Upload
andreea-ioana
View
213
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/12/2019 Bulding Blocks of a New Paradigm for Studying World Politics
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bulding-blocks-of-a-new-paradigm-for-studying-world-politics 1/11
Building blocks of a new paradigm for
studying world politics
Cast in terms of the conference and panel for which this chapter was written,
it is not difficult to presume the existence of “new international realities” that
call for a “new paradigm.” In my judgment the so-called “war on terror” is not
Among the new realities. Terrorist activities have long been a part of theInternational scene. The attacks of September 11, 2001, have certainly added
to the salience of terrorism, but they are neither the vanguard of new
realities nor the foundations of a new paradigm. Any paradigm is a
jail because its coherence derives from a structure that provides an answer to
any developments that might nullify its validity.
8/12/2019 Bulding Blocks of a New Paradigm for Studying World Politics
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bulding-blocks-of-a-new-paradigm-for-studying-world-politics 2/11
For the structure of world politics has undergonen
enormous changes in recent decades, changes that
continue to unfold and become increasingly
discrepant with our conventional paradigms. A
plethora of other dynamics are now at work that
raise serious doubts about the viability of states and
the conditions under which their actions are
relevant to the course of events.
8/12/2019 Bulding Blocks of a New Paradigm for Studying World Politics
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bulding-blocks-of-a-new-paradigm-for-studying-world-politics 3/11
A post-international perspective
Noted briefly in the previous chapter, four conceptual
dynamics – the skill revolution, the organizational
explosion, the pervasive disaggregation of authority, andthe bifurcation of world politics – are especially relevant
inasmuch as they anticipated the new complexities and
can serve as key foundations for a new paradigm. The
dynamics are so thoroughly interrelated, with each
serving as a building block for the others, that theensuing presentation should not be interpreted as a
ranking of their importance.
8/12/2019 Bulding Blocks of a New Paradigm for Studying World Politics
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bulding-blocks-of-a-new-paradigm-for-studying-world-politics 4/11
The skill revolution
For a host of reasons, some derived from the Internet, global television, and other
new technologies, some from diverse forms and sources of travel, some from the
need to cope with ever-greater complexity, and some from the other dynamics
noted below, people the world over have evolved new capacities to render distant
events proximate through enhanced analytic, emotional, and imaginative talents. Put
differently, increasingly people at all levels of community and in every part of the
world have undergone empowerment, a sense that they know when, where, and
how to engage in collective action and thus contribute to the course of events.
This is not to say that all individuals are becoming equally skilled and empowered. Far from it: those
connected to the Internet are doubtless more skillful in relating to world affairs than the vast majority
who do not have a connection. On the contrary, people remain ensconced in the values of their cultures
even as their greater skills extend their understanding of these values and their relevance to issues.
8/12/2019 Bulding Blocks of a New Paradigm for Studying World Politics
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bulding-blocks-of-a-new-paradigm-for-studying-world-politics 5/11
The organizational explosion
Due in good measure to the skill revolution and the more empowered people it is
generating as well as swollen by the networking capacities fostered by the Internet,
but also because of the salience of environmental and human rights issues and a
widespread felt need in an ever more complex world to reach out to like-mindedothers, organizations are being formed at every level of community and throughout
the world. Trend lines descriptive of this phenomenon are difficult to compile
because many organizations do not report to record-keeping centers, but such data as
have been collected as well as numerous anecdotal materials all point to a continuing
growth pattern. Although the pattern may be less pronounced in the United States,
the organizational explosion is so intense that it needs to be treated as the basis forkey parameters of any paradigm designed to account for the new international
realities.
8/12/2019 Bulding Blocks of a New Paradigm for Studying World Politics
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bulding-blocks-of-a-new-paradigm-for-studying-world-politics 6/11
The disaggregation of authority
The skill revolution and the organizational explosion are major
building blocks for one parameter of any new paradigm
designed to analyze the emergent world scene, namely, thecontinuing and extensive process whereby authority is
undergoing disaggregation at every level of community, in
every walk of life, and in all parts of the world. Even some
individuals now can act authoritatively under certain
circumstances. As a consequence, the global stage is evermore crowded with diverse authorities that sometimes
cooperate, often conflict, and endlessly interact.
