Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
2/28/2014 Arranged marriage ticket to India’s military industry | idrw.org
http://idrw.org/?p=34056#more-34056 1/7
Custom Search
HomeIndiaAsiaEuropeN & S America
AfricaExclusiveMy TakeThe Think tank (T3)Magazine
Search
Archives
February 2014January 2014December 2013November 2013
October 2013September 2013August 2013July 2013June 2013May 2013April 2013
Advertisement
2/28/2014 Arranged marriage ticket to India’s military industry | idrw.org
http://idrw.org/?p=34056#more-34056 2/7
« India Looking Abroad For Intermediate Jet Trainers
Arranged marriage ticket to India’s military industry
Published February 28, 2014 | By admin
SOURCE : INDRUS
2/28/2014 Arranged marriage ticket to India’s military industry | idrw.org
http://idrw.org/?p=34056#more-34056 3/7
India is the only major power that purchases the majority – over 70 percent – of its defence requirements throughimports. Over-reliance on defence imports not only leaves the country strategically vulnerable, it also involves a hugedrain of wealth. Plus, the kickbacks that accompany such deals can result in a compromised military and civilianleadership.
It was newly independent India’s Gandhian aversion for war that made it impossible for India to develop a defenceindustrial base. Writing in Rediff, retired Lt Gen Eric A. Vas offers a chilling peek into the mindset of India’s politicalleadership. During the 1948 war when Nehru was being briefed by Indian Air Force pilots in Kashmir, he was told theywere using 500 lb bombs against Pakistan Army infiltrators. He at once said this was an excessive use of force and theless powerful 250 lb bomb should be used, because in his view this was a violation of the principle of minimum force.
Lt Gen Vas says on another occasion, Nehru was shown a brief film about an air-to-air missile the IAF was interestedin. When the clip ended with the missile downing an ‘enemy’ plane in a cloud of flame, Nehru got up in a rage, andshouted, “I will have nothing to do with these sort of weapons” and stormed out of the room followed by his daughterIndira Gandhi.
Nehru’s cue was taken by other – equally misguided – leaders. Speaking on the defence budget in the Lok Sabha in1957, hard boiled Gandhian Acharya Kriplani said: “The mounting expenses on the army must be cut down. Thefollowers of Gandhi and adherents of universal peace should not increase military expenditure.”
Is it any wonder India can’t produce a world class jet while late comer South Korea is designing a stealth fighter?
Days of abstinence are over
After decades of blindly following Gandhi’s disastrous diktats, India is making a philosophy flip – to stay in the fight, youneed military might. Trending currently is a big rush by domestic companies to elbow into a turf for long dominated byforeign defence suppliers.
In a development that should be a wakeup call for India’s Defence Research & Development Organisation (DRDO),Tata Power has for the first time built an Indian prototype of a 155 MM mounted artillery gun system that is 65 per centindigenous.
In 2012 Tata Power became the first Indian private-sector company to beat an overseas defence major, Italy’sSelex, to win a $260 million Indian Air Force contract.
In fact, the $110 billion Tata Group has as many as 14 defence companies, and projects a 40 per cent jump in defencesales in 2014 on the back of outsourcing contracts it has inked with Lockheed Martin and Sirkosky Aircraft.
2/28/2014 Arranged marriage ticket to India’s military industry | idrw.org
http://idrw.org/?p=34056#more-34056 4/7
Automobile major Ashok Leyland has signed an agreement with Sweden’s SAAB to deliver high mobility vehicles forSAAB’s short range surface to air missile (SRSAM) system to compete for the Indian Army’s air defence programme.
At Defexpo 2014 in New Delhi, Larsen & Toubro, which has tied up with Nexter of France, unveiled a new version ofits Caesar 155 MM mounted gun system.
Another JV announced a day before Defexpo 2014 was between Bharat Forge Ltd and Israel’s Elbit Systems. Thecompany intends to build advanced artillery guns and mortars.
Equity and other barriers
Despite the enthusiasm of the private section to enter the defence sector – no doubt with an eye on India’s $120 billionplanned spending over the next five years – it is not going to be an easy market to crack.
Having almost zero experience in the sector, Indian companies will require foreign partners. But foreign companiescannot have more than 26 per cent equity stake in the Indian defence sector. No major manufacturer will jump into a JVto produce high tech weaponry in India unless that limit is raised to at least 49 per cent.
In February 2013, Britain’s BAE Systems walked out of a JV with Mahindra & Mahindra, ending their partnershipformed in 2009. BAE had 26 per cent equity in Mahindra Defence Systems.
Then there’s the offset clause – which makes it mandatory for foreign arms vendors to outsource a good chunk of theirwork to India. But Western companies are unlikely to welcome India’s transformation from the world’s top armsimporter into a weapons production hub. It’s simply bad for their business. A good example is France’s Dassault, whichis playing hardball over offsets to India in connection with the Rafale jet contract.
The Russians are coming
On the other hand, Russian as well as Israeli firms are more open towards transferring technology via partnerships withIndian firms.
