Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
BID TALLY AND ATTENDANCE SHEET Page 1 of 2
BID TITLE: PN#9321 COUNTY ROAD 25E ‘REDSTONE CANYON’ FLOOD RECOVERY PROJECT BID #B16-11
DATE: 11/17/2016 TIME: 2:00 P.M. DEPARTMENT: ENGINEERING
VENDOR Proposal
Form
Anti-Collusion Affidavit
Certificate of Intent to
Sublet
Bid Bond
Revised Bid Schedule - Rev. #1
Cost
Flatiron Constructors, Inc. Y Y Y Y $2,500,518.25
Mountain Constructors Inc. Y Y Y Y $2,673,173.25
Dietzler Construction Corporation Y Y Y Y $2,694,171.00
ESCO Construction Co Y Y Y Y $2,696,619.75
Zak Dirt, Inc. Y Y Y Y $2,712,257.00
American Civic Constructors LLC (dba Mountain West) Y Y Y Y $2,802,855.00
Connell Resources Inc. Y Y Y Y $2,866,038.60
Lawrence Construction Company Y Y Y Y $2,944,000.00
Walsh Construction Y Y Y Y $3,094,404.50
Simon Contractors Y Y Y Y $3,280,830.75
Myers & Sons Construction LP Y Y Y Y $3,340,430.00
Structures Inc. Y Y Y Y $3,395,764.61
Duran Excavating Inc. Y Y Y Y $3,474,698.00
Western States Reclamation Inc. Y Y Y Y $3,671,439.10
SEMA Construction, Inc. Y Y Y Y $4,282,666.50
Rock & Company Inc. Y Y Y Y $4,362,635.91
Engineering Estimate = $3,205,500.00
BID TALLY AND ATTENDANCE SHEET Page 2 of 2
BID TITLE: PN#9321 COUNTY ROAD 25E ‘REDSTONE CANYON’ FLOOD RECOVERY PROJECT BID #B16-11
DATE: 11/17/2016 TIME: 2:00 P.M. DEPARTMENT: ENGINEERING
PEOPLE WHO ATTENDED BID OPENING
VENDOR NAME
Les Brown, Purchasing Agent Larimer County Purchasing Department
Whitney Wilson, Purchasing Department Specialist Larimer County Purchasing Department
John Butcher - Project Engineer American Civil Constructors
Royce Fertig Simon Contractors
Preston Petty Lawrence Construction Company
Robert Cline Structures, Inc.
Tina Hart Zak Dirt, Inc.
Scott Davis Rock & Company
Kyla Hines Walsh Construction Inc.
Tyler Amen Western States Reclamation, Inc.
Dan Giesler Connell Resources, Inc.
Joe Kuntz Mountain Constructors
Jeff Petsche Dietzler Construction
Nancy Guerrero SEMA Construction, Inc.
Gabrial Routzahn Larimer County Engineering
Justin Henkel Flatiron Constructors
Devin Duran Duran Excavating
Sean Weddingfeld Myers & Sons Construction
Rob Murphy ESCO Construction
Flatiron
Constructors
Project No-Phase 9321-1 PW378 (LARC015) Permanent Repairs CR 025E (Redstone Rd) MP 4.73-10.3
Mountain
Constructors
Dietzler
Construction
ESCO
Construction
Zak Dirt American CivilRef
No.
Ref
No.
Item
No. Item DescriptionApprox.
Quan. Unit
Project Bid Unit Price Comparison
:
Bid Opening: 17-Nov-16Page 1
201 Clearing and Grubbing 1 LS 10,000.00 $19,000.00 20,000.001 13,650.00 15,000.00 12,500.00 1
202 Rmvl of Structs & Obstns 1 LS 5,000.00 $2,500.00 20,000.002 2,030.00 3,500.00 5,000.00 2
202 Removal of Pipe 6 EA 400.00 $1,100.00 2,000.003 2,310.00 750.00 2,250.00 3
202 Removal of Fence 210 LF 3.25 $3.50 6.004 3.28 2.00 3.00 4
203 Uncl Exc (Cmpl In Place) 1360 CY 15.00 $15.00 12.005 21.50 18.00 22.00 5
203 Muck Excavation (CIP) 203 TON 15.00 $37.00 10.006 32.40 73.00 58.00 6
203 Rock Excavation (CIP) 3505 CY 32.00 $27.00 40.007 36.00 38.00 39.00 7
203 Blading 32 HR 100.00 $126.00 125.008 185.00 130.00 140.00 8
203 Detour Construction 3 EA 25,000.00 $10,000.00 50,000.009 11,420.00 16,000.00 16,000.00 9
206 Structure Excavation (CIP) 935 CY 30.00 $20.00 20.0010 37.40 22.50 30.00 10
206 Struct Backfill (Special) 425 CY 55.00 $80.00 20.0011 93.00 64.00 90.00 11
207 Topsoil 125 CY 5.00 $18.00 10.0012 12.10 19.00 25.00 12
207 Stockpile Topsoil 125 CY 5.00 $18.00 10.0013 12.10 13.00 19.00 13
208 Erosion Log (12) 635 LF 5.00 $5.00 4.0014 3.89 4.00 4.20 14
208 Erosion Control Supervisor 1 LS 100.00 $7,500.00 5,000.0015 8,710.00 6,500.00 6,000.00 15
304 ABC (Class 5) 1995 TON 40.00 $35.00 30.0016 35.60 31.00 43.00 16
420 Geotextile (E.C.)(Class A) 445 SY 3.50 $3.00 3.0017 3.15 4.00 6.00 17
506 Riprap (6") 140 CY 150.00 $124.00 85.0018 183.50 113.00 67.00 18
506 Riprap (12") 80 CY 95.00 $135.00 90.0019 68.60 130.00 65.00 19
506 Riprap (18") 220 CY 95.00 $139.00 95.0020 35.00 132.00 65.00 20
506 Riprap (24") 275 CY 95.00 $145.00 100.0021 42.30 120.00 65.00 21
