51
BID EVALUATION SHEET Name of the Equipment : AC 80 TON PART- I KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (COMMERCIAL EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Purchase Department) (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance) Sr. No. Evaluation Parameters CLIMATE CONTROL ST Associate USMAN & COMPANY 1 Complete Package/Tender YES YES YES 2 Original Receipt of Tender YES YES YES 3 Affidavit from Bidder YES YES YES 4 Bid Security May be in financial May be in financial May be in financial 5 Bid Validity YES YES YES 6 Delivery Period YES YES YES Remarks: Eligible for part II Eligible for part II Eligible for part II

BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

BID EVALUATION SHEET

Name of the Equipment : AC 80 TON

PART- I KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (COMMERCIAL EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Purchase Department)

(All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters

CLIMATE CONTROL

ST Associate

USMAN & COMPANY

1 Complete Package/Tender YES YES YES

2 Original Receipt of Tender YES YES YES

3 Affidavit from Bidder YES YES YES

4 Bid Security May be in financial May be in financial May be in financial

5 Bid Validity YES YES YES

6 Delivery Period YES YES YES

Remarks: Eligible for part II

Eligible for part II

Eligible for part II

Page 2: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART- II KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (VENDOR EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Technical Evaluation Committee) (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters CLIMATE CONTROL ST ASSOCIATE USMAN & COMPANY

1 Exclusive Authorization / Sole Agent Certificate by the Manufacturer

Yes No No (indirect Authority )

2 Technical & Engineering capability(As defined for the specific tender in specifications) Yes Yes No

3 Certificate from the Manufacturer about the after sales services through agent or itself (In case specifically demanded in the specifications)

No No No

4 Vendor Past performance (In case of unsatisfactory performance, details must be mentioned)

Yes No No

5 Availability of relevant Tools and Testing / Calibration Equipment Yes No No

6 Compliance of Warranty as per tender No No No

Remarks: Not Eligible for further part III

Not Eligible for further part III

Not Eligible for further part III

Page 3: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART – III KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - PRODUCT EVALUATION (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Item Sr.No

SPECIFICATION COMPLIANCE /EVALUATION PARAMETERS

COMPANY CLIMATE CONTROL ST ASSOCIATE USMAN & COMPANY

1

Name of Equipment

Brand PEARL PEARL Acson

Model Not available Not available

Not mentioned Catalogue also not attached

Country of Manufacturer China (not required country of

region) China (not required country of region)

Malaysia

Country of Origin of Product/Model Number China (not required country of

region China (not required

country of region Malaysia

Compliance with defined quality standards

No No No

Specification Compliance features wise:

Specifications:

Offer not attached Offer not attached

No

Technical Eligibility of Product: No No No

Technical Eligibility of Firm: Yes Yes No

BID STATUS: Not Responsive Not Responsive

Not Responsive

Page 4: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

Name of the Equipment : Ambu Bag

PART- I KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (COMMERCIAL EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Purchase Department)

(All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters

Alliance Medial

Bestech Enterprises

Carewell

1 Complete Package/Tender YES YES YES

2 Original Receipt of Tender YES YES YES

3 Affidavit from Bidder YES YES YES

4 Bid Security May be in financial May be in financial May be in financial

5 Bid Validity YES YES YES

6 Delivery Period YES YES YES

Remarks: Eligible for part II Eligible for part II Eligible for part II

Page 5: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART- II KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (VENDOR EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Technical Evaluation Committee) (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters Alliance Medical

Bestech Enterprises

Carewell

1 Exclusive Authorization / Sole Agent Certificate by the Manufacturer Yes No No

2 Technical & Engineering capability(As defined for the specific tender in specifications)

Yes No No

3 Certificate from the Manufacturer about the after sales services through agent or itself (In case specifically demanded in the specifications)

Yes No No

4 Vendor Past performance (In case of unsatisfactory performance, details must be mentioned)

Yes No No

5 Availability of relevant Tools and Testing / Calibration Equipment

Yes No No

6 Compliance of Warranty as per tender Yes No No

Remarks:

Eligible for further part III Not Eligible for further part III Not Eligible for further part III

Page 6: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART – III KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - PRODUCT EVALUATION (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Item Sr.No

SPECIFICATION COMPLIANCE /EVALUATION PARAMETERS

COMPANY Alliance Medical

Bestech Enterprises

Carewell

1

Name of Equipment

Brand Headstar Morton NA

Model Headstar NA NA

Country of Manufacturer Taiwan Turkey Taiwan

Country of Origin of Product/Model Number Taiwan Turkey Taiwan

Compliance with defined quality standards

YES No No

Specification Compliance features wise:

Specifications:

YES YES

YES

Technical Eligibility of Product: YES No No

Technical Eligibility of Firm: Yes No No

BID STATUS: Responsive (Subject to Approval of Sample)

