47
Annexure-I (Court order)

Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

Annexure-I

(Court order)

Page 2: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan
Page 3: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

(Penalty Receipts)

Page 4: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

Annexure-II

Page 5: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

Sr.

No.

Attributes /

Parameter

Issue

Related Damage

Remediation/

EMP Suggested

Probable

Concerns

1

Air Pollution

Particulate &

gaseous emissions of SPM, SO2,

NOx

Flue gas

emissions & process gaseous

emissions

Minimal impact

on surface water

body, flora, fauna as well as soil.

Free health check-up

Camp will be organized.

Measuring Ambient air

Quality on a regular

basis once the project is granted

Environmental

Clearance. This will enable knowing

Incremental pollution.

Insisting on allowing only covered vehicles

to transport goods and

materials

Ensuring only PUC

certified vehicles are

allowed to work at the Site.

We will have around

500 tress in our

premises.

2

Noise

&Vibration

Noise generation

due to various

equipment ,like DG set,

machinery (Pump

Compressors, vehicular

movement etc)

Temporary and

Minimal impact

on Health of Employees.

Personnel Protecting

Equipments (PPE) like

ear muff, ear plug, etc should be provided to

workers, barricading

around construction site and only PUC certified

vehicle should be used

once the project is

granted Environmental

Clearance

Health issue if any

will be addressed at

time to time.

3

Land

Land contamination

Minimal impact on

Soil.(Municipal

solid waste like

rubbish, paper, plastic, garbage

etc.)

Hazardous wastes

like used oil,

discarded containers, used

filter cloths etc.

Efficient solid waste

collection and storage

facility is provided.

All the hazardous waste

will be properly stored

& disposed off to CHWTSDF site or sold

to the authorized vendor

for reuse/recycling.

-

4

Occupational Health

Providing safety Equipments

(PPE), change

rooms including

- It is also suggested that the workers should be

checked for their health

once every six months.

-

Page 6: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

drinking Water facility, WCs as

well as bathrooms

for the workers.

5

Socio-

Economic

Increase in Job

opportunities

- - -

6

Flora & Fauna

Impact due to

manufacturing process.

Minimal impact

on Flora & Fauna.

Green belt is already

developed as per landscaping plan at site

and periphery of the

boundary.

-

7

Traffic Pattern

Increase of

vehicular

movements

Traffic

Congestion

Vehicular movement

will be regulated inside

the site with adequate roads and parking shall

be provided.

-

8 Water Water

contamination

Minimal impact on Flora & Fauna.

Soil as well as

Employee, and other machinery

equipments.

Domestic waste water

will be treated in ETP

followed by RO.

Wastewater will be

segregated into high and

low concentrated

stream.

Storm Water

Management has

already been provided to prevent runoff and water

logging.

Workers to be provided with R.O. /

UV treated water for

drinking before the work is re-started

after obtaining the

related

Environmental

Clearance

Page 7: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

Annexure-III

Page 8: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

Sr.

No.

Attributes

/

Parameter

Issue

Related

Damage

Remediation/

EMP Suggested

Estimated Cost

of Damage/

Remediation

Probable

Concerns

1

Air

Pollution

Particulate &

gaseous

emissions of

SPM, SO2, NOx

Flue gas

emissions &

process

gaseous emissions

Minimal

impact on Surface

water body,

flora, fauna

as well as soil.

Free health check-up

Camp will be organized.

Measuring Ambient

air Quality on a regular basis once

the project granted

Environmental Clearance. This will

enable knowing

Incremental pollution.

Insisting on allowing

Only covered vehicles to transport

goods and materials

Ensuring only PUC certified vehicles are

allowed to work at

the site.

Rs.1,00,000/-

towards One-time health check up.

And Rs

10,75000/-

Towards the

setting-up and operation of an

Additional

Ambient Air Quality control and

monitoring System.

Planting of tress

Rs.50,000 /-

We will have

around 500 tress in our

premises.

2

Noise &Vibration

Noise generation due

various

equipment ,DG set,

machinery

(Pump Compressors,

vehicular

movement etc)

Temporary and

minimal

impact on

Health of

Employees.

Personnel Protecting Equipments (PPE)

like ear muff, ear

plug, etc should be provided to workers,

barricading around

construction site and only PUC certified

vehicle should be

used once the project

is granted Environmental

Clearance

Rs. 1,50,000/-

towards (PPE).

Health issue if any will be

addressed at

time to time.

3

Land

Land

contamination

Minimal

impact on

Soil.

(Municipal solid waste

like rubbish,

paper, plastic,

garbage etc.)

Hazardous

wastes like

used oil,

discarded

Efficient solid waste

collection and

storage facility is proposed.

All the hazardous

waste will be properly stored &

disposed off to

CHWTSDF site or sold to the authorized

vendor for

Rs. 9,00,000/-

setting up and

maintaining of

state of art laboratory and

consumable and

recurring cost.

-

Page 9: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

containers, used filter

cloths etc.

reuse/recycling.

4

Occupational Health

Providing safety

equipments

(PPE), change rooms

including

drinking Water facility,

WCs as well as

bathrooms for

the workers.

- It is also suggested that the workers

should be checked

for their health once every six months.

Providing and maintaining

change

Rooms and Sanitation Facility

Suitable PPE And

Medical Health Check up At

Regular Interval

Approximately Rs

16,00000/-

-

5

Socio-

Economic

Increase in Job

opportunities

- - Socio-economic

development

through CER

activity will be made.

-

6

Flora &

Fauna

Impact due to

manufacturing

process.

Minimal

impact on Flora &

Fauna.

Green belt is already

developed as per

landscaping plan at

site and periphery of

the boundary.

Rs 70,000/- Tree

plantation and

awareness on drip

irrigation

methodology to surrounding

farmers.

-

7

Traffic

Pattern

Increase of

vehicular

movements

Traffic

Congestion

Vehicular movement

will be regulated

inside the site with adequate roads and

parking shall be

provided.

- -

8 Water Water

contamination

Minimal impact on

Flora &

Fauna. Soil as well as

Employee,

other

machinery equipments.

Domestic waste

water will be treated

in ETP followed by RO.

Wastewater will be

segregated into high

and low concentrated stream.

Storm Water

Management has already been

provided to prevent

runoff and water

logging.

