15
City of Los Angeles DEPARTMENT OF BUILDING AND SAFETY 201 NORTH FIGUEROA STREET LOS ANGELES, CA 90012 BOARD OF BUILDING AND SAFETY COMMISSIONERS CALIFORNIA VAN AMBATIELOS PRESIDENT FRANK M. BUSH GENERAL MANAGER SUPERINTENDENT OF BUILDING E FELICIA BRANNON VICE PRESIDENT JOSELYN GEAGA-ROSENTHAL GEORGE HOVAGUIMIAN JAVIER NUNEZ ERIC GARCETTI MAYOR OSAMA YOUNAN, P E. EXECUTIVE OFFICER Council District: # 15 December 23, 2016 Honorable Council of the City of Los Angeles Room 395, City Hall JOB ADDRESS: 2424 SOUTH GAFFEY STREET, LOS ANGELES, CA ASSESSORS PARCEL NO. (APN): 7465-008-028 On February 22, 2011, pursuant to the authority granted by Section 91.103 of the Los Angeles Municipal Code, the Department of Building and Safety (the Department”) investigated and identified code violations at: 2424 South Gaffey Street, Los Angeles, California (the “Property”). A copy of the title report which includes a full legal description of the property is attached as Exhibit A. Following the Departments investigation an order or orders to comply were issued to the property owner and all interested parties. Pursuant to Section 98.0411(a) the order warned that a proposed noncompliance fee may be imposed for failure to comply with the order within 15 days after the compliance date specified in the order or unless an appeal or slight modification is filed within 15 days after the compliance date.The owners failed to comply within the time prescribed by ordinance. The Department imposed non-compliance fee as follows:. Description Amount $ Non-Compliance Code Enforcement fee Late Charge/Collection fee (250%) Accumulated Interest (1 %/month) Title Report fee 550.00 1,375.00 1.386.76 42,00 3.353.76 $ Grand Total Pursuant to the authority granted by Section 7.35.3 of the Los Angeles Administrative Code, it is proposed a lien for a total sum of $3,353.76 recorded against the property. It is requested that the Honorable City Council of the City of Los Angeles (the City Council”) designate the time and place protest can be heard concerning this matter, as set forth in Sections 7.35.3 and 7.35.5 of the Los Angeles Administrative Code. It is further requested that the City Council instruct the Department to deposit to Dept 08, Fund 48R, Balance Sheet Account 2200, any payment received against this hen in the amount of $3,353.76 on the referenced property. A copy of the title report which includes a full legal description of the property is attached as Exhibit A. A list of all the names and addresses of owners and all interested parties entitled to notice is included (Exhibit B). Also attached is a report which includes the current fair market value of the property including all encumbrances of record on the property as of the date of the report (Exhibit C). DEPARTMENT OF BUILDING AND SAFETY Steve Gmgele Chief,^Resource Management Bureau ATTEST: HOLLY WOLCOTT, CITY CLERK Lien confirmed by City Council on: BY: DEPUTY

C of L Angelesclkrep.lacity.org/onlinedocs/2017/17-0160-s107_rpt... · 2/1/2017  · 2424 s gaffey st 106 $289,000 1975 2 2 03/11/2004 1,216 11,667 0.0 comparables 1 2424 s gaffey

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: C of L Angelesclkrep.lacity.org/onlinedocs/2017/17-0160-s107_rpt... · 2/1/2017  · 2424 s gaffey st 106 $289,000 1975 2 2 03/11/2004 1,216 11,667 0.0 comparables 1 2424 s gaffey

City of Los AngelesDEPARTMENT OF

BUILDING AND SAFETY201 NORTH FIGUEROA STREET

LOS ANGELES, CA 90012

BOARD OFBUILDING AND SAFETY

COMMISSIONERSCALIFORNIA

VAN AMBATIELOSPRESIDENT

FRANK M. BUSHGENERAL MANAGER

SUPERINTENDENT OF BUILDINGE FELICIA BRANNON

VICE PRESIDENT

JOSELYN GEAGA-ROSENTHAL GEORGE HOVAGUIMIAN

JAVIER NUNEZ

ERIC GARCETTI MAYOR

OSAMA YOUNAN, P E.EXECUTIVE OFFICER

Council District: # 15December 23, 2016

Honorable Council of the City of Los Angeles Room 395, City Hall

JOB ADDRESS: 2424 SOUTH GAFFEY STREET, LOS ANGELES, CA ASSESSORS PARCEL NO. (APN): 7465-008-028

On February 22, 2011, pursuant to the authority granted by Section 91.103 of the Los Angeles Municipal Code, the Department of Building and Safety (the “Department”) investigated and identified code violations at: 2424 South Gaffey Street, Los Angeles, California (the “Property”). A copy of the title report which includes a full legal description of the property is attached as Exhibit A.

Following the Department’s investigation an order or orders to comply were issued to the property owner and all interested parties. Pursuant to Section 98.0411(a) the order warned that “a proposed noncompliance fee may be imposed for failure to comply with the order within 15 days after the compliance date specified in the order or unless an appeal or slight modification is filed within 15 days after the compliance date.” The owners failed to comply within the time prescribed by ordinance. The Department imposed non-compliance fee as follows:.