Not Responsive Not Responsive

Page 7: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

Name of the Equipment : AUTOCLAVE

PART- I KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (COMMERCIAL EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Purchase Department)

(All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters

TOTAL TECHNOLOGY

Delta Plus International

Clinical Life Advance System

1 Complete Package/Tender YES YES YES YES

2 Original Receipt of Tender YES YES YES YES

3 Affidavit from Bidder YES YES YES YES

4 Bid Security YES YES YES YES

5 Bid Validity YES YES YES YES

6 Delivery Period YES YES YES YES

Remarks: Eligible for part II Eligible for part II Eligible for part II Eligible for part II

Page 8: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART- II KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (VENDOR EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Technical Evaluation Committee) (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters TOTAL

TECHNOLOGY Delta Plus International Clinical Life Advance System

1 Exclusive Authorization / Sole Agent Certificate by the Manufacturer Yes Yes Yes Yes

2 Technical & Engineering capability(As defined for the specific tender in specifications)

Yes Yes Yes Yes

3 Certificate from the Manufacturer about the after sales services through agent or itself (In case specifically demanded in the specifications)

Yes Yes No Yes

4 Vendor Past performance (In case of unsatisfactory performance, details must be mentioned)

Yes No (Sale reference and past performance are

from different customer

No Yes

5 Availability of relevant Tools and Testing / Calibration Equipment

Yes Yes No Yes

6 Compliance of Warranty as per tender Yes Yes No Yes

Remarks:

Eligible for further part III

Eligible for further part III after clarification

Not Eligible for further part III

Eligible for further part III

Page 9: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART – III KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - PRODUCT EVALUATION (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Item Sr.No

SPECIFICATION COMPLIANCE /EVALUATION PARAMETERS

COMPANY

TOTAL TECHNOLOGY

Delta Plus International

Clinical Life Advance System

1

Name of Equipment

Brand MMM Celitron A.J. Costa

Tuttnaur

Model Selectomate CL6618-2

A6615 Amaro 5000

T Max 10

Country of Manufacturer Germany Hungary Portugal

Netherlands

Country of Origin of Product/Model Number Germany Hungary Portugal

Netherlands

Compliance with defined quality standards Yes Yes Yes

Yes

Specification Compliance features wise:

Specifications:

Yes No

(No LCD display on Unloading side)

No

(No LCD display on

Unloading side )

Yes

Technical Eligibility of Product: Yes No No

Yes

Technical Eligibility of Firm: Yes Yes Yes

Yes

BID STATUS: Responsive

Not Responsive

Not Responsive Responsive

Page 10: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

Name of the Equipment : Bed Elevator

PART- I KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (COMMERCIAL EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Purchase Department)

(All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters Shahab & Sons

1 Complete Package/Tender YES

2 Original Receipt of Tender YES

3 Affidavit from Bidder YES

4 Bid Security May be in financial

5 Bid Validity YES

6 Delivery Period YES

Remarks: Eligible for part II

Page 11: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART- II KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (VENDOR EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Technical Evaluation Committee) (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters

Shahab & Sons

1 Exclusive Authorization / Sole Agent Certificate by the Manufacturer

Yes

2 Technical & Engineering capability(As defined for the specific tender in specifications)

NO

3 Certificate from the Manufacturer about the after sales services through agent or itself (In case specifically demanded in the specifications)

NO

4 Vendor Past performance (In case of unsatisfactory performance, details must be mentioned)

NO

5 Availability of relevant Tools and Testing / Calibration Equipment

No

6 Compliance of Warranty as per tender NO

Remarks:

Not Eligible for further part III

Page 12: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART – III KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - PRODUCT EVALUATION (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Item Sr.No

COMPANY

Shahab & Sons

1

Name of Equipment

Brand Delfar

Model DP 860

Country of Manufacturer China

Country of Origin of Product/Model Number China

Compliance with defined quality standards No

Specification Compliance features wise:

Specifications:

Yes

Technical Eligibility of Product: No

Technical Eligibility of Firm: No

BID STATUS:

Not Responsive

Page 13: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

Name of the Equipment : Centrifuge Machine

PART- I KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (COMMERCIAL EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Purchase Department)

(All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters

Med Impax

Interex Company

1 Complete Package/Tender YES YES

2 Original Receipt of Tender YES YES

3 Affidavit from Bidder YES YES

4 Bid Security May be in financial May be in financial

5 Bid Validity YES YES

6 Delivery Period YES YES

Remarks: Eligible for part II

Eligible for part II

Page 14: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART- II KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (VENDOR EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Technical Evaluation Committee) (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters Med Impax Interex Company

1 Exclusive Authorization / Sole Agent Certificate by the Manufacturer Yes Yes

2 Technical & Engineering capability(As defined for the specific tender in specifications)

Yes Yes

3 Certificate from the Manufacturer about the after sales services through agent or itself (In case specifically demanded in the specifications)