601 Concrete Cl D (Wall) 66 CY 700.00 $925.00 1,150.0022 1,330.00 1,035.00 700.00 22
601 Structural Conc. Coating 210 SY 12.50 $20.00 45.0023 40.60 38.00 19.00 23
602 Re-Steel (Epoxy Coated) 12280 LB 1.25 $1.75 1.4024 2.45 1.50 1.20 24
603 36" Corr Steel Pipe (CIP) 85 LF 200.00 $112.00 20.0025 90.20 90.00 55.00 25
603 20 x 6 Ft CBC (Precast) 176 LF 1,500.00 $1,920.00 1,900.0026 1,940.00 1,720.00 2,000.00 26
607 Fence BW W/ Metal Posts 525 LF 8.50 $10.00 10.0027 6.80 9.25 3.00 27
607 Fence Barbed Wire (Temp) 540 LF 5.50 $6.00 10.0028 6.45 6.65 3.00 28
607 End Post 12 EA 181.00 $210.00 50.0029 275.50 200.00 300.00 29
607 Corner & Line Brace Post 35 EA 227.00 $265.00 50.0030 311.50 250.00 300.00 30
620 Field Office (Class 1) 1 EA 20,000.00 $13,000.00 10,000.0031 7,450.00 14,200.00 19,900.00 31
620 Sanitary Facility 4 EA 125.00 $720.00 750.0032 348.50 400.00 2,000.00 32
625 Construction Surveying 1 LS 13,000.00 $13,400.00 15,000.0033 28,840.00 7,700.00 17,500.00 33
626 Mobilization 1 LS 106,000.00 $83,000.00 15,000.0034 34,930.00 66,500.00 130,000.00 34
630 Const.Traffic Control 1 LS 9,300.00 $24,000.00 5,000.0035 10,460.00 10,500.00 8,000.00 35
630 Flagging 220 HR 19.00 $25.00 26.0036 20.90 21.00 36.00 36
630 Traffic Control Management 90 DAY 413.00 $350.00 100.0037 465.00 465.00 495.00 37
630 Traf Control Inspection 90 DAY 104.00 $300.00 100.0038 116.00 116.00 95.00 38
700 F/A MCR 1 FA 150,000.00 $150,000.00 150,000.0039 150,000.00 150,000.00 150,000.00 39
Number of Bids: 16
Number of Contract Days: 150
Total Bid:
% Eng. Estimate:
$1,157,054.50 $1,227,808.00 $1,205,097.00 $1,230,761.90 $1,193,318.75 $1,311,492.00
Engineer's Estimate Total Cost: 1,465,206.15
78.97% 83.80% 82.25% 84.00% 81.44% 89.51%
FEMA SITESProject Bid Unit Price Comparison
Connell
Resources
Project No-Phase 9321-1 PW378 (LARC015) Permanent Repairs CR 025E (Redstone Rd) MP 4.73-10.3
Lawrence
Construction
Walsh
Construction
Simon
Contractors
Myers & Sons
Construction
StructuresRef
No.
Ref
No.
Item
No. Item DescriptionApprox.
Quan. Unit
Project Bid Unit Price Comparison
:
Bid Opening: 17-Nov-16Page 2
201 Clearing and Grubbing 1 LS 15,200.00 $9,300.00 15,000.001 16,500.00 30,000.00 51,603.00 1
202 Rmvl of Structs & Obstns 1 LS 9,040.00 $12,770.00 15,000.002 8,900.00 4,000.00 45,732.00 2
202 Removal of Pipe 6 EA 1,480.00 $707.00 750.003 750.00 1,250.00 1,457.45 3
202 Removal of Fence 210 LF 2.80 $2.50 1.004 5.00 2.00 3.09 4
203 Uncl Exc (Cmpl In Place) 1360 CY 29.40 $17.00 25.005 4.70 22.00 21.63 5
203 Muck Excavation (CIP) 203 TON 72.50 $12.00 50.006 16.00 30.00 91.67 6
203 Rock Excavation (CIP) 3505 CY 34.00 $40.00 27.507 39.00 55.00 37.08 7
203 Blading 32 HR 224.00 $114.00 150.008 165.00 125.00 185.40 8
203 Detour Construction 3 EA 6,220.00 $16,500.00 20,000.009 18,500.00 25,000.00 29,973.00 9
206 Structure Excavation (CIP) 935 CY 22.00 $21.00 20.0010 17.50 20.00 45.32 10
206 Struct Backfill (Special) 425 CY 86.40 $76.00 30.0011 63.50 35.00 126.69 11
207 Topsoil 125 CY 30.20 $9.00 30.0012 39.50 30.00 26.78 12
207 Stockpile Topsoil 125 CY 27.80 $3.00 30.0013 8.00 20.00 11.33 13
208 Erosion Log (12) 635 LF 6.20 $8.25 4.0014 11.00 5.00 6.44 14
208 Erosion Control Supervisor 1 LS 2,250.00 $1,471.00 5,000.0015 1,750.00 10,500.00 26,287.25 15
304 ABC (Class 5) 1995 TON 36.10 $40.00 35.0016 36.00 35.00 28.84 16
420 Geotextile (E.C.)(Class A) 445 SY 4.00 $3.00 10.0017 6.75 10.00 3.61 17
506 Riprap (6") 140 CY 110.00 $126.00 120.0018 200.00 175.00 121.54 18
506 Riprap (12") 80 CY 88.00 $100.00 120.0019 120.00 160.00 118.45 19
506 Riprap (18") 220 CY 84.00 $111.00 125.0020 122.00 140.00 135.96 20
506 Riprap (24") 275 CY 80.00 $110.00 125.0021 225.00 135.00 140.08 21
601 Concrete Cl D (Wall) 66 CY 1,310.00 $880.00 1,000.0022 1,650.00 1,200.00 1,226.01 22
601 Structural Conc. Coating 210 SY 9.00 $10.00 20.0023 76.00 18.00 12.36 23
602 Re-Steel (Epoxy Coated) 12280 LB 2.20 $1.40 2.0024 1.50 1.00 1.30 24
603 36" Corr Steel Pipe (CIP) 85 LF 140.00 $140.00 50.0025 1.00 85.00 98.88 25
