Are There True Contradictions? A Critical Discussion of Graham Priest's "Beyond the Limits of Thought"

8/2/2019 Are There True Contradictions? A Critical Discussion of Graham Priest's "Beyond the Limits of Thought"

1/12

@|f ]jf|f ]|vf Den}|`mkd}kent5 @ D|k}kd`h Mktdvttken ec I|`j`a R|kft})t ,Lf{enm }jf Hkak}tec ]jevij},@v}je|*t+7 G|ifn Maen} `nm C|`no A`v\fskfyfm ye|o*t+7Tev|df7 Gev|n`h ce| Ifnf|`h Rjkheterj{ ec Tdkfndf % Wfk}tdj|kc} c| `hhifafknfYkttfntdj`c}t}jfe|kf( Seh.


2/12

MKTDVTTKENT

@\F ]JF\F ]\VF DEN]\@MKD]KENT5@ D|k}kd`h Mktdvttken ec I|`jà R|kft})t Lf{enm }jf hkak}t ec

}jevij}'

GV\IFNMVAEN]@NM C\@NOA@V

TVAA@\[. ]jf r|ftfn} `|}kdhf d|k}kd`hh{ fzàknft }j|ff `trfd}t ec I|`jà R|kft})tmk`hf}jfkd `n`h{tkt ec sf|{ kare|}`n} oknmt ec hkak}`}kent *}jf hkak} ec yj`} d`n lf fzr|fttfm(mftd|klfm( dendfksfm( oneyn( e| }jf hkak} ec teaf erf|`}ken e| e}jf|+. Ck|t}( k} kt tjeyn}j`} R|kft})t dentkmf|`}kent cedvtkni en Jfifh)t `ddevn} ec }jf kncknk}f d`nne} lf tvt}`knfm(

a`knh{lfd`vtf R|kft} tffat }e |fh{ en ` }ee |ft}|kd}ksf ne}ken ec elgfd}. Tfdenm(

yf mktdvttR|kft})t }|f`}afn} ec }jf r`|`mezft kn D`n}e|k`n tf}}jfe|{. K} kt tjeyn }j`} R|kft} meft ne}`mm|ftt }jf kttvf kn cvhh ifnf|`hk}{? |`}jf|( jf |fhkft en ` |f`mkni ec D`n}e| yjkdj karhkdk}h{`}}|klv}ft ` sf|{ t}|eni r|kndkrhf dendf|nkni pv`n}kckd`}ken esf| `|lk}|`|{ mea`knt }e D`n}e|. ]jk|m( }jf a`kn rkfdf ec R|kft})t ye|o( }jf ted`hhfm ,kndhetv|f tdjfa`,( kt knsft}ki`}fm.

]jkt tdjfa` kt tvrretfm }e ce|a`hkwf }jf de|f ec a`n{ yfhhoneyn r`|`mezft. Yf dh`ka(jeyfsf|( }j`} ce|a`hh{ }jf tdjfa` kt ne} tevnm.

Of{ ye|mt7 mk`hf}jfkta( r`|`dentkt}fn} heikd( r`|`mez( kncknk}{( pv`n}kckd`}ken( mea`kn r|kndkrhf( R|kft}( Jfifh( D`n}e|( D`|}y|kij}

0. KN]\EMVD]KEN

Vnmevl}fmh{( I|`jà R|kft} kt enf ec }jf aet} kare|}`n} `msed`}ft ec `r`|`dentkt}fn} *e| mk`hf}jfkd+ retk}ken yjetf de|f }jftkt kt }j`} }jf|f `|f}|vf den}|`mkd}kent( k.f.( }j`} le}j ` t}`}fafn}( t`{ `( `nm k}t nfi`}ken( ~ `(jehm `} }jf tàf }kaf. Kn ` tf|kft ec jkijh{ knchvfn}k`h heikderjkheterjkd`hrvlhkd`}kent *tff R|kft} _0;9;Q( _0;:=Q( _0;:9Q( `nm R|kft} f} `h. _0;:;Q+jf j`t mfsfherfm `nm mfcfnmfm ` s`|kf}{ ec r`|`dentkt}fn} *e| mk`hf}jfkd+`rr|e`djft `hh tj`|kni }jf a`kn dendfttken }j`} }jf|f `|f }|vf den}|`mkd}kent. Kn den}|`t} }e }jf `ce|fafn}kenfm den}|klv}kent yjkdj `|f ae|f e|hftt }fdjnkd`h }|f`}afn}t lfhenikni }e }jf ckfhm ec ce|a`h heikd( R|kft}( kn

Gev|n`h ce| Ifnf|`h Rjkheterj{ ec Tdkfndf


3/12


4/12

@\F ]JF\F]\VF DEN]\@DMKD]KENT5


5/12


6/12

@\F ]JF\F]\VFDEN]\@DMKD]KENT5


7/12


8/12



9/12


10/12

@\F ]JF\F]\VFDEN]\@DMKD]KENT5 nm kg+( `nm ` cvnd}ken T *}jf mkìen`hktf|+ yjkdj t`}ktc{ }jf cehheyknidenmk}kent *dc. rr. 0=*{+qzkt}t( `nm k%+*Dk+*kk+ kc gdkt ` tvltf} ec ck tvdj }j`} kr*z+X *`+ 6*z+5z*l+:*z+fn

@t enf d`n f`tkh{ tff( kc }jftf denmk}kent `|f t`}ktckfm( enf d`n mf|ksf `den}|`mkd}ken. @dde|mkni }e *k+ yf j`sf }j`} kc+*P+ yjkdj `hheyt vt }e }òfck `t ev| gd.Ney( yk}j *kk.`+ yf el}`kn :*-h+# ck( `nm yk}j *kk.l+ yf if}6*ck+FE. ]jvt( yf j`sf el}`knfm ` den}|`mkd}ken. R|kft} mfaent}|`}ft ce|` nvalf| ec fzàrhft }j`} }jf Kndhetv|f Tdjfa` d`n lf vtfm }e ce|a`hkwf`hh kare|}`n} r`|`mezft *\vttfhh)t( Lv|`hkCe|}k)t( Ak|ka`necc)t( Oefnki)t(

Lf||{)t( `nm \kdj`|m)t r`|`mez+. En }jf enf j`nm }jkt tjeyt }jf i|f`}kare|}`ndf ec }jf Kndhetv|f Tdjfa`. En }jf e}jf| j`nm k} tjeyt }j`} }jftf

r`|`mezft `|f enh{ ifnvknf r`|`mezft kn }jf tfntf ec }jf Kndhetv|fTdjfa` kc }jf Kndhetv|f Tdjfa` kt ce|a`hh{ tevnm.Vnce|}vn`}fh{( }jf h`}}f| kt ne} }jf d`tf. Kn e|mf| }e tff }jkt dentkmf| }jfcvnd}ken T yjkdj kt mfcknfm `t ` cvnd}ken c|ea }jf reyf| tf} ec 5+( k.f. }jf

dh`tt ec `hh tvldh`ttft ec ck( t{alehkd`hh{ ,R*ck+)X kn}e ck767R*ck+ > n

Ney( tkndf 3 kt mfcknfm `t ` cvnd}ken( `nm R|kft} kt elskevth{ ye|okni yk}j}jf t}`nm`|m tf}}jfe|f}kd dendfr} ec ,cvnd}ken,( yf j`sf( l{ }jf mfcknk}kenec :( }j`} ce| fsf|{ fhfafn} gd kn }jf mea`kn ec :

nàfh{ R*ck+ }jf s`hvf


11/12


12/12


Documents

Are There True Contradictions? A Critical Discussion of Graham Priest's "Beyond the Limits of Thought"