vi~yfhgabd ^bvw6: Oiv abe~bgcd vi~lvi` vbgqgdc elvi obd $79>(>>>( gdahy`gdc
oyd`vi`q l olyqbd`q l `lhhbvq vle oi qbi Vi~yfhgabd ^bvw( alv~lvbi gdiv%
iq cvly~q( bd` hbs veq ob b~~ibv filvi oi alyv63
Kyqpgaiq Jvi` V$ Hisgq( Fbvfbvb ^bvgidpi( bd` ^iccw Rygdai( Jhlvg`bQy~viei Alyvp
Jbagdc bd yd~viai`idi` eyhgeghhgld `lhhbv l~~lqggld abe~bgcd( ovii Jhlvg`b
Qy~viei Alyv Kyqgaiq vbgqi` obh b eghhgld `lhhbvq ibao bd` fidii` vle $11
eghhgld gd q~id`gdc fw bd gd`i~id`id cvly~ B cvly~ abhhi` @iid` Kyqgai vle
^lhggaq q~id eghhgldq l `lhhbvq l `iid` oi ovii abd`g`biq gd oi 6>26 viid%
gld ihiagld( bd` g viaigzi` elq l gq eldiw vle Jhlvg`b bplvdiwq 6? Pi abe%
~bgcd bcbgdq mii~gdc oi kyqgaiq ld oi fidao sbq yd`i` fw oi qbi Vi~yfhgabd
^bvw bd` ~vl%alv~lvbi cvly~q hgmi oi Mlao fvloivq Beivgabdq lv ^vlq~ivgw67
Hisgq
^bvgidpi
Rygdai
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
13/128
@gqahlqyvi Hbsq Dii`i` pl Idqyvi Pvbdq~bvidaw gd Ky`gagbh Ihiapgldq sssbeivgabd~vlcviqq
Id`dlpiq
2 B abd`g`bpi gd Siqp Zgvcgdgb q~idp elvi pobd $2 egh%hgld( fyp qoi q~idp oiv lsd eldiw gdqpib` l vbgqgdcabe~bgcd yd`q Abd`g`bpi Qyeebvw; @bzgq( VlfgdKibd( bzbghbfhi bp opp~;,,ssslhhlspoieldiwlvc,`bpbfbqi,QpbpiChbdai,abd`g`bpi~opeh>1/hbqp baaiqqi` Kbdybvw 6>21' Povii abd`g`bpiq lv poi
Jhlvg`b Qy~viei Alyvp vbgqi` bvlyd` obh b eghhgld lh%hbvq ibao( bd` bd lypqg`i cvly~ q~idp $20 eghhgld ldpoigv fiobh( lv bd bzivbci belydp pobp gq kyqp yd`iv$2 eghhgld Fviddbd Aidpiv lv Kyqpgai( 6>26 ky`gagbhabe~bgcd q~id`gdc ixaii`q 21 eghhgld( qyv~bqqiq6>2> q~id`gdc( viqq vihibqi( Laplfiv 6:( 6>26(bzbghbfhi bp opp~;,,sssfviddbdaidpivlvc,aldpidp,viqlyvai,6>26\ky`gagbh\abe~bgcd\q~id`gdc\ix%aii`q\21\eghhgld\qyv~bqqiq\6>2>\q~id`gdc,
6 Avbgc Kbvzgq( Elvi pobd $69 eghhgld vbgqi` ql bv fwlypqg`i cvly~q gd qpbpi Qy~viei Alyvp vbai( DisqLfqivziv( Laplfiv 1>( 6>26( bzbghbfhi bp opp~;,,sssdisqlfqivzivale,6>26,2>,1>,609>:33,elvi%pobd%69%eghhgld%vbgqi`%qlopeh
1 Dlvpo Abvlhgdb z oghhg~ Elvvgq YQB( Gda( Dl 6B>9%0/DA Dlz :( 6>>7' /yd~yfhgqoi` iagqgld'( bzbghbfhibp opp~;,,sssblaqpbpidayq,sss,~yfhga,qa,l~gd%
gldq,6>>7,~`,6%>9%0%0~`
0 Dlvpo Abvlhgdb @i~bvpeidp l Qpbpi( 0?%Olyv Dlpgai;Kyqpgai lv Bhh DA( Dlziefiv 9( 6>26( bzbghbfhi bpopp~;,,sssb~~qfliqpbpidayq,sifb~~q,a\v~p\qibvao\lvc,a\vi~lvp\gebcibq~x26( bzbghbfhi bp opp~;,,s ssdisqlfqivzivale,6>26,26,23,699>7?:,da%qy~viei%alyvp%disfw%abd%~bvpgag~bpiopeh
: DA Al`i l Ky`gagbh Ald`yap Abdld 1/A'/2'
3 Flddiv bd` Fhwpoi( DA Qy~viei Alyvp; Disfw abd~bvpgag~bpi gd vi`gqpvgapgdc abqi
? Egaogcbd Abe~bgcd Jgdbdai Dipslvm( Ydvi~lvpi`
Egaogcbd Qy~viei Alyvp Pihizgqgld B`zivpgqgdc( 6>26Ihiapgld Awahi /6>26'( bzbghbfhi bp opp~;,,ssseadlvc,~`q,vi~lvpq,EQA\PZ~`
7 Viqg`idpgbh Jyd`gdc Al z Qbyvebd( ?>9 DS6` 2?1/Egao 6>22'
2> Egaogcbd Abe~bgcd Jgdbdai Dipslvm( Ydvi~lvpi`Egaogcbd Qy~viei Alyvp Pihizgqgld B`zivpgqgdc( 6>26Ihiapgld Awahi
22 Egaogcbd @i~bvpeidp l Qpbpi( ^lqp%Cidivbh AQ(Fvg`cip Ebvw EaAlvebam lv Kyqpgai( @iaiefiv :(6>26
26 Abd`g`bpi Qyeebvw; Sghhipp( @ld( bzbghbfhi bp opp~;,,ssslhhlspoieldiwlvc,`bpbfbqi,ydgryiabd`g`bpi~opeh21'
21 Gfg`
20 Idpivcw Cyh Qpbpiq( Gda z Qyeeivq( 6?6 QS1` 011/Pix 6>>7'
29 Hii Dgaolhq( Kyqpgai bd` Slvmiv Qbipw( ByqpgdAovldgahi( @ia 62( 6>>3( bzbghbfhi bp opp~;,,sssbyqpgdaovldgahiale,disq,6>>3%26%62,9302:7,
2: Albqpbh Lgh bd` Cbq Alv~( z Cbv{b Idivcw Pvyqp( 6:?QS1` 2 /Pix 6>>?'
23 Abd`g`bpi Qyeebvw; Poigq( Ebvw Kbdi( bzbghbfhibp opp~;,,ssslhhlspoieldiwlvc,`bpbfbqi,Qpbp%iChbdai,abd`g`bpi~opeh21'
2? Gfg`
27 Qy~ivzgqlvw Lv`iv( Siieq z B~~ihhbpi Alyvp( Jgpo@gqpvgap bd` Beivgabd Ji`ivbpgld l Qpbpi( Alydpw( bd`Eydgag~bh Ie~hlwiiq( Dl 22960> /Ghh @ia 22( 6>26' (bzbghbfhi bp opp~;,,sssqpbpighyq,alyvp,qy~vieialyvp,Bddlydai,6>26,262226\6~`
6> Ydallv`gdbpi` Q~id`gdc; Ydallv`gdbpi` q~id`gdclv poi 6>26 vyddgdc l 2QP QY^VIEI % JGP[CIV%BH@ ZBABDAW( bzbghbfhi bp opp~;,,ghhgdlgqqydqogdilvc,qydqogdi,ydallv`gdbpi`Q~id`gdcQibvao~o~26*lai52QP-QY^VIEI-%-JGP[CIVBH@-ZBABDAW /hbqp baaiqqi` @iaiefiv6>26'
62 Pogq cyvi gq fbqi` ld Hicbh ^vlcviqq bdbhwqgq l Mbdpbv
Ei`gbq AEBC bpb Poi Hbs Idlvaieidp Bhhgbdai lBeivgab q~idp bd iqpgebpi` $007(2:> ld pihizgqgld b`qgd pogq vbai( bd` poi Ge~vlzi Egqqgqqg~~g ^BA q~idp bdiqpgebpi` $:6:(>>> gd pogq vbai
66 Gd vi Hbs Idlvaieidp Bhhgbdai l Beivgab( Gda( DL >1%22%>>:10%AZ( 6>22 Pix B~~ Hixgq 7:9: / Pix B~~ @ia7( 6>22'
61 Mdlsd Jyd`ivq l; Hbs Idlvaieidp Bhhgbdai lBeivgab /HIBB'( bzbghbfhi bp opp~;,,sssqpibhpo~baqlvc,yd`ivae26'
60 Pogq cyvi gq fbqi` ld Hicbh ^vlcviqq bdbhwqgq l MbdpbvEi`gbq AEBC `bpb Poi Ge~vlzi Egqqgqqg~~g ^BA q~idpbd iqpgebpi` $:6:(>>>( lv b plpbh l $2>3 eghhgld
69 Logl alyvp ol~iyh cipq hlsiqp vbpgdc( Plhi`l Fhb`i(
Kydi 3( 6>26( bzbghbfhi bp opp~;,,sssplhi`lfhb`iale,Alyvpq,6>26,>:,>3,Logl%alyvp%ol~iyh%cipq%hlsiqp%vbpgdcopeh
6: Fywgdc Pgei 6>26Logl( bzbghbfhi bp opp~;,,sssfviddbdaidpivlvc,aldpidp,viqlyvai,fywgdc\pgei6>26\logl
63 Aldpvgfypgld gdlvebpgld lv Kyqpgai Middi`wqabe~bgcd gq bzbghbfhi povlyco poi Logl @ i~bvpeidpl Qpbpiq ldhgdi abe~bgcd dbdai bpbfbqi Qii;Aldpvgfypgldq Qibvao( bzbghbfhi bp opp~;,,sss6qlqqpbpiloyq,~hq,aldhgdi,;;DL;6;;
6? Jhlvg`b @i~bvpeidp l Qpbpi bd` @iid` Kyqpgai vle^lhgpgaq( Abe~bgcd Jgdbdai Bapgzgpw= GVQ Jlve ??36(^lqp%Cidivbh Ihiapgld Vi~lvp( @iaiefiv :( 6>26
67 CL^q Ydsbvvbdpi` Bqqbyhp( Egbeg Oivbh`( Laplfiv
3( 6>26( bzbghbfhi bp opp~;,,sssegbegoivbh ale,6>26,2>,>3,1>1:023,cl~q%ydsbvvbdpi`%bqqbyhpopeh
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
14/128
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
15/128
Fgc Fyqgdiqq Pbmgdc lziv Qpbpi Qy~viei Alyvpq sssbeivgabd~vlcviqq
Fgc Fyqgdiqq Pbmgdc lziv Qpbpi
Qy~viei Alyvpq
Lvgcgdbhhw ~yfhgqoi`; Bycyqp 6>26
Gdpvl`yapgld bd` qyeebvw
Gd qbi alyvq bavlqq lyv alydvw( alv~lvbi q~iagbh gdiviqq bvi `ldbgdc eldiw
l oi abe~bgcdq l ky`ciq sol gdiv~vi oi hbs gd b ebddiv ob fidiq oigv
aldvgfylvq vboiv obd agg{idq qiimgdc kyqgai Beivgabdq bvi qbvgdc l sbmi y~
l ogq `bdciv( baalv`gdc l viaid ~lhhq( bd` bvi slvvgi` ob gd`gzg`ybhq sgolyeldiw l aldvgfyi ebw dl viaigzi b bgv oibvgdc gd qbi alyvq Gd b viaid ~lhh
?7 ~ivaid l viq~ld`idq qbg` oiw fihgizi oi gdyidai l abe~bgcd aldvgfy%
gldq ld ky`ciq vyhgdcq gq b ~vlfhie2
Ky`ciq qsibv bd lbo ob oiw sghh bdqsiv l oi hbs( dl abe~bgcd aldvgfylvq
G b ~ivqld gq svldci`( oi lv qoi abd ol~i l d` ge~bvgbh kyqgai gd b alyv(
soivi izivwldivgao lv ~llv( sibm lv ~lsivyhgq irybh gd oi iwiq l oi hbs
Fy ogq ~vgdag~hi gq hiqq bd` hiqq vyi sgo ibao ~bqqgdc ky`gagbh ihiagld
Pgvw%igco qbiq ihia oigv ogco alyv ky`ciq(6 bd` idlvelyq belydq l eldiw
bvi ~lyvgdc gdl ky`ciq abe~bgcd sbv aoiqq Jyihi` fw eldiw vle alv~lvbi
gdiviqq bd` hlffwgqq( q~id`gdc ld ky`gagbh abe~bgcdq obq ix~hl`i` gd oi hbq
sl `iab`iq Gd 277> abd`g`biq lv qbi qy~viei alyvq ldhw vbgqi` bvlyd` $1
eghhgld( fy fw oi eg`%277>q( abe~bgcdq sivi vbmgdc gd elvi obd zi geiq ob
belyd( yihi` fw ixvieihw alqhw vbaiq gd Bhbfbeb bd` ixbq1 Pi 6>>> vbai
qbs ogco%alyv abd`g`biq vbgqi elvi obd $09 eghhgld0
Qgdai oid( alv~lvbi Beivgabq gdyidai lziv oi ky`gagbvw obq cvlsd Pi YQ
Aobefiv l Aleeivai( gd ~bvgayhbv( obq fialei b ~lsivyh ~hbwiv gd ky`gagbh vbaiqJvle 6>>2 l 6>>1 gq ~viivvi` abd`g`biq sld 62 l 60 ihiagldq9 Baalv`gdc l
`bb vle oi Dbgldbh Gdqgyi ld Eldiw gd Qbi ^lhggaq( oi aobefiv q~id elvi
obd $2 eghhgld l bg` oi 6>>: abe~bgcdq l sl Logl Qy~viei Alyv kyqgaiq(:
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
16/128
2> Aidpiv lv Beivgabd vlcviqq Abe~bgcd Jgdbdai Hbsq Jbgh bq Alv~lvbpi Eldiw Jhll`q Ky`gagbh Vbaiq
bd` gd oi elq viaid ogco alyv ihiagld gd Bhbfbeb( eldiw vle oi qbiq aobe%
fiv baalydi` lv 0> ~ivaid l bhh abe~bgcd aldvgfygldq3
Alv~lvbi gdiviq cvly~q bvi d`gdc elvi sbwq l agvayezid gqahlqyvi vyhiq
bd` hgegq ld abe~bgcd aldvgfygldq Q~id`gdc fw gd`i~id`id cvly~q /dl
lagbhhw bhgbi` sgo oi abd`g`biq' obq gdavibqi` vbebgabhhw( qyv~bqqgdc ogcoalyv abd`g`biq q~id`gdc gd 6>>?? Baalv`gdc l Kyqgai b Qbmi( elvi obd 7>
~ivaid l q~iagbh gdiviq Z b`q gd 6>>: sivi ~bg` lv fw ~vl%fyqgdiqq gdiviq
cvly~q7 Aldqivzbgzi cvly~q q~id $?7 eghhgld gd ogco alyv ihiagldq gd 6>2>(
ale~bvi` l kyq $69 eghhgld vle ~vlcviqqgzi cvly~q2> Piqi q~id`gdc cyviq
bvi gdale~hii fiabyqi oi `gqahlqyvi vyhiq lv lyqg`i q~id`gdc zbvw( ql oi
qlyvai l oi eldiw gd qbi alyv ihiagldq gq ljid obv` l `gqaivd
Pi ~yfhga abd ix~ia izid elvi eldiw l ll` ogq wibvq ky`gagbh ihiagldq
Qgdai oi 6>2> YQ Qy~viei Alyv `iagqgld gd Agg{idq Ydgi` z$ Ji`ivbh Ihiagld
Aleegqqgld( alv~lvbgldq( ydgldq( bd` gd`gzg`ybhq bvi dls vii vle hgegq ldabe~bgcd q~id`gdc22 Dlvo Abvlhgdb gq oi ldhw qbi sgo b vlfyq ~yfhga dbda%
gdc qwqie lv ky`gagbh ihiagldq( bd` g gq bhql oi vq qbi l qii b qy~iv ~lhgg%
abh bagld aleegpii( lv qy~iv ^BAbd idgw q~bsdi` fwAgg{idq Ydgi` ob
bhhlsq lv ydhgegi` abe~bgcd q~id`gdciqbfhgqoi` l qy~~lv b ~vl%alv~lvbi
ky`ci gd ogq wibvq ihiagld26 Pi YQ Qy~viei Alyv obq bhql eb`i g obv`iv lv
~yfhga dbdagdc qwqieq l viebgd zgbfhi fw vyhgdc ob ebaogdc yd`q( `gq%
vgfyi` l ~yfhgahw yd`i` abd`g`biq soid oigv l~~ldidq q~id`gdc ixaii`q b
aivbgd hizih( bvi b zglhbgld l vii q~iiao vgcoq21
G viaid ogqlvw gq bdw cyg`i( oi vid`q bvi legdlyq lv gd`gzg`ybhq qygdc alv~l%
vbgldq Pi qbiq ob obzi qiid oi elq eldiw gd ky`gagbh ihiagldq dls obzi
qy~viei alyvq ob bvi `legdbi` fw ~vl%alv~lvbi ky`ciq Pi B~~id`gx l ogq
vi~lv hgqq bhh ogco alyv vyhgdcq ld abqiq soivi bd gd`gzg`ybh qyiq b alv~lvbgld
vle 2776 l 6>2> gd oi qgx qbiq ob obzi qiid oi elq ky`gagbh abe~bgcd abqo
gd ob gei ~ivgl`Bhbfbeb( ixbq( Logl( iddqwhzbdgb( Ghhgdlgq( bd` Egaogcbd
Pi `bb gdahy`iq 0>1 abqiq vle 6>>> l 6>2>( bd` gd olqi abqiq oi alyvq vyhi`
gd bzlv l alv~lvbgldq 32 ~ivaid l oi gei20 Pi ogco alyvq ob obzi qiid oi
