34
ARPA ORDER NO. 189-61 MEMORANDUM RM-3334-ARPA OCTOBER 1962 PREPARED FOR: BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley . ADVANCED RESEARCH PROJECTS AGENCY SANTA MONICA CAliFORNIA------

Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    10

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

ARPA ORDER NO. 189-61

MEMORANDUM RM-3334-ARPA OCTOBER 1962

PREPARED FOR:

BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF

LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES

R. 0. Hundley

. ADVANCED RESEARCH PROJECTS AGENCY

-----------~R~no~ SANTA MONICA • CAliFORNIA------

Page 2: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported
Page 3: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

MEMORANDUM

RM-3334-ARPA OCTOBER 1962

ARPA ORDER NO. 189-61

BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF

LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES

R. 0. Hundley

Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported and monitorerl hy the A,h ct!H"t>d H<·search Projel"l' Agency under Contract ~o. SD-79. Any views or conclusions contairwd in this Memorandum

should not he interpr<'lcd as ;Tpresenting the official opinion or policy of AHPA. Permission lo quote or rqnodtH'C must he obtained from The HAND Corporation.

--------------------~Rnno~~ 1700 MAIN Sl • SANTA MONICA • (AllfOI<N!A----------

Page 4: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported
Page 5: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

Hi

PRWAC.C

The research reported in this Memorandum is part of a general

study of the radiation emitted by charged particle beams.

The Memorandum discusses the impact radiation ("bremsstrahlung")

emitted during the collision of low-energy electrons with neutral atoms

and molecules. The study will be of general interest to persons

studying the interaction of matter and radiation.

Page 6: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported
Page 7: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

'l

~2his liemorandmn d.iscusses the bTemsstrahlunc; radiation emitted

durinc; t11e collision o:L' lm1-eneni;-Y electrons -vrith neutral atoms and

molecules. ~rhe cliscussion is limite()_ to the case of lmr-energieq

E :::: 1 ev, ancl so:;:t ;Jhotons, 1io.J <:< r~, 'Jhere E is the electron kinetic

enerc::,-y, and cJ is the radiation frequency. The brerasstrahlung rate

is ex::pressed in terms of' the elastic scattering amplitude, anc1 use

:Ls made o:l various e:q1eriuental and t11eoretical st·uclies or the lm1-

energy elastic scattering o:l electrons by neutral a~coms and molecules.

The Tate o:E' ·bn"L1sstrah11.:w."lc eJaission :C'ro;n a partially ionized gas due

to electron-neu:t1·al r:ollisions is calculate()_, and the results are

" " • , (n . ' - ( ,- ')' p::-eSCJ1CCO. lYl _t~qs., -. r:.O) a110. 'c!.c.). In Eq. ( 29) the elect:C'on-neutral

bremsstrahlung :;:ate :~::., cm1parecl to t1J.e elect:,~on-ion bTemsstrahlunc;

Page 8: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported
Page 9: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

vii

CONTENTS

PHEFACE iii

SUfVfl'f.IARY v

LIST OF FIGURES • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • ix

Section I. INTRODUCTION • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • . • • • • • • 1

II. PELATION OF BREMSSTRAHLUNG TO SCATTERING ••••••••••••••• 4

III. SCATTERING LENGTH APPROXD!fJ\.TION. • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 7

IV. MODIFIED EFFECTI~3-l{ANGE APPHOXIMATION •••••••••••••••••• 11

V. USE OF EXPElmv:JEN'rP.L P.ESULTS FOE !'!Ol.ECULAR NI'l'ROGEN...... 16

VI. COHP iLRISON OF ELECTRON- NEUTPLAL JIJ'ID E'LECTHON- ION BREMSSTRAHLlJTIIG. • • • • • • • • • . • • • • . • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 19

P-El1'ERENCJ:..:S. • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 21

Page 10: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported
Page 11: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

ix

LIST OF FIGURES

l. Momentilltl transfer eros~; section for N2

. . . . . • • • • . . . . . . . • . . . . 18

2. Comparison of electron-ion and electron-neutral bremmstrahlung rates...................................... 20

Page 12: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported
Page 13: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

l

I. INTRODUCTION

The emission of bremsstrahlung radiation during -the collision of

electrons 1d th neutral a·toms and molecules is one of the oldest prob-

lems in quantum electrodynamics, and has been the subject of extensive

research. (l) Theoretical studies of this process have almost invaria-

bly been based on the representation of the neutral target system by

a screened coulomb field. This representation, ~~hich neglects any

effect the incident electron may have on the electronic cloud of the

atom or molecule, is adequate so long as the incident electron has an

energy significantly greater than the energies of the ·bound electrons

or the target system.

