22
Applying Lachmann’s Rules to I Corinthians 14: 34 35 Can women speak in church? “Bible – Origin & Transmission” #12 RadicalGrace.com

Applying Lachmann’s Rules · oòôè oí ÜYYE10t tõv oòpavõv aoòöè ó Uíóçx, Et ó Ita- VI tñp T góvoç. 37 ryàp (lí lhuépat too Nõe, oótoç T 261 TtapouŒía t)íoö

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Applying Lachmann’s Rules · oòôè oí ÜYYE10t tõv oòpavõv aoòöè ó Uíóçx, Et ó Ita- VI tñp T góvoç. 37 ryàp (lí lhuépat too Nõe, oótoç T 261 TtapouŒía t)íoö

Applying Lachmann’s Rules

to

I Corinthians 14: 34 – 35

Can women speak in church?

“Bible – Origin & Transmission” #12 RadicalGrace.com

Page 2: Applying Lachmann’s Rules · oòôè oí ÜYYE10t tõv oòpavõv aoòöè ó Uíóçx, Et ó Ita- VI tñp T góvoç. 37 ryàp (lí lhuépat too Nõe, oótoç T 261 TtapouŒía t)íoö

Nestle-Aland Critical Text United Bible Societies Critical Text

Page 3: Applying Lachmann’s Rules · oòôè oí ÜYYE10t tõv oòpavõv aoòöè ó Uíóçx, Et ó Ita- VI tñp T góvoç. 37 ryàp (lí lhuépat too Nõe, oótoç T 261 TtapouŒía t)íoö

Nestle-Aland United Bible Societies Mt 24

Page 4: Applying Lachmann’s Rules · oòôè oí ÜYYE10t tõv oòpavõv aoòöè ó Uíóçx, Et ó Ita- VI tñp T góvoç. 37 ryàp (lí lhuépat too Nõe, oótoç T 261 TtapouŒía t)íoö

(Unidentified), Bruce Metzger, Kurt Aland, Allen Wikgren, Matthew Black

Munster, Germany -- Institute for NT Textual Research, c. 1960

Page 5: Applying Lachmann’s Rules · oòôè oí ÜYYE10t tõv oòpavõv aoòöè ó Uíóçx, Et ó Ita- VI tñp T góvoç. 37 ryàp (lí lhuépat too Nõe, oótoç T 261 TtapouŒía t)íoö

UBS Greek New Testament Committee: (L-R) Klaus Junack (Aland`s assistant), Matthew Black, Bruce

Metzger, Allen Wikgren, Kurt Aland, and Carlo Maria Martini – Institute for NT Textual Research, c. 1980

Page 6: Applying Lachmann’s Rules · oòôè oí ÜYYE10t tõv oòpavõv aoòöè ó Uíóçx, Et ó Ita- VI tñp T góvoç. 37 ryàp (lí lhuépat too Nõe, oótoç T 261 TtapouŒía t)íoö

Barbara Aland having received the

"Knight's Cross“

of the

Order of Merit

of the

Federal Republic

of Germany

July 2011

Page 7: Applying Lachmann’s Rules · oòôè oí ÜYYE10t tõv oòpavõv aoòöè ó Uíóçx, Et ó Ita- VI tñp T góvoç. 37 ryàp (lí lhuépat too Nõe, oótoç T 261 TtapouŒía t)íoö

Bruce M

Metzger:

A Textual

Commentary

on the

Greek New

Testament

2nd

Edition

Page 8: Applying Lachmann’s Rules · oòôè oí ÜYYE10t tõv oòpavõv aoòöè ó Uíóçx, Et ó Ita- VI tñp T góvoç. 37 ryàp (lí lhuépat too Nõe, oótoç T 261 TtapouŒía t)íoö

Genealogical weighing

Page 9: Applying Lachmann’s Rules · oòôè oí ÜYYE10t tõv oòpavõv aoòöè ó Uíóçx, Et ó Ita- VI tñp T góvoç. 37 ryàp (lí lhuépat too Nõe, oótoç T 261 TtapouŒía t)íoö

The shorter reading

Page 10: Applying Lachmann’s Rules · oòôè oí ÜYYE10t tõv oòpavõv aoòöè ó Uíóçx, Et ó Ita- VI tñp T góvoç. 37 ryàp (lí lhuépat too Nõe, oótoç T 261 TtapouŒía t)íoö