elq abe~bgcd q~id`gdc bvi eyao elvi hgmihw l vyhi gd bzlv l fgc fyqgdiqqiq bd`
bcbgdq gd`gzg`ybhq sol obzi fiid gdkyvi`( qabeei`( lv qyfkiai` l `gqavgegdbgld
Sgo eldiw ~hbwgdc qyao b hbvci vlhi gd ky`gagbh ihiagldq( oi gdiviq cvly~q sgo
oi elq eldiw gdavibqgdchw obzi bd b`zbdbci Gd alyvvlleq bavlqq lyv alyd%
vw( fgc alv~lvbgldq bd` loiv q~iagbh gdiviqq bvi ghgdc oi ~hbwgdc ih` gd oigv
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
17/128
Fgc Fyqgdiqq Pbmgdc lziv Qpbpi Qy~viei Alyvpq sssbeivgabd~vlcviqql
bzlv Ebdw Beivgabdq ~ivaigzi lyv clzivdeid bd` alv~lvbi gdqgygldq bq
gdiv`i~id`id ale~ldidq l b qwqie gd sogao ~lsivyh ihgiq ~hbw fw b `giv%
id qi l vyhiq obd lv`gdbvw agg{idq Qlei iih ob ldhw olqi `ldbgdc eldiw
abd ~hbw b vlhi gd clzivdgdc Pi al{w vihbgldqog~ fisiid clzivdeid bd` fgc
fyqgdiqq obq fialei gdavibqgdchw ahibv gd lyv ky`gagbh ihiagldq
Pgq vi~lv `gqayqqiq ols oi qlbvgdc alq l ky`gagbh ihiagldq hi` l qbi
qy~viei alyv `iagqgldq ob bzlv alv~lvbi hggcbdq lziv gd`gzg`ybhq qiimgdc
l olh` oie baalydbfhi Pi vi~lv ~vlzg`iq ghhyqvbgldq vle qgx qbiq
Bhbfbeb( ixbq( Logl( Dizb`b( Sgqaldqgd( bd` Egaogcbdl ols alv~lvbi
gdiviq cvly~q ob `iqgvi b aivbgd lyalei obzi `ldbi` eldiw l ky`ciq( bd`
oi qbei ky`ciq obzi oid gdiv~vii` oi hbs gd b ebddiv ob baogiziq oigv
alv~lvbi ldlvq iqgvi` lyalei
Jlv qlei qbiq( oi vi~lv `gqayqqiq ols( bjiv bd gdyx l eldiw vle alv~l%
vbi gdiviq cvly~q( ky`ciq obzi bfvy~hw aobdci` oi hbs fw lzivvyhgdc viaid~viai`id Gd Logl( lv ixbe~hi( oi gdqyvbdai gd`yqvw `ldbi` eldiw l ky`ciq
sol oid zli` l lzivyvd viaid abqiq ob oi gd`yqvw `gqbzlvi` Gd loiv
qbiq( qyao bq ixbq( oi alv~lvbi%yd`i` ogco alyv obq gdiv~vii` oi hbs l
vibao aivbgd viqyhq ob oi qbi hicgqhbyvi vikiai` Pgq ky`gagbh ~lhgawebmgdc
fw oi ixbq alyv obq viqyhi` gd abqi hbs ob bzlvq idivcw ale~bdgiq yd`gdc
oi ky`ciq abe~bgcdq
Pgq ~vlfhie gq q~vib`gdc l qbiq ob obzi diziv filvi qiid ix~idqgzi ky`gagbh
vbaiq( qyao bq Sgqaldqgd( soivi gd`i~id`id q~id`gdc fw gdiviq cvly~q lziv%
soihei` oi qbiq ~yfhga dbdagdc qwqie gd oi 6>22 ihiagld Pgq vid` gq
ovibidgdc b yd`beidbh bq~ia l lyv `ielavbaw; oi vgco l Beivgabdq l b
bgv vgbh Soid ky`ciq l~ivbi hgmi ~lhggagbdq( olqi sol hbam ~lhggabh gdyidai
abddl ix~ia bgvdiqq
Pi zbq ebklvgw l hicbh `gq~yiq gd oi Ydgi` Qbiq 79 ~ivaidbvi qiphi`
gd qbi alyvq29 Plqi sol obzi fiid obvei` fw bd ydqbi ~vl`ya lv bd ld%oi%
klf gdkyvw slyh` elq hgmihw hllm l qbi alyvq lv kyqgai Sgo ky`ciq fbami` fw
fgc fyqgdiqq bmgdc lziv lyv alyvq( bvi oivi bdw viebgdgdc gdqgygldq ob abd
olh` ~lsivyh alv~lvbgldq baalydbfhi22 ~lhh( 7> ~ivaid l
olqi qyvziwi` qbg` ky`ciq qolyh` viayqi oieqihziq vle abqiq gdzlhzgdc abe%
~bgcd aldvgfylvq(2: fy viayqbh gq ixvieihw vbvi
B ~bvw l b hbsqyg gd Siq Zgvcgdgb vi~ibi`hw bqmi` b qbi qy~viei alyv kyqgai
l viayqi ogeqih bjiv bd ixiaygzi sgo oi l~~lqgdc ~bvw( b albh ale~bdw( q~id
elvi obd $1 eghhgld ovlyco bd gd`i~id`id idgw l qy~~lv oi ky`ciq ihia%
gld Pi ky`ci viyqi` bd` abq oi `iag`gdc zli lzivyvdgdc b $9> eghhgld ziv%
`ga bcbgdq oi albh ale~bdw 23 Gd 6>>7 oi YQ Qy~viei Alyv vyhi` oi ky`ciqolyh` obzi viayqi` ogeqih Pi alyv dli` ob oi ixiaygziq aldvgfygld
sbq ovii geiq elvi obd oi q~id`gdc fw oi kyqgaiq lsd abe~bgcd Pi YQ
Qy~viei Alyv qbi`( Kyq bq dl ebd gq bhhlsi` l fi b ky`ci gd ogq lsd abyqi(
qgeghbv ibvq l fgbq abd bvgqi soid b ebd aollqiq oi ky`ci gd ogq lsd abyqi2?
Izid ky`ciq bvi bhbvei` b oi cvlsgdc gdyidai l eldiw ld alyvq B 6>>6
qyvziw lyd` ob ?0 ~ivaid l qbi ky`ciq bvi aldaivdi` bfly gdiviq cvly~q
q~id`gdc eldiw ld ky`gagbh abe~bgcdq27 Pi Sgqaldqgd Qy~viei Alyv viaidhw
sbvdi` l bd gdoivid vgqm ob oi ~yfhga ebw gdbaayvbihw ~ivaigzi b kyqgai bq
fiolh`id l gd`gzg`ybhq lv cvly~q ob aldvgfyi l ogq lv oiv abe~bgcd6> Kyqgai
^byh ^igiv( b Vi~yfhgabd ld oi Logl Qy~viei Alyv( obq avggag{i` oi eldiw
lsgdc gdl ogq qbiq ky`gagbh abe~bgcdq Izivwldi gdiviqi` gd aldvgfy%
gdc obq zivw q~iaga gdiviqq( ^igiv qbg` Piw eibd l fi fywgdc b zli
soioiv oiw qyaaii` lv dl( gq obv` l qbw62
Filvi oi ll` l alv~lvbi eldiw ficbd( ei`gb vi~lvq layqi` ld ky`ciq
figdc gdyidai` fw abe~bgcd `ldbgldq vle vgbh hbswivq sgo abqiq ~id`gdc
filvi oie66 Alv~lvbi gdiviqq sivi aldaivdi` ob ldbgldq vle vgbh hbs%
wivq viqyhi` gd alyvq ob bzlvi` gd`gzg`ybhq qygdc alv~lvbgldq Fyqgdiqqiq obsivi oi viryid bvci l hbsqygq( qyao bq gdqyvbdai bd` lfbaal ale~bdgiq(
~yqoi` hicgqhbgld l hgeg hggcbgld61 Pgq ~oidleidld bhql q~yvvi` fgc fyqgdiqq
l idiv oi vbw l ky`gagbh ~lhggaq60
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
19/128
Fgc Fyqgdiqq Pbmgdc lziv Qpbpi Qy~viei Alyvpq sssbeivgabd~vlcviqql
Bq ogq vi~lv qolsq( ogq ilv obq fiid zivw qyaaiqqyh Izid g oi ~vbagai l vgbh
hbswivq `ldbgdc l ky`gagbh abe~bgcd l gdyidai ky`ciq sbq b ~vlfhie( oi alv%
~lvbi gdiviqq obzi elvi obd ale~idqbi` lv bdw ~ivaigzi` gqb`zbdbci oiw
bai` @ldbgldq vle alv~lvbi Beivgab bvi dls lzivsoihegdc `ldbgldq vle
vgbh hbswivq( hbflv ydgldq( bd` cvly~q ob qy~~lv ~vlcviqqgzi ky`gagbh abd`g`biq69
Qlei ~viqq vi~lvq bd` bab`iega qy`giq ld ogq qyfkia ie~obqg{i ob b alv%
vihbgld fisiid `ldbgldq bd` b ky`ciq vyhgdcq `liq dl diaiqqbvghw ~vlzi ob
oi `ldbgldq abyqi` oi ky`ci l vyhi b aivbgd sbw Jlveiv Logl Aogi Kyqgai
Plebq Elwiv( b qy~~lviv l ~yfhga dbdagdc bd` lyco viayqbh vyhiq( qycciqi`
ob gdiviq cvly~q `ldbi fbqi` ld zlgdc ~bpivdq l oi ky`ciq( dl l gdy%
idai b zli gd b ~bvgayhbv abqi6: Gd loiv slv`q( qlei bvcyi q~iagbh gdiviqq bvi
`ldbgdc l lfbgd b ky`ci sgo b aivbgd ~oghlql~ow( dl b viqyh gd b ~bvgayhbv
abqi Pgq `gqgdagld( olsiziv( egqqiq oi ~lgd
Sibhow q~iagbh gdiviqq qolyh` dl fi bfhi l qob~i oi hbs( soioiv ovlycofywgdc b zli lv fywgdc b aivbgd ky`gagbh ~oghlql~ow Gd oi ~bciq ob lhhls( oi
vi~lv `ibghq ols ogq gq ob~~idgdc gd qgx ge~lvbd qbiq bd` ~viqidq b is via%
leeid`bgldq l b``viqq ogq ~vlfhie l ~vizid oi b~~ibvbdai l alvvy~gld(
qbiq abd ge~hieid qvldc viayqbh vyhiq l idqyvi ~bvgiq filvi oi alyv `l dl
`ldbi eldiw l ky`gagbh abe~bgcdq l gdyidai q~iaga abqiq Qbi hicgqhbyviq
bhql qolyh` ~bqq qvldc `gqahlqyvi vyhiq( ql ob agg{idq mdls sol gq yd`gdc
~lhggabh b`q lv ky`ciq
Fgc fyqgdiqq gq gcoidgdc gq cvg~ ld lyv alyvq Gdqib` l qivzgdc bq b hbq viqlv
lv Beivgabdq qiimgdc kyqgai( ky`ciq bvi fid`gdc oi hbs l qbgqw oi aldaivdq l
oigv alv~lvbi `ldlvq
Bhbfbeb
Aldqyeivq mgami` lyp lj alyvp fw qpbpi ky`ciq jyd`i` fw fgc fyqgdiqq
Gd Ebw 6>>7 Mgefivhw Sogi flvvlsi` $2(3>> vle Bhbfbeb ghi Hlbdq( liv%gdc oiv abv bq alhhbivbh Qoi eb`i sl gdiviq ~bweidqoi irygzbhid l b
1>> ~ivaid bddybh gdiviq vbiibao gei qoi vlhhi` lziv oi eldohw hlbd
Qoi oid ~bg` l oi hlbd bd` cl oiv ghi fbam Bhbfbeb ghi Hlbdq dizivoi%
hiqq vi~lqqiqqi` oiv abv b is eldoq hbiv Bq qoi obd`i` oi ls%vyam `vgziv
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
20/128
20 Aidpiv lv Beivgabd vlcviqq Abe~bgcd Jgdbdai Hbsq Jbgh bq Alv~lvbpi Eldiw Jhll`q Ky`gagbh Vbaiq
oi `layeidbgld l oiv vi~bweid( qoi ahbgeq oi ~yqoi` oi cbq bd` dibvhw vbd
lziv oiv Qoi cvbffi` oi `llv l oi vyam( bd` b ~bqqidciv bhhici`hw ~yhhi` oiv
gdqg`i( lvagdc oiv gdl oi fbamqib Qoi qyi` oi `vgziv bd` oi hid`iv lv bqqbyh
bd` svldcyh vi~lqqiqqgld Sogi ~vl`yai` izg`idai qycciqgdc oi hid`iv
lvci` oiv qgcdbyvi ld b hlbd bcviieid63
Sogi sghh diziv qii oiv `bw gd alyv Gd Kyhw 6>22 oi Bhbfbeb Qy~viei Alyv
vizivqi` oi vgbh alyvq bd` oih` ob bd bvfgvbgld ahbyqi gd oiv aldvbaq sgo
oi hid`iv viebgdi` gd iia( izid bjiv oi hlbd sbq ~bg` l6? Sogi sbq lvai`
l bvfgvbi oiv ahbgeq
Pi Bhbfbeb ky`gagbvw obq fialei b avyagbh fbphicvlyd` gd b ~lhggabh sbv
fisiid fgc fyqgdiqq bd` aldqyeivq Fgc fyqgdiqq gq sgddgdc( bd` lv`gdbvw
agg{idq hgmi Sogi bvi oi abqybhgiq Pi `bb gd oi B~~id`gx gdahy`i 31 vyhgdcq
vle 277? l 6>2> gd sogao oi Bhbfbeb Qy~viei Alyv vyhi` ld soioiv l
ale~ih bvfgvbgld Gd 96 l olqi abqiq( oi alyv qg`i` sgo `iid`bdq qiimgdcl ale~ih bvfgvbgld Fgd`gdc bvfgvbgld ahbyqiq obzi ~vlhgivbi` gd aldqyeiv
vbdqbagldq Bdwldi sol lsdq b aihh ~oldi( avi`g abv`( lv b olei obq bhelq
aivbgdhw qgcdi` b aldvba sgo qyao b ahbyqi67
@yi l b rygvm gd Bhbfbeb hbs( b `gq~vl~lvgldbi dyefiv l oi alyvq bvfgvb%
gld abqiq gdzlhzi fywivq l yqi` abvq bd` ebdybayvi` oleiq /vbghivq'1> Pi
yqi l bvfgvbgld ahbyqiq gd oiqi vbdqbagldq obq ix~hl`i` Qgdai 6>>>( soid
byl `ibhivq bd` elfghi olei ebdybayvivq `ldbi` $:>>(>>> l ky`gagbh
abd`g`biq(12 oiqi gdiviq cvly~q obzi q~id bd idlvelyq belyd l eldiw ld
Bhbfbebq ky`gagbh vbaiq Pi qbei ky`ciq sol viaigzi` ogq eldiw obzi zli` l
hgeg aldqyeivq vgco l b kyvw vgbh
Ebdw bvcyi ob bvfgvbgld gq gdoividhw fgbqi` lsbv` alv~lvbi `iid`bdq(
fiabyqi oi bvfgvblvq `l dl ci ~bg` ydhiqq alv~lvbgldq aollqi l yqi oigv
qivzgaiq16 B qy`w l ldi gqavi`gi` bvfgvbgld veq iagqgldq gd Abhglvdgb
vizibhi` ob g vyhi` bcbgdq aldqyeivq gd 70 ~ivaid l gq abqiq11 Alv~lvbgldq(
sogao yqybhhw bzlv bvfgvbgld lziv hggcbgld gd aldqyeiv abqiq(10 obzi q~id
idlvelyq qyeq l eldiw l ihia ~vl%alv~lvbi ky`ciq l oi Bhbfbeb Qy~viei
Alyv( bd` oiw obzi yd`lyfi`hw fidii` vle oi alyvq gdavibqgdc sghhgdc%diqq l lvai aldqyeivq gdl bvfgvbgld
Ihiagldq lv oi Bhbfbeb Qy~viei Alyv obzi fiid lzivvyd fw eldiw vle
alv~lvbi ~lhggabh bagld aleegpiiq( oi Bhbfbeb bhgbi l oi YQ Aobefiv l
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
21/128
Fgc Fyqgdiqq Pbmgdc lziv Qpbpi Qy~viei Alyvpq sssbeivgabd~vlcviqql
Aleeivai( bd` alv~lvbi%yd`i` cvly~q qy~~lvgdc lv vilve Gd viaid wibvq
oiqi ihiagldq obzi fiid beldc oi elq ix~idqgzi gd oi alydvw B b gei soid
Bhbfbebq ~iv ab~gb gdalei sbq $1>(>>>(19 abd`g`biq gd oi 6>>: vbai q~id $219
eghhgld1: Pb cyvi belydq l dibvhw obh l bhh oi eldiw q~id ld ogco alyv
vbaiq dbgldsg`i gd 6>>:13 Gd oi elq viaid ihiagld( eldiw vle Bhbfbebq
Aobefiv l Aleeivai aldqgyi` 0> ~ivaid l bhh abe~bgcd aldvgfygldq1?