Yes No

4 Vendor Past performance (In case of unsatisfactory performance, details must be mentioned)

Yes Yes

5 Availability of relevant Tools and Testing / Calibration Equipment

Yes Yes

6 Compliance of Warranty as per tender Yes No

Remarks:

Eligible for further part III Not Eligible for further part III

Page 15: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART – III KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - PRODUCT EVALUATION (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Item Sr.No

SPECIFICATION COMPLIANCE /EVALUATION PARAMETERS

COMPANY

Med Impax

Interex Company

1

Name of Equipment

Brand Centurion Scientific UK Kubota Corporation

Model Pro Hospital GP

3520

Country of Manufacturer UK Japan

Country of Origin of Product/Model Number UK Japan

Compliance with defined quality standards YES No MHLW

Specification Compliance features wise:

Specifications:

YES Yes

Technical Eligibility of Product: YES No

Technical Eligibility of Firm: Yes Yes

BID STATUS: Responsive

Not Responsive

Page 16: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

Name of the Equipment : Dressing Trolley

PART- I KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (COMMERCIAL EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Purchase Department)

(All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters

Carewell

Bestech Enterprises

Strongman Medical

1 Complete Package/Tender YES YES YES

2 Original Receipt of Tender YES YES YES

3 Affidavit from Bidder YES YES YES

4 Bid Security May be in financial May be in financial May be in financial

5 Bid Validity YES YES YES

6 Delivery Period YES YES YES

Remarks: Eligible for part II

Eligible for part II Eligible for part II

Page 17: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART- II KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (VENDOR EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Technical Evaluation Committee) (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters

Carewell

Bestech Enterprises

Strongman Medical

1 Exclusive Authorization / Sole Agent Certificate by the Manufacturer Yes Yes Yes

2 Technical & Engineering capability(As defined for the specific tender in specifications)

Yes Yes Yes

3 Certificate from the Manufacturer about the after sales services through agent or itself (In case specifically demanded in the specifications)

Yes Yes Yes

4 Vendor Past performance (In case of unsatisfactory performance, details must be mentioned)

Yes Yes Yes

5 Availability of relevant Tools and Testing / Calibration Equipment

Yes Yes Yes

6 Compliance of Warranty as per tender Yes Yes Yes

Remarks: Eligible for part III Eligible for part III Eligible for part III

Page 18: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART – III KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - PRODUCT EVALUATION (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Item Sr.No

SPECIFICATION COMPLIANCE /EVALUATION PARAMETERS

COMPANY

Carewell

Bestech Enterprises

Strongman Medical

1

Name of Equipment

Brand Orient Bestech Strongman

Model Local Local Local

Country of Manufacturer Local Local Local L

ocal

Country of Origin of Product/Model Number Local Local Local L

ocal

Compliance with defined quality standards Yes (ISO) Yes (ISO) Yes (ISO) Y

es (ISO)

Specification Compliance features wise:

Specifications:

YES Yes Yes

Technical Eligibility of Product: YES Yes Yes

Technical Eligibility of Firm: Yes Yes Yes

BID STATUS: Responsive Subject to approval of

sample)

Responsive Subject to approval of sample)

Responsive Subject to approval of sample)

Page 19: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

Name of the Equipment : Drug Dispensing Trolley

PART- I KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (COMMERCIAL EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Purchase Department)

(All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters

Carewell

Bestech Enterprises

Strongman Medical

1 Complete Package/Tender YES YES YES

2 Original Receipt of Tender YES YES YES

3 Affidavit from Bidder YES YES YES

4 Bid Security May be in financial May be in financial May be in financial

5 Bid Validity YES YES YES

6 Delivery Period YES YES YES

Remarks: Eligible for part II

Eligible for part II Eligible for part II

Page 20: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART- II KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (VENDOR EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Technical Evaluation Committee) (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters

Carewell

Bestech Enterprises

Strongman Medical

1 Exclusive Authorization / Sole Agent Certificate by the Manufacturer Yes Yes Yes

2 Technical & Engineering capability(As defined for the specific tender in specifications)

Yes Yes Yes

3 Certificate from the Manufacturer about the after sales services through agent or itself (In case specifically demanded in the specifications)

Yes Yes Yes

4 Vendor Past performance (In case of unsatisfactory performance, details must be mentioned)

Yes Yes Yes

5 Availability of relevant Tools and Testing / Calibration Equipment

Yes Yes Yes

6 Compliance of Warranty as per tender Yes Yes Yes

Remarks: Eligible for part III Eligible for part III Eligible for part III

Page 21: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART – III KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - PRODUCT EVALUATION (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Item Sr.No

SPECIFICATION COMPLIANCE /EVALUATION PARAMETERS

COMPANY

Carewell

Bestech Enterprises

Strongman Medical

1

Name of Equipment

Brand Orient Bestech Strongman

Model Local Local Local

Country of Manufacturer Local Local Local L

ocal

Country of Origin of Product/Model Number Local Local Local L

ocal

Compliance with defined quality standards Yes (ISO) Yes (ISO) Yes (ISO) Y

es (ISO)

Specification Compliance features wise:

Specifications:

YES Yes Yes

Technical Eligibility of Product: YES Yes Yes

Technical Eligibility of Firm: Yes Yes Yes

BID STATUS: Responsive Subject to approval of

sample)

Responsive Subject to approval of sample)

Responsive Subject to approval of sample)

Page 22: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

Name of the Equipment : Examination Couch

PART- I KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (COMMERCIAL EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Purchase Department)

(All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters

Delta Plus International

Strongman Medical

1 Complete Package/Tender YES YES

2 Original Receipt of Tender YES YES

3 Affidavit from Bidder YES YES

4 Bid Security May be in financial May be in financial

5 Bid Validity YES YES

6 Delivery Period YES YES

Remarks: Eligible for part II

Eligible for part II

Page 23: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART- II KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (VENDOR EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Technical Evaluation Committee) (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters

Delta Plus International

Strongman Medical

1 Exclusive Authorization / Sole Agent Certificate by the Manufacturer NO Yes

2 Technical & Engineering capability(As defined for the specific tender in specifications)

Yes Yes

3 Certificate from the Manufacturer about the after sales services through agent or itself (In case specifically demanded in the specifications)

Yes Yes

4 Vendor Past performance (In case of unsatisfactory performance, details must be mentioned)

No Yes

5 Availability of relevant Tools and Testing / Calibration Equipment

Yes Yes

6 Compliance of Warranty as per tender Yes Yes

Remarks:

Not Eligible for further part III Quoted OT Table manual instead of

examination couch, Advance instrumentation is not manufacturer(OEM),

NO FDA 510K only have FDA

Eligible for further part III

Page 24: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART – III KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - PRODUCT EVALUATION (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Item Sr.No

SPECIFICATION COMPLIANCE /EVALUATION PARAMETERS

COMPANY

Delta Plus International

Strongman Medical

1

Name of Equipment

Brand Advanced Instrumentation Yes

Model OT 30

Local

Country of Manufacturer Local

Country of Origin of Product/Model Number Local

Compliance with defined quality standards NO FDA 510K Yes (ISO)

Specification Compliance features wise:

Specifications:

YES Yes

Technical Eligibility of Product: YES Yes

Technical Eligibility of Firm: Yes Yes

BID STATUS: Not Responsive

Responsive Subject to approval of sample)

Page 25: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

Name of the Equipment : Floor Scrubbing Machine

PART- I KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (COMMERCIAL EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Purchase Department)

(All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters Bestech Enterprises

1 Complete Package/Tender YES

2 Original Receipt of Tender YES

3 Affidavit from Bidder YES

4 Bid Security May be in financial

5 Bid Validity YES

6 Delivery Period YES

Remarks: Eligible for part II

Page 26: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART- II KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (VENDOR EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Technical Evaluation Committee) (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters

Bestech Enterprises

1 Exclusive Authorization / Sole Agent Certificate by the Manufacturer

NO

2 Technical & Engineering capability(As defined for the specific tender in specifications)

NO

3 Certificate from the Manufacturer about the after sales services through agent or itself (In case specifically demanded in the specifications)

NO

4 Vendor Past performance (In case of unsatisfactory performance, details must be mentioned)

NO

5 Availability of relevant Tools and Testing / Calibration Equipment

No

6 Compliance of Warranty as per tender NO

Remarks:

Not Eligible for further part III

Page 27: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART – III KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - PRODUCT EVALUATION (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Item Sr.No

COMPANY

Bestech Enterprises

1

Name of Equipment

Brand Numatic

Model Not Available

Country of Manufacturer Not available

Country of Origin of Product/Model Number Not available

Compliance with defined quality standards No

Specification Compliance features wise:

Specifications:

No broacher attached

Technical Eligibility of Product: No

Technical Eligibility of Firm: No

BID STATUS:

Not Responsive

Page 28: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

Name of the Equipment : Holter Recorder

PART- I KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (COMMERCIAL EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Purchase Department)

(All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters

Kasbn International

Delta Plus International

Iqbal & Company Amtrontech Impact International Flowtronix System

1 Complete Package/Tender YES YES YES YES YES YES

2 Original Receipt of Tender YES YES YES YES YES YES

3 Affidavit from Bidder YES YES YES YES YES YES

4 Bid Security May be in financial May be in financial May be in financial May be in financial May be in financial May be in financial

