BGHEP Prefeasibility Report 1984

8/12/2019 BGHEP Prefeasibility Report 1984

1/129

IGnT

IaInII1111

H js l\lalesty's Government of Nepalllinistry oi Water ResourcesElectricity Department

Burhi GandakiHydroelectric ProjectPrefeasibility Study

Vol. IMain Report

KathmanduApril 1984

I


2/129

B

IItIIII

III

IIlII

srudt of the Eydroele'tricProje.. is hec."..".." ofrr..r.r"i.r lresenrs its tesults..""r".i."; an,l reco*endations

oluEes 5s tis ed be10u;

of alrernative Projecr sizes


3/129

allIIIItIIIIII1tII

1.r obje.tire oi stu,rl


4/129

IIIIIIIiIIII

on qualiiy or Lire uaruesI

tI

4.3.I 3 erec t rontI


5/129

3

tItiII'l14a?III1

rrol ecL s izes Prol e- slzes

s.3.4 D;scrip ioo


6/129

tBIttIIa

I1 auaotiries for .irect cosr

111

1111


7/129

TI3

IIII

t 0.2. 1 spillray10,2.5 Poqe sys reEoF valor.quipEent

r 0 ,3.4 rransFo.r

IIIIIItIIII

11.4 sens irlvity Anarysis

I


8/129

n?ll$

ii?q

IIs

oE rhe {1oa}dya L\e'"1)_..d-. .:.ro.::,':""- '': ' -, of surh I cs;dak1 slre( Extrene arua ara tys 1s )


9/129

nIInTIII

1. Project

osv (shee 3 a o )

Prolec s che dule

II1I


10/129

I3

IIII 3-5 lalor coops In

6-3

69

IttI

I1

ttII


11/129

IIII1

II't1

c/ti - is uajes.ris covernnen /neparDeveroPnen ? roj ecr

sr' /.s - Level/Furl suppry Lelelu/sD/s

- Grgaqa rour/Year

t /ha - loue/xec rarer/s

I

1

'1


12/129

rtI

II

rr reana tlYe Prolect srzes

IIItIl1

l:l1


13/129

flIJ

ntl

11{i

tn

?

besr p.oj act r"eariE.r:, is :je3trrsnepal, ( ./r.')

: ojerr,rt:ic:i:s), n rhe nid ieei's.ro:uc/n in 1ri3

n {s cl, oilo'1ne

De?a..Eenr, q ./ri,

,,I

1rh: osja.rivr


14/129

lt

I

1i

llTH

xlI

11I

i) i.ra:t:gatEb) ldeDtliy esrry aoy oajo erobLe,s athe slre (1ts

rerlclous Iandnarks) |d) rnves rBateP oje.i 1n ihe cNrs;d) esLlsete rh. Projecr floods 3nde) de iarninef) eva 1u a te theg) flEally, esrrE:rE oi th. rrojelrP.oi ect con5 L.ucL io -

rhe Proj ec t sdhedule

rr e.netlve p.o jecr sites


15/129

t]nBIJ

nttl

n

II

1

?

,n

?1

Prolecr Day be

thE Projecr iDPlemeotarioo 1srlL e p oj e.t 'i11

ihe Bu.ht candaki proj ecr rsProj e.t is c:1culated as

iI1

I

i

co . or t;e P.djec.(.sr) and capacirt of theproje.i 1s rlxed 600 ts leseecllvc]y.rhe p.oj ect re:

r igh. bank is j sriried.


16/129

xxfi1)

1,]'n

I111

proj e. t 3iea.,ithl P'oject

of rhe projec.rlne or.he project,

conjunctto t 1 h


17/129

fl31lninn

I1

:r111

1

'

tric Projeqt

of he pfoject.