Sgo ldi ixai~gld(17 oi Bhbfbeb Qy~viei Alyv gq dls ale~lqi` idgvihw l
ky`ciq solqi abe~bgcdq sivi yd`i` fw fgc fyqgdiqq( bd` oi alyv gq gdavibq%
gdchw gdahgdi` l vyhi lv ~lsivyh fyqgdiqqiq lziv lv`gdbvw agg{idq0> Bhbfbeb
alyvq ldai ob` b vi~ybgld lv viqgqgdc bvfgvbgld bd` qgamgdc y~ lv aldqye%
ivq Pi YQ Qy~viei Alyv( qbvgdc gd oi 27?>q( ix~bd`i` oi qal~i l oi
Ji`ivbh Bvfgvbgld Ba l virygvi qbi alyvq l oldlv bvfgvbgld ahbyqiq02 Pi
YQ Qy~viei Alyv vi~ibi`hw ovis ly qbi aldqyeiv ~vliagld hbsq ob
hgegi` oi vibao l bvfgvbgld ahbyqiq06 Pi Bhbfbeb ogco alyv viqgqi` oiqi
ilvq lv wibvq( hib`gdc oi YQ Qy~viei Alyv l lzivvyhi g sgai01
Pi alv~lvbi eldiw qbvi` lsgdc l oi Bhbfbeb ky`gagbvw gd oi eg`%277>q(
soid Mbvh Vlzi lvaoiqvbi` oi abe~bgcdq l qizivbh ky`gagbh abd g`biq00
Abd`g`biq gd oi 6>>> vbai q~id bd bqldgqogdc $26 eghhgld( bv elvi obd bdw loiv
qbi Pi Bhbfbeb aob~iv l oi Aobefiv l Aleeivai `ldbi` $23 eghhgld l oi
~vl%alv~lvbi abd`g`biq09 B qy`w l oi alyvq `iagqgldq fisiid 2779 bd` 2777
aldahy`i` ob( bjiv aldqivzbgziq lfbgdi` b ebklvgw gd 277?( bvfgvbgld hbs ficbd
l gh qobv~hw bcbgdq aldqyeivq Pi qy`w lyd` b viebvmbfhw ahlqi alvvihbgld
fisiid b kyqgaiq zliq gd bzlv l bvfgvbgld bd` abe~bgcd `ldbgldq vle fgc fyqg%
diqq0: Pi alyv gd 6>>> bfvy~hw vizivqi` alyvqi ld oi gqqyi l soioiv b sbvvbdw
ahbge yd`iv b i`ivbh qbyi gq qyfkia l bvfgvbgld03 Pi alyv bhql hlsivi` oi
qbd`bv` lv ~vlzgdc ob b aldqyeiv bcvii` l bvfgvbgld0?
Ky cgdc fw oi ogco alyvq viaid bvfgvbgld abqiq( g gq obv` l idw ob alv~lvbi
abe~bgcd aldvgfygldq obzi fiid b cll` gdziqeid Gd oi hbq sl wibvq( oi
alyvq `lami obq gdahy`i` 21 abqiq gd sogao g vizgisi` b hlsiv alyvq `iagqgld ld
qid`gdc b abqi l bvfgvbgld( bd` g obq ldhw vyhi` l vikia bvfgvbgld lyv geiq07
Fw ix~bd`gdc oi vibao l ebd`blvw bvfgvbgld ahbyqiq( oi alyv obq ahlqi` oialyvolyqi `llvq l elvi bd` elvi aldqyeivq Plebq Migo( aldqyeiv b`zlabaw
`gvialv lv Bhbfbeb Hicbh Qivzgaiq( qbg` fgd`gdc bvfgvbgld gq ivvgfhi lv aldqye%
ivq Pi vid` lsbv` bvfgvbgld obq eb`i g obv`iv lv aldqyeivq l d` hicbh oih~
Piviq dl b ~vgzbi hbswiv gd lsd ob sghh bmi b yqi` abv abqi( Migo qbg`9>
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
22/128
2: Aidpiv lv Beivgabd vlcviqq Abe~bgcd Jgdbdai Hbsq Jbgh bq Alv~lvbpi Eldiw Jhll`q Ky`gagbh Vbaiq
Pi byl `ibhivq bvi bhvib`w kye~gdc gd l qy~~lv abd`g`biq gd ogq wibvq
ky`gagbh ihiagld( obzgdc aldvgfyi` elvi l ldi kyqgai obd bdw loiv cvly~ l
`ldlvq92 Aogi Kyqgai Aobvhiq Ebhldi viaigzi` eldiw vle byl `ibhivq soghi
aldqg`ivgdc b abqi gd sogao oi alyv yhgebihw cvbdi` bd bvfgvblv fvlb`
byolvgw l `iag`i soioiv b zbhg` bvfgvbgld bcviieid izid ixgqi`96 Pi
`gqqidgdc ky`ci bvcyi` oivi sbq dl hicbh fbqgq lv oi `iagqgld Pi ebklv%gw l~gdgld sbq svgpid fw Ebhldi( sol viaigzi` $19(>>> vle oi byl `ibhiv
^BAq lv ogq viaid ~vgebvw abe~bgcd91 Ebhldi id`i` y~ hlqgdc oi ~vgebvw
ihiagld l b qlagbhhw aldqivzbgzi ky`ci90
Loiv ky`ciq obzi gqqyi` qgeghbv sbvdgdcq bfly oi YQ Qy~viei Alyvq fvlb`
gdiv~vibgld l oi Ji`ivbh Bvfgvbgld Ba Gd b 2770 aldayvvidai Eldbdb
Qy~viei Alyv Kyqgai ivvw vgisgihiv qbg` i`ivbh ky`ciq ~viividai lv bvfgvb%
gld bq b viei`w lv avls`i` lamiq ieldqvbiq b lbh hbam l aldqg`iv%
bgld lv oi vgcoq l gd`gzg`ybhq vgisgihiv qbg` oi fvlb` gdiv~vibgldq l
oi Ji`ivbh Bvfgvbgld Ba ~iveg b is ebklv alv~lvbgldq l `vbj aldvbaqvicbv`gdc oigv vihbgldqog~ sgo loivq ob geeydg{iq oie vle baalydbfgh%
gw yd`iv oi hbsq l oi qbiq soivi oiw `l fyqgdiqq99 Aldqyeiv b`zlabi
^byh Fhbd` qbwq oi gdavibqgdc yqi l bvfgvbgld fidiq oi sibhogiq bd` elq
~lsivyh gd lyv qlagiw9: Pi elzi lsbv`q bvfgvbgld gq b elzi lsbv`q bd
ialdlew ob qbvq l viqiefhi Pi Oydciv Cbeiq( Fhbd` qbg`93
Pi Bhbfbeb Qy~viei Alyvq viaid bvfgvbgld `iagqgldq obzi eb`i g obv`iv lv
aldqyeivq l olh` baalydbfhi ~bw`bw hid`ivq( yqi` abv `ibhivq( bd` loiv ydqavy~y%
hlyq fyqgdiqqiq Pi ge~ba gq cvibiq ld hls%gdalei aldqyeivq bd` hiqq%i`yabi`
agg{idq sol egco dl yd`ivqbd` oi di ~vgd B 6>>? qyvziw vizibhi` ob 0?
~ivaid l hls%gdalei Bhbfbebdq qyvziwi` qbg` oiw ix~ivgidai` b hicbh ~vlfhie gd
oi ~bq wibv( bd` dibvhw obh l olqi hicbh ~vlfhieq gdzlhzi` aldqyeiv gqqyiq 9?
Piqi qbei agg{idq( olsiziv( bvi dls b b vibh `gqb`zbdbci gd Bhbfbeb alyvq
Ale~bdgiq ob vg~ l aldqyeivq obzi idlvelyq belydq l eldiw l q~id`
gdyidagdc oi ky`gagbvw Bhbfbebdq abd ldhw ol~i qbi hicgqhblvq sghh ayvf
oi gdyidai l eldiw ld ky`gagbh ihiagldq Ji`ivbh vicyhblvq alyh` qlld fbd
bvfgvbgld ahbyqiq gd qlei aldvbaq97 Ydgh oid( Bhbfbeb aldqyeivq abd ix~ia
hgphi ~vliagld vle oigv ky`gagbh qwqie
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
23/128
Fgc Fyqgdiqq Pbmgdc lziv Qpbpi Qy~viei Alyvpq sssbeivgabd~vlcviqql
Pixbq
Alyvp qogih`q lgh ale~bdw `ldlvq jvle hgbfghgpw jlv slvmiv gdkyvgiq
Soid Klqi Oivvivb bvvgzi` lv slvm b oi Agcl vidivw gd Alv~yq Aovgqg ld
Jifvybvw 66( 6>>?( oi ob` dl g`ib g slyh` fi ogq hbq `bw ld oi klf Oivvivb
qyivi` b olvvga baag`id Oi sbq vb~~i` gd b qbiw obvdiqq soghi 99>%`icvii
~ivlhiye ~lyvi` bhh lziv ogq fl`w lv qizivbh egdyiq:> Oivvivb qyvzgzi` sgo
qizivi fyvdq bd` ~ivebdid gdkyvgiq Ogq sgi qbi`( Si abd oyc oge fiabyqi
oi oyvq bhh lziv oi abd oyc ei lv oyc ew hgphi flw:2 Fy fiabyqi l b viaid
ixbq Qy~viei Alyv vyhgdc( oi abddl qyi ogq ie~hlwiv lv dichgcidai
Bjiv viaigzgdc eghhgldq gd abe~bgcd abqo vle oi lgh gd`yqvw( oi kyqgaiq ld
oi ixbq Qy~viei Alyv vyhi` ob aldvba ie~hlwiiq abddl qyi oigv ie~hlw%
ivq lv ld%oi%klf gdkyvgiq Pigv viei`giq bvi hgegi` l slvmivq ale~idqbgld
Oivvivb qbwq slvmivq ale~idqbgld ldhw livq( b elq( b is olyqbd` `lhhbvq
~iv eldo Ogq ei`gabh fghhq bhldi ixaii`i` $6>>(>>> gd oi ovii wibvq bjiv oi
baag`id( bd` Oivvivb sghh viaigzi dl ale~idqbgld lv oi ydgebcgdbfhi belydl ~bgd oi obq id`yvi`:6
Pi lgh gd`yqvw ebmiq sg`iq~vib` yqi l aldvba slvmivq(:1 bd` g q~id wibvq
hlffwgdc oi qbi hicgqhbyvi l gdahy`i aldvba ie~hlwiiq gd oi slvmivq
Pl~ q~id`ivq( 6>>>>7Abd`g`bpi
aldpvgfypgldq
Gd`i~id`idp
ix~id`gpyviqPlpbh
Bhbfbeb @ielavbpga bvpw $9(0:>(223 $> $9(0:>(223
Fyqgdiqq Alydagh lj Bhbfbeb $0(:11(910 $> $0(:11(910
Bhbfbeb Agzgh Kyqpgai Vijlve Aleegppii $6(030(0>9 $660(::1 $6(:77(9:?
