Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

ARe the conditions or the market structure are favourable in jodhpur..so as to open new BPO??The full term paper with uestionnaires.

Citation preview

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    1/39

    1

    A

    TERM PAPER REPORT

    ON

    (A SURVEY)

    SUBMITTED TO: SUBMITTED BY:

    DR.PUJA GEHLOT MRINAL BOHRA

    (M.B.A., Ph.D.) (M.B.A. 2NDSem.)

    Department of Management Studies,

    Jai Narain Vyas University, Jodhpur.

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    2/39

    2

    ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

    I take this opportunity to express my indebtedness and convey my sincere thanks and

    gratitude to all those who have directly or indirectly helped and contributed towards the

    completion of this project. First and foremost, I would like to thank my supervisor Dr.Puja

    Gehlot (Asst.Professor)Department of Management Studies, J.N.V University, Jodhpur, for

    her constant guidance and support throughout this project and thankful, for providing me

    this opportunity.

    Last but not the least I would like to thank all the respondents who spared their valuable time

    in my study and my friends for their valuable suggestions and cooperation in doing the work

    on this term paper.

    MRINAL BOHRA

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    3/39

    3

    CERTIFICATE

    Department of Management Studies,Jai Narain Vyas University,

    Jodhpur (Raj.)

    2013-2015

    This is to certify that term paper entitled FEASIBILITY ANALYSIS OF BPO INDUSTRY IN

    JODHPUR is submittedby Mr. MRINAL BOHRA of second semester in partial fulfillment of

    M.B.A. degree course. The student has sincerely completed the Term paper in our institute.

    This work was prepared under my guidance and supervision.

    Place: Jodhpur Dr.Puja Gehlot

    Date: (Asst.Professor)

    DMS, JNVU, Jodhpur

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    4/39

    4

    CONTENTS

    Preface

    Introduction

    Objectives

    BPO industry in Jodhpur: what are BPOs and what do they offer?

    Evolution of BPO in jodhpur

    Segments in BPO

    Competitive landscape of BPO in jodhpur

    Drivers of BPO growth in jodhpur

    Challenges for HR professional in BPO

    Research methodology

    Data analysis

    Findings

    Conclusion

    References

    Questionnaire

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    5/39

    5

    A

    TERM PAPER

    ON

    FEASIBILITY ANALYSIS OF BPO INDUSTRY IN JODHPUR

    MRINAL BOHRA

    Department of Management Studies,

    Jai Narain Vyas University, Jodhpur

    Rajasthan, India

    E-mail:[email protected]

    PREFACE

    This project is based on BPO INDUSTRY IN JODHPUR. Business Process Outsourcingis the

    delegation of one or more of the business processes to an external provider, which in turn

    owns, manages and controls the selected processes based on some specific standards. It was

    started in JODHPUR in early 1990s by the British Airways who set-up their captive unit in

    Delhi.

    BPO in JODHPUR starts with low-end data entry processes, but now it moves up the value

    chain and deals in core business processes also. Both voice and non-voice BPO Industry exists

    in JODHPUR. Various types of services are performed, call centers being the attraction today

    for the youth.

    Cost competitiveness and talented pool of human resources are the key drivers in the

    growth of BPO industry, but still some factors such as underdeveloped infrastructure and

    competition from other low-cost countries are providing challenge to the Indian industry,

    which needs to be addressed carefully by the cooperation of government, NASSCOM and

    industry itself.

    Still, JODHPUR is shining in the BPO landscape and is the most attractive destination.

    mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]
  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    6/39

    6

    INTRODUCTION

    The origin of BPO does not lie in the modern industrial age, but it has its roots in the remote

    past. Thousands of years ago most people were engaged in hunting, farming, or handicraft

    related activities. They used to barter products among themselves. Distribution was limited

    to how far the vendor could walk and distribute, BPO was limited to how loud they could

    shout. Perhaps the earliest form of BPO was simply the trader shouting out the fact that he

    existed and naming what he had to sell in the local market place. As an instrument of

    marketing, BPO was an effective through multiple sales people reaching many people at one

    time. The American marketing association defines BPO as any paid form of non-personal

    presentation and promotion of ideas, goods or services by an identified sponsor. BPO

    doesnt change the physical properties of the product but then also it is the most

    compulsory expense for creating demand for the product.BPO plays an important role in

    todays competitive business world. BPO is used to introduce a new product in the market. It

    helps to compete with establish brands and, thereby, ensures the survival and success of

    new product. BPO creates demand for the product. BPO spread information about the

    product or services and makes consumers aware about it through various mass media which

    makes positive effect on the mind of the people and creates demand for the product.

    OBJECTIVES

    This survey report is aimed at identifying the fact that if the feasibility of running a BPO can

    be worked in Jodhpur region. Various groups of people working in different organizations are

    targeted for a research survey which will help in understanding the current market trends

    and will conclude about the possibility for the establishment of the BPO sector in Jodhpur

    area.

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    7/39

    7

    BPO INDUSTRY IN JODHPUR: WHAT ARE BPOs AND WHAT DO

    THEY OFFER?

    Business process outsourcing(BPO) is a form of outsourcing that involves the contracting of

    the operations and responsibilities of a specific business functions to a third-party service

    provider.

    People usually misunderstand both the terms, namely BPO and Call centers. But, however,

    there is a difference between BPO and Call Centers. BPO can be simply explained as: An

    organization that is responsible for performing a process or a part of a process of another

    business organization; outsourcing is done to save on costs or gain in productivity. Whereas,

    a call centre performs that part of a client's business which involves handling telephone calls.

    A call centre, for example, might handle customer complaints coming in over a telephone.

    Top BPOs and Business Process Outsourcing Companies are offering basic BPO Services, BPO

    Solutions services, Accounting BPO Services, Tax Processing BPO Services, Bookkeeping BPO

    Services, Chartered Accountants BPO Services, Medical Transcription BPO Services, Legal

    Transcription BPO Services and all types of BPO and offshore outsourcing BPO Solution from

    India.

