Arborist Report - iCityWork · 2019-01-11 · Arborist Report HortScience, Inc. Kennedy Park, Hayward - October 2018 Page 5 The remaining 109 trees were represented by the following:

Arborist Report

Kennedy ParkHayward, CA

PREPARED FOR

Hayward Area Recreation & Park District1099 E St.

Hayward, CA 94541

PREPARED BY:HortScience, Inc.

325 Ray St.Pleasanton, CA 94566

October 2018

Arborist Report Kennedy Park Hayward, CA

Table of Contents

Page Introduction and Overview 1

Tree Assessment Methods 1

Description of Trees 2 Suitability for Preservation 6 Preliminary Evaluation of Impacts and Recommendations 8 Appraisal of Value 9 Maintenance Recommendations 9 Preliminary Tree Preservation Guidelines 11

List of Tables Table 1. Tree condition and frequency of occurrence 3

Table 2. Tree suitability for preservation 7

Exhibits Table 3. Recommendations for Action

Table 4. Appraised value of trees identified for removal

Table 5. Appraised value of trees identified for preservation

Table 6. Maintenance Recommendations

Tree Appraisal Worksheet

Tree Assessment Form

Tree Assessment Map

Arborist Report Kennedy Park

Hayward, CA

Introduction and Overview Hayward Area Recreation and Park District (HARD) is planning to refurbish the 14.5 acre Kennedy Park and combine it with the adjacent 2.5 acre McConaghy Estate Park. HortScience, Inc. was asked to prepare an Arborist Report for the park for submission to the City. This report provides the following information:

1. Assessment of the health and structural condition of the trees within the Kennedy Park and a portion of the McConaghy Estate Park based on a visual inspection from the ground.

2. Evaluation of the suitability for preservation of each tree. 3. An evaluation of the trees that would be preserved and removed based on development

plans. 4. The appraised value of all of the trees 5. Guidelines for tree preservation duri.ng the design, construction and maintenance phases

of development.

Tree Assessment Methods Trees were assessed in January 2018. The assessment included native species 4” and greater in diameter and non-native trees 6” in diameter and greater, located within and adjacent to the proposed project area. Off-site trees with canopies extending over the property line were included in the assessment. The assessment procedure consisted of the following steps:

1. Identifying the tree as to species; 2. Tagging each tree with an identifying number and recording its location on a map; 3. Measuring the trunk diameter at a point 54” above grade; 4. Evaluating the health and structural condition using a scale of 0 – 5:

5 - A healthy, vigorous tree, reasonably free of signs and symptoms of disease, with good structure and form typical of the species.

4 - Tree with slight decline in vigor, small amount of twig dieback, minor structural defects that could be corrected.

3 - Tree with moderate vigor, moderate twig and small branch dieback, thinning of crown, poor leaf color, moderate structural defects that might be mitigated with regular care.

2 - Tree in decline, epicormic growth, extensive dieback of medium to large branches, significant structural defects that cannot be abated.

1 - Tree in severe decline, dieback of scaffold branches and/or trunk; most of foliage from epicormics; extensive structural defects that cannot be abated.

0 – Dead. 5. Rating the suitability for preservation as ”high”, “moderate” or “low”. Suitability for

preservation considers the health, age and structural condition of the tree, and its potential to remain an asset to the site for years to come.

High: Trees with good health and structural stability that have the potential for longevity at the site.

Moderate: Trees with somewhat declining health and/or structural defects that can be abated with treatment. The tree will require more intense management and monitoring, and may have shorter life span than those in ‘high’ category.

Low: Tree in poor health or with significant structural defects that cannot be mitigated. Tree is expected to continue to decline, regardless of treatment. The species or individual may have characteristics that are undesirable for landscapes and generally are unsuited for use areas.

Arborist Report HortScience, Inc. Kennedy Park, Hayward - October 2018 Page 2

Description of Trees Two hundred and ninety-six (296) trees representing 38 species were evaluated (Table 1, following page). The park has a highly diverse tree population, often with groups of trees of one species concentrated together. For all species combined, trees were in good (131 trees or 44% of the population) to fair (109/37%) condition, with 56 trees (19%) in poor. Eight of the trees were on the McConaghy Estate property (#258-265) and 11 were located off-site along the private drive in the southwest corner of the park (#286-296). Descriptions of each tree are found in the Tree Assessment Form and approximate locations are plotted on the Tree Assessment Map (see Exhibits). The most common species assessed was olive, with 30 trees. Twenty-nine (29) of these were concentrated in a group around the benches in the southwest portion of the Park (#44-55 and #83-99). These were mature trees, with multiple trunks measuring from 6” to 18” in diameter. While individual trees had one-sided or asymmetric crowns, the trees had grown together and formed a single, dense canopy. Twenty-five (25) of the trees were in good condition and 5 were in fair. None of the olives were in poor condition. Chinese pistache, with 26 trees, was also well represented. These were spread across the site, with groups of 3 or 4 trees in each of the parking lots and surrounding the petting zoo. The Chinese pistache were semi-mature to mature, with trunk diameters between 5” and 18”. The species had performed well, with 21 in good or excellent condition and 5 in fair. None of the Chinese pistache were in poor condition. Twenty-three (23) Italian stone pines were assessed on the site, with 22 concentrated around the picnic area and benches on the north side. Condition of the trees was evenly spread between poor (8 trees), fair (8 trees) and good (7 trees). The fair to poor condition of many of the Italian stone pines was in part due to the close spacing of the plantings. Like the olives, the trees developed together as a single canopy, with individual trees leaning away from each other as they competed for light. This produced several trees with strong leans, some of which were starting to lift out of the ground (Photo 1).

Photo 1: Looking north at Italian stone pine #231. The tree was one of several in the group around the northern picnic area that had strong leans. Some of these mature Italian stone pines showed evidence of mounding and soil lifting on the back or tension side of the trees.


Table 1. Condition ratings and frequency of occurrence of trees Kennedy Park, Hayward CA

Common Name Scientific Name Condition Total

Poor (1-2)

Fair(3)

Good (4-5)

Red maple Acer rubrum - 1 - 1 Silver maple Acer saccharinum - 1 - 1 African fern pine Afrocarpus falcatus - 1 - 1 Strawberry tree Arbutus unedo 4 2 - 6 Paper birch Betula papyrifera - 1 - 1 Brachychiton Brachychiton sp. - 1 - 1 Carob Ceratonia siliqua 2 10 3 15 Camphor Cinnamomum camphora 4 2 - 6 Blue gum Eucalyptus globulus 1 3 1 5 Compact blue gum Eucalyptus globulus 'compacta' 4 5 4 13 Silver dollar gum Eucalyptus polyanthemos - 2 1 3 Pineapple guava Feijoa sellowiana - 1 1 2 Ash sp. Fraxinus sp. 3 7 5 15 Evergreen ash Fraxinus uhdei - - 1 1 Jacaranda Jacaranda mimosifolia 2 2 4 8 Chinese lantern Koelreuteria paniculata - - 1 1 Crape myrtle Lagerstroemia indica - 4 4 8 Privet Ligustrum japonicum 1 1 - 2 Sweetgum Liquidambar styraciflua 2 7 14 23 Southern magnolia Magnolia grandiflora - - 1 1 Mulberry Morus alba 2 4 - 6 Olive Olea europaea - 5 25 30 Canary island pine Pinus canariensis - 3 - 3 Aleppo pine Pinus halepensis 4 3 - 7 Italian stone pine Pinus pinea 8 8 7 23 Monterey pine Pinus radiata 1 - - 1 Chinese pistache Pistacia chinensis - 5 21 26 London plane Platanus x hispanica - 2 13 15 Lombardy poplar Populus nigra ‘Italica’ 8 8 - 16 Portuguese laurel Prunus lusitanica 3 2 - 5 Evergreen pear Pyrus kawakamii 1 4 1 6 Black locust Robinia pseudoacacia 4 4 2 10 Coast redwood Sequoia sempervirens - - 11 11 Yew Taxus baccata - 1 - 1 Chinese elm Ulmus parvifolia - 1 1 2 Siberian elm Ulmus pumila 1 5 3 9 Ca. fan palm Washingtonia filifera - 1 - 1 Zelkova Zelkova serrata 1 2 7 10

Total 56 109 131 296


Sweetgum, also with 23 trees, had been planted in groups across the site. Four (4) were located in the southeast corner of the park, 8 were concentrated around the play structures in the middle of the park and 9 were in east of the tennis courts. Trunk diameters ranged from 6” to 23”, with 8 young trees (6-11” in diameter), 9 semi-mature (12-17”) and 6 mature (18-23”). Fourteen (14) were in good condition, 7 in fair and 2 in poor. Sixteen (16) Lombardy poplars were assessed, with 10 in a row east of the southern parking lot and the remaining 6 along Golf Course Drive. These were all mature to over-mature trees with trunk diameters between 23” and 48”. The species is not long-lived and these were no exception. Half were in fair condition and half were in poor. Dieback of crowns and trunk cavities with decay were common in the group. Fifteen (15) London planes were assessed. Five (5) had been planted within the park and 10 were off-site trees growing along the private drive on the west side of the property. One third were young, one third were semi-mature and one third were mature. The largest of the London planes (tree #165 at 27” in diameter) was in good condition and was a center piece of the park plantings along Hesperian Blvd. Thirteen (13) London planes were in good condition and 2 were in fair. Fifteen (15) ash trees were growing in the landscape along Golf Course Dr. at the south end of the park. They were mostly semi-mature (12-17” in diameter), with 4 young trees and 4 mature. Many leaned to the south and had fair structure (Photo 2). Seven (7) were in fair condition, 5 were in good and 3 were in poor.

Fifteen (15) carob were assessed, with 10 located in the southern parking lot, 3 in the northern parking lot and 2 in the park. All but four were mature to over-mature, with trunk diameters between 19” and 32”. Where they had been planted in the parking lots, they had typically out-grown the available space and were displacing the asphalt and curbs. Condition of the carobs were fair (10 trees), with 3 in good condition and 2 in poor. Thirteen (13) compact blue gum eucalyptus were included in the assessment, with 11 growing in a row along the northern driveway. These were large trees with a significant visual impact. Stem diameters ranged from 10” to 84” and most had multiple stems arising below the measurement point. Four (4) of the compact blue gums were in poor condition, 5 were in fair and 4 in good. Those in poor condition had extensive dieback (#187) or sulfur fungus (#179 and 188). Sulfur fungus (Laetiporous gilbertsonii) is a common decay fungus of blue gum and causes heart rot (Photo 3, following page).

Photo 2: Looking west at ash #6 *foreground). Ash trees lined the Golf Course Dr. frontage. These were mostly semi-mature and in fair condition. Like ash #6, many of the trees had fair branch structure.


The remaining 109 trees were represented by the following:

11 semi-mature coast redwoods with trunk diameters between 17” and 24”. They were all in good to excellent condition.

10 semi-mature to mature zelkova (18” to 30” in diameter). These were concentrated in the northeast corner of the park and were in good condition (7 trees).

10 black locust, with 5 growing in and around the northern parking lot and 3 along the Hesperian Blvd. frontage. These were semi-mature to mature and in poor (4 trees) to fair (4 trees) condition.

9 Siberian elms, 8 of which were concentrated around the main park entry on Hesperian Blvd. These were mature (19” to 30” in diameter) and in fair (5 trees) to good (3 trees) condition.

8 crape myrtles had been planted around the eastern side of the petting zoo. They were semi-mature (7” to 11” in diameter) and in fair (4 trees) to good (4 trees) condition.

8 jacaranda had been planted among the group of Italian stone pines around the norther picnic benches. They were mostly young 6” to 12”) and in good condition (4 trees).

7 mature to over-mature Aleppo pines (23” to 42” in diameter). Five were growing along the north side of the northern picnic benches and 2 were in the southeast corner of the site. Four (4) were in poor condition and 3 were in fair.

6 trees each of evergreen pear, mulberry, camphor and strawberry tree. The vast majority of these were in fair (11 trees) to poor (12 trees) condition.

5 Portuguese laurels had been planted across the site. These were large shrubs in poor (3 trees) to fair (2 trees) condition.

Photo 3: Looking northeast at compact blue gums #178 and 179. The trees were growing in small islands between parking spaces adjacent to the northern driveway. Inset shows the remnants of sulfur fungus that had developed between stems of tree #179.


5 mature to over-mature blue gum eucalyptus (41” to 80” in diameter) had been planted in and immediately east of the petting zoo. Those in the petting zoo had their trunks wrapped in chain link fence to reduce chewing damage by the goats and those outside the petting zoo were surrounded by concrete. Three (3) were in fair condition, 1 was in good and #29 was in poor. Blue gum #29 had sulfur fungus and a very sparse crown.

3 young to semi-mature Canary Island pines (11” to 15” in diameter) had been planted north of the northern picnic benches. They were all in fair condition.

3 mature silver dollar gum eucalyptus (22” to 35” in diameter) were growing in a group just north of the bathrooms. Two (2) were in fair condition and #199 was in good.

2 each of Chinese elm, privet and pineapple guava. Privets were in fair and poor condition, Chinese elms and pineapple guavas were in fair and good condition.

One (1) each of the following: red maple, silver maple, African fern pine, paper birch, brachychiton, evergreen ash, Chinese lantern, Southern magnolia, Monterey pine, yew and Calif. fan palm.

Overall, 131 trees were in good or excellent condition (44% of the total population), 139 were in fair (36%) and 56 trees were in poor condition (19%). Olive, Chinese pistache, sweetgum, London plane and coast redwood had performed well, while Italian stone pine, Lombardy poplar and black locust had not performed as well. The City of of Hayward does not have a tree protection ordinance but Alameda County protects all trees within the public right-of-way. The public right-of-way was not delineated on the plans or in the field so no determination of which trees are protected by the County has been made. Suitability for Preservation Before evaluating the impacts that will occur during development, it is important to consider the quality of the tree resource itself, and the potential for individual trees to function well over an extended length of time. Trees that are preserved on development sites must be carefully selected to make sure that they may survive development impacts, adapt to a new environment and perform well in the landscape. Our goal is to identify trees that have the potential for long-term health, structural stability and longevity. For trees growing in open fields, away from areas where people and property are present, structural defects and/or poor health presents a low risk of damage or injury if they fail. However, we must be concerned about safety in use areas. Therefore, where development encroaches into existing plantings, we must consider their structural stability as well as their potential to grow and thrive in a new environment. Where development will not occur, the normal life cycles of decline, structural failure and death should be allowed to continue. Evaluation of suitability for preservation considers several factors:

Tree health Healthy, vigorous trees are better able to tolerate impacts such as root injury, demolition

of existing structures, changes in soil grade and moisture, and soil compaction than are non-vigorous trees.

Structural integrity Trees with significant amounts of wood decay and other structural defects that cannot be

corrected are likely to fail. Such trees should not be preserved in areas where damage to people or property is likely. Trees with sulfur fungus, such as blue gum #29 and compact blue gum #188 are examples of such trees.

#72


Species response There is a wide variation in the response of individual species to construction impacts

and changes in the environment. For instance, olive and London plane are more tolerant of construction impacts than are sweetgum and eucalyptus.

Tree age and longevity Old trees, while having significant emotional and aesthetic appeal, have limited

physiological capacity to adjust to an altered environment. Young trees are better able to generate new tissue and respond to change.

