29
Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

Bob GrubbsLead Bridge EngineerODOT Region 3, Tech Center

Lessons LearnedFAST 14, Boston MAFHWA Highways for Life Showcase

Page 2: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

• Longer-lasting highway infrastructure using

• Innovations to accomplish the

• Fast construction of

• Efficient and safe highways and bridges

What is ‘Highways for Life’?FHWA program that promotes:

Page 3: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

• Replace 14 deteriorated bridge superstructures • Minimize impacts to travelers and communities• Reduce the duration of construction as much as possible

(Complete the construction ASAP)• Use cutting-edge innovations• Communicate to the public

FAST14 – Boston Ma.Project Mission

Page 4: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

• Main route from Boston to Northern New England • Over 200,000 ADT with high morning and afternoon peaks

(highest ADT I-5 Oregon is 150K, highest in R3=50K)• Bridges have deteriorated superstructures, deck and girders

Interstate-93Roadway Characteristics

Page 5: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

A day in August 2010

Page 6: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase
Page 7: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

Conventional Construction• 5 stages • 4 years• Worker safety issues• Concern of life of existing

structures

Construction OptionsConventional -vs- ABC

Page 8: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

• Design/Build procurement– Issued Notice-to-Proceed on February 7, 2011– Prep work began March 14

• Superstructure replacement– Superstructure replacement June 1 – Sept 1, 2011– Weekends only (except July 4th)

• Finish work to occur after September 1– Paving, rail, lighting, median, etc...

• All bridge replacements complete in 2011

Project TimelineNot just the construction was accelerated

Page 9: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

Existing Condition of BridgesWhat there is to work with

Bad decks combined with bad girders

Page 10: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

Prep for ABCPrepare existing bridges

Install temporary support for existing bridges

Page 11: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

Prep for ABCPrepare existing bridges

Prepare beam seats for new girders

Page 12: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

Prep for ABCPrepare existing bridges

Sometimes this requires modifications

Page 13: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

Accelerated Bridge ConstructionStep 1 – Friday evening

Transform road from 8-lanes to 4-lanes

Page 14: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

Accelerated Bridge ConstructionStep 2 – Friday night

Demolish the bridges

Page 15: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

Accelerated Bridge ConstructionStep 3 – Saturday morning

Demo completed, ready to place prefab superstructure

Page 16: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

Accelerated Bridge ConstructionStep 3 – Saturday morning

Place prefabricated superstructure

Page 17: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

Accelerated Bridge ConstructionStep 3 – Saturday morning

Place prefabricated superstructure

Page 18: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

Accelerated Bridge ConstructionStep 4 – Saturday afternoon

Prepare joints for closure pour

Page 19: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

Accelerated Bridge ConstructionStep 4 – Saturday afternoon/evening

Closure pour

Page 20: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

Accelerated Bridge ConstructionStep 5 – Sunday

Pave bridge and place barrier

Page 21: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

Accelerated Bridge ConstructionConstruction Video

Play video here

Page 22: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

Lessons LearnedMy observations

Very creative Incentive/Disincentive• Incentives based on meeting overall completion date milestones

($7-million)• Disincentive based on getting road open on Monday morning

– One late Monday -$3.2-million– Two late Mondays -$4.8-million– Three late Mondays -$7-million– PLUS disincentive for late opening

• @ 5:00 -$450K• @ 5:15 -$100K• @ 5:30 -$150K• @ 5:45 -$200K• @ 6:00 -$250K• Total maximum per day = $1.15million

Page 23: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

Lessons LearnedMy observations

• The short time line for design and construction created a “sense of urgency” that made the project successful

Page 24: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

Lessons LearnedMy observations

• They did not ask “What should we do?”• They asked the public

“Here is what we are doing, how can we make it better?”

Page 25: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

Lessons LearnedMy observations

• The engineering is simple, the construction straight forward– To build it fast, make it simple– Less detail, fewer things to go wrong

Page 26: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

Lessons LearnedMy observations

• Formed teams with other agencies, they own the project too

Page 27: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

Lessons LearnedMy observations• Public outreach & communication very important

• The MassDOT Communications Team used– Used Traditional Methods of Communications

– Used Social Media

– Non-Conventional Methods of Communication• Billboards, message boards, state payroll checks, toll booth stickers/tickets

Page 28: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

Can we do this in Oregon?Isthmus Slough Bridge

• ABC methods used• 250-ft of bridge replaced with 13 days of traffic interruption

Page 29: Bob Grubbs Lead Bridge Engineer ODOT Region 3, Tech Center Lessons Learned FAST 14, Boston MA FHWA Highways for Life Showcase

QUESTIONS?