Appendix E Land Use Data, High-tempo FCLP Yearwhidbeyeis.com/Documents/Whidbey Island for posting/Whidbey Islan… · NAS Whidbey Island Complex Growler DEIS, Volume 2 November 2016

NAS Whidbey Island Complex Growler DEIS, Volume 2 November 2016

E-1

Appendix E

Appendix E Land Use Data, High-tempo FCLP Year

NAS Whidbey Island Complex Growler DEIS, Volume 2 November 2016

E-2

Appendix E

This page intentionally left blank.

Table E-1 Land Use Acreage (+/-)1 within the DNL Contours2 for NAS Whidbey Island Complex, Alternative 1 (High-tempo FCLP Year)

Land Use

No Action Alternative (NAA) (dB DNL)

Scenario A (dB DNL)

Scenario B (dB DNL)

Scenario C (dB DNL)

65-69 70-74 >75 Total 65-69 70-74 >75

Total (% change from NAA) 65-69 70-74 >75


Total (% change from NAA)

Ault Field Agriculture 323 305 427 1,055 553

(+230) 362 (+57)

427 (0)

1,342 (+27%)

587 (+264)

338 (+33)

492 (+65)

1,417 (+34%)

582 (+259)

339 (+34)

535 (+108)

1,456 (+38%)

Commercial 38 227 80 345 66 (+28)

199 (-28)

78 (-2)

343 (-1%)

46 (+8)

202 (-25)

107 (+27)

355 (+3%)

64 (+26)

165 (-62)

149 (+69)

378 (+10%)

Federal3 1 0 12 13 1 (0)

0 (0)

12 (0)

13 (0%)

1 (0)

0 (0)

12 (0)

13 (0%)

1 (0)

0 (0)

12 (0)

13 (0%)

Industrial 0 290 271 561 21 (+21)

338 (+48)

202 (-69)

561 (+0%)

1 (+1)

221 (-69)

340 (+69)

562 (0%)

0 (0)

149 (-141)

412 (+141)

561 (0%)

Open Space/Forest 610 284 186 1,080 463 (-147)

421 (+137)

261 (+75)

1,144 (+6%)

430 (-180)

453 (+169)

281 (+95)

1,164 (+8%)

417 (-193)

455 (+171)

316 (+130)

1,188 (+10%)

Parks 509 160 318 987 641 (+132)

228 (+68)

309 (-9)

1,178 (+19%)

711 (+202)

248 (+88)

341 (+23)

1,300 (+32%)

733 (+224)

311 (+151)

388 (+70)

1,432 (+45%)

Residential 1,528 1,166 2,808 5,502 1,841 (+313)

1,168 (+2)

2,860 (+52)

5,869 (+7%)

1,848 (+320)

1,068 (-98)

3,178 (+370)

6,094 (+11%)

1,903 (+375)

1,030 (-136)

3,440 (+632)

6,373 (+16%)

Rural4 426 416 1,395 2,237 438 (+12)

445 (+29)

1,432 (+37)

2,315 (+3%)

415 (-11)

440 (+24)

1,519 (+124)

2,374 (+6%)

395 (-31)

392 (-24)

1,656 (+261)

2,443 (+9%)

Transportation5 118 107 359 584 135 (+17)

93 (-14)

366 (+7)

594 (+2%)

131 (+13)

95 (-12)

389 (+30)

615 (+5%)

140 (+22)

92 (-15)

410 (+51)

642 (+10%)

Other6 11 0 0 11 36 (+25)

0 (0)

0 (0)

36 (+226%)

36 (+25)

0 (0)

0 (0)

36 (+227%)

50 (+39)

5 (+5)

0 (0)

55 (+400%)

Subtotal 3,564 2,955 5,856 12,375 4,195 (+631)

3,254 (+299)

5,947 (+91)

13,396 (+8%)

4,206 (+642)

3,065 (+110)

6,659 (+803)