    The Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) industry in India is a relatively young and nascent, a

    very much promising sector, less than a decade old in this business segment. Despite its

    recent arrival on the Indian map to form a part of the export-oriented IT software and

    services environment, the industry has shown amazing growth and future potential. The

    boom in this segment has created an unparalleled opportunity in India. What began as an

    activity confined to multinational companies, is today a broad based business platform

    backed by leading Indian IT software and services organizations and other third party

    providers.

    There are number ofbenefitsthe BPOs and Call centers provide:

    Major cost reduction

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    8/39

    8

    Better Valued Client Services

    Focus better on Value Added Services and business operations

    Computerized working (No messes with papers/notes).

    Despite its recent arrival on the Indian map to form a part of the export-oriented IT software

    and services environment, the industry has shown amazing growth and future potential. The

    industry has been growing very rapidly. It grew at a rate of 38% over 2005. Important

    business hubs of this industry in India are Bangalore, Hyderabad, Kolkata, Mumbai, Pune,

    Chennai, Ahmadabad and New Delhi. For the FY06 financial year the projections is of ` 7.2

    billion worth of services provided by this industry. The base in terms of headcount being

    roughly 400,000 people directly employed in this Industry.

    The global BPO Industry is estimated to be worth 120-150 billion rupees; of this the offshore

    BPO is estimated to be some ` 11.4 billion. India thus has some 5-6% share of the total

    Industry, but a commanding 63% share of the offshore component.

    BPO

    BASED ON WORK

    NON-VOICE

    BASED ON LOCATION

    VOICE ON-SHORE OFF-SHORE NEAR-SHORE

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    9/39

    9

    EVOLUTION OF BPO IN JODHPUR

    Outsourcing as a concept is probably one of the oldest and most commonly practiced. As a

    concept and practice it pervades all aspects of our livesdomestic as well as professional.

    The idea of outsourcing has its roots in the 'competitive advantage' theory propagated byAdam Smith in his book 'The Wealth of Nations' which was published in the year 1776. Over

    the years, the meaning of the term 'outsourcing' has undergone a sea-change.

    Evolution of BPO in JODHPUR can further be explained under two heads:

    1. HISTORY OF BPO in JODHPUR.

    2. VALUE CHAIN OF BPO in JODHPUR.

    1. HISTORY OF BPO IN JODHPUR: In JODHPUR BPO started with the British airways setting

    their back-office operations in Delhi in early 1980s. Starting from captive units Indian BPO

    moves to the third party BPOs. Thereafter the entry of IT-majors brightens the Indian BPO

    industry in global BPO landscape.

    Following diagram depicts briefly the history of BPO in JODHPUR:

    EARLY 1980s MID 1980s 1990S 2000 2010 2014 0NWARDS

    European

    airlines started

    its back-office

    operations in

    New Delhi.

    BRITISH

    AIRWAYSset its

    captive unit in

    Jodhpur.

    American

    express (AMEX)

    consolidated its

    JAPAC (Japan

    and Asia-Pacific)

    back-office

    operations in

    Jodhpur.

    General Electric

    starts an

    enterprise called

    GECIS (GE Capital

    International

    services) for voice

    operations in

    India. In 1994

    GECIS was spun off

    into GENPACT.

    The NEW

    TELECOM POLICYOF 1999ended the

    state monopoly on

    international

    calling facilities.

    This heralded the

    growth of

    inbound/outboun

    d call centers and

    data processing

    services.

    Pioneered by the

    GE THIRD-PARTYBPOs sprung up

    in India, thereby

    overtaking

    captives.EXL

    EFunds and Daksh

    started its third

    party BPOs in

    Noida, Mumbai

    and Gurgaon

    respectively.

    IT-MAJORS ENTERED

    INTO INDIA. All

    major Indian

    software

    organizations wentinto BPO including

    Infosys, Inforlinx, and

    Patni. By 2003 Daksh

    bought out by IBM,

    Quattro started in

    2009. Convergys,

    SITEL, Accenture,

    Hewlett Packard and

    dell also set up their

    shops in Jodhpur.

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    10/39

    10

    DATA-ENTRY

    DATA-

    CONVERSION

    CALL-CENTRE

    TRANSCRIPTION-PROCESSES-

    NON CORE

    TRANSCRIPTION

    PROCESSES-

    CORE

    2. VALUE CHAIN OF BPO IN JODHPUR:

    Value chain is a chain describing the value of business processes being outsourced to India.

    Value chain can be explained as the importance of business processes to the firm

    outsourcing its business operations. India is moving up in the value-chain. At the beginning

    only low end data entry processes were outsourced to India. With the passage of time trend

    goes on changing. From low value data entry processes chain moves up to core processes

    being outsourced now-a-days. It started with:

    MID-1990s- DATA ENTRY PROCESSES: Data entry simply includes entry of data from papers,

    books or any hard copy format to computer aided soft copy.

    DATA CONVERSION PROCESSES: Conversion of data across various databases on different

    platforms.

    LATE 1990s- CALL CENTRE SERVICES: Call centers are outlets that exist mainly to answer

    inbound or place outbound telephone calls and can exist for the purpose of sales, marketing,

    telemarketing, customer service, technical/non technical support or any other specific

    business activity.

    2010- TRANSCRIPTION PROCESSES: Transcription process implies transcribing the audio or

    visual information into electronic document form.Up till 2000 only non-core activities were

    outsourced. Then the trend changed and today the core activities also occupy a significant

    proportion in total Indian BPO pie. The value chain is explained briefly in the following

    diagram:

    MID

    2010s

    1990s

    TODAY

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    11/39

    11

    SEGMENTS IN BPO

    BPOs inJODHPUR are organized in many segments. Previously there was only low end voice

    operations were outsourced to India. In the early days voice operations were the major

    actors leaving a very small proportion for non-voice activities. But, as India moves up in the

    value chain, non-voice operations starting occupy a bigger proportion of the BPO pie. Except

    voice and non-voice, BPOs in JODHPUR can also be segmented into horizontal and vertical.

