bioethics cases 2010

7/30/2019 bioethics cases 2010

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bioethics-cases-2010 1/25

!"#$%#&'()*&$+%#',-%./0/

*12345%67%)84%"9:;4<2:37%1=%>?@43%+1?95

ABC$*%.DE.FG%./0/

!"#$%&"'()!#*+)',($(



$B+(%0

)84%3HI%19%316HJJ1%K<15?J32%:9%,H28:9@319%+3H34L%J19J?<<493M7%N.O//%19%H%KHJP%1=%J:@H<43342

L%:2%J192:54<:9@%64:9@%3<:KM45O (;49%381?@8%384%:9J<4H24%Q1?M5%<45?J4%J:@H<4334%J192?RK3:19./ES/TG%<H:2:9@%384%3HI%=<1R%N.UKHJP%31%ND%Q1?M5%HM21%R1<4%38H9%51?6M4%<4;49?4%=<1R%384%3HIO

)8:2%<4;49?4%Q1?M5%64%?245%31%:9J<4H24%384%9?R64<%1=%K41KM4%4M:@:6M4%=1<%A45:JH:5%V1<%K4<8HK2

:9%J19J4<3%Q:38%1384<%J8H9@42%H95%<4;49?42G%31%RHP4%:3%K1M:3:JHMM7%=4H2:6M4%31%KH22%J1RK<48492:;4

84HM38%:92?<H9J4%<4=1<R%38H3%Q:MM%<45?J4%384%K4<J493H@4%1=%384%K1K?MH3:19%Q:381?3%6H2:J%:92?<H9J4

=<1R%0WT%31%WTXO )<:KM:9@%384%3HI%:2%423:RH345%31%<45?J4%384%9?R64<%1=%H51M42J4932%H95%71?9@

H5?M32%Q81%64@:9%2R1P:9@%67%Y/TO &3%Q:MM%<45?J4%19M7%;4<7%2M:@83M7%384%9?R64<%1=%1384<

2R1P4<2G%381?@8%:3%Q:MM%<45?J4%384:<%K4<E2R1P4<%J192?RK3:19%0/TO B%84H;7%RHZ1<:37%1=%2R1P4<2

H<4%=<1R%M1Q4<%:9J1R4%6<HJP432%V1;4<%[/T%H<4%:9%384%61331R%:9J1R4%8HM=XO )8?2%384%:9J<4H245

3HI%:2%RH<P45M7%<4@<422:;4\ R123%1=%:3%Q:MM%64%KH:5%67%K41KM4%1=%<4MH3:;4M7%M1Q%:9J1R4O

A1<41;4<G%316HJJ1%:2%3<?M7%H55:J3:;4\ :3%:2%?9?2?HMM7%5:==:J?M3%=1<%38124%Q81%HM<4H57%8H;4%384

8H6:3%31%]?:3O

)84%943%4I3<H%J1232%38H3%2R1P4<2%:RK124%19%1384<2%V84HM38%JH<4%=1<%2R1P:9@%<4MH345%5:24H242

38H3%2R1P4<2%51%913%384R24M;42%KH7%=1<G%8:@84<%Q1<P4<%H6249344:2RG%=:<42G%43JOX%H<4%HM<4H57%R1<4

38H9%J1RK492H345%=1<%67%384%J?<<493%N.UK4<%KHJP%3HIO )84%J1RR19%K4<J4K3:19%L%H95%4;49%R?J8

HJH54R:JHMM7%@?:545%JHMJ?MH3:19%L%1=%384%J1232%38H3%2R1P4<2%:RK124%19%1384<2%:2%:9=MH345O%,8H3%:2

1;4<M11P45%:2%38H3%:95:;:5?HM !"#$%&"'$ 84HM38%JH<4%J1232%H<4%91%8:@84<%VH95%K4<8HK2%M1Q4<X%=1<

2R1P4<2%38H9%=1<%919E2R1P4<2%64JH?24%919E2R1P4<2%49J1?934<%1384<%R45:JHM%K<16M4R2%:9%384:<

1M54<%H@42%H95%M19@4<%74H<2%1=%M:=4G%H95%38H3%2R1P4<2%J123%=4Q4<%+1J:HM%+4J?<:37%H95%K492:19

6494=:32%64JH?24%1=%384:<%281<34<%74H<2O

^J1RK:M45%67%>H?M%A49_4MG%>HJ:=:J%-?384<H9%"9:;4<2:37G%`H9?H<7%.SG%./0/a



$B+(%.

b423H3:19HM%2?<<1@HJ7%:2%64J1R:9@%H%K1K?MH<%QH7%=1<%:9=4<3:M4%J1?KM42%Q4MM%H2%@H7%R49%H95

M426:H9%J1?KM42%31%8H;4%J8:M5<49O%+8:<M47%cH@4<G%5:<4J31<%1=%384%'<@H9:_H3:19%1=%>H<4932%)8<1?@8

+?<<1@HJ7G%H%9H3:19HM%2?KK1<3%@<1?KG%31M5%384%!d%):R42%38H3%384<4%8H;4%6449%H61?3%.[G///

2?<<1@H34%6:<382%2:9J4%0eFDO

)84<4%H<4%3Q1%37K42%1=%2?<<1@HJ7O%)<H5:3:19HM%2?<<1@HJ7%:2%Q849%384%Q1RH9%JH<<7:9@%384%6H67%:2

HM21%384%6:1M1@:JHM%R1384<f%384%<42?M3:9@%J8:M5%:2%J<4H345%=<1R%84<%4@@%H95%2K4<R%=<1R%384%5191<

=H384<O%#4=1<4%&9%g:3<1%h4<3:M:_H3:19%64JHR4%H%23H95H<5%=4<3:M:37%3<4H3R493G%H61?3%0W%74H<2%H@1G

38:2%QH2%384%19M7%2?<<1@HJ7%1K3:19O%#?3%Q:38%384%:93<15?J3:19%1=%&OgOhOG%J1?KM42%91Q%8H;4%384

1K3:19%1=%@423H3:19HM%2?<<1@HJ7G%Q8:J8%:2%Q849%H%2?<<1@H34%R1384<%JH<<:42%H%J8:M5%@4943:JHMM7

?9<4MH345%31%84<O

)84<4%H<4%<1?@8M7%FW/%6:<382%H%74H<%:9;1M;:9@%@423H3:19HM%2?<<1@HJ7%H95%?2?HMM7%384%K<1J422%@142

2R1138M7G%6?3%H%2:3?H3:19%:9%A:J8:@H9%38H3%8H2%6449%=4H3?<45%:9%384%!4Q%d1<P%):R42%H95%19

b115%A1<9:9@%BR4<:JH%H2%Q4MM%H2%H91384<%:9%!4Q%`4<247%281Q2%Q8H3%8HKK492%Q849%38:9@2%@1

6H5M7O #138%384%!4Q%`4<247%JH24%H95%384%A:J8:@H9%JH24%=1J?245%19%J?23157%1=%J8:M5<49%61<9

?2:9@%H%@423H3:19HM%2?<<1@HJ7%J193<HJ3O )84%6:1M1@:JHM%<4MH3:1928:K%1=%H%J8:M5%31%:32%KH<4932%:2%H

K:4J4%1=%:9=1<RH3:19%38H3%=<4]?493M7%64H<2%Q4:@83%19%384%:22?4%1=%J?23157%:9%384%"9:345%+3H342%H95

:9%6138%JH242%384%J1?<32%<?M45%:9%=H;1<%1=%384%@423H3:19HM%R1384<2O

B=34<%3Q1%R:2JH<<:H@42%H95%=:;4%=H:M45%<1?952%1=%:9%;:3<1%=4<3:M:_H3:19G%+J133%H95%BR7%i4814

M11P45%:931%2?<<1@HJ7O%)84%A:J8:@H9%J1?KM4%K?<J8H245%4@@2%H95%2K4<R%=<1R%H9%H9197R1?2

5191<%H95%J1994J345%Q:38%+84MM47%#HP4<%Q81%H@<445%31%JH<<7%384%6H67%H95%@H;4%6:<38%31%3Q:92O

#?3%H3%384%84H<:9@%31%3<H92=4<%@?H<5:H928:KG%#HP4<%M4H<945%38H3%BR7%i4814G%Y0G%QH2%H<<42345%=1<

R:91<%J1JH:94%K122422:19%H95%5:H@91245%Q:38%H9%?92K4J:=:45%K27J813:J%5:21<54<%9:94%74H<2%H@1O#HP4<%QH2%?K243%67%384%:9=1<RH3:19%6?3%HMM1Q45%384%i48142%31%H51K3%384%6H6:42O

B%R1938%MH34<%#HP4<%J8H9@45%84<%R:95O%+84%QH9345%384%6H6:42%6HJPO

i4814%2H72%38H3%284%QH2%?K=<193%Q:38%#HP4<%H61?3%84<%KH23G%H95%i4814j2%K27J8:H3<:23%54JMH<45

i4814%=:3%31%64%H%R1384<G%2H7:9@%284%8H5%3HP49%84<%R45:JH3:19%=H:38=?MM7%=1<%9:94%74H<2%H95%94;4<

R:2245%H9%HKK1:93R493O

#?3%64JH?24%A:J8:@H9%:2%194%1=%=:;4%23H342%Q84<4%2?<<1@HJ7%J193<HJ32%H<4%913%<4J1@9:_45G%384

i48142%8H5%31%<43?<9%384%6H6:42%31%#HP4<O

BR7%i4814%31M5%b115%R1<9:9@%BR4<:JH%38H3%384%#HP4<2j%HJ3:192%H<4%H%JH24%1=%M4@HMkP:59HKK:9@Ok

k&3%311P%R4%H%M19@%3:R4%31%Z?23%J1R4%31%384%54J:2:19O%OOO%)847j<4%1?<%6H6:42Gk%#HP4<%31M5%bABO

k,4%8H5%31%3HP4%1?<%6H6:42%6HJPOk



A4M:22H%#<:2RH9G%H%<4K<15?J3:;4%MHQ74<%Q81%8H2%8H95M45%H61?3%H%381?2H95%2?<<1@HJ7%JH242G%31M5

bAB%38H3%284%64M:4;42%384%6H6:42%64M19@%Q:38%384%i48142G%4;49%381?@8%#HP4<%2H72%284%5:59j3

P91Q%H61?3%BR7%i4814j2%R45:JHM%H95%J<:R:9HM%8:231<7O

k&3%51429j3%Z?23:=7%84<%P44K:9@%384%6H6:42Gk%#<:92RH9%31M5%bABO%k+84%QH2%23:MM%J1RK492H345%=1<

84<%4IK49242G%284%23:MM%H@<445%31%8H95%384%6H6:42%1;4<O%+84%Z?23%64JHR4%Z?5@R493HM%1=%OOO%384:< H6:M:37%31%KH<493%Q:381?3%HMM%38H3%R?J8%4;:549J4O%&3%QH2%HMR123%M:P4%284%OOO%Z?23%54J:545%38H3

64JH?24%38:2%K4<219%8H5%H%R493HM%:MM9422G%38H3%R4H93%284%J1?M59j3%8H95M4%384%J8:M5<49Ok

^+1?<J4\%!4Q%d1<P%):R42%l4J4R64<%S/G%.//ef%+H9%h<H9J:2J1%$8<19:JM4%`H9?H<7%0.G%./0/f%b115

A1<9:9@%BR4<:JHa



$B+(%S

B%=1<4:@9%MH9@?H@4%RHZ1<%:9%84<%249:1<%74H<%1=%J1MM4@4%8H2%<4J4:;45%H%2J81MH<28:K%31%23?57%H6<1H5

=1<%2:I%R19382G%H2%H%21<3%1=%JHK23194%31%84<%?954<@<H5?H34%JH<44<O%*4<%617=<:495%1=%=1?<%74H<2G

81Q4;4<G%Q:38%Q81R%284%81K42%31%2K495%384%<423%1=%84<%M:=4%H95%Q81R%284%M1;42%;4<7%R?J8G%8H2

6449%24<:1?2M7%54K<42245%384%MH23%=4Q%R19382%H95%8H2%31M5%84<%84%4934<3H:92%381?@832%1=%2?:J:54O+84%8H2%6449%K<422:9@%8:R%31%@43%21R4%84MKG%H95%Q849%84%Q493%81R4%=<1R%J1MM4@4%1;4<

)8H9P2@:;:9@%84%5:5%H@<44%31%244%H%K27J8:H3<:23G%Q81%@H;4%8:R%H%5:H@912:2%1=%6:K1MH<%5:21<54<O%*4

QH2%@:;49%R45:JH3:19%=1<%38:2%H95%31M5%84%R?23%2J845?M4%H%=1MM1QE?K%;:2:3O%#?3%84%<4=?242%31%3HP4

384%R45:JH3:19%1<%2J845?M4%384%=1MM1QE?KG%542K:34%8:2%@:<M=<:495m2%?<@:9@O%+84%8H2%28H<45%84<

J19J4<9%H95%5:23<422%Q:38%8:2%KH<4932G%6?3%3847%51%913%64M:4;4%H9738:9@%R?J8%:2%Q<19@%Q:38%8:RG

H95%3847%2H7%84%51429m3%9445%R45:JH3:19EE1?<%21J:437%<4M:42%=H<%311%84H;:M7%19%H93:54K<422H932O

+84%91Q%Q1<<:42%38H3%:=%284%@142%19%84<%23?57%H6<1H5%K<1@<HRG%384<4%Q:MM%64%91%194%31%M11P%H=34<

8:R%H95%84%R:@83%P:MM%8:R24M=O%*4<%1Q9%KH<4932%34MM%84<%384%617%:2%8:2%KH<4932m%<42K192:6:M:37%H95

913%84<2G%6?3%38H3%:29m3%81Q%284%2442%:3O

^,<:3349%67%*:M54%-:954RH99a



$B+(%Y

-:MH%b1M564<@G%H@4%3Q4937E194G%QH2%H5R:3345%H2%H%;1M?93H<7%KH3:493%31%384%H5?M3%K27J8:H3<:J

24<;:J4%1=%H%MH<@4%?9:;4<2:37%34HJ8:9@%812K:3HM%64JH?24%284%8H5%M123%38:<37%K1?952%:9%2:I%R19382

H95%4I3492:;4%1?3EKH3:493%R45:JHM%4;HM?H3:19%8H5%=H:M45%31%<4;4HM%H9%1<@H9:J%6H2:2%=1<%384%Q4:@83

M122O B=34<%384%5:H@912:2%1=%H91<4I:H%94<;12H%QH2%J19=:<R45G%384%KH3:493%QH2%KMHJ45%19%H%8:@8EJHM1<:4%5:43%H95%H%648H;:1<%R15:=:JH3:19%K<1@<HR%2?KKM4R49345%67%:95:;:5?HM%K27J81384<HK7O