Species invasiveness Species that spread across a site and displace desired vegetation are not always appropriate for retention. This is particularly true when indigenous species are displaced. The California Invasive Plant Inventory Database (http://www.cal-ipc.org/paf/) lists species identified as being invasive. Hayward is part of the Central West Floristic Province. Olive and blue gum eucalyptus are both listed as having ‘Limited’ invasiveness.

Each tree was rated for suitability for preservation based upon its age, health, structural condition and ability to safely coexist within a development environment (see Tree Assessment Forms in Exhibits. Table 2 provides a summary of suitability ratings. We consider trees with high suitability for preservation to be the best candidates for preservation. We do not recommend retention of trees with low suitability for preservation in areas where people or property will be present. Retention of trees with moderate suitability for preservation depends upon the intensity of proposed site changes.

Table 2: Tree suitability for preservation

Kennedy Park, Hayward CA

High These are trees with good health and structural stability that have the potential for longevity at the site. Forty-nine (49) trees were considered highly suitable for preservation, including 10 coast redwoods, 10 Chinese pistache, 6 sweetgums, 6 olives, 6 London planes, 3 Italian stone pines, 2 crape myrtles, 2 zelkovas, and one each of Southern magnolia, evergreen ash, Chinese elm and carob.

Moderate Trees in this category have fair health and/or structural defects that may be

abated with treatment. Trees in this category require more intense management and monitoring, and may have shorter life-spans than those in the “high” category. One hundred and seventy-four (174) trees had moderate suitability for preservation, including; 24 olives, 16 Chinese pistache, 15 sweetgums, 11 ash, 11 Italian stone pines, 8 Siberian elms, 8 compact blue gums, 8 London planes, 7 jacarandas, 6 zelkovas, 6 black locusts, 5 Lombardy poplars, 5 crape myrtles, 4 evergreen pear, 4 blue gum, 3 silver dollar gums, 3 Aleppo pines, 2 pineapple guavas, 2 mulberry, 2 Canary Island pines, and 1 each of African fern pine, coast redwood, Chinese elm, brachychiton, camphor, Calif. fan palm, Chinese lantern, Italian stone pine, paper birch, privet, Portuguese laurel, red maple, strawberry tree and yew.

(Continued, following page)


Table 2: Tree suitability for preservation, continued Kennedy Park, Hayward CA

Low Trees in this category are in poor health or have significant defects in

structure that cannot be abated with treatment. These trees can be expected to decline regardless of management. The species or individual tree may possess either characteristics that are undesirable in landscape settings or be unsuited for use areas. Seventy-three (73) trees had low suitability for preservation, including; 11 Lombardy poplars, 8 Italian stone pines, 5 compact blue gums, 5 strawberry trees, 5 camphors, 4 each of ash, carob, black locust, Aleppo pine, mulberry and Portuguese laurel, 2 each of sweetgum, jacaranda and evergreen pear, and 1 each of privet, Canary Island pine, blue gum, crape myrtle, Siberian elm, zelkova, London plane, Monterey pine and silver maple.

Evaluation of Impacts and Recommendations Appropriate tree retention develops a practical match between the location and intensity of construction activities and the quality and health of trees. The Tree Assessment was the reference point for tree condition and quality. Potential impacts from construction were evaluated using the Site Plan (dated August 8, 2018), Grading and Drainage Plan (dated July 6, 2018), and the Utility Plan (dated July 6, 2018) prepared by RRM Design Group. Potential impacts from construction were estimated for each tree. The plan proposes to renovate the park, installing new parking lots, pathways, hardscape, bathroom improvements, fences and a centrally located playground. The most significant impacts to trees would be associated with grading of the site for the construction of the play structures, hardscape, parking lots and pathways. Based on my assessment of the preliminary plans, 147 of the trees can be preserved under the current design. Preservation of these trees is predicated on adhering to the Tree Preservation Guidelines provided on page 10. Some amount of canopy and root pruning may be required for trees identified for preservation (see Tree Preservation Guidelines). I recommend removal for 149 trees, including 97 that would be directly impacted by the proposed changes. Forty-three (43) of the trees identified for removal were of low suitability for preservation and 9 compact blue gum eucalyptus were identified for removal by the City of Hayward (Table 3, Exhibits). Preservation of trees with low suitability is not recommended in areas where people and property will be introduced. Appraisal of Value The City of Hayward requires that the value of all trees identified for removal be established. To accomplish this, I used the standard methods found in Guide for Plant Appraisal, 9th edition (published in 2000 by the International Society of Arboriculture, Champaign IL). In addition, I referred to Species Classification and Group Assignment (2004), a publication of the Western Chapter of the International Society of Arboriculture. These two documents outline the methods employed in tree appraisal. The value of landscape trees is based upon four factors: size, species, condition and location. Size is measured as trunk diameter, normally 54" above grade. The species factor considers the adaptability and appropriateness of the plant in the East Bay area. The Species Classification and Group Assignment lists recommended species ratings and evaluations. Condition reflects the health and structural integrity of the individual, as noted in the Tree Assessment Form. Location considers the site, placement and contribution of the tree in its surrounding landscape. In this case, the trees are located in a mixed-use neighborhood of Hayward, which includes commercial, educational and residential.


The appraised value of the 149 trees recommended for removal was $469,450 (Table 4, Exhibits). The appraised value of the 147 trees identified for preservation was $615,750 (Table 5, Exhibits).

Maintenance Recommendations In an effort to help guide management of the tree resource at Kennedy Park, the following maintenance recommendations are provided for those trees identified for preservation or possible preservation (where additional information is needed). These are recommendations that will help correct existing defects in tree structure, reduce the potential for future failures and improve the health and longevity of those trees that will be retained as part of the playground construction and long-term park renovations. Table 4 (See Exhibits) summarizes the maintenance recommendations and recommendations for individual trees are also provided in the Tree Assessment Form.

Pruning – Pruning (proper and improper) has long-term impacts on tree structure and health. Having employees trained and knowledgeable in proper pruning of ornamental trees and what the industry standards are for pruning trees is critical to maintaining the beauty and longevity of the tree resource.

o Seventeen (17) trees were identified for pruning, including 8 where the length and extension of heavy lateral limbs should be reduced and 9 trees that should have the crowns cleaned of dead, broken and cracked branches.

Cabling and bracing – When trees have codominant or multiple stems emerging at the

same point, there is an elevated risk for a stem failure. In order to reduce the risk of a stem failure, a cable or brace rod can be installed between the stems to reduce this risk.

o Tree #235 was identified as a candidate for installation of a cable or brace between the stems.

Aerial inspections – Where defects may present that cannot be seen from the ground,

we recommend having a certified arborist perform an aerial inspection. The goal of the aerial inspection is to inspect the crown of the tree and identify any defects not visible from the ground.

o I recommend an aerial inspection be performed on Canary Island date palm #156 to inspect the jog in the trunk just below the pineapple.

Monitor – where trees were showing signs of decline but did not warrant removal, we

recommend monitoring their health and structure over time.

o Four (4) trees were recommended for monitoring for changes in health and structure.

Removal – where trees were in decline or wee structurally unstable, they were identified for removal. These trees were not impacted by construction but are listed in Table 3.

o Forty-five (45) trees at Kennedy Park were identified for removal based on low suitability. These are included in the trees identified for removal in Table 3.


Root pruning – Where displacement of infrastructure has occurred, trees may require root pruning when repairs are made. Roots should be exposed by hand to beyond the limit of the infrastructure and cut with a chain saw, hand saw, or other approved root pruning equipment. The Consulting Arborist should be present during root pruning operations to identify where root pruning is required and monitor root pruning activities.

o Twelve (12) trees were displacing the surrounding concrete and are candidates for root pruning.

Mulching - Mulches provide aesthetic, economic and environmental benefits to the

landscape. In general, mulches improve soil health, improve water holding capacity of the soil and return nutrients to the soil as they break down. Mulched landscapes are more resistant to stress, are more aesthetically pleasing, require fewer applications of pesticides and fertilizers, and are ultimately more sustainable than those without mulch cover. I recommend a 3-4” layer of course, wood chip mulch, spread within the dripline of trees. Use of wood chips produced through pruning of trees as mulch is acceptable.

Staking – The goal of staking is to brace the tree against the strongest winds during the establishment period, while not immobilizing it. It is the force of the wind acting on the trunk that promotes trunk strength and taper development. Leaving the stakes on too long can crutch the tree. Generally, I recommend removing all the staking/guying after 1 to 2 growing seasons, with the idea being that the tree should have established sufficient anchoring roots by that time to stand-up on its own. If stability is a concern, it can be checked by rocking the tree back and forth gently prior to removing the stakes.

Tree Preservation Guidelines The following recommendations will help reduce impacts to trees from development as well as maintain and improve their health and vitality through the clearing, grading and construction phases. The key elements of a tree preservation plan for Kennedy Park would include: Design recommendations

1. All plans affecting trees shall be reviewed by the Consulting Arborist with regard to tree impacts. These include, but are not limited to, demolition plans, grading and utility plans, landscape and irrigation plans.

2. A TREE PROTECTION ZONE must be established for trees to be preserved, in which no disturbance is permitted. TREE PROTECTION ZONES for trees identified for preservation are provided in the following table. No grading, excavation, construction or storage of materials shall occur within that zone.

3. Consider making the following adjustments to provide additional space for trees to be preserved:

Adjust the fence location adjacent to trees #44, 45 and 99 to provide a minimum of 5’ from the trees.

Adjust the storm drain/drain inlet locations adjacent to trees as follows: i. #1-5 to keep it at the back of the adjacent curb ii. #71, 91 and 269 to provide a minimum of 8’ from the tree iii. #110, 144 and 145 to provide a minimum of 15’ from the tree

4. No grading, excavation, construction or storage of materials shall occur within that zone.

5. No underground services including utilities, sub-drains, water or sewer shall be placed in

the Tree Protection Zone.


Specific Tree Protection Zones

Tree No. TPZ #14, 90, 181, 182, 183 5' N. DL in all other directions

#56, 203 and 204 5' S. DL in all other directions #218 5' E., DL in all other directions #43 5' SE. and DL in all other directions. #232 6' N. and DL in all other directions. #280 6' E. and DL in all other directions. #97 7' S. and DL in all other directions. #98 7' N. and DL in all other directions. #170 7' E. and DL in all other directions.

#275-279, 281-285 8' E. and DL in all other directions. #206 8' N. DL in all other directions #211 8' S., DL in all other directions #3, 5 10' N. and DL in all other directions. #220 10' E., DL in all other directions

#225, 226 10' W., DL in all other directions #172, 173 11' E. and DL in all other directions.

#262 11' S., DL in all other directions #273 11' NW. and DL in all other directions. #169 12' E., 9’ W., DL in all other directions. #175 12' E., DL in all other directions #158 12' in all directions #152 12' NW. DL in all other directions #110 12' S. DL in all other directions

#160, 174 14' E. DL in all other directions #212 14' S. DL in all other directions #192 15' N. DL in all other directions #235 15' W., 18’ S., DL in all other directions

6. Irrigation systems must be designed so that no trenching will occur within the Tree Protection Zone.

7. As trees withdraw water from the soil, expansive soils may shrink within the root area.

Therefore, foundations, footings and pavements on expansive soils near trees should be designed to withstand differential displacement.

8. Maintain the existing irrigation system. If the existing irrigation system is not functional,

have a temporary system installed (using soaker hoses or pvc laid on the ground and covered with mulch) as soon as possible to supply the trees with water and help them recover and prepare them for impacts associated with the demolition and construction process.

Pre-construction treatments and recommendations

1. The demolition contractor shall meet with the Consulting Arborist before beginning work to discuss work procedures and tree protection.

2. Where possible, cap and abandon all existing underground utilities within the TPZ in place. Removal of utility boxes by hand is acceptable but no trenching should be performed within the TPZ in an effort to remove utilities, irrigation lines, etc.


3. Fence all trees to be retained to completely enclose the Tree Protection Zone prior to demolition, grubbing or grading. Fences shall be 6 ft. chain link or equivalent as approved by the Consulting Arborist. Fences are to remain until all grading and construction is completed.

4. Tree(s) to be removed that have branches extending into the canopy of tree(s) to remain must be removed by a qualified arborist and not by construction contractors. The qualified arborist shall remove the tree in a manner that causes no damage to the tree(s) and understory to remain. Tree stumps shall be ground 12” below ground surface.

5. Prune trees to be preserved to clean the crown of dead branches 1” and larger in

diameter and raise canopies as needed for construction activities. All pruning shall be done by a State of California Licensed Tree Contractor (C61/D49). All pruning shall be done by Certified Arborist or Certified Tree Worker in accordance with the Best Management Practices for Pruning (International Society of Arboriculture, 2002) and adhere to the most recent editions of the American National Standard for Tree Care Operations (Z133.1) and Pruning (A300). The Consulting Arborist will provide pruning specifications prior to site demolition. Branches extending into the work area that can remain following demolition shall be tied back and protected from damage.

6. All tree work shall comply with the Migratory Bird Treaty Act as well as California Fish

and Wildlife code 3503-3513 to not disturb nesting birds. Tree pruning and removal should be scheduled outside of the breeding season to avoid scheduling delays. Breeding bird surveys should be conducted prior to tree work. Qualified biologists should be involved in establishing work buffers for active nests.

7. Any brush clearing required within the TREE PROTECTION ZONE shall be accomplished with hand-operated equipment.

8. Trees to be removed shall be felled so as to fall away from TREE PROTECTION ZONE and avoid pulling and breaking of roots of trees to remain. If roots are entwined, the consultant may require first severing the major woody root mass before extracting the trees, or grinding the stump below ground.

9. All down brush and trees shall be removed from the TREE PROTECTION ZONE either by hand, or with equipment sitting outside the TREE PROTECTION ZONE. Extraction shall occur by lifting the material out, not by skidding across the ground.

10. Apply and maintain 4-6” of wood chip mulch within the TREE PROTECTION ZONE. Recommendations for tree protection during construction

1. Prior to beginning work, the contractors working in the vicinity of trees to be preserved are required to meet with the Consulting Arborist at the site to review all work procedures, access routes, storage areas and tree protection measures.

2. All contractors shall conduct operations in a manner that will prevent damage to trees to

be preserved.

3. Any grading, construction, demolition or other work that is expected to encounter tree roots should be monitored by the Consulting Arborist.

4. Tree protection fences are to remain until all site work has been completed. Fences may

not be relocated or removed without permission of the Consulting Arborist.

5. Construction trailers, traffic and storage areas must remain outside fenced areas at all times.


6. Prior to grading, pad preparation, excavation for foundations/footings/walls, trenching, trees may require root pruning outside the TREE PROTECTION ZONE by cutting all roots cleanly to the depth of the excavation. Roots shall be cut by manually digging a trench and cutting exposed roots with a saw, with a vibrating knife, rock saw, narrow trencher with sharp blades, or other approved root pruning equipment. The Consulting Arborist will identify where root pruning is required and monitor all root pruning activities.

7. If injury should occur to any tree during construction, it should be evaluated as soon as

possible by the Consulting Arborist so that appropriate treatments can be applied.

8. No excess soil, chemicals, debris, equipment or other materials shall be dumped or stored within the Tree Protection Zone.

9. Any additional tree pruning needed for clearance during construction must be performed

by a Certified Arborist and not by construction personnel.