Hecently, because of various applications in atmospheric and

space physics, there has been interest in the bremsstrahlung associated

'.-lith very lm1-energy electrons, having energies much less than the

energies or the bound atomic or rnoleculur electrons. For this region

of energies the theoretical calculations based on a screened coulomb

field are no longer adequate, since the incident electron strongly

distorts the electronic cloud of the target atom or molecule. This

distortion produces induced dipole, and higher-order multipole, fields

surrounding the neutral target system. These induced fields alter

the effective potential acting on the incident electron, and thereby

change the character of the collision process. An understanding of

-the lmv-energy bremsstrahlung is further complicated by the scarcity

of experimental iru:ormation in this energy region.

The purpose of this Memorandum is to extend the theoretical dis-

cussion of bremsstrahlung into the very low-energy region, with

Page 14: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

2

particular emphasis on electron energies belovr 1 ev. The present

discussion 1-1ill be limited to the soft-photon case, .f1,, << E, Hhere E

is the electron ldnetic energy, and w is the radiation frequency.

For this case, the bremsstrahlung matrix element may be expressed

directly in terms of the elastic scattering matrix element, (2 ) a

relationship -vrhich is cliscussed in Section II. (For -11_,,) comparable

to E, there is no direct relation between the bremsstrahlung and

elastic scattering matrix elements. This greatly increases the

difficulty of the problem, which is the reason for not considering

that case here.) Use may then be made of the recent theoretical

and experimental 1vork on the loH-energy elastic scattering of elec-

trans by neutral atoms and molecules. (Reference 3 gives a partial

review of this ~rorlc ) In particular, for very lm-r energies t,he rate

or emission of bremsstrahlung radiation may be expressed in terms of

a single parameter, the S-Have scattering length for the electron-

atom or elect;ron-molecule system. The scattering length is then

obtained :from theoretical or experimental determinations of the zero-

energy scattering cross-section. This is discussed_ in Section III.

The scattering length approximation is correct for all neutral

systems, atomic or molecular. For the case of spherically symmetric

a toms, i. e. , a toms 1-ri th a ground state of zero angular momentum, it

is possible to extend the bremsstrahlung calculation to higher energies

by use of the modified effective-range theory developed by O'Malley,

Rosenberg, and Spruch. (4, 5 ) This theory, ~>rhich takes into account

the polarization effects, represents the scattering cross section as

an expansion in pm-rers of the incident electron momentum; the leading

term of this expansion is the scattering length approximation. In

Page 15: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

3

Section IV, this modified effective-range theory is employed to

extend the bremsstrahlung calculation to the next higher order in

the electron momentum. This extension introduces one new parameter,

the atomic polarizability, which is readily available from experimental

and theoretical studies.

The calculation in Section IV, though only rigorous for atoms of

zero angular momentum, serves as an order of magnitude checl\: on the

region of validity, for all atomic and molecular systc:Oms, of the

scattering length approximation. The results obtained there indicate

that the scattering length approximation is adequate for encre;ies

-1 belm1 about 10 rc;v for all scattering systcYJs uith the possible

exception of molecular nitrogen. The results also suggest that, for

thos·c; etoms to uhich it apiJlj_cs, the calculaJcion based on the modified

:~hould lL' aclcquatc u·;; to of' th::.' ord:T

F'or the case of liT,.. the rercion of validi tv ot' the scatterin&! C:' ~ J ~

length approximation is uncertain clue to experimental discrepancies

in the determination of' the scattering length. Since this is an

important case for atmospheric problems, it is considered in more

detail in Section V, •t~here the bremsstrahlung rate obtained :from the

various experimental determinations of the scattering cross-section

is calculated.

As an application of the results obtained in this Memorandum,

in Section VI the rate of electron-neutral bremsstrahlung and the rate

of electron-ion bremsstrahlung in a partially ionized gas are compared.