    So business process outsourcing can be segmented as:

    1. VOICE AND NON-VOICE BPO.

    2. HORIZONTAL AND VERTICAL BPO.

    1. VOICE AND NON-VOICE BPO:

    INBOUND SALES ACCOUNTING

    OUTBOUND SALES DATA ENTRY

    TELEMARKETING DATABASE MANAGEMENT

    CUSTOMER SERVIC CLAIMS PROCUREMENT

    ORDER PROCESSING TRANSCRIPTION

    TECHNICAL SUPPORT HUMAN RESOURCES

    FIGURE 10- CLASSIFICATION OF VOICE AND NON-VOICE BPO

    BPO

    VOICE-

    BPO

    NON-VOICE

    BPO

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    12/39

    12

    (A) VOICE BPO (FRONT OFFICE OPERATIONS)

    Voice outsourcing is also termed as front office outsourcing. Front office outsourcing services

    have to do with interactions directly with customers, usually over the telephone but can also

    include email, internet, fax, and other forms of interactive communications with customers.

    Organization can concentrate on high valued core business activities by outsourcing its non-

    core front-office operations. It also allows them to reduce the significant expense associated

    with voice element of business. And by outsourcing the non-core activities to the service

    provider who can handle them more efficiently and effectively, customer satisfaction can

    also be increased and create a sustainable, long term, productive relationship.

    Voice activities being outsourced include:

    INBOUND SALES:

    Inbound sales refers to the process where the customer calls your business as a result of

    stimulus such as a marketing promotion, a referral from someone, a direct mail campaign, a

    media advertisement, a contact number on your companys web page, or any type of

    marketing and sales activity where the logical next step in the sales process for the customer

    is to place a call to the business. For an inbound sales process, the call center agent works

    through the sales process to conclude with a sale for your company. Results include making

    a commitment to purchase or placing an actual order for a product or service. This could

    represent anything from a vacation package to a floral arrangement to a subscription to

    almost any type of purchase that can be done over the phone.

    OUTBOUND SALES:

    Outbound sales refer to the proactive selling of products and services using the telephone. In

    inbound selling your customer calls you but in the outbound sales you call your customer for

    affecting a sales activity. This includes contacting the customers who have already

    demonstrated interest by signing up or by contacting your company by mail, email, web,phone, or in-store activity.

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    13/39

    13

    TELEMARKETING:

    Conducting business has changed; its no longer possible to personally visit all your clients

    And customers, in fact with the popularity of the Internet, many clients may not even reside

    in the same city or even country. Establishing and creating a telemarketing service has

    Enabled businesses to connect with all their customers via the phone. A telemarketing

    Service allows you to keep track of customers as they close, merge and relocate. Keeping in

    Regular contact with your clients means being able to record their movements while

    maintaining a marketing and ongoing customer relationship.

    CUSTOMER SERVICE:

    Customer service covers a wide range of services providing assistance, support, information,

    and answers to your customers to a variety of questions and enquiries. Although generally

    customer service is done using inbound calls, it can also be used with outbound calls.

    Examples of outbound customer service include follow-up on orders, confirmation of receipt

    of a product or service, quality surveys with your customers, and more.

    ORDER PROCESSING:

    Order processing includes the process of taking information from your customers so that a

    specific transaction or order can be processed. This applies to either Business to Business or

    Business to Consumer relationships with customers.

    TECHNICAL SUPPORT:

    If your businesss product or service has some element of technology involved, telephone

    oriented technical support can help you cost effectively work with your customers to address

    and solve their questions in this area. The reality of business is that some of your customers

    may miss paying a bill. By using the telephone as a reminder service, a large amount of bills

    can be collected easily and effectively. Doing this sooner than later helps your businessmanages cash flow and improves results.

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    14/39

    14

    APPOINTMENT SETTING:

    For some businesses, a direct contact between people is required to complete the sale or

    provide the service. The challenge is getting the appointment with a potential client. This

    service allows businesses to leverage experts in the area of appointment setting to be able

    take a potential client from expressing interest in your businesss offer to setting up a

    specific time and day for a meeting between that potential client and an account

    representative from your company.

    HELP DESK:

    The help desk function is typically considered to be an internal company function for

    supporting your companys employees and businesses in your supply chain. It can also refer

    to a place for your customers to call to receive help with questions they have.

    MAREKT RESEARCH AND QUALITY SURVEYS:

    Market research or quality surveys help to learn more about your market or your business

    potential, and also helps in determining the quality of your service and products to

    customers. Experienced agents are able to contact and discuss with your existing or potential

    customers to gather valuable information to help you make business decisions.

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    15/39

    15

    COMPETITIVE LANDSCAPE OF BPO IN JODHPUR

    BPO Industry in JODHPUR is growing very fast. It is gaining ground everywhere. There is a lot

    of competition today in BPO landscape. Lets check out which are the major players in

    JODHPUR. We will study this under two heads:

    1. GENGREEN 1. DAKSH-E-SERVICES

    2. WNS GLOBAL 2. ISEVA

    3. IBM DAKSH 3. ICICI ONESOURCE

    4. ADITYA MINACS WORLDWIDE 4. EFUNDS INTERNATIONAL

    5. EXL SERVICE HOLDINGS 5. HCL TECH BPO

    FIGURE 16- TOP BPO COMPANIES IN JODHPUR.

    Now detailed description of all the major players in BPO ground:

    1. GENGREEN:

    Gengreen was born in 1997 as the India-based business process operations for GE Capital. In

    2005, with equity investments from General Atlantic and Oak Hill Capital Partners, it became

    an independent company and was rebranded Gengreen. It is India's No. 1 BPO firm.

    Gengreen manages business for companies around the world with a network of more than

    30 operations centers in nine countries. Gengreen offers services in finance and accounting,

    collections and customer service, insurance, supply chain and procurement, analytics,

    enterprise application and IT infrastructure.

