307
STATE OF CALIFORNIA - NATURAL RESOURCES AGENCY EDMUND G. BROWN, JR., GOVERNOR CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION South Coast Area Office 200 Oceangate, Suite 1000 Long Beach, CA 90802-4302 (562) 590-5071 W18b Filed: October 22, 2012 180th Day: April 20, 2013 Staff: J.Rabin-LB Staff Report: February 22, 2013 Hearing Date: March 6-8, 2013 STAFF REPORT: REGULAR CALENDAR Application No.: 5-12-134 Applicant: City of Newport Beach Brenda Wisneski Location: Balboa Pier Area and Corona Del Mar State Beach, Newport Beach, Orange County (APNs: 048-320-03, 052-051-23, and 052-051-24) Project Description: The City of Newport Beach is seeking a coastal development permit to remove all fire rings from city beaches, including 33 fire rings in the vicinity of the Balboa Pier and 27 fire rings at Corona del Mar State Beach. Staff Recommendation: Denial SUMMARY OF STAFF RECOMMENDATION: The City of Newport Beach is seeking a coastal development permit to remove all fire rings from the city’s beaches. This includes 15 fire rings on the beach west of the Balboa Pier and 18 fire rings located on the beach east of the Balboa Pier. Another 27 fire rings would be removed from the far western edge of Corona del Mar State Beach. Corona del Mar State Beach is owned by the state Department of Parks and Recreation and operated by the City of Newport Beach. The beach fire rings have been a part of the recreational experience in Newport Beach since the late 1940s or early 1950s and are a lower cost visitor and recreational facility. Pursuant to Coastal Act Section 30213: “Lower cost visitor and recreational facilities shall be protected, encouraged, and where feasible, provided. Developments providing public recreational opportunities are preferred.” The fire rings are enjoyed by generations of beachgoers, are very popular and in heavy demand, particularly during the busy summer months. On summer weekends, it is not unusual to have to arrive at the beach when it opens at 6 a.m. in order to claim a fire ring for use later in the afternoon

California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

  • Upload
    scprweb

  • View
    1.375

  • Download
    2

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Citation preview

Page 1: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

STATE OF CALIFORNIA - NATURAL RESOURCES AGENCY EDMUND G. BROWN, JR., GOVERNOR

CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION South Coast Area Office 200 Oceangate, Suite 1000 Long Beach, CA 90802-4302 (562) 590-5071

W18b Filed: October 22, 2012 180th Day: April 20, 2013 Staff: J.Rabin-LB Staff Report: February 22, 2013 Hearing Date: March 6-8, 2013

STAFF REPORT: REGULAR CALENDAR Application No.: 5-12-134 Applicant: City of Newport Beach Brenda Wisneski Location: Balboa Pier Area and Corona Del Mar State Beach,

Newport Beach, Orange County (APNs: 048-320-03, 052-051-23, and 052-051-24)

Project Description: The City of Newport Beach is seeking a coastal development

permit to remove all fire rings from city beaches, including 33 fire rings in the vicinity of the Balboa Pier and 27 fire rings at Corona del Mar State Beach.

Staff Recommendation: Denial

SUMMARY OF STAFF RECOMMENDATION: The City of Newport Beach is seeking a coastal development permit to remove all fire rings from the city’s beaches. This includes 15 fire rings on the beach west of the Balboa Pier and 18 fire rings located on the beach east of the Balboa Pier. Another 27 fire rings would be removed from the far western edge of Corona del Mar State Beach. Corona del Mar State Beach is owned by the state Department of Parks and Recreation and operated by the City of Newport Beach. The beach fire rings have been a part of the recreational experience in Newport Beach since the late 1940s or early 1950s and are a lower cost visitor and recreational facility. Pursuant to Coastal Act Section 30213: “Lower cost visitor and recreational facilities shall be protected, encouraged, and where feasible, provided. Developments providing public recreational opportunities are preferred.” The fire rings are enjoyed by generations of beachgoers, are very popular and in heavy demand, particularly during the busy summer months. On summer weekends, it is not unusual to have to arrive at the beach when it opens at 6 a.m. in order to claim a fire ring for use later in the afternoon

Page 2: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

5-12-134 (City of Newport Beach)

2

or evening. The fire rings are available to the public on a first-come, first-serve basis. There is no charge for their use. Staff is recommending denial because removal of the fire rings would deny the public access to this popular form of lower cost public recreation. In addition, removing the fire rings from the beaches at Newport Beach and Corona del Mar would shift the already high demand for fire rings to other coastal locations, creating new access and recreation demands there. Thus, removal of the fire rings would not be consistent with Section 30212.5 of the Coastal Act, requiring public facilities, like the fire pits, to be distributed throughout an area so as to mitigate against the impacts of overcrowding or overuse by the public of any single area. In its application, the City of Newport Beach proposes to remove the fire rings because of “potential ill health effects to beachgoers and nearby residents due to smoke and particulate matter from fires within the fire rings.” The city relies on a regulation adopted by the South Coast Air Quality Management District that prohibited the installation of new wood-burning fireplaces or wood stoves in new residential and commercial construction. However, Rule 445 adopted in 2008 exempts “campfires, beach bonfires and ceremonial burning.” The city has submitted general scientific studies about the potential health effects of wood smoke, especially particulate matter, in an effort to justify removal of the fire rings. The City Council and the Newport Beach Parks, Beaches and Recreation Commission heard from nearby residents who claim to have suffered adverse health effects from wood smoke they attribute to the fire rings and they want them removed. However, the City Council also heard from supporters of keeping the fire rings in place. According to a City Council staff report dated March 13, 2012, two members of the city’s Parks, Beaches and Recreation Commission urged the city at a February 2012 meeting to conduct an air quality study, but the city chose not to do such a study or to collect air samples from the beaches or adjacent neighborhoods. In response to questions from Commission staff, the city said such a study and sampling would have been inconclusive about the source of the particulate matter. Commission staff does not dispute that some individuals can have adverse health effects from wood smoke. However, the City has not demonstrated that the wood smoke from the City’s beach fire rings are directly responsible for a public health problem. The city acknowledges there is no state or local air quality regulation that prohibits beach fire rings and, as indicated above, the submitted information has not shown that the beach fire rings create such negative impacts as to warrant their removal. There are a variety of other sources of smoke and odors in these areas including private fireplaces, private outdoor fire rings, barbeques, exhaust from both marine and terrestrial diesel vehicles and restaurant equipment vents that would contribute to air quality conditions. Furthermore, there are a variety of measures/alternatives that could be undertaken, short of removing the public beach fire rings, that might address air quality conditions, including but not limited to enforcing the existing prohibition on burning all materials other than wood and the existing rules about the type and quantity of wood being used in beach fire rings. A Commission decision to approve Newport Beach’s request to remove the fire rings could also set a precedent that could lead to removal of beach fire rings from other parts of the coast. It is for these reasons that the Commission staff recommends that the City’s request for a CDP to remove the fire rings be denied.

Page 3: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

5-12-134 (City of Newport Beach)

3

All of the sites involved are in the coastal zone, subject to the commission’s jurisdiction. The City of Newport Beach has a certified Land Use Plan, but does not have a certified Local Coastal Program. The legal standard of review is Chapter 3 policies of the Coastal Act relating to public access and recreation. The City of Newport Beach certified Land Use Plan can be used as guidance.

STAFF NOTE REGARDING PUBLIC COMMENT The fire ring issue has generated intense controversy in Newport Beach. Some homeowners, particularly those immediately adjacent to Corona del Mar State Beach, have been active in supporting the city’s proposal to remove the fire rings. They’ve written letters, sent emails, testified at city hearings and recruited support from organizations across the country that oppose wood burning fires on health grounds. “It is just plain UNHEALTHY,” wrote Daniel J. Leonard, president of the Breakers Drive Homeowners Association, which represents homeowners who live in the subdivision next to the beach. “Now is the time to clean our air, not only for local residents but also for all people enjoying the beaches.” (Exhibit #12) Officials working for two public agencies sent comments on the hazards of wood smoke. (Exhibit #13) Comments also have been received from members of the public opposed to removal of the fire rings. (Exhibit #14) Some opponents mobilized by establishing a website with an electronic petition calling on the city and the Coastal Commission to keep the fire rings. More than 5,500 people signed the on-line petition and nearly 800 wrote comments. “The fire rings are an essential part of southern California beach culture,” wrote website founder David Ruiz in the preamble to the petition. “They offer low cost enjoyment for families. They stand for a tradition that all southern California residents can enjoy and should have the chance to experience with their families for years to come.” (Exhibit #15 is only available in the on-line version of this staff report due to its length.)

Page 4: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

5-12-134 (City of Newport Beach)

4

TABLE OF CONTENTS I.   MOTION AND RESOLUTION ............................................................................................. 5 II.  FINDINGS AND DECLARATIONS: .................................................................................... 5 

A. PROJECT LOCATION & DESCRIPTION .......................................................................... 5 B. PUBLIC ACCESS AND RECREATION ............................................................................. 6 

1.  ALTERNATIVES ANALYSIS .................................................................................. 10 2.  CONSISTENCY WITH COASTAL ACT SECTION 30414 -- STATE AIR

RESOURCES BOARD & LOCAL AIR POLLUTION CONTROL DISTRICTS .... 12 C.  LOCAL COASTAL PROGRAM (LCP) ....................................................................... 14 D.  CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT (CEQA) ................................... 15 

APPENDICES Appendix A – Substantive File Documents EXHIBITS Exhibit 1 – Vicinity Map. Exhibit 2 – Aerial view of Balboa Pier beach area. Exhibit 3 – Aerial photo of Corona del Mar State Beach. Exhibit 4 –  Balboa Pier Area – Closest and Farthest Distances Between Fire Rings & Homes. Exhibit 5 – Corona Del Mar State Beach – Distance from Nearest Fire Ring to Various Houses Exhibit 6 –  Corona Del Mar State Beach – Distance from Farthest Fire Ring to Various Houses Exhibit 7 – City of Newport Beach letter to Commission staff, October 19, 2012. Exhibit 8 – State Department of Parks and Recreation letter to City of Newport Beach, September

26, 2012. Exhibit 9 –   City of Newport Beach – Educational Information Sheet about Beach Fire Rings &

BBQs Exhibit 10 – National Park Service, Fire ring information sheet for Ocean Beach, San Francisco,

Golden Gate National Recreation Area. Exhibit 11 – City of Newport Beach letter to Commission staff, August 10, 2012. Exhibit 12 – Letters in support of removing fire rings. Exhibit 13 – Officials working for public agencies comment on the hazards of wood smoke. Exhibit 14 – Letters from opponents of removing the fire rings. Exhibit 15 – Signatures on petition against removal of fire rings. (This is an on-line exhibit only

and is not in the print version.)

Page 5: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

5-12-134 (City of Newport Beach)

5

I. MOTION AND RESOLUTION Motion:

I move that the Commission approve Coastal Development Permit Application No. 5-12-134 pursuant to the staff recommendation.

Staff recommends a NO vote. Failure of this motion will result in denial of the permit and adoption of the following resolution and findings. The motion passes only by affirmative vote of a majority of the Commissioners present. Resolution:

The Commission hereby denies a coastal development permit for the proposed development on the ground that the development will not conform with the policies of Chapter 3 of the Coastal Act and will prejudice the ability of the local government having jurisdiction over the area to prepare a Local Coastal Program conforming to the provisions of Chapter 3. Approval of the permit would not comply with the California Environmental Quality Act because there are feasible mitigation measures or alternatives that would substantially lessen the significant adverse impacts of the development on the environment.

II. FINDINGS AND DECLARATIONS: A. Project Location & Description

The City of Newport Beach is seeking a coastal development permit to remove all 60 fire rings from city beaches, including 33 fire rings in the vicinity of the Balboa Pier and 27 fire rings at Corona del Mar State Beach. (Exhibit #1) The City of Newport Beach does not have a reservation system for the fire rings and does not charge a fee for their use.

There are 15 fire rings located west of the Balboa Pier near a beachfront parking lot. Another 18 fire rings are located east of the Balboa Pier near a parking lot and beachfront park with an extensive lawn and play field area. The area west of the Balboa Pier includes a wide sandy beach next to a large parking lot. The fire rings are located close to the water, as far away from homes as possible. The Balboa Pier is a major attraction on this narrow section of the Balboa Peninsula. On the east side of the pier are two smaller parking areas and two park areas with green space which form a buffer between the homes on Ocean Front Walk and the sandy beach where the fire rings are located. The east side fire rings are located closer to the water and farther from the nearest houses. Both areas have parking nearby. (Exhibit #2) At Corona del Mar State Beach, there are 27 fire rings on the far western end of the beach next to the jetty that forms the east side of the entrance channel to Newport Harbor. (Exhibit #3) These fire rings are located in the widest stretch of sandy beach, as far from the nearest homes as possible. A

Page 6: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

5-12-134 (City of Newport Beach)

6

concession stand/grill and snack bar and large parking lot separate the fire rings from the homes in the Breakers Drive subdivision adjacent to the beach. Based on historical research provided by the City of Newport Beach, fire rings have been on the city’s beaches since the late 1940s and early 1950s. In response to questions from Commission staff, the city replied in an August 10, 2012 letter that “further research of historical information, photographs, and discussions with longtime residents uncovered that the fire rings were originally installed in the late 1940s and early 1950s at comparable locations to those where they are currently located. The fire rings have been maintained in their concentrated locations due to the fact that all three locations are adjacent to accessible parking facilities and are relatively distant from nearby private homes.” (Exhibit #11, page 4) At all three locations, the fire rings are densely packed into rows three fire rings deep. The number of fire rings in each row varies from 5 to 9, depending on the location. On the west side of the Balboa Pier, the fire rings are from 350 feet to 425 feet from the nearest house. On the east side of the pier, the fire rings between 365 feet and 435 feet from the nearest house on Ocean Front Walk. (Exhibit #4) At Corona del Mar State Beach, the nearest fire ring is 460 feet from the nearest home on the bluff above the beach parking lot (using the distance measurement tool in the Google Earth program).1 The nearest house in the Breakers Drive subdivision, which is at beach level adjacent to the beach parking lot, is approximately 520 feet from the nearest fire ring. The farthest house at the beach level is about 975 feet from the nearest fire ring. (Exhibit #5) The distance from the farthest fire rings to the Breakers Drive homes ranges from 695 feet to as much as 1,030 feet. (Exhibit #6) B. PUBLIC ACCESS AND RECREATION The California Coastal Act requires the Commission to maximize opportunity for coastal access and contains the following relevant policies: 30210. In carrying out the requirement of Section 4 of Article X of the California Constitution, maximum access, which shall be conspicuously posted, and recreational opportunities shall be provided for all the people consistent with public safety needs and the need to protect public rights, rights of private property owners, and natural resource areas from overuse. 30212.5 Whenever appropriate and feasible, public facilities, including parking areas or facilities shall be distributed throughout an area so as to mitigate against the impacts, social and otherwise, of overcrowding or overuse by the public of any single area. 30213. Lower cost visitor and recreational facilities shall be protected, encouraged, and where feasible, provided. Developments providing public recreational opportunities are preferred. 30221. Oceanfront land suitable for recreational use shall be protected for recreational use and development unless present and foreseeable future demand for public or commercial recreational

1 The City estimated this distance at 385 feet. Staff is unsure of the source of the discrepancy.

Page 7: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

5-12-134 (City of Newport Beach)

7

activities that could be accommodated on the property is already adequately provided for in the area. Among the most important goals and requirements of the Coastal Act is the mandate to protect, provide, enhance, and maximize public recreational access opportunities to and along the coast consistent with strong resource conservation principles. The Coastal Act also emphasizes the protection of existing lower cost recreational facilities. Fire rings are one of the popular activities enjoyed by the public at both Corona del Mar State Beach and the city beach near the Balboa Pier. The fire rings provide the opportunity for the quintessential Southern California beach experience – grilling a meal, toasting marshmallows, telling stories, strumming on a guitar, singing songs, celebrating special occasions like family reunions, birthdays, anniversaries, and baptisms. The importance of preserving this lower cost recreational facility for the general public is reflected in an on-line petition that has been signed by 5,578 members of the public in favor of maintaining the fire rings in their present state.2 (Exhibit #15 is not included with the print version of this staff report. It is only available in the on-line version.) The petition template states the following:

To: California Coastal Commission/Newport Beach City Council Members I just signed the following petition addressed to: California Coastal Commission. ---------------- Stop the removal of 60 fire rings at Big Corona State Beach and Balboa. The fire rings are an essential part of southern California beach culture. They offer low cost enjoyment for families. They stand for a tradition that all southern California residents can enjoy and should have the chance to experience with their families for years to come. Help support this petition to stop city council from removing all of Newport Beach's and CDM's fire pits. These fire pits serve as a fun, safe activity for families and people of all ages to go to and enjoy the warm nights in Southern California. There is no reason why these fire pits should be removed. They have been around for a long time and attract tourism and shoppers to the stores and restaurants in the surrounding area. If anything, the removal of these fire pits would hurt the businesses in the area. I ask that the City Council of Newport Beach reassess their plan to remove these fire rings and that the California Coastal Commission deny the permits needed to remove these pits. ---------------- Sincerely, [Your name]

2 http://www.change.org/petitions/california-coastal-commission-newport-beach-city-council-members-stop-the-removal-of-60-fire-rings-at-big-corona-state-beach-and-balboa.

Page 8: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

5-12-134 (City of Newport Beach)

8

The vast majority of signatures on the petition are from visitors from throughout California who go to Newport Beach to enjoy the fire rings and recreational opportunities. Some of those signing the petition live in other states and countries. This demonstrates the importance of these fire rings not just to local residents, but visitors throughout the state. The beach fire rings are so popular and in such limited supply, both locally and regionally, that visitors on summer weekends arrive at 6 a.m. to claim a fire ring for use later that afternoon or evening. They stake a claim by leaving firewood, beach chairs, towels, or gear at the site. They may enjoy other beach activities during the day when the fire ring is not in use. In response to questions from Commission staff, the city says the fire rings are used by both Newport Beach residents and visitors throughout the year. The heaviest use is typically in the summer months from Memorial Day to Labor Day. (Exhibit #11, page 1) The fire rings also receive heavy use during certain off peak periods. For instance, the fire rings are heavily used on the Persian New Year in March when thousands gather at Corona del Mar State Beach and use the fire rings in their celebration festivities. Based on vehicles entering the parking lot at Big Corona del Mar State Beach, the city estimates that 100% of fire rings are used in peak periods during June, July and August. “…Usage sharply declines in other months….” An estimated 36% of the fire rings are used in September, May and April and 14% in March and October. Only 5% of the fire rings are used in November, December, January and February. “…The number of fire rings users fluctuate tremendously during off-peak based on weather conditions,” the City said in an October 19, 2012 letter to Commission staff (Exhibit #7, pages 2-3). The period of lowest fire ring use (November, December, January and February) corresponds to the period of greatest concern about wood smoke emissions from fireplaces and wood stoves since the winter months have more days of meteorological inversions per month than other months of the year, which causes smoke and other pollutants to linger in the lower atmosphere, closer to the ground.3 Therefore, there are likely other sources that contribute more to air quality issues during this period than the smoke coming from a discrete area occupied by the existing fire rings. Corona del Mar State Beach is owned by the state Department of Parks and Recreation and operated by the City of Newport Beach under a 30-year agreement that expires in August 2029. In a September 26, 2012 letter to the city, the Superintendent of the Orange Coast District of State Parks said he believes his predecessor had discussions with the City about removal of the fire rings and may have received some form of permission from the State to remove the fire rings from the property. However, the letter states: “California State Parks believes the current fire rings to be a public benefit, which invites a more diverse visitor population to this unique recreational area.” (Exhibit #8) Removal of the fire rings would deny this diverse visitor population access to those lower cost visitor and recreational facilities and therefore is inconsistent with Coastal Act Section 30213. The permit should be denied because it would exclude a portion of the public drawn to the beach to use and enjoy the fire rings.

3 http://www.wrh.noaa.gov/slc/climate/TemperatureInversions.php.

Page 9: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

5-12-134 (City of Newport Beach)

9

According to information provided by the City, there are beach fire rings at other locations in Orange County. These include approximately 182 fire rings at Bolsa Chica State Beach in Huntington Beach, 83 at Huntington City Beach, 200 at Huntington State Beach, 7 at Aliso County Beach in Laguna Beach, 32 at Doheny State Beach in Dana Point, 160 at San Clemente State Beach and 9 at San Clemente City Beach.4 Although these other fire rings exist, Coastal Act Section 30212.5 emphasizes the importance of distributing public facilities, like fire rings, throughout an area “…so as to mitigate against the impacts, social and otherwise, of overcrowding or overuse by the public of any single area…” The elimination of the subject fire rings is also inconsistent with Coastal Act sections 30210 and 30213 which require that existing recreational facilities, especially lower cost facilities, be protected. Demand for beach fire rings is high wherever they exist. Although there are 673 fire rings located elsewhere on Orange County beaches, there are millions of annual visitors to the beaches of Orange County. Removing the fire rings from the beaches at Newport Beach and Corona del Mar would shift the already high demand to these other locations, creating new access and recreation demands there. Thus, removal of the fire rings would not be consistent with Section 30212.5 of the Coastal Act. Furthermore, there is no guarantee that the fire rings located elsewhere would be retained. Beach fire rings have been targeted for removal at various times at other locations for reasons similar to those cited by the City of Newport Beach. A Commission decision to approve Newport Beach’s request to remove the fire rings could set an adverse precedent leading to removal of fire rings from other parts of the coast. Eliminating the fire rings also is inconsistent with some of the following policies in the City of Newport Beach’s certified land use plan: 3.2.1-1. Protect, and where feasible, expand and enhance recreational opportunities in the coastal zone. 3.2.1-2. Continue to provide opportunities for a wide range of recreational activities at City parks and beaches. 3.2.1-4. Continue to cooperate with the State Department of Parks and Recreation, the State Department of Fish and Game, and Orange County to protect, expand and enhance opportunities for recreational activities at County and State beaches and parks. 3.2.2-1. Continue to protect public coastal access recreational opportunities through the provision of adequate support facilities and services. 3.2.2-2. Distribute support facilities and services in coastal areas to avoid overcrowding and overuse by the public. 3.2.2-3. Maintain the ability to distribute, remove and relocate support facilities and services in coastal areas in response to changes in demographics and recreational interests while continuing to provide comparable facilities and levels of service.

4 City of Newport Beach, Staff Report to City Council, March 13, 2012, Attachment A.

Page 10: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

5-12-134 (City of Newport Beach)

10

The Recreation and Convenience Facilities Section of the city’s land use plan includes the following statement: “Newport Beach provides a number of facilities for the convenience of residents and coastal visitors….Approximately 70 fire rings are provided in the Balboa Pier area and Corona del Mar State Beach.” “The great number and variety of support facilities and services reflects Newport Beach’s commitment to protecting and enhancing public coastal access and recreational opportunities. However, changes in demographics and recreational interests have and will continue to alter the public’s demand for support facilities and services. Therefore, it is important that Newport Beach continue to have the ability to respond to these changes while continuing to provide comparable facilities and levels of service.”5 The City has provided no information to the Commission staff documenting any demographic changes or changes in recreational interests that would justify removal of the fire rings. The City contends that removal of the fire rings and replacement with an open sand beach near the Balboa Pier or an open sand beach, volleyball courts and a children’s play area at Corona del Mar State Beach, will provide comparable facilities and levels of service. (Exhibit 7, page 5) It should be noted that Newport Beach’s LUP says there are between 65 and 75 volleyball courts typically provided at the city’s beaches. Additional volleyball courts and a children’s playground are not comparable facilities and levels of service. Beach fire rings are a unique recreational facility for which there is no substitution. The City says the fire ring area is underutilized because much of the day the fire rings and surrounding area sit empty rather than being used by beachgoers for recreational purposes. However, those who claim fire rings also make use of the beach and the water and do not have to stay at the fire ring all day. The fire rings are often used intensively in the afternoon and evening hours until 10 p.m. when the park and parking lot closes.

1. ALTERNATIVES ANALYSIS The city says it considered and rejected a series of alternatives to removal of the fire rings, concluding none of the alternatives met the objective to fully eliminate the hazards of the fire rings. (Exhibit #11, pages 2-3) The alternatives included: (1) Limiting the hours or days the fire rings could be used; (2) Limiting and enforcing the type of materials burned such as manufactured fire logs that are

reported to burn 60% cleaner than wood; (3) Relocating or reducing the number of fire rings; (4) Dispersing the fire rings; (5) Installing fire log fixtures that burn natural gas; (6) Seasonal removal; As described above, removal of the fire rings is inconsistent with the public access and recreation policies of the Coastal Act. There are alternatives short of removal that would mitigate and/or address concerns raised by the City.

5 City of Newport Beach, Coastal Land Use Plan, page 3-29.

Page 11: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

5-12-134 (City of Newport Beach)

11

For instance, the city, in their application, claims that “users of the fire rings have the tendency to burn inappropriate materials such as treated paper or plastic creating toxic smoke.” The city’s Fire Code allows only the burning of natural wood or commercial logs and prohibits the burning of tree trimmings, yard waste, paper, cardboard, garbage and rubbish. The city says those restrictions are to be enforced by city’s lifeguards, park patrol officers, and code enforcement officers. Therefore, toxic smoke from the fire rings could be reduced through enforcement of existing restrictions on the burning of inappropriate material, such as plastic, painted wood, pallets, and other items. Asked by Commission staff to document issuance of citations for burning inappropriate materials, the city replied: “The City has not issued administrative citations for burning inappropriate materials, so quantified data is not available to substantiate the claim.” The City’s park rangers patrol the beach at peak times and witness improper burning; however, the approach is to proactively educate the public rather than issue citations.” (See Exhibit 7, page 2) In addition to the alternatives listed above, the city could implement the following mitigation measures: (1) Have employees inspect the fire rings periodically during their use for inappropriate materials. (2) Provide more complete educational materials than those currently available. The information sheet submitted by the city emphasizes that No Open Fires or Barbeques are allowed on the beach and “Fires in Designated Fire Rings Only.” The sheet also says “only wood is to be burned in the fire pits. No Pallet Burning & No Charcoal Briquettes.” Nowhere does it discuss prohibitions on burning treated paper or plastic, painted wood or other hazardous materials. (Exhibit 9)

By contrast, the information sheet prepared by the National Park Service for the fire rings at Ocean Beach in San Francisco’s Golden Gate National Recreation Area is much more explicit. (Exhibit 10) “You can keep the tradition of Ocean Beach fires alive by following these simple rules:”

- Burn only untreated, unpainted wood, to keep pollutants and poisons out of the air. - Do not burn pallets or any wood containing nails or other hardware – these objects can be

dangerous. - Bring your own firewood – don’t use driftwood or other natural debris…Locally grown

firewood is best. - Burn clean. Avoid using accelerants such as lighter fluid, as they leave pollution and poisons

in the sand and the air. Paper and kindling are preferred. - Don’t burn trash. Most trash gives off pollution and poisonous gases. - Please observe “Spare the Air days” and do not burn beach fires when air pollution is severe. - The city of Newport Beach also could: (3) Post signs near the fire rings to alert fire ring users about the prohibition on burning certain materials and enforce fines for failure to abide by the restrictions.

(4) Provide nearby recycling bins to collect plastic and glass containers and trash bins for any inappropriate material. (5) Ask the public to restrict the use of fire rings when AQMD declares a “No Burn” day even though, technically, the AQMD “No Burn” restrictions don’t apply to these public recreational fire rings.

Page 12: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

5-12-134 (City of Newport Beach)

12

(6) Disperse the fire rings to reduce their dense concentration. Newport Beach has miles of beachfront, but the 60 fire rings are concentrated in three locations. Other sections of the beach are wider and farther from the nearest homes. There is risk involved in a variety of beach activities, but they are not prohibited. Signs posted at Corona del Mar State Beach warn that “Swimming in Ocean or Surf can be hazardous” because “Waves are powerful. They can badly injure you.” Lifeguards also post warning flags based on water conditions. The National Weather Service issues warnings when high surf or high tides are forecast. Red capital letters are painted on the fire rings warning: Danger Hot Ashes or Hot Coals. Signs warn that “Hot Coals May Be Present” and urge beachgoers not to play in or near fire rings. The sign says: “Always Practice Beach Fire and Fire Ring Safety!” The city could post more explicit signs that warn of the danger of burning plastic, painted wood, pallets, and hazardous materials. The city could enforce its regulations with citations for violators. The existing sign simply says: “Do not burn litter in fire rings.” Therefore, there are alternatives and mitigation measures available that would lessen the potential adverse effects of public use of the fire rings that would allow for their retention consistent with the public access and recreation policies of the Coastal Act.

2. CONSISTENCY WITH COASTAL ACT SECTION 30414 -- State Air Resources Board & local air pollution control districts

Section 30414 of the Coastal Act acknowledges that the establishment and regulation of air quality and emission standards and air pollution control programs rests with the State Air Resources Board and the air pollution control districts and states:

(a) The State Air Resources Board and air pollution control districts established pursuant to state law and consistent with requirements of federal law are the principal public agencies responsible for the establishment of ambient air quality and emission standards and air pollution control programs. The provisions of this division do not authorize the commission or any local government to establish any ambient air quality standard or emission standard, air pollution control program or facility, or to modify any ambient air quality standard, emission standard, or air pollution control program or facility which has been established by the state board or by an air pollution control district.

(b) Any provision of any certified local coastal program which establishes or modifies any ambient air quality standard, any emission standard, any air pollution control program or facility shall be inoperative.

(c) The State Air Resources Board and any air pollution control district may recommend ways in which actions of the commission or any local government can complement or assist in the implementation of established air quality programs.

Air Quality The city relies heavily on the March 2008 action of the South Coast Air Quality Management District (AQMD) in adopting Rule 445, which bans installation of most wood burning fireplaces and wood stoves in new residential or commercial construction. The rule is intended to reduce the emission of particulate matter from wood burning devices. The regulation also established a wood

Page 13: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

5-12-134 (City of Newport Beach)

13

burning curtailment program on days during the months of November, December, January and February whenever particulate pollution levels are forecast to exceed a specified level. The city of Newport Beach includes in its application documents from AQMD, specifically a detailed 2007 study on the health effects of air pollution, including particulate matter. The report notes that particles smaller than 2.5 micrometers are mostly derived from combustion sources, such as automobiles, trucks and other vehicle exhaust, as well as from stationary combustion sources. In recent years, additional focus has been placed on these small particles which can penetrate and deposit deep in the lungs. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has established tighter standards for particulate matter. While wood smoke is one of the contributors of particulate emissions, AQMD’s Rule 445 specifically exempts beach fire rings and ceremonial fires from its restrictions. A press release issued by AQMD on Nov. 3, 2010 also says “campfires, beach bonfires and ceremonial burning are exempt from the wood-burning curtailment program.”6 Asked by Commission staff if any state or local air quality regulation banned beach fire rings in Orange County, the city replied in an August 10, 2012 letter: “There is no regulation that explicitly requires the removal of the fire rings or restrict their use….”(Exhibit 11, page 4) However, the city noted AQMD has rules in place that prohibit wood burning devices like fireplaces and wood stoves in new developments. The city also says: “The health and environmental impacts of wood burning smoke is a well-documented issue that has been studied by agencies outside of the City.” (Exhibit #11, page 4) During the course of the city’s initial deliberations on the fire ring issue in February 2012, two members of the Newport Beach Parks, Beaches, and Recreation Commission “discussed the importance of an air quality study supporting removal.”7 No such study was done. In an August 10, 2012 letter to Commission staff, the City states that they “…explored the possibility of conducting an air quality study and monitoring program, but the determination was made that it was not feasible. Air quality consultants that were contacted indicated that a scientific study would not provide a definitive answer with respect to the source of the wood burning smoke as the particulate matters are the same, be it private or public. In addition, an air quality monitoring program would involve numerous variables such as wind direction, fog conditions, type of wood burned, and would vary by season or time of day.” (Exhibit #11, page 2) In an October 19, 2012 letter, the City said, “…air samples have not been taken at the beach or neighboring homes because the result of such an analysis would be inconclusive on the basis that it would not be possible to determine the source of the particulate emissions.” (Exhibit 7, page 1) In addition, the City acknowledged there is no air quality monitoring station in Newport Beach. Therefore, no data on air pollution levels was submitted.

6 http://www.aqmd.gov/news1/2010/checkbeforeyouburnpr.htm. 7 City of Newport Beach, Staff Report to City Council, dated March 13, 2012, page 2.

Page 14: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

5-12-134 (City of Newport Beach)

14

The City Council and Parks, Beaches, and Recreation Commissioners heard testimony from residents who said smoke from fire rings was affecting their health. Numerous articles were provided on the effects of wood smoke generally. Letters were received from supporters of removing the fire rings (Exhibit #12) and opponents of removal. (Exhibit #14) The Commission staff also has received correspondence from officials working for public agencies, including the South Coast Air Quality Management District and the Chief of the Environmental Health Investigations Branch of the California Department of Public Health commenting on the potential health effects of wood smoke. Their letters are also attached to this staff report. (Exhibit #13) The City of Newport Beach has not documented the air quality impacts of the fire rings near the Balboa Pier or at Corona del Mar State Beach. As discussed above, the City chose not to do an air quality study, did not take air samples at the beach or in adjacent neighborhoods, and did not provide any air quality monitoring data to establish pollution and particulate levels, determine their source, and justify removal of the fire rings. Asked by Commission staff how the City knows the source of smoke in the adjacent neighborhoods, the city replied in the October 19, 2012 letter: “There are no other sources of wood smoke within proximity of the neighborhood during the summer months, when the fire rings are used the most, residential fireplace use is limited.” (See Exhibit #7, page 1) However, the City fails to recognize that outdoor patio fire pits and barbeques are commonplace among private residences in Newport Beach, which are close by, and could in fact be a major contributor of wood smoke and/or odors that residents attribute to the beach fire pits that are at least 350 feet or more away. The summer season also has the heaviest motor vehicle and boat traffic, including boats with diesel engines, into and out of the harbor adjacent to the Corona del Mar fire rings. The City relies on studies about the health impacts of wood smoke generally that are not specific to the Newport Beach fire rings or the beaches in question. The responsibility for establishing air quality control programs and emission standards rests with the California Air Resources Board and local air pollution control districts like the AQMD. It is not the responsibility of the California Coastal Commission. As noted above the AQMD has excluded beach fire pits from its air quality control program. The Commission does not dispute that some individuals can have adverse health effects from wood smoke. However, the City has not demonstrated that the wood smoke from the City’s beach fire rings are directly responsible for a public health problem. Furthermore, the City isn’t under any order to remove the fire pits to meet any requirement of any air pollution control district. There are alternatives that could be implemented, short of removal of the fire pits that could mitigate adverse effects of the fire pits. Therefore, in addition to inconsistency with the public access and recreation policies of Chapter 3 of the Coastal Act, approving Newport Beach’s request to remove the fire rings from the City’s beaches based on potential inconsistency with ambient air quality and emission standards and air pollution control programs would be inconsistent with Coastal Act Section 30414. C. Local Coastal Program (LCP) Section 30604(a) of the Coastal Act provides that the Commission shall issue a coastal development permit only if the project will not prejudice the ability of the local government having

Page 15: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

5-12-134 (City of Newport Beach)

15

jurisdiction to prepare a Local Coastal Program that conforms with the Chapter 3 policies of the Coastal Act. The City of Newport Beach Land Use Plan (LUP) was certified on May 19, 1982. At the October 2005 Coastal Commission Hearing, the certified LUP was updated. In addition, the certified LUP was updated at the October 2009 Coastal Commission Hearing. Since the City only has an LUP, the policies of the LUP are used only as guidance. (Newport Beach LUP policies: 3.2.1-1; 3.2.1-2; 3.2.1-4; 3.2.2-1 through 3.2.2-3 relate to the proposed removal of the beach fire rings.) The removal of all beach fire rings from the city’s beaches is inconsistent with Coastal Act Sections 30212.5 and 30213. Removal of the fire rings would deprive the public of the opportunity to access and use lower cost visitor and recreational facilities that have been a fixture of Newport Beach for more than half a century. In addition, the city is asking for the Commission to approve removal of the fire rings based on concerns about health effects of wood smoke with no air quality data provided. As described in Section 30414 of the Coastal Act, the responsibility to establish air quality standards and air pollution control programs rests with the state Air Resources Control Board and local air pollution control districts, and not the Commission. The South Coast AQMD previously considered a ban on wood smoke and chose to exempt beach fire rings from the controls established under Rule 445. The preceding sections provide findings that the proposed project will not be in conformity with the provisions of Chapter 3. The proposed development will create adverse impacts and is found to be inconsistent with the applicable policies contained in Chapter 3. There are equivalent policies in the City’s certified land use plan with which the proposed development would be inconsistent. Therefore, the Commission finds that approval of the proposed development would prejudice the City of Newport Beach’s ability to prepare a Local Coastal Program for this area consistent with the policies of Chapter 3 of the Coastal Act, as required by Section 30604(a). D. California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Section 13096 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations requires Commission approval of coastal development permits to be supported by a finding showing the permit, as conditioned by any conditions of approval, to be consistent with any applicable requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). Section 21080.5(d)(2)(A) of CEQA prohibits a proposed development from being approved if there are feasible alternatives or feasible mitigation measures available which would substantially lessen any significant adverse effect which the activity may have on the environment. The City of Newport Beach is considered the Lead Agency for the purposes of CEQA, and has issued a categorical exemption for the proposed project. While the City of Newport Beach found that the development could be found consistent with CEQA, the Commission, pursuant to its certified regulatory program under CEQA, the Coastal Act, has found the proposed development would have adverse environmental impacts. The Commission has found the project would have an adverse impact on beach recreation by eliminating a lower cost visitor and recreational facility that has long been popular with beachgoers. There are feasible mitigation measures available, including alternatives to removal. Therefore, the proposed project is not consistent with the policies of the Coastal Act because there are feasible alternatives that would lessen significant adverse impacts which the activity would have on the environment. Therefore, the project must be denied.

Page 16: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

5-12-134 (City of Newport Beach)

16

Appendix A - Substantive File Documents Coastal Permit Application File Number #5-12-134 National Parks Service, “Ocean Beach Fire Rings,” Information Sheet viewed by Commission Staff on February 8, 2013 at: http://www.nps.gov/goga/upload/sb-firerings.pdf South Coast Air Quality Management District, “AQMD Launches Voluntary ‘Check Before You Burn’ Program, Press Release, November 3, 2010, viewed by Commission Staff on September 12, 2012 at: http://www.aqmd.gov/news1/2010/checkbeforeyouburnpr.htm Newport Beach Local Coastal Program, Coastal Land Use Plan, Chapter 3.2 Recreation and Support Facilities, pages 3-24 to 3-30.

Page 17: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Balboa Pier Fire Rings

Corona del Mar State Beach Fire Rings

Fire Ring Locations – Newport Beach and Corona del Mar State Beach

CDP #5‐12‐134Exhibit #1 

Vicinity Map

Page 18: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

18 Fire Rings18 Fire Rings

15 Fire Rings

Aerial view of Balboa Pier Beach Area – Location of Fire Rings

CDP #5‐12‐134Exhibit #2

Page 19: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

27 Fire Rings

Aerial Photo of Corona del Mar State Beach – Location of Fire Rings

CDP #5‐12‐134Exhibit #3

Page 20: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

18 Fire Rings

Balboa Pier Area – Closest and Farthest Distances Between Fire Rings & Homes

CDP #5‐12‐134Exhibit #4

~425’~350’

~435’ ~365’

Page 21: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Corona Del Mar State Beach – Distance from Nearest Fire Ring to Various Houses

~520’~460’

~752’

~975’

CDP #5‐12‐134Exhibit #5

(City Est. = 385’)

Page 22: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Corona Del Mar State Beach – Distance from Farthest Fire Ring to Various Houses

~700’

~695’ ~870’

~1,030’

CDP #5‐12‐134Exhibit #6

Page 23: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

CDP# 5-12-134 Exhibit# 7, page 1 of 5

Page 24: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

CDP# 5-12-134 Exhibit# 7, page 2 of 5

Page 25: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

CDP# 5-12-134 Exhibit# 7, page 3 of 5

Page 26: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

CDP# 5-12-134 Exhibit# 7, page 4 of 5

Page 27: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

CDP# 5-12-134 Exhibit# 7, page 5 of 5

Page 28: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

CDP# 5-12-134 Exhibit# 8

Page 29: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

City of Newport Beach  – Educational Information Sheet about Beach Fire Rings & BBQs

CDP #5‐12‐134                   Exhibit #9

Page 30: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Ocean Beach Fire RingsDonated Art, Clean Burning Practices Allow Fires to Continue

National Park Service U.S. Department of the Interior

Ocean Beach Golden Gate National Parks

In response to beachgoers’ concerns that beach fires were leaving unsafe debris on the beach, as well as concerns about smoke blowing into neighborhood homes, Golden Gate National Parks initiated a public process to consider the future of fires on Ocean Beach.

Instead of banning fires, Golden Gate NP joined several organizations in a creative partnership to install artistic fire rings on portions of the beach away from neighborhood homes. Those organizations, Surfrider Foundation, Burners Without Borders, Ocean Beach Foundation, and Golden Gate National Parks Conservancy, are working with Golden Gate NP to allow fires to continue. Burners Without Borders has begun donating artistic fire rings so that fires can be physically contained. Surfrider, Ocean Beach Foundation and Golden Gate National Parks Conservancy are organizing beach cleanups to keep Ocean Beach clean and safe for both humans and wildlife.

Background

Beach Fire Rules You can help keep the tradition of Ocean Beach fires alive by following these simple rules:

No fires outside rings.

No glass in the fires.

No alcohol on the beach

Burn only untreated, unpainted wood, to keep pollutants and poisons out of the air.

Don’t burn pallets or any wood containing nails or other hardware—these sharp metal objects can be dangerous.

Bring your own firewood—don’t use driftwood or other natural debris, as they serve as wildlife habitat. Gathering, cutting or scavenging of firewood or kindling is not permitted at the beach or in the park. Locally grown firewood is best.

Burn Clean. Avoid using accelerants such as lighter fluid, as they leave pollution and poisons in the sand and the air. Paper and kindling are preferred.

Don’t burn trash. Most trash gives off pollution and poisonous gases.

Don’t try to put out a fire with sand. It only hides and insulates the fire, leaving it more dangerous. Instead, leave the fire to burn out, or put it out with water.

Minors must be supervised by one person 21 or over for each 10 people under 18.

Groups of more than 25 people must obtain a permit by calling (415) 561-4300.

Overnight camping is prohibited.

Observe all posted regulations.

Please observe “Spare the Air days” and do not burn beach fires when air pollution is severe. When air pollution reaches unhealthy levels, the Bay Area Air Quality Management District notifies the public by declaring a “Spare the Air day.” To find out if today is a “Spare the Air day,” visit www.sparetheair.org or call 1-800-HELP-AIR.

CDP #5-12-134 Exhibit #10

Page 31: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

CDP 5-12-134 Exhibit 11, Page 1 of 5

Page 32: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

CDP 5-12-134 Exhibit 11, Page 2 of 5

Page 33: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

CDP 5-12-134 Exhibit 11, Page 3 of 5

Page 34: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

CDP 5-12-134 Exhibit 11, Page 4 of 5

Page 35: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

CDP 5-12-134 Exhibit 11, Page 5 of 5

Page 36: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

CDP #5-12-134

EXHIBIT #12

LETTERS IN SUPPORT OF CITY PROPOSAL TO REMOVE FIRE RINGS

Page 37: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 38: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 39: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 40: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 41: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 42: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 43: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 44: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 45: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 46: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 47: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 48: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 49: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 50: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 51: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 52: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 53: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 54: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 55: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 56: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 57: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 58: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 59: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 60: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 61: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 62: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 63: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 64: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 65: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 66: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 67: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 68: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 69: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 70: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 71: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 72: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 73: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 74: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 75: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 76: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 77: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 78: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 79: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 80: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 81: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 82: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 83: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 84: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 85: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 86: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 87: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 88: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 89: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 90: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 91: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 92: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 93: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 94: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 95: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 96: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 97: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 98: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 99: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 100: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 101: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 102: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

CDP #5-12-134

EXHIBIT #13

LETTERS ON HAZARDS OF WOOD SMOKE FROM OFFICIALS WORKING FOR PUBLIC AGENCIES

Page 103: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 104: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 105: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 106: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 107: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 108: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 109: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 110: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

CDP #5-12-134

EXHIBIT #14

LETTERS IN OPPOSITION TO PROPOSAL TO REMOVE FIRE RINGS.

Page 111: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 112: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 113: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 114: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 115: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 116: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 117: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 118: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 119: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 120: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 121: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 122: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 123: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 124: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 125: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 126: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 127: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 128: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 129: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 130: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 131: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 132: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 133: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 134: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 135: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 136: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 137: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 138: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 139: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 140: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 141: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 142: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 143: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report
Page 144: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

CDP #5-12-134

EXHIBIT #15

PETITION AGAINST REMOVAL OF FIRE RINGS

There are 5,578 signatures, of which 798 also provided written comments

(On-line exhibit only. Not in print version.)

Page 145: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

To: California Coastal Commission/Newport Beach City Council Members I just signed the following petition addressed to: California Coastal Commission. ---------------- Stop the removal of 60 fire rings at Big Corona State Beach and Balboa. The fire rings are an essential part of southern California beach culture. They offer low cost enjoyment for families. They stand for a tradition that all southern California residents can enjoy and should have the chance to experience with their families for years to come. Help support this petition to stop city council from removing all of Newport Beach's and CDM's fire pits. These fire pits serve as a fun, safe activity for families and people of all ages to go to and enjoy the warm nights in Southern California. There is no reason why these fire pits should be removed. They have been around for a long time and attract tourism and shoppers to the stores and restaurants in the surrounding area. If anything, the removal of these fire pits would hurt the businesses in the area. I ask that the City Council of Newport Beach reassess their plan to remove these fire rings and that the California Coastal Commission deny the permits needed to remove these pits. ---------------- 

Sincerely, 

PETITION PREAMBLE CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 146: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Benjamin Deering Irvine CA 92614 United States 9/28/2012

This is where we gather. A place for friends and family to spend time together. The place where stories are told and friends/memories are made.  

KEEP THE FIRE RINGS!!!

Ryan Torres Orange CA 92869 United States 9/23/2012 I love the fire pits and have used them for years!

Ken Hunrichs San Diego CA 92114 United States 9/19/2012

Stop the government from taking away our liberty to live our life as we see fit. We don't need a nanny state making our decisions for us. Instead of 

banning fire rings how about banning meddling politicians. 

Jason Bennett Carlsbad CA 92008 United States 9/19/2012 WHATS WRONG WITH A FIRE ON THE BEACH?

Ryan  Sweeney San Diego CA 92109 United States 9/19/2012 So tired of these politicians trying to remove all of the perks of living near the beach... time to vote these people out

ian Feliney North woodstock NH 03262‐041United States 9/19/2012 gov can suck it to fakie

John Wood Adelanto CA 92301 United States 9/19/2012

The beaches in that area were created at great cost for people's enjoyment, and is one of few outdoor places in the area where families can gather 

and interact with other families on summer nights.

Daniel Burke Dana Point CA 92629 United States 9/19/2012

I grew up with campfires at the beach here in Orange County. It was a big part of my childhood. I can't believe the city wants to get rid of 

something like this. Do they understand what they are taking away from the people they serve?

Volker Hoehne Del Mar CA 92014 United States 9/19/2012

The fire rings are an essential part of southern California beach culture. They offer low cost enjoyment for families. They stand for a tradition that 

all southern California residents can enjoy and should have the chance to experience with their families for years to come.

yvonne cathey San Bernardino CA 92404 United States 9/18/2012 Had many memories with my family , reunions, and pit BBQ's.    It would be a shame to lose the quality times we have.

anthony tran santa ana CA 92704 United States 9/16/2012 I grew up on this beach

Holly Carr Irvine CA 92612 United States 9/12/2012

Tradition.  I love watching the sunset at the beach.  I lived in the IE for 23 years and finally got the opportunity to move to the OC and enjoy the 

beach all year long.

Mary Chaffin Marana AZ 85653 United States 9/11/2012 My children and grandchildren need a place to continue their annual back to school bonfire tradition.

Crysany Bregman Riverside CA 92504 United States 9/5/2012 this is important to me because fire pits are a trade mark of california beaches!

Sujan Ahmed Riverside CA 92505 United States 9/5/2012 Brings family and friends together as an additional activity to celebrate

Dane  Perczak Riverside CA 92507 United States 9/5/2012

The pits bring me and friends together.      I met my girlfriend at a pit hangout.  Most of my favorite summer memories are here. There are many 

things that the city could use the money for instead, and the removal of something that adds fun and bonding in the community would be a waste 

of time, money, and resources.

Patricia Badham Riverside CA 92505 United States 9/5/2012 I love going to the beach and having a fire. Its fun and social, and there arent many places that let you do that.

Hanna Bierich Mission Viejo CA 92692 United States 9/5/2012

I enjoyed the fire pits for years with my children and now I go with my grandchildren. Campfire and marshmallows is a very important part of their 

lives.

Shannon Lowe Riverside CA 92506 United States 9/5/2012 Beach bonfires are the best. We need to keep them around!

frank bierich mission viejo CA 92692 United States 9/5/2012 Please save the pits for this beautiful beach experience and our kids

Beverley jones corona del mar CA 92625 United States 9/3/2012 Because the fire rings are an historic aminity

Paul Work Corona Del Mar CA 92625 United States 9/3/2012 We enjoy the community and friendship that the firepits engender...would be a shame to lose this part of our community...

DeAnn Work Corona Del Mar CA 92625 United States 9/3/2012 Our 6 year old loves the fire pits and we want to continue the tradition!

Richard Martinsen Corona del Mar CA 92625 United States 9/3/2012

I've resided in Corona del Mar since 1969, raised a family, and while growing up utilized the fire pits for fun. Now , as I grow older it's a joy to see 

folks from all over going to the beach and having as much fun as I once did. 

JENNIFER BORTMAN IRVINE CA 92614 United States 9/2/2012 more beach bonfires california has the best beaches ever

Lola Brauning Tustin CA 92780 United States 9/2/2012 Our family enjoys going down every summer and having the fire pits creates an atmosphere for connecting and supporting family tradition.

Jennifer Bierich Laguna Hills CA 92653 United States 9/1/2012 This is an integral part of California beach culture. Don't take away a wonderful beach activity enjoyed by so many people just to please a few.

Tamy Chapman Newport Beach CA 92660‐024United States 9/1/2012

A fun, inexpensive, and safe way to spend time with friends is having bonfires at the beach.  A lot more people enjoy these fire pits than don't.  Let 

those rich people compromise if they want to live by the beauty of the ocean, or let them move.  The beach belongs to everyone.

Ryan Martin Riverside CA 92504 United States 9/1/2012 This is a part of our California culture that is being removed!!!! So sad!

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 147: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Janet Carraman Santa Ana CA 92707 United States 8/30/2012

It's been a family tradition for many years to come to the beach and it with a Bon Fire. This tradition will be lost and I won't be able to build new 

memories with my kids. It's unfair that residents that live near beach shores new of their existance and didn't mind when they bought their home 

so........ what's so different now? If the  removal of the pits is a consequence for the parents negligence of having their kid fall into it them, you 

should have been more attentive with your child. I'm a parent of 2 and I'm always very cautious and attentive with my kids especially when were 

around a fire pit

Pamela  Brooks irvineMonroeIrvine CA 92620 United States 8/29/2012 Family tradition for over 30 years

Lynn  Elliott Glendora CA 91741 United States 8/28/2012 We really enjoy the beach and sitting around the fire pit and talking and roasting marshmallows 

James Lucas Corona CA 92883 United States 8/28/2012

The fire rings allow for good clean family fun. They extend the useable hours at the beach and offer a truly unique and wonderful experience. There 

is nothing more enjoyable than sitting around a campfire, singing songs, telling stories and enjoying the company of friends and family.

Steve Prescott Corona Del Mar CA 92625 United States 8/28/2012

I grew up in Corona del Mar and the fire pits are an integral part of the beach experience. Those fires create positive memories that are never 

forgotten. The greater social good is better served by keeping the fire pits.

Kathy  Corona  corona CA 92880 United States 8/27/2012

this has been a wonderful memory 

since i was child. . to sit around these fire rings with family and friends . Please leave them!!!!!

molly wiehardt newport beach CA 92663 United States 8/25/2012 children recreation that is healthy and happy environment family values are positive

Barbara Boatman Corona del Mar CA 92625 United States 8/25/2012

This is a part of our beach culture ‐ they have been there for years! I used to take the CDM cub scouts there for barbeques on the beach ‐ seems we 

can't do anything anymore, It would be a shame to see them go!

parker keil honolulu HI 96816 United States 8/24/2012

it's a part of Newport Beach's culture and is a great place to come together in order to share ideas and form communities. Having these fire pits in 

place only bring about good things and good times. this has to be stopped. 

Timothy Kennedy Santa Ana CA 92705 United States 8/24/2012

I was brought to these beach pits as a child, and now as a new dad, want the opportunity to carry on that tradition when my son is old enough. 

With the complete entertainment domination of video games, movies, and internet, we need all the opportunities we can to provide simple down 

to earth fun things of the old school variety for our families to enjoy!

Kathleen Rumph Newport Beach CA 92663 United States 8/24/2012 Grew up with them!

Joanie Cafferty Whittier CA 90602 United States 8/24/2012 I can make some pretty mean s'mores in the oven, but what fun is that?

Bruce Ytreeide Newport Beach CA 92657 United States 8/24/2012

It is such a fun tradition for families to enjoy the beach & coastline, day or evening! Tell the NB City Council to stop micro‐managing our beach 

lifestyle!

Sheri Van Dorn Orange 92869 Canada 8/24/2012 part of so cal life. family, friends and fun

Brett Del Valle Newport Beach CA 92663 United States 8/24/2012 Its part of Newport and should stay

Vanessa Molletti Santa Cruz CA 95060 United States 8/24/2012

I grew up going to Huntington and Newport beaches,  I have so many memories at those bonfire pits it's incredible.  There's a reason you have to 

show up early to get a fire pit to sit around, because so many people love it! It will be a sad day if the city goes through with this.

GAYLE BAGGALEY POLLOCK PINES CA 95726 United States 8/23/2012 BECAUSE CALIF IS REGULATING EVERYTHING TOOOO MUCH. LET PEOPLE HAVE FUN.

Alex Espinosa Sacramento CA 95816 United States 8/23/2012 So many great memories.  I run through episodes of nostalgia remembering moments at the firepits including my18th birthday!

Paul Burt Santa Ana CA 92705 United States 8/23/2012

The fire rings are a tradition for my church and would take away the main reason to go to CDM. The beach is meant as a way to escape the 

California heat and the pits make an all‐day beach trip complete.

Mary Eileen Angier Othello WA 99344 United States 8/23/2012

I was born and raised in  Southern CA.  Raised my children  there also. Going to the beach and having family time around the fire pits is a huge thing 

to us and our Church family too. Please keep them.

Dennis Vivanco Anaheim CA 92805 United States 8/23/2012

The pits are important because its where we all come to enjoy the company of our friends with an amazing view of the ocean. Great times continue 

to surround the pits. No need to remove what is still an amazing activity to this day.

Kevin Bolland Orange CA 92869 United States 8/23/2012

Every summer i use the balboa fire pits as a prime place to be with friends who can reunite at the beach after a long year in college. We use the pits 

as a perfect venue for reunions and days of fun.  People use the fire pits as a great place to come together and have a fun time. Newport Beach and 

Corona Del Mar will be less appealing without them

Jason Shahrikian Franklin WI 53132 United States 8/23/2012 I've loved going to the beach to have a great time with friends and family and a big part of it were the firepits, taking them away is a huge mistake.

gil lukosky Newport Beach CA 92663 United States 8/23/2012 Freedom......  How is that a few (apparently influential) people can dictate to us how we spend our time.

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 148: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Kelly New Fullerton CA 92831 United States 8/23/2012

I have gone to the fire pits all my life.  They are a wonderful way to have community, family, and friends gatherings alike.  Please do not remove 

them, as it would be like removing the joy of the summer at the beach, permanently.  In this day and age, we need all the joy that we can still get!!  

Please do not be one more thing that removes our joy from living this life today!

Darren Rector Orange CA 92867 United States 8/23/2012

Take away the fire pits at Corona and Balboa? I see no good reason to take away such a year‐round destination amenity.  I would like to know the 

reasoning behind the Council's decision.  I can't think of a better reason to chill and be social at the beach in the evening.

Kevin Kearns COSTA MESA CA 92627 United States 8/22/2012 A wonderful part of living at the beach. 

Melissa Davis Corona del Mar CA 92625 United States 8/22/2012

As an out of town youth in the 80's, while vacationing on Balboa Island, I used the fire rings. Now I live in Corona del Mar and my children and I use 

the fire pits.

JR Walz Corona del Mar CA 92625 United States 8/22/2012 Love using the firepits

Catherine Anderson Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 8/22/2012

I have 2 small children and we have already shared many memories with friends and families at the fire pits this summer.  I also grew up in the 

area, and some of my best summertime memories involve afternoons and evenings at the fire pits roasting marshmallows with friends and family.  

If Newport Beach removes the fire pits, it would lose some of the essence of what makes it such a special place. I think this would be a travesty.

Angela Rivera Costa Mesa CA 92627 United States 8/22/2012

The fire pits are something I use to use as a kid with friends and family. Now that I have a family of my own and can show them the traditions I had 

as a kid. My kids do enjoy having the bond fires at the beach when we do stay late . Especially the making of smores. Please keep the pits.

thanks

Michael Hardesty Newport Beach CA 92663 United States 8/22/2012 Beach fires are a CA tradition, fun for families and friends. Rings keep them safe! Keep them!

carolyn williams corona delar CA 92625 United States 8/22/2012 attempt to exclude people from public beaches

Jo Barrett Newport Beach CA 92663 United States 8/22/2012 They Have To Stay.......What's  an evening on the beach with friends, and s'mores  without the rings.  It's part of our So Cal beach experience.

Rick Deadmond Centralia IL 62801 United States 8/22/2012

The memories that were spent on the beach around the campfire rings. To lose them would be a tradgidy! Millions of families will be affected by 

the lose of these rings.They need to stay!!

cynthiaq barton balboa ISLAND CA 92662 United States 8/22/2012 We love the fire rings, always go in the fall & winter, please save one of the last bits of history

Madelynn Forgey Newport Beach CA 92663 United States 8/22/2012 This is a Southern California beach tradition for local residents and attracts tourism.

David Cowlin Mission Viejo CA 92691 United States 8/22/2012

This is one of the last places a family can enjoy a FULL DAYS of activity with swimming in the day and a great fire in the evening roasting dogs and 

marshmallows.  Please dont ruin this too!!

Cari Pierce‐Wiggins Placentia CA 92870 United States 8/21/2012

Fire pits at the beach are basic essential part of growing up in So Cal. First with family, then with friends. Then you grow up start your own family 

and the tradition continues from there. Don't take away another great part of growing up So Cal. 

Janice Stone Thomas Sacramento CA 95819 United States 8/20/2012 Memories and wanting more for future generations!

Steve Zeller Anaheim CA 92804 United States 8/19/2012 Tradition, great meeting place for back to school crowds

Colleen Middlebrook Upland CA 91784 United States 8/17/2012

We go to the Corona del mar and enjoy the fire pits with family & friends.   Without the pits, we cannot enjoy the beag after sundown.   Please 

keep the pits.  It also keep the fires safely contained instead of creating opportunity for other to build illegal fires in the sand once there are no pits. 

Burns from burried fires are severe and creates a new hazard to the beaches.  

Liz Bell Santa Monica CA 90404 United States 8/17/2012

This is an affront to beach lovers all over the world.  The Coastal Commission act determined that the beaches belong to all of us, even those who 

want night time fires.

jon muller irvine CA 92603 United States 8/16/2012 why would you ever think to remove such a great summer experence..

Ryder  Buck La Canada CA 91011 United States 8/14/2012

Beach bonfires are a tradition older than the people that populate the Newport homes these days. If these new richie‐rich's want a beach to 

themselves, they should have invested in a private island somewhere isolated. Instead, they chose one of the most beautiful PUBLIC beaches in 

California... so deal with the fact that people other than you are going to enjoy the beaches as well. Dick‐heads.

Dylan Brown Valencia CA 91354 United States 8/14/2012 <a href="http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?v=3912252358390" rel="nofollow">http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?v=3912252358390</a>

Camina Tripodi Arroyo Grande CA 93420 United States 8/14/2012 I want people to protect and enjoy the Marine environment!

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 149: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

C. Churchill Trabuco Canyon CA 92679 United States 8/14/2012

This is a long, long tradition for the People of California that must be preserved. If the People were voting on fire rings at the beaches of California, 

the support would be amazing. Please represent the People of California!

Paula  Fancher Sausalito CA 94965 United States 8/14/2012

My family has owned a home on the Balboa peninsula until recently.  We have, for years, enjoyed the fire pits on the ocean front.  Don't allow 

them to be closed.

Willard Chilcott Costa Mesa CA 92627 United States 8/13/2012

A few Newport Beach residents want the beach for themselves and begrudge the ability of residents from other areas to enjoy the pastime of 

sitting around the fire pits.

Barbara Gallian Corona Del Mar CA 92625 United States 8/13/2012 The fire pits are part of local heritage and belong to the people of Corona del Mar and Newport.

David  Sandow Santa Ana CA 92701 United States 8/13/2012

I have used the fire rings for years and I can't imagine the beach without them. They are a great place for families to gather

S.W. Conser Portland OR 97215 United States 8/13/2012 I have fond memories of summers at Newport Beach going back to when I was eight years old.

Matthew Shichtman Los Angeles CA 90046 United States 8/12/2012

The beach fire pits are an important part of Southern California culture. They have been enjoyed as an inexpensive way for the public to enjoy our 

beaches for years and, and should continue to be enjoyed for years to come. 

Cristina Parada Laguna Hills CA 92656 United States 8/11/2012

The fire rings are a beautiful part of California culture.  As a former CDM resident, I know what it's like to deal with outsiders on the weekends, but 

the people who go there are mostly respectful.  To lose this important gathering place for families and friends would be so sad..

Kathy  White Balboa Island CA 92662 United States 8/11/2012

The fire rings encourage families from all over to use the public beach and that is the the point.  The people up on the bluff need to realize that the 

rings were there first and are a tradition for people from all walks of life.  

Robert LeSueur Corona Del Mar CA 92625 United States 8/11/2012 The fire pits are awesome

Leann Soto Irvine CA 92606 United States 8/10/2012 I want to help save the fire rings! Just discovered this beach this summer and I love it! :) 

Veronica Munoz Pomona CA 91767 United States 8/10/2012

Corona Del Mar holds a special place in my heart. Many of my childhood summers were spent here at the beach with my family, enjoying hotdogs 

and s'mores thanks to the firepits. I came here as a teenager with my friends to enjoy the same festivities. Even to this day, this beach is my 

favorite. I enjoy this shore, the rocky cliffs nearby to explore, and especially the fire pits. Please don't take away from the beach's quality by 

removing some of them. Many people come early in the morning just to reserve one of these for the bonfire later on in the night. With so many 

being taken away, it creates a scarcity that people will have to fight for even more to reserve one. Please reconsider taking away Corona Del Mar's 

fire circles. Thank you. 

Larry Walsh Shadow Hills CA 91040 United States 8/10/2012

Government needs to stay out of our lives. The fire pits have been there longer than any of the council members have been alive. The costal 

commission should not allow our PUBLIC beaches to micro managed by misguided municipalities .

Andrew Chauvin Virginia Beach VA 23462 United States 8/10/2012

As a native Californian I cherish the opportunities to return and share a bonfire with my friends.  It's a tradition I do not want taken away  for selfish 

and cockamanie excuses.  Let us keep our privilege and responsibilities for maintaining a treasured gathering place.

Daniel  Bergh Erie CO 80516 United States 8/10/2012

I grew up in Orange County and to this day one of my fondest memories involves squeezing every last drop out of summer through days in the surf 

and evenings and nights around a bonfire with friends and family.  I return to California each year to visit friends and am now bringing my children 

to the beach.  I would hate to see the interests of some priviliged few, under the guise of public safety, scrap an iconic piece of California' character 

and history.  

AVONELLE KONE NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660 United States 8/10/2012

MY FAMILY HAS LIVED IN NEWPORT BEACH SINCE THE 1920'S.  I FEEL NEWPORT BEACH

IS UNDER ATTACK.   THE FUN ZONE ISSUE, THE EXPANSION OF THE BUILDING HEIGHT

REQUIREMENT AND NOW THE FIRE RINGS.  WE SHOULD STEP BACK AND RETHINK WHAT

WE ARE DOING TO OUR HISTORY.   THE DISRESPECT OF OUR HISTORICAL TOWN IS ALARMING.

AVONELLE KONE 

Steve Galvan Santa Fe Springs CA 90670 United States 8/10/2012 My family and I have been using the fire pits at Corona del Mar for years. It would be a shame if they were to be removed.

jeanie roe corona del mar CA 92625 United States 8/10/2012 Beach bonfires are magical.  Please don't take away this tradition.  

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 150: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

John Larson Santa Maria CA 93454 United States 8/10/2012

My parents first met, 72 years ago last month, at a bonfire on the beach in this area, and I remember fondly the fires my family and friends enjoyed 

while living at the beach during the summers when I was growing up.  The proposed ban smacks heavily of "locals only" elitism!  For the very 

reasons the Coastal Commission has fought for beach access for all of us, fire rings and the fires they surround should be readily available to all.

Ross Currens Newport Beach CA 92663 United States 8/10/2012

This is one of the best family/friend bonding experiences available to us here in Newport Beach. It is absurd to ban beach bon fires. I'm already 

unable to play basketball past 7 pm. I work from 7 a.m. to 6 p.m. throughout the week. We're working on banning every good, enjoyable actvity 

that one can enjoy in our parks in this community. 

April Garfield Laguna Hills CA 92653 United States 8/10/2012

Everyone should have the right to enjoy the beach. Not just wealthy homeowners.  There are less and less fire pits at California beaches.  Let's keep 

the ones we have.  For evenyone's enjoyment, including after the sun goes down, the most enjoyable time to have a fire at a fire pit on the beach. 

Kathryn Hess Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 8/9/2012 I have many happy memories of family BBQ's at the pits.. please allow other families to enjoy the same thing!

Suzanne Deano Irvine CA 92620 United States 8/9/2012

Beach fire pits are the center of DECADES of Orange Country family gatherings and are the epitome of So Cal Beach Night Life...why not take away 

Disneyland while you're at it...

Tammam Beydoun Aliso Viejo CA 92656 United States 8/7/2012 This is an essential part of my childhood I wished to share it with my kids.

Shawn Lee walnut CA 91789 United States 8/7/2012

Why is it that the need of the many are outweighed by the need of the minute?  CDM has been a beach where I have gone for the last 15‐20 years 

to unwind with friends and family, to enjoy a past time that has been experienced and cherished by so many.  Please do not take away one of the 

only areas that people can enjoy this still.  

Barbara Kraus Costa Mesa CA 92627 United States 8/7/2012 I have lived in Newport for 57 years and they are part of our local beach tradition!

Gregory W Hunter Anaheim CA 92805 United States 8/7/2012 Through the years, I have enjoyed visiting with family and friends as we've gathered around the fire pits. I would hate to lose such a special treat! 

Golden Bacheldet Corona Del Mar CA 92625 United States 8/6/2012 The fire pits are soooooooo fun!

Steve Leuck Wickenburg AZ 85358 United States 8/6/2012 I personally have used them since 1952 and people really love them.  Let them stay.  Newport Beach is my hometown.

Kimberlie DuBois Chino CA 91710 United States 8/5/2012

We drive to the beach at least 10 times during the summer, not to mention the rest of the year.   Staying later to watch the sunset and enjoy the 

firepits have been a family tradition since I was a child.  Please reconsider your decision to eliminate the firepits.   PLEASE.

 Raymond Gerbi Newport Beach CA 92662 United States 8/2/2012

Tired of a few newcomers trying to make Newport Beach into Pasadena! Sick of our pandering city council backing them. The air around fire rings 

has NOT been proven harmful to anyone who is around them.

Marilyn Elliott‐Lewis Rawlins WY 82301 United States 8/2/2012 All 5 of my kids are still in the area and this is where I grew up. I don't want to see them removed. It's a tradition!

Arthur Lopez Tustin CA 92782 United States 8/2/2012

It's a signature camping/community building activity. Especially dear to young ones, who Love "smores"! 

It also serves as an incentive to come outdoors to enjoy and appreciate the beauty of our Lord's Creation!! Need I say more?