13,930 (+13%)

4,285 (+721)

2,938 (-17)

7,318 (+1,462)

14,541 (+18%)

OLF Coupeville Agriculture 797 812 33 1,642 401

(-396) 433 (-379)

1,216 (+1,183)

2,050 (+25%)

323 (-474)

548 (-264)

920 (+887)

1,791 (+9%)

529 (-268)

927 (+115)

104 (+71)

1,560 (-5%)

Commercial 1 0 0 1 11 (+10)

1 (+1)

0 (0)

12 (+1,100%)

1 (0)

0 (0)

0 (0)

1 (0%)

0 (-1)

0 (0)

0 (0)

0 (-100%)

Federal3 0 2 8 10 0 (0)

0 (-2)

10 (+2)

10 (0%)

0 (0)

0 (-2)

10 (+2)

10 (0%)

0 (0)

0 (-2)

10 (+2)

10 (0%)

Industrial 0 11 16 27 0 (0)

0 (-11)

27 (+11)

27 (0%)

0 (0)

0 (-11)

27 (+11)

27 (0%)

0 (0)

0 (-11)

27 (+11)

27 (0%)

Open Space/Forest 410 273 134 817 297 (-113)

401 (+128)

573 (+439)

1,271 (+56%)

313 (-97)

433 (+160)

392 (+258)

1,138 (+39%)

437 (+27)

289 (+16)

149 (+15)

875 (+7%)

Parks 48 6 0 54 93 (+45)

10 (+4)

0 (0)

103 (+91%)

47 (-1)

2 (-4)

0 (0)

49 (-9%)

4 (-44)

0 (-6)

0 (0)

4 (-93%)

Residential 1,423 1,084 263 2,770 457 (-966)

1,181 (+97)

2,506 (+2,243)

4,144 (+50%)

509 (-914)

1,754 (+670)

1,676 (+1,413)

3,939 (+42%)

1,578 (+155)

1,393 (+309)

562 (+299)

3,533 (+28%)

Rural4 931 910 333 2,174 296 (-635)

668 (-242)

1,790 (+1,457)

2,754 (+27%)

332 (-599)

933 (+23)

1,340 (+1,007)

2,605 (+20%)

876 (-55)

894 (-16)

568 (+235)

2,338 (+8%)

Transportation5 137 86 54 277 81 (-56)

78 (-8)

243 (+189)

402 (+45%)

69 (-68)

111 (+25)

184 (+130)

364 (+31%)

97 (-40)

134 (+48)

73 (+19)

304 (+10%)

Other6 5 0 0 5 0 (-5)

0 (0)

5 (+5)

5 (0%)

0 (-5)

0 (0)

5 (+5)

5 (0%)

0 (-5)

5 (+5)

0 (0)

5 (0%)

E-3

This page left intentionally blank.

E-4


Land Use


Scenario A (dB DNL)

Scenario B (dB DNL)

Scenario C (dB DNL)

65-69 70-74 >75 Total 65-69 70-74 >75




Subtotal 3,752 3,184 841 7,777 1,636 (-2,116)

2,772 (-412)

6,370 (+5,529)

10,778 (+39%)

1,594 (-2,158)

3,781 (+597)

4,554 (+3,713)

9,929 (+28%)

3,521 (-231)

3,642 (+458)

1,493 (+652)

8,656 (+11%)

TOTAL7 7,316 6,139 6,697 20,152 5,831 (-1,485)

6,026 (-113)

12,317 (+5,620)

24,174 (+20%)

5,800 (-1,516)

6,846 (+707)

11,213 (+4,516)

23,859 (+18%)

7,806 (+490)

6,580 (+441)

8,811 (+2,114)

23,197 (+15%)

