74
“Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor of CEE University of Massachusetts

“Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

“Looking Back and Looking Ahead”

How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering

Alan LuteneggerP.E. PhD. F. ASCEProfessor of CEE

University of Massachusetts

Page 2: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

My Personal-Professional Journey

1975 BS. Construction Engineering

1977 M.S. Geotechnical Engineering

1979 PhD. Geotechnical Engineering

1980 PostDoc Iowa State

1982 NAS Bulgaria

1984-1989 Associate Prof. Clarkson College

1989 – Professor Univ. of Massachusetts

Coordinator – GT Program -10 Years

Department Head - 6 Years

Page 3: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 4: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 5: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 6: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

1. Understand the Fundamentals of Soil Mechanics & Soil Behavior

You Don’t Know What Path Your Career Will Take So Learn Basics

Composition

Shear Strength

Consolidation

Modification/Stabilization

Page 7: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 8: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 9: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 10: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 11: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

2. Understand How Composition May Influence Soil Behavior and

That Soils Are Inherently Complex

Page 12: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 13: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

Time (min.)

0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000

Sp

ecim

en H

eig

ht

(in

.)

0.750

0.760

0.770

0.780

0.790

0.800

0.810

0.820

0.830

0.840

0.850

Mt. Union, Ia. Paleosol

Page 14: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

Initial Dry Unit Weight (Mg/m3)

1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 1.9 2.0

Sw

ell

Pre

ssu

re (

kP

a)

0

200

400

600

800

Buckshot Clay

Heiden Clay

34/218 YSP

NLYSP

Page 15: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 16: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 17: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

Vertical Stress (ksf)

0.1 1 10

Se

cim

en H

eig

ht

(in

.)

0.600

0.620

0.640

0.660

0.680

0.700

0.720

0.740

0.760

S.E. Iowa LoessW = 12.7%

Dry Density = 87.2 lbs/ft3

Page 18: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 19: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 20: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 21: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 22: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 23: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

3. Don’t Be Afraid to Be an Expert Witness

Especially if You Think You Can Help Someone

Page 24: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 25: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 26: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 27: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 28: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 29: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 30: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 31: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

“The Day the House Fell Again?”

Page 32: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

4. Understand Surficial Geology

The Best Way to Understand Surficial Geology is to Go Look at it!

Page 33: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 34: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 35: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 36: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 37: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 38: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 39: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 40: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 41: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

5. Be a Life-Long Student and Take Advantage of Opportunities to Learn

Something New

You Won’t Learn Everything at University and You Simply Can’t Learn Everything

Anyway

Page 42: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 43: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 44: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 45: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 46: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 47: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

6. Understand and Appreciate the Classic GT Literature

A Lot of Really Good Fundamental Work Has Already Been Done – But Isn’t in

Textbooks

1960 – 3 GT Journals2017 – 27 GT Journals

Page 48: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

Often Simple is Best

Free Swell Test

Linear Shrinkage Test

Fall Cone Test

SPT-Torque Test

Page 49: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 50: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

Free Swell Test 1956

Page 51: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

Lime Content (%)

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16

Fre

e S

we

ll In

dex (

%)

0

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

1400

SWy-2

API-26

34 YSP

TS

Page 52: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

Linear Shrinkage Test 1958

Page 53: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

Fall Cone1915 & 1951

Page 54: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 55: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

Age (Hours)

0.1 1 10 100 1000 10000

Undra

ined S

hear

Str

ength

(kP

a)

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

20

Texas Sodium

RS-101

RS-102

Theile RC-32

Gooselake

SHCa-1

SAz-1

Age (Hours)

0.1 1 10 100 1000 10000

Th

ixo

tro

pic

Str

en

gth

Ra

tio

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

Texas Sodium

RS-101

RS-102

Theile RC-32

Gooselake

SCHa-1

SAz-1

Page 56: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

Water Content (%)

20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Und

rain

ed S

he

ar

Str

en

gth

(kP

a)

1

10

100

1000

10000

0% Lime

2% Lime

6% Lime

Page 57: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

SPT-Torque Test - 1988

Page 58: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

N60 (blows/0.3m)

0 10 20 30 40 50 60

f s (

kP

a)

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

fs = 4.1 N60

Std-1

Std-3 (donut)

Std-4 (Safety)

Std-2

Page 59: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

What’s Going on Now and What’s In the Near The Future?

Finishing Academic Work at UMass - 2018

Completing Several Projects

Helicals & Jacked Piles in Clay

Page 60: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

Adhesion of Drilled Piles in

Clay

Page 61: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

Changes in Clay Behavior from Bored

Piles

(Meyerhof & Murdock 1949)

Page 62: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

Grout Migration

Page 63: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

Distance from Grout/Soil Interface (in.)

0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 4.5 5.0 5.5 6.0

Wate

r C

onte

nt (%

)

22

23

24

25

26

27

BBC 0 psi

BBC 5 psi

Distance from Grout/Soil Interface (in.)

0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 4.5 5.0 5.5 6.0

Po

cke

t P

en

etr

om

ete

r (t

sf)

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

4.0

4.5

5.0

BBC 0 psi

BBC 5 psi

Page 64: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

Liquidity Index

-0.6 -0.4 -0.2 0.0 0.2 0.4

Cha

ng

e in

Wate

r C

on

ten

t at

So

il/G

rout

Inte

rfa

ce

(%

)

-4

-2

0

2

4

6

8

W/C = 0.6

Page 65: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

Tomlinson (1957)

Page 66: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

Parsons & Peck (1957)Chicago Clay S

t = 1.8

Water Content (%)

24 25 26 27 28

Undra

ined S

hear

Str

ength

(psf)

1000

Undisturbed

Remolded

104 Days

410 Days

Orrje & Broms (1967)Brunnsbo S

t = 30

Water Content (%)

70 72 74 76 78 80 82 84

Undra

ined S

hear

Str

ength

(ts

f)

0.001

0.01

0.1

1

Undisturbed

Remolded

9 Months

Page 67: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

Flatte - 1972

Page 68: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

Pipe Piles in Clay

HHF Extraction Piles Oct., 2016

Water Content (%)

15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55

De

pth

(ft

.)

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

BH1

2875C-1

2875C-2

BH-2

4.5 Open

6 Open

Page 69: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

H-Piles in ClayHHF Extracted Piles 2016

Water Content (%)

20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55

Depth

(ft.)

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

W8 At Pile Surface

W8 At Failure Surface

BH1

BH-2

Page 70: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

Soils and Geotechnology in Construction

June 2017

In Situ Testing Techniques in Geotechnical Engineering

December 2017

Design, Installation and Applications of Helical Piles and Anchors

June 2018

Page 71: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

Lessons I was Taught(but didn’t know it at the time)

1. Understand the Fundamentals of Soil Mechanics

2. Understand How Soil Composition May Influence Soil Behavior and That Soils are Inherently Complex

3. Understand Surficial Geology

4. Don’t Be Afraid to be an Expert Witness

5. Be a Life-Long Student & Take Advantage of Opportunities to Learn Something New

6. Understand & Appreciate the Literature

Page 72: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 73: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor
Page 74: “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” · “Looking Back and Looking Ahead” How Iowa State Shaped a Career in Geotechnical Engineering Alan Lutenegger P.E. PhD. F. ASCE Professor

Remember

It’s The Journey!