As for the legalities, think of an alternative method of providing insulation if you are so preoccupied.

Karen Johnston Lake Forest CA 92630 United States 8/1/2012

Big Corona has been my favorite beach since childhood, growing up on Balboa Island.  The fire rings are such a treasure and there are so few 

available.  To lose them would be very sad.  They were there long before the few complaining homeowners!

Caroline McCabe Santa Ana CA 92704 United States 8/1/2012

For over 30 years our family has enjoyed the firepits on Thursday nights during the summer.  It has always been a family‐safe and teenager friendly 

way to spend time together.  Please don't take that from our grown‐up kids and their children who are now part of that family tradition!

Albert Barnett Corona del Mar CA 92625 United States 7/31/2012 Another unnecessary government intrusion into our lives.  The firepits are fun to some, and harmless to all.

Kathleen Luby Santan valley AZ 85143 United States 7/31/2012 Used to live and party in Newport, would hate to see the rings go. Good Memories. Please keep the fire rings. Thank‐You

Laural Armster Long Beach CA 90803 United States 7/31/2012

I grew up in central Cali, and spent my teen years reading a book series set in Corona Del Mar. This translated into dreaming about spending 

summers on the beach with my friends, hanging out around the fire rings and learning to surf. It took several years of hard work, but I live in So. Cal 

now, and I do spend summer weekends at the beach learning to surf! Every year I join a group of friends for time at the same fire rings I read about 

as a teen, and we enjoy hanging out and grilling, playing guitars and gorgeous sunsets. Please keep the fire pits. They've been a huge part of my 

dreams. 

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 151: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Charles Mejia Corona CA 92882 United States 7/31/2012

Corona Del Mar is state operated, Newport should not be able to remove the rings, they belong to the people of California and thus the people of 

California should be able to choose weather they want them or not.

Marleen Robinson Orange CA 92868 United States 7/31/2012

Those are state beaches, and local residents must understand the limits of where they reside. It is public lands, and the recreation and enjoyment 

of the beach/ocean shouldn't be limited to the select complaints of those that can afford the beach front property; but the state has the 

responsibility of ensuring access and enjoyment for all citizens.  I work and live in California, and my tax dollars goes into every  aspect of beach 

maintenance, & I support keeping the fire pits!

Diane Cain Irvine CA 92604 United States 7/31/2012

Cookouts at the CdM fire rings are a wonderful tradition for many Southern California families. My extended family come from all over the US, 

building summer trips around a much‐anticipated and always memorable afternoon and evening on the beach at Big Corona. This activity draws 

generations together ‐‐ we celebrate our lives, milestones and each other together at the fire rings. Cookouts there have always been a peaceful 

and safe endeavor for us and for the many other families who enjoy the same. Keep the fire rings as they are!  

Mary Spindler Placentia CA 92870 United States 7/31/2012

I love to come use them, have a group of youth here today 7/31/12. We would go to a different beach. I work in Newport Beach & Love Corona del 

Mar. Please keep the fire pits!!

Martha Fluor Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 7/31/2012 Have used the fire pits in the past for family events.  Wonderful family and friend activity.

JOSEPH CAIN GOLDEN CO 80402 United States 7/28/2012

I grew up in southern California and have 4 Grandchildren there, If we can't enjoy the fire‐pits on the Beach when I visit, Then maybe U have 1 in 

you'r yard We can use? 

Michael Miller Winter Springs FL 32708 United States 7/28/2012

Until I moved to Florida, for almost 15 years, I came to Corona Del Mar every Thursday evening during the summer to enjoy an evening with friends 

and their families. At times we had three generations of family members at the same time. What a shame to remove the fire rings.  

Isn't the California Costal Commission supposed to ensure all residents have access to the  beaches for recreation. This would seem to be at least a 

small step in the wrong direction and in conflict with its charter.

Rochelle McAleer Tustin, CA 92780 United States 7/28/2012

The fire pits are a gathering place for fun beach evenings, social times and making family memories. As such, they are a big part of our Southern 

California culture.  What a big mistake it would be to remove them !!  

Misty Bykowski Shelby Township MI 48317 United States 7/27/2012

The Fire Rings have been an important part of my dear friends life for many many years.  Each Thursday during the summer they reunite with 

friends and family in the same spot.  We always know where to find them.  The mood on the beach is one of fun, love, and cherished memories 

being made.

Please do not take this away from countless families who've discovered the magic of the fire pits and surrounding beach.  It's a special place.  One 

that should be shared with ALL who wish to enjoy it.

Barry McAleer Orange CA 92869 United States 7/27/2012 For once, let reason be the determining factor, not MONEY!!!!

Linda  Rauterkus Santa Ana CA 92705 United States 7/27/2012

We have been coming to CDM on Thursday nights for the past 33 years. Our children were babies when we began this most enjoyable tradition. 

They brought their friends, and now our grandchildren come, our children's friends with their little ones. We enjoy 6 to 10 summer Thursday nights 

at the pits. It is time for family and friends to get together and enjoy the beach and one another. Please don't remove the pits!

amy rodriguez Victorville CA 92392 United States 7/27/2012 u cant get rid of the pits!! Theyre awesome..

Emaan  Baqai Irvine CA 92620 United States 7/26/2012 I love the fire pits!

Alexander Rearick St. Louis MO 63119 United States 7/26/2012

Because it was a great opportunity and experience when I was out there for a seminar. It allowed our group to get to know each other in a 

multitude of ways. I know how awesome of a place and experience it was for me and hope that others will be able to enjoy the same experiences 

as well. Please DO NOT take this amazing place and ALL it has to offer away. Thank You

Naomi Sahlstrom Tracy MN 56175 United States 7/26/2012 I have special memories from a cookout in a fire ring on these very beaches!!!

Sandi Bradford Williams Bay WI 53191 United States 7/26/2012 I enjoy this beach every summer...it's tradition to have a cook out. Please don't take the pits away...

Hilda Rodriguez Redlands CA 92373 United States 7/26/2012

These are the only beaches around me that are close in off that have fire pits. It makes going to the beach even more fun and specially at might its 

the best when beaches have pits makes the whole thing even better!!!!!!!!

Joel Molitor Burlington WI 53105 United States 7/25/2012 I have spent entire days at the fire pits on our yearly visits to CA, and they have been wonderful. 

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 152: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Jessica Molitor Burlington WI 53105 United States 7/25/2012

I have been coming to Corona Del Mar Beach every year for the past 9 years with About 30 Missionary Kids every Summer. Our beach day is a 

highlight for the missionary kids, enjoying the water, hiking the rocks and most of all cooking our dinners and smores with the fire pits. The Group 

has been using the pits for at least 12‐15 years. 

we want to keep this tradition going for years to come with more Missionary Kids. 

Perry Bradford Williams Bay WI 53191 United States 7/25/2012

Every summer we bring a group of Missionary Kids to Corona to enjoy a piece of true southern CA culture.  We have been doing this for well over 

15 years and it is a highlight of our program.  We have always enjoyed our afternoon and evening around the fire...and the local people have been 

wonderful to us...and made us feel welcome.  I hope that this time next year...we can still enjoy this southern CA cultural experience.  

Amanda  Picard Irvine CA 92620 United States 7/24/2012

It's not southern California without bonfires! Traditions are started, memories made, smores and hot dogs roasted. Why would you want to take 

that away?!!!!

Kimberley Hawker Halifax B4B 1S6 Canada 7/24/2012

We visit family in California, and our fondest memories are the fires on the beaches. It's part of California's charm and draw. Please don't take that 

away. 

Matthew Kupferer Irvine CA 92620 United States 7/23/2012

The beaches and firepits are as iconic to SoCal as Disneyland. Removing the fire pits would be destroying one of the key elements to the Southern 

California experience

Heidi Schemel Beaumont CA 92223 United States 7/21/2012

My kids and I love going to Corona Del Mar and staying to cook hot dogs‐‐they look forward to it all year long.  I love the pits at Corona Del Mar 

beach.  It's a smaller beach, which I like for younger kids, and it's easier to meet up with friends.  Please don't take away the fire pits.

Barbara Kellerman Long Beach CA 90808‐271United States 7/18/2012 I am a native Californian and remember the long tradition in California of fire pits.  I feel they add to the beach experience and should be retained.   

Jack Hogan Newport Beach CA 92663 United States 7/18/2012 I enjoy the firepits, they are part of beach culture.  If you dont like beach culture, don't live by the beach.  You wont be missed.

Desiree Berry Corona Del Mar CA 92625 United States 7/18/2012 Leave the Pitts alone! 

Haman Movafagh Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 7/17/2012

since the 7th grade, My friends and I would go to the pits the Sat after school would be out for the summer.  We've been doing that now for 17 

years.  Its become bigger and more meaningful than when we first started.  Old friends now get together from around the country for this one day.  

Old friends bringing there friends, and new friendships created.  These pits mean so much us.  

J. Poole Santa Ana CA 92705 United States 7/16/2012 This should remain a public amenity.

randy workman glendora CA 91741 United States 7/16/2012

My family and a few other families go to Big Corona Beach annually to stay for the day and enjoy an evening of time around the fire and doing 

smors. The kids absolutely love it and have a blast. We get there at 6 am to reserve our favorite pit. It would be a shame to see them removed. We 

wouldn't return...we would just go to any beach. Big Corona is special because of it's fire pits..

antonio barajas ontaio CA 91762 United States 7/15/2012 Stop the removal of 60 fire rings at Big Corona State Beach and Balboa.

Steve Bedaux Burbank CA 91505 United States 7/14/2012

The fire rings are a Newport Beach Land mark.  They have been in place for well over 30 years.   Many life long memories have been generated 

there.  The rings should remain, so more generations can enjoy.  

Donna Garrett 92867 United States 7/9/2012

The fire pits are what bring people to the beach and are a revenue to the city due to the cost of parking. As a member of the National Charity 

League, our girls come and clean the beach as part of their philanthropic work and also want to come and enjoy an evening at the beach BBQing at 

the pits. The beaches do not belong to the homes along the coast, they belong to all residents of california to be enjoyed by all. 

Beth Ulery Orange CA 92867 United States 7/9/2012 keep the Fire Rings at the beaches!!!!!

sandra grusman rancho cucamonga CA 91739 United States 7/9/2012

The fire pits have been a part of my family tradition for many years now. In the summertime my family has a reunion and we all sit around the pit 

to roast s'mores. I would hate for the tradition to be lost. Hopefully you realize that there are many people out there sadend by this. 

                            ‐Sandy

Janice FitzGerald Irvine CA 92620 United States 7/9/2012

Going to the Carona del Mar beach is a tradition.  The firepits include that tradition.  We have spent many summer nights there BBQing and singing 

around the firepits.  Don't take these great memories from future generations!  

BOB PORTALE CORONA DEL MAR CA 92625 United States 7/8/2012 THE PITS ARE A CORONA DEL MAR TRADITION!

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 153: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Cindra Huffman Diamond Bar CA 91765 United States 7/8/2012

The Orange Co. beaches have been part of my life since we moved here in 1969!  Every summer we have cook outs at the fire rings in late 

afternoon & evenigs.  It is part of our summer experience as a family!  I know many others who say the same.

Tabitha Hapl Salida CO 81201 United States 7/7/2012 These are a California right of passage. A tradition that in a changing world we need to keep. Somethings are better left unchanged!

william rankin huntington beach CA 92648 United States 7/7/2012 We have to make people be responsible for their actions and not let the people who teach their kids safety take the fall. KEEP THE PITS!

Marissa Grusman Rancho Cucamonga CA 91739 United States 7/7/2012

Going to the beach in the Summertime has been a family tradition for years. Sitting by the fire and talking and spending time together by the fire is 

a great bond for my family and I. The kids like to make s'mores and it's just a great bond that I would hate to loose. I am signing this petition 

because I think that it would be a terrible thing to break family time up. This is what i have to say about taking the pits out. 

SAVE THE PITS!

Marc McMenamin Flushing NY 11358 United States 7/7/2012

I've been visiting New Port Beach beaches every week all summer since 1965 and the Fire Pits are just part of the enjoyment.  Please save our fire 

pits!

tamara spring Calabasas CA 91302 United States 7/7/2012

Loosing the fire pits is like loosing the dinner table!  It is a special time to join together as family and friends to share your day. There is something 

truly special out on the beach, smelling the salt air with sand between you toes and gazing into a roaring fire.  Somehow all is good... California's 

beaches have been enjoyed for centuries with the use of fire and should be for many years to come.    

Victoria  Cohenour North Las Vegas NV 89031 United States 7/6/2012 To keep the fire pits so that future generations can enjoy them.

Justin Miramontes Mission Viejo CA 92691 United States 7/4/2012

There is actually public safety concerns if they remove these pits and I wonder if local police, firefighter, and paramedics have signed off on this. 

The pits provide a safe, controlled environment for people to enjoy an evening at the beach with a traditional fire pit. Rogue beach fires outside of 

marked fire‐pits are extremely dangerous and cause severe injuries to children who step on a fire pit that was not properly put out (putting it out 

by covering the fire in sand is the worst thing one could do) by the gathering the night before. People will continue this tradition with or without 

the fire pits. The question is if the city will do the responsible thing and allow a safe environment to do it. If they remove the safe pits, will they 

accept partial responsibility for the searing of the next child or a tourists' feet? 

Yvette Calderon Ontario CA 91762 United States 7/4/2012

Its been a family tradition for a couple of years now, to head to the beach and save a pit, so in the evening we can light it and make smores, and 

relax!

Charles wherritt Mission Viejo CA 92691 United States 7/4/2012

These fire pits are a part of history and something that friends and families look forward to.  When we tell people visiting from out of state "lets go 

burn god at the beach" their jaws drop and they ask "you can light a fire at the beach?" and we tell them "only some of them". please don't remove 

this wonderful beach from that short unique list!

Eric Malyszka Newport Beach CA 92663 United States 7/4/2012 Because I enjoy them frequently!!

Bradford Gilliland Las Vegas NV United States 7/4/2012 This is part of the enjoyment of the beach.

zane mayer McCloud CA 96057 United States 7/4/2012

I have spent many wonderful nights utilizing these beaches and fire rings.  Now my children and grandchildren deserve to create similar memories 

for their families.  Improve what has been a beautiful & enjoyable place for thousands of people for many years.  STOP THE STUPIDITY! Fix or 

improve, DO NOT remove!

Travis Hill Irvine CA 92617 United States 7/3/2012 The firepits are my summer life. How fun will CDM be without fire to cook our wienies?!

Jennifer Hagen Irvine CA 92606 United States 7/3/2012 Hey a**holes don't take the pits away!

Jonathan Monte United States 7/3/2012

The Fire Pits are a fun part of our local beach culture and we should definitely keep them. Sounds like most of the arguments to remove them are 

coming from a few snooty rich people that don't like the "smell". They were here before you bought your waterfront mansion. If you don't like em. 

MOVE. 

Paul  Smith Fullerton CA 92831 United States 7/3/2012

This is wrong ! Very wrong. Think of the loss of family traditions, community activities, regional events, all the young lovers ending a perfect date 

night...I can go on...and on... 

Bottom line, it wrong.

Alissa Medart Whittier CA 90603 United States 7/2/2012 The fire pits are a great beach activity. Do not take that away from us!!

Mari Bell Corona del Mar CA 92625 United States 6/28/2012 The fire pits are a great gathering place for CdM friends and families.

Teresa Bell Henderson NV 89074 United States 6/28/2012 We had so much fun around the firepits as kids.  The only problem was getting there early enough to snag one for our group.

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 154: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Dominica Kristedja Santa Ana CA 92705 United States 6/27/2012 The beaches should be for all the public to enjoy not just those who can afford a home on the sand!

Candice DuBose United States 6/27/2012 My family and church always enjoys using the fire pits each summer.  It is a valued tradition and community builder.

Susanne Syben Mosci Irvine CA 92620 United States 6/27/2012 The Fire pits are unique 

Claudia Castanares Newport Beach CA 92657 United States 6/26/2012

I've grown up going to those firepits‐ some of my best memories are spending summers there with my family. I'm getting married next year and 

plan on starting a family shortly after & want to carry on the tradition with my children as well.

Renee Spindle Mira Loma CA 91752 United States 6/25/2012

The fire rings are a beach party tradition.  What's a family reunion beach party with no fire rings.  I would miss passing this tradition on to my 

grandkids.

Heather Maddigan Mission Viejo CA 92691 United States 6/25/2012 My family really looks forward to beach bonfires every summer and its a great experience for our out of town guests! 

Liz Pattison Costa Mesa CA 92627 United States 6/23/2012

I grew up using those firepits and it wouild be awuful if they were removed‐ lets try to keep a little of old Orange County for future generations‐ 

They have been there forever and have never caused a ruckus‐ it really is true that if you live in Orange County you shouldn't be sentimental‐ and 

thats not right !!!

Ted Mortenson Balboa CA 92661 United States 6/23/2012

As a resident since 1967, I resent any action that tries to "remove" that which has become part of our simple freedoms and pleasures in Balboa.  

Our tradition in Balboa does not support this kind of nonsense, and our tolerance of others needs to greatly expand.

carolyn snyder Kalispell MT 59901 United States 6/23/2012 All suffer for the few

Julie Reinbold Sandpoint ID 83864 United States 6/22/2012 Memories and hopefully! future memories for me and everyone else who would experience a bonfire at the beach.

Genevueve  Hunt Happy Valley OR 97086 United States 6/22/2012 It Is a tradition since I lived there and parents need to be more observant about there children near fires and embers.

cheryl  arend newtown CA 6470 United States 6/21/2012

Oh, why would you take away something that has been there for years and years Our family and grandparents far back have enjoyed the simple 

ways of life, (which is so hard to find amongst video games and texting) forever. It is what makes this beach what it is!!!! Whoever is thinking of 

this, know that east coasters come to this beach for this reason. IT provides night time memories . This is what brings back memories of story times 

with family, and brings back those we have lost thru bon fires with the family. There is no need to change something not broken. Thats what makes 

BAlboa ,Balboa!!!!

Richard Purpura Orange CA 92867 United States 6/18/2012

Fire rings are long time tradition for Southern California beach goers.  Any potential negative impact of fire ring use (pollution, hot coals, etc.) is 

more than offset by the enjoyment of there users.

Donna O'Donoghue Brisbane 4060 Australia 6/16/2012 The fire pits made my last vacation very memorable. I would like to see them retained as local families enjoyed them so much.

Jennifer Allen Corona Del Mar CA 92625 United States 6/15/2012

My children and I live just a couple blocks from the beach in CDM. We love using the firepits to make s'mores and have family fun. It is one of the 

main reasons why we choose this beach to live near. We would be really disappointed to see these taken out. 

Charles Masters Corona del Mar CA 92625 United States 6/14/2012

People come from all over Southern California to visit Big Corona, to have a picnic on the beach and cook‐out in these fire pits. The fire pits have 

been there since I was a child (I was born here in 1949). It is a shame that the City of Newport Beach would want to remove such a family‐friendly 

feature of Corona del Mar.

Lynn Matzenger Oxnard CA 93033 United States 6/12/2012 These are what made out beach experiences growing up.  Roasting marshmellows and singing aroung the fire.....

Diana Rivera Moreno Valley CA 92557 United States 6/12/2012

One of the best parts of our traditional summer trips to the beach is the bonfire ‐ roasting hot dogs and making s'mores. I grew up at the So Cal 

beaches and now my son has grown up there ‐ it just won't be the same if you remove the pits. Please keep them!!

Marilyn Scott‐Waters Costa Mesa CA 92626 United States 6/12/2012 Cook outs on the beach with my family are the best part of summer. Beaches are for everyone. 

Louise Rose Costa Mesa CA 92626 United States 6/12/2012 There must be another way to keep the pits safe. Taking them away takes away my rights as a citizen to enjoy our oceans.

Brett Bigelow Irvine CA 92614 United States 6/12/2012 The fire pits have been a part of my beach life.  They are a simple enjoyment & tradition that should remain available to all beach users.

Frances Lindsay Costa Mesa CA 92626 United States 6/11/2012 Stop the removal of the fire pits.

David Sharp Mission Viejo CA 92691 United States 6/10/2012

Just lovely. There is very much enjoyment by many families for a beach campfire picnic!! Clearly the people with power to vote these away lack 

outdoor life apart from a shopping mall...

Very very sad.

MOVE THE PITS AND ALTERNATE FROM TIME TO TIME!!!!!! The tax payers have payed for the equipment already..

Maybe next is no sunset watching!

Frank Dwyer Newport Beach CA 92661 United States 6/10/2012 Environmental Protection gone crazy!

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 155: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Andrea Sea Namaste Venice CA 90291 United States 6/10/2012

I love beach bonfires.  Roasting marshmellows is one of my best childhood memories.  It saddens me that I now have to drive for miles to find a 

place where it's safe and legal to have a bonfire.  Wtih more people in California, we need all the fire rings we have.  We should be adding them, 

not removing them!  (My addresss is currently in Moorpark, CA, but I will soon be moving back to the Santa Monica area, and I have friends in Long 

Beach who prefer to drive south for beach time.)

Theresa O'Keefe Garden Grove CA 92840 United States 6/8/2012

It sickens me that people want to remove everything that is "fun." As for potential lawsuits..maybe if people CONTROLLED their kids their kids 

wouldn't get hurt. People can't control their kids, but they want to CONTROL society.  Disgusting!!

Laura Bounds Orange CA 92869 United States 6/6/2012 Family tradition, warmth and it's a Great California Family tradition... Please keep these Ring fire pits 

Sherrie Green La Habra CA 90631 United States 6/6/2012 A family tradition. 

Paula Duhn Santa Ana CA 92705 United States 6/5/2012

These have been part of my life, all my life.  Why would you take them away due to a few stupid people when millions have enjoyed them for 

decades?!

Erik Swarbrick Mission Viejo CA 92691 United States 6/5/2012 Tired of special interests shutting out the citizens of Ca. from our public areas.

Andrew  Johnson  Upland CA 91784 United States 6/5/2012

I am signing this petition because the solution to the vaguely stated reasons for their removal is extreme.  The people misusing the fire pits are the 

minority.  I attended UC Irvine 2005‐2010 and used the fire pits several times during the years for networking and recreational events and never 

witnessed any problems.  If the stated misuse of the fire pits is a true issue then a compromise needs to be made to maintain the fire pits while 

providing adequate oversight of the rules.  As a frequent user of the fire pits, I pledge to participate in peaceful and non‐violent protests until a 

compromise solution, resulting in the decision to keep the fire pits, is reached.  

~Andrew Johnson

Krissy Danforth Upland CA 91786 United States 6/5/2012

The removal of these fire pits will be the death of a tradition enjoyed by many generations. My children will no longer be able to enjoy cooking 

s'mores over the fire, and I feel this is a huge loss to what it considered a huge cultural staple in Southern California.

Tom  Whitney Fullerton CA 92831 United States 6/4/2012 I want the fire tradition to continue!

Jenifer Russo Corona Del Mar CA 92625 United States 6/3/2012

Big Corona and the fire rings are a big part of my memories growing up. This was the only beach my mom would bring my sister and I to during the 

summer and where we would bring out of town guests. We would BBQ and enjoy the fire pit in the evening. 

Later in life it was a dream come true what my husband and I where fortunate enough to buy a place in the village where we could spend the 

summers with our young sons. At night when I see the fire p

Steve Crouch Orange CA 92869 United States 6/2/2012 Many memories at these fire rings. Good to keep for the community.

Elaine Mullen‐Barrett Laguna Beach CA 92651 United States 6/1/2012 I'm so sick of governmen ruining everything we love. 

Leslie Rolsheim Costa Mesa CA 92627 United States 5/31/2012

I am a third generation Big Corona firepit lover!  Church groups, college groups and families enjoy the firepits there.  Other issues need to be 

addressed, not the firepits.

Mark King Newport Beach CA 92661 United States 5/30/2012

Closing the pits is part of dismantling the family culture that Newport Beach was built on.   Remember the Fun Zone, its history is what popularized 

the peninsula.

Carole Call Costa Mesa CA 92626 United States 5/30/2012

So many happy memories around the firepits with my family and friends.  Even when I was a youth in San Diego and for the past 27 years in Orange 

County at Huntington and Newport.  Please keep the rings.

Karin Garell Newport Beach CA 92657 United States 5/30/2012

The fire pits are a long standing community traditional.  Countless family gatherings, birthday parties, youth groups, etc have gathered and bonded 

over "bonfires" at the beach.  Who in Southern California who has grown up near the beach does not have fond memories of those summer nights 

spent around the bonfire listening to the waves, taking in the salty air, and just feeling the ultimate essence of SUMMER!  The nearby homeowners 

do not have a right to limit the public's use and enjoyment of the beach.  They knew about beach use, including the fire pits, when they moved 

there.  If they don't like it, they can move somewhere else!  If there are issues with the fire pits, they can be resolved in another way.  This unique 

experience should be preserved for the generations to come!!

Connie Cannon Rancho Santa Margarita CA 92688 United States 5/30/2012 Shouldn't a decision like this be on a ballot??

Jennifer Harris Irvine CA 92617 United States 5/29/2012

The fire pits at the beach are a great tradition that my family and I have come to enjoy each year.  We have used them to teach our scouts how to 

build a fire.  It would be sad to see them go.

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 156: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Julia Sutton Costa Mesa CA 92626 United States 5/29/2012 As a 2nd Generation Californian, these fire rings are a part of my history ~ and now, a part of my child's history. Leave them in place!

Paul Thompson Sugarloaf CA 92386 United States 5/27/2012 The beach belongs to the people, not a few politicos...

Gary Temple Kihei HI 96753 United States 5/27/2012

I grew up in OC and going to beach with our family and friends is still some of my fondest memories....Dont stop this for future generations... Go do 

it and eat a smore, you will remember or understand!

David Hanson Corona del mar CA 92625 United States 5/27/2012

I have enjoyed using and looking at the firepits for over 20 years.  I also live on Ocean Blvd. in Corona del mar and believe a majority of residents 

living in Corona del mar support leaving the fire pits as is.  Once again the City Council did not spend the time to find out how the people they serve 

feel about this issue and based their decision on pressure from a small minority.  Let all concerned have ample time to be heard and please 

consider not getting rid of the fire pits with such great haste.

Michael Ormerod Corona del Mar CA 92625 United States 5/26/2012

The city council is  legislating away the character of our town based on transplant complaints and city attorneys justifying their jobs. This is their 

response to the continual harassment of a minute few. What's next? If there is an electrical fire in a house and the new residents do't like the smell 

of the fire, will the city council outlaw all electricity in  windward homes? 

Lynn Popkins San Dimas CA 91773 United States 5/26/2012

We love these pits! my husband and I grew up at these pits during the summer, and are home owning tax payers whose children are now not going 

to have those great memories that we did! This is ridiculous, when will we STOP punishing tax payers by removing what we WANT to pay for, and 

quit forcing us to pay for things we abhor??

Judi Chimits Irvine CA 92614 United States 5/26/2012 Because the PUBLIC has a right to use this beach! We want the fire rings!

Laurie Tooch Newport beach CA 92663 United States 5/26/2012

This is a terrible idea! I have lived in Newport beach for 45 years and still enjoy a fire ring cook out with family and friends. Good clean fun, it is one 

of the nice things about being at the beach. Enjoying a sunset while cooking hot dogs, playing football, eating smores! 

Let's not take away any more of our freedoms to unfounded fears!!

gladys julia smith huntington beach CA 92648 United States 5/25/2012

we've been using the fire pits for 40years

Randy Duarte Newport Beach CA 92663 United States 5/25/2012 As long time residents of Newport, we enjoy the use of these fire pits regularly.

Kerry Lamperts Irvine CA 92604 United States 5/25/2012

I have been a resident of  Newport Beach, Costa Mesa and Irvine for a total of 54 years and have enjoyed countless evenings at Big Corona Beach 

with friends and family around the fire rings. It's a part of our local history and I would really hate to see them removed. It is a State beach and I 

know many come from other Orange County communities to enjoy campfires on the beach. Public access and enjoyment of the fire rings should be 

preserved.

John Kalucki San Francisco CA 94114 United States 5/25/2012

As a long time former resident of Newport Beach, and a annual beach house renter, I would be very disappointed to lose the fire rings. Mixed use 

consistent with conservation is the highest use for the beach, not just what is convenient for the NBPD and certain neighbors.

Kristina  Ruiz‐Mesa Boulder CO 80302 United States 5/25/2012

Beaches are a natural beauty that everyone should be allowed to enjoy. This is a clear case of a few social elites dictating access to the greater 

population.  

Andrew Craft Costa Mesa CA 92626 United States 5/24/2012

Going to the local beach has always been a major part of my summer and the evenings would never be the same if we were to never be able to 

have a BBQ ever again.  Hopefully, the tens of thousands of beach goer can help rally together to keep this Orange County tradition for the years to 

come.

Courtney Urquiza Rancho Cucamonga CA 91729 United States 5/24/2012

We have lived in California all our lives and most of our Summers spent on the beach enjoying the ocean breeze and conversations around the 

bonfires, it is a tradition we hope to pass onto our children as Californians! Pretty soon we wont even be able to lay out our blankets on the sand 

and watch our children building sand castles!!!

Peter Jensen Newport Beach CA 92663 United States 5/24/2012 I love having fires at the beach!

Ron Bergstrom Huntington Beach CA 92649 United States 5/24/2012

Because our children have the right to experience what we did as kids.  Help stop a few property owners from taking this experience away from our 

children and grandchildren.

laura pell irvine CA 92612 United States 5/24/2012

this is a safe and fun FAMILY activity

let's be responsible people

let's save the southern califronia tradition!

Beverly Ganiere costa mesa CA 92626 United States 5/24/2012

We love being able to keep warm on an evening outing to the beach as well as to have hot dogs, smores etc.  Please don't remove the pits.  Keep 

the beach Family Friendly.

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 157: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Kyle Nguyen Irvine CA 92614 United States 5/24/2012 i love those fire rings because they have created great memories and i dont want them to be gone.

Lori Byon Franktown CO 80116 United States 5/24/2012 Do you all want to ban Santa Clause and rule out the tooth fairy, as well?  

Matthew Ketsdever Capistrano Beach CA 92624 United States 5/24/2012

Beach bonfires have been part of our cultural history for decades.  The fire rings provide a reasonable and safe method of containing the fire and 

resultant ashes.  

Ammon Waters salt lake city UT 84111 United States 5/24/2012

I visit Newport Beach every other month and would like to enjoy a firepit for warmth on the cold california nights while there.  This would take 

away from the charm of the place.  Frankly tired of this happening all over the country. 

Janice  Durston Norco CA 92860 United States 5/24/2012

There is something spiritual about a campfire on the beach after dark with the family.  Please don't deprive my kids of one of the last truly CA 

experiences!

Mary McDaniel Riverside CA 92503 United States 5/24/2012

Because the fire pits are a longstanding part of the beach experience that my family has enjoyed for years.  I haven't yet heard a valid argument to 

remove them. Air quality, beach safety, unwanted visitors, etc. will be an issue with or without the pits.  Let's preserve and encourage family time. 

Jan McQueen Huntington Beach CA 92648 United States 5/24/2012

I have been going to this beach for over 20 years ‐ meeting with friends every week over a bonfire dinner.  I even met my husband here.  Why on 

earth would we want to take away the ability to connect with our friends and family in such a healthy and beautiful environment?  Will the city try 

to take away beach access next?  It isn't even the city's beach ‐ it's a STATE beach.  

Jeanette Lamar davis CA 95616 United States 5/24/2012 Our family has used these fire pits for years. It's a wonderful family outing we all look forward to no matter how old we get. 

bj Chandler Tustin CA 92782 United States 5/24/2012 Lots of fun for all ages!

Erin Reyes Hesperia CA 92345 United States 5/23/2012

I really dont get the whole idea of removing the fire pits... if you're a native to southern ca. then you have childhood/teenage and young adult 

memories of nights at the fire pits... what do our state beaches have against fire pits and the people who love them??

Anirudh Thakore Irvine CA 92620 United States 5/23/2012

I want the State/County beaches and parks to be available for use by all. Private Newport Beach residents may choose to do what they want in 

their own backyards but they have no business passing laws to restrict the use of fire pits in public beach parks. They knew fully well all the hazards 

(smoke, etc) when they bought their beach homes. Besides, who are they kidding about a fire hazard? Have you seen how far the pits are from the 

homes?

Mike Maynard Irvine CA 92620 United States 5/23/2012 We want to enjoy a fire by the beach still

Roberta Palfini Irvine CA 92614 United States 5/23/2012 We have so many wonderful family memories with beach cook‐outs.  Don't take the fire rings away!!!

Scott Rychnovsky Irvine CA 92617 United States 5/23/2012 It is a great community activity for our youth.

Raymond Hart Santa Ana CA 92705 United States 5/23/2012

I think they tried this in Huntington Beach not too long ago, and it got shot down because people were outraged at such an asinine measure by City 

Council members.  Perhaps someone can verify that. In any case, fire rings, picnics and barbecues on the beach are a huge part of the fun of going 

to the beach. Why would they even think about removing them? We don't elect these people so they can take away a basic freedom, to go out and 

have a fire ring picnic on the beach. What is the matter with these people?

Kathleen Rios‐Keala Foothill ranch CA 92610 United States 5/23/2012

we grew up with cooking hamburgers roasting marshmellows dont stop this for all the kids !

Renee' Dubbert Johnstown CO 80534 United States 5/23/2012

I grew up there and visit often, our family gets together at the beach around the fire pit.

Sad that you are trying to do this!

David Gruver Norton OH 44203 United States 5/23/2012 The fire rings are always a big part of my visits to the area...one of the main reasons I visit the beaches!!

Sean Moro Irvine CA 92617 United States 5/23/2012

The fire pits have always been a place for wholesome gatherings of friends to eat, talk, and relax at the beach. I've never observed any suspicious 

activity, and mostly I've seen families, church gatherings, and groups of friends using the pits. If the noise of good conversation and fun disturbs the 

residents, let them be reminded that it is a state beach and that the land belongs to all taxpayers of California, not just the ones who can afford to 

live within sight of the beach. In any case, people have to leave by 10pm ‐ how does that keep residents up at night? One final point ‐ even if there 

is a rare occurrence fight or suspicious activity ‐ have we developed into such a risk averse society that we would ban the free use of the pits for 

thousands because of the bad decisions of a few miscreants?

Jia Liu Irvine CA 92617 United States 5/23/2012 Great place for students to go with friends.

Marcy Billings Irvine CA 92606 United States 5/23/2012

We love to bring out Cub Scout pack down to the beach every year.  For many boys this this the only opportunity they have to participate in a 

beach bonfire.  Please consider putting parameters in place so the fire pits are not removed.  Thank you

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 158: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Lisa Tarlton Irvine CA 92620 United States 5/23/2012

Celebrated 50th birthday there.  The fire rings are so desirable, they are reserved by 10 a.m.  Marshmallows, guitar, no glass or alcohol.  Good 

times.

Donna Hattin Denver CO 80220 United States 5/23/2012

There are too few ways to enjoy life in the slow lane... this is a wonderful tradition and hurts no one.  Stop trying to limit the simple pleasures in 

life. Keep the fire pits!

Jeff Taibi Canyon Country CA 91351 United States 5/23/2012 I also have a home in Lake Forest (Orange County).

Kay Pinto Flagstaff AZ 86001 United States 5/22/2012 I grew up in Balboa and visit frequently.  To be able to roast marshmallows on the beach is a treat that trenscends the negatives of the firerings.

Gwen Isarowong Irvine CA 92604 United States 5/22/2012

The enjoyment of the beach and fire pits should remain available to all.  This is a State Beach so all of our tax dollars support its operation.  Please 

don't permit the tyranny of the few...to take away a tradition cherished by so many.

Colt Rhoads Huntington Beach CA 92647 United States 5/22/2012 I'ma Scoutmaster for a local troop and we use this outdoors experience to teach Scouts how to handle fire and protect the environment.

Mark Bachman Irvine CA 92717 United States 5/22/2012

The California beaches are for everyone to enjoy, not just the privileged few with beach front property. This is a California tradition and an 

important part of our heritage.

Rebecca MacIntosh Irvine CA 92606 United States 5/22/2012 Don't stop our evening enjoyment of the beach, the water and the sunset...keep the firerings at our beaches please!

Steven Gross Irvine CA 92697 United States 5/22/2012

I believe that the fire rings add to the allure of southern california, promote good community interactions, and are one of the few 'public' 

opportunities left to encourage groups of people to gather and interact in a non‐commercial way 

Lynnette Sullivan westminster CA 92683 United States 5/22/2012

I have lived six miles from the beach all my life.  I used to go to the beach as a child with my family, surrounding the fire pits with our  chairs, 

stories, laughter and of course S'Mores.  As I grew up I went to the fire pits with my teenage friends.  When I became a Mother, I would take my 

children to the beach to enjoy the storytelling, and once again bonding with family around the fire pits.  Now my children are young adults and 

have started to make their own memories that include a fire pit down at the beach.  

I see the fire pits gone from some of the beaches I used to go to and the amount of fire pit availability dwindle over the years.  I understand the 

inherent liabilities and assets we all have in choosing a place to live. Because I have lived here in Southern California all my life, and anyone else 

who lives here knows, there are certain facts about living close to the beach... There is an incredible abundance of people visiting the beaches 

during the summertime.  There is a lack of parking places.  There is traffic on PCH.  There are fire pits and some smoke associated with them.  If 

people are complaining about the smoke, close your windows on the east, west and south sides of your homes.

  I guarantee you have lived there at least as long as the fire pits have been there, so you knew this was just a part of your home and where you 

live.  It has not gotten worse, if anything it has gotten better since the fire pits are extinguished by 10:00.  

Do people not realize our rights are being taken away slowing and methodically?  

 This most recent city meeting was attended by advocates to remove these 60 fire pits.  

When will this stop?  When our children tell their children, "I remember when we used to be able to walk on the sand and swim in the ocean." ?

If everyone would text, Facebook and email this to everyone they know, maybe this can be stopped.  

<a href="http://SaveThePits.com" rel="nofollow">SaveThePits.com</a>

And don't just tell those who enjoy our beaches and fire pits here in Southern California, tell those that visit here from other states.  I know when 

my relatives or friends visit, we will usually try to make it down to the beach for a final bonfire.

Please don't let this be the true, "Final Bonfire" !  

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 159: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

John Fleming Porterville CA 93257 United States 5/22/2012

I have had the opportunity to use the beach while visiting my family who live in Lakewood.  I found the beaches and the firerings to very useful and 

well taken care of.  I live near a national forest and know some of what its like to have to take care of the environment while trying to provide the 

public the ability to use that environment which was meant for everyone's use not just a select few.

Barbara Ginsberg Irvine CA 92606 United States 5/22/2012

These are our beaches to enjoy, which I have been doing for 40 years, including regular campfires at the beach.  Do not deny us this simple 

opportunity to enjoy camaraderie of family and friends in the evenings at the beach.

Harrison Bachman irvine CA 92617 United States 5/22/2012 I and my friends love hanging out at the fire pits at Corona and it would be a shame to see them go.

Celaine Gruver Norton OH 44203 United States 5/22/2012

I was born and raised in Orange County (I lived in Newport Beach from 3rd thru 5th grade) I grew up coming to the beach and enjoying the fire pits 

regularly. I brought by own sons there as kids too. There was nothing more fun then a day at the fun zone and beach followed by the night time fire 

and weenie roast. My church youth group has had many sing along's around the fire pits too. I cannot believe the NERVE of the locals who think a 

PUBLIC BEACH should be ruled by them! NO WAY! I say SAVE THE PITS!!!!!!!

Eliot Hansen Westminster CA 92683 United States 5/22/2012

Beaches and fire pits in So. Cal. go hand‐in‐hand. So many individuals and groups look forward to summer beach "bonfires." A lot of us have grown 

up with them and have many fond memories of those times cooking and singing and hanging out around them. I would guess that the statistics 

comparing the number of issues regarding firepits vs. the total number of people who go to the beach and use them are small. It would a shame to 

remove the fire pits.

Cherrin L. Druschel Costa Mesa CA 92627 United States 5/22/2012

The beaches belong to all the people not just the rich and famous. I've been going to the beach fire pits since I was a little girl and now I go with my 

grandchildren.

Beatrice Jamieson Phillips Ranch CA 91766 United States 5/22/2012

Such great childhood and young adult memories around a fire ring after a great day at the beach.  Our youth needs to have some place to hang out 

that is safe and wholesome!

Michelle Craghead Newport /beach CA 92663 United States 5/22/2012

These fire pits have been a part of my life growing up and I want all my children to enjoy the same outdoor beach adventures.  It's tradition for so 

many families especially us California Natives.  My family has been here 7 generations.  Don't take away our family traditions.

Dwight Gergens Fountain Valley CA 92708 United States 5/22/2012

Fires on the beach is a California family tradition; something unique to our corner of the country.  Taking the fire rings away would be just as bad as 

removing all the piers (don't get any ideas).  It's part of our culture, and heritage.

Michelle Kobzeff Irvine CA 92604 United States 5/22/2012

We enjoy the fire pits as we have our marching band "end of Band Camp, start of the School year" bonfire there. This is one of the long standing 

traditions we have in or marching band and removing the fire pits would be a shame.

Gerry  Hardin  Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 5/22/2012

Save the Fire Pits at Corona del Mar and all of the Newport Beachs that have them.  They form wonderful memories to families and bond people 

together...the scouts, church youth, people that live far from the beach.  These are public beaches and because some of the "few" entitled 

residents dont want it, they protest.  These are public beachs for the public use.  

Jeff Rhoads Orange CA 92869‐251United States 5/21/2012 I love the tradition of beach parties with a fire.

Wayne Martin Anaheim CA 92801 United States 5/21/2012 I remember this as a kid, and have done it every other year as an adult

Fredric Rhoads Chicago IL 60601 United States 5/21/2012

I grew up in Npt and Big Corona always had the fire [its. I look forward to visiting my extended family and going to the beach in the evening for a 

fire. WHY WOULD YOU WANT TO REMOVE THEM? 

Dale E. McCoig Ben OR 97702 United States 5/21/2012

I and my family were Balboa residents for 23

years and my son for another 20 years and

these rings have been a healthy part of that

culture.   They should remain so for present and future families.

Mike Hougan Corona del Mar CA 92625 United States 5/21/2012

Yet another sad example of government trying to run our lives.

This is a completely unnecessary action.

Erica O'Neill Laguna Hills CA 92653 United States 5/21/2012 The firepits are a huge part of the beach community.  They bring friends, families and loved ones together...why would you want to take them out!

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 160: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Erik Ringman Costa Mesa CA 92626 United States 5/20/2012

Simply put, this is a classic.  It's part of what California IS, especially our little corner of it.  When your friends come in from out of town, are they 

not shocked to discover that the fire pits are one of those things ‐ like a Friday night cruise up Van Nuys ‐ that don't just happen in film fantasy, but 

are in fact a very real part of the fabric of our peculiar local culture?

I had Boy Scout events there as a kid, I've celebrated numerous birthday parties there, I've performed obnoxious comedy routines there, my 

twelfth grade class organized our own sendoff party there, but most importantly I've told stories, made friends, and had more than one decent 

laugh in the crackling glow of those fires.  Removal of these fire rings would be like cutting out a little part out of each of us.  I am reminded of all 

the great attractions my grandparents got to enjoy that I never will, and I would think that we would've learned our lesson so as to avoid doing the 

same thing to our future children.

Gladys J. Smith huntington beach CA 92648 United States 5/20/2012 the firepits are part of our families summers and have been for over 40 years

Thomas Nash Huntington Beach CA 92646 United States 5/20/2012

I have spent many pleasant evenings with family and friends over the years around a fire at CDM.  I hate to see another family friendly feature 

disappear from our area.

Kevin Spangler Corona Del Mar CA 92625 United States 5/20/2012 I've been using the Fire Rings since I was a little kid int the '50s. They are a part of going to the beach! This is a stupid idea to remove them!

Carmen Wilcox Newport Beach CA 92659 United States 5/18/2012 I use these pits for social events throughout the years.  I would hate to end this tradition.

Adam Oliver Stillwater OK 74075 United States 5/18/2012

I grew up there and would some day like to move back with my family. What is better then a night at the beach with family, and friends, having a 

good time next to the fire. Or  getting close to that special someone.... List could go on for ever!

mark schulein Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 5/17/2012 I grew up at those fire rings and want my kids to have the samed experiences and memories. It's the beach!

doris stoughton CORONA DEL MAR CA 92625 United States 5/17/2012

we have lived in Corona del Mar for over 45 years and our extended family LOVES going to Big Corona for a hot dog roast and somemores.  we live 

on Ocean Blvd. and the smoke and visitors are no problem whats so ever!!!  PLEASE KEEP THE FIRE RINGS!!!

Robert Underwood JrCosta Mesa CA 92626 United States 5/17/2012

These pits/fire rings have been a part of my life since 1960 and provided many wonderful memories. Please do not eradicate yet another quality 

opportunity for families in the area.  Families of the OC deserve this iconic traditional gathering experience.     

Heather Reger Costa Mesa CA 92627 United States 5/17/2012

The fire pits are a common area for community members to come together and enjoy the natural beauty of the beach while making s'mores, 

playing guitar and experiencing family and friendship togetherness. They are one of the last great "free" activities our community offers. Please do 

not get rid of them!!

Paula Edwards Newport Beach CA 92663 United States 5/17/2012 The fire rings make for wonderful family outings for our family.  We and our children love them.

Tony San Miguel Irvine CA 92612 United States 5/17/2012 I like to have fire on the beach

Susan Watson Ojai CA 93023 United States 5/17/2012

I remeber the fire rings from when I grew up in Orange. They are a great way to use the beach and experience group gatherings. Hot dogs, smore's, 

and the surf; perfect.

Robert Boragno Corona del Mar CA 92625 United States 5/17/2012

 You can not legislate common sense nor should you legislate for the benefit of a privileged few.  If that were the case, there would be an arm and 

signal at every railroad crossing and Ocean Blvd would be blocked to vehicular traffic.  Hundreds of thousands of people, some not so privileged, 

are able to enjoy the beaches and partake in age old festivities such as swimming, Frisbee and even cooking a hot dog over an open fire. This is 

done at the expense of everyone who resides in California not at the expense of the privileged few.  Beach goers are already restricted from 

smoking, drinking alcohol,

playing with their dogs and must abide by a curfew.  Enough is enough. To placate the few, you will punish many including your house keeper, your 

gardener, your buss boy, your paper boy, your car wash guy and maybe even the 100,000 residents of Newport Beach.   Keep the fire rings. 

Susan Lunny Fort Walton Beach FL 32548 United States 5/17/2012

I spent every Summer there as a child, from the early morning hours to the evening cookouts on the firepits...and was then able to continue the 

tradition on with my son.....many wonderful memories were made there!

Frank Daniels Huntington Beach CA 92646 United States 5/17/2012

Why remove a public service item just because people can't use common sense!!  We're having the same problem here in Huntington Beach.  

People get killed in auto accidents but we don't eliminate cars!!

Thomas Boragno Corona Del Mar CA 92625 United States 5/17/2012 Do not punish the many for the privileged few, the fire pits were not a surprise since they have been the before 90% of the residents lived there

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 161: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Peter Bretschger Corona del Mar CA 92625 United States 5/17/2012

Growing up, beach bonfires, s'mores, and family are all such wonderful influential memories I have in Southern California.  We should be 

promoting facilities that promote the concept of family, community, and enjoyment of our natural resources; not removing them.

Christine Anderson Mission Viejo CA 92691 United States 5/16/2012 This is great family fun! It would be a shame to lose this wonderful family activity. 

Dennis  Keith Corona del Mar CA 92625 United States 5/16/2012

We need MORE, not less, places where we can gather with family and friends‐‐particularly outdoors, and in a safe environment.  Big Corona seems 

a perfect spot where we can get together to enjoy the "great outdoors", the beauty of this special beach, and the long‐standing tradition of sitting 

around wonderful beach bonfires.  The fire rings belong here, and need to stay!!

Joseph Vieyra Irvine CA 92604 United States 5/16/2012

CDM like every beach on the Golden Coast ‐ has a special meaning to thousands of folks across the nation. I have friends from Indiana to South 

Africa that have joined our family on this beach for a mutltude of summer events. The NIMBY's can't wake up one day and realize there is "wood 

smoke' in the air and be shocked it is coming from the beach. Guess I should have the rail tracks relocated cuz after I moved into our home I 

realized there is train traffic at 3am. Fire Rings make a fun, safe place for family and friends to share the California Dream.

Doreen Paul Costa Mesa CA 92626 United States 5/16/2012

Having a beach bon fire gathering of friends and family is one of my favorite all time things to do in life.  It's a guaranteed great time had by all, and 

removing them from any beach would be horrible.

Barbara  Mudge Bandon OR 94711 United States 5/16/2012

I was born in Laguna Beach and lived all of my life in Southern California until 1996. Beach picnics are one of the best memories, especially sitsing 

around a fire after spending the day in the water!

Janice Sauter Nashville TN 37215 United States 5/16/2012

I was born and raised in So Cal....and I lived in Newport Beach for 20 years.  I moved to Nashville 5 years ago but I still consider myself a beach girl.  

The pits at Big Corona are such a part of the beach experience there....they need to stay!!  I get back to Newport several times a year and I would 

hate for the fire pits to be gone.  Summer at Big Corona just wouldn't be the same without the fire pits.

Patti Taketa Corona del Mar CA 92625 United States 5/16/2012

It would be a shame to remove this tradition of enjoying a bon fire at the beach.  I understand that it costs the City money, but they just spent 

MILLIONS on new City buildings.  We pay taxes and should not be denied this simple pleasure.    

Linda Williams Corona del Mar CA 92625 United States 5/16/2012 Long time resident and user of Big Corona Beach.

Shannon Matthews Redlands CA 92374 United States 5/16/2012 Being able to enjoy a fire and s'mores on the beach with you family and friends is a staple in California and should never be taken away.

Rae Cohen Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 5/16/2012

Using fire pits at the beach are a summer tradition for decades. Part of the pleasure of living in the ocean communities.  Affordable pastime for 

persons of all incomes.

katherine Cervantes Costa Mesa CA 92627 United States 5/16/2012

So much is and has been taken away for the easy way life  could be. when memiores are taken away and stories become a pass the way it use to 

be....and we ask how come our kids sit in front of the tv and not get out fresh air. ...this is one of the reason... why I ask take these firerings 

away???a family/ friends  time with  nature,  God has created for us to enjoy. the rings...who do they hurt... no one . please keep them....

philip solomone La Mirada CA 90638 United States 5/15/2012 We come down and use the fire rings for family events. 

mike Ritter Corona Del Mar CA 92625 United States 5/15/2012 They are for the public, not the residents who live at the beach. 

Timothy MontgomeryCoto de Caza CA 92679 United States 5/15/2012

I was born and raised in Newport Beach.  Having summer beach fires is a large part of what makes life worth living.  To remove these fire pits is a 

travesty and crime against tradition.  We will never get them back; our grandchildren will never know the joy of a summer beach party with 

smores.  Shame on the City of Newport Beach!  STOP THIS NOW!!

John Garay Tustin CA 92780 United States 5/15/2012 I have grown up in the area and the fire pits have been the safest ones in the area and it feels like a ploy to raise the values of the home in the area. 

Mariah Kelly Irvine CA 92604 United States 5/15/2012

These pits defined the summers my childhood, adolescence, and young adulthood. I'm not looking forward to the first summer of my LIFE without 

them. 

Sandra Moore Newport Beach, CA CA 92660 United States 5/15/2012

The beaches are public and this is an important part of the history of SOCAL.  Up and down the beaches, you can see and smell the fires, and you 

know families and friends are having a great time and making MEMORIES!!!!!!  Please don't remove the fire pits!!!!!  I want my grandkids to enjoy 

the same experience as I have!!!!  

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 162: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Jennifer Wozniak costa Mesa CA 92626 United States 5/15/2012

The fire pits are an icon of the SoCal beach culture. I understand a few people may be careless and, as a consequence, be injured. But that is 

extremely rare. I do think City Councils along the coast needs to stop wasting time on this issue. Personal responsibility should not equate living in a 

bubble. 

Xuan Nguyen Royal Oak MI 48073 United States 5/15/2012

Because people need to be accountable for their own actions instead of trying to squeeze money out of the government purporting the liability is 

on the government, when it should be on themselves to keep an eye on their children.

If these people don't want their children to get hurt running into fire pits, they should teach their children & keep a better eye on them as to not 

injure themselves by carelessly playing around.

Dan Morgan Huntington Beach 92841 United States Min 5/15/2012

There are public property we are the public.  We use them and we use them responsibly. NIMBYS who hate everything the USA stands for take 

away American traditions to satiate their own emotional immaturity and fear.

Sandra Munoz Santa Ana CA 92706 United States 5/15/2012 I love an evening on the beach around the fire ring with good friends and food. Let us be responsible for our actions.

Teresa Romero Costa Mesa CA 92627 United States 5/15/2012

I have always loved enjoy these recreational bonfire pits with my family, furthermore I would love to continue to do so with my grandson that will 

be born in a few months time!

Karen Muller Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 5/15/2012

The pits are Newport Beach.  Don't further limit public enjoyment of the beach. This is being done to appease people who built homes near the 

pits, when the pits were already there.  This has to stop ‐ these people do not own the beach.  It belongs to the public. 

Susan La Morte Eastvale CA 92880 United States 5/15/2012

All throughout my childhood and adult life I have enjoyed the fire pits at Corona State Beach and Balboa Beach as well. They are a part of the 

character of those beaches and should be preserved for all visitors to enjoy.

Robert Newsom Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 5/15/2012

Our family has enjoyed the fire pits ever since we arrived in Newport‐Mesa in 1976. I have yet to see any sound reason for why they should be 

removed. I suspect that the wish to remove them  is another exclusionary move on the part of the wealthy to discourage ordinary folk from using 

our beaches.

Corinne AndersonSchNewport Beach CA 92660 United States 5/15/2012

STOP taking away things! Teach people how to use them instead and stop trying to control every bit of fun at the beach. It IS our culture. DO NOT 

take that away from us!

steve holt parker CO 80138 United States 5/15/2012

I live in Irvine now and have been taking my kids to the fire pits since they were young.  My daughter's birthdays were always at the fire pits.  She's 

17 now, and we'd like to continue the tradition as well as have other people enjoy them.

Greg Reinker Newport Beach CA 92663 United States 5/15/2012 A unique tradition. Also probably makes more money for the City in parking fees than the cost ($50k/year per Nancy Gardner).

Monica Fiedler Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 5/15/2012 They have been a meeting place for years, a means to enjoy to out‐of‐doors in an ever more urbanized world.

julianne  villalba RANCHO CUCAMONGA CA 9.17E+08 United States 5/15/2012 we love the fire pits! 

Michael Smith Irvine CA 92604 United States 5/15/2012

If some people that live close by don't like them, they should not have purchased there. This is about quality of life with friends, families and 

children. Just the idea of a beach fire is a warming thought. I have wonderful memories of those beach fire rings and am upset that if the city 

council has their way that future generations will not share the same special love for an evening at the beach. It makes me wonder if who ever 

voted on this has never experienced it. Pretty soon, where else will the public be able to go? It's too easy to take away and impossible to get it 

back. Please stop and think. 

morey robert san juan capistrano CA 92675 United States 5/15/2012

I use to live in Newport Beach for over 20 years, and I would take my kids down to the beach there as a family and with small groups of friends..

What is this society coming to that we have to stop doing wholesome family activities because of maybe a few bad apples...

Wendy Torres Irvine CA 92620 United States 5/14/2012

Sadly, public beach use is constantly compromised by posh hotel and residential developments and some beach side residents who feel entitled to 

limiting access to others.  Growing up and now raising a family in Orange County I have many fond memories of my family and friends using these 

beach pits.  Please don't take away a public amenity for the sake of a few.

Rick Stafford Balboa CA 92661 United States 5/14/2012 part of beach heritage ‐ focal point for wholesome beach gatherings after dark

Brian  Allen Huntington Beach CA 92646 United States 5/14/2012 I love the fire pits and we enjoy taking our family to the beach to do so.

Brad Thomas Lake Forest CA 92630 United States 5/14/2012 Many great family cookouts at Big Carona. Other cities are removing them and there almost extinct.

BRET STOUT PLACENTIA CA 92870 United States 5/14/2012

I have spent countless hours at those fire pits with my family and friends with no problem what so ever. The people who are afraid of wood smoke 

need professional mental help!

Rick Holt Anaheim CA 92802 United States 5/14/2012 This is not the time to put a stop to low cost entertainment for the public.

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 163: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Shayne Smith Costa Mesa CA 92626 United States 5/14/2012

There is no VALID reason to remove the fire pits.  "Wood smoke harmuful to health"?  What a joke!!  The fire pits have made people happy for 

decades creating many special memories of family and friends.  Lets move in the RIGHT DIRECTION for once and not take this SPECIAL TRADITION 

away from THE PEOPLE.  Who's idea was this?  I wouldnt want to hang out with that person.  I have high school memories around those fire rings. 

It would be a shame if the young people now couldn't experience the same thing.

William Ramlo Santa Ana CA 92707 United States 5/14/2012

I remember for 30 years my family would go to the fire rings at B street.  The removal of the rings would just be another example of NIMBY and the 

Nanny State.

Mike Jones Huntingtonn Beach CA 92646 United States 5/14/2012 I enjoy nights around a beach fire ring . A cheap so cal tradition.

Candace Leutzinger Anaheim CA 92806 United States 5/13/2012 if you have a problem with people having fun on the beach, then move!

Fred Fourcher Corona Del Mar CA 92625 United States 5/12/2012

I am a Corona Del Mar resident who enjoys the fire rings each summer. We have Boy Scout and Company gatherings at the beach because of the 

fire rings. There is nothing like sitting around the fire with friends. People have been sitting around fires since the discovery of fire. This is just part 

of being human. 

Andrew Contreiras Newport Beach CA 92661 United States 5/9/2012

I recently moved to Newport Beach from Carlsbad, CA. My new place is just two houses and some sand away from the fire pits.  The pits were a 

perk to the location. They were a reason to be here‐‐to have a campfire with friends; to see the fires burning in the night; and to live in such a 

community. It brings people together. Those residents who object to the fire pits have miles of beach on which they could have lived.  The removal 

of the fire pits affects everyone.  

Diane  Valdies Corona Del Mar CA 92625 United States 5/7/2012

The Pits are part of of the  charm and the family  spirit here in CDM. Please don't let the tourists dictate our community. Security and stiff fines 

should help . Thank you.

Michaelyn Pouncey Tracy CA 95376 United States 5/7/2012 I grew up going to these fire pits all the time and I still go and take my kids every time we are in town. 

john bryant Corona Del Mar CA 92625 United States 5/4/2012

We have to make sure we voice our opinion so our Council members know how to support us on this issue. We will be watching closely...the 

majority want the pits to stay. 

Jerry Grinstead Citrus Heights CA 95621 United States 4/29/2012

The National Marshmallow Roasters Institute (NMRI) supports saving  the fire pits on all California Beaches, in service to roasters everywhere. ‐ 

President, NMRI

robert amond northridge CA 91326 United States 4/28/2012

I see a trend of removal of everything in California,  inaccessible access and locked gates to everything is a familiar thing everywhere I go. The 

public is losing access to every natural environment. I am a land developer and a nature photographer. Some things should be preserved, but not 

locked up or removed.  and lastly I remember being a child and having fires on the beach, a fond memory

Bobby Favaro tustin CA 92780 United States 4/20/2012

Those fire pits have sentimental values to alot of people, i don't know about anyone else but when we were younger we had a blast at the pits, 

partied hard ,hooked up numerous times, just plan good times, besides that its not a fire hazard so whats the big deal, who ever wants it removed 

has never really got the chance to truly enjoy them or they are just ASSHOLES

John Capone Irvine CA 92612 United States 4/19/2012

My whole life I have enjoyed going to the beach and making a fire to warm up after playing in the ocean.  I can't believe anyone would want to take 

this simple pleasure and make it illegal.  It could only come from people that have never experienced the serenity of watching a sunset by the fire 

while the kids play.  What a shame

DeAnna Risinger Yorba Linda CA 92886 United States 4/19/2012

Here is one form of family fun as no other. We are blessed  to be close enough to gather and enjoy beachside firepits and it is PREMIUM family fun. 

To have this prohibittted in the future would be a huge injustice to us all!

Victor Cook Corona del Mar CA 92625 United States 4/19/2012

THERE IS ABSOLUTELY NO REASON TO DO THIS. THOSE WHO COMPLAIN ABOUT SMOKE SHOULD NOT HAVE THIS MUCH CONTROL. THESE RINGS 

HAVE BEEN THERE FOR MANY, MANY YEARS AND NO ONE HAS COMPLAINED. CITY COUNCIL IS RIDICULOUS AND ABSURD. NO ONE HAS 

COMPLAINED UNTIL NOW. THESE FIRE RINGS BENEFIT TOO MANY PEOPLE FOR A FEW TO RUIN IT FOR THE REST OF US.

David  Ray Felton CA 95018 United States 4/19/2012 I have enjoyed countless meaningful fires at those rings. They make the beaches useful and magical.

Teresa Taylor Canyon Country CA 91387 United States 4/19/2012

It is a lasting positive memory everyone should have. How many of our kids will NEVER go camping in their whole lives. This simple of a thing gives 

so much joy on so many levels to so many, Please don't take this away from us too. We need positive activities for our youth I propose that more 

fire rings be installed, Do I hear a second on that???

Bert Grandia Westminster CA 92683 United States 4/18/2012 I enjoy having the opportunity to light a fire at the beach with the kids. People (humans) do happen to live on this earth too.

john campbell balboa CA 92661 United States 4/17/2012 I have many memories of being next to a fire and listening to the waves.  Please do not steal this thrill from future generations.

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 164: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

f r idaho springs CO 80452 United States 4/16/2012

When I lived in Newport Beach I used those fire rings regularly with family and friends and still enjoy the wonderful memories of those warm nights 

on the beach!  Leave them there so others can enjoy them as much as we all did and still do!

Carole Morris Corona Del Mar CA 92625 United States 4/16/2012 The greater good is served by having, and not removing, the fire pits.  There are so few places left where people can enjoy the beach in this way.

Molly Curtiss Irvine CA 92614 United States 4/15/2012 I like using them.

Rick Hume Laguna Beach CA 92651 United States 4/15/2012 I am a 4th generation southern California beach city resident and think the fire rings are an important part of our beach culture.

Joel Elowsky Mequon WI 53097 United States 4/15/2012

Tourists visiting Southern California expect to be able to go to the beach and have a fire. This will be one more reason for us to think we are not 

welcome

Dana Sigler‐Wardlow San Dimas CA 91773‐193United States 4/12/2012

As a native Californian, we enjoy spending time at our favorite destination ‐ the beach, especially the Newport area. Fire pits complete the 

experience.

Denise Harvey Auburn CA 95602 United States 4/11/2012

growing up in OC, the fire rings are a huge part of the legacy of life at Newport.  They are a wonderful tradition, and it seems a shame that these 

would now be removed.

Gae Seal Nevada City, Ca 95959 CA 95959 United States 4/11/2012

Since we lived in Newport Beach when I was young, I learned to draw with charcoal that I fished out of these fire pits the day after a nice BBQ! I 

also stepped on a few sparklers that had been buried in the sand after 4th of July fire ring celebrations. Life would not be the same without them 

there to remember happy times.

ricky spence orange CA 92869‐173United States 4/11/2012

i have always gone to these fire pits since i was little it would break my heart if all of theme where removed going to the beach for a campfire is 

one of the best things anyone can do :)

Tyler Burnstein Irvine CA 92604 United States 4/11/2012

Those fire pits are tradition. They are a great way for people to hang out and have fun together. Getting rid of them would be getting rid of alot of 

our childhoods and memories.

Norelle Keller Rocklin CA 95765 United States 4/9/2012

People should have the right to enjoy the beach, have a bit of uninterrupted peace and enjoyment.  EVERYTHING is regulated these days, and a fire 

on the beach started with cavemen.  That should not be taken away.  

Anthony  Miller irvine CA 92612 United States 4/9/2012 I'm from the 909 and it would be a shame to lose something so great

Michael Nolf COSTA MESA CA 92627 United States 4/9/2012 I love using the fire pits. I have had many great times with family and friends while using them.

Leslie Pfaff Los Alamos NM 87544 United States 4/9/2012

Because this is part of the beach experience.  The rings provide safety to the fire area and attracts more people to the area that equals more tourist 

dollars to the area.  ‐

Bobbie Boice Roseburg OR 97470 United States 4/9/2012 For what reason would they need to be removed?  This is ridiculous!  

Howard Ahmanson Corona del Mar CA 92625 United States 4/8/2012 I live within sight of them and I enjoy seeing people enjoy them. And we don't get smoke from them, either! 

Kevin Dun Newport Beach CA 92659 United States 4/8/2012

This is one of the only things in the world that is practically FREE and soooooo much FUN!!!! Instead of removing the pits, remove the complaining 

people. How could they complain, they live in PARADISE!!!

Tracy Robert Newport Beach CA 92661 United States 4/6/2012 You are systematically ruining the history of Newport Beach, City Council.

Jennie Kosko Menlo Park CA 94025 United States 4/6/2012 These fire pits are warm gathering spots for friends, families, church groups, twelve‐step groups and enhance this public community resource.

Sharon Mullins newport beach CA 92660 United States 4/3/2012

There are many changes made for the State Beaches that are made for the greater "good"  but really affect people on a basic level.  One change 

was limiting Triathlons because the public doesn't like it.  This fire pit is the same reasoning that a few people will be happy and many will be 

unhappy.

Scott Lopez Irvine CA 92606 United States 4/3/2012 I love going to the beach and having a bonfire...it's an amazing experience to share with friends and family. Please don't take it away.

Terry Nichols Beaverton OR 97006 United States 4/2/2012

These simple fire pits are perfect for family reunions like the ones my family has. I grew up in southern Calif. and some of the best I've ever had 

were there at the beach, We'd roast hotdogs and hamburgers. We would swim all day and then gather around the pit at night staying warm, 

roasting marsh mellows and catching up on everything going on in each other lives. That's something I still wish to share with my daughter, when 

we make another trip back home.

Tamara Blatt Arden NC 28704 United States 4/2/2012

I was born and raised in Orange County and have so many fond memories of evenings spent at the fire pits.  Removing these pits would take away 

from any hopes of future memories with my family.  

Ted Canedy Corona Del Mar CA 92625 United States 4/2/2012 Because the fire pits are a part of the way I grew up and they are a part of the beach lifestyle that should remain.......

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 165: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Steve  Perkins Santa cruz CA 95060 United States 4/2/2012

From Boy Scouts to beach parties I have many fond memories of hot dogs and marshmallows, skits and songs, lemonade and root beer at the 

Newport Beach fire rings at Balboa Beach. The first time I ever had a s'more was at a beachfront fire ring with my stepmother's girl scout troop. 

Then‐Fountain Valley Mayor Bernie Svalstad was in attendance. 

Used to work at the Stop n Go on PCH and Balboa when Anna (everyone called her 'Grandma') owned the place.. A generous share of our patrons 

were beachgoers who'd stop in for a pack of hot dogs, a beer or a soda... or a trunkfull of ice for their fire‐ring get‐togethers. Some of these people 

came as far away as San Bernardino... even out‐of‐state! Weddings, family‐reunions, even funerals. Some of my more cherished memories were 

getting together for singing fests with a bunch of friends and aquaintences from high‐school and college at those fire pits.

NEVER ran into a melee on Balboa Beach in twenty‐five plus years..

NEVER.

JERRY PRUITT ORANE CA 92867 United States 4/2/2012 HAVE BEEN ENJOYING THESE RINGS FOR ABOUT 50 YEARS!

adriana petersen Corona Del mar CA 92625 United States 4/2/2012

There is absolutely no fire or health hazards to any neighbors in this community...the complaining neighbors would have more risks out of their 

BBQs and fireplaces at home that these open air fire pits so far removed from their homes...taking them out will do more harm to the enjoyment of 

more people than the one or two that are claiming harm or risk.   Let's be realistic here.

sue volpe newport beach CA 92660 United States 4/1/2012 THIS IS AN INTEGRAL PART OF OUR BEACH COMMUNITY.  MY KIDS GREW UP LOVING IT SO PLEASE DON'T TAKE IT AWAY!

conni judson cdm CA 92625 United States 3/31/2012

because i have lived in cdm for 23 years and have loved the fire pits and they have never caused a problem but only added to the charm of this 

little beach village.

Kimberly Sterling Costa Mesa CA 92627 United States 3/30/2012 We have a meeting there every Tuesday that has been going on for 15 years..