ProJect is rocared dn rh


18/129

Efl

n

6sodakl Proj ectTh 1s prolecr

a rqied nt

'lt

11

.I

I,x

't

,nTT

,rr. i" rer ,3/",r5,1r /5.

r-,e. o"2 a ) oe o

the Project1n rhe pr.lec afea. the


19/129

II c n da ki P rci ecicos. of he p oject

94 @onr hs fron

II

II

I

I

l

I

proJecL bas

B/c r tro rs


20/129

T ,''T

'

1't11

L Desrs Frood (Rou ed

1Ii

II

De3 sr frood (Ro ed)c e6 Elea3 tron of u/scre3 Elevarion or D/s


21/129

FI'ntIIt

1

430 3/s


22/129

F

6all

lI3

I3tgIIII

3

-c : e"\I

rarrtuae aEd 12' Ea3t roneitu,rr. th:

projecr lies iE4al o or r -3ou ch

I


23/129

0

3E3

E0

3

.I

nB

3

III

3

g[]

rie ProjecLplojeqt 3ire o.e of the iajor rlloulariesand jolas the

project, detalled

IIr


24/129

IItinuBlIliIgllEIEBII

r najcr .qnr o1tsrs lajesryis xePaL. (uf1c/N).

oi 1/ro0 in

(pora.is ohse atloD) sDd found


25/129

clnInnItillII3Il

a ea dr re4 ha. (D6mand o,e hou5e).

EIEEE

II

polnts lrrlanaulario cnart) erd Beoch

(uf ) coo d ina.es,


26/129

E[lfl$gBg3IgB3EgnllBET


27/129

[]flnnlllullIlnIuEI$Ea1b$B

It

Projec arearajor conPrexes'Prolect srea

3eorosrcar oaPPrDs of Proj ect

.o r d en.1fy najor llreanents.he e ojecr

thtcke (uP ro 40 rc) o rhe


28/129

pIgl

Irt1Ina

Il]I

2ones (r1 . 3.r),irci run

,he,e tie ProjecI

I0IEB

333

vlrh au a; e rna rythere aie rhree

botrnda y (rie. 3-2).


29/129

sltrEI

IEtlBnniIIIuHIlIo8B

rh.ust (xcr) P

Faj or tnrustsj ainber"ee roc e ;o h",".


30/129

Eflgn[]BI]g

III

H3een (1s6e)

i3 qoDpiled (r'rE,. .p ojecL e ee a d th

1th a arre nar/

p ojecL 3re3 bt cans u rrlher,ras e, Bah:,

?esinsula. rrie of rhe ploject area

$IdgEEE333t

r r). rhe sLraLis aPnic

(Flg, 3-6).


31/129

(.HflIflnnnBI0nB

IagI3g

of the P oj..r area w:ssrudy (voru,e vr) estsbrishes the

ceur e (1sc)for rbe e.ojec ares r3years. (Flz, 3_s)

E


32/129

LFtintlugIIIBinf]IJ0ItIE

gIE

4x h1.e auarizrres

o oajo ra d-

rhe P oj3ct(Prare 5). rD rbrs srea


33/129

ttIfltlitfl

(N3rE-s3ri) ac cs;doiontLe (P1rre 6). the phyrrite:

(rro o). ArnaJo strucrurallpstreaF (3 n) (13 n) Loe of dao.

tlqtflE]gi

$?tlIItl0g

lrotar re 6th r13.q1fl) :(.i-et1) aidRa 110 ro 551r, ol orls on rre lsbt tank5:2 " 1o r. 4. ji x 1o_ < .n/ s.

i r^''

E


34/129

g

33

I3

33

IT

I3

I qiDt sets under

nisnry joinLeddoroni es (PraLe 7).

rorl.tlon joldi' risht to opeo /0-:rm)rlghr ro oPe (0-0,5 co)rrgnt td opeE (0,1 cr)

( HRr) r3 proposed

EEtIII


35/129

gIEfl

H

B

tiIn

Il

B

3I

IgIg03IT

rh eroje.. stre

aDd sL-1r. (Refererce voruoe r)

by s.a e ed lungre,


36/129

fi

T

qn

BIE

fl

i3IT

tiIt

1t


37/129

33B3lli33 are rron auarr),auar y sire

auarir site

33

3

E( r d. ov area D)r terraceadladent o borrow


38/129

ilnr

I{l oi ..1 1"r o-...-..o ,." -;. _;"lore. ereva ioDs),B (ar uoper ereverions).::::"' :' '""edan axrs (boiror area

^ard c)

sc eDing ( rofilre.s) vould

g

0dIfl

II'lln

1

.'I

1

id"d rro; rh.


