19
ARCHITECTURE 3410: ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN STUDIO IV The Ohio State University, Austin E. Knowlton School of Architecture AU 2014 – Mondays, Wednesdays, Fridays 1:30 5:18 PM (see schedule) Instructors Jackie Gargus, coordinatrix ([email protected]) Kristi Balliet ([email protected]) Isabela Gould ([email protected]) Laurie Gunzelman ([email protected]) Troy Malmstrom ([email protected]) Zach Snyder ([email protected]) Lisa Tilder ([email protected]) Introduction Architecture 3410 is the first studio of the third year of the undergraduate architecture curriculum at the Knowlton School of Architecture. We will deal with three projects of medium to largescale: a campus athletic facility (4 weeks), a fire station (4 weeks), and a craft brewery (6 weeks). In the interest of exposing students to a variety of perspectives at the Knowlton School, studio instructors will change sections halfway through the term. Students are urged to pursue conceptual, formal, and phenomenal aspects of their designs, but they must also have strong strategies for dealing with the site, program, material, circulation, service, and structure. Format: Studio meetings will be of two types: group pinups or discussions, and desk critiques. Each studio instructor will decide which type of meeting is most appropriate for each class session. Students are required to be in studio for the entirety of class time and must be ready to present at the beginning of class. All communication with the studio instructor should be carefully considered, as it will be critical to evolving directions and assignments. Students must check their university email daily. Deadlines: Students who miss deadlines due to valid extenuating circumstances may submit the required work at a date agreed upon with the instructor. University regulations limit such circumstances to serious personal illness and death in the immediate family, and both cases require written documentation: a doctor’s note or a newspaper obituary. Unexcused late projects are not accepted, incomplete projects are evaluated in relation to their degree of completion, and a student is present only if he or she presents sufficient work to the instructor. A student will be warned by email after the first unexcused absence; a student’s grade may drop one letter grade after the second unexcused absence; and a student with three unexcused absences can be immediately dismissed and given an “E.” Documentation: Students must provide hardcopy and digital reproductions of all final projects. Hardcopy reproductions will consist of images of all final models and 8.5” by 11” reproductions of all presentation drawings. Digital reproductions of both models (as jpegs) and drawings (as PDFs) will be stored on CDs, one CD per student, or dropped in the Instructor’s Homework Folder. Students must submit documentation by 5 PM Thursday, December 18, 2014. Failure to meet this deadline will result in a grade of "incomplete." Evaluation: Studio work is both individual and collective. Criteria of evaluation include not only individual design excellence, but also a student’s contributions to the studio through collective research, team projects, documentation, and discussions. There are three major design projects, as well as additional assignments. Grading is based on a comparison with other students in the course, with students who have taken the course previously, and with the instructors' expectations relative to the objectives of the course. Evaluation of projects is by jury review involving reviewers from other courses, other academic institutions, and architectural firms. For an "A", the student must satisfy the course objectives excellently; for a "B", in an above average manner; for a "C" in an average manner; for a "D" in the lowest acceptable manner; and an "E" denotes that the student has not satisfied the course objectives. Sexual Harassment: O.S.U.'s Sexual Harassment policy, which applies to all faculty, staff, and students, includes lewd remarks and inappropriate comments made in the studio environment, classroom, and computer labs as well as the "display of inappropriate sexually oriented materials in a location where others can see it." Students can file a complaint by contacting Student Judicial Affairs at 2920748. Sanctions include reprimand, suspension, and dismissal from the University.

Arch 3410 F14 - SYL - Proj 1 draft 25AUG14 3410 Sylla… · ! 5! $ Knowlton$School$of$Architecture$ ARCH$3410,$Fall$2014$ Coordinatrix:Gargus$ Studio$Instructors:$Balliet,$Gould,$Gunzelman,$Malmstrom,$Snyder,$Tilder$

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    24

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Arch 3410 F14 - SYL - Proj 1 draft 25AUG14 3410 Sylla… · ! 5! $ Knowlton$School$of$Architecture$ ARCH$3410,$Fall$2014$ Coordinatrix:Gargus$ Studio$Instructors:$Balliet,$Gould,$Gunzelman,$Malmstrom,$Snyder,$Tilder$

