Upload
bustamante-co-llc
View
216
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/18/2019 Bustamante & Co Fee Comparison
1/23
BUSTAMANTE & Co.
Financial Report:
Evaluating Fees & Conflicts
8/18/2019 Bustamante & Co Fee Comparison
2/23
! # 480-269-0863 # www.bustamanteco.com
!"#$% '( )'*+%*+,
3
5
0
6
7
7
!"#$%&'( *++%
,-.-/0 *-1" /1" 23* *++%
3&./0 *++%
8
9
10
1 1
12
13
14
15
16
1 7
,+''$00 4(156
!7+'$8'$%+
39 !7+'$.'/"+
:+00% */';&
,&';/1
8/18/2019 Bustamante & Co Fee Comparison
3/23
!
Advisory Fees & Conflicts
When exploring the advisory eco-system new investors can become downright confused with finding the right
advisor for their particular needs. Having various titles such as ‘financial advisor’, ‘investment advisor’, ‘financial
planner’, ‘financial solutions advisor’, etc. is enough to scare away the most astute investor.
This has become such a major issue for investors that recently the DOL (Department of Labor) enacted a new rule
which will take affect at the end of the year to have all financial advisors “put the client’s interest above their
own”. This may come as a surprise to many investors who have assumed financial professionals put their
client's first regardless. This is not the case.
If you’ve ever worked with a financial advisor who was an employee under the parties named below then they’re
under the “suitability rule” and defined as ‘investment brokers’. This means they only need to have a basic
understanding of your financial situation to place assets in products which may or may not be suitable for you.
Also, they don’t need to disclose certain compensation they received from commissions or other forms of
payments. A short example would be a purchase of a mutual-fund where the ‘share’ cost would only have to be
disclosed not the internal fees.
1. The Retirement Gamble: A look at high cost mutual funds and the conflicts investors face http://to.pbs.org/1VxTCNr
2. The White House Office of the Press Secretary. (2015, February 23). “FACT SHEET: Middle Class Economics:
Strengthening Retirement Security by Cracking Down on Backdoor Payments and Hidden Fees”. Retrieved from
https://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2015/02/23/fact-sheet-middle-class-economics-strengthening-
retirement-security-crac
https://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2015/02/23/fact-sheet-middle-class-economics-strengthening-retirement-security-crachttps://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2015/02/23/fact-sheet-middle-class-economics-strengthening-retirement-security-crachttps://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2015/02/23/fact-sheet-middle-class-economics-strengthening-retirement-security-crachttps://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2015/02/23/fact-sheet-middle-class-economics-strengthening-retirement-security-crac
8/18/2019 Bustamante & Co Fee Comparison
4/23
"
Working With A True Fiduciary
First and foremost there are two “financial advisor” types that are held to two different standards when it comes
to compensation and level of client involvement.
Investment Broker:
In its simplest form an investment broker works for a broker-dealer firm such as a Merrill Lynch, UBS, Morgan
Stanley, etc. or any firm that is also registered as a broker-dealer. These advisors are under suitability rule
standards which means they’re only obligated to assess your financial situation and place you in a suitable
recommendation of investments which may or may not have high fees attached to them. Compensation receivedfrom commissions for the sale of annuities, mutual funds, and other investment products doesn’t need to be
disclosed to clients which is a conflict in itself.
Investment Advisor:
Investment advisors are held to higher standards by law to “act in the client’s best interest over their own”. This
means they tend to be fee only advisors who doesn’t participate in commission based products. Their
transparency is held to a higher standard than the broker-dealer model simply because they’re registered directly
with the SEC or state.
There are generally two ways to find out what type of advisor you’re hiring:
Do research by visiting finra.org or sec.gov and learn about the advisor and how they're compensated.
Just ask! Advisors may say they're fiduciaries but in reality if they work under broker/dealer firms this is not thecase. Make sure to do your due diligence and interview the investment professional about how the y're compensated
8/18/2019 Bustamante & Co Fee Comparison
5/23
%
Survival of The (Un)Fittest
Despite what movies portray, most financial advisors aren’t sitting in front of monitors watching markets move on
a minute-by-minute bases while also trying to build customized financial plans for their clients. Investors would be
surprised to find out that the industry as a whole generally “outsources” the hassle of picking investments for
clients and even building the financial plans. This is done simply because the advisor may not kno w the financial
markets very well, or they want to service more clients and not deal with the details of daily investments or
planning.
There is generally nothing unethical about this practice provided the advisor doesn't charge an exorbitant fee by
passing off this 'customized' solution to clients. Unfortunately, the state of the advisory world is littered with what I
like to call pretender advisors. They're great at sales but never invested their own money for a living. They can read
from brochures about financial planning concepts but can't perform basic excel sheets on cash-flow analysis.
Mediocrity is alive and well and that is why potential investors who shop around for financial expertise needs to
ask what services does a financial planner provide in-house.
Brokerages examined in this report are listed in order of average total fees from highest to lowest. The brokerage
firms represented in this account include those that are tracked by Bustamante & Co., but is not inclusive to all
brokerages.
Ameriprise
TD Ameritrade
E*Trade
Fidelity
Merrill Lynch
Morgan Stanley
Scottrade
UBS
USAA
Wells Fargo
8/18/2019 Bustamante & Co Fee Comparison
6/23
6
8%# .="&, , <
1 + , <
0 # 9
EFKGI
EFHKI
?
@ 1
EFKEI
A # 0 0 '
8 , $ > =
EFKEI
? 1
! !
HFLKI
! " # $ % & $ % ' #
EFMJI
. / , $ 0 # '
1 2 / 3
, 4
EFKKI
5 6 ) 7 !
* 5
EFEJI
) * ! " # $ % + $ , - #
E F N M I
8/18/2019 Bustamante & Co Fee Comparison
7/23
7
A
# 0 0 '
8 ,
$ > =
HFJNI
,-.-/0 *-1" /1" 23* *++%-)2 $&5# ,7/&/57&' 7/*+7+6+7)/G & 96+6&' ,6/: &/: 3"- ,$$
C&* 5&'56'&+$: D0 :717:7/; +#$ 6*$2H* 96+6&' ,6/: &/: 3"-
,$$* D0 +#$ +)+&' &55)6/+ D&'&/5$ N&>& 6/IC$7;#+$: ,6/:
,$$P. Bustamante & Co. ,)6/: +#&+ +#$ &1$2&;$ 96+6&' ,6/: &/:
3"- $4A$/*$ 2&+7)* 2&/;$ ,2)9 JFM NP +)
JFM PF
3&./0 *++%
-)2 $&5# ,7/&/57&' 7/*+7+6+7)/G +#$ &1$2&;$ +)+&' ,$$G
5)9D7/7/; &:17*)20 ,$$* &/: 96+6&' ,6/:T3"- ,$$*G C&*
5&'56'&+$: D0 &::7/; +#$ &1$2&;$ &:17*)20 ,$$ A$25$/+&;$ +)
+#$ &1$2&;$ 96+6&' ,6/:T3"- $4A$/*$ 2&+7)F Bustamante & Co.
,)6/: +#&+ &1$2&;$ +)+&' ,$$ A$25$/+&;$* 2&/;$ ,2)9 QFJUM
NO8??P +) QFVKM N.$227'' W0/5#PF
EFHHI
HFLHI
HFGHI
HFJHI
HFKHI
@$=D#$,># .="&, , <
1 + , <
0 # 9
HFMOI
? 1
! !
HFKNI
?
@ 1
HFKJI
!B#$,># )=+,0 8## C#$2##' 49 @$=D#$,># .="&, # ) = + , 0 8 # # C # $ 2 # < + , > #
@$=D#$,># .="&, , <
1 + , < 0 # 9
EFGMI
EFEPI
? 1 ! !
EFHGI
? @ 1
EFJNI
A # 0 0 '
8 , $ > =
EFGGI
: # $ $ % 0 0
; 9 < 2 /
E F P L I
) * ! " # $ % + $
, - #
8/18/2019 Bustamante & Co Fee Comparison
8/23
$
3&./0 4&%. &5 *++%6 7+/'0( 89 ,$00$&1 :#+' ;< =+/'%
?AA'07/; +#$ 2&/;$ ), ,$$* :)569$/+$: 7/ +#7* 2$A)2+ +) &/ &1$2&;$ &55)6/+ ), XRJJGJJJG
+#$ 5)*+* +) & A)2+,)'7) )1$2 SJ 0$&2* ), 7/1$*+7/; 5)6': *A&/ ,2)9 & #7;# ), XVSUGSVJ ,)2.$227'' W0/5# +) & ')C ), XRJLGYJZ ,)2 O8??F
.='+ %< !B#$,># )=+,0 8##' QB#$ MH R#,$' 49 @$=D#$,># .="&,# .="&,
8/18/2019 Bustamante & Co Fee Comparison
9/23
8
!"#$%$#&'( *+,-.+'/. 0%.+'/.1
:#$$%00 ;9$2&;$* *$'$5+$:F "#$
&1$2&;$ &:17*)20 ,$$ A$25$/+&;$ 7* QFSJM &/: +#$ &1$2&;$
96+6&' ,6/: &/: 3"- $4A$/*$ 2&+7) 7* JFMF .$227'' W0/5#
&1$2&;$ +)+&' ,$$* C)6': 5)*+ & XRJJGJJJ A)2+,)'7) #)':$2
XVSUGSVJ )1$2 SJ 0$&2*F
SPMGTMPH
!B#$,># )=+,0 8## C#$2##' 49 @$=D#$,># .="&, # ) = + , 0 8 # # C # $ 2 # #
@$=D#$,># .="&,
8/18/2019 Bustamante & Co Fee Comparison
10/23
9'
7*89:98;"$ # .="&,# )=+,0 8## C#$2## EFOOI
SLMNTPOL
. = ' + % < ! B # $ , > #
) = + , 0 8 # # '
SH
SETHHHTHHH
SLHHTHHH
SGHHTHHH
SJHHTHHH
SKHHTHHH
) * ! " # $ % + $ , - #
8/18/2019 Bustamante & Co Fee Comparison
11/23
99
!"#$%$#&'( *+,-.+'/. 0%.+'/.1
)* !"#$%+$,-#
[7+# "B ?9$27+2&:$G +#$ &1$2&;$ +)+&' ,$$ A$25$/+&;$ 7* QFZYMF
"#$ &1$2&;$ &:17*)20 ,$$ A$25$/+&;$ 7* QFRSM &/: +#$ &1$2&;$
96+6&' ,6/: &/: 3"- $4A$/*$ 2&+7) 7* JFMF "B ?9$27+2&:$
&1$2&;$ +)+&' ,$$* C)6': 5)*+ & XRJJGJJJ A)2+,)'7) #)':$2
XKLQGKJV )1$2 SJ 0$&2*F
H N EH EN KH KN MH
SLKETLHP
!B#$,># )=+,0 8## C#$2##' 49 @$=D#$,># .="&, # ) = + , 0 8 # # C # $ 2 # #
@$=D#$,># .="&, , <
1 + ,
< 0 # 9
EFGMI
EFEPI
? 1 ! !
EFHGI
? @ 1
EFJNI
A
# 0 0 '
8 , $ > =
EFGGI
: # $ $ % 0 0
; 9
< 2 /
E F P L I
EFJEI
5 6 ) 7
! * 5
.='+ %< !B#$,># )=+,0 8##' QB#$ MH R#,$'
R#,$'
)* !"#$%+$,-# !B#$,># 8## @$#,D-=3<
!"#$% !(")*+$, -## .#$/#01%
!"#$% 2+1%3 -## .#$/#01%
. = ' + % < ! B # $ , > #
) = + , 0 8 # # '
SH
SETHHHTHHH
SLHHTHHH
SGHHTHHH
SJHHTHHH
SKHHTHHH
8/18/2019 Bustamante & Co Fee Comparison
12/23
9!