    BASED ON REVENUE GENERATED BASED ON EMPLOYEE

    SATISFACTION

    TOP BPO COMPANIES IN JODHPUR (2013)

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    16/39

    16

    Accolades won by Gengreen

    'No.1 Best Performing BPO' and 'No.3 Leader in Human Capital Development' by Global Servicesmagazine,

    in 2008

    Top 10 in IAOP's 'Global Outsourcing 100' list, 2007-08

    'Top 10 Employer' distinction, Dalian, China, 2006-08

    'No.1 ITeS-BPO Company' in JODHPUR by NASSCOM, 2008-12

    2. WNS GLOBAL:

    WNS Global serves several industries, including travel, insurance, financial services,

    healthcare, professional services, manufacturing, distribution and retail. Warburg Pincus is

    the majority shareholder in WNS Global Services.

    The NASDAQ-listed company with more than 9,000 professionals was set up in 1996. Neeraj

    Bhargava is a co-founder of WNS (Holdings) Ltd and group chief executive officer. It posted

    quarterly revenue of $116.1 million for the fourth quarter ended March 31, 2008, up 4.9 per

    cent from the corresponding quarter last year. Its revenues stand at `459.9 million, up 30.5

    per cent from fiscal 2007.

    Accolades won by WNS Global

    Nasscom ranking: No. 1 BPO Company for the year 2013

    NeoIT Global Survey: No. 1 'Best Performing' BPOCompany / No. 1 in Human Capital

    3. DAKSH:

    The five-year old IBM Daksh was created by four professionals -- Sanjiv Agarwal, Pawan

    Vaish, MJ Aravind and Venkat Tedanki -- who saw a great opportunity in the business process

    outsourcing space. With no business model to follow, it was a big challenge to set up the

    company. IBM Daksh is known for a good leadership, a focussed vision and an undying

    passion. In April 2004, IBM Corporation acquired Daksh e-Services to serve as a global hub to

    manage business processes for clients from across the world. With 14 service delivery

    centres IN JODHPUR, IBM Daksh has more than 36 centers around the world. Today IBM

    Daksh employs more than 20,000 people. Pavan Vaish is the chief executive officer.

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    17/39

    17

    Accolades for IBM Daksh

    Frost & Sullivan Contact Center Outsourcing Vendor of the Year 2013

    Most Respected BPO Company in JODHPUR(Business World)

    IBM Daksh tops the 2007 Global Outsourcing 100

    4. ADITYA BIRLA MINACS WORLDWIDE:

    Aditya Birla Minacs is part of the `24 billion global conglomerate, the Aditya Birla Group.

    Aditya Birla Minacs was formed when Minacs, Canada's leading BPO Company, and

    Transworks, the BPO arm of Aditya Birla Group, joined hands to become a leading global

    business process outsourcing player.

    Aditya Birla Minacs clocked revenues to the tune of `392 million (or about Rs 1,575 crore) till

    March 2009, a 17 per cent rise over the previous year's `335 million. With over 26 years of

    experience, Aditya Birla Minacs offers BPO solutions for Fortune 500 clients. Minacs has

    more than 12,000 employees at locations in North America, Europe and Asia.

    It serves clients in automotive, banking, financial services, insurance, telecommunications

    and technology verticals. Dev Bhattacharya is the managing director for Aditya Birla Minacs

    Worldwide Ltd, a subsidiary of Aditya Birla Nuvo

    .

    Awards for Aditya Birla Minacs Worldwide

    Dataquest (annual Top 20 BPO listing) - Ranked as India's No 2 BPO company

    NASSCOM 2009-13 - Ranked as India's third largest BPO, based on export revenues

    NASSCOM - Among Top 100 IT innovators in JODHPUR IT People Group.

    5. TRC BPO

    TRC BPO is one of the leader players in the outsourcing industry. It offers services in areas

    such as finance and accounting, banking, HR outsourcing, KPO, insurance, payroll,

    healthcare, telecom, media, travel and entertainment. TCS operates from more than 41

    countries and has more than 155 offices across the globe. Its head office is located in

    Bangalore. It has branches in Jodhpur .While Tata Consultancy Services is India's top

    software company, TRC BPO established a stronghold in the BPO space. The TRC group

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    18/39

    18

    posted a consolidated net profit of Rs 1,290.61 crore (Rs 12.90 billion) for the first quarter

    ended June 30, 2008, an increase of 7.3 per cent compared to the year-ago period.

    Accolades for TCS BPO

    In 2006, TCS BPO was named as one of the world's top BPO providers by the International Association of

    Outsourcing Professionals.

    6. EXL Service Holdings

    EXL Service Holdings came into existence in April 1999 in Delaware, US. It was founded by a

    group of professionals including Vikram Talwar (now executive chairman) and Rohit Kapoor,

    who is now the CEO. Vikram was then the CEO and managing director of Ernst & Young, and

    Rohit managed international investments for clients at Deutsche Bank.

    In August 2001, Conseco acquired EXL and operated as its wholly owned subsidiary. Later, in

    November 2002, Oak Hill Capital Partners L.P. and FT Ventures along with members of the

    senior management team bought EXL from Conseco making it a third party pure-play

    business process outsourcing service provider. The company has seen a fast-paced growth

    with 50 clients and staff strength of 8,200 employees. Revenues for the quarter ended

    March 31, 2008 were $50.9 million compared to $39.9 million in the quarter ended March

    31, 2007, an increase of 27.8 per cent.

    Accolades for EXL Service Holdings

    Recognized as one of the Top 100 hot growth companies for 2007 Among the top 10 best performing BPOs

    in CMP Media's list No.1 rising star in the Global Outsourcing list by International Association of Outsourcing

    Professionals.

    7. ISEVA:

    ISeva is a leading BPO and is a part of e4eGroup. It is an ISO: 9001 2000 Certified company

    and provides services in customer care, transaction processing and data processing. ISeva

    has two facilities in INDIA, which are in JODHPUR and JAIPUR. It has employee strength of

    1,000.