Notes: 1 The difference between the No Action Alternative and Alternative 1 is noted in parentheses. 2 Scenarios A, B, and C are outlined in Section 2.3.1, where the split represents the percent of FCLPs conducted at Ault Field and OLF Coupeville, respectively (i.e., 20/80 FCLP split = 20 percent of FCLPs Ault Field and 80 percent

of FCLPs at OLF Coupeville). 3 "Federal" land use includes federally zoned land. “Federal” does not include the installation boundary. 4 “Rural” includes a variety of living and working uses to provide for a rural lifestyle. In order to further delineate land categorized as “Rural,” parcel property use codes were examined. Parcel properties with use codes 11

(Household, single-family units), 111 (single section), 112 (double section), 113 (triple section), 114 (quad or greater), 12 (Household, 2-4 units), 13 (Household, multiunit 5 or more), 14 (residential condominiums), 15 (mobile home parks or courts), and 18 (all other residential not elsewhere coded) were re-categorized as “Residential” to more accurately assess impacts.

5 The “Transportation” land use category includes gaps in land use data that appeared to be roads; however this Transportation category does not cover all streets within the counties/municipalities. This layer was created in order to minimize data gaps within the land use data.

6 The category “Other” includes land with no zoning attributes assigned to it. Land use data do not include open water, offshore water, shoals, tidal wetlands, or uninhabited islands within San Juan County. 7 Acreages have been rounded to ensure totals sum.

Key: dB = decibel DNL = day-night average sound level

E-5


E-6


Land Use


Scenario A (dB DNL)

Scenario B (dB DNL)

Scenario C (dB DNL)

65-69 70-74 >75 Total 65-69 70-74 >75





(+216) 370 (+65)

418 (-9)

1,327 (+26%)

579 (+256)

337 (+32)

493 (+66)

1,409 (+34%)

585 (+262)

352 (+47)

521 (+94)

1,458 (+38%)

Commercial 38 227 80 345 75 (+37)

192 (-35)

75 (-5)

342 (-1%)

46 (+8)

201 (-26)

108 (+28)

355 (+3%)

60 (+22)

181 (-46)

131 (+51)

372 (+8%)

Federal3 1 0 12 13 1 (0)

0 (0)

12 (0)

13 (0%)

1 (0)

0 (0)

12 (0)

13 (0%)

1 (0)

0 (0)

12 (0)

13 (0%)

Industrial 0 290 271 561 30 (+30)

337 (+47)

195 (-76)

562 (0%)

0 (0)

220 (-70)

341 (+70)

561 (0%)

0 (0)

179 (-111)

383 (+112)

562 (0%)


409 (+125)

254 (+68)

1,139 (+5%)

432 (-178)

451 (+167)

279 (+93)

1,162 (+8%)

422 (-188)

454 (+170)

305 (+119)

1,181 (+9%)

Parks 509 160 318 987 612 (+103)

222 (+62)

300 (-18)

1,134 (+15%)

709 (+200)

248 (+88)

342 (+24)

1,299 (+32%)

729 (+220)

299 (+139)

375 (+57)

1,403 (+42%)

Residential 1,528 1,166 2,808 5,502 1,839 (+311)

1,186 (+20)

2,801 (-7)

5,826 (+6%)

1,848 (+320)

1,066 (-100)

3,181 (+373)

6,095 (+11%)

1,924 (+396)

1,031 (-135)

3,360 (+552)

6,315 (+15%)

Rural4 426 416 1,395 2,237 434 (+8)

453 (+37)

1,414 (+19)

2,301 (+3%)

416 (-10)

440 (+24)

1,519 (+124)

2,375 (+6%)

405 (-21)

409 (-7)

1,617 (+222)

2,431 (+9%)

Transportation5 118 107 359 584 136 (+18)

94 (-13)

361 (+2)

591 (+1%)

131 (+13)

95 (-12)

389 (+30)

615 (+5%)

136 (+18)

91 (-16)

406 (+47)

633 (+8%)

Other6 11 0 0 11 28 (+17)

0 (0)

0 (0)

28 (+155%)

34 (+23)