Page 16: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

4

II. RElATION OF BREMSSTRAHWNG TO SCATTERING

The differential cross section for bremsstrahlung is given by

2rcV 11V I]\~ (l)

where V is the normalization volume, v is the incident velocity, ~~

is the bremsstrahlung matrix element, and the density of :final states,

assuming non-relativistic electron energies and -flcu << E, is given by

(2)

1-rhere d\~:1 ) ,and d,·K are the differential solid angles for the recoil

electron anCl. photon, rcc:spectively, and m is the electron mass.

For non-relativistic electron energies, anCL for 1'iw << E, the

bremsstral1lung matrix element can be expressed in terms o:f the scatter-

ing matrix element M,... as 0

( 2rc )l/2

'fiwv (3)

where Gaussian units are used, c is the photon polarization, and P and

l?' are the incident and final electron momenta. (Equation 3 is

essentially the non-relativistic limit of Eg_. 16-3 in Ref. 2, differing

only in the normalization and choice of units.) Using this, and

expressing M0

in terms of the scattering amplitude F(e) as (6) 0

Page 17: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

5

- 2:rrll2 F(e) mV

(4)

the expression :for the bremstrahlung differential cross section is then

2 2 e I F( 8) I

2 2 3 (2rc) m nw c ( 5)

Summing this expression over the photon polarizations and integrating

over the photon and recoil electron solid angles, the bremsstrahlung

cross section, di:i:ferential 1-lith respect to frequency, becomes

( ") ') L~ ec. v "- dc.IJ 1' 2

do· -=-:;- - (-) - .• I IF(0)1 (l- cos") B )!L -Tic c "' " ' ·

(6)

II II

where p . P 1 = cos e.

For later "1-TOrk, it vrill be useful to express this result in terms

of the scattering phase shifts. To do this, use is made of the rela­

tion (6)

00

F( 0) -11 I (2£, l) io_r

sin o..e PJI,(cos 8) + c mv

.>0

1:1here 5 is the phase shift for the },th partial 1-rave. Keeping only J!,

S and P vmves, the result is

(7)

Page 18: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

6

16 e 2

-fi [ . 2 "' " . 2 2 3 Sln u

0 + ~ Sln o

1 3 m w c

(8)

Page 19: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

7

III. SCATTERING LENGTH APPROXIMATION

In the limit of very lmr energy, the diff'erential scattering

cross section becomes spherically symmetric, and the total scattering

cross section approaches a constant value. (This is true for all

atomic and molecular systems vThich do not possess a permanent electric

dipole moment.) In this limit the scattering amplitude becomes F(n) =A,

where A is the S-wave scattering length, -vrhich is related to the zero-

energy total scattering cross section 0 by 0 0 0

2 = 4rc A • Using this

expression for the scattering amplitude, the bremsstrahlung cross

section, Eq. (6), becomes

(9)

The region of valiclity of this scattering length approximation to the

bremsstrahlung cross-section ·Hill be determined in Section IV, uh::Tc the..'

next higher-order term in the lmr-energy expansion of the scattering

amplitude is taken into account. (Equation (9) 1dll be found to be

valid for most gases for electron energies below about 0.1 ev.)

In recent years there has been a great deal of theoretical and

experimental work on the lo1-r-energy scattering of electrons by neutral

atoms and molecules. As a result of this vrork, values of the S-vrave

scattering length have been determined for a large number of atoms

and molecules. In Table 1 these values are tabulated for various

gases. (As defined here, A is the effective scattering length averaged

over the different possible spin states of the electron-atom or electron-

molecule system. For example, for electron-hydrogen scattering,

Page 20: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

Material

H

N

0

He

Ne

A

Kr

* a 0

-:~·Y.·

2 11. ~ me

8

Table 1

VALUES OF SCATTERING LENGTH

Scattering Length (in units of a )*

0

+3.35

+1.9 +1.49

+1.857 +1.3

0 < A ;S + 0. 7 0 < A ;S + Oo5

~c~" r(

+0.75

+1.23 +1.18

+0.32

~-1.7 -1.46 -1.9

-2.1 -3-7

-3.8 -6.2

X 10-8 = 0.529 em

See References, p. 21

Reference No.