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    19/39

    19

    8. EFUNDS INTERNATIONAL:

    Although Efunds was ranked fourth in the overall E-SAT survey, it had outsmarted its rival

    companies by a convincing margin to get the top slot as the Most Preferred Employer. It has

    been chosen by the most number of employees as a Dream Company to work with. Efunds

    provides excellent services in customer care (both voice and email process), transaction

    processes and back office operations. Its areas of functioning are Financial Services,

    Electronic Funds Network, Retailers, Telecom, Software Development and other businesses.

    Efunds has recruited over 4,000 employees in its branches worldwide. In JODHPUR it has one

    facility in Pal Road and two in Housing Board. It also has two software development centers

    in Chennai. According to sources, Efunds is on the verge of receiving the BS 7799 certificate

    as it has already implemented this internationally recognized security standard in the

    organization.

    9. NIIT SMART SERVE:

    NIIT Smart Serve is a global BPO company, which has expanded its outsourcing business over

    the years. Its services include Insurance, Financial Services, Real Estate, Transportation and

    Technology. The current employee strength of NIIT Smart Serve is more than 800. Its service

    center is located in Gurgaon (New Delhi NCR). It offers services both in customer care and

    back office processing.

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    20/39

    20

    DRIVERS OF BPO GROWTH IN JODHPUR

    A driver is most commonly afactor that contributes to thegrowth of a particular business.

    There are mainly six important business drivers that are pushing enterprises to consider the

    BPO options in JODHPUR. These are:

    1. ABUNDANT TALENT:

    Jodhpurs young demographic profile is an inherent advantage complemented by an

    academic infrastructure that generates a large pool of English speaking talent. Talent

    suitability concerns are being addressed through a combination of government, academia

    and industry led initiatives. It includes efforts by NASSCOM and other education agencies like

    UGC and AICTE to facilitate industry inputs on curriculum and teaching.

    2. SUSTAINED COST COMPETITIVENESS:

    Jodhpur has a strong track record of delivering a significant cost advantage, with clients

    regularly reporting savings of 25%-50% over the original cost base. The ability to achieve

    such high levels of cost advantage by sourcing to India is driven by the ability to access highly

    skilled talent at lower wage cost.

    3. CONTINUED FOCUS ON QUALITY:

    Demonstrated process quality and expertise in service delivery has been a key factor driving

    Jodhpurs leadership in global service delivery. Since the inception of industry in JODHPUR,

    players within the India has been focusing on quality initiatives, to align themselves with

    international standards.

    http://www.investorwords.com/1872/factor.htmlhttp://www.investorwords.com/2258/growth.htmlhttp://www.investorwords.com/2258/growth.htmlhttp://www.investorwords.com/1872/factor.html
  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    21/39

    21

    4. WORLD CLASS INFORMATION SECURITY ENVIRONMENT:

    Indian authorities have built a strong foundation for an info-source environment in the

    country. These include strengthening the regulatory framework through proposed

    amendments to further strengthen the IT Act-2011.

    5. RAPID GROWTH IN KEY BUSINESS INFRASTRUCTURE:

    BPO sector has been a key beneficiary with the cost of international connectivity declining

    rapidly and service level improving significantly. The growth is taking place not only in

    existing urban centres but also in satellite towns and smaller cities.

    6. ENABLING BUSINESS POLICY AND REGULATORY ENVIRONMENT:

    The enabling policy environment in JODHPUR was instrumental in catalyzing the early phase

    of growth in this sector. Policy makers in JODHPUR have laid special emphasis on

    encouraging foreign participation, with participating firms enjoying minimum regulatory and

    policy restrictions along with a broad range of fiscal and procedural incentives.

    B. ISSUES AND CHALLENGES IN BPO GROWTH:

    1. INFRASTRUCTURE CHALLENGE:

    Indias ITES-BPO industry continues to attract significant business from both the US and

    Western Europe. While national issues with infrastructure, e.g. telecommunications system

    etc is being addressed, the local infrastructure (roads, bridges, airports, urban

    transportation, etc) is becoming a bottleneck to the expansion of capacity. Getting a

    connection is still not a hassle-free job. Threat of competition from other emerging countries

    like Philippines, Ireland, Mexico and Brazil among others.

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    22/39

    22

    2. MOVING UP THE VALUE CHAIN:

    Customers are looking for vendors who can provide end-to-end solutions. Indian vendors are

    using several methods like tie-ups with existing players, acquisitions, investing in research

    and development and leveraging industry best practices for expansion.

    3. SHRINKING PROFIT MARGINS:

    To sustain in the highly competitive market, the players are looking for newer revenue

    sources and opportunities to keep cash flowing in. Again with service level agreements

    becoming stringent and sales cycles stretching far in international deals, the BPO service

    providers need deeper pockets and financial muscles. High initial capital investments in the

    industry, long gestational periods, competition leading to reduced billing rates, appreciation

    of rupee against the US dollar have led to increased margin pressures and increased industry

    consolidation.

    4. HUMAN RESOURCE ISSUES:

    Another major problem is the high attrition and growth aspirations of the workforce. Odd

    hours at job and stress are supposed to be major causes of high attrition rate which

    increases recruitment and training costs. The service providers need to spell out a

    comprehensive human resource policy that outlines a clear career progression path for the

    employees.

    5. OTHERS:

    There are several other important issues facing the Indian ITeS-BPO companies which are

    given below

    US subprime crisis and possible slowdown in the US economy may hit Indian ITeS-BPO

    industry as the US contributes a lions share to the Indian ITeS-BPO export revenue

    Declining profit margin due to rise in operating cost coupled with rise in real estateprices in Tier I and II cities, wage inflation etc.

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    23/39

    23

    CHALLENGES FOR HR PROFESSIONAL IN BPO

    HR professional has to face various challenges other than the above stated. These are:

    BRAND EQUITY:

    People still consider BPO to be "low brow", thus making it difficult to attract the best talent.

    So HR managers have to work for its promotion.

    STANDARD PRE JOB TRAINING:

    Again, due to the wide variety of the jobs, lack of general clarity on skill sets, etc, there is no

    standard curriculum, which could be designed and followed.

