Upload
asian-judges-symposium-on-environmental-decision-making-the-rule-of-law-and-environmental-justice
View
217
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/8/2019 Brian Preston - Judicial Special is at Ion in Environmental Law - 12 Advantages
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/brian-preston-judicial-special-is-at-ion-in-environmental-law-12-advantages 1/22
Dymljlbe Zvijlbelzb}lo` l`
I`wlxo`ki`}be Ebq4
28 Bmwb`}baiz
H|
]ni No` Dyz}lji Hxlb` D Vxiz}o`
Jnlig Dymai
Eb`m b`m I`wlxo`ki`} Joyx} og
@ZQ
8/8/2019 Brian Preston - Judicial Special is at Ion in Environmental Law - 12 Advantages
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/brian-preston-judicial-special-is-at-ion-in-environmental-law-12-advantages 2/22
Eb`m b`m I`wlxo`ki`} Joyx} .@ZQ,
]ni Eb`m b`m I`wlxo`ki`} Joyx} og @ZQ .EIJ,
lz }ni glxz} zvijlbelz} i`wlxo`ki`}be zyvixlox joyx}og xijoxm l` }ni qoxem
B} eibz} 28 hi`igl}z nbwi geoqim gxok
iz}bhelznki`} b`m ovixb}lo` og }ni EIJ
8/8/2019 Brian Preston - Judicial Special is at Ion in Environmental Law - 12 Advantages
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/brian-preston-judicial-special-is-at-ion-in-environmental-law-12-advantages 3/22
2 Xb}lo`belzb}lo` og dyxlzmlj}lo`
Xb}lo`belzb}lo` b`m ji`}xbelzb}lo` og dyxlzmlj}lo` xizye}z l`4
L`}iaxb}im b`m jonixi`} i`wlxo`ki`}be dyxlzmlj}lo`
Jxl}ljbe kbzz og jbziz
Ijo`oklj iggljli`jliz gox yzixz b`m vyhelj xizoyxjiz l`―o`i+z}ov znov‛
Hi}}ix rybel}| b`m l``owb}lwi mijlzlo`+kbcl`a l` ho}nzyhz}b`ji b`m vxojimyxi h| jxozz gix}lelzb}lo` hi}qii`mlggixi`} jebzziz og dyxlzmlj}lo`
8/8/2019 Brian Preston - Judicial Special is at Ion in Environmental Law - 12 Advantages
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/brian-preston-judicial-special-is-at-ion-in-environmental-law-12-advantages 4/22
2 Xb}lo`belzb}lo` jo`}
Joyx} hil`a b gojyz og i`wlxo`ki`}be eiabe
mijlzlo`+kbcl`a
L`jxibzim bqbxi`izz og i`wlxo`ki`}be ebq%voelj| b`m lzzyiz h| yzixz% aowix`ki`}%
i`wlxo`ki`}be @AOz% jlwle zojli}|% eiabe b`m o}nix
vxogizzlo`z b`m imyjb}lo`be l`z}l}y}lo`z L`jxibzim i`goxjiki`} og i`wlxo`ki`}be ebq
8/8/2019 Brian Preston - Judicial Special is at Ion in Environmental Law - 12 Advantages
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/brian-preston-judicial-special-is-at-ion-in-environmental-law-12-advantages 5/22
8 Zvijlbelzb}lo`
I`wlxo`ki`}be lzzyiz b`m }ni eiabe b`m voelj|xizvo`ziz mikb`m zvijlbe c`oqeimai b`m i~vix}lzi
Dymljlbe imyjb}lo`4 Dymaiz `iim }o hi imyjb}im bhoy}
b`m b}}y`im }o i`wlxo`ki`}be lzzyiz b`m }ni eiabe b`mvoelj| xizvo`ziz