7

8 n 7

10 11

t3

9 J)~

14

8 14

8 14

Page 21: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

9

A = ~ (3 A 2 A 2 )1

/2

h A and A are the scattering. leng·ths for 2 T + S ' w ere T S

the triplet and singlet states.) Although numerical discrepancies do

exist, Table l shmrs that the order of magnitude of the scattering

length is well established for the various gases, \'lith the possible

exceptions of N2, for which sizable discrepancies exist, and o2

, for

ivhich there are no data.

The rate of bremsstrahlung radiation from a partially ionized

gas due to electron-neutral collisions will now be calculated, using

Eq. (9) for the bremsstrahlung cross section. For the case of mono-

energetic electrons, assuming that the electron velocity is large

compared to the atomic or molecular velocity, the rate of bremsstrahlung

radiation per unit volume of the gas is given by

dPB clo -flw B

d<tl .. v n n

(l_,,, a e

"erhere n is the electron density, and n is the atomic or molecular e a

density. This becomes

~Vhere E is the electron kinetic energy.

in particles/cm3, this becomes

For E in ev, and n and n a e

2.68 X lo-43 E)/2 na ne (:0)

2

:2:

ergs/em~ • sec per rad/sec

(10)

(11)

(12)

Page 22: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

vrhere a 0

10

...n2 8 2 = 0.529 x 10- em is the Bohr radius. me

for order of magnitude estimates, A/a ~- 1.) 0

(Note that,

For a MaX\·le1lian distribution of electrons, the bremsstrahlung

rate is given by

;,rhere

p(v) dv

n n 11w a e

do-B d.w vp(v) dv

2

( )~ ;

2 mv

h m :J; -2KT · n: 2n:KT e

2 v ctv

vrhere T is Jche electron ·temperature. Using ::;;q. (9) this gives

dP B 64 2 2

dw = -::-T72 e A .::m '

n n (2KT)3/2 a e 2

me

For KT in ev, and n and n in partic1esjcm3, this becomes a e

6.04 X 10- (KT):J 43 ~;2 na ne (:o)2

ergs/cm3 · sec per radjsec

(13)

(14)

(15)

(16)

Page 23: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

11

IV. MODIFIED EFFECTIVE-RANGE APPROXIMATION

The scattering length approximation used in Section III is the

first term in the lm-r-energy expansion of the scattering amplitude.

The form of the higher-order terms in this eA~ansion, the effective­

range theory, is vrell knmm for the case of short-range potentials. ( 16)

Recently, a modified effective-range theory has been developed by

O'Malley, Rosenberg, and Spruch, (4, 5) lvhich takes into account the

long-range polarization effects present in electron-neutral scattering.

In this section the results of O'Malley, et al., 1iill be used to

extend the calculation of Section III to the next higher order in

the electron momentum.

The modified effective-range theory applies to the clastic scat-

terinc; of charged particles by spherically symmetric scattering systems

that clo not llossess any permanent multipole moments. It therefore

does not apply to molecules vrhichJ in genera]_~ are not spherically

symmetric, and for uhich inelastic channels involving excited rota-

tional levels of the electronic ground state are very important even

at the lmr energies considered here. It also does not apply to atomic

oxygen which has a permanent electric quadrupole moment. Even for

those systems to 1-rhich it does not rigorously apply, hmrever, it is

eA~ected that a calculation based on the modified effective-range

theory will provide an order of magnitude indication of the region of

validity of the scattering length approximation to the bremsstrahlung

cross section.

The zero and first-order terms in the lo1-r-energy expansion of the

bremsstrahlung cross section in powers of the electron momentum involve

Page 24: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

12

only the S-wave and P-wave scattering phase shifts. (This can be

determined :from the expressions for the higher partial Have phase

shifts given in Ref. 5.) Using the modified effective-range theory

and keeping terms to first order, these phase shifts become(l+, 5)

mv 11"" cot 50

and

1 no:mv - - + _.:.;~--A 3A2 a 11

0

2 2 no:mv 2 15 a -1.1

0

1:1here a is the lm-r-:freguency electric polarizability o:i:' the atom.

In Table 2, values of' C' are e;iven for various atoms ami. r.·JoJccuLcs.

(The polariza.bilities of n2

, N2

02

, He and r ~-"rere 6btainec:L from the

measured values of the dielectric constant ~;; by use or the relation

~;; - 1 = l+nNi:}:, >vhere N is the density.)