10. All trees shall be irrigated on a schedule to be determined by the Consulting Arborist (every 3 to 6 weeks April through October is typical). Each irrigation shall wet the soil within the TREE PROTECTION ZONE to a depth of 24”.

Maintenance of impacted trees Preserved trees will experience a physical environment different from that pre-development. As a result, tree health and structural stability should be monitored. Occasional pruning, fertilization, mulch, pest management, replanting and irrigation may be required. In addition, provisions for monitoring both tree health and structural stability following construction must be made a priority. As trees age, the likelihood of failure of branches or entire trees increases. Therefore, annual inspection for structural condition is recommended. If you have any questions about my observations or recommendations, please contact me. HortScience, Inc.

John Leffingwell Board Certified Master Arborist #WE-3966B Registered Consulting arborist #442


Exhibits

Table 3. Recommendations for Action

Table 4. Appraised value of trees identified for removal

Table 5. Appraised value of trees identified for preservation

Table 6. Maintenance Recommendations

Tree Appraisal Worksheet

Tree Assessment Form

Tree Assessment Map

Table 3Recommendations for ActionKennedy Park, Hayward

Tag Species Trunk Recommendation

Number Diameter(in.)

1 Olive 9,9,8,8,6 Remove, within parking lot2 Ash sp. 17 Preserve, outside impacts3 Ash sp. 18 Preserve, 10' from parking lot4 Ash sp. 10,8,7,5 Preserve, 5' from parking lot5 Ash sp. 15 Preserve, 10' from parking lot6 Ash sp. 7 Remove, low suitability7 Ash sp. 16 Remove, within new entry8 Carrob 27 Remove, within parking lot9 Carrob 28 Remove, within parking lot10 Carrob 26 Remove, within parking lot11 Carrob 20 Remove, within parking lot12 Carrob 25 Remove, within parking lot13 Carrob 19 Remove, within parking lot14 Carrob 15 Remove, within parking lot15 Carrob 12 Remove, within parking lot16 Carrob 25 Remove, within parking lot17 Chinese pistache 12 Remove, within parking lot18 Chinese pistache 11 Remove, within parking lot19 Chinese pistache 10 Remove, within parking lot20 Carrob 25 Remove, within parking lot21 Chinese pistache 10 Preserve, outside impacts22 Chinese pistache 9 Preserve, outside impacts23 Carrob 17 Remove, low suitability24 Carrob 20 Preserve, outside impacts25 Chinese pistache 10 Preserve, outside impacts26 Chinese pistache 6 Preserve, outside impacts27 Blue gum 80 Preserve, outside impacts28 Blue gum 60 Preserve, outside impacts29 Blue gum 60 Remove, low suitability30 Siberian elm 30 Preserve, outside impacts31 Sweetgum 17 Remove, impacted by parking32 Portuguese laurel 9 Remove, low suitability33 Lombardy poplar 42 Preserve, outside impacts34 Lombardy poplar 32 Remove, within path35 Lombardy poplar 38 Remove, low suitability35 Lombardy poplar 36 Remove, within path37 Lombardy poplar 36 Preserve, outside impacts38 Lombardy poplar 23 Remove, low suitability39 Lombardy poplar 30 Remove, low suitability40 Lombardy poplar 29 Preserve, outside impacts41 Lombardy poplar 23 Remove, impacted by sidewalk42 Lombardy poplar 37 Preserve, outside impacts43 Chinese pistache 8 Preserve, 5' from curb44 Olive 10,9,6 Preserve, adjust fence location

Page 1




45 Olive 10,7,6 Preserve, adjust fence location46 Olive 11,10,7,6,6 Preserve, outside impacts47 Olive 12,11 Preserve, outside impacts48 Olive 9,9,8,7,7 Preserve, outside impacts49 Olive 18,14,10 Preserve, outside impacts50 Olive 14,10,9,7 Preserve, outside impacts51 Olive 13,11,6 Preserve, adjacent to DG path52 Olive 16,12,11 Preserve, adjacent to DG path53 Olive 11 Preserve, outside impacts54 Olive 12,10,8,6 Preserve, outside impacts55 Olive 14,10,6 Preserve, outside impacts56 Sweetgum 14 Remove, impacted by path57 Sweetgum 16 Remove, within path58 Chinese pistache 12 Remove, within path59 Chinese pistache 16 Remove, within playground60 Sweetgum 18 Remove, within playground61 Chinese pistache 14 Remove, within playground62 Evergreen pear 12 Remove, within playground63 Evergreen pear 11 Remove, within playground64 Sweetgum 9 Remove, within playground65 Evergreen pear 13 Remove, within playground66 Evergreen pear 13 Remove, within playground67 Evergreen pear 16 Remove, within path68 London plane 12 Remove, within path69 Chinese pistache 10 Remove, within path70 Chinese pistache 12 Preserve, outside impacts71 Chinese pistache 10 Preserve, outside impacts72 Chinese pistache 15 Preserve, outside impacts73 Crape myrtle 8 Preserve, careful demo required74 Crape myrtle 9 Preserve, careful demo required75 Crape myrtle 7 Preserve, careful demo required76 Crape myrtle 7 Remove, within path77 Blue gum 56,41 Preserve, careful demo required78 Blue gum 71 Preserve, careful demo required79 Crape myrtle 8 Remove, within hardscape80 Crape myrtle 8 Remove, within hardscape81 Crape myrtle 9 Preserve, outside impacts82 Crape myrtle 11 Preserve, outside impacts83 Olive 16,10 Preserve, outside impacts84 Olive 8,7 Preserve, outside impacts85 Olive 11,10,8,6 Preserve, outside impacts86 Olive 10,9 Preserve, outside impacts87 Olive 10,8,7 Remove, within path88 Olive 12,11,10,7 Preserve, outside impacts

Page 2




89 Olive 13,10 Preserve, outside impacts90 Olive 13,7 Preserve, 5' from path91 Olive 13,11,9 Preserve, outside impacts92 Olive 11,9,8 Preserve, outside impacts93 Olive 14,13,10 Preserve, outside impacts94 Olive 15 Preserve, outside impacts95 Olive 16 Preserve, outside impacts96 Olive 12,11,9 Preserve, outside impacts97 Olive 14,10 Preserve, 7' from path98 Olive 14,10,7 Preserve, 7' from path99 Olive 10,10,9 Preserve, adjust fence location100 Lombardy poplar 26 Remove, low suitability101 Lombardy poplar 40 Remove, low suitability102 Lombardy poplar 36 Remove, low suitability103 Ash sp. 10 Remove, low suitability104 Ash sp. 11 Remove, low suitability105 Ash sp. 19 Remove, impacted by sidewalk106 Ash sp. 17 Remove, impacted by sidewalk107 Ash sp. 19 Remove, impacted by sidewalk108 Ash sp. 21 Remove, impacted by sidewalk109 Ash sp. 14 Remove, impacted by sidewalk110 Aleppo pine 42 Preserve, 12' from path111 Aleppo pine 37 Remove, low suitability112 Lombardy poplar 41 Remove, low suitability113 Ash sp. 12 Remove, impacted by sidewalk114 Lombardy poplar 46 Remove, impacted by sidewalk115 Ash sp. 13 Remove, within sidewalk116 Pineapple guava 7,6 Preserve, outside impacts117 Strawberry tree 9,7,7,6 Remove, low suitability118 Lombardy poplar 48 Remove, low suitability119 Italian stone pine 20 Preserve, outside impacts120 Chinese pistache 6 Preserve, outside impacts121 Chinese pistache 5 Preserve, outside impacts122 Chinese pistache 5 Preserve, outside impacts123 Black locust 19 Remove, low suitability124 Strawberry tree 13,11,11,9 Remove, low suitability125 Strawberry tree 9,9,8 Remove, low suitability126 Sweetgum 7 Remove, too close to train127 Strawberry tree 8,8,5 Remove, low suitability128 Strawberry tree 13,11,10 Remove, too close to train129 Portuguese laurel 19 Remove, too close to train130 Portuguese laurel 19 Remove, low suitability131 Pineapple guava 8,7 Remove, within path132 Portuguese laurel 18 Preserve, outside impacts

Page 3




133 London plane 7 Preserve, outside impacts134 Sweetgum 11 Preserve, outside impacts135 London plane 9 Preserve, outside impacts136 Southern magnolia 12 Preserve, outside impacts137 London plane 6 Preserve, outside impacts138 Siberian elm 21 Preserve, outside impacts139 Sweetgum 21 Preserve, outside impacts140 Siberian elm 28 Preserve, outside impacts141 Siberian elm 19 Remove, within path142 Siberian elm 23 Remove, low suitability143 Siberian elm 29 Preserve, keep concrete/SD/inlet 15' away144 Siberian elm 19 Preserve, keep concrete/SD/inlet 15' away145 Siberian elm 28 Preserve, keep concrete/SD/inlet 15' away146 Siberian elm 23 Remove, within concrete147 Sweetgum 11 Remove, within concrete148 Sweetgum 15 Remove, within playground149 Evergreen pear 12 Remove, within path150 Sweetgum 12 Preserve, outside impacts151 Sweetgum 10 Preserve, outside impacts152 Evergreen ash 42 Preserve, 12' from concrete153 Sweetgum 18 Remove, low suitability154 Monterey pine 28 Remove, low suitability155 Brachychiton 20 Remove, within path156 Ca. fan palm 34 Preserve, within tree well157 Strawberry tree 10,10,10,9 Preserve, keep concrete 8' away158 Zelkova 20 Preserve, 12' from concrete on 3 sides159 Chinese elm 14,14,11,10 Preserve, keep concrete 8' away160 Zelkova 30 Preserve, 14' from concrete & bocce court161 Zelkova 19 Preserve, keep DG 5' away, SD 8' & concrete 12'

away162 Zelkova 24 Preserve, keep DG 5' away, SD 8' & concrete 12'

away163 Black locust 21 Remove, low suitability164 Paper birch 8 Preserve, outside impacts165 London plane 27 Preserve, outside impacts166 Silver maple 26 Remove, low suitability167 Black locust 21 Preserve, outside impacts168 Chinese pistache 12 Remove, within train tracks169 Zelkova 20 Preserve, 12' from bocce court, 13' from SD, 9'

from concrete170 Chinese pistache 13 Preserve, 5' from bocce court, 8' from SD171 Zelkova 22 Remove, low suitability172 Zelkova 24 Preserve, 11' from concrete173 Zelkova 20 Preserve, 11' from concrete

Page 4




174 Zelkova 18 Preserve, 14' from concrete175 Zelkova 21 Preserve, 12' from concrete176 Mulberry 18 Preserve, new curb 3' S.177 Mulberry 20 Preserve, new curb 3' S.178 Compact blue gum 77,30 Remove, impacted by sidewalk179 Compact blue gum 33,13 Remove, low suitability180 Compact blue gum 53,14 Remove, per City181 Compact blue gum 40,13,12 Remove, per City182 Compact blue gum 30,11 Remove, per City183 Compact blue gum 24,19,15,10 Remove, per City184 Compact blue gum 40,17,15 Remove, per City185 Compact blue gum 31,30,29,15 Remove, per City186 Compact blue gum 52,26,25,12 Remove, per City187 Compact blue gum 69 Remove, per City188 Compact blue gum 84,22 Remove, per City189 Black locust 27 Remove, low suitability190 Jacaranda 12 Remove, within path191 Jacaranda 8 Remove, low suitability192 Italian stone pine 16 Remove, within bioretention193 Canary island pine 15 Remove, low suitability194 Italian stone pine 27 Remove, within path195 Italian stone pine 22 Remove, within path196 Italian stone pine 15 Remove, within path197 Italian stone pine 26 Remove, low suitability198 Silver dollar gum 35 Remove, within path199 Silver dollar gum 22 Remove, impacted by path200 Silver dollar gum 26 Remove, impacted by path & sinks201 Jacaranda 12 Remove, within path202 Sweetgum 13 Remove, within path203 Jacaranda 9 Preserve, 5' from path204 Italian stone pine 18 Preserve, 5' from path205 Aleppo pine 23 Remove, low suitability206 Aleppo pine 32 Preserve, 8' from sidewalk, 12' from SD207 Jacaranda 6 Preserve, outside impacts208 Aleppo pine 25 Remove, low suitability209 Jacaranda 6 Preserve, outside impacts210 Jacaranda 6 Preserve, outside impacts211 Canary island pine 12 Preserve, 8' from path212 Italian stone pine 20 Preserve, 14' from path213 Aleppo pine 29 Remove, low suitability214 Privet 12,9,8,8,7 Preserve, outside impacts215 Privet 22,17 Remove, within sidewalk216 Jacaranda 7 Preserve, outside impacts217 Italian stone pine 22,21 Preserve, outside impacts

Page 5




218 Italian stone pine 22,13 Preserve, 5' from path219 Italian stone pine 22 Remove, low suitability220 Italian stone pine 21 Preserve, 10' from path221 Italian stone pine 17,12 Preserve, outside impacts222 Italian stone pine 13 Preserve, outside impacts223 Italian stone pine 30 Preserve, outside impacts224 Italian stone pine 20 Preserve, outside impacts225 Aleppo pine 40 Preserve, 10' from train tracks226 Italian stone pine 26 Preserve, 10' from train tracks227 Italian stone pine 21 Remove, low suitability228 Italian stone pine 28,25 Preserve, outside impacts229 Canary island pine 11 Preserve, outside impacts230 Italian stone pine 20 Remove, low suitability231 Italian stone pine 27 Remove, low suitability232 Compact blue gum 67 Preserve, 6' from path, 20' from water233 Compact blue gum 41 Remove, low suitability234 Chinese pistache 15 Remove, impacted by path235 Italian stone pine 46 Preserve, 15' E. and 18' N. of path236 Chinese pistache 8 Preserve, outside impacts237 Chinese pistache 10 Remove, within path238 Chinese pistache 9 Remove, impacted by sidewalk239 Chinese pistache 12 Remove, within sidewalk240 Black locust 21 Remove, within parking lot241 Red maple 7 Remove, within parking lot242 Chinese lantern 14 Remove, within parking lot243 Chinese pistache 18 Remove, within parking lot244 Black locust 18 Remove, within parking lot245 Chinese elm 23 Remove, within parking lot246 Black locust 15 Remove, low suitability247 African fern pine 6 Remove, within parking248 Portuguese laurel 15 Remove, low suitability249 Carrob 28 Remove, within parking lot250 Black locust 18 Remove, within parking lot251 Black locust 20 Remove, within parking lot252 Carrob 32 Remove, within parking lot253 Carrob 9 Remove, impacted by parking lot254 Mulberry 21 Remove, impacted by parking lot255 Mulberry 17 Remove, impacted by parking lot256 Mulberry 19 Remove, impacted by parking lot257 Mulberry 25 Remove, low suitability258 Camphor 9,7,7,6,5 Preserve, outside impacts259 Camphor 22 Remove, impacting sidewalk260 Camphor 14 Remove, impacting sidewalk261 Camphor 17 Remove, impacting sidewalk

Page 6




262 Camphor 24 Remove, impacting sidewalk263 Camphor 15 Remove, impacting sidewalk264 Yew 26 Preserve, outside impacts265 Italian stone pine 31,26,18,11 Preserve, outside impacts266 Sweetgum 9 Preserve, outside impacts267 Sweetgum 11 Preserve, outside impacts268 Sweetgum 23 Remove, impacted by sidewalk269 Sweetgum 15 Remove, within lawn renovations270 Sweetgum 17 Remove, within lawn renovations271 Sweetgum 12 Remove, within sidewalk272 Sweetgum 6 Remove, within sidewalk273 Sweetgum 22 Preserve, 11' SE. of sidewalk274 Sweetgum 22 Preserve, outside impacts275 Coast redwood 22 Preserve, 8' W. of parking lot276 Coast redwood 22 Preserve, 8' W. of parking lot277 Coast redwood 22 Preserve, 8' W. of parking lot278 Coast redwood 23 Preserve, 8' W. of parking lot279 Coast redwood 22 Preserve, 8' W. of parking lot280 Coast redwood 18 Preserve, 6' W. of parking lot281 Coast redwood 19 Preserve, 8' W. of parking lot282 Coast redwood 17 Preserve, 8' W. of parking lot283 Coast redwood 19 Preserve, 8' W. of parking lot284 Coast redwood 22 Preserve, 8' W. of parking lot285 Coast redwood 24 Preserve, 8' W. of parking lot286 London plane 17 Preserve, off-site287 London plane 15 Preserve, off-site288 London plane 17 Preserve, off-site289 London plane 17 Preserve, off-site290 London plane 20 Preserve, off-site291 London plane 16 Preserve, off-site292 London plane 21 Preserve, off-site293 London plane 6 Preserve, off-site294 London plane 9 Preserve, off-site295 London plane 15 Preserve, off-site296 Black locust 26,22 Preserve, off-site

Page 7

Table 4Appraised value of tree identified for removalKennedy Park, Hayward

Tag Species Trunk Appraised

Number Diameter Value ($)(in.)