    BENCHMARKS:

    There are hardly any benchmarks for compensation and benefits, performance or HR

    policies. Everyone is charting their own course.

    DEMAND OF CUSTOMER COMPANIES:

    Customer-companies tend to demand better results from outsourcing partners than what

    they could actually expect from their own departments. "When the job is being done 10,000

    miles away, demands on parameters such as quality, turn around timeliness, information

    security, business continuity and disaster recovery, etc, are far higher than at home. So, how

    to be more efficient than the original?

    LACK OF FOCUSED TRAINING AND CERTIFICATIONS:

    Again there is not any kind of training which can be provided to the employees in BPO and

    no bench-marks and certifications to rank them.

    Given this background, the recruiting and compensation challenges of HR departments are

    only understandable.

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    24/39

    24

    Research Methodology

    Primary Data

    Primary data will be collected by using survey method; survey conducted will be on visiting

    the particular BPO offices and centers basis with the help of open and closed end

    questionnaires.

    Sample size

    5-10 Offices

    50 Clients

    Sample inspection- People of all segments of different range including all income groups- the

    lower income group, the middle income group as well as the higher income group.

    Area of research

    Jodhpur

    Sampling technique

    Random

    Secondary Data

    Secondary data will be collected from Magazines, Newspapers, and Internet and

    other sources.

    Tools for measurement

    Open and closed end questionnaires

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    25/39

    25

    DATA ANALYSIS

    After received all of the completed questionnaires from the respondents, there are few steps

    taken to analyze the data. By using Descriptive statistics it is to describe the data such asfrequency, percentage, average, and standard deviation. Then, examining factor analysis will

    be conducted on all items in the instrument. It is very important to ensure that every of the

    step items on the survey are independently measured the theoretical constructs they were

    intended to measure.

    In this study, we are investigating the factors that will help in finding feasible conditions and

    perception towards the establishment of BPO industry. Therefore, a systematic sampling

    approach is being used. The population of this study is the students of Universities and

    working adults / young executives. A total of 50 questionnaires will be distributed to collect

    usable responses throughout the data collection period. I believe that we will be able to

    obtain sufficient information with the amount of 50 respondents that required for the data

    analysis purpose. To avoid biases during the process of conducting the surveys, the

    questionnaires will be randomly distributed to the respondents.

    In order to understand the factors and perception towards the BPO industry, the main

    primary data collection method will be the questionnaires. Questionnaires are a way to

    obtain data needed from a large number of respondents in a specific period of time with it

    lesser time consuming with high response rates and an effectively and efficiently. Email is

    also a method that enables us to reach the respondents from the nationwide and also cost

    saving. The close format questions will be existing in the questionnaires. To be easier to

    calculate and analyze the statistical data we will obtain it by restricting the area of answer

    set.

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    26/39

    26

    FINDINGS

    QUESTION-1

    PERIOD OF WORKING IN THE ORGANISATION:

    Period < 1 year 1-2 years 2-5 years >5years Total

    Respondent 21 13 36 18 40

    Percentage 54 32.5 9 4.5 10

    Findings:From the above information, we can find that out of total sample of 40 respondents almost 54% of them

    are working in the organization for a less than 1 year.

    Almost 32.5% of them working between 1 to 2 years in the organization while 9% of them were working

    between 2 to 5 years.

    The most experienced employees were less; they were about 4.5% who have worked for more than 5

    years.

    Analysis:

    As more than 50%(54%), as a total, of employees working in the various organization are working for less

    than one year, It clearly indicates the sign of high attrition rate(the rate at which employees leave the

    organizations) in BPOs and Call centers.

    If we analyze the whole chart more closely, we find that more than 85% of employees have been in the

    organizations for less than 2 years which reveals that employees like to change their jobs very frequently,

    may be because of lack of motivation or satisfaction purposes.

    The concrete reasons for this would be dug out in the following questions and their results.

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    27/39

    27

    QUESTION-2

    MONTHLY INCOME:

    Income 3000-6000 6000-9000 9000-12000 >12000 Total

    Respondent 19 14 32 24 40

    Percentage 49 37 8 6 10

    Findings:

    Out of total respondents, 49% respondents fall under the category of monthly income of around Rs. 3000

    to 6000 while 37% of them are getting around Rs. 6000 to 9000.

    Where at the other side the employees who were getting salary of Rs. 9000 to 12000, were only 8% while

    there were only 6% employees who were getting salary above Rs. 12000.

    Analysis:

    Nearly half (50%) of the employees work in the call centre fall under the category of Rs.300-6000. It may

    be due to poor financial conditions and also, the education level doesnt matter in other job .

    As the attrition rate is high in this industry, it also result in lower initial salary for the employees, because

    employees will have to accept the salary which ranges mainly from 3000 to 6000 Rupees in Ahmadabad.

    37% of employees fall under the category of salary income of Rs. 6000-9000 which can be said to be a

    standard in this industry but the percentage of which is very low, leading to the conclusion, exploitation of

    candidates.

    Nearly 15% of employees receive their salary in 5 digits which mainly of the employees working for more

    than 4-5 years.

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    28/39

    28

    QUESTION-3

    REASONS FOR JOINING THE ORGANISATION:

    Findings:

    As we see that 63% of employees believe that they find better job environment in this industry than

    working at anywhere else, and 61% agree that they have the reason for growth opportunities to join this

    organization.

    This is followed by Good salary (53%), Opportunity of making better friend circle (36%), Flexibility of

    working (34%), Job content (29%), Transport facility available (21%), and the remaining..

    Analysis:

    The question was purposed to reveal the reasons why employees join this industry

    Since the responding employees were allowed to name the most important reasons for joining, the

    percentage do not add up 100%

    The top 3 reasons for joining this industry are:

    Good work environment

    High growth opportunities

    Salary is good

    The reasons for joining the organization might be a growing IT and ITES industry as well as growing

    number of graduates as well as post graduates focusing on higher growth prospectus. The other reasons

    might be salary, good working environments and the others what our survey has revealed.