Using Eqs. (8), (17) and (18) and keeping terms to first order

in the electron momentum, the bremsstrahlung cross section becomes

2 2 2 da = l~fl. ( e )(2. ) dro (l + 8rr o: mv ) B :;; -KC" c w 15a A 1i

b

By comparing Eqs. (9) and (19), it can be seen that the scattering

length approximation as given in Eq. ( 9) ~>Till be valid for

o: mv ja0

M1 << 1, or (a/a0

2 A) • ( ~) << 1~7 • For helium this

(17)

(18)

(19)

Page 25: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

13

Table 2

VALUES OF POLARIZABILITY

Polarizabili ty Material (in units of

3 ,x-a ) Reference No.

0

H 4.50 17

H2 5.43 Hi

N 7 .081+ LC

N2 11.7 18

0 5-589 10 5-499 19

02 10.6 18

He 1.39 18

A ll.l 18

-24 3 == 0. 148 x 10 em

Page 26: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

14

corresponds to T~ << 10 ev, and for atomic nitrogen, }<; << 0.25 ev.

For the other atomic gases the upper limit of the region of validity

of the sca·ttering length approximation lies bet1vecn these tvro extreme

cases.

As discussed earlier, E~. (19) does not rigorously apply to

molecules. H01·1ever, it is expected that the 10\v-energy e:r:pansion

of the cross section for the molecular case should be of the same

general form. Accordingly Eq. (19) can be used as an estimate of

the order of magnitude of the leading correction term to the scattering

length approximation in the molecular case. Do ill[~ this, for H2

the

scattering len[,rth approximation is found to have the region of validity

c;: << 1 ev .• and :for n2

either :,;: << 1 ev or E << 0. 0.3 e·v, depending

upon >Ihicb value o:f A is user}.

In order to detennine t.he r-egion ot' energj_es for ;/lid;

systems to \Ihich it applies), j_t dO<.Ild be neces;.;ar:y ·to calculate

the ne~(t iJigher-order term in the modi:t'iecl ei'f'ectb.re-range e~:pan;:;ior.

of the scattering amplitude, a problem beyond the scope o:r this

Memorandum. Hmrever, from the results of 0' Malley, et al. , ( 5 ) Eq. ( 19)

is valid up to about 0.5 ev for hydrogen. For other atoms the region

of validity is expected to be sj_milar, so that in e;eneral Eq. ( 19)

uill be valid for spherically symmetric atoms :for energies belovr

about 1 ev.

As in Section III, the rate of ·bremsstrahlung radiation from a

partially ionized gas due to electron-neutral collisions is next

caJ.culated, using Eq. (19) for the bremsstrahlung cross section. For

Page 27: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

15

the ease of monoenergetie eleetrons, the result is

uldeh, for .1:::: in evJ and n anc1 n in l)articles/crn3, becornes a e

2.68 (

,., ) J /•J J 0 ~ r-· c ______.::::____ r -1 {_ + .4)::; 2 -~

a A 0

7:

ergs/em:; · sec per radjsec

For the case of a MaxHellian distri'bution of electr-ons, the

... 1 12 )7(

( 2K~').:. .·~ , [ L

FlC

-'~il~/2 1\c)(--)(;~I<:T):L/:~J ~ 2 2 . 2

c a /'~ :me 0

,,rhich for KT in ev, and n and n in particlesjcm3, becomes a e

ergs/em) · sec per rac1/sec

(20)

(21)

(22)

Page 28: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

16

V. USE OF F;XP"RU.1E1TTAL RESULTS FOR MOLECUIAR NITROGEN

For N2

the result;s previously obtained have not been very

satisfactory clue to discrepancies in the various ex-_flerimental deter-

ruinations o:f the scattering cross section. Because o:f the importance

o:f this case :for at;mospheric problems: in this section is discussed

the bremsstrahlung rate obtained :c'rom the tvlO most recent, and most

divergent, experimental measurements o:f the lou-energy electron-N2

scattering cross section. '-rhis discussion Tvrill give a more detailed

estimate o:f the electron-N2

bremsstrahlung rate than the discussion

in the previous sections, and 11ill illustrate the uncertainty in the

e 2:perimentnl situation.