'94%Q44P%H=34<%H5R:22:19G%+34;49%'m$1991<G%H%K27J8:H3<:23%H==:M:H345%Q:38%H91384<%QH<5G

21M:J:345%A2O%b1M564<@m2%KH<3:J:KH3:19%:9%H%<424H<J8%K<1Z4J3%38H3%Q1?M5%R4H2?<4%384%J19J493<H3:19

1=%6:1@49:J%HR:942%:9%384%6M115%H95%2K:9HM%=M?:5%1=%KH3:4932%2?==4<:9@%=<1R%H91<4I:H%94<;12HO

)8:2%:9;423:@H3:19%QH2%913%:9349545%31%64%1=%5:<4J3%JM:9:JHM%6494=:3%31%384%KH3:493O *1Q4;4<G%384

23?57%J1?M5%J19J4:;H6M7%K<1;:54%:9=1<RH3:19%H61?3%384%K<4249J4%1=%H97%?954<M7:9@

94?<1K872:1M1@:JHM%H691<RHM:3:42%:9%38:2%5:21<54<O A2O%b1M564<@%<4H5:M7%H@<445%31%64%H%2?6Z4J3

H95%2:@945%H%381<1?@8%:9=1<R45%J192493%=1<R%=1<%384%K<131J1MG%Q8:J8%HM<4H57%8H5%:923:3?3:19HM

<4;:4Q%61H<5%V&C#X%HKK<1;HMO B2%H%KH<3:J:KH93%284%Q1?M5%8H;4%6M115%5<HQ9%67%;4:9%24;4<HM

3:R42%H95%Q1?M5%?954<@1%38<44%M?R6H<%V2K:9HMX%K?9J3?<42%n%K<1J45?<42%38H3%JH<<7%H%8:@8%<:2P%1=

5:2J1R=1<3%H95%H%M1Q%<:2P%1=%:9=4J3:19O-:MHm2%K27J8:H3<:J%9?<24G%+8H<19%A:MM4<G%]?423:1945%84<%KH3:493m2%:9JM?2:19%:9%38:2%23?57O

*H;:9@%1624<;45%38H3%HMM%H91<4J3:J%KH3:4932%4H@4<M7%H@<44%31%KH<3:J:KH34%:9%23?5:42%542K:34

5:2J1R=1<3%H95%K13493:HM%8H<RG%!?<24%A:MM4<%<4H21945%38H3%K27J8:H3<:J%:MM9422%RH54%H9%H91<4J3:J

KH3:493%1;4<M7%J11K4<H3:;4%H95%384<467%RH21J8:23:JO )84%KH3:493m2%Q:MM:9@%KH<3:J:KH3:19%:9%384

K<131J1M%J1?M5%64%J1923<?45%H2%H91384<%H91<4J3:J%27RK31RO l<O%'m$1991<%J1?934<45%38H3%A2O

b1M564<@%QH2%=?MM7%J1RK43493%31%;1M?9344<O

^,<:3349%67%*:M54%-:954RH99a



$B+(%W

b4<HM5%,H28:9@319%:2%H%24;4937E38<44E74H<E1M5%RHM4%Q:38%495E23H@4%KH9J<4H3:J%JH9J4<O%)49

74H<2%H@1G%84%2?==4<45%24;4<4%JH<5:HJ%K<16M4R2%H95%QH2%<42?2J:3H345%3Q:J4G%6?3%84%8H2%6449%:9

<4H219H6M7%@115%84HM38%2:9J4%3849%?93:M%8:2%5:H@912:2%1=%JH9J4<O%&9J<4H2:9@M7%Q4HP%H95%=<H:MG%A<O

,H28:9@319%4934<45%812K:J4%JH<4%3Q1%R19382%H@1O%B2:54%=<1R%1384<%27RK31R2G%84%21R43:R42

J1RKMH:92%1=%R:M5%J8423%KH:9O)84%812K:J4%34HR%8H2%H%;4<7%@115%<HKK1<3%Q:38%A<O%,H28:9@319G%8:2%Q:=4G%H95%8:2%H5?M3

5H?@834<G%Q81%:2%1=349%K<42493%:9%84<%KH<4932m%81R4O%A<2O%,H28:9@319%H95%384%812K:J4%9?<24G

`?M:H%)?<94<G%8H;4%H9%42K4J:HMM7%23<19@%<4MH3:1928:KO

A<O%,H28:9@319%?954<23H952%38H3%84%Q:MM%<4J4:;4%91%M:=4EK<1M19@:9@%R4H2?<42%=1<%8:2%JH9J4<G

6?3%84%8H2%<4Z4J345%H%51E913E<42?2J:3H34%1<54<O%*4%64M:4;42G%J:3:9@%8:2%K<4;:1?2%<42?2J:3H3:192G%38H3

57:9@%1=%84H<3%H33HJP%:2%913%b15m2%KMH9%=1<%8:RO%B9%4IKMH9H3:19%1=%384%5:==4<49J4%643Q449%8:2

J195:3:19%91Q%H95%H%54JH54%H@1%8H2%913%HM34<45%8:2%23H9J4O%!4:384<%8H2%H%5:2J?22:19%Q:38%8:2

K872:J:H9G%Q81%31M5%8:R%38H3%$>C%Q1?M5%K<16H6M7%913%<4;:;4%8:RG%H95%38H3%4;49%:=%84%2?<;:;45G

84%Q1?M5%913%8H;4%H%@115%<4J1;4<7O

A<2O%,H28:9@319%:2%]?:43M7%;4<7%?K243%H61?3%8:2%54J:2:19O%+84%QH2%3<H?RH3:_45%67%384

<42?2J:3H3:192%74H<2%H@1G%194%1=%Q8:J8%284%Q:3942245O%+84%8H2%31M5%!?<24%)?<94<%38H3%284%Q:MM%913

JHMM%e00%:=%84<%8?26H95%8H2%H%J<:2:2O

)84%812K:J4%K1M:J7%:2%31%JHMM%e00%Q8494;4<%H%KH3:493%8H2%<4Z4J345%H%l!C%1<54<O%!?<24%)?<94<

?<@42%A<2O%,H28:9@319%31%5:2J?22%$>C%Q:38%84<%8?26H95G%6?3%A<2O%,H28:9@319%<4=?242%H95

<4RH:92%H5HRH93%H61?3%84<%54J:2:19O%+84%:2%J19;:9J45%38H3%$>C%Q:MM%8?<3%84<%8?26H95%H95%38H3%84

Q:MM%495%?K%MH9@?:28:9@%:9%384%812K:3HM%&$"G%Q:381?3%H54]?H34%KHMM:H3:;4%JH<4G%?9H6M4%31%<4J1@9:_4

84<G%=1<%384%<4RH:954<%1=%8:2%M:=4O

)84:<%5H?@834<G%$<723HMG%2?KK1<32%84<%R1384<m2%K12:3:19%H95%HM21%<4=?242%31%5:2J?22%$>C%Q:38

84<%=H384<O%!?<24%)?<94<%Q1954<2%Q84384<%31%6<:9@%:3%?K%Q:38%A<O%,H28:9@319%84<24M=G%6?3

54J:542%913%31O%+84%5142%913%QH93%31%?K243%384%=HR:M7G%?K243%A<O%)?<94<G%1<%J<122%H%61?95H<7

643Q449%84<%<1M4%H2%H%812K:J4%JH<4@:;4<%H95%384%=HR:M7m2%51RH:9O)Q1%Q44P2%MH34<G%A<O%,H28:9@319m2%H9@:9H%8H2%64J1R4%:9J<4H2:9@M7%24;4<4O%!?<24%)?<94<G

2?RR1945%67%H%812K:J4%H:54G%H2242242%8:2%J195:3:19%H95%54J:542%38H3%H%JH<5:HJ%H<<423%RH7%64

:RR:9493O%+84%3?<92%31%M4H;4%384%645<11R%31%JHMM%384%e00O%A<2O%,H28:9@319%23H952%:9%384

511<QH7G%Q:38%$<723HM%94H<67O%)847%493<4H3%84<%913%31%RHP4%384%JHMMO

B2%284%842:3H342G%384%H:54%2H72%3847%R?23%JHMM%e00%<:@83%HQH7O%!?<24%)?<94<%3?<92%31%H2P%A<O

,H28:9@319%Q8H3%31%51G%6?3%84%:2%JM?3J8:9@%8:2%J8423G%?9H6M4%31%2K4HPO%B2%384%=HR:M7%R4R64<2

Z1:9%84<%67%384%645%H95%3<7%31%J1R=1<3%A<O%,H28:9@319G%384%812K:J4%H:54%HKK4H<2%H3%384%511<QH7

H95%H991?9J42G%o&m;4%JHMM45%e00O%(A+%Q:MM%64%84<4%:9%=:;4%R:9?342Op

^,<:3349%67%*:M54%-:954RH99a



$B+(%D

&3%QH2%)12JHm2%HKH<3R493G%<4HMM7O%)84%M:;:9@%<11R%QH2%?9JH<K4345%=1<%@<4H34<%4H24%1=%2M:5:9@%H95

J8H2:9@G%281?M5%284%JH<4%31%6H3%84<%JH39:K%R:J4%?954<%384%21=HO%)Q1%MH<@4%JH<561H<5%61I42%HM21

MH7%19%384%8H<5Q115%=M11<G%281?M5%284%JH<4%31%M?<P%:92:54O%B%K1M4%Q:38%K4<J842%243%H3%5:==4<493

84:@832%23115%64=1<4%384%K:J3?<4%Q:951QG%281?M5%284%JH<4%31%2?<;47%384%KH22:9@%2J494O%B95%Q8:M4

3Q1%2J<H3J8:9@%K1232%Q4<4%H;H:MH6M4%=1<%84<%?24G%384%23H34%1=%384%=?<9:3?<4%JM4H<M7%K<1JMH:R45%38H3284%K<4=4<<45%31%28H<K49%84<%JMHQ2%19%384%?K81M234<7O%)84%19M7%J19J422:19%31%84<%64213345

P44K4<m2%1Q9%3H234%H95%J19;49:49J4%QH2%H9%4MH61<H34%21?95%27234R%=MH9P45%67%<1Q2%1=%;:97M

<4J1<5:9@2%1=%#H<1]?4%H95%9:94344938EJ493?<7%R?2:JG%84H;7%19%384%&3HM:H9%J1RK124<2O

&%M11P45%:9%19%(5R?95%H95%)12JH%H61?3%19J4%H%Q44PG%21R43:R42%6<:9@:9@%H%94Q%$lG

21R43:R42%Z?23%6<:9@:9@%=HJ?M37%@122:KO%&3%8H5%6449%3Q4937%74H<2%2:9J4%384%1M5%@493M4RH9%<43:<45G

6?3%84%M:P45%31%P44K%H6<4H23%1=%54KH<3R493HM%K1M:3:J2%4;49%381?@8%84m5%1?3M:;45%HMM%384%K<1=4221<2

1=%8:2%@494<H3:19G%H95%642:542G%84%49Z1745%8H;:9@%R4%31%3HMP%31O%)84%@<H7%3H667%Q1?M5%Z?RK%1931

8:2%MHK%H95%54RH95%31%64%K43345G%Q:38%2K4J:HM%H33493:19%31%384%Q8:34%6:6%?954<%84<%J8:9G%H95

(5R?95%Q1?M5%34MM%R4%HMM%H61?3%81Q%JM4;4<%284%QH2G%Q8:J8%1K4<H2%284%M:P45%6423G%H95%Q8H3%384

;43%8H5%2H:5%H3%84<%MH23%J84JPE?KO%*4m5%34MM%R4%H61?3%8:2%=1<R4<%23?54932G%311G%21R4%1=%Q81%8H5

P4K3%:9%31?J8G%H95%84m5%]?:_%R4%H61?3%R7%MH3423%<424H<J8G%2:9J4G%M:P4%8:RG%&%QH2%H%2K4J:HM:23%:9

R45:4;HM%(?<1K4H9%8:231<7O

,849%84%JHMM45%R4%38H3%4;49:9@G%=<:@834945G%31%34MM%R4%84%J1?M59m3%6<4H384%=1<%384%K<422?<4%19

8:2%J8423G%&%6<1P4%384%2K445%M:R:3%@433:9@%8:R%31%384%812K:3HM%H95%23H745%Q:38%8:R%Q8:M4%3847

5:H@91245%H%84H<3%H33HJP%:9%K<1@<422O%)84%JH<5:1M1@:23%19%JHMM%31M5%?2%(5R?95%944545%H%JH<5:HJ

JH38434<:_H3:19%21%38H3%284%J1?M5%244%4IHJ3M7%Q8:J8%H<34<:42%1<%;4224M2%Q4<4%6M1JP45O%B=34<%3847

K<4KK45%8:R%&%5:5%R7%6423%31%<4H22?<4%8:RO%o&mMM%64%<:@83%84<4Gp%&%K<1R:245O%od1?m<4%@1:9@%31%64

1PH7Op

o,81mMM%M11P%H=34<%)12JHqp

o&3m2%HMM%3HP49%JH<4%1=O%&%K81945%71?<%94:@861<Op

o&=%&mR%57:9@G%519m3%M43%R4%5:4%84<4O%-43%R4%5:4%H3%81R4G%Q:38%)12JHOpod1?m<4%913%57:9@Op

ol1%3847%P91Q%38H3%71?m<4%R7%54J:2:19%RHP4<%:=%H9738:9@%@142%Q<19@qp%84%H2P45O

od42G%:3m2%:9%71?<%J8H<3O%!138:9@m2%@1:9@%31%@1%Q<19@G%381?@8O%)847m<4%@1:9@%31%=:I%71?%?KOp

o&%QH93%31%5:4%H3%81R4Op

o&%P91QOp

&9%384%R:55M4%1=%384%JH38434<:_H3:19%(5R?95%2?23H:945%H%24J195G%RH22:;4%84H<3%H33HJPO%*4

?954<Q493%H9%4R4<@49J7%51?6M4E67KH22%2?<@4<7G%H95%Q849%:3%QH2%1;4<%3847%311P%8:R%31%384

JH<5:HJ%:93492:;4%JH<4%?9:3O%)847%M43%R4%244%8:R%384%94I3%R1<9:9@G%H9%H2849E=HJ45%4:@837E=:;4E

74H<E1M5%RH9%19%H%84H<3%R19:31<%Q:38%H9%&g%5<:K%H95%b15%P91Q2%81Q%RH97%1384<%3?642%<?99:9@

=<1R%8:2%6157%31%Q84<4;4<%:3%QH2%38H3%3847%Q4<4%2?KK1245%31%@1O

';4<%384%94I3%3Q1%Q44P2%&%J1?M59m3%244%R?J8%:RK<1;4R493G%381?@8%8:2%JH<5:1M1@:23G%l<O+3155H<5G%<4RH:945%J192:23493M7%?K64H3O%B3%=:<23G%(5R?95%<4J1@9:_45%R4%6?3%QH29m3%23<19@

491?@8%31%3HMP%R?J8G%21%&%51Q9M1H545%]?H93:3:42%1=%8:2%=H;1<:34%R?2:JnA1_H<3G%g4<5:G

#1JJ84<:9:G%>?JJ:9:n1931%R7%:>15%H95%84%M:234945%31%:3%=1<%81?<2%H3%H%3:R4O%*:2%84H<3%QH2%21

6H5M7%5HRH@45%38H3%:3%J1?M59m3%K?RK%H54]?H34M7G%Q8:J8%K?3%23<422%19%8:2%P:59472%31%384%K1:93

Q84<4%3847%311%64@H9%31%=H:MO%*4%QH2%311%2:JP%31%4H3G%21%3847%=45%8:R%Q:38%H%9H21@H23<:J%3?64O

)849G%:9%8:2%38:<5%Q44P%:9%384%:93492:;4%JH<4%?9:3G%Z?23%H2%8:2%P:59472%Q4<4%23H<3:9@%31%<42K195%31



3<4H3R493G%84%54;4M1K45%K94?R19:HO%,849%&%JHR4%31%244%8:R%384%94I3%5H7G%384<4%QH2%H%6<4H38:9@

3?64%51Q9%8:2%38<1H3%H95%84%QH2%19%H%;493:MH31<O

o,8H3%8HKK4945qp%&%H2P45%8:2%9?<24O

o*4%8H5%3<1?6M4%6<4H38:9@Op

o#?3%71?%P91Q%84%51429m3%QH93%38:2np

o&3m2%19M7%34RK1<H<7G%Z?23%=1<%24;4937E3Q1%81?<2G%31%@:;4%384%H93:6:13:J2%H%J8H9J4%31%JM4H<%?K384%K94?R19:HOp

&%5:59m3%M:P4%Q84<4%38:9@2%Q4<4%84H545G%6?3%&%H@<445%38H3%384%3?64%J1?M5%23H7%:9G%19%384%23<:J3

?954<23H95:9@%38H3%38:2%QH2%31%64%19M7%34RK1<H<7O%&m5%HM<4H57%@194%1;4<%Q:38%l<O%+3155H<5%384

23H95H<5:_45%=1<R%(5R?95%8H5%2:@945%=:;4%74H<2%H@1G%Q8:J8%QH2%3:3M45%ol4JMH<H3:19%1=%H%l42:<4

=1<%H%!H3?<HM%l4H38p%H95%Q8:J8%23:K?MH345%38H3%o:=%R7%J195:3:19%:2%5434<R:945%31%64%34<R:9HM%H95

:9J?<H6M4G%R7%K872:J:H9%RH7%Q:3881M5%1<%5:2J193:9?4%4I3<H1<5:9H<7%R4H92G%H<3:=:J:HM%9?3<:3:19%1<

875<H3:19G%1<%6138Op%&3%244R45%31%R4%38H3%(5R?95%QH2%2M:5:9@%=?<384<%:931%Z?23%384%P:95%1=

R45:JHM%R1<H22%84%5:59m3%QH93G%H95%38H3%&%Q1?M5%8H;4%31%@43%8:R%1?3%1=%:3O

)847%P4K3%8:R%245H345%21%84%Q1?M59m3%=:@83%384%;493:MH31<O%,849%384%24;4937E3Q1%81?<2%Q4<4

?KG%3847%@H;4%8:R%H%M?9@%=?9J3:19%3423G%Q8:J8G%:9%384%812K:3HMm2%?9M1;4M7%KH<MH9J4G%84%=H:M45O%):R4

31%JHMM%H%8HM3G%&%381?@83O%!13%19M7%8H2%38:2%@194%=H<%491?@8G%:3m2%@194%311%=H<O%&%RH54%H9

HKK1:93R493%Q:38%l<O%+3155H<5%=1<%MH34<%38H3%H=34<9119%H95%H2P45%8:R%31%3HP4%(5R?95%1==%384

;493:MH31<%21%84%J1?M5%5:4%:9%K4HJ4O

o)HP4%8:R%1==%384%;493:MH31<qp%84%2H:5O%o,87G%71?%R?239m3%4;49%38:9P%1=%:3O%><1=4221<

CH951MK8%:29m3%57:9@G%71?%P91QO%*:2%P:59472%H<4%51:9@%R?J8%64334<O%A?J8%64334<O%&9%=HJ3G%8:2

?<:94%1?3K?3%:2%6HJP%?K%31%91<RHMO%B95%384%K94?R19:H%:2%JM4H<:9@%?K%311O%!1G%91G%Q4%9445%31%64

38:9P:9@%R1<4%K12:3:;4M7O%h1<%194%38:9@G%Q4%9445%31%@43%8:2%Q4:@83%?KO%)84%9H21@H23<:J%3?64

244R2%31%64%61384<:9@%8:RG%21%&m5%M:P4%31%:RKMH93%H%>(b%3?64%:931%8:2%H651R49nZ?23%H%2:RKM4

2?<@:JHM%K<1J45?<4nH95%&%HM21%38:9P%8:2%6<4H38:9@%3?64%Q1?M5%64%R1<4%J1R=1<3H6M4%=1<%8:R%:=%Q4

K4<=1<R45%H%3<HJ84131R7Op

&%QH2%HKKHMM45O%o#?3%71?%JH9m3rp%&%K<1342345O%o*4m2%6449%;4<7%JM4H<%=<1R%384%64@:99:9@%38H3%8451429m3%QH93%31%495%?K%M:P4%38:2O%>M4H24%519m3%P44K%51:9@%38:9@2%31%8:RO%>M4H24O%&3m2%3:R4%31%231KOp

+3155H<5%2811P%8:2%84H5O%o&%27RKH38:_4%Q:38%Q8H3%71?m<4%@1:9@%38<1?@8G%6?3%71?%8H;4%31

?954<23H95%38H3%KH3:4932%519m3%HMQH72%R4H9%Q8H3%3847%2H7O%&m;4%2449%:3%21%1=349G%K41KM4%34MM:9@%R4

3847%519m3%QH93%31%M:;4%:=%:3%R4H92%64:9@%19%1I7@49%384%<423%1=%384:<%M:;42G%1<%64:9@%645E61?95G%1<

8H;:9@%31%@1%:931%H%9?<2:9@%81R4O%#?3%3849%Q849%3847%=:95%384R24M;42%:9%38H3%2:3?H3:19G%3847

5:2J1;4<%:3m2%913%H2%6H5%H2%3847%381?@83%:3%Q1?M5%64Op%*4%@H;4%R4%H%Q<7%M:33M4%2R:M4O%o&3m2

J4<3H:9M7%64334<%38H9%64:9@%54H5Op

o*1Q%51%71?%P91Q ()'*+) 5:59m3%R4H9%Q8H3%84%2H:5q%d1?%JH9m3%Z?23%6?MM51_4%<:@83%1;4<%8:2

4IK<422%Q:2842rp

o#?3%84%R:@83%8H;4%J8H9@45%8:2%R:95O%)84<4m2%23:MM%H%J8H9J4%38H3%84mMM%K?MM%38<1?@8O%AH764

913%31%Q84<4%84%JH9%@1%81R4G%6?3%31%Q84<4%84%JH9%23:MM%@43%21R4%KM4H2?<4%1?3%1=%8:2%M:=4O%&%JH9m3%:9@115%J192J:49J4np

o#?3%84%51429m3%QH93np%,4%2K1P4%2:R?M3H941?2M7O

+3155H<5%6M4Q%1?3%H%544K%6<4H38G%H2%381?@8%84%Q4<4%J1?93:9@%31%349O%o)84<4m2%H%K4<=4J3M7

2:RKM4%QH7%31%2433M4%38:2Gp%84%2H:5O%o><1=4221<%CH951MK8%:2%19M7%34RK1<H<:M7%:9JHKHJ:3H345G%71?

P91QO%-43m2%Z?23%3HP4%8:R%1==%245H3:19G%H95%Q849%84%QHP42%?K%Q4%JH9%H2P%8:R%Q84384<%84%QH932

?2%31%J193:9?4%3<4H3R493Op



o!1O%!1G%519m3%51%38H3O%&%P91Q%Q8H3%84%QH932O%&%P91Q ,"'- *4%QH932%8:2%JH3O%*4%QH932%8:2

R?2:JO%*4%QH932%8:2%1M5%M:=4%6HJPO%B95%:=%84%JH9m3%8H;4%38124%38:9@2G%84%QH932%31%5:4%]?:43M7O%B3

81R4G%:=%K122:6M4O%#?3%:=%913G%H3%M4H23%Q:381?3%HMM%384%3?642%H95%RHJ8:942Op

&%H<@?45%:3%1?3%Q:38%8:R%=1<%H91384<%8HM=E81?<G%6?3%&%R:@83%H2%Q4MM%8H;4%2H;45%R7%6<4H38O

+3155H<5%<4RH:945%H5HRH93\%:3%QH29m3%3:R4%31%@:;4%?K%19%(5R?95O%+1%84<4%Q4%H<4O%&%519m3%8H;4

H97%:54H%Q8H3%31%51%94I3O%A7%6:@@423%=4H<%:2%38H3%Q849%3847%QHP4%8:R%31R1<<1Q%84mMM%2H7%742%H95:RK<1;4%Z?23%491?@8%31%495%?K%:9%H%9?<2:9@%81R4G%Q:38%194%J1RKM:JH3:19%H=34<%H91384<%?93:M%84

=:9HMM7%5:42O%&m;4%@13%31%231K%38H3G%6?3%&%JH9m3%244%81QO%&3m2%913%<:@83O%!194%1=%38:2%:2%<:@83O

+1R481QG%&m;4%@13%31%J19;:9J4%384R%31%M43%8:R%5:4%319:@83G%64=1<4%84%8H2%H%J8H9J4%31%@43%64334<O

^,<:3349%67%*:M54%-:954RH99a



$B+(%F

B3%384%H@4%1=%0DG%`HP4%8H2%6449%:9%H95%1?3%1=%384%812K:3HM%RH97%3:R42%1;4<%384%MH23%=4Q%74H<2

Q:38%H%=1<R%1=%M4?P4R:H%38H3%:2%?2?HMM7%J?<H6M4%:9%J8:M5<49%H95%H51M42J4932O%`HP4%:2%?9M?JP7G

381?@8O%*:2%19J1M1@:23%381?@83%84%8H5%54=4H345%384%JH9J4<%6?3%:3%JHR4%6HJPG%H95%91Q%4;49%H%MH23E

5:3J8%6194%RH<<1Q%3<H92KMH93%8H2%=H:M45O`HP4m2%R1384<%:92:232%38H3%84%913%64%31M5%38H3%84%:2%57:9@G%H95%384%K872:J:H92G%2H7:9@%3847%R?23

<42K4J3%84<%Q:2842G%8H;4%=1<6:5549%384%23H==%31%5:2J?22%`HP4m2%K<1@912:2%Q:38%8:RO%>:MH<%+H9J84_G

384%9?<24%Q81%8H2%3HP49%JH<4%1=%`HP4%4;4<7%3:R4%84%8H2%6449%812K:3HM:_45G%:2%;4<7%3<1?6M45%67

38:2O%+84%:2%J19;:9J45%38H3%84%JH9%8H95M4%384%3<?38G%H95%284%=44M2%H2%:=%284%M:42%31%8:R%4;4<7%3:R4

284%2R:M42%49J1?<H@:9@M7%Q849%84%34MM2%84<%H61?3%8:2%KMH92%=1<%384%=?3?<4O%+84%8H2%3HJ3=?MM7%3:<45

31%<H:24%384%2?6Z4J3%Q:38%`HP4m2%19J1M1@:23G%6?3%84%QH2%H6<?K3G%34MM:9@%84<%38H3%284%:2%4R13:19HMM7

1;4<E:9;1M;45%H95%K<1=422:19HMM7%1?3%1=%M:94O

^,<:3349%67%*:M54%-:954RH99a



$B+(%[

A<2O%+8HM4;%H95%*4<%lH?@834<

A<2O%+8HM4;%:2%91Q%4:@837E38<44%74H<2%1M5O%+84%QH2%61<9%:9%>1MH95%H95%42JHK45%31%384%"9:345

+3H342%:9%384%4H<M:423%74H<2%1=%384%+4J195%,1<M5%,H<O%+84%H5HK345%K<4337%]?:JPM7%31%#<11PM79%H95

<H:245%H%=HR:M7%384<4G%6?3%3Q1%74H<2%H@1%284%2?==4<45%H%24<:1?2%23<1P4O%+:9J4%3849%284%8H2%2K493%H

@115%54HM%1=%84<%3:R4%:9%812K:3HM2%H95%9?<2:9@%81R42G%HMQH72%JH<4=?MM7%H3349545%67%84<%5H?@834<G#4JP7%>?39HRG%Q8124%81R4%A<2O%+8HM4;%8H5%28H<45%=1<%384%=:;4%74H<2%Z?23%64=1<4%84<%23<1P4O

A<2O%+8HM4;%:2%91Q%6HJP%:9%384%812K:3HMG%Q:38%H%M19@%M:23%1=%24<:1?2%K<16M4R2O%*4<%K872:J:H92

<4@H<5%84<%2:3?H3:19%H2%o281<3E34<R%2?<;:;H6M4G%M19@E34<R%34<R:9HMOp%#?3%284%23:MM%8H2%K4<:152%1=

M?J:5:37G%H95%84<%5H?@834<%:2%23:MM%544KM7%:9;1M;45%:9%84<%JH<4O

&9%384%1K:9:19%1=%384%34HR%3<4H3:9@%A<2O%+8HM4;G%84<%5H?@834<%RH7%:9%=HJ3%64%311%544KM7

:9;1M;45O%A2O%>?39HR%:2%KH<3:J?MH<M7%J19J4<945%H61?3%384%HR1?93%1=%KH:9%R45:JH3:19%38H3%84<

R1384<%:2%@433:9@O%)84%H9HM@42:J2%<16%84<%R1384<%1=%384%M:33M4%JHKHJ:37%284%8H2%M4=3n:9%KH<3:J?MH<G

384%H6:M:37%31%<4J1@9:_4%84<%5H?@834<m2%K<4249J4O

B3%384%2HR4%3:R4G%A<2O%+8HM4;%8H2%54;4M1K45%H%9?R64<%1=%24<:1?2%K<422?<4%21<42%=<1R%64:9@

645E61?95%21%M19@O%+1R4%1=%38424%H<4%6H5%491?@8%38H3%6194%3:22?4%281Q2%38<1?@8O%+84%94452

<4@?MH<%J8H9@42%1=%5<422:9@2%19%38424%21<42G%H95%38:2%:2%HKKH<493M7%]?:34%H9%?9J1R=1<3H6M4

K<1J45?<4O%*1Q%?9J1R=1<3H6M4G%91%194%JH9%<4HMM7%34MMG%6?3%284%J4<3H:9M7%<4HJ32%94@H3:;4M7%31

384RG%R1H9:9@%H95%3<7:9@%31%K?MM%HQH7O

)84%3<4H3R493%34HR%HM21%=44M2%38H3%:3m2%3:R4%31%23H<3%<438:9P:9@%384%@1HM2%=1<%A<2O%+8HM4;m2%JH<4

R1<4%@494<HMM7O%+84%:2%J?<<493M7%?954<@1:9@%H%9?R64<%1=%:9;H2:;4%3<4H3R4932G%9194%1=%Q8:J8

8H;4%H97%<4HM%J8H9J4%1=%RHP:9@%84<%H97%64334<f%384%6423%3847%JH9%51%:2%2K:9%1?3%84<%M:=4%Z?23%H%M:33M4

M19@4<O%+1R4%1=%384%K872:J:H92%:9;1M;45%:9%84<%JH<4%8H;4%6449%84H<5%31%?334<%384%Q1<5%o=?3:M:37Gp

H95%384%9?<242%:9%KH<3:J?MH<%H<4%;4<7%J19J4<945%38H3%384%H:R%1=%A<2O%+8HM4;m2%3<4H3R493%64%31%P44K

84<%H2%KH:9%=<44%H2%K122:6M4%21%38H3%284%JH9%495%84<%M:=4%:9%5:@9:37%H95%J1R=1<3O

A2O%>?39HR%8H2%H%;4<7%5:==4<493%;:4Q%1=%384%RH334<O%,8:M4%284%51429m3%5497%38H3%84<%R1384<

=HJ42%H%@<:R%1?3M11PG%284%5142%64M:4;4%38H3%384%@<1Q:9@%J192492?2%1=%384%3<4H3R493%34HR%:2:9HKK<1K<:H34G%31%K?3%:3%R:M5M7O%+84%:92:232%38H3%84<%R1384<%J193:9?4%31%<4J4:;4%H@@<422:;4G%M:=4E

2?23H:9:9@%3<4H3R493G%H95%38H3%384%H9HM@42:J2%64%R:9:RHMO%l?<:9@%194%JH<4%J19=4<49J4G%284

4IJMH:R45G%o,84<4%Q4%J1R4%=<1RG%Q4%=:95%:3%1==492:;4%38H3%71?%:92:23%19%5:2J?22:9@%Q:385<HQHM

1=%M:=4%2?KK1<3nQ4%8H;4%94;4<%4;49%3HMP45%H61?3%38424%38:9@2%HR19@%1?<24M;42rp

)8:2%K12:3:19%:2%<HK:5M7%5<:;:9@%384%3<4H3R493%34HR%J<H_7O%)84%JHMM%@142%1?3%31%384%812K:3HMm2

438:J2%J1RR:3344%:9%81K42%38H3%21R4%23<H34@7%=1<%J8H9@:9@%A2O%>?39HRm2%R:95%JH9%64%Q1<P45

1?3O%hH:M:9@%38H3G%K4<8HK2%384<4m2%H%QH7%1=%@433:9@%84<%1?3%1=%384%54J:2:19%RHP:9@%M11KO%B2%194

9?<24%K?32%:3G%o,8:M4%&%<42K4J3%384%?9:]?4%K4<2K4J3:;4%1=%384%=HR:M7G%384<4%8H;4%31%64%M:R:32O%&%=44M

H2%381?@8%&mR%64:9@%=1<J45%31%KH<3:J:KH34%:9%384%H6?24%1=%H%;?M94<H6M4%H5?M3Op



$B+( e

h1<%1;4<%H%54JH54%91QG%84HM38%JH<4%4IK4<32%8H;4%6449%K<1R13:9@%34M4R45:J:94G%1<%384%?24%1=

2H34MM:34%34J891M1@7G%;:541%J19=4<49J:9@%H95%5H3H%3<H92=4<%38<1?@8%K81942%H95%384%&934<943G%31

J1994J3%51J31<2%31%KH3:4932%:9%=H<E=M?9@%M1JHM42O%#?3%H<4%51J31<2%<4H57%=1<%38:2%=1<R%1=

34J891M1@7q

!4Q%34J891M1@:42%:9%84HM38%JH<4%HMQH72%<4]?:<4%H%<4H22422R493%1=%81Q%KH3:4932%H95%51J31<2%6423

<4MH34%31%194%H91384<G%H%Z?5@R493%JHMM%19%Q84384<%384%<4MH3:1928:KG%H95%JH<4G%:2%84MK45%1<%8H<R45

67%4ERH:M:9@%:9234H5%1=%JHMM:9@G%?K5H3:9@%,46%2:342%:9234H5%1=%RH:M:9@%1?3%913:=:JH3:192G%6M1@@:9@

H95%K123:9@%?K5H342%31%)Q:334<%:9234H5%1=%K?6M:28:9@%:9%R45:JHM%Z1?<9HM2O%B95%Q8:M4%R123%51J31<2

64M:4;4%38H3%34J891M1@7%JH9%84MK%31%23<49@3849%384%51J31<EKH3:493%6195G%38H3%8H2%913%6449%384%JH24

=1<%34M4R45:J:94O%&95445G%=1<%RH97%51J31<2G%34M4R45:J:94%:2%2449%31%54K4<219HM:_4%384%<4MH3:1928:K

H95%2H613H@4%3<?23%643Q449%384%51J31<%H95%384%KH3:493O

B%<4J493%23?57%67%<424H<J84<2%H3%384%"9:;4<2:37%1=%)4IH2%A45:JHM%+J811M%:9%*1?2319%M11P45%H3

384%:RKHJ3%1=%34M4R45:J:94%19%KH3:4932%:9%384%:93492:;4%JH<4%?9:3O%BM381?@8%384%<424H<J84<2%8H5

:9:3:HMM7%243%1?3%31%23?57%34M4R45:J:94m2%4==4J3%19%R1<3HM:37G%J1RKM:JH3:192%H95%384%M49@38%1=%23H7

1=%KH3:4932%:9%=:;4%5:==4<493%812K:3HM2G%3847%:9H5;4<3493M7%5:2J1;4<45%384%4I3493%31%Q8:J8%JM:9:J:H92

Q4<4%<4M?J3H93%31%:9J1<K1<H34%38:2%34J891M1@:JHM%J8H9@4O

(;4<7%&O$O"O%KH3:493%:9%384%23?57%<4J4:;45%384%?2?HM%19E2:34%JH<4%38<1?@81?3%384%23?57G%H2%Q4MM%H2

HMM%384%H55:3:19HM%H?5:1;:2?HM%H95%;:3HM%2:@92%R19:31<:9@%1==4<45%67%H%<4R134%J<:3:JHM%JH<4

2K4J:HM:23%.Y%81?<2%H%5H7O%&9%H55:3:19G%4HJ8%KH3:493m2%K872:J:H9%J1?M5%J81124%384%54@<44%31%Q8:J8

384%<4R134%2K4J:HM:232%Q1?M5%64%:9;1M;45%:9 54M:;4<:9@ 5:<4J3%JH<4%n%38H3%:2G%@:;:9@%1<54<2%H95

:934<;49:9@%=<1R%H=H<O

&=%384%KH3:493m2%K872:J:H9%QH9345%19M7%R:9:RHM%<4R134%5:<4J3%:9;1M;4R493G%384%<4R134%JM:9:J:H92Q1?M5%1==4<%JH<4%19M7%5?<:9@%?94IK4J345%M:=4E38<4H349:9@%4R4<@49J:42G%M:P4%2?5549%5<1K2%:9

6M115%K<422?<4%1<%HJ?34%6M445:9@O%&=%384%<4@?MH<%K872:J:H92%QH9345%RHI:R?R%:9;1M;4R493G%384

<4R134%JM:9:J:H92%Q1?M5%Q1<P%31@4384<%Q:38%384%19E2:34%51J31<2%H95%@:;4%<1?3:94%1<54<2%H95

J8H9@4%3<4H3R493%KMH92O

h1<%H9%&O$O"O%KH3:493%384<4%H<4%K13493:HM%H5;H93H@42%31%8H;:9@%H9%o4I3<H%243%1=%4742p%H3%HMM%3:R42G

4742%38H3%R:@83%913:J4%H%5:2J1994J345%R19:31<%1<%H9%4<<H93%KH22:9@G%6?3%K13493:HMM7%<4J?<<493G

M438HM%84H<3%<8738RO%B95%H3%M4H23%H94J513HMM7G%RH97%KH3:4932%244R45%31%Q4MJ1R4%384%H55:3:19HM

R19:31<:9@O%ohHR:M:42%244R45%31%64%;4<7%HJJ4K3:9@%1=%384%34J891M1@7%64JH?24%3847%=4M3%38H3

21R4194%QH2%HMQH72%M11P:9@%:9%19%384%KH3:493Gp%2H:5%l<O%#4MH%>H34MG%384%249:1<%H?381<%1=%384

23?57%H95%4I4J?3:;4%R45:JHM%5:<4J31<%1=%J<:3:JHM%JH<4%H3%384%A4R1<:HM%*4<RH99%*12K:3HME)4IH2A45:JHM%$4934<O

l42K:34%384%244R:9@M7%16;:1?2%H5;H93H@42%H95%KH3:493%Q:MM:9@9422G%81Q4;4<G%384%RHZ1<:37%1=

51J31<2%:9%384%23?57%J8124%31%8H;4%H2%M:33M4%<4R134%:9;1M;4R493%=1<%384:<%KH3:4932%H2%K122:6M4O

AH97%Q4<4%Q1<<:45%H61?3%34M4R45:J:94m2%4==4J3%19%384:<%<4MH3:1928:K2%Q:38%KH3:4932%H95%38H3%:3

R:@83%H5;4<24M7%H==4J3%JH<4O



o+1R4%K872:J:H92%=4M3%Q4%Q4<4%64:9@%311%:93<?2:;4Gp%l<O%>H34M%H5545O%o,4%Q1?M5%<4J1RR495

J8H9@:9@%384%;493:MH31<%2433:9@2G%=1<%4IHRKM4G%6?3%:3%Q1?M59m3%64%81Q%3847%K<HJ3:J45O%)84%51J31<2

Q1?M5%<42K195G%s&3m2%R7%KH3:493f%M4H;4%R4%HM194Om%)847%5:5%913%QH93%./%K41KM4%M11P:9@%:9%19

384:<%KH3:493%H95%244:9@%:=%H9738:9@%4M24%J1?M5%64%5194Op

B95%51J31<2%Q4<4%913%384%19M7%1942%Q81%<42:2345%384%34J891M1@7f%9?<242%5:5G%311O%o+1R4%1=%384

9?<242%=4M3%38H3%21R46157%QH2%M11P:9@%1;4<%384:<%281?M54<%HMM%384%3:R4Gp%l<O%>H34M%J1RR49345O

oB95%21R4194 QH2O%&9%384%<:@83%J1934I3%38H3%Q1?M5%8H;4%6449%84MK=?Mf%6?3%:=%HMM%38H3%384%9?<242

Q4<4%84H<:9@%=<1R%384%<4R134%JM:9:J:H92%QH2%38H3%384:<%KH3:493m2%(ib%M4H52%Q4<4%5:2J1994J345%1<

38H3%H%J4<3H:9%R19:31<%8H5%=HMM49%1==%H@H:9G%3847%49545%?K%=<?23<H345Op%,8:M4%384%9?<242

HJP91QM45@45%38H3%<4R:954<2%M:P4%38424%Q4<4%:RK1<3H93G%oQ4%Q4<4%HM21%61384<:9@%384:<%Q1<P=M1QO

)84%9?<242%Q1?M5%2H7G%s+31K%JHMM:9@%R4O%&%519m3%QH93%31%84H<%38H3%H@H:9Om%p

)8:2%MHJP%1=%HJJ4K3H9J4%RH54%:3%5:==:J?M3%=1<%384%23?57%:9;423:@H31<2%31%H22422%384%:RKHJ3%1=

34M4R45:J:94%19%KH3:4932%Q81%Q4<4%M422%2:JP%6?3%Q81%8H5%R?J8%31%@H:9O%o(H<M7%<4J1@9:3:19%1=

J8H9@42%:9%H%KH3:493m2%23H3?2%:2%Q8H3%<4HMM7%84MK2%:9%J<:3:JHM%JH<4Gp%l<O%>H34M%2H:5O%o,849%H

KH3:493m2%84H<3%231K2%1<%H%KH3:493%:2%JM:9:JHMM7%J<H28:9@G%4;4<7194%P91Q2%H61?3%:3O%#?3%Q849%H

KH3:493m2%84H<3%<H34%@142%?K%2M:@83M7G%913%4;4<7194%JH3J842%38H3O%&=%71?%913:J4%H95%HJ3%?K19%38424

P:952%1=%J8H9@42%4H<M7G%71?%JH9%<42J?4%384%KH3:493%4H<M7Op

^+1?<J4\%)84%!4Q%d1<P%):R42G%`H9O%F%./0/ 833K\UUQQQO973:R42OJ1RU./0/U/0U/FU84HM38U

/FJ849O83RMa



$B+(%0/

'94%JHMM1?2%]?423:19%3?<945%#<:33H97%$H42H<%:931%H%R45:JHM%K:1944<\%o,87%51%71?%4H3%21%R?J8q

&3m2%913%91<RHMOp%B3%38H3%R1R493G%284%QH2%:9%384%$HRK64MM%A:55M4%+J811M%JH=434<:HG%2:33:9@%51Q9

31%84<%?2?HM%M?9J8\%3Q1%J844246?<@4<2G%3Q1%1<54<2%1=%=<:42%H95%H%$1P4O%+84%P94Q%284%Q4:@845%311

R?J8O%*4<%Q81M4%=HR:M7%Q4:@845%311%R?J8O%#?3%84<%Q1<M5%<4;1M;45%H<1?95%=115G%H95%284%J1?M5

913%:RH@:94%H97%1384<%4I:2349J4O

B3%38H3%38H3%R1R493G%284%QH2%:9%384%$HRK64MM%A:55M4%+J811M%JH=434<:HG%2:33:9@%51Q9%31%84<%?2?HM

M?9J8\%3Q1%J844246?<@4<2G%3Q1%1<54<2%1=%=<:42%H95%H%$1P4O%+84%P94Q%284%Q4:@845%311%R?J8O%*4<

Q81M4%=HR:M7%Q4:@845%311%R?J8O

oh115%QH2%R7%6423%=<:495Gp%284%2H:5O%o&3%QH2%HMQH72%384<4%=1<%R4Op%+1R481QG%84<%JMH22RH34m2

3H?93G%6HJP%:9%.//SG%Q1?9545%84<%:9%H%QH7%384%?2?HM%=H3%Z1P42%94;4<%8H5O%+84%=M45%31%384

6H38<11R%H95%Q4K3G%;1Q:9@%31%M124%Q4:@83O%*4<%2HM;H3:19%5:5%913%H<<:;4%?93:M%R1<4%38H9%H%74H<

MH34<%Q849G%H3%H@4%0YG%51J31<2%H3%)4IH2%$8:M5<49m2%*12K:3HM%K4<=1<R45%H%@H23<:J%67KH22%38H3%M4=3

84<%231RHJ8%384%2:_4%1=%H9%4@@O%'9%384%5H7%1=%2?<@4<7G%284%Q4:@845%Y/Y%K1?952O

A2O%$H42H<G%91Q%./%74H<2%1M5%H95%0FW%K1?952G%QH2%384%=:<23%3449H@4<%31%?954<@1%H%@H23<:J%67KH22H3%)4IH2%$8:M5<49m2G%6?3%R1<4%]?:JPM7%=1MM1Q45O%)15H7G%:3%RH:93H:92%194%1=%384%6?2:423%6H<:H3<:J

K<HJ3:J42%=1<%H51M42J4932%:9%384%J1?93<7G%K4<=1<R:9@%194%1<%3Q1%67KH2242%4HJ8%R1938O%BM381?@8

384%K<1J45?<4%:2%23:MM%J192:54<45%4IK4<:R493HM%=1<%J8:M5<49G%:3%:2%=H23%64J1R:9@%384%94I3%=<193%:9

384%6H33M4%H@H:923%K45:H3<:J%1642:37O

o&%819423M7%64M:4;4%38H3%:9%W%31%0/%74H<2%71?mMM%244%H2%RH97%J8:M5<49%@433:9@%Q4:@83EM122

K<1J45?<42%H2%H5?M32Gp%2H:5%l<O%(;H9%!H5M4<G%J1E5:<4J31<%1=%384%'642:37%&923:3?34%H3%$8:M5<49m2

!H3:19HM%A45:JHM%$4934<%:9%,H28:9@319O

#?3%RH97%51J31<2%2H7%<424H<J8%8H2%743%31%423H6M:28%Q84384<%:RR45:H34%:RK<1;4R4932%=<1R

2?<@4<7%Z?23:=7%HM34<:9@%H%J8:M5m2%5:@423:;4%27234RG%K<16H6M7%=1<%M:=4O

od1?%519m3%<4HMM7%P91Q%Q8H3%384%1?3J1R4%:2Gp%2H:5%l<O%(5QH<5%-:;:9@2319G%J8H:<RH9%1=

@H23<1:93423:9HM%H95%4951J<:94%2?<@4<7%H3%384%"9:;4<2:37%1=%)4IH2%+1?38Q4234<9%A45:JHM%$4934<%H3

lHMMH2O%od1?%3HMP%H61?3%384%6494=:3%64:9@%38H3%:3%K<4;4932%P:52%=<1R%34<<:6M4%J8<19:J%5:24H24%MH34<

:9%M:=4O%#?3%21R4%1=%384R%H<4%@1:9@%31%<4@H:9%Q4:@83O%+1R4%1=%384R%H<4%@1:9@%31%8H;4%M19@E34<R

J1RKM:JH3:192%H95%Q4%Q19m3%=:95%1?3%?93:M%MH34<Op

)84%R123%4I3492:;4%2J:493:=:J%23?5:42%1=%@H23<:J%67KH2242%:9%J8:M5<49%8H;4%HKK4H<45%:9%Z?23%384

KH23%=1?<%R19382G%H95%=4Q%23?5:42%8H;4%=1MM1Q45%KH3:4932%=1<%R1<4%38H9%H61?3%3Q1%74H<2%H=34<

2?<@4<7O%)84%5H3H%K<1;:54%<4H219%=1<%6138%49J1?<H@4R493%H95%JH?3:19O%$8:M5<49%51%3495%315<HRH3:JHMM7%2845%4IJ422%Q4:@83%5?<:9@%384%=:<23%74H<O%#?3%H2%Q:38%H5?M32G%384%Q4:@83%M122%34952%31

2M1Q%1;4<%3:R4G%Q:38%384%6157%RH22%:954I%M4;4M:9@%1==%:9%d4H<%.%H3%H%K1:93%38H3%<4RH:92%H61;4

91<RHMO

+1%=H<G%384%23?5:42%8H;4%=1?95%38H3%384%6157%23H<32%31%<4KH:<%:324M=%H2%384%Q4:@83%=HMM2O%h1<%4IHRKM4G

3Q1%74H<2%H=34<%@H23<:J%67KH22G%384%M4=3%2:54%1=%384%84H<3%8H2%23H<345%31%<43?<9%31%91<RHM%:9%R123

H51M42J4932G%HJJ1<5:9@%31%JH<5:1M1@:232%H3%$:9J:99H3:%$8:M5<49m2O%C424H<J8%HM21%2?@@42345%38H3%=1<



H3%M4H23%H2%M19@%H2%384%J8:M5<49%8H;4%6449%=1MM1Q45G%384%K<1J45?<4%HKK4H<45%2H=4G%H95%H61?3%[W%31

e/%K4<J493%1=%H51M42J4932%RH:93H:945%384:<%:9:3:HM%Q4:@83%M122G%l<O%&9@4%2H:5O

#?3%1384<%2?<@4192%Q4<4%913%21%2?<4O%)84%6H95%:2%H%8?RH9ERH54%54;:J4%38H3%J1?M5%64%:9%KMHJ4%=1<

H%M:=43:R4G%H95%H2%2?J8%JH<<:42%H%<:2P%1=%2JH<<:9@%H95%RHM=?9J3:19G%2H:5%l<O%AH<7%-O%#<H953G%384

K45:H3<:J%2?<@419%Q81%84H52%384%*1?2319%K<1@<HRO%o)84<4m2%91%QH7%71?%JH9%@:;4%H%F/E74H< @?H<H9344Gp%284%2H:5O

B95%91%RH334<%384%R43815G%<424H<J84<2%=4H<%38H3%H2%Q4:@83EM122%2?<@4<7%=1<%3449H@4<2%64J1R42

R1<4%K1K?MH<G%21R4%51J31<2%Q:MM%1K4<H34%19%KH3:4932%Q81%281?M5%913%8H;4%384%2?<@4<7%n%Q84384<

34RK345%67%H%K13493:HMM7%M?J<H3:;4%RH<P43%1<%R13:;H345%67%H%2:9J4<4%542:<4%31%84MKO

l<O%!H5M4<%2H72%38H3%384<4%H<4%H%M13%1=%51J31<2%38H3%H<4%@1:9@%31%23H<3%K4<=1<R:9@%384%2?<@4<7%Q81

K<16H6M7%281?M59m3%64G%od1?m<4%@1:9@%31%244%384%H5?M3%2?<@4192%23H<3%31%51%0FE%H95%0DE74H<E1M52G

64JH?24%384%2?<@4<7%:324M=%:2%91%5:==4<493%=<1R%H5?M32Op

#?3%384%KH3:4932%H<4O%)847%H<4%23:MM%:RRH3?<4G%6138%4R13:19HMM7%H95%K872:JHMM7O%h1<%R123%2J:493:=:J

23?5:42G%2?<@:JHM%34HR2%<4]?:<4%38H3%J8:M5<49%?954<@1%R19382%1=%J1?924M:9@%31%RHP4%2?<4%3847

?954<23H95%38H3%384:<%5:@423:;4%27234R2%H<4%H61?3%31%J8H9@4G%H95%21%R?23%384:<%5:432%n%=1<4;4<O

#<:33H97%$H42H<%8H5%31%QH:3%H%74H<%64=1<4%384%2?<@:JHM%34HR%@<H9345%K4<R:22:19%=1<%H%67KH22G%H95

l<O%#<H953%423:RH345%38H3%84<%812K:3HM%8H2%<4=?245%e%1?3%1=%4;4<7%0/%<4]?4232%=1<%2?<@4<7%19%16424

H51M42J4932%64JH?24%1=%51?632%H61?3%384:<%H6:M:37%31%=1MM1Q%38<1?@8O%o&=%71?%519m3%=1MM1Q%384%<?M42

H=34<QH<5G%71?%JH9%5:4Gp%284%2H:5O

B95%l<O%#<H953%Q1<<:42%38H3%4;49%:=%84<%34HR%<4=?242G%1384<2%Q:MM%@:;4%:9G%42K4J:HMM7%H2%R1<4

KH<4932%23H<3%54RH95:9@%384%2?<@4<7%=1<%384:<%J8:M5<49O%`?23%MH23%R1938G%194%R1384<%JHMM45%84< 1==:J4%QH93:9@%H%@H23<:J%6H95%=1<%84<%[E74H<E1M5%5H?@834<O

+?J8%<4]?4232%RHP4%l<O%#<H953%?94H27%H61?3%384%=?3?<4O%+1R4%5H72G%284%2H72G%284%:2%HKKHMM45%31

64%51:9@%6H<:H3<:J2%H3%HMMG%244:9@%21%RH97%J8:M5<49%<H:245%19%=1152%38H3%H<4%JHM1<:4E<:J8%H95

9?3<:3:19EK11<O

o#?3%38424%P:52%H<4%57:9@Gp%284%2H:5O%o,4m;4%J<4H345%21R438:9@%:9%1?<%21J:437%Q4%8H;4%31%?951Op

^+1?<J4\%!4Q%d1<P%):R42G h46<?H<7%0WG%./0/a



$B+(%00

C164<3%$O%,O%(33:9@4<%:2%9:9437E194%74H<2%1M5%H95%84%:2%H%=1?954<%1=%384%J<719:J2%R1;4R493O

,849%84%5:42G%384%6M115%Q:MM%64%5<H:945%=<1R%8:2%6157G%H93:=<44_4%Q:MM%64%K?RK45%:931%8:2

H<34<:42G%H95%81M42%Q:MM%64%5<:MM45%:9%8:2%2P?MMG%H=34<%Q8:J8%84%Q:MM%64%231<45%?K2:54%51Q9%:9%H%;H3

1=%M:]?:5%9:3<1@49%H3%R:9?2%38<44%8?95<45%H95%3Q4937%54@<442%hH8<4984:3O%*4%4IK4J32%31%64

54=<12345G%21R43:R4%643Q449%=:=37%H95%3Q1%8?95<45%74H<2%=<1R%91QG%67%2J:493:232%Q81%Q:MM%RHP48:R%71?9@%H95%23<19@%H95%3:<4M422O%(33:9@4<%8H2%HM<4H57%=<1_49%8:2%R1384<%H95%8:2%3Q1%Q:;42G

HM19@%Q:38%9:9437E3Q1%1384<%K41KM4%Q81%HQH:3%<42?<<4J3:19%:92:54%@:H93%=<44_4<2%:9%H%6?:M5:9@%Z?23

H%=4Q%6M1JP2%=<1R%8:2%81?24G%:9%$M:9319%)1Q928:KG%A:J8:@H9O%)84%$<719:J2%&923:3?34%1JJ?K:42%H

24;49E381?2H95E2]?H<4E=113%QH<481?24%:9%H9%:95?23<:HM%KH<PO%>H23%H%QH:3:9@%<11R%:2%384%2RHMM

1==:J4%1=%B957%cHQHJP:G%Q81%J1923:3?342%KH<3%1=%$O&Om2%=?MME3:R4%23H==O%*4%:2%HM21%194%1=%$O&Om2

R1<4%38H9%4:@83%8?95<45%R4R64<2G%Q8:J8%R4H92%38H3%84%HM21%KMH92%31%64%=<1_49%Q849%84%5:42O

o!4?<1K<424<;H3:19p%:2%Q8H3%:2%K<HJ3:J45%H3%$O&O%H95%:3%8H2%H%2J:493:=:J%H33:3?54G%6?3%38H3%51429m3

RHP4%:3%2J:49J4O%$<45493:HM45%MH61<H31<7%2J:493:232%519m3%@494<HMM7%38:9P%384%54H5%Q:MM%194%5H7

HQHP49O%)84%J192492?2%HKK4H<2%31%64%38H3%Q849%71?%3<7%31%54=<123%H%=<1_49%J1<K24%71?%@43%R?28O

B95%4;49%:=G%:9%384%=?3?<4G%2J:493:232%J1?M5%<4KH:<%384%5HRH@4%5194%31%J4MM2%67%=<44_:9@%H9538HQ:9@G%Q8H3%3847%Q1?M5%8H;4G%H3%6423G%:2%H%JH5H;4<O

)84%$<719:J2%&923:3?34%64M:4;42%38H3%=?3?<4%34J891M1@:42%Q:MM%21M;4%38424%K<16M4R2%6?3%(33:9@4<

8:R24M=%K1:932%1?3%38H3%H97194%QH93:9@%31%<42?<<4J3%H95%<4Z?;49H34%384%54H5%R?23%J1RKM434%=1?<

3H2P2\%J?<4%384%K4<219%1=%Q8H3%P:MM45%84<G%<4;4<24%384%54JH7%38H3%243%:9%643Q449%54H38%H95

=<44_:9@G%<4KH:<%384%5HRH@4%5194%67%384%=<44_:9@%:324M=G%H95%RHP4%84<%71?9@%H@H:9O ,8:M4%:3%:2

913%:RK122:6M4%=1<%J<719:J2%31%2?JJ445f%:3%:2%4IJ4K3:19HMM7%?9M:P4M7O

hHJ45%Q:38%38:2%5H?93:9@%H95%?9M:P4M7%2J49H<:1%Q87%Q1?M5%H97194%J81124%31%64%=<1_49q

><1=4221<%AH<;:9%A:92P7G%Q81%Q:MM%HQH:3%<42?<<4J3:19%H3%BMJ1<%VH%5:==4<493%:923:3?3:19%38H3 K<HJ3:J42%94?<1K<424<;H3:19X%4IKMH:945%8:2%<4H219:9@%=1<%2?KK1<3:9@%J<719:J2%Q:38%38:2%J8H<3\

$<719:J2 &3%,1<P2 &3%51429j3%Q1<P

+:@9%?K -:;4 l:4G%M124%M:=4%:92?<H9J4

l1%!138:9@ l:4 l:4

B91384<%KH3:493%H3%BMJ1<%Z?23:=:45%8:2%54J:2:19%38?2M7\ kA7%54J:2:19%31%64%=<1_49%Q849%&%5:4%:2

R7%1Q9%H95%91194%4M24j2O &=%:3%51429m3%Q1<PG%21%Q8H3q &mR%HM<4H57%54H5O ,87%5142%:3%RH334<%:=%&

2K495%R7%1Q9%R1947%19%@:;:9@%R724M=%H9%4I3<H%J8H9J4%H3%M:=4qp

#?3%H<4%J<719:J2%1<@H9:_H3:192%3<?M7%@:;:9@%H9%4I3<H%1KK1<3?9:37%31%384:<%JM:4932G%1<%H<4%3847%3HP:9@H5;H93H@4%1=%38124%Q81%5<4HR%31%64%:RR1<3HMq

$<719:J2%:2%6H245%19%H%;:4Q%1=%57:9@%H2%H%K<1J422%38H3%JH9%64%231KK45%:9%384%R:9?342G%H95%K4<8HK2

81?<2G%=1MM1Q:9@%JM:9:JHM%54H38O%&9%.//W%H9%438:J2%546H34%:9%384%R45:JHM%Z1?<9HMG%$<:3:JHM%$H<4G

91345%ot=4Q%:=%H97%KH3:4932%K<191?9J45%54H5%67%315H7m2%K872:J:H92%H<4%:9%=HJ3%3<?M7%54H5%67%H97

2J:493:=:JHMM7%<:@1<1?2%J<:34<:HOp $<719:J2%K<1K19493%)81RH2%l19HM5219%8H2%H<@?45%38H3%o54H38p

6H245%19%JH<5:HJ%H<<423%1<%<42?2J:3H3:19%=H:M?<4%:2%H%K?<4M7%21J:HM%J1923<?J3:19%?245%31%Z?23:=7



34<R:9H3:9@%JH<4%1=%57:9@%KH3:4932O%&9%38:2%;:4QG%M4@HM%54H38%H95%:32%H=34<RH38%H<4%H%=1<R%1=

4?38H9H2:H%:9%Q8:J8%2:JP%K41KM4%H<4%H6H951945O &<19:JHMM7%381?@8G%Q4<4%)84%$<719:J2%&923:3?34j2

KH3:4932%913%54JMH<45%M4@HMM7%54H5%K<:1<%31%64:9@%8H9545%1;4<%31%$O&O%384:<%:95?23<7%Q1?M5%913%64

JHKH6M4%1=%M4@HMM7%4I:23:9@O &9%1<54<%=1<%:923:3?3:192%M:P4%$O&O%31%4I:23%3847%R?23%:934<9HMM7%:92:23%31

384:<%JM:4932%38H3%384:<%KH3:4932%H<4%913 81K4M422M7 54H5%Q8:M4%2:R?M3H941?2M7%3HP:9@%H5;H93H@4%1=

384%=HJ3%38H3%384%MHQ%5142%913%4I3495%<4@?MH3:192%38H3%@1;4<9%4IK4<:R493HM%K<1J45?<42%1<%KH3:493<:@832%H95%K<134J3:192%31%38124%Q81%H<4%M4@HMM7%54J4H245O )84%HJ3%1=%J<719:J%=<44_:9@%64M:42%$O&Om2

:93493:192%H95%64M:4=2%H61?3%384%23H3?2%1=%384%oH9H31R:JHM%@:=32p%38H3%3847%1Q9O

o,8H3%1<@H9:_H3:192%M:P4%BMJ1<%H<4%51:9@%:2%34<<:=7:9@Gp%2H72%l<O%A4M:95H%bH<94<G%H%KH3:493m2

<:@83%HJ3:;:23%H95%6:1438:J:23%H3%*H<61<%g:4Q%A45:JHM%$4934<%:9%+4H33M4O o>MHJ42%M:P4%BMJ1<%H<4

3HP:9@%1Q94<28:K%1=%54H5%K41KM4%H2%H9%H9H31R:JHM%@:=3G%H95%3849%3847%3<4H3%38124%J1<K242%M:P4

3847m<4%913%HJ3?HMM7%54H5O )8424%KMHJ42%H<4%<?9%67%]?HJP2%38H3%H<4%HJ3:;4M7%3HP:9@%H5;H93H@4%1=

K41KM4%H95%RHP:9@%K<1R:242%38H3%3847%JH9m3%=?M=:MMO )84<4%94452%31%64%H%27234R%:9%KMHJ4%38H3

K<134J32%H@H:923%38424%21<32%1=%H6?242O%o

^$1RK:M45%=<1R%)84%!4Q%d1<P4<G%+MH34OJ1Ra



$B+( 0.

`?H9%>4<4_%8H5%231RHJ8%KH:92%=1<%H%R1938%64=1<4%54J:5:9@%31%;:2:3%H%84HM38%JM:9:J%84<4%38H3%:2

1K49%)8?<25H7%9:@832%21%R:@<H93%=H<RQ1<P4<2%519j3%R:22%H%5H7%Q1<P:9@%:9%384%=:4M52O

B2%H9%:MM4@HMG%?9:92?<45%:RR:@<H93G%>4<4_%8H2%8H5%K<16M4R2%:9%384%KH23%n%913%19M7%Q:38%8:2

84HM38G%6?3%Q:38%9H;:@H3:9@%384%"O+O%84HM38%JH<4%RH_4O%&9%A:J8:@H9G%384<4%QH2%91%:934<K<434<%H3%8:2M1JHM%84HM38%JM:9:JG%384%6:MM2%8H5%31%64%KH:5%:9%:923HMMR4932G%H95%J1EQ1<P4<2%QH<945%38H3%H%;:2:3%31%H

51J31<%J1?M5%M4H5%31%54K1<3H3:19O%&9%!1<38%$H<1M:9HG%84j2%=1?95%H%84HM38%JH<4%81R4%H3%):==H97

C4;4M2j%Q44PM7%JM:9:J%n%K<1;:5:9@%84%JH9%8:3J8%H%<:54%384<4O

k)84%6:@@423%J19J4<9%:2%@433:9@%2:JPG%64JH?24%71?%519j3%8H;4%H97194%84<4Gk%>4<4_%2H72%H=34<

C4;4M2G%H%=HR:M7%9?<24%K<HJ3:3:194<%H3%384%=454<HMM7%=?9545%JM:9:JG%K<42J<:642%3Q1%H93:6:13:J2%H95

>4K31E#:2R1M%3H6M432%=1<%8:2%6HJ34<:HM%@H23<:3:2O%kd1?%H<4%84<4%67%71?<24M=Ok

B2%384%546H34%1;4<%384%<42:549J7%23H3?2%1=%384%9H3:19j2%423:RH345%0.%R:MM:19%:MM4@HM%:RR:@<H932

61:M2G%H91384<%6H33M4%:2%2:RR4<:9@%1;4<%Q8H3%n%:=%H97%n%6494=:32%3847%5424<;4%Q8:M4%3847j<4%84<4O

+1R4%1=%384%R123%84H345%H<@?R4932%19%384%:22?4%=1J?2%19%84HM38%JH<4O

k)84%K8<H24%j:MM4@HM%:RR:@<H93j%:2%Z?23%<H5:1HJ3:;4%H3%384%R1R493Gk%2H72%-4:@8319%i?G%H%84HM38

H9HM723%H3%384%M:64<HM%$4934<%19%#?5@43%H95%>1M:J7%><:1<:3:42O%k(==1<32%31%K<1;:54%H55:3:19HM

6494=:32%=1<%384%?951J?R49345%Q1?M5%64%422493:HMM7%K4<J4:;45%H2%H55:9@%=?4M%31%384%=:<4Ok

&MM4@HM%:RR:@<H932%JH9%@43%4R4<@49J7%JH<4%38<1?@8%A45:JH:5G%384%=454<HME23H34%K<1@<HR%=1<%384

K11<%H95%K41KM4%Q:38%5:2H6:M:3:42O%#?3%3847%JH9j3%@43%919E4R4<@49J7%JH<4%?9M422%3847%KH7O%)847

H<4%:94M:@:6M4%=1<%R123%1384<%K?6M:J%6494=:32O

lH3H%19%84HM38%JH<4%J1232%=1<%:MM4@HM%:RR:@<H932%H<4%2P43J87%64JH?24%812K:3HM2%H95%J1RR?9:3784HM38%J4934<2%519j3%H2P%H61?3%KH3:4932j%M4@HM%23H3?2O%&9%$HM:=1<9:HG%H%.//Y%23?57%67%384%h454<H3:19

=1<%BR4<:JH9%&RR:@<H3:19%C4=1<R%K?3%384%23H34j2%H99?HM%J123%H3%N0OY%6:MM:19O%+:R:MH<%23?5:42%:9

$1M1<H51%H95%A:994213H%:9%.//W%JHR4%?K%Q:38%R?J8%2RHMM4<%423:RH342\%NS0%R:MM:19%H95%N0F

R:MM:19G%<42K4J3:;4M7O

'94%38:9@%:2%JM4H<\%"951J?R49345%:RR:@<H932%H<4%5<:;:9@%?K%384%9?R64<%1=%K41KM4%Q:381?3

84HM38%:92?<H9J4O%)84%>4Q%*:2KH9:J%$4934<%423:RH342%38H3%WeT%1=%384%9H3:19j2%:MM4@HM%:RR:@<H932

H<4%?9:92?<45G%J1RKH<45%Q:38%.WT%1=%M4@HM%:RR:@<H932%H95%0YT%1=%"O+O%J:3:_492O%&MM4@HM

:RR:@<H932%<4K<42493%H61?3%0WT%1=%384%9H3:19j2%YF%R:MM:19%?9:92?<45%K41KM4%n%H95%H61?3%S/T%1=

384%:9J<4H24%2:9J4%0e[/O

+3H34Q:54G%:MM4@HM%:RR:@<H932%HJJ1?9345%=1<%194%:9%=1?<%94Q%<42:54932%=<1R%0ee/%31%.//YG

HJJ1<5:9@%31%H%"9:;4<2:37%1=%!1<38%$H<1M:9H%23?57O%)84%23H34%<H9P2%9:938%:9%384%9H3:19%=1<%:MM4@HM

:RR:@<H932%Q:38%R1<4%38H9%S//G///G%HJJ1<5:9@%31%384%>4Q%*:2KH9:J%$4934<O

h1<%812K:3HM2G%k384%6?<549%1=%384%?9:92?<45%:RR:@<H93%:2%8?@4Gk%2H72%`4==%+KH54G%;:J4%K<42:5493%1=

384%!1<38%$H<1M:9H%*12K:3HM%B221J:H3:19O%k&3j2%4IKM1545%384%HR1?93%1=%Q1<P%38H3%3847%8H;4%31

51Ok



'KK194932%1=%:MM4@HM%:RR:@<H3:19%244%84HM38%JH<4%H2%H%6494=:3%38H3%:MM4@HM%:RR:@<H932%519j3

5424<;4%n%H95%38H3%3HIKH74<2%JH9j3%H==1<5O

+34;49%$HRH<13H%1=%384%J1924<;H3:;4%$4934<%=1<%&RR:@<H3:19%+3?5:42%2H72%1==4<:9@%919E

4R4<@49J7%A45:JH:5%31%:MM4@HM%:RR:@<H932%Q1?M5%64%R1<4%4IK492:;4%38H9%M4H;:9@%384R?9:92?<45%H95%:9%9445%1=%1JJH2:19HM%812K:3HM%JH<4O%&9%38124%JH242G%812K:3HM2%M124%R1947G%H95

3HIKH74<2%K:JP%?K%384%3H6O

k(:384<%71?%49=1<J4%384%MHQ%H95%519j3%8H;4%21%RH97%:MM4@HM2G%1<%71?%28?3%?K%H61?3%384%J123Gk%84

2H72O

,8:M4%23H34%@1;4<9R4932G%$19@<422G%384%#?28%H5R:9:23<H3:19%H95%K<42:5493:HM%JH95:5H342%Q<423M4

Q:38%81Q%31%K<1;:54%84HM38%J1;4<H@4%31%?9:92?<45%BR4<:JH92G%:MM4@HM%:RR:@<H932%<4M7%19%H

KH3J8Q1<P%1=%=454<HMM7%=?9545%J1RR?9:37%84HM38%J4934<2G%Q8:J8%J8H<@4%M:33M4%=1<%6H2:J%24<;:J42

H95%519j3%244P%K<11=%1=%J:3:_4928:KO%h1<%R45:J:94G%3847%1=349%<4M7%19%=<44%K<42J<:K3:19%2HRKM42%1<

1;4<E384EJ1?934<%5<?@2O

h<1R%.//0%31%.//YG%2K495:9@%=1<%4R4<@49J7%A45:JH:5%=1<%:MM4@HM%:RR:@<H932%<124%67%.[T%:9

!1<38%$H<1M:9HG%2H:5%H%AH<J8%.//F%H<3:JM4%:9%384 ./*0+1!2/#2&,$23'$0"41+25$)"41!2366/4"1&"/+O

C424H<J84<2%J:345%:9J<4H242%:9%J8:M56:<38%H95%K<49H3HM%JH<4G%H2%Q4MM%H2%:9Z?<:42%H95%J8<19:J%5:24H24

J1RKM:JH3:192O

B3%384%23H34%H95%M1JHM%M4;4MG%:MM4@HM%:RR:@<H932%HM<4H57%J123%R1<4%:9%K?6M:J%24<;:J42%2?J8%H2

45?JH3:19%H95%84HM38%JH<4%38H9%3847%KH7%:9%3HI42G%384%$19@<422:19HM%#?5@43%'==:J4%<4K1<345

<4J493M7O%&MM4@HM%:RR:@<H932%RHP4%?K%M422%38H9%WT%1=%384%J123%:9%R123%23H342G%6?3%JM124<%31%0/T%:9

21R4%$HM:=1<9:H%J1?93:42O%&9%.///G%J1?93:42%HM19@%384%A4I:JH9%61<54<%M123%R1<4%38H9%N[//R:MM:19%:9%84HM38%JH<4%24<;:J42%=1<%Q8:J8%3847%Q4<4%913%KH:5f%H61?3%.WT%1=%38H3%Q493%31%JH<4%=1<

:MM4@HM%:RR:@<H932G%HJJ1<5:9@%31%H%<4K1<3%67%384%"9:345%+3H342UA4I:J1%#1<54<%$1?93:42

$1HM:3:19O

&9%!1<38%$H<1M:9Hj2%<?<HM%l?KM:9%$1?937G%R1<4%38H9%194%:9%=1?<%K41KM4%H<4%?9:92?<45O%)84%H<4Hj2

Z16%@<1Q38%:2%:9%M1QEQH@4%H@<:6?2:9422%n%kKM?JP:9@%J8:JP492%H95%@?33:9@%81@2Gk%2H72%b<4@

#1?952G%J8:4=%4I4J?3:;4%1==:J4<%1=%b12849%A45:JHM%$4934<G%384%H<4Hj2%MH<@423%@<1?K%1=%J1RR?9:37

84HM38%J4934<2O%#?2:942242%9445%384%:9=M?I%1=%:MM4@HM%:RR:@<H932%31%3HP4%8H<5E31E=:MM%Z162G%6?3

812K:3HM2%M124%R1947%Q849%384%Q1<P4<2%9445%4R4<@49J7%JH<4O

"93:M%<4J493M7G%R123%:MM4@HM%:RR:@<H932%84<4%8H5%194%84HM38%JH<4%23<H34@7O%k)847%Z?23%Q4<49j3@433:9@%JH<4%64=1<4Gk%#1?952%2H72O%k)847%Q4<4%Z?23%2?==4<:9@%H95%57:9@Ok

^+1?<J4\%`H9?H<7%..G%.//[O%"+B%)15H7G 833K\UUQQQO?2H315H7OJ1RU94Q2UQH28:9@319U

.//[E/0E.0E:RR:@<H93E84HM38JH<4u!O83Ra



$B+(%0S

)84%9?<242%H3%"9:;4<2:37%812K:3HM%Q4<4%281Q:9@%HMM%384%2:@92%1=%K<1=422:19HM%6?<91?3%L%:<<:3H6:M:37G

=H3:@?4G%H95%:RKH3:49J4O 'Q:9@%31%384%Q1<23%9?<2:9@%281<3H@4%:9%8:231<7G%:9J<4H2:9@M7%:MM%H95

=<H@:M4%KH3:4932G%H95%384%oH@:9@p%1=%384%9?<2:9@%23H==%H2%H%Q81M4%<42?M3:9@%:9%H%9?R64<%1=

<43:<4R4932G%384%9?<242%Q81%Q4<4%M4=3%H3%384%6452:54%Q4<4%23<43J845%647195%384:<%M:R:32O B%MH<@4

9?R64<%1=%384%812K:3HMm2%../%9?<242%R43%31%5:2J?22%384:<%5:M4RRHO

'94%1=%384%9?<242G%B994%C164<32G%CO!OG%23H345G

,4%H<4%H3%384%K1:93%Q84<4%1?<%4I8H?23:19%:2%@1:9@%31%H==4J3%KH3:493%Q4M=H<4O B55:3:19HMM7G%&

519m3%38:9P%H97%1=%?2%JH9%J193:9?4%31%3HP4%38:2%R?J8%23<422O%&%38:9P%Q4%8H;4%31%3HP4%H%23H95G

54RH95%H%2HMH<7%:9J<4H24%J1RR492?<H34%Q:38%384%Q1<P%Q4%H<4%64:9@%H2P45%31%51G%H95%H2P%=1<

H9%:9J<4H24%:9%=?MM%3:R4%K12:3:192%19%384%6?2:423%?9:32O

B91384<%9?<24%H5545G%o&=%Q4%8H;4%31G%&%38:9P%Q4%281?M5%@1%19%23<:P4Op%B=34<%J192:54<H6M4

5:2J?22:19G%384%RHZ1<:37%1=%384%9?<242%J19J?<<45O A2O%C164<32%QH2 913 H2%J4<3H:9%H61?3%384%23<:P4

H2%Q4<4%84<%J1MM4H@?42O

)84%?9:19%K<4249345%384:<%54RH952%31%384%812K:3HM%H5R:9:23<H3:19O )84%812K:3HM

H5R:9:23<H3:19%QH2%]?:34%J19J4<945%H61?3%384%9?<242m%38<4H3%31%23<:P4%:=%384:<%54RH952%Q4<4%913

R43O%BM381?@8%384%9?<242%Q4<4%<4]?:<45%31%@:;4%384%812K:3HM%349%5H72%913:J4%31%K<4KH<4%=1<%H

23<:P4G%38H3%QH2%913%H%M13%1=%3:R4%31%3<H92=4<%384%812K:3HMm2%2:JP423%KH3:4932O A2O%C164<32%QH3J845

Q:38%@<1Q:9@%J19J4<9%H2%:3%HKK4H<45%H%23<:P4%QH2%:RR:9493O +84%381?@83%H%23<:P4%R:@83%1<%R:@83

913%64%4==4J3:;4%:9%J8H9@:9@%384%H5R:9:23<H3:19m2%R:95O &9%1384<%23H342%Q84<4%9?<242%8H5%oQHMP45

1?3Gp%384%812K:3HM2%8H5%R4<4M7%8:<45%<4@:234<45%9?<242%Q81%Q4<4%Q:MM:9@%31%J<122%384%23<:P4%_194O

+84%8H5%84H<5%38H3%38424%<4KMHJ4R493%9?<242%21R43:R42%RH54%?KQH<52%1=%NWG///%51MMH<2%K4<

Q44PO +84%P94Q%1=%194%23<:P4%38H3%MH2345%R1<4%38H9%H%R1938O '94%38:9@%QH2%J4<3H:9\%384%23<:P4

8H5%384%K13493:HM%1=%4IK12:9@%H%2?623H93:HM%9?R64< 1= KH3:4932 31 :9J19;49:49J4%H95%K4<8HK2%4;49J192:54<H6M4%<:2PO *1Q4;4<G%38:9@2%J1?M5%913%J193:9?4%384%QH7%3847%8H5%6449%@1:9@O A2O

C164<32%QH2%913%J4<3H:9%Q8H3%284%Q1?M5%51%L%23H7%1<%23<:P4O

^+1?<J4\ $H24%+3?5:42%:9%#:1R45:JHM%(38:J2%l4J:2:19EAHP:9@G%><:9J:KM42G%H95%$H242%C164<3%AO

g4H3J8G%BR7%AO%*H55H5 H95 lH9%$O%(9@M:28 `H9%.//ea



$B+(%0Y

&3m2%H%37K:JHM%5H7%:9%384%(C%Q849%$H<34<%=:952%1?3%84%8H2%6449%H22:@945%31%K<4J4K3%H%94Q%@<1?K%1=

4IJ:345%R45:JHM%23?54932%H22:@945%31%384:<%(C%<13H3:19O%)84%23?54932%H<4%HQH:3:9@%384:<%KH3:493

H22:@9R4932%Q849%H%KH<HR45:J%J<4Q%6?<232%38<1?@8%384%511<%Q:38%H%R:55M4EH@45%RH9

J1RKMH:9:9@%1=%J8423%KH:9O%$H<34<%3?<92%:RR45:H34M7%31%384%KH3:493G%=:<:9@%1==%]?423:192%H61?3%8:2JH<5:HJ%<:2P%=HJ31<2O%,849%H2P45%81Q%RH97%84H<3%H33HJP2%84%8H2%8H5%:9%384%KH23G%384%KH3:493

<42K1952G%o71?%R4H9%:9JM?5:9@%384%194%&mR%8H;:9@%<:@83%91Qqp%)84%KH3:493%:2%R45:JHMM7

23H6:M:_45%Q:38%9:3<1@M7J4<:9%H95%1I7@49%H95%384%23?54932%2J?<<7%1==%31%:934<;:4Q%384:<%KH3:4932O

$H<34<m2%28:=3%51429m3%@1%;4<7%Q4MM%542K:34%84MK%=<1R%384%4H@4<%23?54932O%*4%:2%?<@493M7

2?RR1945%6HJP%31%384%<11R%1=%384%J8423%KH:9%KH3:493%Q81%8H2%H%J154%6M?4%VJH<5:1K?MR19H<7

H<<423XO%*4%64@:92%31%<42?2J:3H34%384%KH3:493%19M7%31%64%:934<<?K345%67%$H<<:4%Q81%8H2%3HP49%H

K8194%JHMM%:9%$H<34<m2%H6249J4%<4MH7:9@%384%94Q2%1=%8:2%@<H95R1384<m2%54H38O%+84%3<:42%31%@43%8:2

H33493:19%6?3%$H<34<%:93492:=:42%8:2%HJ3:;:37O%(;493?HMM7%$H<34<%M11P2%?K%H3%$H<<:4%H95%284%2H72G

o&mR%21<<7G%:3m2%71?<%@<H95R1384<G%284%5:45Op%,:381?3%R:22:9@%H%64H3G%$H<34<%54=3M7%R1;42%H<1?95

384%KH3:493%@:;:9@%R45:JH3:19%1<54<2%H95%=:<:9@%?K%384%54=:6<:MMH31<O%)84%R45:JHM%23?54932%QH3J8:9%HQ4%6?3%194%<4RH<P2G%o:=%71?%519m3%@43%8:R%6HJP%H=34<%S%281JP2G%8:2%J8H9J4%1=%2?<;:;HM%:2

_4<1Op%$H<34<%<42K1952G%oQ4MM%QH3J8%R4p%H95%H334RK32%54=:6<:MMH3:19%H@H:9G%38:2%3:R4%Q:38%384

<43?<9%1=%384%KH3:493m2%84H<3%64H3O%B%9?<24%1624<;42%38H3%384%KH3:493m2%K?K:M2%H<4%o=:I45%H95

5:MH345p%:95:JH3:9@%M:P4M7%6<H:9%54H38%H=34<%H%K<1M19@45%<42?2J:3H3:19O%*4%:22?42%H%=4Q%=:9HM%1<54<2

H95%3849%M4H;42%384%<11R%H6<?K3M7%31%54HM%Q:38%8:2%1Q9%4R13:19HM%H9@?:28O

$H<34<%3<:42%31%5:2493H9@M4%8:R24M=%=<1R%8:2%(C%<42K192:6:M:3:42%21%84%JH9%54HM%Q:38%8:2%1Q9%@<:4=

H95%244%8:2%=HR:M7%R4R64<2O%*4%<4H22:@92%384%R45:JHM%23?54932%31%C1RH91O%'9%8:2%QH7%1?3%1=%384

(CG%$H<34<%QHMP2%KH23%384%<42?2J:3H3:19%<11R%Q84<4%384%23?54932%8H;4%2?:345%?K%:9%234<:M4%@1Q92

H95%H<4%K<HJ3:J:9@%:9;H2:;4%K<1J45?<42%19%384%<42?2J:3H345%KH3:493%Q81%<4RH:92%19%M:=4E2?KK1<3OC1RH91%:2%6H<P:9@%=<1R%384%2:54M:942G%o&=%71?%519m3%M4H<9%31%51%38:2%91QG%71?mMM%94;4<%64%H6M4%31