8/12/2019 Bulding Blocks of a New Paradigm for Studying World Politics
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bulding-blocks-of-a-new-paradigm-for-studying-world-politics 7/11
The bifurcation of world politics
The bifurcation of global structures is a central foundation on which a jailbreak from existing paradigms
must rest. But in this case a jailbreak is especially difficult precisely because the concept of a bifurcated
world necessitates a downgrading of the importance of states as actors – not a dismissal of them by any
means, but simply a downgrading that allows for recognition of the centrality of the numerous
collectivities in the multi-centric world . The difficulties of negotiating a jailbreak in this respect are
somewhat eased by the fact that the bifurcation of world politics has become institutionalized.
Since the summer of 1992 in Rio de Janeiro, when the state-centric world convened to address
environmental problems and more than 3,000 organizations of the multicentric world gathered nearby
to debate the issues and submit resolutions and recommendations to the state-centric delegates.
In effect, the institutionalization of bifurcated global structures has facilitated the emergence of left-
and right-wings in the multi-centric world.
8/12/2019 Bulding Blocks of a New Paradigm for Studying World Politics
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bulding-blocks-of-a-new-paradigm-for-studying-world-politics 8/11
The challenge of analyzing the multi-centric world
Multiple challenges confront analysts seeking to comprehend the role the multicentric
world plays in shaping and sustaining the “new international realities.”
Here four challenges are confronted and, hopefully, clarified. To anticipate the core
problems inheren in each of the four challenges, one is the need to break free of thepremise that the state-centric world is the predominant structure through which
world affairs unfold, a conceptual jailbreak that in turn involves recasting our
understanding of the nature of states, their capacities, and the roles they play on the
world stage. The second involves the definitional need for clarity on the characteristics
of the actors that comprise the multi-centric world. The third focuses on the internal
structure of the multi centric world, its coherence, conflicts, and potentials. The fourthchallenge concerns the need to comprehend the conflicts that can occur within the
multi-centric world as well as those that ensue between it and the statecentric world.
8/12/2019 Bulding Blocks of a New Paradigm for Studying World Politics
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bulding-blocks-of-a-new-paradigm-for-studying-world-politics 9/11
The conceptual challenge
Two related problems confront any effort to conceptualize the nature and role of the multi-centric
world in a global bifurcated structure. One has already been implied, namely, that of rethinking the
nature of the state and recognizing that it is no longer the predominant actor in world politics. Most
states no longer control the flow of money, goods, pollution, drugs,crime, and people across their
borders to the same extent as they did in the past. Perhaps even more difficult is a second conceptual
challenge: that of assessing and delineating the structures of the multi centric world, composed as it is
of myriad organizations with myriad purposes, interests, and capabilities that are undergoing a
continuing disaggregation of authority. By retaining the notion of the overall global structure as
bifurcated, the centrality of states is not underestimate even as the concept of bifurcation makes clear
that they are now faced with formidable foes as well as assessed by helpful partners in the multi-centric
world. By maintaining the concept of bifurcation the emergence of new global structures is highlighted
even as the relevance of states in acknowledged.
8/12/2019 Bulding Blocks of a New Paradigm for Studying World Politics
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bulding-blocks-of-a-new-paradigm-for-studying-world-politics 10/11
Comprehending the range of conflict within the multi-centric world
It goes without saying that the multi-centric world is marked by intense competition
among the actors within its various issue areas. What is perhaps less fully recognized,
however, is the competition and rivalry that unfolds within NGOs as well as between
them. Many of them sustain large bureaucracies that are marked by internal
squabbles that can have significant repercussions.
A good, troubling case in point is that of Save the Children, a humanitarian
organization that has done its share of good work in the past but that recently was
wracked by a conflict between its branches in the United States and the United
Kingdom. Given the nature of bureaucracies, it is hardly surprising that such squabbles
are not infrequent in Save the Children and, presumably, in a number of othertransnational NGOs.
8/12/2019 Bulding Blocks of a New Paradigm for Studying World Politics
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bulding-blocks-of-a-new-paradigm-for-studying-world-politics 11/11
A brief summing up
Conceiving of a bifurcated world marked by a continuing
skill revolution and organizational explosion facilitates an
understanding of the large degree to which global affairs
have become marked by complexity. Such a formulation
(dare I say paradigm) highlights the messiness of the
world scene and the degree to which it is prone toambiguity and contradiction even as it offers building
blocks for a paradigm that serves cogent analysis.