39/129

ri

0nIi

lIi

IB

6

flu

g

I$

Bln'r " :"" , " r joins rh.jolns th 1s irYe .


40/129

Ig

gIg

nILd

tr

the raJo Parrror ihe sed1,""t vierd.t\1 '"".-.".

,"pr"s"o ,d..

c." r1; ra d a ,suzr1,. rh.,...,h. "",-. ...

a d rdnuary rht e ihe

lIagB

I|IaI

nc

ii

E


41/129

E

EI$$

t]t]I0fl

nIII

IEE

rean flo (5od .3/.) s"n"..rru,;,

1ver"e. D 16.h".r e (,r/s )


42/129

tilfl06)IJl]

III

't

'1

U

II

n

IBl]nE

' 1

(Rer. r7 ). rhe oeakca]c latecusinaoffiyd orogy

erhod (P.obab1. axrn o Frood)

f 1..d " ".; r.

a t 7oo mr /s.f 100d sas dete ot;ed by


43/129

ti

flf]

:l

iII0u

B

Il0I

lo : ooo )PJ'" '" ;

I


44/129

gfl[l

3

g$ 11i -4r: q

0I3itl

I

I

proJecr, s ecu. i tyof th serrr sy. iri;on-" :br" ,".._oe .

l|JlJ

Bcandak i piojecL slre.

Pre.rPltatroo (PdP)

rere adlrsred


45/129

l]

f]t

ti

E0g3a

.]"d ""." ., c-rqs,. -.oteothe hrd o Projects

aIe 3r"e" ", 66a n3/kh /y, a d 3 300 n3lknr/rr ;;spec_'''"'9.'""',1 l

633 fl3lk :/y (Ref. 1):

s

I

IIBi

fi


46/129

u[lfl

1'l

'I

Bu

It

g

lBIFT

t

uI$

al

'l


47/129

flfl

E

$l

$]B0

E

suri caid:kr rEoJecr 1s a s torde Proj.ct

the project b_;;r, ds rk.aDsii; r;oo Ph..35rs p r; va 1." r. otc."1c

flB

tI

rhe P o.ject

ard its osjorssiyan ar ( B .h 1

oj tne P. oj a. t,re subjected to


48/129

3II

In

ftn

Ut'i

(atr; (caira,4sr, (s chizo thorax

shourd rrrerefore ba grre; o1.r5 us

:11 " 1" ".adiacear to

0B3Iuu

1

1I


49/129

ll

IIB

n

ilfl

B0l

o 1 31r.r .f rlr o (a1 es

CI

FuBH

g hish dah Proje.rProject m3y act


50/129

Bng

IEIH3

tlor of tbe pioiect.

III1l

lln

E

nI

u3l

I


51/129

E]

[rilnIndB

jI

0I

;$

gI

ProledL, rrr ove a


52/129

riiiltiUgI

project, studies

IIn

tT

Illleeer (.sL) of

the objec lves of.he ::1" . ""'l:""" -" er .e s",,o.:" b"(.,"

TrunLiI

ttj

I


53/129

E]

nnt[lEgI

Ill[]

[l

0fl

0It

"""",:""-.'".l, "'" , fix d ar 525

13'7 4 ri re g h 1s buirt

i. " s1 ";o" ,/e 30 oe,

fls uc:e3 rha ; e(in he oider or 4c @)


54/129

5g$

IinI

n

0.d"? .i d lurje 1 ty,a. T;e

g3lnI

]1]i

ro P oc.a qhy :nd aua il rres

I

tIu

t


55/129


56/129

u

1Ilr

n

I

II

ntl0

fl

EF

i

g

IB

II


57/129

Ifli

IntlIl]3IiII$t,0I


58/129

[l

flI

ilfl

fl

t]