1 Olive 9,9,8,8,6 2,8506 Ash sp. 7 3007 Ash sp. 16 1,9508 Carrob 27 6,1509 Carrob 28 4,700

10 Carrob 26 4,05011 Carrob 20 2,40012 Carrob 25 3,75013 Carrob 19 2,20014 Carrob 15 1,40015 Carrob 12 90016 Carrob 25 3,75017 Chinese pistache 12 3,35018 Chinese pistache 11 2,80019 Chinese pistache 10 2,35020 Carrob 25 3,75023 Carrob 17 95029 Blue gum 60 4,90031 Sweetgum 17 3,20032 Portuguese laurel 9 45034 Lombardy poplar 32 1,55035 Lombardy poplar 38 1,90035 Lombardy poplar 36 3,50038 Lombardy poplar 23 30039 Lombardy poplar 30 1,40041 Lombardy poplar 23 1,35056 Sweetgum 14 2,15057 Sweetgum 16 3,95058 Chinese pistache 12 3,00059 Chinese pistache 16 5,25060 Sweetgum 18 2,15061 Chinese pistache 14 4,05062 Evergreen pear 12 1,45063 Evergreen pear 11 70064 Sweetgum 9 1,30065 Evergreen pear 13 2,35066 Evergreen pear 13 1,70067 Evergreen pear 16 2,50068 London plane 12 1,80069 Chinese pistache 10 2,10076 Crape myrtle 7 85079 Crape myrtle 8 80080 Crape myrtle 8 80087 Olive 10,8,7 2,600100 Lombardy poplar 26 1,200

Page 1




1 Olive 9,9,8,8,6 2,850101 Lombardy poplar 40 4,200102 Lombardy poplar 36 3,600103 Ash sp. 10 400104 Ash sp. 11 450105 Ash sp. 19 2,200106 Ash sp. 17 1,800107 Ash sp. 19 3,100108 Ash sp. 21 1,600109 Ash sp. 14 1,200111 Aleppo pine 37 5,600112 Lombardy poplar 41 2,600113 Ash sp. 12 900114 Lombardy poplar 46 5,100115 Ash sp. 13 1,450117 Strawberry tree 9,7,7,6 700118 Lombardy poplar 48 3,250123 Black locust 19 900124 Strawberry tree 13,11,11,9 4,800125 Strawberry tree 9,9,8 2,250126 Sweetgum 7 850127 Strawberry tree 8,8,5 1,500128 Strawberry tree 13,11,10 6,400129 Portuguese laurel 19 3,700130 Portuguese laurel 19 650131 Pineapple guava 8,7 2,500141 Siberian elm 19 650142 Siberian elm 23 550146 Siberian elm 23 900147 Sweetgum 11 1,350148 Sweetgum 15 3,500149 Evergreen pear 12 1,450153 Sweetgum 18 2,150154 Monterey pine 28 1,200155 Brachychiton 20 2,150163 Black locust 21 1,100166 Silver maple 26 4,450168 Chinese pistache 12 3,350171 Zelkova 22 3,200178 Compact blue gum 77,30 20,300179 Compact blue gum 33,13 2,850180 Compact blue gum 53,14 8,800181 Compact blue gum 40,13,12 6,800182 Compact blue gum 30,11 2,350183 Compact blue gum 24,19,15,10 4,850

Page 2




1 Olive 9,9,8,8,6 2,850184 Compact blue gum 40,17,15 7,600185 Compact blue gum 31,30,29,15 15,150186 Compact blue gum 52,26,25,12 18,750187 Compact blue gum 69 6,150188 Compact blue gum 84,22 2,700189 Black locust 27 1,600190 Jacaranda 12 1,500191 Jacaranda 8 300192 Italian stone pine 16 2,500193 Canary island pine 15 2,200194 Italian stone pine 27 3,000195 Italian stone pine 22 2,000196 Italian stone pine 15 950197 Italian stone pine 26 2,800198 Silver dollar gum 35 17,200199 Silver dollar gum 22 9,900200 Silver dollar gum 26 9,850201 Jacaranda 12 1,500202 Sweetgum 13 1,900205 Aleppo pine 23 2,050208 Aleppo pine 25 2,700213 Aleppo pine 29 3,250215 Privet 22,17 1,650219 Italian stone pine 22 2,000227 Italian stone pine 21 1,850230 Italian stone pine 20 1,650231 Italian stone pine 27 3,000233 Compact blue gum 41 5,200234 Chinese pistache 15 3,300237 Chinese pistache 10 2,100238 Chinese pistache 9 1,900239 Chinese pistache 12 3,350240 Black locust 21 1,800241 Red maple 7 350242 Chinese lantern 14 3,400243 Chinese pistache 18 7,400244 Black locust 18 1,650245 Chinese elm 23 7,700246 Black locust 15 500247 African fern pine 6 550248 Portuguese laurel 15 1,250249 Carrob 28 4,700250 Black locust 18 1,300251 Black locust 20 1,650

Page 3




1 Olive 9,9,8,8,6 2,850252 Carrob 32 8,450253 Carrob 9 300254 Mulberry 21 1,600255 Mulberry 17 1,050256 Mulberry 19 800257 Mulberry 25 1,350259 Camphor 22 6,900260 Camphor 14 1,700261 Camphor 17 2,500262 Camphor 24 8,200263 Camphor 15 1,950268 Sweetgum 23 9,050269 Sweetgum 15 3,500270 Sweetgum 17 4,450271 Sweetgum 12 2,500272 Sweetgum 6 850

Total 469,450

Page 4

Table 5Appraised value of tree identified for preservationKennedy Park, Hayward



2 Ash sp. 17 2,2503 Ash sp. 18 1,8004 Ash sp. 10,8,7,5 1,8505 Ash sp. 15 1,250

21 Chinese pistache 10 1,50022 Chinese pistache 9 1,70024 Carrob 20 3,00025 Chinese pistache 10 2,10026 Chinese pistache 6 55027 Blue gum 80 10,10028 Blue gum 60 8,15030 Siberian elm 30 1,55033 Lombardy poplar 42 4,05037 Lombardy poplar 36 1,90040 Lombardy poplar 29 2,20042 Lombardy poplar 37 3,35043 Chinese pistache 8 1,35044 Olive 10,9,6 2,65045 Olive 10,7,6 1,60046 Olive 11,10,7,6,6 4,15047 Olive 12,11 3,25048 Olive 9,9,8,7,7 3,95049 Olive 18,14,10 2,60050 Olive 14,10,9,7 5,20051 Olive 13,11,6 3,95052 Olive 16,12,11 6,30053 Olive 11 1,50054 Olive 12,10,8,6 4,20055 Olive 14,10,6 4,05070 Chinese pistache 12 2,15071 Chinese pistache 10 2,10072 Chinese pistache 15 4,65073 Crape myrtle 8 1,40074 Crape myrtle 9 1,75075 Crape myrtle 7 60077 Blue gum 56,41 12,80078 Blue gum 71 13,15081 Crape myrtle 9 1,00082 Crape myrtle 11 2,05083 Olive 16,10 4,35084 Olive 8,7 1,40085 Olive 11,10,8,6 3,90086 Olive 10,9 2,25088 Olive 12,11,10,7 5,000

Page 1




89 Olive 13,10 3,30090 Olive 13,7 2,65091 Olive 13,11,9 4,50092 Olive 11,9,8 3,25093 Olive 14,13,10 5,65094 Olive 15 2,75095 Olive 16 3,15096 Olive 12,11,9 4,20097 Olive 14,10 2,60098 Olive 14,10,7 4,20099 Olive 10,10,9 2,450110 Aleppo pine 42 11,300116 Pineapple guava 7,6 1,500119 Italian stone pine 20 5,000120 Chinese pistache 6 1,000121 Chinese pistache 5 750122 Chinese pistache 5 600132 Portuguese laurel 18 2,900133 London plane 7 650134 Sweetgum 11 2,400135 London plane 9 1,350136 Southern magnolia 12 2,600137 London plane 6 500138 Siberian elm 21 750139 Sweetgum 21 4,850140 Siberian elm 28 1,900143 Siberian elm 29 2,050144 Siberian elm 19 650145 Siberian elm 28 1,900150 Sweetgum 12 1,600151 Sweetgum 10 1,150152 Evergreen ash 42 11,350156 Ca. fan palm 34 500157 Strawberry tree 10,10,10,9 5,600158 Zelkova 20 6,150159 Chinese elm 14,14,11,10 12,550160 Zelkova 30 13,750161 Zelkova 19 3,950162 Zelkova 24 8,800164 Paper birch 8 250165 London plane 27 9,800167 Black locust 21 1,800169 Zelkova 20 6,150170 Chinese pistache 13 2,500

Page 2




172 Zelkova 24 8,800173 Zelkova 20 6,150174 Zelkova 18 5,000175 Zelkova 21 4,850176 Mulberry 18 1,200177 Mulberry 20 1,300203 Jacaranda 9 850204 Italian stone pine 18 2,250206 Aleppo pine 32 7,250207 Jacaranda 6 300209 Jacaranda 6 300210 Jacaranda 6 400211 Canary island pine 12 1,450212 Italian stone pine 20 2,800214 Privet 12,9,8,8,7 1,300216 Jacaranda 7 200217 Italian stone pine 22,21 8,950218 Italian stone pine 22,13 4,500220 Italian stone pine 21 3,050221 Italian stone pine 17,12 3,000222 Italian stone pine 13 1,700223 Italian stone pine 30 6,200224 Italian stone pine 20 2,800225 Aleppo pine 40 9,450226 Italian stone pine 26 4,700228 Italian stone pine 28,25 13,550229 Canary island pine 11 1,200232 Compact blue gum 67 12,550235 Italian stone pine 46 17,050236 Chinese pistache 8 1,350258 Camphor 9,7,7,6,5 2,050264 Yew 26 11,000265 Italian stone pine 31,26,18,11 22,150266 Sweetgum 9 1,450267 Sweetgum 11 2,100273 Sweetgum 22 8,300274 Sweetgum 22 8,300275 Coast redwood 22 7,600276 Coast redwood 22 7,600277 Coast redwood 22 7,600278 Coast redwood 23 8,300279 Coast redwood 22 7,600280 Coast redwood 18 3,950281 Coast redwood 19 4,400

Page 3




282 Coast redwood 17 3,550283 Coast redwood 19 4,400284 Coast redwood 22 7,600285 Coast redwood 24 9,000286 London plane 17 3,550287 London plane 15 2,750288 London plane 17 3,550289 London plane 17 3,550290 London plane 20 4,850291 London plane 16 3,150292 London plane 21 5,350293 London plane 6 350294 London plane 9 750295 London plane 15 2,750296 Black locust 26,22 5,900

Total 615,750

Page 4

Table 6Tree maintenance recommendationsKennedy Park, Hayward



27 Blue gum 80 Monitor33 Lombardy poplar 42 Crown clean37 Lombardy poplar 36 Crown clean40 Lombardy poplar 29 Crown clean41 Lombardy poplar 23 Crown clean42 Lombardy poplar 37 Crown clean49 Olive 18,14,10 Crown clean56 Sweetgum 14 Root prune58 Chinese pistache 12 Expand cut-out67 Evergreen pear 16 Root prune68 London plane 12 Root prune69 Chinese pistache 10 Prune to reduce laterals71 Chinese pistache 10 Root prune72 Chinese pistache 15 Root prune77 Blue gum 56,41 Root prune78 Blue gum 71 Root prune79 Crape myrtle 8 Crown clean80 Crape myrtle 8 Crown clean82 Crape myrtle 11 Root prune108 Ash sp. 21 Prune to reduce laterals110 Aleppo pine 42 Prune to reduce laterals114 Lombardy poplar 46 Monitor128 Strawberry tree 13,11,10 Monitor129 Portuguese laurel 19 Monitor132 Portuguese laurel 18 Monitor147 Sweetgum 11 Root prune150 Sweetgum 12 Root prune151 Sweetgum 10 Root prune152 Evergreen ash 42 Root prune156 Ca. fan palm 34 Aerial inspection160 Zelkova 30 Prune to reduce laterals175 Zelkova 21 Prune to reduce laterals176 Mulberry 18 Root prune181 Compact blue gum 40,13,12 Remove stem183 Compact blue gum 24,19,15,10 Crown clean184 Compact blue gum 40,17,15 Prune to reduce laterals206 Aleppo pine 32 Monitor220 Italian stone pine 21 Prune to reduce laterals222 Italian stone pine 13 Crown clean223 Italian stone pine 30 Prune to reduce laterals224 Italian stone pine 20 Crown clean225 Aleppo pine 40 Prune to reduce laterals226 Italian stone pine 26 Prune to reduce laterals228 Italian stone pine 28,25 Crown clean

Page 1

Table 6Tree maintenance recommendationsKennedy Park, Hayward



235 Italian stone pine 46 Cable/brace265 Italian stone pine 31,26,18,11 Root prune

Page 2

Appraisal worksheet for 9th edition and 2004 edition of Species Classification & Group Assignment HortScience|Bartlett Consulting

Hayward Area Recreation and Park District January, 2018Kennedy Park, Hayward CA

Tree Species Condition Trunk Location Species Replacement tree Installation Total Unit Appraised Trunk area Basic Appraised RoundedNo. 0 to 1.0 Diameter 0 to 1.0 0 to 1.0 Size Cost Cost Cost Tree cost Trunk area increase tree cost value value ($50)