Beivgabd Pbx~bwivq Bhhgbdai $> $2(113(600 $2(113(600
Hbsqygp Vijlve ^BA lj Bhbfbeb $2(162(69> $> $2(162(69>
> $6(>>>(>>> $0(>>>(>>> $:(>>>(>>> $?(>>>(>>> $2>(>>>(>>>
$7(772(97:
$9(0:>(223
Qlyvai; opp~;,,fviddbd1a`ddip,`>72`a722f`:331f\>7e:wz~cz~`^vl%gd`gzg`ybh ^vl%alv~lvbpi
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
24/128
2? Aidpiv lv Beivgabd vlcviqq Abe~bgcd Jgdbdai Hbsq Jbgh bq Alv~lvbpi Eldiw Jhll`q Ky`gagbh Vbaiq
ale~idqbgld qwqie( sogao ~ivegq ie~hlwivq l gdqyhbi oieqihziq vle
hgbfghgw lv ld%oi%klf gdkyvgiq fw ~yvaobqgdc slvmivq ale~idqbgld gdqyvbdai
Pi hicgqhbyvi zli` l vikia ogq g`ib qizivbh geiq:0 Pi ixbq Qy~viei Alyv(
gd b 6>>3 abqi( cbzi oi gd`yqvw sob oi hicgqhbyvi slyh` dl( olh`gdc ob
aldvba ie~hlwiiq bvi alzivi` fw slvmivq
ale~idqbgld:9
Gd oi qgx wibvq filvi oi `iagqgld( oi kyqgaiq
ob` baai~i` elvi obd $3>>(>>> vle idivcw
ale~bdgiq:: Kyqgai @ld Sghhip( oi byolv
l oi l~gdgld( ob` viaigzi` bhelq $6>>(>>>
vle oi gd`yqvw( elvi obd bdw loiv kyqgai:3
Piqi abe~bgcd ldbgldq ebw obzi fiid
sihh slvo g( cgzid oi eldiw oiqi ale~b%
dgiq alyh` qbzi gd qiphieidq sgo gdkyvi`
ie~hlwiiq
Pi lgh%bd`%cbq gd`yqvw ie~hlwq ebdw ~il~hi
gd ixbq( bd` g gq beldc oi hbvciq `ldlvq l
abd`g`biq lv oi ixbq Qy~viei Alyv Gd viaid wibvq oi alyvq `iagqgldq
obzi bzlvi` ie~hlwivq lziv gdkyvi` ie~hlwiiq Pi B~~id`gx l ogq vi~lv
gdahy`iq 2? abqiq gd sogao bd gdkyvi` ie~hlwii qyi` ogq ie~hlwiv lv gq gdqyviv
lv gdkyvgiq qyqbgdi` ld oi klf( bd` oi alyv vyhi` lv oi ie~hlwiv gd 20 l
olqi abqiq:?
Pi 6>>3 `iagqgld ld aldvba ie~hlwiiq sbq obvqohw avggag{i` lv ix~bd`gdc
oi hbs gd b ebddiv ob sbq vi~ibi`hw vikiai` fw oi hicgqhbyvi Pi ogco
alyv( vihidgdc l ~yfhga ~viqqyvi( vioibv` oi abqi fy vibaoi` oi qbei ald%
ahyqgld:7 B `gqqidgdc ky`ci aobvci` oi ebklvgw sgo ebmgdc b ~lhgaw aolgai
si bvi dl b hgfivw l ebmi
Pi alyv bai` qgeghbv avggagqe gd b `gqqid vle b viaid abqi bflhgqogdc b ale%
eld hbs ahbge lv gdkyvi` slvmivq Gd 27?? oi ogco alyv iqbfhgqoi` b ahbge
ob bhhlsi` gdkyvi` slvmivq l qyi gdqyvbdai ale~bdgiq lv ydkyqgbfhw viyq%
gdc l ~bw ahbgeq3>
Pi hicgqhbyvi lzivobyhi` oi slvmivq ale~idqbgld qwqieoi dix wibv bd` g aldqg`ivi` bflhgqogdc oi ahbge fy aolqi l b`l~ loiv
vilveq gdqib` Pi alyv dizivoihiqq vyhi` ob oi vilveq eb`i oi aleeld
hbs ahbge yddiaiqqbvw( bd` oi `gqqid aobvci` oi ebklvgw sgo vi~hbagdc oi
Hicgqhbyviq ky`ceid sgo gq lsd32
BQQLAGBPI@ ^VIQQ ^OLPL,KBAM ^HYDMIPP
Klqi Oivvivb( b fyvdi` qyvzgzlvl poi Jifvybvw 6>>? Agpcl avy`ilgh fhbqp gd Alv~yq Aovgqp g( Pixbq(bppid`q b Ab~gplh ~viqq aldividaild hgbfghgpw hbsqygpq ld B~vgh 6?(6>>? Oivvivb idalyvbci` hbsebm%ivq pl yd`l b Pixbq Qy~viei Alyvpvyhgdc pobp alyh` ~vizidp gdkyvi`slvmivq vle hgdc hbsqygpq
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
25/128
Fgc Fyqgdiqq Pbmgdc lziv Qpbpi Qy~viei Alyvpq sssbeivgabd~vlcviqql
Pi alyv gd 6>>? sbq bai` sgo b hbsqyg gdzlhzgdc ow`vbyhga vbayvgdc( lv vbam%
gdc Soghi oi ebklvgw `iahgdi` l vyhi ld soioiv vbamgdc abd cgzi vgqi l b viq%
~bqq hbsqyg( Kyqgai Sghhipq aldayvvgdc l~gdgld gdzlmi` ~lhgaw vibqldq lv gdqgqgdc
oi alyv qolyh` obzi ale~hiihw lviahlqi` b vgco l qyi lv vbamgdc Lyv bq%
cvlsgdc Qbi aldvldq bq%cvlsgdc idivcw dii`q( bd` ixbq abd ghh blv` gq dgi
viqlyvaiq( lv gq hbs( l viebgd qyam gd oi cvlyd`( Sghhip qbi` L~id%id`i`hgbfghgw ovibidq l gdga cvbzi bd` ydeggcbfhi obve( idqyvgdc ob eyao l lyv
Qbiq yd`izihl~i` idivcw qy~~hgiq slyh` qbw ob sbwyd`izihl~i`36
Pi ixbq Qy~viei Alyv obq b ogqlvw l abe~bgcd abqo qabd`bhq Gd oi hbi 27?>q
b :> Egdyiq disq qiceidKyqgai lv Qbhiavggag{i` oi kyqgaiq baai~bdai
l abe~bgcd yd`q vle ~hbgdgq vgbh hbswivq sgo abqiq filvi oi alyv Alv~lvbi
gdiviqq lvcbdg{i` gd oi sbmi l oi qabd`bh bd` fw oi eg`%277>q oi alyv sbq
`legdbi` fw ky`ciq yd`i` fw fgc fyqgdiqq( hlffwgqq( bd` alv~lvbi hbswivq31 B
qy`w l oiqi kyqgaiq zlgdc fiobzglvq lyd` ob oiw bzlvi` alv~lvbi `iid`bdq
gd hbsqygq bcbgdq oie( fy ~hbgdgq alyh` ge~vlzi oigv hyam sgo oi alyv fw`ldbgdc l oi kyqgaiq abe~bgcdq Pi qy`w lyd` oi qyaaiqq vbi lv ~hbgdgq
aldvgfygdc eldiw sbq elvi obd `lyfhi oi qyaaiqq vbi lv ~hbgdgq gd cidivbh30
Ldi l oi kyqgaiq vle ob ivb( ^vgqaghhb Lsid( sbq dlegdbi` l oi Jgjo
Agvayg fw ^viqg`id Cilvci S Fyqo gd 6>>9( fvgdcgdc l hgco qlei ydqiiehw
abe~bgcd aldvgfygldq Bjiv oiv abe~bgcd baai~i` idq l olyqbd`q l `lhhbvq
gd `ldbgldq vle oi lveivhw ogco%wgdc Idvld Alv~( Lsid svli bd l~gdgld
ob vi`yai` oi alv~lvbgldq bxiq bd` `idgi` b hlabh qaollh `gqvga b``ggldbh
vizidyi39 Idvld sbq zivw cidivlyq l ~vl%alv~lvbi abd`g`biq lv oi ogco
alyv( `ldbgdc oyd`vi`q l olyqbd`q l `lhhbvq gd oi eg`%277>q @yvgdc ogq
~ivgl` oi alyv baai~i` sl ly l ovii ~iggldq vle Idvld( vyhgdc gd gq bzlv
flo geiq(3: bd` vikiai` bhh ovii ~iggldq vle ~bvgiq l~~lqgdc oi ale~bdw33
Bjiv Idvld sid fbdmvy~ gd 6>>2 bd` qizivbh l gq ixiaygziq sivi qididai` l
kbgh gei( loiv idivcw alv~lvbgldq ~gami` y~ soivi g hij l Lgh%bd`%cbq ale%
~bdgiq( bq sihh bq oi hbs veq ob vi~viqid oie( bvi beldc oi hbvciq `ldlvq
l oi ixbq Qy~viei Alyv Pi alyv zivw vbvihw vyhiq bcbgdq gq fidibalvq
Pi `bb gd oi B~~id`gx gdahy`iq igco abqiq gd sogao oi dbei` `iid`bd gq bd
idivcw ale~bdw( bd` oi alyv vyhi` lv oi `iid`bdq gd bhh l olqi abqiq3?
Piie~hlwiiq l oiqi ale~bdgiq slvm gd `bdcivlyq qipgdcq( gd ahlqi ~vlxgegw l
alefyqgfhi ebivgbhq G oiw bvi gdkyvi`( oiw sghh obzi b obv` gei olh`gdc oigv
ie~hlwivq baalydbfhi gd alyvq sgo ahlqi giq l lgh ale~bdgiq37
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
26/128
6> Aidpiv lv Beivgabd vlcviqq Abe~bgcd Jgdbdai Hbsq Jbgh bq Alv~lvbpi Eldiw Jhll`q Ky`gagbh Vbaiq
Logl
Gdqyvivq pbmi dl vgqmq sgpo qpbpi qy~viei alyvp
Logl obq qiid qlei l oi elq ix~idqgzi ky`gagbh vbaiq gd oi alydvw( sgo ogco
alyv abd`g`biq vbgqgdc elvi obd $69 eghhgld vle 6>>> l 6>2> Pi qyvci gd
`ldbgldq sbq yihi` fw eldiw vle alv~lvbgldq bd` gdqyvbdai ale~bdgiq Bq
oi eldiw lsi` gd( oi alyv bfvy~hw vizivqi` alyvqi ld b vbdci l gqqyiq l
vyhi gd bzlv l fgc fyqgdiqq PiDis Wlvm geiq ~yfhgqoi` bd bvgahi gd 6>>: ld
oi alyvq id`idaw l vyhi gd bzlv l abe~bgcd aldvgfylvq Pi disq~b~iv
ale~bvi` abqiq gqqyi` fisiid 2770 bd` 6>>: sgo gdiviq cvly~q `ldbgdc l
oi ky`ciq abe~bgcdq Pi bvgahi aldahy`i` ob oi kyqgaiq zli` gd bzlv l
aldvgfylvq 3> ~ivaid l oi gei( sgo ldi ky`ci( Kyqgai ivvidai L@lddihh(
zlgdc lv ogq aldvgfylvq gd 72 ~ivaid l oi abqiq?> Soid ky`ciq zli gd bzlv
l `ldlvq( agg{idq sgoly eldiw l `ldbi bai b vibh `gqb`zbdbci gd alyv
Pi gdqyvbdai gd`yqvw ficbd cgzgdc cidivlyqhw l ~vl%alv~lvbi abd`g`biq
bjiv qizivbh vyhgdcq bcbgdq gdqyvbdai ale~bdgiq gd oi hbi 277>q(?2
gdahy`gdc b2777 `iagqgld ob ix~bd`i` ie~hlwivq ydgdqyvi` ellvgq alzivbci l gdahy`i
ie~hlwiiq sol sivi dl ld oi klf?6 Logl ky`gagbh ihiagldq ob` hldc fiid
beldc oi elq ix~idqgzi gd oi alydvw( fy flo oi 6>>6 bd` 6>>0 vbaiq qbs
abd`g`biq q~id`gdc $: eghhgld`lyfhi oi belyd q~id gd oi 6>>> ihiagld?1
Pl~ q~id`ivq( 6>>>>7Abd`g`bpi
aldpvgfypgldq
Gd`i~id`idp
ix~id`gpyviqPlpbh
Pixbq @ielavbpga ^bvpw $1:(>>> $7>0(73? $70>(73?
Zgdqld * Ihmgdq $0:3(3:? $> $0:3(3:?
Pixbdq jlv Hbsqygp Vijlve $6?0(>09 $> $6?0(>09
Obwdiq * Flldi $60?(0:0 $> $60?(0:0
Jyhfvgcop * Kbslvqmg $60>(?0? $> $60>(?0?
> $6>>(>>> $0>>(>>> $:>>(>>> $?>>(>>> $2(>>>(>>> $2(6>>(>>> $2(0>>(>>>
$70>(73?
$2(60>(?69
Qlyvai; opp~;,,fviddbd1a`ddip,`>72`a722f`:331f\>7e:wz~cz~ ^vl%gd`gzg`ybh ^vl%alv~lvbpi
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
27/128
Fgc Fyqgdiqq Pbmgdc lziv Qpbpi Qy~viei Alyvpq sssbeivgabd~vlcviqql
Gd 6>>0 oi gdqyvbdai gd`yqvw cbzi abd`g`biq lv oi Logl Qy~viei Alyv elvi
obd $:9>(>>> bd` `ldbi` bvlyd` $2 eghhgld l bd gd`i~id`id cvly~ vyddgdc
b`q ob oih~i` sl ~vl%alv~lvbi abd`g`biq sgd oigv qibq?0
Pi alyv gd 6>>1 lzivyvdi` oi 2777 `iagqgld ld ie~hlwivq ydgdqyvi` ellvgq
alzivbci ob q~yvvi` oi gdqyvbdai gd`yqvw l `ldbi l ky`gagbh abd`g`biq(?9
fyoi eldiwi` gdiviqq `g`d ql~ oivi Pi 6>>: abe~bgcdq l Kyqgaiq L@lddihh
bd` Vlfiv Ay~~ sivi bg`i` fw $21 eghhgld vle bd bhgbi l oi Logl Aobefiv
l Aleeivai?: Pi Logl Qy~viei Alyv gq dls `legdbi` fw ky`ciq ob bzlv
alv~lvbgldq bd` gdqyvbdai ale~bdgiq Pi `bb gd oi B~~id`gx gdahy`i 1: abqiq
vle 6>>1 l 6>2>( bd` oi ogco alyv vyhi` lv oi gdqyvbdai ale~bdgiq lv loiv
alv~lvbi `iid`bdq gd bhh fy lyv l oie?3 Qgdai oi alv~lvbi%yd`i` kyqgaiq
llm lziv( oi alyv obq bfvy~hw lzivvyhi` viaid ~viai`id l vyhi gd bzlv l gdqyv%
bdai ale~bdgiq Pi alyv gq b lyco zidyi lv gdkyvi` ~hbgdgq
Pi Fbvfii beghw l Hlvbgd Alydw( Logl( hibvdi` ob oi obv` sbw Pi beghwsbq b ~bvw l b 6>22 abqi qieegdc vle gdkyvgiq oiw qyivi` soghi ld zbab%
gld Pi Fbvfiiq sivi vbzihgdc ovlyco Sgqaldqgd soid sl abvq alhhg`i` soghi
vbzihgdc gd oi l~~lqgi `gviagld Pi abvq abviidi` lziv oi ei`gbd bd` qvyam
oi Fbvfiiq ziogahiq( mghhgdc ldi l oi loiv `vgzivq bd` qivglyqhw gdkyvgdc oi
Fbvfiiq Pi beghw qlyco l ahbge fidiq vle gq ydgdqyvi` ellvgq ~lhgaw
sgo Dbgldsg`i Gdqyvbdai Pi Fbvfiiq vq qyi` oi loiv `vgzivq bd` vialzivi`
1> ~ivaid l oigv hlqqiq Pigv ~lhgaw qbg` Dbgldsg`i slyh` dl ~bw bdw ahbgeq
ydgh loiv gdqyvbdai ~bweidq sivi ixobyqi`( ql oi Fbvfiiq `g` dl hi bd
ydgdqyvi` ellvgq ahbge sgo Dbgldsg`i ydgh oi vq qyg aldahy`i`( olyco g
`g` dlgw oi ale~bdw l b ~lidgbh ahbge??
Pi Logl Qy~viei Alyv ovis ly oi Fbvfiiq hbsqyg( vihwgdc ld bdloiv
~vlzgqgld l oi gdqyvbdai ~lhgaw ob virygvi` ahbgebdq l fvgdc qyg sgogd ovii
wibvq Pi alyv qbg` oi sl ~vlzgqgldq `g` dl ebmi oi ~lhgaw befgcylyq B
`gqqidgdc ky`ci bvcyi` oi ovii%wibv `ib`hgdi qolyh` obzi fiid lhhi` soghi oi
loiv ahbgeq sivi ~yvqyi`; Gdqyvbdai ale~bdgiq bvi ixvieihw viqlyvaiyh b
alhhiagdc ~viegyeq bd` ixaii`gdchw vihyabd l ~bw ahbgeqizid soid bd baag%
`id gq mdlsd l oie bd` oi ahbge gq eivglvglyq?7 Dbgldsg`i obq aldvgf%
yi` elvi eldiw l oi 6>26 abd`g`biq obd bdw loiv `ldlv ql bv7>
Pi alyv obq gqqyi` qizivbh viaid `iagqgldq ob hgeg oi hgbfghgw l ie~hlwivq(
sogao bvi hgmihw l obzi bdw ky`ceidq bcbgdq oie ~bg fw gdqyvbdai ale~b%
dgiq Pi alyv gd 6>2> gqqyi` sl vyhgdcq ob qizivihw ayvbghi` oi vgco l
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
28/128
66 Aidpiv lv Beivgabd vlcviqq Abe~bgcd Jgdbdai Hbsq Jbgh bq Alv~lvbpi Eldiw Jhll`q Ky`gagbh Vbaiq
qyi bd ie~hlwiv lv ld%oi%klf gdkyvgiq72 Pi abqiq y~oih` b hbs qbwgdc ob bd
gdkyvi` ie~hlwii abd ldhw qyi g ogq lv oiv ie~hlwiv baybhhwgdid`i` l gdkyvi
oi ie~hlwii Pgq 6>>9 qbyi sbq oi hicgqhbyviq ogv` bpie~ l hgeg hbsqygq
bcbgdq ie~hlwivq gd ogq ebddiv( fy oi loiv sl qbyiq sivi vyhi` ydaldqg%
ygldbh Sgo b dis ~vl%gdqyvbdai hgdiy~ b oi
alyv( oi ogv` gei sbq oi aobve Kyqgai ^byh^igiv `gqqidi` bd` bvcyi` ob oi hicgqhb%
yviq ~vizglyq qbyiq bvi bq `gqgdcygqobfhi
vle oi ayvvid zivqgld bq b ~gc sgo hg~qgam gq
`gqgdcygqobfhi vle b ~gc sgoly76
Gd 6>>? oi Logl Qy~viei Alyv y~oih` b qb%
yi ob ovis ly b sg`lsq hbsqyg bcbgdq oiv
oyqfbd`q ie~hlwiv lv ogq `ibo vle bqfiqlq
~lgqldgdc Pi fghh b~~hgi` vivlbagzihw bd`
virygvi` aivbgd ei`gabh izg`idai( sogao sbqdl hldciv bzbghbfhi qgdai oi ie~hlwii sbq
`iaibqi` Pi Logl aldqgygld qbwq oi qbi
hicgqhbyvi qobhh obzi dl ~lsiv l ~bqq vivlba%
gzi hbsq( fy oi alyv y~oih` oi qbyi bdwsbw71 Pi `iid`bdq bd` oigv
bplvdiwq ldbi` elvi obd $69(>>> l Kyqgaiq Qvbpld bd` LAlddlv soghi oi
abqi sbq ~id`gdc70
^ivob~q oi elq vbqga ixbe~hi l oi bfvy~ qogj gd oi alyvq kyvgq~vy`idai sbq
b wlydc slebdq hbsqyg bcbgdq oi ebmivq l oi Lvol Izvb Fgvo Aldvlh ^bao
Pi ~hbgdg bhhici` oi vyc abyqi` fhll` ahlq( fy oi Logl Qy~viei Alyv hge%
gi` oi viei`w bzbghbfhi l oiv fw y~olh`gdc b lv vilve qbyi ob ab~~i` ~ydg%
gzi bd` dldialdlega `bebciq Pi 6>>9 qbyi sbq( gd oi alyvq slv`q( qgeghbv gd
hbdcybci bd` ~yv~lqi l ~vizglyq hbsq Pi loiv qbyiq ob` fiid ovlsd ly lv
zglhbgdc qizivbh ~vlzgqgldq l oi Logl aldqgygld( elq viaidhw gd 277779
Kyqgai ^igiv( gd `gqqid( qbg` oi ebklvgw ~bg` eivi hg~ qivzgai l oi vgco l
b kyvw vgbh( sogao gdahy`iq oi vgco l obzi b kyvw bqqiqq `bebciq Yd`iv ogq
alyvq vibqldgdc( oivi gq dlogdc gd oi Logl Aldqgygld l viqvbgd oi Cidivbh
Bqqiefhw vle hgeggdc dldialdlega bebciq l $2( ^igiv bvcyi` Oi b``i ;
G fihgizi ob oi Aldqgygld l Logl gq oi yd beidbh layeid ob ~vliaq
bhh Loglbdq( dl kyq olqi sgo oi elq hlffwgdc ~lsiv$ l`bw gq b bw l
yhhhi` ix~iabgldq lv gdqyvbdai ale~bdgiq bd` ebdybayvivq l `iiagzi( `bd%
BQQLAGBPI@ ^VIQQ ^OLPL,SGHH QOGHHGDC
Logl Kyqpgai ^byh ^igiv hgqpidqpl lvbh bvcyeidpq gd poi LoglQy~viei Alyvp gd Alhyefyq( Logl^igiv gq lpid poi hlbd `gqqidpivpl poi gdavibqgdchw ~vl%alv~lbvpi`iagqgldq l poi Logl Qy~vieiAlyvp
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
29/128
Fgc Fyqgdiqq Pbmgdc lziv Qpbpi Qy~viei Alyvpq sssbeivgabd~vlcviqql
civlyq( lv lxga ~vl`yaq ob abyqi gdkyvw l qleildi gd Logl$ Fy ogq gq b qb` `bw
lv lyv Aldqgygld bd` ogq alyv$ Bd ogq gq b vbcga `bw lv Loglbdq( sol dl
hldciv obzi bdw bqqyvbdai ob oigv Aldqgygld ~vliaq oi vgcoq oiw aoivgqo$7:
Gd viaid wibvq Kyqgai ^igiv obq ljid fiid oi hldi `gqqidiv l oi gdavibqgdchw
~vl%alv~lvbi `iagqgldq l oi Logl Qy~viei Alyv(73
bd` oi gq b qobv~ avgga loi qwqie ob fvlyco Loglbdq ogq alyv Gd oiDis Wlvm geiq ~giai( igiv
qbi`( G diziv ih ql eyao hgmi b ollmiv `lsd fw oi fyq qbgld gd bdw vbai Gzi
iziv fiid gd bq G `g` gd b ky`gagbh vbai 7?
Ky`ci Fghh LDighh obq ydqyaaiqqyhhw vyd lv b qib ld oi alyv qizivbh geiq( soghi
viyqgdc l vbgqi eldiw vle bdwldi; @l wly sbd wlyv abqi `iag`i` fw b ky`ci sol
llm oyd`vi`q l `lhhbvq vle oi l~~lqgdc hbswiv b b alambgh ~bvw> Ldi viaid abd`g`bi ~vl~lqi`ebd`blvw viayqbh vyhiq(2>2 fy oi hlq l Kyqgai LAlddlvq eghhgld%`lhhbv abe~bgcd
Dizb`b
Abqgdlq qpbam poi `iam gd qpbpi qy~viei alyvp
Pi abqgdl bd` lyvgqe gd`yqvgiq obzi hldc sgih`i` idlvelyq gdyidai gd
Dizb`bq qbi clzivdeid( bd` oi alyvq bvi dl ixai~gld Ale~bdgiq bhgbi`
sgo ECE Viqlvq Gdivdbgldbh obzi `ldbi` elvi obd $29>(>>> l oi ayv%
vid kyqgaiq lziv oi wibvq2>6 Abqgdlq bvi beldc oi fgcciq ~hbwivq gd b qwqie
oiHlq Bdcihiq geiq `iqavgfi` bq b cll`%lh`%flw ayhyvi l avldwgqe bd` aoye%
egdiqq ob baai~i` aldgaq l gdiviq bq fyqgdiqq bq yqybh Gd b 6>>: bvgahi
ld alvvy~gld gd Dizb`b alyvq( oi disq~b~iv dli` ob ldi ky`ci sbq mgami`
ly l lai bjiv oi iogaq aleegqqgld lyd` ob oi lh` bd bplvdiw ob oi
sbq %%%i` fiabyqi oi ob`d aldvgfyi` soghi loivq ob`2>1
Gd viaid wibvq oi abqgdl bd` lyvgqe gd`yqvgiq obzi qleigeiq lyd` oieqihziqgd alyv l co bpie~q l bx oie Pi qbi bai` b oyci fy`ci `iag gd 6>>1(
bd` fiabyqi l b aldqgygldbh virygvieid ob b qy~ivebklvgw /sl%ogv`q' l
oi qbi hicgqhbyvi b~~vlzi bdw gdavibqi gd bx vizidyi( oi qbi alyh` dl yd` gq
qaollhq Pi ogco alyv vyhi` oi qy~ivebklvgw virygvieid sbq vye~i` fw oi
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
30/128
60 Aidpiv lv Beivgabd vlcviqq Abe~bgcd Jgdbdai Hbsq Jbgh bq Alv~lvbpi Eldiw Jhll`q Ky`gagbh Vbaiq
hicgqhbyviq aldqgygldbh `yw l yd` qaollhq( bd` g bhhlsi` hicgqhblvq l b~~vlzi
b bx gdavibqi ld fgc fyqgdiqqiq bd` abqgdlq sgo bd lv`gdbvw ebklvgw zli2>0
Pi `iagqgld idcid`ivi` aldvlzivqw bq ebdw baayqi` oi alyv l gcdlvgdc oi
hicgqhbgzi virygvieidq hbg` ly gd oi qbi aldqgygld Aldqivzbgziq ovib%
idi` oi kyqgaiq sgo b viabhh ihiagld2>9
Q~id`gdc ld Dizb`b Qy~viei Alyvvbaiq qmwvlamii` Abd`g`biq gd 6>>0 q~id elvi obd $1 eghhgldovii geiq
oi belyd q~id gd oi ~vizglyq ihiagld2>: Gd 6>>: `ldbgldq vle abqgdlq
baalydi` lv $1>>(>>> l oi $6 eghhgld vbgqi`
fw abd`g`biq lv oi Dizb`b Qy~viei Alyv2>3
ECE abqgdlq cbzi oi abd`g`biq $26>(>>>
ob wibv2>? Bhelq bhh l oi kyqgaiq gdzlhzi`
gd oi 6>>1 `iagqgld( ebdw l sole ob` qivzi`
lv `iab`iq( sivi vi~hbai` fw 6>>: Pi dis
alyv rygihw lzivvyhi` oi 6>>1 `iagqgld bd`
vige~lqi` oi qy~ivebklvgw virygvieidlv bx gdavibqiq( izid soid g gdivivi` sgo
oi aldqgygldbh `yw l b`irybihw yd`
qaollhq2>7
Dizb`b agg{idq( vii vle oi hicgqhbyviq
qy~ivebklvgw virygvieid( obzi viaidhw q~ld%
qlvi` viivid`b ob slyh` cidivbi vizidyi
vle cbegdc( lyvgqe( bd` loiv qlyvaiq l yd` oi qbiq dichiai` i`yabgld
qwqie Gd 6>>? oi qbi qy~viei alyv ovis ly sl gdggbgziq ob slyh` obzi
vbdqivvi` eldiw vle ~vlelgdc lyvgqe l yd`gdc i`yabgld Pi alyv vyhi`
ob izid olyco ~vl~ldidq ob` vihgi` ld qgcdbyvi lveq ~vlzg`i` fw oi qbi(
oi lveq `g` dl gdahy`i qlei gdlvebgld virygvi` fw qbi hbs22> Pi alyv
bhql oih` ob qbi bxiq `l dl b~~hw l eibhq ob bvi ale~i` fw abqgdlq ydhiqq
oi ~bvldq cbzi qleiogdc lv oi eibhq222 Pgq `iagqgld sbq lzivvyhi` fw oi
qbi bx bcidaw( sogao lyd` ob ayqleivq alyh` ldhw viaigzi oi eibhq g oiw
q~id eldiw ld cbegdc( fy bd b~~ibh l oi qbi qy~viei alyv gq ix~iai`226
Abqgdl eldiw ficbd ~lyvgdc gdl Dizb`b Qy~viei Alyv ihiagldq bjiv oi 6>>1
`iagqgld bhhlsgdc b bx fghh l agvayezid oi qy~ivebklvgw virygvieid( bd` qgdaioid oi ogco alyv obq gqqyi` qizivbh `iagqgldq ob viqyh gd abqgdlq bzlg`gdc bxiq
ob slyh` yd` oi qbiq fvlmid i`yabgld qwqie Dizb`bq i`yabgld qwqie gq
~llvhw yd`i`(221 bd` gq bx qwqie gq ldi l oi elq vicviqqgzi gd oi dbgld220 Pi
^vlcviqqgzi Hib`ivqog~ Bhhgbdai l Dizb`b( b qlagbh kyqgai cvly~( gq ol~gdc l ~hbai b
BQQLAGBPI@ ^VIQQ ^OLPL,MGD AOIYDC
Hbq Zicbq abqgdl elcyh QpiziSwddq ale~bdgiq obzi ldbpi`polyqbd`q pl Dizb`b ky`ciq solqy~~lvp fgc pbx fvibmq lv abqgdlq
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
31/128
Fgc Fyqgdiqq Pbmgdc lziv Qpbpi Qy~viei Alyvpq sssbeivgabd~vlcviqql
viivid`ye ld oi 6>20 fbhhl ob slyh` gdavibqi vizidyi vle sibhow Dizb`bdq(
bq sihh bq oi olih( cbegdc( bd` egdgdc gd`yqvgiq Pi cvly~ dliq ob oi qbiq
ayvvid bx ld egdgdc bhhlsq lv b qhis l `i`yagfhi ix~idqiq( viqyhgdc gd sl clh`
egdiq ob vi~lv {ivl bxbfhi zbhyiq `yvgdc wibvq soid oiw obzi ~vl`yai` clh`
slvo b obh fghhgld `lhhbvq lv elvi229
Gd viaid wibvq abqgdlq obzi aobhhidci` qgeghbv vizidyi gdggbgziq gd alyv( bd`
oiw bvi yd`gdc oi abe~bgcdq l ky`ciq sol vyhi ld oi hbsqygq22: ^vl~ldidq
l oiqi gdggbgziq hbam oi qbei ~lhggabh gdyidai bq oi sibhow abqgdl ixiay%
gziq Abqgdl elcyh Qizi Swdd obq fiid b oi lvivld l oi l~~lqggld(223 bd`
ogq ale~bdgiq obzi ldbi` olyqbd`q l Dizb`b ky`ciq22?