Phyllis Paulsen Santa Ana CA 92705 United States 3/30/2012

The fire rings are a tradition at our OC Beaches, and a reason for the families to go to the beach at night, for memories and family night. We all 

grew up in OC with these memories. Don't remove the rings, instead figure out a way to make it a win‐win situation for all of us, which is what you 

were elected to do, and not to act like big government and take one more thing from the people!!

Kim Weber Santa Ana CA 92705 United States 3/30/2012 many happy memories with children, friends and family.  These are no more dangerous than life itself!  UGH!

Tracy Wittman Whittier CA 90606 United States 3/30/2012 Our homeschool group has beach parties at the Balboa rings every summer.  It would be a shame if we couldn't anymore...

Sheri Money Philadelphia PA 19104 United States 3/30/2012

I used these pits as a teenager growing up as one of the only enjoying things to do at night with my friends.  And trust me, we were good kids.  No 

drugs or craziness.  Now that I am older and live elsewhere, I still used the firepits to get together with my friends almost every time I come home 

for a visit.  By the way, I'm from Yorba Linda, so these aren't even right in my backyard but I still use them.  Also, if your primary motive is to 

prevent gangs/drug use there, I've never had a problem with that at the pits, so it can't be THAT big of a deal.  Also, I suspect they'll just keep 

coming.

June Marchigiani Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/30/2012

I've been in NB for 30 yrs and find the city lovely.  A quintessential joy associated with our beaches are the evening fire pit gatherings.  I've never 

noticed the scene to be much more than quiet, easy and so Newport.  On occasion, people get loud, silly, maybe dance (oh no!) or forget to pick up 

their trash.  But the beach‐front home owners should not be dictating public enjoyment on the public beaches, City Council members!  

Peter Mowery Mission Viejo CA 92692 United States 3/29/2012

I am 51 years old and have lived in California all my life.  Some of my favorite memories are picnics at the beach with my Grand Parents and 

watching the sun go down.  It's a tradition we have continued with our children.  Most recently celebrating my daughter's 18th birthday with 

smores and a bonfire.  Please keep the fire rings.  Don't let a few irresponsible people ruin it for us and future generations.

William Sharpe Irvine CA 92620 United States 3/29/2012

The fire pits are a part of Orange County tradition. The last thing our county needs is to have more of its history of beach culture ripped from it. 

Orange County is becoming too sanitized and bland. We need to keep the local flavor alive, and the fire pits are an essential piece of that.

Mark Franco Newport Beach CA 92663 United States 3/29/2012

The fire pit have been a part of Balboa since I was a young child and I think every kid should get to experience roasting marshmallows on the beach 

the same way I did.

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 166: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Puya Vakili Irvine CA 92603 United States 3/28/2012

I have so many incredible childhood and adult memories at this beach.  Taking away these pits would destroy one of the best destinations in 

Orange County and most definitely hurt local economies which depend on the tourism generated by those using the pits.

Brian Lusher King George VA 22485 United States 3/28/2012 Love the beach culture, don't change it.

Baron Night Buena Park CA 90621 United States 3/28/2012 I have lived in Orange County since 1957.  The fire pits have been used  for family outings for decades.  

kevin Brennan S.A. CA 92705 United States 3/28/2012 A part of family and friends fun, a part of history and joy and fun for all.People love the warmth and just plain fun with the fire pits.

michael billings newport beach CA 92663 United States 3/28/2012

It is utterly amaing the beligerent destructive agenda the newport beach city council seems determined to impose on the good nature of the 

character and  appeal of newport beach over the years. Impeach them all and boycott any of their professional and business dealings

Dana  Black Ketchum ID 83340 United States 3/28/2012 I grew up in CdM and have fond memories of the fire pits. Sometime we need to not micro manage problems that are really non exsistent

Gregory Newman Aliso Viejo CA 92656 United States 3/27/2012

I have enjoyed these fire pits for many years, as a resident of CDM and (more recently) an adjacent community. It would be a shame to lose them 

because the residents of CDM and NB are too narrow minded to understand that the California coast is meant to be enjoyed by all residents, not 

just the locals.

Linda Rife Tustin CA 92780 United States 3/27/2012

The fire pits offered a safe, fun activity for me to enjoy as a child and a teenager growing up in Orange County.  I would hate to see this taken away 

from future children and families.  If teenagers don't have these kinds of low cost, safe activities available, what is left for them?

Nathan Copier Logan UT 84321 United States 3/27/2012 Why remove them? I don't see any logical explanation for this.

Charles Rogerson Staines TW18 2SR United Kingdom 3/27/2012

This is ridiculous! What possible benefit could possibly outweigh the obvious negative effect on the local community? The nanny‐state apparatchiks 

need to butt out.

amber brown NRH TX 76180 United States 3/27/2012 They are the best for late gatherings on the beach with your friends. Not only a way to keep warm but to build memories.

ROBERT Hays Agoura Hills CA 91301 United States 3/27/2012

I grew up in Newport Beach.  The fire rings were part of our growing up.  May not mean anything to people outside of the area, but for us, it's 

history.  Please keep them.

Aaron Black irvine CA 92620 United States 3/27/2012 the cdm fire pit are a second home to me and i would be petrified if they where gone.

Allen Ho Irvine CA 92620 United States 3/27/2012

bonfires at the beach are the best memories i have from growing up in orange county and it would not be the same if they weren't there 

anymore...

Christopher Nguyen Irvine CA 92620 United States 3/27/2012 The fire rings are one of the best parts of living in orange county!  If anything, we should add additional fire rings.

Sue Crapo Kaysville UT Km m ,J840United States 3/27/2012 It is a great tradition unique to the area.rr

Penny Darling Balboa Island CA 92662 United States 3/27/2012

I grew up here enjoying the fire pits and so have my children. I can't imagine their not being available. Hopefully Newport will realize their value to 

the community as San Diego has. They are definitely part of our beach culture.

Bernard  DeMarkey Orange CA 92867 United States 3/26/2012

I moved to Southern California,  in 1981.  One of my first and fondess memories of  living in my new adopted home was sitting on the beach in 

front of a fire ring sharing a a beautiful winter evening with a few new friends, in my new home state, begining my new life. It  just does not get any 

better. Please keep the rings!

Thank you

Theresa  Rife Irvine CA 92612 United States 3/26/2012 These fire pits are part of the culture of our home. They contribute positively to our community. 

Moiz Horani West Covina CA 91792 United States 3/26/2012

I love the fire pits and often spend the whole day at the beach just to get a firepit for a nice bonfire with my family in the evenings. As I spend the 

whole day there, I buy food and supplies from local shops in the area. Please do not remove these pits!

Steve Abraham Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/26/2012

As an 18 year resident of Newport Beach, I've always enjoyed the fire pits. Now as a father of three, it's one of the safe, enjoyable, old‐fashioned, 

inexpensive, down‐to‐earth activities we enjoy every year.  Especially with out‐of‐town guests. The City Council needs to think long term before 

they act so quickly.  They've allowed the fun zone to be slowly eliminated, and now this.  It's truly a travesty.  Worst of all, most residents, like 

myself, never even heard about it until after the fact.  This should require a city vote.

Lynne Liden Irvine CA 92603 United States 3/25/2012 I grew up in Newport & value the fire pits & what they  add to the beach & group gatherings.

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 167: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Michelle Huelle Yucca Valley CA 92284 United States 3/25/2012

My whole family grew up playing at those firepits! And I've taken my kids there every year with their grandparents and cousins. If there is illegal or 

dangerous activity happening now, how about we punish the criminals instead of ruining something fun for millions?!

Larry Dunmire Newport Beach CA 92662 United States 3/25/2012 I think the fire rings should remain in the City of Newport Beach, they're a great feature!!!

Karen Brown Charlotte NC 28277 United States 3/25/2012

I grew up in OC and we spent many an evening at the beach around the fire rings!  It was a great way to spend time with family and friends and 

these fire rings should be left there for all to enjoy.  Leave them alone!

Jayne Miller Minneapolis MN 55433 United States 3/25/2012 Tourists enjoy the experience of the fire pit by the ocean that we can't enjoy in central states

Shannon  Erdos‐Jock Dallas TX 75252 United States 3/25/2012

I am a native Californian, who grew up in Orange County. I visit as often as I can and for many years have often enjoyed the firerings at the beach 

without incident. They are a great feature and need to remain. 

Jonathan Chavez Newport Beach CA 92663 United States 3/25/2012

One newsworthy incident shouldn't be a reason to ruin it for everyone else.  Or, this is an excuse for the city to cut more budget money. The city 

has insurance! Deal with the accident and move on.

Dorothy Roden Costa Mesa CA 92626 United States 3/25/2012

Fire pits at the beach are a wonderful resource for friends, families, and community organizations to get together and enjoy the outdoors. I have 

been to many such gatherings with different groups and seen many more others groups gathered around beach fire pits and have never   seen 

anything worse than occasional trash problems. The overwhelming majority of users are great folks enjoying their beach communities.

dawn smisek EL PASO TX 79938 United States 3/25/2012

Some of my best memories were spending time with my family around those things and when I move back out there I want to start a new tradition 

with my kids there!

Rob Vandervort Costa Mesa CA 92627 United States 3/25/2012 Because we have fun using teh rings during teh summer with our children.

Zahsca La Forza Riverside CA 92503 United States 3/25/2012

Our homeschool community has gathered at these firepits for over 8 years. We have made many friends and memories that have had a profound 

impact on all of our lives. Though they are in your community, their removal will affect all of us in the Southland who come to enjoy one of the best 

local beaches around. Please reconsider.

Kirk Fisher Wildomar CA 92595 United States 3/25/2012 The fire pits have been part of our family tradition for generations.  Don't do this.

Allesson Stensing Buffalo MN 55313 United States 3/25/2012

Last summer I was lucky enough to spend a week in California visiting family. On the night before I had to leave and head back to Minnesota my 

host brought me to these fire pits. Seeing all of the families around enjoying the simplistic beauty of a fire and the sounds of the ocean was truly 

inspiring and has made an impression on me forever. Please do not remove these, I would like to take my kids to them when I get older and share 

with them the simple fun and joy they bring.

Theresa Hughes Riverside CA 92504 United States 3/25/2012 Memories of family outings at the beach! Future generations should be allowed to share in these special times and evenings around the fire pits. 

Cindi  Rhodes Orange CA 92865 United States 3/24/2012

This is our culture, our history and the future that we can give to our Californian children.

Please leave the fire pits!!!!!

Sean L costa mesa CA 92626 United States 3/24/2012 I have had way to many good memories uding those fire rings...I would hate to see them gone.

Phillip DiGiacomo Los Angeles CA 90045 United States 3/24/2012

This is a Corona del Mar tradition that should remain for eternity. Its an experience every kid should enjoy and cherish. I'll never forget the fire pits 

and all the fun times. 

Bianca Leichnitz Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/24/2012 I love coming to the fire pits with my family and for special occasions

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 168: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Peter Desforges Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/24/2012

The very vocal but small group of homeowners who are in favor of removing the fire pits claim that they are bothered by the smoke that the fire 

pits generate.  The fire pits were in use long before these homeowners bought their homes so, assuming that they did a reasonable amount of due 

diligence before buying the homes, it is clear that they did so with full knowledge of the existence of the fire pits and the smoke that they generate. 

Now these homeowners want to take this amenity away from the general public because they don't like the smoke?  We live in a free market 

economy where everyone has the right to buy, hold or sell an asset based on the asset's perceived value to the individual buyer or seller.  The fire 

pits existed when these now disgruntled homeowners bought their houses so we can only reasonably assume that either 1) they paid a price that 

they perceived to be discounted in exchange for agreeing to tolerate the smoke or 2) they made a mistake and didn't do their due diligence with 

respect to the smoke generated by the fire pits.  In either event, please don't punish the general public (who greatly enjoy these fire pits) and 

reward this handful of homeowners who are either looking for the windfall of a smoke free house that they didn't originally pay for or who now 

realize that they made a mistake and didn't do sufficient due diligence prior to buying their homes.  What ever happened to the concept of "caveat 

emptor"?  There are plenty of buyers out there who would knowingly tolerate a little smoke on summer nights in exchange for the wonderful views 

and the amenity of being able to use the fire pits themselves.  These fire pits are a wonderful tradition in Newport Beach and it would be a shame 

to see them disappear because of a small group of malcontents.

Maureen Halpert Newport Coast CA 92657 United States 3/24/2012

I bet not one of the people on the City Council uses these fire pits.  I am a Newport resident and have been to many celebrations at Big Corona 

which have extended into the evening.  And the best thing is that there are fire rings that we can all gather around and enjoy the sights and sounds 

of the beach environment.  Does it make sense for the City Council to try to take nature from us?  I don't think so.  

Michelle Nelson Yorba Linda CA 92886 United States 3/24/2012

I was born and raised here and I have watched this once great state go into the toilet because the people in charge are morons who care only 

about special interests. I am sick of this kind of crap. We have HUGE fiscal problems. But instead we go about banning digging holes at the beach, 

the throwing of frisbees at the beach in LA, transfats and things like fire pit removals is over the top. I am so sick of being nannied and regulated to 

the point of absurdity.

Marilyn Ghere Laguna Beach CA 92651 United States 3/24/2012

Just living life every day brings risks.  Our government officials should not try to eliminate every potential hazard by taking away the activities that 

are an important and memorable part of our lives.  Please do the right thing‐‐ keep the fire rings.

Vicki High laguna Beach CA 92652 United States 3/24/2012

I LOVE those fire pits!  We take out of town guests down to the fun zone, then to that beach for our picnic specifically because we can have a fire. If 

you take them out, you'll loose our tourist visits.

Anna Child Huntington Beach CA 92647 United States 3/24/2012

Parents need to be responsible for thier children and watch them. I am so fed up with people suing when they were the ones that were suppose to 

be responsible.. If you stand next to something hot "be careful"! duh

Jeanne Newton West Covina CA 91791 United States 3/24/2012 This is a part of living in Southern California.  This is a family activity that should not be taken from our children and grandchildren

cheryl crocker leander TX 78641 United States 3/24/2012

Because I lived in So. Cal and we would go to the beach almost every day and on the weekends sit out there and cook as a family. We loved going 

out there and our son looked  forward to the weekends so we could have our fire and roast marshmallows. It would be a shame  other family could 

not have such great memories. 

Greg Marshall Irvine CA 92614 United States 3/24/2012

We love the fire pits! Wonderful memories of my daughter's 13th birthday party and 30 of her closest friends!!  And even when we aren't using 

them, it is  wonderful to see others enjoying our greatest natural resource, the beach!  The city should think WWGD...what would Gidget do!

diana warner NEWPORT BEACH CA 92662 United States 3/23/2012

My dad is turning 80 this summer and because we have a wonderful LARGE family that loves the beach..we have already planned the birthday 

party  to be at the beautiful Newport beach fire pits in August!!! ALSO‐My husband has had his office party there too for 3 years!! We need the 

wonderful fire pits!!

Chris Twining Wildomar CA 92595 United States 3/23/2012

Absolutely ridiculous!!!  You should all be ashamed of yourselves!!!  You call yourselves representatives?  Grow Up!!!  Get a life!!!  Leave our 

firepits alone!!!  Common decency prevents me from expressing what I think of you and this idea.  

Wendy McManigal Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/23/2012

The fire pits are a long time family tradition of ours.  My husband & I both grew up in Newport Beach & are now back. We grew up enjoying the fire 

pits and continue to do so now with our own children. Please don't remove them ‐ it would be a tragedy.

Thank you, Wendy McManigal

Karen Harrison Irvine CA 92618 United States 3/23/2012

I want my grandkids to enjoy the beach in the evening like I did growing up.   Also, all of our childrens youth groups use the rings every Saturday 

night.  Can't imagine the beach without the fire rings.

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 169: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Carol Crane Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/23/2012

Enough "chipping away" at old Newport. What's next, kicking out the Dory Fleet fishermen and the vintage surfers from Blackie's? And erecting 

more mega mansions?

mark seaton los osos CA 93402 United States 3/23/2012 have enjoyed o.c. for 20 years fire pits always a highlite

Melinda Woodward Rancho Cucamonga CA 91730 United States 3/23/2012

The Fire pits MUST be SAVED, they are so much a part of Southern California History!

just like The Beach Boys!! ... SAVE THE PITS!!!

Patricia Ross Tustin CA 92780 United States 3/23/2012

The fire rings are part of the whole beach experience.  They are not only a tourist attraction (which helps bring revenues to businesses nearby) but 

locals love them too.  They add enjoyment to recreation at the beach.

Alexa Root Corona del Mar CA 92625 United States 3/23/2012

I like the bonfires, I use them, and they are a positive part of the Big Corona experience for many people.  We lack places where people can have a 

cheap, fun time.  

Stacy Taylor Eastsound WA 98245 United States 3/23/2012

Growing up in CDM there were, emphasis on "WERE" many things & landmarks that made CDM/Newport the special place it was. Most of all them 

are gone now replaced by cookie cutter McMansions and a pre‐fab sterile environment one would find in a hospital. Fun Zone gone, Stables by 

Cameo Shores gone, El Morro trailer park gone, hills to mountain bike through from CDM & LB gone (Npt Cst  complete w/ stepford wives ~ ugh!), 

Crystal Cove gone...now pay to get in & it's a tourist attraction??? The list goes on ad infinitum. Please, please, these fire pits are a huge part of our 

Southern California, moreover CDM/Npt. Beach culture. They have brought endless wonderful memories to us as children, teens now adults with 

children of our own.  

You've got your way in every battle waged to demolish the CDM/Npt. charming beach town it was. Please do not get rid of the fire pits that so 

many enjoy each & every day and night.  

Here is a short but touching video of what we used to have: <a href="http://vimeo.com/38944135" 

rel="nofollow">http://vimeo.com/38944135</a>

Sincerely with heavy heart, 

Stacy

lawrence michalchik buffalo MN 55313 United States 3/23/2012 I visit California every summer and every year me and my father have a bonfire in one of these fire pits at this beach

David Pittman Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/23/2012

Bonfires on the beach are a quintessential California lifestyle. To take that away from the families who enjoy this communal experience is to 

deprive them of one the truly great pleasures in life.

Daniel Archambault Pomona CA 91767 United States 3/23/2012

We used to rent a house in Balboa every su

mmer and our family occasionally go out and cook hot dogs out there. My nieces live in Costa Mesa and they like to go enjoy a nice fire on the 

beach from time to time. Maybe there are a few bad apples using them, but don't let them ruin it for every one. Some people might choose to 

vacation somewhere else.

Rick  Mayer Newport Beach CA 92663 United States 3/23/2012

I have been enjoying the fire pits for decades and hope to enjoy them again with my grandchildren some day. They are an essential part of the 

beach culture of Newport Beach and California. As others have stated this is just another example of our council over ruling a commission as a knee 

jerk reaction. 

Nancy Osso Costa Mesa CA 92626 United States 3/23/2012

The beach and fire pits, hot dogs and Marshmallows are all very much a part of the Southern California summer evening life style.  The pits 

shouldn't be removed.  In addition I think Newport Beach/CDM will lose revenue. Anyone who wants to spend the evening at the beach wants to 

do so because of the fire rings.  I think you will see a decline at the Newport/CDM beaches and Huntington Beach will reap the rewards!

Gordon Kennedy Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/23/2012

We have enjoyed using the fire pits for many years when vacationing here to visit relatives . Now we have moved to the area and are enjoying 

them even more with our two young children. They provide so much fun for so many people and should not be removed.

Brandy Valdez Corona del Mar CA 92625 United States 3/22/2012 It's a family tradition!

Jill Money Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/22/2012

our church has an annual "corn roast" where we gather around the fire pits and cook corn on the cob in salt water from the ocean.  It is a fabulous 

event ‐‐ good, wholesome, clean, fun.  Don't take that away from us!  We love the fire pits.   Loads of good memories as a resident of 30 years.

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 170: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Matthew T HolzmannNewport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/22/2012 this is an incredible instance of both NIMBY and elitism. The fire pits have been a tradition for 50 years.

Lori Butler Vista CA 92084 United States 3/22/2012

I vacation in Newport Beach and grew up their. My son Brandxon is a Newport Beach lifeguard. SanDiego city of, found a way recenlty to preserve 

their fire rings for the beneift of the community and you can too!

J.R. Means Corona del Mar CA 92625 United States 3/22/2012

I am a vocal and voting citizen of Corona del Mar, Ca and have spent the last 23 years enjoying the beaches here in our beautiful city. We love the 

fire rings and use them regularly. Cub Scouts and Brownies. This is a ridiculous claim that the smoke somehow causes health issues for the 

residents of the beach. The folks that are complaining are truely wanting the beach for themselves. They want to limit the draw to the beach so the 

"Inlanders" don't have any reason to stick around and enjoy the beach at night. I am available to speak with you directly if you would like. Thank 

you for your service to our great state.

Gale Friedman Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/22/2012 The fire pits are the best family activity. Please leave them

Evan Miles Santa Ana CA 92703 United States 3/22/2012

These fire pits give me a great opportunity to get kids out of my neighborhood which has trouble and get them to a good enviroment where they 

can cook hot dogs and have some good clean fun. I am in my late 20's and have lived in Orange County my whole life, I would be really 

disappointed if these were removed.

Jay Palchikoff Corona del Mar CA 92625 United States 3/22/2012

As a longtime CDM resident, I want to preserve the fires rings as part of what has made that beach special ever since I was a kid visiting from inland 

OC.  I hear all the arguments about smoke and safety, and I have to ask, "Since when?"   From  the under‐the‐breath comments I've heard over the 

years, I fear that part of this is a smoke screen aimed at reducing the number of inlanders (and particularly Latinos) at  "our" beach.  Shameful if 

true.

Brent Caldwell Irvine CA 92612 United States 3/22/2012

These rings are great opportunities to enjoy the beach and should not be removed because some people are stupid and hurt themselves.  The 

many should not suffer because of the few.

Dan Stone Irvine CA 92614 United States 3/22/2012 It is a great place for the family to get together, enjoy our beautiful weather and ultimately spend money in Newport Beach.

amy noe San Antonio TX 78209 United States 3/22/2012 Love the fire rings!!!!....PLEASE DO NOT REMOVE!!!!!....Enjoyed so much during the nine years we lived in Newport Beach!!!

Tim  Kelley Riverside CA 92501 United States 3/22/2012

To keep it REAL!!!  The beach's are  the people's!!!! The taxpayers of CA!!!  Do not close the fire rings just because you can't do your job in 

enforcing the rules!!!! 

Matthew Healy Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/22/2012 Just plain against 'big government'

Allan Newell Irvine CA 92614 United States 3/22/2012 The fire pits have been a tradition of these beachs and a blessing to stay warm and enjoy the evening and some‐mores for the kids.

Jason Neria Orange CA 92869 United States 3/22/2012 These pits have been part of the best family time we've had every summer. Not having them would be a tragedy.

Richard Andrews Irvine CA 92604 United States 3/22/2012

The City of Newport Beach charges for parking and should be able to manage this long traditional asset.  These fire pits have been a place for  

families and children to gather at the ocean front for food and fellowship, in the beauty of the outdoors, for generations. They are controled and 

contained. This is a lot better then kids hanging out at the malls. Next it will be no volleyball nets. Thanks for passing this along to your friends !

Thomas Andrews Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/22/2012

Don't let the risk adverse city council kill this long term tradition.  The  fire rings are greatplace for families and teens to get together, get out of the 

house and enjoy a summer evening in California.  

Cindy Eddleman Irvine CA 92612 United States 3/22/2012 My family and I have been enjoying the fire rings for over 50 years.  What fun we've had!!  Let's allow other new families to also share that fun.

Barbara L  BaumgartnNewport Beach CA 92662 United States 3/21/2012

DON'T  take away the fire rings as they are a summertime tradition  for  families and friends to gather around for hot dogs, smores, and good time 

memories.

Dani Nichols San Clemente CA 92672 United States 3/21/2012 because my church group and friends have created community and loved these fire pits... do not take away our beach traditions!

Whitney Wright Newport Coast CA 92657 United States 3/21/2012 i've spent years using the fire pits and know just how big a part of the culture they are!

BRIAN DEAN TEMECULA CA 92592 United States 3/21/2012

I GREW UP IN NEWPORT AND THE RINGS WERE A CHANCE TO RELAX, ENJOY THE BEACH AND BE WITH FRIENDS.  HAVE THE LIFEGUARDS/POLICE 

PATROL THE RINGS... IF THE RINGS ARE BEING ABUSED THEN PUNISH THE OFFENDERS, NOT THE CASUAL USER WHO WILL ABIDE BY THE RULES.  IF 

YOU NEED ASSISTANCE IN PATROLS, I WILL VOLUNTEER MY TALENTS....

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 171: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Jacqueline Moran Newport Coast CA 92657 United States 3/21/2012

Please do not remove the rings. We have had many wonderful, family and friends, special gatherings by the  bon‐fires at the

beach. It is a tradition. It is a fun place to gather and enjoy the evenings on the beach and stay warm and make smores and roast marshmellows. 

Diane Harris Denver CO 80210 United States 3/21/2012

Please don't take away the opportunity to show our future generations how great life can be on the beach with your family on a warm summer 

night.  The fire pits represent the beach lifestyle that we all fight so hard to preserve.

Thomas  Clark Capistrano Beach CA 92624 United States 3/21/2012

If we lose community we lose the soul of why we exist as neighbors and the tradition of beach bonfires is a vital legacy to what makes us Southern 

Californians and we would lose the wonderful community‐building and friendship/family enhancing experience of hanging out together. What a 

short‐sighted measure this would be if fire rings are removed. Please look at other ways to reduce costs.

Fred Fourcher Corona Del Mar CA 92625 United States 3/21/2012 I enjoy the rings and my company Bitcentral has beach parties at the beach and we would not do that if the rings were not there.  

Daniel Pugh Long Beach CA 90808 United States 3/21/2012 When I was a kid groups of us sat at these rings and we all remember it fondly. I would like to still do the same in the future.

Stephen Margala Mission Viejo CA 92691 United States 3/21/2012 I enjoy using the firepits.

Carol Heed Yorba Linda CA 92886 United States 3/21/2012 Beach parties would not be the same without a fire!  Please don't remove the fire rings!!!

Richard Lines Hermosa Beach CA 90254 United States 3/21/2012 I can't think of a good reason to remove the firepits. Too much fun to be had there.

Athena Reschke Laguna Niguel CA 92677 United States 3/21/2012

The fire rings are part of our California coastal culture.  They offer a low‐cost entertainment option for families and generate sales for local 

businesses. Keep our beaches alive!

Dan Brock Tustin CA 92780 United States 3/21/2012

I grew up with these fire rings and really enjoyed going to the beach at night for roasting marshmellows and hot dogs at these great beaches. They 

offer great fun, family unity, and lots of memories. WE NEED TO KEEP THEM THERE!!! 

Karen Carboni Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/21/2012

I had all of my birthday parties there as a child and I'd like to share that tradition with my children. Please keep the fire rings‐ it's a great addition to 

Big Corona and so much fun for the whole family.

Bill Balch Huntington Beach CA 92646 United States 3/21/2012 Fire pits are AMERICANA

Jon Spotts Corona del Mar CA 92625 United States 3/21/2012

I often walk the beach at night.  The fire pits draw families to the beach which adds great atmosphere and adds to the safety of the area.  Keep our 

pits.

Jill  McGlasson Orange CA 92869 United States 3/21/2012 We need these fire pits for our children's sake and all the great memories!!!

David Somoya Corona del Mar CA 92625 United States 3/21/2012

I have many fond memories as a child coming to Corona del Mar and staying warm by the fire rings roasting hot dogs and marshmallows.  Now that 

I have children of my own we go and enjoy these fire rings as well.  These rings should stay, not just for ourselves, but for the enjoyment of future 

generations as well.

Hilary Lau Irvine CA 92614 United States 3/21/2012

The beach fire rings are an important part of the beach community! It is a GATHERING PLACE where people of all ages socialize, learn, grow, create 

friendships. If you take these away you kill part of the healthy workings of our community! I know all of the City Planners and workers are always 

looking for ways to bring people into the community, to support the local businesses, to build self sustaining relationships. So why on Earth would 

you vote to remove this vital part of our beach community?? It is the opposite of a smart decision. Please keep the beach fire pits!

Brenda  Falk Corona CA 92882 United States 3/21/2012 It would be a shame to see thise pits removed.  Bon Fires on the beach is something my family enjoys doing during the summers.

susan rauma Hesperia CA 92345 United States 3/21/2012

We come down to CDM as a family several times a year. We have so much fun BBQing food and having smores. We have never seen any gang 

problems or problems of any kind since we've been coming (Over 10 years). We have lost so many freedoms in California all because of the actions 

of some  people who can't control themselves...why not go after them ? and leave the rest of us who act responsibly alone?

Amanda  Garcia Olympia WA 98506 United States 3/21/2012

Althogh, I moved frn California a long time ago, the visits always are longer when I plan on two things: Disnyland and firerings.  Lose.th rings....lose 

ot on a few tourist s.

Daniel  Ortiz Irvine CA 92606 United States 3/21/2012 Bonfires in the summer nights are what make Southern California good times with friends and family

Christine Seegmiller Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/20/2012

Our family and friends have enjoyed numerous gatherings at the beach around the firepits.  Without them, we would not have been drawn 

together.

Kris Urdahl Oakland CA 9410 United States 3/20/2012

Grew up in Orange County and spent many years on the beaches at Newport. This is just one more example of nanny statehood. I believe most 

people are capable of having a fire in a fire ring at the beach without doing harm to the greater populace. What  a ridiculous regulation/law.

Miles Meehan Newport Beach CA 92663 United States 3/20/2012 keep those fire pits, I was just talking about how fun those were

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 172: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Michelle Brickell Menifee CA 92584 United States 3/20/2012

Grew up in Orange County and going to the beach in summer and building a fire was just part of the summertime experience.  It would be 

unfortunate if future generations could not enjoy that as well.

Amy Mireles Fallbrook CA 92028 United States 3/20/2012 Grew up going to OC/LA bonfires in the summer. I want my children to enjoy them as I did. 

Shawn Hoebeck Irvine CA 92617 United States 3/20/2012

This is also a great tradition for UC Irvine students living and studying nearby. The last thing the area needs is people trying to make it even more 

boring. If you want to kill the fun at a beach, kill it somewhere else. I've been there many times and it's always been just a great community of 

people having a great time. I'd hate to see that go.

Patricia Nance Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/20/2012

The fire rings are a fun, safe way to enjoy family & friends at the beach in the evening...a very enjoyable time of day:) Please don't take away this 

venue!

elizabeth barnes Costa Mesa CA 92627 United States 3/20/2012

The fire rings add so much to our beaches! Something for our kids to.Please don't take them away. Normal people don't walk in fire pits or let their 

kids do it. Don't punish us all for someone else's stupidity! 

shanna torp post falls ID 83877 United States 3/20/2012 Because i grew up in southern california ...and the fire pits are one of the many reasons that make cali beaches special 

edward kehoe Newport beach CA 92660 United States 3/20/2012 This is Newport Beach's signature. Tourists love these. Don't drive out business or fun for the locals!

ernesto acuna costa Mesa CA 92626 United States 3/20/2012

Removing the fire rings pits will take away the summer fun after the sun goes down.  Corona Del Mar has always been a place where memories are 

made.  I have lived in Costa Mesa/Newport Beach over 25 years and have always seen young and old bonding together.  Please do not deny future 

generations from making their own memories of gathering around the fire pits and share stories, experiences and great times.

Maria Potts Thornton, CO 80602 CO 80602 United States 3/20/2012

I used to live in this area.  This is an amazing beach and left us with beautiful memories of family bonfires.  Leave the firepits and continue to give 

future generations the same lovely opportunities.

Darryl Walker Medford OR 97504 United States 3/20/2012

I lived in Fountain Valley CA. for 30 years of my life, during that time my family and I used and enjoyed the fire rings at the beach on numerous 

occasions.  As a youth at church we spent a lot of time at the beach having ring side meetings and sing along.  Please don't take those unique 

experiences away from the now and future generations. >

Jason Anthonisen Newport Beach CA 92661 United States 3/20/2012

I have been going to these fire pits in balboa and corona del mar since I was a child!  How selfish would I be if I didn't fight to save these for future 

children?  This is a state beach.  A public beach. Not a country club for the elite!  If you are sensitive to fires, how about not moving next to fires in 

the 1st place!  They took away the funzone bumper cars.  They took away the carousel! Now the want to take away our fire pits???  Not on my 

watch!  Let's fight to preserve what history we have left in Newport beach!  Let's not just sign this and say "I did my part".  Let's make signs.  Post 

them on bulletin boards, in store windows.  Share again and again on Facebook!  Let's save this for future generations!   Utilize your talents!  GOD 

owns every grain of sand on that beach and it is his gift to us.  If I want to play a song of praise to the LORD with my guitar around the fire, it's my 

GOD given right!  If I want to take a date there for romance, it's my right.  If I want to have laughs with some close friends or family that is my right 

also.  This is an American tradition.  Do not let them take this CCC.  Please hear our voice!  Thank you!  

Anamarie  BeschorneMission Viejo CA 92691 United States 3/20/2012 I want everyone to still be able to enjoy the use of the fire rings.  I have had so many memories growing up with my friends and family. 

Carl  Reed Eastvale CA 92880 United States 3/20/2012 My family and I (on a regular basis in the summer) enjoy going to the beach to have fires and family time. To remove them would be a tragedy.  

Lora Venstrom Santa Ana CA 92705 United States 3/20/2012 This is our fundamental right as So. Ca. citizens to have a safe beach fire!

Diane Donovan Placentia CA 92870 United States 3/20/2012

These fire pits have been a wholesome form of inexpensive fun for the 40 years my friends, children and family have been using them and have 

NEVER encountered gang activity or other nuisance situations. These are for the PEOPLE to enjoy OUR beaches.  Please stop taking our freedoms 

away!!

Jeffrey Lockhart Santa Ana CA 92705 United States 3/19/2012

I grew up enjoying bonfires at the beach. As this is only possible on beaches with fire pits, which are already scarce and overcrowded on the best 

days, losing these fire pits at my favorite beach would be devastating!

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 173: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Gabrielle Kerr Costa Mesa CA 92627 United States 3/19/2012

I grew up in Corona Del Mar, and spent all my youth at CDM state beach. I have enjoyed so many evenings at the fire pits, that they are too 

numerous to count. We would get to the beach first thing in the morning to get a fire pit, spent all day long holding onto a fire pit so no one would 

take it, while waiting in anticipation for the sun to set, so we could light our fire pit.  It would be a terrible shame for the children of today not to be 

able experience the same enjoyment that I had as a kid. I don't know what kind of a person would want to take that away from the children and 

their families coming to the beach to enjoy their day in the sand and water and their evenings by the fire pits. Haven't you ever made a s'more? Or 

roasted hot dogs over an open flame? Or sung songs by an open fire? If not, then what a shame, because you missed out on one of the best parts 

of being a lucky kid who lived and grew up in a beach community. These are such wonderful memorable times of my youth, and ones I will treasure 

always. But also the amazing memories we are making as adults as well, since we still go to the beach to enjoy the fire pits with our families and 

friends. This is what you will be taking away from the children of today. I hope you make the right decision and keep the fire pits! 

Nathan King Mesa AZ 85212 United States 3/19/2012

I grew up spending many summer nights gathered around the fire pits with family and/or friends. Every time I come back to California, these pits in 

particular are a required stop for me and my family, regardless of the time of year.  We have an annual family reunion and part of it takes place 

gathered around a fire pit, boiling corn in seawater.  Don't ruin this part of my life.

Meherdad AzadbakhtLong Beach CA 90814 United States 3/19/2012 This is ridiculous. Where is your decency? 

Matthew Gibbs fountain valley CA 92708 United States 3/19/2012

The fire pits are the cornerstone of the California beach experience.  Their removal will damage tourism, lower beach use, and reduce local 

business revenue.

Jill Casserly Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/19/2012

I have enjoyed many happy moments with friends and family around a bonfire at the fire pits at Big Corona and I would like for this tradition to be 

enjoyed by many future generations.

Hunter Stroman Newport Beach CA 92661 United States 3/19/2012 I live on B Street and want the rings to stay!

Dwaine Elder Las Vegas NV 89102 United States 3/19/2012 I have always enjoyed coming down to the beach and spending some time by the fire pits, always meet new people and have a great time

Bruce Billedeaux Portage MI 49024 United States 3/19/2012 Fire rings are iconic. It is one of the reasons we choose Newport when we visit California. What is happening to live and let live California? 

Brad Burlingham Fairview NC 28730 United States 3/19/2012 Spent my first 20 years in Newport and still go back often and use those rings!  A beautiful wonderful tradition and worth the trouble!

Ellery Sorkin Encino CA 91436 United States 3/19/2012

Fire rings complete the four elements, and provide warm food for a good experience, are easy to maintain, and centralize expended firewood.  The 

government is supposed to make our lives better, not make us endure the cold and dark.

Dennis Hollenbeck Chula Vista CA 91913 United States Min 3/19/2012

Although I no longer live in the area I have fond  memories of heading down to Balboa to hang out around the camp fire. They are killing Americas 

Traditions, Southern California Traditions!!! Come on have a heart.

Marjorie Burns Los Angeles CA 90004 United States 3/19/2012 Because fire pits are quintessential California, and provide a safe way to have a cozy evening on the beach.

Barbara Salisbury Tustin CA 92780 United States 3/19/2012

This would be very dissapointing to not be able to spend a day with my friends and family who go for the day and have hot dogs and marshmallows 

for dinner.  Like others have said, this is an attraction to that beach.

Billy  Martin Irvine CA 92619 United States 3/19/2012 That is the best family fun spot in Orange County. Couldnt imagine my kids growing up with fires at the beach. Are you KIDDING???

Robert Guthrie Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/19/2012 Keep the fire rings for our kids and grandkids.

Edward Atkins Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/19/2012 This is a public NOT private beach. The rich people living on the cliff can move to a private beach if they want to regulate it. 

claudean davidson irvine CA 92604 United States 3/19/2012

i grow up going to newport and having bbq's there with family and friends and now my children are doing the same. i would hate to see them 

taken away

Cj  Davidson irvine CA 92604 United States 3/19/2012

i grew up bbq's in newport with family and friends. now over the years my children and there friends and our family still ude the pits. i would hate 

to see them gone

Pete Kuhnen Huntington Beach CA 92646 United States 3/19/2012 Fewer people will visit the beaches in the winter and at night because the fire is gone.  Don't let them go!

mick mccarthy venice CA 90291 United States 3/18/2012

I grew up at the CDM fire pits. Great times, great community would be a shame to have others not share the same experience my family and 

friends were afforded !

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 174: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

John Stapp American Fork UT 84003 United States 3/18/2012

I used to live in Irvine and have fond memories of evenings with the fire pits. They are a wonderful part of many people's lives and I can't think of 

any reason to remove them. 

Frances Pfaff Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/18/2012

If I had an allergy to something, I would stay away from that thing or move away. I would not force other people to avoid the things that bother 

me. Let's keep the tradition of the fire pits, especially at the State Beach at Big Corona where my family and so many others have made valuable 

memories over the years.

John Cannon Santa Ana CA 92705 United States 3/18/2012

What is more Californian then cooking hot dogs with a group friends and children looking out over the Pacific.  My Grandparents had the Balboa 

Pavillion for dancing ‐ now gone.  My brothers and I had the Fun Zone ‐ now gone.  What are we really gaining taking away the fire pits?

Heather Cowley Layton UT 84041 United States 3/18/2012

Sitting around these fires were a HUGE part of my younger years...many happy, inexpensive, carefree times spent here.  I am SO saddened and 

angered to see that removing them is even being considered.  I want the chance to share this part of California with MY kids...please!

Jarrod  Wilbur Orange CA 92867 United States 3/18/2012

These rings allow  thousands of people to enjoy countless hours of cheap and safe enjoyment. Getting rid of them would anger thousands of 

Southern California residences. Me included. For those of you on the council, I would advise you to think about the amount of votes you will be 

GUARANTEED to loose if you choose to get rid of these California landmarks.

Kristin Irish Mission Viejo CA 92692 United States 3/18/2012 Because you're ruining beach culture

Dennis McCracken La Mirada CA 90638 United States 3/18/2012 My family has been using this beach and firepits for years and years.

Grace Parker Bay Point CA 94565 United States 3/18/2012

We need to retain something form our formative years to share with the next generation that brings joy, togetherness and a sense of family!!  Our 

funzone is being slowly dismantled by 'big brother' and NO RESIDENTS are happy about it.  Keep Newport Beach a FAMILY FRIENDLY destination as 

opposed to the concrete jungle that is being created by corproate America!

MaryAnne Shults Mission Viejo CA 92691 United States 3/18/2012

There is little one can do in Orange County anymore that is free, except enjoy our beaches. One of any age can get together with friends and/or 

family and gather around a fire at the beach. Don't take away this enjoyment, and don't destroy part of our culture and history.

Cameron  Schroer Tustin CA 92837 United States 3/18/2012 Iv'e had a lot of great times having bonfires down at the beach. I would hat to see the rings go.

Mark Hinton Orange CA 92867 United States 3/18/2012

The beach is where the ocean meets the sand. People should be able to have something to do in that special place without having to spend money 

at a restaurant, shopping etc.. 

Ellen Ching North Fork CA 93643 United States 3/18/2012

I went to High School in Huntington Beach and have such fond memories of hanging out around bonfires with friends.  Please don't take away 

memories made at the beach with family and friends around a bonfire! 

Jennifer McDonald GREELEY CO 80634 United States 3/18/2012

I grew up in NB in the 70's, 80's and early 90's.  We had a long‐time family tradition of having dinner on the beach with friends and family several 

times each summer. I'd hate to see that tradition taken away for current and future generations. So many things make inexpensive, fun, family 

activities seem to fade away. Please reconsider this decision and keep the fire pits in NB and CdM! 

Greg Prete Laguna Niguel CA 92677 United States 3/18/2012

I grew up going there.  I'd like to make more memories there with our daughters before they're grown and gone to college.  It's always been a 

public place to roast hot‐dogs and smores.  I do agree, however, there should be no burning of plastics, etc., only ordinary firewood.  

Linda Kemmer Salt Lake City UT 84103 United States 3/18/2012 I love the fire rings.  It was a part of my childhood and my adult life.  It is so much fun and will be heartbreaking if this really happens. 

Tobin Bush Laguna hills CA 92653 United States 3/18/2012 If newport does it, Then laguna to redondo beach will do it , and that's WRONG! the pits bring family & freinds together for fun times.

Lynn Kubasek Laguna Beach CA 92651 United States 3/18/2012 This is one of the few places left where we can enjoy a warm fire after a cold swim. 

Heather Spies Huntington Beach CA 92647 United States 3/18/2012

I have spent time being at the fire pits and its a great summer activity whether it be with family or friends, you make it memorable. This is a 

favorite California Pasttime ‐ you cant just take it away.

Merrilee C. Bridgema Charlotte NC 28210 United States 3/18/2012

I grew up in the 70‐80s going to these fire pits with friends and family. Every spring and summer, my daughters and I trek from NC back to 

Newport/CdM and spend many days at CdM beach, using the fire pits. It's a tradition for us. While I seldom see people I know anymore, no one is 

ever misbehaving and seniors as well as families who have little means seem to especially enjoy this lovely, free commodity in an otherwise high‐

price‐point town. Why would we be willing to remove one of the last bits of old Newport charm at the juncture?  Penny wise and pound foolish, my 

friends.

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 175: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Mary Ann Cote Newport OR 97365 United States 3/18/2012

I've enjoyed many a gathering at these fire pits. It would be sad to rob future generations of this simple and sweet activity that is such a part of the 

local culture.  I've moved on to Oregon because of stupid decisions such as these. I hope they are still there when I visit. 

David  Smith Santa Ana CA 92705 United States 3/18/2012 Fun to cookout at the beach

Troy Muenzer Long Beach CA 90803 United States 3/18/2012

Are you kidding me!?! Why wouldn't anyone sign the petition!? The fire rings are a part of a very rich tradition in southern California beach culture 

and for many, many years families and friends have gathered around the fire rings as part of the enjoyment and luxury of living in the area or 

visiting the southern California coast.  It's a great place for young people to hang out and enjoy the beach and it would be very detrimental to 

southern California society if these fire rings were to be removed.

Charles Gates Bon Air VA 23235 United States 3/18/2012

Growing up in Irvine and Newport Beach, our family developed a tradition of having bonfire "corn roasts" for every major family event. ‐ weddings, 

graduation, baby births, etc. We boil hundreds of ears of corn in sea water over a bonfire at the beach. Its still our favorite for when we come back 

to SoCal to visit my parents.

Marie Pollerna Altadena CA 91001 United States 3/18/2012

My sister and her family live in Newport Beach and we have celebrations every summer at Big Corona and made tons of hotdogs and burgers from 

those very fire rings! It would be a great disservice to remove those rings from the Beach!!!  That is the best part of enjoying  Big Corona!!!

Joe McGhie Costa Mesa CA 92626 United States 3/18/2012

Our Scout Troop uses the fire rings very responsibly to host an annual back to school event for parents and Scouts. It is a tradition we would like to 

keep.

Veronica Holbrook Whittier CA 90605 United States 3/18/2012

For as long as I can remember our family has enjoyed spending time together around a bonfire at the beach. It's a summer tradition for our family 

and so many others. You would be destroying one of the legacies of and attractions to the California beaches. 

Joe  Garrett Corona Del Mar CA 92625 United States 3/18/2012

It is hard for me to believe that the City has voted to remove the rings. Besides being a wonderful amenity to the general public, they were placed 

there to control the misuse of portable coal burning stoves and protect  the public from stepping on hot coals and keeps the beachs clean.

It sems lilke we lose more and more of our freedoms every day.

Very Sad!!

Tod Phillips Bend OR 97702 United States 3/18/2012

I grew up in Newport Beach, CA and I could not think of a more classic Southern California pastime of having a fire on the beach. Please don't take 

this away.

Carolyn Carr Newport Beach CA 92662 United States 3/17/2012

The Beach is a place for youth, for families, for fun and frolicking, for surfing and swimming, for babes and bikinis. For nightly fires and music and 

songs.  Now the City of Newport Beach wants to take away the fire rings.  

Who are the residents who moved there fully aware that the fire rings were there, and now want them gone because of "air pollution"?  Do they 

take an early morning swim before going to work?  Or grab their surf board after work and catch a wave?

The Beach is a resource that belongs to the people of the State of California ‐ to enjoy.  Not to be restricted by rules by people of my generation 

who have outgrown their youth and their tolerance for the antics of the beach ‐ and the beach if full of antics!!

I grew up at the beach as a child.  I would get up ‐ grab my boat and water ski all day ‐ play at the beach and have lots of fun.  My dad had a huge 

bell mounted on a pole that he rang so we knew when it was time to come home for dinner.  

I have always said I would live in a closet at the beach rather than live inland ‐ at times my living space wasn't much bigger than a closet.

Now I am 65 and the noise, the traffic, the music, the confusion and everything that comes with beach living does not always appeal to me.  So I 

moved inland.  I still visit the beach and I jokingly tell my friends who are still there that my current neighbors must all be in the "witness protection 

program'.  It is that quiet.  However, the quiet, the peace, the pool outside my back door all fit my life style as an older adult.

Don't take out the fire rings ‐ let another generation of people enjoy what we did.  The beach was never meant to be a place of silence.  Don't use 

the fire rings to get rid of "certain elements" at the beach.  Try and remember how much fun the beach was when you were young.

Besides that juicy steak on your plate is far more likely to kill you than any small amount of "air pollution" from a fire ring.

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 176: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Ava Shaffer  Kailua HI 96734 United States 3/17/2012

Fun times spent with family, friends, youth and school groups gathered around the fire pits roasting food or just keeping warm. So sad that anyone 

in the city council would want to remove them and prevent what is a fun California tradition. Please don't do it!  

Kay Richey Costa Mesa CA 92627 United States 3/17/2012

Having grown up in Costa Mesa, the beach was a part of our lifestyle. Sitting around a fire ring on the beach is one of my fondest childhood 

memories. I would like others to be able to have those same memories. The beach is one of our greatest cultural resources in Orange County, it 

was the reason some of our families moved to this area and had their children grow up Californian. For some of us the fire pits are a family 

tradition. As citizens we deserve to be allowed to use our natural resources. It is a week argument to claim wood fires are a significant source of 

pollution, if it were then the city of Newport Beach is negligent by allowing wood burning fireplaces and backyard fire pits. It would seem more 

reasonable for them to ban Wood fires in personal residences which are more prevalent, and then move onto the beach fire pit issue using the 

data from the residential ban.

Frank Foley La Verne CA 91750 United States 3/17/2012 I agree that fire pits ae part of beach culture, and  part of our So Cal tradition

Kevin Hearle San Mateo CA 94402‐242United States 3/17/2012

My mother's family has been having campfires at the beach in Orange County since before there was an Orange County (it was still part of Los 

Angeles County until the late 1800s), and Big Corona and Balboa have been the best places for that since at least the 1930s.  Roughly six months 

before he died, my father told me the story about how late in junior high school and early in high school he and a guy named "Bud" (later to 

became famous under his given name of "Marlon") Brando went to Big Corona with my grandmother and Brando's mother and grandparents.  

While the adults sat around the campfire, my dad and Bud climbed the cliffs.  The fire rings were perfect gathering points for grunion hunts during 

my own teenage summer nights, and I would hate to see such a wonderful part of the cultural legacy of Southern California removed.

David Carter newport Beach 92660 Cambodia 3/17/2012 I grew up Warming myself on these fire pits with Friends after surfing Big C was my first Spot 

Jacqueline Brogna Rumney NH 3266 United States 3/17/2012

I grew up in Southern Calif. I go back to visit frequently and enjoy going to the beach and reliving those old days.

It's something we do and have done most of my life, I've shared it with my children and hope to share it with theirs as well.

Brian Peelle Fullerton CA 92833 United States 3/17/2012

The fire rings provide light at night and clusters of good people.  If they are removed, walks along the beach at night will be much more dangerous.  

Knowing good groups of people are near, and the glowing light of the fires help keep crime down.  Without them, would you feel safe going for a 

moonlit walk along the beach?

Theresa McCarthy Santee CA 92071 United States 3/17/2012

Officials & Governmental Commissions are now notorious for  taking away the most iconic and harmless enjoyments from the public, while at the 

same time they grant favorable rulings for  corporations with HARMFUL (and ultimately costly, mass‐scale public heath issues).  Leave the fire pits 

alone!   Do REAL public service and protect the public from these catastrophes:

<a href="http://www.electrosmogprevention.org/contact.html" rel="nofollow">http://www.electrosmogprevention.org/contact.html</a>

<a href="http://stopthesanteepowerplant.org/" rel="nofollow">http://stopthesanteepowerplant.org/</a>

Eric Wroolie Redlands CA 92374 United States 3/17/2012

Third‐generation Newport Beach native and frequent visitor to the beach with my kids.  Those fire pits have been there since I was kid.  They are 

not hurting anything ‐ the environment or the nearby residents.  Let them stay!

Nichole Smith Corona CA 92883 United States 3/17/2012 Grew up having family & friend events at these pits and its a tradition I carry on today. 

Marnie Brow Dana Point CA 92629 United States 3/17/2012 Tradition!

Brian Peelle Fullerton CA 92833 United States 3/17/2012

The fire rings provide light at night, and clusters of good people.  Walking along the beach after dark is not scary or dangerous, knowing that good 

people and light are nearby.  Remove the fire rings, and I would expect crime to increase after dark.  I sure wouldn't venture out for a grunion run, 

or just a moonlit walk along the beach anymore.

Please leave the fire rings!  Night after night, wonderful memories are being made with family and friends.

Rachel Gonzales Nuevo CA 92567 United States 3/17/2012 Its wrong. 

Linda Patton Newport Beach CA 92663 United States 3/17/2012 PLEASE do not take away this landmark of Newport, this family tradition... it is one of the things that makes living in Newport so unique.

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 177: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Nancy Razik Lihue HI 96766 United States 3/17/2012

CDM was my favorite hangout as a teenager...  so many fun memories of get‐togethers with friends and family...  the fire rings kept the fire 

contained so we could have fun while keeping everyone safe!  Please keep the rings for future families friends and get‐togethers:)  With aloha, 

Nancy Razik

Nora Seager Newport Beach, CA 92663 United States 3/17/2012

I am signing so that every child has the opportunity to roast a marshmallow at an open fire in the summer and go swimming afterwards.  This is the 

best part of life.  All our relatives come to visit us in Newport and we always go to make hot dogs and smores at the beach.  This is Newport's 

culture.  Stop taking away so much of our history.  For the last 45 years, I have lived in Newport and the beach fire in the summer is part of who we 

are as beach people.

Gray Whelan Portland OR 97202 United States 3/17/2012

I grew up in Newport Beach/CDM and have very fond memories of gathering around the fire rings as a kid. Usually with my church youth group. It 

would be a tragedy to loose such a tradition. Not to mention that fire should be a basic human right. Access to basic heating and cooking. Give me 

a break City Council.

Now that I live in Oregon, we can just dig a hole and have a fire almost anywhere on the beach. I know that would never fly in Newport Beach, CA, 

so fire rings are a great way to do it there. 

Theo Varelas Belmont CA 94002 United States 3/17/2012 cuz governments be hella gay yo

Peter Smith Newport Beach CA 92659 United States 3/17/2012

I'm all for caring for our environment and avoiding air pollution. However... before considering removal of these pits, a proper environmental 

impact study needs to determine how much real pollution they contribute. Seems that this is instigated by a few property owners who would 

prefer the beach in front of their homes to be an extension of their yards, not a public recreation area. How many of these people have owned 

their homes longer than the pits have been there? If not, they chose to buy next to a fire pit. They can either live with it or move. The beaches are 

for everyone ‐ and that includes folks visiting from inland who come and spend their hard‐earned money in our town.

Carlee Darr Costa Mesa CA 92627 United States 3/17/2012

Because the fire pits have been there far before any residents.  This was part of our community from the beginning.  Taking these out won't take 

away our memories, but it won't allow us to do with our kids, what our parents did.  Is there anything left these days from our childhoods?

John Lunde Aliso Viejo CA 92656 United States 3/16/2012 Traditional family fun and an abiding part of SoCal beach culture.  Stop the madness!

Katrina RedelsheimerNewport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/16/2012

There isn't much low‐cost fun to be had in Newport Beach. The fire pits are one of the few. Growing up in Newport Beach without tons of money is 

hard enough already without removing a key source of entertainment and bonding, not to mention warmth on cold Pacific nights.

victor martinez riveside CA 92506 United States 3/16/2012 Go there every summer has been a tradition and very few places near by allow pits anymore. it is part of the California culture!

Taylor Gonzales Riverside CA 92504 United States 3/16/2012 This is absolutely ridiculous. 

Kyle Hojem Irvine CA 92614 United States 3/16/2012

I've gone to Big Corona and Balboa for fire pit use for at least 10 years.  This is utterly disappointing to see the city council take away the pits 

because the beach is open to all.  It's a place to congregate on a nice clear evening to meet with people.  It is not just for locals, it's for people from 

all over SoCal.  Why even have a public beach if people are not allowed to use to its full potential.  I ask you not to grant the permits and to leave 

things as they are.  I thank you and the other users of the fire pits thank you as well.

Michael Brannon Carroll Valley PA 17320 United States 3/16/2012

born and raised in S.C. every time I come home the family has an evening around a pit

fun,safe,and tradition this is cazy!

John Schiesser Newport Beach CA 92661 United States 3/16/2012 I think this provides an excellent extracurricular activity for youth in our city. 

Frank Carpenter Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/16/2012

I am a life‐long resident of Newport Beach and believe the fire pits are a wonderful part of our culture and history. Please don't remove these 

treasured icons of our beach lifestylle and identity!

Alyssa Hamilton Newport Beach CA 92663 United States 3/16/2012 I had many birthdays and other events at these fire pits. Never had a problem. It's part of our culture

Dean Propst San Diego CA 92111 United States 3/16/2012

I am from Tustin and get up to my home area with my family quite a bit.  This has always been one of my favorite things to do and can not wait for 

this summer to introduce my children to this fine beach tradition.

jacquelyn roberts costa mesa CA 92627 United States 3/16/2012

they keep taking away our freedoms my family has had fires on newport beach for over 60 years we never bothered anyone what will be next block 

the whole beach to visitors..

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 178: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Don DeMooy Newport Beach CA 92663 United States 3/16/2012 Part of our history.  Great way to enjoy summer nights.  Save them people!!

steve griggs anaheim CA 92804 United States 3/16/2012 We like to cook out there all the time,who dosent??

Yvonne Villegas Riverside CA 92506 United States 3/16/2012

I love to visit that beach and would miss the pits if they were taken out.  would have to go to another beach.  They have been there this long why 

take them out? 

erika dimeo kissimmee FL 34741 United States 3/16/2012 I grew in in Balboa, the firepits are an amazing aspect of the ambiance.  

William Haggard Riverside CA 92506 United States 3/16/2012 We have been going to the beach to enjoy the firerings with our family and friends for over 40 years.  It would be a shame to re‐move them.

Doris Haggard Riverside CA 92506 United States 3/16/2012 Enjoy beach time in the summer evening.  The fire rings add so much to the experience.

Craig Kessinger Vista CA 92084 United States 3/16/2012

Removal of one of the most interesting features of the beaches is like cutting the throat of those who come visit those beaches...so you can kiss a 

level of social estate and tourism from you coffers for this one..!! Are you really that foolish..!! Oh, I forgot, your legislators, not logicians...!!

Greg Helin West Hills CA 91307 United States 3/16/2012 I grew up in CDM. Those fire pits were an essential part of family gatherings. Hot dogs, smores with my parents...The ARE CDM!

Jeff Elkins Newport Beach CA 92661 United States 3/16/2012

I live right on the beach at Balboa and I am appalled that they would even consider removing the rings.  It is a safe, fun, affordable, and unique 

activity that brings character to our beaches and makes me proud to live in Southern California.  

shauna trute los alamitos CA 90720 United States 3/16/2012

Beach Bon Fires bring family and friends together.  So many condos, apartments, and townhouses, no where for firepits...  The firepits NEED TO 

STAY

Steve Baker Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/16/2012

Those fire rings are such a part of our family life and traditions. They are a key element of beach culture in our unique community. I urge you to 

recognize their place in the fabric of our wonderful community!

Kelly Potts Charlotte NC 28213 United States 3/16/2012

I grew up in Southern California, and bonfires is my absolute favorite memory from my childhood/teenage years.  I participated in hundreds of 

them, and never had any dangerous or bad experiences.  

Karmen Wong Rosemead CA 91770 United States 3/16/2012

These pits are AWESOME. They were the source of many favorite memories! The removal of these pits due to safety reasons are absolute 

RUBBISH. Parents need to WATCH their children! And if people used a little of their BRAINS once in awhile we wouldn't have this problem! 

tim harold newport beach CA 92663 United States 3/16/2012 our family has been enjoying these fire rings for over 40yrs please let them stay

Alma Fausto Costa Mesa CA 92627 United States 3/16/2012

They are one of the few honest and true traditions that are still around during high school: a bonfire for the senior class and a photo of it in the 

yearbook. 

Michelle LeFort Trabuco Canyon CA 92679 United States 3/16/2012

Gathering around a bonfire has been part of the human experience since time began, it's in our DNA. The good that happens around the fire pit 

especially, one by the sea far outweighs any disadvantages. They should be kept for all to enjoy. 

Eric Liu Arcadia CA 91007 United States 3/16/2012

Removing the fire pits is such a bad idea. Staying at the beaches during the day and hanging out with friends is great, but the real fun and bonding 

happens over the bonfires. Some people come to the beaches JUST to bonfire. It's a great way for people to catch up and make great memories 

together. We can't lose this, it's been part of our lives for so long and gives people more incentive to go out. It seems like California  just wants us 

to stay home and become fat, unsociable creatures. This is NOT what California is about. What happened to enjoying the great outdoors, 

California? 

sylvia suh stafford VA 22554 United States 3/16/2012

Born and raised in Southern California, and beaching it during the day and then hanging by the bonfire was a huge part of my childhood. I'm from 

LA County but instead of going to the closer Santa Monica beach, my friends and I used to drive all the way to Newport or Seal Beach just so we 

could have a bonfire. Let the fire pits stay!

Ron Tanase NY NY 10011 United States 3/16/2012 I think Calif. has more pressing issues then community fire rings.

Steven Yampolsky Irvine CA 92612 United States 3/16/2012

Because the council is a bunch of controlling Nazis, and i still do not see why there cannot be legal consumption of WINE on the BEACH....have you 

people not heard of being romantic? evidently not, as you're bitter, intimacy deprived, and pathetic

Meghan Fitzgerald Wildomar CA 92595 United States 3/16/2012

I love bonfires!  My friends & family have often chosen which beach to visit based on whether they have fire rings.  Such a wonderful way to enjoy 

the beach longer & spend time together.  Please do not take away this amazing tradition!

Christine Planchon Redlands CA 92373 United States 3/16/2012

Fire rings are part of southern C a culture.  Enjoyed by locals and tourist alike. The fact the City Council Women on TV last night told beach goers 

who want fire rings to go elsewhere is an insult to all who have enjoyed and continue to enjoy the beaches

Chris Carpenter Kalama WA 98625 United States 3/16/2012

This is where I grew up and is part of that experience.  I want my daughter to have the same joys of watching the sun set with a hot dog over the 

fire as well.

Peter Annabel Chino Hills CA 91709 United States 3/16/2012 Fire rings are an integral part of the coast experience.

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 179: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Jeffrey  Riggs Eastvale CA 91752 United States 3/16/2012

The fire pits are a big part of the beach culture, and the beach culture is a huge part of california's identity. We should not be taking steps to 

remove the things that we have enjoyed as part of our lives for years and years, especially when there is no benefit to removing them.

Tim Grogan Bethel OH 45106 United States 3/16/2012 When i visit California I enjoy this and see it as part of Beach Life. Also as a retired Fire Chief I see no reason to curtail this. 

Robert Lovell Newport Beach CA 92661 United States 3/16/2012

First of all, if these firerings are air polluters, where is the proof and who did the study? Second I would like to see a study compairing the pollution 

that comes from these firerings to other polluters like SUV's, jets, leafblowers and the city council. Just say'n.

Adrian Anhood Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/16/2012 Fire pits are a southern california past time for the youth.

Megan Bunch Kaysville UT 84037 United States 3/16/2012

I grew up in Corona del Mar and one our favorite family activities was gathering around the fire pits for hot dogs, warming our hands and enjoying 

one another's company.  My husband of 18 years even proposed to me during one of these occasions!  I want my children and their children to 

have these same wonderful experiences. Please leave the fire pits!

Matthew Picard Palmdale CA 93551 United States 3/16/2012

I was a Corona Del Mar resident for many years and frequently visit the old stomping grounds.   We had many fires on the beach.  Not having a fire 

on the beach at night? Really? Are the Camp Grounds next?  Hotdogs, marshmallows, s'mores, come on! ... it's one of the last beach traditions.  Let 

us share one of the few things we enjoyed from our childhood with our children and grandchildren.  Before your write this into law, please get out 

from behind your desk, get some sand between your toes while you roast a marshmallow or two, listen to the waves and maybe a guitar then lay 

back and check out the stars.  Please you've got better things to worry about than adding yet another regulation to our already over regulated 

lives.    

Jeffrey Stevens SAN CLEMENTE CA 92672 United States 3/16/2012

Fires at the beach are a big part of California culture. Many commercials that encourage California tourism have people at beach bonfires. Imagine 

the frustration of a family visiting Newport Beach only to discover that the "beach fire" moment they were shown was only fiction.

Cindy Cowlin Mission Viejo CA 92691 United States 3/16/2012

We love having family BBQ's/bonfires at the beach. Play all day in the sun, sand, water, then enjoy a nice fire with some hotdogs and s'mores at 

night. We'd really miss the fire pits.

Patrick Murphy Richardson TX 75080 United States 3/16/2012 Grew up using the rings please do not take something away from my children's future

Jeanette Fisher Fullerton CA 92831 United States 3/16/2012 I've enjoyed the fire rings for over 50 years. Lived in Newport for 18. My husband grew up in Newport.  My children were born there.

Deegie  Phelps Tustin CA 92780 United States 3/16/2012

A family tradition when so many have gone by the wayside. We, our children, and now our grandchildren have enjoyed the bond developed as 

each generation passes the tradition on to the next. There is something magical about a family or group gathered around a beach fire. This is a 

special southern California experience. Please allow the present and future generations to experience the magic.

Susan DiFlorio Anaheim CA 92804 United States 3/16/2012 I love having a bonfire.

paul savage diamond springs CA 95619 United States 3/16/2012 why outlaw such a great and grand tradition that helps keep the beach clean and safer.  Folks are still gonna have fires no matter what.

Bernice Gross berkeley CA 94703 United States 3/16/2012

i love going this beach daytime and evening and have such a fun and safe time with family and friends. the fire pits bring a special environment to 

the evening that would be impossible to replace.

Pamela Saxton Turlock CA 95380 United States 3/16/2012

Fire pits are essential to CA life.  I grew up in So Cal and there is nothing like having friends and family gather around the fire pit. Don't let the drug 

and gangs run the show.  That stuff is everywhere!  What are we going to  do close everything because of fear?  There is nothing like being on the 

beach around a fire that has a calming affect.  I can only guess that you have not experienced that.  As for parking Hello go anywhere can you park 

conveniently? (I don't think so)  

Lisa Marie Murtagh Rancho Cordova CA 95742 United States 3/16/2012

I grew up with these fire rings, this is one of the best parts about the beach.  The memories I have with family and friends is priceless!  Do not 

deprive future generations of this!

peter sellas Kilauea HI 96754 United States 3/16/2012

We grew up in Newport Beach huddled around the fire rings in the winter at the beach. It is a gathering place for friends and family to sit around 

and talk story and laugh and bond. Those are some of the fondest memories of my youth. Why take that away? I'm all for keeping the fire rings for 

future generations to enjoy.

E D Batavia IL 60510 United States 3/16/2012

These are enjoyable social gathering places that provide no hazard to responsible people. Why remove them? These ARE a part of the California 

culture and I've enjoyed them when I lived there.

andrea Rodriguez Santa Barbara CA 93107 United States 3/16/2012 because we need fire pits!

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 180: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

John Sparre Charlotte NC 28277 United States 3/16/2012

These fire rings are an area tradition for many families who grew up in Balboa.  I travel home each Summer to be with family, and the fire rings are 

a natural part of our trips.  As an avid surfer, NHHS grad, and Eagle Scout in my youth, I'm very environmental aware of the impact of these rings.  

It's minimal in my opinion. One more step by NB City Council to ruin a once great area, tourist attraction and revenue generator to local businesses. 

Joelle Escoe Orange CA 92866 United States 3/16/2012

I have so many memories at these beach having a campfire. I want my daughter to experience the same thing

Anita Delgado Lake Elsinore CA 92530 United States 3/16/2012

My fondest memory is those spent at a fire enjoying the sunset at the beach, The awesome time spending with friends. I even took my Girl scouts 

to the beach where we tought them fire safety and how to start a fire. Dont take away the chance for our  children to experience the beach the 

way we loved for many ways. 

Albert Mosley Corona CA 92882 United States 3/16/2012

I understand that the homeowners are tired of the little folks using "their" beach. The exorbitant price of your home doesn't mean you get the 

place all to yourselves. 

Cheryl Paulson Corona CA 92879 United States 3/16/2012 This is one of the 'few' places families and teens can go to get out of the house to have quality time together, fun in the sun, at a reasonable price. 

Michele Thiel Orange CA 92869 United States 3/16/2012 Firepits at the beach have been a family tradition for decades. It is just down right WRONG to take these out. Please don't do it.

Sherry Sumner Newport Beach CA 92662 United States 3/16/2012

These firepits are part of our culture and history In Newport Beach. I have fond memories as a child and adult enjoying at the beach fire pits.  

Please do not remove our ability to enjoy the beach at night. Thanks for your consideration. :)

Linda Swartz Orange CA 92866 United States 3/16/2012

Taking away access to this long‐held tradition in Orange County is wrong.  Obvious they're trying to reduce use for middle class citizens to enhance 

high‐income homeowners in the area. Keep our beaches available for public use. Protect Or.Co. for our family activities. 

Douglas Reid Tustin CA 92780 United States 3/16/2012

I have grown up having beach bonfires in the evenings with my friends, church, and family.  I want my kids to have this same experience.  I think 

that this is a part of the OC beach experience that cannot and should not be extinguished.

Shawn Millbern Trabuco Canyon CA 92679 United States 3/16/2012 Fire rings are a Southern California tradition that encourages family experiences and coastal access.

anna leyenaar mission viejo CA 92691 United States 3/16/2012 This is part of the california culture....people need places to be ble to relax and have free time. It would be criminal to remove this freedom. 

Brandon Marshall Sacramento CA 95826 United States 3/16/2012

I'm from Newport and these fire rings are all part of SoCal. This really is a part of the surfer heritage.