1 Olive 0.5 9,9,8,8,6 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 256 252.2 11,810 2,835 2,8502 Ash sp. 0.7 17 0.6 0.3 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 227 224.76 17,661 2,225 2,2503 Ash sp. 0.5 18 0.6 0.3 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 254 251.76 19,741 1,777 1,8004 Ash sp. 0.7 10,8,7,5 0.6 0.3 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 187 184.76 14,579 1,837 1,8505 Ash sp. 0.5 15 0.6 0.3 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 177 174.76 13,809 1,243 1,2506 Ash sp. 0.5 7 0.6 0.3 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 38 35.76 3,100 279 3007 Ash sp. 0.7 16 0.6 0.3 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 201 198.76 15,658 1,973 1,9508 Carrob 0.7 27 0.67 0.5 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 572 568.2 26,176 6,138 6,1509 Carrob 0.5 28 0.67 0.5 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 615 611.2 28,131 4,712 4,70010 Carrob 0.5 26 0.67 0.5 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 531 527.2 24,312 4,072 4,05011 Carrob 0.5 20 0.67 0.5 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 314 310.2 14,447 2,420 2,40012 Carrob 0.5 25 0.67 0.5 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 491 487.2 22,494 3,768 3,75013 Carrob 0.5 19 0.67 0.5 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 283 279.2 13,038 2,184 2,20014 Carrob 0.5 15 0.67 0.5 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 177 173.2 8,219 1,377 1,40015 Carrob 0.5 12 0.67 0.5 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 113 109.2 5,310 889 90016 Carrob 0.5 25 0.67 0.5 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 491 487.2 22,494 3,768 3,75017 Chinese pistache 0.7 12 0.67 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 113 110.76 8,878 3,331 3,35018 Chinese pistache 0.7 11 0.67 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 95 92.76 7,492 2,811 2,80019 Chinese pistache 0.7 10 0.67 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 79 76.76 6,259 2,348 2,35020 Carrob 0.5 25 0.67 0.5 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 491 487.2 22,494 3,768 3,75021 Chinese pistache 0.5 10 0.6 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 79 76.76 6,259 1,502 1,50022 Chinese pistache 0.7 9 0.6 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 64 61.76 5,103 1,715 1,70023 Carrob 0.3 17 0.6 0.5 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 227 223.2 10,492 944 95024 Carrob 0.7 20 0.6 0.5 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 314 310.2 14,447 3,034 3,00025 Chinese pistache 0.7 10 0.6 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 79 76.76 6,259 2,103 2,10026 Chinese pistache 0.5 6 0.6 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 28 25.76 2,330 559 55027 Blue gum 0.5 80 0.6 0.4 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 2313 2308.25 84,273 10,113 10,10028 Blue gum 0.5 60 0.6 0.4 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 1865 1860.25 67,984 8,158 8,15029 Blue gum 0.3 60 0.6 0.4 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 1865 1860.25 67,984 4,895 4,90030 Siberian elm 0.5 30 0.6 0.2 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 707 702.25 25,879 1,553 1,55031 Sweetgum 0.5 17 0.6 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 227 224.76 17,661 3,179 3,20032 Portuguese laurel 0.3 9 0.6 0.5 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 64 61.76 5,103 459 45033 Lombardy poplar 0.5 42 0.6 0.3 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 1233 1228.25 45,005 4,050 4,05034 Lombardy poplar 0.3 32 0.6 0.3 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 788 783.25 28,824 1,557 1,55035 Lombardy poplar 0.3 36 0.6 0.3 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 974 969.25 35,587 1,922 1,90035 Lombardy poplar 0.5 38 0.6 0.3 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 1063 1058.25 38,823 3,494 3,50037 Lombardy poplar 0.3 36 0.6 0.3 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 974 969.25 35,587 1,922 1,90038 Lombardy poplar 0.1 23 0.6 0.3 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 415 410.25 15,262 275 30039 Lombardy poplar 0.3 30 0.6 0.3 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 707 702.25 25,879 1,397 1,40040 Lombardy poplar 0.5 29 0.6 0.3 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 660 655.25 24,170 2,175 2,20041 Lombardy poplar 0.5 23 0.6 0.3 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 415 410.25 15,262 1,374 1,35042 Lombardy poplar 0.5 37 0.6 0.3 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 1018 1013.25 37,187 3,347 3,35043 Chinese pistache 0.7 8 0.6 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 50 47.76 4,025 1,352 1,35044 Olive 0.7 10,9,6 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 171 167.2 7,946 2,670 2,650

Page 1




45 Olive 0.5 10,7,6 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 145 141.2 6,764 1,623 1,60046 Olive 0.7 11,10,7,6,6 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 268 264.2 12,356 4,152 4,15047 Olive 0.7 12,11 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 208 204.2 9,628 3,235 3,25048 Olive 0.7 9,9,8,7,7 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 254 250.2 11,720 3,938 3,95049 Olive 0.5 18,14,10 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 233 229.2 10,765 2,584 2,60050 Olive 0.7 14,10,9,7 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 335 331.2 15,402 5,175 5,20051 Olive 0.7 13,11,6 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 256 252.2 11,810 3,968 3,95052 Olive 0.7 16,12,11 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 409 405.2 18,766 6,305 6,30053 Olive 0.7 11 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 95 91.2 4,491 1,509 1,50054 Olive 0.7 12,10,8,6 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 270 266.2 12,447 4,182 4,20055 Olive 0.7 14,10,6 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 261 257.2 12,038 4,045 4,05056 Sweetgum 0.5 14 0.6 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 154 151.76 12,037 2,167 2,15057 Sweetgum 0.7 16 0.6 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 201 198.76 15,658 3,946 3,95058 Chinese pistache 0.7 12 0.6 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 113 110.76 8,878 2,983 3,00059 Chinese pistache 0.7 16 0.6 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 201 198.76 15,658 5,261 5,25060 Sweetgum 0.3 18 0.6 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 254 251.76 19,741 2,132 2,15061 Chinese pistache 0.7 14 0.6 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 154 151.76 12,037 4,044 4,05062 Evergreen pear 0.5 12 0.6 0.5 2.09 172.73 172.73 345.46 82.82 113 110.91 9,531 1,430 1,45063 Evergreen pear 0.3 11 0.6 0.5 2.09 172.73 172.73 345.46 82.82 95 92.91 8,040 724 70064 Sweetgum 0.7 9 0.6 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 64 61.76 5,103 1,286 1,30065 Evergreen pear 0.7 13 0.6 0.5 2.09 172.73 172.73 345.46 82.82 133 130.91 11,187 2,349 2,35066 Evergreen pear 0.5 13 0.6 0.5 2.09 172.73 172.73 345.46 82.82 133 130.91 11,187 1,678 1,70067 Evergreen pear 0.5 16 0.6 0.5 2.09 172.73 172.73 345.46 82.82 201 198.91 16,819 2,523 2,50068 London plane 0.7 12 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 113 109.2 5,310 1,784 1,80069 Chinese pistache 0.7 10 0.6 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 79 76.76 6,259 2,103 2,10070 Chinese pistache 0.5 12 0.6 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 113 110.76 8,878 2,131 2,15071 Chinese pistache 0.7 10 0.6 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 79 76.76 6,259 2,103 2,10072 Chinese pistache 0.7 15 0.6 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 177 174.76 13,809 4,640 4,65073 Crape myrtle 0.9 8 0.6 0.6 2.09 172.73 172.73 345.46 82.82 50 47.91 4,313 1,398 1,40074 Crape myrtle 0.9 9 0.6 0.6 2.09 172.73 172.73 345.46 82.82 64 61.91 5,473 1,773 1,75075 Crape myrtle 0.5 7 0.6 0.6 2.09 172.73 172.73 345.46 82.82 38 35.91 3,320 598 60076 Crape myrtle 0.7 7 0.6 0.6 2.09 172.73 172.73 345.46 82.82 38 35.91 3,320 837 85077 Blue gum 0.5 56,41 0.6 0.4 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 2934 2929.25 106,853 12,822 12,80078 Blue gum 0.7 71 0.6 0.4 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 2145 2140.25 78,165 13,132 13,15079 Crape myrtle 0.5 8 0.6 0.6 2.09 172.73 172.73 345.46 82.82 50 47.91 4,313 776 80080 Crape myrtle 0.5 8 0.6 0.6 2.09 172.73 172.73 345.46 82.82 50 47.91 4,313 776 80081 Crape myrtle 0.5 9 0.6 0.6 2.09 172.73 172.73 345.46 82.82 64 61.91 5,473 985 1,00082 Crape myrtle 0.7 11 0.6 0.6 2.09 172.73 172.73 345.46 82.82 95 92.91 8,040 2,026 2,05083 Olive 0.7 16,10 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 280 276.2 12,902 4,335 4,35084 Olive 0.7 8,7 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 88 84.2 4,173 1,402 1,40085 Olive 0.7 11,10,8,6 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 252 248.2 11,629 3,907 3,90086 Olive 0.7 10,9 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 143 139.2 6,673 2,242 2,25087 Olive 0.7 10,8,7 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 167 163.2 7,765 2,609 2,60088 Olive 0.7 12,11,10,7 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 325 321.2 14,947 5,022 5,000

Page 2




89 Olive 0.7 13,10 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 212 208.2 9,810 3,296 3,30090 Olive 0.7 13,7 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 171 167.2 7,946 2,670 2,65091 Olive 0.7 13,11,9 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 292 288.2 13,447 4,518 4,50092 Olive 0.7 11,9,8 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 209 205.2 9,674 3,250 3,25093 Olive 0.7 14,13,10 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 366 362.2 16,811 5,649 5,65094 Olive 0.7 15 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 177 173.2 8,219 2,762 2,75095 Olive 0.7 16 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 201 197.2 9,310 3,128 3,15096 Olive 0.7 12,11,9 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 272 268.2 12,538 4,213 4,20097 Olive 0.5 14,10 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 233 229.2 10,765 2,584 2,60098 Olive 0.7 14,10,7 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 271 267.2 12,492 4,197 4,20099 Olive 0.5 10,10,9 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 222 218.2 10,265 2,464 2,450100 Lombardy poplar 0.3 26 0.67 0.3 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 531 526.25 19,480 1,175 1,200101 Lombardy poplar 0.5 40 0.67 0.3 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 1149 1144.25 41,950 4,216 4,200102 Lombardy poplar 0.5 36 0.67 0.3 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 974 969.25 35,587 3,577 3,600103 Ash sp. 0.3 10 0.67 0.3 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 79 76.76 6,259 377 400104 Ash sp. 0.3 11 0.67 0.3 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 95 92.76 7,492 452 450105 Ash sp. 0.5 19 0.67 0.3 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 283 280.76 21,975 2,209 2,200106 Ash sp. 0.5 17 0.67 0.3 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 227 224.76 17,661 1,775 1,800107 Ash sp. 0.7 19 0.67 0.3 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 283 280.76 21,975 3,092 3,100108 Ash sp. 0.3 21 0.67 0.3 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 346 343.76 26,829 1,618 1,600109 Ash sp. 0.5 14 0.67 0.3 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 154 151.76 12,037 1,210 1,200110 Aleppo pine 0.5 42 0.67 0.6 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 1233 1229.2 56,225 11,301 11,300111 Aleppo pine 0.3 37 0.67 0.6 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 1018 1014.2 46,451 5,602 5,600112 Lombardy poplar 0.3 41 0.67 0.3 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 1191 1186.25 43,478 2,622 2,600113 Ash sp. 0.5 12 0.67 0.3 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 113 110.76 8,878 892 900114 Lombardy poplar 0.5 46 0.67 0.3 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 1392 1387.25 50,786 5,104 5,100115 Ash sp. 0.7 13 0.67 0.3 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 133 130.76 10,419 1,466 1,450116 Pineapple guava 0.5 7,6 0.67 0.8 2.09 172.73 172.73 345.46 82.82 66 63.91 5,638 1,511 1,500117 Strawberry tree 0.1 9,7,7,6 0.67 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 168 165.76 13,116 703 700118 Lombardy poplar 0.3 48 0.67 0.3 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 1468 1463.25 53,549 3,229 3,250119 Italian stone pine 0.9 20 0.6 0.8 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 314 309.25 11,590 5,007 5,000120 Chinese pistache 0.9 6 0.6 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 28 25.76 2,330 1,007 1,000121 Chinese pistache 0.9 5 0.6 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 20 17.76 1,714 740 750122 Chinese pistache 0.7 5 0.6 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 20 17.76 1,714 576 600123 Black locust 0.3 19 0.67 0.2 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 283 280.76 21,975 883 900124 Strawberry tree 0.3 13,11,11,9 0.67 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 387 384.76 29,987 4,822 4,800125 Strawberry tree 0.3 9,9,8 0.67 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 178 175.76 13,886 2,233 2,250126 Sweetgum 0.7 7 0.67 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 38 35.76 3,100 872 850127 Strawberry tree 0.3 8,8,5 0.67 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 120 117.76 9,418 1,514 1,500128 Strawberry tree 0.5 13,11,10 0.67 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 307 304.76 23,824 6,385 6,400129 Portuguese laurel 0.5 19 0.67 0.5 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 283 280.76 21,975 3,681 3,700130 Portuguese laurel 0.1 19 0.6 0.5 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 283 280.76 21,975 659 650131 Pineapple guava 0.7 8,7 0.6 0.8 2.09 172.73 172.73 345.46 82.82 88 85.91 7,461 2,507 2,500132 Portuguese laurel 0.5 18 0.6 0.5 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 254 251.76 19,741 2,961 2,900

Page 3




133 London plane 0.7 7 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 38 34.2 1,900 638 650134 Sweetgum 0.9 11 0.6 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 95 92.76 7,492 2,427 2,400135 London plane 0.9 9 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 64 60.2 3,082 1,331 1,350136 Southern magnolia 0.9 12 0.6 0.9 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 113 109.2 5,310 2,581 2,600137 London plane 0.7 6 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 28 24.2 1,446 486 500138 Siberian elm 0.5 21 0.6 0.2 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 346 341.25 12,753 765 750139 Sweetgum 0.5 21 0.6 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 346 343.76 26,829 4,829 4,850140 Siberian elm 0.7 28 0.6 0.2 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 615 610.25 22,534 1,893 1,900141 Siberian elm 0.5 19 0.6 0.2 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 283 278.25 10,463 628 650142 Siberian elm 0.3 23 0.6 0.2 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 415 410.25 15,262 549 550143 Siberian elm 0.7 29 0.6 0.2 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 660 655.25 24,170 2,030 2,050144 Siberian elm 0.5 19 0.6 0.2 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 283 278.25 10,463 628 650145 Siberian elm 0.7 28 0.6 0.2 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 615 610.25 22,534 1,893 1,900146 Siberian elm 0.5 23 0.6 0.2 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 415 410.25 15,262 916 900147 Sweetgum 0.5 11 0.6 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 95 92.76 7,492 1,349 1,350148 Sweetgum 0.7 15 0.6 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 177 174.76 13,809 3,480 3,500149 Evergreen pear 0.5 12 0.6 0.5 2.09 172.73 172.73 345.46 82.82 113 110.91 9,531 1,430 1,450150 Sweetgum 0.5 12 0.6 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 113 110.76 8,878 1,598 1,600151 Sweetgum 0.5 10 0.6 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 79 76.76 6,259 1,127 1,150152 Evergreen ash 0.7 42 0.6 0.6 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 1233 1228.25 45,005 11,341 11,350153 Sweetgum 0.3 18 0.6 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 254 251.76 19,741 2,132 2,150154 Monterey pine 0.3 28 0.6 0.3 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 615 610.25 22,534 1,217 1,200155 Brachychiton 0.5 20 0.6 0.5 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 314 310.2 14,447 2,167 2,150156 Ca. fan palm 0.5 55 0.6 0.6 1 500 500 1000 30 1 0 2,650 477 500157 Strawberry tree 0.5 10,10,10,9 0.6 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 301 298.76 23,362 5,607 5,600158 Zelkova 0.7 20 0.6 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 314 311.76 24,363 6,140 6,150159 Chinese elm 0.7 14,14,11,10 0.6 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 482 479.76 37,306 12,535 12,550160 Zelkova 0.7 30 0.6 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 707 704.76 54,640 13,769 13,750161 Zelkova 0.5 19 0.6 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 283 280.76 21,975 3,956 3,950162 Zelkova 0.7 24 0.6 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 452 449.76 34,995 8,819 8,800163 Black locust 0.3 21 0.67 0.2 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 346 343.76 26,829 1,079 1,100164 Paper birch 0.5 8 0.67 0.3 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 50 46.2 2,446 246 250165 London plane 0.7 27 0.67 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 572 568.2 26,176 9,821 9,800166 Silver maple 0.5 26 0.67 0.3 2.09 172.73 172.73 345.46 82.82 531 528.91 44,150 4,437 4,450167 Black locust 0.5 21 0.67 0.2 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 346 343.76 26,829 1,798 1,800168 Chinese pistache 0.7 12 0.67 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 113 110.76 8,878 3,331 3,350169 Zelkova 0.7 20 0.6 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 314 311.76 24,363 6,140 6,150170 Chinese pistache 0.5 13 0.6 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 133 130.76 10,419 2,501 2,500171 Zelkova 0.3 22 0.6 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 380 377.76 29,448 3,180 3,200172 Zelkova 0.7 24 0.6 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 452 449.76 34,995 8,819 8,800173 Zelkova 0.7 20 0.6 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 314 311.76 24,363 6,140 6,150174 Zelkova 0.7 18 0.6 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 254 251.76 19,741 4,975 5,000175 Zelkova 0.5 21 0.6 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 346 343.76 26,829 4,829 4,850176 Mulberry 0.5 18 0.67 0.3 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 254 250.2 11,720 1,178 1,200