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    29/39

    29

    QUESTION-4(A)

    MONETORY BENEFITS EMPLOYEES GET:

    Benefits Bonus Commission Overtime

    benefit

    Travel

    allowance

    Total

    Responses 12 14 17 18 40

    Percentage 29.41 8.33 43.13 19.12 10

    Finding:From the above information we come to know that 43.13% of the total employees get the benefit of the

    over time they have done.

    Whereas 29.41% said that they get bonus. 19.12% said that they get travel allowances while only 8.33%

    said that they get commission.

    Analysis:

    As nearly 45% of the total employees gets the benefit of overtime implying that every BPO and Call

    Centre provide a sufficient amount of benefits to the employee so that the employee like to overtime in

    their job

    Almost 30% get bonus which clearly shows that each and every organization provide bonus to the

    employee at the end of the year so that employee are motivated and made willing to do the work sincerely

    Some company like Motif Info and Emphasis Solution provide travel allowance to the employee to make

    the employee feel comfortable and to increase the satisfaction level

    We find that most of the companies do not provide any type of commission to their employees (It also

    depends upon the type and nature of BPOs for e.g. Inbound and Outbound call centers etc.)

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    30/39

    30

    QUESTION-4(B)

    NON-MONETARY BENEFITS:

    Benefit Travelling

    service

    Meals Insurance Sufficient

    breaks

    Awards &

    recognition

    Total

    Responses 4 4 14 17 17 40

    Percentage 2 2 2 2.33 2.33 10

    Findings:

    Asking about the non-monetary benefits, 29.33% of the total responses replied that the employees get

    awards & recognition and sufficient breaks in the organization.

    24.33% said that the employees get free insurance in the organization. While the remaining almost 9%

    said that the employees get meals and travelling services from the organization.

    Analysis:

    We find that insurance, sufficient breaks and award and recognition play major role in non monetary

    benefits given by the organizations.

    Nearly 30% companies provide sufficient (three breaks) to the employees to ensure that their

    productivity does not decease and the employees can work freely during their job hours, also to make sure

    that they do not get bored and lead to fatigue which in turn leads to dissatisfaction.

    30% of companies also provide insurance to their employee to ensure employees security so that they

    can work without any fear in their job, but again only 30% of companies, which is very low (Hidden

    satisfaction motive may be there).

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    31/39

    31

    QUESTION-5

    SATISFIED WITH WORKING IN THE ORGANISATION OR NOT:

    Options Yes No Total

    Respondent 38 2 40

    Percentage 5 5 10

    Finding:

    Almost 95% of the total employees said that they are more or less satisfied with working in the

    organization

    The rest 5% of the employee said that they are not at all satisfied with working in the organization.

    Analysis:

    As many as 95% of employees responded positively saying that they are happy working in the

    organization and are more or less satisfied.

    Only a very small parentage of employees replied negatively who might be having some or the other

    problems relating to monetary aspects or the environment concerns which may be dug out and their

    resistance should be identified to make them satisfied.

    To dig out the level of satisfaction, we asked further question which reveals the more insight about their

    satisfaction level.

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    32/39

    32

    QUESTION-6

    LEVEL OF SATISFACTION:

    Level of satisfaction Low Average High Total

    Respondent 30 2 12 40

    Percentage 1 6 3 10

    Finding:

    Asking about their satisfaction level, 59% said that they are not much satisfied with the organization, it

    can be said that their satisfaction level is average

    Almost 33% said that they are highly satisfied with the organization

    While the remaining 8% were least satisfied

    Analysis:

    The question was purposed to identify the level of satisfaction of employees who are satisfied(from

    among 380 employees)

    As far as satisfaction is concerned, as the above question revealed that 95% of employees are satisfied

    working within the organizations but when asked actually about the level of satisfaction, it reveals that

    majority(nearly 60% of employees) of them are satisfied on average basis

    Only 3% of employees say that the satisfaction level of them is very low inferring that they are least

    satisfied, not up to the level it should be

    Those who are highly satisfied belongs to 33%, which doesnt have any issue regarding their satisfaction

    working in the organizations

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    33/39

    33

    QUESTION-7

    WHETHER THE COMPANY IS VERY OPEN TO IDEAS AND SUGGESTIONS GIVEN BY EMPLOYEES:

    Options Strongly

    agree

    Agree Disagree Strongly

    disagree

    Total

    Respondent 21 17 16 0 40Percentage 3 1 1 0 10

    Finding:

    Out of the total, almost 53% of the employees have strongly agreed with the fact that the company is

    very open to ideas and suggestions given by the employees

    43% are agreeing with this, but not to the level it should be

    There were only 4% who were disagreeing, and nobody falls under the category of strongly Disagree

    Analysis:

    The chart shows that out of 100%, more than half 53% are strongly agree that the company is very open

    to ideas and suggestions given by employees meaning caring for employees suggestions and their

    recommendations

    They believe that company approaches very friendly to the employees suggestions and their ideas and

    actually implement it in the organization, if it is concrete in nature

    If all and all we see, nearly 95% of employees reported favorably that their company believes in open-

    door policies and wants their employees to participate in the organization

    The rest only 4% of employees believe that they are somehow agree, but not very concretely

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    34/39

    34

    QUESTION-8

    WHETHER THE CULTURE OF THE COMPANY IS SUCH THAT IT CREATES WORK ENVIRONMENT:

    Options Positive Negative Stressful Very bad Total

    Respondent 31 5 8 6 40

    Percentage 6 1.5 1 1.5 10

    Finding:

    Out of the total employees 79% said that there is a positive environment in the organization 12.5% said

    that there is a negative environment.

    Almost 7% said that the environment of the company is very stressful in the company and almost 1.5%

    said that it is very bad.

    Analysis:

    As the chart indicates,majority of employees(nearly 80%) are agree that the environment within which

    they work is positive and makes them to work and leads to their motivation and satisfaction in the

    organizations.

    The employee who replied to Negative is nearly 13%, which makes us to infer that the factors that

    creates negative environment prevail in the organization.