Description Amount

$Non-Compliance Code Enforcement fee Late Charge/Collection fee (250%) Accumulated Interest (1 %/month)Title Report fee

550.001,375.001.386.76

42,003.353.76$Grand Total

Pursuant to the authority granted by Section 7.35.3 of the Los Angeles Administrative Code, it is proposed a lien for a total sum of $3,353.76 recorded against the property. It is requested that the Honorable City Council of the City of Los Angeles (the “City Council”) designate the time and place protest can be heard concerning this matter, as set forth in Sections 7.35.3 and 7.35.5 of the Los Angeles Administrative Code.

It is further requested that the City Council instruct the Department to deposit to Dept 08, Fund 48R, Balance Sheet Account 2200, any payment received against this hen in the amount of $3,353.76 on the referenced property. A copy of the title report which includes a full legal description of the property is attached as Exhibit A. A list of all the names and addresses of owners and all interested parties entitled to notice is included (Exhibit B). Also attached is a report which includes the current fair market value of the property including all encumbrances of record on the property as of the date of the report (Exhibit C).

DEPARTMENT OF BUILDING AND SAFETY

Steve GmgeleChief,^Resource Management Bureau

ATTEST: HOLLY WOLCOTT, CITY CLERKLien confirmed by City Council on:

BY:DEPUTY

Page 2: C of L Angelesclkrep.lacity.org/onlinedocs/2017/17-0160-s107_rpt... · 2/1/2017  · 2424 s gaffey st 106 $289,000 1975 2 2 03/11/2004 1,216 11,667 0.0 comparables 1 2424 s gaffey

EXHIBIT A

In2-ResIntuitive Real Estate Solutions

5711 W. SLAUSONAVE., SUITE 170 CULVER CITY, CA 90230

Phone 310-649-2020 310-649-0030 Fax

Property Title ReportPrepared for: City of Los AngelesWork Order No. T13797

Dated as of: 10/26/2016

SCHEDULE A(Reported Property Information)

APNA: 7465-008-028

City: Los Angeles County: Los AngelesProperty Address: 2424 S GAFFEYST

VESTING IN FORMA TION Type of Document: GRANT DEED Grantee : A USTIN BIELA WSKI Grantor: A USTIN BIELA WSKI AND NAOMI JEWETT Deed Date: 08/11/2005 Instr No.: 05-2300039

MAILING ADDRESS: A USTIN BIELA WSKI 2424 S GAFFEY ST APT 106 SAN PEDRO CA 90731

Recorded: 09/23/2005

SCHEDULE BLEGAL DESCRIPTIONTract No: 32209 Abbreviated Description: CITY:REGION/CLUSTER: 14/14493 SUBD: VISTA PACIFICA TR#:32209 TRACT NO 32209 CONDOMINIUM UNIT 6 City/Muni/Twp: REGION/CLUSTER: 14/14493

MORTGAGES/LIENSType of Document: ASSIGNMENT OF DEED OF TRUST

Document#: 15-0844917Recording Date: 07/14/2015 Loan Amount: $392,000 Lender Name: HOMECOMINGS FINANCIAL LLC Borrowers Name: A USTIN BIELA WSKI

MAILING ADDRESS: 1NDECOMM GLOBAL SERVICES 1260 ENERGY LANE ST. PAUL, MN 55108

Page 3: C of L Angelesclkrep.lacity.org/onlinedocs/2017/17-0160-s107_rpt... · 2/1/2017  · 2424 s gaffey st 106 $289,000 1975 2 2 03/11/2004 1,216 11,667 0.0 comparables 1 2424 s gaffey

NEW CENTURY TITLE COMPANY

REQUESTED BY:(WCentury Title Company - Riverside TitleORDER NO.: 2359168 ESCROW NO.: 200S1225-CDB X,

AND WHEN RECORDED MAIL TO:Austin Bielawskl 2424 South Gaffey, #106 San Pedro, CA 90731 05 2300039

A.P.N. 7465-008-028' (SPACE ABOVE THIS LINE IS FOR RECORDER'S USE)

GRANT DEED

THE UNDERSIGNED GRANTOR(S) OECLARE(S) that documentary transfer tax b $.00 (County) $.00 (City) (X) computed on full value of property conveyed, or ( ) computed on full value less liens or encumbrances remaining at time of sale(X) City of San Pedro

( X ) This is a bonaflde gift and the grantor received nothing in return R & T §11911

FOR A VALUABLE CONSIDERATION, receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, Austin Bielawskl, a single man and Naomi Jewett, A Single Woman, As Joint Tenants

hereby GRANT(S) to Austin Bielawski, a single man

the following described real property in the City of San Pedro, County of Los Angeles, State of California:SEE EXHIBIT "A’ ATTACHED HERETO AND MADE A PART HEREOF

-This is a bonafide gift and the grantordeceived nothing in return. R&T 11911-

I

DATED: August 11, 2005

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

COUNTY OF Let,

*ltpUMhj<r before

liaawski6kci'\ltfiC4 ticjWOn me

s

Personalty appeared. fly*;*’'*___KL

______AUaMri-__75/ui;Stf~___________4aaa

Naoraf JewettPersonally known to me (or proved to me on, the basis of satisfactory evidence) to be the person(s) whose name(s) istgfejsubscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that he/sfie/they executed the same lnrfils/t>^raH&r authorized capaaty(les), and that by hfe/lyetatiiir) s^nature(s) on meinstrument the pereon(s) or the entity upon behalTof which the person(s) acted, executed the instrument ‘

a - ~ ~ ^SHAIMAKASIR

Commission # 1546406 I Notary PubBc • CcSfomta

San Bomartflno County My Comm , Expires Am 22.2C

WITNESS my hand and official seal.