Russia also does not adopt a hypocritical posture when it comes to how or where its weapons are used. The UnitedStates is the biggest culprit in this regard, and is known to cut off military supplies, especially during a crunch. BothPakistan and Egypt have suffered from America’s moralistic flipflop, which springs from the country’s Puritan ChristianDNA.
Moscow was one of the first to help India establish a defence industry, transferring serious technology at a time whenthe West turned its back. It is currently helping out in several big-ticket projects, including nuclear powered submarines,indigenous aircraft carriers, theatre air defence missiles and hypersonic missiles.
Among the new artillery pieces on show at Defexpo 2014 was a new Arjun tank chassis mated with a Russian built M-46 130mm self-propelled gun system. Known as the Arjun Catapult, the vehicle was developed by the DRDO’s IndianCombat Vehicle Research & Development Establishment. The Indian Army is reportedly planning to buy 40 of theseheavy hitters to equip two artillery regiments.
Need for Indian partners
However, Russia has to change tack and start partnering with private sector companies. This is imperative becausedoing business in India means getting past the country’s notoriously slow and powerful bureaucracy, and India’s privatesector has the expertise in oiling the levers of the bureaucratic machinery.
Going by the size and intent of the Russian contingent at Defexpo 2014, the bear appears willing to learn new tricks.Rosoboronexport – Russia’s primary weapons export cartel – came out all guns blazing, with as many as 48 companiesat the expo.
Rosoboronexport says it will explore joint development and production deals in India for weaponry and military
2/28/2014 Arranged marriage ticket to India’s military industry | idrw.org
http://idrw.org/?p=34056#more-34056 5/7
equipment. Its talks with potential local partners are in almost all cases “directly related to setting up JVs, establishinglicensed production and transfer of technology” says Ivan Goncharenko, the company’s First Deputy General Director.
Also promising is the new partnership between Morinformsystem Agat and Pipavav Shipyard, the first Indian corporateshipyard to be granted clearance to build warships and other vessels for the Indian Navy.
The two companies inked a series of MoUs on the sidelines of Defexpo 2014. Key projects they are likely to work oninclude radar, sonar, robotics, “high-speed surface shipbuilding” and a Combat Management System that’s strategicallyimportant for the Indian Navy.
Bilateral synergies
In 2012 the Kauffman Foundation published a survey that showed 29 per cent of all defence and aerospace startups inthe United States were established by Indians.
Considering that Indians comprise barely 1 per cent of America’s population, that’s some achievement. It is hardlysurprising that the United States gives priority green cards to Indian immigrants who possess high-tech skills.
However, for most Indians migration is a last resort; they would rather seek work locally provided challenging jobs anda conducive work environment are available. If the current wave of joint ventures between the private sector and foreignweapons manufacturers results in a thriving military industry in the country, many of these engineers are likely to stayhome.
Any way you look at it, it’s win-win for both sides. The benefits to India from Russian technology and expertise areobvious.
And by offshoring production to India, the Russian armaments industry – which faces a serious manpower shortage –could find its future weapons designers from Indian universities. Plus, it could tap experienced Indian defence industryengineers – who are forced to retire at the shockingly young age of 60.
Posted in India
Be the f irst of your friends to like this.Like
2/28/2014 Arranged marriage ticket to India’s military industry | idrw.org
http://idrw.org/?p=34056#more-34056 6/7
China developing world’s most accurate cruise …
8 comments
TATA SED developing “desi Blackberry” for Armed
… 3 comments
J-20 may have better ground attack capability
than F-22 12 comments
Akash missile test fired for third time 3 comments
AROUND THE WEB
ALSO ON IDRW.ORG
WHAT'S THIS?
Heart Attack: How Your Body
Warns You Days Before
Newsmax Health
What Cellulite Really Is: This Will
Shock You! Lifegooroo
What I Learned at Rehab
TheFix.com
2 Comments idrw.org Login
Sort by Best Share
Join the discussion…
• Reply •
laldo • an hour ago
the only reason why our defense sector always relied on imports is that our politician over decades
have swindled crores in bribes & scams, if our sector would have been privatized years ago it would
have been a different India who would have started exporting weapons into a profitable sector. Its lack
of foresight & failure which we have to face.
2
• Reply •
ramdas • an hour ago
When you are surrounded by cut throat enemies you need to fight to preserve peace. Nehru gandhi
family have totally misguided india. Lord Krishna fought the mahabharatha war against the unjust for
peace to prevail . He has not told Arjuna to give up weapons and follow the path of Buddhist ahimsa.
Buddhism philosphy is routed from India. We need to rout the congis. Vote modi.
Subscribe Add Disqus to your site
Favorite
Share ›
Share ›
Subscribe Via Email
Enter your email address:
2/28/2014 Arranged marriage ticket to India’s military industry | idrw.org
http://idrw.org/?p=34056#more-34056 7/7
Subscribe
Delivered by FeedBurner
Links
Aero India 2011 Photo AlbumIndian Defence News
Advertisement
Copyright © Idrw.org 2006. All Rights Reserved.Fair Use
idrw.org
Powered by IDRW OS 2.0