The ez:per:i_ments in question, basc;ci either· on L;easu,~ements or the

electron io:·ift vcJ_oc:i_ty in applied electric fn)

f'L:lds, '-' oc on :cri.cro-

r li2 F(e) (1-cos:)dO (24)

In terms o:f o~1 , the bremsstrahlung cross section, as given in Ect. (6),

-becomes

c1o13 ( 2)( )') 4 e v c

3:rr fie c (25)

For the case m: monoenergetic eJ.ectrons the rate oi' bremsstrahlung

racliation from a partially ionized gas due Jco electron-neu-tral calli-

sions then becomes

Page 29: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

For ['; in ev,

4 )rc

and n and ne, in particles/ cm3, this becomes a

rl

ul1ere the values of csd/1ra "'- for n2. obta1nec1 from Eel's. 9 and 12 are

c. 0

(26)

(27)

plotted 1n Fig. l. From the figure, it can be noteo_ tbat at very lou

energies there is a factor of 10 uncerta1nty in the bremsstrahlung

rate from N". c_

:~s c1_iscuss2d in ,Section llT, if the e:xperimental :cesult~c; o: ?ac:.:,

.~--J.:t·c co i'

.if th~~ C>:-_f)e:r-ill121TCa2_

cesults of 1\.nderson and Golclstccin ( 12

) are correct, the scatterinG

lengt.h approximation is -I valid up to at least }~ ,~ 10 -- ev.

Page 30: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

(\J 0

0

24

20

16

--z 12

~

8

4

0 I0- 3 2

~ ""' ~Anderson and Goldstein

~

""' ~ i ~ r-..

~ y

~ ----r---- Pack aodl PheT -4 6 8 10-2 2 4 6 8 10-l 2 4

Electronic energy, ev

Fig. I- Momentum transfer cross section for N 2

I

_v I

6 8

1-' co

Page 31: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

19

VI. COMPARISON OF ELl~CTRON-NEUTRAL MID j~Lf~CTRON-ION BREMSSTRAHlUNG

In a partially ionized gas~ electron-neutral bremsstrahlung and

electron-ion bremsstrahlung are competing processes. It is inter-

esting to determine Hhich is the dominating bremsstrahlung process

for various degrees of ionization. In the soft-photon limit, 1'iw << KT, and for the case of lmJ-electron energies, KT < 700 ev, the 1·ate of

bremsstrahlung radiation due to electron-ion collisions is given by(2o)

dP ion ~

H}Jere r p

16 2 7.e

./

r e

2 [ ~ IG.'(KT)l/2 J ln 1.3) ~ ::<~ 0

(28)

:i.s the ionic· charge, anci a ]Vja:.c'.iellian distri-bution

If the; scattering lengtb. appcoz:ipation, as c;iven. i:n ;: ·, _, "~L• ( 1)))

:i.s used rm' the rate or electTon-neutral -bremsstrahlun[S, then the

ratio of the electron-ion bremsstrahlung :cate to the electron-neutral

bremsstrahlung rate, R = (dPion/c1JJ)/(c1PB/dco), becomes

( 2)~-H = ~ ~c 2 2 2 n Z (a ) ( 2) [ 1/2 J _i__ .....£ :nc . ln 1. 33 KT (KT)

n A KT ?iuJ E a o

In Fig. 2 the quantity R(najz2ni)(l\/a

0)2

is plotted l'or various

values of KT and 1'i.c)/l<'r. From these results the relative importance

(29)

or electron-ion awl electron-neutral bremsstrahlung can be determined

:for a 11ide range of physical conditions.

Page 32: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

N r---..

<tlcf ...____... _..---.....

ol E C N N ~

a::

20

10 6

10 5

103~--~-L-L~~~--~--~L-~LW~--~~~~~~ 10- 3

KT, ev

Fig. 2- Comparison of electron-ion and e lee t ron- n eutra I bremsstra hI un.g rates

Page 33: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

REFERENCES

1. Koch, H. W. and J. W. Motz, "Bremsstrahlnng Cross Section Formulas and Related Data," Revs. Mod. Phys., Vol. 31, No. 4, October 1959, PP• 920-955·

2. Jauch, J. M. and F. Rohrlich, The Theory of Photons and Electrons, Addison-Wesley Publishing Company, Reading, Mass., 1955, Chap. 16.