'11

$

lg

nfli " co-ne- r:r

reis,".t ".t

I 6.P(relaredr. rur3l po 1ariotr) as.35o i 1976/ji tons,lrie in rr30/:1,

1

11

T

II


59/129

IrE

tB

B$

gI$

flArcolE halor

p.".i , ." ,, ,"of randl;cLedDess crearry

gB

BI1llE

.,i".a{ i e.." t. u s per..il,a

rhe prolecr 53lessdeveloPeddrst.lclsBr 3uil. 1D D jor rrad

fiB


60/129

FE

gl

k

Bg

u

tii

a d a,o' 0e r

I0Inti

f;n

I

1

(


61/129

L]

ftFu

irl (r)flU

II

cB

In

[i

nfl

consunp 1o by Erevation ( n pereentaee)

ti


62/129

It

30I3Il

II

deve ropdea are h6jdrproductloi (Rs.rrves ock deve opneni).

farrry ha3 6.373lnEET

I


63/129

tUft

B3

0a rhe survey colducied approprtate lever; o,

(ha) ares (ha)

g

Bg

Ii3

Ifl


64/129

t3

G

3II

tE

coEPeasarrd (xNRs )

IIII3tl

III


65/129

flliIgIn

.1 t ".d:.". yo,; s r ror roo" erev.rto".Llvestock pdPtliLion

a

iIIj

forr""ed bt buil,rrig

g


66/129

t0[loU3gI

i r o 1io,i.P

3l

tI

EI

I3IlT


67/129IiIIn

Iiltll

ig

0

I

Efl

EB

Etl

0I

Po e systeo (cNPs) i3

projcts tnof these Prolec s aid rne najor

p ojecr sucn ds BurniP ojecr Hourd

Projec s,or1dsspL ce .ieki Projec ,,rr.a,..". ". :n" .p,

caadarr P.ojec

hydro p oje. r chP ojecr *or1d aiso


68/129

FF

E

nltg

g

$iga

g

i- r17i:i

6{h/Y

sapt candaki j 1991roLalj etr rr iecL: 19:o

$

fiE

$q

prolect, 1t

pioject endnI3


69/129

Il

B

Etfi

tl en years (1e65-1e74)

caDdakr, sublecr ro

1

8fr(l

I3liIlU

tl?

(.s ) at Burhl( oL),ere a so varledoDtihLs P oiecr capacliy.rhe flri::De ;y cap a:


70/129

Ftlg

tl

g

I$

E]

llgl

EIai

E

cardaki proj

Er saPr.and;kij ani

- d3(. P,oje.,.

9 ":: .

,, .br-. :. " ;

pa ticurar p oie.r


71/129

I3

BBl]

tjg

E

stt a ed t, rhe i'raiiff

fo r o eie sy of 4 c/kvhof:''Po"erth i, ,",; r".l

c/krh, as e5 riDa ad

3ig0x

at27.lc eIe:l ate.This1r7" lDreresr.(see "r3rrf f

'1

id

be $ 10c/krlyr arq6. e0/r{/rr atsLudy", Exhlrit 5.3).

.o be 11 ./k h,

72,a./k"h

,l


72/129

a[lE1l

B]d5B

frolecL "r,es

...e5ti'.tedb'1r..,r

tnu

InllII


73/129

IIt

IIllII

ll

I

t

I1

1

:lI


74/129

ri "t,

tIt

nt11

n

EIi

fl

I


75/129I

III

I

IIII

ea

Bg3

tIII


76/129

B

l

jB

llIII

I=:;ir: E:;a:'*;:;ilai:rE::: : :',,ii' :r::i,it: : ri :;::: fl i:ir:: ;i,:-srg i i:: s :i ir-:ie;l:: :: il::ri: ;:::; l :I

III


77/129

II=

t

IIII

11


78/129

EE3

;-- til :F:'" E:-'", ;::";;

a:e:t---;:e:

-t :::"l --fel E

l"--

III

IIt

III

5"=

.i"lr:< -.".,i: _1.= i9. =. :*; q,'6i':i -:"--i: - Fiai ::i;: : l i:i.'.3

=l;-3,i; Er ali;:: -: lc

:'" i. 9 =- , a::{l :i' l ..E :.e g i::;r;. rE: : .."-';:. o.::..i 5 : ::i: t


79/129

rNE

3

flB

B

Proj ec - Racoonended capacltl

n3

II

1lI

iEII$

Projecr at eacll

. andak I ro jeqt,ourd be a qajojus ify Lhe j c . 4 o e a r 3 1 c o s s

ore objec iyery, benfit/cost ar?lysis o:bererr /.qs r ,aiio rorProjecr size

I


80/129

{B$

IID

benerrt/ccs;

I3

3IEtil

E

rhrs be ef 1r/.dsr1'"c-'"" o"'".t- '"" . ." su_1r - daL. Prole...


81/129

B3lIIIaI

IDI

III

3IEIT

(.sL) tro in cnaprer 6,

a r ter atrve (11)(Ns) frod s techrnicar YrekPoirt.

(Ns) atterEarlve ras been

I


82/129

3

":"".

3

1

tI

3

tII

TEI


83/129

li

I0ll

i

li

flf,r

u

I

fl

zor4 (zone i)


84/129

tffltlfln

co e Dasisn ( zd e 1)

,nnT

ni

iIlII

(st. dard p oc.or) l')

(zores 2a arc ?B) aqd r ansrrlon (zone."""1,p. .,.".. "r;"-,." "B$lT

't

DesrcDs 12one5 : aEc 3)


85/129

t:tlF]

6

f]t]

A,1

IEIgi

tl


86/129

gr

F[lIit

flIIfiltll

IntEI

g0

t

IIiI


87/129

:iB

B

g3

IIG

BE

3l3I

IE


88/129

flflt]

i:

IBn

ntl

:r i''tnto lhe tner'thE;

- q: .l:, "epac-dovis eao.o.fe da;s

".'."'"

iI?1lB

ii' 1

1,

I


89/129


90/129

{

Ig

eB

0

rE

3-5 ) rhe a LinE

.B

in

E

rie P ojecr s

gtIIlri

'tI


91/129

nEIn

FI

fi

Ei

P;ovrstoa foi s tl;i:

3

IIBIE

oi rhe /s c.fterdsr

d/s corferdan

IEE

dB

0I


92/129

Ea

I3Il3n

I333B

b/s s d heop nr?,,,;n sr d,.

t

nII

,lI


93/129

[l

fliEi

Ig

lIfi

E] r /s

3ro lapprox) aDd rs 4oo

I

gB


94/129

0Ill

trl1

and d/. roPe or 1r1]n31ce ibe ch:i e1 li11 ;"tre u/s cofferdsh,

ITnfir

Iilt

B3

tl

',..'j,.. ;""

'.. "'t

df si:e 1 x 10 o. Tl;to'.rs b irt oi to o;

IE0

schedure h,; bee


95/129

E

3'3

EI

3Ii3

a

12 3oo mr/s_

durrrior rr.ods 1s t.;6 ;.

frood r ti 6.5

I33

3

ro 053 m:r/s of,arer.


96/129

6od''"" osr65'r/"-1" ' " t:.1

p.oject desis, ,..".: p,"p.,1" """. "f is ;. tr.. .rd.. o., ".o r/s /n aDd 1n@ay arreln 2so E3/s/n,

naximui Yqlodltr durrns P olecr

" g,'". ;,"p""." .." -"d,",

fT[]

I?

iln

fi

EiII

tr

I

gntin

aIE


97/129

6

Ig

IB

gB

IItrfl

lrI

$


98/129


99/129

l[;

ilt

flugi

B luqoel \Hrr)gIfi

rE

a) lnnu a I ross orb) Recur;iaa 3niual

t.lltll0

oi rhc kir,(Fis- 3,i).'.

"tth ,rr".: r,k.;rrP r o p o s c .i , I E r e r e , r ) .

r/ s. rhi5 verocir/ 1


100/129

I

FII

aid dtreDsi..tie 'e ;

t

a$

giIreparr/servlc e oofr

IfiE8I

II


101/129

ti

t0I

IrnnF

Bli$

$g

specrri. sPeei (ne rr.)0c: l dr".har6., h }s


102/129

IIgi

IIB

IIIi

n

IIrll

'I

' :l '"id "".."-:":'" ':' ",,"Bl oa ioed rejecrior,lrF:dy ood on

-l-'n":i ''11

'l'[


103/129


104/129

ItIIIt

(ilsnr of-,ay ) III oaei trre toLal rtne ragrn.66 kv. De arI3 0f tnese s 3tron5 0r Lhe:i:l::1"'i..'."

'rod - prol.ct srrf.

:"" """t 'c'rP'""r " tr'""q"rp'."t_h. PlolFcr 6tr il:1ll "':'P"'i:c:..5 u3"d 3 o11,: prota.r, rh.

II

I


105/129

ftFnugI

,l

'l1I1

Il]

BBn

1" .n" Ra rh,";d,

I

Bn,J

'l


106/129

B

EIIgn

": " 1..9 , ...,, tsrth cye .head shleld,lr;

a"".,"''.,

(qrenhait Byc oelectrlc P.oj;cL_

InIIfrU

IIEII$I


107/129

5

1

InI

D

I

III

flIB

trxoa

Proje.r t:sood. Hrc/N, s plarnip ojecr,irr

s. a c cd;d t s

. ' ero, ;,, b,id^" 3."".

hyder projecthyder Ploject rhe ProjecLProlecr,irr pass veryProJect stre.

3nu?l

u


108/129

gl

Ii

I'

?ll

IgI

n

n

0'"nEu

I

g

?

I


109/129

IIrT,F"0IE

3'.iillun3

1ten.A]]o,a ces

or tne P ojec

cois t uc ton P.o jecrs

11

'

ltil1

I


110/129

v

l

'l,l

IInnu

3tI

tIl r Proje.r c add rotsl:

sl Dec.33 xrriro 6

'


111/129

IIII

3

3

I3

E

i1

Ii3t ol

isIt


112/129

II3It

,

II'

n

I

I


113/129

I::l.I

tr3

II

,I

n

IiI

:lilIIInI1

1


114/129

3I

l3

IB

;l,1

i

:: ^ : 5: :"

gl r qoE ":;

nnII

I

',1

'1


115/129

,J:-l;1

oIB

333II

.L

E.: Iq 44 Fqc c -:

o :_EF ; i:-;1

?

Ii

'l'l

1 jl :


116/129

3

I3lI

I

3

"1:l=f,

lJ

III

5l ="J5:l :i"il :ETIIIII1


117/129

I]q3

I

II

lrIT

iII3

:iil

il ;

gEI

"J"

I

11


118/129

,:l;i;i

3BllI

iliII

' o rooq4-rP :.j

IgI

IItT

lIlI lg

;l ;


119/129

r:i

'ji;l

iIgg

nIq

J;l

.l-

n3Eu?

II

H


120/129

I

"1;:1

'

n'

IlI

3lIl3g

l5

n

T

I'l,1


121/129

33

:l-:l::lil :' : :

InIT

IlTII

:l

Il

'l

.ait=i:

'1


122/129

T3

-;13l

3

;lJIII

IIII

Hl4

IT't1


123/129

3G

-,;l;:lsl

lg

tI

,t'

,l

III3

tII

nIIIII


124/129

il3I

i.r rIe ,rrjecr.rratioD of treoo.r od irar P.oje.r,I " ,, ."

scredule ro f l-.;

ttl

il

,l

j

a$j ,..,?trl'3


125/129

tI

6

I

u6Uf

[]

I

nU

tl

u

nll

0E

6

flfitl

lo .1iec osuie


126/129

EtII

T

n

nn

uAll

i3I

nIgt

I

llEE

ju3t prevlous

I ,".'.,""


127/129

Et3

IiII

3I the porrar p.eParairo

3En

,1


128/129

llI

t

It

II$t

E

IIl

Ig

3Ilt

I

IoPo r of i jor rq 1pnP'r


129/129

,'

II : " P rol ". tifl

ga

Documents

BGHEP Prefeasibility Report 1984