5 Bid Validity YES YES YES YES YES YES

6 Delivery Period YES YES YES YES YES YES

Remarks: Eligible for

part II

Eligible for part II Eligible for part

II

Eligible for part II Eligible for part II Eligible for part II

Page 29: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART- II KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (VENDOR EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Technical Evaluation Committee) (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters Kasbn International

Delta Plus International

Iqbal & Company Amtrontech Impact International Flowtronix

System

1 Exclusive Authorization / Sole Agent Certificate by the Manufacturer Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

2 Technical & Engineering capability(As defined for the specific tender in specifications)

Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

3 Certificate from the Manufacturer about the after sales services through agent or itself (In case specifically demanded in the specifications)

Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No

4 Vendor Past performance (In case of unsatisfactory performance, details must be mentioned)

Yes No No Yes No No

5 Availability of relevant Tools and Testing / Calibration Equipment

Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

6 Compliance of Warranty as per tender Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No

Remarks:

Eligible for further part III

Not Eligible for further part III

Not Eligible for further part III

Eligible for further part III

Not Eligible for further part III

Not Eligible for further

part III

Page 30: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART – III KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - PRODUCT EVALUATION (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Item Sr.No

SPECIFICATION COMPLIANCE /EVALUATION PARAMETERS

COMPANY

Kasbn International

Delta Plus International

Iqbal & Company Amtrontech Impact International Flowtronix System

1

Name of Equipment

Brand LUMED Lab Tech Bio Medical

Manufacturer Mortara Instrument

Cardioline DMS Software

Model Euro Holter 3View 3 channel

EC-3H 3 channel

DL 800 3 channel

H12 + 12 Channel

Walk 400H DMS 300-4AL

Country of Manufacturer Italy

Hungary USA USA Italy USA

Country of Origin of Product/Model Number Italy

Hungary USA USA Italy China

Compliance with defined quality standards YES Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Specification Compliance features wise:

Specifications:

No

(Sampling Rate not as required )

No (sampling rate 1024 instead of 10000)

No (sampling rate 256instead of 10000)

Yes No Yes

Technical Eligibility of Product: No No No Yes No No

Technical Eligibility of Firm: YES NO NO Yes No No

BID STATUS: Not Responsive

Not Responsive Not Responsive

Responsive Not Responsive Not Responsive

Page 31: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

Name of the Equipment : Instrument Trolley

PART- I KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (COMMERCIAL EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Purchase Department)

(All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters

Carewell

Bestech Enterprises

Strongman Medical

1 Complete Package/Tender YES YES YES

2 Original Receipt of Tender YES YES YES

3 Affidavit from Bidder YES YES YES

4 Bid Security May be in financial May be in financial May be in financial

5 Bid Validity YES YES YES

6 Delivery Period YES YES YES

Remarks: Eligible for part II

Eligible for part II Eligible for part II

Page 32: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART- II KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (VENDOR EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Technical Evaluation Committee) (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters

Carewell

Bestech Enterprises

Strongman Medical

1 Exclusive Authorization / Sole Agent Certificate by the Manufacturer Yes Yes Yes

2 Technical & Engineering capability(As defined for the specific tender in specifications)

Yes Yes Yes

3 Certificate from the Manufacturer about the after sales services through agent or itself (In case specifically demanded in the specifications)

Yes Yes Yes

4 Vendor Past performance (In case of unsatisfactory performance, details must be mentioned)

Yes Yes Yes

5 Availability of relevant Tools and Testing / Calibration Equipment

Yes Yes Yes

6 Compliance of Warranty as per tender Yes Yes Yes

Remarks: Eligible for part III Eligible for part III Eligible for part III

Page 33: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART – III KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - PRODUCT EVALUATION (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Item Sr.No

SPECIFICATION COMPLIANCE /EVALUATION PARAMETERS

COMPANY

Carewell

Bestech Enterprises

Strongman Medical

1

Name of Equipment

Brand Orient Bestech Strongman

Model Local Local Local

Country of Manufacturer Local Local Local L

ocal

Country of Origin of Product/Model Number Local Local Local L

ocal

Compliance with defined quality standards Yes (ISO) Yes (ISO) Yes (ISO) Y

es (ISO)

Specification Compliance features wise:

Specifications:

YES Yes Yes

Technical Eligibility of Product: YES Yes Yes

Technical Eligibility of Firm: Yes Yes Yes

BID STATUS: Responsive Subject to approval of

sample)

Responsive Subject to approval of sample)

Responsive Subject to approval of sample)

Page 34: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

Name of the Equipment : Laryngoscope

PART- I KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (COMMERCIAL EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Purchase Department)

(All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters

Alliance Medial

Usman & Company

Quintex Medical Carewell

Alam Medix

Bestech Enterprises

1 Complete Package/Tender YES YES YES YES YES YES

2 Original Receipt of Tender YES YES YES YES YES YES

3 Affidavit from Bidder YES YES YES YES YES YES

4 Bid Security May be in financial May be in financial May be in financial May be in financial May be in financial May be in financial

