Upload
joleen-williams
View
219
Download
3
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Atkins’ Diet:Atkins’ Diet: Does it REALLY Work? Does it REALLY Work?
Dr. Christine Simpson, MD Dr. Christine Simpson, MD FRCPCFRCPC
General Internal MedicineGeneral Internal Medicine
CHIP Director, EdmontonCHIP Director, Edmonton
Who? Who?
• Dr. Atkins, cardiologistDr. Atkins, cardiologist
• Sold 10 million copies of his book, Sold 10 million copies of his book,
“ “Diet Revolution”, copyrighted Diet Revolution”, copyrighted 1973 1973
• Other contemporaries:Other contemporaries:– ““The Zone”, by SearsThe Zone”, by Sears– ““Protein Power”, by EadesProtein Power”, by Eades
Why?Why?
• Obesity epidemic began in the late 70’sObesity epidemic began in the late 70’s
• Continual spiral upwards, despite the Continual spiral upwards, despite the
low-fat dietary messages promotedlow-fat dietary messages promoted
by the medical professionby the medical profession
• 60% Americans overweight (BMI >25),60% Americans overweight (BMI >25),
30% are obese (BMI >30)30% are obese (BMI >30)
What?What?
• During the 1970’s, new concepts about fatDuring the 1970’s, new concepts about fat
* primary nutritional evil* primary nutritional evil
* especially saturated fat of meat & dairy* especially saturated fat of meat & dairy
• Atkins countered this by promising weightAtkins countered this by promising weight
loss while eating steak, eggs and butter toloss while eating steak, eggs and butter to
our heart’s content BECAUSE:our heart’s content BECAUSE:
* carbs cause obesity and heart * carbs cause obesity and heart diseasedisease
One follower says of the One follower says of the diet:diet:• Atkins allowed his readers to eat “truly Atkins allowed his readers to eat “truly
luxurious foods without limit,” as he put it, luxurious foods without limit,” as he put it, “lobster with butter sauce, steak with “lobster with butter sauce, steak with bearnaise sauce…bacon cheeseburgers,” bearnaise sauce…bacon cheeseburgers,” but allowed no starches or refined but allowed no starches or refined carbohydrates, which means no sugars or carbohydrates, which means no sugars or anything made from flour. Atkins banned anything made from flour. Atkins banned even fruit juices, and permitted only a even fruit juices, and permitted only a modicum of vegetables, although the latter modicum of vegetables, although the latter were negotiable, as diet progressed. were negotiable, as diet progressed.
Garry TaubesGarry Taubes
How? How?
• High glycemic index foods (carbs that areHigh glycemic index foods (carbs that are
absorbed quickly) promote absorbed quickly) promote hyperglycemiahyperglycemia
…….an insulin surge…..then hypoglycemia.an insulin surge…..then hypoglycemia
• This leads to hunger and MORE carbsThis leads to hunger and MORE carbs
carvings; hence, increased caloric intakecarvings; hence, increased caloric intake
• During the insulin surge, sugar is During the insulin surge, sugar is
transformed into FAT and muscletransformed into FAT and muscle
The hypothesis:The hypothesis:
• With a carb-depleted diet, there are NOWith a carb-depleted diet, there are NO
insulin surgesinsulin surges
• When cellular glucose is depleted, fat When cellular glucose is depleted, fat and muscle metabolism (break-down) and muscle metabolism (break-down) beginsbegins
• This is the process called “ketosis”, This is the process called “ketosis”, which is identical to that seen in which is identical to that seen in starvationstarvation
Is there any scientific Is there any scientific evidence?evidence?• Up until 2002, virtually nothingUp until 2002, virtually nothing
• Most “evidence” was anecdotalMost “evidence” was anecdotal
• The best scientific evidence requires:The best scientific evidence requires:
* a randomized, controlled trial * a randomized, controlled trial
testing two groups of subjects:testing two groups of subjects:
a) Atkins diet versusa) Atkins diet versus
b) high carb dietb) high carb diet
* Must look for benefits AND harm over time!* Must look for benefits AND harm over time!
Two recent scientific Two recent scientific studies:studies:
• July 2002, July 2002, American Journal of American Journal of MedicineMedicine
• May 2003, May 2003, New England Journal New England Journal
of Medicineof Medicine
• Funded by the National Institute of Funded by the National Institute of HealthHealth
The Details:The Details:
• 132 people, average weight 286 pounds132 people, average weight 286 pounds
• 63 people, average weight 217 pounds63 people, average weight 217 pounds
• Low carb (25-30 g/day, ~100-120 Cal)Low carb (25-30 g/day, ~100-120 Cal)
• High carb (200-300 g/day, ~1200 Cal,High carb (200-300 g/day, ~1200 Cal,
25% fat)25% fat)
Followed for ONLY one year!Followed for ONLY one year!
The Results:The Results:
• Low carb:Low carb:– 1) in 6 months, lost1) in 6 months, lost
13 pounds13 pounds
- 2) in 6 months, lost- 2) in 6 months, lost
15 15 pounds;pounds;
regained 1/3regained 1/3
- HDL increased by 18%- HDL increased by 18%
-Trigs decreased by 28%-Trigs decreased by 28%- No diff in LDL or BPNo diff in LDL or BP
• High carbHigh carb– 1) in 6 months, lost1) in 6 months, lost
4 pounds4 pounds
- 2) in 6 months, lost- 2) in 6 months, lost
7 pounds;7 pounds;
regained regained 1/51/5
- HDL increased by 3%- HDL increased by 3%- Trigs increased by 1%Trigs increased by 1%- No diff in LDL or BPNo diff in LDL or BP
The Conclusion:The Conclusion:
• A carb-depleted diet results in greater A carb-depleted diet results in greater
weight loss in 6 months, and does not weight loss in 6 months, and does not cause significant harm to the lipid cause significant harm to the lipid profile (perhaps even a benefit?).profile (perhaps even a benefit?).
• ie. “A healthy, short-term method forie. “A healthy, short-term method for
weight loss!”weight loss!”
??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
•Does that really Does that really make sense?make sense?
Studies are inherently Studies are inherently flawed!flawed!
• Flawed in design and interpretationFlawed in design and interpretation
• Very low sample size, very short-Very low sample size, very short-termterm
• 40% drop-out rate (same in both 40% drop-out rate (same in both groups)groups)
What we were NOT told:What we were NOT told:
• Carb-eaters caught up with weight Carb-eaters caught up with weight loss during the 2loss during the 2ndnd 6 months 6 months
• Diet compositions were actually NOTDiet compositions were actually NOTdrastically different:drastically different:
* 41% (Atkins) fat versus 33%* 41% (Atkins) fat versus 33%* Dean Ornish says:* Dean Ornish says:
“ “they have compared two diets, they have compared two diets, neither of which is very effective” neither of which is very effective”
An even closer look:An even closer look:
• Most of the weight lost in the Atkins dietMost of the weight lost in the Atkins diet
group was due to a decreased total group was due to a decreased total
amount of consumed calories!amount of consumed calories!
• The initial weight loss is water, followed The initial weight loss is water, followed
by fat AND muscle; is ketosis dangerous?by fat AND muscle; is ketosis dangerous?
• The lipid profile changes can not be The lipid profile changes can not be
considered secondary to diet considered secondary to diet compositionscompositions
One more point:One more point:
• Ketosis theory and blood sugar/insulinKetosis theory and blood sugar/insulin
surge mechanism:surge mechanism:
- NOT true when whole grains, legumes,- NOT true when whole grains, legumes,
and high-fiber fruits and vegetablesand high-fiber fruits and vegetables
are consumedare consumed
““Foods as grown, simply prepared!”Foods as grown, simply prepared!”
The REAL scientific The REAL scientific conclusion:conclusion:• ““longer and larger studies are requiredlonger and larger studies are required
to determine the long-term safety and to determine the long-term safety and efficacy of low-carbohydrate, high-protein, efficacy of low-carbohydrate, high-protein, high-fat diets.”high-fat diets.”
• The debate continues, but the studies to date The debate continues, but the studies to date do NOT prove superiority of an Atkins-style do NOT prove superiority of an Atkins-style diet over a high COMPLEX carbohydrate diet;diet over a high COMPLEX carbohydrate diet;
• Rather, they simply re-emphasize that Rather, they simply re-emphasize that calorie restriction aids in short-term weight calorie restriction aids in short-term weight loss.loss.
Any volunteers for further Any volunteers for further studies?studies?
•Questions?Questions?
•Comments?Comments?
Point 1:Point 1:
•Save a quarter on Save a quarter on your food bill…your food bill…
… …and add 10 years to and add 10 years to your life!your life!