LU/tAJLK-Signature

(TTio m for official notary seal)

Grant Deed 1258111-04 MAIL TAX STATEMENTS AS DIRECTED ABOVE

Page 4: C of L Angelesclkrep.lacity.org/onlinedocs/2017/17-0160-s107_rpt... · 2/1/2017  · 2424 s gaffey st 106 $289,000 1975 2 2 03/11/2004 1,216 11,667 0.0 comparables 1 2424 s gaffey

■ t

3GOVERNMENT CODE 27361.7

I CERTIFY UNDER PENALTY OF PERJURY THAT THE NOTARY SEAL ON THE DOCUMENT TO WHICH THIS STATEMENT IS ATTACHED READS AS FOLLOWS:

NAME’OF NOTARY:

IS'Us'l'OL,___________________

PLACE OF EXECUTION: *SaS\ A^UUZAJLla^

COMMISSION NO.:.

DATE COMMISSION EXPIRES:

MANUFACTURER/VENDOR NO.:,

DATE: ft CSSIGNATURE:

\

05 2300039

Page 5: C of L Angelesclkrep.lacity.org/onlinedocs/2017/17-0160-s107_rpt... · 2/1/2017  · 2424 s gaffey st 106 $289,000 1975 2 2 03/11/2004 1,216 11,667 0.0 comparables 1 2424 s gaffey

Recording Requested By and When Recorded Return To:Indecomm Global Services 1260 Energy Lane St. Paul, MN 55108

Assignment of Deed of TrustDated: July 9, 2015 Loan: 7473256949

Package: 79954446 Document: 5382286

For value received Ocwen Loan Servicing, LLC, 1661 Worthington Road, Suite 100, West Palm Beach, FL 33409, the undersigned hereby grants, assigns and transfers to Green Tree Servicing LLC, 7360 South Kyrene Rd, T314, Tempe, AZ 85283, all beneficial interest under a certain Deed of Trust dated March 27, 2007 executed by AUSTIN BIELAWSKI, A SINGLE MAN and recorded in Book XX on Page(s) XX as Document Number 20070844515 on April 9, 2007 in the office of the County Recorder of Los Angeles County, California.

i

Ocwen Loan Servicing, LLC .

Yu Yee Vang, ^Assistant Secretary

By:

)STATE OF Minnesota

COUNTY Hennepin )SS ‘U05382286*

This instrument was acknowledged before me on July 9, 2015, by Yu Yee Vang as Assistant Secretary of Ocwen Loan Servicing, LLC

Prepared By:Umavathy S 1260 Energy Lane ST Paul, MN 55108

Randy Kiko Chon, Notary Public My Commission expires: January 31, 2017

RANDY KIKO CHONNotary Public-Minnesota

Ty My Commission E*pinw Jan 31, 2pt719 S

Page 6: C of L Angelesclkrep.lacity.org/onlinedocs/2017/17-0160-s107_rpt... · 2/1/2017  · 2424 s gaffey st 106 $289,000 1975 2 2 03/11/2004 1,216 11,667 0.0 comparables 1 2424 s gaffey

EXHIBIT B

ASSIGNED INSPECTOR: SERGIO RODRIGUEZ JOB ADDRESS: 2424 SOUTH GAFFEY STREET, LOS ANGELES, CA ASSESSORS PARCEL NO. (APN): 7465-008-028

Date: December 23,2016

Last Full Title: 10/26/2016 Last Update to Title:

LIST OF OWNERS AND INTERESTED PARTIES

1). AUSTIN BIELAWSKI 2424 S GAFFEY ST APT 106 SAN PEDRO, CA 90731 CAPACITY: OWNER

2). INDECOMM GLOBAL SERVICES 1260 ENERGY LANE ST. PAUL, MN 55108 CAPACITY: INTERESTED PARTY

Page 7: C of L Angelesclkrep.lacity.org/onlinedocs/2017/17-0160-s107_rpt... · 2/1/2017  · 2424 s gaffey st 106 $289,000 1975 2 2 03/11/2004 1,216 11,667 0.0 comparables 1 2424 s gaffey

EXHIBIT CRealQuest.com ® - Report

Property Detail ReportFor Property Located At. __2424 S GAFFEY ST 106, SAN PEDRO, CA 90731-5881

^ CcsrslogicRealQuest Professional

Owner Information

Owner Name:Mailing Address:

; Vesting Codes:t Location Information

Legal Description:; County:

Census Tract / Block:T ownship-Range-Sect:Legal Book/Page:Legal Lot:Legal Block:Market Area:

; Neighbor Code:j Owner Transfer Information

Recording/Sale Date:Sale Price:Document #:

; Last Market Sale Information■ Recording/Sale Date:

Sale Price:Sale Type:Document #:Deed Type:Transfer Document#:New Construction:

■ Title Company:Lender:Seller Name:Prior Sale Information

: Prior Rec/Sale Date: i Prior Sale Price:

Prior Doc Number:Prior Deed Type:Property Characteristics

Gross Area:Living Area:Tot Adj Area:

. Above Grade:Total Rooms:Bedrooms:Bath(F/H):Year Built/Eff:Fireplace:# of Stories:Other Improvements:Site InformationZoning:Lot Area:Land Use:

| Site Influence: i Tax Information . Total Value:

Land Value:Improvement Value:Total Taxable Value:

BIELAWSKI AUSTIN ___ _ „„„„2424 S GAFFEY ST #106, SAN PEDRO CA 90731-5881 C024SMII

TRACT NO 32209 CONDOMINIUM UNIT 6 LOS ANGELES, CA 2972.01 /2

7465-008-028APN:Alternate APN: Subdivision:Map Reference: Tract#:School District: School District Name: Munic/Township:

32209 78-F5 /32209LOS ANGELES

848-841

181

GRANT DEED2300040

Deed Type:1st Mtg Document #:

09/23/2005 / 08/11/2005

2300039

$274,550 / CONV 4.00 / ADJ585359

1st Mtg Amount/Type: 1st Mtg Int. Rate/Type: 1st Mtg Document #: 2nd Mtg Amount/Type: 2nd Mtg Int. Rate/Type: Price Per SqFt: Multi/Split Sale:

03/11/2004 / 02/13/2004$289,000FULL585358GRANT DEED

//$237.66

FIRST AMERICAN TITLE BANK OF AMERICA MURCHISON JOHN R

Prior Lender:Prior 1st Mtg Amt/Type: Prior 1st Mtg Rate/Type:

01/30/2004 / 01/12/2004$275,000213111GRANT DEED

//

Construction: Heat Type: Exterior wall: Porch Type: Patio Type: Pool:Air Cond: Style:Quality:

ROLL COMPOSITION Condition:

PARKING AVAILParking Type: Garage Area: Garage Capacity. Parking Spaces: Basement Area: Finish Bsmnt Area: Basement Type: Roof Type: Foundation:Roof Material:

CENTRALSTUCCO1,216 2

24221 CONVENTIONAL1975/1975

SLAB/4.00SHED

CONDOMINIUM (010C)County Use: State Use: Water Type: Sewer Type:

0.27Acres:Lot Width/Depth: Res/Comm Units:

LARD1.511,667CONDOMINIUM

x19/1

$4,150.54Property Tax: Tax Area:Tax Exemption:

2016Assessed Year: Improved %: Tax Year:

$340,000$232,400$107,600$340,000

1432%2016

12/21/2016http://proclassic.realquest.eom/jsp/report.jsp?&client-&action-confirm&type getreport...

Page 8: C of L Angelesclkrep.lacity.org/onlinedocs/2017/17-0160-s107_rpt... · 2/1/2017  · 2424 s gaffey st 106 $289,000 1975 2 2 03/11/2004 1,216 11,667 0.0 comparables 1 2424 s gaffey

Page 1 of 1RealQuest.com ® - Report

^ CcreLogie

RealQuest ProfessionalComparable SummaryFor Property Located At

2424 S GAFFEY ST 106, SAN PEDRO, CA 90731-588111 Comparabie(s) found. (Click on the address to view more property information)

► Configure Display Fields► View Report ► Modify Comparable Search Criteria

Summary Statistics For Selected Properties: 11

________Subject Property$289,000

1,216 $237.66

Low High$448,000

1,382$390.77

Average$379,409

1,208$317.03

$150,0001,035

$115.47

Sale Price Bldg/Living Area Price/Sqft Year Built Lot Area BedroomsBathrooms/RestroomsStoriesTotal ValueDistance From Subject

1975 1969 1991 198211,667 4,501 58,373 14,510

2 2 3 22 2 3 2

4.00 1.00 2.504.00$340,000 $56,082 $289,975$416,092

0.00 0.17 0.45 0.32

*= user supplied for search only

0 # F Address Sale Price Yr Bit Bed Baths/Restrooms(Full) Last Recording Bld/Liv Lot Area Dist

Subject Property2424 S GAFFEY ST 106 $289,000 1975 2 2 03/11/2004 1,216 11,667 0.0

Comparables1 2424 S GAFFEY ST 101 $375,000 1973 05/12/2016 1,382 11,667 0.0

08/17/2016 1,239 4,501 0.17

3 202 2339 S CABRILLO AVE A $448,000 1981

2702 S PECK AVE 7 $447,000 1969

2 2

0 3[7j 4 2030 S CABRILLO AVE 104 $352,500 1974

2 2 05/24/2016 1,235 10,754 0.17

06/14/2016 1,035 14,427 0.27

08/03/2016 1,253 10,011 0.3

11/29/2016 1,140 5,001 0.33

08/29/2016 1,150 5,001 0.33

2 2

$447,000 1973 2

$375,000 1991 2

$375,000 1991 2

$399,000 1987 2

$390,000 1987 2

$150,000 1990 2

$415,000 1990 2

2910 S PECK AVE 20 5 2

934 W26TH ST 26 3

0 7 934W26TH ST 1 3

760 W30TH ST 138 3 07/12/2016 1,195 12,793 0.3900 9 760 W 30TH ST 5 3 11/08/2016 1,300 12,793 0.39

07/15/2016 1,299 58,373 0.422222 S MESA ST 1610 2

3130 S PECK AVE 111 2 03/22/2016 1,062 14,287 0 450

http://proclassic.realquest.com/j sp/report.jsp?&client=&action=confirm&type=getreport... 12/21/2016

Page 9: C of L Angelesclkrep.lacity.org/onlinedocs/2017/17-0160-s107_rpt... · 2/1/2017  · 2424 s gaffey st 106 $289,000 1975 2 2 03/11/2004 1,216 11,667 0.0 comparables 1 2424 s gaffey

Page 1 of 4RealQuest.com ® - Report

^ CoreLogic

R e a IQ u e s t Prof e s s i o n a IComparable Sales ReportFor Property Located At

2424 S GAFFEY ST 106, SAN PEDRO, CA 90731-5881

11 Comparable(s) Selected.

Summary Statistics:Report Date: 12/21/2016

High AverageSubject Low

$150,000 $448,000 $379,409$289,000Sale Price

1,382 1,2081,216 1,035Bldg/Living Area

$390.77 $317.03$237.66 $115.47Price/Sqft

1991 19821975 1969Year Built

58,37311,667 4,501 14,510Lot Area

2 3 22Bedrooms

2 2 3 2Bathrooms/Restrooms

4.00 1.00 4.00 2.50Stories

$416,092 $289,975$340,000 $56,082Total Value

Distance From Subject 0.00 0.17 0.45 0.32

*= user supplied for search only

http://proclassic.realquest.com/jsp/report.jsp?type=getreport&client=&action=confirm&r... 12/21/2016

Page 10: C of L Angelesclkrep.lacity.org/onlinedocs/2017/17-0160-s107_rpt... · 2/1/2017  · 2424 s gaffey st 106 $289,000 1975 2 2 03/11/2004 1,216 11,667 0.0 comparables 1 2424 s gaffey

Page 2 of 4RealQuest.com ® - Report

Distance From Subject:0.0 (miles)Comp #:1 Address: Owner Name:

i Seller Name: APN:County: Subdivision: Rec Date: Sale Date: Sale Price: Sale Type: Document #: 1st Mtg Amt:

Total Value:

Land Use:

2424 S GAFFEY ST 101, SAN PEDRO, CA 90731-5880 MEACHAM JONATHAN/BRITTON CANDICE ARAGON LEONARD A 7465-008-023 LOS ANGELES, CA 32209 05/12/2016 04/12/2016 $375,000 FULL 546172 $345,000

$180,458

CONDOMINIUM

Map Reference: Census Tract: Zoning:Prior Rec Date: Prior Sale Date: Prior Sale Price: Prior Sale Type: Acres:Lot Area:

# of Stories:

Park Area/Cap#:

Living Area: Total Rooms: Bedrooms: Bath(F/H):Yr Built/Eff: Air Cond: Style: Fireplace: Pool:

Roof Mat:

Parking:

1,38278-F5 /2972.01LARD1.507/13/199906/26/1999$139,000FULL

532/1973/1973

CONVENTIONAL/0.27

11,667ROLLCOMPOSITION PARKING AVAIL

4.00

12

Distance From Subject:0.17 (miles)Comp #:2 Address: Owner Name: Seller Name: APN:County: Subdivision: Rec Date: Sale Date: Sale Price: Sale Type: Document #: 1st Mtg Amt: Total Value: Land Use:

2339 S CABRILLO AVE A, SAN PEDRO, CA 90731-5815 HEMPHILL WAYNE O MINTLINE INC 7463-006-034 LOS ANGELES, CA PECKS GRAND VIEW TR 08/17/2016 08/12/2016 $448,000 FULL 972806 $439,885 $250,000 CONDOMINIUM

Map Reference: Census Tract: Zoning:Prior Rec Date: Prior Sale Date: Prior Sale Price: Prior Sale Type: Acres:Lot Area:# of Stories:Park Area/Cap#:

78-F5 /2972.02LARD208/07/201508/04/2015$250,000FULL

Living Area: Total Rooms: Bedrooms: Bath(F/H):Yr Built/Eff; Air Cond: Style: Fireplace: Pool:Roof Mat; Parking:

1,239522/1981/1981

CONTEMPORARYY/10.10

4,5011.00 TILE

BASEMENT/

Distance From Subject:0.17 (miles)Comp #:3 Address: Owner Name: Seller Name: APN:County: Subdivision: Rec Date; Sale Date: Sale Price: Sale Type: Document #: 1st Mtg Amt: Total Value: Land Use:

2702 S PECK AVE 7, SAN PEDRO, CA 90731-6540 PIAZZA MARIE F CLEARY PAULINE A TRUST 7465-016-037 LOS ANGELES, CA 32340 05/24/2016 05/02/2016 $447,000 FULL 589333 $125,000 $416,092 CONDOMINIUM

Map Reference: Census Tract: Zoning:Prior Rec Date: Prior Sale Date: Prior Sale Price: Prior Sale Type: Acres:Lot Area:# of Stories:Park Area/Cap#:

78-F5 / 2976.02 LARD2 12/11/2012 10/16/2012 $400,000 FULL

Living Area: Total Rooms; Bedrooms: Bath(F/H):Yr Built/Eff: Air Cond: Style: Fireplace: Pool:Roof Mat: Parking:

1,235

22/1969/1969

0.25 /10,754

/

Comp #:4 Address: Owner Name: Seller Name: APN:County: Subdivision: Rec Date: Sale Date: Sale Price: Sale Type: Document #: 1st Mtg Amt: Total Value: Land Use:

Distance From Subject:0.27 (miles)2030 S CABRILLO AVE 104, SAN PEDRO, CA 90731-5364 FIAMENGO VINKA V MICIANO-JOHNSON ELIZABETH 7462-021-034 LOS ANGELES, CA 32342 06/14/2016 05/19/2016 $352,500 FULL 684882 $282,000 $336,546 CONDOMINIUM

Map Reference: Census Tract: Zoning:Prior Rec Date: Prior Sale Date: Prior Sale Price: Prior Sale Type: Acres:Lot Area:# of Stories:Park Area/Cap#:

78-F4 /2972.01LARD1.504/09/201403/18/2014$325,000FULL

Living Area: Total Rooms: Bedrooms: Bath(F/H):Yr BuilVEff: Air Cond: Style: Fireplace: Pool:Roof Mat: Parking:

1,035

22/1974/ 1975

0.33 /14,427

/

http://proclassic.realquest.com/jsp/report.j sp?type=getreport&client:=&action=confirm&r... 12/21/2016

Page 11: C of L Angelesclkrep.lacity.org/onlinedocs/2017/17-0160-s107_rpt... · 2/1/2017  · 2424 s gaffey st 106 $289,000 1975 2 2 03/11/2004 1,216 11,667 0.0 comparables 1 2424 s gaffey

Page 3 of 4RealQuest.com ® - Report

Distance From Subject:Q.3 (miles)Comp #:5 Address: Owner Name: Seller Name: APN:County: Subdivision: Rec Date: Sale Date: Sale Price: Sale Type: Document #: 1st Mtg Amt: Total Value: Land Use:

2910 S PECK AVE 2, SAN PEDRO, CA 90731-6683 CROFT CYNTHIA HICKERSON T LIVING TRUST 7465-018-034 LOS ANGELES, CA 32309 08/03/2016 07/05/2016 $447,000 FULL 915924 $348,000 $56,082CONDOMINIUM

Map Reference: Census Tract: Zoning:Prior Rec Date: Prior Sale Date: Prior Sale Price: Prior Sale Type: Acres:Lot Area:# of Stories:Park Area/Cap#:

78-F5 /2976.02LARD201/14/199809/05/1997$154,540FULL

Living Area: Total Rooms: Bedrooms: Bath(F/H):Yr Built/Eff: Air Cond: Style: Fireplace: Pool;Roof Mat: Parking:

1,253

22/1973/1973

0.23 /

10,011

/

Distance From Subject:0.33 (miles)Comp #:6 Address: Owner Name: Seller Name: APN:County: Subdivision: Rec Date: Sale Date: Sale Price: Sale Type: Document #: 1st Mtg Amt: Total Value: Land Use:

934 W 26TH ST 2, SAN PEDRO, CA 90731-5704 NINO JULIO C & MARITZA L CALLAGHAN STEPHEN J 7463-014-049 LOS ANGELES, CA PECKS GRAND VIEW 11/29/2016 11/07/2016 $375,000 FULL 1494165 $363,750 $349,492 CONDOMINIUM

Living Area: Total Rooms; Bedrooms: Bath(F/H):Yr Built/Eff: Air Cond: Style: Fireplace; Pool:Roof Mat: Parking:

1,140Map Reference: Census Tract: Zoning:Prior Rec Date: Prior Sale Date: Prior Sale Price: Prior Sale Type: Acres:Lot Area:# of Stories:Park Area/Cap#:

78-F5/2975.00LARD209/12/201308/08/2013$337,000FULL

23/1991/1991

0.11 /5,001

/

Comp #:7 Address: Owner Name: Seller Name: APN:County: Subdivision: Rec Date: Sale Date: Sale Price: Sale Type: Document #: 1st Mtg Amt: Total Value: Land Use:

Distance From Subject:0.33 (miles)934 W 26TH ST 1, SAN PEDRO, CA 90731-5704 SANTOS OSCAR E & HOLLY H PAPPAS MARK A 7463-014-048 LOS ANGELES, CA PECKS GRAND VIEW TR 08/29/2016 08/03/2016 $375,000 FULL 1031570 $356,250 $350,000 CONDOMINIUM

Map Reference: Census Tract: Zoning:Prior Rec Date: Prior Sale Date: Prior Sale Price: Prior Sale Type: Acres:Lot Area:# of Stories:Park Area/Cap#:

78-F5 /2975.00LARD209/23/200508/08/2005$445,000FULL

Living Area: Total Rooms: Bedrooms: Bath(F/H):Yr Built/Eff: Air Cond:

1,150

23/1991 /1991

Style:Fireplace:0.11 /

5,001 Pool:Roof Mat: Parking:/

Comp #:8 Address: Owner Name; Seller Name: APN:County: Subdivision: Rec Date: Sale Date: Sale Price: Sale Type: Document #: 1st Mtg Amt: Total Value: Land Use:

Distance From Subject:0.39 (miles)760 W 30TH ST 13, SAN PEDRO, CA 90731-6691 MISTRY RAJAN C & CHANDRAKANT K GILBERT HELEN T TRUST 7469-007-061 LOS ANGELES, CA 43417 07/12/2016 06/22/2016 $399,000 FULL 811723 $319,200 $390,000 CONDOMINIUM

Map Reference: Census Tract: Zoning:Prior Rec Date: Prior Sale Date: Prior Sale Price: Prior Sale Type: Acres:Lot Area:# of Stories:Park Area/Cap#:

78-F5 /2975.00LARD203/31/201010/20/2009$400,000FULL

Living Area: Total Rooms: Bedrooms: Bath(F/H):Yr Built/Eff: Air Cond: Style: Fireplace: Pool:Roof Mat: Parking:

1,195

23/1987/1987

0.29 /12,793

I

http://proclassic.realquest.com/jsp/report.jsp?type=getreport&client=&action=confirm&r... 12/21/2016

Page 12: C of L Angelesclkrep.lacity.org/onlinedocs/2017/17-0160-s107_rpt... · 2/1/2017  · 2424 s gaffey st 106 $289,000 1975 2 2 03/11/2004 1,216 11,667 0.0 comparables 1 2424 s gaffey

RealQuest.com ® - Report Page 4 of 4

Comp #:9 Address: Owner Name: Seller Name: APN:County: Subdivision: Rec Date: Sale Date: Sale Price: Sale Type: Document #: 1st Mtg Amt: Total Value: Land Use:

Distance From Subject:0.39 (miles)760 W 30TH ST 5, SAN PEDRO, CA 90731-6692 GRAEFFORREST & ANH CONSTABLE TREVOR J & G TRUST 7469-007-053 LOS ANGELES, CA 43417 11/08/2016 10/07/2016 $390,000 FULL 1395509 $370,500 $288,931 CONDOMINIUM

Map Reference: Census Tract: Zoning:Prior Rec Date: Prior Sale Date: Prior Sale Price: Prior Sale Type: Acres:Lot Area:# of Stories:Park Area/Cap#:

78-F5 /2975.00LARD203/02/200102/09/2001$227,000FULL

Living Area: Total Rooms: Bedrooms: Bath(F/H):Yr Built/Eff: Air Cond: Style: Fireplace: Pool:Roof Mat: Parking:

1,300

23/1987/1987

0.29 /12,793

/

Comp #:1Q Address: Owner Name: Seller Name: APN:County: Subdivision: Rec Date: Sale Date: Sale Price: Sale Type: Document #: 1st Mtg Amt: Total Value: Land Use:

Distance From Subject:0.42 (miles)2222 S MESA ST 16, SAN PEDRO, CA 90731-5993 SOCIAL V HOMES INC KLOTZKIN KENNETH C 7465-004-041 LOS ANGELES, CA 46548 07/15/201$07/08/2016 $150,000 FULL 831868

Map Reference: Census Tract: Zoning:Prior Rec Date: Prior Sale Date: Prior Sale Price: Prior Sale Type: Acres:Lot Area:# of Stories: Park Area/Cap#:

Living Area: Total Rooms: Bedrooms: Bath(F/H):Yr Built/Eff: Air Cond: Style: Fireplace: Pool:Roof Mat: Parking:

79-A5 / 2971.20 LARD 09/14/2000

1,299

2211990/1990

$70,000

1.34 /58,373

$239,253CONDOMINIUM /

Comp#:11 Address: Owner Name: Seller Name: APN:County: Subdivision: Rec Date: Sale Date: Sale Price: Sale Type: Document #: 1st Mtg Amt: Total Value: Land Use:

Distance From Subject:0.45 (miles)3130 S PECK AVE 1, SAN PEDRO, CA 90731-6791 TATE JEFFREY L LACROSS LARRY 7465-029-030 LOS ANGELES, CA 44886 03/22/2016 02/19/2016 $415,000 FULL 308638 $394,250 $332,873 CONDOMINIUM

Map Reference: Census Tract: Zoning:Prior Rec Date: Prior Sale Date: Prior Sale Price: Prior Sale Type: Acres:Lot Area:# of Stories:Park Area/Cap#:

78-F6 /2976.02LARD210/30/201207/09/2012$320,000FULL

Living Area: Total Rooms: Bedrooms: Bath(F/H):Yr Built/Eff: Air Cond: Style: Fireplace: Pool:Roof Mat; Parking:

1,062

2211990/1990

0.33 /14,287

/

http ://proclassic.realquest.com/j sp/report.j sp?type=getreport&client=&action=confirm&r... 12/21/2016

Page 13: C of L Angelesclkrep.lacity.org/onlinedocs/2017/17-0160-s107_rpt... · 2/1/2017  · 2424 s gaffey st 106 $289,000 1975 2 2 03/11/2004 1,216 11,667 0.0 comparables 1 2424 s gaffey

EXHIBIT D

ASSIGNED INSPECTOR: SERGIO RODRIGUEZ JOB ADDRESS: 2424 SOUTH GAFFEY STREET, LOS ANGELES, CA ASSESSORS PARCEL NO. (APN): 7465-008-028

Date: December 23, 2016

CASE#: 403980 ORDER NO: A-2692104

EFFECTIVE DATE OF ORDER TO COMPLY: January 28,2011 COMPLIANCE EXPECTED DATE: February 22,2011 DATE COMPLIANCE OBTAINED: September 07, 2012

LIST OF IDENTIFIED CODE VIOLATIONS(ORDER TO COMPLY)

VIOLATIONS:

SEE ATTACHED ORDER # A-2692104

Page 14: C of L Angelesclkrep.lacity.org/onlinedocs/2017/17-0160-s107_rpt... · 2/1/2017  · 2424 s gaffey st 106 $289,000 1975 2 2 03/11/2004 1,216 11,667 0.0 comparables 1 2424 s gaffey

M

City of Los AngelesQ BOARD OF

BUILDING AND SAFETY COMMISSIONERS

l"1 DEPARTMENT OF

BUILDING AND SAFETY201 NORTH FIGUEROA STREET

LOS ANGELES, CA 90012

CALIFORNIA0N MARSHA L. BROWN

PRESIDENT

VAN AMBATIELOS VICE-PRESIDENT

VICTOR H. CUEVAS HELENA JUBANY

ELENOREA. WILLIAMS

I'm0 ROBERT R. "Bud" OVROM

GENERAL MANAGER

RAYMOND S. CHAN, C.E., S.E.EXECUTIVE OFFICER

a{i.j

ANTONIO R. VILLARAIGOSA MAYOR

H

w

ORDER TO COMPLYcn

in

AUSTIN BIELAWSKI2424 SO. GAFFEY STREET UNIT 106SAN PEDRO, CALIFORNIA 90731

CASE #: 403980 ORDER #: A-2692104

EFFECTIVE DATE: January 28,2011 COMPLIANCE DATE: February 22,2011

OWNER OF

SITE ADDRESS:ASSESSORS PARCEL NO.: 7465-008-^

ZONE: RD1.5; Min. Per Unit 1,500

2424 S GAFFEY STmmm0]

An inspection has revealed that the property (Site Address) listed above is in violation of the Los Angeles Municipal Code (L.A.M.C.) as follows:

VIOLATION(S):

1. The guard rail or portion thereof is in need of general maintenance and repair.

You are therefore ordered to: 1) Repair, replace and or maintain the guard rail.2) Continue to maintain in good repair.

Code Section(s) in Violation: 91.8104,91.103.1, 12.21A.l.(a) of the L.A.M.C.

Location: Deck at rear of dwelling leading to alley.

NON-COMPLIANCE FEE WARNING:

YOU ARE IN VIOLATION OF THE L.A.M.C. IT IS YOUR RESPONSIBILITY TO CORRECT THE VIOLATION^) AND CONTACT THE INSPECTOR LISTED BELOW TO ARRANGE FOR A COMPLIANCE INSPECTION BEFORE THE NON-COMPLIANCE FEE IS IMPOSED. Failure to correct the violations and arrange for the compliance inspection within 15 day from the Compliance Date, will result in imposition of the fee noted below.

A proposed r.oncompliance fee in the amount of$550.00 may be imposed for failure to comply with the order within 15 days after the compliance date specified in the order or unless an appeal or request for slight modification is filed within 15 days of the compliance date.If an appeal or request for slight modification is not filed within 15 days of the compliance date or extensions granted therefrom, the

determination of the department to impose and collect a non-compliance fee shall be final. Section 98.0411 L. A.M.C.

NOTE: FAILURE TO PAY THE NON-COMPLIANCE FEE WITHIN 30 DAYS AFTER THE DATE OF MAILING THE INVOICE,MAY RESULT IN A LATE CHARGE OF TWO (2) TIMES THE NON-COMPLIANCE FEE PLUS A 50 PERCENT COLLECTION FEE FOR A TOTAL OF $1,925.00.Any person who fails to pay the non-compliance fee, late charge and collection fee shall also pay interest. Interest shall be calculated at the rate of one percent per month.

PENALTY WARNING:

Any person who violates or causes or permits another person to violate any provision of the Los Angeles Municipal Code (L.A.M.C.) is guilty of a misdemeanor which is punishable by a fine of not more than $1000.00 and/or six (6) months imprisonment for each violation. Section 11.00 (m) L.A.M.C.

CODE ENFORCEMENT BUREAU For routine City business and non-emergency services: Call 3-1-1

www.ladbs.orgSLA (6) DBS

Page I of2DEPARTMENT OF BULUMMC AND SAFETY

Page 15: C of L Angelesclkrep.lacity.org/onlinedocs/2017/17-0160-s107_rpt... · 2/1/2017  · 2424 s gaffey st 106 $289,000 1975 2 2 03/11/2004 1,216 11,667 0.0 comparables 1 2424 s gaffey

APPEAL PROCEDURES:There is an appeal procedure established in this city whereby the Department of Building and Safety and the Board of Building and Safety Commissioners have the authority to hear and determine err or abuse of discretion, or requests for slight modification of the requirements contained in this order when appropriate fees have been paid. Section 98.0403.1 and 98.0403.2 L.A.M.C.

If you have any questions or require any additional information please feel free to contact me at (310)732-4532. Office hours are 7:00 a.m. to 3:30 p.m. Monday through Thursday.

Date:Inspector: January 20.2011

BOB DUNN638 S. BEACON ST., ROOM 276 SAN PEDRO, CA 90731 (310)732-4532

01/

’1EWED BY

CODE ENFORCEMENT BUREAU For routine City business and non-emergency services: Call 3-1-1

www.ladbs.orgDBSELA TllllIlM1.*in n'.mm Page 2 of2

DEPARTMENT OF BUILDING AND SAFETY