Rs.75,00000/- we

will installed

striper coloum,RO unit, distillation

unit & waste water

recovery unit.

Workers to be provided with

R.O. /

UV treated water for

drinking

before the

work is re-started after

obtaining the

related Environmental

Clearance

Thus, the cost assessment related to environmental degradation and its remediation as stated above

would be: Rs 1,14,,45,000./-

Page 10: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

Annexure-IV

Page 11: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

CHAPTER – 12

ASSESSMENT OF ECOLOGICAL DAMAGE, REMEDIATION

PLAN AND NATURALANDCOMMUNITY RESOURCE

AUGMENTATION PLAN

As per the MoEFCC notification dated 14th March, 2017 an application was made to MoEFCC (EAC

Violation) by M/s.Vadivarhe Speciality Chemicals Ltd.at Gut No.204, Nashik-Mumbai, Highway,

A/P-Wadivarhe, Tal-Igatpuri, Dist-Nashik-422403,Maharashtra [FileNo.J-11011/123/2016-IA II (I))

and Proposal No:IA/MH/IND2/52374/2016, dated 30th March 2016].

The project was reconsidered in 14th meeting of Expert Appraisal Committee for the proposal

involving violation of the EIA Notification, 2006 (for reconsideration of Terms of References of

M/s.Vadivarhe Speciality Chemicals., Gut No.204, Nashik - Mumbai Highway, A/P-Wadivarhe, Tal-

Igatpuri, Dist-Nashik-422403, Maharashtra was held at MoEFCC, New Delhi on 22th-24th

October,2018. EAC (Violation) have prescribed ToRs (published under MoEFCC website Projects

under Violation, date of meeting 22nd to 24th October 2018) for the preparation of Environmental

Impact Assessment Report and Environmental Management Plan (Including Assessment of ecological

damage and the remediation plan and the natural and community resource augmentation plan to be

prepared as an independent chapter in the EIA.

In order to carry out the environmental/ ecological damage assessment and formulation of related

remediation plan and the natural and community resource augmentation plan with respect to

M/s.Vadivarhe Speciality Chemicals Ltd. has proposed for expansion of existing products as well as

addition of new products. The existing production capacity of the plant is 12.85 MT/M and proposed

production capacity will be 22.018 MT/M. Thus the total production capacity after expansion and

addition of new products will be 34.868 MT/M without obtaining prior Environmental Clearance

under the Environment Impact Assessment Notification, 2006 (as amended from time to time),

M/s.Wadivarhe Speciality Chemicals Ltd. has assigned the work of carrying out the above stated

study to a NABL Accredited and QCI / NABET Accredited organization i.e. M/s.Green Circle. Inc,

Vadodara.

The various issues/suggestions/ objections/ opinion raised by the participants and responded by the

representatives of the project proponent during the public hearing as well as budget/fund allocated to

address these issues/suggestions/ objections/ opinion are as under

1) M/s.Vadivarhe Speciality Chemicals Ltd. (VSCL) is an existing unit in production

Manufacturing and R & D in Intermediates and Bulk Drugs.VSCL is a Zero Liquid Discharge

(ZLD) unit. The air emissions are regularly monitored by 3rd Party accredited by NABL and results have been consistently within MPCB/CPCB approved limits.

12.1. Preamble

12.2. Public Hearing Points / Issues and Company’s Response

Page 12: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined

Emergency Preparedness plan as well as on regular basis mock drills is being carried out by VSCL to ensure emergency preparedness.

3) VSCL provides employment to locals in accordance with the law. At present, more than 95%

of locals are engaged in their workforce and VSCL give preference to local people based on

their education, skill, qualification and experience.

Table -12.1: Points / Issues raised during public hearing and company’s response

Sr. No. Issue

Vadivarhe Speciality Chemicals Ltd. (VSCL)

Action Plan Related To The Issue

Proposed Allocation

of Funds by VSCL

(Rs.)

1. Employment 1) The Company gives preference to locals for

employment. Almost 95% of the employees are

from Maharashtra and 80 % local surrounding.

The Company gives wages exceeding that

stipulated in minimum wages act, and includes

welfare benefits, uniform, subsidized food etc.

The Company endeavors to continue this

practice of fair treatment of all employees.

2) The proposed project envisages requirement

of additional manpower of about 30, which will

be preferentially recruited from surrounding

villages depending on requisite skills and

qualification.

3) Also, internship / assistance will be provided

to ITI /graduate/ undergraduate/students of local

villages for their skill development.

Rs.1,50,000/-

2. Woman

Empowerment

1) The company to organize small camps for

ladies to promote formulation of” Bachat Gut”

and skill development.

2) Beti-Bachav program will be organized,

3)Company will organized health camp for girls

Rs. 70,000/-

3. Environmental

issue due to

release of

pollutants

1) Our air emission is regularly monitored by

3rd Party accredited by NABL and results have

been consistently within MPCB/CPCB approved

limits.

2) MPCB collects samples of water and air the

results are consistently within limit.

3) VSCL have rain water harvesting scheme in

Rs.11,80,000./-

Page 13: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

Sr. No. Issue

Vadivarhe Speciality Chemicals Ltd. (VSCL)

Action Plan Related To The Issue

Proposed Allocation

of Funds by VSCL

(Rs.)

place precautions are been taken for no water on

ground goes out rather goes out without testing.

4) Company have planned up-to Tertiary

treatment plant from the point of view of waste

water disposal. VSCL have also conducted

adequacy and efficacy study of ETP.

5) The Company has a comprehensive On-site

Emergency Plan, which is reviewed and updated

annually. Mock drills are conducted at regular

intervals to ensure emergency preparedness.

Total Rs.14,00000 /-

As per the ToR the following studies were carried out with respect to the above existing production

capacity of the plant is 12.85 MT/M and proposed production capacity will be 22.018 MT/M. Thus

the total production capacity after expansion and addition of new products will be 34.868 MT/M.

activity carried out within the factory existing premises at M/s.Vadivarhe Speciality Chemicals.Gut

No.204, Nashik - Mumbai highway, A/P-Wadivarhe, Tal-Igatpuri, Dist-Nashik-422403, Maharashtra.

Ecological/environmental damage assessment

Remediation plan

The natural and community resource augmentation plan

12.3.1 Introduction

M/s.Vadivarhe Speciality Chemicals. Nashik awarded us the work of assessment of the impacts due to

the Production capacity after expansion and addition of new products will be 34.868 MT/M. We have

carried out the assessment during March-May 2016. The following pages describe the assessment

with respect to the same. The details have been enumerated in the following pages.

Project: M/s.Vadivarhe Speciality Chemicals.Gut No.204, Nashik - Mumbai highway, A/P-

Wadivarhe, Tal-Igatpuri, Dist-Nashik-422403, Maharashtra.

Violation Details:- Industry for its existing operation obtained CTE vide letter no.BO/RO-Nsk/PCI-I/946-07/E/CC-329 dated 05.04.2007 which was obtained after EIA Notification

,2006.hence,the industry for its existing operation did not obtain Environmental Clearance,

therefore, it is violation of provisions contained under Environmental (Protection) Act, 1986 by not following EIA Notification,2006.

12.3. Ecological / Environmental Damage Assessment

Page 14: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

12.3.2 Assessment of Environmental / Ecological Damage Due To the existing products as well

as addition of new products.

The collection and analysis of data with respect to air, water, land, noise and other environmental attributes was carried out by NABL accredited laboratory and details are

presented in Chapter-3.

Assessment of environmental / ecological damage with respect to air, water, noise,

soil/land, flora & fauna, occupation health and other environmental attributes due to the

existing products as well as addition of new products. are presented under:

Table -12.2: Assessment of Environmental / Ecological Damage and Remediation/ EMP suggested

Sr.

No

.

Attribute

s /

Paramete

r

Issue

Related

Damage

Remediation/

EMP Suggested

Estimated Cost

of Damage/

Remediation

Probable

Concerns

1

Air

Pollution

Particulate &

gaseous emissions of

SPM, SO2,

NOx

Flue gas

emissions & process

gaseous

emissions

Minimal

impact on

Surface water body,

flora, fauna

as well as soil.

Free health check-up

Camp will be

organized.

Measuring Ambient

air Quality on a regular basis once

the project granted

Environmental

Clearance. This will enable knowing

Incremental

pollution.

Insisting on allowing

Only covered

vehicles to transport goods and materials

Ensuring only PUC

certified vehicles are allowed to work at

the site.

Rs.1,00,000/-towards

One-time health

check up.

And Rs 10,75000/- Towards the setting-

up and operation of

an Additional

Ambient Air Quality control and

monitoring System.

Planting of tress

Rs.50,000 /-

We will have

around 500

tress in our premises.

2

Noise

&Vibration

Noise generation due

various

equipment

,DG set, machinery

(Pump

Compressors, vehicular

movement etc)

Temporary and

minimal

impact on

Health of

Employees.

Personnel Protecting Equipments (PPE)

like ear muff, ear

plug, etc should be

provided to workers, barricading around

construction site and

only PUC certified vehicle should be

used once the project

Rs. 1,50,000/-

towards (PPE).

Health issue if any will be

addressed at

time to time.

Page 15: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

is granted Environmental

Clearance

3

Land

Land contamination

Minimal impact on

Soil

.(Municipal solid waste

like rubbish,

paper,plastic,

garbage etc.)

Hazardous

wastes like used oil,

discarded

containers, used filter

cloths etc.

Efficient solid waste

collection and

storage facility is provided.

All the hazardous

waste will be properly stored &

disposed off to

CHWTSDF site or sold to the authorized

vendor for

reuse/recycling.

Rs. 9,00,000/-

4

Occupatio

nal Health

Providing

safety

equipments (PPE),

change rooms

including

drinking Water facility,

WCs as well

as bathrooms for the

workers.

- It is also suggested

that the workers

should be checked for their health once

every six months.

Providing and

maintaining change

Rooms and Sanitation Facility

Suitable PPE And

Medical Health

Check up At Regular Interval

Approximately Rs

16,00000/-

-

5

Socio-

Economic

Increase in Job

opportunities

- - Socio-economic

development through

CER activity will be

made.

-

6

Flora &

Fauna

Impact due to

manufacturing process.

Minimal

impact on

Flora &

Fauna.

Green belt is already

developed as per landscaping plan at

site and periphery of

the boundary.

Rs 70,000/- Tree

plantation and awareness on drip

irrigation

methodology to

surrounding farmers.

-

7

Traffic

Pattern

Increase of

vehicular movements

Traffic

Congestion

Vehicular movement

will be regulated inside the site with

adequate roads and

parking shall be

provided.

- -

8 Water Water

contamination

Minimal

impact on

Flora & Fauna. Soil

as well as

Employee,

Domestic waste

water will be treated in ETP followed by

RO.

Wastewater will be

Rs.75,00000/- we

will installed striper coloum,RO unit,

distillation unit &

waste water recovery

unit.

Workers to

be

provided with R.O. /

UV treated

water for

Page 16: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

other machinery

equipments.

segregated into high and low concentrated

stream.

Storm Water

Management has already been

provided to prevent

runoff and water logging.

drinking before the

work is re-

started after

obtaining the related

Environment

al

Clearance

Thus, the cost assessment related to environmental degradation and its remediation as stated above

would be: Rs 1,14,45,000./-

The details remediation / environment management plan with respect to various environmental

attributes are suggested / recommended under section 12.2.

The total fund Rs 1,14,45,000./-is allocated for remediation/environment management plan.

The augmentation plan will be multi fold in nature and will be in conjunction with the damage

Assessment as stated earlier.

Activities for the augmentation plan can be classified in major categories as under:

A. Natural Resource Augmentation Plan

B. Community Augmentation Plan will consist of

Infrastructure Development Work

Soft Skill Development Work

Various filed/activities under natural and community resource augmentation plan with allocated

Budgetary details are given below:

Table -12.3: The natural and community resource augmentation plan with allocated budgetary

Sr.

No.

Filed/ Activity Budgetary

Allocation (Rs)

A NATURAL RESOURCE AUGMENTATION PLAN

1 Water Conservation and Decantation 1,00,000/-

2 Nature Conservation Society 4,00,000/-

3 Cleanliness and Hygiene Program for Good Health under “Swach Bharat”Abhiyan in Schools

10,000/-

4 Tree Plantation 50,000/-

Sub-total (A) 5,60,000/-

B COMMUNITY AUGMENTATION PLAN

B-1 Infrastructure development work

1 Construction of Class Room 1,00,000/-

2 Repairs and Maintenance 25,000/-

3 Construction of separate toilet blocks for boys & girls in schools

25,000/-

4 Periodical arrangement of Health check-ups: specialized 1,00,000/-

12.4. Remediation / Environment Management Plan and Cost

12.5. Natural And Community Resource Augmentation Plan

Page 17: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

checkups can be planned for different medical specialty, like eyes, skin, dental etc and de-addiction camp

5 Procurement of Medicines & Healthcare Supplies for

Occupational Health Center

25,000/-

6 Organize awareness campaign for Swachh Bharat Abhiyan, Beti Bachao Beti Padhao and Women Empowerment.

20,000/-

7 Development/ promotion of drip irrigation methodology to

surrounding farmers

20,000/-

Sub-total (B1) 3,15,000

B-2 Soft Skill Development Work

1 Organize skill development program for sustainable income generation & livelihood for the community like training on

tailoring, embroidery, etc.

10,000/-

2 Imparting entrepreneurship development training to local

people

10,000/-

3 Internship to local graduate/undergraduate students 1,50,000/-

4 Provision of uniform, notebooks, study materials, computers for students and maintenance of school building.

1,00,000/-

5 Awareness program for reduction of plastic waste reduction

/ solid waste management

10,000/-

6 Upgrade school library 10,000/-

Sub-total (B2) 2,90,000/-

Total fund allocated towards natural and community resource

Augmentation plan. (Sub-total : A+B1+B2)

11,65,000/-

It may be noted that since no production has been carried out even though till date, no economic

benefit has occurred to the project proponent.

As there is no construction activity, there won’t be any significant damage to the environment

The summary of budgetary allocation with respect to violation activity and remediation/ EMP

measures suggested/recommended, natural and community resource augmentation plan as well as

public hearing aspects is stated under:

Table -12.4: Summary of budgetary allocation with respect to violation activity and remediation

Sr.

No.

Description Estimated Cost

(Rs.)

1 Estimated cost of damage / remediation with respect to

ecological aspects

1,14,45,000/- (Cr)

2 Natural and community resource augmentation plan 11,65,000/-

3 Budgetary allocation to address the various

issues/suggestions/ objections/opinion raised by the 14,00,000 /-

12.6. Economic Benefit Due To Violation Activity

12.7. Conclusion and Recommendation

Page 18: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

participants during the Public Hearing.

A Total (1+ 2+ 3) 1,40,10,000 /-

The proposed activities under the remediation/ EMP measures suggested/recommended, natural and

community resource augmentation plan as well as public hearing aspects will be implemented in a

phased manner.

It may be noted that the project proponent will also give a bank guarantee equivalent to the amount of

remediation plan, natural and community resource augmentation plan as well as public hearing

aspects i.e. Rs 1,40,10,000/- Cr to Maharashtra Pollution control board which could be returned on

completion of the above stated plan.

12.8. Implementation Schedule of Planned Activities And Related Bank Guarantee

Page 19: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

Annexure-V

Page 20: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

(Public Hearing Proceeding)

Sr

No.

Name of

person and

address

Point Represented Reply for the project proponent

1 Shri. Gajiram

Narayan Bhor

r/o Wadivarhe

He said that What will you

do for the women? What will

you do for the girls?

A. I have told the company to organize

small camps for ladies to promote

formulation of “ Bachat Gut “and

skill development. Although this is

not a point here but I would like to

state that the girls near Kalyan of your

age have undertaken work of

embroidery and I am happy and

pleased to mention that those girls at

this point of time from small small

villages have brought women together

and have done a business of Rs. 1.5

Crores in a year.

B. I think this subject does not belong to

us. Men are not able to hold a needle If

rest of the men felt insulted please

pardon me. I think art of embroidery to

women is perhaps by birth. Thus we

have suggested to start this type of

embroidery or such type of classes or

regular classes for women. I feel if we

introduce such type of activities for

women which would bring out their

capabilities, women of many villages

will not require anybody to uplift them.

They themselves will attain their up

liftment. The company is committed to

provide the things which are required

from that point of view.

C. With respect to views of the Hon’ble

Chairman of Wadivarhe Speciality

Chemicals Ltd, mentioned that as said

by the Honour, definitely Beti-Bachav

is one of our programmes. In fact now

girls in no field are lacking behind.

Girls are in the forefront in all the

fields. Second point is we have

suggested the company to organize

health camps from the view point of

health of girls. And third is skill

development. Thus we have proposed

Page 21: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

these three things.

2 Sarpanch of

Wadivhare

village Kumari

Priti tai

Shejwal.

He said that I am in the

capacity of Sarpanch wish to

request you that this company is situated. at the

distance of 10 KM from our

Wadivarhe village. The

human being is suffering a great deal from the chemicals

that are emitted from these

companies .Similarly, the animals also suffer. There are

small streams and Mukne

Dam which is also nearby. People also drink water from

them. I therefore only request

the company that we have

sent number of proposals to other companies that the

chemical water that is

flowing from their companies is consumed by

our animals and by some

people. I request all, and also

to your company. I do not recollect that any

complainant has been

received against your company. However, 1 to 2

days back, one such

complaint was received from one of the companies that no

crop survives in the fields of

our farmers due to their

chemicals. I request you that if you discharge any

chemical from your

company, please do some processing so that human

beings are not suffered.. You

have also given good projects to Wadivarhe village through

CSR for example it may be

regarding school education

or regarding development of the village. As you said you

have completed projects of

the cost of 27 lakhs

The office bearers of the company gave

assurance that it will be ensured that no

pollution problems will arise in the

vicinity due to company. Similarly, the

representatives of the company gave

assurance that positive response will be

offered on behalf of the company for

development and progress of the village.

3 Dy. Sarpanch of

Wadivarhe

village, Shri.

Ambadas Katore

He said that the chemical

companies so far have

added to lot of pollution.

As to date heaps of letters

have been dumped in our

gram panchyat concerning

Assurance was given on behalf of the

company representative to make efforts to see

that no nuisance from pollution of the

company will be created.

Page 22: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

subject of water pollution.

2 to 4 days before a

complaint was received

against a chemical

company. You are

therefore, required to take

utmost care. Only then the

things will work. Today

also yellow dark water was

observed in the well.

Please exercise control

otherwise all the people

will be havocked. Today’s also village people

say Gram Panchayat to

provide drinking water. Today’s also the situation is

so serious that there is a

question asked whether to bring water from here or not.

You should let us know, as to

what action you will be

taking in respect of the water of the company being discharged out of the

boundaries. 4 Member of the

environment

public hearing

and Regional Officer Shri.

Rajendra Patil

Saheb

He said that whether the

existing STP which you have

fitted for water pollution

control is adequate to take the load of 22 MT per month

after expansion in the

background of your proposed

manufactured product. If yes how? If not what steps you

have taken to upgrade the

existing system. Secondly, how whatever the waste of

spent which is generated

from the process is disposed-

off in a scientific manner so as there IS no any nuisance

to near by surrounding area

no doubt the unit is doing good but precautionary

measures shall be taken in

future so as there should not BE any deterioration in &

around the premises. So all

the precautionary measures

should be taken that whatever the effluent or solid

waste which is generated

A. First point is that we use two words i.e.

Adequacy and Efficiency in the STP, in

which you treat water so far.

B. Second point that he raised is relating to

spent solvent etc. i.e. relating to the

disposal of hazardous waste.

C. And third point is in pursuant to the first

point. It relates to the measures that you

will take from the point of view of

expansion. The answer for the same is to

do three things i.e. Up-gradation,

Expansion and as we say Optimization.

RO Reverse Osmosis Plant 2, 1

thereafter Ozonizer to reduce COD or

BOD from the Effluent. Recovery of

spent solvent or Recovery of Solvent is

done before it goes to ETP. First point is

that, because of this pollution can be

reduced; secondly we will have to

introduce some Balancing Equipment

from point of view of the expansion. For

that also we have provided solution

measures in our Environment

Page 23: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

from the unit shall be disposed off in a scientific

manner through the

authorized agency. So my

question is that how this existing and proposed will

work?

Memorandum.

D. Third point, we have identified some

companies from point of view of the

hazardous waste which will re-cycle or

recover the same so that there will be no

material loss and no nuisance here and

there The waste will not be thrown

anywhere. We have membership of

CHWTSDF Ranjangaon where

maximum material which cannot be

recycled or reused will be given to.

However, in case of other material, it so

happens that in the plant only we can do

material recovery to some extent. So we

will recover in plant itself. If there are

companies doing recovery and approved

by MPCB which we call as authorized

we have plans to give our material to

them 5 Co-ordinator

of the

Environment

Public hearing

and Sub-

Regional

Officer Shri

Kude

He said that What do you do

with Waste water disposal? In reply to question of the Hon’ble Co-

ordinator Shri. Kude saheb, representative

mentioned that we have planned up-to Tertiary treatment plant from the point of

view of waste water disposal. We have also

conducted adequacy and efficacy study of ETP. We came to know from this angle that

some of the things are not adequate and

some things are not efficient. From that point

of view, we have taken measures and have plans to invest nearly Rs. 1.5 crores so that

the said water will be available to us for re-

cycling. Since there will be Tertiary Treatment, no water will be released outside

6 A Village

Development

Officer of

Wadivarhe,

He said that what percent

of water will be worthy to

be used. i.e. one point. The

second point is, if suppose,

due to environment of the

company health of the

villagers is endangered.

What can you do about it?

Secondly, you should give

written undertaking to this

village that you can give

compensation if the water

under the land is not fit for

consumption or what

measures you will take for

the purpose. Other things

follow thereafter. Note this

A. In reply to question of the Village

Development Officer, representative

mentioned that he would like to tell

only at the beginning that the water is

not discharged anywhere here and

there. Therefore, there is no possibility

of mixing of any water with ground

water. Secondly, as we have rain water

harvesting scheme in place precautions

are been taken for no water on ground

goes out rather goes out without testing.

B. We have carried out ground water testing

within 10 KM area. At least at present no

such pollution is observed. We have

made survey for 3 months of January,

February & March. The last point raised

Page 24: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

point that written

undertaking has to be

given. Nothing will

happen during 2 -5 years.

However in the course of

time anything can happen

within 10-20 years. At that

time all the persons are

new. So please see that for

how many years written

undertaking can be given

for nothing like this

happens.

is if drinking water is contaminated. The

first thing in this is that the public

hearing of the company that we are

conducting just now is legal means

lawful. Thus there are statutory bindings.

There is a Ministry of Environment &

Forest at Delhi which will impose most

of the conditions and all these conditions

we all can see in website. Thus there

won’t be any situation whereby you are

unaware of the conditions set for them.

All the conditions will be mentioned in

writing. Therefore, this will again lead to

transparency in this. Thus the company

cannot do any act without telling you,

and therefore, that is the purpose of

calling you all here.

C. Fifthly, as you have said it should be in

writing. The ways and means herein are

that, if any situation occurs because of

this company or any other then a

statutory binding is always applicable not

only on this but on all companies and it

is in writing only. It is done in writing

only. I would like to say that we all are

required to give all this to the

Environment Ministry in writing only.

Page 25: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

Annexure-VI

Page 26: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

Baseline Monitoring Study

(24th October’18 to 25th November’18)

Ambient Air Quality

Ambient Air Quality in the Study Area

Location Code

Name of Location

Distance from site

Direction from site Justification

AAQ-1 Project Site - - Project Site

AAQ-2 Wadivare 1.52 Km NNW Nearest Village

AAQ-3 Kurhegaon 2.97 km SE Upwind

AAQ-4 Gadgadsangvi 4.14 Km NW Downwind

AAQ-5 Dahegaon 6.16 Km NW Downwind

AAQ-6 Gondedumla 2.37 Km S Lateral Side

AAQ-7 Lahamagewadi 4 Km N Lateral Side

AAQ-8 Belgaon 3.48 Km ESE Lateral Side

Page 27: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

Locations PM 10

(µg/m3)

PM 2.5

(µg/m3)

SO2

(µg/

m3)

NOx

(µg/m3)

CO

(mg/m

3)

NH3

(µg/m3

)

Pb

(µg/m3

)

O3

(µg/m3

)

C6H6

(µg/m3

)

As

(ng/

m3)

Ni

(ng/m3

)

Benzo

(a)

Pyrene

(ng/m3

)

VOC

(ppm)

AAQ1-

Maximum 85.0 40.0 11.1 23.8 0.64 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

Minimum 65.3 30.7 8.5 18.3 0.49 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

Average 72.3 34.0 9.4 20.3 0.54 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

98percentile 83.6 39.3 10.9 23.4 0.63 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

AAQ2-

Maximum 97.7 51.8 10.7 27.4 0.68 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

Minimum 76.1 40.3 8.4 21.3 0.53 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

Average 85.2 45.1 9.4 23.8 0.60 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

98percentile 97.6 51.7 10.7 27.3 0.68 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

AAQ3-

Maximum 76.3 35.9 8.4 17.5 0.42 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

Minimum 59.1 27.8 6.5 13.6 0.33 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

Average 65.2 30.6 7.2 15.0 0.36 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

98percentile 75.1 35.3 8.3 17.3 0.41 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

AAQ4-

Maximum 78.3 35.2 7.0 18.0 78.3 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

Minimum 60.6 27.3 5.5 13.9 60.6 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

Average 66.9 30.1 6.0 15.4 66.9 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

98percentile 77.1 34.7 6.9 17.7 77.1 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

AAQ5-

Maximum 81.2 38.2 11.4 24.4 0.57 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

Minimum 62.9 29.6 8.8 18.9 0.44 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

Average 69.4 32.6 9.7 20.8 0.49 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

98percentile 79.9 37.6 11.2 24.0 0.56 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

AAQ6-

Maximum 88.3 41.5 10.6 25.6 0.57 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

Minimum 68.4 32.1 8.2 19.8 0.44 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

Average 75.5 35.5 9.1 21.9 0.49 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

Page 28: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

Ambient Air Quality Monitoring Results (24-hour average)

98percentile 86.9 40.8 10.4 25.2 0.56 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

AAQ7-

Maximum 85.1 41.6 8.1 22.9 0.47 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

Minimum 65.8 32.2 6.3 17.7 0.36 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

Average 72.67 35.6 6.9 19.6 0.40 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

98percentile 83.7 41.0 8.0 22.6 0.46 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

AAQ8-

Maximum 86.1 40.5 9.5 24.1 0.60 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

Minimum 66.7 31.3 7.3 18.7 0.47 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

Average 73.6 34.6 8.1 20.6 0.52 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

98percentile 84.7 39.8 9.3 23.7 0.59 <20 <0.01 <20 <3.0 <5 <1.0 <0.01 <1

Page 29: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

Noise

Ambient Noise Quality in the Study Area

S.

No. Location name Zone Units

Day Time Night Time

Result

CPCB

Permissible

Limit

Result

CPCB

Permissible

Limit

1. Project Site Industrial dB(A) Leq 68.2 75 55.6 70

2. Wadivarhe Village Residential dB(A) Leq 54.4 55 43.5 45

3. Nandur Vaidya Silent Zone dB(A) Leq 51.3 50 37.2 40

4. Gadgadsangvi Residential dB(A) Leq 53.1 55 44.2 45

5. Dahegaon Residential dB(A) Leq 51.8 55 44.1 45

6. NH 3 Mumbai-

Nashik Commercial dB(A) Leq 63.0 65 53.8 55

7. Lahamagewadi Silent Zone dB(A) Leq 46.9 50 39.0 40

8. Janori Village Residential dB(A) Leq 53.9 55 43.2 45 (Source: Monitoring during Study period by GCI)

Water Quality

Ground Water Sampling in the Study Area

Location Code Name of Location Distance from site Direction from site

GW -1 Project Site - -

GW -2 Wadivare Village 1.52 Km NNW

GW -3 Janori village 4.92 Km SSE

GW -4 Gadgadsangvi village 4.14 Km NW

GW -5 Dahegaon Village 6.16 Km NW

GW -6 Padlideshmukh Village 5.05 Km S

GW -7 Lahamagewadi 4 Km N

GW -8 Nandur Vaidya Village 6.15 Km ESE (Source: Analysis during study period, GCI)

Page 30: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

No Parameter Units Result Reference Method

Sample Identification GW1 GW2 GW3 GW4 GW5 GW6 GW7 GW8

1. pH --- 6.98 7.28 7.43 7.32 7.52 7.73 7.47 7.69 APHA 4500 H+

2. Conductivity mS/cm 0.35 0.42 0.30 0.26 0.39 0.52 0.32 0.47 APHA 2510

3. Turbidity NTU <2 <2 <2 <2 <2 <2 <2 <2 APHA 2130

4. Color Hazen <5 <5 <5 <5 <5 <5 <5 <5 APHA 2120

5. Odor - Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable APHA 2150

6. Total Dissolved Solid mg/L 228 273 195 169 253 338 208 306 APHA 2540 C

7. Total Suspended

Solid mg/L 2 4 3 3 2 4 3 5 APHA 2540 B

8. Sulphate mg/L 7.5 4.6 7.0 4.5 6.6 3.5 2.5 11.6 APHA 4500- SO42-

9. Chloride mg/L 23 39 19 31 39 24 52 33 APHA 4500 - Cl-

10. Total Hardness mg/L 168 195 217 278 312 242 159 270 APHA 2340

11. Calcium as Ca mg/L 49.2 58 65.2 63.6 72.8 74 35.6 56.8 APHA -3500 Ca

12. Magnesium Mg mg/L 10.9 12.2 13.1 28.9 31.6 13.9 17.0 31.1 APHA 3500-Mg

13. Alkalinity mg/L 108 118 97 83 69 72 117 65 APHA 2320

14. Copper mg/L <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 APHA 3500-Cu

15. Zinc mg/L <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 APHA 3500-Zn

16. Iron mg/L 0.13 0.11 0.15 0.13 0.08 0.16 0.1 <0.1 APHA 3500-Fe

17. Lead mg/L <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 APHA 3500-Pb

18. Nickel mg/L <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 APHA 3500-Ni

19. Cadmium mg/L <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 APHA 3500-C

20. Total Coliform MPN/100

ml 24 34 43 17 25 15 27 11 APHA 9221 B

21. Faecal Coliform MPN/100

ml Absent

Absent Absent Absent Absent Absent Absent Absent APHA 9221 E

22. E. Coli MPN/100

ml

Absent Absent Absent Absent Absent Absent Absent Absent APHA 9221 F

23. Calcium Hardness as

CaCO3 mg/L 123 145 163 159 182 185 89 142 APHA 3500-Ca

24. Magnesium Hardness

as CaCO3 mg/L 45 50 54 119 130 57 70 128 APHA 3500-Mg

25. Phenol mg/L <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 APHA 5530

26. Fluoride mg/L 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.78 0.62 0.5 0.7 0.6 APHA 4500-F-

27. Salinity mg/L 41.4 70.2 34.2 55.8 70.2 43.2 93.6 59.4 APHA 2520 B

Page 31: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

28. Dissolved Oxygen mg/L 5.3 5.8 6.0 5.7 5.3 5.6 5.0 4.8 APHA 4500-O-C

Page 32: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

Surface Water Quality:

Surface Water Sampling in the Study Area

Location

Code Name of Location Distance from site Direction from site

SW -1 Pond near Wadivare Village 2.25 Km NNW

SW -2 Mukane Dam Reservoir 2.69 Km SW

SW-3 Waldavi Dam Reservoir 6 Km N

SW-4 Darna Reservoir Up Stream 8.55 Km SSE

SW-5 Darna Reservoir Down

Stream 8.37 Km ESE

SW-6 Rajur Bahula Pond 7.41 Km NNE

SW-7 Aund Vahal Nallah Up

Stream 4.3 Km SSW

SW-8 Aund Vahal Nallah Down

Stream 6.53 Km SE

(Source: Analysis during study period, GCI)

Page 33: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

Surface water Sampling Result

No Parameter Units Result Reference Method Sample Identification SW1 SW2 SW3 SW4 SW5 SW6 SW7 SW8

1. pH --- 7.46 7.25 7.63 7.48 7.59 7.64 7.71 7.28 APHA 4500 H+

2. Conductivity

mS/cm 906 962 1080 936 874 966 778 996 APHA 2510

3. Turbidity NTU <2 <2 <2 <2 <2 <2 <2 <2 APHA 2130

4. Color Hazen <5 <5 <5 <5 <5 <5 <5 <5 APHA 2120

5. Odor - Agreeable

Agreeable

Agreeable

Agreeable

Agreeable

Agreeable

Agreeable

Agreeable

APHA 2150

6. Total Dissolved Solid

mg/L 589 624 702 608 568 628 506 648 APHA 2540 C

7. Total Suspended Solid

mg/L 8 12 10 14 11 9 13 15 APHA 2540 B

8. Sulphate mg/L 32.5 24.6 37.0 47.5 23.6 30.5 24.5 34.6 APHA 4500- SO4

2-

9. Chloride mg/L 87 94 121 146 139 124 152 133 APHA 4500 - Cl-

10. Total Hardness

mg/L 368 389 397 378 412 342 359 370 APHA 2340

11. Calcium as Ca

mg/L 86.4 93.6 99.2 86.4 95.6 105.2 114 102.4 APHA -3500 Ca

12. Magnesium Mg

mg/L 36.9 37.7 36.2 39.4 42.0 19.2 17.9 27.7 APHA 3500-Mg

13. Alkalinity mg/L 87 79 85 76 83 96 102 78 APHA 2320

14. Copper mg/L <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 APHA

3500-Cu

15. Zinc mg/L <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 APHA

3500-Zn

16. Iron mg/L 0.13 0.11 0.15 0.13 0.08 0.16 0.1 <0.1 APHA

3500-Fe

17. Lead mg/L <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 APHA

3500-Pb

18. Nickel mg/L <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 APHA

3500-Ni

19. Cadmium mg/L <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 APHA

3500-C

20. Total Coliform

MPN/100 ml

110 130 94 140 79 170 210 140 APHA 9221 B

21. Faecal Coliform

MPN/100 ml

Absent

Absent Absent

Absent

Absent

Absent

Absent

Absent

APHA 9221 E

22. E. Coli MPN/100 ml

Absent

Absent Absent

Absent

Absent

Absent

Absent

Absent

APHA 9221 F

23. Calcium Hardness as CaCO3

mg/L 216 234 248 216 239 263 285 256 APHA 3500-Ca

24. Magnesium Hardness as CaCO3

mg/L 152 155 149 162 173 79 74 114 APHA 3500-Mg

25. Phenol mg/L <0.00

1 <0.001

<0.001

<0.001

<0.001

<0.001

<0.001

<0.001

APHA 5530

26. Fluoride mg/L 1.0 1.2 1.12 0.72 0.6 1.1 1.20 1.0 APHA 4500-F-

27. Salinity mg/L 156.6 169.2 217.8 262.8 250.2 223.2 273.6 239.4 APHA 2520

Page 34: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

Soil

Soil Sampling in the Study Area

Location

Code Sampling Locations Distance, km Direction

S-1 Project Site - -

S-2 Wadivare 1.52 km NNW

S-3 Kurhegaon 2.97 km SE

S-4 Gadagadsangvi 4.14 km NW

S-5 Dahegaon 6.16 km NW

S-6 Padlideshmukh 5.05 km S

S-7 Lahamagewadi 4 km N

S-8 Nandur Vaidya 6.15 km ESE (Source: Analysis during study period, GCI)

B

28. Dissolved Oxygen

mg/L 3.8 4.3 4.0 4.2 4.7 4.4 4.1 4.6 APHA 4500-O-C

Page 35: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

Physiochemical Characteristics of Soil

Sr.

No. Parameters Unit

Results Reference Method

S1 S2 S3 S4 S5 S6 S7 S8

1 pH - 7.82 7.91 7.84 7.98 8.1 7.8 7.63 7.91 IS 2720 : Part 26 : 1987

3 Electrical Conductivity ms/cm 0.78 0.58 0.42 0.37 0.49 0.49 0.52 0.31 IS 14767: 2000

4 Soil Moisture Content % 33 38 31 28 32 34 25 37 IS 2720 – Part – 2

5 Organic Carbon % 0.42 0.28 0.34 0.51 0.23 0.56 0.41 0.34 IS 2720 : Part 22 : 1972

6 Organic Matter % 0.72 0.48 0.58 0.87 0.39 0.96 0.71 0.58 IS 2720 : Part 22 : 1972

7 Phosphorus mg/kg 36 25 42 33 23 36 31 44 APHA 4500 – P

8 Total Nitrogen mg/kg 146 152 140 160 154 166 174 143 APHA 4500-NORG

9 Potassium as K mg/kg 63 68 57 65 47 59 66 72 APHA 3500 – K - B

10 Calcium mg/kg 202 219.4 209 215 208 221 218 210 APHA 3500 –Ca– B

11 Magnesium mg/kg 40.1 39.3 42.2 32.7 48.1 33.2 29.6 46.2 APHA 3500 –Mg

12 Chloride mg/kg 237 223 246 301 286 279 292 310 IS 6925: 1973

13 Copper as Cu mg/kg 33 38 26 36 22 36 28 35 APHA 3111 B

14 Zinc as Zn mg/kg 3.7 2.7 3.3 2.6 2.9 3.3 3.9 2.6 APHA 3111 B

15 Iron as Fe mg/kg 0.23 0.28 0.36 0.33 0.27 0.37 0.26 0.20 APHA 3111 B

16 Lead as Pb mg/kg 0.48 0.52 0.39 0.51 0.42 0.53 0.33 0.24 APHA 3500-Pb

17 Nickel as Ni mg/kg 4.21 4.63 4.52 3.96 4.28 5.12 4.63 4.33 APHA 3500-Ni

Source: Analysis Report

Page 36: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

(Photographs of Ambient Air Monitoring)

Project Site Belgaon

Dahegaon Kurhegaon

Page 37: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

Dahegaon Gadgadsangvi

Lahamagewadi Project Site

(Photographs of Soil Sampling)

Page 38: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

Project site Wadivare

Nandur Vaidya NH 3 Mumbai- Nashik

(Photographs of Noise Monitoring)

Page 39: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

(Photographs of Surface water Sampling)

Aund Vahal Nallah Down Stream

Aund Vahal Nallah Up Stream

Darna Reservoir Down Stream

Darna Reservoir Up Stream

Page 40: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

Dahegaon Lahamagewadi

Nandur Vaidya Janori

(Photographs of Ground water Sampling)

Page 41: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

Annexure-VII

Page 42: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

Existing: VSCL has initiated various CER activities for the development

and care of the area.

Existing Project

Corporate Environmental Responsibility for the year 2015-2016

Sr. No. CER Activities Amount in

Lacs Villages

1 Construction of Class Room at

Madhyamik Vidyalay Wadivarhe 1,00,000/- Wadivarhe

2

Development of Infrastructural Facilities

for providing Education at Maharishi

Markandeshwar University Trust

24,00,000/- Wadivarhe

3 Repairs and Maintenance including

Painting at Wadivarhe School 3,00,000/- Wadivarhe

Total for the year 2015-2016 27,00,000/-

Corporate Environmental Responsibility for the year 2016-2017

1 Medical Assistance to a Villager

Mr.Babbu Usman Shaikh - Jakir 10,000/- Wadivarhe

2 Repairs and Maintenance at Wadivarhe

School 46,500/- Wadivarhe

3 Help to Matoshree Vrudhashram 25,000/- Wadivarhe

4 Installation of High Mast Lamps at

Wadivarhe Village 6,31,014/- Wadivarhe

Total for the year 2016-2017 7,12,514/-

Corporate Environmental Responsibility for the year 2017-2018

1

Paid to Satyam Pharma for Medical Aid to

a female Villager Mrs.Sonali Sandeep

Kshirsagar

1,00,000/- Wadivarhe

2 Paid to Nature Conservation Society of

Nashik 4,00,000/- Wadivarhe

3 Donation to Rural Police Fund through

Superintendent of Police 25,000/- Wadivarhe

4 Water Conservation and Decantation

11,02,260/- Sinnar

Total for the year 2017-2018 16,27,260/-

Corporate Environmental Responsibility for the year 2018-2019

Expenditure done till 26/11/2018 (Date of uploading online application for EC)

1 Nature Conservation Society 3,00,000/- Wadivarhe

2 Water Conservation and Decantation 1,00,000/- Wadivarhe

3 Tree Plantation and taking care for 100%

survival 14,210/- Ambad

Expenses till 26/11/2018(Date of

uploading online application for EC) for

the year 2018-2019 4,14,210/-

Page 43: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

Proposed: VSCL has also budgeted various CER activities for future which

includes;

Corporate Environmental Responsibility for the year 2018-2019 and 2019-2020

Sr.

No. CER Activities Amount in Lacks Villages

1

Medical Camps at Gram

Panchayat Schools, distribution of

spectacles and providing free

treatment and medicines to needy.

1,00,000/-

Wadivarhe

2 Tree Plantation on pathways and

taking care for 100% survival 35,790/-

Wadivarhe

3

Cleanliness and Hygiene Program

for Good Health under “Swach

Bharat”Abhiyan in Schools 10,000/-

Posters Banners

and Video Clips

.(Wadivarhe,Gon

de,belgaon,purhe

gaon)

4

“BetiBachav - BetiPadhav”

Campaign in nearby Villages

10,000/-

Posters Banners

and Video Clips

.(Lahamagewadi,

Sangeon,Padlides

hmukh, Nandur

vaidya )

5 Water Conservation and

Decantation 1,00,000/- Gonde

6 Nature Conservation Society

5,00,000/- Nandurmadmesh

war

Total for the year 2018-2019

and 2019-2020 7,55,790/-

Page 44: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

(Photographs of Proposed CER Activity)

Development of Infrastructural

Facilities for providing Education at

Maharishi Markandeshwar University

Trust

Construction of Class Room at

Madhyamik Vidyalay Wadivarhe

Medical camp arranged at Grampachayat school, Wadivarhe

Page 45: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

j hg

Water Conservation and Decantation Tree Plantation

Installation of High Mast Lamps at

Wadivarhe Village Roadside plantation Outside factory

premise

Page 46: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

Annexure-VIII

Page 47: Annexure-Ienvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC...2) VSCL have taken sufficient measures to prevent and contain any leaks as per well defined Emergency Preparedness plan

(Certificate issued by Maharashtra Enviro Power Ltd,

for valid membership for CHWTSDF)