603 20 x 6 Ft CBC (Precast) 176 LF 1,870.00 $1,878.00 2,500.0026 2,625.00 2,800.00 1,950.00 26
607 Fence BW W/ Metal Posts 525 LF 9.00 $6.40 2.0027 5.00 2.25 8.24 27
607 Fence Barbed Wire (Temp) 540 LF 5.60 $6.00 2.0028 5.00 2.25 5.15 28
607 End Post 12 EA 196.00 $258.00 12.0029 200.00 275.00 180.25 29
607 Corner & Line Brace Post 35 EA 246.00 $292.00 12.0030 350.00 215.00 226.60 30
620 Field Office (Class 1) 1 EA 28,500.00 $12,400.00 3,500.0031 40,000.00 18,000.00 19,485.36 31
620 Sanitary Facility 4 EA 613.00 $1,475.00 1,000.0032 300.00 350.00 664.50 32
625 Construction Surveying 1 LS 16,000.00 $18,500.00 17,500.0033 12,000.00 9,500.00 18,581.20 33
626 Mobilization 1 LS 125,000.00 $140,150.00 122,000.0034 89,000.00 75,000.00 202,018.51 34
630 Const.Traffic Control 1 LS 45,400.00 $8,189.00 20,000.0035 10,600.00 47,500.00 9,270.00 35
630 Flagging 220 HR 19.86 $32.00 30.0036 18.00 24.00 18.54 36
630 Traffic Control Management 90 DAY 441.30 $818.00 700.0037 400.00 700.00 412.00 37
630 Traf Control Inspection 90 DAY 110.32 $245.00 175.0038 100.00 175.00 103.00 38
700 F/A MCR 1 FA 150,000.00 $150,000.00 150,000.0039 150,000.00 150,000.00 150,000.00 39
Number of Bids: 16
Number of Contract Days: 150
Total Bid:
% Eng. Estimate:
$1,337,318.00 $1,344,895.75 $1,393,141.50 $1,474,326.25 $1,576,641.25 $1,586,720.44
Engineer's Estimate Total Cost: 1,465,206.15
91.27% 91.79% 95.08% 100.62% 107.61% 108.29%
FEMA SITESProject Bid Unit Price Comparison
Duran
Excavating
Project No-Phase 9321-1 PW378 (LARC015) Permanent Repairs CR 025E (Redstone Rd) MP 4.73-10.3
Western
States
SEMA
Construction
Rock &
Company
Ref
No.
Ref
No.
Item
No. Item DescriptionApprox.
Quan. Unit
Project Bid Unit Price Comparison
:
Bid Opening: 17-Nov-16Page 3
201 Clearing and Grubbing 1 LS 24,000.00 $24,750.00 100,000.001 17,307.82 1
202 Rmvl of Structs & Obstns 1 LS 24,000.00 $4,155.00 50,000.002 15,473.89 2
202 Removal of Pipe 6 EA 3,400.00 $1,995.00 3,000.003 3,641.73 3
202 Removal of Fence 210 LF 2.50 $6.90 2.504 3.36 4
203 Uncl Exc (Cmpl In Place) 1360 CY 25.00 $45.00 40.005 34.99 5
203 Muck Excavation (CIP) 203 TON 56.00 $29.00 55.006 35.99 6
203 Rock Excavation (CIP) 3505 CY 60.00 $58.50 60.007 62.01 7
203 Blading 32 HR 205.00 $124.00 175.008 134.50 8
203 Detour Construction 3 EA 21,705.00 $19,600.00 25,000.009 23,537.40 9
206 Structure Excavation (CIP) 935 CY 23.00 $30.50 40.0010 40.23 10
206 Struct Backfill (Special) 425 CY 95.00 $89.00 100.0011 51.45 11
207 Topsoil 125 CY 16.00 $20.50 15.0012 71.71 12
207 Stockpile Topsoil 125 CY 16.00 $40.50 15.0013 28.44 13
208 Erosion Log (12) 635 LF 10.00 $16.00 5.0014 11.21 14
208 Erosion Control Supervisor 1 LS 11,000.00 $5,928.00 5,500.0015 11,152.24 15
304 ABC (Class 5) 1995 TON 35.00 $31.50 45.0016 42.68 16
420 Geotextile (E.C.)(Class A) 445 SY 5.00 $6.10 5.0017 11.21 17
506 Riprap (6") 140 CY 42.00 $294.00 150.0018 121.90 18
506 Riprap (12") 80 CY 45.00 $178.00 150.0019 121.90 19
506 Riprap (18") 220 CY 80.00 $155.00 150.0020 135.91 20
506 Riprap (24") 275 CY 90.00 $145.00 150.0021 149.92 21
601 Concrete Cl D (Wall) 66 CY 963.00 $1,338.00 1,100.0022 867.06 22
601 Structural Conc. Coating 210 SY 47.00 $34.85 12.0023 3.92 23
602 Re-Steel (Epoxy Coated) 12280 LB 3.00 $2.10 1.1024 2.01 24
603 36" Corr Steel Pipe (CIP) 85 LF 76.00 $133.00 200.0025 180.73 25
603 20 x 6 Ft CBC (Precast) 176 LF 2,400.00 $2,290.00 2,700.0026 3,892.66 26
607 Fence BW W/ Metal Posts 525 LF 6.50 $9.70 6.0027 7.85 27
607 Fence Barbed Wire (Temp) 540 LF 6.50 $6.50 6.0028 5.60 28
607 End Post 12 EA 260.00 $240.25 240.0029 784.58 29
607 Corner & Line Brace Post 35 EA 410.00 $250.50 270.0030 784.58 30
620 Field Office (Class 1) 1 EA 11,000.00 $15,650.00 30,000.0031 39,228.99 31
620 Sanitary Facility 4 EA 990.00 $1,095.00 300.0032 1,120.83 32
625 Construction Surveying 1 LS 66,000.00 $12,228.00 30,000.0033 17,933.25 33
626 Mobilization 1 LS 112,000.00 $203,950.00 200,000.0034 140,276.15 34
630 Const.Traffic Control 1 LS 31,000.00 $26,150.00 15,000.0035 46,051.43 35
630 Flagging 220 HR 28.00 $40.00 26.0036 26.32 36