3. Gerjuoy, E., "Atomic Scattering Processes," Revs. Mod. Phys., Vol. 33, No. 4, October 1961, PP· 544-553·

4. O'Malley, T. F., L. Spruch and L. Rosenberg, "Modification of Effective-Range Theory in the Presence of Long-Range (r-4) Potential," J. Math. Phys., Vol. 2, No. 4, July-August 1961, pp. 491-498.

5. O'Malley, T. F., L. Rosenberg and L. Spruch, "Low-Energy Scattering of a Charged Particle by a Neutral Polarizable System," Phys. Rev., Vol. 125, No. 4, February 15, 1962, pp. 1300-1310.

6. Merzbacher, E., Quantum Mechanics, John vliley and Sons, Nevl York, N.Y., 1961, Chap. 21.

7. Schwartz, C., ''lnectron Scat,tcring t'rom Hydrogen, r'hy::;. J:tev., Vol. 121t, No. ~), December 1, 1961, pp. 1468-11+71.

8. Phelps, A. V., 0. T. Fundingsland and S. C. Brown, "Microwave Determination of the Probability of Collision of Slow Electrons in Gases," Phys. Rev., Vol. 84, No. 3, November 1, 1951, pp. 559-562.

9. Pack, J. L. and A. V. Phelps, "Drift Velocities of Slow Electrons in Helium, Neon, Argon, Hydrogen, and Nitrogen," Phys. Rev., Vol. 121, No. 3, February 1, 1961, pp. 798-806.

10. Klein, M. M. and K. A. Brueckner, "Interaction of Slow Electrons with Atomic Oxygen and Atomic Nitrogen," Phys. Rev., Vol. 111, No. 4, August 15, 1958, pp. 1115-1128.

11. Byatt, W. J., F. 0. Lane, Jr. and L. D. Watkins, Radial Eigen­functions, Phase Shifts, Total Elastic, Differential Elastic, and Momentum Transfer Cross Sections for Electrons Scattered from Oxygen and Nitrogen Atoms, Sandia Corporation, Albuquerque, N. Mex., Report SC-4363 (TR), October 1959.

Page 34: Bremsstrahlung During the Collision of Low-Energy …BREMSSTRAHLUNG DURING THE COLLISION OF LOW-ENERGY ELECTRONS WITH NEUTRAL ATOMS AND MOLECULES R. 0. Hundley Thi' n''l'ilrch j, ,-upported

12. Anderson, J. M. and L. Goldstein, "Momentum Transfer Cross Section and Fractional Energy Loss in the Collisions of Slow Electrons with Nitrogen Molecules," Phys. Rev., Vol. 102, No. 2, April 15, 1956, PP• 388-389.

13. Lin, s. C. and B. Kivel, "Slow-Electron Scattering by Atomic Oxygen," Phys. Rev., Vol. 114, No. 4, May 15, 1959, pp. 1026-1027.

14. O'Malley, T. F. and L. Spruch, "Extrapolation of Electron-Rare Gas Atom Cross Sections to Zero Energy," Bull. Am. Phys. Soc., Ser. II, Vol. 7, January 24, 1962, p. 69.

15. Ki vel, B., "Elastic Scattering of Lo\v-Energy Electrons by Argon," Phys. Rev., Vol. 116, No. 14, November 15, 1959, pp. 926-927.

16. Blatt, J. M. and V. F. Weisskopf, Theoretical Nuclear Physics, John Wiley and Sons, New York, N.Y., 1952, Chap. 2.

17. Pauling, L., "Theoretical Prediction of the Physical Properties of Many Electron Atoms and Ions. Mole Refraction, Diamagnetic Susceptibility and Extension in Space," Proc. Roy. Soc., Vol.A 114, January 1927, pp. 181-211.

18. American Institute of Physics Handbook, McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York, N.Y., 1957, p. 5-lk[.

19. Cooper, .J. H. and J. B. Martin, E:led.ron Photodetacbment from Ionr> and Ji',lasJdc Collisions Cross ~)c'ctionE for O, C> Cl, and F, Phy s. Rev. , Vol. 126, No. !1, May 1'5, 1962, pp. lhtl2-l1+88.

20. Kogan, V. I. and A. B. Migdal, "The Bremsstrahlnng Spectrum Dependence on Electron Temperature of a Plasma,' in Plasma Physics and the Problem of Controlled Thermonuclear Reactions, Vol. I, edited by M. A. Leontovich, Pergamon Press, Inc., London, England, 1961, pp. 205-212.