  1  

ARCHITECTURE  3410:  ARCHITECTURAL  DESIGN  STUDIO  IV  The  Ohio  State  University,  Austin  E.  Knowlton  School  of  Architecture  AU  2014  –  Mondays,  Wednesdays,  Fridays  1:30  -­‐  5:18  PM  (see  schedule)    Instructors  Jackie  Gargus,  coordinatrix    ([email protected])  Kristi  Balliet  ([email protected])  Isabela  Gould  ([email protected])  Laurie  Gunzelman  ([email protected])  Troy  Malmstrom  ([email protected])  Zach  Snyder  ([email protected])  Lisa  Tilder  ([email protected])      Introduction    Architecture  3410  is  the  first  studio  of  the  third  year  of  the  undergraduate  architecture  curriculum  at  the  Knowlton  School  of  Architecture.  We  will  deal  with  three  projects  of  medium  to  large-­‐scale:    a  campus  athletic  facility  (4  weeks),  a  fire  station  (4  weeks),  and  a  craft  brewery  (6  weeks).    In  the  interest  of  exposing  students  to  a  variety  of  perspectives  at  the  Knowlton  School,  studio  instructors  will  change  sections  halfway  through  the  term.  Students  are  urged  to  pursue  conceptual,  formal,  and  phenomenal  aspects  of  their  designs,  but  they  must  also  have  strong  strategies  for  dealing  with  the  site,  program,  material,  circulation,  service,  and  structure.    Format:  Studio  meetings  will  be  of  two  types:  group  pin-­‐ups  or  discussions,  and  desk  critiques.    Each  studio  instructor  will  decide  which  type  of  meeting  is  most  appropriate  for  each  class  session.    Students  are  required  to  be  in  studio  for  the  entirety  of  class  time  and  must  be  ready  to  present  at  the  beginning  of  class.  All  communication  with  the  studio  instructor  should  be  carefully  considered,  as  it  will  be  critical  to  evolving  directions  and  assignments.  Students  must  check  their  university  email  daily.      Deadlines:  Students  who  miss  deadlines  due  to  valid  extenuating  circumstances  may  submit  the  required  work  at  a  date  agreed  upon  with  the  instructor.  University  regulations  limit  such  circumstances  to  serious  personal  illness  and  death  in  the  immediate  family,  and  both  cases  require  written  documentation:  a  doctor’s  note  or  a  newspaper  obituary.  Unexcused  late  projects  are  not  accepted,  incomplete  projects  are  evaluated  in  relation  to  their  degree  of  completion,  and  a  student  is  present  only  if  he  or  she  presents  sufficient  work  to  the  instructor.  A  student  will  be  warned  by  email  after  the  first  unexcused  absence;  a  student’s  grade  may  drop  one  letter  grade  after  the  second  unexcused  absence;  and  a  student  with  three  unexcused  absences  can  be  immediately  dismissed  and  given  an  “E.”      Documentation:  Students  must  provide  hardcopy  and  digital  reproductions  of  all  final  projects.  Hardcopy  reproductions  will  consist  of  images  of  all  final  models  and  8.5”  by  11”  reproductions  of  all  presentation  drawings.  Digital  reproductions  of  both  models  (as  jpegs)  and  drawings  (as  PDFs)  will  be  stored  on  CDs,  one  CD  per  student,  or  dropped  in  the  Instructor’s  Homework  Folder.  Students  must  submit  documentation  by  5  PM  Thursday,  December  18,  2014.  Failure  to  meet  this  deadline  will  result  in  a  grade  of  "incomplete."      Evaluation:  Studio  work  is  both  individual  and  collective.  Criteria  of  evaluation  include  not  only  individual  design  excellence,  but  also  a  student’s  contributions  to  the  studio  through  collective  research,  team  projects,  documentation,  and  discussions.  There  are  three  major  design  projects,  as  well  as  additional  assignments.  Grading  is  based  on  a  comparison  with  other  students  in  the  course,  with  students  who  have  taken  the  course  previously,  and  with  the  instructors'  expectations  relative  to  the  objectives  of  the  course.  Evaluation  of  projects  is  by  jury  review  involving  reviewers  from  other  courses,  other  academic  institutions,  and  architectural  firms.  For  an  "A",  the  student  must  satisfy  the  course  objectives  excellently;  for  a  "B",  in  an  above  average  manner;  for  a  "C"  in  an  average  manner;  for  a  "D"  in  the  lowest  acceptable  manner;  and  an  "E"  denotes  that  the  student  has  not  satisfied  the  course  objectives.      Sexual  Harassment:  O.S.U.'s  Sexual  Harassment  policy,  which  applies  to  all  faculty,  staff,  and  students,  includes  lewd  remarks  and  inappropriate  comments  made  in  the  studio  environment,  classroom,  and  computer  labs  as  well  as  the  "display  of  inappropriate  sexually  oriented  materials  in  a  location  where  others  can  see  it."  Students  can  file  a  complaint  by  contacting  Student  Judicial  Affairs  at  292-­‐0748.  Sanctions  include  reprimand,  suspension,  and  dismissal  from  the  University.  

Page 2: Arch 3410 F14 - SYL - Proj 1 draft 25AUG14 3410 Sylla… · ! 5! $ Knowlton$School$of$Architecture$ ARCH$3410,$Fall$2014$ Coordinatrix:Gargus$ Studio$Instructors:$Balliet,$Gould,$Gunzelman,$Malmstrom,$Snyder,$Tilder$

  2  

 Students  with  Disabilities:  If  students  require  accommodation  for  disabilities,  they  should  immediately  arrange  an  appointment  with  their  professors  and  the  Office  for  Disability  Services.  At  the  appointment,  the  professors,  disability  counselors,  and  student  can  discuss  the  course  format,  anticipate  needs  and  decide  upon  accommodations.  Professors  rely  on  the  Office  for  Disability  Services  for  assistance  in  verifying  the  need  for  accommodations  and  developing  accommodation  strategies.      Student  Safety:  University  escort  service  provides  safe  transportation  7:30AM-­‐3AM.  Call  292-­‐3322.      Studio  Behavior:  Students  must  work  in  the  studio,  because  of  the  collaborative  nature  of  research  and  the  shared  development  of  techniques.  Students  are  responsible  for  keeping  their  areas  clean,  their  floors  free  from  obstructions,  and  all  studio  furniture  in  good  condition  and  original  location.  All  presentation  materials  must  be  removed  from  review  spaces  following  reviews  and  all  studio  materials  must  be  removed  from  the  building  at  the  close  of  every  quarter.  Students  may,  however,  store  material  in  their  credenzas  over  winter  and  spring  breaks.    Studios  are  inspected  on  the  last  day  of  final  exams  –  negligent  students  are  subject  to  grade  withholding  and  maintenance  costs.  Also  note:    •  The  following  items  are  prohibited  in  Knowlton  Hall:  non-­‐KSA  furniture,  liquor,  weapons,  bicycles,  skateboards,  rollerblades,  and  pets.    •  The  following  tools  are  prohibited  in  Knowlton  Hall:  spray  paints,  foam  cutter  wands,  welding  devices,  heat  guns,  and  any  flame  or  gaseous  liquid  device.    •  The  following  safety  compliances  must  be  observed:  electrical  power  cords  cannot  be  connected  in  a  series  or  extend  over  traffic  areas;  fire  extinguishers  must  remain  accessible  and  in  full  view;  access  to  stairwells,  corridors,  and  aisles  must  maintain  a  44”  clear  width  and  handrails  must  be  unobstructed.  •  Building  surfaces  cannot  be  marked,  anchored  to,  or  penetrated.    •  Installations  may  not  occur  in  any  part  of  the  building  except  by  permission  of  the  KSA  Building  Coordinator.    •  Power  tools  are  restricted  to  the  shop  except  when  permission  is  granted  by  the  KSA  Building  Coordinator.    •  Loud  noise  is  forbidden.    •  Graffiti  and  vandalism  are  grounds  for  disciplinary  action.      SCHEDULE  Project  1:  OSU  Athletic  Facility        1     27  Aug,  Wednesday  Introduction,  Project  1  Assigned,  research  assigned,  site  model  assigned,  site  visit  

29  Aug,  Friday  Studio  Session,  research  due,  parti  review,  site  analysis  discussion    

2     1  Sept,  LABOR  DAY,  NO  CLASSES  3  Sept,  Wednesday  Studio  Session      5  Sept,  Friday  Studio  Session        

3     8  Sept,  Monday  Studio  Session      10  Sept,  Wednesday  Mid  review,  site  model  complete  12  Sept,  Friday  Studio  Session        

4     15  Sept,  Monday  Studio  Session      17  Sept,  Wednesday  Studio  session    19  Sept,  Friday  Studio  session      

Project  2:  Urban  Fire  Station    5     22  Sept,  Project  1-­‐  FINAL  REVIEW,  Project  2-­‐  Assigned,  research  assigned,  site  model  assigned  

24  Sept,  Wednesday  Studio  session,  research  due,  parti  review,  site  analysis  discussion  26  Sept,  Friday  Studio  session      

6     29  Sept,  Monday  Studio  session    1  Oct,  Wednesday  Studio  session    3  Oct,  Friday  Studio  session    

Page 3: Arch 3410 F14 - SYL - Proj 1 draft 25AUG14 3410 Sylla… · ! 5! $ Knowlton$School$of$Architecture$ ARCH$3410,$Fall$2014$ Coordinatrix:Gargus$ Studio$Instructors:$Balliet,$Gould,$Gunzelman,$Malmstrom,$Snyder,$Tilder$

  3  

     7     6  Oct,  Monday  Studio  session    

8  Oct,  Wednesday  Mid  Review  Project  2,  site  model  complete  10  Oct,  Friday  Studio  session      

8     13  Oct,  Monday  Studio  session    15  Oct,  Wednesday  Studio  session    17  Oct,  Friday  Studio  session    

 Project  3:  Craft  Brewery  9     20  Oct,  Monday  Project  2:  FINAL  REVIEW,  Project  3:  Assigned,  research  assigned,  site  model  assigned  

22  Oct,  Wednesday  Field  Trip  to  Cincinnati  (money  will  be  collected  for  the  excursion.)  24  Oct,  Friday  Studio  session,  research  due,  parti  review,  site  analysis  discussion    

10     27  Oct,  Monday  Studio  session    29  Oct,  Wednesday  Studio  session    31  Oct,  Friday  Studio  session    

 11     3  Nov,  Monday  Studio  session  

5  Nov,  Wednesday  Studio  session    7  Nov,  Friday  Studio  session    

 12     10  Nov,  Monday  Mid  Review  Project  3,  site  model  complete  

12  Nov,  Wednesday  Studio  session    14  Nov,  Friday  Studio  session      

13     17  Nov,  Monday  Studio  session  19  Nov,  Wednesday  Studio  session  21  Nov,  Friday  Studio  session    

 14   24  Nov,  Monday  Studio  session    

26  Nov,  Wednesday  THANKSGIVING  BREAK,  NO  CLASSES    28  Nov,  Friday  THANKSGIVING  BREAK,  NO  CLASSES    

15     1  Dec,  Monday  Studio  session    3  Dec,  Wednesday  Project4-­‐  FINAL  REVIEW    5  Dec,  Friday  Work  on  Portfolio    

16     8  Dec,  Monday  Work  on  Portfolio  10  Dec,  Wednesday      No  Class  12  Dec,  Friday  No  Class    

17   17  Dec,  Documentation  of  Studio  work  due  (see  above  for  details)    

READINGS:  Studio  instructors  are  free  to  assign  readings  of  their  choice.  

Page 4: Arch 3410 F14 - SYL - Proj 1 draft 25AUG14 3410 Sylla… · ! 5! $ Knowlton$School$of$Architecture$ ARCH$3410,$Fall$2014$ Coordinatrix:Gargus$ Studio$Instructors:$Balliet,$Gould,$Gunzelman,$Malmstrom,$Snyder,$Tilder$

  4  

         Studio  Sections    

     

BALLIET  Brown,  Sam  Bryson,  Coy  Gurtz,  Justin  Kuns,  Vincent  Lau,  Katie  Loversidge,    Kathleen  Schiering,  Daniel  Sheets,  Ian  Shirk,  Ellen  Strzepek,  Gabriel  Tian,  Shangyu  Yuan,  Xuran      

GARGUS  Dai,  Jianan  Doherty,  Brandon  Dzierzak,  Rachael  Eland,  Kayla  Ford,  Gabriel  Hawks,  George  Luckenbach,  Tori  Leavitt,  Skyla  Moore,  Max  Park,  Jae  Hyun  Ronan,  Claire  Schweer,  Nicholas        

GOULD  Autin,  Kristin  Curtona,  David  Gan,  Shiying  Gutierrez,  Lizeth  Hu,  Haobo  Jannazo,  Dominic  Poland,  Josiah  Lindsey,  Shauna  Sandhu,  Alexandra  Steckel,  Stephen  Sun,  Zhixin          

MALMSTROM   SNYDER   TILDER/  GUNZLEMAN  Conley,  David  Guthrie,  Cameron  Hirzel,  Hannah  Jones,  Melissa  Luna,  Calvin  Schellin,  Elise  Schlesinger,  Jay  Selvaggio,  Anthony  Sui,  Wenli  Watson,  Andrew  Yang,  Yidi  Zaworski,  Zachary          

Clemons,  Emily  Detroit,  Ryan  Fisher,  Dan  Geiser,  Breanna  He,  Yang  Jackson,  Alexander  Miller,  Andrew  Mosure,  Nathan  Reed,  Bradley  Roman,  Bethany  Wang,  Can            

Bertocchi,  Kristina  Clapper,  Sarah  Mallett,  Alexis  Blackson,  Meghan  Letizia,  Chase  Weizhen,  Jia  Corbitt,  Michael  Mei,  Xiaoshuo  Rennekamp,  Michael  Autry,  Lane  Leber,  Nolan  Hayes,  Matthew        

     

Page 5: Arch 3410 F14 - SYL - Proj 1 draft 25AUG14 3410 Sylla… · ! 5! $ Knowlton$School$of$Architecture$ ARCH$3410,$Fall$2014$ Coordinatrix:Gargus$ Studio$Instructors:$Balliet,$Gould,$Gunzelman,$Malmstrom,$Snyder,$Tilder$

  5  

 Knowlton  School  of  Architecture  ARCH  3410,  Fall  2014  Coordinatrix:  Gargus  Studio  Instructors:  Balliet,  Gould,  Gunzelman,  Malmstrom,  Snyder,  Tilder  M,  W,  F  1:50-­‐5:15      

NEW  JESSE  OWENS  RECREATION  CENTER  NORTH                                                                                                                    OHIO  STATE  UNIVERSITY  

 

   

Jesse  Owens,  one  of  the  greatest  athletes  of  all  times,  was  also  a  graduate  of  the  Ohio  State  University.  While  a  member  of  the  Ohio  State  University  Track  and  Field  Team,  Owens  excelled  at  the  long  jump  and  sprints.  At  an  Ann  Arbor  track  meet  in  1935,  Owens  set  three  world  records  and  tied  a  fourth  in  the  span  of  45  minutes,  a  feat  considered  by  many  to  be  one  of  the  most  remarkable  accomplishments  ever  achieved  by  any  athlete.  The  following  year  Owens  represented  the  United  States  at  the  1936  Berlin  Olympics  (Hitler’s  Olympics)  where  he  earned  four  gold  medals,  the  most  of  any  athlete  at  the  games.  Through  his  athletic  excellence,  focus,  sportsmanship,  and  poise  he  single-­‐handedly  demonstrated  the  falsehood  of  Hitler’s  claims  of  Aryan  supremacy.  In  honor  of  its  most  famous  alumnus,  the  Ohio  State  University  has  named  the  football  stadium,  the  stadium  plaza,  and  a  number  of  ancillary  recreation  facilities  after  him.    Our  project  is  to  redesign  and  replace  one  of  the  Jesse  Owens  Recreation  Facilities  with  a  new  building,  one  more  worthy  of  its  namesake.  The  new  building  will  be  around  60,000  SF  and  replace  the  old  facility  of  28,000  SF.  

The  Ohio  State  University  has  made  it  a  priority  to  create  a  stronger  presence  and  a  more  urbane  edge  along  its  northern  boundary  on  Lane  Avenue.  The  redevelopment  of  the  North  Campus  Dormitory  cluster  was  a  first  step  in  that  direction,  as  was  the  construction  of  the  new  Student  Resources  Center.    The  old  Jesse  Owens  North  Recreation  Center  makes  an  indifferent  address  to  its  prominent  location.  Hence,  the  decision  was  taken  to  replace  the  glulam  shed  of  the  old  Recreation  Center  with  a  new  building.  Unlike  the  previous  facilities,  which  were  organized  on  one  level,  the  University  has  expressed  a  desire  for  a  multi-­‐story  building,  which  can  better  define  the  street  edge  while  maximizing  land  usage  efficiencies.  Unlike  RPAC,  which  is  scaled  to  accommodate  a  great  number  of  people  and  a  wide  range  of  sports  and  training  facilities,  the  Jesse  Owens  North  Facility,  while  open  to  the  entire  university,  is  specifically  intended  as  an  amenity  for  the  North  Campus  dormitories.  Design  of  the  landscape  surrounding  the  building  will  be  necessary  to  accommodate  exterior  exercise  activities  and  landscape  can  be  used  to  strengthen  the  relationship  of  the  Rec  Center  to  the  dormitory  area.        When  it  was  first  constructed,  the  curved  glulam  structure  of  the  old  Jesse  Owens  North  Facility  was  considered  to  be  a  marvel  of  structural  engineering  and  design.    The  University  would  like  the  new  facility  to  likewise  pay  heed  to  the  design  opportunities  afforded  by  designing  a  long-­‐span  structure  and  to  the  potential  of  a  powerful  architectural  statement  on  Lane  Avenue  to  promote  the  forward-­‐looking  image  that  the  University  wishes  to  project.    

Page 6: Arch 3410 F14 - SYL - Proj 1 draft 25AUG14 3410 Sylla… · ! 5! $ Knowlton$School$of$Architecture$ ARCH$3410,$Fall$2014$ Coordinatrix:Gargus$ Studio$Instructors:$Balliet,$Gould,$Gunzelman,$Malmstrom,$Snyder,$Tilder$

  6  

SITE    Your  project  will  occupy  the  site  of  the  old  Jesse  Owens  North  Recreation  Facility,  which  will  be  demolished.  The  site  is  around  88,700  SF,  bounded  by  Lane  Avenue  to  the  north,  Neil  Avenue  to  the  east  and  south  and  the  Student  Academic  Services  Building  to  the  west.  The  North  Campus  dormitories  are  located  just  across  Neil,  to  the  east,  (CAD  Files  will  be  provided  by  the  University  Architect.)      

     

Page 7: Arch 3410 F14 - SYL - Proj 1 draft 25AUG14 3410 Sylla… · ! 5! $ Knowlton$School$of$Architecture$ ARCH$3410,$Fall$2014$ Coordinatrix:Gargus$ Studio$Instructors:$Balliet,$Gould,$Gunzelman,$Malmstrom,$Snyder,$Tilder$

  7  

 SITE        

   

Page 8: Arch 3410 F14 - SYL - Proj 1 draft 25AUG14 3410 Sylla… · ! 5! $ Knowlton$School$of$Architecture$ ARCH$3410,$Fall$2014$ Coordinatrix:Gargus$ Studio$Instructors:$Balliet,$Gould,$Gunzelman,$Malmstrom,$Snyder,$Tilder$

  8  

PROGRAM    ENTRY  AREA  Entry  with  airlock  Lobby  Space  

- Membership  desk  area:           140  SF  - Control  point             40  SF  - Lounge  with  WIFI           600  SF  - Public  M  &  F  bathrooms  @  at  least  two  WCS     as  needed  - Juice  bar/  snacks           180  SF  - Juice  bar  seating  (seating  for  at  least  30)     as  needed  - Access  to  main,  honorific  vertical  circulation    - OSU  Souvenir  &  Jesse  Owens  Memorabilia  Shop    - (May  be  grouped  with  other  staffed  areas)       400  SF  

 SERVICE  SPACES  

- Director’s  office           200  SF  - Staff  work  space  (2  work  stations)       220  SF  - Meeting  room           300  SF  - Mechanical  space           100  SF      - Administration  storage         100  SF  - Copy  machine  room/  area         as  needed  - Janitor  Closets  w/  Trash  and  Recycling         50  SF  - Building  Storage             200  SF  - Loading,  Receiving,  trash         as  needed  

 ATHLETICS  SPACES  

- Women’s  locker  room         as  needed  o 4  -­‐  Showers    o 40  -­‐  Lockers  o 3  -­‐  Changing  rooms  o 4  –  WCs/  sinks  o 1  -­‐  Sauna  

 - Men’s  locker  room           as  needed  

o 4  -­‐  Showers    o 40  -­‐  Lockers  o 3  -­‐  Changing  rooms  o 4  –  WCs/  sinks  o 1  -­‐  Sauna  

 - Gymnasium  (courts  &  surrounding  space)     as  needed  

o 2  basketball  courts  (@  50’  x  94’)  OR  (flexible-­‐  can  be  used  for  either)  

o 3  volleyball  courts  (@  30’  x  60’)    

- Exercise  Equipment  area  (can  be  in  several  areas)     3000  SF  o Strength  training  machines  o Free  Weights  o Cardio  Machines  (treadmills,  stationary  bicycles,  elliptical,  rowing,  etc.)  o Kickboxing  and/  or  Boxing  Bags  o TRX  Zone  

 

Page 9: Arch 3410 F14 - SYL - Proj 1 draft 25AUG14 3410 Sylla… · ! 5! $ Knowlton$School$of$Architecture$ ARCH$3410,$Fall$2014$ Coordinatrix:Gargus$ Studio$Instructors:$Balliet,$Gould,$Gunzelman,$Malmstrom,$Snyder,$Tilder$

  9  

 - First  aid/  training  room         150  SF  - Equipment  storage  (can  be  in  several  areas)     300  SF  - Running  track  (any  shape)         as  needed  - Yoga/  dance/  aerobics  classroom:       750  SF  - Racquet  Ball  Courts    (3  @  40’  long,  20’,  and  20’)  - Ping  Pong    Tables  (at  least  2)         as  needed  - Climbing  Wall  Area  (Wall  at  least  35’-­‐0”  high)     as  needed  - Vending  machines           50  SF  

   EXTERIOR  SPACES  

- Exterior  seating  for  Juice  Bar  and  Food  Trucks  - Ping  pong  tables  - Badminton  court(s)  (at  least  2  @  20’  x  44’)  - Bike  Storage  - Paracourse  stations    - Parking  for  two  food  trucks  (can  be  on  a  designated  part  of  a  street,  but  not  Lane)  - Double  Long  jump  sandpit  and  approach  @  13’  x  115’    - (Can  also  be  used  for  bocce  ball  when  jumpers  are  not  present  @  13’  x  91’)  

-        MISCELLANEOUS  Net  to  gross  efficiency  65%            Significant  daylight  must  reach  all  major  spaces.  Building  must  be  accessible,  i.e.  elevator  or  ramps  are  required  to  all  major  spaces      At  least  two  fire  stairs/  fire  escapes  are  required.      FINAL  REQUIREMENTS  Site  Plan       1”=  50’-­‐0”    Plans   (all  levels)   1/16=1’0”    Sections  (at  least  2)   1/16=1’0”    Elevations  (Lane  Ave  and  one  other)  1/16=1’0”    Site  Model:       scale  to  be  determined  by  sections  Site  Model     to  fit  in  class  site  model    Final  Model:       1/16  =  1’0:  1/16”=1’-­‐0”  Plans,  sections,  and  elevations    2  renderings  of  interior  spaces    1  rendering  of  building  exterior  2  of  these  renderings  must  be  sufficiently  developed  to  indicate  material  qualities,  daylight  and  program  accommodation),    Minimum  print  size  15”x20  ”  

Page 10: Arch 3410 F14 - SYL - Proj 1 draft 25AUG14 3410 Sylla… · ! 5! $ Knowlton$School$of$Architecture$ ARCH$3410,$Fall$2014$ Coordinatrix:Gargus$ Studio$Instructors:$Balliet,$Gould,$Gunzelman,$Malmstrom,$Snyder,$Tilder$

  10  

CALENDAR:)ARCH)3410)/)Fall)2014

Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday24 25 26 27 28 29 30

Classes=begin:=Assign=Project=#=1==

Project=#1

Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday30 1 2 3 4 5 6

LABOR=DAY=M=================NO=CLASSES

Project=1 Project=1

7 8 9 10 11 12 13

Project=1=midreview Project=1 Project=1

14 15 16 17 18 19 20

Project=1 Project=1 Project=1

21 22 23 24 25 26 27

Project=1=FINAL=REVVIEW=Project=2=assigned

Project=2 Project=2

28 29 30 1 2 3 4

Project=2 Project=2 Project=2

Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday5 6 7 8 9 10 11

Project=2=midreview Project=2 Project=2

12 13 14 15 16 17 18

Project=2Project=2=(=OSU=last=day=of=1st=session=classes)

Project=2=Final=Review=Project=3=assigned

Project=2

19 20 21 22 23 24 25

Project=2=Final=Review=Project=3=assigned

FIELD=TRIP=TO=CINCINNATI

Project=3

26 27 28 29 30 31 1

Project=3 Project=3 Project=3

Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday2 3 4 5 6 7 8

Project=3 Project=3 Midreview=#1

9 10 11 12 13 14 15

Project=3=midreviewVETERAN'S=DAY=M============NO=CLASSES

Project=3 Project=3

16 17 18 19 20 21 22

Project=3 Project=3 Project=3

23 24 25 26 27 28 29

Project=3THANKSGIVINGM============NO=CLASSES

THANKSGIVINGM============NO=CLASSES

THANKSGIVINGM============NO=CLASSES

Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday30 1 2 3 4 5 6

Project=3 Project=3=Final=Review== work=on=Portfolio

7 8 9 10 11 12 13

work=on=Portfolio LAST=DAY=OF=CLASSES========== = EXAMS EXAMS

14 15 16 17 18 18 20

EXAMS EXAMS EXAMSSTUDIO=DOCUMENTATION=DUE

=

August)2014

November)2014

December)2014

September)2014

October)2014

Page 11: Arch 3410 F14 - SYL - Proj 1 draft 25AUG14 3410 Sylla… · ! 5! $ Knowlton$School$of$Architecture$ ARCH$3410,$Fall$2014$ Coordinatrix:Gargus$ Studio$Instructors:$Balliet,$Gould,$Gunzelman,$Malmstrom,$Snyder,$Tilder$

  11  

     

Page 12: Arch 3410 F14 - SYL - Proj 1 draft 25AUG14 3410 Sylla… · ! 5! $ Knowlton$School$of$Architecture$ ARCH$3410,$Fall$2014$ Coordinatrix:Gargus$ Studio$Instructors:$Balliet,$Gould,$Gunzelman,$Malmstrom,$Snyder,$Tilder$

  12  

 

Page 13: Arch 3410 F14 - SYL - Proj 1 draft 25AUG14 3410 Sylla… · ! 5! $ Knowlton$School$of$Architecture$ ARCH$3410,$Fall$2014$ Coordinatrix:Gargus$ Studio$Instructors:$Balliet,$Gould,$Gunzelman,$Malmstrom,$Snyder,$Tilder$

Arch  3410    Project  2  Fall  2014      

The  New  Wexner  Gallery  and  Art  Center    

   

Assigned  22  September,  Monday  Mid-­‐review:  6  October,  Monday    Final  Review:  20  October,  Monday    BRIEF:  In   the   aftermath   of   wildly   the   successful   exhibition   at   the   Wexner   Center,   Transfigurations:  Modern  Masters  from  the  Wexner  Family  Collection,  Leslie  and  Abigail  Wexner  have  decided  to  establish  a  gallery  to  house  a  permanent  display  of  works  from  their  collection.  The  gallery  will  display   about   twenty  works,  which   each   student  must   select   from   the   current   exhibition.   The  designers  are  urged  to  consider  lighting  conditions  and  a  strategy  for  moving  visitors  through  the  gallery  to  best  show  off  the  art  works.    In  addition  to  displaying  works  by  recognized  masters,  like  Picasso,  Giacometti,  De  Koonig,  Degas,  and  Dubuffet,   all   of  whom  are  well-­‐represented   in   the   collection,   the  Wexners  would   like   the  new  gallery   to  act  as  a  catalyst   in  pushing  Columbus   to   the   forefront  of   the  art   scene.    Hence,  there  will  also  be  community  outreach  spaces,   like  classrooms,  a   lecture  hall,  a  café,  a  visitors’  shop,   and   an   area   for   children’s   art,   as   well   as   apartments   and   workspace   for   three   visiting  artists.  An  additional  requirement  is  an  exterior  space,  which  can  be  used  to  hold  “Art  Symposia,”  modeled   after   outdoor   stone   carving   competitions,   which   take   place   on   the   main   piazze   of  Tuscan  marble  quarry  towns,  like  Cararra,  Massa,  and  Pietrasanta.  This  exterior  space  should  also  be   able   to   accommodate   informal   concerts,   performances,   performance   art,   small-­‐scale  theatrical  works,  and  community  activities.  The  aim  is  to  educate  the  public  about  art  by  making  art   part   of   their   lives,   and   to   create   a   reputation   for   Columbus   as   an   art   center   by   inviting  internationally  renowned  artists  to  partake  in  these  events.      

Page 14: Arch 3410 F14 - SYL - Proj 1 draft 25AUG14 3410 Sylla… · ! 5! $ Knowlton$School$of$Architecture$ ARCH$3410,$Fall$2014$ Coordinatrix:Gargus$ Studio$Instructors:$Balliet,$Gould,$Gunzelman,$Malmstrom,$Snyder,$Tilder$

SITE:      Northeast  corner  of  Broad  &  Washington    A  site  on  Broad  Street  was  selected,  so  that  the  gallery  can  contribute  to  the  development  of  the  Arts  District,   i.e.   the  area  adjacent  to  the  Columbus  Art  Museum,  the  campus  of   the  Columbus  College  of  Art   and  Design   (CCAD),   and   the  writer-­‐in-­‐residence  program  at   the  near-­‐by  Thurber  House.     The   clients   also   recognize   the  historical   importance  of  Broad   Street   in  Columbus,   as   a  collector  of  major  civic  buildings.  They  urge  the  designer  consider  The  new  gallery  as  part  of  this  urban  structure,  and  to  use  it  to  help  stave  off  the  erosion  and  dissolution  of  the  edge  of  Broad  Street  (initiated  by  the  plethora  of  parking  lots  on  the  sites  of  formerly  grand  building.)      

     

     http://www.franklincountyoh.metacama.com/do/selectDisplay?select=GIS&curpid=01003946690    

SITE%

Demolish%%exis/ng%building%

Page 15: Arch 3410 F14 - SYL - Proj 1 draft 25AUG14 3410 Sylla… · ! 5! $ Knowlton$School$of$Architecture$ ARCH$3410,$Fall$2014$ Coordinatrix:Gargus$ Studio$Instructors:$Balliet,$Gould,$Gunzelman,$Malmstrom,$Snyder,$Tilder$

       

   

             

Page 16: Arch 3410 F14 - SYL - Proj 1 draft 25AUG14 3410 Sylla… · ! 5! $ Knowlton$School$of$Architecture$ ARCH$3410,$Fall$2014$ Coordinatrix:Gargus$ Studio$Instructors:$Balliet,$Gould,$Gunzelman,$Malmstrom,$Snyder,$Tilder$

PROGRAM  ENTRY  AREA  

Airlock         as  needed  Lobby         1200  SF  Ticket  Desk       200  SF  Coat  Check       220  SF  Public  Bathrooms       2  @  200  SF  Museum  Shop       500  SF  Café   400  SF  or  as  needed,  with  

seating  for  20  (adjacent  to  outside  seating)  

TOTAL   2740  SF    ADMINISTRATION  

Director’s  Office       200  SF  Curator’s  Office       180  SF  Education  Office       2  stations  @  120  SF  Docents’  lounge       350  SF  Conference  Room     400  SF  Admin.  Assistants       3  stations  at  150  SF  Copier  area       as  needed  Admin  Storage       as  needed  Workers’  kitchenette     as  needed  TOTAL         2120  SF  

 TECHINCAL  SUPPORT  SPACES  

Installation  Staff  Area     400  SF  Conservator’s  Area     250  SF    Webmaster/  IT       300  SF  Crating,  Framing  area     300  SF  Staff  Workshop       220  Loading  Dock       150  SF  Loading  Storage       200  SF  Janitor’s  Closet       2  @  50  SF  Mechanical  Space     as  needed  Trash  area       80  SF  TOTAL         2000  SF  

 GALLERY  

Wexner  Collection:     6500  SF  +/-­‐  20  +/-­‐  artworks  (student’s  choice)  Video/cinema  gallery     500  SF  Visiting  Artist  Galleries     2500  SF               9500  SF    

 EDUCATION  &  COMMUNITY  SPACES  

Auditorium           1250  SF  +/-­‐  Classrooms       3  @  450  SG  

  Adult  Ed  Teaching  Studios     2  @  300  SF     WCs         2  @  125  

Children’s  workshop     650  SF           4100  SF        

Page 17: Arch 3410 F14 - SYL - Proj 1 draft 25AUG14 3410 Sylla… · ! 5! $ Knowlton$School$of$Architecture$ ARCH$3410,$Fall$2014$ Coordinatrix:Gargus$ Studio$Instructors:$Balliet,$Gould,$Gunzelman,$Malmstrom,$Snyder,$Tilder$

ARTIST  IN  RESIDENCE  SPACES  Artist  Apartments     3  @  800  SF    Artist  Studios       3  @  400  SF  Teaching  Studio       450  SG  Children’s  workshop     650  SF  Library/  Shared  Lounge     450  SF             5150  SF        

 EXTERIOR  SPACE  

Art  Symposia  Space  (for  open  air     as  needed  Art  competitions,  Performances,  Informal  concerts,  performance  Art,  community  events,  etc.  Exterior  Seating  for  Café     as  needed  Parking  For  25  cars  Parking  for  2  busses  Access  to  loading  dock  and  trash  area.      

Site: Total SF = 41,850 Program: Total SF = +/- 30,000 SF (not including exterior site work) Net to gross efficiency 65% Significant daylight must reach all major spaces. Lighting of galleries in a major design issue FINAL REQUIREMENTS Site Plan 1”= 50’-0” Site Model 1/16 or 1/32=1’0” Physical model 1/16 – 1’0” Plans all levels 1/32=1’0” Sections (at least 2) 1/32=1’0” and elevations Elevations (if not clear in rhino or physical model) 1/32=1’0” Digital model (Rhino or harder) Massing model at the scale of the site, if the site model is not at 1/16. 2 renderings of interior semi-public spaces 1 rendering of building exterior 2 of these renderings must be sufficiently developed to indicate material qualities, daylight and inhabitation)

     

Page 18: Arch 3410 F14 - SYL - Proj 1 draft 25AUG14 3410 Sylla… · ! 5! $ Knowlton$School$of$Architecture$ ARCH$3410,$Fall$2014$ Coordinatrix:Gargus$ Studio$Instructors:$Balliet,$Gould,$Gunzelman,$Malmstrom,$Snyder,$Tilder$

MONDAY:  22  September  2014,  Program  distributed,  precedents  assigned    WEDNESDAY:    24  September  2014,  2:00,    Field  trip  &  Site  Visit    2:00  WEXNER  CENTER  FIELD  TRIP  Transfigurations:  Modern  Masters  from  the  Wexner  Family  Collection  

§ Meet  in  the  Mershon  lobby.    § Your  entrance  to  the  Wexner  Center  Exhibition  has  been  reserved.  § No  backpacks  or  big  bags  can  be  brought  into  the  exhibition.    § Provisions  will  me  made  for  you  to  store  your  things  in  the  Mershon  lobby.  § You  may  bring  a  pencil  and  notebook  into  the  space,  but  no  pens  are  permitted.  § Sketchbook  size  is  limited  to  12x18.  § Any  small  bags  you  bring  into  the  exhibition  will  be  checked.        § “Docents”  (i.e.  students  trained  to  discuss  the  exhibition)  will  be  scattered  throughout  the  

galleries  to  answer  any  questions  you  may  have.    TASKS:  

§ Wander  through  the  exhibition.      § Be  amazed  that  this  is  the  stuff  that  the  Wexners  have  in  their  house.    § Try  to  figure  out  the  core  interests  of  the  various  artists.  

o Figuration?  o Abstraction?  o Materiality?  o Dematerialization?  o Flatness?  o Pictorial  Space?  o Opticality?  o Tactility?  o Statis?  o Kinesis?  o Space/Time?  o Timelessness?  o Gesture?  o Caricature?  o Action  Painting?  o Horses?  

§ Try  to  figure  out  themes  in  the  collection  and  themes  in  the  work.    § Take  notes  and  sketch/  diagram  favorite  works  with  your  pencil.    § Pick  your  favorite  object  and  be  prepared  to  say  why.    § Select  around  20  of  your  favorite  works,  to  be  included  in  the  collection  

o of  your  design  of  the  New  Wexner  Gallery.    § Also  pay  attention  to  the  Wexner  Center  itself.      § How  does  the  architecture  support  or  subtract  from  the  experience  of  viewing  art?  

 SITE  VISIT  (After  the  Wexner  Center  Field  Trip)  

§ Go  to  the  Site:  From  the  Wexner  Center:      o Walk  to  the  bus  stop  on  High  &  15th  Street  o Take  the  #2  COTA  bus  to  Broad  &  High  o Switch  to  the  #10  Bus  or  walk  for  10  minutes  to  the  site.  o You  can  also  drive,  if  you  have  a  car.  

§ Analyze  and  document  the  site  o Take  photos,  make  sketches  o Note  relationship  to  CCAD  campus  o Pay  attention  to  views,  scale,  light,  kinds  of  neighborhoods,  etc.  o Gather  info  on  neighboring  buildings  you  will  need  for  site  model.  

 

Page 19: Arch 3410 F14 - SYL - Proj 1 draft 25AUG14 3410 Sylla… · ! 5! $ Knowlton$School$of$Architecture$ ARCH$3410,$Fall$2014$ Coordinatrix:Gargus$ Studio$Instructors:$Balliet,$Gould,$Gunzelman,$Malmstrom,$Snyder,$Tilder$

Museum/ Gallery Precedents Precedent research assigned: 22 September, 2014; due 16 September, 2014  Amateur  Architect  (Wang  Shu  )   History  Museum,  Ningbo,  China  2003-­‐08  BIG  (Bjarke  Ingels  Group)     Danish  National  Museum,  Copenhagen,  Denmark  2013  Calatrava,  Santiago       Milwaukee  Art  Museum  ,  Milwaukee,  Wisconsin,  2001  Cook,  Peter       Kunsthaus,  Graz,  Austria2003  Coop  Himmelblau       Museum  of  the  Confluence,  Lyonm  France  2014  Coop  Himmelblau         Akron  Art  Museum,  Akron,  OH  (2007  addition)    Diller,  Scofidio,  Renfro     ICA,  Boston,  MA,  2002  Eisenman,  Peter       Wexner  Center,  Columbus,  1989  FR-­‐EE  (Fernando  Romero)     Museo  Soumaya,    Mexico  City,  2011  Gehry,  Frank       Vitra  Museum,  Weil-­‐am-­‐Rhein,  Germany,  1987  Gehry,  Frank       Guggenheim  Museum,  Bilbao,  Spain  Gehry,  Frank       Weisman  Museum,  Minneapolis,  MN,  1993  Hadid,  Zaha       MAXII,  Rome  2010  Hadid,  Zaha         Contemporary  Arts  Center,  Cincinnati,  2003  Hadid,  Zaha       Phaeno  Museum,  Wolfsburg,  Germany  1998  Herzog  &  de  Meuron     Caixa  Forum,  Madrid  2001-­‐07  Herzog  &  de  Meuron     de  Young  Museum,  San  Francisco  2005  Herzog  &  de  Meuron     Schaulager,  Basel  2003  Herzog  &  de  Meuron     Perez  Art  Museum,  Miami,  2013  Holl,  Steven       Sifang  Musuem,  Nanjing,  China  2003  Holl,  Steven       Nelson  Atkins,  Kansas  City,  MO  1999-­‐2007  Holl,  Steven       Kiasma  Museum  of  Contemporary  Art,  Helsinki,  1992-­‐98  Kahn,  Louis       Kimbell  Art  Museum,  Fort  Worth  Texas,      1966-­‐72  Kuma,  Kengo       Nezu  Art  Museum,  Tokyo,  ai,  2011  Kuma,  Kengo       GC  Prostho  Museum,  Kasuga,  2006  Kurokawa,  Kisho       The  National  Art  Center,  Tokyo,  Japan  2009  Libeskind,Daniel        Jewish  Museum,  Berlin,    1987  Meier,  Richard       Museum  Angewandte  Kunst  (MAK  ),  Frankfurt,  1979-­‐85  Mies  van  der  Rohe,  Ludwig     Neue  Nationalgalerie,  Berlin,1968  Moussavi,  Farshid    (FOA)     MoCA,  Cleveland,  2012  Neutelings  Riedijk                             Sound  and  Vision  Institute,  Hilversum,  1999-­‐2006  Neutelings  Riedijk       Museum  aan  de  Stroom,  (MAS),  Antwerp,  2010    Nouvel,  Jean       Quai  Branly  Museum,  Paris,  1999-­‐2006  Nouvel,  Jean       Arab  Institute,  Paris,  1981  Nouvel,  Jean       Cartier  Foundation,  Paris  1994  OMA,  (Rem  Koolhaas)     Kunsthalle,  Rotterdam,  1992  Ortner  &  Ortner       MUMOK,  Vienna,  2001  Piano,  Renzo       NEMO  (New  Metropolis  Museum),  Amsterdam,  1997  Piano,  Renzo       Beyeler  Foundation,  Riehen,  Switzerland  1997  Piano,  Renzo       de  Menil  Foundation,  Houston,  TX,  1982-­‐86  Piano  &  Rogers       Pompidou  Center,  Paris  1977  SANAA,           New  Museum,  New  York,  2007  SANAA         21st  Century  Art  Museum,  Kanazawa,  Japan,  2004  SANAA         Glass  Pavilion,  Toledo,  OH,    2007  SANAA  (Nishizawa,  Ryue)       Hiroshi  Senju  Museum,  Karuizawa,  Japan  2010  Scarpa,  Carlo       Querini  Stampalia  Foundation,  Venice,  1963  Siza,  Alvaro       Serralves  Foundation,  Porto,  1991-­‐99  Stirling,  James       Staatsgalerie,  Stuttgart  1984  Taniguchi,  Yoshio       Gallery  of  the  Horyji  Treasures,  Tokyo,  1998  Trahan  Architects       Louisiana  State  Museum  and  Sports  Hall  of  Fame,  Natchitoches,  LA  2013  Tschumi  ,  Bernard         New  Acropolis  Museum,  Athens  2003-­‐09  UN  Studio       Mercedes  Museum,  Stuttgart,    2001-­‐06  Williams  &  Tsien       Folk  Art  Museum,  New  York  2001  Wright,  Frank,  Lloyd     Guggenheim  Museum,  New  York,  1959  Yim,  Rocco       Guanggdong  Museum,  Guangzhou,  2004-­‐2010  Zumthor,  Peter       Kunsthaus,  Bregenz,  1997  Zumthor,  Peter       Kolumba  Diocesan  Museum,  Cologne,  Germany  1997