12
If it looks like 7 Be and says it’s 7 Be it doesn’t always mean that it is 7 Be Robert Hardy Jackie Pates

Be it doesn’t always mean that it is Be · What 7Be is used for Blake et al. (1999) Applied Radiation and Isotopes.51, 599–605

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Be it doesn’t always mean that it is Be · What 7Be is used for Blake et al. (1999) Applied Radiation and Isotopes.51, 599–605

If it looks like 7Be and says it’s 7Be it doesn’t always mean that

it is 7Be

Robert Hardy

Jackie Pates

Page 2: Be it doesn’t always mean that it is Be · What 7Be is used for Blake et al. (1999) Applied Radiation and Isotopes.51, 599–605

Overview

• Context of the work

– 7Be as a environmental tracer

• Data that was recorded

– Looking good

– Wait that can’t be 7Be…

• What was really measured

– The mystery nuclide

Page 3: Be it doesn’t always mean that it is Be · What 7Be is used for Blake et al. (1999) Applied Radiation and Isotopes.51, 599–605

7Be Production

7Be N2 O2

Page 4: Be it doesn’t always mean that it is Be · What 7Be is used for Blake et al. (1999) Applied Radiation and Isotopes.51, 599–605

What 7Be is used for

Blake et al. (1999) Applied Radiation and Isotopes. 51, 599–605

Page 5: Be it doesn’t always mean that it is Be · What 7Be is used for Blake et al. (1999) Applied Radiation and Isotopes.51, 599–605

Clean-up of Tracer

Page 6: Be it doesn’t always mean that it is Be · What 7Be is used for Blake et al. (1999) Applied Radiation and Isotopes.51, 599–605

Gamma spectrum

Page 7: Be it doesn’t always mean that it is Be · What 7Be is used for Blake et al. (1999) Applied Radiation and Isotopes.51, 599–605

Resin binding experiments

• Used tracer to investigate how “Be” binds under different acid concentrations

Horwitz and McAlister (2005) Solvent Extraction and Ion Exchange. 23, 611-629

Page 8: Be it doesn’t always mean that it is Be · What 7Be is used for Blake et al. (1999) Applied Radiation and Isotopes.51, 599–605

“Let’s just check”

Recounted vials after ~300 day. All Be should be gone

Some 54Mn in tracer so recounted to assess 54Mn contribution to count rate

Page 9: Be it doesn’t always mean that it is Be · What 7Be is used for Blake et al. (1999) Applied Radiation and Isotopes.51, 599–605

It’s not 7Be but what is it? Let’s make a model

When optimised model includes NO Be and half-life of X of ~340 days

Model Variables: Counts of Be, Counts of X, Half-life of X

Page 10: Be it doesn’t always mean that it is Be · What 7Be is used for Blake et al. (1999) Applied Radiation and Isotopes.51, 599–605

Possible candidates

Searched every element with half-life 300-360 days

Element Z N Decay Half-life (days)49V 23 26 ε 330

54Mn 25 29 ε+β+, β-   312.3

145Sm 62 83 ε 340

248Cf 98 150 α, SF 333.5

249Bk 97 152 β-,α, SF 320

Page 11: Be it doesn’t always mean that it is Be · What 7Be is used for Blake et al. (1999) Applied Radiation and Isotopes.51, 599–605

Back to Gamma Spectroscopy 145Sm, 61 keV, 12%

54Mn, 835 keV, 99%

7Be, 477 keV, 10%

49V no gamma

Page 12: Be it doesn’t always mean that it is Be · What 7Be is used for Blake et al. (1999) Applied Radiation and Isotopes.51, 599–605

Conclusion

• 7Be not easily detected with LS

– Counting efficiency too low

• Contamination may be present

– Issues with safety

• What are you really handling/disposing of

– Calibration problems

• Counting efficiency

RH funded by studentship from NERC and ACTF Resins supplied by Steffen Happel (Triskem)