630 Traffic Control Management 90 DAY 650.00 $690.10 230.0037 767.52 37
630 Traf Control Inspection 90 DAY 140.00 $212.50 810.0038 191.88 38
700 F/A MCR 1 FA 150,000.00 $150,000.00 150,000.0039 150,000.00 39
Number of Bids: 16
Number of Contract Days: 150
Total Bid:
% Eng. Estimate:
$1,618,118.50 $1,720,613.50 $1,941,633.00 $1,998,175.42
Engineer's Estimate Total Cost: 1,465,206.15
110.44% 117.43% 132.52% 136.38%
FEMA SITESProject Bid Unit Price Comparison
Engineer's
Estimate
Project No-Phase 9321-1 PW378 (LARC015) Permanent Repairs CR 025E (Redstone Rd) MP 4.73-10.3
Ref
No.
Ref
No.
Item
No. Item DescriptionApprox.
Quan. Unit
Summary of Unit Price Comparison
:
Bid Opening: 17-Nov-16Page 1
Low Bid Unit
Price
Average of
All Bids
Avg. of 5 Low
Bids
Low Unit
Price
High Unit
Price
Number of Bids: 16
201 Clearing and Grubbing 1 LS 11,000.00 10,000.00 24,613.181 15,530.00 9,300.00 100,000.00 1
202 Rmvl of Structs & Obstns 1 LS 8,000.00 5,000.00 14,193.812 6,606.00 2,030.00 50,000.00 2
202 Removal of Pipe 6 EA 1,200.00 400.00 1,702.573 1,312.00 400.00 3,641.73 3
202 Removal of Fence 210 LF 1.20 3.25 3.294 3.61 1.00 6.90 4
203 Uncl Exc (Cmpl In Place) 1360 CY 16.22 15.00 23.015 16.30 4.70 45.00 5
203 Muck Excavation (CIP) 203 TON 31.43 15.00 42.106 33.48 10.00 91.67 6
203 Rock Excavation (CIP) 3505 CY 52.25 32.00 42.827 34.60 27.00 62.01 7
203 Blading 32 HR 150.00 100.00 150.498 133.20 100.00 224.00 8
203 Detour Construction 3 EA 25,000.00 25,000.00 20,903.469 22,484.00 6,220.00 50,000.00 9
206 Structure Excavation (CIP) 935 CY 20.11 30.00 27.4710 25.98 17.50 45.32 10
206 Struct Backfill (Special) 425 CY 47.67 55.00 72.1911 62.40 20.00 126.69 11
207 Topsoil 125 CY 16.20 5.00 23.6112 12.82 5.00 71.71 12
207 Stockpile Topsoil 125 CY 11.29 5.00 17.3213 11.62 3.00 40.50 13
208 Erosion Log (12) 635 LF 5.63 5.00 6.8214 4.38 3.89 16.00 14
208 Erosion Control Supervisor 1 LS 8,000.00 100.00 7,165.5315 5,562.00 100.00 26,287.25 15
304 ABC (Class 5) 1995 TON 17.68 40.00 36.2316 34.32 28.84 45.00 16
420 Geotextile (E.C.)(Class A) 445 SY 9.25 3.50 5.4617 3.33 3.00 11.21 17
506 Riprap (6") 140 CY 52.25 150.00 136.4318 131.10 42.00 294.00 18
506 Riprap (12") 80 CY 65.00 95.00 111.5619 103.72 45.00 178.00 19
506 Riprap (18") 220 CY 86.21 95.00 112.4920 99.20 35.00 155.00 20
506 Riprap (24") 275 CY 125.19 95.00 119.8321 100.46 42.30 225.00 21
601 Concrete Cl D (Wall) 66 CY 572.36 700.00 1,085.8822 1,028.00 700.00 1,650.00 22
601 Structural Conc. Coating 210 SY 20.52 12.50 26.1423 31.22 3.92 76.00 23
602 Re-Steel (Epoxy Coated) 12280 LB 2.95 1.25 1.7024 1.67 1.00 3.00 24
603 36" Corr Steel Pipe (CIP) 85 LF 118.50 200.00 104.4925 102.44 1.00 200.00 25
603 20 x 6 Ft CBC (Precast) 176 LF 2,800.00 1,500.00 2,242.8526 1,796.00 1,500.00 3,892.66 26
607 Fence BW W/ Metal Posts 525 LF 4.95 8.50 6.9127 8.91 2.00 10.00 27
607 Fence Barbed Wire (Temp) 540 LF 3.50 5.50 5.5128 6.92 2.00 10.00 28
607 End Post 12 EA 286.00 181.00 241.4129 183.30 12.00 784.58 29
607 Corner & Line Brace Post 35 EA 350.00 227.00 278.7630 220.70 12.00 784.58 30
620 Field Office (Class 1) 1 EA 20,000.00 20,000.00 18,894.6531 12,930.00 3,500.00 40,000.00 31
620 Sanitary Facility 4 EA 1,200.00 125.00 765.7432 468.70 125.00 2,000.00 32
625 Construction Surveying 1 LS 20,000.00 13,000.00 19,605.1533 15,588.00 7,700.00 66,000.00 33
626 Mobilization 1 LS 100,000.00 106,000.00 115,301.5434 61,086.00 15,000.00 203,950.00 34
630 Const.Traffic Control 1 LS 44,000.00 9,300.00 20,401.2835 11,852.00 5,000.00 47,500.00 35
630 Flagging 220 HR 23.20 19.00 25.6636 22.38 18.00 40.00 36
630 Traffic Control Management 90 DAY 350.00 413.00 506.0637 358.60 100.00 818.00 37
630 Traf Control Inspection 90 DAY 125.00 104.00 193.3638 147.20 95.00 810.00 38
700 F/A MCR 1 FA 150,000.00 150,000.00 150,000.0039 150,000.00 150,000.00 150,000.00 39
FEMA SITESSummary of Unit Price Comparison
Flatiron
Constructors
Project No-Phase 9321-1 PW378 (LARC015) Permanent Repairs CR 025E (Redstone Rd) MP 4.73-10.3
Mountain
Constructors
Dietzler
Construction
ESCO
Construction
Zak Dirt American CivilRef
No.