0 (0)

0 (0)

34 (+209%)

47 (+36)

4 (+4)

0 (0)

51 (+364%)

Subtotal 3,564 2,955 5,856 12,375 4,170 (+606)

3,263 (+308)

5,830 (-26)

13,263 (+7%)

4,196 (+632)

3,058 (+103)

6,664 (+808)

13,918 (+12%)

4,309 (+745)

3,000 (+45)

7,110 (+1,254)

14,419 (+17%)


(-462) 454 (-358)

1,159 (+1,126)

1,948 (+19%)

344 (-453)

554 (-258)

860 (+827)

1,758 (+7%)

518 (-279)

905 (+93)

153 (+120)

1,576 (-4%)

Commercial 1 0 0 1 4 (+3)

0 (0)

0 (0)

4 (+300%)

1 (0)

0 (0)

0 (0)

1 (0%)

0 (-1)

0 (0)

0 (0)

0 (-100%)

Federal3 0 2 8 10 0 (0)

0 (-2)

10 (+2)

10 (0)

0 (0)

0 (-2)

10 (+2)

10 (0)

0 (0)

0 (-2)

10 (+2)

10 (0)

Industrial 0 11 16 27 0 (0)

0 (-11)

27 (+11)

27 (0%)

0 (0)

0 (-11)

27 (+11)

27 (0%)

0 (0)

0 (-11)

27 (+11)

27 (0%)


422 (+149)

515 (+381)

1,244 (+52%)

330 (-80)

410 (+137)

368 (+234)

1,108 (+36%)

436 (+26)

297 (+24)

156 (+22)

889 (+9%)

Parks 48 6 0 54 82 (+34)

7 (+1)

0 (0)

89 (+65%)

40 (-8)

1 (-5)

0 (0)

41 (-24%)

5 (-43)

0 (-6)

0 (0)

5 (-91%)

Residential 1,423 1,084 263 2,770 453 (-970)

1,321 (+237)

2,315 (+2,052)

4,089 (+48%)

595 (-828)

1,805 (+721)

1,506 (+1,243)

3,906 (+41%)

1,523 (+100)

1,434 (+350)

599 (+336)

3,556 (+28%)

Rural4 931 910 333 2,174 313 (-618)

757 (-153)

1,661 (+1,328)

2,731 (+26%)

359 (-572)

937 (+27)

1,285 (+952)

2,581 (+19%)

857 (-74)

883 (-27)

615 (+282)

2,355 (+8%)

Transportation5 137 86 54 277 81 (-56)

81 (-5)

231 (+177)

393 (+42%)

69 (-68)

116 (+30)

174 (+120)

359 (+30%)

92 (-45)

136 (+50)

77 (+23)

305 (+10%)

Other6 5 0 0 5 0 (-5)

0 (0)

5 (+5)

5 (0%)

0 (-5)

0 (0)

5 (+5)

5 (0%)

0 (-5)

5 (+5)

0 (0)

5 (0%)

E-7


E-8


Land Use


Scenario A (dB DNL)

Scenario B (dB DNL)

Scenario C (dB DNL)

65-69 70-74 >75 Total 65-69 70-74 >75




Subtotal 3,752 3,184 841 7,777 1,575 (-2,177)

3,042 (-142)

5,923 (+5,082)

10,540 (+36%)

1,738 (-2,014)

3,823 (+639)

4,235 (+3,394)

9,796 (+26%)

3,431 (-321)

3,660 (+476)

1,637 (+796)

8,728 (+12%)

TOTAL7 7,316 6,139 6,697 20,152 5,745 (-1,571)

6,305 (+166)

11,753 (+5,056)

23,803 (+18%)

5,934 (-1,382)

6,881 (+742)

10,899 (+4,202)

23,714 (+18%)

7,740 (+424)

6,660 (+521)

8,747 (+2,050)

23,147 (+15%)

Notes: 1 The difference between the No Action Alternative and Alternative 1 is noted in parentheses. 2 Scenarios A, B, and C are outlined in Section 2.3.1, where the split represents the percent of FCLPs conducted at Ault Field and OLF Coupeville, respectively (i.e., 20/80 FCLP split = 20 percent of FCLPs Ault Field and 80 percent

of FCLPs at OLF Coupeville). 3 "Federal" land use includes federally zoned land. “Federal” does not include the installation boundary. 4 “Rural” includes a variety of living and working uses to provide for a rural lifestyle. In order to further delineate land categorized as “Rural,” parcel property use codes were examined. Parcel properties with use codes 11





E-9


E-10


Land Use


Scenario A (dB DNL)

Scenario B (dB DNL)

Scenario C (dB DNL)

65-69 70-74 >75 Total 65-69 70-74 >75





(+246) 369 (+64)

422 (-5)

1,360 (+29%)

604 (+281)

339 (+34)

488 (+61)

1,431 (+36%)

556 (+233)

352 (+47)

519 (+92)

1,427 (+35%)

Commercial 38 227 80 345 70 (+32)

195 (-32)

77 (-3)

342 (-<1%)

46 (+8)

203 (-24)

106 (+26)

355 (+3%)

59 (+21)

183 (-44)

128 (+48)

370 (+7%)

Federal3 1 0 12 13 1 (0)

0 (0)

12 (0)

13 (0%)

1 (0)

0 (0)

12 (0)

13 (0%)

1 (0)

0 (0)

12 (0)

13 (0%)

Industrial 0 290 271 561 24 (+24)

339 (+49)

199 (-72)

562 (+<1%)

0 (0)

229 (-61)

332 (+61)

561 (0%)

0 (0)

184 (-106)

377 (+106)

561 (0%)


427 (+143)

261 (+75)

1,146 (+6%)

428 (-182)

456 (+172)

281 (+95)

1,165 (+8%)

430 (-180)

444 (+160)

301 (+115)

1,175 (+9%)

Parks 509 160 318 987 641 (+132)

229 (+69)

305 (-13)

1,175 (+19%)

715 (+206)

247 (+87)

339 (+21)

1,301 (+32%)

724 (+215)

294 (+134)

372 (+54)

1,390 (+41%)

Residential 1,528 1,166 2,808 5,502 1,851 (+323)

1,181 (+15)

2,832 (+24)

5,864 (+7%)

1,859 (+331)

1,074 (-92)

3,159 (+351)

6,092 (+11%)

1,897 (+369)

1,030 (-136)

3,344 (+536)

6,271 (+14%)

Rural4 426 416 1,395 2,237 434 (+8)

450 (+34)

1,427 (+32)

2,311 (+3%)

415 (-11)

445 (+29)

1,515 (+120)

2,375 (+6%)

407 (-19)

407 (-9)

1,607 (+212)

2,421 (+8%)

Transportation5 118 107 359 584 136 (+18)

93 (-14)

364 (+5)

593 (+2%)

131 (+13)

95 (-12)

388 (+29)

614 (+5%)

135 (+17)

91 (-16)

404 (+45)

630 (+8%)

Other6 11 0 0 11 37 (+26)

0 (0)

0 (0)

37 (+236%)

37 (+26)

0 (0)

0 (0)

37 (+236%)

45 (+34)

3 (+3)

0 (0)

48 (+336%)

Subtotal 3,564 2,955 5,856 12,375 4,221 (+657)

3,283 (+328)

5,899 (+43)

13,403 (+8%)

4,236 (+672)

3,088 (+133)

6,620 (+764)

13,944 (+13%)

4,254 (+690)

2,988 (+33)

7,064 (+1,208)

14,306 (+16%)


(-409) 439 (-373)

1,202 (+1,169)

2,029 (+24%)

320 (-477)

549 (-263)

929 (+896)

1,798 (+10%)

520 (-277)

916 (+104)

136 (+103)

1,572 (-4%)

Commercial 1 0 0 1 9 (+8)

1 (+1)

0 (0)

10 (+900%)

1 (0)

0 (0)

0 (0)

1 (0%)

0 (-1)

0 (0)

0 (0)

0 (-100%)

Federal3 0 2 8 10 0 (0)

0 (-2)

10 (+2)

10 (0%)

0 (0)

0 (-2)

10 (+2)

10 (0%)

0 (0)

0 (-2)

10 (+2)

10 (0%)

Industrial 0 11 16 27 0 (0)

0 (-11)

27 (+11)

27 (0%)

0 (0)

0 (-11)

27 (+11)

27 (0%)

0 (0)

0 (-11)

27 (+11)

27 (0%)


408 (+135)

557 (+423)

1,266 (+55%)

316 (-94)

432 (+159)

396 (+262)

1,144 (+40%)

436 (+26)

295 (+22)

154 (+20)

885 (+8%)

Parks 48 6 0 54 90 (+42)

9 (+3)

0 (0)

99 (+83%)

48 (0)

2 (-4)

0 (0)

50 (-7%)

5 (-43)

0 (-6)

0 (0)

5 (-91%)

Residential 1,423 1,084 263 2,770 454 (-969)

1,219 (+135)

2,455 (+2,192)

4,128 (+49%)

500 (-923)

1,743 (+659)

1,701 (+1,438)

3,944 (+42%)

1,536 (+113)

1,426 (+342)

591 (+328)

3,553 (+28%)

Rural4 931 910 333 2,174 302 (-629)

692 (-218)

1,755 (+1,422)

2,749 (+26%)

328 (-603)

932 (+22)

1,349 (+1,016)

2,609 (+20%)

862 (-69)

887 (-23)

603 (+270)

2,352 (+8%)

Transportation5 137 86 54 277 81 (-56)

79 (-7)

239 (+185)

399 (+44%)

69 (-68)

110 (+24)

186 (+132)

365 (+32%)

93 (-44)

136 (+50)

76 (+22)

305 (+10%)

Other6 5 0 0 5 0 (-5)

0 (0)

5 (+5)

5 (0%)

0 (-5)

0 (0)

5 (+5)

5 (0%)

0 (-5)

5 (+5)

0 (0)

5 (0%)

E-11


E-12


Land Use


Scenario A (dB DNL)

Scenario B (dB DNL)

Scenario C (dB DNL)

65-69 70-74 >75 Total 65-69 70-74 >75




Subtotal 3,752 3,184 841 7,777 1,625 (-2,127)

2,847 (-337)

6,250 (+5,409)

10,722 (+38%)

1,582 (-2,170)

3,768 (+584)

4,603 (+3,762)

9,953 (+28%)

3,452 (-300)

3,665 (+481)

1,597 (+756)

8,714 (+12%)

TOTAL7 7,316 6,139 6,697 20,152 5,846 (-1,470)

6,130 (-9)

12,149 (+5,452)

24,125 (+20%)

5,818 (-1,498)

6,856 (+717)

11,223 (+4,526)

23,897 (+19%)

7,706 (+390)

6,653 (+514)

8,661 (+1,964)

23,020 (+14%)

Notes: 1 The difference between the No Action Alternative and Alternative 1 is noted in parentheses. 2 Scenarios A, B, and C are outlined in Section 2.3.1, where the split represents the percent of FCLPs conducted at Ault Field and OLF Coupeville, respectively (i.e., 20/80 FCLP split = 20 percent of FCLPs Ault Field and 80

percent of FCLPs at OLF Coupeville). 3 "Federal" land use includes federally zoned land. “Federal” does not include the installation boundary. 4 “Rural” includes a variety of living and working uses to provide for a rural lifestyle. In order to further delineate land categorized as “Rural,” parcel property use codes were examined. Parcel properties with use codes 11





E-13


E-14