Page 4




177 Mulberry 0.5 20 0.6 0.3 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 314 310.2 14,447 1,300 1,300178 Compact blue gum 0.7 77,30 0.67 0.4 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 2970 2965.25 108,162 20,291 20,300179 Compact blue gum 0.3 33,13 0.67 0.4 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 968 963.25 35,369 2,844 2,850180 Compact blue gum 0.5 53,14 0.67 0.4 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 1799 1794.25 65,584 8,788 8,800181 Compact blue gum 0.5 40,13,12 0.67 0.4 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 1395 1390.25 50,895 6,820 6,800182 Compact blue gum 0.3 30,11 0.67 0.4 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 802 797.25 29,333 2,358 2,350183 Compact blue gum 0.5 24,19,15,10 0.67 0.4 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 991 986.25 36,206 4,852 4,850184 Compact blue gum 0.5 40,17,15 0.67 0.4 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 1553 1548.25 56,640 7,590 7,600185 Compact blue gum 0.7 31,30,29,15 0.67 0.4 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 2216 2211.25 80,747 15,148 15,150186 Compact blue gum 0.7 52,26,25,12 0.67 0.4 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 2746 2741.25 100,017 18,763 18,750187 Compact blue gum 0.3 69 0.67 0.4 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 2100 2095.25 76,529 6,153 6,150188 Compact blue gum 0.1 84,22 0.67 0.4 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 2750 2745.25 100,163 2,684 2,700189 Black locust 0.3 27 0.6 0.2 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 572 569.76 44,240 1,593 1,600190 Jacaranda 0.7 12 0.6 0.4 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 113 110.76 8,878 1,492 1,500191 Jacaranda 0.3 8 0.6 0.4 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 50 47.76 4,025 290 300192 Italian stone pine 0.7 16 0.6 0.8 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 201 196.25 7,481 2,514 2,500193 Canary island pine 0.5 15 0.6 0.9 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 177 173.2 8,219 2,219 2,200194 Italian stone pine 0.3 27 0.6 0.8 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 572 567.25 20,971 3,020 3,000195 Italian stone pine 0.3 22 0.6 0.8 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 380 375.25 13,990 2,014 2,000196 Italian stone pine 0.3 15 0.6 0.8 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 177 172.25 6,608 952 950197 Italian stone pine 0.3 26 0.6 0.8 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 531 526.25 19,480 2,805 2,800198 Silver dollar gum 0.5 35 0.6 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 928 925.76 71,666 17,200 17,200199 Silver dollar gum 0.7 22 0.6 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 380 377.76 29,448 9,895 9,900200 Silver dollar gum 0.5 26 0.6 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 531 528.76 41,081 9,859 9,850201 Jacaranda 0.7 12 0.6 0.4 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 113 110.76 8,878 1,492 1,500202 Sweetgum 0.5 13 0.6 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 133 130.76 10,419 1,875 1,900203 Jacaranda 0.7 9 0.6 0.4 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 64 61.76 5,103 857 850204 Italian stone pine 0.5 18 0.6 0.8 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 254 249.25 9,408 2,258 2,250205 Aleppo pine 0.3 23 0.6 0.6 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 415 411.2 19,039 2,056 2,050206 Aleppo pine 0.5 32 0.67 0.6 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 788 784.2 35,995 7,235 7,250207 Jacaranda 0.5 6 0.67 0.4 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 28 25.76 2,330 312 300208 Aleppo pine 0.3 25 0.67 0.6 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 491 487.2 22,494 2,713 2,700209 Jacaranda 0.5 6 0.67 0.4 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 28 25.76 2,330 312 300210 Jacaranda 0.7 6 0.67 0.4 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 28 25.76 2,330 437 400211 Canary island pine 0.5 12 0.6 0.9 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 113 109.2 5,310 1,434 1,450212 Italian stone pine 0.5 20 0.6 0.8 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 314 309.25 11,590 2,782 2,800213 Aleppo pine 0.3 29 0.6 0.6 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 660 656.2 30,176 3,259 3,250214 Privet 0.5 12,9,8,8,7 0.6 0.3 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 315 311.2 14,493 1,304 1,300215 Privet 0.3 22,17 0.67 0.3 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 607 603.2 27,767 1,674 1,650216 Jacaranda 0.3 7 0.6 0.4 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 38 35.76 3,100 223 200217 Italian stone pine 0.7 22,21 0.6 0.8 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 726 721.25 26,570 8,928 8,950218 Italian stone pine 0.5 22,13 0.6 0.8 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 513 508.25 18,825 4,518 4,500219 Italian stone pine 0.3 22 0.6 0.8 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 380 375.25 13,990 2,014 2,000220 Italian stone pine 0.5 21 0.6 0.8 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 346 341.25 12,753 3,061 3,050

Page 5




221 Italian stone pine 0.5 17,12 0.6 0.8 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 340 335.25 12,535 3,008 3,000222 Italian stone pine 0.7 13 0.6 0.8 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 133 128.25 5,009 1,683 1,700223 Italian stone pine 0.5 30 0.6 0.8 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 707 702.25 25,879 6,211 6,200224 Italian stone pine 0.5 20 0.6 0.8 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 314 309.25 11,590 2,782 2,800225 Aleppo pine 0.5 40 0.6 0.6 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 1149 1145.2 52,406 9,433 9,450226 Italian stone pine 0.5 26 0.6 0.8 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 531 526.25 19,480 4,675 4,700227 Italian stone pine 0.3 21 0.6 0.8 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 346 341.25 12,753 1,836 1,850228 Italian stone pine 0.7 28,25 0.6 0.8 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 1106 1101.25 40,387 13,570 13,550229 Canary island pine 0.5 11 0.6 0.9 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 95 91.2 4,491 1,213 1,200230 Italian stone pine 0.3 20 0.6 0.8 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 314 309.25 11,590 1,669 1,650231 Italian stone pine 0.3 27 0.6 0.8 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 572 567.25 20,971 3,020 3,000232 Compact blue gum 0.7 67 0.6 0.4 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 2052 2047.25 74,783 12,564 12,550233 Compact blue gum 0.5 41 0.6 0.4 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 1191 1186.25 43,478 5,217 5,200234 Chinese pistache 0.5 15 0.6 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 177 174.76 13,809 3,314 3,300235 Italian stone pine 0.7 46 0.6 0.8 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 1392 1387.25 50,786 17,064 17,050236 Chinese pistache 0.7 8 0.6 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 50 47.76 4,025 1,352 1,350237 Chinese pistache 0.7 10 0.6 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 79 76.76 6,259 2,103 2,100238 Chinese pistache 0.7 9 0.67 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 64 61.76 5,103 1,915 1,900239 Chinese pistache 0.7 12 0.67 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 113 110.76 8,878 3,331 3,350240 Black locust 0.5 21 0.67 0.2 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 346 343.76 26,829 1,798 1,800241 Red maple 0.5 7 0.67 0.7 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 38 33.25 1,554 365 350242 Chinese lantern 0.7 14 0.67 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 154 151.76 12,037 3,387 3,400243 Chinese pistache 0.7 18 0.67 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 254 251.76 19,741 7,407 7,400244 Black locust 0.7 18 0.6 0.2 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 254 251.76 19,741 1,658 1,650245 Chinese elm 0.5 23 0.6 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 415 412.76 32,144 7,715 7,700246 Black locust 0.3 15 0.6 0.2 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 177 174.76 13,809 497 500247 African fern pine 0.5 6 0.6 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 28 25.76 2,330 559 550248 Portuguese laurel 0.3 15 0.6 0.5 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 177 174.76 13,809 1,243 1,250249 Carrob 0.5 28 0.67 0.5 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 615 611.2 28,131 4,712 4,700250 Black locust 0.5 18 0.67 0.2 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 254 251.76 19,741 1,323 1,300251 Black locust 0.5 20 0.67 0.2 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 314 311.76 24,363 1,632 1,650252 Carrob 0.7 32 0.67 0.5 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 788 784.2 35,995 8,441 8,450253 Carrob 0.3 9 0.67 0.5 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 64 60.2 3,082 310 300254 Mulberry 0.5 21 0.67 0.3 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 346 342.2 15,902 1,598 1,600255 Mulberry 0.5 17 0.67 0.3 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 227 223.2 10,492 1,054 1,050256 Mulberry 0.3 19 0.67 0.3 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 283 279.2 13,038 786 800257 Mulberry 0.3 25 0.67 0.3 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 491 487.2 22,494 1,356 1,350258 Camphor 0.3 9,7,7,6,5 0.67 0.7 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 188 185.76 14,656 2,062 2,050259 Camphor 0.5 22 0.67 0.7 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 380 377.76 29,448 6,906 6,900260 Camphor 0.3 14 0.67 0.7 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 154 151.76 12,037 1,694 1,700261 Camphor 0.3 17 0.67 0.7 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 227 224.76 17,661 2,485 2,500262 Camphor 0.5 24 0.67 0.7 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 452 449.76 34,995 8,206 8,200263 Camphor 0.3 15 0.67 0.7 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 177 174.76 13,809 1,943 1,950264 Yew 0.5 26 0.67 0.8 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 531 528.76 41,081 11,010 11,000

Page 6




265 Italian stone pine 0.7 31,26,18,11 0.67 0.8 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 1619 1614.25 59,040 22,152 22,150266 Sweetgum 0.7 9 0.67 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 64 61.76 5,103 1,436 1,450267 Sweetgum 0.7 11 0.67 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 95 92.76 7,492 2,108 2,100268 Sweetgum 0.7 23 0.67 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 415 412.76 32,144 9,045 9,050269 Sweetgum 0.7 15 0.6 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 177 174.76 13,809 3,480 3,500270 Sweetgum 0.7 17 0.6 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 227 224.76 17,661 4,451 4,450271 Sweetgum 0.7 12 0.67 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 113 110.76 8,878 2,498 2,500272 Sweetgum 0.9 6 0.67 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 28 25.76 2,330 843 850273 Sweetgum 0.7 22 0.67 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 380 377.76 29,448 8,287 8,300274 Sweetgum 0.7 22 0.67 0.6 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 380 377.76 29,448 8,287 8,300275 Coast redwood 0.9 22 0.67 0.9 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 380 375.25 13,990 7,592 7,600276 Coast redwood 0.9 22 0.67 0.9 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 380 375.25 13,990 7,592 7,600277 Coast redwood 0.9 22 0.67 0.9 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 380 375.25 13,990 7,592 7,600278 Coast redwood 0.9 23 0.67 0.9 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 415 410.25 15,262 8,283 8,300279 Coast redwood 0.9 22 0.67 0.9 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 380 375.25 13,990 7,592 7,600280 Coast redwood 0.7 18 0.67 0.9 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 254 249.25 9,408 3,971 3,950281 Coast redwood 0.7 19 0.67 0.9 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 283 278.25 10,463 4,416 4,400282 Coast redwood 0.7 17 0.67 0.9 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 227 222.25 8,426 3,557 3,550283 Coast redwood 0.7 19 0.67 0.9 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 283 278.25 10,463 4,416 4,400284 Coast redwood 0.9 22 0.67 0.9 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 380 375.25 13,990 7,592 7,600285 Coast redwood 0.9 24 0.67 0.9 4.75 172.73 172.73 345.46 36.36 452 447.25 16,607 9,013 9,000286 London plane 0.7 17 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 227 223.2 10,492 3,525 3,550287 London plane 0.7 15 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 177 173.2 8,219 2,762 2,750288 London plane 0.7 17 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 227 223.2 10,492 3,525 3,550289 London plane 0.7 17 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 227 223.2 10,492 3,525 3,550290 London plane 0.7 20 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 314 310.2 14,447 4,854 4,850291 London plane 0.7 16 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 201 197.2 9,310 3,128 3,150292 London plane 0.7 21 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 346 342.2 15,902 5,343 5,350293 London plane 0.5 6 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 28 24.2 1,446 347 350294 London plane 0.5 9 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 64 60.2 3,082 740 750295 London plane 0.7 15 0.6 0.8 3.8 172.73 172.73 345.46 45.46 177 173.2 8,219 2,762 2,750296 Black locust 0.7 26,22 0.6 0.2 2.24 172.73 172.73 345.46 77.04 911 908.76 70,356 5,910 5,900

Total 1,085,200

Largest commonly available = 24" boxLocation = 60% Site, 60% Placement and 60% ContributionAdd 10% for placement and contribution for perimiter/screening and parking lot/shading treesTrunks > than 30" - used Adjusted Trunk Areas from 9th Ed.

Page 7

TREE SPECIES SIZE CONDITION SUITABILITY COMMENTS RECOMMENDATIONNo. DIAMETER 1=POOR FOR

(in inches) 5=EXCELLENT PRESERVATION

1 Olive 9,9,8,8,6 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at base; one stem failed at base; trunk wounds.

--

2 Ash sp. 17 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 10’; one sided W.; fair branch structure.

--

3 Ash sp. 18 3 Moderate Codominant trunks at 6’; crossing branches; slight lean S.; fair structure.

--

4 Ash sp. 10,8,7,5 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 1’; good form; seam in attachment.

--

5 Ash sp. 15 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 8’; narrow attachments; poor branch structure.

--

6 Ash sp. 7 3 Low Multiple attachments at 8’; leans SE.; poor structure. --

7 Ash sp. 16 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 7’; leans SE.; fair structure. --

8 Carrob 27 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 6’; good form; in parking lot island; displacing curb/asphalt 5”.

