1
S88 Invited Speakers Assessing diet quality: Challenges and opportuni- ties in assessing dietary intake in children Rebecca Golley Sansom Institute for Health Research, University South Australia Diet indices capture whole diet better than sin- gle nutrients or food groups, and are thought to reflect overall dietary patterns. The use of an index can aid our understanding of how the complex mix of foods we eat influences health outcomes. This is particularly useful in child obesity research, as multiple aspects of diet influence energy balance. This presentation will describe the development and validation of a food-based index that reflects adherence to the Australian Dietary Guidelines for Children and Adolescents. The challenges of assess- ing diet quality in the context of child obesity will also be discussed. Data were analysed from 4—16 year old par- ticipants of the 2007 Australian National Nutrition and Physical Activity Survey (n = 3416). Eleven index items reflecting the dietary guidelines were devel- oped (total possible score of 100). The mean DGI-CA score was 53.6 ± 15.2 (range 5.98—92.3). Children most commonly scored full points for the ‘Meat and alternatives’ indicator (49—64%) and were least commonly scored full points on the ‘Vegetables’ indicator (9—15%). Few children scored full points on the ‘Extra foods’ indicator (20—38%). However, preliminary analysis found only a weak relation- ship between DQI-CA score and weight status. This identified areas for further analysis and may reflect factors such as under-reporting, the indicators and scoring system, as well as foods included for anal- ysis. The DGI-CA is a food-based diet index appropri- ate for use with Australian children. With further validation, this index could be used to monitor pop- ulation nutrition, as well as inform and evaluate child obesity interventions. doi:10.1016/j.orcp.2010.09.172 How much do we believe what families tell us about dietary change? Validation and reporting of dietary outcomes Tracy Burrows School of Health Sciences, University of Newcastle Studies that include dietary outcomes as part of evaluating child obesity interventions are lim- ited. This may reflect the range of challenges associated with assessing diet in children includ- ing: limited availability of validated tools for use with paediatric populations; cost and participant- burden associated with dietary assessment; and child-specific considerations such as age, cognitive abilities, portions size estimates and parent ver- sus child reporting. Food frequency questionnaires (FFQ) are one type of dietary assessment method that and are commonly used in studies with large sample sizes. The Australian Child and Adolescent Eating Survey (ACAES) is a semi-quantitative FFQ. This tool has been validated against 24 h recall for self-report use in children aged 9 to 16 and nutritional biomarkers for parent report in children aged 5 to 12. Plasma carotenoids and red blood cell fatty acids showed moderate, but statistically significant correlations (ranging between 0.3—0.6, P < 0.05) between parent reported dietary intakes of children 5—12 years and plasma carotenoids as markers of fruit and vegetable intake in addition to red blood cell membrane fatty acids as markers of fat intake. While the absolute values are dependent on other metabolic factors including bioavailabil- ity and efficiency of absorption, results indicates that when a parent reports an increase in F&V using ACAES, it is reflected in increased total plasma carotenoids concentration. Assessment of change in food consumption will inform interventions as people eat food not nutri- ents. Future studies could consider additional biomarker assessments to assist with validation of reported of dietary intakes in children. Report the objectives of the dietary inter- ventions. Many studies did not report dietary outcomes, and it is unclear whether food intake data was not collected or was collected but not used because it was of poor quality or because the focus in reporting was only on changes in the primary outcome of weight status. If children’s dietary intakes are assessed and reported regularly using similar instruments, comparisons over time and across interventions will be facilitated. doi:10.1016/j.orcp.2010.09.173 Ghrelin and neurodegenerative effects on satiety Zane Andrews Department of Physiology, Monash University The brain plays a critical role in the regulation of energy homeostasis, glucose homeostasis and obesity. Traditionally the hypothalamus has been the center of research focus and can be consid- ered as the ‘‘homeostatic’’ center regulating food intake and body weight. Indeed, many hormones such as leptin, insulin and ghrelin act within the

Assessing diet quality: Challenges and opportunities in assessing dietary intake in children