Ref
No.
Item
No. Item DescriptionApprox.
Quan. Unit
Project Bid Unit Price Comparison
:
Bid Opening: 18-Nov-16Page 1
201 Clearing and Grubbing 1 LS 15,000.00 $25,000.00 20,000.001 16,430.00 23,000.00 12,500.00 1
202 Rmvl of Structs & Obstns 1 LS 10,000.00 $2,500.00 20,000.002 10,840.00 7,400.00 5,000.00 2
202 Removal of Pipe 9 EA 400.00 $1,100.00 1,000.003 1,100.00 1,200.00 2,250.00 3
202 Removal of Fence 840 LF 3.25 $3.50 10.004 4.47 2.00 3.00 4
203 Muck Excavation (CIP) 342 TON 15.00 $37.00 10.005 28.80 73.00 60.00 5
203 Rock Excavation (CIP) 500 CY 32.00 $40.00 30.006 42.10 31.00 35.00 6
203 Detour Construction 5 EA 25,000.00 $10,000.00 50,000.007 10,620.00 24,000.00 16,000.00 7
206 Structure Excavation (CIP) 1515 CY 30.00 $20.00 20.008 37.70 29.00 30.00 8
206 Struct Backfill (Special) 770 CY 55.00 $80.00 20.009 92.90 66.00 90.00 9
207 Topsoil 170 CY 5.00 $18.00 10.0010 12.10 19.00 27.00 10
207 Stockpile Topsoil 170 CY 5.00 $18.00 10.0011 12.10 13.00 20.00 11
208 Erosion Log (12) 1080 LF 5.00 $5.00 4.0012 3.89 4.00 4.20 12
208 Erosion Control Supervisor 1 LS 100.00 $7,500.00 5,000.0013 8,710.00 9,500.00 6,000.00 13
304 ABC (Class 5) 985 TON 40.00 $35.00 30.0014 37.00 42.00 14
420 Geotextile (E.C.)(Class A) 810 SY 3.50 $3.00 4.0015 3.15 4.00 6.00 15
506 Riprap (12") 85 CY 95.00 $135.00 85.0016 69.70 143.00 67.00 16
506 Riprap (18") 295 CY 95.00 $139.00 95.0017 35.00 150.00 67.00 17
506 Riprap (24") 680 CY 95.00 $145.00 100.0018 42.20 120.00 67.00 18
601 Concrete Cl D (Wall) 120 CY 700.00 $925.00 1,150.0019 1,330.00 1,035.00 700.00 19
601 Structural Conc. Coating 365 SY 12.50 $20.00 45.0020 40.60 38.00 19.00 20
602 Re-Steel (Epoxy Coated) 20335 LB 1.25 $1.75 1.4021 2.45 1.50 1.20 21
603 36" Corr Steel Pipe (CIP) 110 LF 200.00 $112.00 20.0022 53.60 90.00 55.00 22
603 60" Corr Steel Pipe (CIP) 35 LF 300.00 $160.00 20.0023 191.50 115.00 75.00 23
603 20 x 5 Ft CBC (Precast) 146 LF 1,500.00 $1,840.00 1,800.0024 2,020.00 1,705.00 1,885.00 24
603 20 x 6 Ft CBC (Precast) 150 LF 1,500.00 $1,920.00 1,900.0025 1,900.00 1,720.00 1,950.00 25
607 Fence BW W/ Metal Posts 835 LF 8.50 $10.00 10.0026 6.80 9.25 3.00 26
607 Fence Barbed Wire (Temp) 840 LF 5.50 $6.00 10.0027 6.45 6.65 3.00 27
607 10' Gate (Metal) 2 EA 520.00 $600.00 400.0028 662.50 600.00 450.00 28
607 End Post 16 EA 190.00 $210.00 50.0029 275.50 200.00 300.00 29
607 Corner & Line Brace Post 58 EA 230.00 $265.00 50.0030 311.50 250.00 300.00 30
620 Sanitary Facility 5 EA 100.00 $720.00 750.0031 348.50 400.00 2,000.00 31
625 Construction Surveying 1 LS 13,000.00 $13,400.00 20,000.0032 34,760.00 12,000.00 18,000.00 32
626 Mobilization 1 LS 106,000.00 $50,000.00 20,000.0033 30,850.00 90,000.00 140,000.00 33
630 Const.Traffic Control 1 LS 9,300.00 $7,200.00 5,000.0034 10,460.00 15,000.00 8,000.00 34
630 Flagging 200 HR 19.00 $25.00 26.0035 20.90 21.00 36.00 35
630 Traffic Control Management 50 DAY 413.00 $350.00 100.0036 465.00 465.00 495.00 36
630 Traf Control Inspection 50 DAY 104.00 $300.00 100.0037 116.00 116.00 95.00 37
700 F/A MCR 1 FA 150,000.00 $150,000.00 150,000.0038 150,000.00 150,000.00 150,000.00 38
Number of Bids: 16
Number of Contract Days: 150
Total Bid:
% Eng. Estimate:
$1,343,463.75 $1,445,365.25 $1,489,074.00 $1,430,791.85 $1,518,938.25 $1,491,363.00
Engineer's Estimate Total Cost: 1,740,337.26
77.20% 83.05% 85.56% 82.21% 87.28% 85.69%
NON-FEMA SITESProject Bid Unit Price Comparison
Total Bid for A + B: $2,500,518.25 $2,673,173.25 $2,694,171.00 $2,696,619.75 $2,712,257.00 $2,802,855.00