!"#$%$#&'( *+,-.+'/. 0%.+'/.1
A#00' 8,$>=
[7+# [$''* -&2;)G +#$ &1$2&;$ +)+&' ,$$ A$25$/+&;$ 7* QFUUMF
"#$ &1$2&;$ &:17*)20 ,$$ A$25$/+&;$ 7* QFLQM &/: +#$
&1$2&;$ 96+6&' ,6/: &/: 3"- $4A$/*$ 2&+7) 7* JFMF [$''*
-&2;) &1$2&;$ +)+&' ,$$* C)6': 5)*+ & XRJJGJJJ A)2+,)'7)
#)':$2
XZKUGJSV )1$2 SJ 0$&2*F
H N EH EN KH KN MH
SOLGTHMP
. = ' + % < ! B # $ , > #
) = + , 0 8 # # '
!B#$,># )=+,0 8## C#$2##' 49 @$=D#$,># .="&, # ) = + , 0 8 # # C # $ 2 # #
@$=D#$,># .="&,
8/18/2019 Bustamante & Co Fee Comparison
13/23
9:
!"#$%$#&'( *+,-.+'/. 0%.+'/.1
:=$>,< 1+, #
) = + , 0 8 # # '
!B#$,># )=+,0 8## C#$2##' 49 @$=D#$,># .="&, # ) = + , 0 8 # # C # $ 2 # #
@$=D#$,># .="&,
8/18/2019 Bustamante & Co Fee Comparison
14/23
9;
!"#$%$#&'( *+,-.+'/. 0%.+'/.1
./,$0#' 12/3,4
[7+# (#&2'$* 85#C&DG +#$ &1$2&;$ +)+&' ,$$ A$25$/+&;$ 7*
QFYKMF "#$ &1$2&;$ &:17*)20 ,$$ A$25$/+&;$ 7* QFLLM &/: +#$
&1$2&;$ 96+6&' ,6/: &/: 3"- $4A$/*$ 2&+7) 7* JFMF
(#&2'$* 85#C&D &1$2&;$ +)+&' ,$$* C)6': 5)*+ & XRJJGJJJ
A)2+,)'7) #)':$2 XUVVGZRU )1$2 SJ 0$&2*F\
H N EH EN KH KN MHSH
SGPPTONG
SETHHHTHHH
SLHHTHHH
SGHHTHHH
SJHHTHHH
SKHHTHHH . = ' + % < ! B # $ , > #
) = + , 0 8 # # '
!B#$,># )=+,0 8## C#$2##' 49 @$=D#$,># .="&, # ) = + , 0 8 # # C # $ 2 # #
@$=D#$,># .="&,
8/18/2019 Bustamante & Co Fee Comparison
15/23
9%
!"#$%$#&'( *+,-.+'/. 0%.+'/.1
?@1
[7+# O=8G +#$ &1$2&;$ +)+&' ,$$ A$25$/+&;$ 7* QFYRMF "#$
&1$2&;$ &:17*)20 ,$$ A$25$/+&;$ 7* QFLQM &/: +#$ &1$2&;$
96+6&' ,6/: &/: 3"- $4A$/*$ 2&+7) 7* JFMF O=8 &1$2&;$
+)+&' ,$$* C)6': 5)*+ & XRJJGJJJ A)2+,)'7) #)':$2 XUKRGYLL
)1$2 SJ 0$&2*F
H N EH EN KH KN MHSH
SGLNTJKK
SETHHHTHHH
SLHHTHHH
SGHHTHHH
SJHHTHHH
SKHHTHHH . = ' + % < ! B # $ , > # ) = + , 0 8 # # '
!B#$,># )=+,0 8## C#$2##' 49 @$=D#$,># .="&, # ) = + , 0 8 # # C # $ 2 # #
@$=D#$,># .="&,
8/18/2019 Bustamante & Co Fee Comparison
16/23
96
!"#$%$#&'( *+,-.+'/. 0%.+'/.1
56)7!*5
[7+# 3\"%?B3G +#$ &1$2&;$ +)+&' ,$$ A$25$/+&;$ 7* QFYQMF
"#$ &1$2&;$ &:17*)20 ,$$ A$25$/+&;$ 7* QFQYM &/: +#$
&1$2&;$ 96+6&' ,6/: &/: 3"- $4A$/*$ 2&+7) 7* JFMF
3\"%?B3 &1$2&;$ +)+&' ,$$* C)6': 5)*+ & XRJJGJJJ A)2+,)'7)
#)':$2 XUUSGKLU )1$2 SJ 0$&2*F\
H N EH EN KH KN MHSH
SGGMTLKG
SETHHHTHHH
SLHHTHHH
SGHHTHHH
SJHHTHHH
SKHHTHHH . = ' + % < ! B # $ , > # ) = + , 0 8 # # '
!B#$,># )=+,0 8## C#$2##' 49 @$=D#$,># .="&, # ) = + , 0 8 # # C # $ 2 # #