5 Bid Validity YES YES YES YES YES YES

6 Delivery Period YES YES YES YES YES YES

Remarks: Eligible for

part II

Eligible for part II Eligible for part

II Eligible for part

II

Eligible for part II Eligible for part

II

Page 35: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART- II KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (VENDOR EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Technical Evaluation Committee) (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters Alliance Medical

Usman & Company

Quintex Medical Carewell

Alam Medix Bestech Enterprises

1 Exclusive Authorization / Sole Agent Certificate by the Manufacturer Yes No Yes No Yes No

2 Technical & Engineering capability(As defined for the specific tender in specifications)

Yes No Yes No Yes No

3 Certificate from the Manufacturer about the after sales services through agent or itself (In case specifically demanded in the specifications)

Yes No Yes No Yes No

4 Vendor Past performance (In case of unsatisfactory performance, details must be mentioned)

Yes No Yes No Yes No

5 Availability of relevant Tools and Testing / Calibration Equipment

Yes No Yes No Yes No

6 Compliance of Warranty as per tender Yes No Yes No Yes No

Remarks:

Eligible for further part III

Not Eligible for further part III

Eligible for further part III

Not Eligible for further part III

Eligible for further part III

Not Eligible for further part III

Page 36: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART – III KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - PRODUCT EVALUATION (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Item Sr.No

SPECIFICATION COMPLIANCE /EVALUATION PARAMETERS

COMPANY

Alliance Medical

Usman & Company

Quintex Medical Carewell

Alam Medix Bestech Enterprises

1

Name of Equipment

Brand Reister Reister Fazzini Reister Despomed Local instead of

imported

Model 7040 7070

Not Available 100007 7040 7070

DM-02-116-00

Country of Manufacturer Germany Germany Italy Germany UK

Country of Origin of Product/Model Number Germany Germany Italy Germany UK

Compliance with defined quality standards YES No Yes No YES

Specification Compliance features wise:

Specifications:

YES No

Yes

No YES

Technical Eligibility of Product: YES No Yes No YES

Technical Eligibility of Firm: Yes No Yes No Yes

BID STATUS: Responsive (Subject to Approval of Sample)

Not Responsive Responsive (Subject to Approval of Sample)

Not Responsive Responsive

(Subject to Approval of Sample)

Not Responsive

Page 37: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

Name of the Equipment : Nebulizer

PART- I KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (COMMERCIAL EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Purchase Department)

(All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters

Med Impax

Alam Medix

Usman & Company

Delta Plus Bestech Enterprises Quintex Medical

1 Complete Package/Tender YES YES YES YES YES YES

2 Original Receipt of Tender YES YES YES YES YES YES

3 Affidavit from Bidder YES YES YES YES YES YES

4 Bid Security May be in financial May be in financial May be in financial May be in financial May be in financial May be in financial

5 Bid Validity YES YES YES YES YES YES

6 Delivery Period YES YES YES YES YES YES

Remarks: Eligible for

part II Eligible for part

II Eligible for part

II Eligible for part

II Eligible for part

II Eligible for part

II

Page 38: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART- II KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (VENDOR EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Technical Evaluation Committee) (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters Med Impax

Alam Medix

Usman & Company

Delta Plus Bestech Enterprises Quintex Medical

1 Exclusive Authorization / Sole Agent Certificate by the Manufacturer Yes Yes No Yes(expired) Yes Yes

2 Technical & Engineering capability(As defined for the specific tender in specifications)

Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

3 Certificate from the Manufacturer about the after sales services through agent or itself (In case specifically demanded in the specifications)

Yes Yes No

No No Yes

4 Vendor Past performance (In case of unsatisfactory performance, details must be mentioned)

Yes Yes No

No No Yes

5 Availability of relevant Tools and Testing / Calibration Equipment

Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

6 Compliance of Warranty as per tender Yes Yes No No No Yes

Remarks:

Eligible for further part III

Eligible for further part III

Not Eligible for further part III

Not Eligible for further part III

Not Eligible for further part III

Eligible for further part III

Page 39: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART – III KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - PRODUCT EVALUATION (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Item Sr.No

SPECIFICATION COMPLIANCE /EVALUATION PARAMETERS

COMPANY

Med Impax

Alam Medix

Usman & Company Delta Plus

Bestech Enterprises

Quintex Medical

1

Name of Equipment

Brand Shin-EI Industries SUCHATZKI

Shin-EI Industries Hirtz Siem Nova System Assistance

Medical

Model Comfort 2000 KU-400

Micro 802/802U Comfort 2000 KU-400

Hico Ultrasound 810 1001NEB DP 100+

Country of Manufacturer Japan Germany Japan Germany Italy France

Country of Origin of Product/Model Number Japan Germany Japan Germany Italy France

Compliance with defined quality standards YES Yes No Yes Yes Yes

Specification Compliance features wise:

Specifications:

YES Yes

Yes

Yes Yes

No (time range is 02 to 9.59 minutes instead of 0 to 60 minutes

Technical Eligibility of Product: YES YES No No Yes No

Technical Eligibility of Firm: Yes Yes No No No Yes

BID STATUS: Responsive Responsive

Not Responsive Not Responsive Not Responsive

Not Responsive

Page 40: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

Name of the Equipment : Patient Screen

PART- I KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (COMMERCIAL EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Purchase Department)

(All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters

Carewell

Bestech Enterprises

Strongman Medical

1 Complete Package/Tender YES YES YES

2 Original Receipt of Tender YES YES YES

3 Affidavit from Bidder YES YES YES

4 Bid Security May be in financial May be in financial May be in financial

5 Bid Validity YES YES YES

6 Delivery Period YES YES YES

Remarks: Eligible for part II

Eligible for part II Eligible for part II

Page 41: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART- II KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (VENDOR EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Technical Evaluation Committee) (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters

Carewell

Bestech Enterprises

Strongman Medical

1 Exclusive Authorization / Sole Agent Certificate by the Manufacturer Yes Yes Yes

2 Technical & Engineering capability(As defined for the specific tender in specifications)

Yes Yes Yes

3 Certificate from the Manufacturer about the after sales services through agent or itself (In case specifically demanded in the specifications)

Yes Yes Yes

4 Vendor Past performance (In case of unsatisfactory performance, details must be mentioned)

Yes Yes Yes

5 Availability of relevant Tools and Testing / Calibration Equipment

Yes Yes Yes

6 Compliance of Warranty as per tender Yes Yes Yes

Remarks: Eligible for part III Eligible for part III Eligible for part III

Page 42: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART – III KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - PRODUCT EVALUATION (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Item Sr.No

SPECIFICATION COMPLIANCE /EVALUATION PARAMETERS

COMPANY

Carewell

Bestech Enterprises

Strongman Medical

1

Name of Equipment

Brand Orient Bestech Strongman

Model Local Local Local

Country of Manufacturer Local Local Local L

ocal

Country of Origin of Product/Model Number Local Local Local L

ocal

Compliance with defined quality standards Yes (ISO) Yes (ISO) Yes (ISO) Y

es (ISO)

Specification Compliance features wise:

Specifications:

YES Yes Yes

Technical Eligibility of Product: YES Yes Yes

Technical Eligibility of Firm: Yes Yes Yes

BID STATUS: Responsive Subject to approval of

sample)

Responsive Subject to approval of sample)

Responsive Subject to approval of sample)

Page 43: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

Name of the Equipment : Sucker Machine (Demo Required)

PART- I KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (COMMERCIAL EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Purchase Department)

(All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters

Kasbn International Quintex Medical Bestech Enterprises

1 Complete Package/Tender YES YES YES

2 Original Receipt of Tender YES YES YES

3 Affidavit from Bidder YES YES YES

4 Bid Security May be in financial May be in financial May be in financial

5 Bid Validity YES YES YES

6 Delivery Period YES YES YES

Remarks: Eligible for part II

Eligible for part II

Eligible for part II

Page 44: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART- II KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (VENDOR EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Technical Evaluation Committee) (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters Kasbn International Quintex Medical Bestech Enterprises

1 Exclusive Authorization / Sole Agent Certificate by the Manufacturer Yes Yes Yes

2 Technical & Engineering capability(As defined for the specific tender in specifications)

Yes Yes Yes

3 Certificate from the Manufacturer about the after sales services through agent or itself (In case specifically demanded in the specifications)

Yes Yes NO

4 Vendor Past performance (In case of unsatisfactory performance, details must be mentioned)

Yes Yes NO

5 Availability of relevant Tools and Testing / Calibration Equipment

Yes Yes Yes

6 Compliance of Warranty as per tender Yes Yes NO

Remarks:

Eligible for further part III

Eligible for further part III Not Eligible for further part III

Page 45: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART – III KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - PRODUCT EVALUATION (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Item Sr.No

SPECIFICATION COMPLIANCE /EVALUATION PARAMETERS

COMPANY

Kasbn International Quintex Medical Bestech Enterprises

1

Name of Equipment

Brand ORDISI Fazzini Siem Nova

Model FV series SH

F-100/F4 6110A4 junior

Country of Manufacturer Spain Italy Italy

Country of Origin of Product/Model Number Spain Italy Italy

Compliance with defined quality standards YES Yes Yes

Specification Compliance features wise:

Specifications:

Yes Yes

Yes

Technical Eligibility of Product: Yes Yes Ys

Technical Eligibility of Firm: Yes Yes No

BID STATUS: Responsive

Responsive

Not Responsive

Page 46: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

Name of the Equipment : Temporary Pacemaker

PART- I KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (COMMERCIAL EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Purchase Department)

(All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters

Alliance Medial

Impact International

ACP System Intrex Company

1 Complete Package/Tender YES YES YES YES

2 Original Receipt of Tender YES YES YES YES

3 Affidavit from Bidder YES YES YES YES

4 Bid Security May be in financial May be in financial May be in financial May be in financial

5 Bid Validity YES YES YES YES

6 Delivery Period YES YES YES YES

Remarks: Eligible for part II Eligible for part II Eligible for part II Eligible for part II

Page 47: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART- II KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (VENDOR EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Technical Evaluation Committee) (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters

Alliance Medical

Impact International

ACP System

Intrex Company

1 Exclusive Authorization / Sole Agent Certificate by the Manufacturer Yes No Yes No

2 Technical & Engineering capability(As defined for the specific tender in specifications)

Yes Yes No Yes

3 Certificate from the Manufacturer about the after sales services through agent or itself (In case specifically demanded in the specifications)

Yes Yes No No

4 Vendor Past performance (In case of unsatisfactory performance, details must be mentioned)

Yes No No Yes

5 Availability of relevant Tools and Testing / Calibration Equipment

Yes Yes No Yes

6 Compliance of Warranty as per tender Yes Yes No Yes

Remarks:

Eligible for further part III

Not Eligible for further part III

Not Eligible for further part III

Not Eligible for further part III

Page 48: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART – III KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - PRODUCT EVALUATION (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Item Sr.No

SPECIFICATION COMPLIANCE /EVALUATION PARAMETERS

COMPANY

Alliance Medical

Impact International

ACP System

Intrex Company

1

Name of Equipment

Brand Osypka AG Oscor Medtronic Oscor

Model PACE 101H

PACE 101H 5391 PACE 101H

Country of Manufacturer Germany USA USA USA

Country of Origin of Product/Model Number Germany Germany USA Germany

Compliance with defined quality standards YES NO FDA 510K No FDA 510K No FDA 510K

Specification Compliance features wise:

Specifications:

YES Yes

Yes

Yes

Technical Eligibility of Product: YES No No No

Technical Eligibility of Firm: Yes No No No

BID STATUS: Responsive

Not Responsive

Not Responsive

Not Responsive

Page 49: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

Name of the Equipment : Wheel Chair

PART- I KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (COMMERCIAL EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Purchase Department)

(All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters

Carewell

Bestech Enterprises

Strongman Medical

1 Complete Package/Tender YES YES YES

2 Original Receipt of Tender YES YES YES

3 Affidavit from Bidder YES YES YES

4 Bid Security May be in financial May be in financial May be in financial

5 Bid Validity YES YES YES

6 Delivery Period YES YES YES

Remarks: Eligible for part II

Eligible for part II Eligible for part II

Page 50: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART- II KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (VENDOR EVALUATION) (To be evaluated by Technical Evaluation Committee) (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Sr. No.

Evaluation Parameters

Carewell

Bestech Enterprises

Strongman Medical

1 Exclusive Authorization / Sole Agent Certificate by the Manufacturer Yes Yes Yes

2 Technical & Engineering capability(As defined for the specific tender in specifications)

Yes Yes Yes

3 Certificate from the Manufacturer about the after sales services through agent or itself (In case specifically demanded in the specifications)

Yes Yes Yes

4 Vendor Past performance (In case of unsatisfactory performance, details must be mentioned)

Yes Yes Yes

5 Availability of relevant Tools and Testing / Calibration Equipment

Yes Yes Yes

6 Compliance of Warranty as per tender Yes Yes Yes

Remarks: Eligible for part III Eligible for part III Eligible for part III

Page 51: BID EVALUATION SHEET - Punjabeproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/2202_COMBINE.pdf · 2016. 4. 11. · Celitron A.J. Costa Tuttnaur Model Selectomate CL6618-2 A6615 Amaro 5000 T Max

PART – III KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - PRODUCT EVALUATION (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Item Sr.No

SPECIFICATION COMPLIANCE /EVALUATION PARAMETERS

COMPANY

Carewell

Bestech Enterprises

Strongman Medical

1

Name of Equipment

Brand Orient Bestech Strongman

Model Local Local Local

Country of Manufacturer Local Local Local L

ocal

Country of Origin of Product/Model Number Local Local Local L

ocal

Compliance with defined quality standards Yes (ISO) Yes (ISO) Yes (ISO) Y

es (ISO)

Specification Compliance features wise:

Specifications:

YES Yes Yes

Technical Eligibility of Product: YES Yes Yes

Technical Eligibility of Firm: Yes Yes Yes

BID STATUS: Responsive Subject to approval of

sample)

Responsive Subject to approval of sample)

Responsive Subject to approval of sample)