Root prune

9 Carrob 28 3 Low Multiple attachments at 7’; ganoderma at base SW.; no basal flare; displacing curb/asphalt 5”.

Monitor/root prune

10 Carrob 26 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 7’; leans E.; in parking lot island; displacing curb/asphalt 3”.

Root prune

11 Carrob 20 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 7’; laterals E.; displacing asphalt 3”.

Root prune

12 Carrob 25 3 Low Multiple attachments at 6’; poor color; twig dieback; displacing asphalt 5”.

Root prune

Tree Assessment Kennedy ParkHayward, CaliforniaJanuary 2018

Page 1




13 Carrob 19 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 5’; leans NW.; no basal flare; in parking lot island; displacing curb/asphalt 6”.

Root prune

14 Carrob 15 3 Moderate Codominant trunks at 5’; no basal flare; small crown; displacing asphalt 4”.

Root prune

15 Carrob 12 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 6’; small crown; displacing asphalt 3”.

Root prune

16 Carrob 25 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 7’; twig dieback; displacing asphalt 6”.

Root prune

17 Chinese pistache 12 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 10’; one sided E.; fair structure.

--

18 Chinese pistache 11 4 High Multiple attachments at 10’; good form and structure; displacing asphalt 3’.

Root prune

19 Chinese pistache 10 4 High Multiple attachments at 10’; good form and structure; displacing asphalt 2”.

Root prune

20 Carrob 25 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 7’; in parking lot island; 6” dead branch E.; displacing asphalt 3”.

Root prune

21 Chinese pistache 10 3 Moderate Codominant trunks at 6’; leans N. & resting on fence; in goat area.

--

22 Chinese pistache 9 4 High Multiple attachments at 7’; good form and structure; in goat area.

--

23 Carrob 17 2 Low Multiple attachments at 8’; strong lean S. & resting on fence; trunk decay.

Remove tree

24 Carrob 20 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 7’; leans SE. & resting on fence.

--

Page 2




25 Chinese pistache 10 4 High Codominant trunks at 6’; good form and structure; in goat area.

--

26 Chinese pistache 6 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 7’; broken branches; fair structure; in goat area.

--

27 Blue gum 80 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 10’; upright form; embedded dance around trunk & bark removed by goats; in goat area.

Monitor

28 Blue gum 60 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 8’; narrow form; fence around trunk; in goat area.

--

29 Blue gum 60 2 Low Multiple attachments at 10’; large trunk wound SE.; sulfur fungus; sparse crown; fence around trunk; in goat area.

Remove tree

30 Siberian elm 30 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 15’; history of branch failures; pruning wounds with decay; bacterial

--

31 Sweetgum 17 3 Moderate Codominant trunks at 7’; seam in attachment; one sided S.

--

32 Portuguese laurel 9 2 Low Poor form and structure. Remove tree33 Lombardy poplar 42 3 Low Multiple attachments at 10’; upright form; dead

branches to 5”. Crown clean

34 Lombardy poplar 32 2 Low Multiple attachments at 10’; one sided N.; lost tops; dead branches to 8”.

Remove tree

35 Lombardy poplar 36 2 Low Multiple attachments at 10’; one sided S.; lost tops; dead branches to 6”.

Remove tree

35 Lombardy poplar 38 3 Low Multiple attachments at 4’; SE. stem hollow at 4’; twig dieback.

Remove tree

Page 3




37 Lombardy poplar 36 2 Low Codominant trunks at 5’; narrow form; lost tops; dead branches to 6”.

Crown clean

38 Lombardy poplar 23 1 Low Large basal cavity W.; narrow form; lost tops; dead branches to 8”.

Remove tree

39 Lombardy poplar 30 2 Low Multiple attachments at 10’; one sided SE.; hangers; lost tops; dead branches to 6”.

Remove tree

40 Lombardy poplar 29 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 10’; one sided E.; dead branches to 3”.

Crown clean

41 Lombardy poplar 23 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 10’; one sided W.; dead branches to 3”.

Crown clean

42 Lombardy poplar 37 3 Moderate Codominant trunks at 10’; one sided S.; dead branches to 4”.

Crown clean

43 Chinese pistache 8 4 Moderate Codominant trunks at 6’; fair structure. --44 Olive 10,9,6 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 1’; one sided E.; suppressed. --45 Olive 10,7,6 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at base; suppressed & one

sided E. --

46 Olive 11,10,7,6,6 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at base; suppressed & one sided E.; low branches E.

--

47 Olive 12,11 4 Moderate Codominant trunks at base;narrow form; a little sparse.

--

48 Olive 9,9,8,7,7 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at base; one sided S.; low branches S.

--

49 Olive 18,14,10 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 3’; narrow form; N. stem very sparse.

Crown clean

50 Olive 14,10,9,7 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 3’; good form; trunk wounds. --

Page 4




51 Olive 13,11,6 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 3’; one sided S.; trunk wounds.

--

52 Olive 16,12,11 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 3’; low lateral S.; trunk wounds.

--

53 Olive 11 4 High Multiple attachments at 7’; one sided N. --54 Olive 12,10,8,6 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 1’; one sided N..; trunk

wounds; twig dieback.--

55 Olive 14,10,6 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 1’; one sided NE..; trunk wounds; twig dieback.

--

56 Sweetgum 14 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 12’; seam in attachment; displacing sidewalk 2”.

Root prune

57 Sweetgum 16 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 12’; included bark; flat trunk flat W.

Cable/brace

58 Chinese pistache 12 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 7’; fair branch structure; in 4x4 cut-out; displacing concrete 5”.

Expand cut-out

59 Chinese pistache 16 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 7’; good form and structure; hanger N.; in 4x4 cut-out; displacing concrete 5”.

Expand cut-out

60 Sweetgum 18 2 Low Codominant trunks at 4’; seam in attachment; displacing sidewalk 12”.

Remove tree

61 Chinese pistache 14 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 8’; good form and structure; lateral N.

Prune to reduce laterals

62 Evergreen pear 12 3 Low Codominant trunks at 7’; leans N.; poor form and structure.


63 Evergreen pear 11 2 Low Slight lean S.; trunk wound w/ crack; failing towards playground.

Remove tree

Page 5




64 Sweetgum 9 4 Moderate Codominant trunks at 8’; seam in attachment; fair structure.

--

65 Evergreen pear 13 4 Moderate Codominant trunks at 8’; good form; fair branch structure.

--

66 Evergreen pear 13 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 7’; slight lean S.; in 4x4 cut-out.

--

67 Evergreen pear 16 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 7’; one sided E.; in 4x4 cut-out & displacing concrete 5”.

Root prune

68 London plane 12 4 Moderate Codominant trunks at 10’ & 12’; slight lean E.; in 6x6 cut-out & displacing concrete 5”.

Root prune

69 Chinese pistache 10 4 Moderate Codominant trunks at 7’; slight lean E.; history of branch failures; in 4x4 cut-out.


70 Chinese pistache 12 3 Moderate Codominant trunks at 12’; one sided S.; trunk wound E.; in 4x4 cut-out.

--

71 Chinese pistache 10 4 Moderate Codominant trunks at 8’; narrow form; in 4x4 cut-out & displacing concrete 2”.

Root prune

72 Chinese pistache 15 4 High Multiple attachments at 8’; good form and structure; in 4x4 cut-out & displacing concrete 1”.

Root prune

73 Crape myrtle 8 5 High Good form and structure; in 4x4 cut-out & displacing concrete 1”.

--

74 Crape myrtle 9 5 High Good form and structure; in 4x4 cut-out. --75 Crape myrtle 7 3 Low Good form and structure; trunk wounds W.; in 4x4

cut-out. --

76 Crape myrtle 7 4 Moderate Crowded; one sided SW.; trunk wounds; in 4x4 cut-out.

--

Page 6




77 Blue gum 56,41 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 10’; one sided W.; twig dieback; in 8x8 cut-out & displacing concrete 4”.

Root prune

78 Blue gum 71 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 10’; one sided E.; dead branches to 3”; in 8x8 cut-out & displacing & pillowing over concrete.

Root prune

Crape myrtle Crown clean80 Crape myrtle 8 3 Moderate Good form; 3” dead branch; trunk wounds; in 4x4 cut-

out. Crown clean

81 Crape myrtle 9 3 Moderate Fair structure; in 4x4 cut-out. --82 Crape myrtle 11 4 Moderate Good form; bark loss NE.; completely filled 4x4 cut-

out; displacing concrete 2”. Root prune

83 Olive 16,10 4 High Multiple attachments at 4’; low stem NW.; good form; trunk wounds.

--

84 Olive 8,7 4 Moderate Codominant trunks at base; good form; trunk wounds.

--

85 Olive 11,10,8,6 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 4’; good form; twig dieback; trunk wounds.

--

86 Olive 10,9 4 Moderate Codominant trunks at base; good form; twig dieback; trunk wounds.

--

87 Olive 10,8,7 4 High Multiple attachments at 4’; crossing stems; twig dieback; trunk wounds.

--

88 Olive 12,11,10,7 4 High Multiple attachments at 4’; crossing stems; twig dieback; trunk wounds.

--

89 Olive 13,10 4 Moderate Codominant trunks at 2’; good form; twig dieback; trunk wounds.

--

Page 7




90 Olive 13,7 4 Moderate Codominant trunks at 2’; 7” stem suppressed; twig dieback; trunk wounds.

--

91 Olive 13,11,9 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 4’; asymmetric form; twig dieback; trunk wounds.

--

92 Olive 11,9,8 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 2’; asymmetric form; twig dieback; trunk wounds.

--

93 Olive 14,13,10 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 4’; crowded; asymmetric form; twig dieback; trunk wounds.

--

94 Olive 15 4 High Codominant trunks at 10’; good form form; one sided N.; trunk wounds.

--

95 Olive 16 4 High Codominant trunks at 10’; good form form; a little one sided E.

--

96 Olive 12,11,9 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 4’; crowded; narrow form; twig dieback; trunk wounds.

--

97 Olive 14,10 3 Moderate Codominant trunks at 4’ & 6’’; one sided SE.; moderate dieback.

--

98 Olive 14,10,7 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 4’; crowded; one sided SE.; twig dieback; trunk wounds.

--

99 Olive 10,10,9 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 2’; one sided S.; twig dieback; trunk wounds.

--

100 Lombardy poplar 26 2 Low Multiple attachments at 10’; leaning & one sided S.; lost tops; dead branches to 3”.

Remove tree

101 Lombardy poplar 40 3 Low Multiple attachments at 10’; upright form; basal cavity; dead branches to 3”.

Remove tree

102 Lombardy poplar 36 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 10’; upright form; trunk cavity @ 7’; dead branches to 3”.

--

Page 8




103 Ash sp. 10 2 Low Leans S.; poor form as structure. --104 Ash sp. 11 2 Low Lateral W.; poor form as structure. --105 Ash sp. 19 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 5’; twisted branches; fair

form as structure; laterals N. --

106 Ash sp. 17 3 Moderate Stems removed S.; fair form as structure; lateral N. --107 Ash sp. 19 4 Moderate Codominant trunks at 6’; S. stem suppressed. --108 Ash sp. 21 2 Low Codominant trunks at 7’; large branch failure; large

trunk wound. Prune to reduce laterals

109 Ash sp. 14 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 7’; good form; large trunk wound.

--

110 Aleppo pine 42 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 4’; very one sided W. over beaches; heavy laterals; dead branch to 3”.


111 Aleppo pine 37 2 Low Multiple attachments at 8’; very one sided E.; sparse crown; dead branch to 3”.

Remove tree

112 Lombardy poplar 41 2 Low Multiple attachments at 10’; leaning & one sided S.; basal cavity & decay; dead branches to 3”.

Remove tree

113 Ash sp. 12 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 7’; asymmetric form. --114 Lombardy poplar 46 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 10’; one sided S.; dead

branches to 3”. Monitor

115 Ash sp. 13 4 Moderate Codominant trunks at 6’; asymmetric form; lateral N. --116 Pineapple guava 7,6 3 Moderate Codominant trunks at base; suppressed; leans SE. --

117 Strawberry tree 9,7,7,6 1 Low Codominant trunks at base; all but dead. Remove tree118 Lombardy poplar 48 2 Low Codominant trunks at 8’; upright form; basal cavity &

decay; dead branches to 3”. Monitor

Page 9




119 Italian stone pine 20 5 High Multiple attachments at 10’; slight lean E.; good form and structure.

--

120 Chinese pistache 6 5 High Multiple attachments at 6’; good form and structure; a little one sided E.

--

121 Chinese pistache 5 5 High Codominant trunks at 6’; included bark; good form and structure.

--

122 Chinese pistache 5 4 High Multiple attachments at 7’; broken branches; good form and structure.

--

123 Black locust 19 2 Low Slight lean E.; basal wounds & decay; crack in trunk. Remove tree124 Strawberry tree 13,11,11,9 2 Low Multiple attachments at 3’; declining; cracks forming

in stems. Remove tree

125 Strawberry tree 9,9,8 2 Low Multiple attachments at base; decay in attachments; declining.

Remove tree

126 Sweetgum 7 4 Moderate Good young tree; girdled branch W.; fair form and structure.

--

127 Strawberry tree 8,8,5 2 Low Multiple attachments at base; basal decay; declining. Remove tree128 Strawberry tree 13,11,10 3 Low Multiple attachments at 2’; basal decay; E. stem

declining. Monitor

129 Portuguese laurel 19 3 Low Multiple attachments at 5’; good form; moderate dieback.

Monitor

130 Portuguese laurel 19 1 Low Strong lean SE.; failing at base; soil & roots cracking on tension side.

Remove tree

131 Pineapple guava 8,7 4 Moderate Codominant trunks at base; leans E. --132 Portuguese laurel 18 3 Moderate Codominant trunks at 7’; leans SW.; good form;

trunk wounds; dieback. Monitor

Page 10




133 London plane 7 4 Moderate Good young tree; slight lean E.; fair form and structure.

--

134 Sweetgum 11 5 High Multiple attachments at 10’; good form and structure. --135 London plane 9 5 High Multiple attachments at 8’; good form and structure;

slight lean SE. --

136 Southern magnolia 12 5 High Multiple attachments at 8’; good form and structure. --137 London plane 6 4 Moderate Good young tree; slight lean S.; fair form and

structure. --

138 Siberian elm 21 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 10’; one sided S.; history of branch failures.

--

139 Sweetgum 21 3 Moderate Upright form; lateral S.; trunk wound from ground to 12’; history of branch failures.

--

140 Siberian elm 28 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 10’; one sided E.; pruning wounds; bacterial wet wood.

--

141 Siberian elm 19 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 10’; asymmetric form; cavity in attachment.

--

142 Siberian elm 23 2 Low Multiple attachments at 10’; poor form and structure; cavities with decay.

Remove tree

143 Siberian elm 29 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 10’; good form; pruning wounds; bacterial wet wood.

--

144 Siberian elm 19 3 Moderate Asymmetric form; crown reduced. --145 Siberian elm 28 4 Moderate Codominant trunks at 8’; crown reduced; pruning

wounds; bacterial wet wood; in 6x6 cut-out & displacing concrete 3”.