Connell
Resources
Project No-Phase 9321-1 PW378 (LARC015) Permanent Repairs CR 025E (Redstone Rd) MP 4.73-10.3
Lawrence
Construction
Walsh
Construction
Simon
Contractors
Myers & Sons StructuresRef
No.
Ref
No.
Item
No. Item DescriptionApprox.
Quan. Unit
Project Bid Unit Price Comparison
:
Bid Opening: 18-Nov-16Page 2
201 Clearing and Grubbing 1 LS 25,300.00 $9,520.00 25,000.001 16,500.00 30,000.00 53,869.00 1
202 Rmvl of Structs & Obstns 1 LS 7,680.00 $12,772.00 25,000.002 8,900.00 4,000.00 45,114.00 2
202 Removal of Pipe 9 EA 1,410.00 $670.00 750.003 750.00 1,250.00 1,457.45 3
202 Removal of Fence 840 LF 2.80 $2.50 1.004 5.00 1.25 3.09 4
203 Muck Excavation (CIP) 342 TON 78.80 $12.00 50.005 16.00 30.00 91.67 5
203 Rock Excavation (CIP) 500 CY 43.60 $39.00 27.506 39.00 65.00 110.21 6
203 Detour Construction 5 EA 6,220.00 $16,860.00 20,000.007 18,500.00 20,000.00 28,325.00 7
206 Structure Excavation (CIP) 1515 CY 22.20 $21.00 18.008 17.50 20.00 36.05 8
206 Struct Backfill (Special) 770 CY 83.60 $76.00 30.009 63.50 35.00 125.66 9
207 Topsoil 170 CY 22.20 $9.00 30.0010 39.50 30.00 29.87 10
207 Stockpile Topsoil 170 CY 27.80 $3.00 30.0011 8.00 20.00 11.33 11
208 Erosion Log (12) 1080 LF 6.15 $8.25 4.0012 11.00 5.00 6.44 12
208 Erosion Control Supervisor 1 LS 2,250.00 $1,471.00 5,000.0013 1,750.00 6,000.00 26,287.25 13
304 ABC (Class 5) 985 TON 36.20 $39.00 35.0014 36.00 40.00 39.14 14
420 Geotextile (E.C.)(Class A) 810 SY 3.90 $3.00 10.0015 6.75 8.00 3.61 15
506 Riprap (12") 85 CY 88.00 $100.00 120.0016 120.00 130.00 133.90 16
506 Riprap (18") 295 CY 84.00 $111.00 120.0017 122.00 130.00 145.23 17
506 Riprap (24") 680 CY 80.00 $110.00 125.0018 225.00 130.00 149.35 18
601 Concrete Cl D (Wall) 120 CY 1,300.00 $888.00 1,000.0019 1,650.00 1,100.00 1,112.75 19
601 Structural Conc. Coating 365 SY 9.00 $10.00 20.0020 76.00 18.00 12.36 20
602 Re-Steel (Epoxy Coated) 20335 LB 2.20 $1.40 2.0021 1.50 1.00 1.30 21
603 36" Corr Steel Pipe (CIP) 110 LF 120.00 $141.00 50.0022 1.00 85.00 97.85 22
603 60" Corr Steel Pipe (CIP) 35 LF 145.00 $250.00 100.0023 1.00 150.00 152.44 23
603 20 x 5 Ft CBC (Precast) 146 LF 1,770.00 $1,813.00 2,300.0024 2,190.00 2,750.00 1,700.00 24
603 20 x 6 Ft CBC (Precast) 150 LF 1,930.00 $1,952.00 2,500.0025 2,625.00 2,800.00 1,900.00 25
607 Fence BW W/ Metal Posts 835 LF 9.00 $6.00 2.0026 5.00 2.25 8.24 26
607 Fence Barbed Wire (Temp) 840 LF 5.60 $6.00 2.0027 5.00 2.25 5.15 27
607 10' Gate (Metal) 2 EA 559.00 $622.00 500.0028 500.00 750.00 515.00 28
607 End Post 16 EA 196.00 $260.00 12.0029 200.00 265.00 180.25 29
607 Corner & Line Brace Post 58 EA 246.00 $300.00 12.0030 350.00 245.00 226.60 30
620 Sanitary Facility 5 EA 613.00 $1,475.00 1,000.0031 300.00 225.00 498.38 31
625 Construction Surveying 1 LS 17,400.00 $21,270.00 15,000.0032 12,000.00 8,500.00 9,290.60 32
626 Mobilization 1 LS 111,600.00 $201,460.25 137,000.0033 110,000.00 60,000.00 134,838.13 33
630 Const.Traffic Control 1 LS 45,400.00 $8,186.00 20,000.0034 10,600.00 27,000.00 9,270.00 34
630 Flagging 200 HR 19.86 $32.00 30.0035 18.00 24.00 18.54 35
630 Traffic Control Management 50 DAY 441.30 $818.00 700.0036 400.00 700.00 412.00 36
630 Traf Control Inspection 50 DAY 110.32 $245.00 175.0037 100.00 175.00 103.00 37
700 F/A MCR 1 FA 150,000.00 $150,000.00 150,000.0038 150,000.00 150,000.00 150,000.00 38
Number of Bids: 16
Number of Contract Days: 150
Total Bid:
% Eng. Estimate:
$1,528,720.60 $1,599,104.25 $1,701,263.00 $1,806,504.50 $1,763,788.75 $1,809,044.17
