44

c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

�������������� ������ �������������� ��� ����� �!�"�$#%������� !�

&!')(�*!+-,.,.+-,0/ 1!2"3547683:9"35;&�<.=-<.4?>�@BADCFEHG-GIA

J K�LNMO.PRQTSTU%M.V?PWL

X)Y[Z�\^]^_5`ba�c?dBegfih�jlkWmon^p�fqcrYHfis:c?t5crY5u�v:wHcrwyxzp{n|x}n�~���fyu{n�k�n5fB�?���z�gc^���qc�Y�f� wle�u{��~�u�e����ze�k7c��^��~�5t�mojzY���u�e�n|Y�~nrm���n^jzYHfB��f�d|crp{egcru�e�n^Y��.h�n^p{��xzp�����e�~��?��t�`re�Y�u{wz��e�pk�n5fB�?�)`DcrY�e�k$cr�^���qe�~�cT~�jzk��R�y�����?u � �?�?Y�cT~��:�?u���w���c�Y�f�cT~�����n|Y�f�u{�?p�k� � wze���wTu�c��:��~��?c�p{��n�m�u{wl��u{�?�5u{jzp���f���n^k�x�n^Yl�?YBu�~�crYHf n�m�~�n|k���c|fzfBe�u{e�d:��Yzn^eg~��:�¡�wl�Tn^�5¢{����u�~ � wze���w£c�p{�¤��n^Y5u�c�e�Yz��fqe�Yy�0�}����n^Yl�¥u�n�u{wz��~��:�?u���w£�"¦�¡�wz�§~��Tn^�5¨¢{�§��u�~�c�p{��c|~{~�jzk���f�u{n��}�©fB�?��e�k�e�u{��fª�5t!��n^Y5u{n|jzp�~ � e�u�wR«�Yze�u{�b����Yz�^u�w�~c�Y�f���eg~c�|�?n^k��?u{p�e��¬¨­u�tBx���e�k7cr�|�:�NX)u®eg~�u{wz�?Y�Y�c�u{jzp�cr��u�n!c^~{~�jzk��Nu{w�c�u��¯eg~bc$mojzY���u{e�n|Y¯n�m��n|jzY�fB��fbd|crp{egcru�e�n^Y��¡�wzeg~"c^~{~�jzk�xzu�e�n|Y � e����|wzn � �?d:�?pI����°:jz��~�u{e�n^Yz��f�e�Y®u�wze�~-xHcrx��?p?�X)Y�Z?\|\^±5`²v:u�crYz���?tT³�~�wz�?p�`�´��?n^Yle�f�µ¶j�f5e�Y"`IcrY�f�·k7c^f!¸�cru{��k�e~�e�k�xl��e¹«H��fWu{wl�

h�jlkWmon^p�f�º»v:wHcrw7k�n5fB�?�­�¡�wz��e�p�k�n5fB�?� � e����I�}�bY�c�k���fWu�wz��³�µ�¸¼k�n5fB�?�)�D½�n^u�wk�n5fB�?��~bc�p{�N��°¾jle�xzx���f � e�u�w�crY�c����|n^p{e�u{wzk � wzeg�¬w�tBe��?��fl~u{wz�!¿Àp{e��^w5u�fB����n|k�x�n:~�eÁ¨u�e�n|Y"Â�iÃÅÄ�R�ÆÄ��n�mbc��|e�d:�?Y�e�k$cr�^����¡�wzeg~ª¿Çp{e��|wBu©fB����n|k�x�n:~�e�u{e�n^Y"Â"k�e�Yze�kNe�È���~�c���?p{u�cre�Y¤�?Yz�?p��^t:��½�n^u�w�k�n5fB�?�g~®c�p{�7�^e�dBe�Yz�T~�n^k��$c^�?���§~{~®u�n¯u�wz��k��§crYze�Yz�7nrmÉcrYe�k7cr�|�:`5~�e�Y����bu{wz��t7crp���c�e�k��§f�cru�fB��u{����u�e�Yz��u�wz�bn^�5¢{����u�~���n^Y5u�cre�Yz��f�e�Y7e�u?�

X)Y�u�wz��~��®Yln^u{�§~ � � � e����"k�n:~�u{��tWmon5��j�~�n^YTu�wz�W³�µ�¸¼k�n5fB�?�)�FÊ�?p{��e�~�n^jzp«Hp�~�up���~�jl��u?Ë.´��?u�j�~�c|~{~�jlk���u{wHcru � �Éc�xzp{e�n^p{eI�BYln � u�wz�bn^�5¢{����u�~ � wle���w7crp��b��n^Y5u�c�e�Yz�§fe�Y7crY7e�k7cr�|�b�TcrY�f�u�w�cru�u�wz��³�µ¸¤cr���|n^p�e�u{wlkÌe�~%crxzxz��e���fNu{nN�-¦lXÍu � e����-���bxzp{n�d:��fu�w�cruF~�n|k��xle������§~Î���?��n^Yz�|e�Yz��u{n�u�wz��Ïoxzw5tz~�e��?c��ÑÐ�n^�5¢{����u�~�c�p{�bc�� � c§tl~e�Y���n^p{x�n|p�cru���fe�YBu�n7u{wz��Ä�T��n^k�x�n^Yl�?YBub�5tTu{wz�$cr���|n^p�e�u{wlk Ï­~��?��¡�wz�?n|p{�?kÅÒ����?��n � Ð��7¡�wz�?p���mon^p��v�u�crYl���?t�³�~�wz�?p?`-´�jlk�e�Yze�u�cbÓ²�§~��:`lcrY�f7u{wz�©~�����n|Y�f7crjzu�wzn^p�w�c?d:�����?�?Y���n:n^�5e�Yz��mon^pn|u{wz��p�k�n5fB�?�g~���³�Yz��n�m�u�wz��~���k�n5fB�?�g~¶eg~�crY�c���t5È?��f�e�YTu{wz��~���Yzn^u���~�c�Y�f-`"e�Y�~�n^k��

Z

Page 2: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

��c^~��§~�`Bx��?p�mon^p�k7~kWj���w����?u�u{�?p%u{w�c�Y�u{wl��³�µ¸Tk�n5fB�?�­`:c^~�xlp{n�d:��f�e�Y�¡�wz�?n^p��?k Z^Z^�¡�wz�§~���Yln^u{�§~�c�p{��n|p{��crYze�È?��f�c|~�mon|����n � ~��²v:�§��u{e�n^Y�~"±5`:Òc�Y�f � ��n|YBu�cre�Y�e�Y5u{p�n5fBj��¬¨u�n^p�tRp��?k7c�p{�l~²n^Y!e�k7c��^�bxzp�n5����~{~�e�Yz�l`}Yl�?jzp{n|xzw5tz~�e�n^��n^�|t:`�crY�f�k�n5fB�?��e�Yz�z��v�����u{e�n^Y�~

_7u{n��!crp{�$fB�?d:n^u���fTu{n�u�wz�7~�u�crYHfzcrp�f ³�µ�¸ k�n5fB�?�)���8«�p�~�u�c���u��?p{Y�c�u{e�d:�Wu�n�u{wl�³�µ�¸ k�n5fB�?�eg~�~�u�j�fBe���f e�Y¥v�����u{e�n^Y¤]BË�¡�wl������Yzn|p{kÅe�~�p{�?xl��c^����f �5t�c�½��§~�n�dYln^p{k e�Y!u{wzeg~¶Yz� � k�n5fB�?� � wzeg�¬w fBn:��~Yzn|ub��w�crYz�|��u{wz��Yzn^p�k n�m�e�Y�fBeg�?cru�n^p�mojzY��¬¨u�e�n|Y�~�nrm�p{����u{e¹«}cr�z����fBn|k7cre�Y�~�� ¡�wze�~�c���u{��p{Y�c�u{e�d:�Nk�n5fB���²����c^fl~�u{n�crY�c����^n|p{e�u{wzk� wle���wReg~�~�e�k�e��gcrp.u{n�an^Yln^wznlÂÀ~ � c§d:�����?u%~�wlp{e�Yl�^c��^�:�%X)YTv:����u�e�n^Y!\�u{n!Z^Zbu{wz��³�µ�¸k�n5fB�?�zeg~crxzxl��e��§f�u{n�cb���gc^~�~În�m"u��?�Bu�jzp{�§f�e�k7c��^��~c�Y�f�u{wz��fBp�c � ��c|�¬�l~nrm�u{wz��³�µ�¸k�n5fB�?�"c�p{��crYHcr��t5È?��fI��v:����u�e�n^Y�Z�±ªeg~�fB�?d:n^u���fWu�nWu�wz�bYz� � ³�~�wz�?p�¨)Ó.��~��®k�n5fB�?�)�

��� �TO�V�� ��O�� ��V��S����¥UFP�OM� ��

�[�z��c|�¬�!c�Y�f � wze�u���e�k7c��^��� eg~fB��«�Yz��f!c^~bcªmojzY���u{e�n|YT��Ï��-Ðà ��Ï�� �"!#�%$�Ð � wzeg�¬weg~®Y�c�k���f�u�wz���^p��?t:¨)���?d:�?�n�m&�(')�©¦+*���~��?u���Ï��-Ð�Ã-,ReÁm�u{wz�Nx�n^e�YBu.�¼eg~®�z�gc^���e�Y�u{wz���|e�d:�?Y¤e�k7c��^�7c�Y�fq��Ï��-Ð�ÃÅZReÁm&�¥eg~��zp{e��^w5u � wze�u{�:�¤¡�wz�?Y���Ï���Ð/'�01,2!?Z43c�Y�fqu{wl��d|cr��jz��n�m���Ï��-Ð�e�~�u{wz�!�^p{��t¾¨­���?d:����cru�u{wz�!x}n|e�Y5u5�"¦%¡�wz��xHcre�p!Ï��6!���Ï��-Ð{Ðeg~Y�c�k���fTc�xze��5�?�­�b¡�wz�W��n|jzY�fB��f�mojzY���u{e�n|Y���Ï���Ð�eg~Yzn^u���n|YBu�e�Y5jzn^jH~e�Y��^�?Yl�?p�c��)�s^jlk�x�fBeg~{��n|YBu�e�Y5jze�u�e���~"nrm���Ï��-ÐDcrp{��xl��c?tBe�Yz�bc�:��t�p{n|���%e�Y�e�k$cr�^�%xzp{n5����~{~�e�Yz�l��v:j���wf5e�~{��n^Y5u{e�Y5jze�u{e��§~�c�p{���^�?Yz��p�cru���fW�5t�u�wz��§fB�^��~.nrm�u{wz��n^�5¢{����u�~ � wze���wNcrp���xzp���~��?Y5ue�Yu�wz���|e�d:�?YNe�k7c��^�:�7��u.u{wzeg~²����d:�?�znrm�u�wz�bfBeg~{��jH~{~�e�n^Y�u�wz���|p{�?t:¨)���?d:�?���7e�~%c®��n^jzYHfB��fk���c^~�jzp�c��z���mojlY���u{e�n^Y"�¡�wzeg~�e�k�k���fBegcru{����tNp�creg~���~bcWmojzY�flcrk��?Y5u�c���eg~{~�jz�:`�~�e�Y�����e�u�e�~b�����§crp�u�w�crubk�n�~�u

��n|jzY�fB��f�k���c^~�jzp�c��z����mojlY���u{e�n^Y�~bfBn!Yzn^u���n|p{p���~�x�n^YHf¯u{n!Y�cru�jzp�c��²e�k7cr�|��~���v:e�k�e¹¨�gcrp���tNc®p�crY�f5n^k ~���°:jz�?Y����n�m����?u�u{�?p�~�e�~.Yzn^uFc®x�n:�?k�n^p�cbYzn�d:�?�)�8� YHcru{jlp�cr�Ie�k7c��^�wHc^~�cªk��§crYze�Yz��c�Y�fRk��§crYze�Yz�rmojz��e�k7cr�|��~�~�wzn^jz�gfR����c^fB�§°¾j�c�u{�?��t�k�n5fB������f-�

� «�p�~�u!crxzxzp�n:c|�¬w0u�n�k�n5fB�?��e�Yz��YHcru{jlp�cr��e�k7c��^��~���n^Y�~�e�~�u�~�e�Y ~�u�j�fBt5e�Yz��u{wl��gc � ~ � wze���wq�|n�d:�?p{Y�u{wz�?e�pWxlp{n5fBj���u{e�n|Y"�[¡�wz�!�^�?n|k��?u{p�e��?c���n^p��:crYle�È�c�u{e�n|Y£nrm�u{wl�~�jzp{p�n^jzYHfBe�Yz� � n^p���f�crY�fqu�wz���gc � ~Nnrmbn|xzu{eg�?~Wc�p{����n|Y����?p�Yz��f-� ½�jzuWn|Yz�T~�wzn^jl��fYln^u®mon|p{�|�?u�u�nRu�cr�:�Ne�Y¤c^�?��n^jzY5u�u�wz�Wxlp{n5����~�~�e�Yz�Tc|�¬wze��?d:��f��5tTu{wz�Nw5jzk7crYTd5e�~�e�n|Y~�tz~�u{�?k ��¡�wzeg~¶xlp{n5����~�~�e�Yz�7�?c�Y�����j�~���fTc^~�c�����jz��mon^p�k�n5fB�?��e�Yz��YHcru{jlp�cr��e�k$cr�^�§~��a�c§d5e�f7Êjl�}��� � p{e�u{��~�e�Y90 ÒBZ"3)Ë

:";=<?>A@B@DCFE?>FGHCAI�JK>F;ML�JBIKNPOQ>SR"IUT";WV�JXTHR�T?@&CF;ZY\[]CFGX^FCFG?T?I`_�JKabJK;A^SR"I�>F;%THc

±

Page 3: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

:5NQCFaST CAIXIUT ��� IUT Y I�> E��2JB@ Y�� � >F; I N T L�>FG�� >�� C � �>F;�����C�bCA@`JK;CF; CAI IUT ��� I I�> >FE4I�CFJK; C�Y T?I�CFJB@BT Y�� ;ZY T G#R"I�CF;ZYFJK;A^ >� IKN T � N�� RbJK>A@ >?^��>� >F;%T R � CA@B@ � CFG?I >�.I N T.<4T"G T E GHCA@7<?>FG?I T�����IKN T R"I�G"JKCAI T.<?>FG IUT�� c >FG IKN T� G4J � CFG���a J R�� CA@ <?>FG?I T������������ G � CFJK; T! &>FG?I NQCSR/E4T?T"; I�>�Y T?IUT"G � JK;%TNQ>FL IKN T a J R��2CA@ JK;"�b>FG � CAI�JK>F; <?> � JK;A^#�bGH> � I N T�T��FT/J R�NQCF;ZY @BT Y CF;QYI�G CF; R��b>FG � T Y�E���I N T E GHCFJK;$�����%� T#@B@1R JK; IKN T � G"J � CFG��5a J R��2CA@�<?>FG IUT�� c&I�>L NQJK< N�IKN T > � I�JK< ;%T G4aST � GH>��T <4IKR'&�L�JBI N�>F;%T JK; IUT"G � T YFJKCAI T ;(�2<4@BT��AR.JK;)�I T"G � >SR�T Y+*9CFG T��bCFG � >FG T�T�� CF<4I�JK;A^=JK; IKN T"JKG R"I�J � � @,�AR G T�-��2JKG T � T"; IKR��O N T <?> �.� >F;%THR"I I/� � T >� <4T?@ @1R10 G THR � >SR"I a J ^ >FGH>��AR"@,� ;Q>AI I�>5C�< JKG <��2�@ CFG R � >AIKc E��FI I�>�C�R?NQ>FG I�@ JK;%T R�T ^ � T";2I3��I�> C�YFCFG���@ JK; THc�C�E G"J ^SN2I @DJK;%THc>FG I�>�CF; T Y ^ T&E?>�� ;ZYFCFG�� E4T#I�L T?T ; YFCFG4� CF;QY @ J ^�N2I�156�2G IKN T"G � >FG T`T CF<?N<4T?@B@ J R&JK;+78�ZT";Z<4T Y5JK;/JBI R90 G"JK;A^ E�� C G THR"I�G"JK<4I T Y�G CF;A^ T�>�&@ JK;%T&>FG"JXT"; I�C:�I�JK>F; R�; C @ JK;%T � >FG?T IKNQCF; CFE?>��FI1<>= I�>'?)@ Y T ^FG T?T RA�b>FG � IKN T > � I�J � � �^ T";%T"G CA@B@,� T"a >B�FT R ;Z>�G THR � >F; R�T��8C J T"G?T"; I <4T#@B@1R � G?T!��T"G YFJ T G T"; I >FG4J!�T"; I�CAI�JK>F; R?c CF;ZY�;Z>5>F;%T.>FG"JXT"; I�CAI�JK>F; c aST G I�JK<?CA@1c NQ>FG"JEDb>F; I�CA@6>FG >FE4@ J�-�� TJ R G?T � G THR�T ; I T Y � >FG?T�I NQCF;�CF;(��>AIKN T"G���O N THR�T&>FE R�T"G"a CAI�JK>F; R?c � CFY T`JK;<>F�=�GSc6NQCFY�;Z>AI�E4T?T"; � G T YFJK<"I T Y�CF;ZY�<?C � T&CSR&C�<?> ��� @BT#I T�R�� G � G4J R�T������IH<4T?@B@�JK; IKN T @BT!�"I N T � J R � N T"G T � J ^SN2I G THR � >F;ZY I�>�C�E G"J ^SN2I G?T Y @ JK;%T.>FG4J!�T"; IUT Y�CAIKJK= Y T ^FG?T?THR I�> I N T�NQ>FG"JEDb>F; I�CA@ c8JK;5C R � CA@ @ G T ^FJK>F; >� IKN T�G"J ^SN2Ia J R�� CA@L0 T?@ YSc&E��FIM�bCFJB@7I�>�G THR � >F;ZY5I�> aST"G?I�JK<?CA@�@ JK;%THR?c NQ>FG"JEDb>F; I�CA@+@DJK;%THR?c>FG L6NQJBI T CF;ZY�E4@DCF<+�5@DJK;%THR������

H�I CF; T CFG @N�9R"I�C ^ T�>�9>��2G G T R�T CFGH< N OQ>FG#R"IUT";�V JXTHR�T?@ CF;ZY : E4T ^FCF;I�> CSR"��L6N T?I N T G I N T a J R�� CA@ <?>FG?I T���L�CSR����F@B@,� <?>F;Z; T <4I T Y�CAI&E JKG IKNFc >FGL N T?IKN T"G5I N T >FGX^FCF;ZJEDbCAI�JK>F; L T NQCFY R�T?T"; JK; CFY��F@ I CF;ZJ � CA@1R�G?T�-�� JKG?T Y� >SR"I�;ZCAI�CA@6T�� � T"G"JXT";Z<4TA�b>FG&JBI R Y T"aST?@D> �O� T"; IP� :?I J RA�bCFJKG I�> RbC�� IKNQCAI�IKN T� G T"a CFJB@DJK;A^ > � JK;ZJK>F;=>� � R��A<?NQ>A@ >?^FJ R"I R�JK; IKN T�0(�"I�JXTHR�CF;ZY RbJE��I�JXT R L8CSRI NQCAI�I N T/L�JKG"JK;A^ >� IKN T/E GHCFJK;9CF;ZY <4T"G?I�CFJK; @N� >� IKN T5<4T G T"E G CA@�<?>FG?I T��bcL�CSR @ CFGX^ T#@,� C � G >SY��2<4I�>� � >SR"I%�U;ZCAI�CA@�T�� � T"G"JXT";Z<4T��

V]T�E4T ^FCF;=E�� R?NQ>FL�JK;A^ IKNQCAI�C ;%T"L�E?>FG"; CF;ZJ � CA@ I NQCAI NQCFY >F;%T T��FT<?>FaST"G T YQ�b>FG9C � T G4JK>�Y=CSR�R?NQ>FG I/CSR CQ��T L L T?T��bR E4T <?C � T9E4@ JK;ZY)JK;I NQCAI T�� T�� V]T�<?>��F@ Y R?NQ>FL I NQCAI IKN T E"@ JK;ZYF;%THR?R]L�CSR ;Z>AI IKN T G THR��F@ I>��Rb> � T5CFEb;Z>FG � CA@DJBI/� JK; IKN T�T+� THc E�� I >� � J RbL�JKG"JK;A^�JK; IKN T�<?>FG?I T��bcRbJK;Z<4T IKN T.G THR � >F; R�THRR�bG > � I N T.G T#I�JK;ZC�L T"G?T�;Z>FG � CA@1c L N T"G?T CSR R"I�J � ���@ CAI�JK; ^]IKN T5T��FT I NQCAI NQCFY E4T?T";9<?>FaST"G T Y T a >B�FT Y�;Z> G T � >F; R�TR�bGH> � IKN T

Ò

Page 4: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

<?>FG IUT�����O N T R�T T! T <4IKR.>� T+� T >�<?<4@N� RbJK>F;�<?>�� @ Y/E4T � G >�Y�� <4T Y�>F; @N� Y��2G+�JK;A^�C < G4JBI�JK<?CA@ � T"G4JK>�Y�>� R�T"a�T"GHCA@ � >F; IKNFR�R�� E?R�T�-�� T ; I I�> E JKG?I NK�=O N T� T G4JK>�Y >� � @ CSR"I�JK<bJBI/��JK; I NQJ R R�� R"IUT � L�CSR�IKN T"G T!�b>FG?T R"I�G4JK<4I @,� @ J � JBIUT Y)���@ JK;ZJK<?CA@`T�� � T"G"JXT";Z<4T c��b>FG T�� C ��� @ T L�JBIKN <?>F;A^ T";QJBI�CA@ <?CAI�CFGHCF<"I R?c R���^:�^ THR"IKR�IKNQCAI JK; N�� � CF; R IKN T�<bG4JBI�JK<?CA@ � T"G4JK>�Y�T���I T ;ZYSR��b>FG R�T"aST"G CA@ �FT CFG#R�bGH> � EbJKG IKNK� � � G � G4J RbJK; ^A@,� c E4@ JK;QY�b>A@ YFJK;A^5E?>AIKN�T��FTHR&JK;��A>��2;A^ � >F;2�FT+� R� GH>�Y�� <4T Y��bCFG @BT R?R�R�T"aST"G?T5T! T <4IKR?c T aST"; I NQ>���^SN�IKN T CF;ZJ � CA@1R/E4T <?C � TE4@ JK;ZY�JK; E?>AI N/T�� T R���� G THR�� � CFE4@,� IKN T�E4@DJK;ZYF;%THR?R&J R Y�� T JK; � CFG I CAI6@BT CSR"II�> T! T <4IKR >F;�NQJ ^�N T"G a J R��2CA@8CFG T CSR�� O NQJ R YFJ T"G?T";Z<4T.JK; I N T�T! T <"I R >�� >F;Z>�<�� @DCFG�CF;QY EbJK;Z>�<�� @DCFG >�<?<4@,�ARbJK>F; � � R"I`NQCFaST�E4T?T ; � GH>�Y�� <4T Y�E��<?> ��� T#I�JBI�JK>F; c G CAI N T"G`IKNQCF; E�� RbJ ��� @BT YFJ R�� R�T��

� T G#NQC � R�IKN T � >SR"I%R��2G � G4J RbJK;A^&G THR��F@ I >��I N T R�T�R"I/�2YFJXTHR L�CSR I N T Y T � >F;)�R"I�G CAI�JK>F; IKNQCAI7CAI7E JKG?I NFc I NQJ R G T ^FJK>F;�>� <?>FG?I T�� G T R � >F;QYSR a�T"G � � �2< N�@DJE�FTCFY�� @ I <?>FG IUT���� � G"JXT"; I�CAI�JK>F; R�T?@BT <4I�JKa JBI � cO�b>FG.T�� C ��� @BTHc J R � G THR�T ; I I�>�CR"I�G"JE� JK;A^ Y T ^FG T?T c CF;ZY I N T >FG4JXT ; I�CAI�JK>F; <?>A@,� � ;FR NQCFaST E4T ^��2;(I�> Y T"�aST?@ > � ��V T <?>F;Z<4@,�2Y T IKNQCAI IKN T.Y T � G4JKabCAI�JK>F; T! T <"I R.I NQCAI L T NQCFY�R�T?T";L T"G T�IKN T G T R�� @ I >� Y T?IUT"G"JK>FGHCAI�JK>F; >� <?>F;Z;%T <4I�JK>F; R � G T R�T"; I6JK; @DCFGX^ T � CFG?ICAI E JKG?I NFc GHCAIKN T"G`I NQCF;�RbJ ��� @,�/C �bCFJB@,�2G T I�>�CFY�-�� JKG?T <?>F;Z;%T <"I�JK>F; R CSR.CG THR��F@ I >�/@ CF<+�]>��C @BT CFG";ZJK;A^ T�� � T"G4JXT ;Z<4T�� � � T <bJ 0 < <?>FG?I�JK<?CA@ <?>F;Z; T < �I�JK>F; R?c CAI�@BT CSR"I)�b>FG IKNQJ R G T ^FJK>F;�>� <?>FG IUT�� c CFG T�IKN�� R � CFG I @,� JK;Q;ZCAI T CF;QY� CFG?I @,� IKN T G?THR�� @ I7>�`T�� � T"G"JXT";Z<4T c�CF;ZY ;Z>AIKc8CSR IKN T � G?T"a JK>��AR�^ T"; T"GHCAI�JK>F;>� � R��A< NQ>A@D> ^ J R"I R NQCFY IKNQ>��S^�N2I c�T�� <"@,� RbJKa�T?@,��IKN T G T R�� @ I >��T�� � T"G"JXT";Z<4T��

O NQJ R/L�>FG4��JK; � >�� ; ^ <?CAI R CF;ZY � >F;2� T�� R?c THR � T < JKCA@B@N�]IKN T <?>F;Z<4T � I >�I N T�<bG4JBI�JK<?CA@ � T"G"JK>�YSc6@BT Y I�>�C � T CF; R�>� � G T"a�T"; I�JK>F;�>� >F;%T�>� I N T�<?> � �� >F;%THR"IM�b>FG � R >� E4@DJK;ZYF;%THR?R?c�IKN T � >F;Q>S<�� @ CFG E4@ JK;ZYF; THR?R &�C � E4@,� > � JKC+*I NQCAI G T R�� @ I G?THR�� @ I R �bG > � R"I�G CFE J R � �AR &���< G >SR?R T+� T���>FG���L�CA@B@ T�� T��/*L�8� > � T GHCAI�JK;A^ R��2GX^FJK<?CA@ @,� CAI CF; T CFG?@,��C ^ T I�>5<?>FG"G T <4I�IKN T <?>F;ZYFJBI�JK>F; JBIJ R � >SR?RbJKE4@BT/I�> � G T R�T"G4a�T5abJ RbJK>F; JK; I N T/I�L8> T�� T R?c CF;ZY T"aST"; � G?T"aST"; II N T�@D>SR?R�>�/E JK;Q>S<�� @ CFG Y T � IKN � T"G <4T � I�JK>F;]IKNQCAI`CA@ � >SR"I CA@ L�C�� R/G THR��F@ IKR�bGH> � R"I�GHCFE J R � �AR�� H R >�"I T"; NQC ��� T"; R JK; Rb< JXT ;Z<4THc�IKNQJ R E4T";%T 0 < JKCA@ G T"�R�� @ I >� >��2G G?THR�T CFGH< N L�CSR -��2JBI T �2;+�b>FGHR�T?T";$� V]T YFJKY ;Z>AI R�T#I >�� I�I�>� G T"aST ; I C R � T <bJ 0 < �b>FG � >� E"@ JK;ZYF;%THR?R� I N T YFJ Rb<?>FaST"G"JXTHR <?C � T�CSR CE��B� � G >�Y�� <4I8>� R"I � Y�� JK;A^�I N T&;Z>FG � CA@ E G CFJK;$� :"G >F;ZJK<?CA@B@N� c7NQCFY�L T R�T?I�CAII N T�a�T"G ��E4T ^ JK;Z;ZJK;A^�I�> �2;ZY T"GHR"I�CF;QY�C � E4@,�A> � JKCSc L T&L�>��F@ Y NQCFaST&E4T ^��2;

Page 5: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

E�� L�>FG�� JK;A^ >F; I N T/T�� THc&;Q>AI N T�EbGHCFJK; c&CF;ZY L8>�� @ Y ;Q>AI NQCFaST ^F>AIXIUT";CF;(�AL N T G T���:�R�� R � T <4I ;Q> ��� ;QYFJK;A^ C ^ T ;Z<�� L�>��F@ Y]NQCFa�T R�� ��� >FG?IUT Y C� GH> � >SRbCA@ I�> R"I � Y��/C � E4@,�A> � JKC�E�� � CB� JK; ^ � JK< GH>AT?@ T <4I�G >�Y T G T <?>FG YFJK;A^SR�bGH> � I N T.<?>FG?I T�� � O N T.Y T � G"JKa CAI�JK>F;]R"I/�2YFJXTHR/E4T ^FCF;�CSR C5RbJKY T � GH>��T <"ICF;ZY�YFJKY5;Z>AI G?T�-��2JKG T&CF;(� CFYFYFJBI�JK>F;ZCA@7G?THRb>��2GH<4THR��

��;ZY T G#R"I�CF;ZYFJK;A^ IKN T`N�� � CF; E G CFJK; J R.>F;%T�>� IKN T`^ G T CAIUTHR"I < NQCA@ @BT";A^2THRI NQCAI�Rb< JXT";2I�J R"IKR1�bCF<4T�� :?I J R&R�� G?T?@,��I N T � >SR"I <?> ��� @BT�� � CF<?NQJK;%T JK;�IKN T� ;Z>FL�; �2;ZJKaST G#R�T��`:#I NQCSR.<?> �.� >F; @,�5E4T?T"; IKNQ>��S^SN2I I NQCAI8�2;ZY T"GHR"I�CF;ZY:�JK;A^ IKN T�E G CFJK; J R.C5NQ> � T#@BTHR?R'-�� THR"IKc�RbJK;Z<4T IKN T � CFJK; I�>�>A@8L T NQCFaST�I�>L�>FG4� L�JBIKN J R >��2G >FL�;�E GHCFJK;K�`:`NQCFaST.;%T"aST"G R�T?T ; CF;(� � T"G"JBI JK; IKNQJ R@ >?^FJK< c&CF;ZY�I N T L8>FG4� : NQCFaST Y THRb< G"JKE4T Y N T G THc I�>?^ T?IKN T"G L�JBIKN�G T R�T CFGH< NJK;\N��2;ZYFG T Y�>��@ CFE?>FG CAI�>FG"JXTHR?c`NQCSR R�� G?T?@,��CA@ G T CFY�� @ T Y I�>9G T � CFG�� CFE4@BT� GH>?^FG T R?R�JK; � ;ZY T G#R"I�CF;ZYFJK;A^ IKN T E GHCFJK;Fc T"aST"; IKNQ>��S^SN9JBI&J R����AR"I`C�E4T"�^FJK;Z;ZJK;A^L�

�p��bu{wz��~���fBeg~{��n�d:�?p�e���~.�zp{egfB�^e�Yz�Nu{wz�b�:c�xT���?u � �?�?Y7Yz��jzp{n|xzwBtl~�e�n^��n^�^t!c�Y�fRe�kW¨c��^��xzp{n5���§~{~�e�Yz������e�d:�?Y7kNt�~���e���YBu�e¹«I�u�p�c�e�Yze�Yz�z`IX � n|jz��f!c^~��!c�Yzn^u�wz�?pb°:jz��~�u{e�n|Y"Ë: R I N T � GH>�<4THR?RbJK;A^ � T"G �b>FG � T Y5E��5IKN T � G4J � CFG�� a J R�� CA@8<?>FG?I T�� CFY T�-��2CAI T#@,� � >SY T#@BT YE�� CF; CAI�> � JK<�Y T <?> ��� >SRbJBI�JK>F;����Y�fB�?pbu�wz�W�|�?Yz�?p�e���Y�crk���nrm.CAI�> � JK<�Y T <?> ��� >:�RbJBI�JK>F; R�` � �$«HY�f¯k7c�YBt�c����^n|p{e�u{wzk7~bp�c�Yz�^e�Yz� mop�n^k 5 >�� G"JXT"G5CF;ZCA@N� RbJ R�u{n L�CFaST#@BT?ICF;QCA@,� RbJ R�`�e�YH����j�f5e�Yz� � G4JK;Z<bJ � CA@ ��> ��� >F;%T ; I#H&;ZCA@,� RbJ R�`c�Y�f):";ZY T � T";QY T"; I ��> � �� >F;%T ; I�H&;ZCA@,� RbJ R���¡�wl�W�gc^~�u�u � nTc����|n^p{e�u{wzk$~�crp��7cre�k���fTcrub«�Y�fBe�Yz�T~�e�k�xl����c�Y�fjlYze�d:�?p�~{c�� E��2JB@ YFJK;A^9E4@ >�<+� R�e�Y�~�e�fB�Nc��|e�d:�?Y ����c|~{~�nrm¶~�e��|Y�cr�g~�n^pbe�k7c��^��~��b¡�wze�~ � e������������c�p{eÁ«���f�e�Y�u{wl��Yz�?�5u�~�����u�e�n^YH~�� �Y��?�zc�k�xz����nrm E��2JB@ YFJK;A^ E"@ >�<+� Rbe�~��^e�d:��YT�Btxlwzn^Yz��k���~�e�Y�~�x��?�§�¬wTxzp�n5����~�~�e�Yl�z�wzn|Yz�?k���~�crp{��u�wz�N~�wln^p{u���~�ubxze�������~�nrm¶~�n|jzY�f� wle���w�~�u{e�����w�c?d:��cb��e�Yl�^jzeg~�u{eg�¶k���crYze�Yz�z��a�c?d5e�f�Ê�jz���?��u{�?����~j�~²u�w�cruF~�n|k������?���g~În�mu�wz��xzp{e�k7crp�t�d5e�~�jHcr����n|p{u��?�Ncrp���fB��u{����u�e�Yz�bu�wz��~�e�k�xl����~�u��|�?n^k���u{p{eg�²�?Y5u{e�u{e���~ � wzeg�¬w~�u{e����5w�c?d:��ck���c�Yze�Yz��e�YNc�YWe�k7cr�|�:���%crYNu{wzeg~�xzp�n5����~{~�e�Yz�b����dBe�� � ��f�c^~c�Y�c�u{n|k�e��f5����n^k�x}n�~�e�u{e�n|Y �

��~�����n|Y�f�n^�H~��?p�d^c�u{e�n^Y���n^Y����?p{Y�~�u{wz�%p{n^����n�m-�§fB�^��fB��u{����u�e�n|Y�e�Y©a�c?dBegf�Êjz���?�­ÂÀ~� n^p��-�.v:n^k��F���?����~-e�Y�u�wz��xzp�e�k7c�p{t�d5e�~�j�cr����n^p{u��?��crp���~�x�����egcr��e�È?��f�e�YNf5�?u{����u{e�Yl���e�Yz�~��?�^k��?YBu�~ � e�u�wTc��^e�d:��YRn|p{e��?YBu�cru�e�n^Y���¡�wz��xHcrp�c�k�n^jlYBu�e�k�x�n|p{u�c�Y����bnrmÎ�^�?n|k��?u{p�te�Y�u{wle�~®xlp{n5����~�~�e�Yz��c^fBd:n5��cru{�§~Émon^pNc!����c|~{~bnrm�k�n5fB�?�g~ � wl�?p{��n|Yz��eg~®��n:n|�Be�Yz��mon^pu�wz��~�e�k�xz����~�u��^�?n|k��?u�p{e��.~�u{p{jH��u{jzp���~ � wzeg�¬w�«Hu²u�wz��fzc�u�cB�.¡�wl��~���p��?k7crp��z~"x�c?d:��u{wl�p�n:c|fRu{n�u�wz��k�n5f5�?��~ � wze���w � ��p{��k���YBu�e�n^Yl��fªe�Y7n^jzp�e�YBu�p{n5fBj���u{e�n|Y"�.¡�wz��«�p�~�u�n^Yl�

_

Page 6: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

eg~¶u�wz��h�jlkWmon^p�f¾¨{v�w�crw!k�n5fB�?�­� �Æ~�e�k�e��gcrp��ljzub~�e�k�xz���?p�k�n5f5�?� � c|~xzp{n|x�n:~��§f��Btv�u�crYl���?t�³�~�wz��p?`B´��?n|Yze�f�µ�j�fBe�Y"`|crY�f�·k7c|f�¸�cru��?k�e:c�Y�f � e����:����u�p{��c�u{��fbwz�?p{���+��Yc���u��?p{Y�c�u{e�d:�u{n�u{wz��³�µ¸�k�n5fB��� � e����:����~�u{j�f5e���fbe�Y�v:����u�e�n|Y�]�crYHf®u{wl����n|p{p{�§~�x�n^Y�f:¨e�Yz�7c����^n|p{e�u{wzk e�~�~�e�k�e���crp�u�n!c � c?d:�?���?u�~�wzp{e�Yz�|cr�|� � wze���w"`-e�Y�c�~��?YH~��:`-p�����n|Y���e�����~~�n^k��$cru{n|k�e���fB����n|k�x�n:~�e�u{e�n^Y�~ � e�u{w�~�n^k���d|c�p{e�c�u{e�n^Y�c���crxzxzp�n:c|�¬wz�§~�� ��~�e�u � c|~c���p���c^fBt�u{n^�gf-`zn^jlp�fBeg~{��jH~{~�e�n^Y � e����-Y�c�u{jzp�cr����t�����c^f�u{nNu{wl�ª³�~�wz�?p�¨­Ó.��~���k�n5fB�?�­�

� �ÌMDP � V�U Q� ®UFP � ��P �V�M.V?PWL �

X)Y7u{wl� *��?��~�u{�?p�ÂÀ~�fBeg��u{e�n^Y�c�p{t:`5u{wz� � n^p�f�CF;ZCA@N� RbJ R�eg~�fB��«�Yz�§fRc|~Fmon|����n � ~�ËH E G?T CB� JK;A^ � � >��C L6NQ>A@BT JK;2I�> JBIKR � CFG?I R/Rb> CSR�I�> 0 ;ZY >��FI IKN T"JKG;ZCAI/�2G T��¡�wz��p{��mon|p{��crY�c���t5È?e�Yz��c�mojzY���u�e�n^Y�`Bc�~�e��^Y�c��)`zc�Y�e�k$cr�^��k���crY�~��zp{��c��Be�Yz�be�u.e�Y5u{n

~�e�k�xl���?p.�?Y5u{e�u{e��§~²Y�c�k���f E��2JB@ YFJK;A^�E4@ >�<+�bR�`+I�J � T"� �bG?T�-�� T ;Z<��5CAI�> � R�`zn^p.L�CFaST?@ T?I R��¡�wle�~�e�~ � wHcru � �!�?c����FcrY CAI�> � JK<�Y T <?> ��� >SRbJBI�JK>F;B�¤¡�wze�~�xHcrp�c|fBe��|k ~�xlp�crYl�¯n|jzue�YT~�e��^YHcr�n|p�e�k7c��^��xzp{n5���§~{~�e�Yz�7c�Y�f e�Y�k7c�u{wz��k7cru�e��?~.e�Y�u�wz�N~���d:�?YBu�e���~�� �e�d:�?YTc����c^~�~��!nrm�~�e��^Y�c���~�`¾e�k7cr�|��~�n|p�mojzY���u�e�n|Y�~�` � ��c�p{����n:n^�5e�Yz��mon^pDu{wz��~�e�k�xz����~�u��?Y5u{e�u{e��§~� wle���w��^��Yz�?p�c�u{�©cr�����?���?k��?Y5u�~.� '��.¦I¡�wz��~����?Y5u{e�u{e���~�crp���Y�c�k���f CAI�> � R�c�Y�fTcrp��u�wz���zjze��gfBe�Yl���z��n5���l~ mop{n|k � wze���w � ���?c�Y���n^Y�~�u{p{jH��u%crY5tN�]'����5t�~�jze�u�cr�z�����e�Yz�§crp��n^kN�ze�Y�c�u{e�n^Y�~��¡�wzeg~�fB��«�Yze�u{e�n^Y7e�k�xl��e��§~Îu � n�m­c^��u�~�ËÏ­c¾Ð �b>FG YFJ Rb<?>Fa�T"G4JK; ^5I N T CAI�> � R?c�IKN T`RbJ ^F;ZCA@1R�� '�� ;%T?T Y5I�>5E4T CF;ZCA@,��D�T YÏÑ�-Ð]C�R��A; IKN THRbJ R/J R/;%T?T Y T Y �b>FG < N T <+� JK; ^]IKNQCAI`IKN T CAI�> � R ^ T";%T"G CAI T IKN T�RbJ ^F;ZCA@1R�]'��.¦

��u{n|k�e��.fB�§��n^k�x�n�~�e�u�e�n|Y�~ � �?p{��~��?k�e�Y�cr�:e�Y�k7crY5t�n^u�wz�?p%~{��e��?Y5u{eÁ«I��«��?��fl~��X)YN��wz�?kW¨eg~�u�p{t:`"u{wl�ª«�p�~�u��zjze��gfBe�Yl���z��n5���l~ � �?p{�Nxzjzp��W�����?k���YBu�~�������Bu � �ª«HY�f k�n^���§��jz���§~c�Y�f�c�u{n^k$~��X)YNxzw5tz~�e��?~�u�wz��~���c�u{n^k$~²c�p{��mojzp{u�wz�?p%fB����n^k�x�n:~���f�e�Y5u{n�~�e�k�xz����p��?Y5u{eÁ¨u�e���~���·�zc�k�xz����~�cr��n^jlY�f�e�Y!n^u{wl�?p�~���e���Y�����~���X)Y�~�e��|Y�cr�n|pe�k7cr�|�bxzp{n5���§~{~�e�Yz�z`�u{wl�f5��«�Yze�u{e�n|Y�nrm�u{wl�R�ljze��gfBe�Yz�!�z��n5���l~�`u{wl�Ru�t5x���nrm�xzp{n5����~{~�e�Yz��n^Yz�$~�wzn|jz��f�j�~��7u{nf5����n^k�x}n�~���c�~�e��^Y�c���e�YBu�nNc�~��?p�e���~�n�m.�zjze���fBe�Yz���l��n5���z~�`�crY�f7u{wz�bp{jl����~�u�n��}��j�~��§fe�Y7u{wz��~�t5Y5u{wz��~�e�~�c�p{����n^Y5u{���BuFfB�?x��?Y�fB��YBu�c|~¶e�u � e����I����~�wzn � Y"�´��?u�j�~"k��?Y5u{e�n^Y�cFmo� � �?�lcrk�xl����~��"¡�wz�.n^�gfB��~�u�n^xlu{e�n|Y�eg~-u{wz� � e�YHfBn � ��fb¸zn^jzp�e��?pc�Y�cr��tz~�e�~.n^p�~�wln^p{u�¨)u�e�k���¸zn|jzp{e��?p�c�Y�cr��tz~�e�~�����YW��°:jze�d^c����?Y5umon^p�kWjz�gcru�e�n^Y � c^~��|e�d:�?Y

Page 7: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

�5t�a��?YzYzeg~ ��c��}n|p�e�Y7Z?\ � _�c�Y�fWe�~�u{n5fzc?t��5Yzn � Y�c|~ � CFE?>FG L�CFa�T?@BT?IKR���³Yl��fBe�k��?YB¨~�e�n|Y�cr� ��c���n^p � c?d:�?���?u�~.c�p{��u{wz�mojlY���u{e�n^Y�~�������� � � à �?�BxIÏ��Ï���������Ð $ Ð5��n:~�Ï�������� Ð�¦¡�wl��~���mojzYH��u{e�n^Y�~bcrp�����c��}�������§fR�5tTc�x�n^e�Y5u�Ï����b!���Ð�e�Y!u{wz�Nu{e�k���mop{��°:jz�?YH��t7xz��c�Yz�:���~�Yzn^u�e�����f7�Bt$a�?YzYzeg~ ��cr��n^p�crYHf�cr�g~�nN�Bt!´���?n^Y�½�p�e�����n^jze�Y"`:e¹mÎc ��cr��n^p � c?d:�?����u� ����� � � e�~�jzY5mon^��f5��fRe�YBu�n�u{wz�bu{e�k���¨omop{��°:jz�?YH��t�xz�gcrYz��`ze�u���n�d:�?p�~�cWfBeg~{�bcrp�n^jzYHfRu{wl�x�n|e�Y5u7Ï�����!���Ðbn�m�u�wz�7u{e�k���¨Ñmop���°:jz�?Y���t!xz��c�Yz�:��¡�wz� crp���c�nrmbu�wz�!~�x�n^uNe�~�± �ic�Y�fu�wze�~�~�tz~�u{�?k$cru{eg�ª�gc^���¯n�m���n5�?cr��e�È�c�u{e�n^Y�e�~��?�5xz�gcre�Yl��f¯�5t�Ê��e�~���YB���?p���jzY����?p{u�cre�Y5u�txlp{e�YH��e�xz���:�h�n|p{���^�?Yz��p�cr����t:`|���?u.j�~%��n^Y�~�e�fB��p�c�Z�¨�a[~�e��^Y�c��I��Ï���Ð � wz�?p{���DfB�?Yzn|u{��~.u{wz��u{e�k��d|c�p{e�c��z����� �YBmon^�gfBe�Yl����Ï���Ð�e�Y¯u�wz�Nu{e�k���mop{��°:jz�?Y���t�xz�gcrYz��crk�n|jzY5u�~�u{n!u{p{t5e�Yl��u{n

f5p�c � u{wl���^p�crxzw! nrm.u�wz��e�Y�~�u�crY5u�crYl�?n^j�~�mop{��°:jz�?Y���t"��Ï���Ð?!�dBe�� � ��f�c^~�c�mojzY���u�e�n|Yn�m�u�wz��u�e�k��Nd|crp{egcr�z���#��¦X)Y�n^u�wz�?p � n|p�fz~�` � � � e�~�w�u{n � p{e�u{��u�wz��kNj�~�eg�?cr�%~���n^p��� wle����b��e�~�u��?Yze�Yz�Wu�nWu�wz��kNj�~�e��^�%Ê�?e�Y�~��?Y5���?p{�Nxzp�e�Y���e�xz���É~{c?tz~�u{w�c�u$ ¤�?c�YzYzn^u��}�Nc�|p�c�xzw"`��zjzu�e�YH~�u{�§c^f�e�~�c�u{wzeg�¬����jzp�d:� � e���w!��n�d:�?p�~%c���c�p{�^�©crp���cB�

µ��?u{jlp{Yze�Yz��u{n ��cr��n^p � c?d:�?����u�~�`%e�u7������n^k���~ªYHcru{jlp�cr�bu�n¥��d:�?Yz��t�~�x�c^����u{wl�x�n|e�Y5u�~bÏ�� � !��FÐ�e�Y�u{wl�®u�e�k���¨Ñmop���°¾jl�?Y���t�xz�gcrYz��� ��cr��n^pb��n^Y�~�e�fB�?p���fRu�wz�b�^p�e�fRn�m.u{wl�u�e�k���mop{�§°¾jz��Y���t�xz��c�Yz�TfB��«�Yz��f��5t!�&% à , !('�ZA!('b± !*)+)+)�!,�.-Éà , !('b±/��!(' � ��!*)+)+)c�Y�f¥u�wz�T��n^p{p���~�x�n|Y�fBe�Yl��x�c?dBe�Yz���Bt�c|f?¢�c^���?YBuNp{�§��u�c�Yz�^����~10 � % - � à 032 !42R� Z43�50 ±/�76U!�±/�Ï86H�yZ�Ð�3�!92 !46 ';: $ ¦I¡�wze�~�x�c?dBe�Yz�Weg~���n|Y�~�eg~�u{��YBu � e�u�w�Ê�?e�~��?Y5�}��p{��jzY����?p�¨u�cre�YBu�t7xzp{e�Y���e�xz���©crY�f � c^~bcr�g~�n!c^fBd:n5��cru{�§f��Bt�´��"½�p{e�����n|jze�Y���X)Yz�^p�e�fTa�c�jz������wze���~jlYBd:�?e�����fTu{wl��f5p�c � ��c^���l~�nrm�u{wz��~�� ��c���n^p � c§d:�����?u�~���X)Y�fB�?��f�u{wz�!����n:~��§f¼��e�Yz�§crp~�x�crY£n�mbu{wl� ��cr��n^p � c§d:�����?u�~®e�~#< $ Ï>= $ Ð��zjzuNu{wl���?�5x�crYH~�e�n|Yqn�m�c�mojzY���u{e�n|Yqe�Y< $ Ï8= $ Ð�c|~�cT~��?p�e���~bnrm ��c���n^p � c?d:�?����u�~�e�~bjzY�~�u�cr�z���:`.~�e�Y�����e�u�Yz����fz~®���Bu�p{�?k�����t�gcrp��^�b��n:�(?7��e��?Y5u�~��DÊn � �?d:��pe¹m@� % ÃA2$eg~²p��?xz��c|����f��BtB� % ÃDC@2 � wz�?p�� ,FEDC!E0ZA!u�wz�?Y�u{wl�7��n^p�p{��~�x�n^Y�fBe�Yz����c���n^p � c?d:�?����u�~mon^p�k crY�n�d:�?p���n^k�xz���?u{�©~�tl~�u��?k n|p�cmop�crk�� 0 ±BZ"3)�³�u{wl�?p�~�n^��jzu{e�n^Y�~ � �?p{�Nxzp{n|x�n:~��§f�µ¶n|Y�cr�gf �.n^eÁmok7crY�c�Y�fTu{wz��~�����n^Y�f�crjzu�wzn^p��¡�wl��~��bYz� � cr���^n|p{e�u�wzk7~%crp{�bY�c�k���f @D>S<?CA@ I�G"J ^F>F;Z> � T#I�G"JK<�E?CSR�THRFcrY�f7crp���cre�k���f�cruc�Y�cr��tBÈ�e�Yz�!°:j�c^~�e¹¨Í~�u�c�u{e�n^Y�c�p{t�crjHfBe�n!~�e��^Y�c���~/0 Ò^±�3)`�0 Ò^_�3)�N·�Bx�c�Y�fBe�Yz�!cR~�e��|Y�cr�.e�Y5u{n

c7��n5�?c���u�p{e��|n^Yzn|k��?u�p{e����Hc^~�eg~®���?�|e�Y�~ � e�u{w¤c�~��?�^k��?YBu�cru�e�n^Y�nrm�u�wz�N�^e�d:��Y�~�e��^YHcr�)�¡�wle�~�~����^k��?Y5u�c�u{e�n^Y�eg~�j�~�e�Yz�N~�n|k��b~�x�����e¹«I� � e�YHfBn � ~ � wze���w7crp���e�Y���n^p�x�n^p�c�u{��f�e�Yu�wz��cr���|n^p�e�u{wlkT���Y�n^xzu�e�k7c����wzn|e�����n�m�u{wl� � e�Y�fBn � ~ � e����Dxzp{n�d5e�fB��u�wz��~�x�crp�~���~�up��?xzp���~��?Y5u�c�u{e�n^Y"��³�Y�����u�wz��~�e��|Y�cr�.e�~b~��?�^k���YBu���f-`�u{wz�NYz�?�5ub~�u��?x�e�~�j�~�e�Yz�!crY�c��¹¨u��?p{YH~�u{e�d:��¸zn^jzp�e��?p%~���p{e��§~��?�5x�crY�~�e�n|Y"���i±?¨�ayd:�?p�~�e�n^YNnrm�u�wze�~.c����^n|p{e�u{wzk �?�5e�~�u�~�zjzu

Page 8: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

u�wz��~��?�|k��?Y5u�c�u{e�n|Y�e�~�kNj���wWk�n^p{�É��n^Y�~�u{p�cre�Yl��fRu�w�crY!e�Y�Z¬¨Ía��I¡�w�cru��?�5xz��c�e�Y�~ � wBt±?¨�a ��n5��cr��u{p{e��^n|Yzn^k���u{p{eg����c^~���~��?c�YzYzn^ub����j�~���f�c|~É�§fB�^��¨ÍfB�?u�����u�n^p�~�`-c|~�n^xzx�n:~���fu�n �%c�Y�f ���~)¨�a�n^Yzn|wznzÂÇ~���jzp�d:�?���?u�~`0ÁZ?±S3­�¡�e�k���¨Í~{�?c����Dcr���|n^p�e�u{wlk7~}�����?c�k���x}n|xzjz�gcrp�e�Y�u�wz�.��crp���t��?e��|wBu�e���~��"¡�wz�?t���k��?p{�|��f

c�uNcr��n^jlu�u{wz�7~�crk��Nu{e�k���e�Y¼fBe�~�u{e�YH��u���n^k�kNjzYze�u{e��?~��7XÍY¤e�k7c��^��xzp�n5����~{~�e�Yz��c�Y�f��n^k�xzjlu{�?pIdBeg~�e�n|Y"`�n^Yz�F~�wzn|jz��fbk��?Y5u{e�n|Y�u{wl�²mojzY�flcrk��?Y5u�c��:c|�¬wze��?d:�?k���Y5u�~z�BtÉa�c?dBegfhTc�p{p90 Ò � 3 � wzn � c^~!~�u�j�fBt5e�Yz��u{wl�¯xzp�n5����~�~�e�Yl�qx��?p�mon|p{k��§fq�Bt�u{wz��wBjlk7crY£d5e¹¨~�e�n|Y�~�tl~�u��?kT�NhTcrp�p�fBeg~{��n�d:�?p���f�u{e�k���¨Í~{�?c���� � c?d:�?���?u�~e�Y¤��n|YzYz����u�e�n|Y � e�u{w���f5�^��¨f5�?u{����u{e�n|Y"�7hTcrp�p?ÂÇ~ � c?d:�?���?u�~�crp{��e�~�n|u{p�n^xzeg�Wc�Y�f�u{wz��k�n^u{wl�?p�¨ � c?d:�?���?ueg~bfB��«�Yz�§fc|~���Ï��-ÐÃ���� � wz�?p����IÏ��-Ð�à �?�5x-Ï&�� �� $ Ð�crYHf�� eg~Éu�wz�N��crxl��c^��e�crY��W¡�wl�Wn|u{wz�?phTc�p{p � c?d:�?����u�~bcrp����� �®Ã���� � ��Ï�� � � Ð � wz�?p������ ,�eg~®u�wz�7~{��cr���$crY�f�� ' = $eg~ªu�wz�7x�n:~�e�u{e�n^Y£nrmÉu{wz� � c?d:�?���?u?��X)uNe�~�~�u{p{e��Be�Yz��u{n�n^��~��?p{d:�7u{wHcruNu{wzeg~ªxze�n^Yz���?p�¨e�Yz� � n^p��W�5t�a�c§d5e�fNhTcrp�p?`5u{wz�bf5e�~{��nrd:��p{t�n�mx5t5p�crk�e�fzc���cr���^n^p�e�u�wzk7~�Bt�½�jzp�u�c�Y�f��fB�?��~�n^Y"`�crY�f�u{wz��mojlY�fzcrk��?YBu�cr� � n^p{���Bt.������zc�Y�fBp{� ��p{n:~�~�k7c�YzYNcrYHfWs^��c�Y�h�n|p�¨���?u � �?p���c^��wze��?d:��fbcru.c���n^jzu.u{wl��~{c�k���u�e�k����"¡�wz��p���c^f5�?pe�~"p{��mo�?p{p���f®u�n 0 \�3Bn|p�0 Ò|_S3)�

´��?uNj�~Wp��?u{jlp{Yqu�n�a�c§d5e�f�Êjz���?�­� : R�JBI � >SR?RbJKE4@ T�I�> � >�Y T?@ IKN T <4T?@ @1R�JK; IKN T� G"J � CFG�� a J R��2CA@ <?>FG?I T�� E�� Rb> � T L�CFa�T?@BT?IKR���� L NQJK<?N R?NQ>��F@ Y <?> � E JK; T I N T �bG T4�-�� T";Q<�� @D>S<?CA@DJEDbCAI�JK>F;�>�`IKN T � CFE?>FG�L�CFaST#@BT?IKR�I�> ^2T?I N T G`L�JBIKN�I N T�@ >�<?CA@ JEDbCAI�JK>F;�>�`IKN T� G >SR?R � CF;Z;)�X[]>FG @BT#I6L�CFaST#@BT?IKR&JK; I N T�R � CF<4T YF> � CFJK; � �¥~�e�Yz�|���.n^p�u{wzn|Yzn^p�k7cr�:�Hc^~�eg~��n^Y�~�e�~�u�e�Yz��nrm � c?d:�?���?u�~ � e�u�wTu{wz��~���u{wzp��?��f5�?�^p��?��~n�m²mop��?��fBn|k Ï­~{�?c����:`zmop{��°:jz�?YH��tc�Y�fTx}n�~�e�u{e�n|Y-Ðbf5n:��~®Yzn|ub�?�Beg~�u���¡�wze�~�����c^fz~�u�nR«�d:�Nc���u{��p{Y�c�u{e�d:�©~�n|��jzu�e�n^YH~ � wzeg�¬wp�crYz�|�®mop�n^kÌu�wz�b�}�§~�u�¨­��c|~���~�cr���^n^p�e�u�wzk7~�u{n�� �"!�¦B����u�j�~����®k�n^p{�É~�x�����eÁ«I�^�µ�n^Y�c���f �.n^eÁmok7crY�xzp�n^x�n:~���fWu�n�w�c?d:��c^�?����~{~u{n�c��e��zp�crp�t���n|YBu�cre�Yle�Yz�be�Y5«�Yze�u��?��t

k$crY5t�n^p�u{wzn|Yzn^p�k7cr�z�Hc^~��§~���³�Yz��mop{���?��t�xle����z~�c��c|~�e�~e�Y�u{wl����e��lp�crp�t�crY�f�u{wzeg~�mop��?��¨f5n^kÅxzp{n�d5e�fB��~bj�~ � e�u�w�c$«HYz�?p�u�jzYze�Yz�Tnrm�u�wz�7~{��cr���§~�`u{wl�Wmop{��°:jz�?YH��e���~�crY�f�u{wl�x�n�~�e�u�e�n|Y�~�nrmDu{wz��u{e�k���¨Ñmop���°:jz�?Y���tÉcru{n|k7~ � wle���w7crp���j�~��§f-���0~���������u�e�n|Y�c����^n|p{e�u{wzkt5e�����fz~.u{wz�b��c|~�e�~ � wzeg�¬wW«Hu�~�cª�|e�d:�?Y7~�e��|Y�cr�"n|p�c��^e�d:�?Y�e�k$cr�^��n^xzu�e�k7c�����t���.n|e¹mok7c�Y"ÂÀ~W����~�u7��c^~�e�~�c����|n^p{e�u{wzk eg~�crY c^fzc�xzu{e�d:��cr���|n^p�e�u{wlk crY�fit5e�����fz~�c

��n^Y5u{�?�5u�fB��x}��Y�fB�?Y5u�c�u{n^k�e���fB����n|k�x�n:~�e�u{e�n^Y"�D¡�wz��¿Àk$cru���wze�Yz�bxzjzp�~�jze�uFcr���^n^p�e�u�wzkTÂe�YBu�p{n5fBjH����fT�Bt�v:u ��?xzw�c�Yz�7hTc�����c�ube�~b~�e�k�e��gcrp�e�Y�~�xze�p�e�u?�7³�Yz�7~�u�crp�u�~ � e�u{w¤crY����¾¨u�p{�?k��?��t��gcrp��^�Nnrd:��p���n|k�xz����u{����n^��������u{e�n|Y � nrm�u�e�k���¨�~��?cr����¨Ñmop���°:jz�?Y���t � c?d:�?���?u�~#�¦¡�wl��~�� � c?d:�?����u�~-c�p{��Yzn|p{k7c���e�È?��f�5t�$%�&$"$�Ã[Z|¦ ��e�d:�?Y�c~�e��^YHcr�zn|pc�Y�e�k7c��^�.� !�n^Yl�xle����z~.c � c?d:�?���?u'� � ' �Tt5e��?�gfBe�Yz�bu�wz�b��crp��^��~�u���n^p�p{�?�gcru�e�n^Y)( �.à E£� !*���+� � e�u{w!�-¦

]

Page 9: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

¡�wl�?Y ( � � ��e�~�~�jz�H~�u{p�c^��u���f®mop{n|k � � wle���w�t5e��?�gfz~"c¶«�p�~�up���~�egfBj�cr�l� ��¦:³�Yz��xzp�n5���?��fz~n|YTu{wzeg~¶p���~�egfBj�c��c�Y�f n|�zu�c�e�Y�~�c�~���°:jz�?YH����� � !���� Z !}n�m�p���~�egfBj�c���~���¸�e�YHcr����t�u{wl�� CAI�< NQJK;A^ � � GHR�� JBIlcr���^n^p�e�u�wzk[xzp{n�d5e�fB��~"j�~ � e�u{w�u�wz��~��?p{e���~ ���Bx�c�Y�~�e�n^YN�TÃ���� � � � ¦¡�wz��kWjz��u{eÁ¨)�gc§t:��p{��f®p{��xzp{��~��?Y5u�cru�e�n|Y�~²n�me�k7cr�|��~ � �?p��e�YBu�p{n5fBj�����fWc�Y�f7~�u�j�fBe��§f�5t �k�e�p7�d:�?p��zj���w"`:µ�n^Y�c���f �.n^e¹mok$crY"`:c�Y�f�¸zp�c�Y��n|e�~����Bh���t:�?p?��¡�wz�?t�p�����n|Y���e����

CAI�> � JK<5Y T <?> ��� >SRbJBI�JK>F; R � e�u{w�u{wl�N�$����k�n5f5�?��~�nrm�h�jzkNmon^p�f!º v:w�c�w"��X)Y 0 Ò^]S3� �bp{��c|f

O N T8� ;QY T"G @N�AJK;A^ CSR?R�� ��� I�JK>F; E4THNQJK;ZY R"I�CF;QYFCFGHY <?> ��� G?THR?RbJK>F; � T?IKNQ>�YSRJ R`IKNQCAI�I N T E?CSRbJ R &UT�� ^L� IKN T�C �`O E?CSRbJ R?c >FG&C L�CFa�T?@BT?I�E?CSRbJ R/* � R�T Y��b>FG<?> ��� G THR?RbJK>F; J R L T?@ @ CFYFC � I T Y`I�> � >SR"I J � C ^2THR�� ���2G�C ��� GH>�CF< N �b>A@ @ >FL RC�<?> ��� @BT?IUT?@,� YFJ T"G T";2I�YFJKG?T <4I�JK>F;K;�� JK; R"IUT CFY�>�A�b>FG < JK;A^�CA@ @6J � C ^ THR&I�>CFYFC � I I�>5>F;%T`RbJK; ^[email protected]?CSRbJ R?c�L T �AR�T C5<?>A@ @BT <4I�JK>F; >� @DJKE GHCFG"JXTHR >� E?CSR�T RI�>5G?T � G T R�T"; I C�RbJK;A^[email protected] � C ^ T��

O N T � CFJK; <?>F; I�G4JKE�� I�JK>F;=>��I NQJ R�L8>FG4�9J R�C9;%T"L � CFG CFYFJ ^ � �b>FG�J � �C ^ T <?> ��� G?THR?RbJK>F;$� V]T Y THRb< G"JKE4T�C ;%T"L � �F@ I�J!��@ C�� T"G?T Y G?T � G THR�T ; I�C:�I�JK>F;=I T <?NQ;ZJ�-��ZT#�b>FG J � C ^ THR�� H&;MJ � C ^2T J R9T";Z<?>�Y T Y CSR IKN T�R�� � T"G+�� >SRbJBI�JK>F;�>� >F; T � CFJK;�C ��� G >B� J � CAI�JK>F; c�CF;QY5C.R�T�-�� T";Q<4T >� G?THRbJKY�� CA@ R��O N T R"I�G?T";A^AIKN/>��IKN T � �F@ I�J!��@ C��FT"G T Y � T?IKNQ>�Y <?> � THR �bG > � IKN TM�bCF<4I�IKNQCAIL T � R�T YFJ T G T"; I E?CSR�THR I�>�T";Z<?>�Y T IKN T � CFJK; C ��� G >B� J � CAI�JK>F;�CF;ZY IKN TG THRbJKY��2CA@1R��R56>FG�JK; R"I�CF;Z<4THc L�T`<?CF; � R�T�; � C L�CFa�T?@BT?I E?CSRbJ R�I�> T";Z<?>�Y T&C<?>SCFGHR�T � CFJK; C ��� G >B� J � CAI�JK>F;�>��IKN T J � C ^ T c�� L�CFaST?@BT#I � CF<+� T?I`E?CSR�T RI�> T";Z<?>�Y T5IUT���I �2G T Y � CAI I T"G"; R?c��\E G �AR?N2@BT?I E?CSR�THR I�> T";Z<?>�Y T5@D>S<?CA@DJED�T Y>FG4JXT";2I T Y5IUT���I � G?T Y ��T CAI/�2G T R?c T?I�<B�

C � G"JK;A^ T CF< N JBIUT"GHCAI�JK>F; >� I N T CA@ ^F>FG4JBIKN � c L T.<?>SY T IKN T G T RbJKY�� CA@ � CFG?IJK;)C @ >SR?R�� L�C���; L T�>F;2@,� G?T?I�CFJK;=IKN T � >SR"I RbJ ^F;ZJ 0 <?CF;2I R"I�G��2<4I/�2G T R>�5IKN T�G?THRbJKY�� CA@ � CFG IKc L6NQJK< N G THR��F@ IKR�JK; C]R � CFG#R�T G?T � G T R�T"; I�CAI�JK>F; >�I N T/G T RbJKY�� CA@!� `T <?C��AR�T�T CF< N @DC�� T"G NQCSR C R � CFGHR�T G?T � G THR�T ; I�CAI�JK>F; JK;I N T CSR?Rb>S<bJKCAI T Y�E?CSRbJ R?c IKN T R�� � T G � >SRbJBI�JK>F; >�5@DC�� T"GHR�CF< NQJXT"a�THR C aST G �<?> ��� CF<"I�<?>�YFJK;A^)� 8� R�T#@BT <4I�JK;A^�YFJ T"G T ; I�L�CFaST#@BT?I CF;QY�L�CFaST?@BT#I � CF<+�FT?IE?CSR�THR?c L T/CA@B@D>FLPYFJ T"G T";2IA��T CAI/�2G T R I�>�E4T/YFJ Rb<?>FaST"G T Y JK; IKN T/J � C ^ T��5 �2G?I N T"G � >FG T c�L�JBIKN T CF< N ;%T"L=E?CSRbJ R L T <?CF; T";Z<?>�Y T CF;ZY/<?> ��� T ; RbCAI T�b>FG IKN T�CFG?I�J �bCF<"I R < G T CAIUT Y5E��5IKN T.-��2CF; I�JEDbCAI�JK>F;9>� IKN T <?>AT�� < JXT";2I R >�I N T � G?T"a JK>��AR E?CSR�THR�� O NQJ R � �F@ I�J!��@ C��FT"G T Y5G?T � G T R�T"; I�CAI�JK>F;5NQCSR C @ >AI >�

\

Page 10: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

E4T C�� I�J ��� @ � >AI T ; I�JKCA@ C ��� @ JK<?CAI�JK>F;FR�JK; � CF;(�`CFG T CSR >� J � C ^ T � G >�<4THR?RbJK;A^ScCF;ZY�J � C ^ T <?>�YFJK;A^)�X)Y�c�~�u�p{e��Be�Yz�bx�crx��?p�`B�?Y5u{e�u{���§f�� � T GX^ T";Q<4T >� RbJ ��� @BT"� <4T?@B@8G T <4T � I�JKaST 0 T?@DY � GH> � �

T G I�JXTHR E�� @BT CFG";ZJK;A^ C R � CFG#R�T <?>SY T��b>FG ;ZCAI � G CA@ J � C ^2THR?c�e�Y�� CAI/�2G T�`xlx"� � , ��¨ � ,|\B`Z�\^\ � `�Ï)Ò^]5ZrÐ�`�½��?����³���~�w�crjH~��?Y�crY�f7a���sz��¸�e�����f�xzp{n|x}n�~���u{wz�mon|����n � e�Yz��xHcrp�c|fBe��|kTËu�wz��wle��^wl��t�~�x}�§��e�c���e�È���f�u�c^~��z~�nrm�u�wz�T��������~�~�u�j�fBe��§f¥�5tqa�c§d5e�f�Êjl�}������n|jz��f����u�wz��p���~�jz��u�n�m.c�YR��d:n^��jlu{e�n|Y�crp�t�xzp{n5����~{~ � wzeg�¬w$~��?������u{�§fªu�wze�~%~�n^��jzu{e�n^Y"�.¡�wl��~��?���§�¬¨u�e�n|Y7��p{e�u{�?p�e�n|Y�e�~���n^Y���eg~�e�n^Y�crY�fWp�n^�zjH~�u{Yl��~{~���¡�w�c�u�eg~ � w5t7³�g~�w�c�j�~���Y7crY�f�¸�e��?�gfz~c�e�k��§f�crub«�Y�fBe�Yz�7u{wz�Nk�n�~�ub��n|Y���eg~��Np{�?xzp���~���YBu�cru{e�n^YTn�m�u{wz�N���gc^~�~®nrm¶cr���Y�cru�jzp�c��e�k7cr�|��~�� XÍYH~�u{�§c^f�nrm�xzp{n5����~{~�e�Yz��c�����YHcru{jlp�cr��e�k7cr�|��~�`�u{wz��t¯j�~���f�~�n|k���xzeg��u{jzp���~n�m.��c�Y�fz~��?crx���~�mon^jzYHfRe�Y!cNfzcru�cW��c|~�e�~���¸zn|p�fBeg~{��n�d:�?p�e�Yz��u{wz��k�n:~�u���n|Y���eg~��bp{�?xlp{��¨~��?Y5u�cru�e�n|Y"`"u{wz�?t!j�~��§fTcrY¤cr���|n^p�e�u{wlk Y�crk��§f]:��AH�`-n|p�X)Y�f5�?x��?Y�fB�?Y5u �.n^k�x�n^Yl�?YBu��Y�cr��tz~�e�~�� : �AH � e����²���7f5��«�Yz��fTe�Y¤u{wz��~��WYln^u{�§~��!XÍubw�c�xzx��?Yz��f�u�w�cru�u{wz�N�zjze���f¾¨e�Yz���z��n5�¬�l~�mon^jzY�f��5tT³���~�wHcrj�~��?Y�crY�fT¸�e��?�gfz~c�p{�N����n:~���u{n$~�n^k��®n�m%u{wz� � c?d:�?����u�~���?��n^Yz�|e�Yz�7u�n �.n^eÁmok7crY"ÂÇ~��e��zp�c�p{e���~�� � ~�e�k�e���crp�c�xzxzp�n:c^��w¤�?crYT����mon^jzY�fTe�Y�� �YB¨~�jzx��?p{d5e�~���f¯����crp�Yze�Yz���R�5t�Ê���½���½�c�p{��n � Ï ���jzp�c�����n^k�xzjlu�cru�e�n|YqZ|`xzx"�T±|\^_§¨ÍÒBZ|Z^`Z�\^]|\¾Ð�� Ê���½���½�c�p{��n � cr�g~�n¤~�jz�|�^��~�u�~�u{wHcruNk7crk�k�cr�g~®j�~��T��n|Y���eg~��!crY�fq�(?7��e��?Y5up��?xzp���~��?Y5u�c�u{e�n^Y�~�u�n�xzp{n5���§~{~�Y�cru�jzp�c���e�k7cr�|��~��

½���mon|p{� ����n�~�e�Yl�¯u�wze�~�~�����u�e�n^Y�`����?uNj�~Wk��?YBu�e�n|Yqc¤~�p{e��Be�Yz�¤fBe�~���n�d:�?p{t��5t�·kW¨k$crY5jz�?���%c�Y�f ���~�c�Y�f�a�c?dBegf�an^Yln^wzn 0¹Z|Z43)`�0ÁZ?±�3 � wz�?p��7cru�n^k�eg�Wf5����n^k�x}n�~�e�u{e�n|Y�~c�Y�fW�|�?n^k���u{p{t©crp��u�p{jz��t�p{�§��n^Y���e����§f-��XÍY�mojz���-��n^Y5u{p�c|~�u � e�u�w �.n^eÁmok7crY�ÂÀ~�����~�u²�Hc^~�eg~~���crp��¬w�` �%c�Y�f ���~�crY�f¤an^Yzn|wzn � wz�?p��W��n:n^�5e�Yz��mon|p�n^Yl� ��c|~�eg~ � wzeg�¬w � n^jz�gf¯n^xzu�e¹¨k$cr����tN��n^k�xzp{��~�~.cr�����?crp�u{n:n|Y�e�k$cr�^�§~��Ê��?p{�bc���crp{u�n:n^Y!e�k7c��^����n^Y�~�e�~�u�~�nrm�«�Yze�u{�?��tk$crY5t�p{�?�|e�n|Y�~���!"Z �������/!"fB����e�k�e�u{��fW�5t!~�k�n:n|u{wT��n^jzYHfzcrp�e���~ ��¦I¡�wz�N�?c�p�¨u�n:n^Y�e�k7cr�|��eg~�p{��°:jze�p{��f�u�n®����~�k�n:n^u�wWe�Y�~�egfB����c^��w �� � e�u{w�¢{jzk�x�f5e�~{��n^Y5u{e�Y5jze�u{e��§~c|��p{n�~{~u�wz����n|jzY�fzc�p{t ��nrm����¦IX­m���b!�� '���!}eg~c�YTn^p{u�wzn^Yln^p{k$cr����c^~�e�~�` � �©fB��¨Yln^u{���5t���§Ï)�"Ð"u{wz��Yln^p{k $������� $"$ � wz��p{����²fB�?Yzn|u{��~u{wl���}�§~�u.c�xzxzp{n��5e�k7c�u{e�n^Y�u{n�7�BtNcb��e�Yz��crp%��n|kW�le�Y�c�u{e�n|YN���à C ��� � � ��¦�¦?¦¬��C!"� ��# ¦ ��~�e�Yl��c�~�u�c�Y�fzcrp�f � c?d:�?����u���Bx�c�Y�~�e�n^Y"` � ��n^�zu�cre�Y$���Ï­� Ð.Ã�� � �&%U$ ¦ ��~�e�Yl��c�¸zn^jzp�e��?p%~���p{e��§~²�?�5x�crYH~�e�n|Y"`:u{wz���?p�¨p�n^p � n|jz��f�w�c?d:�����?�?Y'� � �&%)( c�Y�f � e�u{wNan|Yzn^wlnr¨ �%crY�f ��§~��jlp{d:�?���?u�~�`ru�wz���?p{p�n^p�Ï)~�u{e������n^k�xzjlu{��f�e�Y�< $ Ð�eg~²p���fBj����§fªu�n� � � ÏÑ��n^�*�zÐ)+ %U$ ¦ �x�u�n�u�wz���n^��crp{e�u{wzk�e���u{��p{kT`^u�wze�~��n^Y5d:�?p{�|�?Y�����p�c�u{��eg~�n^xzu�e�k7c��)��X.�?crYzYln^u�p{�§~�e�~�u�°¾jln^u{e�Yz� �%c�Y�f ���~�crYHfRa�n^Yzn|wznz�%X)Y0ÁZ?±�3"u{wz�?t � p{e�u��

:"; �bCF<"I ;%T��2GH>SRb<bJXT"; I�J R"I R NQCFaST JKY T"; I�J 0 T Y T Y ^ T"� � G >�<4THR?RbJK;A^�;%T��2GH>F;FR�JK;I N T T CFG?@ JXTHR"I7CF;ZY � >SR"I���� ;ZYFC � T ; I�CA@FR"I�C ^ THR�>� IKN T � G >�<4THR?RbJK;A^ � J � T?@DJK;%T

Zb,

Page 11: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

� � >F; L6NQJK< N � C �.� CA@ JKCF; a J R��2CA@ � GH>�<4THR?RbJK; ^ J R E�� JB@ I�����UO NQJ R.CFG?I�JK<4@ T J R� >AI�JKa CAIUT Y E�� ��� ;QYFC � T"; I�CA@9-�� T R"I�JK>F; R <?>F;Z<4T"G";ZJK;A^5IKN T � CAIKN T � CAI�JK<?CA@G T � G?THR�T"; I�CAI�JK>F;�>�&>FE ��T <"I R <?>F; I�CFJK;A^�T Y ^ T R�;�L NQCAI�J R�IKN T R � CFGHR�THR"I8G T � �G THR�T";2I�CAI�JK>F;�>� ��� ;Z<"I�JK>F; R¶��Ï�� �"!?� $�Ð�I NQCAI8<?>F; I�CFJK;/R � >�>AIKN/G T ^FJK>F;FR&E�� ICA@1Rb> T Y ^ THR �

� K�LTQ� `� bLTQ� ®LNM���P � ��PWL� ®LNM �ÅL�� �b� �V��

*£wl�?Ybe�u-���Beg~�u�~�`A:";ZY T � T ;ZY T"; IR��> ��� >F;%T";2I$H&;ZCA@,� RbJ R-e�k�xzp�nrd:�§~Bn^Y � G"JK;Z< J � CA@���> � �� >F;%T ; I H&;QCA@,� RbJ R��DX)Y���n^u�w��?c|~���~�` � ��c�p{���|e�d:�?Y©c®��n^��������u�e�n^Y ��Ã����¤Ï���Ð#! � ' ���n�m�d:�§��u{n|p�~�¤Ï���Ðb���?��n^Yz�|e�Yz�Tu�nT~�n^k��7Ê�e������?p�u�~�x�c|���� c�Y�f�c�xzp{n|��cr�le���e�u�tT��c ��� Ï ��Ð�n^Y ��¦-¡�wle�~�xzp{n|��cr�ze���e�u�t���c � e�YHfBe��?c�u{��~�wln � ��e��:�?��tNc�~�x�����eÁ«I��e�k7c��^�be�~�u{n���mon|jzY�fWe�Y �.¦2*¯��~�wHcr����c^~�~�jzk���u{wHcru�u�wz�b����YBu��?pnrmD�^p�c?dBe�u�t���Ã�������Ï ��Ð �� Ï ��Ðn�m ��eg~ ,5��XÑm � � ! � ' ��!ze�~�c�Y�n^p�u{wzn|Yzn^p�k7cr�D��c^~�e�~n�m� ! � ��fB�?Yln^u{���Bt�� � Ï �Ð�Ã� 0 $�� � � ������� � (�� ���"$ $ 3�u�wz���?�5x}�§��u{��f ~{°:j�crp���f �?p�p{n|pTe�Y[u{wz���?�5x�c�Y�~�e�n^Y8n�m� ' �.¦b¡�wz�?Y u{wz���bcrp�wBjzYl�?YB¨�´�n ��?d:���Hc^~�eg~ eg~R�zjle���u c^~Rmon|����n � ~�Ëiu{wl�¥d:�§��u{n|p�~� � !"� � !+)+)*)S! � � !+)*)+)�c�p{��e�Y�f5j���u{e�d:�?��t�fB��«�Yz��f0�5t£p{��°:jze�p�e�Yz��u{w�c�uTu{wz�¤Yz�?�5u��?p�p{n^p� ��� � Ï �DÐ�e�~®k�e�Yze�kWe�È?�?f7�BtTu�wz�7��wzn^eg����nrm'� � � � ¦XÑm � ��crp{���^e�d:��Y�c!����n|j�f�� ��n^Y5¨~�e�~�u{e�Yl��nrm"! x�n^e�YBu�~� ' =$#�!�Z ��� �%!=!DcrY�f¯eÁm�u{wz�$���?Y5u{�?p�n�m��|p�c?d5e�u�t��n�m � e�~ ,B` � �����?u'& ���7u{wz����e�Yl�Wu�wzp{n|jz�^w , � wzeg�¬w�xzp{n�d5e�fB�§~®j�~ � e�u{w�u�wz������~�u«Huu�n ��c�Y�f � ����n|Y�~�egfB�?p�u{wz�bw5tBx��?p�xz��c�Yz�'( � wzeg�¬w!e�~�x��?p{x��?Y�f5e���jz�gcrp�u�n)&�¦ *��u�wz�?Y ��n^Y�~�e�fB��pWu�wz��n|p{u{wln^�^n|Y�cr��xzp{n�¢{�§��u{e�n^Y � ��n�m �[n^Y*( c�Y�f � �7xzp�n5���?��f�n^Yu�wze�~�Yz� � ����n^j�f7nrm.x�n^e�YBu�~���XÑm ��eg~¶u�wz�bjzYze�u���jl�}� 0 ��Z,+�±2!?Z,+§±S3 #�- = # ��°¾jle�xzx���f� e�u{wNu{wz��´����}�§~��^jl��k���c|~�jzp��:`ru�wz�?Y�crY5t�n^p�u{wzn|Yzn^p�k7cr�z�Hc^~�eg~²n�m@= # eg~c.��´���c^~�e�~��¡�wl��~�����n|Y�f¥n|p�fB�?pN~�u�c�u{e�~�u{eg�?~�nrmbu�wz�7��jl�}� crY�f�u�wz�7��cr����crp{�!e�fB��YBu�e��?c��)��X)Y¼mojl�����n^Y5u{p�c|~�u � e�u{w�u�wze�~.jzY�fB�?u��?p{k�e�Y�c�u{e�n|Y"`Z:";ZY T � T ;ZY T"; I ��> ��� >F; T"; I H&;ZCA@,� RbJ R�t5e��?�gfz~u�wz��p{e��^w5u��Hc^~�eg~u{n^�|�?u{wl�?p � e�u�w�u�wz����n^p�p{����u�e�YBmon^p�k7cru�e�n^Y�u{w�c�u.cb��jz����eg~�Yzn|u.c���cr���)�´��?u�j�~WYzn � ��n^YH~�e�f5�?p�: ;ZY T � T";ZY T ; I ��> ��� >F;%T ; I#H&;ZCA@,� RbJ R��)��~Ne�Yqu�wz�/��´

f5����n^k�x}n�~�e�u{e�n|Y"` � ��c�p{��~�u{j�f5tBe�Yz��c�m­crk�e���t �¤Ã0����Ï��FÐ?! � '�����nrm²~�e��|Y�cr�g~c�Y�f� ��crp{�b�|e�d:�?Y�xlp{n^�Hcr�ze���e�u�tN��c � �� Ï ��Ð%n^Y ��¦�¸zn^p�u{wl��~�cr�:�bnrmÎ~�e�k�xz��e���e�u�t|` � �É«Hp�~�uc|~{~�jzk��.Åà = # ¦-¡�wl�?Y1��Ï ��Ðà �"Ï �F!���Ð#!�Z ��� ���/! � '��`!}eg~�~{c�k�xz����f�n^Y�5Z !�± !*)+)+)�!"�)�5¦"³�Yz��eg~¶e�YBu��?p{�§~�u{�§fWe�Y!�BYzn � e�Yz��e¹mDu{wl��~��©~�e��|Y�cr�g~���n|jz��f7�}� � p{e�u{u{��Yc|~�c���e�Yz��c�p���n^kN�ze�Y�c�u{e�n^YTnrm32 e�YHfB�?x��?Y�fB��YBub~�n^jzp�����~54 ��Ï���Ð#!?¦�¦�¦B!�4���Ï ��Ð?! �P'���¦

Z|Z

Page 12: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

*��bu{wz��Y � n^jz�gf�w�c?d:�

�"Ï �F!���ÐDÃ���C � > % � 4 % Ï���Ð Ï�Z ���$� ��Ð Ï{ZrÐ

� wl�?p{�7u{wl�Rk$cru{p�e�� ! ÃÅÏ8C � > % � ÐH� �� � # � � % ��� e�~NfB�?u��?p{k�e�Yze�~�e�����XÍY�n|u{wz�?p � n^p�fz~�¤Ï���ÐNà !��%Ï��FÐ?!#� ' �`! � wl�?p{����Ï ��Ð?! � ' �`!eg~�u{wz���^e�d:��Y���n^��������u{e�n|Y�c�Y�f� wl�?p{�b��n^u�w�u{wl� � 5�2 k$cru{p�e�� ![crYHfRu{wl��~�n^jzp�����~��%Ï���ÐFcrp��®jlYz�BYln � Y�� *£wz��Ye�u��?�5e�~�u�~�`5u{wz��:��AH fB����n^k�x�n:~�e�u�e�n^Y7n�m.cN~�u�n5�¬w�c|~�u�e���xzp{n5����~{~ ��Ï��4!���Ð?! � ' 0 � !*�?3�!:e�~f5��«�Yz��f�e�Y�cN~�e�k�e��gcrp � c?t7c�Y�f�p{��c|fz~

��Ï��4!���Ð.à ���C %�Ï���ÐÍ�/%�Ï���Ð Ï)±¾Ð

� wl�?p{��u{wz��p�crYHfBn^k d^c�p{egcr�z����~�C % Ï ��Ð�c�p{��e�Y�fB�?x��?Y�f5�?YBu��v:e�k�e��gcrp{��t�c ��´¤fB����n|kW¨x�n�~�e�u�e�n|YTtBe��?��fz~�cN~���p{e��§~¶�?�5x�c�Y�~�e�n^Y�Ï­±¾Ð � wl�?p{��u{wz�bp�c�Y�fBn|k d|crp�e�cr�l����~�C % Ï���ÐFcrp��n|p{u�wzn^�|n^Y�c�� � e�u{w!p{��~�x}�§��uu�n�u{wl��xzp�n^��c��ze���e�u�t7��c � ��XÍYTu�wz� ��c�j�~{~�e�crY���c^~���`"c ��´f5����n^k�x}n�~�e�u{e�n|Y�e�~�c�� � c§tl~�crY�:��AH �zX)Y7�^��Yz�?p�c��"u{wz��t7fBe��I�?p��

h�n�~�u®m­c�k�e���e���~ ��nrm�~�e��^YHcr��~�fBn�Yln^u�wHc§d:�Nc�Y :��AH �"¡�wl��~���eg~�u{wz�N��c^f�Yz� � ~��½�jlu�e¹m :��AH£�?�5e�~�u�~�`Be�u��lp{e�Yl�:~�c���n^u�n�m.e�Y5mon^p{k$cru{e�n^Y"�DÊ�?p��bcrp��®u � n��?�zc�k�xz����~��³�jzp�«�p�~�u����zc�k�xz���!e�~�u{wl�¯p�crk�x£xzp�n5����~�~���¡�wz��p�crk�x£xlp{n5����~�~ �¤Ï��"!���ÐNe�~

e�Y�fB�?�5��f£�Bt � ' 0 , !?Z"3�crYHf0fB��«�Yl��fi�5t �¤Ï��"!���Ð�à � ~�e , � � E � c�Y�f�¤Ï��"!���Ð.ÃD����Z[~�e � � � �[Z^¦lX­m c.�bcrp�wBjlYz�?YB¨�´�n ��?d:�ÉfB����n|k�x�n:~�e�u{e�n^YNe�~.crxzxl��e��§fu�nWu�wz�bp�c�k�x"`Bu�wz�bp{��~�jz��u�eg~�u{wz�bu�p{e��|n^Yzn|k��?u�p{e���~�tl~�u��?k�~�e�Y"Ï82 � ��Ð?!42 �[ZA!�c�Y�fRu�wze�~p��?xzp���~��?Y5u�c�u{e�n^YNe�~�~�j��I�?p{e�Yz�®mop�n^k�u � n�k$cre�YNf5p�c � ��c^���l~��.X)u�eg~²~���n � crYHfRf5n:��~²Yzn|uxlp{n�dBegfB�Nu{wz�Np{e��^w5u�e�Y5mon^p{k$cru{e�n^Y�Ï � wze���w¯eg~®u�wz��¢{jlk�x�f5e�~{��n^Y5u{e�Y5jze�u�t!c�u ��Ð��7½�jzu: �AHyfBn:��~�Yzn|u�?�5e�~�u²mon|pu�wz�bp�crk�x"�²³�Yz���?c�YzYzn^u � p{e�u{�

��Ï��"!���Ð.à ���C %|Ï���Ð���%?Ï���Ð Ï)Ò¾Ð

� wl�?p{��� %�Ï���Щcrp���e�YHfB�?x��?Y�fB��YBu�p�crY�fBn|k d|crp�cregcr�z����~��y¡�wz�!�}�§~�uNn^Yz� �?crYyfBn�e�~u�nNcrxzxl��t�crYTc����|n^p{e�u{wzk � wzeg�¬w�t5e�����fz~u{wl�®e�Y�fB�?x��?YHfB�?Y5u���n|k�x�n^Yz�?Y5u�~ � wz�?Y�u�wz��~����n^k�x�n^Yl�?YBu�~²�?�5e�~�u?�.¡�wz��YRu�wz��:��AH CA@ ^F>FG"JBIKN � xzp�n�dBegfB��~�j�~ � e�u{w7u{wz� � c§d:�����?uF~���¨p�e���~"�?�5x�crYH~�e�n|Y�nrmIu{wl��p�crk�x"��¡�wz����n|YBd:��p{�^��Y����%~�x��?��f�eg~��?�5x�n^Yz�?Y5u{egcr�­��¡�wle�~�����c^fz~u�n7u{wz�N��n|Y�����j�~�e�n^YTu{wHcru : �AHÆcr���|n^p�e�u{wlk7~f5nRu�wz�?e�p����~�u � wl�?YTu{wz��tTcrp��Ncrxzxl��e��§f

Z�±

Page 13: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

u�n�~�e��|Y�cr�g~ � e�u{w!~�u{p{n|Yz��u�p�crYH~�e���YBu�~�n^p�u{nNe�k$cr�^�§~��¡�wz��~��§��n^Y�f����zc�k�xz���%e�~�u�wz��jzYze�u.��jz���:�.¡�wl�?Y�u{wz�`: �AH�nrm�u{wz����jl�}��eg~jzYze�°:jz�

ÏojzxNu{n�c�x��?p�kWjzu�cru�e�n^YIÐ�crY�fNtBe��?��fz~"u{wl�k�n�~�u%��n|Y���e�~���crY�fNk���crYle�YBmojz�lfB��~���p{e�xzu{e�n^Yn�m�c7��jz���:�©¡�wz�N~�n|jzp����§~®c�p{��wz��p{��u{wl�Wj�~�j�cr�Î��n:n^p�fBe�Y�c�u{��~�`�u�wz��k7cru�p{e���!8eg~u{wl�egfB�?Y5u{e�u�t�`.crY�f�u{wz� ��jz����eg~WfB��«�Yz��f��BtD��Z,+§± � � � Z�+�±2!�Z�� � � ��¦¶´��?ujH~�~�u{p���~{~�u�w�cruNc1��´��?�5x�c�Y�~�e�n^Y�e�~�c�Y(: �AH8e�Y�u{wl� ��crj�~�~�e�c�Y£�?c|~��:`.~�e�Y�����u{wz��Ye�Y�fB�?x��?YHfB�?Y����Ne�~be�k�xl��e��§f��BtTn|p{u{wln^�^n|Y�cr��e�u�t:��¡�wz��p�crk�x�xzp�n5����~{~�c�Y�f�u{wz��jzYze�u��jz����c�p{�bYzn|u���crjH~{~�egcrYTxzp�n5����~�~���~��

� ��� � ���� �O���� STQTV�L���� �bM� � V � PRQ� �

¡�wl�RxHcrp�c|fBe��|k nrm CAI�> � JK< Y T <?> ��� >SRbJBI�JK>F;FR � c^~�~��?k�e�Y�cr�.e�Y¤u{wz�7xzp�������fBe�Yz�T~����¬¨u�e�n|Y�~�� ��u{n^k�e��bfB����n|k�x�n:~�e�u{e�n^Y�~�crp{�N�zp�e�fB�|e�Yz�7u{wl���:crx¤�}��u � �?�?Y���n|k�xzjzu�cru�e�n^YHcr�k��?u{wzn5fl~®c�Y�f¯Yz��jzp{n|xzwBtl~�e�n^��n^�^t�� *��WYzn � u�cr�:��crYzn|u{wz�?pbp�n:c^f�c�Y�f¯~�u{j�f5t�~�n^k��d|c�p{e�c�u{e�n^Y�c���crxzxzp�n:c|�¬wz�§~ªu�nTe�k7c��^�7c�Y�cr��tz~�e�~��¤¡�wz�T³�~�wz�?p�¨�µ�j�fBe�YB¨Í¸}c�u{�?k�e²k�n5fB�?�Ï�³�µ¸²Ð � e����"����~�e�Yz�|����f�n|jzu?��X)Y!u{wzeg~¶k�n5f5�?�)`lcrY�e�k7cr�|� � e����"����d5e�� � ��f�c^~�~�n^k���¨u�wze�Yl�Ru�w�cru��?c�Y¯����fBp�c � Y��Bt c�x�cre�YBu��?p?�����?jzp{n|xzw5tz~�e�n^��n^�|t�e�~�p��?xz��c|����f��5tTc�p{u?�X)Y�f5�?��f�u{wl�?t���n^u{w�p{�?��t�n^Y�u{wz��p{�?k$crp{�|c��z����xzp�n^x��?p�u{e��§~În�m"u�wz�w5jzk7c�Y��zp�c�e�Y"�.¡�wl�³�µ�¸¥k�n5f5�?�-eg~¶k�n|u{e�d^c�u{��fN�Bt7e����¹¨­x�n:~��§fRe�Y5d:�?p�~���xzp�n^�z���?k7~%crY�f�u�wz�����8Yzn|p{k�e�~cNp{�?�|jz��c�p{e�ȧcru{e�n^Y � wzeg�¬w!xzp{��~��?p{d:�§~���fB�^�§~ 0 �A� 3­��a�?Yzn|e�~�e�Yz��eg~c�x�crp�u{eg��jz��c�p���zc�kW¨xl���:� ��~�e�u � e����"����xzp�nrd:�§f$e�Y�u�wz��~���Yzn^u���~�` O N T � R?N T"G"�3 �2YFJK;)�35 CAIUT � J CA@ ^ >FG4JBIKN �J R JK;ZY T?T Y � T"G!�b>FG � JK;A^�C]IKNQG THR?NQ>A@DYFJK;A^ L NQJK<?N J R RbJ � JB@DCFG I�>�I N T L�CFaST?@BT#I R?NQG"JK;2���C ^2T�Y T!0 ; T Y E��QC CFa JKY C >F;Z>SNQ>^��h�n|p{��xlp{����eg~��?��tTu{wz�!³�µ�¸0c����^n|p{e�u{wzk wHc^~�u{wl�mon|����n � e�Yz��xzp�n^x��?p�u�tIË�u{wl�?p{���?�5e�~�u�~�cNYzn^p�k $ ) $�bcrY�f�c�u{wzp���~�wln^��f �$ � ~�j���wTu{w�c�uc�Y¯e�k7cr�|�N� � e�u{w¤c�Yzn^p�k $�� $� � �$ � eg~�xzjzubu{n�,7crY�f¤crY�e�k7c��^� � e�u�w�c�Yzn|p{k�gcrp��^�?p�u{w�c�YTu{wz��u{wzp���~�wln^��f7e�~�p{��f5j�����f��5t�c�«��5��f�c�k�n^jlYBubÏ­~��?�©¡�wz�?n^p��?k ±Wc�Y�fe�u�~u � n���n|p{n^����c�p{e��§~¬Ð��D¡�wze�~.e�~.~�e�k�e��gcrpu�n�an^Yzn|wznzÂÇ~ � c?d:�?���?u.~�wlp{e�Yl�^c��^�:�.¡�wl�®³�µ�¸c����|n^p{e�u{wzk �?c�Y�����d5e�� � ��f7c^~����?e�Yl��c�~�wzp{e�Yz�|cr�|� � wz�?p���u�wz���?k�xzw�c^~�e�~�eg~�xzjzu�n^Yu�wz���|�?n^k���u{p{t��Ê�?p�����n^k���~.u{wz����c^f�Yz� � ~���¡�wl��³�µ¸�cr���^n|p{e�u�wzk crY�f!an^Yzn|wznzÂÇ~� c?d:�?���?u�~�wzp{e�Yz�|cr�^�7xzp���~���YBubu{wl��~�crk���fBp�c � �Hc^���-��X)Y�cT~�tl~�u��?k7c�u{e�� � c?t�xze��§����~� wle���wW���?��n^Yz��u{n�u�wz��u�p{jz��n^�5¢{����u�~.��n^Y5u�c�e�Yz�§fWe�Y�crY�e�k7cr�|��crp�� � e�x���fWn|jzu��5t�u{wl�c����|n^p{e�u{wzk c�Y�f�dBe�� � �§fRc|~���?��n|Yz�^e�Yz�Nu{n�u�wz��u��?�Bu�jzp{�§fR��n^k�x�n^Yl�?YBu���¡�wz�W³�~�wl�?p�¨Ó.��~��bcr���^n|p{e�u�wzk�x��?p�mon|p{k7~.�}��u{u{��pbÏ)¡�wz�?n|p{�?k Z^ZrÐ��¡�wz��³�µ�¸qk�n5fB�?�"eg~�c�~�e�k�xz��e¹«��§f$d|c�p{e�c�YBu�n^YTu{wl�Nh�jzkWmon^p�f7º v:wHcrw�k�n5fB�?�­�

Z�Ò

Page 14: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

X)YT��n^u�wTk�n5fB�?�g~�`Ic��^e�d:��Y�e�k$cr�^�beg~n^xzu�e�k7c�����t7~�xz��e�u�e�Y5u{n�u � n�x�crp�u�~���crYHfT�}¦IX)Yu�wz�!h�jzkWmon|p�f�º v:wHcrwqk�n5fB�?�)`u�wz�7�^e�d:�?Y�e�k7c��^�7�£e�~�fB��«�Yz��f�n�d:�?pNc�fBn^k7c�e�Y��`zu�wz���!��n^k�x}n|Yz�?Y5u����?��n^Yz��~u{nNu{wz��~�jz��~�xHc^��� � ���[n�m ����` � wle���w���n^Y�~�e�~�u�~¶n�mmojlY���u{e�n^Y�~be�Y ��� � wzn:~��!fBe�~�u{p{e��zjzu�e�n^YHcr���|p�c|fBe��?Y5u�f5n:��~�Yzn^uN��n^Y5u�cre�Y�cT~�e�Yz�^jl��crpf5e��Ij�~���k���c^~�jzp{�:��X)YTn^u�wz�?p � n|p�fz~�` u�wze�~�fBeg~�u{p�e��zjlu{e�n|Y�cr���^p�c^fBe��?Y5u�����e�~�u{wl�N~�jzk���?u � �?�?Y�crY�< � mojlY���u{e�n^Y7c�Y�f�cbk���c^~�jzp{����crp{p�e���f��5tNc®n^Yl�bfBe�k��?Y�~�e�n^Y�c���~�e�Yz�^jl��crp~��?u����.¡�wz�?Y!u{wz�Éh�jzkWmon^p�f�º v:w�c�w7x}��Y�cr��u�t�n^Y�u�wz���"Ï��-Ð.��n|k�x�n^Yz��YBu%e�~�cN~�jzk�ÎÏ)�-Ð����?u � ���?Y�u � nTu��?p{k7~���¡�wz�W«�p�~�uNu{�?p�k eg~®u{wl�Rn|Yz��¨ÍfBe�k��?Y�~�e�n^Y�c���Ê�c�j�~{f5n^p �k���c^~�jzp{��n�m�����¡�wz�©~�����n^Y�f7n^Yz��e�~�u{wz��~{°:j�c�p{��n�m.u{wl�1< $ Yzn|p{kÌn�m�u�wz�b�^p�c^fBe��?YBun�mN�"Ï��-ÐN��cr����jz��c�u{��f�n^Yyu{wz�¤��n^k�xz���?kN�?Y5u�n�m�u{wle�~�~�e�Yz�|jz��c�p�~��?u���� ¡�wz�Tu�wze�p�fu��?p{k�n�m�u{wl���.Ï­��Ð%mojzY���u�e�n^YHcr��e�~u�wz�N~{°:j�crp���nrm%u{wl�#< $ Yzn|p{k nrmF�}Ï��-Ð�¦I¡�wz�?YTu{wl�mojlY���u{e�n^Y�c��"u{nN���®k�e�Yze�kWe�È?�?f�e�~

�.Ï)�-ÐÃ� �� � � ��� � $ � ���;C � Ï��TÐ"��� $�� $ $���� wl�?p{� � Ï��TÐÉfB�?Yzn|u{��~�u�wz��Z�¨�f5e�k��?YH~�e�n|Y�cr�ÎÊ�crj�~�fBn^p �£k��§c^~�jlp{��nrm��7¦¡�wl�Wu � nx�n�~�e�u�e�d:�bx�c�p�crk��?u{�?p�~ C�crY�f���Yl�?��f�u{n�����u{jzYz�§f$� �-�§��u{e�d:�?��t:����~�e�~�u{wz�©�?c^~��®mon^pu�wz�Nx�crp�crk��?u��?p���e�Y�u�wz�R³�~�wz�?p�¨Íµ�j�fBe�Y5¨�¸�cru��?k�ek�n5fB�?�)`"eÁm�C£e�~�~�k7cr���)`-u�wz�?Y�u�n:nk$crY5tWn|�5¢{����u�~ � e����I�}��fB��u{����u���f-�¡�wzeg~k�n5fB���"p�creg~���~�����crjlu{e¹mojl��k7c�u{wz��k7cru�e��?c��}xlp{n^�l���?k7~ � wle���w�w�c?d:�bkWjH�¬w7u{nf5n � e�u{w�u�wz�.u{wz��n^p{tbn�m�k�e�Yle�k7c���~�jzp�m­c^���§~ 0 ±^±S3­�X)Y�u�wz�%h�jzkWmon|p�fbcrY�f�v:w�c�w�k�n5fB�?�­`u��?�5u{jzp���~�crp��®u�p{��c�u{��f7c|~¶Yzn|e�~��:�¡�wz��³�µ�¸qk�n5fB�?�De�~�~�e�k�e���crp��`�YTe�k7cr�|����Ï��-Ð�e�~�cr�:c�e�Y�c�~�jzk ���?u � ���?Y�u � n��n^k�x�n^Yl�?YBu�~���c�Y�f���¦�¡�wz�®«Hp�~�u���n^k�x�n^Yl�?YBu��7u�c��:��~��crp{�bn�m.u{wz�bn|�5¢{����u�~ � wzeg�¬wc�p{��e�Y�����j�fB��fNe�Y�u�wz�b�^e�d:�?Y7e�k7c��^�b�-¦�¡�wl��~���n^�5¢{����u�~��?crY!����w5jzk7crY7���?e�Yz�:~�`-c�Yze¹¨

k$cr��~�`5~�n^k��mojzp{Yle�u{jlp{��n|p�n^u{wl�?p�e�u��?k7~���¡�wz�bk7c�e�Y�c^~�~�jzk�xlu{e�n|Y!��n^Y����?p{Yze�Yz��u�wz��~��n|�5¢{����u�~²~�c?tz~.u{w�c�u�u{wl�?t���crY�����fBp�c � Y7�BtNcbx�cre�YBu��?p%~�e�Y�����u{wz�?tNc�p{�bf5�?��e�k�e�u���f��Bt~�n^k�����n^jzY�flcrp{e���~ � wze���wTw�c?d:�®«HYze�u������?Yz�|u{w�~���¡�wle�~n|��~��?p�d|cru{e�n^Y�e�Y�f5e��?c�u{��~�u{w�c�uu�wz��~�x�c|��������n�m�mojzY���u{e�n|Y�~�nrmF�}n|jzY�fB�§f¯d|crp{egcru�e�n^Y � e����xz�gc§t�c��:�?t!p{n|���Ne�YTu{wl�³�µ�¸�k�n5fB�?�­��¡�wze�~ � e����z������n|k���������crp��?peÁm"~�n^k���xlp{n^x��?p�u{e���~nrm���� crp{��p{��dBe�� � ��fI�

³�Yz��eg~¶u��?k�xzu���f�u{n7~�c§t!u{w�c�u�u{wl��e�Y�fBeg�?cru�n^p�mojzY���u�e�n|Y����DÏ��-Ð�nrmFc�f5n^k7c�e�Y ����?��n^Yz��~¶u�n�u{wl��~�x�c^��� ���[nrmDmojzY���u�e�n^YH~¶n�m.��n^jzY�f5��f�d|crp{egcru�e�n^Y!e¹mÎcrY�f7n^Yz��t7e¹mDe�u�~��n|jzY�fzc�p{t�� � w�c^~�c®«�Yze�u{�����?Yz�^u�w!crY�f�u{wHcru�u{wz� ���[Yln^p{k nrm����DÏ��-Ð.��°:j�cr�g~²u{wl����?Yz�|u{w7nrm.u�wz�b��n^jzY�flcrp{t���¡�wze�~�~�u�cru��?k��?Y5u�eg~�������c�p{��tWd|cr��e�f�e�Y7u�wz� � � �?c|~��b�zjzu�e�~

Z �

Page 15: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

Yln^u.u{p�jz�e�YW�|�?Yz�?p�cr�­�¡�wz� ���yYzn^p�k � e����l�}��~�n:n|Y!fB��«�Yz�§f-�X)YNn^p�f5�?p.u{nbu{p���cru.u{wl��|�?Yz�?p�cr�.��c^~���`-a� ��e�n^p{�|e.fB��«HYz��f�u{wl��p{�§fBj�����f���n|jzY�fzc�p{t � � � nrmFcWk���c^~�jzp�c��z���~��?u���c�Y�f¯xzp�nrd:�§f u�w�crubu{wl� ����Yzn^p�k nrm�� �qe�~�u�wz��Z�¨�f5e�k��?YH~�e�n|Y�cr�%Ê�c�j�~{f5n^p �k���c^~�jzp{��n�me�u�~�p���fBj����§f$��n|jzY�fzc�p{t:�¸zn^p!fB��«�Yze�Yl��u{wzeg~�p{��fBjH����f¥��n|jzY�fzc�p{t:`����?u�j�~7fB�?Yln^u{�T�5tM�NÏ��6!��^Ð�u{wz�T�Hcr���

���?YBu��?p{�§f�cru�� � e�u{w7p�c^fBe�j�~���¦ *��bu{wz��YRmon^����n � a� �e�n^p��^e)Ë����������� ����� O N T G?T Y�� <4T Y E?>��2;ZYFCFG�� � � �P>� � J R IKN T�R�T?I�>� � >FJK; IKR�� E4T#@ >F;A^FJK;A^IKN T <4@ >SR�T Y R�� ��� >FG I�>���TÃ��� � R�� < N�IKNQCAI�I N T �b>A@ @ >FL�JK;A^ @DJ � JBI T�� J R"IKR

��e�k��� �

� �F�NÏ��6!��^Ð��� �'� �F�NÏ��6!��^Ð � Ã��-Ï��-Ð Ï � Ð

�YTe�Y�fBeg�?cru�n^p�mojzY���u�e�n|Y��������?��n|Yz�:~�u�n]��� e¹mFcrY�fTn^Yl��tTe¹m � � � w�c|~�cW«�Yze�u{�Z�¨�f5e�k��?YH~�e�n|Y�cr�HÊ�crj�~�fBn^p �!k���c^~�jzp{���h�n^p���|�?Yz�?p�cr����t�cmojzYH��u{e�n^Y���Ï��-ÐDfB��«HYz��f�n^Y= $ ���?��n|Yz�:~�u�n ��� e¹mbÏ­c¾ÐÉ��Ï��-Ð�d^c�Yze�~�wz��~�cru�e�YB«�Yze�u�tTe�Y¤c � �§cr�¤~��?Y�~���c�Y�f£ÏÑ�-Ðu�wz�7fBeg~�u�p{e��ljzu{e�n^Y�c����^p�c^fBe��?Y5u ���¥n�mb��Ï��-Ð�eg~�c¯ÏÑd:�§��u{n|p�d|cr��jz��f}Ð��}n|jzY�fB�§fq½�n^p��?�k���c^~�jzp{�:� �Y£c�xzx�crp��?Y5u{��t � ��cr�:�?pNf5��«�Yze�u{e�n|Y�p{��c|fz~�c^~�mon^����n � ~�ËT�i���?��n^Yz��~Wu{n���yeÁm-e�u�~.fBeg~�u{p�e��zjlu{e�n|Y�cr�l�^p�c|fBe���YBu.e�~DcªÏod:����u�n^pd|cr��jz��f}Ð���n^jlY�fB��f�½�n|p{�?�lk���c^~�jzp{���¡�wl�?Y7e�~�e�~���c|~�e���tWxlp{n�d:��f�u{w�c�u���Ã��©��( � wz��p{� (�e�~�cN��n^Y�~�u�c�YBu�crY�f���u��?Y�fz~�u{n,Ncru�e�YB«�Yze�u�tWe�YRu�wz� � ��c��7~���Y�~��:�.h�n|p{�?n�d:�?p �7���?��n|Yz�:~�u{n#< $ Ï8= $ Ð%crY�f � �bw�c?d:�

$ � $"$ �Z±�� � $�� $���� Ï)_¾Ð

¡�wl��xzp{n:n�m.nrmFÏ)_:Ð.p{�?��e���~n|YRu�wz�b��n�¨�c�p{��c�egfB�?Y5u{e�u�t©crY�f � e����-���bf5�?��c?t:��fNc§mou��?p�¡�wz��¨n|p{�?k Z^�¡�wz����n^Y�fBe�u{e�n^Y£c�u�e�Y5«�Yze�u�t�~{c?tl~ªu�w�cru$�����8u{�?Y�fl~ªu�n ,�cru�e�YB«�Yle�u�t � wz�?YB¨��d:�?p � eg~Wc mojlY���u{e�n^Y�e�Yqu�wz�Tv5��w � crp{u�ÈT���gc^~�~��y¸zn^pNe�Y�~�u�crYH���:`�c�YBt�mojzY���u{e�n|Yqe�Y

<"!|Ï8= $ Ð#!�Z �$# E&% ! u��?Y�fz~bu{n ,�cru�e�YB«HYze�u�t�e�Y¯u�wze�~ � ��c���~��?YH~��:���Y���°¾jle�d|c§¨���?Y5u�fB��«�Yze�u�e�n|YTnrm`��� e�~�|e�d:�?Y!�Bt!u{wz��mon|����n � e�Yz��n^�H~��?p�d^c�u{e�n^Y"��XÑmF�¯���?��n^Yz��~®u{n���8!Bu�wz�?Y�u�wz�?p����?�5e�~�u�~.c���n^Y�~�u�c�YBu � ~�j���w�u{wHcru�mon^p���d:�?p{t©��n^k�xHc^��u���tN~�jlxzx�n^p{u���f��n^Y5u{e�Y5jzn|j�~FmojlY���u{e�n^Y�� !zu{wz�©��n^Y5d:n^��jzu{e�n^Y7xzp{n5f5j���u('�à �)� �7���?��n^Yz��~u{n�� � c�Y�f~�cru�e�~Í«H��~�$ �*'$ � � � $ � $ � ¦ �.n|YBd:�?p�~��?��tWu�wze�~�xlp{n^x��?p�u�t���w�c�p�c^��u{�?p�e�È?��~ ���D¦

*£wz��Y�u{wl�W³�~�wz��p�¨Íµ¶j�f5e�YB¨Í¸�cru{��k�e-k�n5f5�?�"e�~����?e�Yz�Nj�~���f-`IcW~�x}�§��e¹«I�bfB��«�Yze�u�e�n|Yn�mbu{wl� ��� Yzn^p�k eg~W��p{j���egcr����t�Yz�?��fB�§f-�£X)Y�fB�?�§f¼u�wz�¯³�µ�¸0k�n5fB�?��c�k�n^jzY5u�~�u{n

Z�_

Page 16: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

k�e�Yze�kWe�È?eÁYz��c©mojzYH��u{e�n^Y�c�� � wze���w7��n|YBu�cre�YH~¶u�wze�~ ���[Yzn|p{kT�7*¯� � e����-e�k�x�n:~���u{w�c�uu�wze�~Yzn|p{k�����e�~�n^u{p�n^xzeg�^�²´���u�j�~.�}���^e�Y��Bt�u�wz��~�e�k�xl�����?c|~�� � wz�?p{� �����}����n^Yl�:~�u{n< � Ï8= $ Ð�¦:¡�wz�?Y�u{wz�`����¨)Yzn|p{kÆnrm�� � e����:����fB��«�Yz�§f�c^~ $�� $��"� Ã � � ����Ï��-Ð � � � ¦�*��u�wz�?Y � p{e�u{���]' �� �� � crY�f�u{wzeg~ÎmojzYH��u{e�n^Y�~�x�c|��� � e����z����jH~���mojz��e�Y � w�c�u²mon|����n � ~��XÑm��� eg~�cW�^��Yz�?p�c��½�n|p{�?�"k���c^~�jzp{�:`zn|jzpb~�e�k�xz��t�k�e�Y�fB��f�c�xzxzp�n:c^��w¤fBn:��~Yzn|u � n|p{��ljzu�xHc§d:�.u�wz� � c§t�u{n�u�wz�mon^����n � e�Yz��fB��«�Yle�u{e�n^Y"�6*�� � p�e�u{� � �Ã����NcrYHf � �%fB��«�Yl�u�wz�b½�n|p{�?�Ik���c^~�jzp{�����Bt�� Ã � �7� ��� � � $ �À¦z½�tNu{wl��µ�c^f5n^YB¨ �e��:n5f5tBk�u{wz��n^p{��k � �wHc§d:� � �Ã�� �Ï���Ð�� ! ��à ZA!�±2! � wz�?p����"�Ï��-Ð�crp{�$½�n^p{���ÎmojlY���u{e�n^Y�~ � e�u�w�d|cr��jl��~®e�Y0���Z !?Z43­¦z¸�e�Y�cr����tNu{wz��½�n^p��?�"k���c|~�jzp���� �!Ï)� Ð �^eg~�fB��«�Yz�§f$�5t

� ��Ï)�"Ð �^à � $ � ��� $$ � Ï � Ð*����?crY ��n^Y�����j�fB��Ë

����������� ��� � O N T5��� ;Z>FG � >����J R�IKN T�I�>AI�CA@ � CSR?R >��IKN T �>FG T#@ � T CSR��2G T� ��Ï)�"Ð �Ǧ*£e�u{w¤crY�n|�Bd5e�n|j�~bcr�zjH~���n�m���crYl�^j�c��^�:` � � � p{e�u�� $�� $ �"� à � � � � � $ � � � $ � $ � � ¦*£e�u{w7u{wl��~��bYz� � Yzn|u�cru�e�n|Y�~¶u�wz����nr¨Ícrp���c�e�fB�?Y5u{e�u�tWp���c^fz~�c|~Fmon|����n � ~ 0 � 3­`70¹Z?_�3)���� � ������� �M_8T?I���Ï���Ð�E4T�C G T CA@ a CA@,�ZT Y � T CSR��2GHCFE"@BT ��� ;Q<4I�JK>F; Y T!0 ; T Y >F; IKN T� @DCF;%T CF;ZY E4T?@D>F;A^FJK;A^ I�>����¦+_8T?I8�AR Y T";Z>AIUT/E�� � �U!��&' = !8I N T � T CSR��2GHCFE"@BT R�T#IY T 0 ;%T Y�E��

� ��Ã�� ��'9= $ ����Ï��-Ð'� ��� Ï �^Ð_8T?I � � � ��E4T�IKN T G T Y��2<4T Y�E?>��2;ZYFCFG ��>��� ��CF;ZY 6�Ï���Ð�I N T <��UYFJ � T"; RbJK>F;QCA@�� C�� RbYF>FG! � T CSR��2G T � Ï � � � �)Ð�¦ O N T"; >F; T`NQCSR

$�� $��"� Ã � � �� �

6�Ï���Ð � � Ï)]¾ÐX)Y�n|u{wz��p � n|p�fz~�u�wz�b~�jzk n�mDcr���-u{wl�����?Yl�^u{wH~²nrm�u�wz�����?d:�?��~��?u�~.nrmÎ�Rt5e��?�gfz~u{wz� ���Yln^p{k[n�m"�I¦�¡�wze�~�egfB�?Y5u{e�u�t�Yz�?�§fz~ u�n�������n|k�xz���?u{��f � e�u{w�u{wz�.mon^����n � e�Yz��n^�H~��?p�d^c�u{e�n^Y

��Ï��-Ð.à ��e�k� ���0 � �� �� ��� Ï��-Ð � � � 253 Ï)\¾Ð

� wl�?p{�bu{wl�®��e�k�e�ue�~�u�cr�:�?Y � e�u{w7p{��~�x�����u�u{nNu{wl� � ��cr� � u{n^x�n|��n^�|t7nrm ���D¦

Z �

Page 17: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

� «�p�~�u�crxlxzp{n��5e�k7c�u{e�n|Y�u�n�u{wzeg~u{wl�?n^p��?k � c^~��^e�d:�?Y�e�YTu{wz��xze�n^Yz���?p{e�Yz� � n|p{��5t�¸����?k�e�Yz�Tc�Y�fqµ�e�~�wz�?��crYHfq¡�wz�?n|p{�?k Z � c|~W��n|k�xz���?u{��fT�5tqa�� ��e�n^p{�|e)�=��Yc|fBd5e�~��§f$p���mo�?p��?Y�����eg~ 0¹Zb,S3)�µ�n^jz�|wz��t ~�x���c��Be�Yz��¡�wz�?n|p{�?k ZT~�c?tz~�u{w�c�u7crY5t¥mojlY���u{e�n^Y �ie�Y ��� �?c�Y£���

� p�e�u�u{�?Y!c^~�c���n|YBd:�?����n|kW�ze�Y�cru�e�n|Y�nrm.e�Y�fBeg�?cru�n^p�mojzY���u{e�n|Y�~�nrmÎfBn|k7cre�Y�~ � e�u�wRp����¬¨u�e¹«Ic��z������n|jzY�fzc�p{e��§~���XÑmFcWx�n:~�e�u{e�d:�N��n^YH~�u�c�YBu � �?�5e�~�u�~~�j���wTu{w�c�u®u�wz��Yzn|p{k $�) $e�Y�c�mojzY���u�e�n|Y�cr�I½�crYHc^��w�~�x�c^��� �[~{c�u{eg~Í«���~"$ ���'$� � � Ï � � ��Ð"mon|p�crY5tN½�n^p��?�I~��?u�.!Bu�wz�?Y ��� e�~���n^Y5u�cre�Yz��f�e�Y �Æc�Y�f � ��w�c?d:��$�� $ � � $�� $��"��e�YNmojz�����^��Yz�?p�c���e�u�t��¡�wle�~�p{��k7crp���e�~�c�xzxz��e���f � wl�?Y � à < $ Ï8= $ Ð�¦z¡�wz��YRu�wz��eg~�n^x��?p�e�k���u{p{eg��e�Yz�§°¾j�c���e�u�tt5e�����fz~ � à �$�� $�� crYHfqu{wz�!xzp{n:n�m�n�m�Ï)_¾Ð©e�~N��n^k�xl���?u��:�qX)Y�k7crY5t��?�lcrk�xl����~�crYc���u��?p{Y�c�u{e�d:�®d:��p�~�e�n^Y!nrm�Ï)\:Ð�eg~j�~���mojz�)��XÑm%� ' ��� � ��f5�?Yzn^u����5t!� � crY�fT� � u{wl�mojlY���u{e�n^Y�~�~�jzx�Ï)��Ï��-Ð?!?,:Ð�crY�f�~�jzx"Ï&����Ï��-Ð?!?,:Ð�¦¡�wl�?Y�� � c�Y�f�� ���}n|u{w����?��n|Yz�Tu{n���D¦F*£wz�?Y��Reg~²cbYzn^Y5¨)Yz���:cru�e�d:��mojzY���u�e�n|YWe�Y����8!�Ï)\¾ÐDu�c��:��~u{wz��mon^����n � e�Yz��~�e�k�xz���mon|p{k���Ï���Ð�à � �� � � � Ï��-Ð � ��¦7� «HY�cr�%p{�?k7c�p{� ��n^Y����?p{Y�~bu{wz�$crxzxzp�n��Be�k7cru�e�n^YTn�mbcmojlY���u{e�n^Y!� ' ���[�5t�~�e�k�xz���¶mojlY���u{e�n^Y�~���´��?u�j�~�x�c?d:��u�wz�bxz��c�Yz� � e�u{w!��n^Yl�^p{jl�?YBu~�°¾jHcrp{�§~���Ï �F!42}Ð?! 25' : $ !|u{wz��~�e�È?��¨­����Yz�^u�w�nrm��©Ï �F!42}Ð��}��e�Yz�b± � !��5' ��¦S*���u{wz��YwHc§d:�� ���� �� � �� ��� �M: �N�P' ���8!&L T�Y T";Z>AIUT IKN T � T CF; abCA@,� T >�N�P>F;��©Ï �F!42�Ð�E��2TÏ �F!42}Ð&CF;ZY L T <?>F; RbJKY T"G�I N T�RbJ ��� @BT ��� ;Z<"I�JK>F;��� Y T!0 ; T Y�E������Ï��-Ð.à 2TÏ �F!42�Ð&>F;T CF<?N �©Ï �F!42�Ð�¦`O N T";�L T NQCFaST $��� $��"� � � $�� $���� CF;ZYW�� L T CB� @,��<?>F;ZaST"G ^ THR�I�>W�CSR � IUT";ZYSR I�>5JK;+0 ;ZJBI �2�¡�wl��~�e�k�xz���7xzp�n:nrm�n�m p{n|x�n:~�e�u{e�n^YÆZ eg~W����mouWu�n¥u�wz��p���c^f5�?p?� �Y£n^u�wz�?p�jH~���mojz�p��?k7c�p{�Ne�~��^e�d:�?Y��5t�u{wl�Émon|����n � e�Yz������k�k�c� ��� ��� �M:!� �BÏ��¬Ð J R�C _ J � Rb< NQJBI�DK��� ;Z<"I�JK>F;�>� I N T G T CA@2a CFG"JKCFE4@BT � CF;ZY J �.� ' ��� !IKN T";

$ �5Ï)�"Ð $ �"� � $ �� � � $ � $�� $ ��� Ï{Z ,:Ð

X)Y � w�c�u¶mon|����n � ~ �5Ï���Ðà ,�e¹m.� � ,2! �BÏ��¬ÐDÃD��eÁm�, � � �[Z !�crY�f �BÏ���Ðà Z�e¹m.���0Z^¦¡�wz�7³�µ¸£c����|n^p{e�u{wzk cre�k7~c�u�fB����n|k�x�n:~�e�Yz�7c�Y¯e�k7cr�|����e�Y5u{n7c�~�jzkÅ�W� �

���?u � �?�?Y�u � nb��n^k�x}n|Yz�?Y5u�~���¡�wl��«�p�~�u.��n^k�x}n|Yz�?Y5u��u�c��:��~��?crp���nrm � w�cru.k�e��^w5u"���f5p�c � YT�Bt cWx�c�e�Y5u{�?p�j�~�e�Yz�!cWx��?Y���e��)��¡�wz�?p{��mon^p{��u�wze�~���n^k�x�n|Yz�?Y5ueg~�c^fB�§°¾j�c�u{�?��tk�n5fB�?���§fª�5t7c®mojzY���u{e�n|Y7e�Y ���D¦�¡�wz��u��?�Bu�jzp{�ÉcrY�f7u{wz�bYzn|e�~��b���?��n^Yz��u�n�u{wz����n|kW¨x�n|Yz�?Y5u.�}¦�¡�wl�?YN��e�~�c�~��:��u���w®n�mIu{wz�%�^e�d:��Y�e�k$cr�^�%c�Y�f�u{wzeg~�~��:�?u���w��W��crxzu�jzp{��~"u{wl�

Z��

Page 18: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

k$cre�Y��^�?n|k��?u�p{e���mo��c�u{jzp���~nrmIu{wl���^e�d:��Y�e�k7c��^���I¦^¡�wz���b��n^k�x}n|Yz�?Y5ue�~�k�n^p�����n|kW¨xl���?�!crYHf�e�~Yzn|ubfB��~���p{e�����f��Bt!cWmojzY���u{e�n|Y�cr�D½�crYHc^��w�~�x�c|����e�Y!u{wz��³�µ�¸qk�n5fB�?�­�X)Y�u�wz��³�µ�¸ik�n5fB�?�­`� ' < $ Ï>= $ Ðb~�e�Y�������n|u{w��£crY�f���crp��!~{°:j�crp���¨)e�YBu��?�^p�cr�z���:�¡�wl�®³�µ�¸Tcr���|n^p�e�u{wlk�fB�?x��?Y�fz~.n^Y�c�u{jzYze�Yz�bx�crp�crk���u{�?p �)�=,B¦z³��5¢{����u�~ � e�u�w�~�e�È?�����~{~�u�w�crY �$ � � e����-���bu{p���cru���f7c^~�~�n^k���u��?�5u{jzp���c�Y�f � e�x���f�n^jlu¶mop�n^k��"¦ *��bu{wz��Yc�p{p�e�d:��u�nWu�wz��fB��«�Yze�u{e�n^Y7nrmDu{wz��c����^n|p{e�u{wzkT������������ ��� � _�T?I.�=' < $ Ï8= $ Ð�¦ O N T"; IKN T � 85 Y T <?> ��� >SRbJBI�JK>F;R�qà �$� � >�� � JK;ZJ � JED�THR&IKN TA���2;Z<4I�JK>F;ZCA@ �ÎÏ)�-Ðà $��$����ª� � $�� $ $$ C � >F;A^5CA@ @7Y T <?> ��� >SRbJBI�JK>F; R>�¶�=CSR C R�� � E4T?I�L�T?T"; C���� ;Z<"I�JK>F;7� ' ��� CF;ZY�� ' < $ Ï8= $ Ð�¦´Ic�u{�?p�n^Y�u�wz�R³�µ�¸ k�n5fB�?� � e�������N�^�?Yz��p�cr��e�È?�§fTcrY�f¯u�wz��~�x�c|������� � e�������p��?xz�gc^����fb�Btbn|u{wz�?p"mojzY���u{e�n|Y�cr�l~�xHc^����~��.¡�wze�~ � e����:x�c?d:��u�wz� � c§tb���?u � ���?Y�u�wz�³�µ�¸c����|n^p{e�u{wzk crY�f7u{wz��m­crk�n^j�~ � c§d:�����?u%~�wlp{e�Yl�^c��^�:�

� � O.P�� �OM.Vb ��P��£M �� � � � ������P�O�V�M�� �

´���uRjH~�fB�?Yln^u{���5t �� �� � u{wl������n:~�jzp{��e�Y ���Ånrm�u�wz����e�Yl��crp!~�xHc^����nrm�~�k�n:n^u�wmojlY���u{e�n^Y�~ � e�u�w���n^k�x�c^��u�~�jzxzx�n^p�u?�bX)Y�n|u{wz��p � n|p�fz~�� ' �� �� � k���c�Y�~���� ';< � ¦Ê��?p{� �� �� � fB�?Yzn|u{��~�u{wl��wzn|k�n^�|�?Yz�?n|j�~d:�?p�~�e�n|Y7nrm%u{wz�©~�u�crY�fzc�p�f�v:n^��n|���?d!~�xHc^���:�¡�wl��fBjHcr�.~�x�c^���Nnrm �� �� � eg~u{wz��½�crYHc^��w�~�x�c|�����»��n^Y�~�e�~�u{e�Yl�Rn�m�c�����|�?Yz�?p�cr��e�È?��fmojlY���u{e�n^Y�~ � � wze���w7�?c�Y���� � p{e�u�u{�?Y!c|~

��ÃyfBe�d Ï{Z^Z�Ð

� wl�?p{�� ÃÅÏ ' �"!�' $�Ð5' < � 5;< � ¦.¡�wz��Yln^p{k�nrm �¤e�Y�� e�~�fB��Yzn^u���f��Bt $ � $�c�Y�f�e�~�fB��«�Yz��f�c|~ª���?e�Yz�Tu{wl��e�YB«HkWjzk n�m�$� $ � � wz�?p{��u{wzeg~�e�YB«�kNjzk e�~���n|kW¨xljzu{��f�n�d:�?p�cr���f5����n^k�x}n�~�e�u{e�n|Y�~bÏ{Z^Z�Ð�nrm �I¦"Ê�?p���c�Y�f�e�Y � w�c�umon^����n � ~$� $ � Ã~�jzx �� �� � ��TÏ���Ð � ! �� �à � ' � � $ � � '%$ � $ ¦%¡�wz�?Y < $ - � crYHf u�wz�T~�x�c^�������7e�~f5��«�Yz��f7c|~¶u�wz������n�~�jzp��®n�m < $ e�Y���¦%*��bw�c?d:� 0 ÒF� 3� ��� ��� � O N T �CF;ZCF< N R � CF<4T ��� J R�IKN T�Y��2CA@+R � CF<4T�>������CF;ZY�I N T ;Q>FG � JK;��� J R I N T Y�� CA@7;Q>FG � �¡�wle�~�e�k�xz��e���~.u{wz�bmon^����n � e�Yz�Nxzp�n^x��?p{u�tIË�e¹m%cN~���°:jz�?YH����� �nrm.mojzYH��u{e�n^Y�~����?��n|Yz�^e�Yz�u�n ��� ��n^Y5d:�?p{�|��~�u{n���e�Y�u�wz�NfBeg~�u{p�e��zjlu{e�n|Y�cr�D~���Y�~��©crY�f�eÁm"$�� $���� � ZA!�u{wz��YT����?��n^Yz��~�u{n ���ÆcrY�f $�� $���� �[Z|¦z¡�wzeg~ � �§cr����n^k�xHc^��u�Yz��~{~.xzp{n|x��?p{u�tNe�k�xz��e���~"u{wl�

Z�]

Page 19: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

���Beg~�u{��Y�����n�mu�wz�bn^xzu�e�k7c���³�µ¸�fB�§��n^k�x�n�~�e�u�e�n|Y7crY�f7jzYzeg°¾jz��Yz��~{~�eg~�~�u�crY�fzc�p�f-�¡�wz��mon|����n � e�Yz�����?k�k7c � e����"���®Yl�?��fB��fI�

� ��� ��� � :!� E?>AI NN� CF;ZY���E4T?@D>F;A^�I�>1< $ !7I N T";�L T`NQCFaST

� � � Ï��-Ð���Ï��-Ð � � ��� $�� $��"� $�� $� Ï{Z?±:иzn|p�xzp{n�d5e�Yz�Ne�u�`}e�ub~�j ?7���§~¶u�n7crxzxlp{n:c|�¬w��Te�Y < $ �5t!c�~��§°¾jz��Y�����n�m.mojzY���u�e�n^YH~¶e�Y�� �� � ¦�¡�wl��f5�?u�c�e���~���crY7���®mon^jlY�f�e�Y90 ÒF� 3)�

�Y�e�k7cr�|���y~{c�u{e�~)«���~�,�� ��Ï��-Ð � Z7c�Y�f�u{wz�!�q��n^k�x�n^Yl�?YBu�e�Yzwl�?p{e�u�~®u�wze�~xlp{n^x��?p�u�t:��¡�wl��xzp�n:nrm%nrm.u�wze�~�p��?k7c�p{�Ne�~���c^~�t:��XÑmÎ� Ã �ª�¼�We�~�u�wz�W³�µ�¸�fB����n|kW¨x�n�~�e�u�e�n|Y"` � �Ww�c?d:���qà �BÏ­� Ð�à �BÏ)�-Ð�A�b¦ *��Nu{wz�?Y¤w�c?d:��$ �BÏ)�-Ð $��"� � $�� $��"�c�Y�f�� �bÏ��-Ð �Bà � �BÏ­� Ð.� �BÏ)�-Ð � � � ��Ï��-Ð.��� Ï��-Ð �À¦�¡�wl�?p{��mon|p{� $(��$"$'� $�� $"$c�Y�f�u{wl�jlYze�°:jz�?Yz�§~{~�nrmDu{wl�ª³�µ�¸�fB����n|k�x�n:~�e�u{e�n^Y7e�k�xl��e��§~�Rà �5Ï)�-Ð%c^~�c�YzYzn^jlY�����f-�

�Y5u{n|Yze�Y �.w�c�kW��n|�����Nk7c|fB��u{wl�$mon|����n � e�Yz����p�j���e�c���p��?k7crp��-��´��?u�� � ���7u{wl�����n:~���f7��n^Y5d:�?��~�jz�H~��?u�n�m < $ Ï>= $ Ð%fB��«�Yz�§f$�5t�$�) $� � �$ � ¦�¡�wz��Y � �bw�c?d:���� � ������� � O N T � 85 Y T <?> ��� >SRbJBI�JK>F;���à Ä����Ä� >� C ���2;Z<4I�JK>F;W��' < $ Ï>= $ Ð&J R^ JKaST";�E��

Ä�ªÃ ��p{�.e�YBm�� $��#��� $"$��T� '�� � � Ï{Z?Ò:С�wl�xzp�n:nrm�n�m"u{wle�~u{wz��n^p{��k � e����l�}���^e�d:�?Y�e�YNu{wl��mon^����n � e�Yz��~��§��u{e�n^Y"�D¸Hn|p.u{wz��u{e�k�����?e�Yz�z`z���?u�jH~��n|k�k��?Y5un|YT¡�wz�?n|p{�?k ±B�� ��������� � ���M_�T#I���' < $ Ï>= $ Ð�¦6:!� $�� $� � �$ � !+IKN T"; IKN T'� 85 Y T <?> ��� >SRbJBI�JK>F;�>�� J R.^FJKaST ;=E��¯Ä�qà ,2!Ä��à �-¦ : ��$�� $��� �$ � ! JBI J R ^FJKa�T";=E����iÃÅÄ�R�[Ä�=L N T"G?T$|Ä� $��à �$ � CF;ZY�$��#�iÄ� $"$�J R � JK;ZJ � CA@6� ;ZY T G IKNQCAI <?>F; R"I�GHCFJK; IP��.n|p{n^����c�p{t�Z�e�~�Yzn � p��?xzwzp�c^~���f�e�Y!cªk�n^p{��e�Y5u{jze�u{e�d:� � c?tIË

� ��������� � � �):!�"$�� $ � � �$ � ! IKN T";�� J R&C IUT���I �2G T&<?>FG4G�� � I T Y E�� CF;5CFYFYFJBI�JKa�T�;Z>FJ R�TCF;QY�YF>ATHR ;Z>AI <?>F; I�CFJK; CF;(� >FE ��T <4IP�µ��?u{jlp{Yze�Yz�¯u�n �.n|p{n|����c�p{tyZTc�Y�fqc|~{~�jlk�e�Yz� $�� $��� �$ � ! � ��w�c?d:�!�8à Ä���Ä�Z! $�� $��à �$ � crYHf�$¾Ä� $"$e�~�k�e�Yze�k�cr��jzY�f5�?pu�wz��~���p{�§°¾jze�p{�?k��?YBu�~����Y!n^u�wz�?p��¬w�c�p�¨

c|��u{��p{e�ȧcru{e�n^Y7nrm%u�wz�bn^xzu�e�k7c��"x�cre�p�Ï�Ä� !�Ä�BÐ�eg~¶�|e�d:�?Y7�5t��Tà Ä�W�iÄ�Z! $^Ä� $�¶Ã �$ � !�c�Y�f� Ä��Ä�ªÃ $:Ä� $��"�+$^Ä� $�?¦�¡�wzeg~�����c|fz~�u{nNu{wz��mon|����n � e�Yz�NfB��«�Yle�u{e�n^Y"Ë

Z�\

Page 20: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

����������� ��� � H � CFJKG�Ï­� !��HÐ >��I�L�> ���2;Z<4I�JK>F; R JK;1< $ Ï>= $ Ð�J R&;QC � T Y CF;�T���I�G?T � CA@� CFJKG`J ����' ��� CF;ZY'���� � ��à $�� $��"� $�� $��¦¡�wl�?n^p��?k�±N�?crY7���bp{�?xzwlp�c^~���fRe�YBu�n�u{wz��mon|����n � e�Yz�Nc^~�~��?p�u{e�n|Y� ��������� � � � :!� $�� $�&� �$ � !�IKN T � 85 Y T <?> ��� >SRbJBI�JK>F;N�¯Ã Ä�W�iÄ� >��� J R.< NQCFG"�CF<"I T"G"JED�T Y�E�� IKN T �b>A@ @ >FL�JK;A^ I�L�> � GH> � T"G?I�JXT R�; &�C+*)$^Ä� $ � à �$ � CF;ZY &�E *7Ï�Ä� !rÄ�zÐ J R.CF;T���I�G?T � CA@ � CFJKG �¡�wl��p{��c|fB�?peg~�p{��mo��p{p{�§f®u{n 0 Ò �b3 � wz�?p�� �.n^p�n^���gcrp�t�Òeg~��^e�d:�?Y�cbfBe�p{����u�xzp�n:nrm����.n^p�n^�Á¨�gcrp�e���~�Z|`�±Wc�Y�f�ÒNcrp���u{������e�Yz��jH~¶u�w�cru�u{wz��³�µ�¸qcr���^n|p{e�u�wzkÌeg~�cW~�wzp{e�Yz�|cr�^� � wz�?p��u�wz�bu{wzp���~�wln^��f�eg~ �$ � ¦

� ��� ��� �"MO���U�M �:P�O � S � �bM²V�PWL P��¥M��� � � � ��� ��P �O�V�M � �

� xzp�n:nrmbn�m�¡�wz�?n^p��?kű�e�~��|e�d:�?Y�Yln � �!¡�wzeg~®xzp�n:nrm�e�~®d|c���e�f�e�Y¤c�k�n^p����^�?Yz��p�cr���n^Y5u{�?�5u � wzeg�¬w7p���c^fz~�c^~²mon|����n � ~��´���u Å���7cRp���cr�%Êe������?p{uÉ~�x�c|���:�7¡�wz��Yln^p{kÅe�Y eg~bfB�?Yzn|u{��fT�Bt � ) �Ic�Y�f¯u{wl���n^p{p���~�x�n|Y�fBe�Yl�Te�YzYz��p�xzp�n5fBj���u�eg~ � )���¦´��?u�������c7Yzn^Y5¨)�?k�xzu�t�����n�~���f���n^Y5d:�?�~�jz��~��?un�m �¦-´��?u�j�~�fB��«HYz��#�Ë ��� =��:�)%����5t

#-Ï���Ð.à ~�jzx � �B)������5' �.� Ï{Z � С�wle�~}mojzY���u{e�n|Y�cr��#be�~"��n^Y5d:�?�-`���n � ��p"~���k�e¹¨Í��n^Y5u{e�YBjln^j�~IcrY�f�~{cru�e�~)«���~ #-Ï��Q��Ð%à � #IÏ��-Ðmon|p����=,2!`��' �¦-´���u�� ' Ì���b�^e�d:��Y"���k�n^Yz�©cr����fB����n|k�x�n:~�e�u{e�n^Y�~%��à �®� �n�mb� � � � c�YBu�u�n�«�Y�f�u{wl��n^Yz��mon|p � wze���w�u{wl�R��Yz�?p{�|t �ÎÏ��-Ð�à #IÏ��-Ð.� � ��� � $ e�~k�e�Yze�k�c��)� *��!fB�?Yzn|u{�7�Bt¼� à Ä�R� Ä�¯u�wze�~�n|xzu{e�k7cr�FfB����n|k�x�n:~�e�u{e�n^Y"��*£e�u�wzn^jzu��n:n:~�e�Yz���|�?Yz�?p�cr��e�u�t � �b�?crY!c|~{~�jlk�� �7à Z,+§±B¦IXÍuF~�j,?$����~.u{n�p��?xz��c|��� �0�5t �$ � �0u{nn|�zu�c�e�Y!u{wz�b�^��Yz�?p�c����?c^~��:�.¸zn^����n � e�Yz� ��YBu�n^Yze�Y �.w�crkN��n^����� � �®wHc§d:���� � ������� � V�JBI N IKN T � G?T <4T YFJK;A^ ;Q>AI�CAI�JK>F; R IKN T > � I�J � CA@&Y T <?> ��� >SRbJBI�JK>F;��»ÃÄ���0Ä��J R�^FJKa�T"; E��

Ä�ªÃ �p��.e�YBm�� � �#��� � ��� '��.� Ï{Z?_:С�wl��xzp{n:n�m�nrm�¡�wl�?n^p��?k Ò�e�~�Yzn^u%fBe�?7��jl��u?��X)u.��n|Y�~�eg~�u�~Îe�YNcrxzxl��t5e�Yz�bu{wl�����?�����zp�c�u{��fd:n|Y ��?jzk7c�YzY�k�e�Yze�k�cr��u�wz�?n|p{�?k�u{nNu{wz��mojzYH��u{e�n^Y�c��

��Ï�� !��HÐÃ(�1)���� Z± � �#� � � $ ! ��'�5!�� '�� Ï{Z � Ð

± ,

Page 21: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

¡�wl��k�e�Yze�k�cr��u�wz�?n^p��?k[~�c§tl~-u{wl�²mon^����n � e�Yl�z�´��?u����}�Fc��n^k�x�c|��u"c�Y�f���n^Y5d:�?��~��?u?�´���u ������c���n^Y5d:�?��~��?u � wze���w�f5n:��~ Yln^uYz����f�u{n������|e�d:�?Y�c�u{n|x}n|��n|�^e���cr��~�u{p{jH��u{jzp��:�*�����n^YH~�e�f5�?p�c�mojzY���u�e�n|Y�cr�7�8ËZ� 5 � �� =�¦Z*¯�ÉfB��«�Yz� Ë2� �� = )��%���c�Y�f� Ë � �� � �)%�� =Ì�Bt

Ï��-Ð.Ãy~�jlx �F��Ï�� !��HÐ � � '��.� Ï{ZS�|Ðc�Y�f�~�e�k�e���c�p{��t

�©Ï �zÐãe�Y5m �F�©Ï��6!��zÐ ����'��.� Ï{Z?]:Ð*���n|�Bd5e�n|j�~���t�w�c?d:� ��Ï �HÐ � ��Ï��6!��zÐ � Ï���Ð � wzeg�¬w�e�k�xz��e���~�~�jzx � ��Ï �HÐ#!��M'�5��à � � C8à e�YBm�� Ï��-Ð#! �)'P�.�5¦.¡�wz�7k�e�Yze�k�cr�Tu�wz�?n^p��?kÅtBe��?��fz~FC8à �jlY�fB�?p�u�wz��mon^����n � e�Yz�Nc|~{~�jlk�xzu{e�n^Y�~��� � ������� � _8T?I'�AR�CSR?R�� � T I NQCAI � �� ��Ï��6!��HÐ J R]<?>F;ZaST�� CF;ZY @ >FL T"G R�T � J!�<?>F;2I�JK;(�2>��AR�>F; � �b>FG T"a�T"G � � ' �%¦ _�T#I � R/CA@ Rb> CSR?R�� � T I NQCAI � �� ��Ï��6!��HÐ J R<?>F;Q<?CFaST >F; ���b>FG`T"aST G �`� '���¦ O N T ;�IKN T"G T`T�� J R"I R CF; T#@BT � T"; I�Ä� ' �PR��2< N/I NQCAI Ï�Ä��Ð.à ��¦¸zn|p�c�xzxz��tBe�Yz�!¡�wz�?n^p��?k � ` � ��«��Tc7��crp��^�#0 � ZNc�Y�f�fB��«HYz�5� - �c^~b���?e�Yz�u�wz������n:~���f���cr��� � � � � 00��°:jze�xzx���f � e�u{w7u{wz� � ��c��7u{n^x�n|��n^�|t:��¡�wz�®mojlY���u{e�n^Y�c�� �eg~�fB��«�Yl��fR�5tTÏ{Z � Ð���¡�wz�?n|p{�?k � ~{c?tl~¶u�w�cru Ï��-Ð.à #-Ï��-Ð�� �$ � �#� � � $ p{��c|�¬wz�§~�e�u�~k�e�Yze�k�jzk C£cru7Ä�"¦"¡�wz��Y��©Ï �zÐ�p{��c|�¬wl��~�e�u�~�k7cr�5e�kNjzk � cru7Ä�TcrY�f£Ä�Reg~bfB��«�Yz�§f�5t�Ï{Z�_¾Ð�� *���u{wz�?Y!w�c?d:����Ã�Ä�W�[Ä�7crY�f�¡�wz�?n|p{�?k ÒWeg~xzp{n�d:��fI��¡�wz�NfB��u�cre���~n�mu�wze�~xzp�n:nrmÎcrp������mou.u{n�u�wz��p{��c|fB�?p?�.¸zn|p²xlp{n�dBe�Yz��¡�wz�?n|p{�?k ±®e�u�~�j,?$����~u{nbn^�H~��?p�d:�u�w�cru #-Ï­�-вà $�� $��"�T�Bt!´��?k�k7cbÒB�

� � � PRQ� � � ���7 ®Q PWL � �� ��P � L!P�O �

*���fB�?Yln^u{���5t���Ï8= $ Ð"u{wl�v5��w � crp�u{È����gc^~{~DcrY�f��5t�����Ï8= $ Ð"u{wl��fBj�cr�H~�x�c|����nrmIu{��kW¨x��?p���f�fBeg~�u�p{e��ljzu{e�n^Y�~���� mojzYH��u{e�n^Y�c��"½�crYHc^��w7~�x�c|��� � e�~�f5��«�Yz��fN�Bt�u�wz��xzp�n^x��?p{u�t��Ï>= $ Ð - � - � � Ï8= $ Ð � wl�?p{��u�wz��u � nT��kW����fzf5e�Yz��~®c�p{�7��n^Y5u{e�Y5jzn|j�~�n^Yz�§~���X)Y�|�?Yz�?p�cr����Ï8= $ Ð�e�~.Yzn^uFfB�?Y�~��e�Y�� crY�f � ����?u � �FfB�?Yzn|u{��u�wz������n�~�jzp��e�Y �ynrm�u{wl�~�x�c^����nrm%u���~�u�e�Yz��mojzY���u�e�n|Y�~���¡�wz��~�x�c^��� � � eg~¶u�wz��f5j�cr�.~�x�c^����nrm����bcrYHf�Yzn^u�n�m��e�YT�^�?Yz��p�cr�­�N¡�wz��Yzn^p�k e�Y � � e�~bfB��Yzn^u���f��Bt $�) $��¦�XÑm��ÌÃW���8!-u�wz�?Y � �be�~f5��«�Yz��fT�5tT�M'D< $ crY�f ���=' < � ¦"¡�wz�N�^��Yz�?p�c���e�È?��f¯³�µ¸£k�n5fB����~ � �Ww�c?d:��e�Yk�e�Y�f�c�p{�b��c|~���f7n^Y7u{wz�b�?Yl�?p{�|t

� Ï)�-Ðà $�� $ ��� � $�� ��� $ $$ Ï{Z?\:Ð

±5Z

Page 22: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

¡�wl�n|xzu{e�k7cr��f5����n^k�x}n�~�e�u{e�n|Y���à Ä��¤Ä��eg~²u�wz�n|Yz� � wzeg�¬w�k�e�Yze�k�eÁÈ?��~ � Ï­�-Ð�¦5¡�wze�~n|xzu{e�k7cr�%fB�§��n^k�x�n�~�e�u�e�n|Y¯�?�5e�~�u�~�crY�f�e�~bjzYzeg°¾jz� � wz�?Yl�?d:�?pbu{wz�$½�crY�c|�¬w�~�xHc^��� �wHc^~�u{wz��mon^����n � e�Yl�Txzp{n|x}��p{u�t-ËWmon|pW��d:�?p{t¤~���°:jz�?YH���7� ' �.! �M' � !D~�j���w�u{w�c�u$�� $ ���[Z�c�Y�f $�� ���� $"$ � ,2! � � % ! � �bw�c?d:��$�� $ � �[Z|¦Z*£e�u{w7u�wz��~��bYzn|u�c?¨u�e�n|Y�~¡�wl�?n^p��?k Òªeg~~�u{e����-d|cr��e�f!crY�f�Ä�We�~�u{wz�©crp��^jzk���YBu%nrm%e�YBm�� $��#��� $"$ � $�� $� ��$ � �5¦

¡�wz�!½���~�n�d�~�x�c|����� à �� �� �� e�~�����n�~���u�n ����c^~�e�u � e����²���7xzp�nrd:�§f ���?��n � �h�n|p{�?n�d:�?p.u�wze�~�½���~�n�d�~�x�c^����e�~�e�~�n^k�n|p{xzwle���u{nNc�u{p�e�d5e�c��-~���°:jz�?Y�����~�xHc^����crYHf$u�wze�~eg~�n|k�n^p�xzwze�~�k e�~��^e�d:�?Y��Bt�u�wz� � c§d:�����?u��?�BxHcrY�~�e�n^Y�� ´��?uNj�~���n|Y�~�egfB�?pNYzn � u{wl�d|c�p{e�c�YBu�nrm%u{wz�N³�µ¸�cr���|n^p�e�u{wlk � wz�?p���u�wz�5���8Yln^p{k e�~�p{�?xl��c^����fR�5t7u{wz��Yzn|p{ke�Y���¦"X)u � e�����u�wz�?YT����xzp{n�d:��f�u�w�cru�u{wz�N����n^k�x}n|Yz�?Y5ueg~n^�lu�cre�Yz��f��5t!c$d|c�p{e�c�YBun|Y�u�wz��~�u�c�Y�fzc�p�f � c?d:�?���?uF~�wzp�e�Yz�|c��^�:�¡�wz��~�x�c^��� ���Æ�?crY�����fB��«HYz��fW�5tWu�wz�b�?�5e�~�u��?Y�����n�m.c���n^Y�~�u�crY5u �[~�j���w�u{w�c�u

mon|p��?d:�?p�t �5'9= $ � �bw�c?d:�$���Ï&) ���HÐ ����Ï&)¹Ð $ ��� ��� � � Ï)±A,:Ð

¡�wl����n � �?p���n^jzYHf n�m�u{wl��~��©��n^Y�~�u�c�YBu�~�� e�~�cWYln^p{k � wze���w�eg~��°:jze�d|c����?Y5uu�n�u{wl�jH~�j�c�� ����Yzn|p{k n�m��-¦�v:e�k�e��gcrp{��t�u{wl�Wwzn|k�n^�|�?Yz�?n|j�~b½���~�n�d ~�x�c|����� à �� �� �� e�~f5��«�Yz��fN�Bt�u�wz���?�5e�~�u{�?YH���n�m.c���n^Y�~�u�crY5u"�[~�jH�¬w�u�w�cru�mon|p��?d:�?p�t � '9= $ � �bw�c?d:�

$���Ï) ���zÐ"����Ï)^���zÐ@��±|��Ï&)¹Ð $ ��� ����� � Ï)±BZ�С�wl���?kN����fzfBe�Yz� ��� - ��eg~�n^�5dBe�n^j�~�c�Y�fq~�wzn^jl��fq���T��n|k�x�c�p{��f�u{n�u{wl� � ������5Yzn � Y�m­c^��u�u{w�c�u�cR´�e�x�~��¬wle�u{ÈbmojzY���u�e�n|Y�cr� � c?tz~���?��n^Yz��~�u{n�u�wz����tB�|kWjlY�f7����c|~{~�`u�wz����n^Y5d:�?p�~���Yzn^u����?e�Yz��u�p{jz���.XÍu%e�~�u�wz�?p{��mon^p{�É~�jzp�xzp{eg~�e�Yl��u{w�c�u¶mon|p�c���crp��^����n|�����§�¬¨u�e�n|Y¯n�m�mojzY���u�e�n^YH~®u{wl�Wu � n7Yzn|p{k7~bc�p{����°:jze�d^c����?Y5u?�NÊ��p{��e�~bu{wz��mojz����~�u{n|p{t:��´��?u� # fB�?Yzn|u{�Tu{wl�T��n|�����§��u{e�n^Y�nrm©~�u��?x¥mojlY���u{e�n^Y�~ � e�u{w � ����d:�?��~��£X)Yqn^u�wz�?pNu{�?p�k7~��à ( ��� � � � )+)+)���( # � ��� � wz��p{� ���"!+)+)+)b!4� # crp���½�n|p{�?��~��?u�~�c�Y�f�( �?!+)*)+)�!*( # crp����p���cr����n:� ?7��e��?Y5u�~��+*��®u�wz�?Y7w�c?d:���� � ������� � O N T G T T�� J R"I6I�L�> � >SRbJBI�JKaST <?>F; R"I�CF; I R'���&CF;ZY � ��R��2< N�IKNQCAI:�b>FG T"aST"G��� ' � # L T NQCFa�T

��� $�� $ ��$�� $��"��� � � � $�� $ Ï)±^±:С�wz�Nxzp�n:nrm�nrm�¡�wl�?n^p��?kÅ_Rp��?��e���~¶n|Y�c�f5�?�?xTu{wl�?n^p��?k �Bt � ��?p�crp�f¯½�n|jzp�fzc�j�f

0 � 3­�.X­m ��'9=�! � ��fB��«�Yz��� � Ï���Ð.Ã[Ï��@� ��Ð � ¦Z*��bu{wz��YRwHc§d:�±|±

Page 23: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

��� � ������� � O N T G T�T�� J R"IKR9C <?>F; R"I�CF; I ���]R��2< N IKNQCAI c8�b>FG]T aST"G��¯� ' � CF;ZY� '9= !8L T`NQCFaST$ � � Ï­� Ð $�� ��� $�� $ Ï)±^Ò:Ð

½���mon|p{��p��?u{jzp�Yze�Yl��u{n!¡�wz�?n|p{�?k _B`����?u�j�~�p{��~�u�c�u{��¡�wz�?n^p��?k � jzYHfB�?p�u�wz�ªmon|�¹¨��n � e�Yz��mon|p{kTË� ��������� � � � :!�#��� � �),2!�L�T�L�G"JBIUT ��à 0 � !*�?3 CF;ZY�Y T!0 ;%T C���� ;Z<"I�JK>F;����?Ï���Ð >�IKN T G?T CA@ a CFG"JKCFE4@BT�� E���� � Ï���Ð.à ,�J ��� � � !�� � Ï���Ð.ÃD������J � �$� ��� �S!7CF;QY 0 ;QCA@B@,�� � Ï���Ð.à � ����J � ��� ��¦ O N T ; L T`NQCFaST

$�� � Ï)�"Ð $��y± ��� $�� $ Ï)± � ÐX)Y�fB����f�����Ï���Ð.à � Ï���Ð@� � � Ï���Ð�¦�¡�wl�?Y�u�wz��xzp�n:nrm%nrmF¡�wz��n^p{��k _����?�^e�Y�~ � e�u{wTc~�e�k�xl���?p%�?c|~��:Ë

� ��� ��� � _�T#I � - = $ E4T C �>FG T#@+R�T?I&CF;ZY @BT?I ��� I N T JK;ZYFJK<?CAI�>FG ���2;Z<4I�JK>F; >��©¦ O N T ; L T`NQCFaST Z

± $ ��� $�� $ ���'$��"� � $ ��� $ Ï)±^_:Ð

¡�wz�bxzp�n:nrm.n�m�Ï­±^_:Ð.p{�?��e���~n^Y!c�Y�n^�5d5e�n^jH~²p{��k7crp��-ËDX­m�� !*��!5crY�f (c����-���?��n^Yz�Nu{n� ,2!?Z,�2!zu�wz�?Y � �bw�c?d:�

� � ��� ����� �$��± �²��( � Ï)± � С�wl��xzp�n:nrm.eg~¶u�p{e�d5e�c��"c�Y�fR����mou�u{nNu{wz�bp���c^fB��p?�%µ¶�?u�jzp{Yle�Yz�Nu{n!Ï)±|_¾Ð�` � ��c�xzxz��t Ï)± � Ðu�n���Ã���DÏ���� �HÐ#!*�à � �.Ï��-Ð?!�c�Y�f�(�Ã���.Ï��1���zÐ�¦�¡�wzeg~¶t5e��?�gfz~�u{wl�®p�e��|wBu�¨)w�c�Y�f�§~�u{e�k7cru��e�Y�Ï)±^_:Ð��%¡�wz�b����mou�¨)wHcrY�f7��~�u�e�k7c�u{��e�~�u{p�jz��mon^p�crY5tWmojzY���u{e�n|Y!�]'����¦

*���Yzn � u{p���cru.u�wz���^��Yz�?p�c��I�?c^~���e�Y7¡�wl�?n^p��?k�_B��*£e�u{wzn|jzu���n:n:~�e�Yz���^��Yz�?p�c���e�u�t�`� ����crY�c|~{~�jlk���( �BE ("$#E )+)+) E ( � ¦�¡�wl�7��n^p�n^����crp�tTnrm�¡�wz��n^p{��k � e�~bcrxzxl��e��§f� e�u{w�� # à 0 ( # � �?! ( # 3)¦ *��bu{wz��YRn|�zu�c�e�Y

$�Ï ( # ��( # � ��Ð �����+$�� ��� $�� $ Ï)± �|Ðv�e�Y���� $ ��� $���� � $ � �+$6!ze�u�e�k�xz��e���~

$�Ï ( # ��( # � ��Ð �����+$��"� � ��� $�� $ Ï)±^]:Ð

±|Ò

Page 24: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

*���u�wz�?Y���n|Y�~�egfB�?p � % à � % ;)+)+) � # à � � ����Ï���Ð � ( % �5¦�¡�wz�!��n^p�n^����crp�t¯n�m¡�wl�?n^p��?k � eg~�crxlxz��e���fRu�n � % Ã-0 ( % � �"! ( % 3�Ï � e�u{w (4�®Ã ,��5t!��n^Y5d:�?Y5u{e�n|Y-ÐFcrY�f � �n|�zu�c�e�Y

$�Ï ( % ��( % � ��Ð � � � $��"� � ��� $�� $ Ï)±^\:н�jlu�� à � # � Ï ( % ��( % � ��Ð � � � crYHfRu{wl�®u�p{egcrYz�|���be�Yz�§°¾j�c���e�u�t���Y�fz~�u{wz�bxzp�n:nrm��v:e�Y�����u�wz������Yzn|p{kÅc�Y�f¯u{wl�N½���~�n�dTYzn|p{kÅcrp��W�§°¾jze�d|cr����YBu�n^Yz�§~Émon^p�~�e�k�xz���

mojlY���u{e�n^Y�~�`ze�u�eg~�u{�?k�xlu{e�Yl�®u�nWp��?xz�gc^����u�wz��~�u�crY�fzc�p�f¯³�µ�¸¼��Yz�?p{�|tW�5t� Ï)�-Ðà $�� $ � � $�� $ $$ Ï)ÒA,:Ð

� wl�?p{���ªÃ �#����c^~�����mon^p��:��yk7cre�Y�fBe �I�?p{�?YH��� � e�u{w�u�wz�b~�u�crYHfzcrp�f ³�µ�¸�cr���^n|p{e�u�wzk�e�~���n^k�e�Yz��mop{n^k�u{wl�m­c^��uu�w�cru�u�wz��½�crY�c|�¬w!~�x�c^��� �ye�~�Yln^u���n|YBu�cre�Yl��f�e�Y9< $ Ï>= $ Ð�¦zX)Y�~�u{��c|f �ye�~%��n^Y5u�c�e�Yz�§fe�Yqu�wz��´�n^p��?YBu�ÈT~�x�c^���!< $ � ¦ � u�t5xze��?c����?�lcrk�xz���7nrm©c mojzY���u{e�n|Yqe�Y ��e�~�� � � � �� wle���w�e�~�Yzn|u�~{°:j�crp��be�Y5u{�?�|p�cr�l���:� �n:n5f�Yl� � ~�crp�����n^k�e�Yz�z�D¡�wz��~�x�c|��� �0c|fBk�e�u�~c�~�e�k�xz��� � c?d:�?���?uF�¬wHcrp�c|��u{��p{e�ȧcru{e�n^Y"��´��?u�Ï ���?!*��$"!*� + Ð%����u{wlp{�?�bmojzY���u�e�n^YH~¶e�Y�u{wl�v¾�¬w � c�p{u{È!���gc^~�~W~�j��¬w�u�w�cru�u�wz�!��n^��������u{e�n|Y�� 8 % à ± �Ï­± ��� 2}Ð?!$� ' : !�2 ': $ !�� ' � ���?!*��$ ! � + �2!zeg~�crY7n^p�u{wzn|Yzn^p�k7cr����c^~�e�~�n�m <

$ ¦Z*¯�bu{wl�?Y7w�c?d:�� ��� ����� H ���2;Z<4I�JK>F;b� ' < $ � E4T?@D>F;A^SR�I�> �yà �� �� �� J � CF;ZY >F; @N�`J � JBI R L�CFaST#@BT?I<?>AT�� < JXT ; I R#(�Ï �F!42�вà � � � > % � � RbCAI�J R����

~�jlx ��Ï �% �� �

� (rÏ �F!42}Ð � Ð.à � E % Ï)ÒBZ�Ð

� J � JB@ CFG @N� C�IUT ��� T"G?T Y YFJ R"I�G4JKE��FI�JK>F; � E4T?@ >F;A^�R5I�> I N T Y�� CA@+R � CF<4T � � à �� � �� �� J �CF;QY�>F;2@,� J �.JBIKR L�CFaST#@BT?I&<?> T �=<bJXT"; IKR (�Ï �F! 2}Ð`RbCAI�J R����

�~�jzx% � (�Ï �F! 2}Ð �:à � � E % Ï)Ò^±:Ð

*���p��?k�e�YHf�u{wz��p{��c|fB�?p%u{w�c�u � � eg~²Yzn|u�u{wl�bfBj�c��"~�xHc^����n�m �£�zjzu%p�c�u{wz�?p%u{wz�ÉfBj�cr�n�m.u{wl������n:~�jzp{�be�Y �yn�m.u{wz��~�x�c^���bn�m.u{��~�u{e�Yz��mojzY���u�e�n|Y�~��.¡�wz��Yzn^p�kÌnrm²� e�Y �� �� ��c�Y�f¥u�wz��e�YB«�kNjzkÅnrm ��e�Y0Ï)Ò5ZrЩcrp�����°:jze�d|c����?Y5u�Yzn^p�k7~�crYHfqc�~�e�k�e���crp�p{�?k$crp{�c�xzxz��e���~�u�n �� � �� �� crYHf)� � ¦5X)YWn|u{wz��p � n^p�fz~u{wz��u � n�½���~�n�d©~�x�c|����~ �� �� �� crY�f �� � �� ��c�p{�Ne�fB��YBu�e¹«���f7u{n!~�e�k�xz����~���°:jz�?Y����N~�x�c^����~���¡�wle�~�e�~Yln^u�u�wz�N�?c|~���mon^p�u�wz��~�x�c^������[n�mmojzY���u{e�n|Y�~�nrmD��n^jzYHfB��f�d|crp�e�cru�e�n|Y"��*¯�bw�c?d:�/0¹Z�� 3�c�Y�f 0ÁZ?]S3­Ë

± �

Page 25: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

��� � ������� � V�JBI N/RbC � T ;Z>AI�CAI�JK>F; R?c IKN T L�CFaST?@BT#I�<?> T �=<bJXT"; IKR"(�Ï �F!42}Ð >� C����2;Z< �I�JK>F;b�]'����PE4T#@ >F;A^ I�> L T CB��� 6 � ¦2[�>FG T � G T < J R�T#@,�`I N T"G?T T�� J R"IKR&C <?>F; R"I�CF;2I � L NQJK< N>F;2@,�5Y T � T";ZYSR.>F;�I N T L�CFa�T?@BT?I&E?CSRbJ R`R��2< N�I NQCAI(�b>FG T"aST"G�� � >SRbJBI�JKaST�� !�L T`NQCFa�T

� �5Ï �F!42}Ð ' : + � � (�Ï �F! 2}Ð � �� � �� � $�� $��"� Ï)Ò^Ò:Ð

Ê�n � �?d:�?p�Ï)Ò|Ò¾Ðbf5n:��~®Yzn|u���w�crp�c^��u��?p{e�È?� ��� c�Y�fqÏ)Ò|Ò¾ÐÉfBn:��~�Yzn^u��?d:�?YTe�k�xz��t!�='�� �� �� ¦*���Yzn � u{jzp�Y�u{n�u{wz��d|crp�e�c�YBu�n�m.u{wl��³�µ�¸qc����|n^p{e�u{wzk � *�� � p{e�u{� � à �� �� ��

c�Y�fRu�wz�bYz� � �?Yz�?p��^t�eg~�fB��«�Yl��f��Bt� Ï)�-Ð.à $�� $ � � $�� ��� $ $$ Ï)Ò � Ð

¡�wl��n^xzu�e�k7c��.fB����n|k�x�n:~�e�u{e�n^Y �¥Ã Ä�W�[Ä�Reg~u{wl��n^Yz� � wze���wTk�e�Yze�kNe�È���~ � Ï­�-Ð�¦IXÍu���Beg~�u�~DcrY�f�e�~�jlYze�°:jz�:��¸zp{n|k8Yzn � n|Y � ��c�p{���¬wz�§cru{e�Yz��crY�fN~�u�cru{e�Yz�bu{w�c�u.u{wz��Yzn|p{ke�Y��ieg~�Yzn^u�fB��«HYz��f��Bt Ï)±BZ�Ð��ljzu�e�Y�~�u{��c|f��Bt$��$7Ãy~�jzx ��

�% �� �

� (��:Ï �F! 2}Ð � Ï)Ò^_:Ð

� wle���w�e�~�crY���°:jze�d|c����?Y5u�Yzn^p�kT��Ê�?p�� (��:Ï �F!42�Ð�crp���u{wz� � c?d:�?����u���n:� ?$��e��?Y5u�~�nrmF�"¦*£e�u{w!u{wz��~���Yzn|u�c�u{e�n|Y�~ � Ï­��Ð%à $�� $W� � �Ï)�-Ð � wz�?p{� �Ï­�-Ð�à � � % � (��^Ï �F! 2}Ð �(��:Ï �F!42}Ð � $ ¦�¡�wze�~-d|c�p{e�c�YBu"n|Ybu{wz��³�µ¸�cr���|n^p�e�u{wlk0����c|fz~-u{n�u�wz�mon^����n � e�Yz�Fcr���^n^p�e�u�wzkT�

*�� � crY5u�u{n�«�Y�f7u{wz��~���°¾jl�?Y���� ��Ï �F! 2}Ð � wze���w�k�e�k�e�k�e�È��§~~�jzx �Ï �% � �

����Ï �F!42}Ð � ÐI� ��%

� (��^Ï �F!42}Ð@����Ï �F!42�Ð � $ Ï)Ò � Ð

¡�wl�?Y�u{wl� � c?d:�?���?u.��n:� ?$��e��?YBu�~�nrmÎ��c�p{�"(��5Ï �F!42}Ð.à ��Ï �F! 2}Ð?!bÏ �F! 2}Ð ' : +�¦5¡�wzeg~²n^x5¨u�e�k�e�È�cru�e�n|YWxzp�n^�z���?k �?crY!�}��~�n^��d:�§fW�Bt�u{wz��mon^����n � e�Yl��xzp{n5���§fBjzp{����´��?u�cªx�n�~�e�u�e�d:�Y5jzkN���?p����}�%�^e�d:�?Y�c�Y�f����?u"jH~c^~�~�jzk��%u{w�c�u�mon^p���c|�¬w �F!^u{wz�F~���°:jz�?YH��� �}Ï �F!42}Ð?! 2�': $ !Beg~���n^Y�~�u{p�e���u���fW�5t�c���e�k�e�u{��f��zjHfB�^�?u�f5��«�Yz��fN�Bt � % �� � ����Ï �F!42�Ð � ���¦ *���crp��c|~��:��fbu{n�k�e�Yze�k�eÁÈ?� �Ï­�-Ð � e�u{wze�Y�u{wle�~"�zj�fB�|�?u��e�k�e�u�cru�e�n^Y��"¡�wze�~�xzp{n|�z���?k[eg~ Y�c�k���f�Ï��zÐ�¦:¡�wl��k�e�Yze�k�jzk0n�m �Ï)�-Ð"eg~fB�?Yln^u{�§fª�5t$��Ï��HÐ�¦ p{n|�z���?k �Ï��HÐ���crYN�}��fB����n^jB¨xl����f�e�Y5u{n�c�~���°:jz�?Y�����nrm�xlp{n^�l���?k7~���·²c|�¬w�n^Yz��n�m�u{wz��k e�~.~�u�crY�fzc�p�f7crYHfWp{��c|fz~�c|~mon|����n � ~�Ë V T CFG?T ^FJKaST ; C R�T�-��ZT";Z<4T&� % ! 2�' : !8CF;ZY5C � >SRbJBI�JKaST ;�� � E4T"G���¦ O N T";L�T�L�CF;2I I�> � JK;QJ � JED�T�� % � � % ��� % � $ �2;ZY T"G IKN T.<?>F; R"I�G CFJK; I � % � � % � ����¦�¡�wze�~�e�~

±|_

Page 26: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

cNd^c�p{egcrY5u�n^YTu�wz��~�u�crYHfzcrp�f � c§d:�����?u�~�wzp{e�Yz�|cr�^����X)Y�fB�?�§f � % crY�f � % ~�wzn|jz��f�w�c?d:�u�wz�N~{c�k���~�e��|Y�crY�f�~{c�u{e�~)mot ,�� � � % �!� � � % �À¦I¡�wz��~���u � n�p{�§°¾jze�p{�?k��?YBu�~�~�c§t!u{w�c�uu�wz� � c§d:�����?ub��n:� ?7��e��?Y5u�~bcrp��7~�wlp{jzYz��u{n � crp�fl~�,B�T¡�wz�$~�����n|Y�f�~�u{�?x���n^Y�~�e�~�u�~®e�Yk�e�Yze�kWe�È?eÁYz� �®� � ��Ï��HÐ%n�d:�?p��5' 0 , ! %£ÐÎcrY�f7e�~�����mou�u{n�u�wz�bp{��c|fB�?p?�*��b~{c�e�f � �bcrp��b��wz��cru�e�Yz�l�X)Y�fB����fªu�wze�~%crxzxlp{n:c|�¬w!�?c�Y�����°¾jz�§~�u{e�n^Yz�§f-�+*£wz��Y

f5��«�Yz��fT�5t�Ï)ÒBZ�Ð�`u�wz�WYln^p{kÅe�Y �� �� �� f5�?x��?Y�fz~bn^Y�u�wz� � c?d:�?���?u���c^~�e�~��7X)ube�~�Yzn|uu�p�c�Y�~��gcru{e�n^Y crY�f7p{n^u�cru�e�n^Y!e�Y5d|crp{egcrY5u?�

� �ÅL�� �b� �V���P��iM8 �7M²S!O� ®Q V�� � �� �

��~�e�u � c|~cr��p{��c|fBt�~�cre�fI`^u{wz��³�µ�¸Tcr���^n^p�e�u�wzk[e�~c�e�k���fbc�u.fB����n|k�x�n:~�e�Yz�bc�Y�e�k7c��^���e�Y5u{n cT~�jzk��$� � � wz��p{���¼p��?xzp���~��?Y5u�~bu{wz�Nn^�5¢{�§��u�~���n^Y5u�c�e�Yz��f�e�Y�� � wze����7�k�n5fB�?��~"u{wl��u{�?�5u{jzp���f���n|k�x�n^Yz�?Y5u�~��6*¯��~�w�cr�����¬wHcr�����?Yz�|��u{wle�~ � n|p{�5e�Yz��w5t5x}n|u{wz�§~�e�~� e�u{w�c���n|��������u{e�n^Y�n�m�~�t5Y5u{wz�?u�e���e�k7cr�|��~ � wzeg�¬w�crp���?�5xz��e���e�u{�?��t��^e�d:�?Y�c|~�cb~�jlk ����¨u � �?�?Y7cN�?crp�u{n:n|YTe�k7c��^� �!c�Y�f�c�u��?�5u{jzp�� '"¦�h�n|p{�bxzp{�§��e�~��?��t � ����n|Y�~�egfB�?p�cN~�jzk��Ã��D� ' � wz��p{�+��e�~�u�wz��~�e�k�xl����~�u�~��:�?u��¬w � ���?c�Y�«��^jzp�� � wze���� '�e�~c�YWn�~{��e����gcru{e�Yz�mojlY���u{e�n^YTk�n5f5�?��e�Yz��c�u��?�Bu�jzp{�§fT��n^k�x�n|Yz�?Y5u?��¸Hn|p�e�YH~�u�c�Y���� '"Ï��-Ð�à 2TÏ ���-Ð �%Ï��-Ð� wl�?p{� 2TÏ��-Ð"e�~.c���n^Y5u{e�YBjzn|j�~�mojzY���u�e�n|Y � wzeg�¬w�eg~.±/�}¨­x}��p{e�n5f5e���e�YNn^Yz��d|crp{egcr�z����c�Y�fwHc^~cd|c�Yze�~�wze�Yz��k���crY � wze���� �7e�~"u{wz��e�Y�fBeg�?cru�n^p"mojzY���u�e�n^Y�nrmIc�p{����u�e¹«Ic��z���%fBn|k7cre�Y"�*�� � p�e�u���� # Ï��-ÐÃ��IÏ��-Ðr� ��Ï���Ð 2TÏ ���-ÐHcrY�f�� � e����5����crp��ze�u�p�c�p{e���tb��crp��^�:� ��CF; IKN T�R�5 CA@ ^F>FG"JBI N � E4T.I�G�� R"IUT Y � C >ATHR I N T � �5 CA@ ^F>FG"JBIKN � �AJXT#@ Y C Y T <?> ��� >SRbJBI�JK>F;� # Ã�Ä� # �0Ä� # L N T"G?T IKN T R"� T?I�<?NqÄ� # J R <4@ >SR�T�I�>�IKN T�>FG"J ^FJK;ZCA@7R"�FT?I�< N�� �!h�n^p��xlp{����eg~��?��t � ���?�Bx�����u�Ä� # Ã������ # !rÄ� # à ' ��� # � wz��p{��u{wz� <

$ Yzn|p{k nrm�u{wz���?p�p{n^pu��?p{k�� # u{��Y�fz~�u{n/,B�¡�wzeg~²m­cre�p{t�u�cr���beg~�jzYBu�p{jz��`z~�e�Y����bu{wl�ª³�µ�¸�cr���^n|p{e�u�wzk crxzxl��e��§fWu{n���Ã��7f5n:��~

Yln^u��|�?u �$��c^���7�zjzu�e�Y�~�u���c^f!cªYz� � mojlY���u{e�n^Y���I¦ �0k�n|p{�bxzp{�§��e�~���~�u�cru��?k��?Y5u � e�������7�^e�d:�?Y�e�Y ´���k�k7c�Zb,B��¡�wz�7����~�u�u�n¯���7�?�5x�����u{�§f e�Y¥u�wz�7�^�?Yl�?p�c���~���u{u{e�Yz�Te�~Ä� # Ã������� # !�Ä� # Ã�'�� �B����B�� # ¦z¡�wzeg~¶eg~�u{p�jz�:`zc|~¡�wl�?n^p��?k�] � e����Iu{�?���-j�~��

¡�wz��n^p{��k ] � e����%crxzxl��t�u�n�u{wl� ³�µ�¸0cr���^n|p{e�u�wzkT`��zjzu�c���~�nTu{nTk�n|p{�N�^�?Yz��p�cr���n^Y5u{�?�5u�~��`*¯�����?�|e�Y � e�u�w�c�Êe������?p{u�~�xHc^��� Åc�Y�f $ ) $ � e����DfB�?Yzn|u{��u{wl�N��n^p�p{��¨~�x�n^Y�fBe�Yz��Yln^p{k �+*���crp{���^e�d:�?YNc�f5�?Y�~���~�jz��~�x�c^��� � - Ìu{n|�^�?u�wz�?p � e�u�wNc®Yzn|p{k� wle���wReg~F«HYze�u��®n|Y � c�Y�f�f5�?Yzn^u���fR�5t�$ ) $�?¦�XÑm � +' �8!zu{wz�?Y $"� $�¶Ã %y¦ ´���uj�~

± �

Page 27: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

c|~{~�jzk��bu{w�c�u�u{wz�bYzn|p{k $�) $��e�~���n � �?p�~��?k�e¹¨Í��n^Y5u{e�YBjzn|j�~n^Y TË$"� $� � Z¤crY�f ��e�k ���

$"�1� � $�à , � $"� $� �0Z Ï)Ò �|Ð

´��?u�j�~�f5�?Yzn^u����5t � - � u{wz�©����n�~���f7��n|YBd:�?�$~��?u�fB��«�Yl��fR�5t�$ ) $�� Z�c�Y�f���?u �� Ë �� � ����u{wz��n|p{u�wzn^�|n^Y�c���xzp�n�¢{����u�e�n^Y � �� Ï��-Ð�Ã��Re�~�u{wz��x}n|e�Y5ube�Y �� wle���w�k�e�Yle�kNe�È?��~ $�� ��� $�¦ *����BYln � mop{n|kÌ¡�wl�?n^p��?ḵ�u�w�cru�u�wz��fB����n|k�x�n:~�e�u{e�n^Y�|e�d:�?YN�5tWu�wz��³�µ�¸�c����^n|p{e�u{wzk�e�~ �Rà ����Z!��ªÃ �� Ï��-Ð�¦2*¯p�e�u{e�Yz�10 � à ��� �� !� �bw�c?d:� 0 � Ï��-Ðà �}¦l¡�wz��k7c�e�YNu{wz��n^p{��kÌnrm.u�wze�~�~�����u�e�n^Y7eg~�u{wz��mon^����n � e�Yl�zË��� � ������� 5 >FG T"aST G � ��' /! � � ' L T`NQCFaST

$+0 � Ï�� � Ð@� 0 � Ï���Ð $ � Z�ÒBÏ%$"�$.� $"� � $?Ð $"� � � � $� Ï)Ò^]:н���mon|p{�bxzp�nrd5e�Yl�N¡�wz�?n^p��?k�]5`}���?u�j�~�p{��u{jzp�YRu�nWu�wz��³�µ¸�cr���^n|p{e�u�wzkT�.¡�wz��Y��

� e��������NfB��«�Yz�§fR�5t $�) $��� �$ � � wz�?p���$ ) $��e�~�u{wz�Nf5j�cr�Yln^p{k c^~e�Y�v:����u�e�n|Y � �¡�wl�?n^p��?k�]�p{��c|fz~� ��������� � � � V]T&<?>F; RbJKY T G I N T � 85 � >�Y T?@ L�JBIKN C ^FJKa�T"; a CA@,�ZT >�&I N T � CFGHC � T"�IUT"G �I¦ _8T?I"� � CF;ZYb�A$ E4T�I�L�>���� ;Z<"I�JK>F; R JK; < $ Ï>= $ Ð�¦ _8T?I-���Ãy� I�T�� E4T`IKN T � 85Y T <?> ��� >SRbJBI�JK>F; >����b!$�Wà ZA!�±5¦`O N T"; L T`NQCFaST

$�� $ ��� � $"$ � Z�ÒBÏ%$�� � $"$� $��A$ $"$�Ð � $�� $ ���F� $� Ï)Ò^\:Ð*���Yzn � c^~{~�jzk���u�w�cruF�A$�eg~�c�~�jlk��A$�Ãy�F�-� '����?u � �?��Y7c��?crp�u{n:n|YRe�k7cr�|���F�c�Y�f�c�u��?�5u{jzp���f7��n^k�x�n|Yz�?Y5u 'T~{c�u{eg~Ímot5e�Yz��$ ' $� � ��¦ *��®u�wz�?Y7w�c?d:�

$��%$ ��� � $"$ �[Z?Ò5Ï�$��A$ $"$� $��F� $"$¬Ð � � � Ï � ,:ÐX)Yqn|u{wz��p � n^p�fz~Wu�wz�T³�µ�¸8c����|n^p{e�u{wzk fBn:��~WYzn|uWx��?p�mon^p�k � wHcru���n^jz�gf¥w�c?d:����?��Y�fBp{��c�k���f-`I~�e�Y�����u{wz�N�?c�p{u�n:n^Y���n|k�x�n^Yz��YBu�� � e�~�Yzn^u�xlp{��~��?p{d:��fI�bXÍYH~�u{�§c^f�e�u

eg~�k�n5fBeÁ«���fWe�YBu�nN� � ¦�¡�wle�~����?e�Yl��~�cre�fI`zu{wz��³�µ¸�c����^n|p{e�u{wzk�c|��u�~�e�Y!c���n|Y�~�eg~�u��?YBu� c?t-Ë � wz��Y�e�u�eg~�crxlxz��e���fWu{nN� � e�u�t5e��?�gfz~.� � Ãy� � �¤� � c�Y�f � wz�?Y7e�u%e�~�c�xzxz��e���f�u{n� $¶Ã � �|� '�e�u�tBe��?��fl~�� $¶Ã �%$:�N�A$ � wz�?p���� $¶Ã � �����Ï�� �{Ð#!��A$�Ãy�F��� ' ���Ï � �{Ð�¦½���mon|p{��xzp�n�dBe�Yz�bu{wz��~���§~�u{e�k7cru���~�`�����uj�~k7cr�:�Fcmo� � p��?k7crp��z~���¡�wz�p��?����d^c�Y����n�m�Ï)Ò^]:Ð���n|k���~²mop{n|k�u{wz�bm­c^��u�u{w�c�u�e�Y!k7crY5t7c�xzxz��eg�?cru�e�n|Y�~¶u�wz��Yln^p{k � wze���w!��n^Y5¨u�p{n|��~�� � � �¥e�~�kNj���w � ��c��:�?p�u�w�crY�u{wz��Yzn^p�k � wze���w�eg~�j�~���f�e�Y�u{wz�7����mou�¨­w�crYHf

±F�

Page 28: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

~�e�fB�7n�mNÏ)Ò|]¾Ð��yX)u�e�~�e�YHfB�?��f�u{wl����c^~��7mon^pNu{wz�T³�µ�¸8cr���^n|p{e�u�wzkT��¡�wz�?n|p{�?k ]Te�~Yln^u�e�Y5u{��p{��~�u{e�Yl� � wz�?Y $"� � �=� $� � Z^¦.X)Y�fB�?�§f¯u{wz��k7crxzxle�Yz� �� eg~�cT��n^Y5u{p�c^�¬¨u�e�n|Yqc�Y�f 0 � e�~W´�e�x�~{��wze�u{È:� *��RwHc§d:� $+0 � Ï�� � Ð�� 0 � Ï��-Ð $ ��± $"�9� � � $ � wzeg�¬we�k�xzp�nrd:�§~¶n|YqÏ­Ò^]¾Ð��5*¯� � e����xzp�nrd:��u�wz�Nn^xzu�e�k7c���e�u�t�n�m�u{wz�N~�°¾jHcrp{��p{n:n^u�e�Y�Ï)Ò|]¾Ð��¡�wl����n^jzY5u{�?p�¨)���zc�k�xz��� � wzeg�¬w � e����I�}�b�|e�d:�?Y����?��n � ��n|Y����?p�Y�~�u{wl��~�u�c�Y�fzcrp�f ³�µ�¸c����|n^p{e�u{wzk ��¡�wz�7��n^Y�����j�~�e�n^Y�e�Y¤¡�wz�?n|p{�?kÅ]!fBn:��~®Yln^u�c�xzxz��t¯u�n �� ¦²³�u�wz�?p � eg~��� � � n^jz�gfRw�c?d:��$"� �,� � $'� � $"� � � � $ � � wz��Yz�?d:�?p $"� $'�8Z ! $"� � $'�8Z ! � wzeg�¬weg~¶Yln^u�u�p{jz�:���0u{p�e�d5e�c�����n^jzY5u{��p�¨­�?�zc�k�xz����e�~��^e�d:�?Y��5t�u{wl��j�~�j�cr��³�µ�¸qc����^n|p{e�u{wzkc�xzxz��e���f�u{n©� � Ã(,�crYHf�� $ Ï���Ð.à ��n:~?Ï � )?�-Ð���Ï��-Ð�¦:Ê��?p{� �Reg~²c�~�k�n:n|u{w��ljzk�x�mojzY��¬¨u�e�n|Y�crY�f��ye�~�c�p{�ze�u{p�crp{e���t7��c�p{�|�:��¡�wl�?Y $�� $ $ � � �� � � � wze�����$�� $ ��� � $ $ � ( � ,B¦¸�e�Y�c�����tTu�wz� � �?e��^w5u��^e�d:�?Y��Bt $"� $�� $"� � $�e�Y�u{wl�Wp�e��^w5u�¨­w�c�Y�f�~�e�f5�Wn�m�Ï­Ò^]¾ÐÉ�?crY5¨Yln^u����b�?p�c|~���f-�.¡�wl��~�e�k�xl����~�u.��n^jlYBu��?p�¨­�?�lcrk�xz����fBn:��~�Yzn^u���n^Y�����p{Y�u�wz��~�u�c�Y�fzc�p�f³�µ�¸0cr���^n|p{e�u�wzk �zjlu�u{wz� � c?d:�?���?u�~�wzp�e�Yz�|c��^�:�¤XÍu�e�~��|e�d:�?Y��5t à 6 $ Ï&� Ðbc�Y�f$"� $��à $"� $ � ÃÆ~�jzx � � � �À¦"Ê��?p{� �� Ï��-Ðà ��Te�~�fB��«�Yz��f��5t �� � à � � e¹m � � � �!�ÌZ� wle���� �� � Ã[~�e��|Y � � eÁm.Yzn^u��bX)Y�n^u�wz�?p � n^p�fz~$0 � Ï��-Ð�Ã����eg~�fB��«�Yl��fR�5t��� � à ,WeÁm� � � � �0Zbc�Y�f��� � à � � ��~�e��|Y � � eÁm�Yzn^u���¡�wle�~²n|x��?p�c�u{n^p 0 � eg~�c�~�wlp{e�Yl�^c��^� � wzeg�¬wxljz���g~�u{wz����n:� ?7��e��?Y5u�~"��c^����u{n ,B��*���Yzn � ��wz�����WÏ­Ò^]:Ð�n|YWu�wz��u � nb~��§°¾jz��Y�����~�Ï�� � Ðc�Y�fTÏ�� �� Ð.fB��«�Yz��fW�5t � �� Ã[Z� �De¹m%Z'� � � � crY�f5� �� Ã(,®e¹m � � �[��Z|¦ *£wz��Y� � à Z®eÁm�Z � � � � crY�f�� � à ,ªeÁm � � ���£ZA! � �bw�c?d:� $"� � � � $ � à � � wze����$+0 � Ï�� � Ð@�;0 � Ï��-Ð $¶Ã � � ��¦l¡�wz����n|Y�~�u�crY5ubZ?Ò�e�~�n|�Bd5e�n|j�~���t�Yzn^u�n^xlu{e�k$cr�)�¡�wz�bxzp�n:nrm%nrmΡ�wz�?n|p{�?k ]ª���?�|e�Y�~ � e�u�w�c�~�u�c�Y�fzcrp�f����?k�k�c

� ��� ��� � _�T#I � - E4T C <4@ >SR�T Y�<?>F;QaST�� R�T?IP� _8T?I � �`' /! �+��à �� Ï�� ��Ð?! � ��Ã� � � �� Ï�� �?Ð?! CF;ZY � à $ � � $�¦Z:!�8� �à � �|� �A� L N T"G T �A� '�� CF;ZY�$ �F� $� � � � $"� � $�!IKN T"; L T NQCFaST

$ � �.� � � $ �£±���� �

$± $"� � $ Ï � Z�Ð

¡�wz�bxzp�n:nrm%e�~�~�u�c�Y�fzcrp�f�c�Y�fR����mou�u�nWu�wz�bp{��c|fB�?p?�¸zp{n|k Yzn � n|Y �£e�~.fB��«�Yz��f��Bt�$ ) $� �[Z�crYHfWu{wz��n|u{wz��p�Yzn|u�cru�e�n|Y�~²n�m´��?k�k$c

� crp��b�:�?xzu?�7*¯�bu�wz�?Y7w�c?d:�� ��� ��� �):!� ,"E�� �[Z ! ,"E �$� Z ! � �¶Ã � �"���A�?! $ � � $� � ��� $"� � $�! $��A� $� �Z�� �%!7IKN T"; L�T`NQCFaST

$ � � ��� � $� \ � ��� � $"� � $ Ï � ±:Ð

±|]

Page 29: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

¸zn|p�xzp�nrd5e�Yl�¯Ï � ±:Ð�` � ��f5��«�Yz� ��A�bÃ�Ï�ZÉ� �zÐ � � �A� � wle���w¯�?YH~�jzp���~�$ �� � $� ��Z�c�Y�f��A� ' �%¦ *���u{wz�?Y fB��«HYz� ��F��à � � ����A��¦½�t�u{p�e�d5e�cr�Écr���|�?�zp�c � �¯wHc§d:� ��F��ÃÏ�Z�� �zÐ � � �F��� �}Ï�Z�� �zÐ � � � ��crY�f7u{wz�bu�p{e�c�Yz�^���be�Yz��°:j�c���e�u�t�e�k�xz��e���~

$ �� � $ � � ��� $"� � $�! �¯Ã ��� �Z¶� � � � �Ï{Z�� �HÐ $"� � $ �

��� �Z¶� � Ï � Ò:Ð

³�Y7u{wl�®n|u{wz��pw�c�Y�f-`zu�wz��fB��«�Yze�u{e�n^Y7nrm �� �FcrY�f7u{wz�bu�p{e�c�Yz�^���be�Yz��°:j�c���e�u�t��|e�d:�$ �� �.��� � $�

�Z�� � Ï)±� �HÐ $"� � $ Ï �A� Ð

¸�e�Y�c�����tT´��?k�k7c � e�~�c�xzxz��e���fRu�n7u{wz�N~�jz��n^xzu�e�k7c��.fB����n|k�x�n:~�e�u{e�n^Y � ��à �� �� ��A��¦¡�wle�~�e�~�u�wz�bYzn^Y5¨)u�p{e�d5e�c��"e�Yz�|p{��f5e��?Y5u�n�m.u{wz�bxzp�n:nrm��%X)u�tBe��?��fz~

$ �� �.��� � $�y±� ��� � $± $"� � $ Ï � _:Ð

�.n|kW�le�Yze�Yz��Ï �A� Ð � e�u�w�Ï � _:Ð�t5e�����fz~�Ï � ±:Ð��

*��bYzn � xzp{n�d:�b¡�wl�?n^p��?k�]�jzY�fB�?p�u�wz��mon^����n � e�Yz��mon|p{k� ��� ��� :!�/��' /!?� � ' /! �»Ã �R� �Z! �0à �� Ï��-Ð#! � � à � � � � � ! � � à �� Ï�� � Ð?! � à $ � $�! � � à $ � � $�!�CF;QY $"� � � � $� �[ZA!7I N T ;

$ � � ��� $�0Z�Ò $"� � � � $��Ï�$"� $� $"� � $?Ð Ï � � ÐX)Y�´��?k�k7cW]5` � eg~�fB��«HYz��f�c^~�e�Y¤¡�wz�?n|p{�?k ]B� *���w�c?d:� , ' � � wze���w¯e�k�xz��e���~$ � $ � $"� $�¦X)Y�fB����f¯u{wl��u{p�e�d5e�cr�%fB�§��n^k�x�n�~�e�u�e�n|Y � à �$� ,�eg~��¬wHcr�����?Yz�|e�Yz�7u{wl�n|xzu{e�k7cr�ÎfB����n|k�x�n:~�e�u{e�n^Y��¥Ã ��� �z¦6*¯��cr�g~�n�wHc§d:��$ � � $$� $"� � $�¦�¡�wz�Nxzp{n:n�m�n�m´���k�k7cb]W~�u�c�p{u�~ � e�u�w7u{wz��mon^����n � e�Yl��m­c^��u

� � � � � � � �Z�� � Ï%$"�$� $"� � $?Ð Ï � �|Ð

� wl�?p{� �.à $"�1� � � $�?¦¸zn^p�xzp�nrd5e�Yl�7Ï � �|Ð�`�n^Yz� � p{e�u{��~ �RÃ(� � � �1� � � à � � � � � � �1� � � à � � � � � � �

� e�u{w � � � Ã[Ï{Z"����Ð � � Ï � � ��� ��� � Ðc�Y�f � � � à � � � �� ��� Ï � � ��� ��� � Ð�¦Hv�e�Y���� $�� $� �[ZA!

±|\

Page 30: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

u�wz��u{p�e�c�Yz�^����e�Yz��°:j�c���e�u�t�t5e�����fz~ $�� � � $� �[Z^¦�XÍuDe�k�xz��e���~ $ � $ � $ � � � $%~�e�Y�������à ����eg~�n^xzu�e�k7c��)�D¡�wz��fB��«�Yze�u{e�n^Y7nrm � � � crY�f7u{wz�bu{p�e�c�Yz�^���®e�Yz��°:j�cr��e�u�t�t5e��?�gf

$ � � � $� $ � � $.� �Z�� � $�� � � �1�9� � $ Ï � ]:Ð

v�e�Y���� � � à � � � � � c�Y�f $ � � $ � $"� � $�! � �RwHc§d:� $�� � � � �M� � $ � $"�$�� $"� � $�¦�.n|kW�le�Yze�Yz��u�wze�~���~�u{e�k7cru�� � e�u{w�$ � $ � $ � � � $�crY�f�Ï � ]¾Ð�` � ��n^�zu�cre�Y

� � � � � �Z¶��� Ï�$"� $� $"� � $?Ð Ï � \:Ð

½�jlu��TcrY�f�� � c�p{��xl��c?tBe�Yz�N~�t5k�k���u{p{e���p�n^���§~�� *���cr��~�nWwHc§d:� � � � � � �� ��� Ï%$"�$.�$"� � $?Ð%crY�f�Ï � �^Ð.mon^����n � ~²mop{n^k u{wz��~��bu � nWe�Yz��°:j�cr��e�u�e���~��

*��bYzn � p��?u{jzp�Y�u{n �7à �� ��c�Y�f � p�e�u{� �$à � ���!� � wz�?p{� �ià � ���9�F� � ��¦¡�wl�?Y�$(��$ � �[Z²���FcrY�f�$ � � $ � � � �� ��� Ï�$"� $� $"� � $?Ð�5tTÏ � �^Ð���´��?k�k7c �bt5e��?�gfz~

$ � � ��� $ �[Z?ÒBÏ%$"� $²� $"� � $?Ð � � Ï)_A,:Ðc|~c�YzYzn|jzY�����fI�

J�� � ��M²V�� ���rV�M � V�L ��� �P�O� � �

¡�wl�?n^p��?k ]7e�~bn^xzu�e�k7c��e�Y�u�wz��mon^����n � e�Yz� ~��?Y�~��:�!¡�wz�7~{°:j�c�p{��p�n:n^u�e�Y¤u{wz��µÊbvn�m7Ï­Ò^\¾Ð$�?crYlYzn^u!�}��p{��xz��c|����fq�5tycrYy�?�Bx�n|Yz�?Y5uR�gcrp��^�?p7u{wHcrY Z�+�±B¦�¸zn^p7xzp{n�d5e�Yz�u�wze�~�p{��k7crp��-`.���?uNj�~�f5�?Yzn^u����5t�& u{wl��jzYze�u7fBeg~{�¯Ï­���?Y5u{�?p���f�cru/, � e�u�w£p�c|fBe�j�~Z�ÐNcrYHfifB��Yzn^u��T�Bt�&

u{wl��fBe�~������?Y5u{��p{��f�cru�,5` � e�u�w£p�c|fBe�j�~!Z�� ��¦ �.n^Y�~�e�fB�?p�F�à ��� !��A$�à �����{¦I¡�wz�?Y � ��w�c?d:� $��A$ ��� � $�'� ��¦-¡�wle�~¶mon|����n � ~�mop{n|k cWk�n|p{��|�?Yz�?p�cr�"n|��~��?p�d|cru{e�n^Y!�^e�d:��Y��Bt�u{wz��mon^����n � e�Yl�����?k�k$cB�� ��� ����� :!�'� J R C5GHCFYFJKCA@���� ;Z<"I�JK>F;�CF;ZY5J � '"Ï �^Ð.à �

�� �� 4��IÏ 4^Ð � 4F!�IKN T";

$ � $�Fà $ '$ � Ï)_BZ�С�wl��xzp{n:n�m"nrm�´��?k�k7c�\�e�~�~�u{p�cre��^w5u�mon^p � c�p�f-�.X)u.~�j,?7����~�u{n � p{e�u�� �IÏ ��Ð%à *� Ï�� � '-Ðr�� Ï � '�Ð � wze���w�mon^����n � ~Îmop{n|k u�wz�bfB��«�Yze�u�e�n|YWn�m ' ¦l¡�wz�?Y��ÃyfBe�d /! �Ã[Ï%�

�'6! �'�Ð

c�Y�f�$��$ � à $ ' $ � ¦|¡�wze�~"e�k�xz��e���~ $ � $� � $ ' $ � ¦^¡�wl����n � �?p���n|jzY�f�e�~"kNj��¬w���c^~)¨e��?p?��¡�wz��Yln^p{k[n�m"c�p�c^f5e�cr�:mojzY���u{e�n|Y���Ï �^Ð"e�Y ����Ï8= $ Ð"eg~�~�e�k�xl��t�±/� � �� � � � Ï ��Ð � � � �r¦

Ò ,

Page 31: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

����n � ��pW��n^jlY�f n�m�u{wz� fBj�cr��Yzn^p�k $ � $�Weg~W�^e�d:�?Yq�5t�±/�b~�jzx � � �� �IÏ �^ÐÍ��Ï �^Ð � � �� wl�?p{��u�wze�~b~�jlxzp{�?kNjzkÌeg~b��n^k�xljzu{��f7n^Y�u{wz�N��n^��������u�e�n^Y!nrm¶cr���Du{��~�u{e�Yl�$mojlY���u{e�n^Y�~~�cru�e�~Ímot5e�Yl�N±/�"� �� � � � Ï ��Ð � � � � �0Z^¦I¡�wze�~���Y�fz~�u{wl�®xlp{n:nrm%n�m�´��?k�k7cb\B�´��?k�k7cb\ªe�k�xz��e���~�u�wz��mon^����n � e�Yz��p���~�jz��u

� ��� ��� � � _�T?I ��� Y T";Z>AIUT IKN T�JK;QYFJK<?CAI�>FG1��� ;Q<4I�JK>F; >�5IKN T/YFJ Rb<�� � �*� 0b¦ V TIKN T"; NQCFaST�$ ��� $�$à 0 +�±5¦ O N T � �5 Y T <?> ��� >SRbJBI�JK>F; >� ��� J R.^FJKaST";=E�� ���iÃ�����$���9L N T"G?T.��� Ã(,5J � � 0 �[Z�CF;ZYb����Ã[Ï�Z7� �� � Ð ����!�����à �� � ���9J � � 0 �0Z^¦¡�wl��«�p�~�ubc^~�~��?p�u{e�n|YTnrm�´��?k�k$c�Z ,�e�~��^e�d:�?Y��5t¯´��?k�k7c�\5��¡�wz�N~�����n|Y�f�n^Yz��mon|�¹¨��n � ~Îmop{n|k u�wz�b��w�crp�c^��u��?p{e�È�cru�e�n|YWn�mu�wz�®³�µ�¸�fB����n^k�x�n:~�e�u�e�n^YN�^e�d:�?Y��5tN¡�wz�?n|p{�?k±5��*¯��w�c?d:� $���� $��à �$ � c�Y�f � ���"��� � �Rà $����'$��"� $����+$� � wzeg�¬w��?YHfz~²u�wz��xzp{n:n�m��

*���p{��u{jzp�Y¯u�n�u{wl��n^xzu�e�k7c���e�u�t!���gcre�kT�5��~�~�jzk�e�Yz����Ã�± !�u{wz�!³�µ�¸yfB����n|kW¨x�n�~�e�u�e�n|Y�nrm��F��crY�f�� $�c�p{�7�F��à � ��y� �#!��A$�à �%$�� �A$ � wz�?p{��� ��à �$ �F�"!�� $ªÃÏ�Z7� �$�B� ��� � ÐÍ�A$�¦�XÍu.e�k�xz��e���~-� $ �7� �.à �$�B� ��� � �F�B�

� � $ �$�B� ��� � � � � wz��p{� � � e�~�u�wz��e�Y�f5e��?c�u{n^pmojlY���u{e�n^Y�n�m�u{wz�$crYzY5jz��jH~WZ � � � � � Z�� ��¦�¸�e�Y�cr����t $�� $ �y� � $"$ � � �$ � wzeg�¬we�k�xz��e���~u{wl�®n|xzu{e�k7cr��e�u�t:�

J�J �)��� � � �b � P��iM8 �7M²S!O� �

*��7~�u{e�������n|Y�~�egfB�?p�u{wz��n|p{e��^e�YHcr�³�~�wz�?p�¨Íµ�j�fBe�Y5¨�¸�cru��?k�e%cr���^n|p{e�u�wzkT�TÊ��?p{��crY�f�e�Y� wHcru�mon^����n � ~�` $ ) $��f5�?Yzn^u���~�u{wl��Yzn^p�k e�Y�u{wl�7½�crY�c|�¬w¼~�x�c|����� � wle���w¯eg~®u{wl�f5j�cr��n�m �� �� � ¦D¡�wz�T³�µ�¸0fB�§��n^k�x�n�~�e�u�e�n|Y�tBe��?��fl~®�£Ã ,�ÏÑYznTn|�5¢{����u�Ð � wz�?Yl�?d:�?p$�� $� � �$ � ¦�*¯�!Yzn ��� n^jl��f¥��e��:��u�n����?u{u��?pNjzY�fB�?p�~�u�crY�fqu�wz��k��§crYze�Yz�Tnrmbu�wze�~��n^Y�fBe�u{e�n^Y"�.h�n|p{�bxzp{�§��e�~��?��t � ��c�e�k�c�u�~�wzn � e�Yz�Nu{wl�Émon|����n � e�Yz�� ���� �� � �� ��� � ��Rb< JB@B@ CAI�JK;A^ � CAI I T G4; R NQCFaST C�R � CA@B@ $ ) $ � ;Q>FG � �¡�wle�~®eg~�~�u{e�����c7d^c��^jz�!~�u�cru��?k��?Y5u�~�e�Y���� � �7fBegf¯Yzn|uNfB��«�Yz� � w�cruNc�Y¥n�~{��e����gcru{e�Yz�xHcru{u��?p{Y!e�~�crY�f�u�wz��~�k7cr����Yz�§~{~���n^Y�fBe�u{e�n^Y�e�Y p{n|x�n:~�e�u{e�n^Y�±�fBn:�§~¶Yzn|u�k���c�Y!crY5t¾¨u�wze�Yl�z� p{n|x}n�~�e�u{e�n|Y�Ò � e����-u�c��:���?crp��®n�m.u{wl��~��be�~�~�jz�§~��

¸zn^p�u{wl�®u�e�k������?e�Yl�z`z����u�j�~�e�Y5u{p�n5fBj�����u�wz��mon^����n � e�Yz�Nf5��«�Yze�u{e�n|Y"Ë

Ò5Z

Page 32: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

����������� ��� �)_�T?I ��E4T C ;Z>F;)�U; T ^FCAI�JKa�T >FG T?@ � T CSR��2G T�� V]T�RbC�� IKNQCAI �9J R C � �)�C CFa JKY � T CSR��2G T&J �`IKN T"G?T T�� J R"IKR.C <?>F;FR"I�CF; I �PR�� <?N�I NQCAI(�b>FG T aST"G�� YFJ Rb< &�Ï�� � ! 0�Ð<4T ; I T G T Y�CAI7� � L�JBI N G CFYFJ�� R�0-L T`NQCFaST

�Ï &�Ï�� � ! 0�Ð{Ð � � 0 Ï)_^±:иzn|p�e�YH~�u�c�Y��������?uF ����7c�p{����u{e¹«}cr�z���N��jzp{d:�Ne�Y¤u{wz�Nxz��c�Yz�7c�Y�f����?u��qf5�?Yzn^u���u{wl�c�p��¬¨­����Yz�^u�w�n^Y! �¦I¡�wz�?Y �Te�~�c ��jzt!a�c?d5e�fRk���c^~�jzp{�be¹m²crY�f�n|Yz��t7e¹m� �e�~��wz�Ámon^p�~p��?�^jl��crp�� ��jzt�a�c?d5e�f�xzp�n�d:��f u�w�crubu�wze�~b��n|Y�fBe�u�e�n|Y¯eg~É�§°¾jze�d|cr����YBu�u{n!u{wz�N��n^jzY�f:¨�§fBYz��~�~nrm%u{wl� �%crjH�¬w5t�e�YBu��?�^p�cr��n^x��?p�c�u{n|pbc^��u�e�Yz��n^Y;< $ Ï� � � ��Ð�¦"XÑm ��eg~�c�~�e��^Yz�§f½�n|p{�?�lk���c^~�jzp{��` � ��~{c?tNu{w�c�u �7e�~%c ��jzt�a�c?d5e�f�k���c^~�jzp{��eÁm�c�Y�fWn^Yl��t�e¹m�u{wz��k���c?¨~�jzp{� � �'��~{c�u{e�~)«���~.Ï)_|±¾Ð�c�Y�f�u{wz�%n^xzu�e�k7c�� �qe�Y�Ï­_^±¾Ð � e����:u�wz�?Y�����f5�?Yzn^u���f®�5t�$��+$���¦�YHfB�?p�~�u�c�Y�fBe�Yl��u{wl�bfBj�c��-Yzn|p{k $ ) $��eg~²kNj��¬w���c^~�e��?p%e¹m�n^Yz�bu�c��:��~e�Y7c|�?��n|jzYBu

u�wz��mon^����n � e�Yz��u�wz�?n|p{�?k��� � ������� � H-;Q>F;)�U;%T ^FCAI�JKaST �>FG T#@ � T CSR��2G T � E4T?@ >F;A^SR I�> � J � CF;ZY >F; @N� J � �J R C � �L� C CFa JKY � T CSR��2G T��´���u�j�~N~�u{p���~{~Nu{w�c�u7¡�wz�?n|p{�?k \�fBn:�§~$Yln^u�wzn|��f�e�Y£f5e�k��?YH~�e�n|Y�~���c�p{�|�?p�u{wHcrYy±B�½���mon^p{��xlp{n�dBe�Yz�!¡�wz�?n|p{�?k \$���?u�j�~�~�u�p{��~�~Ée�u�~k���crYze�Yz�z� *¯�NYz�?��f�u�n7xzp{n�d:��u{wl�mon|����n � e�Yz����~�u{e�k$cru{�

� � � � �'� � � $�� $��"� $��+$�� Ï)_^Ò:Ð

� wl�?Yz�?d:�?p��¥���?��n^Yz��~�u{n7u{wz��v�n^��n^���?d�~�x�c|��� �� �� � ¦�´��?ubj�~b~�u�p{��~�~Éu�w�crubu�wz�R´IÊbvn�m�Ï)_|ҾРfBn:��~TYzn^u�w�c?d:��c k���crYze�Yz�qeÁm7� ' ���D¦b¸zn^pTe�Y�~�u�crY�����u�wz�qe�YBu��?�^p�cr�����Ï�� �"!?,¾Ð � � �beg~Ék���crYze�Yz�^����~{~�e¹m�� ')���¦�X)Y�fB�?�§f¯c�mojzY���u�e�n^Y�e�Y ���Ìf5n:��~®Yzn|uwHc§d:��c®u�p�c|���n|Y7c®��e�Yz��c�Y�fWeg~În|Yz��tNf5��«�Yz��f�cr��k�n:~�uD�?d:�?p{t � wz�?p��:�6*¯��Yzn � p{��u{jzp�Yu�n7u{wz�Nxzp{n:n�m���³�Yz� � c?tTe�~�n^�5dBe�n^j�~��NXÍu�~�j,?7����~�u{n7u{��~�uNÏ)_^Ò:Ð�n|Y�cWmojzY���u�e�n^Y¤���f5��«�Yz��f��5tT���Ï���Ð�Ã�Z�n^YTu�wz�NfBe�~��$&�Ï�� ��! 0�Ð � e�u�w����Ï��-Ðà ,�n^jlu�~�egfB��u{wl�NfBe�~��&�Ï�� ��!�± 0�Ð�u{n^�|�?u{wl�?p � e�u�w����DÏ��-Ð�à $ � � � � �� e�Y����?u � ���?Y"�T¡�wz��Y $����+$���� à � 0c�Y�f � ��� � � � �DÏ &�Ï�� �A!(0�Ð?!I~�e�Y����(��e�~�Yzn|YB¨)Yl�?�:c�u{e�d:����¡�wzeg~¶�?YHfz~u{wl����c|~�t7x�crp�un�m.u{wl�®xlp{n:nrm��

¡�wz��n|u{wz��pbfBe�p�����u�e�n^Y!e�~k�n^p{��e�Y5d:n^��d:��f-��X)ub~�j,?$����~�u{n7u�p{��c�u�u{wz�©�?c^~�� � wz�?p����Ï��-Ð � ,B¦.¸zn|p�xzp{n�d5e�Yz�¤Ï)_^Ò:Ð � ��p{��xz��c|�����£�5t � �#��� wl�?p{� �

Ï��-Ð�à ��� ��Ï%�

Ð�¦¡�wl�¼mojlY���u{e�n^Y �8e�~T~�k�n:n^u�w � e�u{wÆ��n|k�x�c|��uT~�jzxzx�n^p�u�c�Y�f8~�cru{eg~Í«��§~ � � à Z^¦¡�wle�~�x��?p{k�e�u�~Wu�n��?�Bu��?Y�f0Ï­_^Ò¾Ð�u{n crY5t¥mojzY���u{e�n|Y0� ' ��� c�Y�f � w�c�u7e�~��?d:�?Y

Ò|±

Page 33: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

k�n^p{�Te�k�x�n^p�u�crY5u7e�u7x��?p{k�e�u�~Nu{nqjH~�� � ��cr�£��e�k�e�u�~�e�Y ���¦�h�n^p���xzp�����e�~��?��t � ���crYycrxlxzp{n�c^��wyc mojzY���u�e�n|Y£�W'���� � e�u{wy��n|k�x�c^��u{��t¤~�jlxzx�n^p{u���fqmojzY���u�e�n^YH~ªe�Y���D¦ ���?�Bu�u{wz�§~��WmojzYH��u{e�n^Y�~�c�p{�7p{�?xl��c^����f¯�5t�~�e�k�xz���ªmojlY���u{e�n^Y�~�`�c|~�e�Y�p�n^x�n:~�e¹¨u�e�n|Y[Z^�8´��?u�jH~WYzn � fB��Yzn^u����5t£�0c���n^k�x�c|��u{��t�~�jlxzx�n^p{u���fy~�e�k�xz����mojzY���u{e�n|Y"�¡�wl�?Y£��Ï��-ÐWà � #� ( � ?Ï��-Ð � wz�?p{��,�� ( � E ( ��EŦ?¦?¦�E ( # ¦.Ê�?p�� � Ne�~�u{wl�e�Y�fBeg�?cru�n^p�mojzY���u�e�n|Y¯n�m�c�~���u �� � wze���wTe�~�cW«�Yze�u��WjlYze�n|Y�nrm¶~{°:j�crp���~��5*�� � p{e�u{���FÃ)�� N¦�¦?¦ �� # ¦:¸�e�Y�cr����t�$�� $��"�Tà � # � �� Ï ( � � � ( �Ð�6 � wz�?p{��6 Îe�~u{wz������Yz�^u�wn�m�u{wz�N��n^jzYHfzcrp�t �!���¦�¸�e�YHcr����t � � � �ià � # � �� ( �ÏU���Ð�¦�½�jzu���Nà �� � �� � �� wle���wqe�k�xz��e���~ �ÏU���Ð�à �DÏ)���Ð�� �Ï&�� � ��Ð�¦ ��~�e�Yz� ����?�­ÂÀ~�u{p�crY�~)mon^p{k$cru{e�n^Y � �n|�zu�c�e�Y � � � � à � #� Ï ( � ( � ��Ð �Ï&��?Ð�¦�Ê�?p���( � �ià ,5¦bXÍu!u{wz��Y8~�j,?$����~�u{njH~��7u{wz�Nmon^����n � e�Yz��^ T > � T#I�G"JK<?CA@ THR"I�J � CAIUT)�DÏ)�Ð � $��'$�� � Ï �!�Ð � wzeg�¬w�e�k�xz��e���~�DÏ)���Ð � � 6 $��+$���crYHf)��� � � � ��$�� $��"�+$��'$���¦�¡�wze�~�eg~�¡�wz�?n|p{�?k�\5��¸zn|pxzp�n�d¾¨e�Yz��n^jlp��~�u{e�k7cru�� � � � p�e�u����yc^~�u{wl�É«HYze�u��®jlYze�n|YRn�m.e�u�~���n^YlYz����u���f7��n^k�x�n|Yz�?Y5u�~� ��c�Y�f � �TfB��Yzn^u��R�5t < ��u{wz�7����Yz�^u�w¥n�m �!� ��¦%¡�wz�?Y � � e�~N��n|YBu�cre�Yl��f�e�Y£cf5e�~{�"&"�qnrmDp�c|fBe�jH~�< ��¦zX)u�~�j,?$����~²u�n�j�~��©Ï)_^±:Ðmon^p &"�£u�n�xzp�nrd:��u{wz� ^2T > � T?I�G"JK<?CA@T R"I�J � CAIUT��

¡�wz��n^p{��k \7e�~�Yzn^u�d|cr��egf¯e�Y�n^u�wz�?p©fBe�k���Y�~�e�n^Y�~���X)Y�fB�?�§f¯c!fBn^k7c�e�Y � - = +� wle�u{w� $ Ï �!�Ð �0Z��?crY!���®jlYB��n^jlY�fB��f-���jzt�a�c?dBegfªk���c^~�jzp{��~Dcrp{��Yz�?�§fB��f�e�YNjzY�fB�?p�~�u�crY�fBe�Yz��u�wz��x}n|e�Y5u � e�~���kNjz��u�e�xz��e¹¨��p�~�nrm ���¦

����������� ��� � V]T RbC�� IKNQCAI�C � T CSR��2GHCFE4@BT ���2;Z<4I�JK>F;$2TÏ��-Ð&J R C � >FJK; I�L�J R�T � � @ I�J!�� @DJXT"G >�`���-J �?c(�b>FG T"a�T"G �b� '�����!6IKN TA���2;Z<4I�JK>F;��IÏ��-Ð.Ã�2TÏ���ÐÍ��Ï���Ð&CA@ Rb>5E4T?@ >F;A^�RI�> ���D¦¡�wl������n:~���fR�|p�c�xzw�u�wz�?n^p��?kÌt5e��?�gfz~²u�wz����n^Y5u{e�YBjle�u�tWn�m.u{wl�®k$crxzxze�Yz� ! ËB��Ï��-Ð ��2TÏ���ÐÍ��Ï���Ð�¦ *��bu{wz�?Y7w�c?d:��mon^p���d:�?p{t�� ' ����!

$�2 Ï��-Ð���Ï��-Ð $��"� � � $�� $���� Ï)_ � ÐX)u�eg~�p{��c|fBe���t�~��?�?Y�u{w�c�u�Ï­_ � Ð�e�k�xz��e���~ 2TÏ��-Ð/' < � ¦.XÑm 2TÏ��-Ð5' < � !e�u©~�j,?$����~u�n¯xlp{n�d:��Ï)_ � Ð � wl�?Y£�P' �� �� � ¦.XÍYHfB�?��f�e¹m®� 'W���8!u{wz�?p��7�?�Beg~�u�~�c¯~���°¾jl�?Y������ ' �� �� � ~�j��¬w�u�w�cru $��� $��"� � $�� $����0crY�f���e�k $�� �y�� $"$7à , � wze���w��?Y�fz~u�wz��xlp{n:nrm©nrm�n^jlp�p{�?k$crp{�I�yXÑm��W' �� �� � � �!w�c?d:����Ï 2R�"Ð7à 2 ����� � � 2T¦v�e�Y���� 2 ' < � ! � ��w�c?d:�'2 ��� ' < � crY�f � �Nc�p{�N����f�u�n���~�u{e�k$cru{e�Yz� $�� � 2�$ ��¦v�e�Y������)' �� �� � e�k�xz��e���~ � � ��' �� �� � !��?d:�?p�tBu�wze�Yz�7�?YHfz~ � e�u{w�u�wz�7��n|k�xzjzu�cru{e�n^Y

Ò|Ò

Page 34: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

n�m � � � 2�� � � � � wz�?Y���e�~�c$Yln^YB¨­Yz�?��cru{e�d:��mojzY���u�e�n|YTe�Y �� �� � ¦I¡�wz�?Y¤¡�wz�?n^p��?k \e�k�xz��e���~u{wl�Émon|����n � e�Yz���� � ������� � � H � T CSR��2GHCFE4@ T ���2;Z<4I�JK>F;12 Ï��-Ð J R C � >FJK;2I�L�J R�T � � @ I�J � @ JXT"G >� ���J � CF;ZY�>F; @,�5J ��2 ' < � Ï>= $ Ð CF;ZY�� 2 J R�C � �L�#C CFa JKY � T CSR��2G T��¸zn|pe�Y�~�u�crY����b���?u�j�~���n^Y�~�e�fB��pu�wz�be�Y�fBeg�?cru�n^p�mojzY���u�e�n|Y � � n�m%cNfBn^k7c�e�Y � � e�u{wTcp�����u�e¹«Ic��z���b��n^jzYHfzcrp�t:��¡�wl�?Y�� � e�~�cNx}n|e�Y � e�~���kNjz��u�e�xz��e��?p.nrm���� eÁm%crYHf�n^Yz��tReÁm� � eg~�c ��jzt$a�c?dBegfR��jzp{d:�:�

*���u{wz��Y�crxzxz��tT¡�wz��n^p{��k Z ,�u�n�u{�?�5u{jlp{��c�Y�cr��tz~�e�~���¡�wz��mon|����n � e�Yz�7��n|p{n|����c�p{txlp{�?��j�fB��~�u{wl��c�Y�cr��tz~�e�~�nrm�~�n^k��Tu��?�Bu�jzp{�§~ � wle���w0c�p{��xzp{��~��?Y5uRe�Y0~�n^k���v F³�¡e�k7cr�|��~��� ��������� � � � _�T#I �AR/Y T!0 ;%T/I N T � �F@ I�J � @ JXT"G5;Z>FG � >�52 E�� $�2�$

�à $�2�$ � �$ � 2 $��%¦�O N T"; I N T G T T�� J R"I R C5<?>F; R"I�CF; I ��� R�� < N�IKNQCAI

$�2 Ï��-Ð���Ï��-Ð $� � ��� $�2�$�$�� $� Ï)_^_:Ð

�b>FG T"a�T"G ���]' < $ ¦´���u�j�~c�Y�cr��tBÈ���c�u{���Bu�jzp{� � wle���w�c�xzx���crp�~¶e�YT~�n^k���v F³�¡ie�k7cr�|��~²n�m.u{wl����e�u�tWn�m¡"n^jl��n^jH~��:�!X)u���n^Y�����p{Y�~�u{wl��x��?p{e�n5fBe���x�cru�u{�?p�Y�~®n�m�~�n|k���p{n:n�m­~��T¡�wz�§~��Nx�cru�u{�?p�Y�~c�p{�©fB��~{��p{e�����f7�Bt�u{wz�bmon^����n � e�Yz�Nk�n5fB�?�­� *������?�|e�Y � e�u{w cªp���cr�Á¨)d|c���jz��f�mojzY���u�e�n|Y�¶Ï��-Ð�à ��Ï�� �"!#�%$�Ð ' < � Ï>= $ Ð � wle���wqe�~ C�¨­x��?p{e�n5fBe���e�Y � � Ë ��Ï�� �� C�!?� $�Ð�Ã�¶Ï�� �"!?� $¬Ð�¦"Ê�?p���crYHf e�Y � w�cru�mon^����n � ~�` Cqe�~�c7~�k$cr����x�n:~�e�u{e�d:��Y5jzkN�}��p?�`*��Ncr��~�nc|~{~�jzk��1���� �¶Ï��"!?� $¬Ð � �Tà ,Te�f5�?YBu�e��?c�����t¯e�Y=� $�¦%¡�wz�T��c�u{u��?pNc^~�~�jzk�xlu{e�n|Y£�?c�Y£���°:jz��~�u{e�n^Yz��fNcrYHf � e��������b~�jlxzxzp{�§~{~��§fWe�Y7cbk�n^k��?YBu��"¡�wzeg~²x��?p{e�n5fBe���mojzY���u{e�n|Y1��Ï���Ðeg~Wk�n5fB����e�Yl�¯u�wz�¯x��?p�e�n5fBeg��x�cru�u{�?p�Yin�m�u{wz��p{n:n�m�`�zjzu � �Tw�c?d:�Tu{n�fB�?��e�k�e�u�u{wl�x�n�~�e�u�e�n|Yin�m�u{wl�Tp{n:nrm�� ¡�wze�~�e�~Nu�cr�:��Y£�?c�p{���Bt�u{wl�Te�Y�fBeg�?cru�n^pWmojlY���u{e�n^Yynrm�u{wl�p�n:nrm�`bn^p7k�n|p{�T�^��Yz�?p�c�����tq�5t£c¼mojlY���u{e�n^Y 2 ' < � ~�j��¬wyu{wHcru�� 2 eg~�c ��jzta�c§d5e�f�k���c^~�jzp{����¡�wz��k�n5fB�?�.nrm�u�wz��p{n:n�m�eg~®�|e�d:�?Y��BtTu�wz��xzp�n5fBj���u 2TÏ��-Ð���Ï��-Ð�¦¡�wl�?Y�½��?p{YH~�u{��e�Y"ÂÇ~�e�Yz��°:j�c���e�u�e���~�t5e�����f�$�"$�'� � $ C $�"$ � ¦-¡�wl�?p{��mon|p{��u{wz��xzp{n5fBjH��u2TÏ���Ð���Ï��-ÐDe�~�c�u{�?�5u{jzp���e�Y!cN~��?YH~��b�^e�d:�?Y7�BtNu{wz��mon|����n � e�Yz����~�u�e�k7c�u{�:Ë� ���� �� � �� ��� � V�JBI N I N T � G?T <4T YFJK;A^5;Z>AI�CAI�JK>F; R.L T`NQCFaST

$�2TÏ��-Ð���Ï��-Ð $� � ���(C $�"$ � Ï�$�2�$ � � $ � 2 $��.Ð Ï)_ � Ð

Ò �

Page 35: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

*��bYzn � u{p���cru�u�wz��mojz����v �³�¡ie�k7c��^�b��Ï��-Ð � wzeg�¬w7e�~�c�~�jzk��Ï��-вà � ��Ï��-ÐI� 2TÏ��-Ð��¶Ï��-Ð Ï)_ �|Ð

� wl�?p{�N� � ' < $ crY�f/2TÏ��-Ð?! ��Ï��-Ð�c�p{�Nc|~®c���nrd:���`*¯�Nc�xzxz��t!u{wz�N³�µ¸£c����^n|p{e�u{wzku�n�� ��c�Y�f�n^�zu�cre�Y

� ��Ãy� ���� � Ï)_^]:Ð*��Nu{wz�?Y��:�?�?xTu�wz��~{crk���d^c���jz�NnrmFu{wz�Nu{jlYze�Yz�7x�c�p�c�k��?u{��p �¤crY�f � ��crxzxl��tTu{wl�³�µ�¸qc����^n|p{e�u{wzk u{n7�-¦I¡�wz�?n|p{�?k ]Wt5e�����fz~��¯ÃÆ�ª��� � wz�?p���$��1��� � $"$ � � � Cc�Y�f $��#�8Ï­� ���D��Ï���Ð 2TÏ��-Ð{Ð $"$ � � � C�¦�´��?u�j�~�Yzn � ��n^k�x�crp��Ru � n¯e�k7cr�|��~W�c�Y�f�� �Nnrm�u�wz�!��e�u�tTnrmÉ¡"n^jz��n^j�~��:`²u�wz�W«�p�~�u�n|Yz� � e�u{w¤u{wz�7p{n:n�mbc�Y�f�u{wz�!~�����n^YHfn|Yz� � e�u{wzn|jzu�e�u?��¡�wl��³�µ¸ycr���^n^p�e�u�wzkÅ~�xz��e�u�~�� ��e�Y5u{n!c�~�jzk�� �%�y� � � wz�?p��7� �eg~¶u�cr�5e�Yz�$�?crp���nrmÎu{wz��u{�?�5jzp{�§f���n|k�x�n^Yz�?Y5u�~ � wle���w � ��p{��cr��p{��c|fBt�xzp���~���YBu�e�Y�u{wl�v F³�¡�e�k$cr�^���"XÑm � �Fc^fzf�u�wz��p�n:nrm"u�nb� �b!ru�wz�³�µ�¸Tcr���^n^p�e�wzk � e����:e�YH��n^p�x}n|p�c�u{��u{wl�mojl���5p{n:nrmIe�Y�~�egfB��u�wz��u��?�Bu�jzp{�Fc^~���n^Yz�Éc^~u{wz�%k���c�Y®d|c���jz��n�m�u{wz��n�~{��e����gcru{e�Yz��x�cru�u{�?p�Yeg~`,¯Ï � ��wz��p{��Yz�?�|������ubcrY��?p{p�n^pbu{��p{k � wle���wTe�~ �Ï � C²Ð{Ð�� *£w�cru � n^jz�gf w�c�xzx��?YeÁm �Æe�~ Cix��?p�e�n5fBeg�ªe�Y � ���zjlu�u{wl��k���c�Y¯d|cr��jz��n�m �[e�~bYzn^u�È?�?p{n � *�� � e����%~����u�w�crubu�wz��³�µ¸£c����^n|p{e�u{wzk fBn:��~�Yzn^u�e�Y���n|p{x�n^p�cru��Wu�wz��mojz���Dp{n:nrmFe�Y5u{n�u�wz��u{���Bu�jzp{���n^k�x�n^Yl�?YBu��yXÍYHfB�?��f � ��wHc§d:�#� à � � � � � � wz��p{� � � mojz�Á«����g~�u{wz�!d|crYzeg~�wze�Yz�k���crY ��n^Y�f5e�u{e�n^Y�c�Y�f�� � fBn:�§~ÉYln^u�fB�?x��?Y�f�n|Y � � ¦I¡�wz�?Y�u{wz��xlp{n5fBj���u � � 2Å�?c�Y����e�Y���n^p�x�n^p�c�u{��fTe�Y5u{n�� � c�Y�f � ��w�c?d:�©�¼ÃÆ� � ��21� � ��21� � ¦%*��N�?crYTjH~���u{wl�xlp{�����§fBe�Yz�Nf5e�~{��j�~{~�e�n^Y � wl�?p{��� � crY�f121� � c�p{���|��jz�§fRu{n|�^�?u�wz�?p�� *£wl�?Y�u�wz�W³�µ�¸c����|n^p{e�u{wzk�e�~Ncrxzxz��e���f�u{n�u{wz��mojz����e�k7c��^�7��Ï��-Ð�à � � Ï��-в�D��Ï��-Ð 2TÏ��-Ð?!�e�u�t5e��?�gfz~�0Ã����y� � wz�?p��7�}Ï��-Ð�Ã�� � � � � Ï��-Ð 2TÏ��-Ð� 0ÉÏ��-Ð�¦D¡�wze�~��?p�p{n|p�u{�?p�k 0bÏ��-Ðbe�~��n^k�e�Yz�mop{n|k u{wz��Yl� � ¿Çn^�5¢{����u� ��� 2 � wze���wWeg~�Yzn � ��n|kW�ze�Yz��f � e�u{wN� ��c�Y�f � wzeg�¬wf5n:��~¶Yln^u�~�u�c?t�e�Y�~�egfB�b�7�zjzu�~�x�n^e���~��%!lc^~��?�Bxl��cre�Yz��fW�5t �.n^p{n|���gcrp{t!Ò5�

J � L� � ��� ��P�OFV�M�� � ��� ��M8�ªL �b `� � �8�� �O ��LTQ� S � V�LTV�M�� � �

¡�wle�~�Yz� � c����^n|p{e�u{wzk eg~ÉYHcrk���f�u�wz�7³�~�wz�?p�¨)Ó.��~��Ncr���|n^p�e�u{wlkT��X)u�eg~®c7d|crp{egcrY5ubn^Yu�wz�7~�u�crYHfzcrp�f ³�µ�¸0cr���^n|p{e�u�wzkT�!¡�wz�7Yzn^u�cru�e�n^YH~�nrm�u{wl��xzp{�§����fBe�Yz�T~�����u{e�n^Y�~�crp���:��xzu?Ë �[fB�?Yln^u{�§~²u{wl�bfBj�c��"~�xHc^���bnrm �� �� � crYHf$u�wz��Yzn|p{k�e�Y�� e�~"$ ) $��¦lÊ�?p{��u{wl��|e�d:�?YNe�k$cr�^��f5n:��~²Yzn|u�Yz����fªu�n����bc�mojzY���u�e�n^Y�e�Y < $ �zjzuF�?crY7c���~�n����bc®u��?k�x��?p���ff5e�~�u�p{e��zjzu{e�n^Y����?��n^Yz�|e�Yz��u{n ��¦ *��bc�e�k cru�~�xz��e�u{u�e�Yz��u{wzeg~²e�k$cr�^��e�Y5u{n�c�~�jzkÌ�b���� wl�?p{�%u{wz��u � nÉ��n^k�x�n|Yz�?Y5u�~���crY�f��bw�c?d:��u{wl��~{c�k���k���crYze�Yz��c^~e�Y�u{wl��~�u�c�Y�fzc�p�f

Ò|_

Page 36: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

³�µ�¸£cr���^n^p�e�u�wzkTË�u�wz��n^�5¢{����u�~ � wze���wTc�p{��xzp���~��?Y5u�e�YTu{wl���^e�d:��Y�e�k$cr�^����~�wzn^jl��f���?��n^Yz�Nu{n$��crYHf�u{wz�bu{���Bu�jzp{��f7��n|k�x�n^Yz��YBu�~�crY�f�u�wz�bYzn^eg~���c�p{��e�Y���n|p{x�n^p�cru���fRe�Y��¦"¡�wz��mojzY���u{e�n|Y�cr� � � � crY5u®u�n7k�e�Yze�k�eÁÈ?�be�~�Yzn � � Ï­��Ð�à $�� $��"�R�� $�� $�?¦6��Yn|xzu{e�k7cr�DfB����n^k�x�n:~�e�u�e�n^YT���Beg~�u�~��zjzu�eg~ÉYlnR��n^Yz�|�?p�jzYle�°:jz��e�Y�~�n^k���e�Y�~�u�crYH����~��.���n^jzY5u{�?p�¨)���zc�k�xz��� � e���������fB�§~{��p�e�����fR���?��n � ��¡�wz��p�n^����nrm%u{wl��u{jlYze�Yz��x�crp�crk��?u��?p�7eg~�fBe��I�?p��?Y5u?`zc|~É´���k�k7c�Z?±�u{�?����~.j�~���*��b�}���^e�Y � e�u�w�c�Y�n|�Bd5e�n|j�~�p{�?k$crp{�IË� ��� ��� ��� 5 >FG.T aST"G�� ��� ;Q<4I�JK>F;7� ' ��� L T`NQCFaST $�� $ $$ � $�� $� $�� $����=CF;ZY

$�� $�Z± � � $�� $"$ �

Z� � $�� $��"� Ï)_^\:Ð

¡�wl�N~�����n|Y�f���~�u{e�k$cru{��mon|����n � ~¶mop�n^k u{wz��eg~�n^x��?p�e�k���u{p{eg�e�Yl��°¾jHcr��e�u�t7crY�f�c�~�e�k�xz���f5j�cr��e�u�t!crp{�|jzk��?Y5u�tBe��?��fz~�u{wl�®«�p�~�u�n|Yz�:��¡�wz��mon^����n � e�Yz�Nn^�H~��?p�d^c�u{e�n^Y�e�~�cWu�p{e�dBegcr���n^Y�~���°¾jl�?Y�����n�m�´��?k�k$cªZ|Z^�� ��� ��� � �):!��,FE � � � ��!+IKN T'� R?N T"G"���%T R�T�CA@ ^ >FG4JBIKN � �AJXT?@ YSR¶�Rà , !���Ãy�-¦¡�wle�~�~�wln^jz�gf¥���!��n^k�xHcrp{�§f � e�u�w¥u�wz�!~�e�k�e��gcrp�~�u�cru{��k��?Y5u���n|Y����?p�Yze�Yz�!u{wz�T³�µ�¸c����|n^p{e�u{wzk Ë $�� $ � � �$ � � �Rà ,2!��ªÃ �-¦5¡�wz��xzp�n:nrmDnrm.´��?k�k$c�Z?±�eg~²~�u{p�cre��|wBu�mon^p�¨� crp�f-�+*���w�c?d:��$�� $ � � $�� $ � � $����N� $ � � �

( � $��$ ��� ��$����N�$ � ¦|¡�wzeg~�n^�5dBe�n^j�~���te�k�xz��e���~ � $�� $� � �

( � $��$����R� � $������$��¦"XÑm�� E � ��!}u�wz���?Yz�?p��^t!nrm%u{wz��u�p{e�dBegcr�f5����n^k�x}n�~�e�u{e�n|Y�nrm �$�|e�d:�?Y��5tN��à ,��7�7e�~.~�k$cr�����?p"u{wHcrY � Ï)�-Ð�¦:X)ue�k�xl��e��§~���à ,B¦XÑm ��à � ��!l�Rà ,�e�~�~�u�e�����c�~�n^��jzu{e�n^Y!�zjzu�u{wzeg~�~�n^��jzu{e�n^Y!e�~�Yzn|ujzYle�°:jz�be�Y7�^�?Yl�?p�c��)��[��n|jzY5u{�?p�¨)�?�lcrk�xz��� � e����-���b�^e�d:��Y7c§mou��?pu�wz��mon^����n � e�Yz�Nf5��«�Yze�u{e�n|Y"������������ ���� H����2;Z<4I�JK>F;�� ' ��� J R�T�� I�G?T � CA@7J � $�� $ $$ à $�� $� $�� $��"�¡�wl��n^Yl��t����zc�k�xz����nrmFcrYT�?�5u{p��?k7c��}mojzY���u{e�n|Y � ��w�c?d:��e�Y�k�e�Y�f�e�~�u{wz��e�Y�f5e��?c�u{n^pmojlY���u{e�n^Y�nrm�c�f5e�~{�|� ´���uWj�~ � p{e�u{� � à $�� $ � !*�¯Ã $�� $ $ !�c�Y�f (¯Ã $�� $ �"� ¦.XÑm��à ( + �%!zu�wz�?Y7c����"u�wz��fB����n|k�x�n:~�e�u{e�n^Y�~%� à C��W� Ï{Z �!CÐ�� ! C '�Ï�,2!?ZrÐ%w�c?d:��u{wl�~�crk�����Yz�?p{�|t:�N¡�wze�~b~�wzn � ~®u{wHcrubu{wz�7³�~�wz��p�¨­Ó²�§~��NfB����n^k�x�n:~�e�u�e�n^YTeg~�Yzn^u�jzYze�°:jz�e�Y7�^�?Yz��p�cr�­�

*��¯Yln � xzp{n�d:�Tu�w�cru7e�Yy~�n^k�����c^~��§~$u�wz��³�~�wz�?p�¨)Ó.��~���cr���|n^p�e�u{wlk x}��p�mon^p�k7~kNj���w����?u{u��?p�u{wHcrYTu{wl�W³�µ¸�c����^n|p{e�u{wzkT�F¡�wz�®mon|����n � e�Yz��u{wz��n^p{��k eg~�cª«�p�~�u�~�u{��x� wle���w�~�wln^jz�gf��}�F��n^k�xz���?u���f�5tbk�n^p��²k$cru{wl�?k7cru�e��?~IcrY�f�k�n^p{�.Y5jzk��?p�e��?c��^�?�5x��?p{eÁ¨k��?YBu�~��6*�� � n^jl��f���e��:��u�n®u�w�crYl� ��e�������~s^��p �n^k��Îmon|p.xzp{n�d5e�fBe�Yz��j�~ � e�u�w�YBjlk��?p{n|j�~���zc�k�xz���§~��6*¯�bw�c?d:�

Ò �

Page 37: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

��� � ������� ���M_8T?I�� 'P��� E4T T���I�G T � CA@ CF;ZY @BT?I � R�CSR?R�� � T�� � (�+ � L N T"G?T��à $�� $�&CF;ZY (à $�� $����¦�O N T"; IKN T � R?N T"G"���%THR�T&CA@ ^F>FG"JBIKN � �AJXT#@ YSR.�Rà � !���à ,B¦_8T?I � R ;Z>FL I�G T CAI C � >FG?T`JK;Qa >A@ aST Y RbJBI � CAI�JK>F; L N T"G?T���Ã��b� ' L�JBIKN�$ ' $� � �"! �E4T JK;A^]T���I�G?T � CA@!�`_8T?I ��à $ � $� ! (�à $ � $��"��!�CF;QY @ T?I8� R CSR?R�� � T�� � ( + �}¦�O N T";IKN T'� R?N T"G"���%T R�T CA@ ^F>FG"JBI N � � JXT?@ YSR C�Y T <?> ��� >SRbJBI�JK>F;W� Ã ����� L6N T"G T�� J R.<4@ >SR�TI�> �\JK; < $ ¦ []>FG T � G T <bJ R�T?@,�

$��B� � $� � ± � �� ��( + � !�$��B� � $"$ � �©Ï���Ð � � Ï � ,:Ð

¡�wzeg~Yz�?d:�?p�w�crxlx}��Y�~ � e�u{w�u{wl��~�u�crYHfzcrp�f$³�µ�¸¯c����^n|p{e�u{wzkT`|~�e�Y�����~�n^k���~�e��^Yle¹«z¨��crY5uxze��§����~"nrmIu{wz��n|�5¢{����u�~crp���cr� � c?tz~�e�Y���n|p{x�n^p�cru{�§fªe�YBu�nu�wz������n|k�x�n^Yz��YBu���¡�wl���n^Y�~�u�crY5u�©Ï���Ð�à �©Ï�� ! ��Ð � e����.�����?�5xz��eg��e�u���¡�wz��xzp{n:n�m�n�m�u{wz��«�p�~�uN~�u�cru{��k��?Y5ue�Y�¡�wz�?n|p{�?k Z|Z�e�~b�?�Bu�p{�?k��?��t7~�e�k�xl���:�7³Yl� � p{e�u{��~�$�� $ $$ à � �I� � �7� � �-� � � ¦´���k�k7c7Ò�tBe��?��fl~ � � �-� � � � � � $�� $ �"� � wzeg�¬w¤e�k�xz��e���~"� $ � � $��$ ��� � ( $�� $ � ¦v�e�Y������ $ à � (�! � ��w�c?d:� ( � $��$ ��� � � $�� $ � E $��$ ��� � � $�� $ � jzYz���§~{~���à ,B¦¡�wl���?Yz��p{�^t�nrm.u�wz��u�p{e�d5e�c��"fB�§��n^k�x�n�~�e�u�e�n|Y��Tà �$�\,ªeg~¶k�e�Yze�k�cr�Ic�Y�fRu�wze�~��?Y�fz~u�wz�bxzp{n:n�m��¡�wz�bxzp�n:nrm%nrmDu{wl��~�����n|Y�f�~�u�cru��?k��?Y5u.e�~�~�e�k�e���crp��6*¯��«�p�~�u � p{e�u��

��à � ��Ï���Ð �IÏ��-Ð � �Rà $ � $ $$ � � �IÏ��-Ð�'"Ï��-Ð � ��à � �"� �"$ Ï � Z�Ð*���cr�g~�nNw�c?d:�

��à � �"Ï��-Ð �IÏ��-Ð � �ª� � �}Ï���Ð �IÏ��-Ð � ��à � + � � ( Ï � ±:Ðv�e�Y����"�!e�~�?�5u{p��?k7c�� � ��wHc§d:� � � à $ � $ � $ � $ �"� ¦�´��?k�k7c�Ò$t5e�����fz~�u{wz�bmon^����n � e�Yz���n|jzY�fz~ � $ � �$ � $ �"� $ ' $ � c�Y�f�� + ��� ( � $ � $ � $�� $ �"� � $ � $ �"� $ '$ � ¦l¡�wz�?p���mon^p��

$ � $ � $ � $ �"� � $ � $ �"� $ ' $ � � $ � $ � $�� $ �"� � $ � $ ��� $ ' $ � Ï � Ò:ÐX)u�~�j,?7����~�u{nNfBe�dBegfB���5t�$ � $ � u{n�n^�lu�cre�Y

$ � $��"� � (� $ ' $� � $�� $��"�W� (

� $�� $� Ï �S� н�jlu � ��cr�g~�n�w�c?d:�

$�� $��"��� � $�� $� � $ � $����W� � $ ' $� Ï � _:Ð

ÒF�

Page 38: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

~�e�Y������Tà �ª���Weg~�c^~{~�jzk���f7u{nN����crY!n^xzu�e�k7c��"fB�§��n^k�x�n�~�e�u�e�n|Y"�¶v�e�Y������ � ( + �%!e�u�~�j,?$����~7u{n ��n^kN�ze�Yz��Ï ��� Ð crY�f�Ï � _:Ð7u{nyn^�zu�cre�Y $�� $� � � � �

% � � �

% ��¦�*¯��w�c?d:�� � ��à '!�[�qcrYHf $�� � � $� � ± � �� � �

% �5tqu�wz��u{p{egcrYz�|����e�Yz�§°¾j�c���e�u�t�� ³�Yu�wz�Nn^u{wl�?pbw�crY�f¤� à ���£�7e�~bcrY�n|xzu{e�k7cr�.³�~�wz��p�¨­Ó²�§~���fB����n|k�x�n:~�e�u{e�n^Y�crYHf � �wHc§d:� $��$���� � $ � $���� � � � � wze���w�tBe��?��fl~)$�� � � $���� � ± $ � $���� � � ��¦.¡�wz��Y� � � ��� � $ � ��� $�� � � $����+$��$��� $� �£± � �� � �

% $ � $����©� � �-¦l¡�wze�~���Y�fz~²u�wz��xzp�n:nrmn�m.u{wl��~�����n|Y�f7c^~{~��?p{u�e�n|Y"�

�Y��?�lcrk�xl����n�m�crY����Bu�p{�?k7c�� mojlY���u{e�n^Y�e�~�u{wl�We�Y�fBe���cru{n|p�mojzY���u�e�n^Y�nrm�c!fBe�~��^�X)ube�~������§crpbu{w�c�u�n|u{wz�?p��?�lcrk�xz����~�~�wzn^jz�gf��}�$~�u{jHfBe���fI�7¡�wz�?p{�$crp{�Nmo� � �?�5u{p��?k7c��mojlY���u{e�n^Y�~�c�Y�fRu�w�cru�e�~ � w5t � �®e�Y�~�u���c^f�xzp�n^x�n:~�� � w�c�u � ���?cr����¿Àxl��cre�Y7e�k7c��^��~�Â��¡�wzeg~.~�����u�e�n|Y�e�~c�e�k���f�cru.xzp�nrd5e�Yl��u{w�c�u'�{xz�gcre�YNe�k$cr�^�§~ �w�c?d:��cu�p{e�dBegcr�-³�~�wl�?p�¨Ó.��~���fB�§��n^k�x�n�~�e�u�e�n|Y"��X)u��?�5xz�gcre�YH~¶u�wz��wze��|wz�?p�x��?p�mon^p�k7crY�����~¶n�m%u{wz��³�~�wl�?p�¨­Ó.��~��c����|n^p{e�u{wzk ` � wz�?Y���n^k�x�crp���f � e�u�wWu�wz�®³�µ�¸¯c����|n^p{e�u{wzk �+*�����?�|e�Y � e�u{w�fB��«HYze�Yz�xl��cre�Y7e�k7c��^��~������������� ��� H ���2;Z<4I�JK>F;��)' ��� J R C � @ CFJK; J � C ^ T/J �5IKN T"G?T T�� J R"IKR�CF;Z>AIKN T"G���2;Z<4I�JK>F;��' ����R�� <?N IKNQCAI

� ��Ï��-Ð �IÏ��-Ð � �Rà $�� $ �"� � � � $ � $ � Ã[Z Ï � � ÐX)Y�n|u{wz��p � n|p�fz~�c�mojzY���u�e�n|Y7��e�~%c�xz��c�e�YNe�k7c��^��e¹m�u{wl�?p{�����Beg~�u�~.c�~�����n^YHfªmojzY���u�e�n|Y��'�����! � �à ,2!-~�j���wRu�w�cru � ��Ï��-Ð �IÏ��-Ð � ��à $�� $��"�+$ � $��¦�¸zn^p�n^�zu�cre�Yle�Yz�!Ï � � Ð�`�e�uu�wz�?Y!~�j ?7���§~�u{nNp{�?xz�gc^��� ���5t C ��mon^p�cN~�jze�u�c��z���bx�n:~�e�u{e�d:�b��n|Y�~�u�crY5u C.¦

XÑmÉ�qe�~�cTxz��c�e�Y�e�k7cr�|�:`u{wz�7x�c�e�p7Ï­� ! ��Ð�eg~��?�5u{p{��k7cr�.e�Y�u�wz�!~��?Y�~��7nrm 0 3�c�Y�f� � � e����F~{c?t�u�w�cru ��eg~Wf5j�cr��u�n��-¦Dh�n^p��Rxlp{����eg~��?��t:`����?u�j�~�c�xzxz��t�u�wz�!~�u�c�Y�fzc�p�f³�µ�¸qc����^n|p{e�u{wzkÌu�n7c��^e�d:��YRe�k7cr�|��� ' ���¦IXÑm $�� $� � �$ � !�u{wl�ª³�µ�¸qc����^n|p{e�u{wzkt5e�����fz~b�0Ã��R�y� � wz�?p���$�� $�Wà �$ � crYHf � �"Ï��-Ð���Ï��-Ð � �qà $��$����+$�� $��¦²v:e�Y������Ãy�F��� ' ���8!¾e�u�e�k�xz��e���~"u{w�c�u��$eg~�c�xz�gcre�Y�e�k7c��^�:���.n|YBd:�?p�~��?��t�e¹mD��e�~%c®xz�gcre�Ye�k7cr�|��crY�f�eÁm%��e�~�fBj�cr�Du{n7�6!zu{wl�?Y��¯Ã[�W� �$ � �Weg~u{wz�N³�µ¸�fB����n|k�x�n:~�e�u{e�n^Y�n�m�I¦ *�����crYT��n^Y�����j�fB�:Ë� ���� �� � �� ��� � � @ CFJK; J � C ^ THR]<?>FJK;Z< JKY T L�JBIKN R"�FT?I�< N THR � G >Fa JKY T Y E���I N T � 85CA@ ^F>FG4JBIKN � C ��� @ JXT Y I�> ���2;Z<4I�JK>F; R >� E?>��2;ZY T Y�a CFG"JKCAI�JK>F;K�Ê��p{�bc�p{��~�n^k���n^u{wl�?p��?�lcrk�xz����~.crY�f!��n^jlYBu��?p�¨­�?�lcrk�xz����~��

Ò|]

Page 39: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

´��?u �Ì���TcT�}n|jzY�fB�§f£fBn^k7c�e�Y � e�u�w£c�� +�¨­��n^jzY�flcrp{t��0¡�wz�?Y�u{wz�!e�Y�f5e��?c�u{n^pmojlY���u{e�n^Y�� � n�m*��e�~.c�xz��c�e�Y�e�k$cr�^����X)Y�f5�?��f � ����n|Y�~�egfB�?pu�wz��Yzn^p�k7cr�ld:����u{n|p �-Ï���Ðc�u`� ' �!�ycrYHfR�?�5u{�?YHf$e�uu�n�c � $ ¨­d:����u�n^p�«�����f�TÏ���ÐF~�jH�¬w7u{wHcru�$� $ � Ã[Z^¦ *��u�wz�?Y!fB��«HYz� ��Ã[fBe�d c�Y�f � �®wHc§d:� $ � $� �0Z|¦-½�jzu

� � � � �Rà � � ��� ) � �RÃ* � Ï � �Ð Ï � �|Ð

X)ube�k�xz��e���~�$ � $��ÃÌZ�crY�f��¥eg~®c�xz�gcre�Y¯e�k7cr�|�:�Wv:e�k�e��gcrp{��t7c�xze��§��� � e�~�����n|Y�~�u�crY5umojlY���u{e�n^Y � e�u�w�¢{jzk�x7fBeg~{��n|YBu�e�Y5jze�u�e���~.c|��p{n�~{~ � +�¨­�}n|jzY�fzc�p{e���~e�~�c�xz�gcre�Y�e�k7c��^�:�

Ê��p{��crp{��u � n���n^jzY5u{��p�¨­�?�zc�k�xz����~���¡�wz��e�Y�fBeg�?cru�n^pmojzY���u�e�n|YWn�m.cbx}n|��t5�^n|Y7�?crY5¨Yln^u�����c¯xz�gcre�Yqe�k$cr�^��`�c^~We�uWeg~Wxzp�nrd:�§f¥e�Y 0 3­�)� ~�����n|Y�f£��n^jlYBu��?p�¨­�?�lcrk�xz����e�~�|e�d:�?Y��5t���Ï��-Ð�à ���BxIÏ� � � � $ Ð�¦.¡�wz�?Y � � � � � à $�� $����0crY�f $ � $�RÃ�ZRe�k�xz��t�IÏ��-Ð�à � � � � � ¦D¡�wze�~&�¤�?c�YzYzn|u��}����n^Yl�Tu{n ���D¦Ên � ��d:�?p�u{wl��p�c|fBe�c���mojzY���u�e�n^Y �f5��«�Yz��f��5t���Ï���Ð.Ã[Z � wz�?Y � � � �[ZA! ��Ï��-вà � � � � $ e¹m#� � � �[ZA!zeg~c�xz�gcre�Y�e�k$cr�^���*��bYzn � w�c?d:�:Ë��� � ������� � �)_8T?I�� E4T�C � @ CFJK; J � C ^ T CF;ZY]@ T?I+� E4T Y�� CA@�I�>��-¦ : ��� � �,�7Ã$ � $�����!�I N T"; IKN T <?>FG"G THR � >F;ZYFJK;A^�� R?N T"G"���%T R�T�Y T <?> ��� >SRbJBI�JK>F;�>�b� J R I N T.I�G"JKa JKCA@Y T <?> ��� >SRbJBI�JK>F; ^FJKaST"; E��T� à � !��0à ,B¦`_8T?I.�AR�;Z>FL�I�G?T CAI�C � >FG?T JK;Qa >A@ aST YRbJBI �2CAI�JK>F; L N T"G?T�� à �N��' L�JBIKN�$ ' $� � �"! � E4T JK;A^�C � @ CFJK; J � C ^ T�� _�T?I ��(E4TY��2CA@7I�>&� CF;QY)����à $ �� $��"�¦+: ����� ����!8I N T"; IKN T � R?N T G+��� THR�T CA@ ^F>FG"JBIKN � �AJXT#@ YSRC/Y T <?> ��� >SRbJBI�JK>F;W��Ãy����� L6N T"G T�� J R.<4@ >SR�T I�>&�9JK; < $ ¦ []>FG T � G T <bJ R�T?@,�

$��1� � $� � ± � ��B� � � ! $��"� � $"$ � ��Ï���Ð � � Ï � ]:Ð

¡�wl��xzp{n:n�m"e�~�u{wz��~�crk��Fc^~e�YN¡�wz��n^p{��kÌZ^Z|��*¯��c�p{�|jz���Bt©��n^Y5u{p�c^fBeg��u{e�n^Y"�´��?u%��Ã���¼�ª����c�Y7n^xzu�e�k7c��"fB����n^k�x�n:~�e�u�e�n^Y�k�e�Yze�kWe�È?eÁYz� � Ï­��Ð�¦ ���?�?xle�Yz��u{wz�bYzn|u�cru�e�n|Y�~n�m%a��«HYze�u�e�n^Y � � � � �®wHc§d:�

$�� $ �"� Ã�q� � � �RÃ�£� � � �ª� �£� � � �Rà � � ��� $ Ï�Ð

½�jlu�� � � � � $�� $ �"� c�Y�f � � $ � � $�� $ � $ � $ �"� �Bt�´��?k�k7cNÒB�NX)u�e�k�xz��e���~�$�� $ ��� �$�� $����F� $�� $� $ � $��"�9E $�� $��"��� � $�� $��jzYz����~{~��ªÃ ,5¦:¡�wz�%u{p{e�dBegcr�lfB����n|k�x�n:~�e�u{e�n^Y��Ãy�W�\,ªeg~ � e�YzYle�Yz�l�

Ò|\

Page 40: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

� �F �O� ®LTU �

0ÁZ43�·��?��fB����~�n|Y"`:µb��Êe�Yz�^n|p�crYle)`|crY�fN·���v:e�k�n^Y���������eo��� G IKNQ>?^F>F;ZCA@ � �AG C � JKY I�GHCF;FR���b>FG � �b>FG J � C ^ T.<?>�YFJK;A^)� p�n5���?��fBe�Yz�:~bv .X�· �.n|YBmo�?p��?Y�����n^YTÓ�eg~�j�c����.n^kW¨kNjzYze���cru{e�n^Y�~�crYHf�X)k7cr�|�p{n5���§~{~�e�Yz�TX�X�`-d:n^�­�"] � _B`²³���u�n^���?p�± ��¨�±|\¯Ï�Z?\^]F�^Ðxzx"��_ ,§¨Í_^]5�

0 ±S3�v�� ¨�X��?�k$crp{e5c�Y�fNsz� ¨Í¸�� �%crp�fBn:~�nz� @DJK;ZY.Rb>��2GH<4T R�T � CFGHCAI�JK>F; �XR�T � J � CFG C � T?I�G4JK<R"I�CAI�J R"I�JK<?CA@`C ��� G >�CF< NK��X�·²·.·�¡ p�crY�~���n^Y0v�e��z� p{n5�^� � �0Ï�Z^Z�Ð�Ë�± � \^±§¨Í± � ,A,5`�n�d:�?kN���?p�Z?\|\ ��`�v:x�����egcr�-eg~{~�jz�bn^Y�Yl�?jzp�c��"Yz�?u � n|p{�l~��

0 ÒS3�´��?�kN�zp�n:~�e�nz�9��>FGHRb>5JK; I�GH>�Y�� I I�JKa >5CA@B@DC IUT >FG"JKC ^ T > � T?I�G4JK<?C/Y T?@B@ C5[�J R��2GHC5T YCA@B@ T � � � T G 0 <bJ [�JK;QJ � T��-v5��jzn|��c ��n^p{k$cr����v:jzx��?p{e�n^p��W´�����u�jzp{� �n|u{��~�` eg~{cB`Z?\|\ ���

0 � 3 ���?��YBu�n^Yzegc^fBeg~"crY�f ����³�xzx��?Yzwl�?e�kT`?�§fz~��8V CFaST#@BT?IKR&CF;ZY � I�CAI�J R"I�JK< R��:´�����u{jzp���n|u{��~be�Yqv:u�cru�e�~�u�e��?~�`�Z ,|ÒB`�� � � � � µ¶�?YH��n^Y5u{p���~�¸zp�c�Y���n�¨�½��?���^��~�`�v:xzp�e�Yz�|�?p�¨Ó.�?p{�gcr�7Ï�Z?\^\|_¾Ð

0 _S3���?�jz���?p�u�c�Y�f�sr¨�¸��#�j�¢{n^�­��[�>�Y T?@ JK;A^9aST"G�� >SRb< JB@B@DCAI�>FG�� RbJ ^ ;ZCA@1R��1H ��� @ JK<?C:�I�JK>F; R I�>5J � C ^2T � GH>�<4THR?RbJK;A^)�lX ��µ�X ��`¾Ylnz� � ]F��]5`�Ï­±A,A,|Ò¾Ð

0 � 3�sr¨Í¸��?�j�¢{n|�)`����?�jz���?p�u?`´���½��gcrY��¬¨Í¸ ��?p�crj�fI`�c�Y�f ��� �.w�crkN��n^�����:��X)k7cr�|�NfB��¨��n|k�x�n:~�e�u{e�n^Y"Ë8�xzxz��e��?c�u{e�n|YWu�n�u{�?�5u{jlp{��f�e�k7c��^��~.c�Y�f�v2��µ£e�k7c��^��~��BX ��µ�XU�Yznl� � ��, � `Ï­±A, ,^Ò¾Ð

0 � 3����½�n^jlp�fzc�j�f�c�Y�f�h��Ç·¶�Ça����bcru��?�"�K56>F;Q<4I�JK>F;FR'-��2J�> ���T"G T";2I R��2G @ THR THR � CF<4THRY T `T Rb>FaB��hTcru�w"� �YzY��zÒA,|Ò�Ï{Z�\^\|_¾Ð � _^Ò§¨ � �§_B�

0 ]S3����½�n^jlp�fzc�j�f-`.56>F;Q<4I�JK>F;FR -��2J > ���T"G T";2I R��2G]@ THR THR � CF<4THR9Y T `THRb>Fa T?I Y TOQG4JXT"E4T#@!���YzY"�FXÍYH~�u?�FÊ�?Yzp�e �n^e�Y��?c�p ��:`&�Y�cr��tz~��TYzn^Y ��e�Y ���cre�p{�:`bZ ,£Ï�Z?\^\|Ò¾Ð� Z�Ò§¨ � ±|±B�

0 \S3 ��Çsz�À½�jzp�u�c�Y�f7·¶�ÇÊ�� ��fB�?��~�n^Y"��O N T�_7C � @ CF< JKCF; � �AG C � JKY CSR C/<?> ��� CF<"I�<?>�Y T��X�·.·²·�¡ p�crY�~�� �.n|k�kNjzY"�5ÒBZ|Ï � Ð�ËÀ_|Ò^±§¨Í_ � ,B`7�xzp�e��DZ?\^]|ÒB�0¹Zb,S3 �Y�f5p{��cb½�p�c�e�fB�§~��)H ��� GH>B� J � CAI�JK>F;5>� �bG?T?T�YFJ Rb<?>F; I�JK;(� JBI � � GH>FE"@BT � R��B´�����u{jzp��

�n|u{��~�e�Y�hTc�u{wz��k7cru�e��?~.Yznz�"Z � \ � ` v�xzp{e�Yz�^�?pb�Z?\|\BZr��

� ,

Page 41: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

0¹Z|Z43�·k�k7c�YBjz�����%c�Y�f ���~Tc�Y�f[a�c?dBegfian|Yzn^wlnz�.&JKY ^ T?@BT?IKR�; C��FT�� I�> NQJ ^SN T"G"�YFJ � T"; RbJK>F;QCA@ JK; IUT"G � JBIXIUT";Z<�� � wze��­�¡"p�crYH~��µb�²v�n5�^�²´�n|Y�f-��� Ï�Z?\^\|\¾Ð�Yznz�ZS� � ,5`-± � \^_?¨�±|_A,|\z�

0¹Z�±S3�·�� �%crYHf ���~�c�Y�f�a���an^Yzn|wznz� � T"L I�J ^SN2I9�bGHC � THR >��<��2G"aST?@BT?IKR�CF;ZY�> � I�J � CA@G T � G THR�T";2I�CAI�JK>F; >�/>FE ��T <4IKR�L�JBIKN � JXT <4T"L�J R�T � $ RbJK;A^��F@ CFG"JBI�JXTHR�� �.n^k�kNjzYzeg�?c§¨u{e�n^Y�~�n|Y jzp���c�Y�f ��xzxz��e���f�hTc�u{wz�?k$cru{eg�?~�`:Ó.n^�­�}´�ÓbX�X�`-Ï)± ,A, � Ð�,|±BZ?\?¨U,|±^± � �

0¹Z�ÒS3 ����}��p{u �.n^wz�?Y�� � � � T"G"JK<?CA@�CF;ZCA@,� RbJ R�>� L�CFaST?@ T?I � T?IKNQ>�YSR��.Ê�crY�f5�}n:n|�in�mY5jzk��?p�e��?c��-c�Y�cr��tz~�e�~�` �� ��� �.e�crp����?uFcrY�f7sz�Á´��¹´�e�n|Y�~���fz~��"Ï�Z?\|\^\¾Ð��0¹Z � 3�sz� ¨Í¸�� �%crp�fBn:~�nz� @ JK;ZY�RbJ ^F;ZCA@6R�T � CFGHCAI�JK>F;$;�R"I�CAI�J R"I�JK<?CA@ � G"JK;Z< J � @ THR�� p{n5���?��f¾¨e�Yl�:~²n�mu�wz�bX�·.·.· v�x}�§��e�c��-e�~�~�jz��n^Y7�z��e�Y�fNe�fB�?Y5u{eÁ«I�?c�u{e�n|Y�c�Y�fW��~�u{e�k7cru�e�n^Y �Ï{Zb,¾Ð�Ë�± ,A,^\?¨�± ,^±|_B`³���u{n|�}��pbZ?\^\|]B�

0¹Z�_S3�µ��?Y �� �%crp{k�n^Y�c5` *��?YB¨�´�e�crYl�NÊ � c�Yz��º0½�p�jzYzn©¡ n|p{p ��§~{crYle)� � G CF<4I�JK<?CA@ I�J � T"��bG T�-�� T";Q<��5CF;ZCA@,� RbJ R ���?c^fB��k�e�� p{��~�~�Ï{Z?\|\^]:Ð��

0¹Z � 3 ����}��p{u�.n^wz��Yqc�Y�f�µ�n^���?p�uNµ¶t5c�Y"� V CFaST?@ T?I R�CF;ZY � �F@ I�J Rb<?CA@ T RbJ ^F;ZCA@ � GH>:�<4THR?RbJK;A^|� �.w�c�xzk7c�Y�c�Y�f�Ê�cr���­`}´�n|Y�fBn^Y¤Ï{Z�\^\^_:Ð��

0¹Z�� 3 ����}��p{u �.n|wz�?Y"`�µ�n^YHcr��f!a�?Ó.n^p��:` ��?Y���wzn���u{p{jH~�wz�?d$crY�f7Ên|Yz����j"� � >F;)�@ JK;%T CFG=C ��� G >B� J � CAI�JK>F; CF;ZY I N T R � CF<4T ����Ï�0 $ Ð�¦��k��?p{eg�?crYÆs^n^jlp{Y�c��Rn�mhTcru�wz�?k7c�u{eg�?~�`�Z?±5ZWÏ�Z?\|\^\¾Ð¶_^] ��¨ � ±^]5�

0¹Z�]S3 ����}��p{u �.n^wl�?Y"` *�n^�Ámo�:crYl��a�crwzk���Y"`�X)Yz�^p�e�f�a�crjz������wze��§~c�Y�fTµ¶n|Y�cr�gfTa��¨Ó.n^p��:��� CFG � >F;QJK< H&;ZCA@,� RbJ R.>� IKN T`R � CF<4T ���D¦-Ï�v:�?xzu��?kW���?p%±|_B`I±A,A, ,¾Ð

0¹Z�\S3�µ�n^Y�c���f£µb� �.n|e¹mok7c�Y"�1H�YFC � IUT Y � �F@ I�JKG?THRb>A@,�FI�JK>F; CF;ZCA@,� RbJ R?c ��> ��� � I�CAI�JK>F; c� J ^F;QCA@ � G >�<4THR?RbJK;A^Sc8CF;ZY � � T GHCAI�>FG IKN T >FG ��� p{n5���?��fBe�Yz�:~nrmIu�wz��X �%h�`���t:n^u{nÏ{Z�\^\ ,¾Ð�xzx���] ��\?¨�]|]^]5`�v:xzp�e�Yz�|�?p�¨­Ó.�?p{�gcr�z�

0 ± ,S3�µb��µ®� �.n|e¹mok7c�Y7crY�f!h��BÓ��Z*£eg�¬�:��p{w�c�j�~��?p���� ;2I�G > � �B�UE?CSR�T Y5CA@ ^F>FG4JBIKN � R �b>FGE4THR"I%�UE?CSRbJ R R�T?@BT <4I�JK>F;B�IX�·²·.·£¡"p�c�Y�~���X)YBmonl��¡�wz�?n^p�t:`�hTcrp��¬w�Z�\^\^±5�

0 ±5Z43�X)Yz�^p�e�fÅa�crjl�}�§�¬wze���~�� O T"; @BT <"I/�2G THR->F; L�CFaST#@BT?IKR��qv5XU��h wze���c^f5�?��xzwle�cÏ{Z�\^\|±¾Ð��

0 ±|±S3��jzt¤a�c?dBegf-� � JK; ^�� @DCFG/R�T#I R�>� � JK;ZJ � JED�T"GHR��b>FG IKN T�[�� � �b>FGHY:� � NQCSN'���2;Z< �I�JK>F;ZCA@À�I½�e�p{�5w��c�j�~��?p�Ï)± ,A, � Ð��

� Z

Page 42: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

0 ±|ÒS3�µ�n^YTa��?Ó.n^p{���!� >F; @DJK;%T CFG�C ��� GH>B� J � CAI�JK>F;B�Q����u�c �jzk��?p{eg�?c�Ï{Z?\|\^]:Ð�xzx"�I_BZ�¨Z?_ ,B�0 ± � 3�µ�n^YTa��?Ó.n^p{��`�½"¢ �n^p{Y s:c � �?p�u{w!crY�f7Ó%c^~�e�� �n^x�n�dI�1��> ��� G?THR?RbJK>F; >�.L�CFaST#@BT?I

Y T <?> ��� >SRbJBI�JK>F;FR��F�k��?p�e��?c�YNs^n^jzp�Y�cr�InrmDhTc�u{wz�?k$cru{eg�?~�Z^Z � Ï{Z?\|\^±:Ð.xzx"�Z��ÒF��¨��]|_B�

0 ±|_S3�µ�n^Y�a�?Ó.n^p���crYHfW½�p�c^fB���?t�sz�B´�j���e��?p?�,56CSR"I7L8CFaST?@BT?I�IUT < NQ;ZJ�-��ZTHR9�b>FG ;%T CFG�> � �I�J � CA@ J � C ^2T�<?> ��� G T R?RbJK>F;B�Z?\|\^±�X�·²·.·[h�e���e�u�crp{t �.n^k�kNjzYzeg�?cru�e�n|Y�~��.n^Y5¨mo�?p��?Y�����³���u�n^���?pbZ|Z¬¨�Z � `DÏ{Z?\|\^±:Ð��

0 ± � 3�a�c?d5e�f�an^Yzn|wznz� � >F;2@ JK;%T CFG � >A@,�FI�JK>F; >� _ JK;%T CFG :";ZaST G#R�T � G >FE4@BT � R E��V CFa�T?@BT?I%���ZC ^��ZT?@KT?I I T C�T <?> ��� >SRbJBI�JK>F;B�7�xzxz��e���f¤crY�f �.n^k�xzjlu�cru�e�n|Y�cr��Ê�c�p�¨k�n|Yze��`��Y�cr��tz~�e�~�±5`"Z ,5Z¬¨�Z?± � Ï�Z?\^\|_¾Ð��

0 ±F� 3�a�c?d5e�f an|Yzn^wznl� H&E R"I�GHCF<"I R"I�CAI�J R"I�JK<?CA@)T R"I�J � CAI�JK>F; CF;QY � >�Y T"G"; NQCFG"�� >F;ZJK<�CF;ZCA@,� RbJ R�� p{n5���?��fBe�Yz�:~�n�m�u{wz�7X �%h�` � �jlp{e���w£Ï�Z?\^\ � Ð�xzx"�D\^\ ��¨�Zb,A,|_½�e�p�� �c�j�~���p?�

0 ±|]S3�a�c?d5e�f�an|Yzn^wlnz`%µ¶n|Y�a�?Ó.n^p��:`X)Yz�|p{egf�a�crjl�}�§�¬wze���~bcrY�f�hTc�p{u{e�Y¯Ó.�?u�u{�?p���e­�C CAI�C�<?> ��� G THR?RbJK>F;/CF;ZY.NQCFG � >F;ZJK<`CF;QCA@,� RbJ R��5X�·.·²·�¡"p�c�Y�~��:n^Y$XÍY5mon^p{k$cru{e�n^Y¡�wz�?n|p{t:`zÓ.n|�)� � � ` �n � `-³���u�n^���?pbZ�\^\^]5`"± � Ò^_?¨�± � � � �

0 ±|\S3�a�c?d5e�f�an|Yzn^wln�c�Y�f�X�c�e�Y�s^n|wzY�~�u{n^Yl�:��V�CFaST?@BT?I R?NQG4JK;�� C ^ T�;�H R�� ��� I�> � JKC �sz�Àµb�¹v�u�cru�e�~�u?�}v�n5�^��½ Ï�Z?\|\^_¾Ð¶_ � � ±�xlx"��ÒA,5Z¬¨ÍÒ � \5�0 Ò ,S3�a�?YlYze�~ ��cr��n^p�� O N T >FG ��>� <?> �.� �2;ZJK<?CAI�JK>F;$�"sz��X�·.·�`�� � Ï{Z�\ � � Ð�xzx�� � ±|\§¨

� _F�:�IÒ^Ò|\§¨ÍÒ � ±5�0 Ò5Z43�Êjz���?�§a�� C J Rb<�� GHRb>�Y T JK;ZaSTHR"I�JKY��2GHC Y T C >�<4I�>FG � >F;Z>FG"J R���C��ARbC)� �Yle�d:�?p�~�e¹¨fzc|f �jzu�n^Yzn|k7c�fB��hTc^f5p{e�fI�-Ï{Z�\^\F�^Ð

0 Ò|±S3�v:u ��?xzw�c�Yz�Ns:c ��crp�f-`���d:��~�h��?t:�?p�`-c�Y�fTµ¶n|���?p{u�a��"µ�t5crY��`V�CFaST?@BT?IKR�; OQ>�>A@1R�b>FG � < JXT";Q<4T�CF;ZY O T < NQ;Z>A@ >?^����-v5XU��h Ï)± ,A,5ZrÐ

0 Ò|ÒS3��e�������~%s ��?p �n|k��:� ��NK�IC.�0 Ò � 3��� �bcrYle�È�~�cB�`_7C � GHC �.� CFJKG?T�Y�� �Q>FJKG ��·.f-��aegfB�?p{n|u?` �p{u�~7º v¾��e��?YH����~Ï{Z�\^\F�^Ð

� ±

Page 43: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

0 Ò|_S3�v:u ��?xzw�c�Yz��hTc�����c�u?��H-V CFaST?@ T?I OZ>��2G >� � J ^ ;ZCA@ � GH>�<4THR?RbJK;A^L� ����c^fB�?k�e�� Îp���~{~Ï{Z�\^\|]¾Ð��

0 Ò � 3�a���hTc�p{p�� �+J RbJK>F; c H�<?> ��� �FI�CAI�JK>F;ZCA@8JK;ZaSTHR"I�J ^FCAI�JK>F; JK; I�>�IKN T`N�� � CF;�G T � G T"�R�T"; I�CAI�JK>F; CF;ZY � GH>�<4THR?RbJK;A^.>� a J R��2CA@ JK;+�b>FG � CAI�JK>F;B�F*[�ÇÊ��:¸zp{�?��k7crYNc�Y�f �.nz�Ï{Z�\^]|±¾Ð

0 ÒF� 3 ����h���t:�?p?�K� Rb<bJB@B@ CAI�JK;A^ � CAIXIUT"G"; R&JK;5J � C ^ T � G >S<4T R?RbJK;A^ CF;QY�JK;/Rb> � T ;Z>F; @ JK;)�T CFG T"a >A@,�FI�JK>F;\T�-��2CAI�JK>F; R���Ï�´�� � e�~�h���k�n^p�e�cr�"´�����u{jzp���~¬Ð ��h¯v!Ï­±A,A,5ZrÐ

0 Ò|]S3�¸zp�c�Y��n^eg~ ���Ih��?t:�?p��%[��F@ I�J!��@ C��FT"G T Y�J � C ^ T�G?T � G T R�T"; I�CAI�JK>F;$; C ��� @ JK<?CAI�JK>F;]I�>J � C ^ T <?> ��� G?THR?RbJK>F;$� �n^u���~�fB����n^jlp�~bfBj �.�?Y5u{p��N·k�e�����½�n|p{�?��Ï�v:�?xzu��Z � ¨a���|�-Z?]5`�Z�\^\|]¾Ð��

0 Ò|\S3�s^��c�YB¨�h�eg�¬wl�?��h�n^p��?��crY�f¯v��?p{�|e�n�v:n|��e�k�e�Yze­� �ZCFG4JKCAI�JK>F;ZCA@ � T?IKNQ>SYSR JK; J � C ^ TR�T ^ � T";2I�CAI�JK>F;B�I½�e�p{�5w��c�j�~��?p�`z½�n�~�u{n|Y�Ï�Z?\^\|_¾Ð��

0 � ,S3�a�c?d5e�f7h�jzkWmon|p�f-� �>�>B�/G?T"a JXT"L >F; 0 Ò|]S3­�z½�jz�����?u�e�Y�n�mu�wz� �k��?p�e��?c�YNhTcru{w5¨�?k7c�u{eg�?cr�"v:n5��e��?u�t:`BÓ.n|�)�zÒ|ÒB`�Y"�À±5` �xzp�e��Z�\^\ � �

0 � Z43�a�c?d5e�fTh�jzkWmon|p�f!crY�f�s:c?t5crY5u�v:w�c�w"� �>��2;ZYFCFG ��Y T?IUT <4I�JK>F; E�� � JK;ZJ � JEDbJK;A^���2;Z<4I�JK>F;ZCA@1R�� Îp�n5�^�IX�·.·.· �.n|YBm�� �.n^k�x"�5Ó�e�~�� c�u{u��?p{Y!µ�����n^�|Yze�u�e�n|Y"`"Z?\|]^_B�

0 � ±S3�a���h�jlkWmon^p�fWc�Y�f�sz��v�w�crw"� � � I�J � CA@7G T � G?THR�T"; I�CAI�JK>F;FR E�� � JXT <4T"L�J R�T`R � >�>AI N���2;Z<4I�JK>F; R�CF;ZY CSR?Rb>�< JKCAI T Y a CFG"JKCAI�JK>F;ZCA@ � GH>FE4@ T � R�� �.n^k�kT� jzp{� �xzxz��e���fhTcru�wz�?k7c�u{eg�?~�` � ±7Ï)_:Ð�Ï�Z?\|]^\¾ÐF_ � ��¨ � ]|_B�

0 � ÒS3�v:u�crYz���?tR³�~�wz�?p�crYHf ´���n^YzegfRµ�j�fBe�Y"� OQ>AI�CA@6a CFG"JKCAI�JK>F;�E?CSR�T Y5J � C ^ T G THR"I�>FGHC:�I�JK>F; L�JBIKN��bG?T?T�@ >�<?CA@ <?>F;FR"I�G CFJK; I R��lX)Y p{n5�|�zX�·.·²·�X �%X �`:d:n^��X�`¾xHcr�^�§~�ÒBZ¬¨ÍÒ^_5`�j�~�u{e�Y¯Ï­¡ ���zc|~¬Ð �®v2��` �n�dI��Z?\|\ � �

0 � � 3�v:u�crYz���?t�³�~�wz��p?`"´��?n^Yzegf�µ�j�fBe�Y�c�Y�f�·k7c|f7¸}c�u{�?k�e)� � >F; @ JK; T CFG I�>AI�CA@8a CFG"J!�CAI�JK>F; E?CSR�T Y5;Z>FJ R�T G T � >Fa CA@6CA@ ^ >FG4JBIKN � R�� w5tz~�e��?c�a�` � ,7Ï{Z?\|\^±:Ð�±^_|\§¨Í± � ]5�

0 � _S3�v���³�~�wz�?p?` ����v:n|���:`:c�Y�f�´��{Ó.��~��:�2: � C ^ T�Y T <?> ��� >SRbJBI�JK>F; CF;QY�G THR"I�>FGHCAI�JK>F; �AR��JK;A^ I�>AI�CA@�a CFG"JKCAI�JK>F; � JK;ZJ � JEDbCAI�JK>F; CF;ZY� � � �U;Z>FG � �"h�jl��u{eg~{�?c�����h�n5fB�?��e�Yz�crYHf v:e�kWjz�gcru�e�n^Y!ZNÏ)Ò¾Ð�Ë�Ï)± ,A,^Ò:Ð�Ò � \§¨ÍÒ � ,B�

0 � � 3 ���³�~ � c���f-�K� ;�IKN T E?>�� ;ZY T YF; THR?R�>� IKN T � C ��� JK;A^�� �� � � � JK; `THRb>Fa R � CF<4THR���.n^k�k��?Y5u?� �Yle�dI� �%crp�n^��e�Y�c���Ò|ÒRÏ�Z?\|\^±¾Ð¶_ ��¨ � � �

� Ò

Page 44: c^~ §~ `Bx ?p mon^p k7~kWj w ?u u{ ?p%u{w c Y u{wl ³ µ ¸Tk ...frey/papers/levelsets/Haddad A... · cfjk;! &>fg?i nqcsr/e4t?t"; i >y t?iut"g jk;%t nq>fl ikn t a j r 2ca@

0 � � 3�s:c^c�� ��?�?u�p{�:� � T"L=IKNQ>��S^SN2IKR >F; &THRb>Fa � � CF<4THR���ajz�:� �Yle�dI�zhTcru�w"�"v:�?p{e���~Ï{Z�\ � � Ð��0 � ]S3 ��c�n^�5ev5cre�u{nz�-´�n5��cr�D¸H�§cru{jlp{��·�Bu�p�c^��u{e�n|Y!crY�f�e�u�~�crxzxl��e���cru{e�n^Y�~�j�~�e�Yz�Nc�´�e¹¨�zp�crp{tNnrm ½�c^~���~��:e�Y!¿Á¡"n^xzeg�?~e�Y/�Y�cr��tz~�e�~.crYHfWe�u�~²c�xzxz��e��?c�u{e�n|Y�~�Â�Ï­µ®�5µb� �.n|e¹m�¨k7c�Y7·.f-�¹Ð�*�n^p���f v¾��e��?Y5u{eÁ«I� Îjl�"� �.nz��Ï{Z�\^\^\:Ð��

0 � \S3 ��c�n^�5ev5cre�u{nz`I½��Àh��-´Ic�p�~�n^Y�crYHf�½���½��?Yzeg�¬wln^j"� � � CFG#RbJBI � a?R��+R"I�CAI�J R"I�JK<?CA@7JK;)�Y T � T";ZY T ;Z<4T1�bGH> � C�E4THR"I&E?CSRbJ R.a JXT"LA� � >FJK; Io��¡ n$crxzx���c�p�e�Y *¤c?d:�?���?u���xzxz��eÁ¨�?c�u{e�n|Y�~�e�Y¯v�e��^YHcr��crYHfTXÍk$cr�^� Îp�n5����~�~�e�Yl��ÓbX{X�XÏ���� ���f5p{n^jl�ze)` ���Ǹ��¹´Ic�e�Yz��`crYHf�h�� ��� ��Y�~��?p��§fz~¬Ð p{n5�|� v .X�· � Z^Z�\�Ï)± ,A,A,:Ð�`IX)YBd5e�u���f c�x}��p?�

0 _ ,S3 ��c�n^�5ev5c�e�u{nl� _�T CSR"I R"I�CAI�J R"I�JK<?CA@ @,�B�UY T � T ;ZY T"; I E?CSRbJ R CF;ZY JBIKR�C ��� @ JK<?CAI�JK>F; I�>J � C ^ T � >�Y T?@ JK; ^^�Z*�c?d:�?���?u �xzxz��e��?c�u{e�n^Y�~.e�YTv:e��|Y�cr��c�Y�f7X)k7cr�|� p{n5����~�~�e�Yz�ÓbX.Ï���� ���fBp�n^jz�le)`F���Ǹ��¹´Ic�e�Yz��`:crY�f�h�� ��� �Y�~��?p.��fz~¬Ð Îp�n5�^�}v ²X�·�Ò � _|]®xzx"�± � ¨�ÒF�7Ï{Z�\^\|]¾Ð��

0 _5Z43�´��{Ó.��~���c�Y�f vH��³�~�wz�?p��%[]>SY T#@ JK;A^5IUT���I � G?THR L�JBIKN�I�>AI�CA@7a CFG"JKCAI�JK>F; � JK;QJ � JEDbC:�I�JK>F; CF;ZY�>SRb< JB@ @ CAI�JK;A^ � CAI IUT"G4;FR�JK;�J � C ^ T � GH>�<4THR?RbJK;A^L��s^n^jzp�Y�cr��nrm�v5��e��?Y5u{eÁ«I��.n^k�xzjzu{e�Yz�7Z?\7Ï)± ,A,|Ò¾ÐF_^_^Ò?¨�_F��±5�

0 _|±S3�´��{Ó.��~���c�Y�fqv���³�~�wz��p?� � X)k7c��^��fB�?Yzn|e�~�e�Yz�Tc�Y�f�fB�§��n^k�x�n�~�e�u�e�n|Y � e�u�w�u{n|u�cr�d|crp�e�cru�e�n|Y®k�e�Yze�k�eÁÈ�cru�e�n^Y�c�Y�f®n�~{��e����gcru{n|p{t�mojzY���u�e�n|Y�~���v:x�����e�c��^eg~{~�jl�²n|Y�hTcru{w5¨�?k7c�u{eg�?~�crY�fyX)k7cr�|� �YHcr��tl~�eg~�`�s^n^jlp{Y�c��®n�mNhTc�u{wz�?k$cru{eg�?cr��X)k7c��^e�Yz��c�Y�fÓ�eg~�e�n|Y"`z± ,B`�Ï)± ,A, � Ð ��¨�Z�]B�

0 _|ÒS3 ��e�Yz���egcrY�*¯j¤crY�f�v:n|Yz� �.w5jzY ��wBj"�L�bGH> � @ >�<?CA@)��T CAI � G?THR�I�>5^A@ >FE?CA@ � T"G"�<4T � I�JK>F;$� ���jzp{n5��n|k�xzjzu�e�Yz�l`z± � ¨Í± �:`Is^jz��tTZ?\|\^\B�

���e"Ê�c|fzfzc|f�º ��d:��~�h��?t:��p�%h¯´ �·.��n|���bYzn^p�k7cr���b~�jlx ��?p{e��?jzp��bfB��%c^��w�crY\ � ±^Ò|_ � � �%Ê`� � �.��f5�?�¸zp�c�Y��������������� ����������������������������������

� �