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

iwbcas(tsETfnacsPomrfoitAc

iebr

vodutpdua

d

G

Z

oo

S88

Assessing diet quality: Challenges and opportuni-ties in assessing dietary intake in children

Rebecca Golley

Sansom Institute for Health Research, UniversitySouth Australia

Diet indices capture whole diet better than sin-gle nutrients or food groups, and are thought toreflect overall dietary patterns. The use of an indexcan aid our understanding of how the complex mixof foods we eat influences health outcomes. Thisis particularly useful in child obesity research, asmultiple aspects of diet influence energy balance.This presentation will describe the developmentand validation of a food-based index that reflectsadherence to the Australian Dietary Guidelines forChildren and Adolescents. The challenges of assess-ing diet quality in the context of child obesity willalso be discussed.

Data were analysed from 4—16 year old par-ticipants of the 2007 Australian National Nutritionand Physical Activity Survey (n = 3416). Eleven indexitems reflecting the dietary guidelines were devel-oped (total possible score of 100). The mean DGI-CAscore was 53.6 ± 15.2 (range 5.98—92.3). Childrenmost commonly scored full points for the ‘Meatand alternatives’ indicator (49—64%) and were leastcommonly scored full points on the ‘Vegetables’indicator (9—15%). Few children scored full pointson the ‘Extra foods’ indicator (20—38%). However,preliminary analysis found only a weak relation-ship between DQI-CA score and weight status. Thisidentified areas for further analysis and may reflectfactors such as under-reporting, the indicators andscoring system, as well as foods included for anal-ysis.

The DGI-CA is a food-based diet index appropri-ate for use with Australian children. With furthervalidation, this index could be used to monitor pop-ulation nutrition, as well as inform and evaluatechild obesity interventions.

doi:10.1016/j.orcp.2010.09.172

How much do we believe what families tell usabout dietary change? Validation and reporting ofdietary outcomes

Tracy Burrows

School of Health Sciences, University of Newcastle

Studies that include dietary outcomes as partof evaluating child obesity interventions are lim-ited. This may reflect the range of challengesassociated with assessing diet in children includ-

teis

Invited Speakers

ng: limited availability of validated tools for useith paediatric populations; cost and participant-urden associated with dietary assessment; andhild-specific considerations such as age, cognitivebilities, portions size estimates and parent ver-us child reporting. Food frequency questionnairesFFQ) are one type of dietary assessment methodhat and are commonly used in studies with largeample sizes. The Australian Child and Adolescentating Survey (ACAES) is a semi-quantitative FFQ.his tool has been validated against 24 h recallor self-report use in children aged 9 to 16 andutritional biomarkers for parent report in childrenged 5 to 12. Plasma carotenoids and red bloodell fatty acids showed moderate, but statisticallyignificant correlations (ranging between 0.3—0.6,< 0.05) between parent reported dietary intakesf children 5—12 years and plasma carotenoids asarkers of fruit and vegetable intake in addition to

ed blood cell membrane fatty acids as markers ofat intake. While the absolute values are dependentn other metabolic factors including bioavailabil-ty and efficiency of absorption, results indicateshat when a parent reports an increase in F&V usingCAES, it is reflected in increased total plasmaarotenoids concentration.

Assessment of change in food consumption willnform interventions as people eat food not nutri-nts. Future studies could consider additionaliomarker assessments to assist with validation ofeported of dietary intakes in children.

Report the objectives of the dietary inter-entions. Many studies did not report dietaryutcomes, and it is unclear whether food intakeata was not collected or was collected but notsed because it was of poor quality or becausehe focus in reporting was only on changes in therimary outcome of weight status. If children’sietary intakes are assessed and reported regularlysing similar instruments, comparisons over timend across interventions will be facilitated.

oi:10.1016/j.orcp.2010.09.173

hrelin and neurodegenerative effects on satiety

ane Andrews

Department of Physiology, Monash University

The brain plays a critical role in the regulationf energy homeostasis, glucose homeostasis andbesity. Traditionally the hypothalamus has been

he center of research focus and can be consid-red as the ‘‘homeostatic’’ center regulating foodntake and body weight. Indeed, many hormonesuch as leptin, insulin and ghrelin act within the