The more difficult

reading

Page 11: Applying Lachmann’s Rules · oòôè oí ÜYYE10t tõv oòpavõv aoòöè ó Uíóçx, Et ó Ita- VI tñp T góvoç. 37 ryàp (lí lhuépat too Nõe, oótoç T 261 TtapouŒía t)íoö

The reading which

explains all the readings

but which itself is

not explained by the others

Page 12: Applying Lachmann’s Rules · oòôè oí ÜYYE10t tõv oòpavõv aoòöè ó Uíóçx, Et ó Ita- VI tñp T góvoç. 37 ryàp (lí lhuépat too Nõe, oótoç T 261 TtapouŒía t)íoö

The older reading

Page 13: Applying Lachmann’s Rules · oòôè oí ÜYYE10t tõv oòpavõv aoòöè ó Uíóçx, Et ó Ita- VI tñp T góvoç. 37 ryàp (lí lhuépat too Nõe, oótoç T 261 TtapouŒía t)íoö

The reading

supported by

Church Fathers in other areas

Page 14: Applying Lachmann’s Rules · oòôè oí ÜYYE10t tõv oòpavõv aoòöè ó Uíóçx, Et ó Ita- VI tñp T góvoç. 37 ryàp (lí lhuépat too Nõe, oótoç T 261 TtapouŒía t)íoö

Nestle-Aland

End of First

Corinthians 14

Page 15: Applying Lachmann’s Rules · oòôè oí ÜYYE10t tõv oòpavõv aoòöè ó Uíóçx, Et ó Ita- VI tñp T góvoç. 37 ryàp (lí lhuépat too Nõe, oótoç T 261 TtapouŒía t)íoö

Nestle-Aland: End of I Corinthians 14 apparatus

Page 16: Applying Lachmann’s Rules · oòôè oí ÜYYE10t tõv oòpavõv aoòöè ó Uíóçx, Et ó Ita- VI tñp T góvoç. 37 ryàp (lí lhuépat too Nõe, oótoç T 261 TtapouŒía t)íoö

Vaticanus -

Distegmi

(Umlaut)

Page 17: Applying Lachmann’s Rules · oòôè oí ÜYYE10t tõv oòpavõv aoòöè ó Uíóçx, Et ó Ita- VI tñp T góvoç. 37 ryàp (lí lhuépat too Nõe, oótoç T 261 TtapouŒía t)íoö

I Corinthians 14

Distegmi (Umlaut)

Page 18: Applying Lachmann’s Rules · oòôè oí ÜYYE10t tõv oòpavõv aoòöè ó Uíóçx, Et ó Ita- VI tñp T góvoç. 37 ryàp (lí lhuépat too Nõe, oótoç T 261 TtapouŒía t)íoö

Codex

Fuldensis

Page 19: Applying Lachmann’s Rules · oòôè oí ÜYYE10t tõv oòpavõv aoòöè ó Uíóçx, Et ó Ita- VI tñp T góvoç. 37 ryàp (lí lhuépat too Nõe, oótoç T 261 TtapouŒía t)íoö

Capua,

Italy

Capua

Page 20: Applying Lachmann’s Rules · oòôè oí ÜYYE10t tõv oòpavõv aoòöè ó Uíóçx, Et ó Ita- VI tñp T góvoç. 37 ryàp (lí lhuépat too Nõe, oótoç T 261 TtapouŒía t)íoö

Opening of Colossians -- Sinaiticus correctors

Page 21: Applying Lachmann’s Rules · oòôè oí ÜYYE10t tõv oòpavõv aoòöè ó Uíóçx, Et ó Ita- VI tñp T góvoç. 37 ryàp (lí lhuépat too Nõe, oótoç T 261 TtapouŒía t)íoö

Nestle Aland: End of I Corinthians 14 apparatus

Page 22: Applying Lachmann’s Rules · oòôè oí ÜYYE10t tõv oòpavõv aoòöè ó Uíóçx, Et ó Ita- VI tñp T góvoç. 37 ryàp (lí lhuépat too Nõe, oótoç T 261 TtapouŒía t)íoö

God

is not confusion

but

peace

I Corinthians 14: 33