Engineer's Estimate Total Cost: 1,740,337.26
87.84% 91.88% 97.75% 103.80% 101.35% 103.95%
NON-FEMA SITESProject Bid Unit Price Comparison
Total Bid for A + B: $2,866,038.60 $2,944,000.00 $3,094,404.50 $3,280,830.75 $3,340,430.00 $3,395,764.61
Duran
Excavating
Project No-Phase 9321-1 PW378 (LARC015) Permanent Repairs CR 025E (Redstone Rd) MP 4.73-10.3
Western
States
SEMA
Construction
Rock &
Company
Ref
No.
Ref
No.
Item
No. Item DescriptionApprox.
Quan. Unit
Project Bid Unit Price Comparison
:
Bid Opening: 18-Nov-16Page 3
201 Clearing and Grubbing 1 LS 30,000.00 $31,300.00 150,000.001 17,307.82 1
202 Rmvl of Structs & Obstns 1 LS 30,000.00 $13,900.00 70,000.002 15,473.89 2
202 Removal of Pipe 9 EA 3,400.00 $2,220.00 3,000.003 3,641.73 3
202 Removal of Fence 840 LF 2.50 $4.30 2.504 3.36 4
203 Muck Excavation (CIP) 342 TON 56.00 $23.00 55.005 34.99 5
203 Rock Excavation (CIP) 500 CY 91.00 $59.50 95.006 66.82 6
203 Detour Construction 5 EA 21,000.00 $16,500.00 25,000.007 23,537.40 7
206 Structure Excavation (CIP) 1515 CY 27.00 $30.00 50.008 40.23 8
206 Struct Backfill (Special) 770 CY 95.00 $91.00 100.009 51.45 9
207 Topsoil 170 CY 16.00 $45.00 15.0010 71.71 10
207 Stockpile Topsoil 170 CY 16.00 $39.00 15.0011 28.44 11
208 Erosion Log (12) 1080 LF 10.00 $15.50 5.0012 11.21 12
208 Erosion Control Supervisor 1 LS 11,000.00 $5,927.50 5,500.0013 11,152.24 13
304 ABC (Class 5) 985 TON 35.00 $32.00 55.0014 42.68 14
420 Geotextile (E.C.)(Class A) 810 SY 5.00 $5.35 5.0015 11.21 15
506 Riprap (12") 85 CY 42.00 $176.00 175.0016 121.90 16
506 Riprap (18") 295 CY 80.00 $151.00 175.0017 135.91 17
506 Riprap (24") 680 CY 90.00 $139.00 175.0018 149.92 18
601 Concrete Cl D (Wall) 120 CY 963.00 $1,240.00 1,100.0019 867.06 19
601 Structural Conc. Coating 365 SY 47.00 $25.25 12.0020 3.92 20
602 Re-Steel (Epoxy Coated) 20335 LB 3.00 $2.00 1.1021 2.01 21
603 36" Corr Steel Pipe (CIP) 110 LF 76.00 $101.00 200.0022 180.73 22
603 60" Corr Steel Pipe (CIP) 35 LF 140.00 $824.00 250.0023 290.26 23
603 20 x 5 Ft CBC (Precast) 146 LF 2,400.00 $2,305.00 2,700.0024 3,820.93 24
603 20 x 6 Ft CBC (Precast) 150 LF 2,460.00 $2,325.00 2,800.0025 3,892.66 25
607 Fence BW W/ Metal Posts 835 LF 6.50 $9.25 6.0026 7.85 26
607 Fence Barbed Wire (Temp) 840 LF 6.50 $6.10 6.0027 5.60 27
607 10' Gate (Metal) 2 EA 630.00 $863.75 600.0028 3,362.49 28
607 End Post 16 EA 260.00 $226.10 240.0029 784.58 29
607 Corner & Line Brace Post 58 EA 400.00 $242.75 270.0030 784.58 30
620 Sanitary Facility 5 EA 990.00 $1,060.00 300.0031 1,120.83 31
625 Construction Surveying 1 LS 54,000.00 $11,178.00 30,000.0032 17,933.25 32
626 Mobilization 1 LS 88,000.00 $216,750.00 200,000.0033 140,276.15 33
630 Const.Traffic Control 1 LS 18,100.00 $26,400.00 15,000.0034 27,411.56 34
630 Flagging 200 HR 28.00 $40.20 26.0035 26.32 35
630 Traffic Control Management 50 DAY 650.00 $696.00 230.0036 767.52 36
630 Traf Control Inspection 50 DAY 140.00 $218.30 810.0037 191.88 37
700 F/A MCR 1 FA 150,000.00 $150,000.00 150,000.0038 150,000.00 38
Number of Bids: 16
Number of Contract Days: 150
Total Bid:
% Eng. Estimate:
$1,856,579.50 $1,950,825.60 $2,341,033.50 $2,364,460.49
Engineer's Estimate Total Cost: 1,740,337.26
106.68% 112.09% 134.52% 135.86%
NON-FEMA SITESProject Bid Unit Price Comparison
Total Bid for A + B: $3,474,698.00 $3,671,439.10 $4,282,666.50 $4,362,635.91
Engineer's
Estimate
Project No-Phase 9321-1 PW378 (LARC015) Permanent Repairs CR 025E (Redstone Rd) MP 4.73-10.3
Ref
No.