Root prune

146 Siberian elm 23 3 Moderate Codominant trunks at 7’; one sided N.; in 5x5 cut-out & displacing concrete 2”.

Root prune

Page 11




147 Sweetgum 11 3 Moderate Upright; fair form and structure; in 4x4 cut-out & displacing concrete 3”.

Root prune

148 Sweetgum 15 4 Moderate Upright; good form and structure; in 4x4 cut-out & displacing concrete 8”.

Root prune

149 Evergreen pear 12 3 Moderate Codominant trunks at 10’; fair form and structure; in 4x4 cut-out.

--

150 Sweetgum 12 3 Moderate One sided SW.; lost large limb NE.; in 4x4 cut-out & displacing concrete 5”.

Root prune

151 Sweetgum 10 3 Moderate Suppressed; one sided S.; in 4x4 cut-out & displacing concrete 2”.

Root prune

152 Evergreen ash 42 4 High Multiple attachments at 15’; good form and structure; displacing concrete 3”.

Root prune

153 Sweetgum 18 2 Low Suppressed; lost top; basal wound & trunk wound at 12’.

Remove tree

154 Monterey pine 28 2 Low Poor form and structure; declining. Remove tree155 Brachychiton 20 3 Moderate Fair form and structure; history of branch failure; no

basal flare. --

156 Ca. fan palm 34 3 Moderate Several cavities; slight jog just below pineapple; extensive trunk/spoke wounds.

Aerial inspection

157 Strawberry tree 10,10,10,9 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at base; good form; trunk wounds.

Monitor

158 Zelkova 20 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 8’; one sided W.; good form; trunk & branch wounds.

--

159 Chinese elm 14,14,11,10 4 High Multiple attachments at 8’; good form and structure; cavity E. at old pruning wound.

--

Page 12




160 Zelkova 30 4 High Good form and structure; heavy lateral E.; branch tear-out E.


161 Zelkova 19 3 Moderate Crowded; narrow form; 5” dead branch N. Crown clean162 Zelkova 24 4 Moderate One sided N.; heavy lateral N.; pruning wounds. Prune to reduce laterals163 Black locust 21 2 Low Multiple attachments at 10’; slight lean SW.; basal

wound & decay NE.; included bark. Remove tree

164 Paper birch 8 3 Moderate Codominant trunks at 7’; small crown; small pruning wound.

--

165 London plane 27 4 High Multiple attachments at 18’; good form and structure. --166 Silver maple 26 3 Low Multiple attachments at 15’; large pruning wound

NE.; canopy reduced. --

167 Black locust 21 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 10’; upright form; basal wound & decay N.; included bark.

--

168 Chinese pistache 12 4 High Multiple attachments at 8’; wide attachments; good form.

--

169 Zelkova 20 4 Moderate Asymmetric form; small laterals. --170 Chinese pistache 13 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 8’; one sided S.; heavy

laterals. --

171 Zelkova 22 2 Low Leaning and one sided W.; topped; poor form and structure.

--

172 Zelkova 24 4 High Multiple attachments at 10’; narrow attachments; upright form.

--

173 Zelkova 20 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 8’; asymmetric form; laterals W.

--

174 Zelkova 18 4 Moderate Codominant trunks at 8’; asymmetric form; laterals E.

--

Page 13




175 Zelkova 21 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 10’; narrow attachments; asymmetric form; laterals.


176 Mulberry 18 3 Moderate Codominant trunks at 8’; one sided N.; displaying as Pahala drive 6”.

Root prune

177 Mulberry 20 3 Moderate Codominant trunks at 10’; large trunk wound in attachment.

--

178 Compact blue gum 77,30 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 4’ to 10’; one sided E.; dieback; displacing asphalt drive 3”.

Root prune

179 Compact blue gum 33,13 2 Low Codominant trunks at 1’ & 4’; sulfur fungus in lower attachment; 13” stem hollow and leaning N. over drive.

Remove stem

180 Compact blue gum 53,14 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 5’; upright form; dieback. --181 Compact blue gum 40,13,12 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 5’; narrow form; dieback in

smaller stems. Remove stem

182 Compact blue gum 30,11 2 Low Codominant trunks at 2’; cavity w/ decay; small stem dead.

Remove tree

183 Compact blue gum 24,19,15,10 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 5’; narrow form; moderate dieback.

Crown clean

184 Compact blue gum 40,17,15 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 3’ to 5’; narrow form; lateral N.; dieback.


185 Compact blue gum 31,30,29,15 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 4’; upright form; dieback. --186 Compact blue gum 52,26,25,12 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 4’ to 10’; upright form;

dieback. --

187 Compact blue gum 69 2 Low Multiple attachments at 6’ to 10’; upright form; extensive dieback.

Monitor

Page 14




188 Compact blue gum 84,22 1 Low Multiple attachments at 10’; sulfur fungus in attachment; upright form; extensive dieback.

Remove tree

189 Black locust 27 2 Low Codominant trunks at 8’ & 10’; strong lean SE; several wounds; dieback.

Monitor

190 Jacaranda 12 4 Moderate Codominant trunks at 7’; lean S. --191 Jacaranda 8 2 Low Small crown; trunk wound from 3’ to 10’. --192 Italian stone pine 16 4 High Slight lean SW.; good form and structure. --193 Canary island pine 15 3 Low Codominant trunks at 20’; upright; moderate

dieback. Remove tree

194 Italian stone pine 27 2 Low Strong lean W. over bench; poor form and structure; lifting out of ground.

Remove tree

195 Italian stone pine 22 2 Low Strong lean W. over bench; poor form and structure; starting to lift out of ground.

Remove tree

196 Italian stone pine 15 2 Low Strong lean W. over bench; poor form and structure; dieback.

Remove tree

197 Italian stone pine 26 2 Low Strong lean W.; poor form and structure; starting to lift out of ground.

Remove tree

198 Silver dollar gum 35 3 Moderate Canopy bowed and one sided W.; fair structure; recently pruned.

--

199 Silver dollar gum 22 4 Moderate Upright form; high crown. --200 Silver dollar gum 26 3 Moderate One sided S.; large stem removed S.; recently

pruned. --

201 Jacaranda 12 4 Moderate Codominant trunks at 7’; leaning & one sided S. --202 Sweetgum 13 3 Moderate Upright form; pruning wounds; small cavity at 10’ E. --203 Jacaranda 9 4 Moderate Codominant trunks at 7’; leans SE. --204 Italian stone pine 18 3 Moderate Codominant trunks at 6’; slight lean S. --

Page 15




205 Aleppo pine 23 2 Low Strong lean S.; crook at 6’; extensive dieback. Remove tree206 Aleppo pine 32 3 Moderate Codominant trunks at 10’; sweeps from base but

upright; dieback. Monitor

207 Jacaranda 6 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 6’; slight lean S.; small crown.

--

208 Aleppo pine 25 2 Low Strong lean S. over benches; moderate dieback. Remove tree209 Jacaranda 6 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 6’; slight lean W.; small

crown. --

210 Jacaranda 6 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 6’; upright form; small crown. --

211 Canary island pine 12 3 Moderate Slight lean & one sided S.; trunk wounds. --212 Italian stone pine 20 3 Moderate Codominant trunks at 6’; leans S.; fair form and

structure. --

213 Aleppo pine 29 2 Low Crown bowed & one sided W. over benches; poor form and structure; dieback.

Remove tree

214 Privet 12,9,8,8,7 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at base; one sided N. --215 Privet 22,17 2 Low Codominant trunks at 2’; extensive dieback in upper

crown. Remove tree

216 Jacaranda 7 2 Low Suppressed; one sided NW. --217 Italian stone pine 22,21 4 Moderate Codominant trunks at 4’; one sided NW. --218 Italian stone pine 22,13 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 5’; suppressed; one sided S. --

219 Italian stone pine 22 2 Low Suppressed; strong lean S.; starting to lift out of ground.

Remove tree

220 Italian stone pine 21 3 Moderate Slight lean & one sided S.; long lateral S. Prune to reduce laterals221 Italian stone pine 17,12 3 Moderate Codominant trunks at 3’; fair form and structure. --

Page 16




222 Italian stone pine 13 4 Moderate Upright form; lower branches dead. Crown clean223 Italian stone pine 30 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 6’; one sided E.; long laterals

E. Prune to reduce laterals

224 Italian stone pine 20 3 Moderate Codominant trunks at 5’; sparse crown; lower branches dead.

Crown clean

225 Aleppo pine 40 3 Moderate Codominant trunks at 6’; one stem upright, other stem one sided NW.; heavy laterals.


226 Italian stone pine 26 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 6’; suppressed & one sided SW.; lateral W.; lower branches dead.


227 Italian stone pine 21 2 Low Strong lean S.; poor form and structure. Remove tree228 Italian stone pine 28,25 4 Moderate Codominant trunks at 4’; crowded & one sided W.;

dead branches to 5”Crown clean

229 Canary island pine 11 3 Moderate Crowded; upright with slight sweeps in trunk. --230 Italian stone pine 20 2 Low Lean W. to horizontal; poor form and structure. Remove tree231 Italian stone pine 27 2 Low Strong lean W.; sparse crown; poor form and

structure. Remove tree

232 Compact blue gum 67 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 10’; upright form; dieback. --

233 Compact blue gum 41 3 Low Multiple attachments at 4’; suppressed & one sided S.; moderate dieback.

Remove tree

234 Chinese pistache 15 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 10’; suppressed & one sided W.; trunk wounds.

--

235 Italian stone pine 46 4 High Multiple attachments at 5’; good form, fair structure Cable/brace236 Chinese pistache 8 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 6’; slightly one sided W. --237 Chinese pistache 10 4 Moderate Codominant trunks at 6’; branch failures N.; fair form

and structure. --

Page 17




238 Chinese pistache 9 4 Moderate Codominant trunks at 4’; lateral W.; fair form and structure.

--

239 Chinese pistache 12 4 High Codominant trunks at 6’; good form and structure. --

240 Black locust 21 3 Moderate Codominant trunks at 8’; upright form; in medium parking lot island; displaced curb 2”.

Root prune

241 Red maple 7 3 Moderate Codominant trunks at 7’; very narrow attachment; upright form.

--

242 Chinese lantern 14 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 7’; slight lean E.; good form. --243 Chinese pistache 18 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 7’; one stem forms lateral W. Remove stem244 Black locust 18 4 Moderate Multiple attachments at 10’; upright form. --245 Chinese elm 23 3 Moderate Codominant trunks at 8’; one stem topped; fair form

and structure. --

246 Black locust 15 2 Low Multiple attachments at 10’; upright form; half dead. Remove tree247 African fern pine 6 3 Moderate Suppressed; slight lean & one sided W. --248 Portuguese laurel 15 2 Low Codominant trunks at 6’; large trunk wound w/ fungal

growth. Remove tree

249 Carrob 28 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 6’; asymmetric form; in medium parking lot island; displaced curb 5”.

Root prune

250 Black locust 18 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 10’; upright form; no basal flare; in medium parking lot island; displaced asphalt 2”.

Root prune

251 Black locust 20 3 Moderate Multiple attachments at 10’; upright form; no cavity W.; in medium parking lot island; displaced asphalt 2”.

Root prune

Page 18




252 Carrob 32 4 High Multiple attachments at 8’; spreading form; in medium parking lot island; displaced curb 8”.

Root prune

253 Carrob 9 2 Low Small crown; trunk wounds; in medium parking lot island.

--

254 Mulberry 21 3 Low Multiple attachments at 6’; topped form overhead utilities; displaced asphalt 2”.


255 Mulberry 17 3 Low Topped form overhead utilities; displaced asphalt 2”. Prune to reduce laterals

256 Mulberry 19 2 Low Multiple attachments at 7’; topped form overhead utilities; displaced asphalt 3”.


257 Mulberry 25 2 Low Multiple attachments at 7’; W. stem cracked at attachment; topped form overhead utilities; displaced asphalt 6”.

Remove tree

258 Camphor 9,7,7,6,5 2 Low McConaghy Estate tree; multiple attachments at base; one sided S.

--

259 Camphor 22 3 Low McConaghy Estate tree; multiple attachments at 6’; narrow form; laterals S.

--

260 Camphor 14 2 Low McConaghy Estate tree; codominant trunks at 6’; narrow form; dead branches to 2”.

--

261 Camphor 17 2 Low McConaghy Estate tree; codominant trunks at 6’; narrow form; S. stem dying back.

--

262 Camphor 24 3 Moderate McConaghy Estate tree; multiple attachments at 6’; narrow form; laterals S.

--

263 Camphor 15 2 Low McConaghy Estate tree; stems removed at 6’; one stem remains.

--

Page 19




264 Yew 26 3 Moderate McConaghy Estate tree; multiple attachments at 10’; good form; moderate dieback.

--

265 Italian stone pine 31,26,18,11 4 Moderate McConaghy Estate tree; multiple attachments at 5’; one sided W.; displacing sidewalk 8”.

Root prune

266 Sweetgum 9 4 High Good young tree; slight crooks. --267 Sweetgum 11 4 High Multiple attachments at 10’; included bark; good

form. --

268 Sweetgum 23 4 High Good form; small hanger NW. over sidewalk; girdling roots; displacing sidewalk 3”.

Root prune

269 Sweetgum 15 4 Moderate Good form; a little one sided W. --270 Sweetgum 17 4 Moderate Codominant trunks at 15’; included bark; displacing

sidewalk 3”. Root prune

271 Sweetgum 12 4 High Good young tree; slight crooks. --272 Sweetgum 6 5 High Good young tree; slight crooks. --273 Sweetgum 22 4 Moderate Good form; slightly one sided N. --274 Sweetgum 22 4 Moderate Codominant trunks at 20’; included bark; upright

form. --

275 Coast redwood 22 5 High Good, upright form. --276 Coast redwood 22 5 High Good, upright form. --277 Coast redwood 22 5 High Good, upright form. --278 Coast redwood 23 5 High Good, upright form. --279 Coast redwood 22 5 High Good, upright form. --280 Coast redwood 18 4 High Good, upright form; a little sparse. --281 Coast redwood 19 4 High Good, upright form; a little sparse. --282 Coast redwood 17 4 Moderate Good, upright form; a little sparse; lost top. --283 Coast redwood 19 4 High Good, upright form; a little sparse. --

Page 20




284 Coast redwood 22 5 High Good, upright form. --285 Coast redwood 24 5 High Good, upright form. --286 London plane 17 4 High Off-site; multiple attachments at 8’; laterals W. --287 London plane 15 4 Moderate Off-site; codominant trunks at 7’; narrow form. --288 London plane 17 4 Moderate Off-site; codominant trunks at 5’; slight lean SE.;

laterals NW. --

289 London plane 17 4 High Off-site; codominant trunks at 9’; good form. --290 London plane 20 4 High Off-site; codominant trunks at 5’; good form; high

lateral E. --

291 London plane 16 4 Moderate Off-site; multiple attachments at 10’; slight lean W. --292 London plane 21 4 High Off-site; multiple attachments at 8’; good form. --293 London plane 6 3 Low Off-site; crook at 7’; leans NW.; poor form. --294 London plane 9 3 Moderate Off-site; crook at 5’; fair form and structure. --295 London plane 15 4 Moderate Off-site; multiple attachments at 6’; one sided S. --296 Black locust 26,22 4 Moderate Off-site; codominant trunks at base; good form;

pillowing over concrete walk; dieback. --

Page 21

Documents

Arborist Report - iCityWork · 2019-01-11 · Arborist Report HortScience, Inc. Kennedy Park, Hayward - October 2018 Page 5 The remaining 109 trees were represented by the following: