21
English title: The Two Russian -Revolutions, and, Once Again, On the Theory of Permanent Revolution 6177

and, On the Theory of Permanent Revolution

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: and, On the Theory of Permanent Revolution

English title: The Two Russian -Revolutions, and, Once Again, On the Theory of Permanent Revolution

6177

Page 2: and, On the Theory of Permanent Revolution

--, '

14.~ .)~'

rs'w\.o ~~1~.S..,,z;~ilp.) I

·. ·. J .•

I 6178 j

Page 3: and, On the Theory of Permanent Revolution

-

-· . . '-'"""",; ut..w:;~,:- ... ; ... t;rt"'_,..; v' ~~ ~ r'.ii' • .,~ )} <J})S~ cJ~,.:.LJ

.;» j <J'-t-»1"_,:, S .,;t..S cJI..-.;1 ,1~ 0<1 1.:,i.

.~ • .J;t.,~;~ ..~,;1•.J}~ I; loS.$; ... 14srJ~J

,' t . .e:-()JJJj~~ ~~~~-~.iit-~ . .• ; .

"''L-l.:l .:.IS'..,.,. J .:.1}4'6 ...:,..:t.., s t..,.,_,t,.: ..

• ..._, />'-. .;1,,w,...,

I •••• l': •• ltt)!(

,..._,....,. 4 ..... ,li .,.., ., • ...,; .. ~,.:-IS:: - C!"¥

• .:..:.1,...,; ,.,_.,T ( · l ...,:.,) ,., u.-.i" 4--..

~,.. .:. .. }L., .;., ,,.IS_,.~\:.., 1i ,.>.:.IS:: D< i 0 "U'

6179

Page 4: and, On the Theory of Permanent Revolution

';.....rut:..J"" ~. .·

.s;,..,-1,1.1 t._.J;W, •."'-1 J-;p ~ ..J.,;.pL ..,__..., 11Y 1

.sl_,., ;I , .:...l_.&".,_)li;l JJ JJ Jl ..... ); t-<- ;I_,:..,.. ~ ~ ,....f.-;p

....:: ,..,.. J,., Jp~ Lr-' Jo.o .,> J J .6 _,:...:.1.6..;.. .Uti. o) ~ T u'--'il:: ,;,o

"~JJ..;;,.T .sJ;Ip .6 J}J ..,.,lti:l ...,·<.<1,....0 i} ;1 .:.4--=-JY

-6-.I;S,JI;,J:.,~ .)3,_,:,1;1, .,;IJ;_.),..:JJ\.-, IJJt....,l.., J.-1.

c.S.i,J.J~.t. I.S'>! "t'->-~t.:.;'. r:,~'l.I'J ,J,, ~Jw~I.S~; tS-4- ,..a.;

JJJ' JJ. J.><u•5)•.s#.il.s~ Jl_,.,.:l ;1 o:l u:-}1, ,:.;.l.,;l..,.s..,

,... Jf:<J.>< ,.._,_ ~~.1 ;l._u "'~ J3 ,;I J;; I. 4.1 )>!;;,,... J-;y

'"'--I.,.;. JJ J,li. JJ 1,1. ~-.. Jl,j ,.L,-..:.....:1,::,..: ~ et"" ~I)>\>.,

.sWAI, .6 .;.J\:..1 "": )::,.o> , .a 1... t'..,.l< ,;.II:.. I "<-J~ ,;It 1i J ~ J I

.,..,,..I..slx;l. J_,; Jl,.. "'1-" l/.ISt",, J)i.,...:. .i~rJJ~ ' . :

I~ ..,J_,., • .,.4 .:.T,;I 111 .. =-'l,.:J~~J'.il u-'~ .&, J.><•"'-'­

•j'(it..

,;,.; .. ,j-J>- .... ~ .l: 4 .;t:., _,.ot.. .a;~ )J J.>-!'J "''"\,

,_,.,, ..:1,:,.:,1 .,..._,6 J,..:.;r,) ...,~,..,~ J,,}..,....,J)>: 5

6180

'

.. ' ..

·'{ / I

i

Page 5: and, On the Theory of Permanent Revolution

"'-'YI r,l. ... ..,.)t;.;l ... ~ J,..~..:-..:1.__,.,.... : .... ~ .. ; "''- ~ .., .. ll:wl..,

-'.iu ..!!.-., .;,:.>-1 .. _., J,.o..:. ~ .,:,.:5..6.1,.:, .. .........., ... ..., ,.....;

_1;_,::1.] ... '"' J..-.,: ~ .. ,., J"" ... ;I '.j, ~ .yS • ,.,..... .S-.1;5;J

• ~' .S_..,.Ifi,.t' &,.:l- .. y 1.:., In~ Jl;,.._

o,.rl..ii;~ .,,.illT ~ ~~.1! l.l LS~y~ .. \ \.\ Y J 1 1• o ..:.~)ti;l 'f..,..,_:;;I.Jl.o::. J~,.-,..,.....1 .;,.IS:..}.;!, JJ>t< ..s .,:>t;;l, .. .;,l..o • ..:I ·4 ":')I;.; I "'~ _....., •.U:,}l ,1 .S I~, ~I •"'-' .:-.<.;,Tl, .J_;.;.,: r\; .S

•-~.hvi..Jti:;1 4( tSI,,.,L-:1" .A,a:.~rl..,- c)lb.,l.·~, ~ (J}~.J rJ'-'·". . ,_ T

r--" ,,1,.,.1e1u ... .:-,:-.;,l.x~~~ .. ll::lr~...;;t,_..,JP., .x.

. -'"' U~1 ... ,.J~.; ~1-Jl.:..~l ~ r-A 1 J.-;,: _,,.._~Lt.'-" ... ( "-!~1,} . .!.;

-ft,J l, .J..,I:UJ;;, _, u). ;I,~ l,)t;.;l .;,,1;1 &,:J J.lo.:, ~ l, . .!.,I,

f._,;'t;uG.., 1, •P. .u:I.J> "'_..... /. ....,_. .,lti.:l P.J "-' . .,1·. -6 _,.,.I

, 4 ;; .... ,;..; .,:,.:S-6.1..-' .. ..,., .. A;.,.;$,!., ..I.,I)JJ.h'ii"' .::,1,

. .-......:..at,_;..~~ ·~T ~ ,} ::.1..,~ d..:. 1$

J.J;jr'. "'~~ ~~ , 1. o- y l!--~)ti;l .J·~ ~lb._,.J ,l~ .• _t.

.;,.......:.l,_,...,..JJd,::l)',._, J.,._,_j,IS•.:';.o.l, .y :;,s, .$_..,.'ft,J1;;,

,bU., .. ~ .s.t, _,,..:.1);.: ..b&;~;l.h'ii ... .,.I :• ..,Jj ..,~,~,..-,

~~"'"' ~,., 4:1-JJJJ J~~l.:,l)' ,.t.. ,;..I,; I,· J-;j;, &,.:l ..s!;.AIS" ...... ' I . . I

,;,.t,.c.l.:,l} .... ,l, .:,JJI ..sl.., IS .. ,., ~.,..::., t.,.\,.:.1. ....... ~,·~"'I T

~.l.l.:.! ":'~ ...,J.>';l, r~ I, f T , .. J..;.,: • .t:J.H •4~..-' .;,T

.. ,.;;11..:......; .... ~~:: u...,.. .:.~,., ... v:,tTu- ~"'""" .l .:.-'ul

.J...... ~~",_..,~A",_.. ,,T,., 116·1.~t;)l:.;.l" ~lio _,

E:1R1~

.. ·'·

I f , .

Page 6: and, On the Theory of Permanent Revolution

-

• •1

~ ·~J ";- 1~ i 1. 1 J~ .5»:-I;S_,H.lrJ ~.il.:....;J ;~r.JJ J .,)

• .;i,;..,.,..,.J;...I l, ..-I},." J\.-.>- ~,IJ • "A'J" Jl .).>1 .;!_,;.;... -T

, .JA.J',.,;.,, .Jii.," ..r-' :.,_,",J,;Ij,." Jl,..,_ ,l)S ..,..;... :.M> e'"" . .., ";; r}: .f' f.,.. .s <S1 .L. , .....: J:...;., :....... : ·"·"'"~ J. ~

,J-..>1... -5 .:...:l';l, ~'".:,I.., I.....,...;> I"~ ,1 11 r. -n J"

-~ J•riJ J~ ~.,C C:SJf.!J~ IS~ ~.r·' .6 \" 11:1-JJ'":-X;,;I Qub ;t ;:.S _____ _, .......

.. 1.!-..!l..c

x l.h- ~}I, ~Jj.; ,,.,,~,;'4 _;I~., ;I~ ~lcb~.J.J ~f

~ ~I;Jo+.O .1"' ,, 1 , 1 • :ns., -'-":' "l...:..t;JC.;.t "Jl.J"' 1,. o .Jti..

u- .64-;TL; .Jii. .;,.I • "_,.; ·..,. •• ,)..,..1},." .J!,.. ..... .._t..:, l}ul.:S.:I• .;,t,;..

~'" .Jii. .:,1 JL..:,Il, • ..:...1,...,_ '""I"}"' ..,..,J5"1 ,, ¥G r'l..._. • • ·';Jl..- '-""'JL; r~ • .:.~~ v.:J .Jii. • "-"',..1-'<-1..:. r!..: .:.!;..:, Go-

• "'1'1· J-:_,; 111 • ~li. ~J"' J C;-lu.,~ · ~ LJJrl

~1., f~..s~ '.~At~}.} .,tS' »4-.Jr' 1., ~"it,!-~ ,;1 U:tl

f .d.,;, .(;,;5;,1J .,...1.,1'-' l, '"-"' .:,I .:k J y~ ~I..,. I., .. ~ 45 !I•Y ;J;S'J" j:._;_;.;_sJ-'l,J 1.<:;1;1._... .;,4-...;1,,"~).4,

·r:!l..;tJ.,..:., Jj:oe .uJ 1,. /) ~~~ ,J,... ~.• I :L,.. < .. ,6, "\.;;1 ·li;l \S:· I .S •l. ... •I" L1 · \Or ~ U~J". t-' ~ "1"'l' fJt ('~!- . -- .F-'!

._,1_,..., J....._,;.S._,I..,._.....,.~...:..Ir~ [..,:....),·""'..,_, ..,;,t,.;,Jw

':-lli;l C.JI.J.i; 1.,_:;.: .;,.I • J-"' J .... •IJJJ Jl J .....:,.""<1 .... .t.JJ<)hv­

._,..,_:; "< 1......, ~~ ,1 .SI~, J,_ J:...:.t= d..._,~;ui...:S:;I r;;l AI, ",

, .:.--,;.1 ~ ti1b. • J""r-.t= .;,T ;I 1, ~...;,,... ,,1..,..,.lli;1

·· .. l

. f i

..

Page 7: and, On the Theory of Permanent Revolution

:~wt.,..,;,...,, ~~ ..... rl!.l ~ J~ },~ .:JI,~I..:~I._;,_...t..,.,.\;S,J ..__s..,Jii;l.:i,..:.. .slo,....:S jl J,; ...,,,._.lui..: _;l,j...,..,.lli.:l,~ ~J~

.;..1. ~4Jll; r-1'-,.. "'. ~\; :.t.. .:J,_J'- .oll.b. :...,,,.._ ~

...-,_~p,. .,L>I.,..,, 1, •• ..,lli:l-, t...o..:. .s· ~t; ~ c'lik..l

._;1.£1\; . .,.:_,.5~ '< I A• • ""IJ..>.,~._,.5) • .! fJI_,;"..,lli;l ,.,....Jw • J.i-f •,r!-1....!. .J.J~~> A.1!-- -'-"! ~JI.J

u!'")> J-;_,.J..._, 'Jt, J,l .....,..;,_,.... rJI"" ..,:X.: I"' I....,~ .s~ .;..I

~ .s"~ c)>~l~ci~}_,; l,.y';}:;S)S..,:..~)" Jt.•-'-'­

~J-;-" ~ 1 ~~ .l...J' ·..,Jii;l ,;pJ..I_,..: u.r-• • .,...,..., .r. ,;....

·' Jji .;,!, ·~L.:. uT '" J-;;:. ~""'""'~§.;..I • Jp

..,_....._,_~, ..,...!,.... r4"1 t; '"""I jl•~ ~~I,....,_.,.. u- ~ ~T· .,..._ .

.s1 ,·" ').}$.!:.. .,.,JS.:J,,.;~ ....:.t,..,_;... <><*""'' .;,IS...,.t.:jl ~ '{1....JI1,::...J .Wj\.:u- • .6t>,- _fi._:_t.,. J.,li.,J,'\'.)...b.tl 1 .:.J.b.

. .•. . .

'"lli;l .,:,:5.1..1.>-' .._ .... ,t..~J I..! JS,J.-J' .slA IS""J.H ..,, ,.... .r'-y •,......,..,. u- .6 .:...--.J-.> T u.t I ,..,_.; .._, ..).. J,.} \, .., , . .

'- ...,..) ~ ~ • ,ft Ali- 4 J-.H..,..., "' • ~ .s;,.l!a $ ..,,.1§_..1 1 :- Jl,;_..,..,t.;..-1 t, (,_.s} • .;,I..;:T rl; )..,...l.f>,." J!,....,..

";;~ .:l,:;' ... \.,""1 ,J..,In .,..,,,..,)t;.;l j~.,: .. _,.,... "-..,.'" ri.:-=-IM t,

~ r 1:., .t ..,.,.lft;J ~ .,..t.o).; .hi: .6 r-s .:. t.~l JL....:,.• t, ,.:t;:.. • J..~.;:,......., .~, .. re1 ... .s u--=-1).; .bi; ... 4 ...;_,. .:.t:...,.l J...,.t.; ........ JA'.H .:,..:-1.:.\,l~ J-.H"'-1 ~.Jo':1' ,j~l I. .... jl • J}~ )I,...,

I .. I

i

Page 8: and, On the Theory of Permanent Revolution

.\ . ,. •<· • J} J .,~,_,.,. .;-JI,_;I. ..J,L.; J ~;I ..,,_;..:.. ""') .X I. ,...,;1 . ..... 1,.-

,tL:..,.., r-" J....;_,; 1 J _,s; .,_,_, ,,1.., ._,.'X;; I <>n!' _......., .$ .-.lft,J J,

~ ~t,;b'!'-:-'t)>l ~ ,,....lft,..J J~,_ ~'"' ..!!- _,...,.,.J~\~.i.... :_,..,,

;1• £.1.x .;- t;.;,,...,.t..,.~.., IJ,r::,J..O 1.1 •• ..,~,.;.,~,...,.};I~

r4' "'"'1_;>_,. J .,;~,i_.,.,.h.._,:;.:-,1.,. ·<=-I _;l,j_.,.,:lli:l v=l ~ ~.,..:T • ~ ,}-;.; • Jl J._r_;..S IJ. -'-J

.,-1_;}_,. J ,..,.41 J\;.:, r-:-:.-o ;I J.i ...,~..,._. l,..<-..,..11,_;1. .,~,.:.-., I."

'..wl,.:; ~ .ua.l.~ jl ~~\-!i' ,~-~ ~_,.,.; .·~-' }}~Jt .),. t., Jl,';~

J.-JJ .;,UW.J;I ~;.;"-" I.,.S•.:-1 ~v=l •• " Y.o.,\,., ._,:\,.~

J_:i;...... (..;:..;,; 4 ..s'P.-' A.: rJti ....:..;~ ~)l~l .J.u.r: uUth..i .•• ~"i..-.A

•. :. , .o.::-1 _;.5 r-" J ;I ,j> . .,-!,.. <.<_...AJ._;:;; ,,1.., ,:,l.:.:l_,::, .c.::...,: , . { tY1 ,6-....iJ:I.,_l'\•o

L....o, ·r•_,s;"'-"I,JJ .J--'< .;,i ,_$. c)> .... ..J.r-.§..-.JI:i- <>l.x V' •

l,..:l....o )" o.::-1 ji.J.>Ir-4- .,;I; '-'"-\,..• • -\1} .J.> ._,.~:;;1_ .sl.x <J'I..:JI-' ~ •

( tAr ...._..;..,

_,, J.-:. .:t} .,.~~.,..t..:.~.r~A.h-,:~T}~c.l'A.oJ-A J-;y

I HI Jl...,)~ .,_.4-JJ 11 e1JJJ • .6 -'}J vi J-' J'~)l..,l ...,_.:j '-': J ,I_,......, " .&,1, I..,S.~ 1.,..,:.:, J ... v .>I J .;,L.:.: _,bU., ¥• 1.._,::..:1_,:.;..­

jl.._._, <.<l,.J'-,•"-JJ Jl...:,l 1., .... _;> ...,J_,;jl., ... ,., •• 1 ... <>'IJ ~,..:J.,

1.,5...,;:....- • "-'~ ~_,_.:.:.' !.,S-A"~,.,~.:.. ~t.. .w.. 4 •J!S _.,~1 H 1 Jl-, ll..:..! ...,J,:;I., JJ ~_.,._,;.::;.§;I '-'l,jl.ll\., 11 ;5.;i)

_._,., ,..,_J._,..~ 1 1.1 Jl..., .S..,.,..I_;S,l :_.,.I'!"JJ .S _._,., .si.Jt.. ( Jf>J-.4-

6181

..

..

/ I

i

Page 9: and, On the Theory of Permanent Revolution

-

t..:,.......l~4.'U..u~f::'!'"

~~ ..~)'Jtl..:.Tt.r'J..io t.:l,.;$1 ,_, jl r-'~ c$)t;;IJ~~1.P." o~\.H-J",· .• "

~ tS)'J:: r1S.:.AJ.~..h;.;,.~ ;S)t"...:1..J..D t.Ju ~~ ~5· ...._;.. ... .t~ ~

(r11 <J"•II•o) •• .. .-j J"""'"'"""'"')u. ~IS' ,..c,T-,. i!;,;l• ~·~ II • I.J-' .§...:-"!::!'~ r':).,.l v.<1 ~>'

l,.,.~.s.:l v-...Y~ .:,.,:.1 .S:.,I Ar. Jl... ~ ~ ..... .;-... - I I!\ , .. .s Jr.'.

' . ..o.:~,,.,_..:...,; ~ 1, II • I to'>- ..:1..,~- -'~ •-'.ft <.!.r.I'J i:f}:.r'

.::., .. ~ ,IS...,.. I"''...,. ..5 ph;\..• ,)u. .;,.I • .j,.S..-4-., ,:,.;I J J\, •

.:,.-tl .JJJit,;..; IJ.:p.. ft$";"1~ b> '-rS:-_,.~, ~ cJt.iJ f.S.r.AJ~ .S 1r:- c c.:..i~

.;..1•'-< ..._; ) .>J .>)..j_.•~r,;; ..,...S;I J,; .Y,.. I I I Y .;\.r-.JJ .J!-, v-.?>-t-. . (fli' ...:i rl V V' • I I • • i • • (' ......,__,: ) ( ciJJ J •;}.,. - .

..5 J.a .Sire-,.._,\., .:I..,_,;.....,..U.. .;,~1 .>fi,.;"'ij u'\..;_r .5.:-1 ..,....,

.j-1..5 J~ .:.~ 1 ,,,J ~>< -'4• Ji.Y. 11 n .:.->-r-;1.5 ...,h:"-".~1.•).:,.> ·

.I I IY .,_)t;:l <.1:-J-"' J.>.J JjA}~! rJI..,,_,.lli;l <.!~ <.!Jl.o...:ltl_.,l

·~,;.:' tS~~~~ .·,) ... ; 1.$~ 0T .JP."J~ . . .

.5 .;:1_,1;: ,5 .>~ 11 , 0 _,41..,_~1J ..,._,:ljf'1" .J.>< 4\..,liJJ ii;i.> .:.<1"

c:)!l,.,1 V-< 1 : ~J JS.; ·~->' p, .. ....,r,...,. r,1...,.,.lli:, '-'~., 1...._,

-j .... u1.u.l ~JJ ~; ..... ,~..,_)1;.:1 i.:.-.1 ,<,;., .;,;1 fot...rf!1JJJ ._;1,_1,.],..,

U<I.Jt.. 1! tlbi.:1 d, ,.;._..~r.,, • nju;,_ .._.. U<l.;.> ..,1.,: J1 .;-l JIJ

( V J \ .:.W.., 11. 0 ) .•..o-1 ,.&,.! ..,..•1.: )1.\S J,i...> J ~

~ ...W""" ~ .. ~:;, .Jli.=l ~ .Jt.. ; 1 tu..:1 ""lu,J;, .. &.-4-:.1 .:S:

..,...;,_;S ..6,1_..:.~..,_1~...._,-, .}.1.: II•V.;.>JI.&..!•..u>L:.ll,;

6185 'd

.. /

i

'

~ ..

Page 10: and, On the Theory of Permanent Revolution

-

, L,.S.._..:.:..,J&..._->}Ji~ t;,;.5t,u.u: H.,'"''"'' ,.,_.,..,._,.lli;l

• ~ r1'"' l_,:i ~I; ,.; ;-' ul .J!o.,-> I 1 I•; .> 1 ..,:l..,._..L,., l,S.....,:J.,,

.:.--.§.4- "'l,:;...l.,s..,!: ., .>, ~ ->_,.; _.,;;... .:},-> ,_.{ • ....;_;; .6 ul .:IS; v..J11

;I

( I

..,~4-..:.I_,.L.:. ~,;.;.., .h"ii J ->..,.: d~ };'6 <i,.b; '-h .;,l:l:i.o->

u ..... ,...., ... 5) • .:#>'. "'-''"'" • ..._,_,.,,s,·., 1.,.5.,..:.:. ,L,S.,A '

1 ~ V<-< ~4-..-I_,.,.L.:. oJ'-'1.> _,.1;,.1, .j.....;;. , ..:-1 .:..L;.._,

., ·~, ..;t.h:' ""'T.r ;'-:=-~;)(;.,, ""'' , ...... ..,. .:y..,j c:t:.:., ~,..,.... .....,,.;._, •.,_" u\,;1:!,_.. .,..I..~· ttl< r"' ~ .,:ll,b ;;;~,. 1,-.:....,..S,I..

• ,:....,.I

~ .;,l:l:i.o-> • ..::...,.,.b • J.;;..: 4,. .,:L,; J~ . ..:,.I~~~ ..,:i.;,.);.;.,

~ISJI ~ ,.>1.:;1._,.:;. I_,:T_,I ~.,.:,_\,;I.:J;_, .&,'.>1_.,. t.,..,rS .;,1..._, J.....;_,;

l,S..A~ ....,~ 4-:1...., ,..,, J.....;;...;l.:. Jt....,.,.,. • ..,-\,...tF.r..e..:.. ~J ..,•J .>). J. ,...,,1:!5...· ' • ~»!,!....,,,....,.,:..:; • ., ,, ~U" ....... '

. 4 ,..,.... . .;I, I.

-'JJ-- , .. J-.lfi,J);.: .J.l:l, ',,, ... ..,.lli;l ..s~ .. .)...;;. 1..,:;..:

.,J> u)-> ,,_~,:., "''" :1."' ., &. . ....A:;~ .,_" ui,}:J,.., d _,..:,.,...::...,.,.b

• .,....;.~,1.:T•, (.:..Sli...,.J...., ul,,l.:.l )"u->j->", "..-1;;)1;..1 .;,1-W"

• ~~j

-;.;lo!l....o.u..,:~l5 ,y-St,s.S 4 ._,;L.. .r'.J: ~ .... u-1

6186

.,

I I, ' ' •

Page 11: and, On the Theory of Permanent Revolution

! J

I

~

..

. ,l.8T9 v, ,, ~ :o(_,-~~rr., ,,_.~.. :;i'~F' ,...·,:.""" i<f.~:...:.,i!'!K;Iil .1:>" ,rcr~, ... .....:rr;;-

;rr,..r i 1.,..,r ........,..,__,~<:>"',.. {I"=1'=''1Cf"""!>r• r 1~r • 1r 'r"'f"~"'..r .rtt?:;<t"l" ~-,""~ • ~:-'l"'fsf:" 1!"!l<.., .-.r "~~"' ~ r"f 1"'""5" 1' 11rr r.-r- :;"'':"'1 ~' r ...,..,- Sl' A • II ({ r or-r r

I~, 5" '1-r.- :"1'" .! <-{' ..,..,....,.. • :;"'Sl :"'¥1,.. ""1 "f.".r:> ~;., S ~ ~ •' r I ,r:. J?- "f'~f' .... ..,.. ~rrl~"' :'!::'"':;"'<' s''"'l "'r>rr. 'I'':> ,....., .. rf ,..,.,., 1'"!lC..,,, "'if""'""" 'r" ....,..,. ;.,..... 5" "P ,...-{..,_ ,..«:>,..,-,., ,..1::-'o"

...... ,--,:'!X~' ... "P ""' ..... "' '~"":'- ~~'f' "51" I"". IS~ . . .

sr 7 :;«,.,, • ........,_., ( .,r,<:>'.,.p' i 1<:> .. ,,,':' r•~ ''""""' ir'-11( • >-- - .> ..

,.r.c-, '!\!"' Cl • \ l r.lr,., 1 ~.,. .lrr ~( 1-=-- ...r...:... e:"'CY' ·( -:."""l"' ""fl~ . . -~..,.,0 !'<"<'"p ...-{.., .... """lr ..... (1=-'P 1-""". ( '"' rrr,~'"""r':[' .,....,

• {'";.'"<""">'l...,..l(r•><"r 'I'KJr 1:-:-ii"r S""'"'l""'lr.,..-,. {r<:' ""'""J

1r :;«r• I"K.;, .,. 1rJ r1 '{1..<' .,.rr > "'Y •'>" 1¥r r1 .-J 1r .,.,..r->'"lr.,J

.! ,.-f ,.,.-_,.. ' I;;<:> ""'"'"' .,.<r -:! <-{' I"""" r I ,._J .;..,.. "1 r '"'"\ (I">"' . -

,

Page 12: and, On the Theory of Permanent Revolution

' / J

• '""'-' r 4-:1 ' .,.,;... r1""1 .;.I.;'-

·_J ___ \_j • Jl..t;}} ,.~U;,;I *'J!"' 1,~ .f-;>-· ci1.jLu_,~j\.....bii v,..U

' - :. . _;.U.. .;.l.W :,6 \,;.. J I I 1 • ~ 1>. ~ »" > ~<.1'1""'-'-< 1> > \S;, I J 1 • .,S.x ' 'i,;l ~- ~.;~,._,'I"--.~..!!.- -1 bl;.. 'I" --1·<~. .. ..-:' loT"'~ ') ,) ..,._....)" tY- j .J ~,.. _ _,_

~ r--A t.....;...~,_. • &).: :~J.; · ..;.:-- ~;; ·s'~A .s'14 •.J;i; -J~~i :.u1

J...li.;."i;~l,l.: ,...l.- .hW j!_._,l,ui:J,_.. .;_ Jl J }} _...:·\:~~ •;).,. •

• .JI .J rl~l, .Jy, ~JI J

'-"'i...:_,; 1., 1,. J_,_, ~ 1., ,y. ,~L.:. .;.i 1, '"''J ~..:..,.; .:r-1 ..-x ..!!.-J;LJ;Il~...:- r,,_,.'-:">!;.:1 ~~ ;..c,;... __ j'f_ .5~\ _,,T~.:..~~tt'.J,.J

.__.). .h:;;"' d,,,:_,,..,>IS..:;l.. .:r-1' -'.1-1 >~;I... d,_,z >h: ;I ~ ._,;l.;l..

W- u'tJ~~;S;;,' ~ ~~t4.o}l;. . ..,~..r.J .. ..;.,~"~ .. u'J~j >J 1 \ ·~·;i 1., ._,l.k,l> C1t"' ,.,.;l,.:._;fo-)" J_,_,.,_,; c)> II·. • >J ,J.-:p

• .:...!1.!: Jl J r4-'1 111 V J I I • • W. Jl... IT ,j_,.b .

'"--' <>~,_., Jl J .;..,:! 1--,; ,5 I I I y ._.,1,._,\:JJx ._,;)I;; I ,_,;.. 'Jl,~li:k

.l>---'-" 1, 1 v ,;.t,;.,.lti:l r ...,_,,,s 4S "',, ..,..,:_, r'-"-1..-, .>,J} ;,..,. _,_,_,

' ....,..,,;lb.:l 6v">J ~ .,_,:;.,..,"' ~'-'- 1 ..,'<>~~ ... ..,_)I;; I u' ~~ ._,..Sh.,;' ,_,_,_, '-'>lf:.;,,l:>} ...,___,._,., ..,,._..,,.,.1:5 .:r.' • _,_,,..,_,; fi;L,

iyJL-; 1"\..J,:..... • -=-'u'>~JI: r" J ._.,lb.: I"""' r" . .5 ,...,: =~ •j1..c4U:!' 'w-'v=--st ~'"=")li.:t LS~ ~~~ J-:.; ~~ ~.J ;l JL.. 1 1 1 v

I"W>-' ~\;..;>'li: .,~ .s}.u...,_, .,-.!> ~ ~i. ~IS.,-.!>

"'"\:6;,-'" ,Wr>< v,:J L,,l ...;)(:.;..! .,.b_,_,_,.:; ._,li:..,..,U";....;.,oo-1

,,_h..!.;T!~...., L..;;.:,t.S-=-...1" ,};tu.> 1 I...I:J,,.d,.:lj,._, ._,lll;l

6188

.,

/ . f.. I .

'

Page 13: and, On the Theory of Permanent Revolution

, ~ ..,T",;,bli.o ~ , 1,,1::!,..., ..,-ll''""'""'1,5,. ~ .s»'~ ~ • ,,...,...., , ..,} • .,••-1

~ ,_..; j I 1, ~_,..:.!, ) ... .; .,;I .:k. .&, 1.:.1.,:1..:.1.~ J I , .:-I • .J...!

vJJcJ.- o~~,..L.,J· ~ v.:J.!.:.,~;) ..~.Jt~~ vt...!i .c...:\J .r£;AJ. l 1 lY

'-:')ii.;l..,_, .;.,1.5.;.....:,1 '"~ .£ 1.1'-'-1 l:l'"""" 1..:.;.., ~ .;..1

-F~ "1~r4--ll;"..,_._r...::J} r:i-•,L_,J ,J....S ~,_,; ,_;1....:_.;,,1,. .

.r-< cJ:l" J,_.,T ..,1_..,;.:; .5 t.JI .;..I ~\;1~...,..;...:,5. ".~-< .:r-:J J,..,i ..,t..

-~ul...i'-~~I.SJJjlu~>:~J.J J}.J .}.-;?t.S~..:-.-1~~

J <. ;I J;" <( ..... I I I •• "'.:5. I . •I ., " <( -<1\.~ I IS <·• r~ ~" ~.Y. JJ ...,- '""'- ~ ..,.--- ~" ve .s-

L...! ..,..:S .:....S..:. • •.1'1 .;.,. .,.u _,t.....:. .,.., y i :~t.:. '-"-" .,..1..• ., A ......,.. • J.>-1 J ~-, .,:.--.J\,.._~1 JS;...,. ..),..._, • J • ..:-I :;;.5 ._;,1..;. '"\,.

._, ~ ~ J_,.,.,..)ii.;ld.4JI,J &.. ,:j...;_., r,l..,-::)ii.;l ..,..,:.; ., .;..1 • ..<..:.

1.:-".i-"-.h...,: ~-~ ~J..u~ . .s c~, '"="')ts;' ,t.:.JJ..~..;_,ts:;, J:_,_;r ""u,:,.; ..:t}

~ '--' J- .,.:.J .. j...:;_.; .:5 J .... ~ •j\; J ....:. .:r--tl ~"'<!,A . .:-,.,- J-:_.; ..

'' 1 ...... .,_)I;; I .s.Jt!:JJ .s ~ ,jl.:S:I .SJ\,. .,...,,.,.)(>;1 j:jJI:; ,_... 'JI.,

~5 1 A•. Jt..., ..,.~,I. :.,l\.;. ~.»-,~ _r..e.l?" .:5 I...!..:.!..;)[;.-" , ..:-I

~ .:5 .;,WT.si,}:J,.., .sl.xiJ'<")ii.;l u"-"' ,,1.,. • ) ... ..: }, .;,.J,I .sl-"

_,5 ,1., ~ l:i,p 11 r ! :.,.., ' .._..,:s;,.; .J1< • .J _,5 c)-. ..:..0.\, 1, l A\ A ..,_ )ii.; I J

..,._~u\..:S:I ..,.:'- J.L.;, ~ ~"' 4-:,I,J J..:_.; • .J} .. u..:,,

4<...:. ... ,..., ~ _., .:i_...:.. .st....,.:.'> .:5 Jp .... I,J..,.S). jl)fl "'.:5 .;,~,;,.\; "'~~ ._,..)> '-'-1.1.,;-", ..a...,. .:1,1 1, .:il.ul.:S:I ,.s ,.t....,.& ..;i

6189 IJ ..

.. •.

.,

,,

I I

j

Page 14: and, On the Theory of Permanent Revolution

~T,s .a~vl.:.i~..A.:.J;W;l J-.:.r . .;}..t,-u,r'; ..~,.;..u~J'

• "-. ....,.,, .s..,£,.; A ..,:t.,.... ~~..,:;1 "'~'" ,.J;:," t.,.:i>~,l.

I "'-I ....,1; :,r} ~,.; ~}'.~' .,....,.....,~..,, .s ... .;.. "'' "' '"'' ,_J,l..;.,.S ""'l,. .,._.,;;, 4,.; ..; ..... • ...... , "-JJ ;} • .J~ ~~ 1.1'

• ~'i,. J_..,;.b_,..:, _.,;; <.>'~I.L,_,..:. .S 1, ~,l.}.xl 0<1''-,S._,..:.;. ,&,I

-" ..... ..a,.:SL,JI__,_,) l, _.;I_,; .., , I -"I. "'...., ....:.".,. )1;.:1.;.'5 _,... ....-..::.._,·,)I

~~ ;1 J.;;l; ~~ .s..c.,::..,... ~ .s~,l. }..,I.,, ;,~w)>;l ·.;S_,....J,o; •":..J.,.:. _,,.,.t: ...:.:I; '"f> 1....,..;\..:S;I ,};..J, . .sU.,..,; rl.;

J-l,.:":}•.J" ~ ~ ..... .sl.o..,..:S :,~.,,""'~'"',I.,:, I • "" ~ J'.JJIJ .sj,J

~..,..,....,· (~1;,6' ..;..., UJ)' .s}·· '"" ) ... ~1 .sl.o. ,.;\.\...

,S _,; "f> ,).;_.. ,;, I j I J , "I " ..; l.,b; I ~ ,._:;S .!!, "< 1.,.: T l,S._,..:.;. .5;,! 1.., "

;j,l,. .:,:..:1 "..," );;}\.,, yT , ....,1, .t w\..:S;I •)L;. '" , ..J,. .st..,..,; .,#

,;....-. ~ "-" J...i.ll: ,)} """"'..- I; ..t.,\5. u:l,., '..,:t.,....u_,li, .;;li,b

~. "-JJ':-lll;l.,:..,l; • -""ji; ~.,lJ'".s..<l...:>l".,ol.)"l.:.~l..:..l"j.

1.3

· ( n Ao.P 1 r;.. .s ~~ J JJ'P' \.I • 4 -=~\i5 t.,.s,._...::. "< .,#.;...t, <SI.X ojl..:;l .:r--"

l~I,JI. ~ ~ • ...,.1: (TA I o.P <~ ~ )" J..j~,.l _,lo=-1,... -'<~ • J--;; .:r.' .:."1" Jl;;.;l\, .,..s ,,...1..:. 1, J--;; .;,,~..pw r<''*' ;.~ }.f!.. ..,.)I;.; I ~JJ'J-' u.JI:-11'"""',......,,"' JJI "' u-JI:-1 .:.l.yl :......j "' ..:...\,. ,...,1.; .t _.,...,. • ,._:;S 4,~ • .,:-.JI;,_\; • r...,.ll,..,_" ., I,:T .S <J'l.,-.­

JI, , • ,_. ..,:J ~ .,.1,.._. .S t.,.:T 1; • Ja,l,!_,l.,.l,... _,.....,., • :.u_ J,..:> ,Ji; 1,~ jl..,_lt.,.}-..:.,t,.~,l • .cil .t r-"'il ,~,..:,. 11 IV

..

..

/ I

i

Page 15: and, On the Theory of Permanent Revolution

"'-'.>'II •• , .. yi .s,.~ ,I.S 1"''\,. .;1...;1 )., .r-~,1 .,1_,.,. ) ...,~.:,.

.,. )I..J;I .sl_, ...- b; :;JI.,. t!...., • ., .S ci'J\,. ( .,.;1..., .;,I"" ~ ...:. ~ . -• ..._.,. •}-.:1 • .. ,., .t.»lp. \,)~,.., ,....,, ')JI.,. ;1>1 ..,1 •• - .;--.JI,.....-

.,.~1 v-i}l." •.a.:S,. J;.;l, I 1 • • r.\;-r• ~;lrl ~,1

.__,_ JS.:.:. ',151 .si.J~'-" .s1fo- I_;; rl..:l.,' ,.,;-_,.~)-! ,;,;~_,~-"

J .>I.._,._:.!,. rJ I-'-" ._,.)!;.;I 4, ).: ... 1,->-1. • ,..fi... .SJA< .;--.J 1,...,_ ._,. )li; I . .

(~AhPir ~) •• ,..,_,o-',1,..,.:

·- ....i: _,~ 1 . ·•· _..1.;..,.~1 ,S Ll._;_. _..I.:~ I ~I ~ • ~J .r:- lS~.»-"' R 0 ~ ~ 0 J J oO tJ J" 0

..,.;..1..,...<>' .;,I..:..>,..: I, '-'"'4''-',.,..~ .s .s-'->- .;,i ..,_ t..}--.:;1 ,1:>,..

.__s _,,.., J'll:.>' ._,._.. .S )>1;.. """" J- • •• A ;,,...,rL,.;' .>}...:..;~1

~,; I.S~ ~ ,, .J,.:.. ~ ~4, .J..! ~ "v-'rS Ct- ,_,L_,-' ·~ ,4-\.i

.sJ.-''J;> Ji.: 1.,1, "'""'""'; J.-;;; '"'I; I 1 .,., ri 'i ..,< J.s- •J.. cl-, . . . .

~ ..,I.S -'JJ'.:.<IJJ- .,.,.:...:,;.sJ.-'..,.,_..J'J.,,J,;.,,,s_~jl

.,.JU.. rl..: .:,.:.l ~", ....,~.:,. .,.;;;.. ...:.:S ;,.;1 .>_,.)\,;.. • .s.,..1 .:-.lti:l

• .. ,., .:...:1 J ;I_, I 'JI,;.. d;..,...,..., 1.,-:.:1,.;,;

.u.ol_,;...x ;,_.: !,} .;,1~}5 .S .,,., ,.1 .;,;I 1., .J..,IJJ-' ~ ~t;. ,S 1_,.;T ;I .. - ' t

.;..lt..,.....> .J>-;;; ,•.,1., .u.olp..;,t.:.: 1;1 r4->'J:k 1. .,·,.:-I,>

.r-11:...1 g-:5 4.,• r--!1,.....- • u# .,,.,_; I•;}.,. ;I .;--.JI.:,...I.:,::I:.,;..,.

.,,~}' J, . ....,_:..;.,c:..o-1 .;~.,_lti:l ,;-..SJ!. r...,... 1., .J.,t;.:, .. 1,

,._-,.JA:,...I.:,:: I .._..,<:.-I , ...:. ~ .,J\:...1 .,.1r. JS 4 :.,1:., ..,....; .r''""""' .,~.:~:;.. • ..,.~..,~t"'J' ".JJ>J"urJ. J-:;;; •"J'...,. ..o;IJ ~

..,:""'-" .:,l.:tu..> .&.• "A"J" IJ -'P.& l.,jC ~ •} ..... IIJ IJ ~ 6191~;

•.

..

. '

/ t

I

Page 16: and, On the Theory of Permanent Revolution

..,_. • ..._.J<:I~ ~"<I, I ~~A•U" • ~ ~) • .,.__.. )S:.:!,..:,~J,I; .....

~ ~J"' .}-;.,;~~;,.,. 4~ ~~...-;! J,;.S~T J .,.....J. J:t- ;,l,J"•u:.t.,;;,J ~.h...;: .s.;_, ,r_,; l/.15 d.....,!:o.:.S_,.

~.; :_,t.:1 • .J~ ·~ o..D; ~,.s Jl;h-1.;,.,:.:1 :;5 ~,.,,_. tSJl.....:....l

,__!; J,li.pr---'!;,._!;_,:.:1_ .;,.it... I ..,.t.vl.ojJI.,. ~J~JJ L..,;; ,} ..., . . . ~ .J.!..... f .;,l:I.U.J IS)t;;l•..t.:; r.SJ~ ~i¥..H..,; J.J>-: c~ .. l,.,! .,,......_-~l; ~ '-"" • ..w.;.:..Jt... v..l~ .;.)>;! .;~.,_)!A;!~"-.- .S ;l..:IA .:..1,

• JJ}~Jt...~ ~).;l•t.., ..._, ~ .-,.4:. dl,Jl.s..,.:;,J .;.... J...;_,J....,.:.S_,. ... ~ ~ .,,

-,.l!l:l"-""' '< .;, ... 1 J ,1.,.:.1..._ ,1 "''Hv')(;; ..:,.11 • ....,1, u\.£1 .i:T...,

.S.r- ;IV";' .6 .;n.ft:..LJ-;_,; :;.,~~ ;...;_, ... w:..,t..- ~)t,.;1 tJ~~ l 1 1 y

:....t__.,..,~I.,~IS,.,..tcS~ c.#~'l.J. ,__; .t.:-:1..:.:.,;1;..:.-;J.!"" ~ ._., .;,.it... I .;;...,;,_..;.,.,, ,_L.;,J ,, ... ,....,_l;;L, .;'~ cS) J.,~ .... ... ~

.:.S ~ ... ;,rs ... ~ ,,...~...; )L;.. ... ...,._ ,J.s,. ~ _ ..s) ... .,~ ....... ~.o.,;,t' 'f'~t.:.;l, 4~ cS'J' vJJ-J "<tJ...:. .S,.~ .;,.it... I ..:,.11 • ..:.~1,.:. .oft o:...i},_, I 1 T! Jl.., ,j...;y 1 1 • o ':-4- "< ,...., <JJjU.:.~ J,...S _..,!;..

..,..1, (?" Jfflu.ll.,,c:...i_.,.J_,; 1""-'.:j...-.;l t;~l;...l!.-v:l~}

H .;,l'.a;• -'.JJ'J-' I, •Y- 1 T-.:.'.u-'JJ ~ ~T ~;1 _..,)l;..cSI.><

..t-:c.:&l.t .5 J~ oLI!.- ~· -'.f-1!'1 • .,.,,I ..a: ... ~ _,,.,~. J-;,;. ~. 4..lf'.;

e'"-'-' .... I.: .jJ;. ,~;I.. ... ~;t.., ... ,... J ..,..,.:;, ... ,... ,, ,j..:;); .,.:.1

.t,;L:!\~1..._, ...,., .:.\.-' 1, J_.;_,, _.,_, .:J,.'~ cSJ~.il.. 4 u.l .S 4.ilj1

6192

.. l

f l

I.

Page 17: and, On the Theory of Permanent Revolution

;

._;,;~ <.$_,!; .;..._u\.£1 J -',(;\,..:.....; l,.i_,..!:.. 1., u'~jL ;~I ,1.:; "< .5

• .,j.L .}.."'I.,_.;; ,I <JI"' ,_.I,

..,_lli;l <JLo"-" :...~~,, ... 4w,, ._,lli;l <.$~<.$_,!; 4 .,.;J.ru ~. . -~ 6_,; ""~ ..b.:i,;..; tS ~t.,~ v' u.J,.._; ~ ..... ..;J' ~~.~ ul,:_,. .. ' ,..c,;S

~,,. . .J~.J"),.... v.:-1 J _. '-=-'.ct.,.;' ..t;..!~ ~)Q;t A-"...: ~J"" ~

..,. 'L.i;l L..b; • 4 .; ...... ..,_lli;l,w 4 l,,.... J~~..,_lli;l 4 l, .;,....., . - . . y .;,I,.;,.; '-!-1~ l,:t ..:.,>j_,. • ;,_, <JI,;_,:; ~I;_,.,;.._;,;,.;.. 4 1 1 1 y

J~ ......,I.., ..,I ,}J ,,.,~ ,\,...., .;.<ll ('+"' • ;1;..:.,.-: J.!. 4""

ll~J'-:-';..:J~r' ,,~,J~ Jg.JJ J;l..t..Lnl- "".k~;l J~,l,...,.._ ,1_,:i ... ~ ~,, ~'.H f, . t ,..~ ,, .6\.stot:lt'J •..:..j ;~ :.~'-t.JJV'~' ,,..u;S

-.JJ}.~- [~~] uT ~ti.r• 111V "'.J ~.:_.; 4t · 4 J-4D J_,.; 4.b; . - . .

":- 'U:I .:,Yi},;~ .5 ~it, . .;...:>' 1, • ~ JL,, .;,o:.i ~~·e:li."

d__.,::l)'_,.; Jl,..,_ <JiP..,;,.>. J <J;~j ..,h., })<5 ~; • ..:....!~ 1, • o

;~ .:.<I~~~ <JI,, .,..1_,s,., JI,..,...<=.,.JW JL 1. ".:.~jl ,..,_t

-<41- T '-"' ·..,__;..: .;,~.)L '•~ • ) • "..:.....I •......,S ,\,...., .F'tlT "< ~~ "'~ v-"-.t-, ).:t~ 1, -<4-"< ,,...,11:; ~ ( ;l:l~ 1, -

1 • .JL 1 t .:a-'iJS • Jl, • I ,, t_.t.,t ..:.....!,.. J t.,S...,t <JWI: jl <.$1 ... )1.;. f 4 .... ~.<to. ~ rJ' :;::s,, uo • • • ,:.S,; J ;:.-:.., ,; t ""')1.;. 4 li,;' • ..,_t I 1 • T , .

<JJI.. .6 d,:t. t},-'!' ..,..b.. "' f 4 ..,~, <to,,,.. J.J.,J,.j •li.:,~ ..r-4 ( ~ ~ J ,.II../""'..,; ~ "ti1t )

6193 ~~

.. I • ,.

l

Page 18: and, On the Theory of Permanent Revolution

"

. ...._,•t; 1, ,"y ;" tJI ... -,.)(;.;1..,~, I,T ~I t<"l" .;,1..:.: ~ ~ _.,J.;I...o.

.,.1,:1 J,t;...,.,Ht ;" 11 ·•-, ..s~u~}f:;.J,...,; ~J}...,..£1,

JJ'- J; "r • :_. J ..s' ..:,I ;J .,_JJ-,. )(;.;I (:.ul: ~; tIS:;..., ~ ..s 1~ , .::-1

..:.-.,; ~_,. ~~~ ~T~u·~~ J~ c$1~~v~ .)~~'J}jiJ'6

~\.:..., ..;J,, ..s}""'~J- .;,i .,)..>!-~ ,jv. "~; sci; ._,;l,-.- . ..s}",~r

..-1..--5,..,.,1., ..,'i..;.f 11r· ..... .J...l,1;"'"';'} • ...,..; .,:~..s1•"<"<

4., ._JJ ~1...:..1 11 ..J1 "J< :.,_,~ 1; ,..c.:.;.:l,.;.-,.)(;.;1 J ~~ .,;Jl:..l

' """~l:..l ~t,; .. ,4ul .... i,! .. } JJ ·~, ..;J, .. ..s) .. .,t.,..~L,.. . . . .

..._,,;·,~ • ...,..:S.blb....:1 '< ..sJ/S.:.J,,~ 4 .,t.., ""~uilt\;" ,L:..I,;.

,..);.k ~ : ..... ~.... ~..,;;""~ ._,;l.j;~,,_, .. "'1 ~ '.1.,; ~ ..,J.;!...o.,

... ,., ... .,..,s r, .. .,:~.X..~..sl,,1, ,I; ,;...Jl:..l

.x'.1uJ U~.JIT ... ,;,~- ~..:, ~.:~)tj;t ~J~ ;-.ut.-:. ~r.:-'h' .;t ,.­

,.....,T..-1.,')1;;1 jl..sil-"1~1, A d._..,.:;; Jl,...:1 ~t;.;, ...-4..-1,.,.u •

. :. .. ;,. ... ),;, 4 .. J...,

, , . ~. «-t- ) • .. ·r1-'fo ..c.:t.,""u. J,...l ( J,; :............,..:.;.:;~ ) . . ' . . .........:t..., • ..c.: ..r-"l.jl-.:J,;t;:,.,_,!.,~..s};IS-,.,;..4'<}$' ( 1•Y·

.............. ).., .&,1..;-, .;-.. l, •• ...-'Jl;.l .:00 l,lrJ , .. ~t,..J...,:

~.:,.:... e1J;"} .;s' v.el • ...,,; r i1~1 .~ ,,t.i .;J=·"""W ..sl"' .b,~ ,, .• .., >: .. ,., '"JJr,,, ...... A,;...f.,u... ...S..su..,...:t., ..,-1ii J;.>.;:S

I r1 61.94 . ..

..

..

,r· I

/

Page 19: and, On the Theory of Permanent Revolution

.,-5-;,;; ~ • v 1,:.-..:...: .;,- '-:' )t;; I J ,i. • ..lh,-\::S I ~ "< ,,_; ,It: _ 1

( 1-' •I · • t.~ d,. ~· ·. '\Vf I""" I~»-~ ) r:.r..····:U, .... ~. ~

~o;-4- ~\ -l 'lY 'f 1 c:FJ'":-'\..~ c ,!)A"'~ ) ,..!..:.!, 1 !.>(_;,; ~ -'f ( \ I YT ,.:)fo.,

' ·..,..;,- .;,J~ cl- •}._,/ Jd' t'':..,..., J,l ~"' ,,_,,It: -r ,r :._.... r .o.4-, • f "lSI~ ..,..:S .!.\, J' ,_...JI,...,.. • r1 ' :..,..., , r,.. -'-4-.

. J-;~ ~'~~)tc\ fj}:. J-' ·r,'•'"=':tc' l.S~ ol.! ~J'.;..:..l} . ..:.t-< 11.r ~ ',;;;.,.;' .:>,.... • <l..,.._..;)

uP~\1 1· ,"!"~·1.•r'J ~~ tA J~~lj,t=ic J.-;,;v,:L t

(AVIJA1'

,1!.1~ ;t f.'l'\-·CitAt.:.~ct' ~~~~}.:T-o ( \I IT , j_..:..l,\t Jl;,...,\lp,l

._,.Ji;l 1._?). ~ Jo,:.T J' ..,u.... _,o.T ...;1}iJ1,"' ,_,.:. ,~~:;~- 1

'lAb(.JOc ~ ~~~ {1,,1 ,,t_.

e\;. ,~1 ,_,.J, .,,_.. .;,IA..il .;,J_,.l ,:,..:,,h.._,; ,.~.,o 4-T J,_..l.l"

... t,.z.; Ji:.- ..,.:r- :,~:..., ~ _,:....._,.. ~,.· ..i\;.:1..6.-_,; • ~ I) ~..:,:li.,li

.._s r" .bJ d" ..,1_, ,y.>-1 .;:.}•UJJ"" ..,.4-; <fAJ'< <fl_, 1J ,,_..~

.~...A" .;,I..:..,) .:I}SI,, ._.;.lilll.,..:-1~,., ·..,;11i»< "J~ .~ ..a..t: •j4-1,.....:

~..;.:T J:..,. )'u..:. • ..,$ .;4.,1 e'l. .s\t}:J,,. ..,..:,..- Ji:.- ......... \.;\.. ....... I • .....:\.," r,,..,..,..)ls;l" .,~.,.

6195/i

..

••

I f

j

Page 20: and, On the Theory of Permanent Revolution

1 1 • y Jt..., ._JJ .;,1.,1)5 .:.1,;1_,5,. .J J\,-,_ o.,; ~ 0

:)::.5..-lb.J;I_ y

(lnr.~ _,.,..._I 1 t fJ.J ~,: .S:..~ui}IJ~ .:.<1, nvuo. 4-;l...o - ~

• .J,.J}u:.... .Jji,. ...,.,, .,~, 1 • •.r- .s1......,r,iJ.J ~

.. • • 1 • u" 4-: l...o , .;,.;J - , 1J.i-!-J.J .;,.;J 1i • • - Y . .slo.:.:,; ;1.s_,:.l.l5 s _,;..., .slrJ_,; Ji:- I •

o:....t._,.,_; ...,.,, .;,~ ~;.:}~.: ·r ..,..,,.. ;. -~· .._,, 1., . • .,_)Ia.; I

~,.;.. .;l,.:. ..,Lo,;,S:;I J1 .:,II . ( 1 1 lY ,._,\'!\,...! •~I;, ::1.;.,4-, ~ )

-\:S,.J • ~ ~,: J .,.:J ..S'.:...:,I..-~1-=-~~ 11.:....1,_;. , .:-I}.J '.J

JA:.,.I..,:,I" 'u,.:J IJ ~T .;,\,.:.. ..S' .j.}o t,..:.: • :..,I...J_, ,j,.- • .sLo~ (1rl:~) ~, .J,....._.;,~.J..S' ...,~_,.):t~~ Wt6.,.,...... .J}..

• .J) .JU"I...;.o,l I 1 • • ·- V .sl.-JI....,

"--t~ J...;_,;,~-'f!J·.J,,r,~ ...bJ.,...;J~A.: J,_.:,tt;L.~-1.1 ,_..,,.s.,.wtb., ·~,.;,I...; I =.t:... .,w,: .:..lJ • ;~,.J .:.l:tia.J

• I IVY .;,h.., I: J ,'-t-; t ,.,L..

...._~, .yl1 .J .s)"""L""") J,l.:-.;, r-~ o, .J_,..: ,11:;_ 1 t -· . ,......,1,).:,.-Jl:,:;.., .;, ............ .;,\,~t'~ •, • .;..-.11:...1•, (" .;,I})S r\,i J,l:i.,.J

,:;,J, .:.I} . .::: I 1....,:; ~1.,_4- ) • o.~.J\;i1 ,.......S,L .,..,_t:S,.J ( • .._,, -----

6196

Page 21: and, On the Theory of Permanent Revolution

·11-L..!:t..:.' . ·I . •I ..t:l ,..., =.:t.o~ • LIS..;~···~' I ·L;. U'.l .,. • I'JJ .I J~ ~ ~ ¥. .,r;v;J Y'.J~ .

...,....}cs, . ....:t,., .........s.~.::..:\..;1 .;I..., "',.......,~.. .... -~,1. :...u J\_.j.:S~ IS(,.T i-' ......,.;.w,.., .,.:iill.s~ , .. ~~ ...... , w,...: .

• .ri-J' ~-'·t"'' l,ciJL;.. ....... .6.:-1 .;t..S <l..t:l -4;r. .,.., .. ....._. $o ,vS,L. ,tT , .. .a..1> ..,1 ~L1 11 U.....:,_.;.,IS ,_. • -'}.ell.. I j

:...U "'';..-LI., u-'j< !$ ,;,.:0. i.:...r u~j< \;lt.i,.li,.:. • ..._t.;.;l,l'

-,~ ,;~.o,;,.,_...~.,;it,~.slj,, ........,S).~I, .. j... 11 .. r;T

.....,s;_,. •;},.,..:.S,__..,.)l;:l -'~ , .. .y..., :-~"' u.4-u-''-'.;,... . . ~i;c.S~ J .w.; lr ~-',.:; .. ~ J_,i., •J-bJ ;;J~~~J d.r' Ul-'1·,· .

. rJ> "-1-.s} ... ,.~,,.. r::--.s;l..cl j< ,.$ 4, ...... 4 -,t.., •;,1,.

,l.::...f;l.s,~. ,;1-;1 .sl.t-~ }}-'-1,};1 ....... J <} ..,o~, .. ~, .,.,.... u,._;S I; 1,\t.i,t:j .. \;r_f"L;, • _._, ..... ~~·\; <~J IS-'1}:..........,

•. ·, ,,..,.lli:l J .;_a, • .s .. r;T, r---S,L...,.\:5 , .. ~ IS-'.....:0 ,tT

. ..,_, ... .~~r , .. ~·

6197 J.o

..