]ijn`ljbe i~vix}z4 Mijlzlo`+kbcl`a rybel}|%
iggij}lwi`izz b`m iggljli`j| jb` hi i`nb`jim h| }nibwblebhlel}| ql}nl` }ni joyx} og }ijn`ljbe i~vix}z
Vxbj}lji kbciz vixgij}4 Zvijlbelzb}lo` l`jxibzizc`oqeimai b`m i~vix}lzi owix }lki
8/8/2019 Brian Preston - Judicial Special is at Ion in Environmental Law - 12 Advantages
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/brian-preston-judicial-special-is-at-ion-in-environmental-law-12-advantages 6/22
: Kye}l+moox Joyx}noyzi
Xb}lo`belzb}lo`% zvijlbelzb}lo` b`m }ni bwblebhlel}| og bxb`ai og }ijn`ljbe i~vix}lzi gbjlel}b}iz BMX4
Xb}lo`belzb}lo`4 }ni Joyx} nbz dyxlzmlj}lo` }o mibe ql}n kye}lvei
gbji}z og b` i`wlxo`ki`}be mlzvy}i Zvijlbelzb}lo`4 gbjlel}b}iz b hi}}ix bvvxijlb}lo` og }ni `b}yxi b`m
jnbxbj}ixlz}ljz og i`wlxo`ki`}be mlzvy}iz b`m zieij}lo` og BMX
kijnb`lzk gox ibjn mlzvy}i
Bwblebhlel}| og }ijn`ljbe i~vix}z i`bheiz }nilx yzi l`
jo`jlelb}lo` b`m `iy}xbe iwbeyb}lo`% b`m lkvxowiz }ni rybel}|%
iggij}lwi`izz b`m iggljli`j| og bmdymljb}lo`
8/8/2019 Brian Preston - Judicial Special is at Ion in Environmental Law - 12 Advantages
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/brian-preston-judicial-special-is-at-ion-in-environmental-law-12-advantages 7/22
8/8/2019 Brian Preston - Judicial Special is at Ion in Environmental Law - 12 Advantages
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/brian-preston-judicial-special-is-at-ion-in-environmental-law-12-advantages 8/22
9 L`mivi`mi`ji gxok Aowix`ki`}
Iz}bhelznl`a b` i`wlxo`ki`}be joyx} bz b joyx}%
xb}nix }nb` bz b` oxab` og }ni i~ijy}lwi bxk og
aowix`ki`}% b`m bz b zyvixlox joyx} og xijoxm%
xb}nix }nb` b` l`gixlox joyx} ox }xlhy`be% i`nb`jiz
l`mivi`mi`ji
8/8/2019 Brian Preston - Judicial Special is at Ion in Environmental Law - 12 Advantages
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/brian-preston-judicial-special-is-at-ion-in-environmental-law-12-advantages 9/22
7 Xizvo`zlwi`izz }o I`wlxo`ki`}be
Vxoheikz B` i`wlxo`ki`}be joyx} lz hi}}ix bhei }o bmmxizz }ni
vxizzl`a% vixwbzlwi b`m vix`ljloyz i`wlxo`ki`}bevxoheikz }nb} jo`gxo`} zojli}| .zyjn bz jelkb}i jnb`ai
b`m eozz og hlomlwixzl}|, @iq l`z}l}y}lo`z b`m jxib}lwi b}}l}ymiz bxi xirylxim
Zvijlbelzb}lo` i`bheiz yzi og zvijlbe c`oqeimai b`mi~vix}lzi l` ho}n }ni vxojizz b`m }ni zyhz}b`ji og xizoey}lo` og }nizi vxoheikz
Xb}lo`belzb}lo` i`ebxaiz }ni xikimliz bwblebhei
8/8/2019 Brian Preston - Judicial Special is at Ion in Environmental Law - 12 Advantages
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/brian-preston-judicial-special-is-at-ion-in-environmental-law-12-advantages 10/22
1 Gbjlel}b}iz Bjjizz }o Dyz}lji
Bjjizz }o dyz}lji l`jeymiz bjjizz }o i`wlxo`ki`}be dyz}lji
B joyx} jb` gbjlel}b}i bjjizz }o dyz}lji ho}n h|4
L}z zyhz}b`}lwi mijlzlo`z3
L}z vxbj}ljiz b`m vxojimyxiz3 b`m
Bmmxizzl`a l`irybel}| og bekz
Zyhz}b`}lwi mijlzlo`z jb` yvnoem gy`mbki`}be
jo`z}l}y}lo`be% z}b}y}ox| b`m nykb` xlan}z og bjjizz }o
dyz}lji
8/8/2019 Brian Preston - Judicial Special is at Ion in Environmental Law - 12 Advantages
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/brian-preston-judicial-special-is-at-ion-in-environmental-law-12-advantages 11/22
1 Gbjlel}b}iz Bjjizz }o Dyz}lji jo`}
B joyx}“z vxbj}lji b`m vxojimyxi jb` gbjlel}b}i bjjizz }o dyz}lji h|4
Xikowl`a hbxxlixz }o vyhelj l`}ixiz} el}lab}lo`
Beeoql`a vbx}liz }o bvvibx h| wbxloyz kib`z .eiabe
xivxizi`}b}lo`% bai`} by}noxlzim l` qxl}l`a ox l` vixzo`,
Gbjlel}b}l`a bjjizz }o l`goxkb}lo` ia xirylxl`a mlzjowix| og mojyki`}z b`m xibzo`z gox mijlzlo` h| aowix`ki`} bai`jliz
Gbjlel}b}l`a }ni dyz}% ryljc b`m jnibv xizoey}lo` og vxojiiml`az
8/8/2019 Brian Preston - Judicial Special is at Ion in Environmental Law - 12 Advantages
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/brian-preston-judicial-special-is-at-ion-in-environmental-law-12-advantages 12/22
1 Bjjizz }o Dyz}lji jo`}
B joyx} jb` bmmxizz l`irybel}| og bekz hi}qii` vbx}liz4 Zvijlbelzb}lo` b`m }ni bwblebhlel}| og }ijn`ljbe i~vix}z ximxizziz
l` vbx} l`irybel}| og xizoyxjiz b`m bjjizz }o i~vix} bzzlz}b`ji b`miwlmi`ji
Bjjizz gox vixzo`z ql}n mlzbhlel}liz3
Bjjizz }o niev b`m l`goxkb}lo` .h| joyx} qihzl}i% l`goxkb}lo`znii}z b`m xialz}x| z}bgg,3
Bjjizz gox y`xivxizi`}im el}lab`}z .zvijlbe gbj} znii} bz qiee bzo}nix zoyxjiz og zieg+niev bhowi,3 b`m
Aioaxbvnljbe bjjizzlhlel}| .yzi og iJoyx}% }ieivno`ijo`gixi`jiz% wlmio+jo`gixi`jl`a% joy`}x| nibxl`az% o`+zl}i
nibxl`az b`m }bcl`a iwlmi`ji o`+zl}i,
8/8/2019 Brian Preston - Judicial Special is at Ion in Environmental Law - 12 Advantages
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/brian-preston-judicial-special-is-at-ion-in-environmental-law-12-advantages 13/22
> Miwieovki`} og I`wlxo`ki`}be
Dyxlzvxymi`ji ]ni EIJ nbz znoq` }nb} b` i`wlxo`ki`}be joyx}
og }ni xirylzl}i z}b}yz nbz koxi zvijlbelzim
c`oqeimai% nbz koxi jbziz b`m ovvox}y`l}|% b`m lz
koxi elcie| }o miwieov i`wlxo`ki`}be
dyxlzvxymi`ji
]ni EIJ“z mijlzlo`z nbwi miwieovim bzvij}z og zyhz}b`}lwi% vxojimyxbe% xiz}oxb}lwi% }nixbviy}lj
b`m mlz}xlhy}lwi dyz}lji
8/8/2019 Brian Preston - Judicial Special is at Ion in Environmental Law - 12 Advantages
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/brian-preston-judicial-special-is-at-ion-in-environmental-law-12-advantages 14/22
I`wlxo`ki`}be Dyxlzvxymi`ji4
I~bkveiz
Zyhz}b`}lwi dyz}lji4
ijoeoaljbee| zyz}bl`bhei miwieovki`} .l`}iaxb}lo` vxl`jlvei%
vxijby}lo`bx| vxl`jlvei% l`}ix b`m l`}xb ai`ixb}lo`be iryl}|%
jo`zixwb}lo` og hloeoaljbe mlwixzl}| b`m ijoeoaljbe l`}iaxl}| b`m
l`}ix`belzb}lo` og i~}ix`be% i`wlxo`ki`}be joz}z l`jeyml`a }ni
voeey}ix vb|z vxl`jlvei,3
i`wlxo`ki`}be lkvbj} bzzizzki`}3 vyhelj }xyz}3 b`m
zi`}i`jl`a gox i`wlxo`ki`}be jxlki
8/8/2019 Brian Preston - Judicial Special is at Ion in Environmental Law - 12 Advantages
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/brian-preston-judicial-special-is-at-ion-in-environmental-law-12-advantages 15/22
I`wlxo`ki`}be Dyxlzvxymi`ji4
I~bkveizVxojimyxbe dyz}lji4 bjjizz }o dyz}lji l`jeyml`a
xikowbe og hbxxlixz }o vyhelj l`}ixiz} el}lab}lo` l`
xieb}lo` }o4
Z}b`ml`a
L`}ixeojy}ox| l`dy`j}lo`z
Zijyxl}| gox joz}zEbjniz
Joz}z
8/8/2019 Brian Preston - Judicial Special is at Ion in Environmental Law - 12 Advantages
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/brian-preston-judicial-special-is-at-ion-in-environmental-law-12-advantages 16/22
I`wlxo`ki`}be Dyxlzvxymi`ji4
I~bkveiz
Mlz}xlhy}lwi dyz}lji4 l`}ix b`m l`}xb ai`ixb}lo`beiryl}|% voeey}ix vb|z vxl`jlvei% hbeb`jl`a vyhelj
b`m vxlwb}i xlan}z b`m xizvo`zlhlel}liz
Xiz}oxb}lwi dyz}lji4 wlj}lk+oggi`mix kimlb}lo`b`m voeey}ix vb|z vxl`jlvei gox i`wlxo`ki`}bejxlki
]nixbviy}lj dyz}lji4 vxbj}lji b`m vxojimyxi }olkvxowi qiegbxi og el}lab`}z
8/8/2019 Brian Preston - Judicial Special is at Ion in Environmental Law - 12 Advantages
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/brian-preston-judicial-special-is-at-ion-in-environmental-law-12-advantages 17/22
< Hi}}ix Joyx} Bmkl`lz}xb}lo`
]ni EIJ komie gbjlel}b}im hi}}ix bjnliwiki`} og }ni ohdij}lwiz og joyx} bmkl`lz}xb}lo` og iryl}|%
iggij}lwi`izz b`m iggljli`j|
]ni EIJ nbz% xieb}lwi }o o}nix joyx}z l` @ZQ%
kl`lkbe mieb| b`m hbjceoa% b`m nlan jeibxb`ji
xb}iz b`m vxomyj}lwl}|
8/8/2019 Brian Preston - Judicial Special is at Ion in Environmental Law - 12 Advantages
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/brian-preston-judicial-special-is-at-ion-in-environmental-law-12-advantages 18/22
26 Y`lg|l`a i}noz b`m klzzlo`
Xb}lo`belzb}lo` b`m zvijlbelzb}lo` alwi b` oxab`ljjonixi`ji }o }ni Joyx} b`m l}z qoxc
]ni `b}yxi og i`wlxo`ki`}be ebq alwiz b y`lg|l`a i}noz
b`m klzzlo` Izvxl} mi joxvz og i`wlxo`ki`}be joyx}4
EIJ vixzo``ie hieliwi }ni Joyx} b`m l}z qoxc bxi lkvox}b`} b`mbxi kbcl`a b mlggixi`ji3
]ni| wliq }nikziewiz bz vbx} og b }ibk3 `o} bz l`mlwlmybezqoxcl`a l`mivi`mi`}e|3 b`m
]ni yzixz% eiabe xivxizi`}b}lwiz b`m i~vix}z bezo znbxi l` }nlz
zvlxl} b`m klzzlo`
8/8/2019 Brian Preston - Judicial Special is at Ion in Environmental Law - 12 Advantages
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/brian-preston-judicial-special-is-at-ion-in-environmental-law-12-advantages 19/22
22 Wbeyi+bmml`a gy`j}lo`
]ni EIJ“z mijlzlo`z b`m qoxc nbwi ai`ixb}im wbeyi bvbx}gxok }ni vbx}ljyebx jbzi ox }bzc l`woewim4
Yvnoeml`a b`m i~veljb}lo` og i`wlxo`ki`}be ebq b`m wbeyiz3
L` kixl}z xiwliq bvvibez% }ni joyx}“z mijlzlo`z bmm wbeyi }obmkl`lz}xb}lwi mijlzlo`+kbcl`a ]ni joyx} i~}xbvoeb}iz
vxl`jlveiz gxok }ni jbziz b`m vyheljlziz }nik ]ni vxl`jlveiz jb`
hi yzim h| bai`jliz l` gy}yxi mijlzlo`+kbcl`a
8/8/2019 Brian Preston - Judicial Special is at Ion in Environmental Law - 12 Advantages
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/brian-preston-judicial-special-is-at-ion-in-environmental-law-12-advantages 20/22
22 Wbeyi+bmml`a gy`j}lo` jo`}
]ni EIJ nbz bezo hii` b` l``owb}ox b`m `b}lo`beeibmix l` joyx} vxbj}ljiz b`m vxojimyxiz l`jeyml`a4
iJoyx} jbzi kb`baiki`}3
I~vix} iwlmi`ji l`jeyml`a joyx}+mlxij}im dol`}jo`gixi`jl`a b`m xivox}% jo`jyxxi`} iwlmi`ji b`mvbx}liz“ zl`aei i~vix}z3
O`+zl}i nibxl`az b`m }bcl`a iwlmi`ji o` zl}i3 b`mGlxz} joyx} l` }ni qoxem }o lkveiki`} }ni L`}ix`b}lo`be
Gxbkiqoxc gox Joyx} I~jieei`ji
8/8/2019 Brian Preston - Judicial Special is at Ion in Environmental Law - 12 Advantages
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/brian-preston-judicial-special-is-at-ion-in-environmental-law-12-advantages 21/22
28 Gei~lhlel}| b`m L``owb}lo`
Ebxai% iz}bhelznim joyx}z jb` hi jo`zixwb}lwi b`mnbwi l`ix}lb + jnb`ai lz zeoq b`m xizlz}im
]ni gbj} }nb} }ni EIJ lz b zivbxb}i joyx} nbzi`bheim gei~lhlel}| b`m l``owb}lo` Jnb`aiz }o
vxbj}ljiz b`m vxojimyxi joyem hi bjnliwim ryljce|
b`m ql}n qlmi zyvvox} ql}nl` }ni l`z}l}y}lo`
8/8/2019 Brian Preston - Judicial Special is at Ion in Environmental Law - 12 Advantages
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/brian-preston-judicial-special-is-at-ion-in-environmental-law-12-advantages 22/22
Jo`jeyzlo`
]ni EIJ lz y`moyh}ime| b komie og b zyjjizzgyei`wlxo`ki`}be joyx}
L} lz eo`a iz}bhelznim + :6 |ibxz
L} nbz b vxi+ikl`i`} l`}ix`b}lo`be b`m `b}lo`be xivy}b}lo`
L} nbz xijilwim kb`| gbwoyxbhei xiwliqz b`m hii` b hbzlz
gox xijokki`mb}lo`z gox b` i`wlxo`ki`} joyx}
L} lz jo`}l`yl`a }o bmbv} }o kii} }ni i`wlxo`ki`}be
jnbeei`aiz og }ni gy}yxi