If in fact there is gang and drug activity removing the fire rings wont get rid of them, actually I think it will increase it bc it shows the city council 

doesn't care about the citizens so I think it will drive kids to say, "fu** the man and Ill burn this place down since I don't have a designated place to 

do it."

This is ignorant of the city council.

christine limon claremont CA 91711 United States 3/16/2012 I grew up using these fire rings and even in my 50's I still enjoy.  It is a simple pleasure! Please rethink their removal.

Kylen Sharpe Nashville 37212 United Arab Emira 3/16/2012

Balboa is my home and so are these firepits.  Continuing to discourage people traveling to the peninsula continues to put hard working people out 

of business and turn our once thriving town into something I hardly recognize.  We can't lose the merry‐go‐round and the firepits in the same year. 

Leslie Dean Irvine CA 92603 United States 3/16/2012

We lived in Newport Beach for 30 years and the I can't remember the fire rings being any problem.  They are part of Newport Beach and what 

makes summer fun!  Quit trying to run everybody's life for them and leave the fire rings alone ‐ my god the water is way more dangerous are you 

going to take that away too?

Jeff Jensen Irvine CA 92606 United States 3/16/2012 Want to keep the fire pits, they are a great family activity resource

Dana Leavitt Highland UT 84003 United States 3/16/2012 The beach is the one place where things don't change much!  Save our piece of history and happy memories!

Christine Broaddus Corona del Mar CA 92625 United States 3/16/2012

The fire pits were there when the people complaining moved in!!!!!  They are used by too many people to remove them for a few.

IT IS A STATE BEACH!

Keryn Douglass Mission Viejo CA 92691 United States 3/16/2012 It is a wonderful tradition over the summer to gather around the fire pit... would be totally tragic to remove these!

Jan Balas Costa Mesa CA 92627 United States 3/16/2012 What will are children think of us?

Sheri Bright Santa Rosa CA 95409 United States 3/16/2012 Grew up with camp fires on CDM and I would like to be able to take my son to enjoy what I did as a kid!

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 181: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Amy Croushore Claremont CA 91711 United States 3/16/2012

i have been enjoying the fire pits since 1967, and i have never encountered any unsavory activity. please let the fire pits remain. it is a great 

attraction to be able to stay and bbq or just enjoy time with friend and family. i believe that the 10 PM closing helps keep the undesireables away. i 

have been at the beach for a month every year, and i am saddened that the fun zone is no longer available. please save the fire pits, so that the 

generations of families to come can enjoy great memories at Newport Beach. I worry that if the pits are removed that the beach will simply 

become a free‐for‐all in the evenings. 

Hillary Jones orange CA 92867 United States 3/16/2012 there is no point in moving them. serves as memories, lost cost fun, tradition, and a plain old good time. that's what makes SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA

RHONDA HAMMERMRANCHO MIRAGE CA 92270 United States 3/16/2012

THE FIRE PITS ARE AN OLD FAMILY/FRIENDS TRADITION.  MANY AN HOUR HAS BEEN SPENT COOKING DINNER, ETC.  IT HAS ALWAYS BEEN CLEAN 

FUN ENJOYED BY MANY GENERATIONS.  WHAT A SHAME TO STOP THIS NOW.

Scott Schorling Laguna Beach CA 90803 United States 3/16/2012

In the past 2 years, LA has banned frisbees and footballs, Laguna banned fishing, now Newport is banning fire pits!! All in the name of the 

"environment and personal safety" So long, "the land of the FREE and the home of the BRAVE" we are now the land of the RESTRICTED, the FAT 

and the STUPID...

Phillips Lacy Lubbock TX 79424 United States 3/16/2012

Igrew up in Newport Beach in the 1950's and had many great family beach cookouts at Big Corona, and also on the Balboa/Newport side of the 

jetty.

Don  Prindle yorba linda CA 92886 United States 3/16/2012 To STOP the removal of the fire rings.

Andrea Ward Orange CA 92869 United States 3/16/2012

I enjoy the firepits as an inexpensive family activity, and also splurge on the local businesses while we're there.  I would really oppose removing the 

firerings from the beach.  Thank you for your time.

Theo Luthin Santa Rosa CA 95404 United States 3/16/2012

We visit family in Southern California often and having a fire on the beach is always one of the highlights of our trips.  It's a beach tradition and an 

experience that is unique and very valuable to the area.  How many fantastic, memorable and low cost family experiences are left in Southern 

California?

Margaret Heuner Newport Beach CA 92663 United States 3/16/2012 Families should be able to have picnics on the beach in the summer.

Steve Gibson Riverside CA 92508 United States 3/16/2012

Beachside camp fires are a tradition for many friends, families, and groups, as well as part of the culture of Southern California.  I have been going 

to the Balboa fire pits for years.  I struggle to see what benefit or reason there is for removing the fire pits.  Removing the fire pits would be a huge 

loss for California.

Catalina Chabot moreno valley CA 92551 United States 3/16/2012 Because this is a part of the beach environment, leave it be!

Anita Shanahan Claremont CA 91711 United States 3/16/2012 Grew up enjoying the fire pit as did my children.

Cora Judd Irvine CA 92604 United States 3/16/2012 We LOVE the fire pits!!

Mark Nass Poulsbo WA 98370 United States 3/15/2012

This has been a tradition for generations of my family. I am saddened that future youth and families might miss out on this memorable activity that  

is part of growing up here and our local culture.  What is next?  Should we ban Boogie Boarding because it draws unsupervised long haired youth to 

the shoreline?  Let's ban flip flops on the beach, because when you loose one they don't bio‐degrade.  City governments need to get a grip and 

spend their time on job creation and economic development, not restricting use of our beaches. 

Kristin Fogg Riverside CA 92503 United States 3/15/2012

We have our daughter's birthday at Corona Del Mar every year and family has said that we should continue the tradition even when she's too old 

to want to celebrate with us.  It's sad that this is going to be her 16th and maybe the last beachy birthday we have for her and the tradition dies.

Danielle Davis San Clemente CA 92673 United States 3/15/2012 To save this part of California's history that we all love.

Jennifer Gonzalez Santa Ana CA 92704 United States 3/15/2012

there are less strict measure that can be taken to reduce the environmental element in this matter. people will gather with the intentions of crime 

no matter if there is a fire pit or not.  Fire is dangerous and has been since its discovery.  

Put the responsibility on the individuals and do not punish or jump to removal simply because it's a quick fix funded by the rich private citizens.  

Residents chose to live at a public beach with the understanding of what a public beach is.  Smoke, sand, dirt, people.  don't take away the beach 

from the citizens who love and appreciate it.  Take away the crime and add preventative measures.  This is not a fix but a bandaid and a distancing 

measure.  

dennis vadura trabuco canyon CA 92679 United States 3/15/2012

we enjoy the fire pits at least 6‐8 times per year. This is  a shame.  Also the pits are the ONLY reason we go to the beach, without it the merchants 

at the beach will not get our business.

Marco Garcia Rancho Santa Margarita CA 92688 United States 3/15/2012 I use the fire pits very often and would hate to see them go.

Jennifer Peterson Burbank CA 91505 United States 3/15/2012 Because we enjoy using these.

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 182: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Dave Snyder irvine CA 92604 United States 3/15/2012 WHAT THE HELL IS WRONG WITH YOU? Don't remove the pits!

Mandy McMahan Reston VA 20191 United States 3/15/2012 I use to live there and the fire rings were amazing and added an attraction to spend time at these beaches other than just the sand and water. 

Diana Relth La Habra Heights CA 90631 United States 3/15/2012 There are better options to maintain safety and reduce smoke‐related illness than removing the fire pits completely.

Christine Robertson Tustin CA 92780 United States 3/15/2012 I do not want these fire rings removed from Big Corona!

Sean Ogle Brea CA 92821 United States 3/15/2012

I have spent many birthdays with friends and family around these fire rings. They are some of my finding memories. To deprive anyone of that 

same joy would be a great injustice. Keep the fires burning.

Shannon Pooler Fullerton CA 92831 United States 3/15/2012

Bonfires in the pits on summer nights are what make Southern California...It brings people together in ways unique to California. Many a nights 

have been spent around a bonfire in Newport for everything from church gatherings to birthdays to nights where you just need to escape reality. 

It's bonfires are what make the beach experience! Please do not remove them...it would be a travesty. 

darek swiatkowski mission viejo CA 92692 United States 3/15/2012 Love bone fire at beach , great time no crime 

Wendy Wehofer Tustin CA 92780 United States 3/15/2012 Because this is over the top and wrong!!

Blake Butler Irvine CA 92606 United States 3/15/2012 I believe in keeping the fire rings and to continue to keep our beaches clean.

Rick Allen Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/15/2012 The fire rings are of great value to CDM's culture and history, and s good way for families to bond and enjoy the beach, whether local or visiting.

Madison Turner Newport Coast CA 92657 United States 3/15/2012

I have so many family memories from the fire pits, and I would like to make more with my children in the future. The fire pits should not be taken 

out!

Susan Darnell‐ComettLondon WC1N 2NTUnited Kingdom 3/15/2012

The fire rings have always been a part of life in CdM. They have been used and enjoyed by the residents of all ages, I grew up in CdM and am 

planning to move back there in the near future. It makes me sad that my daughter won't be able to enjoy family bar‐b‐q s at the fire rings the way I 

did. My family's house is on Heliotrope, right up from the fire rings and they have never bothered us. I think the people who are complaining about 

them should sell their houses and move inland where the smell of beach cook‐outs will not bother them.

Susie Hughes San Juan Capistrano CA 92675 United States 3/15/2012 Because I grew up in Newport...many fires at Corona with MANY fond memories!!

Kristin Ruck Santa Ana CA 92704 United States 3/15/2012 The city council is micro‐managing every aspect of neighborhood life‐‐and it needs to stop!

Jamie Dow Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/15/2012

This idea is absurd.  The reasons given were that it's better for air quality (in which case, ban gasoline vehicles, barbeques and fireplaces as well) 

and it will stop gang activity (which is not only untrue, but also wouldn't it be better to keep gangs in a centralized well‐lit area than all around the 

city and a dark beach?).  These are obviously nonsense reasons, and the fire pits, which are a tradition and bring money to the city, should stay.  It's 

an anti‐business move, as many small businesses already have a hard time surviving with the anti‐tourist stance the city has.  That beach belongs to 

everyone in the state, not just the citizens of Newport Beach, and a few old wealthy citizens should not be able to take away the small amount of 

low‐cost fun which is left in our fair city.

Elizabeth Creely San Francisco      94110 United States 3/15/2012 What the hell? This is my childhood and one of the few things left my Newport Beach that still speak to the small hometown it was! Stop!

susan graham Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/15/2012

The fire pits in Newport have been an integral part of Big Corona and Newport Beach.  The people who moved to the beaches were well aware of 

these when they chose to move there.  In addition, this is really a movement by the homeowner's to exclude people the homeowner's deem 

unworthy from the beaches.  I want to keep the beaches open to everyone ‐ and the fire pits are a key part of that.

Kevin Folino Cottonwood CA 96022 United States 3/15/2012

I grew up in Southern California, and having fires on the beach with good friends was always a great way to spend an day/evening at the beach!  As 

a returning Southern Californian, it would be heartbreaking to have such  memorable part of my life removed because of an unfortunate event. 

Please, reconsider the removal of the fire pits.

Thank you.

Matthew Shapiro Corona del Mar CA 92625 United States 3/15/2012

The fire rings at these beaches were an enormous part of my childhood and I want future generations to be able to enjoy the beach as much as I 

did. 

Charmaine Rosa Costa Mesa CA 92627 United States 3/15/2012 I grew up in CDM!!!!!

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 183: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Neil Horlock Broken Arrow OK 74012 United States 3/15/2012

Three small reasons to keep the pits: First, as a former surfer of Southern California beaches, I remember fondly seeing and being part of fires on 

the beach. It is part of the coastal cultural tradition. Secondly, pulling the pits simply removes another avenue of enjoyment on a list of things to do 

for those who come to the coast. Some people specifically come just for the benefit of having a fire at the beach. What better way to warm 

yourself up after an evening dip in the Pacific! Lastly,  Local merchants would loose that revenue they presently enjoy due to the sales of hot 

chocolate, Hershey bars, marshmellows, graham crackers, hot dogs and fixings, cokes, and fire wood. Please don't pull the pits...I would like to 

bring my grandkids out to California sometime in the next couple of years and be able to go to the beach and have a fire!

adam rittmiller merced CA 95348 United States 3/15/2012

Since I was a small boy in elementary school, there have been memories formed at the fire pits on Big Corona.

Such fond memories and now my friends and I, now entering our 30s, are looking at the first summer in literally as far back as we can remember 

where we may not be able to have our annual reunion and gathering of friends and families. 

Shame on you.

Gabriel Pettinicchio Fullerton CA 92832 United States 3/15/2012

Everything is being taken away from us.  These ridiculous lawsuits must be stopped, before we become imprisoned in our own homes.  We want 

the "Nannies, to leave and take care of their own families, NOT MINE!

Alysha Dameshek Laguna Beach CA 92651 United States 3/15/2012

I grew up with Bon Fires.  I feel that we handle them safely.  Why should we lose something that has and continues to make amazing memories for 

so many people. If you take the pits away people are going to start their own fires and make their own pits and it is not going to be good.   I assure 

you.  

Susy Herbert Fullerton CA 92832 United States 3/15/2012

I grew up in Corona Del Mar, and those fire rings were very much apart of my memories at the beach!  Don't understand why they want to remove 

them!

Jenson Crawford Culver City CA 90230 United States 3/15/2012

The firepits are part of what makes these beaches special.  We bring our son and his cub scout pack down to enjoy an evening fire on the beach the 

way that we did as when we were young.

MARK SIMON CORONA DEL MAR CA 92625 United States 3/15/2012

The fire rings are an essential part of southern California beach culture. They offer low cost enjoyment for families. They stand for a tradition that 

all southern California residents can enjoy and should have the chance to experience with their families for years to come

kristen molinari corona del mar CA 92625 United States 3/15/2012

You MUST KEEP THE FIRE RINGS!!!  They are a staple and have, for years, provided cherished memories for 1000's of families over the years!!  Both 

my kids always had their Bday parties at the rings... COME ON!! 

Hilary WHITE Costa Mesa CA 92627 United States 3/15/2012 Because I grew up at Big Corona! We have REAL problems in this world and the Firepits are not one of them.  INSANITY!! 

Keith Holland Costa Mesa CA 92627 United States 3/15/2012

The fire pits gives people a place to go in the evening and relax with friends, taking them away will push locals in the southern california area away 

forcing them to drive even further to have a mellow night out

Nathan Lozano Anaheim CA 92807 United States 3/15/2012 I'm paying taxes, I want them to go to that.

Dianne Wen Orange CA 92867 United States 3/15/2012

Without the bonfire pits I will have no reason to go to the beach.  I dislike sand and saltwater, but I go to roast marshmellows and hang out with 

my friends.

Heather Oglesby Irvine CA 92620 United States 3/15/2012 I grew up in H.B. and the firepits are supposed to be there, they are part of the beach. The smell is the best part.

Duane Downs Murrieta CA 92562 United States 3/15/2012

I've been using these fire pits for years. It's been an exciting place for my family to spend a hot summer night sitting around a fire pit roastng hot 

dogs and marshmellows. It's like the people that buy homes next to an airport and don't hear the airplanes untill after thy move in. KEEP! the fire 

pits.

Emily Novelo Costa Mesa CA 92626 United States 3/15/2012

These fire pits are the main reason why I choose Big Corona and Balboa beaches. They hold so many memories from family bonfires, ones with 

friends during high school, and a place to reconnect after we had all gone off to college and such. Now having a child of my own I have looked 

forward to his bonfire birthday parties and seeing him create his own special beach memories in the same place I did.

Nancy Shoemate Santa Ana CA 92705 United States 3/15/2012

I was born and raised in Corona del Mar.  A bonfire at the beach was so much a part of my youth.  I am almost 60 now and hope that younger 

families and teenagers can retain the same access to the fun of sitting around the fire with friends and family that I had.

Jennifer Partlow BEACON NY 12508 United States 3/15/2012 The fire pits were a fantastic part of my college experience ‐‐ don't take that away from others!

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 184: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Charles Bing Palm Desert CA 92211 United States 3/15/2012 I grew up in CdM and we'd spend hours at the beach using the fire rings for warmth, gatherings and just plain fun !!  Don't ruin "OUR" beaches !!

celeste atkins Orange CA 92867 United States 3/15/2012

I have grown up with these fire pits and have had MANY family events and memories happen here. It would be so tragic to lose such memories and 

to ruin the possibility of new memories being created. 

Colleen Kearfott Newport Beach. CA 92661 United States 3/15/2012

I am an owner here at Oceanfront and enjoy the fire pits that are literally right outside my home. I will be very upset when they remove them and 

hope that they dont. I have lived here for over 3 years and do not have one complaint to make. And I also have two young children and do not fear 

their safety. 

aaron zide Newport Beach CA 92663 United States 3/15/2012

I lived in NB/CM?HB all my life and it would be a tragedy if these went away. These are a staple of the city culture and the ability to provide fun, 

free, outdoor social scene that should be passed down for generations. Don't take these away because of a few bad apples. I sick of new money 

ruining and lawyers taking away the very essence of our cities.

beth Kiley Corona Del mar CA 92625 United States 3/15/2012 I live in the area and we use the fire pits often.They are a postive place for teenagers and adults.  Please Keep Them. B. Kiley

Linda Lagasse Trabuco Canyon CA 92679 United States 3/15/2012

Because i love fire pits and they shouldn't be removed for the reasons listed,.  We have all grown up with fire pits and I'm alive and healthy.  Don't 

let a few bad apples and grumpy rich people enjoy the fire pits.

Carrie Graber South Pasadena CA 91030 United States 3/15/2012

I strongly reject this. Yet another summer‐spoiling, nanny‐inflicting, freedom‐usurping reason to not love my home state of California. I guarantee 

I've been enjoying this right longer than any city council members have been sitting. Don't eliminate a revenue generating, culturally significant 

resource.

Adam Forni Newport Beach CA 92661 United States 3/15/2012 I am a resident.  I have lived 8 blocks from these pits for five years.  Please keep them!

Tracy Cervellone Lake Forest CA 92630 United States 3/15/2012 Get the government OUT of our daily lives. Geez. Having any fun at all will soon be illegal. 

Kristina Olah Newport Beach CA 92663 United States 3/15/2012 Too much history and enjoyment for families has been taken away all for the sake of $$, we pay a good deal of taxes where does it go?

Tammi Cluck newport beach 92663 United States Min 3/15/2012

keep all or hald of the firepits. You dont ban all at onve!!!

Jennifer Hardy Pine River MN 56474 United States 3/15/2012 I lived in Newport forever! This is a dumb ideal... Always happy people there. Good grief!

Dana Glover Kingman AZ 86401 United States 3/15/2012 I grew up there and had so much fun on the beach.  Many campfires and cookouts

Melanie Wong Hacienda Heights CA 91745 United States 3/15/2012 I think fire pits are a major attraction for beach goers too. 

Adam Stapish Rancho Santa Margarita CA 92688 United States 3/15/2012 stop taking everything fun away California!

Richard Gibson Long Beach CA 90803 United States 3/15/2012 I use those fire rings at Newport nearly every summer! Are you seriously taking them away?

Allison Lusk‐MauvezinSan Clemente CA 92673 United States 3/15/2012

I grew up in Newport Beach and the fire pits are part of the beach experience. Learning to build a fire in Girl Scouts, family reunions, inexpensive 

"vacation days," are all on the list of good reasons to keep the fire pits. If The Coastal Commission practices what they preach and truly wants to 

maximize public recreational opportunities and access for everyone, then I hope they will deny the permit. 

tom walker costa mesa CA 92627 United States 3/15/2012 they have been there sense i was a kid and i want my kids to enjoy them also. We alway go down and do mashmellows, my daughter loves them

ashley bernel newport beach CA 92663 United States 3/15/2012

Fire pits offer a safe way for people to enjoy fires on the beach.  Taking them away would only cause people to try and find their own ways to have 

bon fires and could lead to destruction of the beaches.

Geoffrey Simmon Newport Coast CA 92657 United States 3/15/2012

The fire‐pits have been a fun public resource that has enriched the community. I have enjoyed many a fine BBQ at them, especially back during my 

high school years. I think it is a shame that something with such popular support is going to be removed. Nancy Gardner has been trying to do this 

for years but each time there has been a popular outcry. It looks like City Council finally were ably to quietly push this through. The excuses that 

city council uses, "for safety reasons" is a flimsy justification that has no real evidence to support it. The real reason why City Council does it is 

because they are insular cronies who want to transform public space into private space. They are more concerned about the privileges of the few 

over the public interest.  I believe they would make it a private beach if they could. It is a shame that they are that  are doing this when they should 

be working to serve the public. Let's not lose a piece of Newport Beach tradion,  Let us keep our fire‐pits.

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 185: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Alec Torelli Irvine 92614 United States Min 3/15/2012

Good job David. I'll do what I can to help spread the word on this. 

For years Orange County has been able to enjoy bonfires on the beach. It's so much a part of our culture that it's featured in movies and TV shows. 

Let's keep this tradition alive for our children to enjoy. 

Ted Bell El Cajon CA 92021 United States 3/15/2012

Lots of people enjoy the beach and fire pits responsibly.  It's not like local residents purchased beachfront property under duress and without 

knowing or being able to understand that fire pits nearby might..  heaven forbid... smell.. like SMOKE.  This is an unreasinable attack against people 

who go to the beach for a low cost, and simple pleasure.   How did this become worthy of attention, much less action?

Someone should also mention to them that if they don't want to live near headshops, strip clubs, adult stores or other socially questionable places, 

buy property far, far away from such establishments.

In the near future, I guess I'll go to a small beach town that doesn't have such uppity, boorish and snobbish locals whose sole gripe seems to be 

that less fortunate people who aren't able to afford beach property come to the beach, free of charge, and enjoy themselves.  Oh, the humanity!

Susan Jackson Westminster CA 92683 United States 3/15/2012 Freedom

David Goldstein Seattle WA 98117‐500United States 3/15/2012 When I was a teenager in OC, this spot was my hangout.  Please leave a gathering place for decent teens!  Beach beats streets.

Sharon McAleer Orange CA 92869 United States 3/15/2012 Save one of the greatest parts of summer nights at the beach!

ROBERT  COURY NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660 United States 3/15/2012

We have loved and enjoyed the beach fire pits for years.  I'm sure these feelings are shared by literally thousands of californians, including many, 

many locals.  LEAVE IT ALONE !!

Janice  McKinnon Temple City CA 91780 United States 3/15/2012 Pit fires on the beach are a part of living in California that affords fun for all  ages especially extended families.  DON'T TAKE THIS AWAY FROM US.

Ruth  Steinhart Glendale CA 91205 United States 3/15/2012

 The ritual of gathering around a camp fire goes back hundreds of thousands of years.  It still is an important way for humans to connect with one 

another and commune with nature.  Without the fire pits, sharing stories, singing and playing guitar, and telling jokes just won't be the same. The 

beach belongs to all of us.  Please do not allow the wealthy residents of Newport Beach to take this integral part of the beach experience away 

from the public.   

Jordan Reynolds Villa Park CA 92861 United States 3/15/2012 Yet another freedom a small group of "do gooders" are stripping away from the general public.  Utter Bullshit.

Laura Mohr Aliso Viejo CA 92656 United States 3/15/2012

I grew up in Corona del Mar! The fire rings are a landmark and great place for family and friends to get together and celebrate an iconic American 

tradition... roasting hot dogs and marshmallows around the fire pit at the beach!!!!

Tom McKnight Costa Mesa CA 92628 United States 3/15/2012 This is enjoyment and a tradition of many families along our coast.

wendy walder cherry valley CA 92223 United States 3/15/2012 Use the fire pits every summer while staying in corona del mar

Gang Banger Santa Ana CA 92701 United States 3/15/2012 i like to sell drugs there

chris swingen santa ana CA 92704 United States 3/15/2012

I grew up at the beach and remember the good times at the fire pits. No one wants to see anyone get hurt, much less a child because of the pits. 

Parents need to be more responsible when their children are on the beach. I understand that a lot of them need repairs, so if possible, repair them. 

Everyone needs to assume that they are a danger and be cautious and educate their kids as well. We can't take away everything that might be a 

danger as we would not have anything.

Wendy Danbury Orange CA 92867 United States 3/15/2012

26 years ago, my husband proposed to me by one of these historic fire rings. Years later, my sons celebrated their first 20‐mile hike with their 

fellow Boy Scouts around aonther fire ring. These are just two of countless memories from good times around the fire rings, laughing, singing, 

eating, and sharing with friends and family. Please don't remove them; I hope to cook hot dogs with grandchildren one day and teach them how to 

make s'mores.

Julia Schmidt Orange CA 92865 United States 3/15/2012

I grew up at the beaches along the California coast line. Bonfires are a huge part of that. Please don't remove the fire pits. They are a wonderful 

memory to my friends and I.

Dan Curran Corona Del Mar CA 92625 United States 3/15/2012

I grew up going to those beaches.  Some of my earliest memories are at the fire pits.  I haven't heard of any reason why they're being removed, but 

wondered if some of them may be able to stay.  It's already $15 to park at Corona Del Mar beach.  Even if a small fee is charged, that would be 

better than taking them out completely.

Lacy Jones Orange CA 92869 United States 3/15/2012 i believe  in this right! 

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 186: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Jeffrey Manzer Lake Forest CA 92630 United States 3/15/2012

The fire rings throughout Orange County's coastal beaches are an essential part of our community, and have been a part of my family's fondest 

reunions and experiences for generations.  I too hope I will be able to continue this tradition of marshmallow roasts and beach cookouts whilst 

watching the sunset, after a day of enjoying the Pacific.  Work to ensure safety measures, if this is an issue ‐ but please, do NOT eliminate the 

opportunity to enjoy our coast to the best of our abilities.

Sarah Smith New Providence NJ 7974 United States 3/15/2012

You can't punish everyone for the lack of responsibility of the few. It isn't the fire pits' fault that a few people can't use common sense around 

them. 

Susie Wren Fullerton CA 92831 United States 3/15/2012

As a teen, two things kept me out of trouble on the weekends ‐ beach BBQs and the Fun Zone.  We went almost every weekend.  One is already 

gone.....  

David Glenn El Paso TX 79936 United States 3/15/2012

I grew up there‐ I've been a Soldier now for 25 years, but I still consider Newport "Home". Those fire rings need to be there for me to take my 

grandkids to them.

John Lusk Mission Viejo CA 92692 United States 3/15/2012

The only people getting hurt by these are the ones lacking common sense.  The fire rings today are 200% safer than what we had available 40 years 

ago. 

Pamela  Jacobs Newport Beach CA 92661 United States 3/15/2012 Save the fire pits in Balboa and Corona Del Mar

Joy Millam Fountain Valley CA 92708 United States 3/15/2012

Fire rings are a wonderful tradition that needs to continue. They bring families and strangers together. It is unique to our area and should continue 

to further this wonderful beach cultural treasure. It is a wonderful tradition that brings us all together. I've never had a bad experience near the 

rings, nor have I seen any crime, fights, or drugs. What I have seen are people who come together ‐‐ friends and strangers. I've shared my ring with 

others and been fortunate enough to have it reciprocated. Please stop the removal. 

joshua malouf santa barabara CA 93101 United States 3/15/2012 I grew up with those fire pits..

Jim Moloney Newport Beach CA 92662 United States 3/15/2012

The fire pits are a piece of history and part of Newport Beach in the summertime.  It's fine to regulate their use (i.e., permit fires only during certain 

hours, and limit what can be burned in the basins), but they should NOT be banned altogether.  Stop the City and State from regulating us to death. 

Leave the fire pits in place!  Thank you.  Jim M.

Nicholas Bowden Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/15/2012

I am signing this because of the countless priceless memories I've had at Big Corona around the firepits. They are a deep part of the love and 

adoration I have for Big C and Balboa

Tina Hoffman Balboa Newport Beach CA 92661 United States 3/15/2012

As a mother of 4th generation Newport BEACH natives, our entire family continues to be in horrified disbelief to have already lost too much 

significant Newport BEACH history and opportunities for our descendants to experience any nostalgic family FUN to create their own cherished 

memories de javu removal of The Balboa Carouselle,  Scary Dark Ride, Spinning Tin Soldiers, FUN zone  Rock climbing, Historic Balboa Market, 100 

yr old gorgeous plush trees previously beautifying Historic Balboa Main Street, Parkers Seafood/Emerald Forest restaurant concert venue, The 

Historic Balboa Theatre, 1940s Bubbles  restaurant concert venue, The Historic Bank of America  A+ restaurant concert venue, The historic Reuben 

E Lee Riverboat restaurant concert venue, and FUN in the FUN zone replaced by a so called museum with a history of removing history instead of 

preserving opportunities for future generations to enJOY and appreciate it...BEACH residents, merchants and visitors whose unfortunate health 

and/or finances are negatively affected by BEACH activity including  water, sand, bonfires, music and laughter aka FUN should be moved 

elsewhere. End of story.

Courtney Rotondo Irvine CA 92604 United States 3/15/2012

SO MANY PEOPLE USE FIRE PITS ALL THE TIME! People will just start having random fires on the beach if they take the pits out. The fire pits are a 

part of the beach that people of every age love, and it would be idiotic to get rid of things that are used by EVERYONE.

Linsey Carbone Balboa Island CA 92662 United States 3/15/2012 The fire pits are one of the best things about SoCal beaches. Banning them destroys a precious part of our local culture!

Cheryl Gonzalez Running Springs CA 92382 United States 3/15/2012

Fire rings are great family fun! Don't take them away!! We would drive from the mountains to beach and not come home till our fire ring ritual 

ended the day!! We are running out of healthy fun for our loved ones...enough with the ridiculous restrictions already!

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 187: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Timorei Andraos Irvine CA 92606 United States 3/15/2012

There are few nighttime activities in Orange County for the under 21 age group that are cheap and fun. Besides spending another evening watching 

TV and playing video games on the couch at home‐‐which can only to the obesity epidemic‐‐ the bonfire pits have provided a fun, cost‐effective 

means of entertainment for not only an age group stuck in an awkward limbo between being too young for some things and too old for others, but 

also as a place for friends and families to hang out and enjoy each other's company by way of a truly authentic southern California past time.

Rachel Lomeli Corona CA 92882 United States 3/15/2012 Our family loves to enjoy a beach bonfire or two each summer.  They are already almost impossible to get.  Please do not remove any more.

garrett peterson costa mesa CA 92627 United States 3/15/2012

I am signing this because i find it unsound that such a decision can be made by a group of seven people (despite their power as elected officials) i 

believe that this decision, which took 30 seconds after an hour of protest, was made before the representitives had heard any information from 

the people. this type of representation is not the type that the city should be proud of. In this type of action the newport mesa district has created 

a haven for drugs and subversive cultures. Over the years i have seen the skating rink removed, kona lanes taken out, the removal of the fire pits 

would be one among many things that has been taken away from the youth to enjoy. This town is starting to become a place where you must be an 

adult (or age appropriate representation of one) or face challenges in finding cheap and safe entertainment. 

Marian Clark Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/15/2012

I've spent countless nights with my family at those fire pits for more than 25 years. They're a cherished family tradition. As a Newport Beach 

resident, I'm dismayed they are being removed.

Laura Clayton  Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/15/2012 So many of my memories from growing up with my family in Newport are around those fire pits. Please don't take them away!!

Alyssa Ocampo San Francisco CA 94132 United States 3/15/2012

This has been one of my past times for as long as i can remember. Having the fire pits there are a huge part of the southern california culture. 

There aren't many people who have them and when i bring friends from out of town they are amazed we have this. The fire rings are truly 

beautiful. I usd to live a half hour away from the beach and when we go, its an all day trip. I shop at all the local places for food and wood and 

business will suffer if they are closed down. I know live in San Francisco and everytime i go visit SoCal, the fire rings are something i look most 

forward to. Lets save the fire rings. 

Tom Nguyen Irvine CA 92604 United States 3/15/2012

I am a surf instructor in Newport Beach and I think this is an elitist decision that ostracizes people instead of welcoming them to our beautiful city 

and beaches. 

Brittany Phillips Balboa CA 92661 United States 3/15/2012

i have lived on the balboa peninsula all my life for the 21 years i have been alive and these are MEMORIES... everything kills you theses days.. 

microwaves, cell phones, etc... whats some bonfire pits going to do to us.. pollute the air just a little more? KEEP THE PITS!

Leslie Cox Costa Mesa CA 92627 United States 3/15/2012

My family & I have enjoyed these fire pits for years, actually, for 4 generations. End of summer gatherings on Labor Day weekend by a cozy warm 

fire in Balboa, with family &  friends,  are some of my fondest memories. Please preserve this for future generations.

carol peck corona del mar CA 92625 United States 3/15/2012

As residents we LOVE fire rings.  The are a wonderful part of living in CDM/NB!!  We have enjoyed them as a family for years.  It is shocking that the 

city council would take it upon themselves to just remove them without polling residents to see what the majority sentiment is.  City council is 

supposed to be representing US.  This is awful and its sad.  

Lisa Clayton Newport Beach CA 92660 United States 3/15/2012

The fire rings are a wonderful tradition.  Our family has enjoyed them for 25 years.  The reasons given for taking them out don't outweight the 

reasons to keep them.  Don't be part of the nanny state‐‐‐allow us to take care of our safety while using them.

Mason Steel Driftwood TX 78619 United States 3/15/2012 Beach fires are a part of the CA lifestyle.  The pit out them in a controlled area and minmizes enviromental impact.

jesi  silveria irvine CA 92620 United States 3/15/2012 I LOVE ENJOYING THE FIRE PITS WITH FRIENDS & FAMILY... AND MORE COMFORT AT THE BEACH ON THE COOLER DAYS!!!!

Kim Tacheny Chino Hills CA 91709 United States 3/15/2012 I use those firepits with my family and friends.  We are OVER 40 and have a great time!  Don't take them away.

Monica Holbrook Costa Mesa CA 92626 United States 3/15/2012

This is a public space. It's ludicrous that a few overly rich, spoiled people feel they have a right to make the beach their private yard. It's akin to 

complaints about sea lions. Don't like it? Move to where you can build your own and gate it off. Get off the peninsula. 

Barbara Espinoza Costa Mesa CA 92627 United States 3/15/2012 I have lived in Southern California most of my life and the fire rings are a part of my childhood, present and future.

Vanessa Juteau Twin Peaks CA 92391 United States 3/15/2012

My grandmother has her birthday beach party at Big Corona every year. We make s'mores and hot dogs... please don't ruin another tradition with 

urbanization

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 188: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment

Matthew Stayner Los Angeles CA 90045 United States 3/15/2012

I have been going to Big Corona for 30 years, and one of the highlights are the nightly bonfires.  Our family used to live on Ocean Avenue above Big 

Corona, and having the extra beach traffic at night was never a problem.  There are only a handful of places to have bonfires on the beach left in 

California, so please preserve this important part of our historic culture.

Linda Baker Irvine CA 92604 United States 3/15/2012

These fire rings represent years of family reunions, places for young people to make memories and bond through music and nature and just plain 

amazing, down to earth fun and joy.  Don't let them go because of the irresponsible people who don't watch their children.

Brian Hoogerbrugge Irvine CA 92618 United States 3/15/2012

I have used these rings since I was a small boy, and plan to bring my own children to enjoy the wonderful experience of a beach bonfire.  I hate the 

knee jerk reaction of, "oh, 1 person got hurt; better ban it!" rather than finding creative solutions to life's problems.  This sort of thinking is carving 

away too many fun things in the name of "safety".

Ana Thompson North Tustin CA 92705 United States 3/15/2012

Newport Beach budget issues!?  Really?  Air Pollution!?  Really?

Tourism and family enjoyment...yes, REALLY!

Nick Askew Eugene OR 97402 United States 3/15/2012

I grew up in Orange County and CDM is always where we go with family when we come back to town. It's been a family and church tradition for as 

long as I can remember to gather around the fire pits, make smores, and have a good time.

Kali Kleinberg Orange CA 92867 United States 3/15/2012 Save the PITS!!!!!!!!!!!! I would not go to these beaches otherwise. 

Kyle McFarland newport beach CA 92660 United States 3/15/2012 These are the things that make the beach a great place to be

Grace Jasmine Gilbert AZ 85234 United States 3/15/2012 lifelong SoCal resident‐ spent many hours at THESE firepits having a blast. Find something better to do with taxpayers money!

Matthew  McArdle San Diego CA 92105 United States 3/15/2012 I grew up with those fire pits. It would be a shame to remove them.

Petition Signatures with Comments CDP# 5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 189: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Name City State Zip Code Country Signed OnDavid Ruiz 3/14/2012Lauren Smeekens Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/14/2012Emily Johnson Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/14/2012caitlin gomez costa mesa 92627 Uganda 3/14/2012Mike Ruiz Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/14/2012Matt Horovitz Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/14/2012Harry Oranges Napa California 94559 United States 3/14/2012Danielle Davis San Clemente California 92673 United States 3/14/2012stephanie smeekens San Francisco California 94118 United States 3/14/2012Kendall Hayward Irvine California 92604 United States 3/14/2012emily haglund Irvine California 92614 United States 3/14/2012Brandon Mahrt Santa Ana California 92704 United States 3/14/2012Michelle Aspis Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/14/2012Katie Meseck Irvine California 92603 United States 3/14/2012Jon Principe Tustin California 92782 United States 3/14/2012Ryan Kemp Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/14/2012Joshua Lewis San Diego California 92115 United States 3/14/2012Chris Conover Irvine California 92604 United States 3/14/2012Leonardo Cesareo San Francisco California 94107 United States 3/14/2012michael compass santa ana California 92707 United States 3/14/2012kent ma lake forest California 92630 United States 3/14/2012sarah bettencourt winchester California 92596 United States 3/14/2012Bruce Eckhaus Las Vegas Nevada 89141 United States 3/14/2012Jason Anthonisen Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/14/2012ryan Forman Irvine California 92606 United States 3/14/2012Jennifer Delany Irvine California 92614 United States 3/14/2012Joel Valentino Seattle Washington 98105 United States 3/14/2012Stacy Grigg Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 3/14/2012Carey Emery El Cajon California 92021 United States 3/14/2012Kameron Niksefat San Francisco California 94117 United States 3/14/2012Shannon Bieger Irvine California 92602 United States 3/14/2012Paulina Swiatkowski Mission Viejo California 92692 United States 3/14/2012Todd Snyder San Francisco California 94115 United States 3/14/2012James Ryan Irvine California 92604 United States 3/14/2012Pegah Asgari Irvine California 92612 United States 3/14/2012van stokes huntington park California 90255 United States 3/14/2012Federico Lische Irvine California 92614 United States 3/14/2012Rebecca Geevs Irvine California 92614 United States 3/14/2012roman smirnov Irvine California 92614 United States 3/14/2012Joy Carter Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/14/2012Erick Bieger Irvine California 92602 United States 3/14/2012Thomas Eastmond Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/14/2012Jennifer Gonzalez Santa Ana California 92704 United States 3/14/2012richard banbury Irvine California 92604 United States 3/14/2012WAYNE HERTEL LAGUNA NIGUEL California 92677 United States 3/14/2012Miriam Pina Santa Ana California 92703 United States 3/14/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 190: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

dennis vadura trabuco canyon California 92679 United States 3/14/2012chris marshall mission viejo California 92691 United States 3/14/2012Jessica Cupples Orange California 92869 United States 3/14/2012shelby fectzo palmdale California 93550 United States 3/14/2012Courtney Nelson Seal Beach California 90740 United States 3/14/2012Donna Roth Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/14/2012Sasha Zdjanskaya Irvine California 92606 United States 3/14/2012Scott Austin Henrico Virginia 23233 United States 3/14/2012Marco Garcia Rancho Santa Margarita California 92688 United States 3/14/2012Jennifer Peterson Burbank California 91505 United States 3/14/2012Dave Snyder irvine California 92604 United States 3/14/2012Alicia Berhow Orange California 92868 United States 3/14/2012Dave Newell Long Beach California 90813 United States 3/14/2012Rev Michael Pierce Mi‐Wuk Village California 95346‐0310 United States 3/14/2012Javier Sanguinetti Irvine California 92614 United States 3/14/2012Mike Amato Long Beach California 90815 United States 3/14/2012Mandy McMahan Reston Virginia 20191 United States 3/14/2012Elizabeth Incitti Garden Grove California 92843 United States 3/14/2012cutberto garcia La Habra California 90631 United States 3/14/2012Cristella Bakke Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/14/2012Ashley Thompson RSM California 92688 United States 3/14/2012Danica Clifton Upland California 91786 United States 3/14/2012Hannah Dolin Laguna Niguel California 92677 United States 3/14/2012Crystalyn Loparo Placentia California 92870 United States 3/14/2012Deanne Metz Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/14/2012Sarah Brennan longview Washington 98623 United States 3/14/2012Diana Relth La Habra Heights California 90631 United States 3/14/2012Christine Robertson Tustin California 92780 United States 3/14/2012James Fraizer Irvine California 92618 United States 3/14/2012Chris Fant Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/14/2012Courtney Kinsman Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/14/2012Emily Selden Apple Valley California 92307 United States 3/14/2012Bryan Karaffa Fullerton California 92833 United States 3/14/2012Sara Clark Los Angeles California 90019 United States 3/14/2012Ed Sims Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 3/14/2012Cristin  Schwarz Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/14/2012j misiak oak park Illinois 60302 United States 3/14/2012Kyle Jarrell Garden Grove California 92841‐3222 United States 3/14/2012Eileen Roach Cayucos California 93430 United States 3/14/2012Kris Chase Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 3/14/2012Wendy Wuitschick Tustin California 92780 United States 3/14/2012Phil Wade Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 3/14/2012Jessica Smith Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/14/2012Vanessa Frei Irvine California 92604 United States 3/14/2012Elizabeth Chappell Santee California 92071 United States 3/14/2012Ashley Junker santa ana California 92711 United States 3/14/2012Mikhail Sorsher Irvine California 92604 United States 3/14/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 191: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Cody O'Connor Irvine California 92614 United States 3/14/2012mat teeter Anaheim California 92804 United States 3/14/2012Brianna Shults Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 3/14/2012Liz Kuhl Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/14/2012Chris Egger Fullerton California 92646 United States 3/14/2012Kristen Lewis Irvine California 92614 United States 3/14/2012Sean Ogle Brea California 92821 United States 3/14/2012Davina Parnell Riverside California 92507 United States 3/14/2012Dennis Bottoms Dickson Tennessee 37055 United States 3/14/2012Shannon Pooler Fullerton California 92831 United States 3/14/2012darek swiatkowski mission viejo California 92692 United States 3/14/2012Joe Lawson Redlands CA California 92373 United States 3/14/2012Trudy Lewis Spirit Lake Idaho 83869 United States 3/14/2012Christy Miric Walnut Creek California 94597 United States 3/14/2012Paniz Meradji Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/14/2012Matt Cavan Dana Point California 92629 United States 3/14/2012Elizabeth Ceja Santa Ana California 92703 United States 3/14/2012James Cook Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 3/14/2012Danielle Floriano lindale Texas 75771 United States 3/14/2012Christine  Keene Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 3/14/2012Tasha Bantau Corona California 92881 United States 3/14/2012Sabrina  Pattas Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/14/2012Sherri Burnett Los Angeles California 90029 United States 3/14/2012Wendy Wehofer Tustin California 92780 United States 3/14/2012Amy Potter Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/14/2012Eileen Clark anaheim California 92804 United States 3/14/2012Keo Powell Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/14/2012Logan Wheeler Northridge California 91325 United States 3/14/2012Ken Welle Anaheim California 92801 United States 3/14/2012Jeff Emde Las Vegas Nevada 89148 United States 3/14/2012Jo Oring reno Nevada 89509 United States 3/14/2012Nadine Turner Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/14/2012Ashley Lanphar Orange California 92868 United States 3/14/2012Blake Butler Irvine California 92606 United States 3/14/2012Brent Dutton Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/14/2012lauren powers Petaluma California 94952 United States 3/14/2012Danielle Cross Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/14/2012ted wells newport beach California 92660 United States 3/14/2012Joanne Shields Carlsbad California 92008 United States 3/14/2012bob lapworth Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 3/14/2012Rick Allen Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/14/2012Sylvia Santiago North Las Vegas Nevada 89032 United States 3/14/2012Kyle Tolmasov santa ana California 92704 United States 3/14/2012Dan DeDonato San Clemente California 92672 United States 3/14/2012Madison Turner Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/14/2012Andrea Andera Thousand Oaks California 91360 United States 3/14/2012Susan Darnell‐Comett London WC1N 2NT United Kingdom 3/14/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 192: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Michael Rolfes Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/14/2012Susie Hughes San Juan Capistrano California 92675‐1123 United States 3/14/2012Peter Belden Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/14/2012Jill  Sager Los Angeles California 90049 United States 3/14/2012Sarah Powell huntington beach California 92646 United States 3/14/2012Polly Tracy Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/14/2012Scott Eskew Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/14/2012Aura Walker Culver City California 90230 United States 3/14/2012Michele Graham Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/14/2012Marisa Klein Capistrano Beach California 92624 United States 3/14/2012Dave Darab Misson Viejo California 92692 United States 3/14/2012Kristin Ruck Santa Ana California 92704 United States 3/14/2012Jessica Gilberstadt Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/14/2012Stephen Ruck Santa Ana California 92704 United States 3/14/2012Angelina Speier goleta California 93117 United States 3/14/2012Jonathan Sobotor San Clemente California 92673 United States 3/14/2012Kelly Taber Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/14/2012Jamie Dow Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/14/2012Linda Kolina Orange California 92865 United States 3/14/2012Katie Demiranda Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/14/2012Monique Guice Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 3/14/2012elizabeth creely San Francisco California 94110 United States 3/14/2012William Banning Newport Beach California 92662 United States 3/14/2012jenieve davenport Newport Beach California 92658 United States 3/14/2012Elizabeth  Gonzalez  Placentia California 92870 United States 3/14/2012Matthew Bush Waialua Hawaii 96791 United States 3/14/2012Tyler Choi Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/14/2012Jose delajara Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/14/2012susan graham Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/14/2012Samantha Turner Newport Coast California 92657‐1007 United States 3/14/2012Catherine Drage Villa Park California 92861 United States 3/14/2012Ashley  Buckalew‐RomRiverside California 92507 United States 3/14/2012STACI ABSHIRE bellingham Washington 98226 United States 3/14/2012Christopher Mclean Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 3/14/2012Nora  Soto Yorba Linda California 92887 United States 3/14/2012Arya keyhan laguna beach California 92652 United States 3/14/2012Matthew Shapiro Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/14/2012Robert Long Irvine California 92604 United States 3/14/2012Avery Amies Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/14/2012Carlos Quezada Santa Ana California 92706 United States 3/14/2012Dan Markham Orange California 92865 United States 3/14/2012Dustin Lemos Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/14/2012Erin Sills Irvine California 92612 United States 3/14/2012alex bojorquez anahiem California 92808 United States 3/14/2012Mette Light Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/14/2012Lindsey Woller Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/14/2012katie harrison Fullerton California 92834 United States 3/14/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 193: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Andy Rodriguez Huntingtong Beach California 92647 United States 3/14/2012Cole Cunningham Chino Hills California 91709 United States 3/14/2012Scott Paciorka Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/14/2012Jessee Bojorquez  Anaheim California 92808 United States 3/14/2012Katie Cole Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/14/2012Jennifer Welle Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 3/14/2012Evan M Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/14/2012Joseph Bryson Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/14/2012Charmaine Rosa Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/14/2012Erin Cavanaugh San Mateo California 94402 United States 3/14/2012Neil Horlock Broken Arrow Oklahoma 74012 United States 3/14/2012Kawika Tarayao NEWPORT BEACH California 92660 United States 3/14/2012Kelly Hagins Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/14/2012Nick Anas Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/14/2012Erin doyle anaheim California 92805 United States 3/14/2012adam rittmiller merced California 95348 United States 3/14/2012Gabriel Pettinicchio Fullerton California 92832 United States 3/14/2012ricardo soria fountain valley California 92708 United States 3/14/2012Alysha Dameshek Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 3/14/2012Tiffany Drage Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/14/2012Kimberly Wells CDM California 92625 United States 3/14/2012Amanda Welty Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/14/2012Ross  Mcilwain Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/14/2012Mercy Yang Irvine California 92606 United States 3/14/2012Melody Bahu Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/14/2012Jennifer Otenti Long Beach California 90815 United States 3/14/2012Stacy Spalding Irvine California 92612 United States 3/14/2012Calvin Anderson Irvine California 92620 United States 3/14/2012Brigide Daily Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/14/2012Christopher Preston Davis California 95618 United States 3/14/2012Kimberly Farrell Westminster California 92683 United States 3/14/2012Logan Ma Irvine California 92606 United States 3/14/2012Mary Kelley Rancho Palos Verdes California 90732 United States 3/14/2012Michael Glenn Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/14/2012Cameron Sinclair newport beach California 92663 United States 3/14/2012jane owen newport beach California 92660 United States 3/14/2012Carl Edelblute Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/14/2012Kristina Hagel Laguna Niguel California 92677 United States 3/14/2012Jeffrey Thurnher Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/14/2012Michael Hussey Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/14/2012Rory Heaney irvine California 92606 United States 3/14/2012Ryan Rasmussen Orange California 92866 United States 3/14/2012Andriy Nikitin Irvine California 92619 United States 3/14/2012Skeeter Leeper Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/14/2012Kathleen Pine Irvine California 92617 United States 3/14/2012Felisha Rossi Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/14/2012Laurie Veitch Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/14/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 194: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Pat ward Lincoln Nebraska 68506 United States 3/14/2012Barbara Adair corona del mar California 92625 United States 3/14/2012Nicole Sahimi Irvine California 92604 United States 3/14/2012Aleisha Herrod aliso viejo California 92656 United States 3/14/2012Chanel Arola Santa Monica California 90405 United States 3/14/2012Morgann Havig Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/14/2012Tiffany McClure Cherry Valley California 92223 United States 3/14/2012Jacques Manciet Irvine California 92618 United States 3/14/2012Jose Sanchez North Las Vegas Nevada 89032 United States 3/14/2012Jim Buie Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/14/2012Katherine Reedy Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/14/2012steve lally costa mesa California 92627 United States 3/14/2012maria Andara  Mission Viejo California 92692 United States 3/14/2012ralph martinez huntington beach California 92646 United States 3/14/2012dan Heimerman  Hutchinson Kansas 67501 United States 3/14/2012Summer Bailey Balboa Island California 92662 United States 3/14/2012Carolyn Shargay Irvine California 92604 United States 3/14/2012Kenny shields huntington beach California 92647 United States 3/14/2012Denise da Silva Fullerton 92832 Cambodia 3/14/2012Susy Herbert Fullerton California 92832 United States 3/14/2012Jenson Crawford Culver City California 90230 United States 3/14/2012katrona anger newport 4020 Australia 3/14/2012Annalisa Rivera Placentia California 92870 United States 3/14/2012Stephen Hunter Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 3/14/2012Jacqueline Kamel Dana Point California 92629 United States 3/14/2012Erin Nelson Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/14/2012sorayah okcuoglu new york New York 10003 United States 3/14/2012James Dow Balboa California 92663 United States 3/14/2012stephanie lopez San Clemente California 92672 United States 3/14/2012Jordan Spigner Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/14/2012Jon Lopez Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/14/2012MARK SIMON CORONA DEL MAR California 92625 United States 3/14/2012Dana Dunford Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/14/2012Susan Iredale Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/14/2012Ryan Stampe Haleiwa Hawaii 96712 United States 3/14/2012Yolanda Sellers Orange California 92869 United States 3/14/2012Adam Kinder Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/14/2012Dana  Wong Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 3/14/2012kent ma lake forest California 92630 United States 3/14/2012Kylie Garrett Irvine California 92604 United States 3/14/2012Terry Lynne Stulik Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/14/2012kristen molinari corona del mar California 92625 United States 3/14/2012Liz Dinkel Yorba Linda California 92887 United States 3/14/2012Danny Papurt Irvine California 92604 United States 3/14/2012Mike Schindler Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/14/2012Sara Diercksmeier Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/14/2012Cindy Brahs Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/14/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 195: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Tom Freeman Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/14/2012Jaclyn Anthonisen Paso Robles California 93446 United States 3/14/2012Chris Banning Riverside California 92508 United States 3/14/2012Andrew Abajian Seal Beach California 90740 United States 3/14/2012Colin Duffy Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/14/2012Laura  Curtis Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/14/2012Jean Gutierrez Manchester Washington 98353 United States 3/14/2012Hilary WHITE Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/14/2012Mark Wheeler Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 3/14/2012Leanne Herbert Villa Park California 92861 United States 3/14/2012Ben Smeekens San Jose California 95125 United States 3/14/2012Caroline Bradshaw Irvine California 92614 United States 3/14/2012Regina Loxsom Irvine California 92604 United States 3/14/2012Fatin Zubi costa mesa California 92626 United States 3/14/2012Ian Jorgensen Pomona California 91768 United States 3/14/2012Randy Perdew newport beach California 92663 United States 3/14/2012Eugene Shvarts Sherman Oaks California 91403 United States 3/14/2012Angela Steele Pomona California 91768 United States 3/14/2012Keith Holland Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/14/2012Ryan Fodor Lakewood Colorado 80214 United States 3/14/2012Cassandra Buzby Irvine California 92606 United States 3/14/2012darleen rodriguez costa mesa California 92627 United States 3/14/2012Essa Bahu Norco California 92860 United States 3/14/2012David Macken Dublin 16 Ireland 3/14/2012Alexis Hickox Irvine California 92612 United States 3/14/2012Cheryl lazio Santa Ana California 92707 United States 3/14/2012Joline Vela Corona, California 92879 United States 3/14/2012shaun dunavan 3/14/2012Sonia Lino Anaheim California 92805 United States 3/14/2012Jose Cruz Corona California 92879 United States 3/14/2012Marilee Terrell Irvine California 92603 United States 3/14/2012Robin  Marmor Capistrano Beach California 92624 United States 3/14/2012Summer Ellison Bellflower California 90706 United States 3/14/2012Katharine Hawes Menlo Park California 94025 United States 3/14/2012Jamie Troxel Garden Grove California 92845 United States 3/14/2012Nathan Lozano Anaheim California 92807 United States 3/14/2012Blake Maxwell Newport Beach California 92662 United States 3/14/2012Cynthia Kelley Euless Texas 76040 United States 3/14/2012Amy  Bloom Los Angeles California 90038 United States 3/14/2012Tim Steed Newport BEach California 92661 United States 3/14/2012Tyler Kiehnle Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/14/2012Dianne Wen Orange California 92867 United States 3/14/2012Kelly Young Irvine California 92602 United States 3/14/2012CHeri Ketner Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/14/2012shelby bradley brea California 92821 United States 3/14/2012Paul Welsh Escondido California 92026 United States 3/14/2012Kendall Kelly irvine California 92614 United States 3/14/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 196: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Laura Gifford Brea California 92821 United States 3/14/2012brian hoang irvine California 92606 United States 3/14/2012Timothy Dupuie Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/14/2012Heather Oglesby Irvine California 92620 United States 3/14/2012Lane Tran Tustin California 92782 United States 3/14/2012Kyle Cassidy huntington beach California 92648 United States 3/14/2012Tina Caswell Irvine California 92606 United States 3/14/2012Scott Boureston Tustin California 92780 United States 3/14/2012David Brumbley Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/14/2012Sarah Wong Irvine California 92603 United States 3/14/2012janelle gumaer costa mesa California 92627 United States 3/14/2012Matt McLaren Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/14/2012Melody Calvert irvine California 92602 United States 3/14/2012Tiffany Viles Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/14/2012Andy Lam Irvine California 92604 United States 3/14/2012Tim Waterhouse Newport Beach California 92662 United States 3/14/2012Tyleena Fowler Henderson Nevada 89011 United States 3/14/2012Duane Downs Murrieta California 92562 United States 3/14/2012Emily Novelo Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/14/2012Nancy Shoemate Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/14/2012ricky sullivan costa mesa California 92627 United States 3/14/2012Sarah Dehaan Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/14/2012Erika Morozumi Irvine California 92604 United States 3/14/2012Wade Peng Santa ana California 92704 United States 3/14/2012Julie Garn Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/14/2012rob kirby orange California 92866 United States 3/14/2012Jennifer Partlow BEACON New York 12508 United States 3/14/2012Mairelise Robinson Simi Valley California 93065 United States 3/14/2012Bret Rosol Newport beach California 92663 United States 3/14/2012Emanuel Patrascu Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 3/14/2012Lourdes Bottger Irvine California 92603 United States 3/14/2012Charles Bing Palm Desert California 92211 United States 3/14/2012francisco garcia sunset beach California 90742 United States 3/14/2012guy williamson newport beach California 92662 United States 3/14/2012Mason Brown Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/14/2012Pamela Russell Irvine California 92064 United States 3/14/2012Christy Gregory Chicago Illinois 60647 United States 3/14/2012Cindy Sanchez Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/14/2012celeste atkins Orange California 92867 United States 3/14/2012brad mendenhall newport beach California 92661 United States 3/14/2012Kristen Schlom Santa Ana California 92707 United States 3/15/2012Nick  Radosavljevic Oak Park Illinois 60301 United States 3/15/2012Jessica Kasper Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012Colleen Kearfott Newport Beach. California 92661 United States 3/15/2012lanning delany studio city California 91602 United States 3/15/2012Kathryn Gray Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Jennifer Walker Lake Elsinore California 92532 United States 3/15/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 197: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Andrew Clapp Tustin California 92782 United States 3/15/2012Frank Kim Los Angeles California 90020 United States 3/15/2012Amber Hullibarger Manhattan beach California 90266 United States 3/15/2012Alison Allen San Clemente California 92673 United States 3/15/2012Jack Lansford Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Kris Laursen Carlsbad California 92009 United States 3/15/2012Ines Franklin Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/15/2012aaron zide Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Melody Knight Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012john clark Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012beth Kiley Corona Del mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Linda Lagasse Trabuco Canyon California 92679 United States 3/15/2012Sherry Adams Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Karine Marois Irvine 92604 Armenia 3/15/2012Val Treadaway Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012greg lehman pacific grove California 93950 United States 3/15/2012patrick knowles newport beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012david Chatrier Virginia Beach Virginia 23454 United States 3/15/2012Katie Stephens Irvine California 92618 United States 3/15/2012Chris Okey Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012lAURA SCOTT SA JACINTO California 92583 United States 3/15/2012Pat  Higgins Ketchum Idaho 83340 United States 3/15/2012Breeann Angeleri Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012Kouki Yoshijo Los Angeles California 90024 United States 3/15/2012Sharon Liu Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012Lluis Soler Irvine California 92617 United States 3/15/2012Mike Baba Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/15/2012Amber Sheesley Orange California 92869 United States 3/15/2012Carolin Loose Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Deborah Stone RSM California 92688 United States 3/15/2012Andrew Martelle Irvine California 92612 United States 3/15/2012Lauren BiggS Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/15/2012Pamela  Bowers  Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012everett barker oceanside California 92056 United States 3/15/2012Don Marshall Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012Daniel Walters Orange California 92869 United States 3/15/2012Dennis Cook Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012Mijanou Pham Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/15/2012Cynthia Bui Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012tim park irvine California 92603 United States 3/15/2012Andre van der Pol Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Anna Scherrei Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Paul Smith Orange California 92866 United States 3/15/2012Warren taylor costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Mark Wyland Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Connie Duddridge Greenbank Washington 98253 United States 3/15/2012Nima Mohseni Irvine California 92606 United States 3/15/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 198: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Carrie Graber Corona California 92881 United States 3/15/2012Mark Nass Poulsbo Washington 98370 United States 3/15/2012Jordan Pulver Thousand Oaks California 91362 United States 3/15/2012Chris Gayer Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 3/15/2012Julie Wells Laguna Niguel California 92677 United States 3/15/2012Delphia Weissert Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 3/15/2012Issei Tanaka Irvine California 92606 United States 3/15/2012bethany  huff Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Patty Douglas Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012David Hansen west covina California 91791 United States 3/15/2012Dave Knecht Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Nicole Lipari Corona California 92878 United States 3/15/2012John Gleason Newport Beach California 92658 United States 3/15/2012Jen Epperson Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012Victor Ramirez Corona California 92882 United States 3/15/2012Gloria Tran Orange California 92865 United States 3/15/2012Christina Ferraro Fullerton California 92833 United States 3/15/2012Graham Longstreet Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/15/2012Randy Bunney San Clemente California 92672 United States 3/15/2012shirley  verge newport beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Lindy Yow Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012Heather Dryer Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012Kurt Page Laguna Niguel California 92677 United States 3/15/2012Brian Dreiling Layton Utah 84041 United States 3/15/2012William Van LandinghaBrooklyn New York 11218 United States 3/15/2012Krista Mora Victorville California 92395 United States 3/15/2012Katherine Gasztonyi Irvine California 92614 United States 3/15/2012Gene Loza North Hollywood California 91601 United States 3/15/2012Adam Forni Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/15/2012katherine tran Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Ric Anderson Lake Elsinore California 92530 United States 3/15/2012Tom Lappas Tustin California 92780 United States 3/15/2012Kristi Cortegana Irvine California 92606 United States 3/15/2012Hans Fink Orange California 92866 United States 3/15/2012James Ruchardson Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Golie Alemi Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/15/2012Michael Biagi Santa Ana California 92626 United States 3/15/2012Ardith Benzmiller Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Christopher Allmann Irvine California 92606 United States 3/15/2012Arnold Beckman Henderson Nevada 89052 United States 3/15/2012Charise Payne San Clemente California 92672 United States 3/15/2012albert ruiz Upland California 91786 United States 3/15/2012pamela rosa costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012Garett Wilkinson Corona California 92879 United States 3/15/2012randy cicero Portland Oregon 97203 United States 3/15/2012Farris Owenati Irvine California 92614 United States 3/15/2012Andrea Hughes Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 199: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Tracy Cervellone Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/15/2012Amy Hung Irvine California 92606 United States 3/15/2012Stephanie Cernek Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 3/15/2012Desdemona  Bandini Irvine California 92614 United States 3/15/2012Elizabeth Fearn Westminster California 92683 United States 3/15/2012Robert Schramm Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Kristina Olah Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Rishik Pillai Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012Tammi Cluck newport beach 92663 United States Mino 3/15/2012Jennifer Hardy Pine River Minnesota 56474 United States 3/15/2012Lauren Bunn Irvine California 92614 United States 3/15/2012Joan Pritchard Fountain Valley California 92708 United States 3/15/2012Jack Turner Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/15/2012MiChele Schueller Corona California 92882 United States 3/15/2012Christina Mainero Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Barbara Danzi Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/15/2012Jennifer Hendricks Tustin California 92780 United States 3/15/2012Denise Nassif Irvine California Irvine, United States 3/15/2012chloe romley san francisco California 94112 United States 3/15/2012Rithwik Hari Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012Dana Glover Kingman Arizona 86401 United States 3/15/2012Aimee Lambes Tustin California 92780 United States 3/15/2012Sumit Shah San Diego California 92129 United States 3/15/2012bryan virgil Temecula California 92590 United States 3/15/2012Jessica Doyle Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Brian Tran irvine California 92612 United States 3/15/2012Kathy Bunney San Clemente California 92672 United States 3/15/2012Donna Aigner Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Bill Dyment Irvine California 92602 United States 3/15/2012Ande Dow Bakersfield California 93312 United States 3/15/2012Nora Pullen Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012Scott Diggs La Serena 11111 Chile 3/15/2012nicholas smith Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012Melanie Wong Hacienda Heights California 91745 United States 3/15/2012chris schiller Orange California 92865 United States 3/15/2012Kristin Fogg Riverside California 92503 United States 3/15/2012Adam Stapish Rancho Santa Margarita California 92688 United States 3/15/2012Janette Wilson Fallbrook California 92088 United States 3/15/2012Steven Smeekens San Jose California 95125 United States 3/15/2012Daniel Mata Irvine California 92603 United States 3/15/2012Marilyn Yuan Irvine California 92617 United States 3/15/2012Cathy Buttermore Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Jennifer Lissoy Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/15/2012Thomas Poznanski irvine  California 92606 United States 3/15/2012justin nguyen irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012Wendy Byars orange California 92867 United States 3/15/2012Ken Vien rosemead California 91770 United States 3/15/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 200: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Rachel Leuthen Orange California 92867 United States 3/15/2012kamara shephard san pedro California 90731 United States 3/15/2012Katie Staudinger Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Yuichi Yoshida Irvine California 92606 United States 3/15/2012Jeff  Vaughn Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 3/15/2012Hannah PabiadzimskayIrvine California 92606 United States 3/15/2012Jill Jones Laguna Niguel California 92677 United States 3/15/2012Henry Phung Westminster California 92683 United States 3/15/2012Francey Ayala Corona California 92882 United States 3/15/2012Ngan Tran Westminster California 92683 United States 3/15/2012Patti Phillips Balboa California 92661 United States 3/15/2012Judy Guo Irvine California 92612 United States 3/15/2012Richard Gibson Long Beach California 90803 United States 3/15/2012Allison Lusk‐Mauvezin San Clemente California 92673 United States 3/15/2012Gerald Matlack orange California 92865 United States 3/15/2012Gina Hernandez Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Casey Reynolds Yucca Valley California 92284 United States 3/15/2012linda Simmonds corona del mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Rachel Phelps Irvine California 92614 United States 3/15/2012Paulina Young Irvine California 92602 United States 3/15/2012don eisenhauer Henderson Nevada 89015 United States 3/15/2012Andrew hernandez Newport beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Lorraine Barba Ontario California 91761 United States 3/15/2012Elizabeth Stake Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012brian huynh irvine  California 92612 United States 3/15/2012Alexis Spaeth Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/15/2012Shelli Riddle Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Ashley Meyer Highlands Ranch Colorado 80126 United States 3/15/2012Phil  Mitchell Maricopa Arizona 85138 United States 3/15/2012G. McPhee altadena California 91001 United States 3/15/2012Scott Bright Anaheim California 92804 United States 3/15/2012Kira Lunar irvine  California 92603 United States 3/15/2012amir bah san francisco California 94131 United States 3/15/2012Michelle LaMar Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012Rose Cunningham‐AhuSanta Ana California 9205 United States 3/15/2012John Upton Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012Joshua Leith Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012tom walker costa mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Linda Dominic Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012susan ratliff corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Joe D'Errico Boise Idaho 83704 United States 3/15/2012Mark Wrzesniewski Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/15/2012Sara Gibson Irvine California 92602 United States 3/15/2012Amy Erickson Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 3/15/2012Serena  Seshadri Irvine California 92617 United States 3/15/2012ryan oconnell irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012Scott Wilson Fallbrook California 92088 United States 3/15/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 201: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

ashley bernel newport beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Lauren Cude Riverside California 92508 United States 3/15/2012Jon Spinac New York New York 10010 United States 3/15/2012Kirk Siglock Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/15/2012Jonathan Dhauw Irvine California 92617 United States 3/15/2012Annie Carignan Irvine California 92618 United States 3/15/2012Shawn  Thayer Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Adam Garcia Irvine California 92612 United States 3/15/2012jonathan vergona simi valley California 93065 United States 3/15/2012Kathryn Williams Encinitas California 92024 United States 3/15/2012Susan Nass Poulsbo Washington 98370 United States 3/15/2012Geoffrey Simmon Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/15/2012Alina Kalakoutski Irvine California 92618 United States 3/15/2012Alec Torelli Irvine 92614 United States Mino 3/15/2012Kara Burns Agoura Hills California 91301 United States 3/15/2012Kimberly Meyer Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Robert Peary La Habra California 90631 United States 3/15/2012Chris Schwarz Los Angeles California 90049 United States 3/15/2012brent ranek newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Bradley  Buzby Irvine California 92606 United States 3/15/2012Amy Barnett San Antonio Texas 78209 United States 3/15/2012Abdullah Mamun Tustin California 92780 United States 3/15/2012Ted Bell El Cajon California 92021 United States 3/15/2012polly bishop Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/15/2012Eric Meyer Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012greg wangler costa mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012Sara Matza Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012Debra Ball Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Cynthia Harris Tustin California 92780 United States 3/15/2012Stacy Halim Irvine California 92620 United States 3/15/2012Sandra Norby Tustin California 92780 United States 3/15/2012Jon Conk Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 3/15/2012Rebecca Nguyen Irvine California 92614 United States 3/15/2012holly buban Lake Forest 92630 United States 3/15/2012Susan Jackson Westminster California 92683 United States 3/15/2012Lisa Fox Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Robert Jennings Colorado Springs Colorado 80923 United States 3/15/2012David Goldstein Seattle Washington 98117‐5001 United States 3/15/2012Roger Brannon La Habra California 90631 United States 3/15/2012Ryan altshuler Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 3/15/2012Derek Saruwatari Tustin California 92780 United States 3/15/2012kendra williams Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012Michael McKinnon Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Sharon McAleer Orange California 92869 United States 3/15/2012Candyce Reynolds Yucca Valley California 92284 United States 3/15/2012Susan Geer Chandler Arizona 85225 United States 3/15/2012barbara dunphy garden grove California 92841 United States 3/15/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 202: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Rina Horton Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/15/2012Matthew Everitt Tustin California 92782 United States 3/15/2012Linda  Ramage Newport Beach  California 92661 United States 3/15/2012Ronni Keichline Walnut Park California 90255 United States 3/15/2012Charles Hellingson Long Beach California 90804 United States 3/15/2012janae gallo Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Juan Garcia Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Sue Jackson Tustin California 92780 United States 3/15/2012Steven  Johnson  Santa Ana  California 92704 United States 3/15/2012Tracey Lapworth Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 3/15/2012Karleen Wolonsky Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012ROBERT  COURY NEWPORT BEACH California 92660 United States 3/15/2012eren diaz Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Nathan Tupman Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/15/2012Norman Giroux Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012margaret bigby‐lambemoreno valley  California 92557 United States 3/15/2012Beth Enniss Lake Elsinore California 92532 United States 3/15/2012Nick Manzer Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012Julie Jensen Orange California 92865 United States 3/15/2012jennifer walker Lake Forest California 92691 United States 3/15/2012zachary cargile San Clemente California 92673 United States 3/15/2012earl lyons thousand Oaks California 91362 United States 3/15/2012Crystal Huang Irvine California 92606 United States 3/15/2012Jordan Adajar Orange California 92866 United States 3/15/2012Jim Scudder Costa Mesa 92627 Seychelles 3/15/2012Amy Calderone Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/15/2012Nick Jones orange California 92866 United States 3/15/2012Lynne Liu Irvine California 92606 United States 3/15/2012Ashley Palmer Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012Elizabeth De Witt Newport Beach California 92662 United States 3/15/2012Paul Musco Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Kelley Nazionale Ontario California 91764 United States 3/15/2012Janice  McKinnon Temple City California 91780 United States 3/15/2012Sheldon Dyer Irvine California 92612 United States 3/15/2012Diane L Irvine California 92603 United States 3/15/2012Ruth Steinhart Glendale California 91205 United States 3/15/2012Adelis Herrrra Phoenix Arizona 85007 United States 3/15/2012KRISTINE SIMON CORONA DEL MAR California 92625 United States 3/15/2012gavin dias newport beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Jordan Reynolds Villa Park California 92861 United States 3/15/2012Robert Donald Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Jenny Pham Irvine California 92606 United States 3/15/2012Lorraine O'Keefe Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Donel  Belovsky Orange California 92867 United States 3/15/2012Judy Gray Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012Joanna Hsu Tustin California 92782 United States 3/15/2012vicki ballon Irvine California 92603 United States 3/15/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 203: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Katie Beavers Orange California 92867 United States 3/15/2012Vivian Nguyen Irvine California 92618 United States 3/15/2012Charles McAuliffe newport beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Tim Burnham Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012debra teran newport beach California 92661 United States 3/15/2012Kianna Jaye Seattle Washington 98101 United States 3/15/2012Laura Mohr Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/15/2012Robin Edwards Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/15/2012Jordin  Williams Thousand Oaks California 91362 United States 3/15/2012Nora Griffin Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/15/2012Kyra Pelachik Orange California 92867 United States 3/15/2012Sasha Roe Los Angeles California 90034 United States 3/15/2012Matthew Meddock Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 3/15/2012Shannon Woodruff Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Brittany Kish Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 3/15/2012Tom McKnight Costa Mesa California 92628 United States 3/15/2012Patrick Calkins Irvine California 92620 United States 3/15/2012Valerie Vichikov Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012jim mcglocklin Everett Washington 98204 United States 3/15/2012Adam Hogan San Marcos California 92069 United States 3/15/2012matthew andino Loomis California 95650 United States 3/15/2012Dale Welch Corona California 92881 United States 3/15/2012Jonathan Rowe Reseda California 91335 United States 3/15/2012Michael Tuttle Moreno Valley California 92557 United States 3/15/2012Kassie Busby la habra hts California 90631 United States 3/15/2012Julie Klotz Irvine California 92603 United States 3/15/2012Patricia Hou new york New York 10003 United States 3/15/2012Oscar Barcenas Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/15/2012Michael West Tustin California 92780 United States 3/15/2012Wes boese Surprise Arizona 85378 United States 3/15/2012Brady Robles Pomona California 91767 United States 3/15/2012Cameron Montalvo Atherton California 94027 United States 3/15/2012Daniel  McGlocklin san bernardino California 92404 United States 3/15/2012Magin  Razani Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012Johnny Deurmeier Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 3/15/2012zach guzman costa mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012David Randolph Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012Jennifer Stevenson Westminster California 92683 United States 3/15/2012james meddock Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012curtis corbett los angeles California 90045 United States 3/15/2012Jenna Thomas Irvine California 92620 United States 3/15/2012Amanda Starn Ontario California 91762 United States 3/15/2012Not Smart Beverly Hills California 90210 United States 3/15/2012Dumband Dumber newport beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Taylor Stroup Orange California 92869 United States 3/15/2012shannon reilly perris California 92570 United States 3/15/2012Ian McEwan Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 204: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Bert Tarayao Newport Beach California 92660‐2930 United States 3/15/2012leticia curiel tustin California 92780 United States 3/15/2012Mike Tunney newport beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Dumband Dumber newport beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012wendy walder cherry valley California 92223 United States 3/15/2012Courtney Grigg Bozeman Montana 59718 United States 3/15/2012Gang Banger Santa Ana California 92701 United States 3/15/2012Kedar Tilak Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Nancy Duong Fountain Valley California 92708 United States 3/15/2012Coastal Commission beverly hills California 90210 United States 3/15/2012Heather Perla Alta Loma California 91737 United States 3/15/2012Jennifer Oldham Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Paul Whipple Tustin California 92780 United States 3/15/2012Ravid Duiz newport beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Nisha  Nalamala Irvine California 92606 United States 3/15/2012Theodore Striegel Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012chris swingen santa ana California 92704 United States 3/15/2012tracy bradley Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Faulty List costa mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Chuck  DeMoss Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Diana Lee Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012Salty Burns costa mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Meth Dealer costa mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012jeremy ward mission viejo California 92692 United States 3/15/2012Lee Bregman Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012Prison Yard costa mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Shikhar Gupta Irvine California 92606 United States 3/15/2012Plastic Burner costa mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012kelly vang Garden Grove California 92843 United States 3/15/2012Burning Toxins costa mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012nick schycker San Antonio Texas 78258 United States 3/15/2012Isign Everything beverly hills California 90210 United States 3/15/2012Heidi Dawson Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/15/2012Cocaine Dealer beverly hills California 90210 United States 3/15/2012Dumband Drunk beverly hills California 90210 United States 3/15/2012Nancy Kossky Tustin California 92780 United States 3/15/2012Trash Burner beverly hills California 90210 United States 3/15/2012Nora Garcia Pomona California 91766 United States 3/15/2012April Smith Norco California 92860 United States 3/15/2012Yasiu Kruszynski Chicago Illinois 60613‐0011 United States 3/15/2012Robert St.Thomas Buena park California 90620 United States 3/15/2012David Medina Santa Ana California 92703 United States 3/15/2012Noelle McCabe‐DuongTustin California 92782 United States 3/15/2012Jennifer Bletscher Tustin California 92780 United States 3/15/2012Wendy Danbury Orange California 92867 United States 3/15/2012Carver Young Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Erica Sorensen Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/15/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 205: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

jerry sivongsay tustin California 92780 United States 3/15/2012Alexander  Hopkins CDM California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Jonathan Noel Laguna Niguel California 92677 United States 3/15/2012caitlin lim irvine California 92617 United States 3/15/2012FLAVIA MERLINO Pomona California 91766 United States 3/15/2012Kevin Cheng Fountain Valley California 92708 United States 3/15/2012Janice Hawkins Huntington Beach California 92615 United States 3/15/2012Sarah Peake Anaheim California 92808 United States 3/15/2012Aria Hartson Poway California 92064 United States 3/15/2012Eric Nareshni Placentia California 92870 United States 3/15/2012Jamie Breustedt Stanton California 90680 United States 3/15/2012stephanie hong Hacienda Heights California 91745 United States 3/15/2012Amy Hendren Orange California 92867 United States 3/15/2012Julia Schmidt Orange California 92865 United States 3/15/2012Dan Morgan Irvine California 92612 United States 3/15/2012Dan Curran Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Alan Bosshardt  Hawthorne California 90250 United States 3/15/2012Cathy Do Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Jessica O Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012Chris Cooper Del Mar California 92014 United States 3/15/2012Matt Barlow Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Martin Tibbs In the uk tn40 1dt United Kingdom 3/15/2012Vilasay Souvannasane Tustin California 92780 United States 3/15/2012Shelby Eser Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012Andrew Bullene Santa Rosa California 95407 United States 3/15/2012Jack Rogers Pleasanton California 94588 United States 3/15/2012Casi Phelan Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/15/2012Mihail Schoolov San Diego California 92107 United States 3/15/2012holly spalione lake forest California 92630 United States 3/15/2012Kevin Folino Cottonwood California 96022 United States 3/15/2012Brittany Maufras Irvine California 92612 United States 3/15/2012jim lomeli Carlsbad California 92008 United States 3/15/2012Nhi Nguyen Irvine California 92612 United States 3/15/2012Devin Tryon Mission Viejo California 92692 United States 3/15/2012Allison Chapman Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Lacy Jones Orange California 92869 United States 3/15/2012trisha priest Oceanside California 92058 United States 3/15/2012Jeffrey Manzer Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/15/2012Florian Weisse Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 3/15/2012Kaley Lockshaw Paso Robles California 93446 United States 3/15/2012lauren Young corona del mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Genevieve Schaub Newport Beach California 92657 United States 3/15/2012corin fisher Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012Jennifer Morse Irvine California 92614 United States 3/15/2012Liz Mamey Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012James Stockard Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/15/2012Elizabeth O'Halloran Kettering NN16 0DA United Kingdom 3/15/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 206: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Cindy Thompson Riverside California 92507 United States 3/15/2012joe balfour Lancaster California 93536 United States 3/15/2012Capt Jeff Inshaw newport Beach California 92646 United States 3/15/2012Amber Davies Irvine California 92614 United States 3/15/2012cal knott Costa mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012Sarah Dozier Claremont California 91711 United States 3/15/2012aida catalan Santa Ana California 92707 United States 3/15/2012Karen Lehnecker North Royalton Ohio 44133 United States 3/15/2012Jim Steinmetz Dublin California 94568 United States 3/15/2012Fabricio Mondragon Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Annette Kelley Anaheim California 92805 United States 3/15/2012Monique  O'Brien Incline Village Nevada 89450 United States 3/15/2012kevin neppl Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012Kirk Del Valle Woodland Hilla California 91367 United States 3/15/2012Susie Wren Fullerton California 92831 United States 3/15/2012Youchen Wang Hercules California 94547 United States 3/15/2012Donna Peterson Anaheim California 92807 United States 3/15/2012Steve Moses Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012David Glenn El Paso Texas 79936 United States 3/15/2012Barbie Turner Orange California 92867 United States 3/15/2012John Lusk Mission Viejo California 92692 United States 3/15/2012Pamela  Jacobs Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/15/2012Rebecca Van hofwege Riverside California 92509 United States 3/15/2012Kelly Kohl  Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Shouvik Ghosh Irvine California 92620 United States 3/15/2012Debbie Speier Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Joseph Nartin Newbury Park California 91320 United States 3/15/2012Jacalyn Arseneau San Bernardino California 92407 United States 3/15/2012ANN HARRIS Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Marissa goerke san diego California 92107 United States 3/15/2012Keith Willig Menlo Park California 94025 United States 3/15/2012Rochelle Skalla Arvada Colorado 80005 United States 3/15/2012christienne morgan delray beach Florida 92661 United States 3/15/2012Allison Sheppard Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Paul Woock Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 3/15/2012Sarah  Davis 92504 3/15/2012Lori Heck Laguna Niguel California 92677 United States 3/15/2012Cindi Brown Placentia California 92870 United States 3/15/2012Linda Brown Costa mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012david anastos newport beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Brittany Buie Buffalo New York 14216 United States 3/15/2012elise sherman arcadia California 91006 United States 3/15/2012mike anaya Covina California 91724 United States 3/15/2012Karen Mathieu Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012George Skorka Santa Clarita California 91390 United States 3/15/2012Andrew Rawlings Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012Kristen Wallace Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 207: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

John  Moody Salem Oregon 97302 United States 3/15/2012Bob Noll Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Ryan Logan Bay Point California 94565 United States 3/15/2012Darla Hompson Ontario California 91761‐0120 United States 3/15/2012Vanessa Dowell Salinas California 93901 United States 3/15/2012Jay Chaisson Orange California 92867 United States 3/15/2012Arie Stern Playa Del Rey California 90293 United States 3/15/2012Lauren Jackson Bakersfield California 93313 United States 3/15/2012Anne Belden Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Michael Tucker Poulsbo Washington 98370 United States 3/15/2012Kim Maxam Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Arthur Yelsey Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Pierce Meehan Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012sharon  warner tustin California 92860 United States 3/15/2012Mari Anna Johnson Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Katie Kalwitz Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012chris strayer Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Priyanka Bhalla Huntington Beach California 92615 United States 3/15/2012hannah dvorak Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/15/2012Brent Broaddus Santa Ana California 92725 United States 3/15/2012Mary Jo Muller Ladera Ranch California 92694 United States 3/15/2012Heather Mendoza Orange California 92866 United States 3/15/2012Joy Millam Fountain Valley California 92708 United States 3/15/2012Carver Young Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Nena Caloca Riverside California 92504 United States 3/15/2012Courtney Friend Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/15/2012Barbara Laube Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/15/2012joshua malouf santa barbara California 93101 United States 3/15/2012Carlos Quesada Norwalk California 90650 United States 3/15/2012steve horton CA California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Fabian Carrillo Hollywood Florida 33020 United States 3/15/2012Paul Guerard Irvine California 92620 United States 3/15/2012Howard Berkowitz Costa MEsa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Vince Smith Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/15/2012Jim Moloney Newport Beach California 92662 United States 3/15/2012William Hulse Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/15/2012Jodi Zalanka Corona California 92882 United States 3/15/2012Nicholas Bowden Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Bob Lusk Irvine California 92612 United States 3/15/2012Michael Foley Stanton California 90680 United States 3/15/2012Michael Mundy Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Deborah Hogan Balboa Island California 92662 United States 3/15/2012Lori  Sheppard Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Debbie Gude Santa Barbara California 93109 United States 3/15/2012thomas brimer costa mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012Rayna Anderson corona del mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Bill Godwin San Francisco California 94107 United States 3/15/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 208: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Winnona Gaviglio Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 3/15/2012Tina Hoffman Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012jAke kalwitz Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012Shaun  Kenneday Las Vegas Nevada 89131 United States 3/15/2012LINDA GONZALEZ SUNLAND California 91041 United States 3/15/2012Tim Poole Lexington Park Maryland 20653 United States 3/15/2012Courtney Rotondo Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012chris corbett Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012TYler Kent newport beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012John Carlyle Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012BRIAN STANDERS NEWPORT BEACH California 90663 United States 3/15/2012Linsey Carbone Balboa Island California 92662 United States 3/15/2012Cheryl Gonzalez Running Springs California 92382 United States 3/15/2012Timorei Andraos Irvine California 92606 United States 3/15/2012Erin Walsh Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/15/2012DeAna Glaser Tustin California 92780 United States 3/15/2012deborah  defeo Corona California 92883 United States 3/15/2012Lindsey Ryan Yucaipa California 92399 United States 3/15/2012robyn barnhill irvine California 92614 United States 3/15/2012Rachel Lomeli Corona California 92882 United States 3/15/2012Katie Powell Costa Mesa California 92627‐1437 United States 3/15/2012Megan Moss Newport beach California 92661 United States 3/15/2012garrett peterson costa mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012julius buslon North Hollywood California 91605 United States 3/15/2012Dan Livingston Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Brent Fredericks COSTA MESA California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Marian Clark Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Julio Aguilar Santa Ana California 92707 United States 3/15/2012Lou Tirado Tustin California 92780 United States 3/15/2012Noah Aros Irvine California 92620 United States 3/15/2012John Russell Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Chasen Cameron Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012Chloe Haack Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012Laura Clayton  Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012William Clayton New York New York 10044 United States 3/15/2012Kristen Tett  Yorba Linda California 92887 United States 3/15/2012Jeremy Leasure Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 3/15/2012Alana Juteau Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012keira foster Riverside California 92505 United States 3/15/2012ben hicks Irvine California 92606 United States 3/15/2012Christine King Irvine California 92620 United States 3/15/2012Nicole Poole Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Alyssa  Ocampo San Francisco California 94132 United States 3/15/2012Cameron Pemstein Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Tom Nguyen Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012Tom Billings Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Lauren Helfrich Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 209: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Steven Alexander Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Ashleigh fehmie WESTMINSTER 92683 Uganda 3/15/2012Adam Gorevitz Irvine California 92620 United States 3/15/2012Danielle Wakefield Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012D'Marie Mulattieri Laguna Beach California 92652 United States 3/15/2012chase lefevre Irvine California 92614 United States 3/15/2012Tina Lugay dayton Ohio 45414 United States 3/15/2012Brittany Phillips Balboa California 92661 United States 3/15/2012Jay Stallman Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 3/15/2012leslie jackson Boise Idaho 83702 United States 3/15/2012Friedrick Michel Fountain Valley California 92708 United States 3/15/2012Nakisa Motamedi irvine California 92620 United States 3/15/2012Leslie Cox Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Jenna Jakowatz Irvine California 92620 United States 3/15/2012carol peck corona del mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Cynthia Shettler Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012maily creamer Santa Ana California 92706 United States 3/15/2012BELINDA BARTLETT HUNTINGTON BEACH California 92646 United States 3/15/2012Michael Mosier Old Saybrook Connecticut 6475 United States 3/15/2012Troy Holland La Mirada California 90638 United States 3/15/2012Jessica Bordner Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/15/2012Sharon Crawford Norco California 92860 United States 3/15/2012Lisa Clayton Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Shirley Greene Riverside California 92504 United States 3/15/2012Andy Wolfe Newport beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Mason Steel Driftwood Texas 78619 United States 3/15/2012Stephen Weller San Dimas California 91773 United States 3/15/2012Michael Busch Tustin California 92780 United States 3/15/2012Lana Benson Fort Worth Texas 76109 United States 3/15/2012Jason Gorevitz Irvine California 92620 United States 3/15/2012bryan flores irvine California 92612 United States 3/15/2012Jennifer Henning Coeur d Alene Idaho 83815 United States 3/15/2012jesi  silveria irvine California 92620 United States 3/15/2012Sarah Baxter Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/15/2012Kim Tacheny Chino Hills California 91709 United States 3/15/2012Daniel O'Hara Ladera Ranch California 92694 United States 3/15/2012charles crowley Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Jenna Harbin Westminster California 92683 United States 3/15/2012valerie flores tustin California 92780 United States 3/15/2012jennifer legliu Skyforest California 92378 United States 3/15/2012Cassandra Boyce Fairfield California 94534 United States 3/15/2012Jeff Sample Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Kristen Crumly Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 3/15/2012Linh Pham Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012William Banning Los Gatos California 95033 United States 3/15/2012Karen Yelsey Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Melanie Powers Newport beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 210: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Shervin Farivar Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 3/15/2012Monica Holbrook Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012Carole Levers Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 3/15/2012Amy Bennett Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012Allen Lorentzen Goleta California 93117 United States 3/15/2012Gail Chasin Irvine California 92620 United States 3/15/2012Elizabeth Downard Orange California 92869 United States 3/15/2012Taylor Rios Irvine California 92602 United States 3/15/2012Tony Harding Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Heshani Wijemanne Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012Mike Battin Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Elizabeth Smith Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012rick wedgeworth Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Jae Pickering Ontario California 91764 United States 3/15/2012Annette Kerr Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/15/2012Barbara Espinoza Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012kelley souter Westminster California 92683 United States 3/15/2012Krystal Cooper Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Joshua Dufour Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 3/15/2012Stephanie Devine Anaheim California 92807 United States 3/15/2012heidi orick molalla 97038 United States Mino 3/15/2012Mike Post Orange California 92867 United States 3/15/2012steve Mcfarland  Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Monica Principe Brea California 92821 United States 3/15/2012James Baldwin Balboa California 92661 United States 3/15/2012Rhoderic Lumba Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Claire  Bodenhoefer Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Vanessa Juteau Twin Peaks California 92391 United States 3/15/2012Barbara Cornelson chino hills California 91709 United States 3/15/2012Cory Murphy Irvine California 92603 United States 3/15/2012Matt Stayner Los Angeles California 90045 United States 3/15/2012Matthew Carter Santa Ana California 92701 United States 3/15/2012Lilly Luong Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/15/2012Karen Chavez Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012David Smith Carrollton Texas 75006 United States 3/15/2012Peter Phelps Long Beach California 90814 United States 3/15/2012Naneh Apkarian Irvine California 92617 United States 3/15/2012Alana Robertson Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Terrye Peterson Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Patrick Flynn Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Eric Alexander San Luis Obispo California 93401 United States 3/15/2012Anette Packer Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Linda Baker Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012Brian Hoogerbrugge Irvine California 92618 United States 3/15/2012Nicholas Mamey brooklline Massachusetts 2445 United States 3/15/2012Ana Thompson North Tustin California 92705 United States 3/15/2012Alice Apkarian Irvine California 92617‐4034 United States 3/15/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 211: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Michelle Knell Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States 3/15/2012Thomas  Washburn Irvine California 92620 United States 3/15/2012Brandon Barrett Newport Beach California 92662 United States 3/15/2012Michelle Hodge Cypress California 90630 United States 3/15/2012Greta Guyer San Diego California 92109 United States 3/15/2012ashley hickson corona del mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012andrew bielefeld irvine California 92620 United States 3/15/2012Nick Askew Eugene Oregon 97402 United States 3/15/2012Sarah Light Berkeley California 94720 United States 3/15/2012Mia Truong Midway City California 92655 United States 3/15/2012Kathryn Quiroz Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 3/15/2012James Monte lake forest California 92630 United States 3/15/2012Barry Haun San Clemente California 92673 United States 3/15/2012Justin Elizalde Garden Grove California 92840 United States 3/15/2012Ashley Opp Snowmass Village Colorado 81615 United States 3/15/2012Alex Chavira Garden Grove California 92840 United States 3/15/2012anthony mennella aliso viejo California 92656 United States 3/15/2012Terry Johnson La Habra California 90631 United States 3/15/2012Masha Chizhik Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Kali Kleinberg Orange California 92867 United States 3/15/2012kristofer allen Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Ed Cruz santa ana California 92701 United States 3/15/2012Patti Hershey Chino Hills California 91709 United States 3/15/2012Rachel Seideman Calabasas California 91302 United States 3/15/2012Kyle McFarland newport beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Ben Randall Alamo California 94507 United States 3/15/2012Dan Mazur irvine California 92614 United States 3/15/2012hunter alvarado costa mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012Sayo Taguchi Irvine California 92618 United States 3/15/2012Kelly Schlabs San Dimas California 91773 United States 3/15/2012Delane Turnet San Juan Capistrano California 92675 United States 3/15/2012Kaela Himell Orange California 92865 United States 3/15/2012Amy Powell Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Danielle King Orange California 92867 United States 3/15/2012Lindsay  Sluyters Anaheim California 92807 United States 3/15/2012Alec Fong Boston 2215 Cambodia 3/15/2012Alex Belove San Ramon California 94582 United States 3/15/2012Alexsa Cordova Garden Grove California 92841 United States 3/15/2012Janet Harker Irvine California 92614 United States 3/15/2012Ron Perry Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Robbie Caywood lakewood California 90712 United States 3/15/2012Kyla Kerr Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/15/2012Don Lindfors Orange California 92867 United States 3/15/2012Grace Jasmine Gilbert Arizona 85234 United States 3/15/2012Merritt Blake Irvine California 92614 United States 3/15/2012Janet Peters Bow Washington 98232 United States 3/15/2012Amy Aylward Bothell Washington 88021 United States 3/15/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 212: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

JOHN Deurmeier mornongo vly ca.92256 California 92256 United States 3/15/2012Tim Thein Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/15/2012Betty Schweickert Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Karine Laurent Orange California 92866 United States 3/15/2012Jeremy Ginsberg Goleta California 93117 United States 3/15/2012Shawna Shope Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 3/15/2012Shelly Malmon Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012Jenna Sample Tustin California 92780 United States 3/15/2012Matthew  McArdle San Diego California 92105 United States 3/15/2012Stacey  Cavaglieri Poway California 92064 United States 3/15/2012Elliot Bilsland Irvine California 92612 United States 3/15/2012Ian north huntington beach California 92646 United States 3/15/2012Jessica Ethell Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Christian Frost Newhall California 91321 United States 3/15/2012Trevor Twitchell Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012Solange Rousset  Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Dennis Lee Pasadena California 91101 United States 3/15/2012Duane Zobrist White Sulphur Springs West Virginia 24986 United States 3/15/2012Daniel Jongeward Brawley California 92227 United States 3/15/2012Tammy Benson Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Simon Avedissian Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012chelsea holmes Irvine California 92620 United States 3/15/2012Stacey Kelley Riverside California 92501 United States 3/15/2012Amberleigh Dancy Villa Park California 92861 United States 3/15/2012John Lunde Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/15/2012Babette Webster Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Katrina Redelsheimer Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Kelly Prime Asheville North Carolina 28804 United States 3/15/2012maura jacobsen cheyenne Wyoming 820009 United States 3/15/2012Jonathan Suite Concord California 94520 United States 3/15/2012brittany rowley Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Chad clarkChadClark Corona California 92881 United States 3/15/2012scott thomas orange California 92866 United States 3/15/2012LAURIE HERNANDEZ Norwalk California 90650 United States 3/15/2012victor martinez riveside California 92506 United States 3/15/2012Patrick Jennings Burbank California 91506 United States 3/15/2012Kellan Flores Riverside California 92505 United States 3/15/2012Max Black Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012Taylor Gonzales Riverside California 92504 United States 3/15/2012Blake Matlock Bend Oregon 97701 United States 3/15/2012Sandra  Ixta Chino California 91710 United States 3/15/2012Mary Varallo Whittier California 90603 United States 3/15/2012Misty Welle Port Orchard Washington 98366 United States 3/15/2012John Schieldge Chino California 91710 United States 3/15/2012Rex Nelson Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Marissa Frost Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Tyler Rohren RSM 92688 Cambodia 3/15/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 213: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Michael Gracia Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Patricia  Van HelfterenStanton California 90680 United States 3/15/2012Meredith Mandel Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Jarred Stetser Tempe Arizona 85282 United States 3/15/2012William  Douglass Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Nick Heimer La Mirada California 90638 United States 3/15/2012Tonya Lewis Big Bear City California 92314 United States 3/15/2012Peter Finch NEWPORT BEACH California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Dan Devine Irvine California 92618 United States 3/15/2012Jessica Welham Irvine California 92606 United States 3/15/2012Carrie Coffman Long Beach California 90802 United States 3/15/2012wendy mosley Beaverton Oregon 97007 United States 3/15/2012Tyler Lee Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/15/2012adam baydu San Juan Capistrano California 92675 United States 3/15/2012Rick Ross Irvine California 92606 United States 3/15/2012Gilberto Ramirez Anaheim California 92802 United States 3/15/2012Cambria  Mansfield Newport beach California 92662 United States 3/15/2012Mitchell Gray Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012kevin botenhagen big bear lake California 92315 United States 3/15/2012shirin tale‐yazdi Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Tamara Franklin Elkhornf Nebraska 68022 United States 3/15/2012Sarah Baugher Irvine California 92618 United States 3/15/2012tim peterson lake elsinore California 92530 United States 3/15/2012claudia gassin Irvline California 92620 United States 3/15/2012Tawnya Pataky Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 3/15/2012Tommy Newton‐Neal Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012KelLy Yesia Fullerton California 92835 United States 3/15/2012Marina Chizhik Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Amy Bering Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 3/15/2012Mark Adams Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Andrew  Britton  Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Ed McDonald Santa Ana California 92707 United States 3/15/2012Tara Poulsen Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 3/15/2012Tomoko Lee Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/15/2012Jessica McNair San Diego California 92104 United States 3/15/2012Curtis Jackson New York New York 21906 United States 3/15/2012Joe Varga Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/15/2012Andree Patti Placentia California 92870 United States 3/15/2012Kevin Montecinos Goose Creek South Carolina 29445 United States 3/15/2012Laura Myers San Juan Capistrano California 92675 United States 3/15/2012Brian  Stewart Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012David Becker irvine California 92612 United States 3/15/2012alex rahmani irvine California 92618 United States 3/15/2012Weatherford Clayton Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Frances Burke Davis California 95616 United States 3/15/2012Robin Ward Half moon Bay California 94019 United States 3/15/2012Laura Leith irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 214: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Wesley Hockinson Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Jon Rauterkus Capistrano Beach California 92624 United States 3/15/2012John Terrell Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Aubrey Anderson San Clemente California 92672 United States 3/15/2012angela zendejas lake forest California 92630 United States 3/15/2012Kelly Kelly Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012Deborah  Leung Rocklin California 95765 United States 3/15/2012Kyle Hojem Irvine California 92614 United States 3/15/2012Jarond Suman Pleasant Grove Utah 84062 United States 3/15/2012scott mickelson quincy California 95971 United States 3/15/2012Ashley Lawrence Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012Susan Stayner Kaysville Utah 84037 United States 3/15/2012Laura Lettieri Fullerton California 92835 United States 3/15/2012Lisa kling Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Stephanie Player Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Michelle Mortensen Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Linda Geanados Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Becki Judge Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Ana Jimenez Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/15/2012jeremy hong La Habra California 90631 United States 3/15/2012Kevin Nguyen Irvine California 92617 United States 3/15/2012david noel costa mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Angela Strom Huntington Beach California 92649 United States 3/15/2012Bernadette  Macias Redlands California 92374 United States 3/15/2012David McKinnon New Port Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Kirby Burnham Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Daniel Picciotto Culver city California 90230 United States 3/15/2012Connor McDonald Orange California 92866 United States 3/15/2012Anna Milkovits Riverside California 92505 United States 3/15/2012aubrey delano garden grove California 92845 United States 3/15/2012Aubrey DeLano Garden Grove California 92845 United States 3/15/2012Ryan Aubrey long beach California 90802 United States 3/15/2012Tyler  Sivero San Diego California 92110 United States 3/15/2012Tawny Phelps Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Amanda Young Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/15/2012chris bindloss irvine California 92620 United States 3/15/2012Nick benson Patton California 92369 United States 3/15/2012Barbara Morihiro Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Jared Raymond Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012Allison Fife danville California 94526 United States 3/15/2012Shannon Brennan Balboa California 92661 United States 3/15/2012Emil  Davis Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/15/2012Lance  Hutchins Riverside California 92507 United States 3/15/2012Sally Weber Bend Oregon 97701 United States 3/15/2012Rachel Turney Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Paula McCabe Ladera Ranch California 92694 United States 3/15/2012Charlotte Roberts Van Nuys California 91405 United States 3/15/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 215: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Vincent  Simmon Newport Coast 92657 United States Mino 3/15/2012Dawn Krosby Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 3/15/2012Jessica Sanford Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 3/15/2012Regina Jennings Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Katherine Smith Yuma 85365 United States 3/15/2012Brie Jenkins Irvine California 92620 United States 3/15/2012Erika Diotalevi Greenwood Indiana 46143 United States 3/15/2012Brian Stephens Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Allison Hecht Irvine California 92603 United States 3/15/2012Denise Sale Yorba Linda California 92887 United States 3/15/2012Melissa Avila Madrid 92627 Spain 3/15/2012kacey Klein Los Angeles California 90005 United States 3/15/2012michel montmorency Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Sylvia Nguyen Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/15/2012Brian Wiseman Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Raven Goode Riverside California 92504 United States 3/15/2012Jessica Deback Riverside California 92503 United States 3/15/2012Allan Cook Duarte California 91010 United States 3/15/2012Michael Brannon Carroll Valley Pennsylvania 17320 United States 3/15/2012Steve Rhoads Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Jennifer Gray Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012John Schiesser Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/15/2012Daniel Bskin Anaheim California 92807 United States 3/15/2012Karissa Chavez Anaheim California 92805 United States 3/15/2012Kelly Haggard Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Lexie Shah Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Johnny Herrera Long Beach California 90810 United States 3/15/2012Frank Carpenter Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Brooke Briggs Irvine California 92618 United States 3/15/2012Alan Haggard San Diego California 92105‐5104 United States 3/15/2012Branen Munson yucaipa California 92399 United States 3/15/2012Tatiana Rivera Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 3/15/2012corey coreyruston Fallbrook California 92028 United States 3/15/2012Rose Shaw Colton California 92324 United States 3/15/2012Dang Nguyen Irvine California 92617 United States 3/15/2012adam young aliso viejo California 92656 United States 3/15/2012Kari Hall Newport Beach California 92662 United States 3/15/2012Alyssa Hamilton Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Kevin Clark Newport Beach California 92662 United States 3/15/2012Christopher Stone Laguna Niguel California 92677 United States 3/15/2012Monica Kerr Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012liz villalobos Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/15/2012Martin Fredericks St. Thomas Virgin Islands 804 United States 3/15/2012Jessica  McClafferty Virginia Beach Virginia 23451 United States 3/15/2012Don Thompson Ontario California 91761 United States 3/15/2012David Boyd Whittier California 90603 United States 3/15/2012Dean Propst San Diego California 92111 United States 3/15/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 216: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Damian Shirk Knoxville Tennessee 37919 United States 3/15/2012Akane Everitt Tustin California 92782 United States 3/15/2012Lauren Valantine Orange California 92869 United States 3/15/2012Tracy Kerley Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Dale Bremner Irvine California 92602 United States 3/15/2012Daniel Gallegly Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 3/15/2012jacquelyn roberts costa mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Kari Vespia Santa Ana California 92707 United States 3/15/2012Pauline Duarte Long Beach California 90808 United States 3/15/2012bill bangert, jr Orange California 92868 United States 3/15/2012Victor Pham Tustin California 92780 United States 3/15/2012jessica jeffreys orange ca California 92865 United States 3/15/2012sandra. rodriguez Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/15/2012Don DeMooy Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Jean Herbst Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012James Whitehouse Irvine California 92618 United States 3/15/2012CHRIS WESTPHAL Redwood City California 94062‐2258 United States 3/15/2012Fred Hurst Fullerton California 92832 United States 3/15/2012Caitlin Sogoian Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012steve griggs anaheim California 92804 United States 3/15/2012Lorenza Robbins Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Robert Pfister SANTA ANA California 92705 United States 3/15/2012Yvonne Villegas Riverside California 92507 United States 3/15/2012Steve Struck Capistrano Beach California 92624 United States 3/15/2012Judi Baumgartner Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 3/15/2012ROSALIA MALDONADOTUJUNGA California 91042 United States 3/15/2012LaUra Mitsch Lahaina Hawaii 96761 United States 3/15/2012cynde gannaway brea California 92821 United States 3/15/2012diana molinari san pedro 90731 United States Mino 3/15/2012Erika DiMeo kissimmee Florida 34741 United States 3/15/2012Patrick Danforth Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 3/15/2012Grete Howland Glendale California 91206 United States 3/15/2012Sara Cunningham Anaheim California 92805 United States 3/15/2012William Haggard Riverside California 92506 United States 3/15/2012Bridget Doonan Irvine California 92612 United States 3/15/2012Matthew Hogan thousand oaks California 91360 United States 3/15/2012Cynthia Hiland Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Mary Mintle Grants Pass Oregon 97526 United States 3/15/2012Doris Haggard Riverside California 92506 United States 3/15/2012Lizeth Zamora Santa Ana California 92701 United States 3/15/2012Conrado Geronimo Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 3/15/2012Erika Torres Stanton California 90680 United States 3/15/2012Scott Neally Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/15/2012Paula Ganninger Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Cynthia Robinson Bass Lake California 93604 United States 3/15/2012Carlos Hernandez Santa Ana California 92701 United States 3/15/2012Susan Manzer Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/15/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 217: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

tom savage Diamond Springs California 95619 United States 3/15/2012Aaron Cohen Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Karol  Murphy Seal Beach California 90740 United States 3/15/2012mel olsob Garden Grove California 92845 United States 3/15/2012Alex Kerr Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/15/2012George Grayson Cincinnati Ohio 45209 United States 3/15/2012Lilian Crawford Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/15/2012Craig Kessinger Vista California 92084 United States 3/15/2012Gregory R  Smith Tesuque New Mexico 87574 United States 3/15/2012Sally Van Horn Whittier California 90604 United States 3/15/2012Kimi Kawaguchi Tustin California 92782 United States 3/15/2012Camie Thompson Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Charles Prince Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 3/15/2012Beth Malloy Palo Cedro California 96073 United States 3/15/2012Bonnie PAPA Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012alexandra torres Irvine California 92620 United States 3/15/2012BILL MELLON Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 3/15/2012hiver alvear Anaheim California 92805 United States 3/15/2012Bekie Olson Garden Grove California 92845 United States 3/15/2012Lauran Huff Los Angeles California 90048 United States 3/15/2012Greg Helin West Hills California 91307 United States 3/15/2012Mandy Medrick Irvine California 92606 United States 3/15/2012Roxanne Robles Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Christy Hatrick Santa Ana California 92707 United States 3/15/2012Alex Petrosian Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Gaby Timsit irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012Joseph  McArthur Irvine California 92612 United States 3/15/2012Kimberly Smedeby Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Ashley  Sharp Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Elaine Vasquez Eastvale California 92880 United States 3/15/2012Nico Fish Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012landon carpenter newport beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012dana huffman Westminster California 92683 United States 3/15/2012amanda milligna orange California 92869 United States 3/15/2012Gabrielle  Ray  Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 3/15/2012Kyle Kleckner New Orleans Louisiana 70122 United States 3/15/2012karla  petatan Santa Ana California 92707 United States 3/15/2012jaime esquivel Santa Ana California 92701 United States 3/15/2012Stephanie Ainsworth Irvine California 92614 United States 3/15/2012Tara Lanigan San Juan Capistrano California 92675 United States 3/15/2012Diana Martin El Monte California 91731 United States 3/15/2012Jewelly Hart Anaheim California 92807 United States 3/15/2012Virginia Rimbach Crockett California 94525 United States 3/15/2012Lydia Marinos Carlsbad California 92011 United States 3/15/2012Jack  Skahen Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/15/2012Jeff Elkins Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/15/2012shauna trute los alamitos California 90720 United States 3/15/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 218: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Cortney Veenker Mammoth Lakes California 93546 United States 3/15/2012Matt Butterworth Irvine California 92614 United States 3/15/2012Candy York Buellton California 93427 United States 3/15/2012Steve Baker Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Donnella Andraos Irvine California 92606 United States 3/15/2012Stephen Murphy Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/15/2012Caroline Sauter Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Kelly Potts Charlotte North Carolina 28213 United States 3/15/2012Gwen Scott Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012delaram danesh irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012Daniel Venegas Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Julia Zuniga Santa Ana California 92701 United States 3/15/2012abby herbert Kansas City Missouri 64106 United States 3/15/2012freddy castelan Anaheim California 92806 United States 3/15/2012Brock Schuler Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/15/2012Richard Pharo  Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/15/2012Ellen Peck Irvine California 92617 United States 3/15/2012Angela Konno Garden Grove California 92844 United States 3/15/2012Anthony Grace sacramento California 95835 United States 3/15/2012Aaron Lynn Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 3/15/2012Michael Burbank Irvine California 92604 United States 3/15/2012Jessica Jones Fountain Valley California 92708 United States 3/15/2012Carolyn Warren Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/15/2012Malin Fletcher Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/15/2012Robbie Patterson Potomac Maryland 20854 United States 3/16/2012Blake Whitcomb Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/16/2012Jamie Anthinisen Bluffton South Carolina 29910 United States 3/16/2012Omeid Heidari Irvine California 92617 United States 3/16/2012Kathy Temple Vrebalo Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012Renee Soria Riverside California 92503 United States 3/16/2012Xavier Alvarez Pico Rivera California 90660 United States 3/16/2012Mackenzie Cooper capistrano beach California 92624 United States 3/16/2012Kimberley Appleby Lake Elsinore California 92530 United States 3/16/2012mark hueppelsheuser newport beach California 92661 United States 3/16/2012Karen Flores Corona California 92879 United States 3/16/2012Ryan Borda Irvine California 92620‐1847 United States 3/16/2012Raphael Salazar‐GarciaMoreno Valley California 92553 United States 3/16/2012Julie Wooden Santa Ana California 92706 United States 3/16/2012Stephanie Anderson Whittier California 90604 United States 3/16/2012Shane Duggan irvine California 92604 United States 3/16/2012sandy de young Newport beach California 92663 United States 3/16/2012HARUN OZKAN CORONA California 92880 United States 3/16/2012Terri Haikalis Anaheim Hills California 92808 United States 3/16/2012Karmen Wong Rosemead California 91770 United States 3/16/2012Ashley Kim Irvine California 92606 United States 3/16/2012tim harold newport beach California 92663 United States 3/16/2012Glenn Parrish Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/16/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 219: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Suzanne Thomas Altadena California 91001 United States 3/16/2012Sally Lu Irvine California 92617 United States 3/16/2012Brad Yau Arcadia California 91006 United States 3/16/2012Morgan Webster costa mesa California 92627 United States 3/16/2012Andrew Trout Corona California 92880 United States 3/16/2012Barry Liu Arcadia California 91007 United States 3/16/2012Benjamin Wu Stanton California 90680 United States 3/16/2012tracy ewing Balboa California 92662 United States 3/16/2012Alma Fausto Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/16/2012Shannon Green Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012Taft Rattanavipapong San Gabriel California 91775 United States 3/16/2012Tim Harold Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/16/2012Angela Graham Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012Michelle LeFort Trabuco Canyon California 92679 United States 3/16/2012kenia fuentes Santa Ana California 92701 United States 3/16/2012brad franco orange California 92869 United States 3/16/2012Anne‐Marie Larsen Temecula California 92592 United States 3/16/2012nathan lynch cerritos California 90703 United States 3/16/2012diana mendoza costa mesa California 92627 United States 3/16/2012Shannon Hynes Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 3/16/2012Taylor McCormack Orange California 92866 United States 3/16/2012Dan Flinn Glendale Arizona 85308 United States 3/16/2012Kira Anderson newport coast California 92657 United States 3/16/2012michelle allen corona California 92880 United States 3/16/2012andy luong fountain valley California 92708 United States 3/16/2012George Chiao Industry California 91748 United States 3/16/2012Tiffany Young Irvine California 92612 United States 3/16/2012Ariane Frost Salt Lake City Utah 84111 United States 3/16/2012Eric Liu Arcadia California 91007 United States 3/16/2012Donna Anderson newport coasr California 92657 United States 3/16/2012Daniel Eccles Orange California 92868 United States 3/16/2012Amy Lese Trabuco Canyon California 92679 United States 3/16/2012spencer song irvine California 92612 United States 3/16/2012Tiffany Chan Arcadia California 91007 United States 3/16/2012doug  Anderson Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/16/2012geneva peck pruitt san gabriel California 91778 United States 3/16/2012Priscilla Lu Long Beach California 90804 United States 3/16/2012Ryan  Anderson Tempe Arizona 85281 United States 3/16/2012cheryl hubka Anaheim California 92802 United States 3/16/2012Josh Hanson Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/16/2012Sylvia Suh new bern North Carolina 28562 United States 3/16/2012pamela sargeant newport beach California 92663 United States 3/16/2012mike kang la habra California 90631 United States 3/16/2012Harrison Chen Irvine California 92614 United States 3/16/2012krista holquin Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/16/2012John Virata Westminster California 92683 United States 3/16/2012Hsuan Lin Irvine California 92606 United States 3/16/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 220: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Ron Tanase NY New York 10011 United States 3/16/2012Steven Yampolsky Irvine California 92612 United States 3/16/2012Stanley Ku Arcadia California 91006 United States 3/16/2012Pieter Drahn Petaluma California 94954 United States 3/16/2012CHRISTOPHER LLOYD‐ CORONA DEL MAR California 92625 United States 3/16/2012Iris Yang Arcadia California 91006 United States 3/16/2012celestine ernst claremont California 91711 United States 3/16/2012Jade Turney Tustin California 92782 United States 3/16/2012Dulce Sotelo Goleta California 93117 United States 3/16/2012Bree Vought Irvine California 92604 United States 3/16/2012Melody Chi Tustin California 92782 United States 3/16/2012Tyler Haikalis Anaheim Hills California 92808 United States 3/16/2012Victoria Bryant Tustin California 92780 United States 3/16/2012Rex Yarwood Irvine California 92602 United States 3/16/2012Mark Urkov Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 3/16/2012Heather Adams Tyrone New Mexico 88065 United States 3/16/2012Rachel Yelsey Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012Ryan Dupuie Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012Brian Boyle Newport Beach California 82661 United States 3/16/2012Tiffany Hernandez Playa Del Rey California 90293 United States 3/16/2012Laura Bilder Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012Meghan Fitzgerald Wildomar California 92595 United States 3/16/2012STEVEN LEE westminster California 92683 United States 3/16/2012Aline Papazian Albuquerque New Mexico 87122 United States 3/16/2012Lilja Addeman Costa Mesa 92627 United States Mino 3/16/2012Chris Doble Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 3/16/2012Todd Aldama Irvine California 92604 United States 3/16/2012James Bayley Costa Mesa 92627 United States Mino 3/16/2012Kristin  Becerra  Hesperia California 92345 United States 3/16/2012Jeffrey Tanner Playa Del Rey California 90293 United States 3/16/2012Debbie Davis Yucca Valley California 92284 United States 3/16/2012Desiree McDermott yorba Linda California 92886 United States 3/16/2012Lori‐Lyn  Gonzales Nuevo California 92567 United States 3/16/2012Elle Wood Austin Texas 78734 United States 3/16/2012Elise Shickler Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/16/2012Jeffrey Tran Westminster California 92683 United States 3/16/2012Sarah  Brayton Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/16/2012Louis Louis Orange California 92865 United States 3/16/2012Diane VonDerAhe Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012Mike Liu San Diego California 92122 United States 3/16/2012Suzanne Hanks Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012samantha welle 3/16/2012Shelly Scott CDM 92625 United States Mino 3/16/2012IaN Powers Corona California 92879 United States 3/16/2012Steve Bjorkman Irvine California 92603 United States 3/16/2012Regina Livesay Hermosa Beach California 90254 United States 3/16/2012Eric Polyn San Diego California 92104 United States 3/16/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 221: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Amit Silverstein Irvine California 92618 United States 3/16/2012Brent Richards Garden Grove California 92845 United States 3/16/2012Thomas Dennis Fox River Grove Illinois 60021 United States 3/16/2012Emily Chen Berkeley California 94705 United States 3/16/2012Gilda Garcia North Hollywood California 91601 United States 3/16/2012Sara Schirmer Balboa 92661 United States Mino 3/16/2012Christine Planchon Redlands California 92373 United States 3/16/2012Brad Adkins Irvine California 92602 United States 3/16/2012Geno Adair Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012KAREN HOOGERBRUG Corona California 92879 United States 3/16/2012John Woodruff Costa Mesa, California 92627 United States 3/16/2012Brian Carbone Newport Beach California 92662 United States 3/16/2012William Lee Tujunga California 91042 United States 3/16/2012Barbara Klinger Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012Jordan Mo San Gabriel California 91776 United States 3/16/2012Andrei Toma Glendale California 91206 United States 3/16/2012PENNIE HUGHES SHAWNEE Oklahoma 74804 United States 3/16/2012johnny  dip el monte California 91733 United States 3/16/2012Chris Caines RSM California 92688 United States 3/16/2012Danny Dreyer Irvine California 92618 United States 3/16/2012DANNY Ngo GARDEN GROVE California 92843 United States 3/16/2012Robert Wolfshagen Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 3/16/2012Bo Taylor Los Angeles California 90034 United States 3/16/2012Christine Watkins Anaheim California 92803 United States 3/16/2012Kelly Sawyer Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/16/2012Bryon Barker Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/16/2012Hugh Thomas Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 3/16/2012Henry Ha Rosemead 91770 Uganda 3/16/2012Taylor Stein Agoura California 91301 United States 3/16/2012k feldmann Brea California 92821 United States 3/16/2012Anne Yelsey Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012Gavin Juteau Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 3/16/2012Katherine Lansford San Marcos California 92069 United States 3/16/2012jessica scism newport beach California 92661 United States 3/16/2012Celine  DeGuire Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012Aimee Morgan Dana Point California 92629 United States 3/16/2012Chris Carpenter Kalama Washington 98625 United States 3/16/2012Gayle Lipson Anaheim California 92806 United States 3/16/2012Arin brown Chantilly Virginia 20151 United States 3/16/2012Brian Winters newport beach California 92663 United States 3/16/2012Peter Annabel Chino Hills California 91709 United States 3/16/2012Matthew Goethals Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012Ian Young Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/16/2012Aaron Israel Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012Stacey Manning Birmingham Alabama 35244 United States 3/16/2012Erica Galvez Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012Daniel Clemens  Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/16/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 222: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Jeffrey  Riggs Eastvale California 91752 United States 3/16/2012Ken Tabacchi Irvine California 92620 United States 3/16/2012Davyn Louis Tustin California 92780 United States 3/16/2012Richard Morris Salinas California 93901 United States 3/16/2012Wendy  Nevitt Tustin California 92780 United States 3/16/2012Deanna whitaker Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 3/16/2012Tim Grogan Bethel Ohio 45106 United States 3/16/2012Laura  Sigrist  Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/16/2012Julie Otott Trabuco Canyon California 92679 United States 3/16/2012Karen Jones Kihei Hawaii 96753 United States 3/16/2012brendan baggs irvine California 92604 United States 3/16/2012Catherine Carpenter Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012Denise Smeltzer Shingle Springs California 95682 United States 3/16/2012Alfred Slim Lake forest California 92630 United States 3/16/2012matt courtney Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/16/2012Rick Campbell Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/16/2012jimmy ngo Oxnard California 93030 United States 3/16/2012joe carafello Los Angeles California 90048 United States 3/16/2012mark yeterian newport beach California 92661 United States 3/16/2012Alec Marken Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 3/16/2012Suzanne Predney San Diego California 92110 United States 3/16/2012henry vuong South El Monte California 91733 United States 3/16/2012Robert Lovell Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/16/2012terry luttrell corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012Adrian Anhood Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012Allegra Batista Orange California 92866 United States 3/16/2012Harrison Pham Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/16/2012Lee Hernandez Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/16/2012Annetta Bettis Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 3/16/2012Megan Bunch Kaysville Utah 84037 United States 3/16/2012William Hale Garden Grove California 9284 United States 3/16/2012Matthew Picard Palmdale California 93551 United States 3/16/2012brenda padilla Beverly Hills California 90211 United States 3/16/2012Zach Willner irvine California 92620 United States 3/16/2012Susan Burke Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/16/2012Cory Leaders Las Vegas Nevada 89123 United States 3/16/2012Andrew Webb Garden Grove California 92840 United States 3/16/2012Jennifer Barnette Santa Ana California 92707 United States 3/16/2012Lisa Piraino Laguna Niguel California 92677 United States 3/16/2012Andrew Brown Irvine California 92603 United States 3/16/2012Alexis Wong Arcadia California 91007 United States 3/16/2012stefanie cox‐derryberrCorona California 92879 United States 3/16/2012Samuel Jih Hacienda Heights California 91745 United States 3/16/2012Nancy Eklof Reno Nevada 89509 United States 3/16/2012Christine Alanis IRVINE California 92612‐8574 United States 3/16/2012Kathy Contreras Garden Grove California 92843 United States 3/16/2012JOSEPH RENFRO LONG BEACH California 90810 United States 3/16/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 223: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Hartmut Luecke Irvine California 92617 United States 3/16/2012Alicia Jensen Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012Vicki Gray Santa Ana California 92799 United States 3/16/2012Mary Park sylmar California 91342 United States 3/16/2012phillip cha northridge California 91326 United States 3/16/2012Susan Freitas Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012bob molinaro newport beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012Joy Nussen Timsit Irvine California 92604 United States 3/16/2012christina aranda Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 3/16/2012Cindy Christeson Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012Ryan McDonald Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012Christine Wang Irvine California 92614 United States 3/16/2012mary stearns lake elsinore California 92530 United States 3/16/2012Malissa tem Cerritos California 90703 United States 3/16/2012brittany harris Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/16/2012Alex Gaynor Anaheim California 92808 United States 3/16/2012April Strong Balboa California 92661 United States 3/16/2012Rebecca Magdaleno Buena Park California 90620 United States 3/16/2012Jeffrey Stevens SAN CLEMENTE California 92672 United States 3/16/2012Meilynda Herbst Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 3/16/2012Ryan Ly Santa Ana California 92704 United States 3/16/2012Rene Powers Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/16/2012Yessenia Garcia Garden Grove California 92844 United States 3/16/2012Patrick Sims Irvine California 92617 United States 3/16/2012Frank Flores Whittier California 90601 United States 3/16/2012Elizabeth Diz Corona California 92882 United States 3/16/2012Brad Dupuie Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012kim brennan Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012Mackenzie Conover Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/16/2012Brandon Rego Irvine California 92604 United States 3/16/2012Nicole Barnes Rancho Santa Margarita California 92688 United States 3/16/2012Cindy Cowlin Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 3/16/2012rana sabeh Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 3/16/2012Connie Munn Anaheim California 92804 United States 3/16/2012Dean  Sexton  Riverside California 92503 United States 3/16/2012Colby Stearns Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012ENDER  OZKAN CORONA California 92880 United States 3/16/2012Mia Ogletree Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/16/2012Robbi Forbes Santa Ana California 92704 United States 3/16/2012Ashley  Neff Newport Beach California 92662 United States 3/16/2012angelica morga NUEVO California 92567 United States 3/16/2012Randy Guyer Palm Desert California 92260 United States 3/16/2012Matt Manni Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012Patrick Murphy Richardson Texas 75080 United States 3/16/2012Patrick Capilouto Huntington Beach California 92649 United States 3/16/2012Patsee Ober Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 3/16/2012Zack Caldwell Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/16/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 224: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Jeanette Fisher Fullerton California 92831 United States 3/16/2012Sylvia Reyes anaheim California 92802 United States 3/16/2012Andrew Olsin Huntington Beach California 92649 United States 3/16/2012Pamela Mayhew Signal Hill California 90755‐1055 United States 3/16/2012Kari Brooner Park City Utah 84098 United States 3/16/2012Tammy Nguyen Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/16/2012Paul Neff Corona del Mar California 92660 United States 3/16/2012Meg Broad Orange California 92867 United States 3/16/2012whitney hendrickson 92663 3/16/2012Deegie  Phelps Tustin California 92780 United States 3/16/2012Markus Dreseler Irvine California 92617 United States 3/16/2012Nick Gingold corona del mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012Michelle Miller Santa Ana California 92703 United States 3/16/2012Gennaro Pignataro Garden Grove California 92843 United States 3/16/2012Dasha Holubec West Hollywood California 90069 United States 3/16/2012Meaghan Bunney Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/16/2012Jenni Seager Palmdale California 93551 United States 3/16/2012Holly Kennedy Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/16/2012Steven Luu Temple City California 91780 United States 3/16/2012Erin Lee Santa Ana California 92795 United States 3/16/2012Matt Remick Rancho Cucamonga California 91739 United States 3/16/2012Guy Barker San Juan Capistrano California 92675 United States 3/16/2012Ann Endicott Tustin California 92780 United States 3/16/2012Susan DiFlorio Anaheim California 92804 United States 3/16/2012Cody Jensen Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/16/2012Steve Weatherly Dana Point California 92629 United States 3/16/2012daniela tamone borgosesia 13100 Italy 3/16/2012Jeff Suchy Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 3/16/2012Diana Thompson Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/16/2012Dana Owad San Diego California 92110 United States 3/16/2012Norm Manalac Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 3/16/2012Kathleen Herman La Mirada California 90638 United States 3/16/2012Bob Gomez Tustin California 92780 United States 3/16/2012Maricela Gomez santa ana California 92704 United States 3/16/2012Elizabeth del Valle Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/16/2012dutch lamons corona dek mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012paul savage diamond springs California 95619 United States 3/16/2012Ron Davis Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012Lauren Timeus Tustin California 92782 United States 3/16/2012Josh Goldstein Irvine California 92614 United States 3/16/2012Ashley Eskew Yorba Linda California 92887 United States 3/16/2012Steve Vaughn Long Beach California 90814 United States 3/16/2012Rochelle O'Donnell Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/16/2012Brian Duggan Garden Grove California 92843 United States 3/16/2012Olivia Clement San Francisco California 94115 United States 3/16/2012Coral Mestas Temecula California 92592 United States 3/16/2012Tyler Dunigan Orange California 92867 United States 3/16/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 225: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Chris Hooker Orange California 92869 United States 3/16/2012Josh Yelsey Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012Sabrina Garde Tustin California 92780 United States 3/16/2012SULTAN OZKAN CORONA California 92880 United States 3/16/2012Anji Young Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012Angela Williams Bend Oregon 97701 United States 3/16/2012Bernice Gross berkeley California 94703 United States 3/16/2012Melissa Raum Ladera Ranch California 92694 United States 3/16/2012Jon Chan Arcadia California 91007 United States 3/16/2012Susie Matta Irvine California 92606 United States 3/16/2012Carl Mead Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 3/16/2012Tom Akoury Simi Valley California 93063 United States 3/16/2012Susan Peck Sunnyvale California 94086 United States 3/16/2012shanni hanein solana beach California 92075 United States 3/16/2012Sheer Best Irvine California 92696 United States 3/16/2012Kelsey Conover Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012Pamela Saxton Turlock California 95380 United States 3/16/2012Bill Weeshoff Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012Lisa Marie Murtagh Rancho Cordova California 95742 United States 3/16/2012Mike Giamalva Ocean Springs Mississippi 39564 United States 3/16/2012Deborah Porto Villa Park California 92861 United States 3/16/2012taylor tosh long Beach California 90802 United States 3/16/2012Christopher Campbell Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 3/16/2012Kevin Lu Irvine California 92617 United States 3/16/2012thanh le santa ana California 92704 United States 3/16/2012Denise Edgell Westminster California 92684 United States 3/16/2012Carol Fisher Greenville South Carolina 29605 United States 3/16/2012lindsay hadland Irvine California 92604 United States 3/16/2012Tamara Thomas Altadena California 91001 United States 3/16/2012Vivian Ly Santa Ana California 92704 United States 3/16/2012Carolyn Carter Rancho Santa Margarita California 92679 United States 3/16/2012Brandon Evangelista Toronto m3j1r9 Canada 3/16/2012Jenna Douglass San Francisco California 94118 United States 3/16/2012peter sellas Kilauea Hawaii 96754 United States 3/16/2012peyman heydari newport beach California 92663 United States 3/16/2012Danny Nguyen SANTA ANA California 92704‐5044 United States 3/16/2012Penny Lee Irvine California 92612 United States 3/16/2012Marta  Hullihen Laguna Niguel California 92677 United States 3/16/2012Rachel Lane Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012Alex Kiskachi Irvine California 92603 United States 3/16/2012Gail Moss Borgosesia 13011 Italy 3/16/2012Paulette Persails Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012Vickie Pearson Hacienda Heights California 91745 United States 3/16/2012Ed DeMask Batavia Illinois 60510 United States 3/16/2012Anne Maynard Irvine California 92603 United States 3/16/2012Tim McGrath Thousand Oaks California 91361 United States 3/16/2012Michael Bass High Point North Carolina 27265 United States 3/16/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 226: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Andrea Rodriguez Goleta California 93117 United States 3/16/2012miguel garibay irvine California 92620 United States 3/16/2012Jenette Brannon Huntington Beach California 92649 United States 3/16/2012Frances French Buffalo, N.Y. New York 14222 United States 3/16/2012Suba Dread Tucson Arizona 85712 United States 3/16/2012Brian DeCair mission Viejo California 92692 United States 3/16/2012John Sparre Charlotte North Carolina 28277 United States 3/16/2012Kathryn Chew La Canada California 91011 United States 3/16/2012Eric Glenn Bluffton South Carolina 29910 United States 3/16/2012enrique palacios long beach California 90802 United States 3/16/2012Joelle Escoe Orange California 92866 United States 3/16/2012Christina Hunter Scottsdale Arizona 85255 United States 3/16/2012Heidi Edmunds Batimore Maryland 21202 United States 3/16/2012Brad Johnson Santa Ana California 92704 United States 3/16/2012lisa todd McKinney Texas 75070 United States 3/16/2012Anita Delgado Lake Elsinore California 92530 United States 3/16/2012jeri carey irvine California 92604 United States 3/16/2012Robert Schooler Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/16/2012Dan Wiseman Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012Malcolm Gault‐WilliamSanta Barbara California 93105 United States 3/16/2012Kristen Farish Torrance California 90504 United States 3/16/2012Jackie Finamore Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/16/2012Todd Jafvert Perry Iowa 50220 United States 3/16/2012Danaer Brewste Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/16/2012Daniel Neben Irvine California 92612 United States 3/16/2012Kylen Sharpe Nashville 37212 United Arab Emirate 3/16/2012Michelle Hancock Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/16/2012Josh Yelsey Chicago Illinois United States 3/16/2012kush dennis tustin California 92780 United States 3/16/2012Nicole  Donoso Orange California 92869 United States 3/16/2012Darren Santos Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 3/16/2012Gary Albert San Clemente California 92673 United States 3/16/2012Ed Weaver Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 3/16/2012Anne Appleby Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/16/2012Christy Greene Riverside California 92508 United States 3/16/2012Michael Ginther Tustin California 92780 United States 3/16/2012Jeff  Roundy Whittier California 90603 United States 3/16/2012Mary Andrulaitis Santa Barbara California 93105 United States 3/16/2012Dennis Flynn Salt Lake City Utah 84106 United States 3/16/2012Matt Earl Woodland Hills California 91364 United States 3/16/2012Cheryl Paulson Corona California 92879 United States 3/16/2012Merry Knowles Pasadena California 91104 United States 3/16/2012Sharon Tisdale LagUna Beach California 92651 United States 3/16/2012Linda Scholle Irvine California 92604 United States 3/16/2012Albert Mosley Corona California 92882 United States 3/16/2012greg person costa mesa California 92627 United States 3/16/2012Ryan Hernandez Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/16/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 227: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

michael mcaleer midway city California 92655 United States 3/16/2012Michele Thiel Orange California 92869 United States 3/16/2012charles vaughan temple City California 91780 United States 3/16/2012Amy DavIs Denton Texas 76207 United States 3/16/2012Sherry Sumner Newport Beach California 92662 United States 3/16/2012Marianne Stewart Irvine California 92620 United States 3/16/2012Marianna Sumina Mountain View California 94040 United States 3/16/2012Linda Swartz Orange California 92866 United States 3/16/2012Christopher Duey Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012Malorie Caldwell Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/16/2012Holly Files Mission Viejo California 92692 United States 3/16/2012KARLA helms frazier Midway City California 92655 United States 3/16/2012Robert Kelly Balboa Island California 92663 United States 3/16/2012Velda Chan Arcadia California 91006 United States 3/16/2012Diana Colline Tustin California 92782 United States 3/16/2012Martin Kemper Irvine California 92617 United States 3/16/2012christine petersen Newport Coast California 92675 United States 3/16/2012Kathy Henry Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/16/2012Lee  Wald Tarzana California 91356 United States 3/16/2012Nancy Mooslin Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/16/2012Douglas Reid Tustin California 92780 United States 3/16/2012Tom Picard Fillmore California 93015 United States 3/16/2012Shawn Millbern Trabuco Canyon California 92679 United States 3/16/2012Scott Samuel Mission Viejo California 92692 United States 3/16/2012Myra Neben Irvine California 92604 United States 3/16/2012Asdrig Vehian Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/16/2012daniel brown irvine California 92603 United States 3/16/2012John Chaffin Corona California 92879 United States 3/16/2012Richard  Dutch Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/16/2012Chris  Silva Irvine California 92620 United States 3/16/2012Juan Olivares santa ana California 92701 United States 3/16/2012anna leyenaar mission viejo California 92691 United States 3/16/2012James Bottom Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012brandon marshall Sacramento California 95820 United States 3/16/2012Robert  Long Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 3/16/2012christine limon claremont California 91711 United States 3/16/2012Craig Anderson Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/16/2012Nicholas Tsu Los Angeles California 90025 United States 3/16/2012Michael Di sano Newport Beach California 92662 United States 3/16/2012Lisa  Miles  Huntington Beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012Jennifer Rodriguez Irvine California 92604 United States 3/16/2012amanda whipple Dana Point California 92629 United States 3/16/2012Justin hupp Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012jon worsham Buena Park California 90620 United States 3/16/2012Katherine Bon Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/16/2012Amber Carrillo Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 3/16/2012Cesar Duran Santa Ana California 92707 United States 3/16/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 228: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Leslie Dean Irvine California 92603 United States 3/16/2012Phuong Bui Westminster California 92683 United States 3/16/2012Jeff Brewster Fullerton California 92833 United States 3/16/2012Alison Frech Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/16/2012Jennifer Pham Westminster California 92683 United States 3/16/2012Steph Smith menifee California 92586 United States 3/16/2012Jacqueline McLean Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 3/16/2012Barbara Watson Las Vegas Nevada 89113 United States 3/16/2012Claudia  Sermeno LH California 92653 United States 3/16/2012Emily  Holden Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/16/2012Cristi Sturgill Mount Vernon Kentucky 40456 United States 3/16/2012Jennifer Dart Anaheim California 92807 United States 3/16/2012Guy glimpse Fountain Valley California 92708 United States 3/16/2012Altman Joseph Livermore California 94551 United States 3/16/2012Jeff Jensen Irvine California 92606 United States 3/16/2012Christina Reid Corona Del Mar 92625 United States 3/16/2012Kathleen MuhlenkampMurrieta California 92562 United States 3/16/2012Corey Cunningham Santa Barbara California 93101 United States 3/16/2012Jade Beardsley Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 3/16/2012Rachel Santley‐Smith South Lake Tahoe California 96150 United States 3/16/2012Dana Leavitt Highland Utah 84003 United States 3/16/2012France's Loussararian Riverside California 92508 United States 3/16/2012brittany madvig san diego California 92109 United States 3/16/2012Angela Nunez Los Angeles California 90036 United States 3/16/2012Christine Broaddus Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012Bill Jackson Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012Sal Ceja Santa Ana California 92701 United States 3/16/2012Michelle Barry Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/16/2012melinda luthin corona del mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012Rene Lausen Newport Beach California 92661‐1461 United States 3/16/2012Steve Turner Irvine California 92618 United States 3/16/2012Bryn Murray Buena Park California 90621 United States 3/16/2012Keryn Douglass Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 3/16/2012Nicole  Lee Ladera Ranch California 92694 United States 3/16/2012Daniel  Gorczyca Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012Edie Crabtree Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/16/2012alexis plunkett Anaheim California 92807 United States 3/16/2012Megan Forte Brooklyn New York 11211 United States 3/16/2012bill dupuie corona del mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012Sharon Best Irvine California 92606 United States 3/16/2012Jaclyn Lund Clackamas Oregon 97015 United States 3/16/2012Griffin Tamura Irvine California 92620 United States 3/16/2012Caitlin Reid Tustin California 92780 United States 3/16/2012Jan Balas Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/16/2012Sheri Dabney Santa Rosa California 95409 United States 3/16/2012Amy Croushore Claremont California 91711 United States 3/16/2012camie velin corona del mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 229: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Jennifer McCullough Orange California 92866 United States 3/16/2012Bradley Thomas Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/16/2012jack flynn corona del mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012Anne MacPherson Tustin California 92782 United States 3/16/2012Alejandro Sanchez‐LopIrvine California 92606 United States 3/16/2012Daniel Schoonover Orange California 92867 United States 3/16/2012Arthur  Cervantes Irvine California 92617 United States 3/16/2012Deanna Daniels‐Jacint Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 3/16/2012Gena Horn Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/16/2012Kelly Laugharn Morro Bay California 93442 United States 3/16/2012Jayme Corbin Fullerton California 92832 United States 3/16/2012Alex  Mathews Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012sean Rezai Los Angeles California 90066 United States 3/16/2012Dustin Ogle Concord California 94518 United States 3/16/2012Debbie Taylor 3/16/2012KERRY PARKER MALIBU California 90265 United States 3/16/2012Paul Wilkinson laguna hills California 92653 United States 3/16/2012Kimrey Levy Quincy California 95971 United States 3/16/2012Ashley Wilson Longmont Colorado 80501 United States 3/16/2012Carol Lehmann Seaford New York 11783 United States 3/16/2012Jonathan Gryn Irvine California 90630 United States 3/16/2012Dugaldo Avalos palmdale California 93551 United States 3/16/2012Daniel Gibson Irvine California 92602 United States 3/16/2012Hillary Jones orange California 92867 United States 3/16/2012RHONDA HAMMERMARANCHO MIRAGE California 92270 United States 3/16/2012Linde Johnson Orange California 92869 United States 3/16/2012John Tyson LAWRENCE Kansas 66044‐3986 United States 3/16/2012Scott Schorling Laguna Beach California 90803 United States 3/16/2012Phillips Lacy Lubbock Texas 79424 United States 3/16/2012Alex Wu Irvine California 92617 United States 3/16/2012Avanti Frick Pasadena California 91107 United States 3/16/2012deanna koncz foothill ranch California 92610 United States 3/16/2012Charles Figueroa Santa Ana California 92707 United States 3/16/2012Alexander Scholnick Oakland California 94608 United States 3/16/2012Maria Antonakis Chico California 95973 United States 3/16/2012Nick Mathews Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012KEven Obrien Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/16/2012Luis  Gutierrez riverside California 92509 United States 3/16/2012Don  Prindle yorba linda California 92886 United States 3/16/2012Gary  Rittmiller Rio Linda California 95673 United States 3/16/2012John Scoby Corte Madera California 94976 United States 3/16/2012Brenda Greer Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 3/16/2012steven schiesser newport beach California 92658 United States 3/16/2012Otis Woodruff Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/16/2012Dimidrios Kokkinias San Bernardino California 92407 United States 3/16/2012Paul Ransons Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/16/2012Angela Fator  Irvine California 92614 United States 3/16/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 230: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Pamela Bingham San Gabriel California 91775 United States 3/16/2012Brian Austin Irvine California 92617 United States 3/16/2012Linda Roberts Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012ron best irvine California 92606 United States 3/16/2012katie nelson los angeles California 90064 United States 3/16/2012Kathleen Sullivan 92625 California 92625 United States 3/16/2012Uzziel VAlle colton California 92324 United States 3/16/2012Mikea Alvarez Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/16/2012Payam Khodadady Irvine California 92617 United States 3/16/2012Glenna  Hamilton elberton Georgia 30635 United States 3/16/2012Ryan Routon Big Bear Lake California 92315 United States 3/16/2012Ernie Caluza Corona California 92882 United States 3/16/2012Dennis Upton Tampa Florida 33624 United States 3/16/2012Toni Culpepper Placentia California 92870 United States 3/16/2012Lacey Walswick Placentia California 92870 United States 3/16/2012Tony Nese Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012Cynthia Mowery Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/16/2012Amanda Lewis Irvine California 92620 United States 3/16/2012Carla Hummel Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/16/2012Bobbie Herbert Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 3/16/2012pam jones r.s.m. California 92688 United States 3/16/2012Camille Harman Baltimore Maryland 21224 United States 3/16/2012William Scullin Oakland California 94608 United States 3/16/2012michele mutzke newport coast California 92657 United States 3/16/2012Andrea Ward Orange California 92869 United States 3/16/2012Darrin J Kubancek Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012Theo Luthin Santa Rosa California 95404 United States 3/16/2012Charles Olson Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/16/2012Christine Light Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012Chris Frey Reno Nevada 89523 United States 3/16/2012Margaret Heuner Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/16/2012Justin Papa Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012whitney  hockinson corona del mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012Nichole Slykhous Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012brian gillum diamond bar California 91765 United States 3/16/2012Steve Gibson Riverside California 92508 United States 3/16/2012Mark Meierhoefer Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/16/2012Alexander Long Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/16/2012Jeremy Oliver Temecula California 92592 United States 3/16/2012Erika Lavalley Bolton Massachusetts 1740 United States 3/16/2012Christopher Volland Fredericksburg Virginia 22406 United States 3/16/2012Gilda Gilak Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/16/2012Pat Burton Orange California 92869 United States 3/16/2012frank nigro Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012Shawn Barsten Anaheim Hills California 92808 United States 3/16/2012Catalina Chabot moreno valley California 92551 United States 3/16/2012Gregory PARKER BUENA PARK California 90620 United States 3/16/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 231: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Lien Ly‐Guerrero Irvine California 92604 United States 3/16/2012LANI WILLIAMS IRVINE California 92614 United States 3/16/2012Lisa Tzouvelekis Pomona California 91767 United States 3/16/2012Virginia Drew Irvine California 92603 United States 3/16/2012lisa quick murrieta California 92563 United States 3/16/2012Lance Phillips Canyon Lake California 92587 United States 3/16/2012Rozalind Jensen Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/16/2012nicholas wilson Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/16/2012Michelle Muth Temecula California 92592 United States 3/16/2012Anita Shanahan Claremont California 91711 United States 3/16/2012Debby Barton Balboa Island California 92662‐1189 United States 3/16/2012Beth Sher Irvine California 92604 United States 3/16/2012Greg Wheat Buena  Park California 90620 United States 3/16/2012Cora Judd Irvine California 92604 United States 3/16/2012Chloe Goddard Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/16/2012Maureen Parker Irvine California 92614 United States 3/16/2012carrie slayback newport beach California 92663 United States 3/16/2012Leah Webster Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/16/2012Brenda Barnes Pomona California 91766 United States 3/16/2012Deborah Vincenti Las Cruces New Mexico 88007 United States 3/16/2012Cheryl Kosky Newport Beach California 92662 United States 3/16/2012Evin Riemer Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/16/2012Donna Fox Tucson Arizona 85715 United States 3/16/2012June Palomino Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/17/2012Patricia Nesbit Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/17/2012Blake Smith Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/17/2012Keely Orlando Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/17/2012Jon Duperroy Lake Forest California 92609 United States 3/17/2012Lance Meehl Joplin Missouri 64804 United States 3/17/2012Elizabeth Wise Glendale California 91204 United States 3/17/2012William Wakeman Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/17/2012Arthur Akerspn Mission Viejo California 92692 United States 3/17/2012Zaundra Fernandez Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/17/2012nick bassirpour Irvine California 92617 United States 3/17/2012kevin kramer Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/17/2012Colette Hance San Juan Capistrano California 92675 United States 3/17/2012Veronica LaMarca Temecula California 92592 United States 3/17/2012Laura Lee Smith Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/17/2012Connie Danskin Kailua Hawaii 96734 United States 3/17/2012Carolyn Carr Balboa California 92662 United States 3/17/2012April Anderson Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/17/2012Karen Cowie Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/17/2012Ava Shaffer  Kailua Hawaii 96734 United States 3/17/2012Arlene Garrett Irvine California 92612 United States 3/17/2012Tina Page Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/17/2012Elizabeth McCombs Irvine California 92620 United States 3/17/2012sam french  Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/17/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 232: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Kathy Molinaro San Juan Capistrano California 92675 United States 3/17/2012Joslyn Morrall Hanalei Hawaii 96714 United States 3/17/2012W D Smith Brigham Utah 84302 United States 3/17/2012Tracy Fox NEWPORT BEACH California 92661 United States 3/17/2012Ellen  Shockro Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/17/2012Mary Hayden Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 3/17/2012Sade's Weiner Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/17/2012Alex Gulledge Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/17/2012Susan Anderson Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/17/2012George Hicks Torrance California 90504 United States 3/17/2012Bonnie Wheatfill Garden Grove California 92845 United States 3/17/2012Julian Rusinek Gardena California 90245 United States 3/17/2012Alexander TzouvelekisPomona California 91767 United States 3/17/2012Kay Richey Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/17/2012Michael Rabbitt los angeles California 90031 United States 3/17/2012sharon cyrkin irvine California 92612 United States 3/17/2012Nancy Bentley carlsbad California 92009 United States 3/17/2012Erica Beverly Antioch California 94509 United States 3/17/2012Kathleen Romero Mission Viejo California 92692 United States 3/17/2012Lynda Cook Foresthill California 95631 United States 3/17/2012Greg Smith Huntington Beac California 92648 United States 3/17/2012Elaine Moore Portland Oregon 97206 United States 3/17/2012Andrew Sale San Diego California 92126 United States 3/17/2012Phillip Langford Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/17/2012Frank Foley La Verne California 91750 United States 3/17/2012Kevin Hearle San Mateo California 94402‐2426 United States 3/17/2012Howard Burns Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 3/17/2012Steve Hops San Clemente California 92672 United States 3/17/2012Crystal Kerr Santa Cruz California 95062 United States 3/17/2012candace hurley Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 3/17/2012David Carter newport Beach 92660 Cambodia 3/17/2012Antonia Burns Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 3/17/2012Cindy Dupuie Corona Del MAr California 92625 United States 3/17/2012Kathy Kipp Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/17/2012James Martin Tampa Florida 33624 United States 3/17/2012Lindsay Wood Laguna Niguel California 92677 United States 3/17/2012Brittany Knowles Stevenson Ranch California 91381 United States 3/17/2012Barbara winn Fountain Valley California 92708 United States 3/17/2012Lisa Babilonia La Mirada California 90638 United States 3/17/2012Alexander Iles Chatsworth California 91311 United States 3/17/2012Delores Alvarado Orange California 92867 United States 3/17/2012Gail McGowan Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/17/2012Sally Edmunds Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/17/2012Robert Silvernail Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/17/2012Jennifer Owens Sun City California 92586 United States 3/17/2012Robert Bemus Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/17/2012Mary Campbell Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/17/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 233: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Jeffrey Netzer Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/17/2012Andrea badger Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/17/2012Carolyn Frost Santa Clarita California 91321 United States 3/17/2012Andrew Gulledge Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/17/2012Brandi Samson Ontario California 91764 United States 3/17/2012Katherine  Irvin Long Beach California 90814 United States 3/17/2012Walter Buchhagen Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/17/2012Larry Brixey Irvine California 92604 United States 3/17/2012charles walk newport beach California 92663 United States 3/17/2012b p anaheim California 92802 United States 3/17/2012Karen Rossi Huntington Beach California 92615 United States 3/17/2012Chris Cowie  Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/17/2012Katy McAloney Elsah Illinois 62028 United States 3/17/2012Cesar Ruvalcaba Santa Ana California 92707 United States 3/17/2012Julie Hardesty Newport Beach California 92662 United States 3/17/2012Jennifer  Reed‐CosmanCorona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/17/2012Lauren‐Michelle Kraft Newport Beach California 92657 United States 3/17/2012Ben  Garcia Laguna Niguel California 92653 United States 3/17/2012Natasha Leite de Mou Rio de Janeiro 20511030 Brazil 3/17/2012Jacqueline Brogna Rumney New Hampshire 3266 United States 3/17/2012Michael Schmidt Richmond Virginia 23226 United States 3/17/2012Alex Arnold Jacksonville Florida 32224‐3801 United States 3/17/2012Alexander Arnold Jacksonville Florida 32224‐3801 United States 3/17/2012German Abril Anaheim California 92807 United States 3/17/2012Ken Starka San Clemente California 92673 United States 3/17/2012Rachel Miller Surprise Arizona 85388 United States 3/17/2012greg davis Orange California 92869 United States 3/17/2012Ana Lavenant Fullerton California 92833 United States 3/17/2012Melanie Swenson Provo Utah 84604 United States 3/17/2012Lisa Nordholm Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 3/17/2012Scott Shepherd Long Beach California 90803 United States 3/17/2012Kenley Farace San Juan Capistrano California 92675 United States 3/17/2012gray nesbit newport beach California 92663 United States 3/17/2012Brett King Paso Robles California 93446 United States 3/17/2012Janice Langford Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/17/2012Elissa Francis Thousand Oaks California 91362 United States 3/17/2012william grove Jacksonville Florida 32211 United States 3/17/2012Lloyd Schmid Anaheim California 92806 United States 3/17/2012Todd Hales Rancho Santa Margarita California 92688 United States 3/17/2012Peter Hayden Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 3/17/2012Nicole Smith Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/17/2012Pascale  Claus Banning California 92220 United States 3/17/2012Carlos Oregon Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/17/2012Deb Buffleben Santa Rosa California 95401 United States 3/17/2012Blake Allred Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/17/2012Cindy Duvall Provo Utah 84604 United States 3/17/2012Red Barrett Bonsall California 92003 United States 3/17/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 234: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Kevin  Allen Orange California 92866 United States 3/17/2012Jon Jorgensen Mission Viejo California 92692 United States 3/17/2012CHristine Webb Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 3/17/2012Josh Proffit Rancho Santa Margarita California 92688 United States 3/17/2012Theresa McCarthy Santee California 92071 United States 3/17/2012Kirk Rogers Anaheim California 92802 United States 3/17/2012Adia Hoag Washington District Of Colu 20002‐3604 United States 3/17/2012Norm Breedlove Carlsbad California 92011 United States 3/17/2012Eric Wroolie Redlands California 92374 United States 3/17/2012Lynne Hart Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 3/17/2012Thomas Prochoren Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/17/2012Anne  Hoover Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/17/2012Charlenw Dudman santa ana California 92707 United States 3/17/2012Kim Newett Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/17/2012Nichole Smith Corona California 92883 United States 3/17/2012Joseph Lavers Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/17/2012Brenda Bredvik Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 3/17/2012CARLA SENTENO Meridian Idaho 83642 United States 3/17/2012Brian Peelle Fullerton California 92833 United States 3/17/2012Cindy Lonsdale Riverside California 92506 United States 3/17/2012Rachel Gonzales Nuevo California 92567 United States 3/17/2012Patricia Bastien Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/17/2012Linda Patton Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/17/2012Marnie Brow Dana Point California 92629 United States 3/17/2012Nancy Razik Lihue Hawaii 96766 United States 3/17/2012Robert Levyssohn Rancho Cucamonga California 91737 United States 3/17/2012Holly MacLean San Francisco California 94117 United States 3/17/2012Brooke Sprowl Newport Beac California 92660 United States 3/17/2012Stephen Hauptfuhr Los Angeles California 90042 United States 3/17/2012bradley senner Los Gatos California 95032 United States 3/17/2012Neil Borges Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 3/17/2012Gerald Skaggs Brentwood California 94513 United States 3/17/2012Bryan LeSueur orange California 92866 United States 3/17/2012Bryan Buck Irvine California 92618 United States 3/17/2012Sylvia Nim Oakland California 94606 United States 3/17/2012Robert  Weiner Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/17/2012Michelle Brown placentia California 92870 United States 3/17/2012Gray Whelan Portland Oregon 97202 United States 3/17/2012Darwin Pearson Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/17/2012Grace Thomas Anaheim California 92806 United States 3/17/2012Hillary Karges Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/17/2012Rick Risser Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/17/2012Braden LeSueur Provo Utah 84601 United States 3/17/2012Nora Seager Newport Beach, California 92663 United States 3/17/2012mICHELLE Seiler Placentia California 92870 United States 3/17/2012blaire garcia brooklyn New York 11234 United States 3/17/2012Tony Aiello costa mesa California 92626 United States 3/17/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 235: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Jill Cook Placentia California 92870 United States 3/17/2012Sue Bustamante Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 3/17/2012Nancie Carpenter Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/17/2012Joanne Long Las Vegas Nevada 89103 United States 3/17/2012Kayleen Farrer Brea California 92821 United States 3/17/2012Theo Varelas Belmont California 94002 United States 3/17/2012Gemina Gowdy Capistrano Beach California 92624 United States 3/17/2012Andrew Debiase Fullerton California 92835 United States 3/17/2012Lori T Irvine California 91406 United States 3/17/2012nathanael yoon Irvine California 92612 United States 3/17/2012Phi‐Yen Vu Santa Ana California 92704 United States 3/17/2012suki kaur irvine California 92617 United States 3/17/2012Kim Hudson Tucson Arizona 85711 United States 3/17/2012Steven Nelson Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/17/2012Howard Dinh Irvine California 92603 United States 3/17/2012George Bauer fONTANA California 92336 United States 3/17/2012Peter Smith Newport Beach California 92659 United States 3/17/2012Umair Shahbaz Irvine California 92606 United States 3/17/2012Francis  Sabas Irvine California 92612 United States 3/17/2012kathi whitaker yorba linda California 92886 United States 3/17/2012Maxwell Bogard Irvine California 92612 United States 3/17/2012Cheryl Lynn Murrieta California 92563 United States 3/17/2012Robert Wells Garden Grove California 92845 United States 3/17/2012Carlee Darr Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/17/2012Sondra Vaxmosky Westminster California 92683 United States 3/17/2012Dorothy Stephens Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/17/2012Brant Grother Lakewood California 90713 United States 3/17/2012mick mccarthy venice California 90291 United States 3/17/2012Henry Kim Corona California 92881 United States 3/17/2012Anne  Schindler Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/17/2012Abbe  Karges Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/17/2012Annalee Reid Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/17/2012roxanne huish Laguan Niguel California 92656 United States 3/17/2012eric weber lake elsinore California 92530 United States 3/17/2012Donna Hosterman Irvine California 92612 United States 3/17/2012Raymond Reyes Santa Fe Springs California 90670 United States 3/17/2012Erin Flint Layton Utah 84041 United States 3/17/2012Susan Cruz Fullerton California 92832 United States 3/17/2012Shannon Nelson Dana Point California 92629 United States 3/17/2012Leslie Casserly Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/17/2012Anita Meister‐Boyd Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/17/2012Ian Shepley Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 3/17/2012Mike Fitzpatrick Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/17/2012John Stapp American Fork Utah 84003 United States 3/17/2012Frances Pfaff Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/17/2012chuck evans Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 3/17/2012Dao Cao Irvine California 92606 United States 3/17/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 236: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Susan Bell Orange California 92869 United States 3/17/2012Allen Murray Newport Beach California 92660‐9059 United States 3/17/2012John Cannon Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/18/2012Theresa Grenier Ocala Florida 34473 United States 3/18/2012Jonathan Hales Riverside California 92508 United States 3/18/2012Heather Cowley Layton Utah 84041 United States 3/18/2012Jarrod  Wilbur Orange California 92867 United States 3/18/2012stephanie smith midway city California 92655 United States 3/18/2012Adam Johnson Santa Ana California 92707 United States 3/18/2012Benjamin  Muz Irvine California 92617 United States 3/18/2012Annette  Gregersen Renton Washington 98056 United States 3/18/2012Florian Termin San Diego California 92024 United States 3/18/2012Devan Duenas IRVINE California 92612 United States 3/18/2012Amy Riley Fontana California 92336 United States 3/18/2012Ian Montgomery orange California 92867 United States 3/18/2012Darryl Harris Henderson Nevada 89011 United States 3/18/2012richard alarcon Tustin California ca United States 3/18/2012Christina Hales Riverside California 92508 United States 3/18/2012Darryl Harris Henderson Nevada 89011 United States 3/18/2012Shaye Bastien durham North Carolina 27708 United States 3/18/2012Michael Louthan Irvine California 92617 United States 3/18/2012david whitehead Riverside California 92506 United States 3/18/2012Kristin Irish Mission Viejo California 92692 United States 3/18/2012Alyssa Snyder Barcelona Connecticut 92614 United States 3/18/2012Colin Kingston Walnut California 91789 United States 3/18/2012Valarie Honn Fullerton California 92837 United States 3/18/2012Whitney Luigs Orange California 92865 United States 3/18/2012Ashlee Roybal Irvine California 92617 United States 3/18/2012Nabeel Qureshi Buena Park California 90620 United States 3/18/2012Dennis McCracken La Mirada California 90638 United States 3/18/2012Christy Raczka Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/18/2012Maria Seager South Pasadena California 91030 United States 3/18/2012Grace Parker Newport Beach California 92661‐1109 United States 3/18/2012Amy  Hahn Anaheim California 92807 United States 3/18/2012Chloe Anguiano Costa mesa California 92627 United States 3/18/2012Ryan Crandall Orange California 92865 United States 3/18/2012cort strickeer newport beach California 92627 United States 3/18/2012Robin Canfield Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/18/2012Jade Johnson Columbia South Carolina 29229 United States 3/18/2012lauren neilson virginia beach Virginia 23454 United States 3/18/2012Sean Ziebarth Fountain Valley California 92708 United States 3/18/2012Maena Whitelegge costa mesa California 92627 United States 3/18/2012Julieta Roberto Mar del Plata 7600 Argentina 3/18/2012Amber Sykes Red Bluff California 96080 United States 3/18/2012Cole Skene Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/18/2012Charlene Rakhshani Huntington Beach California 92646‐4151 United States 3/18/2012Robert Freeman Tustin California 92780 United States 3/18/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 237: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Cody Maddox Columbia South Carolina 29229 United States 3/18/2012Adam Huey Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 3/18/2012Andrew Hoang TUSTIN California 92780 United States 3/18/2012Shane Shane Yamamo tustin California 92780 United States 3/18/2012Brad Lockhart Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/18/2012Susan seager Denver Colorado 80221 United States 3/18/2012Tami Darr‐Rico Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 3/18/2012MaryAnne Shults Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 3/18/2012Cameron  Schroer Tustin California 92837 United States 3/18/2012Bonnie Gausewitz Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/18/2012Yvonne Lasham Colton California 92324 United States 3/18/2012Natalie Platon Irvine California 92612 United States 3/18/2012Pamala Evans Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/18/2012Ashley  Lewis Park City Utah 84098 United States 3/18/2012Bob Rabun Lake Arrowhead California 92352 United States 3/18/2012Marga Tamplin Antioch California 94509 United States 3/18/2012Mark Hinton Orange California 92867 United States 3/18/2012Nichole Fox Palo Alto California 94306 United States 3/18/2012Sidelle Brown Loma Linda California 92354 United States 3/18/2012Amy Nottingham Riverside California 92508 United States 3/18/2012Chandler Hosterman Erie Pennsylvania 16563 United States 3/18/2012jackie reeves Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/18/2012Ellen Ching North Fork California 93643 United States 3/18/2012Amy Swearingen Placentia California 92870 United States 3/18/2012Jonathan Ong Sunnyvale California 94089 United States 3/18/2012Katherine Bryant Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/18/2012K.C. Heylin Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/18/2012pam erickson Tustin California 92780 United States 3/18/2012Michele Chamberlain Oceanside California 92057 United States 3/18/2012Jennifer McDonald GREELEY Colorado 80634 United States 3/18/2012Melinda Masters Villa Park California 92861 United States 3/18/2012JOHN KUCERA Del Mar California 92014 United States 3/18/2012Nick Trenton Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/18/2012Thomas  Toland  Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/18/2012Judy Smith Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/18/2012Alice Vayner Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/18/2012Karen Jou Costa Mesa California 92614 United States 3/18/2012Greg Prete Laguna Niguel California 92677 United States 3/18/2012zenah achten Laguna Niguel California 92677‐4008 United States 3/18/2012michael martin Tustin California 92780 United States 3/18/2012Jeffrey Hallin Santa Ana California 92706 United States 3/18/2012Kyle Garbett Glendora California 91741 United States 3/18/2012Linda Kemmer Salt Lake City Utah 84103 United States 3/18/2012Nick Cucinella Long Beach California 90803 United States 3/18/2012Wayne Osato Tustin California 92781 United States 3/18/2012Magda Pastrana Santa Ana California 92701 United States 3/18/2012Sara Cooper Balboa Island California 92662 United States 3/18/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 238: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Aj Natnat Fremont California 94538 United States 3/18/2012LINDA QUALM SAN DIEGO California 92021 United States 3/18/2012Rene Romero Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/18/2012cathan cokas Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/18/2012Rebecca Knapp Menifee California 92584 United States 3/18/2012MaryAnne Newman morgantown West Virginia 26501 United States 3/18/2012Amie Blackman Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/18/2012Alison Wong Los Angeles California 90024 United States 3/18/2012joshua klein houston Texas 77009 United States 3/18/2012Merrilee C. BridgemanCharlotte North Carolina 28210 United States 3/18/2012Karen Prete Laguna Niguel California 92677 United States 3/18/2012Brandi Gill Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/18/2012tina sills newport beach California 92660‐4006 United States 3/18/2012Jerry  Vallierr Riverside California 92508 United States 3/18/2012Ruby  Cohan  Marina California 93933 United States 3/18/2012Lynn Kubasek Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 3/18/2012Carla Ferrier Glade Hill Virginia 24092 United States 3/18/2012Anne Peterson Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/18/2012Christine Lockhart Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 3/18/2012Lauren Mitchell Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/18/2012Laura  Jones Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/18/2012Dara Weiner Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/18/2012Robert Weiner Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/18/2012Steve  Harper Irvine California 92604 United States 3/18/2012Richard Wise Cape Coral Florida 33909 United States 3/18/2012cherie edborg Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 3/18/2012Jack Holke Pleasanton California 94566 United States 3/18/2012Vince Sosa Fountain Valley California 92708 United States 3/18/2012dawn castle aliso viejo California 92656 United States 3/18/2012Elizabeth osborne Fountain valley California 92708 United States 3/18/2012Jennifer Rulon Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/18/2012james hannon angelus oaks California 92305 United States 3/18/2012Gary Bowman Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/18/2012Tobin Bush Laguna hills California 92653 United States 3/18/2012peter jarman Salt Lake City Utah 84103 United States 3/18/2012Sarah Green Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/18/2012Tanya MacLean Tustin California 92782 United States 3/18/2012Gwen Fisher Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/18/2012Curt Lockhart Provo Utah 84604 United States 3/18/2012Carolyn Roberts Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 3/18/2012Rita Viselli Tustin California 92782 United States 3/18/2012Barbie Dalke Salem Oregon 97304 United States 3/18/2012Kary  Hill Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/18/2012Beth Goings Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/18/2012Mike Mitchell Laguna Niguel California 92677 United States 3/18/2012CURTIS  HABSIEGER COSTA MESA California 92627 United States 3/18/2012Dionne Dietrich Woodridge Illinois 60517 United States 3/18/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 239: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Heather Spies Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 3/18/2012David Bailey Fullerton California 92832 United States 3/18/2012Mark Welch Phoenix Arizona 85013 United States 3/18/2012April  Ross costa mesa California 92627 United States 3/18/2012TONI HOWARD Corona California 92880 United States 3/18/2012Jeremy Isturis Bellflower California 90706 United States 3/18/2012Mark Rigney Los Angeles California 90057 United States 3/18/2012Mary Ann Cote Newport Oregon 97365 United States 3/18/2012David  Smith Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/18/2012Greg St. John Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/18/2012carol romo Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/18/2012Peter DuBois Los Angeles California 90024 United States 3/18/2012chris lanahan fountain valley California 92807 United States 3/18/2012Donna Gingold Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/18/2012Jon Dishon Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/18/2012Jessica Scheurer Newport Beach California 92662 United States 3/18/2012Maryam Rokhideh Mission Viejo California 92692 United States 3/18/2012Kelsey Pearson Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/18/2012Michael Bayer Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/18/2012Stephanie McGraw Huntington Beach California 92649 United States 3/18/2012Terri Mayhugh Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/18/2012Erin Lea Irvine California 92614 United States 3/18/2012Anne  Blake costa mesa California 92627 United States 3/18/2012Martin Schmidt Huntington Beach, CA California 92646 United States 3/18/2012Kermin Orellana Tustin California 92780 United States 3/18/2012Megan Rennie Reno Nevada 89523 United States 3/18/2012Jason Wickham Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/18/2012Dianna Kubasek orange California 92865 United States 3/18/2012jim erickson costa mesa California 92627 United States 3/18/2012Cameron Hess North Tustin California 92705‐1141 United States 3/18/2012Katie Hall Manhattan Beach California 90266 United States 3/18/2012Sheri Gailliard Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/18/2012Charlotte Kessy Westminster California 92685 United States 3/18/2012Belinda Jones Orange California 92869 United States 3/18/2012Vivian Walker Pasadena California 91105 United States 3/18/2012Drake Hawkins Tempe Arizona 85282 United States 3/18/2012Odd‐Arne Roth Sandnes 4324 Norway 3/18/2012Roberta Tarr Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/18/2012Steve Pham Stanton California 90680 United States 3/18/2012Troy Muenzer Long Beach California 90803 United States 3/18/2012Sonja Thomas orange California 92866 United States 3/18/2012Scott Barnes Henderson Nevada 89002 United States 3/18/2012blaine prow newport beach California 92660 United States 3/18/2012Nikki Hayes Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/18/2012PhiLlip Silva Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/18/2012Dustin Carpenter newport beach California 92660 United States 3/18/2012Lori Parnass San Gabriel California 91775 United States 3/18/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 240: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Emei Ha Tustin California 92782 United States 3/18/2012Melissa Gabriele Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/18/2012Gina Vincent pacific palisades California 90272 United States 3/18/2012Verel Huff Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/18/2012liza angel fullerton California 92831 United States 3/18/2012Charles Gates Bon Air Virginia 23235 United States 3/18/2012PAtrick Reedy Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/18/2012KC Ferguson Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/18/2012Imelda Bodie Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/18/2012Curtis Oliver Cheney Kansas 67025 United States 3/18/2012Adriana Gomez Orange California 92869 United States 3/18/2012Louis rulon Phoenix Arizona 85083 United States 3/18/2012David Brown Orange California 92869 United States 3/18/2012Kevin del Toro newport beach California 92660 United States 3/18/2012Robert Crawford Lyons Colorado 80540 United States 3/18/2012Marie Pollerna Altadena California 91001 United States 3/18/2012Julia Davis Albany Oregon 97322 United States 3/18/2012Mark McAdams Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/18/2012Helen Waters Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/18/2012Brett Robinson Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/18/2012Jill Cole Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/18/2012Abram Rodriguez Irvine California 92604 United States 3/18/2012Joe McGhie Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/18/2012Jessica Brown costa mesa California 92627 United States 3/18/2012Tiffany Gates Irvine California 92620 United States 3/18/2012Tony Shaw Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/18/2012Stacy Cameron Rancho Santa Margarita California 92688 United States 3/18/2012suzanne flint newport beach California 92633 United States 3/18/2012Bridgette  Clonts  Tustin California 92780 United States 3/18/2012Stephen  Bradshaw Orange California 92867 United States 3/18/2012Olivia Frost Balboa Island California 92662 United States 3/18/2012Veronica Holbrook Whittier California 90605 United States 3/18/2012Tiana andraos irvine California 92606 United States 3/18/2012Wyatt Andraos Irvine California 92606 United States 3/18/2012William King Newport Beach Georgia 92660 United States 3/18/2012Dave Anderson Rancho Santa Margarita California 92688 United States 3/18/2012Monica King Menifee California 92584 United States 3/18/2012Roderick Graham Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/18/2012Lacey Bredsguard Irvine California 92618 United States 3/18/2012Joe  Garrett Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/18/2012Tod Phillips Bend Oregon 97702 United States 3/18/2012Heidi Wilfert Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/18/2012Brittanee  Licari Corona California 92882 United States 3/18/2012Kristina Pierce Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/18/2012Julie  Mercurio Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/18/2012Amber Phelps Salt Lake City Utah 84105 United States 3/18/2012Rhonda Borth Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/18/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 241: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Stephanie Moore Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/18/2012Nathan Clonts Tustin California 92780 United States 3/18/2012Brett Brewer Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/18/2012Cheron Palmer Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 3/18/2012vanessa reynolds Los Alamitos California 90720 United States 3/18/2012Charlie Wood Irvine California 92614 United States 3/18/2012Shelley Arnold Corona California 92879 United States 3/18/2012Joe Peterson Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/18/2012Barbara Perry Santa Ana California 92704 United States 3/18/2012David Sperling Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/18/2012Gail Abramo Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/18/2012Amy Cordova Santa Ana California 92703 United States 3/18/2012Kathy Royak Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/18/2012Brenda Wilfert Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/18/2012Margaret Harrison Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/19/2012Steve Wherry Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/19/2012Leslie Moore El Dorado Hills California 95762 United States 3/19/2012Alison Davis Orange California 92869 United States 3/19/2012elizabeth barnick newport beach California 92660 United States 3/19/2012Elisa Garrett corona del mar California 92625 United States 3/19/2012Carol Warsaw Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/19/2012Lorel Roehl Irvine California 92603 United States 3/19/2012Jody Morton Green Bay Wisconsin 54303 United States 3/19/2012Jeffrey Lockhart Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/19/2012chris walmer Hermosa Beach California 90254 United States 3/19/2012Christie Osborn Loma Linda California 92354 United States 3/19/2012Rachael Fisher Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/19/2012brianna bowen Orange California 92867 United States 3/19/2012Alicia Ginsberg Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/19/2012Rachelle Olinger LADERA RANCH California 92694 United States 3/19/2012Brian Herbel Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/19/2012J S Foothill Ranch California 92610 United States 3/19/2012susan depalma balboa island California 92662 United States 3/19/2012Chardonnay Flores Santa Ana California 92707 United States 3/19/2012Worth Dayley Tooele Utah 84074 United States 3/19/2012linda ventriglia newport beach California 92663 United States 3/19/2012Christine McDonald Orange California 92867 United States 3/19/2012Marlana Rael Nuevo California 92567 United States 3/19/2012Gabrielle Kerr Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/19/2012Lori Bloom Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/19/2012Evan Wanamaker Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/19/2012Jessica La Combe Garden Grove California 92843 United States 3/19/2012Cynthia Orphan Riverside California 92503 United States 3/19/2012Bill Nemec Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/19/2012David  Manne Newport Beach California 92658 United States 3/19/2012Carolyn Rooney Tustin California 92780 United States 3/19/2012Penny Popov Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/19/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 242: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

barry stevens Santa Monica California 90403 United States 3/19/2012Tyrus Papa Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/19/2012alan campos nuevo California 92567 United States 3/19/2012Anne Kimball riverside California 92505 United States 3/19/2012Kathy Garner San Clemente California 92673 United States 3/19/2012george kent Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/19/2012Sophia Barton Balboa California 92662 United States 3/19/2012Heather Hokanson Palmdale California 93551 United States 3/19/2012Chase Dorian Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/19/2012Andrew Pearson Seattle Washington 98106 United States 3/19/2012Heidi Helfrich Perris California 92571 United States 3/19/2012Craig McGregor Cathedral City California 92234 United States 3/19/2012Marta Blalock Newport Beach California 92633 United States 3/19/2012Heidi Attia Long Beach California 90803 United States 3/19/2012Nathan King Mesa Arizona 85212 United States 3/19/2012Jjr George  Peppard yuma Arizona 85367 United States 3/19/2012Matt Clay Trabuco Canyon California 92679 United States 3/19/2012TiA Gibbd Long Beach California 90814 United States 3/19/2012Crystal Chitwood South Gate California 90280 United States 3/19/2012Daniel Felechner Irvine California 92604 United States 3/19/2012Erin O'Leary Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/19/2012Tracy Hartman Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 3/19/2012Meherdad Azadbakht Long Beach California 90814 United States 3/19/2012Amy Dailey Brawley California 92227‐1408 United States 3/19/2012Barbara Crowell Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/19/2012Bridget Ross Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/19/2012Mike Kelly Orange California 92869 United States 3/19/2012Jaron Tillman Moreno Valley California 92555 United States 3/19/2012Vivian Maier San Francisco California 94116 United States 3/19/2012Dianne Felton Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/19/2012Nikki Hezar Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/19/2012Laurie Brooks Irvine California 92602 United States 3/19/2012Melissa Warner Tustin California 92780 United States 3/19/2012Carolyn Bockrath Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/19/2012Sam McGee Rancho Santa Margarita California 92688 United States 3/19/2012Amy Gorman Placentia California 92870 United States 3/19/2012Roman Naik Rancho Santa Margarita California 92688 United States 3/19/2012Christopher Perez Corona California 92882 United States 3/19/2012Michael Rauma Queen Creek Arizona 85142 United States 3/19/2012Kevin Sims Riverside California 92509 United States 3/19/2012Haleigh Bruns Tustin California 92780 United States 3/19/2012Susan Duby Corona del Mar California 92627 United States 3/19/2012Crislena Zezelj Edmonton T5G 2J5 Canada 3/19/2012Amanda Leckband Brawley California 92227 United States 3/19/2012GRACIE LOPEZ Whitter California 90604 United States 3/19/2012MARK HEASLEY ANAHEIM California 92808 United States 3/19/2012Michael Mcclain Anaheim California 92807 United States 3/19/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 243: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Gina Berman Pomona California 91766 United States 3/19/2012cindy davis Oramge California 92869 United States 3/19/2012Robin Senour Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/19/2012Matthew Gibbs fountain valley California 92708 United States 3/19/2012yvan agbo lyon 69001 France 3/19/2012Roger Marsh San Juan Capistrano California 92675 United States 3/19/2012Gina Johnston Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/19/2012Jill Casserly Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/19/2012Blake Brewer Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/19/2012Sean Carroll Huntington Beach California 92649 United States 3/19/2012Merri Laursen Fallbrook California 92028 United States 3/19/2012Ryan Beck Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/19/2012Carmen Marinez Hemet California 92545 United States 3/19/2012Sheree Spraglin Reseda California 91335 United States 3/19/2012Hunter Stroman Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/19/2012Gary Jensen Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/19/2012Cami Smith San Diego California 92103 United States 3/19/2012Annette Wong Covina California 91722 United States 3/19/2012Angelina Gripp Redondo Beach California 90278 United States 3/19/2012Paige Wiseman Irvine California 92612 United States 3/19/2012daniel gavitt riverside California 92509 United States 3/19/2012Dwaine Elder Las Vegas Nevada 89102 United States 3/19/2012Eric Fraide Palm Springs California 92263 United States 3/19/2012Bruce Billedeaux Portage Michigan 49024 United States 3/19/2012Brad Burlingham Fairview North Carolina 28730 United States 3/19/2012Mark Swenson 3/19/2012Kristina Murphy Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/19/2012Jeff Foy Irvine California 92620 United States 3/19/2012Ellery Sorkin Encino California 91436 United States 3/19/2012Ruth Tiglio Chino California 91710 United States 3/19/2012Allyson Rhoads Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 3/19/2012Kim  Bradbury Palm Desert California 92211 United States 3/19/2012Dennis Hollenbeck Chula Vista CA 91913 United States Mino 3/19/2012Robert Haefelfinger Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/19/2012Garrett Sorensen orange California 92869 United States 3/19/2012Don Gramme Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/19/2012Pooja BhaLla Irvine California 92614 United States 3/19/2012Caroline Olearnek Cypress California 90630 United States 3/19/2012Tamara Malik San Jose California 95125 United States 3/19/2012Vance Lam los angeles California 90031 United States 3/19/2012Ashley Wysocki Corona California 92882 United States 3/19/2012Yvonne Vidal Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/19/2012Rhonda McClure Wylie Texas 75098 United States 3/19/2012Olimpia Newlove San Clemente California 92672 United States 3/19/2012Brian Jones Orange California 92869 United States 3/19/2012Quinn Truong Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/19/2012Rachel Marie MagaoaySanta Ana California 92705 United States 3/19/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 244: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Marjorie Burns Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 3/19/2012Joe Jones Irvine California 92603 United States 3/19/2012Georgianna  Wright Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/19/2012john kidde corona del mar California 92625 United States 3/19/2012Thomas Butman Irvine California 92620 United States 3/19/2012Vanessa Holder Sherman Oaks California 91423 United States 3/19/2012Deanna Senior Rancho Mirage California 92270 United States 3/19/2012Shanti sahgal Anaheim California 92807 United States 3/19/2012Carson Carpenter Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/19/2012Chris Brady Mission Viejo California 92692 United States 3/19/2012Reza Bagherpour Irvine California 92614 United States 3/19/2012Kellie parker Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/19/2012Erin Gargan Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 3/19/2012Victoria Borth Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/19/2012Lisa Stablein orange California 92867 United States 3/19/2012Marianne Steinberg Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/19/2012Diane Fitzsimmons Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/19/2012Tori Borth Newport Beach California United States 3/19/2012JANET FOLCKE Coto de Caza California 92679 United States 3/19/2012Barbara Salisbury Tustin California 92780 United States 3/19/2012Shamoon Budhwani Rancho Santa Margarita California 92688 United States 3/19/2012Jennifer  Brown Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/19/2012Brett Brown Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/19/2012Ashley Parole Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/19/2012LaDONNA VISSER SANTA FE SPRINGS California 90670 United States 3/19/2012Matthew Page Huntington Beach California 92647‐6160 United States 3/19/2012Edie Brier Winnemucca Nevada 89445 United States 3/19/2012amanda adkins Riverside California 92509 United States 3/19/2012Virginia Richards Santa Ana California 92704 United States 3/19/2012Darren Schmidt Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 3/19/2012jan dorian newport beach California 92660 United States 3/19/2012Billy  Martin Irvine California 92619 United States 3/19/2012Molly Wallace Fountain Valley California 92708 United States 3/19/2012Linda Gregson Irvine California 92604 United States 3/19/2012Jessica Taylor Irvine California 92604 United States 3/19/2012Beverly Kahlenberg Simi Valley California 93065 United States 3/19/2012Kevin  Benton San Clemente California 92673 United States 3/19/2012Justin  Watt Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/19/2012Cathy riordan Grand Rapids Minnesota 55744 United States 3/19/2012Craig Medici Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/19/2012Kevin Drain Simi Valley California 93065 United States 3/19/2012ty jones laguna beach California 92629 United States 3/19/2012Robert Guthrie Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/19/2012Christine cooley San Francisco California 94109 United States 3/19/2012Courday Farnam Irvine California 92603 United States 3/19/2012Carlee Brown San Digeo California 92104 United States 3/19/2012Edward Atkins Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/19/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 245: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

robert sant San Clemente California 92672 United States 3/19/2012Kyle Scribner Yucaipa California 92399 United States 3/19/2012Amanda MuZinich Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/19/2012Emily Knight Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/19/2012Erik Hale Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/19/2012David  May Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/19/2012Melanie de Arakal Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/19/2012John Pollock Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/19/2012Amy  Hoogenboom Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/19/2012Sean Osborn San Luis Obispo California 93405 United States 3/19/2012dawn pfaff Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/19/2012claudean davidson irvine California 92604 United States 3/19/2012claudean davidson irvine California 92604 United States 3/19/2012Jon‐Michael Evans Irvine California 92618 United States 3/19/2012Nichole Story Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/19/2012Lynnette Opp Orange California 92869 United States 3/19/2012Dave Felde Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/19/2012Pete Kuhnen Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 3/19/2012Kyle Evams Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/19/2012jordan white newport beach California 92661 United States 3/19/2012Crystal  Ives Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 3/19/2012Alan Weir Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 3/19/2012Kevin O'Neill II Riverside California 92506 United States 3/19/2012Paul dalven  Orange California 92866 United States 3/19/2012William Clark Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/19/2012Christine Seegmiller Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/19/2012April Dickson Long Beach California 90814 United States 3/19/2012Kris Urdahl Oakland California 9410 United States 3/19/2012Burly Man Santa Maria California 93456 United States 3/19/2012Miles Meehan Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/19/2012Sherry Reves Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 3/19/2012Julie Patterson Makawao Hawaii 96768 United States 3/19/2012Erik Smith Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/19/2012Paul Fernandez Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/19/2012brooke canterbury newport beach California 92661 United States 3/19/2012Al Freeman Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 3/19/2012Gloria Cornell GG California 92840 United States 3/19/2012Wendy Hafer Cox Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/19/2012nan west irvine California 92614 United States 3/19/2012Kyle Manning Monticello Arkansas 71655 United States 3/19/2012Michael Murad Tustin California 92782 United States 3/19/2012suzanne Podany Newport Beach California 92662 United States 3/19/2012Diana Atkin Running Springs California 92382 United States 3/19/2012Madeleine Dickerson Irvine California 92617 United States 3/19/2012Melissa Stern Los Angeles California 90036 United States 3/19/2012Tiffany Granato Orange California 92865 United States 3/19/2012Rebecca Kaplan San Diego California 92108 United States 3/19/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 246: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Allie Guthrie Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/20/2012Betsy  Barry Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/20/2012Michelle Brickell Menifee California 92584 United States 3/20/2012Brittani Heim Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/20/2012Alexandra Ayon Santa Ana California 92701 United States 3/20/2012Matt Pickrel irvine California 92604 United States 3/20/2012David Withers Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/20/2012Jessica Haefelfinger Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/20/2012tiffany smith Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 3/20/2012Amy Mireles Fallbrook California 92028 United States 3/20/2012Bryan  Cooper Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/20/2012Kellen Pocock Tustin California 92782‐3357 United States 3/20/2012Alan Baron Newport Beach 92660 United States Mino 3/20/2012Kara Russek Tustin California 92780 United States 3/20/2012Erik Hansen Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/20/2012Shawn Hoebeck Irvine California 92617 United States 3/20/2012Allison Danielson Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/20/2012Karen Busey Madeira Beach Florida 33708 United States 3/20/2012Valeria Villa‐Anzlado santa ana California 92707 United States 3/20/2012Roy Boman Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/20/2012Renee West NB California 92660 United States 3/20/2012julius rizzotti newport beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012Terry Ridge Lakeview Oregon 97630 United States 3/20/2012Evelyn Leonard Corona California 92880 United States 3/20/2012Patricia Nance Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012Bruce Miller Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/20/2012lori Madlen Santa Maria California 93456 United States 3/20/2012Jai  Syal los angeles California 90024 United States 3/20/2012virginia mumford HUntington Beach California 92648 United States 3/20/2012Becky Fischer Orange California 92869 United States 3/20/2012SANDI ORTIZ Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/20/2012Chris  Drain Chula Vista California 91913‐3502 United States 3/20/2012Irene  Vincent Laguna Niguel California 92677 United States 3/20/2012Lisa  Schmit Upland California 91786 United States 3/20/2012elizabeth barnes Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/20/2012Michelle Vo Irvine California 92617 United States 3/20/2012Jim Ferguson Balboa Island California 92662 United States 3/20/2012carl davidson glendale California 91214 United States 3/20/2012Margaret Walker Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/20/2012Daniel Pickrel Irvine California 92604 United States 3/20/2012Ann Colm Newport Beach California 92662 United States 3/20/2012Daniel Urdahl Los Angeles California 90045 United States 3/20/2012steven guzowski Newport Beach California 92662 United States 3/20/2012Margaret Pimm Portland Oregon 97206 United States 3/20/2012Dale Stoica Fullerton California 92833 United States 3/20/2012Karen Nichols Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012Candace Rheem Newport Beach California 92662 United States 3/20/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 247: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

dania tellez santa ana California 92704 United States 3/20/2012shanna torp post falls Idaho 83877 United States 3/20/2012ken snyder aliso viejo California 92656 United States 3/20/2012Mark Boyes Orange California 92869 United States 3/20/2012Erin Crane Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/20/2012Donna Lee Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012Susan Kelhi Anaheim California 92802 United States 3/20/2012Scott Kimball newport beach California 92662 United States 3/20/2012Samantha Fellner Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012sasha parmeter newport beach California 92663 United States 3/20/2012Krista Murr Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012sarah santore San Clemente California 92673 United States 3/20/2012Ralph Higgs mission Viejo California 92691 United States 3/20/2012edward kehoe Newport beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012Kemmer Fitzsimmons Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/20/2012Derrick Ruiz Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012Jasmine Hyde Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012max gerard newport beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012Michelle Banta Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/20/2012Daniel Mitchell Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012Vladi Vadura Trabuco Canyon California 92679 United States 3/20/2012tina davalos Corona California 92882 United States 3/20/2012Stacy Healy Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/20/2012Dan Stevens Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012Tyler Jones Laguna Niguel California 92677 United States 3/20/2012Nicole Lee Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/20/2012kelsey Campbell Orange California 92869 United States 3/20/2012Matthew Scrub Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012sharon paxson Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/20/2012Jennifer  Beard Newport beach California 92660‐0700 United States 3/20/2012alia O poway California 92064 United States 3/20/2012craig thomas Dana Point California 92629 United States 3/20/2012Chad Martinez Dana Point California 92629 United States 3/20/2012Cullen Lewis Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012william herrmann costa mesa California 92627 United States 3/20/2012Brent Burke Tustin California 92780 United States 3/20/2012Lukas Ronaldson newport beach California 92663 United States 3/20/2012Renee Lockhart Riverside California 92503 United States 3/20/2012Breanna Gallardo Homeland California 92548 United States 3/20/2012Tanya Walker Riverside California 92503 United States 3/20/2012marisa rheem Albuquerque New Mexico 87123 United States 3/20/2012ernesto acuna costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/20/2012Michael Lebeau Los Alamitos California 90720 United States 3/20/2012Jocelyn Rheem Potomac Maryland 20854 United States 3/20/2012Barbara Kimball Tustin California 92780 United States 3/20/2012Maria Potts Thornton, CO 80602 Colorado 80602 United States 3/20/2012Michael Brooks Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 248: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Ali Taylor Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/20/2012jen hunter Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/20/2012jeni rosenthal Corona Del Mar 92625 United States 3/20/2012Michael Brusic Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012Patrick McCormack Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/20/2012Bonita Onsrud Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 3/20/2012Kristin Kenney Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012diana Tiffany Westminster California 92683 United States 3/20/2012Darryl Walker Medford Oregon 97504 United States 3/20/2012Conner Ferguson Newport Beach California 92662 United States 3/20/2012Wiliam More Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012Ryan  Dalton  Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012Robert Hughes Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012Paula Martin Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/20/2012Lisa Cannon Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/20/2012James Kline Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012Katherine Johnson Irvine California 92602 United States 3/20/2012C Rivers Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 3/20/2012betty volk huntington beach California 92647 United States 3/20/2012Brett Crowley Santa Monica California 90404 United States 3/20/2012Chris Rohan Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/20/2012megan peyton Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012Anamarie  Thomas Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/20/2012Bill Horner Tustin California 92780 United States 3/20/2012Cynthia Williams Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 3/20/2012Patricia Zemanek El Cerrito California 94530 United States 3/20/2012Carl  Reed Eastvale California 92880 United States 3/20/2012Lora Venstrom Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/20/2012Lindsay Norman San Francisco California 94109 United States 3/20/2012Amanda Brooks Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/20/2012Samantha  May Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/20/2012Lauren Goeres‐Hill Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 3/20/2012Diane Donovan Placentia California 92870 United States 3/20/2012kathryn knox newport beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012corrina miller westchester California 90045 United States 3/20/2012jock begg Newport Beach California 92660‐7939 United States 3/20/2012Marie Atkins Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012Trisha Hiller‐Kile lake elsinore California 92530 United States 3/20/2012Dave Kooi Anaheim California 92805 United States 3/20/2012Brenda McCroskey Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/20/2012sally martin Newport Beach California 92662 United States 3/20/2012Douglas  Tabor North Tustin California 92705 United States 3/20/2012Brian  White Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012Anne Vogel La Verne California 91750 United States 3/20/2012Jill Richardson dana point California 92629 United States 3/20/2012Lauren Budd Fullerton California 92831 United States 3/20/2012Catherine Hollinger Ladera Ranch California 92694 United States 3/20/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 249: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Ann Schumacher Santa Monica California 90404 United States 3/20/2012Mary Hames  Sitka Alaska 99835 United States 3/20/2012crew chamberlain fullerton California 92832 United States 3/20/2012Becky  Bee CDM California 92625 United States 3/20/2012Dennis Sweeney San Juan Capistrano California 92675 United States 3/20/2012Vivian Falzetti Palos Verdes Estates California 90274 United States 3/20/2012Krysty Proznik Los Angeles California 90025 United States 3/20/2012Dennis Bress Newport Beach California 92662 United States 3/20/2012Dani Nichols San Clemente California 92672 United States 3/20/2012Ann Reese Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 3/20/2012Whitney Wright Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/20/2012Megan Samarin Irvine California 92620 United States 3/20/2012BRIAN DEAN TEMECULA California 92592 United States 3/20/2012Kathy Youngman Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012JOSHrvine WEBSTER Irvine California 92614 United States 3/20/2012Dolly Ginter Irvine California 92606 United States 3/20/2012David Skelton Tustin California 92780 United States 3/20/2012Theresa Rogers Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/20/2012Barbara Solis Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/20/2012Priscilla  Solis Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/20/2012Hank Hsieh Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 3/20/2012Efren Reyes CA California 92626 United States 3/20/2012Antone Davis Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/20/2012Mike Munson Manhattan Beach California 90266 United States 3/20/2012Genghis Quan clovis California 93611 United States 3/20/2012Dianna VanderWall Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012james lugo newport beach California 92663 United States 3/20/2012Jacqueline Moran Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/20/2012Janice Wallace Glendale Arizona 85302 United States 3/20/2012Emily Lyons Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012Anne Gordinier Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012Diane Harris Denver Colorado 80210 United States 3/20/2012Michael Jacobs Temecula California 92592 United States 3/20/2012Jesse I Costa Mesa, CA California 92627 United States 3/20/2012Beth Donavin Moreno Valley California 92557 United States 3/20/2012Dain Ouradnik North Hollywood California 91601 United States 3/20/2012Allison Kenyon Irvine California 92620 United States 3/20/2012Thomas  Clark Capistrano Beach California 92624 United States 3/20/2012Joanna Takegami Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/20/2012Buu  Ngo Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/20/2012Bertha Paquette Santa Ana California 92707 United States 3/20/2012Ellen Loftin Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 3/20/2012janice  Munemitsu Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/20/2012Bob Orlof Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/20/2012Charlene Palmer Long Beach California 90802 United States 3/20/2012Bethany Lomas Hemet California 92545 United States 3/20/2012Jonathan Nichols Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/20/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 250: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