Ref
No.
Item
No. Item DescriptionApprox.
Quan. Unit
Summary of Unit Price Comparison
:
Bid Opening: 18-Nov-16Page 1
Low Bid Unit
Price
Average of
All Bids
Avg. of 5 Low
Bids
Low Unit
Price
High Unit
Price
Number of Bids: 16
201 Clearing and Grubbing 1 LS 11,000.00 15,000.00 31,295.431 19,886.00 9,520.00 150,000.00 1
202 Rmvl of Structs & Obstns 1 LS 8,000.00 10,000.00 18,036.242 10,148.00 2,500.00 70,000.00 2
202 Removal of Pipe 9 EA 1,200.00 400.00 1,599.953 960.00 400.00 3,641.73 3
202 Removal of Fence 840 LF 1.20 3.25 3.414 4.64 1.00 10.00 4
203 Muck Excavation (CIP) 342 TON 31.43 15.00 41.955 32.76 10.00 91.67 5
203 Rock Excavation (CIP) 500 CY 52.25 32.00 52.926 35.02 27.50 110.21 6
203 Detour Construction 5 EA 25,000.00 25,000.00 20,722.657 23,924.00 6,220.00 50,000.00 7
206 Structure Excavation (CIP) 1515 CY 20.11 30.00 28.048 27.34 17.50 50.00 8
206 Struct Backfill (Special) 770 CY 47.67 55.00 72.199 62.78 20.00 125.66 9
207 Topsoil 170 CY 16.20 5.00 24.9610 12.82 5.00 71.71 10
207 Stockpile Topsoil 170 CY 11.29 5.00 17.2911 11.62 3.00 39.00 11
208 Erosion Log (12) 1080 LF 5.63 5.00 6.7912 4.38 3.89 15.50 12
208 Erosion Control Supervisor 1 LS 8,000.00 100.00 7,071.7513 6,162.00 100.00 26,287.25 13
304 ABC (Class 5) 985 TON 17.68 40.00 38.2714 35.50 30.00 55.00 14
420 Geotextile (E.C.)(Class A) 810 SY 9.25 3.50 5.3415 3.53 3.00 11.21 15
506 Riprap (12") 85 CY 65.00 95.00 112.5916 105.54 42.00 176.00 16
506 Riprap (18") 295 CY 86.21 95.00 114.7017 102.80 35.00 175.00 17
506 Riprap (24") 680 CY 125.19 95.00 121.4018 100.44 42.20 225.00 18
601 Concrete Cl D (Wall) 120 CY 572.36 700.00 1,066.3019 1,028.00 700.00 1,650.00 19
601 Structural Conc. Coating 365 SY 20.52 12.50 25.5420 31.22 3.92 76.00 20
602 Re-Steel (Epoxy Coated) 20335 LB 2.95 1.25 1.6921 1.67 1.00 3.00 21
603 36" Corr Steel Pipe (CIP) 110 LF 118.50 200.00 98.9522 95.12 1.00 200.00 22
603 60" Corr Steel Pipe (CIP) 35 LF 122.00 300.00 197.7623 157.30 1.00 824.00 23
603 20 x 5 Ft CBC (Precast) 146 LF 2,500.00 1,500.00 2,156.1824 1,773.00 1,500.00 3,820.93 24
603 20 x 6 Ft CBC (Precast) 150 LF 2,800.00 1,500.00 2,254.6725 1,788.00 1,500.00 3,892.66 25
607 Fence BW W/ Metal Posts 835 LF 4.95 8.50 6.8526 8.91 2.00 10.00 26
607 Fence Barbed Wire (Temp) 840 LF 3.50 5.50 5.4927 6.92 2.00 10.00 27
607 10' Gate (Metal) 2 EA 465.00 520.00 758.4228 556.50 400.00 3,362.49 28
607 End Post 16 EA 286.00 190.00 240.5929 185.10 12.00 784.58 29
607 Corner & Line Brace Post 58 EA 350.00 230.00 280.2130 221.30 12.00 784.58 30
620 Sanitary Facility 5 EA 1,200.00 100.00 743.7931 463.70 100.00 2,000.00 31
625 Construction Surveying 1 LS 25,000.00 13,000.00 19,233.2432 18,632.00 8,500.00 54,000.00 32
626 Mobilization 1 LS 100,000.00 106,000.00 114,798.4133 59,370.00 20,000.00 216,750.00 33
630 Const.Traffic Control 1 LS 40,000.00 9,300.00 16,395.4734 9,392.00 5,000.00 45,400.00 34
630 Flagging 200 HR 23.20 19.00 25.6835 22.38 18.00 40.20 35
630 Traffic Control Management 50 DAY 350.00 413.00 506.4336 358.60 100.00 818.00 36
630 Traf Control Inspection 50 DAY 125.00 104.00 193.7237 147.20 95.00 810.00 37
700 F/A MCR 1 FA 150,000.00 150,000.00 150,000.0038 150,000.00 150,000.00 150,000.00 38
NON-FEMA SITESSummary of Unit Price Comparison