2H;4%H97194Op%$H<34<%:2%=?<:1?2%H95%1<54<2%384R%31%231KO%o)8:2%:2%913%H%JH5H;4<%MH6p%84%281?32O

C1RH91%<431<32%38H3%384%KH3:493%Q:MM%5:4%H97QH7%6?3%84%M4H52%384%2844K:28%23?54932%1?3%1=%384

<11RO%)84%JH<5:HJ%R19:31<%281Q2%38H3%384<4%:2%91%M19@4<%H%84H<3%64H3%H95%H%54Z4J345%H95

4I8H?2345%$H<34<%3?<92%1==%384%M:=4%2?KK1<3%27234R2O

,:381?3%H54]?H34%3<H:9:9@%1KK1<3?9:3:42G%R45:JHM%23?54932%H95%<42:5493%K872:J:H92%JH9913

64J1R4%J1RK43493%:9%K4<=1<R:9@%R45:JHM%K<1J45?<42O%)8:2%:2%42K4J:HMM7%3<?4%:9%384%JH24%1=%M:=4E

2H;:9@%K<1J45?<42%5?<:9@%H%R45:JHM%<42?2J:3H3:19%Q84<4%384%1KK1<3?9:3:42%=1<%K<HJ3:J4%RH7%64%=4Q

H95%=H<%643Q449%H95%384%8:@8423%M4;4M%1=%2P:MM%:2%944545%31%K<1;:54%384%6423%J8H9J4%=1<%2?JJ422%H95

31%R:9:R:_4%H97%8H<R%31%384%KH3:493O%-:=4E2H;:9@%K<1J45?<42%Q8:J8%J1RR19M7%=HMM%:931%38:2JH34@1<7%H<4%49513<HJ84HM%:93?6H3:19G%J493<HM%;491?2%JH38434<%KMHJ4R493G%;491?2%J?351Q9G

K4<:JH<5:1J49342:2G%:93<H12241?2%JH38434<%KMHJ4R493G%381<HJ1231R7%3?64%KMHJ4R493G

J<:J1387<131R7G%H95%381<HJ131R7%Q:38%J<122EJMHRK:9@%1=%384%H1<3HO%)84%MH334<%3Q1%K<1J45?<42%H<4

94;4<%K4<=1<R45%19%H%919E4R4<@493%6H2:2O%$4<3H:9%R45:JHM%2K4J:HM3:42%2?J8%H2%4R4<@49J7

R45:J:94G%J<:3:JHM%JH<4G%H95%9419H31M1@7G%8H;4%384%@<4H3423%9445%=1<%K<HJ3:J4%1KK1<3?9:3:42%5?4%31

384%M:P4M:8115%1=%8H;:9@%31%K4<=1<R%38424%K<1J45?<42%:9%K<HJ3:J4O



&9%21R4%2:3?H3:192G%<42:54932%H95%R45:JHM%23?54932%RH7%M4H<9%31%K4<=1<R%M:=4E2H;:9@%K<1J45?<42

19%H%K4<219%Q81%8H2%5:45%;4<7%<4J493M7%V94QM7%54J4H245XG%K4<8HK2%:RR45:H34M7%H=34<%H9

?92?JJ422=?M%<42?2J:3H3:19%Q849%384%KH3:493%8H2%6449%K<191?9J45%54H5O%)8:2%3<H:9:9@%R43815%8H2

6449%K<1K1245%67%21R4%R45:JHM%45?JH31<2%H2%1K3:RHM%=1<%24;4<HM%<4H2192O%h:<23G%H=34<%54H38G%384

KH3:493%:2%91%M19@4<%4IK1245%31%H55:3:19HM%8H<R%1<%<:2PO%+4J195G%64=1<4%<:@1<%R1<3:2%2432%:9G%384

3:22?42%1=%384%6157%Q:MM%<4RH:9%KM:H6M4%H95%6423%HKK<1I:RH34%384%J195:3:192%?954<%Q8:J8%384 K<1J45?<4%:2%91<RHMM7%5194O%)8:2%8H2%6449%H<@?45%31%64%42K4J:HMM7%3<?4%=1<%384%2P:MM%1=

49513<HJ84HM%:93?6H3:19G%Q84<4%JH5H;4<%H95%RH9:P:9%R154M2%=1<%3<H:9:9@%8H;4%913%6449%=1?95%31

64%H2%?24=?MO%h:9HMM7G%384%2?K4<;:2:19%H95%34HJ8:9@%1=%384%K<1J45?<4%JH9%64%5194%?954<%M422

23<422=?M%J195:3:192%21%384%J8H9J4%=1<%2?JJ422%:2%RHI:R:_45O

$?<<493M7G%384<4%H<4%RH97%3<H:9:9@%:923:3?3:192%Q8:J8%HMM1Q%384%K<HJ3:J4%1=%M:=4E2H;:9@%K<1J45?<42

19%384%94QM7%54J4H245O%B%0eeY%2?<;47%1=%4R4<@49J7%R45:J:94%H95%H5?M3%H95%K45:H3<:J%J<:3:JHM

JH<4%3<H:9:9@%K<1@<HR2%:95:JH345%38H3%SeT%?245%38:2%R43815%=1<%34HJ8:9@%<42?2J:3H3:19

K<1J45?<42O%(R4<@49J7%R45:J:94%H95%9419H31M1@7%K<1@<HR2%?245%:3%R123%J1RR19M7%H95%3<HJ84HM

:93?6H3:19%QH2%384%R123%J1RR19%K<1J45?<4%K4<=1<R45O

^+1?<J4\%`:MM%AO%#H<49%#:1438:J2O943a



$B+( 0W

)4H<2%Q4MM%?K%:9%>O%b?9Hj2%4742%H2%84%23H<42%H3%H%M19@%2JH<%<?99:9@%51Q9%8:2%2:54O%B%74H<%H@1G%84

H334RK345%31%23H;4%1==%R1?93:9@%5463%67%2QHKK:9@%194%1=%8:2%84HM387%P:59472%=1<%]?:JP%JH28O

k*?RH92%519j3%9445%3Q1%P:59472G%&%QH2%RH54%31%64M:4;4Gk%84%2H:5O%k&%JH9%24MM%R7%4I3<H%P:5947

H95%64J1R4%<:J8G%&%381?@83Ok

B3%384%3:R4G%H9%1<@H9%3<H54<%K<1R:245%b?9HG%S[G%H%R131<:_45E<:JP28HQ%5<:;4<%Q:38%H%=1?<38E@<H54

45?JH3:19G%N.GW//%=1<%384%P:5947G%1=%Q8:J8%84%4;493?HMM7%<4J4:;45%19M7%8HM=O%+:9J4%3849G%84%8H2

4IK4<:49J45%4IJ<?J:H3:9@%KH:9%:9%8:2%8:K%38H3%8H2%P4K3%8:R%=<1R%Q1<P:9@%=?MM%3:R4%H95%K?2845

8:R%544K4<%:9%5463O

&9%<4J493%74H<2G%RH97%&95:H9%J:3:42%E%M:P4%$8499H:%:9%21?384<9%&95:H%E%8H;4%64J1R4%8?62%1=%H

R?<P7%6?2:9422%:9%P:5947%3<H92KMH932G%542K:34%H%0eeY%9H3:19Q:54%6H9%19%8?RH9%1<@H9%2HM42%V384

)<H92KMH93%1=%*?RH9%'<@H9%BJ3%23H342%19M7%<4MH3:;42%1=%KH3:4932%JH9%519H34%P:59472XO

B9%:9=M?I%1=%KH3:4932G%RH:9M7%=1<4:@94<2G%244P:9@%384%3<H92KMH932G%8H2%RH54%384%:MM:J:3%RH<P43%H

M?J<H3:;4%6?2:9422O%+1R4%H9HM7232%2H7%384%6?2:9422%38<:;42%=1<%384%2HR4%<4H2192%38H3%8H;4%RH54

&95:H%H%31K%5423:9H3:19%=1<%R45:JHM%31?<:2R\%M1Q%J123%H95%]?HM:=:45%51J31<2O%&9%=HJ3G%R45:JHM

31?<:2R%:2%4IK4J345%31%<4HJ8%N.O.%6:MM:19%67%./0.G%HJJ1<5:9@%31%@1;4<9R493%423:RH342O

!13%2?<K<:2:9@M7G%H9%1<@H9:_45%@<1?K%1=%1<@H9%3<H54<2%:9%JH81132%Q:38%?92J<?K?M1?2%51J31<2%:2

J1923H93M7%19%384%K<1QM%=1<%5191<2%M:P4%b?9HO

&9%b?<@H19G%H%K128%!4Q%l4M8:%2?6?<6G%K1M:J4%MH23%R1938%6?2345%H9%:MM4@HM%1<@H9%<HJP43G%Q8:J8

:9JM?545%51J31<2G%9?<242G%KH381M1@7%JM:9:J2%H95%812K:3HM2O%&9%384%KH23%0Y%74H<2G%384%KH<3:J:KH932

HMM4@45M7%<4R1;45%P:59472%=<1R%H61?3%W//%5H7%MH61<4<2G%384%RHZ1<:37%1=%384R%H65?J345%1<

J19945G%64=1<4%24MM:9@%384%1<@H92%31%Q4HM387%JM:4932O

>1M:J4%2H7%384%51J31<%64M:4;45%31%64%384%RH234<R:95%648:95%384%1K4<H3:19G%BR:3%i?RH<G%24H<J845

=1<%5191<2%67%J<?:2:9@%:9%M?I?<7%JH<2%1?3=:3345%Q:38%R45:JHM%3423:9@%RHJ8:942G%H95%P4K3

21K8:23:JH345%2?<@:JHM%4]?:KR493%:9%H%<42:5493:HM%HKH<3R493O%&9%8:2%1==:J4G%K1M:J4%=1?95%M4334<2%H95

4ERH:M%R422H@42%=<1R%Y[%K41KM4%=<1R%9:94%J1?93<:42%:9]?:<:9@%H61?3%3<H92KMH932O

!4KHM424%H?381<:3:42%2H7%3847%Q19j3%4I3<H5:34%i?RH<%?93:M%3847%=:9:28%H9%:9;423:@H3:19%19%Q84384<

84%;:1MH345%J?<<49J7%MHQ2%67%913%54JMH<:9@%N.S/G///%:9%JH28%H95%H%J84JP%=1<%N.YG///%38H3%84%QH2

JH<<7:9@%Q849%H<<42345O%*4%:2%2J845?M45%31%HKK4H<%:9%H%!4KHM424%J1?<3%+?95H7O

&9%H91384<%8:@8EK<1=:M4%H<<423G%H%<491Q945%$8499H:%2?<@419G%>HMH9:%CH;:J8H95<H9G%QH2%H<<42345:9%'J3164<%:9%A?R6H:%=1<%:9;1M;4R493%:9%H%P:5947%<HJP43O%*4%H5R:3345%31%H<<H9@:9@%1<@H9

3<H92KMH932%=1<%Q4HM387%=1<4:@94<2%E%RH:9M7%=<1R%>4<2:H9%b?M=%23H342%H95%AHMH72:HG%Q81R%84

J8H<@45%?K%31%N.WG///O%A?R6H:%K1M:J4%2H7%CH;:J8H95<H9%8H5%K4<=1<R45%643Q449%Y/%H95%0//

:MM4@HM%3<H92KMH932%2:9J4%.//.O



'9%)8?<25H7G%K1M:J4%H<<42345%i?RH<%:9%$8:3QH9G%H%!4KHM424%Z?9@M4%<421<3O%-1JHM%94Q2%<4K1<32

2H:5%84%QH2%:5493:=:45%67%H%8134M%4RKM1744%Q81%<4J1@9:_45%8:R%=<1R%&95:H9%34M4;:2:19

6<1H5JH232%2449%:9%!4KHMO%k&%8H;4%913%5?K45%H976157Gk%i?RH<%MH34<%31M5%<4K1<34<2%:9%iH38RH95?G

HJJ1<5:9@%31%384%B221J:H345%><422O

>1M:J4%2H7%P:5947%5191<2%JH9%4H<9%643Q449%N0G.W/%H95%N.GW//G%Q8:M4%<4J:K:4932%KH7%H2%R?J8%H2N.WG///G%HJJ1<5:9@%31%BJ3:19B:5%&95:HG%H9%H93:EK1;4<37%1<@H9:_H3:19%38H3%8H2%Q1<P45%Q:38%P:5947

3<H54%;:J3:R2%:9%384%21?384<9%23H34%1=%)HR:M%!H5?O

)84%2HR4%K<1J45?<4%JH9%J123%H2%R?J8%H2%NF/G///%:9%$8:9H%H95%N[WG///%:9%384%"9:345%+3H342O

k)8424%R:55M4R49%HJ3%R1<4%M:P4%J?3EH95E@<H6%R49%Q8124%19M7%:934<423%:2%31%8HJP%1?3%384%1<@H9Gk

2H:5%B99:4%)81RH2G%H%=:4M5%J1EJ11<5:9H31<%=1<%BJ3:19B:5%:9%$8499H:G%=1<R4<M7%P91Q9%H2%AH5<H2O

k)8:2%:2%H%<4K<48492:6M4%H6?24%1=%384%K11<G%H95%38:2%K<HJ3:J4%94452%31%64%J?<645Ok

)81RH2%2H72%RH97%R:55M4R49%37K:JHMM7%RH2]?4<H54%384%5191<2%H2%<4MH3:;42%31%J:<J?R;493%384

MHQ%Q8:M4%RH97%=1<4:@94<2%:9%9445%1=%H%P:5947%H<<:;4%19%31?<:23%;:2H2%<H384<%38H9%384%<4]?:<45

R45:JHM%;:2H2f%21R4%<421<3%31%=HM24%51J?R4932O

^+1?<J4\%+H9%h<H9J:2J1%$8<19:JM4%h46<?H<7%/eG%.//[%833K\UUH<3:JM42O2=@H34OJ1RU.//[E/.E/eU94Q2U

0F0Y0..Fu0uP:59472E3<H92KMH932ER45:JHME31?<:2RU.a

Documents

bioethics cases 2010