@$=D#$,># .="&,
8/18/2019 Bustamante & Co Fee Comparison
17/23
97
!"#$%$#&'( *+,-.+'/. 0%.+'/.1
8%-#0%+9
[7+# -7:$'7+0G +#$ &1$2&;$ +)+&' ,$$ A$25$/+&;$ 7* QFSUMF
"#$ &1$2&;$ &:17*)20 ,$$ A$25$/+&;$ 7* QFQSM &/: +#$
&1$2&;$ 96+6&' ,6/: &/: 3"- $4A$/*$ 2&+7) 7* JFMF
-7:$'7+0 &1$2&;$ +)+&' ,$$* C)6': 5)*+ & XRJJGJJJ
A)2+,)'7) #)':$2 XUYLGQQQ )1$2 SJ 0$&2*F
H N EH EN KH KN MHSH
SGJKTEEE
SETHHHTHHH
SLHHTHHH
SGHHTHHH
SJHHTHHH
SKHHTHHH . = ' + % < ! B # $ , > # ) = + , 0 8 # # '
!B#$,># )=+,0 8## C#$2##' 49 @$=D#$,># .="&, # ) = + , 0 8 # # C # $ 2 # #
@$=D#$,># .="&,
8/18/2019 Bustamante & Co Fee Comparison
18/23
9$
!"#$%$#&'( *+,-.+'/. 0%.+'/.1
[7+# 85)++2&:$G +#$ &1$2&;$ +)+&' ,$$ A$25$/+&;$ 7*
QFQVMF "#$ &1$2&;$ &:17*)20 ,$$ A$25$/+&;$ 7* QFJLM &/:
+#$ &1$2&;$ 96+6&' ,6/: &/: 3"- $4A$/*$ 2&+7) 7* JFMF
85)++2&:$ &1$2&;$ +)+&' ,$$* C)6': 5)*+ & XRJJGJJJ
A)2+,)'7) #)':$2 XRUQGVJK )1$2 SJ 0$&2*F
H N EH EN KH KN MHSH
SNGETPHL
SETHHHTHHH
SLHHTHHH
SGHHTHHH
SJHHTHHH
SKHHTHHH . = ' + % < ! B # $ , > # ) = + , 0 8 # # '
!B#$,># )=+,0 8## C#$2##' 49 @$=D#$,># .="&, # ) = + , 0 8 # # C # $ 2 # #
@$=D#$,># .="&,
8/18/2019 Bustamante & Co Fee Comparison
19/23
98
!"#$%$#&'( *+,-.+'/. 0%.+'/.1
?1!!
[7+# O8??G +#$ &1$2&;$ +)+&' ,$$ A$25$/+&;$ 7* QFJUMF "#$
&1$2&;$ &:17*)20 ,$$ A$25$/+&;$ 7* JFKLM &/: +#$ &1$2&;$
96+6&' ,6/: &/: 3"- $4A$/*$ 2&+7) 7* JFMF O8?? &1$2&;$
+)+&' ,$$* C)6': 5)*+ & XRJJGJJJ A)2+,)'7) #)':$2 XRJLGYJZ
)1$2 SJ 0$&2*F
?1!! !B#$,># 8## @$#,D-=3<
!"#$% !(")*+$, -## .#$/#01%
!"#$% 2+1%3 -## .#$/#01%
H N EH EN KH KN MHSH
SNHKTJHO
SETHHHTHHH
SLHHTHHH
SGHHTHHH
SJHHTHHH
SKHHTHHH . = ' + % < ! B # $ , > # ) = + , 0 8 # # '
!B#$,># )=+,0 8## C#$2##' 49 @$=D#$,># .="&, # ) = + , 0 8 # # C # $ 2 # #
@$=D#$,># .="&,
8/18/2019 Bustamante & Co Fee Comparison
20/23
!'
Bustamante & Co. Comparision
Our tranche-based fee structure is based on getting paid only if we
perform. With 3 tranches, our 1st fee tranche is lower than any other in
the dataset of the eleven selected brokerages, With Bustamante & Cos
tranche 1 fee percentage at 0.60% a $500,000 portfolio holder would
payout in fees $291,760. Along with our unique fee structure, clients are
not subjected to paying for account fees, service or maintenance, and
trading fees.
Bustamante & Co. Tranche 1 Fee Breakdown
0.10%
45608
$291,760
.='+ %< !B#$,># )=+,0 8##' QB#$ MH R#,$' 49 @$=D#$,># .="&, , <
1 + , < 0 # 9
EFGMI
EFEPI
? 1 ! !
EFHGI
? @ 1
EFJNI
A
# 0 0 '
8 , $ > =
EFGGI
: # $ $ % 0 0
; 9
< 2 /
E F P L I
) * ! " # $ % + $ , - # Average ETF Expense Ratio
Tranche-1 Fee Percentage
Average Total Fees After 30 Years
Bustamante & Co. has 3 tranches paid out annually. Tranche 2& 3 are not paid out unless our firm meets performance metrics
and the capital base does not drop below tranche 2 & 3 levels.
8/18/2019 Bustamante & Co Fee Comparison
21/23
#$
Based on the findings of this report, the difficulty for investors in finding the right financial professional to work
with boils down to what their fees are, and what conflicts advisors have that could hinder the advice th at
potential clients may receive. It is well known that the cost of fees associated with investment accounts varies by
firm, but the numbers show that over time fees can really cut into retirement savings over the long haul. The
results show that fees based on a fraction of a percentage may seem trivial at the outset, however, they balloon to
enormous proportions over the life of a long-term investment program.
Our view is very simple when it comes to fees and working with clients. If we underperformed in our portfolios
on behalf of our clients, and if they don't meet certain planning milestones we set out for them, then we shouldn't
be compensated. We are the only firm in Arizona who bases their fees on underlying metrics that can be
measured in real-time so clients know exactly why they pay us.
The summary shows that at 1.98% in average total fee percentage, Merrill Lynch had the highest overall average
total fee percentage of the eleven selected brokerages, representing the worst offender in costs related to fees on
investments.
At 1.06% in average total fee percentage, USAA had the lowest overall average total fee percentage of the eleven
selected brokerages, coming in higher than Bustamante & Co. tranche 1 fee at 0.60%
8/18/2019 Bustamante & Co Fee Comparison
22/23
##
To uncover fees associated with investments, Bustamante & Co. employed machine learning and human
training to calculate both the average advisory fee for managed accounts and average fund related fees.
Bustamante & Co. created a dataset for each financial institution and analyzed a total of 9,365 advised
accounts and 146,559 accounts with fund related fees across the 11 financial institutions. Data from the
3rd Quarter of 2014 were used to examine the range of each fee type and calculate the average total fee
of each financial institution and the data include a 10% trim to remove outliers. The 30-year projected
fee metric is based on an account annual growth rate of 7% and average total fees remaining consistent
to the derived rates over the 30-year period.
Advisory Fee Calculation Example:
Total Portfolio = $100,000
Annual Advisory Fee = $1,500
Advisory Fee % ($1,500 / $100,000 = 1.5%) = 1.5%
Mutual Fund/ETF Fee Calculation Example:
Total Portfolio = $100,000
Annual Mutual Fund/ETF Fee = $1,000Expense Ratio (unweighted) ($1,000 / $100,000 = 1.0%) = 1.0%
Total Fee Calculation Example:
Total Portfolio = $100,000
Total Fee (Advisor + Fund) = $2,500
Total Fee % ($2,500 / $100,000 = 1.0%) = 2.5%
8/18/2019 Bustamante & Co Fee Comparison
23/23
!"#$%'()#
This communication and all data are for informational purposes only and do not constitute a recommendation to buy or sell securities. You should not rely on this information
as the primary basis of your investment, financial, or tax planning decisions. You should consult your legal or tax professional regarding your specific situation. Third party data
is obtained from sources believed to be reliable. However, Bustamante & Co. cannot guarantee that data’s currency, accuracy, timeliness, completeness or fitness for any
particular purpose. Certain sections of this commentary may contain forward-looking statements that are based on our reasonable expectations, estimate, projections and
assumptions. Forward-looking statements are not guarantees of future performance and involve certain risks and uncertainties, which are difficult to predict. Past performance is
not a guarantee of future return, nor is it necessarily indicative of future performance. Keep in mind investing involves risk. The value of your investment will fluctuate over
time and you may gain or lose money.