adrienne saylor newport beach California 92663 United States 3/20/2012debbie ellis costa mesa California 92626 United States 3/20/2012Fred Fourcher Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/20/2012Mark Barker Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/20/2012joseph mccarthy corona del mar California 92625 United States 3/20/2012Matthew Vazquez Cypress California 90630 United States 3/20/2012Janet Hegland Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/20/2012loyal parsons silverado California 92676 United States 3/20/2012Igor Cruz Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/20/2012Daniel Pugh Long Beach California 90808 United States 3/20/2012Stephen Margala Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 3/20/2012Alex Keighley Dana Point California 92629 United States 3/20/2012Carol Heed Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 3/20/2012Mark Perlmutter Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/20/2012Alf Doberstein Irvine California 92604 United States 3/20/2012Wallace Grissette Placentia California 92870 United States 3/20/2012Kris Gustafson Irvine California 92618 United States 3/20/2012Nik Froehlich Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/20/2012NATHAN DAY NEWPORT BEACH California 92660 United States 3/20/2012Karen Ellis Thousand Oaks California 91362 United States 3/20/2012Shannon Dwyer Long Beach California 90803 United States 3/21/2012Alexandra Barton Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/21/2012Richard Lines Hermosa Beach California 90254 United States 3/21/2012Athena Reschke Laguna Niguel California 92677 United States 3/21/2012Gart Sutton Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/21/2012Dan Brock Tustin California 92780 United States 3/21/2012Tony Sanders London SE8 3PB United Kingdom 3/21/2012Justin KurthJustinK Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Antoinette Hancock Newpoprt Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Lauri Fitzpatrick Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Anjail Mitchell Santa Ana California 92703 United States 3/21/2012Susan Lew Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Stefanie Geoghegan Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012alexander  boullon Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Andrew Santa Maria Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Liz Morgan Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012John Dickinson Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/21/2012Karen Carboni Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Kristen Brown Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Bill Balch Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 3/21/2012Karen  Musselman Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Linda Langley Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Linda Valdivia Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 3/21/2012Pam Harvey Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Alison Bray Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Tanya Fisher newport beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Mary Venturini Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 251: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Julia Coleman Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012ana lucia huntington beach California 92648 United States 3/21/2012Barbara L  BaumgartneNewport Beach California 92662 United States 3/21/2012Maria Redman Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Shelli Black Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Tara  Drake‐Hueston Millbury Massachusetts 1527 United States 3/21/2012Ryan Hueston Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/21/2012Sue Lloyd Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Matt Lintschinger Irvine California 92612 United States 3/21/2012Allison Brown St. Louis Missouri 63139 United States 3/21/2012Marc Hines Carlsbad California 92018 United States 3/21/2012Michelle Erickson Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/21/2012Wendy Braun Balboa Island California 92662 United States 3/21/2012Pamela Daily Placentia California 92870 United States 3/21/2012Scott Peotter Irvine California 92614 United States 3/21/2012Cindy Frazier Corona del Mar California 92625` United States 3/21/2012Frank DANIELE NEWPORT BEACH California 92660‐ United States 3/21/2012patricia tyson newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Alexi Kim Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/21/2012Bradley Willard Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/21/2012Steve Brahs Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Jon Spotts Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/21/2012Laura Zublin NEWPORT BEACH California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Kyle Miller Tustin California 92780 United States 3/21/2012janeen Rainier Sun city California 92585 United States 3/21/2012Jill  McGlasson Orange California 92869 United States 3/21/2012grant  anderson trabuco canyon California 92679 United States 3/21/2012Courtney Brown Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012clendon hodges riverside California 92508 United States 3/21/2012Chase  McElroy newport beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Drew Blumenthal corona del mar California 92625 United States 3/21/2012Ryon Sabouni newport coast California 92657 United States 3/21/2012vicki norman newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Jerrilynn Kline Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Blake  Motal corona del mar California 92625 United States 3/21/2012Quentin Moses corona del mar California 92625 United States 3/21/2012Jane Jones Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012BLAKE LESUEUR Trabuco canyon California 92679 United States 3/21/2012victoria gates newport beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Laureen Miranda Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/21/2012Debbie Dacumos Pomona California 91767‐3361 United States 3/21/2012Rachel Howard Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/21/2012jillian zosh Irvine California 92614 United States 3/21/2012Jayne Braga Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/21/2012Brooke Yetter Pasadena California 91101 United States 3/21/2012David Somoya Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/21/2012Joanne Dahlberg Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 252: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Jody danese Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Brittany Spear Las Vegas Nevada 89121 United States 3/21/2012karen parks newport beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Ellen Gaar Irvine California 92612 United States 3/21/2012Lisa Hupp Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Hilary Lau Irvine California 92614 United States 3/21/2012Brenda  Falk Corona California 92882 United States 3/21/2012Bradley Hampton Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/21/2012susan rauma Hesperia California 92345 United States 3/21/2012Amy Youngman Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Nishant Patel Irvine California 92603 United States 3/21/2012jacob ruck Irvine California 92614 United States 3/21/2012Austin Ahlborg los angeles California 90034 United States 3/21/2012Amanda  Garcia Olympia Washington 98506 United States 3/21/2012DeAnn Gardner Victorville California 92392 United States 3/21/2012Susan Nelson Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/21/2012Adam Nichols San Clemente California 92672 United States 3/21/2012Allie Rodriguez Orange California 92867 United States 3/21/2012Julia Herrington Costa MesA California 92627 United States 3/21/2012Michael Carey Balboa California 92662 United States 3/21/2012jane bangert long beach California 90814 United States 3/21/2012Kyle Evans Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/21/2012Matthew Ruck Irvine California 92614 United States 3/21/2012Pam Ragland Rancho Santa Margarita California 92688 United States 3/21/2012Daniel  Ortiz Irvine California 92606 United States 3/21/2012Shauna dye westminster California 92683 United States 3/21/2012Katherine  Berkowitz Brandon Florida 33511 United States 3/21/2012Ellen Solaas Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Jim Moise Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/21/2012Pam Spruce Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Brian Jacobs Wildomar California 92595 United States 3/21/2012Jackie Davis Newport beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012steve kearbey Hailey Idaho 83333 United States 3/21/2012Brandy Valdez Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/21/2012Adriana Moran Santa Ana California 92704 United States 3/21/2012Melissa Beck Long Beach California 90808 United States 3/21/2012Justin Sogoian Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/21/2012Stan Smith Laguna Niguel California 92677 United States 3/21/2012Judith Walthour Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 3/21/2012Paul King Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Jill Money Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Noel Duarte Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012courtney wesson Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Jeff Montgomery Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/21/2012Brittany Stidham Orland California 95963 United States 3/21/2012Marjorie Burnett cathedral city California 92234 United States 3/21/2012Alison Drain Lake Arrowhead California 92352 United States 3/21/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 253: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Matthew T Holzmann Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012anastasia moore irvine California 92620 United States 3/21/2012Lori Butler Vista California 92084 United States 3/21/2012Justin Langenberg Irvine California 92612 United States 3/21/2012Mary Morrison Costa Mesa California 92663 United States 3/21/2012Blair Eldridge newport beach California 92663 United States 3/21/2012Dennis Murphy Pleasanton California 94566 United States 3/21/2012Roger Luetkenhaus Huntington Beach California 92649 United States 3/21/2012J.R. Means Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/21/2012Crystal O Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/21/2012Brett  Spencer Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/21/2012Linda Painter Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Judi Warren Ladera Ranch California 92694 United States 3/21/2012Jackie Saxton College Station  Texas 77845 United States 3/21/2012Elizabeth vargas Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/21/2012Alexa Friedman Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Hana Simon Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Heidi Stimmler Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/21/2012Gale Friedman Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Luana Tontz Sun City California 92586 United States 3/21/2012Tamar vartanian irvine California 92620 United States 3/21/2012suzanne desforges newport beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012robin lawrence palm desert California 92260 United States 3/21/2012Nicole Doyle Dana Point California 92629 United States 3/21/2012Dan Reitz Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/21/2012Mary Wilhelm Anaheim California 92805 United States 3/21/2012chad hasbrouck ALTA LOMA California 91737 United States 3/21/2012Rachael Pizzo Huntington Beach California 92649 United States 3/21/2012Adam Masters Vista California 92081 United States 3/21/2012Evan Miles Santa Ana California 92703 United States 3/21/2012Heather Martin Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 3/21/2012Jay Palchikoff Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/21/2012Terri Green Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Anna Wooten Santa Ana California 92704 United States 3/21/2012Christopher Doyle Dana Point California 92629 United States 3/21/2012Jodie Evans Las Vegas Nevada 89103 United States 3/21/2012Barbi Townsend Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Michele Woodward Newport Beach California 926609 United States 3/21/2012barbara whalen costa mesa California 92626 United States 3/21/2012Claire Namdar Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/21/2012Jonathan Langford Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/21/2012Charles Roy Newport beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Brent Caldwell Irvine California 92612 United States 3/21/2012Bill Grunklee Fountain Valley California 92705 United States 3/21/2012Lisa Kassel Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Cheryl Lundstrom Irvine California 92620 United States 3/21/2012Tricia Kovely Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/21/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 254: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Dan Stone Irvine California 92614 United States 3/21/2012Dwight Hanson Irvine California 92604 United States 3/21/2012Keila Halili Tustin California 92780 United States 3/21/2012amy noe San Antonio Texas 78209 United States 3/21/2012Elizabeth  Buzzell Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/21/2012Barbara Nash Irvine California 92620 United States 3/21/2012Tim  Kelley Riverside California 92501 United States 3/21/2012Matthew Healy Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012nicole quinn Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Allan Newell Irvine California 92614 United States 3/21/2012michael michalchik newport beach California 92660 United States 3/21/2012Amber Woods Las Vegas Nevada 89148 United States 3/21/2012Russell Reeves San Juan Capistrano California 92675 United States 3/21/2012Adam Little Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/22/2012Jason Neria Orange California 92869 United States 3/22/2012Richard Andrews Irvine California 92604 United States 3/22/2012Craig Smith Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/22/2012Thomas Andrews Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/22/2012Marla  Layer Solvang California 93463 United States 3/22/2012Cindy Eddleman Irvine California 92612 United States 3/22/2012Cynthia lefmann Dana Point California 92629 United States 3/22/2012Christina Hampton Orange California 92869 United States 3/22/2012shane wooten Santa Ana California 92704 United States 3/22/2012Gary Acker Tustin California 92782 United States 3/22/2012chris Cloherty Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/22/2012diana warner NEWPORT BEACH California 92662 United States 3/22/2012Joseph Keichline San Diego California 92102 United States 3/22/2012bryson lefmann irvine California 92620 United States 3/22/2012Chris Twining Wildomar California 92595 United States 3/22/2012Stephanie Smith Anaheim California 92804 United States 3/22/2012Karen  Odell‐Barber Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/22/2012Kimberly Feinberg Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/22/2012Madeline  Ewles Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/22/2012Brad Starr Temecula California 92591 United States 3/22/2012Kevin Charles Irvine California 92612 United States 3/22/2012cynthia desurra Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/22/2012Wendy McManigal Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/22/2012tina morris Kamuela Hawaii 96743‐0238 United States 3/22/2012Kaitlin Patton Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/22/2012Rose Bourne Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/22/2012Karen Harrison Irvine California 92618 United States 3/22/2012Vivian Tang Irvine California 92617 United States 3/22/2012Cecilia Mah Monterey Park California 91754 United States 3/22/2012Kathryn Olson Irvine California 92618 United States 3/22/2012Carol Crane Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/22/2012Barry Zanck Irvine California 92603 United States 3/22/2012mark seaton los osos California 93402 United States 3/22/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 255: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Melinda Woodward Rancho Cucamonga California 91730 United States 3/22/2012Lisa Stanson Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/22/2012Patricia Ross Tustin California 92780 United States 3/22/2012Joan Sonnenberg Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/22/2012Cheri Ryan Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/22/2012Alexa Root Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/22/2012Grant Donaldson Tustin California 92780 United States 3/22/2012amanda zail Orange California 92866 United States 3/22/2012Teresa Marquez Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/22/2012Stacy  Taylor Laguna Niguel  California 92677 United States 3/22/2012Monica Davis Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/22/2012Julie Walehwa Anaheim California 92802 United States 3/22/2012Kent Moorlach Anaheim California 92807 United States 3/22/2012Charles Woodard New York New York 10001 United States 3/22/2012Nancy Dacumos Oak Hills California 92344 United States 3/22/2012Lawrence Michalchik buffalo Minnesota 55313 United States 3/22/2012Suzanne Hill Oceanside California 92057 United States 3/22/2012Erin Kerrigan Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/22/2012Becki Black Donatelli huntington beach California 92648 United States 3/22/2012Jessica Harris Orange California 92869 United States 3/22/2012Carol Cohn Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/22/2012Robert Andrews Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/22/2012Steven Shneider Silverado California 92676 United States 3/22/2012David Pittman Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/22/2012James Barber Newport Beach California 926660 United States 3/22/2012Pauline Scott Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/22/2012alexa rome Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/22/2012Deana Courreges Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 3/22/2012Bob LeCours Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/22/2012Megan Alvarez SANTA ANA California 92707 United States 3/22/2012Megan Hartshorne Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 3/22/2012marci franklin Newport beach California 92660 United States 3/22/2012Steve  Wolff Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/22/2012Daniel Archambault Pomona California 91767 United States 3/22/2012michelle o 84041 3/22/2012Jack Wu Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/22/2012Marybeth Waniek Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/22/2012ryan moe newport beach California 92660 United States 3/22/2012Eric  Tabon Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 3/22/2012Sheryl Hartshorne Irvine California 92620 United States 3/22/2012Jeff Greene Placentia California 92870 United States 3/22/2012Courtney Savage Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 3/22/2012Rick  Mayer Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/22/2012Donna Ostrom Irvine California 92623 United States 3/22/2012lara marcello Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/22/2012Nancy Osso Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/22/2012Sabrina Arce Irvine California 92617 United States 3/22/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 256: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Jesse Briggs Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/22/2012Mignon Whitaker Orange California 92866 United States 3/22/2012Robert Jacobsen Trabuco Canyon California 92679 United States 3/22/2012Christy Moffitt Villa Park California 92867 United States 3/22/2012Christopher Lal Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/22/2012Joshua Wrye Ontario California 91761 United States 3/22/2012Gordon Kennedy Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/22/2012Wrenna Johnson Irvine California 92603 United States 3/22/2012steve  bethel Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/22/2012Lisa Gastinger Riverside California 92503 United States 3/22/2012Scott Carpenter Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 3/22/2012Nina Vlatkovic Niskayuna New York 12309 United States 3/22/2012Amy Laurendeau Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/22/2012Rachel  Johnson Fullerton California 92831 United States 3/22/2012Cindi  Rhodes Orange California 92865 United States 3/22/2012Connor Kiley Irvine California 92614 United States 3/22/2012Sean L costa mesa California 92626 United States 3/22/2012Kurt Williams Ontario California 91762 United States 3/22/2012Christine Cochran Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/22/2012Marcia Behne Helendale California 92342 United States 3/22/2012Deanna Osborn Orange California 92867 United States 3/22/2012Roberta Gardner Murrieta California 92562 United States 3/22/2012Richard Dutch Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/22/2012Tracey Beaver Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/22/2012Lorina Amaral Pico 9950‐361 Portugal 3/22/2012Mike Lutton Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/22/2012Eileen Peters Newport Coast California 92657 United States 3/22/2012Claudio Galegos Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/22/2012Phillip DiGiacomo Los Angeles California 90045 United States 3/22/2012Bianca Leichnitz Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/22/2012Karen (KC) Kroeger Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/22/2012Peter Desforges Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/22/2012kim kegans newport beach California 92660 United States 3/22/2012yvonneYvonne claytonCerritos California 90703 United States 3/22/2012AnA Meshkin Newport Beach California 92657 United States 3/22/2012susan joyner Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/22/2012Trevor Strickland Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/22/2012Timothy Gallegos Covina California 91724 United States 3/22/2012Tom Wells El Monte California 91731 United States 3/22/2012F L Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/22/2012Tracy Wells El Monte California 91731 United States 3/22/2012Linda Rutan Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/22/2012Robert Evans Orange California 92865 United States 3/22/2012Maureen Halpert Newport Beach California 92658 United States 3/23/2012Dayna McCallum Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/23/2012joey peysar South Pasadena California 91030 United States 3/23/2012Michelle Nelson Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 3/23/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 257: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Marilyn Ghere Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 3/23/2012Jay Lindsay Orange California 92866 United States 3/23/2012Jim Child Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 3/23/2012Vicki High Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 3/23/2012Anna Child Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 3/23/2012Jeanne Newton West Covina California 91791 United States 3/23/2012Teresa  Fitzpatrick Anaheim California 92805 United States 3/23/2012Brian Fitzpatrick Anaheim California 92805 United States 3/23/2012'Shanna Torp Coeur d'Alene Idaho United States 3/23/2012Deanna Miranda Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/23/2012Betsy OGDEN Mesa Idaho 83643 United States 3/23/2012bryan browns  la habra California 90631 United States 3/23/2012Sue Dart Tustin California 92780 United States 3/23/2012cheryl crocker  leander Texas 78645 United States 3/23/2012Simon Battersby Denver Colorado 80228 United States 3/23/2012Sterling Hedani Murrieta California 92562 United States 3/23/2012Amanda Billett Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/23/2012Vicki Giansante Rowland Heights California 91748 United States 3/23/2012Chelsea Hilbert Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/23/2012Janae Lee Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/23/2012Erica Diaz Santa Ana California 92707 United States 3/23/2012Lisa Bickel Rathdrum Idaho 83858 United States 3/23/2012Marjean Hoyt Tustin California 92780 United States 3/23/2012Anna Sanchez Brea California 92821 United States 3/23/2012laura  serna Fountain Valley California 92708 United States 3/23/2012Greg Marshall Irvine California 92614 United States 3/23/2012Robyn  Vermilyea Petaluma California 94952 United States 3/23/2012laura gordon fullerton California 92835 United States 3/23/2012Ann Sebek Irvine California 92614 United States 3/23/2012Jordan Feole La Verne California 91750 United States 3/23/2012Lynne Liden Irvine California 92603 United States 3/23/2012Scott Young Whittier California 90603 United States 3/23/2012Rebecca Giansante Rowland Heights California 91748 United States 3/23/2012Joel Warren Cornwall New York 12518 United States 3/23/2012George Zankich glendora California 91740 United States 3/23/2012Stephanie Divito Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 3/23/2012robin pelton corona del mar  California 92625 United States 3/23/2012Michelle Huelle Yucca Valley California 92284 United States 3/23/2012Diane  Johansen Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/23/2012karie decker corona del mar California 92625 United States 3/23/2012Bonnie Tovaas Gilman Hot Springs California 92583 United States 3/23/2012Steve Johannes Moose Wyoming 83001 United States 3/23/2012James Morris Surprise Arizona 85379 United States 3/23/2012Larry Dunmire Newport Beach California 92662 United States 3/23/2012Anthony Kuo Irvine California 92612 United States 3/23/2012Venus  Montoya Chino Hills California 91709 United States 3/23/2012Sherry Vermillion Upland California 91784 United States 3/23/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 258: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Patti Johns Corona California 92880 United States 3/23/2012Taisha Bonilla Los Angeles California 90026 United States 3/23/2012Alyson Vislocky Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/23/2012Brian Jackson Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 3/23/2012chuck Bluemel Long Beach California 90815 United States 3/23/2012Chris Livesey Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/23/2012Karen Brown Charlotte North Carolina 28277 United States 3/23/2012Mark Strickland Rancho Santa Margarita California 92688 United States 3/23/2012Chris Rock‐Andre Placentia California 92870 United States 3/23/2012Gloria Stahmer Claremont California 91711 United States 3/23/2012Maura Mikulec Capistrano Beach California 92624 United States 3/23/2012Meghan Anderson‐CoaChico California 95928 United States 3/23/2012Janeen Oliver Los Alamitos California 90720 United States 3/23/2012Lori Jackson L.A. California 90039 United States 3/23/2012patrick ROBLES SAN LUIS OBISPO California 93401 United States 3/23/2012Walter Bell Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/23/2012Courtney Frystak Los Angeles California 90029 United States 3/23/2012John Tovaas Lakewood California 90713 United States 3/23/2012Amy  Bellanger Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/23/2012Jayne Miller Coon Rapids Minnesota 55433 United States 3/23/2012Kevin Babb Irvine California 92604 United States 3/23/2012Eric Overturf Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/23/2012Catherine Spencer gardena California 90248 United States 3/23/2012William Ferguson Los Angeles California 90039 United States 3/23/2012Keith Rodenhuis Costa Mesa California 92626‐6544 United States 3/23/2012Bill Stellmacher Diamond Bar California 91765 United States 3/23/2012Jen Prink Benicia California 94510 United States 3/23/2012Brad Davis Fullerton California 92832 United States 3/23/2012Andrew Monteabaro Lakewood California 90713 United States 3/23/2012Ankit Patel tustin California 92780 United States 3/23/2012Shannon  Erdos‐Jock Dallas Texas 75252 United States 3/23/2012Emily Tonkin Pebble beach California 93953 United States 3/23/2012Angela Lambert Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/23/2012Jonathan Chavez Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/23/2012Nikki Miller Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/23/2012Brian Anderson Santa Cruz California 95060 United States 3/23/2012Dorothy Roden Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/23/2012Julie Nicholson Temecula California 92592 United States 3/23/2012Scott Kohan newport beach California 92663 United States 3/23/2012casey chiu irvine California 92602 United States 3/23/2012Hannie Peng Tustin California 92782 United States 3/23/2012Casey  Page Irvine California 92604 United States 3/23/2012Zachary Kelly Irvine California 92604 United States 3/23/2012Trisha  Wilson Cypress California 90630 United States 3/23/2012Caroline Busby Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/23/2012denise bray huntington beach California 92646 United States 3/23/2012Renee Wilcox Yucca Valley California 92284 United States 3/23/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 259: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Nicole Huelle Yucca Valley California 92284 United States 3/23/2012dawn smisek EL PASO Texas 79938 United States 3/23/2012Carrie Steen Orange California 92866 United States 3/23/2012Priscilla Barrett Placentia California 92870 United States 3/23/2012Catherine Bartz Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/24/2012Joan Bell Irivne California 92614 United States 3/24/2012katharine sentz Riverside California 92506 United States 3/24/2012Cathleen Earle Chino California 91710 United States 3/24/2012Rob Vandervort Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/24/2012Michelle Jensen Riverside California 92503 United States 3/24/2012Daniyal Ali Irvine California 92603 United States 3/24/2012Chris Kerstner Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/24/2012Kirk Fisher Wildomar California 92595 United States 3/24/2012Nick Kozloski Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 3/24/2012Marcus swartz Bellflower California 90706 United States 3/24/2012cherrill Kawakami Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/24/2012Allesson Stensing Buffalo Minnesota 55313 United States 3/24/2012mark abshire santa ana California 92705 United States 3/24/2012kara kenney Irvine California 92604 United States 3/24/2012Jennifer West Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/24/2012Jeff Jones Riverside California 92506 United States 3/24/2012Theresa Hughes Riverside California 92504 United States 3/24/2012Christopher Bowden Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/24/2012Gabi Schwaiger Irvine California 92603 United States 3/24/2012Sharon Hanson Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/24/2012Sean Kopeny Dana Point California 92629 United States 3/24/2012Bernard  DeMarkey Orange California 92867 United States 3/24/2012John Barkume Monrovia California 91016 United States 3/24/2012Paige McKinney Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/24/2012Tiffany Zukerberg Corona del mar California 92625 United States 3/24/2012jon bowden santa ana California 92626 United States 3/24/2012Tutrinh Vo Orange California 92869 United States 3/24/2012Elsa Nguyen Irvine California 92617 United States 3/24/2012Steven Tidball Orangevale California 95662 United States 3/24/2012William Roche Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 3/24/2012isabel  Rojas Unterhaching 82008 unterhGermany 3/24/2012Jonathan Brooks Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/24/2012Julie James Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 3/24/2012Stephen Newman Newport Beach California 92662 United States 3/24/2012ashley martinez Whittier California 90605 United States 3/24/2012dan   rosenthal cdm California 92625 United States 3/24/2012Thomas Rock Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/24/2012Viki Smith Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/24/2012lara montagne santa ana California 92702 United States 3/24/2012Dena Ress huntington beach California 92615 United States 3/24/2012Leah Lowthorp Dana Point California 92629 United States 3/24/2012Ellen Albright Stanton California 90680 United States 3/24/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 260: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Kerstin  Schmitt Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/24/2012Cathleen  Nebrida Carlsbad California 92010 United States 3/24/2012Theresa  Rife Irvine California 92612 United States 3/24/2012Rebecca Kaplan San Diego California 92108 United States 3/24/2012Tom Dietz Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 3/24/2012Hayley DeKlotz Irvine California 92604 United States 3/25/2012Jennifer Cernek Hemet California 92543 United States 3/25/2012Moiz Horani West Covina California 91792 United States 3/25/2012Cheryl Rife Irvine California 92612‐2230 United States 3/25/2012Steve Abraham Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/25/2012Lindsey  Moise  Arlington Virginia 22205 United States 3/25/2012Jocelyn Holmes Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/25/2012thomas stapp san francisco California 94131 United States 3/25/2012Gregory Newman Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 3/25/2012Linda Rife Tustin California 92780 United States 3/25/2012Dina Mead Wilmette Illinois 60091 United States 3/25/2012Myda Suhal Corona California 92881 United States 3/25/2012Alyssa Vargha Anaheim California 92807 United States 3/25/2012Nathan Copier Logan Utah 84321 United States 3/25/2012Mike Anderson Orange California 92869 United States 3/25/2012maisam dewji Fullerton California 92833 United States 3/25/2012Charles Rogerson Staines TW18 2SR United Kingdom 3/25/2012Matt Sonnenberg Trabuco Canyon California 92679 United States 3/25/2012James Feederle Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/25/2012Melissa  MacArthur  Irvine California 92604 United States 3/25/2012Ian Proehl Irvine California 92604 United States 3/25/2012amber brown NRH Texas 76180 United States 3/25/2012Matt Maroney Los Angeles California 90012 United States 3/25/2012Eric Dow Diamond Bar California 91765 United States 3/25/2012tera shatsky NB California 92657 United States 3/25/2012Debbie Bolduc Orange California 92869 United States 3/25/2012Terra Anders Midvale Utah 84047 United States 3/25/2012Lori Bohnet Garden Grove California 92842 United States 3/25/2012Chris  Kervin NRH Texas 76180 United States 3/25/2012Amy Jones Balboa Island California 92662 United States 3/25/2012janelle saloga Garden Grove California 92840 United States 3/25/2012gayle hachiya huntington beach California 92646 United States 3/25/2012Jason  Jacobs Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 3/25/2012dan lebo costa mesa California 92627 United States 3/25/2012Deborah Gentry Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/25/2012Matthew Blair Los Angeles California 90036 United States 3/25/2012ROBERT Hays Agoura Hills California 91301 United States 3/25/2012Aaron Black irvine California 92620 United States 3/25/2012kristen hollowaty san francisco California 94118 United States 3/25/2012Mark Cohen Lagina Beach California 92651 United States 3/25/2012Herman  Cundall San Clemente California 92672 United States 3/25/2012Vanessa Valdes Newport Beach California 92625 United States 3/25/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 261: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Jennifer Huang Irvine California 92606 United States 3/25/2012Allison Ross San Diego California 92108 United States 3/25/2012Jeane Ruston Balboa Island California 92662 United States 3/25/2012Jeanette Liao Los Angeles California 90025 United States 3/25/2012Allen Ho Irvine California 92620 United States 3/25/2012Alex Hernandez Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/25/2012Christopher Nguyen Irvine California 92620 United States 3/25/2012Allan Bartlett Irvine California 92603 United States 3/25/2012Roge Zhao TUstin California 92782 United States 3/25/2012Piet Agle Irvine California 92603 United States 3/25/2012Lisa  Perry  Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/25/2012Mason Rhodes orange California 92865 United States 3/25/2012Kellie Watson Menifee California 92584 United States 3/26/2012Kevin Hagerty Fountain Valley California 92708 United States 3/26/2012Sue Crapo Kaysville Utah Km m ,J8403 United States 3/26/2012Joyce Cylwik Big Bear Lake California 92315 United States 3/26/2012Ursula Quinn Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/26/2012Ann Asgari Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/26/2012Chris Tran Irvine California 92618 United States 3/26/2012Amanda Lin Irvine California 92614 United States 3/26/2012Andrew Bowden Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/26/2012bob foyle Orange California 92869 United States 3/26/2012Penny Darling Balboa Island California 92662 United States 3/26/2012adam krsanson newport beach California 92660 United States 3/26/2012Eric Eilenberg Tustin California 92780 United States 3/26/2012Amy Washburn Tustin California 92780 United States 3/26/2012Scott Mailly Irvine California 92614 United States 3/26/2012Chelsea Hilliard Irvine California 92604 United States 3/26/2012Meghan  Macias Irvine California 92620 United States 3/26/2012Jen Anderson Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/26/2012Diane Smith Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/26/2012Mikelle Fish Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/26/2012Brian Hightower Austin Texas 78729 United States 3/26/2012Ricky Qi Irvine California 92620 United States 3/26/2012Elizabeth Herndon Villa Park California 92861 United States 3/26/2012Puya Vakili Irvine California 92603 United States 3/26/2012jon kuhl Orange California 92866 United States 3/26/2012julia  patton Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/26/2012Britton Huycke Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/26/2012Barbara Wagner Irvine California 92612 United States 3/26/2012Shasha Jhaveri Irvine California 92612 United States 3/26/2012Brian Lusher King George Virginia 22485 United States 3/26/2012Mason Flannery Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/26/2012Melissa Banks Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/26/2012Cora Flannery Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/26/2012Jane Pace Orange California 92869 United States 3/26/2012Heather Hodgson Orange California 92867 United States 3/26/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 262: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Andrew Ducote Ladera Ranch California 92694 United States 3/26/2012David Poole Tustin California 92701 United States 3/26/2012Baron Night Buena Park California 90621 United States 3/26/2012Ed Timmons Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/26/2012Natalee Gunther Ladera Ranch California 92694 United States 3/26/2012Ben Colcol Anaheim California 92806 United States 3/26/2012Sophia Harding Huntington Beach California 92649 United States 3/27/2012Andrew Tran Irvine California 92604 United States 3/27/2012Cherie Rife Lake Forest California 92630 United States 3/27/2012Amanda Arias newport beach California 92661 United States 3/27/2012naomi menezes irvine California 92618 United States 3/27/2012Jenny Tate Chino California 91710 United States 3/27/2012Chris Behrend San Diego California 92115 United States 3/27/2012Lauren Hanson Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 3/27/2012kevin Brennan S.A. California 92705 United States 3/27/2012bria still newport beach California 92661 United States 3/27/2012michael billings newport beach California 92663 United States 3/27/2012Anne P Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 3/27/2012Teri Porteous Irvine California 92620 United States 3/27/2012Alexander Cameron Louisville Kentucky 40207 United States 3/27/2012Dana  Black Ketchum Idaho 83340 United States 3/27/2012Richard Shaw Newport Beach California 92662 United States 3/27/2012winter herrera Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 3/27/2012Gail Mooers newport beach California 92663 United States 3/27/2012Robert Henning II Garden Grove California 92841 United States 3/27/2012Bob Kline Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/27/2012heather hovis Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/27/2012Athena Anderson Orange California 92867 United States 3/27/2012don green irvine California 92604 United States 3/27/2012Brian Amende Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/27/2012Peter Mowery Mission Viejo California 92692 United States 3/27/2012Cheryl Hepburn Huntington Beach California 92649 United States 3/27/2012Rick Vollstedt  Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 3/27/2012Dana  Estes Riverside California 92504 United States 3/27/2012Daniel Barta Placentia California 92870 United States 3/28/2012William Eeles Tustin California 92780 United States 3/28/2012Angela Pena  Tustin California 92782 United States 3/28/2012Ryan Nguyen Irvine California 92612 United States 3/28/2012Edward Ono Fountain Valley California 92708 United States 3/28/2012Jenifer Weiman Newport Beach California 92659 United States 3/28/2012Stefan  Tidy Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/28/2012ramsey Kukalis  Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/28/2012Padraig Cullen Laguna Hills California 92625 United States 3/28/2012Thomas Geib Balboa California 92661 United States 3/28/2012Cindy Suter Palm Springs California 92262 United States 3/28/2012William Sharpe Irvine California 92620 United States 3/28/2012Sara Johnston Irvine California 92620 United States 3/28/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 263: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Michael Corboy Golden Colorado 80410 United States 3/28/2012Adam Tornquist Irvine California 92617 United States 3/28/2012Kevin  Tornquist IRvine California 92604 United States 3/28/2012Abdul El‐Haj Ibrahim Irvine California 92606 United States 3/28/2012Sorasit Wanichpan Irvine California 92604 United States 3/28/2012Scott Yokoyama Irvine California 92604 United States 3/28/2012Lisa Gustafson Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/28/2012Amy Wolken Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/28/2012Mark Franco Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/28/2012Bobby Marquez Irvine California 92620 United States 3/28/2012irene conforti Irvine California 92620 United States 3/28/2012Shelby Galler Costa Mesa California 92628 United States 3/28/2012Keith Fierro San Bernardino California 92404 United States 3/28/2012Elena Piercey Irvine California 92618 United States 3/28/2012Anders Goacher Roanoke Virginia 24018 United States 3/28/2012Alexander Avery Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/28/2012Christopher Gravitt Irvine California 92602 United States 3/28/2012Michael Hattan Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/28/2012Jamie Durston Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/28/2012Crystal Newton San Dimas California 91773 United States 3/28/2012Derek Haynsworth Santa Cruz California 95062 United States 3/28/2012Randy Wilcox Tustin California 92782 United States 3/28/2012Lindsey Reed costa mesa California 92626 United States 3/28/2012kathleen  rould Rancho Cucamonga California 91737 United States 3/29/2012michele rould Rancho Cucamonga California 91737 United States 3/29/2012Nancy  Gadol  Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/29/2012Kelly Fitzsimmons Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/29/2012Spencer  Jallali Tustin California 92782 United States 3/29/2012Kimberly Sterling Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/29/2012Susan Hillseth South Pasadena California 91030 United States 3/29/2012Kevin Astor Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/29/2012Jan Fleming Hunt. Bch California 714 United States 3/29/2012Shirley Adams Lancaster California 93539 United States 3/29/2012Ethan Bartolic Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/29/2012Daniel loyer costa mesa California 92627 United States 3/29/2012Kyle Sherman Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/29/2012Patricia Moise Irvine California 92614 United States 3/29/2012Kyla Mulhern costa mesa California 92628 United States 3/29/2012Hannah Bearden Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/29/2012Phyllis Paulsen Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/29/2012Dana Fier Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/29/2012Melanie Dobson Irvine California 92614 United States 3/29/2012Kenneth  Meissner Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/29/2012Kim Weber Santa Ana California 92705 United States 3/29/2012Bernadette Forte San Diego California 92107 United States 3/29/2012Kathleen Farrell costa Mesa California 92626 United States 3/29/2012Tyler Barrett San Diego 92106 United States Mino 3/29/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 264: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Lisa Henderson Orange California 92866 United States 3/29/2012Tracy Wittman Whittier California 90606 United States 3/30/2012Sandra Orwin Corona California 92883 United States 3/30/2012Alex Quinn Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/30/2012Doudlas McBride Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/30/2012Laura  Timms Long Beach California 90801 United States 3/30/2012chuck conway newport beach California 92660 United States 3/30/2012Faye Miller Oceanside California 92057 United States 3/30/2012lena mercuri cypress California 90630 United States 3/30/2012Carmen Cimini Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/30/2012Jamie Meagher Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/30/2012tony Riva Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/30/2012lisa schultz Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/30/2012charles  Schultz Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/30/2012Art Paquette Santa Ana California 92707 United States 3/30/2012Paul Tolman Garden Grove California 92841 United States 3/30/2012Sheri Money Philadelphia Pennsylvania 19104 United States 3/30/2012Jennifer Cole Suwanee Georgia 30024 United States 3/30/2012Christine Martin Inglewood California 90301 United States 3/30/2012George Wong Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 3/30/2012Steven Wang Irvine California 92620 United States 3/30/2012Christopher Ng Irvine California 92604 United States 3/30/2012Pamela Saloga Johnstown Pennsylvania 15904 United States 3/30/2012June Marchigiani Newport Beach California 92660 United States 3/30/2012Jeni Erickson Newport Beach California 92663 United States 3/30/2012Jonathan Wade Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 3/30/2012William King‐Lewis Las Vegas Nevada 89138 United States 3/30/2012Karen McNeeley Ladera Ranch California 92694 United States 3/30/2012Joshua Chang Monterey Park California 91755 United States 3/30/2012Sarah Albaugh Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 3/30/2012Meg Hanrahan Corona California 92882 United States 3/30/2012Amy Whiley San Mateo California 94401 United States 3/30/2012Curtis Nelson Murrieta California 92563 United States 3/30/2012Nathan  Lin Cerritos California 90703 United States 3/30/2012Thomas Duncan Tustin California 92780 United States 3/30/2012Rick Peyton  San Mateo California 94402 United States 3/30/2012Denise Ransdell Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/30/2012Jamie  Chen La Palma California 90623 United States 3/30/2012Alan Ray Huntington Beach California 92649 United States 3/30/2012Garrett Gentry Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/30/2012Cynthia Whitley Woodland California 95695 United States 3/30/2012Andrew esguerra Westminster California 92683 United States 3/30/2012Thu Luu Irvine California 92604 United States 3/30/2012Ron Schlemmer Rogue River Oregon 97537 United States 3/30/2012conni judson cdm California 92625 United States 3/30/2012Rico Santiago Brea California 92821 United States 3/30/2012trevor clark Irvine California 92618 United States 3/31/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 265: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

tom green SANTA MONICA California 90405 United States 3/31/2012Alex Ray Newport Beach California 92661 United States 3/31/2012Collin Sherman Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 3/31/2012roger tirabassi corona del mar California 92625 United States 3/31/2012Jenna Judson Palm Desert California 92211 United States 3/31/2012HAN HUA GARDEN GROVE California 92843 United States 3/31/2012brian phan fountain valley California 92708 United States 3/31/2012Joseph Vu Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 3/31/2012Jennifer Keane Fountain Valley California 92708 United States 4/1/2012Julie Finn Chino California 91710 United States 4/1/2012sue volpe newport beach California 92660 United States 4/1/2012molly moreno moreno valley California 92551 United States 4/1/2012Allyson Cunha newport beach California 92656 United States 4/1/2012Barry Long Richmond Virginia 23227 United States 4/1/2012Stephanie Reahm Las Vegas Nevada 89148 United States 4/1/2012Lisa Anderson Newport Beach California 92660 United States 4/1/2012Pepper Puckett Red Bluff California 96080 United States 4/1/2012Marty Herron Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 4/1/2012James Clarke Newport Beach California 92660 United States 4/1/2012Samuel Cisneros Glendora California 91740 United States 4/1/2012Arman Beirami Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 4/1/2012Anthony Paduano Newport Beach California 92663 United States 4/1/2012Leopoldo Torres Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 4/2/2012Giovanna Cruz Tustin California 92780 United States 4/2/2012George Bates Tustin California 92780 United States 4/2/2012Christa Borggreve Newport Beach California 92663 United States 4/2/2012Edna Abrahamson Anaheim Hills California 92807 United States 4/2/2012brent sephel tustin California 92780 United States 4/2/2012paulette collins Temecula California 92592 United States 4/2/2012michael brown simi valley California 93063 United States 4/2/2012Terry Nichols Beaverton Oregon 97006 United States 4/2/2012William Billetter Fountain Valley California 92708 United States 4/2/2012Sandy Sandino‐SalsmaOrange California 92869 United States 4/2/2012Tamara Blatt Arden North Carolina 28704 United States 4/2/2012Ted Canedy Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 4/2/2012maureen Sullivan Corona California 92882 United States 4/2/2012C Csank Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 4/2/2012Ali Alsaleh North Hollywood California 91601 United States 4/2/2012Jeff Smith Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 4/2/2012Steve  Perkins Santa cruz California 95060 United States 4/2/2012Chris Craven Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 4/2/2012KATRIN HORZAD IRVINE California 92629 United States 4/2/2012JERRY PRUITT ORANE California 92867 United States 4/2/2012Annahita Mahdavi Irvine California 92612 United States 4/2/2012Feri Shafiei Tustin California 92782 United States 4/2/2012John Kolb Jr Belmont Michigan 49306 United States 4/2/2012adriana petersen Corona Del mar California 92625 United States 4/2/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 266: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Gary Clark Irvine California 92603 United States 4/3/2012Aimee Duff Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 4/3/2012Zack Bates RSM California 92688 United States 4/3/2012Keyan Safyari los angeles California 90025 United States 4/3/2012Kelly Ketcho Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 4/3/2012Jeremy Beyor Rialto California 92377 United States 4/3/2012Fred Ketcho Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 4/3/2012Olya Krapivina Los Angeles California 90046 United States 4/3/2012Jesse Wilson Sherman Oaks California 91423 United States 4/3/2012tina lambert Clovis California 93611 United States 4/3/2012Cathy Pinkert Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 4/3/2012Heather Christiano Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 4/3/2012joe durica mission viejo California 92692 United States 4/3/2012chriss  arrowood rsm California 92688 United States 4/3/2012Tim Lister Long Beach California 90802 United States 4/3/2012Sharon Mullins newport beach California 92660 United States 4/3/2012Mary Kanotz Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 4/3/2012Scott Lopez Irvine California 92606 United States 4/3/2012Andrew  Herron Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 4/3/2012Joann Skinner Columbus Ohio 43206 United States 4/3/2012Shannon Magner Newport Beach California 92663 United States 4/3/2012jerelyn Bradshaw Orange California 92868 United States 4/3/2012Bradford Charlton Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 4/4/2012John Hamel Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 4/4/2012Alex Espinoza Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 4/4/2012Erika Primeau newport beach California 92663 United States 4/4/2012dave ecclestone gilbert Arizona 85297 United States 4/4/2012Gale Galbraith Huntington Beach California 92649 United States 4/5/2012Gibran Stout Newport Beach California 98660 United States 4/5/2012Patricia Gray Buena Park California 90620 United States 4/5/2012suzanne johnson CHICO California 95928 United States 4/5/2012suzanne bragg Corona del mar California 92625 United States 4/5/2012Karen Blackstone Newport Beach California 92660 United States 4/5/2012Ryan Christopher Newport Beach California 92660 United States 4/5/2012Maggie brewer Newport Beach California 92663 United States 4/6/2012Dwayne Adams Orange California 92867 United States 4/6/2012Tracy Robert Newport Beach California 92661 United States 4/6/2012Jennie Kosko Menlo Park California 94025 United States 4/6/2012Michell lisowski mission viejo California 92692 United States 4/7/2012David Corcoran Oceanside California 92057 United States 4/7/2012scott seabaugh corona del mar California 92625 United States 4/7/2012Susan Oliver Ocean View Hawaii 96737 United States 4/8/2012Howard Ahmanson Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 4/8/2012Michael Resk Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 4/8/2012Tatiana Bahu Anaheim California 92807 United States 4/8/2012Tyler Williamson Lake Forest California 92630 United States 4/8/2012Laura Collier Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 4/8/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 267: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Kevin Dun Newport Beach California 92659 United States 4/8/2012Brandon Kingcaid Newport Beach California 92660 United States 4/8/2012Amy St. John Mableton Georgia 30126 United States 4/8/2012John Tran Newport Beach California 92663 United States 4/8/2012Elizabeth Key Fullerton California 92831 United States 4/8/2012Vern Glaser Tustin California 92780 United States 4/9/2012Julia Hayashi irvine California 92620 United States 4/9/2012Luis Figueroa Santa Ana California 92707 United States 4/9/2012Norelle Keller Rocklin California 95765 United States 4/9/2012Michael Bjorkman Irvine California 92603 United States 4/9/2012Anthony  Miller irvine California 92612 United States 4/9/2012Beverly Plass Irvine California 92620 United States 4/9/2012denelle reid San Juan Capistrano California 92675 United States 4/9/2012Ainsley Buie costa mesa California 92627 United States 4/9/2012Michael Nolf COSTA MESA California 92627 United States 4/9/2012brandon wronski orange California 92869 United States 4/9/2012Leslie Pfaff Los Alamos New Mexico 87544 United States 4/9/2012Julie  Hurley Aurora Ohio 44202 United States 4/9/2012Sharon Gentry Irvine California 92603 United States 4/9/2012Joe Herrera Mission Viejo California 92692 United States 4/9/2012Denise Mitchell Fullerton California 92831 United States 4/9/2012Josephine Kneisel Van Nuys California 91406 United States 4/9/2012Deborah Southworth Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 4/9/2012carla wallace Laguna Niguel California 92677 United States 4/9/2012Bobbie Boice Roseburg Oregon 97470 United States 4/9/2012Alizabeth James Surprise Arizona 85388 United States 4/9/2012stephen giglio CA California 92780 United States 4/9/2012Bianka Rivera Santa Ana California 92706 United States 4/9/2012Shirley Ogletree Oceanside California 92057 United States 4/9/2012Suzanne  Hobbs  Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 4/10/2012Catherine Shatafian Newport Beach California 92661 United States 4/10/2012brian southworth newport beach California 92663 United States 4/10/2012Cherie Mansfield Newport Beach California 92662 United States 4/10/2012Beverley jones corona del mar California 92625 United States 4/10/2012James Hill Irvine California 92620 United States 4/10/2012Amie Wylie Fullerton California 92832 United States 4/10/2012Derrick fuhrmann costa mesa California 92626 United States 4/10/2012Sherry Hadland Irvine California 92604 United States 4/10/2012Janis Clarke Palm Desert California 92260 United States 4/10/2012Samantha Willard Laguna Niguel California 92677 United States 4/10/2012Denise Harvey Auburn California 95602 United States 4/11/2012Cynthia  Martin Penn Valley California 95946 United States 4/11/2012Taylor Madden Irvine California 92604 United States 4/11/2012Chris Shenton Tustin California 92780 United States 4/11/2012Gae Seal Nevada City, Ca 95959 California 95959 United States 4/11/2012Nico Reese Irvine California 92604 United States 4/11/2012Lang Pierce Irvine California 92618 United States 4/11/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 268: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

ricky spence orange California 92869‐1738 United States 4/11/2012Trevor Sikes Irvine California 92612 United States 4/11/2012Tyler Burnstein Irvine California 92604 United States 4/11/2012Kaylie Scott Orange California 92867 United States 4/11/2012Renzo Mascia Dana Point California 92629 United States 4/11/2012Klaire Melnick Irvine California 92614‐7581 United States 4/11/2012Zak Young Irvine California 92620 United States 4/11/2012Hailey  Smith Newport Beach California 92661 United States 4/11/2012david sigler San Dimas California 91773 United States 4/12/2012Kelly Botto Yorba Linda California 92887 United States 4/12/2012Tereza Yzaguirre Riverside California 92509 United States 4/12/2012Dana Sigler‐Wardlow San Dimas California 91773‐1938 United States 4/12/2012Christine Powers LA HABRA HEIGHTS California 90631 United States 4/12/2012Timothy Trinidad Glendale California 91202 United States 4/12/2012Tim  Wylie Fullerton California 92832 United States 4/12/2012Ariel Oxman Santa Fe Springs California 90670 United States 4/12/2012Bri Goetz Tustin California 92780 United States 4/13/2012briana storms Mckinney Texas 75070 United States 4/13/2012Eric Moore Newport Beach California 92661 United States 4/13/2012Matthew Wright san dimas California 91773 United States 4/13/2012Maureen Jaroscak Santa Fe Springs California 90670 United States 4/13/2012Chris Meadows Irvine California 92614 United States 4/14/2012Peter Ventura Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 4/14/2012Molly Curtiss Irvine California 92614 United States 4/15/2012RuthAnn Santos Whittier California 90605 United States 4/15/2012James Ray Newport Beach California 92661 United States 4/15/2012Barry Whitesides Irvine California 92604 United States 4/15/2012Rick Hume Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 4/15/2012Dennis Pascua Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 4/15/2012Kenneth Pratt Irvine California 92620 United States 4/15/2012steve rabago Laguna Beach California 92652 United States 4/15/2012Linda Cortese newport beach California 92660 United States 4/15/2012Betty Dooley Balboa California 92661 United States 4/15/2012Joel Elowsky Mequon Wisconsin 53097 United States 4/15/2012Aria Ziatabarai Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 4/16/2012Jeff Grimm San Diego California 92130 United States 4/16/2012Kelly Kay Mill Valley California 94941 United States 4/16/2012William Norwine Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 4/16/2012flora rompas idaho springs Colorado 80452 United States 4/16/2012Mark Devenpeck Irvine California 92612 United States 4/16/2012Carole Morris Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 4/16/2012john campbell balboa California 92661 United States 4/17/2012lynn dombrowski irvine California 92617 United States 4/17/2012Nedda Kay Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 4/17/2012Ross Muller Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 4/17/2012Heather Talbott Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 4/18/2012Sandra Sullivan Anaheim California 92804 United States 4/18/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 269: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

christian talbott Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 4/18/2012Amy Hernandez Tustin California 92782 United States 4/18/2012Teresa Campos Corona California 92882 United States 4/18/2012Christina  Bucaro Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 4/18/2012Cassidy Macdonald Newport Beach California 92660 United States 4/18/2012Kati Mowat Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 4/18/2012Bert Grandia Westminster California 92683 United States 4/18/2012John Capone Irvine California 92612 United States 4/19/2012Brenda McCune Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 4/19/2012DeAnna Risinger Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 4/19/2012Tim McCune yorba linda California 92886 United States 4/19/2012Michelle Mantyla Newport Beach California 92663 United States 4/19/2012Victor Cook Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 4/19/2012David  Ray Felton California 95018 United States 4/19/2012Teresa Taylor Canyon Country California 91387 United States 4/19/2012D Dansby Orange California 92866 United States 4/20/2012Laurie Latham Brea California 92823 United States 4/20/2012Bobby Favaro tustin California 92780 United States 4/20/2012Winston Hodge Newport Beach California 92660 United States 4/20/2012Andrew Dorsett Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 4/20/2012Meghan Reeve Newport Beach California 92660 United States 4/22/2012Denise Martin rialto California 92377 United States 4/22/2012Carla Chun santa ana California 92705 United States 4/23/2012Cal Culmer Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 4/23/2012Stephany Rudd Long Beach California 90803 United States 4/24/2012David Silva Summerland California 93067 United States 4/24/2012Deb Marsteller Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 4/24/2012Kate Fancher Orange California 92868 United States 4/24/2012Lisa May Corona California 92882 United States 4/24/2012Steven Alan Fry San Juan Capistrano California 92675 United States 4/27/2012Charles Long Davis California 95616 United States 4/28/2012Georgette Johnson Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 4/28/2012robert amond northridge California 91326 United States 4/28/2012Thomas Christiansen San Clemente California 92672 United States 4/29/2012Carolyn Prough Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 4/29/2012Sharon Rhodes Dana Point California 92629 United States 4/29/2012Jerry Grinstead Citrus Heights California 95621 United States 4/29/2012nathan nguyen garden grove California 92841 United States 5/2/2012josephine hsai Hacienda Heights California 91745 United States 5/2/2012James Yang Fountain Valley California 92708 United States 5/2/2012Tan Tran Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 5/2/2012Yosuke Arai Garden Grove California 92845 United States 5/2/2012Mimi Tiet Garden Grove California 92840 United States 5/2/2012Choy NanthavongdouaMoreno Valley California 92553 United States 5/2/2012Melissa Thomas Altadena California 91001 United States 5/3/2012john bryant Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 5/4/2012Carrie Bryant Newport Beach California 92662 United States 5/6/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 270: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Juan  Lopez corona California 92882 United States 5/6/2012Steve Iverson Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 5/7/2012James Rigdon Long Beach California 90804 United States 5/7/2012Diane  Valdies Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 5/7/2012Jennifer Crump Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 5/7/2012Michele Burnside Irvine California 92606 United States 5/7/2012Cindy Petrovich Irvine California 92606 United States 5/7/2012Irma Aguilar hays Seal Beach California 90740 United States 5/7/2012Deena Carpenter Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 5/7/2012James Hunter Irvine California 92604 United States 5/7/2012Jeffrey Ellison Riverside California 92509 United States 5/7/2012Dora Arellano Glendora California 91741 United States 5/7/2012Michaelyn Pouncey Tracy California 95376 United States 5/7/2012Peggy Evans Irvine California 92604 United States 5/7/2012Terri Hastings Roseville California 95678 United States 5/8/2012Nate Wyne LOS ANGELES California 90066 United States 5/8/2012Andrew Contreiras Newport Beach California 92661 United States 5/9/2012Tom Nouri Irvine California 92614 United States 5/9/2012Neil Hueston Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/9/2012Barrett Steele Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/9/2012Wade Cleveland Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 5/10/2012Ricci King Seattle Washington 98126 United States 5/10/2012Maryam Pakdelan Orange 92863 United States Mino 5/10/2012Solmaz N Irvine California 92614 United States 5/11/2012Fred Fourcher Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 5/11/2012T Shea Laguna Beach California 92652 United States 5/11/2012marie shea Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 5/11/2012Shaylon Hummrt Claremont California 91711 United States 5/12/2012Shanelle Ruiz Winnipeg R2P0W7 Canada 5/12/2012Cindy Chie Irvine California 92620 United States 5/12/2012Bart Crane Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 5/12/2012Michelle Palhetas Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 5/12/2012Kerry Collick Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/12/2012Candace  Leutzinger Anaheim California 92806 United States 5/13/2012Stephen Herman Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 5/14/2012jane bodie newport beach California 92661 United States 5/14/2012John Racunas Newport Beach California 92657 United States 5/14/2012Jon Frank newport beach California 92662 United States 5/14/2012Michael Abbott Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/14/2012shawn selph corona del mar California 92625 United States 5/14/2012Stacy Peterson NB California 92663 United States 5/14/2012Wendy Torres Irvine California 92620 United States 5/14/2012Jon ahuna Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/14/2012Nicole Marotta Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/14/2012Linda Viramontes La Habra California 90631 United States 5/14/2012Craig Johnson Fountain Valley California 92708 United States 5/14/2012Jennifer Heslar Rancho Santa Margarita California 92688 United States 5/14/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 271: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Travis Mantych Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/14/2012Chris Schroeder Lake Forest California 92630 United States 5/14/2012Rick Stafford Balboa California 92661 United States 5/14/2012Heather Soliz Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 5/14/2012Brian  Allen Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 5/14/2012Luis Torres Irvine California 92620 United States 5/14/2012Julie Stafford Newport Beach California 92661 United States 5/14/2012Esteban  hernandez Anaheim California 92805 United States 5/14/2012Diana Krause Irvine California 92612 United States 5/14/2012Rene Amador Garden Grove California 92843 United States 5/14/2012Valerie Schratz Tustin California 92780 United States 5/14/2012Evan Call Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/14/2012myrna ruiz santa ana California 92707 United States 5/14/2012Brad Thomas Lake Forest California 92630 United States 5/14/2012Sarah Evans Santa Ana California 92705 United States 5/14/2012Glenn Landenberger Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 5/14/2012Eric Paolinelli Fresno California 93730 United States 5/14/2012derek poon ALISO VIEJO California 92656 United States 5/14/2012laura hazen Santa Ana California 92704 United States 5/14/2012BRET STOUT PLACENTIA California 92870 United States 5/14/2012Cheryl Cooper Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/14/2012Mark Quade Chino Hills California 91709 United States 5/14/2012Brandt Teske Wildwood Missouri 63038 United States 5/14/2012christina pearce Rancho Santa Margarita California 92688 United States 5/14/2012Rick Holt Anaheim California 92802 United States 5/14/2012Kim  Cuenca Fullerton California 92833 United States 5/14/2012Shayne Smith Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/14/2012Vidal  Aguilar Anaheim California 92805 United States 5/14/2012corey wegner costa mesa California 92651 United States 5/14/2012gabriela t. huntington beach California 92646 United States 5/14/2012Robert Hazen Ladera Ranch California 92694 United States 5/14/2012John Haffner Irvine California 92603 United States 5/14/2012John Mooney Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 5/14/2012scott seymour Mission Viejo California 92692 United States 5/14/2012Joshua Canter Irvine California 92612 United States 5/14/2012Ignacio Tiscareno Anaheim California 92806 United States 5/14/2012Chris Colwell Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 5/14/2012joseph jennings newport beach California 92660 United States 5/14/2012Tamara Davis Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 5/14/2012Jen Robinson Tustin California 92782 United States 5/14/2012William Ramlo Santa Ana California 92707 United States 5/14/2012anand damle irvine California 92612 United States 5/14/2012Chris Ritterhern Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 5/14/2012Michael Call Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/14/2012ben koontz newport beach California 92659 United States 5/14/2012Michael Martz Tustin California 92782 United States 5/14/2012Mike Jones Huntingtonn Beach California 92646 United States 5/14/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 272: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Stephen Wetterau Laguna Niguel California 92677 United States 5/14/2012ROBERT LASERIA Anaheim California 92805 United States 5/14/2012Cynthia Hamilton Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/15/2012Tony Bell Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/15/2012josh mcdonald newport beac California 92663 United States 5/15/2012Mayra Perez Stanton California 90680 United States 5/15/2012philip solomone La Mirada California 90638 United States 5/15/2012RICK SANCHEZ anaheim California 92801 United States 5/15/2012mike Ritter Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 5/15/2012Scott Rhodes Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 5/15/2012Nate Rangel Santa Ana California 92704 United States 5/15/2012Timothy Montgomery Coto de Caza California 92679 United States 5/15/2012Lauren Biron Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/15/2012nicholas wilson Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/15/2012Gretchen MontgomeryCoto de Caza California 92679 United States 5/15/2012Brad Rosten Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/15/2012Kelly McWhirter Anaheim California 92801 United States 5/15/2012Carmen McWhirter Anaheim California 92801 United States 5/15/2012vanessa Strodel Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/15/2012Tamara Aiello Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/15/2012John Garay Tustin California 92780 United States 5/15/2012Jamie Schroeder Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/15/2012Mariah Kelly Irvine California 92604 United States 5/15/2012Brandon Hatcher Irvine California 92620 United States 5/15/2012Lauren McDonell Irvine California 92604 United States 5/15/2012Sharon George Irvine California 92617 United States 5/15/2012Tess Myers RSM California 92688 United States 5/15/2012Sarah Bixler Liverpool New York 13090 United States 5/15/2012BRIAN EBERHARDT eastvale California 92880 United States 5/15/2012Megan Downs Tustin California 92780 United States 5/15/2012Sandra Moore Newport Beach, CA California 92660 United States 5/15/2012Jorge  Luqueno  Orange California 92869 United States 5/15/2012Greg Hicks Orange California 92867 United States 5/15/2012Kristen  McNelly Anaheim California 92805 United States 5/15/2012alberto zavala Santa Ana California 92705 United States 5/15/2012John Schroeder Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/15/2012Christina McKinley 5/15/2012Luis amador Sun City California 92587 United States 5/15/2012Barbara Ralston Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/15/2012Mark Kroischke La Hanna California 90631 United States 5/15/2012Brian Carey Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/15/2012Amanda Hawley Placentia California 92870 United States 5/15/2012Linda Schultz Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 5/15/2012Ted Giakas Newport beach California 92663 United States 5/15/2012Wynnie Thoi Tustin California 92780 United States 5/15/2012kristin bents costa mesa California 92626 United States 5/15/2012Nicholas Carey Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/15/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 273: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Jennifer Wozniak costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/15/2012Jeanne Barragan Fountain Valley California 92708 United States 5/15/2012carol armstrong irvine California 92623 United States 5/15/2012Stephanie Johnson Austin Texas 78732 United States 5/15/2012Jeanne O'Shea Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/15/2012Douglas Hansberger Irvine California 92604 United States 5/15/2012Gene Viramontes Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 5/15/2012Yassi Sabahi Irvine California 92614 United States 5/15/2012Brian Nguyen Irvine California 92604 United States 5/15/2012Szymon Babiarz COSTA MESA California 92627 United States 5/15/2012Gary La Morte Irvine California 92604 United States 5/15/2012kelly bumpus huntington beach California 92648 United States 5/15/2012Dan Morgan Huntington Beach 92841 United States Mino 5/15/2012Nancy Johnston Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/15/2012Michelle Johnston Anaheim California 92807 United States 5/15/2012Sharron Carey Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/15/2012Mark Nebeker Tustin California 92782 United States 5/15/2012Dedebrink Brink Newport Coast California 92657 United States 5/15/2012Karla Reo Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/15/2012Megan Carey Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/15/2012Sandra Munoz Santa Ana California 92706 United States 5/15/2012Guadalupe Neri Mira Loma California 91752 United States 5/15/2012Richard Lugo Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/15/2012Dave Morris  Irvine California 92606 United States 5/15/2012Teresa Romero Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/15/2012Diane Cameron Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/15/2012Ellen Einkauf Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/15/2012krista schultz santa ana California 92704 United States 5/15/2012mike cernak fountain valley California 92708 United States 5/15/2012Christian Beyer Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/15/2012Lindsay Quaintance Rancho Cucamonga California 91730 United States 5/15/2012Karen Muller Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/15/2012Dorthy Burns Fontana California 92337 United States 5/15/2012William Ferry Corona del MAr California 92625 United States 5/15/2012brian corrigan corona del mar California 92625 United States 5/15/2012Susan La Morte Eastvale California 92880 United States 5/15/2012Robert Newsom Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/15/2012Corinne AndersonSchoNewport Beach California 92660 United States 5/15/2012Michael La Morte Corona California 92880 United States 5/15/2012elaine coffman newport beach, ca California 92661 United States 5/15/2012Delbert Parsons Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/15/2012steve holt parker Colorado 80138 United States 5/15/2012Jennifer Burback Newoprt Beach California 92660 United States 5/15/2012Brian Grondahl Overland Park Kansas 66209 United States 5/15/2012Darlene Parsons Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/15/2012ANNE STAFFORD CORONA DEL MAR California 92625 United States 5/15/2012Greg Reinker Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/15/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 274: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Betty Bottorf Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/15/2012Paul Goodwin Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/15/2012Robert McKennon Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/15/2012Tracy Murphy Irvine California 92620 United States 5/15/2012Patricia Insley Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/15/2012Judy hamada Rowland Heights California 91748 United States 5/15/2012Natalie Basmaciyan Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/15/2012Leslie Stuart Irvine California 92612 United States 5/15/2012Matthew Gula Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/15/2012brian wilson newport beach California 926671 United States 5/15/2012Monica Fiedler Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/15/2012julianne  villalba RANCHO CUCAMONGA California 917306087 United States 5/15/2012Jack Hunter Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/15/2012Sal Grijalva Trabuco Canyon California 92679 United States 5/15/2012Deane  Bottorf Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/15/2012Kathleen Gee Fairfield California 94534 United States 5/15/2012Michael Smith Irvine California 92604 United States 5/15/2012Tracey Perry Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 5/15/2012sherry cagle newport beach California 92660 United States 5/15/2012Deborah Webb Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/15/2012ignacio sanchez newport beach California 92663 United States 5/15/2012Sandi Ciz Lake Forest California 92630 United States 5/15/2012Roman Darmer Newport Beach California The fire ringsUnited States 5/15/2012morey robert san juan capistrano California 92675 United States 5/15/2012Sanene Talcott Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 5/15/2012Lisa Jordan Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 5/15/2012Gene Tafoya Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/15/2012Roberta Kern Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/15/2012Ann Mellini Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 5/15/2012Jennifer  Ruddy Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/15/2012LAWRENCE   (TOM) HOBALBOA ISLAND California 92662 United States 5/15/2012dee  Turner Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/15/2012cat newsom Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/15/2012Teresa Rogers Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/15/2012Melinda Wagner Moreno Valley California 92553 United States 5/15/2012ricjard pedetsen Irvine California 92604 United States 5/15/2012Bob  Ctvrtlik Newport Beach California 92662 United States 5/15/2012John Snow Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/15/2012Christine Anderson Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 5/15/2012Joanne Keith Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/15/2012Maria Berber Fullerton California 92832 United States 5/15/2012Natalie Mata Fullerton California 92832 United States 5/15/2012Joseph Vieyra Irvine California 92604 United States 5/15/2012Doreen Paul Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/15/2012Tyson McKenzie Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/15/2012SEAN HENTHORN COSTA MESA California 92626 United States 5/15/2012Dan Klinetobe Brea California 92821 United States 5/15/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 275: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Stephen Sholkoff, MD Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/15/2012michelle sholkoff newport beach California 92660 United States 5/15/2012Mary Clark Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/15/2012Michael Heil Costa Mesa California 92626‐2822 United States 5/15/2012Brett Rogers Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/15/2012HUGH BOWE COSTA MESA California 92627 United States 5/15/2012Jennifer Fry Irvine California 92620 United States 5/15/2012rebecca waters mission viejo California 92692 United States 5/15/2012Shari Buescher Mission Viejo California 92692 United States 5/15/2012chris elliott costa mesa California 92627 United States 5/15/2012Sean Michael Newport California 92663 United States 5/15/2012Morgan Riley Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/15/2012Kristen Hessinger Tustin California 92782 United States 5/15/2012ADAM C CHAVEZ Corona California 92881 United States 5/16/2012christine borden corona del mar California 92625 United States 5/16/2012Jennifer Young Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/16/2012Michael Dean Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/16/2012Patricia Richardson Wildomar California 92595 United States 5/16/2012Caryn Wahlstrom Newport Beach California 92661 United States 5/16/2012Earl Pendly Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/16/2012Jesus  mata Fullerton California 92832 United States 5/16/2012Shan Barclay Tustin California 92780 United States 5/16/2012Peggy Pugh Newport California 92660 United States 5/16/2012Kelley Brown ashburn Virginia 20148 United States 5/16/2012Ryan Sabin Newport Beach California 92661 United States 5/16/2012Barbara  Mudge Bandon Oregon 94711 United States 5/16/2012Tamara Cross Fountain Valley California 92708 United States 5/16/2012Janice Mortenson Laguna Niguel California 92677 United States 5/16/2012pat hernandez Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 5/16/2012Esperanza Martin apple valley California 92308 United States 5/16/2012Nancy Ringman Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/16/2012Tim Werdel Tustin California 92780 United States 5/16/2012Tom Ringman Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/16/2012Rebecca Nguyen Santa Ana California 92704 United States 5/16/2012Estuardo Huertas Santa Ana California 92704 United States 5/16/2012Myrna Ireland Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/16/2012Annie Outlaw Coos Bay Oregon 97420 United States 5/16/2012James Stockard Newport Beach California 92661 United States 5/16/2012John Watson Scotch Plains New Jersey 7076 United States 5/16/2012ELIZABETH DECOU NORCO California 92860 United States 5/16/2012FLETCHER OLSON Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/16/2012Patti Lindsay Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/16/2012Janice Sauter Nashville Tennessee 37215 United States 5/16/2012Julie  Huelle Sunset Beach California 90742 United States 5/16/2012Barbara Johnson Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/16/2012Melinda Jones Irvine California 92612 United States 5/16/2012Karen K Carlson Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/16/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 276: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Tony Medina Ladera Ranch California 92694 United States 5/16/2012Keith Hernandez Santa Ana California 92707 United States 5/16/2012Patti Taketa Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/16/2012verda schroeder corona del mar California 92625 United States 5/16/2012Joanne Pineda Santa Ana California 92703 United States 5/16/2012Clinton Weinrich Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 5/16/2012Bob Mckenzie Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/16/2012Margie Hubbard Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/16/2012Deborah Exley Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/16/2012jim kupsh ladera ranch California 92694 United States 5/16/2012Sara LaFramboise Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/16/2012Mary Allen Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/16/2012Jim Rush Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/16/2012Caroline Taketa Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/16/2012lisa cordes corona del mar California 92625 United States 5/16/2012Erica Sarabia Santa Ana California 92707 United States 5/16/2012Samuel Frausto Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 5/16/2012Keegan Bell Orange California 92867 United States 5/16/2012Carol Baker Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/16/2012justin bridges Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 5/16/2012Valerie Zwerling Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/16/2012Megan Zwerling Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/16/2012Robert Zwerling Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/16/2012kelsey  svensson coto de caza California 92679 United States 5/16/2012John Coasta corona del mar California 92625 United States 5/16/2012Henry Yen Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/16/2012Eva  Duran Riverside California 92505 United States 5/16/2012Jeff Enright San Mateo California 94403 United States 5/16/2012lucas toohey newport beach California 92661 United States 5/16/2012Rachel Sherman Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/16/2012Daniel Pico santa ana California 92704 United States 5/16/2012Justin Roberts Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/16/2012theodoros kapogianis Fullerton California 92833 United States 5/16/2012William Ayoub Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 5/16/2012Natalie Rhone Newport Coast California 92657 United States 5/16/2012laura gutierrez fullerton California 92833 United States 5/16/2012Michael Bacus Newport Beack California 92663 United States 5/16/2012Hannah Pierce San Marino California 91108 United States 5/16/2012Sean Franklin Long Beach California 90807 United States 5/16/2012shana contreiras Newport Beach California 92661 United States 5/16/2012Hilda Gonzalez Whittier California 90605 United States 5/16/2012David Bottorf Kihei Hawaii 96753 United States 5/16/2012Gretchen Reinke Newport Beach California 92661 United States 5/16/2012Bill Rhinesmith Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/16/2012steve heine newport beach California 92660 United States 5/16/2012Doug Forde Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 5/16/2012Lucinda Marder Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/16/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 277: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Lisa Cowan Rincon Georgia 31326 United States 5/16/2012Amy Brick Whittier California 90605 United States 5/16/2012Carol and Rich Hoppe Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/16/2012danielle darlow La Habra California 90631 United States 5/16/2012Chris M Santa Ana California 92704 United States 5/16/2012Ed De ferrante Irvine California 92614 United States 5/16/2012jackie diamond clinton township Michigan 48038 United States 5/16/2012Linda Thompson Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/16/2012Trish Norman Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/16/2012Clive Norman Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/16/2012Linda Jovanelly Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/16/2012Rick Greaney Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/16/2012Roland Rapp Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/16/2012Roger Lockhart Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/16/2012Sally Rapp Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/16/2012Staci Leary Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/16/2012Linda Williams Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/16/2012Nicole Bissonnette Ladera Ranch California 92694 United States 5/16/2012Shannon Matthews Redlands California 92374 United States 5/16/2012Annalise Winkle Irvine California 92602 United States 5/16/2012Stephanie  Sweeny Mission Viejo California 92692 United States 5/16/2012Mary  Hardesty Newport Beach California 92662 United States 5/16/2012Cindy Kupper Balboa Island California 92662 United States 5/16/2012Matt Primeau Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/16/2012julie heredia los angeles California 90032 United States 5/16/2012Carol Noe Los Angeles California 90045 United States 5/16/2012Matthew Canepa Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/16/2012Armando  Saldana Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/16/2012Lisa Clayton Everett Washington 98208 United States 5/16/2012Mike Vogt Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/16/2012Sandra Valle Santa Ana California 92707 United States 5/16/2012William Weiss Playa del Rey California 90293 United States 5/16/2012Kristina Rotella Smithfield Rhode Island 2917 United States 5/16/2012Gabriella Rapp Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/16/2012Lori Madison sun city California 92585 United States 5/16/2012Rae Cohen Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/16/2012Richard Yocom Sun Lakes Arizona 85248 United States 5/16/2012Shayla DeGrazio Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/16/2012Brandon Cohen Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 5/16/2012David Weeks Wildomar California 92595 United States 5/16/2012John Canepa Lakewood California 90713 United States 5/16/2012Mark Valsi Sierra Madre California 91025 United States 5/16/2012Joshua Cline Fullerton California 92831 United States 5/16/2012Delbert Chesebro Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/16/2012katherine Cervantes Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/16/2012Gary Cohen Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 5/16/2012Kris McHone Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/16/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 278: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Cheryl Thomas Highland California 92346 United States 5/16/2012Nichole  Maydon Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/16/2012jim thompson newport beach California 92660 United States 5/16/2012mark schulein Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/16/2012Gwen Lazicki Newport Beach California 92661 United States 5/16/2012j paul  wilson costa mesa California 92627 United States 5/16/2012doris stoughton CORONA DEL MAR California 92625 United States 5/16/2012Robert Underwood Jr. Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/16/2012Elizabeth Slater Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/16/2012Heather Reger Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/16/2012Dennis Keith Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/16/2012Eugene Rapp Hayward California 94544 United States 5/16/2012Kiefer Cohen Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/16/2012Paula Edwards Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/17/2012rosalie stewart tucson Arizona 85735 United States 5/17/2012Dino Fierro Moreno Valley California 92553 United States 5/17/2012Rob Bailey Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/17/2012Barbara Guerrero oceanside California 92056 United States 5/17/2012Kris Radke Glendale Arizona 85308 United States 5/17/2012Tony San Miguel Irvine California 92612 United States 5/17/2012Evelyn  Garcia Anaheim California 92804 United States 5/17/2012Jennifer Shaw San Diego California 92102 United States 5/17/2012Lesley  Obaditch Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/17/2012Greg  Forde Salt Lake City Utah 84119 United States 5/17/2012John McMahon Newport Beach California 92661 United States 5/17/2012Amy Worthington Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/17/2012kevin holmes Newport Beach California 92661 United States 5/17/2012Annette  Armendariz Maple Valley Washington 98038 United States 5/17/2012Adele reilly newport coast California 92657 United States 5/17/2012Kayleigh bond Santa Ana California 92707 United States 5/17/2012Marie Frequez Tustin California 92780 United States 5/17/2012kathleen sullivan fountian valley California 92708 United States 5/17/2012Kristyn Foxworth SM California 93455 United States 5/17/2012Elizabeth Bindrup costa mesa California 92627 United States 5/17/2012Alice Remer Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/17/2012pat froehlich cdm California 92625 United States 5/17/2012Susan Watson Ojai California 93023 United States 5/17/2012Christina McLean Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/17/2012Cristy Fischbeck Capistrano Beach California 92624 United States 5/17/2012Robert Boragno Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/17/2012Susan Lunny Fort Walton Beach Florida 32548 United States 5/17/2012Tracey Borowski Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/17/2012Frank Daniels Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 5/17/2012Thomas Boragno Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 5/17/2012Laura and Phil Dietz Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/17/2012Peter Bretschger Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/17/2012Wolfgang Gehner Highland California 92346 United States 5/17/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 279: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Marissa Crandall Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/17/2012Chris Sammons Placentia California 92870 United States 5/17/2012bill bennett newport beach California 92663 United States 5/18/2012Janice White Stafford Virginia 22556‐800 United States 5/18/2012Diana Thiele Lakewood California 90715 United States 5/18/2012Keith Rogers Chino Hills California 91709 United States 5/18/2012David Gregory Santa Ana California 92707 United States 5/18/2012Regina Stryker Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/18/2012Nancy Beach Pacific Palisades, CA California 90272 United States 5/18/2012Carmen Wilcox Newport Beach California 92659 United States 5/18/2012Beverly  Krassner Irvine California 92612 United States 5/18/2012jakub tejchman santa ana California 92703 United States 5/18/2012Dana Cornelius Irvine California 92614 United States 5/18/2012Ryan Kwiatkowski newport beach California 92661 United States 5/18/2012Jeff Showalter Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/18/2012Mary grace Card san diego California 92103 United States 5/18/2012Ashley Woodward Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 5/18/2012Stuart Strnad Newport Beach California 92661 United States 5/18/2012Monica Truxton Mission Viejo California 92692 United States 5/18/2012Laurie  Valenzuela  Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/18/2012Adam Oliver Stillwater Oklahoma 74075 United States 5/18/2012Ashley Johnson Garden Grove California 92841 United States 5/18/2012BRIAN SCOTT NEWPORT BEACH California 92661 United States 5/18/2012Abel Enriquez Garden Grove California 92840 United States 5/18/2012jon Chastain Santa Ana California 92707 United States 5/18/2012Colleen Lein Riverside California 92503 United States 5/18/2012Ginny Sanderson Buena Park California 90620 United States 5/19/2012Michal Callahan Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/19/2012Douglas Bottorf Highland California 92346 United States 5/19/2012Judy Ischinger Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/19/2012Victoria Scott Newport Beach California 92661 United States 5/19/2012Betsy Harano Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/19/2012Christina Neumann Corvallis Oregon 97333 United States 5/19/2012Jenna Scott Newport Beach California 92661 United States 5/19/2012Kelly Jones Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/19/2012Betty Sisemore Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 5/19/2012Michael  Johnson Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/19/2012Belinda Northrop Las Vegas Nevada 89105 United States 5/19/2012Nikki Rhinehart‐MoldoMission Viejo California 92692 United States 5/19/2012Stevie Jay Las Vegas Nevada 89081 United States 5/19/2012Keith Lempka hemet California 92545 United States 5/19/2012Sharon Mirza Rancho Santa Margarita California 92688 United States 5/19/2012Dan  Rogers Laguna Woods California 92637 United States 5/19/2012Cassi La Morte Corona California 92880 United States 5/19/2012David Grabowski Rosemead California 91770 United States 5/19/2012Natalie Smith Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/19/2012Ryan Padilla Lake Forest California 92630 United States 5/19/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 280: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Alex Gonick Ontario California 91764 United States 5/19/2012Lisa Rumsey Foothill Ranch California 92610 United States 5/19/2012Patty Padilla Lake Forest California 92630 United States 5/19/2012Kris Zilberstein Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/19/2012Erik Ringman Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/19/2012michael mcfadden  san juan capistrano California 92675 United States 5/19/2012Robert Rouhani Newport Beach California 92658 United States 5/19/2012Anthony Mainero Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/19/2012mickayla  nelson corona California 93883 United States 5/19/2012Kayla Thomas port hueneme California 93041 United States 5/19/2012Adam Stanton Fountain Valley California 92708 United States 5/19/2012Euan Rugg Dallas Texas 75219 United States 5/19/2012Kerry Pettis Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/20/2012Buckley Crispin Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/20/2012Gabrielle Sagona Orange California 92866 United States 5/20/2012Rochelle Pendleton Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 5/20/2012Paulette Pappas Balboa California 92661 United States 5/20/2012J Gimbernat Newport Beach California 92661 United States 5/20/2012Debra Hardwick Sun City California 92587 United States 5/20/2012gladys julia smith huntington beach California 92648 United States 5/20/2012Jeff Pettis Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/20/2012Melissa McDaniel Riverside California 92503 United States 5/20/2012Michelle Jones Tharp Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/20/2012Jordan Gray Alta Loma California 91737 United States 5/20/2012Toni  Gray Alta LOma California 91737 United States 5/20/2012Dylan Houle Washington District Of Colu 20008 United States 5/20/2012Christopher Karjala Irvine California 92612 United States 5/20/2012Tara Michaelson La Habra California 90631 United States 5/20/2012James O'Hare san Clemente California 92672 United States 5/20/2012Thomas Nash Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 5/20/2012Linda Fleming Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/20/2012Sarah Adams Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/20/2012Drew Kenworthy Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 5/20/2012tina waunch Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/20/2012David  Hendrickson Burleigh Heads 4220 Australia 5/20/2012karen prioleau Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/20/2012Helene Prioleau Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/20/2012jennifer stockman newport beach California 92660 United States 5/20/2012Laure Morrelli Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/20/2012Mandara Hogarth West Covina California 91791 United States 5/20/2012Kevin Spangler Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 5/20/2012Jeff Rhoads Orange California 92869‐2511 United States 5/21/2012Edward Martindale Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/21/2012Calyn Walton Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/21/2012Renetta Morrelli Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/21/2012Wayne Martin Anaheim California 92801 United States 5/21/2012Nancy Martin Kapaa Hawaii 96746 United States 5/21/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 281: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Brock McDonald  Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/21/2012Tanya Fahlen Newport Beach California 92662 United States 5/21/2012Fredric Rhoads Chicago Illinois 60601 United States 5/21/2012Jay Stallman Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 5/21/2012Jeff Reuter Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/21/2012Robin Oderman Marblehead Massachusetts 1945 United States 5/21/2012Claudia Strandstra Simi Valley California 93065 United States 5/21/2012Lion Wintemute Irvine California 92603 United States 5/21/2012Katie Hazen Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/21/2012Gino Morrelli  Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/21/2012Valarie Follett Fremont California 94587 United States 5/21/2012Wyatt Muller Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/21/2012oscar hernandez Riverside California 92503 United States 5/21/2012Dale E. McCoig Ben Oregon 97702 United States 5/21/2012Jackie Bisset Chandler Arizona 85249 United States 5/21/2012Nancy Hamblin Colorado Springs Colorado 80920 United States 5/21/2012Fred Klein   Eastsound Washington 98245 United States 5/21/2012Richard Miller CDM California 92625 United States 5/21/2012Mike Hougan Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/21/2012Greg Buschhausen Murrieta California 92563 United States 5/21/2012Colleen Crommett Dove Canyon California 92679 United States 5/21/2012Norma Ingold Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/21/2012Erica O'Neill Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 5/21/2012HILARIE MOORE CORONA DEL MAR California 92625 United States 5/21/2012Roger Prasser Newport Coast California 92657 United States 5/21/2012Gloria Oakes Newport Beach California 92661 United States 5/22/2012Victoria Martinez Big Pine California 93513 United States 5/22/2012Rian Ladd Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/22/2012kevin sullivan Huntington Beach California 92649 United States 5/22/2012Michelle Lilly Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/22/2012jennie strait Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/22/2012rob tighe newport beach California 92663 United States 5/22/2012Bradley Johnson Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/22/2012Bob park dana point California 92629 United States 5/22/2012Cynthia Boragno Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/22/2012Brian Bowie Toda City 335‐0022 Japan 5/22/2012Hannah Sullivan Westminster California 92683 United States 5/22/2012Robert Sullivan Santa Ana California 92701 United States 5/22/2012Grady Sanderson Orange California 92867 United States 5/22/2012Kammy Miller Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/22/2012Kay Pinto Flagstaff Arizona 86001 United States 5/22/2012Scott McAdams Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/22/2012Karla  Guyer Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 5/22/2012Marie Fresquez Tustin California 92780 United States 5/22/2012nikki dutton Garden Grove California 92845 United States 5/22/2012Brent Noblitt Irvine California 92604 United States 5/22/2012Alan Bradford Irvine California 92604 United States 5/22/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 282: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Gwen Isarowong Irvine California 92604 United States 5/22/2012Shawn Gillespie Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/22/2012seamus fallon anaheim California 92802 United States 5/22/2012Richard Ruiz Irvine California 92620 United States 5/22/2012Richard West Fountain Valley California 92708 United States 5/22/2012Colt Rhoads Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 5/22/2012Lance Brown Irvine California 92606 United States 5/22/2012Maria T. Munoz Covina California 91724 United States 5/22/2012Mark Bachman Irvine California 92617 United States 5/22/2012Gwen Nishida Irvine California 92614 United States 5/22/2012Tyler Dubbert Fort Collins Colorado 815 United States 5/22/2012Tammy Smecker‐HaneIrvine California 92617 United States 5/22/2012Jo McClary Cypress California 90630 United States 5/22/2012Rebecca MacIntosh Irvine California 92606 United States 5/22/2012Robert Davis Irvine California 92606 United States 5/22/2012Eric Jones Irvine California 92604 United States 5/22/2012Kevin Lui Irvine California 92612 United States 5/22/2012Steven Gross Irvine California 92697 United States 5/22/2012Muoi Tran san jose California 95110 United States 5/22/2012Cecilia  Gimenez Grants Pass Oregon 97526 United States 5/22/2012Lynnette Sullivan westminster California 92683 United States 5/22/2012Barbara Elter Irvine California 92620 United States 5/22/2012John Fleming Porterville California 93257 United States 5/22/2012Russell McDaniel Irvine California 92618 United States 5/22/2012Dennis Kasper Los Alamitos California 90720 United States 5/22/2012kenny situ irvine California 92612 United States 5/22/2012Barbara Ginsberg Irvine California 92606 United States 5/22/2012Charles Graham Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/22/2012Sheila Fitzgerald Irvine California 92614 United States 5/22/2012Candace Hinton Studio City California 91607 United States 5/22/2012Velva Axtell Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/22/2012Jennifer Lambeth Irvine California 92604 United States 5/22/2012Harrison Bachman irvine California 92617 United States 5/22/2012Eugene Holdt Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 5/22/2012Don Grey Laguna Niguel California 92677 United States 5/22/2012Anu Gundappa Irvine California 92612 United States 5/22/2012Gianmarc Johns Irvine California 92606 United States 5/22/2012Celaine Gruver Norton Ohio 44203 United States 5/22/2012Rebecca Nagel Irvine California 92614 United States 5/22/2012Luke  Kelly Irvine California 92606 United States 5/22/2012Rod Gamble Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/22/2012Eliot Hansen Westminster California 92683 United States 5/22/2012Yolanda Agredano Irvine California 92604 United States 5/22/2012Cherrin L. Druschel Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/22/2012Mary Gipson Tustin California 92780 United States 5/22/2012Beatrice Jamieson Phillips Ranch California 91766 United States 5/22/2012Michelle Craghead Newport /beach California 92663 United States 5/22/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 283: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Nisha Govind Irvine California 92620 United States 5/22/2012Victoria Kleczko Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/22/2012Suzanne Kobzeff Irvine California 92604 United States 5/22/2012Raja Kolli Irvine California 92619 United States 5/22/2012Dwight Gergens Fountain Valley California 92708 United States 5/22/2012Spencer Klamm Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/22/2012Susan Harlan Irvine California 92604 United States 5/22/2012Nicholas Tallarida Irvine California 92617 United States 5/22/2012Denise Gibbs Irvine California 92604 United States 5/22/2012Jennifer Tang irvine California 92612 United States 5/22/2012Shaz Shaz Irvine California 92618 United States 5/22/2012Jeff Wolfson San Jose California 95131‐2635 United States 5/22/2012Garry Shuck Irvine California 92612 United States 5/22/2012Kathleen Michaels Irvine California 92604 United States 5/22/2012arezou goshtasbi Irvine California 92603 United States 5/22/2012robert mcharris newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/22/2012Lindsey Lovell San Clemente California 92672 United States 5/22/2012Brad Lovell Santa Ana California 92705 United States 5/22/2012Rebekah Laverty Fountain Valley California 92708 United States 5/22/2012raffi garboushian whittier California 90602 United States 5/22/2012Dian  Romonosky Irvine California 92617 United States 5/22/2012Camilo Arango Irvine California 92614 United States 5/22/2012Don Swenson Hemet California 92544 United States 5/22/2012Michelle Kobzeff Irvine California 92604 United States 5/22/2012Gerry  Hardin  Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/22/2012Scott Buehl Upland California 91786 United States 5/22/2012Catherine Lapid cypress Colorado 90630 United States 5/22/2012Brett Farrell Springdale Arkansas 72765 United States 5/22/2012Lisa Yarnl Santa Ana California 92706 United States 5/22/2012Russell Carter Santa Ana California 92705 United States 5/22/2012Sheila Schumakere La Verne California 91750 United States 5/22/2012Gerald Sewell Corona California 92883 United States 5/22/2012Rose Romonosky Pontiac Illinois 61764 United States 5/22/2012Michael Moore Santa Ana California 92705 United States 5/22/2012Raul Kich Irvine California 92604 United States 5/23/2012Danielle Barrett San Diego California 92124 United States 5/23/2012Erin Reyes Hesperia California 92345 United States 5/23/2012juliana stonis newport beach California 92663 United States 5/23/2012Wendy Tichihara Huntington Beach California 82649 United States 5/23/2012Janette Boyd Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 5/23/2012Alexander Krochman Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/23/2012Anirudh Thakore Irvine California 92620 United States 5/23/2012Marcia Obstfeld Irvine California 92603 United States 5/23/2012S Squirrel Edgewater Maryland 21037 United States 5/23/2012Jacqueline Judy  Irvine California 92620 United States 5/23/2012Ryan Levenson Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/23/2012Mike Maynard Irvine California 92620 United States 5/23/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 284: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Georgina Salazar San Diego California 92105 United States 5/23/2012Laura Kasperowicz Irvine California 92604 United States 5/23/2012nick milosevic lake arrowhead California 92352 United States 5/23/2012Travis Rabenberg Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/23/2012Jeff Ellmore Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/23/2012Angelina Lopez Santa Ana California 92705 United States 5/23/2012Byron Luoma Irvine California 92623 United States 5/23/2012Jeff Sporcich Anaheim California 92805 United States 5/23/2012Carol McIntosh Irvine California 92604 United States 5/23/2012Jennifer Jones Irvine California 92604 United States 5/23/2012Jeffrey Peterson Irvine California 92617 United States 5/23/2012Nancy Perez Aliso Viejo California 82656 United States 5/23/2012Jayson Ridenour huntington beach California 92647 United States 5/23/2012Virginia Anders. Ellmo Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/23/2012Taylor  Best Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/23/2012Luke Jensen Irvine California 92620 United States 5/23/2012Melissa  Allmann Irvine California 92606 United States 5/23/2012Cathlyn Stansifer Irvine California 92620 United States 5/23/2012diane gardner Corona California 92880‐9054 United States 5/23/2012David Abella Irvine California 92614 United States 5/23/2012Andrea Young Irvine California 92618 United States 5/23/2012misty brown Victorville California 92395 United States 5/23/2012Bryan Castleman Claremont California 91711 United States 5/23/2012Betty Shiihara Irvine California 92606 United States 5/23/2012Steven Jones Balboa California 92661 United States 5/23/2012Elisabeth Buckley Eatontown New Jersey 7724 United States 5/23/2012Alex Fabrizio Irvine California 92614 United States 5/23/2012Roberta Palfini Irvine California 92614 United States 5/23/2012Steve Iwashita Los Angeles California 90025 United States 5/23/2012Teresa Leigh Irvine California 92614 United States 5/23/2012Legita Law Irvine California 92618 United States 5/23/2012Richard Leigh Irvine California 92614 United States 5/23/2012Michael Nguyen Santa Ana California 92704 United States 5/23/2012Alex Kaschmitter Newport Beach California 92661 United States 5/23/2012Denise Bandsma La Habra California 90631 United States 5/23/2012Elisa Morello San Pedro California 90731 United States 5/23/2012Albert Ng Irvine California 92603 United States 5/23/2012Jeff Weight Westminster California 92683 United States 5/23/2012Scott Rychnovsky Irvine California 92617 United States 5/23/2012Gregory Suryn Irvine California 92697 United States 5/23/2012Raymond Hart Santa Ana California 92705 United States 5/23/2012Daniel Lee Fountain Valley California 92708 United States 5/23/2012Amanda Gilliam Irvine California 92617 United States 5/23/2012Robert Gorkin Exton Pennsylvania 19341 United States 5/23/2012eduardo mier y teran irvine California 92604 United States 5/23/2012Robert Peck Riverside California 92505 United States 5/23/2012Alice Ishigame‐Tao Irvine California 92606 United States 5/23/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 285: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Kathy Brook‐Wong Irvine California 92620 United States 5/23/2012Sarah Cook Irvine California 92617 United States 5/23/2012Carolyn Gulley‐Lin Irvine California 92620 United States 5/23/2012Marcy Sargenti Irvine California 92603 United States 5/23/2012douglas spindler Irvine California 92604 United States 5/23/2012Kathleen Rios‐Keala Foothill ranch California 92610 United States 5/23/2012Michelle Casteel Rsm California 92688 United States 5/23/2012Phil Dubbert Fort Collins Colorado 80528 United States 5/23/2012Renee' Dubbert Johnstown Colorado 80534 United States 5/23/2012Christine Lecce Tustin California 92780 United States 5/23/2012lourdes tovar laguna hills California Lourdes TovaUnited States 5/23/2012David Gruver Norton Ohio 44203 United States 5/23/2012Scott Owens Long Beach California 90802 United States 5/23/2012Lou Kirk Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/23/2012Michele Dubbert Fort Collins Colorado 80528 United States 5/23/2012Massie Hatch IRVINE California 92604 United States 5/23/2012Andy  MCTIGUE Irvine California 92604 United States 5/23/2012Melissa Foust Irvine California 92623 United States 5/23/2012Janine Baran Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/23/2012richard  lasalle San Juan Capistrano California 92675 United States 5/23/2012Jeffery Wolf Fullerton California 92831 United States 5/23/2012Maureen Reilly Irvine California 92617 United States 5/23/2012Tiffany Ho Irvine California 92606 United States 5/23/2012Edward Hill ORANGE California 92867 United States 5/23/2012Brandon Krull Irvine California 92617 United States 5/23/2012Timothy Young Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 5/23/2012Nicholas Sizemore Irvine California 92617 United States 5/23/2012Sean Moro Irvine California 92617 United States 5/23/2012James McHenry Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 5/23/2012Anne Szklarski Irvine California 92617 United States 5/23/2012Kim Sowersby Lakewood California 92870 United States 5/23/2012Patricia Bartlett Irvine California 92612 United States 5/23/2012Lucas Nguyen Irvine California 92620 United States 5/23/2012Ken Kerr Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 5/23/2012Kevin sober Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/23/2012shalini patel Tustin California 92782 United States 5/23/2012Gordon Alexander Irvine California 92604 United States 5/23/2012Joseph Trimmer Tustin California 92780 United States 5/23/2012sadie calhoun Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/23/2012Rai King Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 5/23/2012Jia Liu Irvine California 92617 United States 5/23/2012David Shaffer Irvine California 92617 United States 5/23/2012Linda Molyneux Orange California 92865 United States 5/23/2012Erik Charles Irvine California 92617 United States 5/23/2012Brynn Enevoldsen Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/23/2012Dawn Eilers‐Dunn Irvine California 92614 United States 5/23/2012Marcy Billings Irvine California 92606 United States 5/23/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 286: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Adam Harper Villa Park California 92861 United States 5/23/2012Calli Hansen Orange California 92867 United States 5/23/2012Lisa Tarlton Irvine California 92620 United States 5/23/2012Mary Maduena Santa Ana California 92706 United States 5/23/2012Margaret Greene Irvine California 92617 United States 5/23/2012Lynda Vandeventer Lakewood California 90715 United States 5/23/2012Julie Martin Balboa Island California 92662 United States 5/23/2012Gale Feldman Santa Monica California 90403 United States 5/23/2012Bobby Earl Hamilton Chandler Arizona 85224 United States 5/23/2012Donna Hattin Hermosa Beach California 90254 United States 5/23/2012Hala Abduljalil Irvine California 92606 United States 5/23/2012Jeff Taibi Canyon Country California 91351 United States 5/23/2012Shannon Cook Fullerton California 92832 United States 5/23/2012Josh Vriens Yorba Linda California 92887 United States 5/23/2012Rommie  Webb Irvine California 92620 United States 5/23/2012sathiyamoorthy varathIrvine California 92604 United States 5/23/2012Robert Muirhead Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 5/23/2012Carol Trapschuh Huntington Beach California 92649 United States 5/23/2012L Thomas huntington beach California 92648 United States 5/23/2012Reed Meseck IRVINE California 92603 United States 5/23/2012Helen Harper Villa Park California 92861 United States 5/23/2012Linda bergstrom Huntington Beach California 92649 United States 5/23/2012ken burkhardt quakertown New Jersey 8868 United States 5/23/2012Desiree Patterson Orange California 92869 United States 5/23/2012Chelsea McTigue Irvine California 92604 United States 5/23/2012Eileen Stephens Fountain Valley California 92708 United States 5/23/2012Andrew Craft Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/23/2012Courtney Urquiza Rancho Cucamonga California 91729 United States 5/23/2012branden vriens yorba linda California 92887 United States 5/23/2012Bradley Davidson Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 5/23/2012Stacey DePalma Glendale Arizona 85308 United States 5/23/2012Teresa Hufman Fullerton California 92835 United States 5/24/2012Cameron Vieyra Irvine California 92604 United States 5/24/2012Peter Jensen Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/24/2012Theresa Schultz Irvine California 92606 United States 5/24/2012Guy Durr Moreno Valley California 92555 United States 5/24/2012Stephen Cauffman Irvine California 92617 United States 5/24/2012Ron Bergstrom Huntington Beach California 92649 United States 5/24/2012Chris  Tucker  Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 5/24/2012Chandler Hull San Clemente California 92672 United States 5/24/2012Jason Trapschuh Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 5/24/2012Judith Osnain Pasadena California 91104 United States 5/24/2012Paul Osnain Pasadena California 91104 United States 5/24/2012nick keener yorba linda California 92887 United States 5/24/2012Jennifer Yamaguchi Irvine California 92614 United States 5/24/2012Jae Lyu Irvine California 92606 United States 5/24/2012Tony King Moreno Valley California 92555 United States 5/24/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 287: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Brett Macnaugh Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 5/24/2012laura pell irvine California 92612 United States 5/24/2012Karen wilcox San Diego California 92103 United States 5/24/2012Noah Obstfeld Irvine California 92603 United States 5/24/2012Carol Winston Santa Monica California 90406‐0177 United States 5/24/2012Caleb Brown Irvine California 92604 United States 5/24/2012nick  castillo yorba linda California 92886 United States 5/24/2012Maurice Ling Irvine California 92606 United States 5/24/2012Kate Kernutt Irvine California 92602 United States 5/24/2012Beverly Ganiere costa mesa California 92626 United States 5/24/2012Kyle Nguyen Irvine California 92614 United States 5/24/2012John Harris Anaheim California 92806 United States 5/24/2012ROBERT  PRADO ORANGE California 92869 United States 5/24/2012Ryan Torres Irvine California 92604 United States 5/24/2012neil kasperowicz kaspeirvine California 92604 United States 5/24/2012Aaron  Chavez Santa Ana California 92707 United States 5/24/2012Bryan Orozco Irvine California 92614 United States 5/24/2012Lori Byon Franktown Colorado 80116 United States 5/24/2012Terry Mitchell Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/24/2012Matthew Ketsdever Capistrano Beach California 92624 United States 5/24/2012Cate Allen Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/24/2012Bruce Schultz Irvine California 92606 United States 5/24/2012Kimberly Kich Irvine California 92604 United States 5/24/2012Susan  Gamble Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/24/2012Teena H Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 5/24/2012Anna Black Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/24/2012john Courtright Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 5/24/2012Glenn Williams Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/24/2012Ammon Waters salt lake city Utah 84111 United States 5/24/2012Tanya Kinton Lake Forest California 92630 United States 5/24/2012Andrew Kich Irvine California 92604 United States 5/24/2012Elizabeth  Stillman Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/24/2012Philipp Roosen Irvine California 92617 United States 5/24/2012Tanya Napier Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 5/24/2012Carlie Myers Riverside California 92509 United States 5/24/2012Adriana Jimenez Whittier California 90605 United States 5/24/2012Janice  Durston Norco California 92860 United States 5/24/2012Barbara Sommars Long Beach California 90804 United States 5/24/2012William Napier Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 5/24/2012Chris Hazen Santa Ana California 92704 United States 5/24/2012Mary McDaniel Riverside California 92503 United States 5/24/2012Jan McQueen Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 5/24/2012katie miller ontario California 91762 United States 5/24/2012Carl Martin Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 5/24/2012Connie Schafhauser  San Juan Capistrano California 92675 United States 5/24/2012Jeanette Lamar davis California 95616 United States 5/24/2012Melissa Durston Norco California 92860 United States 5/24/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 288: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Max Nupen Irvine California 92606 United States 5/24/2012Sara Alex Santa Ana California 92705 United States 5/24/2012Sean Eyre Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 5/24/2012bj Chandler Tustin California 92782 United States 5/24/2012Chelsea Gould everett Washington 98203 United States 5/25/2012Dane Griffith pomona California 91766 United States 5/25/2012Dan Snipes Dana Point California 92629 United States 5/25/2012gladys julia smith huntington beach California 92648 United States 5/25/2012Jessica Garcia Garden Grove California 92843 United States 5/25/2012Mary Smihula Santa Ana California 92701 United States 5/25/2012Nikki Prosser Temecula California 92592 United States 5/25/2012Audrey Fober Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 5/25/2012Randy Duarte Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/25/2012frankie dominguez huntington beach California 92647 United States 5/25/2012Chris Bremer Tustin California 92780 United States 5/25/2012Aaron Narayan Irvine California 92618 United States 5/25/2012Olivia   Allen  San Ramon California 94583 United States 5/25/2012Tim Walsh FULLERTON California 92832 United States 5/25/2012Mark Powers Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/25/2012frank heim Moreno Valley California 92553 United States 5/25/2012Stacy Bush Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 5/25/2012Maryann Goodman Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/25/2012Bill Reiff Long Beach California 90803 United States 5/25/2012Dori Dumon Irvine California 92604 United States 5/25/2012Carol Brown Irvine California 92606 United States 5/25/2012Darin Dohi Torrance California 90504 United States 5/25/2012marcia martin Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/25/2012Sheri Crockett Los Angeles California 90077 United States 5/25/2012Kerry Lamperts Irvine California 92604 United States 5/25/2012John Kalucki San Francisco California 94114 United States 5/25/2012Peter McQueen Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 5/25/2012Kristina  Ruiz‐Mesa Boulder Colorado 80302 United States 5/25/2012larry moore hawthorne California 90250 United States 5/25/2012Sandy Cherry Fox Point Wisconsin 53217 United States 5/25/2012Nancy Wooldridge Trabuco Canyon California 92679 United States 5/25/2012Scott Henderson Highland California 92346 United States 5/25/2012Leigh Anne Lim Irvine California 92606 United States 5/25/2012Michael Ormerod Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/26/2012Jordan  Incledon Irvine California 92606 United States 5/26/2012Lynn Popkins San Dimas California 91773 United States 5/26/2012Leslie Sterrett Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/26/2012Ryan Christiansen Irvine California 92604 United States 5/26/2012Kathryn Young Newport Beach California 92663 United States 5/26/2012Judi Chimits Irvine California 92614 United States 5/26/2012Ron  Guyer Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/26/2012Suzanne Nelson Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 5/26/2012Laurie Tooch Newport beach California 92663 United States 5/26/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 289: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Robert Palfini Irvine California 92614 United States 5/26/2012Dr. Eric  Vanek Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 5/26/2012Patricia Gonzalez Orange California 92867 United States 5/26/2012Chantel Menzie‐WilluaGrand Terrace California 92313 United States 5/26/2012Sohil majdiSohilMajdi Irvine California 92618 United States 5/26/2012Beth Vance Irvine California 92620 United States 5/26/2012Cindy Sprick Sammamish Washington 98075 United States 5/26/2012samuel hardin Aptos California 95003 United States 5/26/2012Dan  Rosenthal Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 5/26/2012joanna della gatta Camarillo California 93012 United States 5/27/2012Iryna  Danyuk Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 5/27/2012DeAnna Franklin Las Vegas Nevada 89148 United States 5/27/2012Paul Thompson Sugarloaf California 92386 United States 5/27/2012james franklin Las Vegas Nevada 89148 United States 5/27/2012Christina Nelson Moreno Valley California 92551 United States 5/27/2012james birschbach costa mesa California 92627 United States 5/27/2012Gary Temple Kihei Hawaii 96753 United States 5/27/2012Kurt Ericson Newport Beach California 92661 United States 5/27/2012Frans Van Overeem Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 5/27/2012David Hanson Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 5/27/2012dee dawson balboa island California 92662 United States 5/28/2012Susan Allen Orange California 92868 United States 5/28/2012Hunter Patton Irvine California 92620 United States 5/28/2012Harrison Scoville Irvine California 92620 United States 5/28/2012Lane Daigle Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 5/28/2012Jennifer Harris Irvine California 92617 United States 5/29/2012Joseph Carlson Irvine California 92697 United States 5/29/2012Georgia Walling Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/29/2012Kristynne Simmons Rancho Cucamonga California 91737 United States 5/29/2012Dave Shackleton Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/29/2012Paula Hicks Ponca City Oklahoma 74604 United States 5/29/2012Julia Sutton Costa Mesa` California 92626‐2659 United States 5/29/2012Lisa Chen Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/29/2012Sharon Peile Irvine California 92620 United States 5/29/2012Judy Nebeker Santa Clara Utah 84765 United States 5/29/2012cassidy cardon Boise Idaho 83704 United States 5/29/2012Nancy  Do Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/29/2012Michael McGuire West Hollywood California 90069 United States 5/29/2012William Eastes Pomona California 91767 United States 5/29/2012Maureen Toal Newport Coast California 92657 United States 5/29/2012Charles Carter Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 5/29/2012Chad Forrello Los Angeles California 90026 United States 5/29/2012joseph  stack newport beach California 92663 United States 5/29/2012lesley jacobs Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 5/29/2012Kirstie Semler ST. George Utah 84770 United States 5/29/2012Sharon Schoneberger Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/29/2012MARYBETH BROPHY COSTA MESA California 92626 United States 5/30/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 290: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Alexis Broske Tustin California 92780 United States 5/30/2012Mark King Newport Beach California 92661 United States 5/30/2012Kathleen Ward San Clemente California 92672 United States 5/30/2012Carole Call Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 5/30/2012scot semonell newport beach California 92663 United States 5/30/2012Karin Garell Newport Beach California 92657 United States 5/30/2012LIsa Morsey Newport Coast California 92657 United States 5/30/2012Gretchen Allen Incline Village Nevada 89451 United States 5/30/2012sim sadoski newport beach California 92660 United States 5/30/2012Connie Cannon Rancho Santa Margarita California 92688 United States 5/30/2012Leslie Kazarian Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 5/31/2012Moya Monroe Newport Beach California 92660 United States 5/31/2012jennifer Robert Newport Coast California 92657 United States 5/31/2012Jody Gantos Newport Coast California 92657 United States 5/31/2012Rick  Rolsheim Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/31/2012Leslie Rolsheim Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 5/31/2012Anneliese Agren San Gregorio California 94074 United States 5/31/2012Elaine Mullen‐Barrett Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 6/1/2012Rose Barnes Temecula California 92591 United States 6/1/2012Marianne Corns Dallas Georgia 30132 United States 6/1/2012Mohammed El Makka Irvine California 92617 United States 6/1/2012DOUGLAS  STEWART MOBILE Alabama 36619 United States 6/1/2012Judy Hawley anaheim California 92805 United States 6/1/2012Jeremiah Broske Tustin California 92780 United States 6/1/2012Philip Garrett Newport Beach California 92661 United States 6/2/2012Lauralyn Johnson Orange California 92865 United States 6/2/2012Christina Elmore Wrightsville Beach North Carolina 28480 United States 6/2/2012Steve Crouch Orange California 92869 United States 6/2/2012Jenifer Russo Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 6/3/2012John Kirin Virginia City Nevada 89440 United States 6/4/2012Tom  Whitney Fullerton California 92831 United States 6/4/2012Kenny Stapleton Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 6/4/2012Joanna Stapleton san diego California 92122 United States 6/4/2012Linda Nelson Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 6/5/2012Paula Duhn  Santa Ana California 92705 United States 6/5/2012SHIRLEY TAPLEY SANTA ANA California 92705 United States 6/5/2012Patricia  Cosby  Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 6/5/2012Erik Swarbrick Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 6/5/2012Liz Crittenden Sacramento California 95831 United States 6/5/2012D Bandini Tustin California 92782 United States 6/5/2012Andrew  Johnson  Upland California 91784 United States 6/5/2012Sara Timberlake Pomona California 91766 United States 6/5/2012Krissy Danforth Upland California 91786 United States 6/5/2012Andy Kite Woodstock Georgia 30189 United States 6/5/2012Brandon Shean Rancho Cucamonga California 91701 United States 6/5/2012valerie ramirez Hesperia California 92345 United States 6/6/2012Becky Mejia Ontario, ca California 91762 United States 6/6/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 291: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Jason Young Rancho Cucamonga California 91739 United States 6/6/2012Dennis  Kiley Los Angeles California 90066 United States 6/6/2012Samantha Danforth Upland California 91786 United States 6/6/2012Annie Danforth Upland California 91786 United States 6/6/2012Justin Budds Upland California 91786 United States 6/6/2012Laura Bounds Orange California 92869 United States 6/6/2012Sherrie Green La Habra California 90631 United States 6/6/2012Michele  Nyssen Newport Beach California 92663 United States 6/6/2012Arya Moalemi Yorba Linda California 92887 United States 6/6/2012ERik Kaiser Lakewood California 90713 United States 6/6/2012Vadim Mozyrsky Irvine California 92618 United States 6/7/2012Lee Payne Newport Beach California 92661 United States 6/7/2012Diana Jianas Newport Beach California 92660 United States 6/8/2012Gil Garcia Fontana California 92336 United States 6/8/2012Theresa O'Keefe Garden Grove California 92840 United States 6/8/2012kalani Green Corona California 92882 United States 6/9/2012Chris Ehrlich Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 6/9/2012Nadine  Rodriguez Newport Bch. California 92660 United States 6/10/2012Hillary Ascensao Santa Clara California 95051 United States 6/10/2012Hailei Reyes Bonita California 91902 United States 6/10/2012Jana Perez Santa Ana California 92704 United States 6/10/2012David Sharp Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 6/10/2012Tammy Duncan Corona California 92882 United States 6/10/2012Frank Dwyer Newport Beach California 92661 United States 6/10/2012Benj Clarke Long Beach California 90815 United States 6/10/2012Jenny Anne Hannon Ventura California 93001 United States 6/10/2012Andrea Sea Namaste Moorpark California 93021 United States 6/10/2012Patricia Taillon Raleigh North Carolina 27614 United States 6/11/2012Geoff Forgie Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 6/11/2012Frances Lindsay Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 6/11/2012Paula Northington Irvine California 92606 United States 6/11/2012julius northington irvine California 92606 United States 6/11/2012cathy bjorklund costa mesa California 92627 United States 6/11/2012Gayle Kraus Irvine California 92603 United States 6/12/2012Lynn Matzenger United States 6/12/2012Diana Rivera Moreno Valley California 92557 United States 6/12/2012David Nopens Riverside California 92503 United States 6/12/2012Marilyn Scott‐Waters Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 6/12/2012Louise Rose Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 6/12/2012Brett Bigelow Irvine California 92614 United States 6/12/2012Mark Jeske Kirkland Washington 98034 United States 6/12/2012Desiree Rozenberg United States 6/12/2012Stan Gibson United States 6/12/2012Kim Escamilla Rancho Cucamonga California 91737 United States 6/13/2012Robin  Ehrlich Monument Colorado 80132 United States 6/13/2012Cody Gerhold Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 6/13/2012Niki Devlin Irvine California 92614 United States 6/13/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 292: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Megan Henderson Irvine California 92614 United States 6/13/2012calvin murphy Irvine California 92618 United States 6/13/2012Ina Karamchandani Irvine California 92614 United States 6/14/2012Michael Schowengerd Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 6/14/2012Audrey Fajardo Newport Coast California 92657 United States 6/14/2012Kari Dennis Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 6/14/2012Alex Trujillo Tustin California 92780 United States 6/14/2012Charles Masters Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 6/14/2012Jennifer Allen Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 6/15/2012Laura Allen Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 6/15/2012Alejandra Gonzalez‐PaMission Viejo California 92691 United States 6/16/2012kyle bryson Irvine California 92612 United States 6/16/2012Donna O'Donoghue Brisbane 4060 Australia 6/16/2012Alex Cornwell Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 6/17/2012Rachel Tallon Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 6/17/2012Lauren Tallon Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 6/17/2012Daryl Tallon Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 6/17/2012Chris Teague Irvine California 92620 United States 6/18/2012Richard Purpura Orange California 92867 United States 6/18/2012David Purpura Irvine California 92612 United States 6/18/2012Daniel Purpura Orange California 92867 United States 6/18/2012Charlene  Mandau Irvine California 92602 United States 6/18/2012wes grimm newpor beach California 92663 United States 6/18/2012Dana Ruminski Irvine California 92617 United States 6/18/2012Brent Spang Irvine California 92617 United States 6/18/2012Agnesa Avanesian Irvine California 92617 United States 6/18/2012james fitzpatrick laguna niguel California 92677 United States 6/19/2012William Ross Irvine California 92617 United States 6/19/2012Ruth Pena Irvine California 92612 United States 6/19/2012David Chorak Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 6/19/2012Daniel Cortez Irvine California 92612 United States 6/21/2012Amber Schwinn Newhall California 91321 United States 6/21/2012Marissa Calille Chatsworth California 91311 United States 6/21/2012wes thoroughman irvine California 92604 United States 6/21/2012Kyrie Workman Edmond Oklahoma 73012 United States 6/21/2012Laurie Morgan Newhall California 91321 United States 6/21/2012cheryl  arend newtown California 6470 United States 6/21/2012Johnny Schwinn Canyon Country California 91387 United States 6/21/2012Kathryn Lindsay Riverside California 92503 United States 6/21/2012sandra Burck Santa Monica California 90403 United States 6/21/2012Robert Holman Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 6/22/2012Geoff Jezowski Orange California 92869 United States 6/22/2012Julie Reinbold Sandpoint Idaho 83864 United States 6/22/2012Genevueve  Hunt Happy Valley Oregon 97086 United States 6/22/2012Elizabeth Greenwood San Pedro California 90731 United States 6/22/2012David Tersigni Camarillo California 93012‐5213 United States 6/22/2012Kirk McELwain Fountain Valley California 92708‐1349 United States 6/22/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 293: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