Swdd obq bhql lyd` ogeqih iefvlghi` gd b fgpiv hbflv gq~yi sgo ogq ie~hlwiiq
Ogq abqgdlq gdqgyi` b ~lhgaw virygvgdc gq `ibhivq l qobvi g~q sgo ebdbcivq( bd`
oi `ibhivq lvcbdg{i` b ydgld l co fbam227 Pi Dizb`b Aleegqqgldiv l Hbflv
vyhi` gd 6>2> ob oi ~lhgaw `g` dl zglhbi qbi hbflv hbsq26> Hbq Dlziefiv bqbi alyv `gqbcvii`( fy oi ogco alyv gq ix~iai` l vizgis oi `iagqgld262
L oi ayvvid eiefivq l oi alyv( ldhw Kyqgai Dbdaw Qbgpb obq dl viaigzi`
abe~bgcd aldvgfygldq vle abqgdlq Qbgpb sbq( olsiziv( ibyvi` gd oi 6>>:Hlq
Bdcihiq geiq bvgahi ld alvvy~gld gd Dizb`b alyvq @iqavgfgdc ldi l Qbgpq yd%
`vbgqivq( oi geiq qbg`( Bhh 99 hbswivq l hbs veq cgzgdc $9>> lv elvi ob` abqiq
bqqgcdi` l oiv alyvvlle lv ~id`gdc filvi oiv Ldi ve sgo b ~vl`ya hgbfghgw
abqi ~id`gdc filvi oiv oih` b yd`vbgqiv ob dipi` oi ky`ci $6>(>>>( bd` Qbgpb
ob` vyhi` gd oi veq bzlv b hibq lyv geiq gd oi :> `bwq filvi oi yd`vbgqiv266
Pi ix~lq `g` dl `iiv oi kyqgai Qbgpb vbgqi` $01(>>>bhelq bhh l g vle
hbswivqgd 6>>?( izid olyco qoi `g` dl bai viihiagld ydgh ogq wibv Gd
@iaiefiv 6>>7 oi kyqgaiq b`l~i` b dis Al`i l Ky`gagbh Ald`ya( sogao qbwq
oiw sghh viayqi oieqihziq g oigv ge~bvgbhgw egco vibqldbfhw fi ryiqgldi`(
fy oiw vikiai` sl ~vl~lqbhq l q~iagw soid abe~bgcd aldvgfygldq virygvi
viayqbh261 Izid bjiv oiHlq Bdcihiq geiq ghhyqvbi` ols abe~bgcd eldiw alv%
vy~q kyqgai( :? ~ivaid l Dizb`b zlivq vikiai` b 6>2> viivid`ye l obzi oi
clzivdlv b~~lgd ky`ciq bd` q~bvi oie vle oi `gvw fyqgdiqq l ~lhggaq260
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
32/128
6: Aidpiv lv Beivgabd vlcviqq Abe~bgcd Jgdbdai Hbsq Jbgh bq Alv~lvbpi Eldiw Jhll`q Ky`gagbh Vbaiq
Sgqaldqgd
Alv~lvbpi%jyd`i` ky`ciq qoyp lv`gdbvw Sgqaldqgdgpiq lyp lj agzga
~bvpgag~bpgld
Gd viaid wibvq Sgqaldqgd ~lhggaq obq fiid aobvbaivg{i` fw fgpiv ~bvgqbdqog~
bd` `gzgqgzidiqq Pi Sgqaldqgd Qy~viei Alyv gq dl ixai~gld Kyqgai Bdd
Sbhqo Fvb`hiw qbwq oi ogco alyv gq gd oi avlqqvi l oi fbphi figdc lyco
fisiid q~iagbh gdiviq cvly~q Fvb`hiw bvcyiq oi fgc eldiw ~lyvgdc gdl
viaid ihiagldq obq hi` l ow~iv~bvgqbdqog~ ld oi fidao Pi alyv obq qiid
bavgeldglyq gdcogdc bd` qizivbh iogaq gdziqgcbgldq Kyqgai @bzg` vlqqiv
gq baayqi` l ~ypgdc Fvb`hiw gd b aolmiolh`(269 bd` oi obq b`egpi` viivvgdc l
bdloiv alhhibcyi bq b lbh fgao26:
Pgq vbdalvlyq belq~oivi cvis slvqi bjiv bd ix~idqgzi 6>22 ihiagld( sogao
sbq sg`ihw zgisi` bq b viivid`ye ld Clz Qalp Sbhmivq bdgydgld ~lhgagiq263
Clz Sbhmivq bdg%alhhiagzi fbvcbgdgdc hbs cidivbi` zioieid l~~lqggld vle
lvcbdg{i` hbflv Pi fghh dibvhw ihgegdbi` ~yfhga ie~hlwiiq alhhiagzi fbvcbgdgdcvgcoq bd` qvbdchi` oigv ydgldq fw hgeggdc oi alhhiagld l `yiq26? ^vl%hbflv
bagzgqq laay~gi` oi qbiolyqi lv siimq Lyvbci` @ielavbq i` oi qbi l
bzlg` b rylvye bjiv oi clzivdlv bqmi` ~lhgai l lvai oie l oi hicgqhbyvi267
Pl~ q~id`ivq( 6>>>>7Abd`g`bpi
aldpvgfypgldq
Gd`i~id`idp
ix~id`gpyviqPlpbh
ECE Egvbci $29:(>>> $> $29:(>>>
Flw` Cbegdc $7>(>>> $> $7>(>>>
Qpbpgld Abqgdlq $3:(910 $> $3:(910
Albqp Olpihq * Abqgdlq $32(>>> $> $32(>>>
Ebgdlv Ichip Alpphi $3>(>>> $> $3>(>>>
> $2>>(>>> $6>>(>>> $1>>(>>> $0>>(>>>
$171(910
$3>(>>>
Qlyvai; opp~;,,fviddbd1a`ddip,`>72`a722f`:331f\>7e:wz~cz~`Abqgdl eldiw^vl%gd`gzg`ybh
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
33/128
Fgc Fyqgdiqq Pbmgdc lziv Qpbpi Qy~viei Alyvpq sssbeivgabd~vlcviqql
l agvayezid rylvye virygvieidq( Vi~yfhgabdq abvzi` ly b qi~bvbi fghh lv oi
alhhiagzi fbvcbgdgdc ~vlzgqgldq Kyq bjiv 0;>> ~e ld Ebvao 7( 6>22( Vi~yfhgabdq
bddlydai` b :;>> ~e eiigdc ld oi vizgqi` fghh21> Cgzid oi qolv dlgai oi
ei`gb bd` oi ~yfhga sivi dl qyvi sob sbq bmgdc ~hbai Pi qbmiq sivi idlv%
elyq fy Vi~yfhgabdq iqqidgbhhw ~bqqi` ogq aldvlzivqgbh fghh ly l oi ~yfhga iwi
Bjivsbv ( flo qg`iq yvdi` oigv bpidgld l oi Sgqaldqgd ogco alyv( ~lyvgdceldiw gdl oi vbai lv oi l~id qib Pi ogco alyv sbq dbvvlshw `gzg`i` bhldc
g`ilhlcgabh hgdiq bd` g sbq ix~iai` l vyhi ld oi aldqgygldbhgw l oi fghh
G qiieq oi kyqgaiq ebw obzi qiid ogq alegdc Gd 6>>3 oi idgvi alyv
qgcdi` b hiiv abhhgdc lv ~yfhga gdbdagdc lv ogco alyv abd`g`biq( sbvdgdc
ob oi ~yfhga ebw gdbaayvbihw ~ivaigzi b kyqgai bq fiolh`id l gd`gzg`ybhq
lv cvly~q ob aldvgfyi l ogq lv oiv abe~bgcd212 oi hicgqhbyvi ale%
~hgi` fw ~bqqgdc oi Ge~bvgbh Kyqgai Ba gd
6>>7( sogao ~vlzg`i` ~yfhga gdbdagdc lv
abd`g`biq sol alhhiai` b aivbgd belyd gdqebhh ~vgzbi `ldbgldq Fy izid sgo ~yfhga
gdbdagdc( oi 6>22 ihiagld qbs b`q yd`i`
fw gd`i~id`id q~iagbh gdiviq cvly~q
hll`gdc oi bgvsbziq
Pi abd`g`biq vbgqi` b is oyd`vi` olyqbd`
`lhhbvq( elqhw vle ~yfhga dbdagdc Q~iagbh
gdiviq cvly~q( olsiziv( q~id b hibq $19 egh%
hgld ld ihizgqgld b`q216 ^vlqqiv sbq qy~~lvi`
fw elvi obd $6 eghhgld vle fgc fyqgdiqq
cvly~q( oi ib ^bvw l Sgqaldqgd( bd` oi
Sgqaldqgd Ahyf lv Cvlso Dibvhw obh l ogq
eldiw abei vle Agg{idq lv b Qvldc Beivgab( b qob`lsw cvly~ bhgbi` sgo
oi Mlao fvloivq Beivgabdq lv vlq~ivgw211 Pi cvly~ vbd egqhib`gdc bpbam
b`q bcbgdq Sgqaldqgd Bqqgqbd Qbi Bplvdiw Cidivbh KlBddi Mhl~~idfyvc(
^vlqqivq l~~ldid Mhl~~idfyvc sbq qy~~lvi` fw elvi obd $2 eghhgld vle
cvly~q bhgbi` sgo Sgqaldqgd hbflv ydgldq210 ^vlqqiv oih` ldl ogq qib fw b
vb{lv%ogd ebvcgd
Pi alv~lvbi gdiviqq qy~~lvgdc ^vlqqiv aoiivi` soid oi alyvq aldqivzb%
gzi ebklvgw y~oih` Sbhmivq bdg%alhhiagzi fbvcbgdgdc hbs gd oi sbmi l oi
ihiagld219 B vgbh alyv ob` fhlami` oi hbs fiabyqi hicgqhblvq zglhbi` oi
qbiq L~id Eiigdcq Hbs( sogao virygviq 60%olyv dlgai l hicgqhbgzi eiigdcq
BQQLAGBPI@ ^VIQQ ^OLPL,KLOD OBVP
Sgqaldqgd Qy~viei Alyvp K@bzg` ^vlqqiv ~lqiq b ryiq`yvgdc b oibvgdc pl aldqg`isoipoiv poi qpbpi alyvp qolixivagqi kyvgq`gapgld lziv evihbpgdc pl poi ~bqqbci l 6Bap 2>( aleeldhw viivvi` poi fy`cip vi~bgv fghh( ld Ky6>22 Poi aldpvlzivqgbh fghh ihgegdbpiq poi alhhiapgzi fbgdc vgcopq l ~yfhga ie~hlw
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
34/128
6? Aidpiv lv Beivgabd vlcviqq Abe~bgcd Jgdbdai Hbsq Jbgh bq Alv~lvbpi Eldiw Jhll`q Ky`gagbh Vbaiq
/Hicgqhblvq ~lqi` b dlgai hiqq obd sl olyvq filvi oi eiigdc' Gd y~olh`%
gdc oi qbyi( oi ogco alyv aobvbaivg{i` oi L~id Eiigdcq Hbs bq b vyhi l
hicgqhbgzi ~vlai`yvi bd` `iivvi` l oi hicgqhbyvi21:
Pi ebklvgw ale~hiihw bf`gabi` gq viq~ldqgfghgw l idqyvi oi ~yfhga abd ~bv%
gag~bi gd oi hicgqhbgzi ~vlaiqq Gd oiv `gqqid Aogi Kyqgai Qogvhiw Bfvbobeqldqbg` oi L~id Eiigdcq Hbs ge~hgabiq oi ~yfhgaq aldqgygldbh vgco l baaiqq
hicgqhbgzi ~vlaii`gdcq( bd` qoi bvcyi` oi ebklvgw q vibqldgdc sbq ahibvhw
`gqgdcidylyq( fbqi` ld `gqgdlvebgld vlqqivq l~gdgld aldayvvgdc sgo oi
ebklvgw( soghi gdqgqgdc oi alyv eyq fi bflzi ~lhggaq( sid l cvib hidcoq l
`iqavgfi oi yvfyhid ~lhggabh geiq ob ~viqidhw aldqyei Sgqaldqgd213
Pi alyvq ~vl%alv~lvbi ebklvgw obq bhql bai` l idqyvi sibhow q~iagbh
gdiviqq abd `vlsd ly oi zlgaiq l lv`gdbvw agg{idq gd oi ky`gagbh bvidb Pi
alyv zli`bhldc g`ilhlcgabh hgdiql sibmid gq viayqbh vyhi bd` b`l~
oi qbd`bv` qycciqi` fw oi Sgqaldqgd Vibhlvq Bqqlagbgld bd` SgqaldqgdqEbdybayvivq bd` Aleeivai(21? b cvly~ sogao `ldbi` dibvhw $2 eghhgld l
qy~~lv vlqqivq viihiagld gd 6>22217 Pi dis vyhi qbiq ob abe~bgcd `ldb%
gldq abd diziv fi oi qlhi fbqgq lv viayqbh Gd `gqqid( Kyqgai Fvb`hiw ix~viqqi`
bhbve ob ky`ciq abe~bgcdq abd dls bqm ~bvgiq filvi oi alyv lv abe~bgcd
aldvgfygldq Ky`ciq eyq fi ~ivaigzi` bq fiwld` ~vgai( Fvb`hiw qbi` Qoi
avggag{i` oi ebklvgw lv b`l~gdc slv`%lv%slv` oi qavg~ l q~iagbh gdiv%
iqq ob ebw sbd l qsbw oi viqyhq l yyvi ky`gagbh abe~bgcdq20> Pi alyv
qiieq gdid ld ebmgdc g ibqgiv lv fgc eldiw l gdyidai oi ky`gagbvw( b oi
ix~idqi l hggcbdq sgoly zbq viqlyvaiq
Pi ~vl%alv~lvbi ebklvgw ieivci` bjiv b zgaglyq 6>>? ihiagld gd sogao b
agvayg alyv ky`ci( Egaobih Cbfhiebd( iibi gdayefid Kyqgai Hlygq Fyhiv
Bjiv Kyqgai Fyhiv zli` l ix~bd` hgbfghgw lv ebdybayvivq l hib` ~bgd( fgc
fyqgdiqq q~id eghhgldq l `iib oge fw vyddgdc vbagbhhw gdci` b`q ob ibyvi`
legdlyq bd` vgcoidgdc gebciq l avgegdbhq Kyqgai Cbfhiebd sbq aobvci` sgo
iogaq zglhbgldq lv b Z q~l ob aobvci` ob Kyqgai Fyhiv ob lyd` b hll~%
olhi sogao bhhlsi` b aogh` vb~gq l cl vii bd` bqqbyh bdloiv aogh`202 Kyqgai
Fyhiv( oi vq fhbam kyqgai ld oi ogco alyv( ~vliqi` ob oi vi~viqidi` oi
`iid`bd bq b ~yfhga `iid`iv bd` ob oi baybhhw hlq oi abqi Pi `iid`bdldhw vb~i` bdloiv aogh` bjiv qivzgdc ogq qididai
Kyqgai Cbfhiebd obq fiid avggag{i` lv baai~gdc elvi obd $2>(>>> slvo
l vii hicbh qivzgaiq l co oi iogaq aobvciq206 Oi viaigzi` oi qivzgaiq vle
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
35/128
Fgc Fyqgdiqq Pbmgdc lziv Qpbpi Qy~viei Alyvpq sssbeivgabd~vlcviqql
Egaobih Fiq * Jvgi`vgao( oi qbei hbs ve ob `iid`i` Clz Sbhmivq bdg%
ydgld fghh Pvii l oi lyv eiefivq l oi aldqivzbgzi ebklvgw obzi fiid
aobvci` sgo iogaq zglhbgldq( bd` oi alyv viaidhw zli`bhldc g`ilhlcgabh
hgdiqdl l vib~~lgd oi iogaq gdziqgcblv201 ^vlqqiv qiieq l obzi qayphi`
oi gdziqgcbgld gdl oi bhhici` aolmiolh`( sogao laayvvi` `yvgdc oi `ihgfivb%
gld l oi bdgydgld fghh abqi200
Pi alyv obq fiid bd iefbvvbqqeid l Sgqaldqgd agg{idq bd` l ky`ciq izivw%
soivi B Kyhw 6>22 ~lhh lyd` ob ldhw 11 ~ivaid l Sgqaldqgdgiq ob` ald%
`idai gd oigv ogco alyv209 Pi kyqgaiq bvi ahibvhw ydbfhi l ~lhgai oieqihziq ld
iogabh gqqyiq bd` aldgaq l gdiviq Kyqgai Fvb`hiw obq avggag{i` oi vihbxbgld
l iogaq qbd`bv`q Si qolyh`d fi bflzi oi hbs( qoi qbg`20:
Sgo oi alyv ahlqihw `gzg`i`( oi ky`gagbh ihiagld dix wibv ~vlegqiq l fi kyq
bq aldidglyq Pi qbiq ~yfhga dbdagdc alyh` dl mii~ y~ sgo oi lyqg`i
alv~lvbi eldiw gd oi 6>22 vbai( fy dls ob Vi~yfhgabdq gd oi hicgqhbyviobzi ihgegdbi` ~yfhga dbdagdc gd b 6>22 fy`ci fghh(203 agg{idq abd ix~ia izid
elvi alv~lvbi eldiw gd ky`gagbh ihiagldq Pgq gei( olsiziv( oi `ldbgldq abd
cl `gviahw l oi abd`g`biq( bd` oi dis viayqbh qbd`bv` sghh idqyvi ob `ldlvq
eldiw sghh fi b cll` gdziqeid
Pl~ q~id`ivq( 6>>>>7Abd`g`bpi
aldpvgfypgldq
Gd`i~id`idp
ix~id`gpyviqPlpbh
Sgqaldqgd Ebdyjbapyvivq * Aleeivai $7(:>> $6(>26(30? $6(>66(10?
Cvibpiv Sgqaldqgd Aleegppii $> $2(31:(919 $2(31:(919
Ahyf jlv Cvlspo $> $:22(6:2 $:22(6:2
Albhgpgld jlv Beivgabq Jbeghgiq $> $17?(>3? $17?(>3?
Sgqaldqgd I`yabpgld Bqqlagbpgld $> $0?(162 $0?(162
> $9>>(>>> $2(>>>(>>> $2(9>>(>>> $6(>>>(>>> $6(9>>(>>> $1(>>>(>>> $1(9>>(>>>
$2(3?0(?9:
$1(>12(:?3
Qlyvai; opp~;,,fviddbd1a`ddip,`>72`a722f`:331f\>7e:wz~cz~`^vl%gd`gzg`ybh ^vl%alv~lvbpi
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
36/128
1> Aidpiv lv Beivgabd vlcviqq Abe~bgcd Jgdbdai Hbsq Jbgh bq Alv~lvbpi Eldiw Jhll`q Ky`gagbh Vbaiq
Egaogcbd
Eldiw jhll`gdc qpbpi alyvpq gd plvp vijlve fbpphiq
Bjiv Ebpgi Olsbv` sbq olq~gbhg{i` lv b qvlmi gd 2776( qoi ficbd viaigzgdcvibeid b Pi Sihhdiqq Aidiv gd Dis Fybhl( Egaogcbd Olsbv` ob` b ogq%
lvw l ow~ividqgld( oibv `gqibqi( bd` vidbh ~vlfhieq Pi aidivq ~owqgagbd
eldglvi` oiv fhll` ~viqqyvi bd` vibi` oiv ow~ividqgld Gd hbi 2771 Olsbv`q
~owqgagbd viivvi` oiv l b di~ovlhlcgq( sol ficbd `gbhwqgq vibeid gd Ebw
2770 Olsbv` sbq b`egpi` l oi olq~gbh gd Dlziefiv 2779 bd` oiv ald`ggld
`iivglvbi` Qoi ~bqqi` bsbw bd` oiv qizid aogh`vid bd` qizid qgfhgdcq qyi` oiv
oibho abvi ~vlzg`ivq lv dichgcidai gd vibgdc oiv ald`ggldq20? Piw qyi` oi
oibho abvi ~vlzg`ivq lv svldcyh `ibo bd` oi kyvw bsbv`i` oie $2> eghhgld
gd dldialdlega `bebciq @yi l Egaogcbdq ab~ ld dldialdlega `bebciq( ols%
iziv( oi ky`ci vi`yai` ob belyd l $9>>(>>>207
Pi Egaogcbd hicgqhbyvi obq ~bqqi` lv vilve hicgqhbgld sgo qlei l oi
qvgaiq hgegq ld hbsqygq Ydhgmi alyvq gd loiv qbiq( oi Egaogcbd ogco alyv
obq dl bai` l qvgmi `lsd oiqi hgegq bq ydaldqgygldbh Soid oi Ghhgdlgq
Qy~viei Alyv qvyam `lsd b hgeg ld `bebciq gd 6>2>( g bamdlshi`ci` ob
hgegq ld `bebciq `idw oi elq qizivihw gdkyvi` ~ivqldq oigv yhh eibqyvi l
kyqgai29> /qii flx ld lhhlsgdc ~bci' lv vilve b`zlabiq bqqiv ob vgzlhlyq
hbsqygq bvi oyvgdc oi ialdlew(292 fy b ab~ ld `bebciq ldhw biaq ~hbgdgq
ob obzi eb`i g ovlyco b vgbh bd` ob` b kyvw bsbv` oie qyfqbdgbh `bebciq296
Jbai sgo b `ihyci l alv~lvbi eldiw gd gq ihiagldq( oi Egaogcbd Qy~viei
Alyv obq bf`gabi` gq viq~ldqgfghgw l ~vlia olqi sgo oi elq qizivi gdky%
vgiq Pi ogco alyv( sgo b ~vl%alv~lvbi ebklvgw lv bvlyd` 26 wibvq( y~oih`
qlei l oi qbiq egdlv lv vilve eibqyviq Gd 6>>0 oi alyv vyhi` ob b hbs
ab~~gdc `bebciq lv ~hbgdgq sol hibqi vidbh abvq b $6>(>>> `liq dl zglhbi
oi vgco l kyvw vgbh ~vliai` fw oi qbi aldqgygld Pi `gqqid bvcyi`( Pi
vgco l b kyvw vgbh gq ghhyqlvw gd oi elq qizivi abqiq( olqi gd sogao oi belyd
l `bebciq ixaii`q $6>(>>> oi vgco l b kyvw vgbh gq dl qbgqi` fw ~vl%
zg`gdc kyvlvq oi l~~lvydgw l bddlydai bd bsbv` bd` oid obzi g bvfgvbvghwgcdlvi` sgo dl vicbv` lv oi baq l oi abqi29: Gd loiv abqiq oi alyv qge~hw
vivbgdi` vle vizgisgdc b hlsiv alyvq `iagqgld gd bzlv l lv vilve Pi
Egaogcbd Alyv l B~~ibhq( vihwgdc ld oi ogco alyvq vidbh abv abqi( y~oih` b
qbyi ob hgegq dldialdlega `bebciq gd ei`gabh ebh~vbagai bagldq293
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
37/128
Fgc Fyqgdiqq Pbmgdc lziv Qpbpi Qy~viei Alyvpq sssbeivgabd~vlcviqql
@yvgdc oi ihiagldq ob cbzi aldqivzbgziq b ebklvgw277? bd` 6>>>`ldbgldq
vle oi oibho abvi gd`yqvw gdavibqi` qobv~hw( l kyq hiqq obd $1>>(>>> ibao wibv29?
Sgo ~vl%alv~lvbi kyqgaiq gd oi ebklvgw lv oi dix 2> wibvq( oi ogco alyv ldhw
vyhi` gd bzlv l gd`gzg`ybhq qygdc gdqyvbdai ale~bdgiq( olq~gbhq( lv loiv alv~lvbi
`iid`bdq ld zivw vbvi laabqgldq297 Pi B~~id`gx l ogq vi~lv qolsq ob soid
~vl%alv~lvbi kyqgaiq aldvlhhi` oi fidao( oi zbq ebklvgw l vyhgdcq gdzlhzgdc bd
gd`gzg`ybh qygdc b alv~lvbgld viqyhi` gd b 9%6 vyhgdc lv oi alv~lvbgld2:>
Bjiv aldqivzbgzi ky`ciq hlq oigv ebklvgw gd 6>>?( oi dis alyv vihbxi` oi fyv%
`id l ~vll gd ei`gabh ebh~vbagai abqiq2:2 Pi oibho abvi gd`yqvw qlyd`i` bhbve
fihhq bd` gdavibqi` ldbgldq l ~vl%alv~lvbi kyqgaiq bd` oi Egaogcbd Vi~yfhgabd
^bvw2:6 Pi gdqyvbdai gd`yqvw cbzi elvi obd sgai oi belyd bq gd oi ~vizglyq
ihiagld Gd`yqvw cvly~q bd` oi Vi~yfhgabd bvw q~id kyq hiqq obd $2 eghhgld
ibao ld b`q qy~~lvgdc Kyqgai Vlfiv Wlydc bd` aobhhidciv Ebvw Mihhw gd 6>2>(
baalv`gdc l `bb vle oi Dbgldbh Gdqgyi l Eldiw gd Qbi ^lhggaq2:1 Wlydcq
l~~ldid viaigzi` kyq elvi obd $9>(>>> vle qbi @ielavbq2:0 Pi sl ~vl%
alv~lvbi kyqgaiq sld( bd` oi oibho abvi gd`yqvw fviboi` b qgco l vihgi2:9
B fg~bvgqbd bqmlvai( sogao gdahy`i` Kyqgai Ebvghwd Mihhw( ixbegdi oi ~vlfhieq
qyvvlyd`gdc Egaogcbdq ky`gagbh ihiagldq bd` viaidhw gqqyi` b qabogdc vi~lv Pi
bqmlvai dli` ob oi zbq ebklvgw l abqiq filvi oi ogco alyv gdzlhzi abe~bgcd
Zivdld Fiqp `vlzi b lvmhgp Ldi `bw gd 2779( poi ebqp l ogq lvmhgp
alhhb~qi` soghi elzgdc qhbfq l olp qpiih Ow`vbyhga yg` gd poi eb%
aogdi gcdgpi` bd` idcyhi` Fiqp gd b vifbhh Oi qyvzgzi` sgpo qizivi
fyvdq ld 0> ~ivaidp l ogq fl`w Fiqp qyi` poi ebdybapyvivq l poi
lvmhgp bd` poi ow`vbyhga yg` Yd`iv b plvp vilve qpbpypi( polyco( oi
alyh` ldhw vialziv $9>>(>>> lv dldialdlega `bebciq
Poi Ghhgdlgq Qy~viei Alyvp( olsiziv( vyhi` poi hgegp ydaldqpgpypgldbh(
d`gdc gp sbq dlp kyqpgi` fw poi clbh l vi`yagdc poi alqp l oibhpo
abvi Poi qpbpi aldqpgpypgld liq dlp ~ivegp poi idpgvi fyv`id l poi
bdpgag~bpi` alqp qbzgdcq pl viqp ld ldi ahbqq l gdkyvi` ~hbgdpgq291
Fiqp alyh` yhhw vialziv vle ogq gdkyvgiq Poi Ghhgdlgq ogco alyvp obq
povlsd lyp qizivbh qpbpyplvw ab~q ld `bebciq290 Gp obq vialcdg{i`
pobp fiabyqi ab~q ldhw alei gdpl ~hbw soid b kyvw bsbv`q `
bflzi b aivpbgd poviqolh`( qyao hicgqhbpgld obveq ~hbgdpgq s
elqp qizivi gdkyvgiq 299
Poi Ghhgdlgq Qy~viei Alyvp( ydhgmi poi lpoiv alyvpq gd pogq vi~
vi~viqidp aivpbgd `gqpvgapq gd poi qpbpi Pogq obq hi` pl b vihbpgz
qgqpidp g`ilhlcgabh ebmiy~ l poi alyvp( fiabyqi hgfivbh abd`
obzi yqybhhw ~vizbghi` gd yvfbd `gqpvgapq( bd` aldqivzbpgzi ab
gd vyvbh `gqpvgapq Ldai ky`ciq bvi ihiapi` pl poi ogco alyvp( po
ydaldpiqpi` vipidpgld ihiapgldq Pogq qwqpie obq viqyhpi` gd
alyvp pobp gq dlp bq ~lhgpgag{i` bq gd lpoiv qpbpiq( bq poi `bpb l
alyvp abqiq gd poi b~~id`gx qolsq
Ghhgdlgq Qy~viei Alyvp jgcopq plvp vijlve
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
38/128
16 Aidpiv lv Beivgabd vlcviqq Abe~bgcd Jgdbdai Hbsq Jbgh bq Alv~lvbpi Eldiw Jhll`q Ky`gagbh Vbaiq
aldvgfylvq Egaogcbd zlivq bhvib`w fihgizi ob abe~bgcd q~id`gdc obq gdiai`
oi `iagqgld%ebmgdc l oigv ky`gagbvw2:: Egaogcbdq `gqahlqyvi hbsq lv gd`i~id`id
q~id`gdc bvi dllvglyqhw sibm(2:3 bd` q~id`gdc obq cvlsd l bhbvegdc hizihq2:?