CAROL VOISINE Villa Park California 92861 United States 6/22/2012Liz Pattison Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 6/22/2012Ted Mortenson Balboa California 92661 United States 6/22/2012Sandra Waite Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 6/22/2012Barry Kazmer St Cloud Minnesota 56303 United States 6/22/2012Carol Markel Huntington Beach California 92647 United States 6/23/2012carolyn snyder Kalispell Montana 59901 United States 6/23/2012Martha Felix Tustin California 92782 United States 6/23/2012Christine Bone irvine California 92606 United States 6/23/2012Jennifer L Taylor Irvine California 92604 United States 6/24/2012Adrienne Danet Orange California 92869 United States 6/24/2012Bryan Juedes Mira Loma California 91752 United States 6/24/2012Renee Spindle Mira Loma California 91752 United States 6/25/2012Hilary  Juedes Mira Loma California 91752 United States 6/25/2012Brad Stevens Long Beach California 90815 United States 6/25/2012Shelley Dutt RSF California 92067 United States 6/25/2012bradly daily Corona California 92879 United States 6/25/2012Tracy  Buchanan San Diego California 92115 United States 6/25/2012Julie Ann Muzzall Brea California 92821 United States 6/25/2012Heather Maddigan Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 6/25/2012Alejandra Ascencio Stanton California 90680 United States 6/26/2012Eve Lowey Newport Coast California 92657 United States 6/26/2012Claudia Castanares Newport Beach California 92657 United States 6/26/2012Cindi C Newport Beach California 92782 United States 6/26/2012Kate Horwitz Tustin California 92780 United States 6/26/2012Griffin Dunzer Newport Beach California 92660 United States 6/26/2012krysten norkaitis United States 6/26/2012susie  Alvarez Riversdie California 92503 United States 6/27/2012Debbie Zaragoza Riverside California 92509 United States 6/27/2012Kathy Meadows Ogden Utah 84405 United States 6/27/2012Paula Telles Irvine California 92604 United States 6/27/2012Susan Lyons Irvine California 92604 United States 6/27/2012tori west seal beach California 90740 United States 6/27/2012Natalie Meyerson Santa Ana California 92705 United States 6/27/2012Margaret  Quinn Santa Ana California 92705 United States 6/27/2012Jennifer Gause Tustin California 92780 United States 6/27/2012Jennifer Lam United States 6/27/2012Donna Speck United States 6/27/2012Lori Mehl United States 6/27/2012Star Wilkinson La Habra California 90631 United States 6/27/2012Bonnie Barlow Irvine California 92604 United States 6/27/2012Amy Hellewell Irvine California 92620 United States 6/27/2012Dominica Kristedja Santa Ana California 92705 United States 6/27/2012Candice DuBose United States 6/27/2012Courtney Coleman United States 6/27/2012Marci Wagner Riverside California 92508 United States 6/27/2012Carla Narvaez Irvine California 92602 United States 6/27/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 294: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Susanne Syben MoscicIrvine California 92620 United States 6/27/2012John Cannon Santa Ana California 92705 United States 6/27/2012john sellers Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 6/27/2012beth dixon Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 6/28/2012Mari Bell Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 6/28/2012Teresa Bell Henderson Nevada 89074 United States 6/28/2012Bennett Segelman 92630 United States 6/29/2012Aaron Attarian Irvine California 92612 United States 6/29/2012Eric & Bonnie Schultz Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 6/29/2012Jessica Wolder Irvine California 92604 United States 6/29/2012Don Lee Tustin California 92780 United States 6/29/2012Debbie Harris United States 6/30/2012Virginia Partridge Santa Ana California 92707 United States 6/30/2012Eric Pruessing Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 6/30/2012Malorie Briley newport Beach California 92661 United States 7/1/2012christopher ortiz United States 7/1/2012richard  briley 92867 United States 7/1/2012debbie briley Orange California 92867 United States 7/1/2012Stephanie Mathis Newport Beach California 92661 United States 7/1/2012Samantha Barber Orange California 92869 United States 7/1/2012Nick Morey Orange California 92867 United States 7/2/2012Alissa Medart Whittier California 90603 United States 7/2/2012Heather Corneliys Anaheim California 92806 United States 7/2/2012Jaime Lazos Santa Ana California 92706 United States 7/2/2012Christopher Jackson Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 7/2/2012Dwight Calwhite Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 7/2/2012Yessica Salcedo Santa Ana California 92707 United States 7/2/2012Rae‐Lynn  Weaver Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 7/2/2012Russell Chorlton Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 7/2/2012Travis Hill Irvine California 92617 United States 7/3/2012Jennifer Hagen Irvine California 92606 United States 7/3/2012Nina Elisius Newport Beach California 92660 United States 7/3/2012Jonathan Monte United States 7/3/2012Kyle Ohlin Oakland California 94607 United States 7/3/2012David Leatherman Torrance California 90501 United States 7/3/2012Claire Weaver United States 7/3/2012Chris Tate Long Beach California 90815 United States 7/3/2012Paul  Smith Fullerton California 92831 United States 7/3/2012Chet Wilson Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 7/3/2012nicole stranz los angeles California 90031 United States 7/3/2012Kimberly Gomez Elk Grove California 95758 United States 7/3/2012Tina Simons Hermosa Beach California 90254 United States 7/3/2012Travis Landholm Harbor City California 90710 United States 7/3/2012Jeremy Bowden Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 7/3/2012RAY VASQUEZ CORONA DEL MAR California 92625 United States 7/3/2012Cheryl Allison Newport Beach California 92660 United States 7/3/2012Yvette Calderon United States 7/4/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 295: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Cristina Perez Pomona California 91766 United States 7/4/2012Cassandra Valencia Angelus Oaks California 92305 United States 7/4/2012Charles wherritt Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 7/4/2012Christine Fulmer Angelus Oaks California 92305 United States 7/4/2012rosie rodriguez Walnut California 91789 United States 7/4/2012Andrew Mundschau Orange California 92867 United States 7/4/2012Eric Malyszka Newport Beach California 92663 United States 7/4/2012Meghan  Macias Irvine California 92620 United States 7/4/2012Bradford Gilliland United States 7/4/2012Ronald HILL HUNTINGTON BEACH California 92647 United States 7/4/2012Janet Coughlin Silverado California 92676 United States 7/4/2012Ada Pham Orange California 92867 United States 7/4/2012Justin Miramontes Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 7/4/2012Aaron Roach Orange California 92865 United States 7/4/2012zane mayer McCloud California 96057 United States 7/4/2012Jana Egan Newport Beach California 92663 United States 7/4/2012Ryan Ford Costa Mesa California 91423 United States 7/4/2012Jennifer Bolander Ladera Ranch California 92694 United States 7/4/2012stephanie ramirez Fontana California 92337 United States 7/4/2012Kim Kautzer Alta Loma California 91737 United States 7/4/2012Lee Buckingham Riverside California 92503 United States 7/4/2012Karah Fredricks 91786 United States 7/4/2012Emily Saltarelli Orange California 92869 United States 7/5/2012Janel Buckingham United States 7/5/2012Chanel Tsai United States 7/5/2012Brenda Darcy Placentia California 92870 United States 7/5/2012Catherine Breen Irvine California 92614 United States 7/5/2012Hasti Ahangi Tustin California 92782 United States 7/5/2012Brian Phan placentia California 92870 United States 7/5/2012Jacqueline Ramos Irvine California 92602 United States 7/5/2012Harika Kothapalli United States 7/5/2012jessica arnaldo irvine California 92604 United States 7/5/2012Sang‐Soo Lee irvine California 92620 United States 7/5/2012Kevin Krause Irvine California 92602 United States 7/5/2012jereme Durkin Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 7/5/2012Robynn Durkin Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 7/5/2012Allen Lin Diamond Bar California 91765 United States 7/6/2012Tiffany Lawrence Rancho Cucamonga California 91701 United States 7/6/2012Jennifer Welsh foothill ranch California 92610 United States 7/6/2012Bill Beyer Long Beach California 90802 United States 7/6/2012Jacqueline Farrar Alta Loma California 91701 United States 7/6/2012Daniel Jepson Rancho cucamonga California 91737 United States 7/6/2012Nancy Sturgis 91711 United States 7/6/2012Victoria  Cohenour North Las Vegas Nevada 89031 United States 7/6/2012Tabitha Hapl Salida Colorado 81201 United States 7/6/2012Andrew Spring Calabasas California 91302 United States 7/6/2012william rankin huntington beach California 92648 United States 7/6/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 296: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Starla Heath Upland California 91786 United States 7/6/2012christine lukes rialto  California 92376 United States 7/6/2012Marissa Grusman Rancho Cucamonga California 91739 United States 7/6/2012Jonathan Baldwin Newport Beach California 92663 United States 7/7/2012Chiquita Stonecipher Rancho Cucamonga California 91730 United States 7/7/2012tamara spring Calabasas California 91302 United States 7/7/2012Araceli Nunez Rancho Cucamonga California 91730 United States 7/7/2012Norbert Plante Valencia California 91355 United States 7/8/2012Lauren Martinez brea California 92821 United States 7/8/2012BOB PORTALE CORONA DEL MAR California 92625 7/8/2012Ann Perry 92627 7/8/2012Cindra Huffman Diamond Bar California 91765 United States 7/8/2012Donna Garrett 92867 7/9/2012Beth Ulery Orange California 92867 United States 7/9/2012sandra grusman rancho cucamonga California 91739 United States 7/9/2012sera grusman rancho cucamonga California 91739 United States 7/9/2012andrew grusman rancho cucamonga California 91739 United States 7/9/2012Andrea Mills Villa Park California 92861 United States 7/9/2012Don Garrett Anaheim California 92808 United States 7/9/2012Rick Cutler Anaheim California 92807 United States 7/9/2012mary kuli Villa Park California 92861 United States 7/9/2012Jodie Goode Seal Beach California 90740 7/9/2012Michael Farrel Orange California 92867 United States 7/9/2012Robin vigil Tustin California 92780 United States 7/9/2012Janice FitzGerald Irvine 92620 United States Mino 7/9/2012karla kjellin‐elder 7/9/2012Neily Messerschmidt Garden Grove California 92840 United States 7/9/2012Gladys Pineda Orange California 92868 United States 7/9/2012Tara Eaton Orange California 92869 United States 7/9/2012Terri Samuels Irvine California 92604 United States 7/10/2012Lindsey Bonno costa mesa California 92627 United States 7/10/2012melody sayrany ircine California 92612 United States 7/10/2012Jenifer Logue Marina Del Rey California 90292 United States 7/10/2012Elisa Lahoutifard Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 7/10/2012patrick nelsen Balboa California 92661 United States 7/10/2012mary ludlow el segundo California 90245 United States 7/10/2012STEVE SCHUSTER SANTA ANA California 92706 United States 7/10/2012Carolyn Sevier Ontario California 91761 United States 7/10/2012Vernean Nelsen San Juan Capistrano California 92675 United States 7/10/2012Di‐Anna Schuster Santa Ana California 92706 United States 7/10/2012casey postma fullerton California 92833 United States 7/10/2012james mata fullerton California 92833 United States 7/10/2012Amy Howland La Verne California 91750 United States 7/11/2012Eric Christensen Rancho Santa Margarita California 92688 United States 7/11/2012John Blank Orange California 92869 United States 7/11/2012Kim  Magdaleno Santa Ana California 92703 United States 7/11/2012Rick Dell Orange California 92869 United States 7/11/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 297: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

cheri brewer Whittier California 90604 United States 7/12/2012SONJA GRANT Newport Beach California 92660 United States 7/12/2012Shawn Roberts Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 7/12/2012Loyd Goolsby Huntington Beach California 92648 United States 7/12/2012Aimmee Hagler‐CalvanNorthridge California 91326 United States 7/12/2012Salme Taagepera Irvine California 92612 United States 7/12/2012Steve Bedaux Burbank California 91505 United States 7/13/2012Meghan Delaney Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 7/13/2012Jessica Marquardt Orange California 92869 United States 7/14/2012Meg Marquardt Orange California 92869 United States 7/14/2012Mai Vu Orange California 92869 United States 7/14/2012michael dissingerMichRancho Santa Margarita California 92688 United States 7/14/2012antonio barajas ontaio California 91762 United States 7/14/2012Sean Sheridan Las Vegas Nevada 89129 United States 7/14/2012cynthia thomas corona del mar California 92625 United States 7/14/2012Hannah Kilfoyle Lake Forest California 92630 United States 7/15/2012Sherry Morin Irvine California 92604 United States 7/15/2012Bobbie Garza Newport Beach California 92660 United States 7/15/2012Mary Ann Ehrnman Rancho Santa Margarita California 92688 United States 7/15/2012J. Poole Santa Ana California 92705 United States 7/15/2012randy workman glendora California 91741 United States 7/15/2012CARLOS GARCIA Pomona California 91766 United States 7/16/2012Maria Ortiz Montclair California 91763 United States 7/16/2012Haman Movafagh Newport Beach California 92660 United States 7/16/2012Samuel Lopez Chino California 91710 United States 7/16/2012Laura Salas Brea California 92821 United States 7/17/2012Amaris  Salas Brea California 92821 United States 7/17/2012Esteban Jardon Newport Coast California 92657 United States 7/17/2012afsi mostajab Irvine California 92623 United States 7/17/2012Barbara Kellerman Long Beach California 90808 United States 7/17/2012Joan  Cachola Irvine California 92620 United States 7/17/2012Jack Hogan Newport Beach California 92663 United States 7/18/2012Dominic Riccabona Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 7/18/2012Desiree Berry Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 7/18/2012Stephen Gonzales Long Beach California 90801 United States 7/18/2012Melanie Santer Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 7/18/2012Kati Kern Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 7/18/2012Shawn Rolin Irvine California 92614 United States 7/18/2012Graeme Geddes Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 7/18/2012Eric Gould Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 7/18/2012Melinda Jack corona del mar California 92625 United States 7/19/2012Jonathan Hobbs Grand Junction Colorado 81501 United States 7/19/2012Dean Curci 7/19/2012Stephanie  Castle Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 7/19/2012Raveendra and Gira MCorona Del Mar California 92625 United States 7/19/2012Jennifer Reilly  Redwood City California 94063 United States 7/19/2012Shawn ONeill Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 7/19/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 298: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

jerald kompelien calimesa California 92320 United States 7/19/2012Anja Crotts Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 7/20/2012allison cassara huntington beach California 92646 United States 7/21/2012STEFFIN BUTLER GRANADA HILLS California 91344 United States 7/21/2012Heidi Schemel Beaumont California 92223 United States 7/21/2012paul wright newport beach California 92660 United States 7/22/2012Stephanie Revolloso Ontario California 91761 United States 7/22/2012Victoria Aguirre Placentia California 92870 United States 7/23/2012Angela Nguyen Irvine California 92620 United States 7/23/2012Tori Bynon Irvine California 92620 United States 7/23/2012Matthew Kupferer Irvine California 92620 United States 7/23/2012katrina Luu Irvine California 92620 United States 7/23/2012Michelle Siu Irvine California 92620 United States 7/23/2012Shazib Haq Laguna Niguel California 92677 United States 7/23/2012Kailei Simpson Irvine California 92620 United States 7/23/2012Philippa Hawker Irvine California 92620 United States 7/24/2012janice chun irvine California 92620 United States 7/24/2012Amanda  Picard Irvine California 92620 United States 7/24/2012Elena Ferrero Irvine California 92620 United States 7/24/2012Melodie Varzandeh Irvine California 92620 United States 7/24/2012Emily Bishop Irvine California 92620 United States 7/24/2012Ashley Yonamine Irvine California 92620 United States 7/24/2012Kimberley Hawker Halifax B4B 1S6 Canada 7/24/2012Sumer Celaya hot springs village Arkansas 71909 United States 7/24/2012Joseph Kupferer Irvine California 92620 United States 7/24/2012Claudia Nguyen Irvine California 92620 United States 7/24/2012jacob mercado Pomona California 91767 United States 7/24/2012Nicole Johnson Irvine California 92620 United States 7/24/2012Joel Molitor Burlington Wisconsin 53105 United States 7/25/2012Jessica Molitor Burlington Wisconsin 53105 United States 7/25/2012sandy macari Beecher City Illinois 62565 United States 7/25/2012Perry Bradford Williams Bay Wisconsin 53191 United States 7/25/2012Caleb Choi Santa Ana California 92706 United States 7/25/2012Harland Koch Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 7/25/2012Elliot Johnson Goroka 444 Papua New Guinea 7/25/2012Janet Kronbach Seattle Washington 98133 United States 7/25/2012Joani Arciniega Cedar Glen California 92321 United States 7/26/2012Mike Skon Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 7/26/2012Emaan Baqai Irvine California 92620 United States 7/26/2012Angie Nguyen Irvine California 92620 United States 7/26/2012Gerard kevin De vera Torrance California 90501 United States 7/26/2012Alexander Rearick St. Louis Missouri 63119 United States 7/26/2012Naomi Sahlstrom Tracy Minnesota 56175 United States 7/26/2012Brent Bounds New York New York 10025 United States 7/26/2012Tamara Walton Corona California 92882 United States 7/26/2012Paul Niager Jacksonville Florida 32223 United States 7/26/2012Sandi Bradford Williams Bay Wisconsin 53191 United States 7/26/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 299: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Kayley Ingalls Canyon Country California 91351 United States 7/26/2012Creighton RothenbergNewport Beach California 92660 United States 7/26/2012Alexander Doty Santa Ana California 92707 United States 7/26/2012Katrin Rothenberger Newport Beach California 92660 United States 7/26/2012Hilda Rodriguez Redlands California 92373 United States 7/26/2012jay hatch huntington beach California 92649 United States 7/27/2012an Nguyen  Walnut California 91789 United States 7/27/2012tom christensen corona del mar California 92925 United States 7/27/2012Peter Rauterkus Santa Ana California 92705 United States 7/27/2012Misty Bykowski Shelby Township Michigan 48317 United States 7/27/2012Alex McClure WYLIE Texas 75098 United States 7/27/2012Elaine Rauterkus San Clemente California E92673 United States 7/27/2012Barry McAleer Orange California 92869 United States 7/27/2012Terri Benkey Orange California 92869 United States 7/27/2012Linda  Rauterkus Santa Ana California 92705 United States 7/27/2012Jim Nista Long Beach California 90802 United States 7/27/2012Ashley Vallin Fontana California 92337 United States 7/27/2012Gale Brandt Santa Ana California 92705 United States 7/27/2012amy rodriguez Victorville California 92392 United States 7/27/2012mayra rodriguez victorville California 92394 United States 7/27/2012ARMANDO DE LA TOR Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 7/27/2012nicky  rodriguez victorville California 92392 United States 7/27/2012Melody  Nista Cypress California 90630 United States 7/27/2012julie port redlands California 92374 United States 7/27/2012Michael Rauterkus Tustin California 92780 United States 7/27/2012Cindy Earp Redondo California 90277 United States 7/27/2012Zaheera Wahid San Diego California 92131 United States 7/27/2012Benjamin C Niles Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 7/27/2012Rory Talmon Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 7/27/2012Adrianna Areas Riverside California 92509 United States 7/27/2012Howard Nista Cypress California 90630 United States 7/28/2012JOSEPH CAIN GOLDEN Colorado 80402 United States 7/28/2012Sean Genovese Helotes Texas 78023 United States 7/28/2012Susan Dodge Mission Viejo California 92692 United States 7/28/2012Michael Miller Winter Springs Florida 32708 United States 7/28/2012Rochelle McAleer Tustin, California 92780 United States 7/28/2012Sylvia Cline Brea California 92821 United States 7/29/2012Linda LeFave Victorville California 92392 United States 7/29/2012Luis Rodriguez Redlands California 92373 United States 7/30/2012Ana Rodriguez Redlands California 92373 United States 7/30/2012Richard Jensen Fort Collins Colorado 80525 United States 7/30/2012Kelly  Wilson Gilbert Arizona 85296 United States 7/30/2012Ashlee Candelaria Redlands California 92374 United States 7/30/2012Hilda Rodriguez Pflugerville Texas 78660 United States 7/30/2012Kathleen Didier Santa Ana California 92705 United States 7/30/2012jamie fleri mission viejo California 92691 United States 7/30/2012Kathleen Riley Orange California 92869 United States 7/31/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 300: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Jenifer Culbertson Newport Beach California 92660 United States 7/31/2012Darlene Rametta Rancho Cucamonga California 91739 United States 7/31/2012Anthony Evegan Newport Beach California 92660 United States 7/31/2012ron whiteman corona del mar California 92625 United States 7/31/2012Vivian  Manly Rowland Heights California 91748 United States 7/31/2012Danielle Rivas Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 7/31/2012Monica Siegenthaler Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 7/31/2012Giselle Allard Laguna Niguel California 92677 United States 7/31/2012Scott Wendrick irvine California 92620 United States 7/31/2012Rachel King Yorba Linda California 92887 United States 7/31/2012melinda wendrick irvine California 92620 United States 7/31/2012greg figge Newport Beach California 92660 United States 7/31/2012Albert Barnett Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 7/31/2012Lo Yu Irvine California 92617 United States 7/31/2012Kathleen Luby Santan valley Arizona 85143 United States 7/31/2012joanne capetan corona del mar California 92625 United States 7/31/2012Laural Armster Long Beach California 90803 United States 7/31/2012Michael Lewis Newport Beach California 92660 United States 7/31/2012Todd Willardson Newport Beach California 92657 United States 7/31/2012Richard Larsen santa ana California 92705 United States 7/31/2012Christine Robinson Orange California 92869 United States 7/31/2012Lisa Orozco Anaheim California 92801 United States 7/31/2012Charles Mejia Corona California 92882 United States 7/31/2012Marleen Robinson Orange California 92868 United States 7/31/2012rebecca salgado Garden Grove California 92843 United States 7/31/2012Cynthia Seppala Orange California 92869 United States 7/31/2012Gary Goubert Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 7/31/2012vanessa craven santa ana California 92707 United States 7/31/2012Chris Jordan  Laguna Niguel California 92677 United States 7/31/2012Kelli  Sharp Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 7/31/2012Laine Butler Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 7/31/2012Diane Cain Irvine California 92604 United States 7/31/2012AL BRUDER NEWPORT COAST California 92662 United States 7/31/2012Sandra Aicher Irvine California 92620 United States 7/31/2012Forston Ireland Marina del Rey California 90292 United States 7/31/2012Mary Spindler Placentia California 92870 United States 7/31/2012jim price Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 7/31/2012Field Amundson Newport Beach California 92661 United States 7/31/2012Jodie Noblett Chino California 91710 United States 7/31/2012Martha Fluor Newport Beach California 92660 United States 7/31/2012Marissa Rehmet Campbellsville Kentucky 42718 United States 8/1/2012Kelly Clark Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 8/1/2012sara heslington Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 8/1/2012Ignacio Gonzalez Santa Ana California 92704 United States 8/1/2012Alex Moosavi Newport Beach California 92661 United States 8/1/2012William Plaxico Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 8/1/2012Katie Schrenk Newport Beach California 92661 United States 8/1/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 301: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Amanda Hartzler Plymouth Michigan 48170 United States 8/1/2012Toby Ponnay Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 8/1/2012Robert Moodey Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 8/1/2012Deanna Trento Irvine California 92612 United States 8/1/2012Maria Page San Clemente California 92672 United States 8/1/2012Lauren  Vajda Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 8/1/2012Christina Womack Santa Ana California 92706 United States 8/1/2012Joan Principe La Habra California 90632 United States 8/1/2012Karen Johnston Lake Forest California 92630 United States 8/1/2012Caroline McCabe Santa Ana California 92704 United States 8/1/2012rebecca abarca Garden Grove California 92843 United States 8/1/2012 Raymond Gerbi Newport Beach California 92662 United States 8/2/2012Marilyn Elliott‐Lewis Rawlins Wyoming 82301 United States 8/2/2012Arthur Lopez Tustin California 92782 United States 8/2/2012steve xenos,PhD Newport Beach California 92661 United States 8/2/2012Judith  Ells Las Vegas Nevada 89131 United States 8/2/2012Christine Theriault Shady Cove Oregon 97539 United States 8/2/2012Mary Jacobsen Encampment Wyoming 82325 United States 8/2/2012Timothy Kragten anaheim California 92806‐4707 United States 8/3/2012Shannon  Teichmann Vista California 92081 United States 8/3/2012Ian Wales Newport Beach California 92663 United States 8/3/2012Dale Critchfield Riverside California 92506 United States 8/4/2012Maribel Diaz Los Angeles California 90033 United States 8/4/2012Martha Chavez Los Angeles California 90033 United States 8/4/2012Brenda Sanche Apple Valley California 92307 United States 8/4/2012yomayra Garcia Riverisde California 92504 United States 8/5/2012Nona Wolverton Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 8/5/2012ELISEO Vasquez Placentia California 92870 United States 8/5/2012Kailey Grant Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 8/5/2012Sheli Tuzzolino Salta loma Alabama Al United States 8/5/2012Kimberlie DuBois Chino  California 91710 United States 8/5/2012Chontte Hocum Laguna Niguel California 92677 United States 8/6/2012Nancy Healis Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 8/6/2012arnie blumenthal CDM California 92625 United States 8/6/2012Valerie Schnieders Newport Beach California 92660 United States 8/6/2012Golden Bacheldet Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 8/6/2012Nanette Grant Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 8/6/2012cody larsen costa mesa California 92627 United States 8/6/2012Nikki Moorhouse irvine California 92620 United States 8/6/2012Susan  Whitlock Huntington Beach California 92646 United States 8/6/2012Andrew Hunt Balboa Island California 92662 United States 8/6/2012tamara mccoy corona del mar California 92625 United States 8/6/2012Steve Leuck Florissant Colorado 80816 United States 8/6/2012Dianne Putman Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 8/7/2012Christina Phan New York New York 10016 United States 8/7/2012Tammam Beydoun Aliso Viejo California 92656 United States 8/7/2012Bryant Lee Irvine California 92620 United States 8/7/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 302: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Juliane Huang NEW YORK New York 10021 United States 8/7/2012Bowie viloriaBowieviloNewport beach California 92661 United States 8/7/2012Claudia Flores Ontario California 91764 United States 8/7/2012Peter Ahn Irvine California 92602 United States 8/7/2012Ryan McGillivary Santa Ana California 92706 United States 8/7/2012ray ng irvine California 92606 United States 8/7/2012Joshua Cheng Irvine California 92606 United States 8/7/2012Shawn Lee walnut California 91789 United States 8/7/2012Tony Tran San Francisco California 94107 United States 8/7/2012Kathleen Keh Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 8/7/2012Estella Wu Los Angeles California 90035 United States 8/7/2012Ryan Dacko Rancho Cucamonga California 91739 United States 8/7/2012Barbara Kraus Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 8/7/2012Gregory W Hunter Anaheim California 92805 United States 8/7/2012Hamzah Beydoun irvine California 92681 United States 8/8/2012Melissa Mokhtari Irvine California 92606 United States 8/8/2012Nicola Smith Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 8/8/2012Wendy Petitjean Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 8/8/2012Linda Daley Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 8/8/2012Caitlin Culbertson Newport Beach California 92660 United States 8/9/2012Jeff Culbertson Newport Beach California 92660 United States 8/9/2012Kathryn Hess Newport Beach California 92660 United States 8/9/2012Dhruv Sharma Newport Beach California 92661 United States 8/9/2012Suzanne Deano Irvine California 92620 United States 8/9/2012Robert Craven Rancho Santa Margarita California 92688 United States 8/9/2012Kristianna Jupin Germantown Maryland 20874 United States 8/9/2012Nora Hull Orange California 92869 United States 8/9/2012Melody  Hansen Lakewood California 90713 United States 8/10/2012Carrie Pavlik Orange California 92869 United States 8/10/2012Matthew Quan Newport Beach California 92660 United States 8/10/2012Leann Soto Irvine California 92606 United States 8/10/2012Richard LeClair  Irvine California 92614 United States 8/10/2012Matthew Cheah Irvine California 92614 United States 8/10/2012Lauren Oberreiter Newport Beach California 92660 United States 8/10/2012David "Chip" RobinsonCorona del Mar California 92625 United States 8/10/2012Matt Shipman Corona del mar California 92625 United States 8/10/2012Greg Stai Placentia California 92871 United States 8/10/2012Veronica Munoz Pomona California 91767 United States 8/10/2012Larry Walsh Shadow Hills California 91040 United States 8/10/2012Andrew Chauvin Virginia Beach Virginia 23462 United States 8/10/2012wolf‐peter beech newport beach California 92663 United States 8/10/2012Cindy Powell Newport Beach, California 92661‐1024 United States 8/10/2012Daniel  Bergh Erie Colorado 80516 United States 8/10/2012Sabine Reichert Silverado California 92676 United States 8/10/2012Brian Dooley Silverado California 92676 United States 8/10/2012John Garrott Anaheim California 92807 United States 8/10/2012Elizabeth Foster San Francisco California 94107 United States 8/10/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 303: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Donna king Laguna Niguel California 92677 United States 8/10/2012AVONELLE KONE NEWPORT BEACH California 92660 United States 8/10/2012Steve Galvan Santa Fe Springs California 90670 United States 8/10/2012jeanie roe corona del mar California 92625 United States 8/10/2012Alan Satkin Santa Ana California 92706 United States 8/10/2012lisa sawdon laguna niguel California 92677 United States 8/10/2012Keith Kudell Orange California 92867 United States 8/10/2012Brian Demsky Irvine California 92617 United States 8/10/2012Yolanda Rios Santa Ana California 92704 United States 8/10/2012Paul Willett Santa Ana California 92704 United States 8/10/2012Michael Poulsen Playa del Rey California 90293 United States 8/10/2012John Larson Santa Maria California 93454 United States 8/10/2012T F Ahmed Torrance California 90503 United States 8/10/2012Ulrike Proctor Sierra madre California 91024 United States 8/10/2012Ross Currens Newport Beach California 92663 United States 8/10/2012April Garfield Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 8/10/2012Lillian T Tustin California 92780 United States 8/10/2012Ted Chen Irvine California 92603 United States 8/10/2012jason slagle Glendale California 91206 United States 8/10/2012Jackie Warren Newport Beach California 92662 United States 8/10/2012Tammy Tatro Anaheim California 92808 United States 8/11/2012Greg Garfield Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 8/11/2012Cristina Parada Laguna Hills California 92656 United States 8/11/2012Eric O'Brien Newport Beach California 92663‐3409 United States 8/11/2012Kathy  White Balboa Island California 92662 United States 8/11/2012Robert LeSueur Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 8/11/2012John Garcia Montebello California 90640 United States 8/11/2012Ben Graves San Diego California 92101 United States 8/11/2012Rebecca Pettit Riverside California 92506 United States 8/11/2012Carolyn Beach Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 8/12/2012Linda Maher Newport Beach California 92658 United States 8/12/2012Paul Suihler Newport Beach California 92658 United States 8/12/2012Stacie Pestel Fountain Valley California 92708 United States 8/12/2012Matthew Shichtman Los Angeles California 90046 United States 8/12/2012Jeff Traintime Burbank California 91505 United States Mino 8/12/2012Willard Chilcott Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 8/13/2012Gabrielle Waring Los Angeles California 90019 United States 8/13/2012Abigail Morris Ann Arbor California 90028 United States 8/13/2012Timothy Currens Newport Beach California 92663 United States 8/13/2012Barbara Gallian Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 8/13/2012kathy nomura fountain valley California 92708 United States 8/13/2012Daniella Kellogg Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 8/13/2012David  Sandow Santa Ana California 92701 United States 8/13/2012Rachel Page Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 8/13/2012Steve Page Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 8/13/2012S.W. Conser Portland Oregon 97215 United States 8/13/2012Ryder  Buck La Canada California 91011 United States 8/14/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 304: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Jacob Gonzales Hollywood California 90028 United States 8/14/2012Dylan Brown Valencia California 91354 United States 8/14/2012Johnny Banchero Manhattan Beach California 90266 United States 8/14/2012Camina Tripodi Arroyo Grande  California 93420 United States 8/14/2012Charles Churchill Trabuco Canyon California 92679 United States 8/14/2012Carol Powell Plano Texas 75093 United States 8/14/2012Paula Fancher Sausalito California 94965 United States 8/14/2012Ashley Tetlow Los Angeles California 90021 United States 8/14/2012Leah Mirabal La Habra California 90631 United States 8/16/2012raymond mirabal La Habra California 90631 United States 8/16/2012jon muller irvine California 92603 United States 8/16/2012Zena Polly Lake Forest California 92630 United States 8/17/2012Colleen Middlebrook Upland California 91784 United States 8/17/2012Liz Bell Santa Monica California 90404 United States 8/17/2012Carrie  Cervantez Rancho Cucamonga California 91730 United States 8/17/2012Steve Zeller Anaheim California 92804 United States 8/19/2012Mary Protzko La Crescenta California 91214 United States 8/20/2012Janice Stone Thomas Sacramento California 95819 United States 8/20/2012Sara Cipollone Corona California 92880 United States 8/20/2012stacey ahsmuhs Placentia California 92870 United States 8/21/2012Tammy Sadler Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 8/21/2012Richard Sadler Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 8/21/2012Shari Cardinez Yorba Linda California 92886 United States 8/21/2012Cari Pierce‐Wiggins Placentia California 92870 United States 8/21/2012jeff stevens Newport Beach California 92663 United States 8/21/2012cheryl chapman Santa Ana California 92705 United States 8/21/2012allison kearns costa mesa California 92627 United States 8/22/2012billy sun irvine California 92612 United States 8/22/2012Kathy Gilbert Newport Beach California 92663 United States 8/22/2012Kevin Kearns COSTA MESA California 92627 United States 8/22/2012Margaret Jorth Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 8/22/2012Melissa Davis Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 8/22/2012Gina Lesley Newport Beach California 92663 United States 8/22/2012JR Walz Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 8/22/2012Scott Hardesty Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 8/22/2012Catherine Anderson Newport Beach California 92660 United States 8/22/2012Angela Rivera Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 8/22/2012Michael Hardesty Newport Beach California 92663 United States 8/22/2012Michael Daily Newport Beach California 92663 United States 8/22/2012Gail Zook Newport Beach California 92663 United States 8/22/2012jed weinstein CDM New York 92625 United States 8/22/2012carolyn williams corona delar California 92625 United States 8/22/2012Jo Barrett Newport Beach California 92663 United States 8/22/2012Richard Deadmond Centralia Illinois 62801 United States 8/22/2012Carolyn Van Schoick Newport Beach California 92663 United States 8/22/2012Megan Rokos Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 8/22/2012cynthiaq barton balboa ISLAND California 92662 United States 8/22/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 305: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Madelynn Forgey Newport Beach California 92663 United States 8/22/2012David Cowlin Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 8/22/2012Janet Kennedy Midvale Utah 84047 United States 8/23/2012Warren Zook Newport Beach California 92663 United States 8/23/2012Lisa Petit Garden Grove California 92840 United States 8/23/2012GAYLE BAGGALEY POLLOCK PINES California 95726 United States 8/23/2012Justin Phelps Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 8/23/2012Alex Espinosa Sacramento California 95816 United States 8/23/2012Autumn Noesser Orange California 92869 United States 8/23/2012Paul Burt Santa Ana California 92705 United States 8/23/2012Mary Eileen Angier Othello Washington 99344 United States 8/23/2012Dennis Vivanco Anaheim California 92805 United States 8/23/2012Erin  O'Brien Santa Ana California 92706 United States 8/23/2012Monica Bloom Newport Beach California 92663 United States 8/23/2012Megan Moore Orange California 92869 United States 8/23/2012Jonell Diaz Orange California 92869 United States 8/23/2012Melanie Eddy Newport Beach California 92660 United States 8/23/2012Kevin Bolland Orange California 92869 United States 8/23/2012Jason Shahrikian Franklin Wisconsin 53132 United States 8/23/2012gil lukosky Newport Beach California 92663 United States 8/23/2012Valerie Lukosky Newport Beach California 92663 United States 8/23/2012Adam Hertzberg Orange California 92869 United States 8/23/2012Kelly New Fullerton California 92831 United States 8/23/2012Darren Rector Orange California 92867 United States 8/23/2012Michael LaBorde Belton Missouri 64012 United States 8/23/2012parker keil honolulu Hawaii 96816 United States 8/24/2012Dawn Goforth Hickory North Carolina 28601 United States 8/24/2012Brad New Placentia California 92871 United States 8/24/2012Robert Nelson Orange California 92867 United States 8/24/2012Timothy Kennedy Santa Ana California 92705 United States 8/24/2012Kathleen Rumph Newport Beach California 92663 United States 8/24/2012Kerry Mills yorba linda California 92886 United States 8/24/2012Joanie Cafferty Whittier California 90602 United States 8/24/2012Bill Dyment Irvine California 92602 United States 8/24/2012Steve Mitchem Yucca Valley California 92284 United States 8/24/2012Bruce Ytreeide Newport Beach California 92657 United States 8/24/2012SOFI OZDEN LAKE FOREST California 92630 United States 8/24/2012Sheri Van Dorn Orange California 92869 United States 8/24/2012Brett Del Valle Newport Beach California 92663 United States 8/24/2012Lance Tolsma Corona California 92881 United States 8/24/2012Nicole Foster Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 8/24/2012Vanessa Molletti Corona California 95033 United States 8/24/2012Bob clark laguna beach California 92651 United States 8/25/2012molly wiehardt newport beach California 92663 United States 8/25/2012Barbara Boatman Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 8/25/2012Diane Cowan Costa Mesa California 92626 United States 8/26/2012Masako Popick Costa Mesa California 92627 United States 8/26/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 306: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Kathy  Corona  corona California 92880 United States 8/27/2012Lynn Elliott Glendora California 91741 United States 8/27/2012James Lucas Corona California 92883 United States 8/28/2012Olivia apodaca Riverside California 92507 United States 8/28/2012Steve Prescott Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 8/28/2012Michelle  Lucas  Corona California 92883 United States 8/28/2012Tom Higgs Newport Beach California 92663 United States 8/28/2012Pamela  Brooks irvineMonroeIrvine California 92620 United States 8/29/2012Janet Carraman Santa Ana California 92707 United States 8/30/2012John Richard Young norristown Pennsylvania 19401‐1531 United States 8/30/2012Amy Prindle Grand Terrace California 92313 United States 8/31/2012Jennifer Bierich Laguna Hills California 92653 United States 9/1/2012Tamy Chapman Newport Beach California 92660‐0245 United States 9/1/2012Ryan Martin Riverside California 92504 United States 9/1/2012JENNIFER BORTMAN IRVINE California 92614 United States 9/2/2012Jay Sills Riverside California 92506 United States 9/2/2012Jill Morgan Laguna Beach California 92651 United States 9/2/2012Lola Brauning Tustin California 92780 United States 9/2/2012Paul Work Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 9/3/2012Sean Ortega Manhattan Beach California 90266 United States 9/3/2012DeAnn Work Corona Del Mar California 92625 United States 9/3/2012Richard Martinsen Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 9/3/2012Amanda Hernandez Corona California 92882 United States 9/3/2012raul roybal Orange California 92865 United States 9/4/2012Ruben Rincon Whittier California 90723 United States 9/4/2012Justin Pardee Riverside California 92506 United States 9/5/2012Matthew Takahashi Anaheim California 92804 United States 9/5/2012Crysany Bregman Riverside California 92504 United States 9/5/2012Sujan Ahmed Riverside California 92505 United States 9/5/2012Lorralie Bregman Riverside California 92504 United States 9/5/2012Dane  Perczak Riverside California 92507 United States 9/5/2012Jessica Kelley Mira Loma California 91752 United States 9/5/2012Patricia Badham Riverside California 92505 United States 9/5/2012Kendra Stewart Perris California 92571 United States 9/5/2012Julia Sudds Moreno Valley California 92557 United States 9/5/2012Amber Scott Riverside California 92505 United States 9/5/2012Hanna Bierich Mission Viejo California 92692 United States 9/5/2012Shannon Lowe Riverside California 92506 United States 9/5/2012frank bierich mission viejo California 92692 United States 9/5/2012Nikki Gregory Chino Hills California 91709 United States 9/8/2012Jeanette Bebeau Newport Beach California 92663 United States 9/10/2012Nedra Craig Irvine California 92604 United States 9/10/2012Mary Chaffin Marana Arizona 85653 United States 9/11/2012Holly Carr Irvine California 92612 United States 9/12/2012Ray Kudukis Fountain Valley California 92708 United States 9/13/2012Don Ambrose Estancia New Mexico 87016 United States 9/14/2012John Nickerson Corona del Mar California 92625 United States 9/15/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15

Page 307: California Coastal Commission: Newport Beach Fire Rings Report

Tien Tran Westminster California 92683 United States 9/15/2012Binh Tran Westminster California 92683 United States 9/15/2012Diane Nguyen Garden Grove California 92840 United States 9/15/2012anthony tran Westminster California 92683 United States 9/16/2012anthony tran santa ana California 92704 United States 9/16/2012Quynh Nguyen westminster California 92683 United States 9/16/2012Quynh Nguyen Hutington Beach California 92683 United States 9/16/2012JIMMY NGUYEN HUNTINGTON BEACH California 92647 United States 9/16/2012Christopher Le westminster California 92683 United States 9/16/2012Michelle Tran Westminster California 92683 United States 9/16/2012Tien Tran Westminster California 92683 United States 9/18/2012yvonne cathey Anaheim California 928‐4 United States 9/18/2012Mary Hulbert corona del mar California 92625 United States 9/19/2012Ken Hunrichs San Diego California 92114 United States 9/19/2012Christopher Davis Vista California 92081 United States 9/19/2012Jason Bennett Carlsbad California 92008 United States 9/19/2012Ryan  Sweeney San Diego California 92109 United States 9/19/2012ian Feliney NORTH WOODSTOCK New Hampshire03262‐0411 United States 9/19/2012Bryan Gener Poway California 92064 United States 9/19/2012Daniel Burke Dana Point California 92629 United States 9/19/2012David Pierce Santee California 92071 United States 9/19/2012Volker Hoehne San Diego  California 92122 United States 9/19/2012Scott Anderson San Diego California 92139 United States 9/19/2012James Seymour Mission Viejo California 92691 United States 9/19/2012Brandon Ward Huntington beach California 92646 United States 9/19/2012grant mueller san gabriel California 91776 United States 9/20/2012Marie Hunrichs San Diego California 92114‐1524 United States 9/20/2012Thomas Lynch San Diego California 92117 United States 9/20/2012corinne ponce mission viejo California 92691 United States 9/20/2012TJ  Parcells San Diego California 92103 United States 9/20/2012Jennifer McLellan Hacienda Heights California 91745 United States 9/22/2012Ryan Torres Orange California 92869 United States 9/23/2012Benjamin Deering Irvine California 92614 United States 9/28/2012

SIGNATURES TO PETITION CDP#5-12-134 EXHIBIT #15