Egaogcbd obq dlegdbhhw dld~bvgqbd ky`gagbh ihiagldq( fy oi hbfih `liq dl
eibd eyao Abd`g`biq bvi aolqid fw ~bvw hib`ivq b qbi aldzidgldq( bd`oi qbi ~bvgiq bvi ljid oi fgcciq abe~bgcd q~id`ivq Ql soghi oi ~bvgiq bvi
gdzlhzi` b izivw qbci l oi abe~bgcdq( zlivq `l dl qii ~bvw bhgbgld hgqi`
ld oi fbhhl Kyqgai Ebvghwd Mihhw qbg` Egaogcbdq dlegdbgdc ~vlaiqq gdiaq
oi ~vlaiqq sgo b ~bvgqbd ale~ldid ob gq obv` l `idw2:7 B 6>2> Ydgzivqgw
l Aogabcl qy`w ixbegdi` ~bvgqbdqog~ beldc ogco alyv ky`ciq bd` vbdmi` oi
Egaogcbd Qy~viei Alyv ib` hbq23>
Hgmi loiv ky`gagbvgiq bvlyd` oi alydvw( oi Egaogcbd ogco alyv obq fialei b
~lhggabh fbphiih` lv cvly~q ob qy~~lv bd` l~~lqi hicgqhbgzi bpie~q l ab~
`bebciq lv gdkyvi` ~hbgdgq Pi qbi ~lhggabh ~bvgiq co ld fiobh l oigvqy~~lvivq fw ~ye~gdc eldiw gdl ky`gagbh ihiagldq Pi ryiqgld l soioiv
ab~~gdc bebciq lv gdkyvi` ~hbgdgq zglhbiq b hggcbdq aldqgygldbh vgcoq
qiieq l `i~id` qlhihw ld sogao ~lhggabh ~bvw obq b ebklvgw ld oi alyv
Soid oi hbs qogjq sgo oi ~lhggabh sgd`q( oi ~yfhga ryiqgldq oi gdicvgw l
oi ky`gagbvw Pi alyvq qiie l fi wi bdloiv ~lhggabh fvbdao l clzivdeid(
soivi oi zlgaiq l agg{idq sgoly eldiw l aldvgfyi ljid cl ydoibv`
Pl~ q~id`ivq( 6>>>>7Abd`g`bpi
aldpvgfypgldq
Gd`i~id`idp
ix~id`gpyviq+Plpbh
Egaogcbd Aobefiv lj Aleeivai $2:0(20> $6(?69(699 $6(7?7(179
Egaogcbd @ielavbpga bvpw $627(206 $6(0:3(262 $6(:?:(6:1
Egaogcbd Vi~yfhgabd ^bvpw $623(611 $6(06>(16? $6(:13(9:2
Agpg{idq jlv Ky`gagbh Vijlve $> $136(>70 $136(>70
Bdd Bvflv ^BA $2>6(>>> $6>?(>>> $12>(>>>
> $2(>>>(>>> $6(>>>(>>> $1(>>>(>>> $0(>>>(>>> $9(>>>(>>> $:(>>>(>>> $3(>>>(>>>
$6(:?:(6:1
$:(1>7(>9>
Qlyvai; opp~;,,fviddbd1a`ddip,`>72`a722f :331f\>7e:wz~cz~`^vl%gd`gzg`ybh ^vl%alv~lvbpi
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
39/128
Fgc Fyqgdiqq Pbmgdc lziv Qpbpi Qy~viei Alyvpq sssbeivgabd~vlcviqql
Aldahyqgld
Pi gd`i~id`idai l lyv ky`gagbvw gq yd`iv bpbam Alv~lvbi gdiviq cvly~q
bvi q~id`gdc idlvelyq belydq l eldiw l ihia ky`ciq qwe~boiga l oigv
abyqiq Pi ll` l eldiw gdl qbi alyvq obq viqyhi` gd alv~lvbi%vgid`hw
alyvq ob bvi dl ~vliagdc gd`gzg`ybh vgcoq232
Ky`ciq egco slvvw ob vyhgdcbcbgdq sibhow alv~lvbgldq alyh` obve oigv bfghgw l sgd viihiagld( qgdai oi
abd`g`bi sgo oi elq eldiw yqybhhw sgdq236
^vlcviqqgziq bvi hbvcihw qgpgdc ld oi qg`ihgdiq bq alv~lvbi gdiviqq bvi bmgdc
lziv oi fidao Hbflv ydgldq bd` vgbh hbswivq yqi` l cgzi cidivlyqhw l hgfivbh
abd`g`biq( fy oiqi cvly~q bvi figdc lzivsoihei` fw alv~lvbi eldiw Ldi
vi~lv lyd` ob kyq ovii alv~lvbi gdiviq cvly~q q~id 21 geiq oi belyd
ob ydgldq q~id gd oi elq viaid ky`gagbh ihiagld awahi231 Gd Bhbfbeb vgbh
hbswivq bvi dls `ldbgdc l qlagbhhw aldqivzbgzi Vi~yfhgabd abd`g`biq(230
fy gd loiv qbiq( oiw zi cgzid y~ bhlcioiv Eibqyviq hgmi lv vilve bd`Sgqaldqgdq bdghbflv fg hh ebmi g obv`iv lv vgbh hbswivq bd` hbflv ydgldq l
qyvzgzi( hi bhldi ebvqobh oigv viqlyvaiq l qy~~lv ~vlcviqqgzi ky`ciq Piqi
cvly~q abddl ol~i l ebao oi viqlyvaiq l fgc fyqgdiqq G eldiw mii~q
lzivsoihegdc ky`gagbh ihiagldq( Beivgabdq sghh obzi elvi bd` elvi ky`ciq
sol bzlv alv~lvbgldq lziv gd`gzg`ybhq
G `liq dl obzi l fi ogq sbw Gd ba( g sbq dl bhsbwq ogq sbw Soid Beivgab
sbq lyd`i`( ogco alyvq sivi dl ihiai Ji`ivbh ky`ciq obzi diziv fiid
ihiai` Pi eg`%27o aidyvw qbs oi ~l~yhgq sbzi yqoivi` gd fw ^viqg`id
Bd`vis Kbamqld( bd` qbiq ficbd l beid` oigv aldqgygldq l ihia ogco alyv
ky`ciq239 B oi gei( agg{idq zgisi` ihiagldq bq b eibdq l vii ky`ciq vle oi
gdyidai l oi ~lhggabh fvbdaoiq l clzivdeid( sogao sivi aldvlhhi` fw q~i%
agbh gdiviqq Fy dls( oi qbei q~iagbh gdiviqq obzi bmid lziv ky`gagbh ihiagldq
Ky`ciq b~~ibv l fi kyq bdloiv ~lhggabh fvbdao( qyfkia l oi qbei alvvy~gdc
gdyidai l abe~bgcd abqo Ols abd agg{idq sol hbam ~lhggabh gdyidai ~ivaigzi
oi alyvvlle bq b hizih ~hbwgdc ih`26 Ky`gagbh Vbaiq Fvibm Q~id`gdc Vialv`
Pi ~vbagai l ihiagdc ky`ciq gq oivi l qbw fy oivi bvi qi~q si abd bmi l
ebmi oi qwqie slvm lv izivwldi( dl kyq sibhow q~iagbh gdiviqq Agg{idq
eyq gdlve oieqihziq l abd`g`biq rybhgabgldq bd` ~lqggldq gdqib` l
vihwgdc ld egqhib`gdc b`q vle q~iagbh gdiviq cvly~q Beivgabdq qolyh` `iebd`
lyco viayqbh qbd`bv`q l idqyvi ~bvgiq l hbsqygq abddl yqi eldiw l gdy%
idai ky`ciq Bd` bhh qbiq qolyh`( b oi zivw hibq( ge~hieid qvldc `gqahlqyvivyhiq Pgq sghh bhhls agg{idq l mdls oi qlyvai l b ~lhggabh b` bd` `iag`i
soioiv l vyq gq zivbagw
Gd 6>22 YQ Qy~viei Alyv Kyqgai Qbd`vb @bw LAlddlv( b gvihiqq b`zlabi lv
ky`gagbh abe~bgcd dbdai vilve qgdai hibzgdc oi YQ Qy~viei Alyv( svli;
Si bhh ix~ia ky`ciq l fi baalydbfhi l oi hbs vboiv obd ~lhggabh qy~%
~lvivq lv q~iagbh gdiviqq$ Fy ihiai` ky`ciq gd ebdw qbiq bvi ale~ihhi` l
qlhgag eldiw lv oigv ihiagld abe~bgcdq( qleigeiq le hbswivq bd` ~bvgiq
b~~ibvgdc filvi oie$ Soioiv lv dl oiqi aldvgfygldq baybhhw gh oi qabhiql kyqgaiq( ovii ly l izivw lyv Beivgabdq fihgizi ob abe~bgcd aldvgfygldq
bia alyvvlle iagqgldq$ Pgq avgqgq l ald`idai gd oi ge~bvgbhgw l oi
ky`gagbvw gq vibh bd` cvlsgdc$ Hi ydb``viqqi`( oi ~ivai~gld ob kyqgai gq lv
qbhi sghh yd`ivegdi oi vyhi l hbs ob oi alyvq bvi qy~~lqi` l y~olh`$237
Lyv aldqgygldbh zbhyiq bvi yd`iv bpbam fw ~lsivyh alv~lvbi gdiviqq bd` si
eyq co l ~viqivzi oie G si sbd l viyvd oi ky`gagbvw l gq vgcoyh vlhi l
~vliagdc gd`gzg`ybhq vle oi bfyqiq l ~lsivyh gdqgygldq( oid Beivgabdq eyq
`iebd` ob ky`ciq bd` hicgqhblvq ql~ oi ll` l eldiw gdl ky`gagbh ihiagldq
B~~id`gx
l ghhyqvbi oi ge~ba l ky`gagbh abe~bgcd aldvgfygldq ld oi hbs( oi Aidiv
lv Beivgabd ^vlcviqq ixbegdi` ogco%alyv vyhgdcq lv oi qgx qbiq ob obzi
qiid oi elq eldiw q~id gd ky`gagbh ihiagldq vle 2776 l 6>22 Pi vyhgdcq
gd ogq `bb qi gdahy`i abqiq gd sogao bd gd`gzg`ybh gq oi ~hbgdg( bd` oi dbei`
`iid`bd gq b alv~lvbgld( ~vgzbi ie~hlwiv( gdqgygldbh oibho abvi ~vlzg`iv(
lv loiv fyqgdiqq Pi `bb bhql gdahy`i abqiq gd sogao bd gd`gzg`ybh gq qiimgdcslvmivq ale~idqbgld fidiq lv fidiq vle bd gdqyviv
Gd oi el`ivd `ifbi lziv lv vilve( ky`gagbh bagzgqe( bd` oi vlhi l oi
ky`gagbvw( b qbi ky`ciq g`ilhlcw ljid viivq l oi id`idaw l zli lv igoiv
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
41/128
Fgc Fyqgdiqq Pbmgdc lziv Qpbpi Qy~viei Alyvpq sssbeivgabd~vlcviqql
alv~lvbgldq lv gd`gzg`ybhq gd oiqi abqiq Pi `bb ldhw gdahy`iq abqiq sgo b
`gqqidgdc l~gdgld fiabyqi oiqi abqiq ghhyqvbi b alyvq g`ilhlcgabh `gzg`i
Ydbdgelyq abqiq bvi lqidqgfhw ydaldvlzivqgbh
Gd qlei qbiq( oi `bb lv qlei wibvq gq qabd( ~viqyebfhw fiabyqi oi alyv
gqqyi` ebdw ydbdgelyq vyhgdcq Gd ixbq( lv ixbe~hi( oi alyv obq gqqyi` qizivbhydbdgelyq vyhgdcq gdzlhzgdc lv vilve bd` ie~hlwiv hgbfghgw ob bzlv alv~lvb%
gldq( bd` qyao `iagqgldq slyh` ~vlfbfhw dl obzi fiid ydbdgelyq ob` oi alyv
dl ob` qyao b qvldc id`idaw l bzlv alv~lvbgldq lziv gd`gzg`ybhq2
Pi `bb ixahy`iq abqiq gd sogao ky`ciq vle loiv alyvq bvi qgpgdc( abqiq gdzlhz%
gdc ~vlai`yvbh gqqyiq( hicbh iogaq vyhgdcq( bd` abqiq `iag`i` sgoly bd l~gdgld
Pi vibqld; Qyao abqiq `l dl qoi` hgco ld b alyvq g`ilhlcgabh hibdgdc Pi `bb
bhql ixahy`iq abqiq ld viebd` vle oi YQ Qy~viei Alyv bd` abqiq vioibv`
gd hgco l abqi hbs obd`i` `lsd soghi oi b~~ibh sbq ~id`gdc Gd olqi agvaye%
qbdaiq( kyqgaiq ljid zli l b~~hw ~viai`id izid olyco oiw `gqbcvii sgooi yd`ivhwgdc `iagqgld Qgeghbv l loiv qy`giq l kyqgaiq g`ilhlcgiq( oi `bb
layqiq ld lv bd` ie~hlweid abqiq bd` `liq dl gdahy`i beghw hbs( ~vl~ivw(
lv sghhq bd` vyq gqqyiq
Hgqi` gd aovldlhlcgabh lv`iv fw wibv( oi abqiq gd sogao oi alyv qg`iq sgo oi
~hbgdg bvi gd fhyi( bd` oi abqiq `iag`i` lv oi `iid`bd bvi gd vi` Pi `bbqi
gdahy`iq b lbh l 9:2 abqiq Gd 279 l olqi abqiq( oi ogco alyvq vyhi` gd bzlv
l bd gd`gzg`ybh ~hbgdg Pi alyvq vyhi` gd bzlv l alv~lvbi `iid`bdq gd 1::
l oi 9:2 abqiq Jlv oi elq ix~idqgzi qbiq( oivi gq bd lfzglyq qogj gd bzlv l
~vl%alv~lvbi `iagqgldq bjiv oi ll` l q~iagbh gdiviq eldiw ficbd6
Bhbfbeb
Pi Bhbfbeb Qy~viei Alyv gq dls `legdbi` fw ky`ciq sol bzlv alv~lvbgldq
lziv gd`gzg`ybhq Jvle 2776 l 277? oi alyv vyhi` gd bzlv l ~hbgdgq lziv
alv~lvbi `iid`bdq gd 30 l oi 262 abqiq gd oi `bb qi Jvle 2777 l 6>2>(
olsiziv( oi alyv vyhi` lv alv~lvbi `iid`bdq gd 211 l 276 abqiq qy`gi`
7/30/2019 Campaign Finance Laws Fail as Corporate Money Floods Judicial Races
42/128
1: Aidpiv lv Beivgabd vlcviqq Abe~bgcd Jgdbdai Hbsq Jbgh bq Alv~lvbpi Eldiw Jhll`q Ky`gagbh Vbaiq
Pixbq
Pi vid` l gdavibqgdc alv~lvbi abe~bgcd `ldbgldq ebw obzi qbvi` sgo oi
ixbq alyvq Fw oi eg`%277>q( ~vlalv~lvbi ky`ciq legdbi` oi fidao bd`
vlygdihw vyhi` gd bzlv l alv~lvbi gdiviqq L oi 2>> abqiq gd oi `bb qi( oi
alyv vyhi` lv alv~lvbi `iid`bdq bd` bcbgdq gd`gzg`ybh ~hbgdgq gd :7 l oiabqiq Bq dli` bflzi( `bb gq qabd lv oi elq viaid wibvq qy`gi` fiabyqi oi
alyv vibaoi` ebdw ydbdgelyq iagqgldq
Logl
Logl obq hldc qiid qlei l oi elq ix~idqgzi ky`gagbh ihiagldq gd oi alydvw
Pi bfvy~ bd` ahibv aobdci gd oi g`ilhlcw l oi alyv gq bhbvegdc Jvle 2776
l 6>>6( oi alyv vyhi` lv gd`gzg`ybh ~hbgdgq gd 9: l oi :? abqiq qy`gi`
Jvle 6>>6 l 6>2>( olsiziv( oi alyv vyhi` lv alv~lvbi `iid`bdq gd 16 lyl 1: abqiq qy`gi`
Egaogcbd
Pi Egaogcbd ogco alyv qolsq b ahibv id`idaw l vyhi lv alv~lvbgldq lziv
gd`gzg`ybh ~hbgdgq Bholyco gq kyvgq~vy`idai sbq qleisob fbhbdai` gd oi
ibvhw 277>q( oi abqiq qy`gi` lzivsoihegdchw bzlv `iid`bdq Ly l oi 210
abqiq gd oi `bb qi( 2>9 viqyhi` gd b vyhgdc lv oi alv~lvbi `iid`bd
Ghhgdlgq
Pi zbq ebklvgw l ky`gagbh ihiagldq gd Ghhgdlgq obzi hbvcihw bzlg`i` oi ll` l
q~iagbh%gdiviq eldiw Gd 6>>> bd` 6>>0( olsiziv( abd`g`biq lv oi ogco alyv
q~id $? eghhgld bd`