    7% of employees came up with the opinion that the environment in the organization is such that it

    creates stress within them, may be because of the pressure and the load of the work, call handling or the

    travelling stress or the way they interact with their subordinates and colleagues.

    Those factors that create this negative environment in the organization should be identified and their

    resistance should be removed to increase the satisfaction level of employees.

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    35/39

    35

    QUESTION-10

    WHETHER EMLOYEES RECEIVE THE PROPER TRAINING WHEN EMPLOYEE NEEDS TO DO THEIR JOB WELL:

    Options Strongly

    agree

    Agree Disagree Strongly

    disagree

    Total

    Respondent 24 12 2 2 40

    Percentage 6 2 1 1 10

    Finding:

    Almost 60% of the total employees are strongly agree that they get the proper training when they need

    to do their job well.

    While 32% are agreeing to this fact.

    The remaining 8% are not agreeing to this fact, out of which 5% is disagree and 3% is strongly disagree.

    Analysis:

    Training is the base for working in the organization.

    We found that most of the employees responded that they are being given the training by their

    organization whenever it is needed.

    This shows that the employees can work easily and safely because they are provided with the training.

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    36/39

    36

    CONCLUSION

    The research was aimed at identifying the factors that influence the satisfaction level ofemployees working in BPOs and Call centers at JODHPUR. I hereby would like to conclude y

    research by saying that employee satisfaction is not the result of only one or two factor. But

    it is sourced from various factors like working environment within which they work, relations

    with their colleagues, supervisors, bosses, and rest of the employees, their expectation when

    they join the organization and the realization of the same and many more what we have

    highlighted in our project.

    Its a result of these factors mentioned above that plays major role in determination of the

    satisfaction level of employee. Employee is motivated and get satisfied not because only

    what they perceive and what they realize after joining, but it is their belief, values and the

    way of working along with their attitude towards organization and work that we think, put

    major emphasis in determining the satisfaction level of employees. Though it is agreed that a

    very modern, educated, youth oriented and sophisticated industry like BPOs and Call

    centers, employees tend to believe what they think is more rewarding and shining for them,

    is appropriate and a growth fuelling for them. I think employees are what they think and

    believe in, beyond a point. I do believe that satisfaction level of employees is going up in this

    industry, but challenges remain at the same level. Organizations and HR team will have to

    work hard to convert a dissatisfied or less dissatisfied employee into a more satisfied,

    motivated and a result oriented employee. Satisfaction level of employees can be increased

    by taking into account various stets and programs along with concrete policies, this major

    problems of this kind, we think, can be lowered down. Also recommendation of ours can be

    a great help to this industry.

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    37/39

    37

    REFERENCES

    Report of Journal of industrial Engineering and Management

    A report on Enhancing Global Competition in BPO: What India should do? By Dr. S.

    Srinivasan.

    A research paper on Indian Call centers by Shanti Nandlal Tiwari, a T.Y.B.M.S. Student

    India's publishing BPO industry to cross USD 1.2 billion by 2012-A report.

    A DQ-IDC INDIA SURVEY: BPO Employee Satisfaction Survey 2003, 2004,2007,2008.

    Ahmedabad, Jaipur and Nagpur amongst 31 emerging cities globally for the IT / BPO

    industryKPMG Report.

    A report on Linking Employee Satisfaction with Productivity,Performance and Customer

    Satisfaction.

    The book Research Methodology by Panneerselvem R. /first edition/New Delhi

    Publication, Prentice hall of India Pvt. Ltd., 2005/ Page referred to from 1 to 16, 17 to 38, and

    218.

    Research Methodology by M.C. Burney D.H./ 1st

    Edition/Singapore, Thomson India Pvt.

    Ltd., 2001/ Page referred to from 1 to 111.

    Research Methodology for Management by Sajahan S./ 2nd

    Edition/ New Delhi Publication

    House, 2005/ Page refereed to from 1 to 144, 247 to 378.

    Designing and Managing a Research Project by Michael Jay Polo and David Walter/ 1st

    Edition/ A division of scope India Publication/ Page referred to from 1 to 53

    Articles Collected from Business line, Magazines and Journals.

    A report on Let Your Call Center Customer Service Representatives be a Judge!

    commissioned by manpower -September 2013.

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    38/39

    38

    Questionnaire for Studying the Feasibility of BPOs in Jodhpur

    Purpose:

    The survey is aimed at identifying the factors that how the feasibility of running a BPO

    can work in Jodhpur region. The data and information given by you in this questionnaire will

    be kept confidential and used for educational purposes only.

    Name: _____________________________________________________________

    Gender: _________ Age: ______ Designation: _____________________

    Organization: _______________________________________________________

    Questions:

    1.How long have you been working in an organization?

    less than 1 year 1-2 years

    2-5 years more than 5 years

    2.

    Your monthly income:

    Rs. 3000-6000 Rs.6000-9000

    Rs. 9000-12000 above Rs. 12000

    3. Specify the reason/s for joining the organization:-

    (You may tick more than one option)

    Good work environment High growth opportunities

    Salary is good Transport facility available

    Job content can make a lot of friends

    Flexibility of time didnt get a better job

    Education level does not matter

    Others, please specify: ______________________________

  • 5/21/2018 Analysis the feasibilty of BPO in Jodhpur

    39/39

    39

    4.Do you feel these monetary and non-monetary benefits motivate you and affect your

    satisfaction?

    Yes

    No

    5.

    (I) Please indicate the level of satisfaction from the job.

    Low

    Average

    High

    If No, then please specify the reason/s:

    _________________________________________

    6.

    The company is very open to ideas and suggestions given by employees:

    Strongly Agree Agree

    Disagree Strongly Disagree

    7.The culture of the company is such that it creates work environment

    Positive Negative

    Highly Positive Highly negative

    8. I am satisfied with the kind of salary hikes I get:

    Satisfied Highly satisfied

    Dissatisfied Highly Dissatisfied

    9. There is a strong feeling of teamwork and cooperation in the organization

    Strongly Agree Agree

    Disagree

    Strongly Disagree

    10.I receive the training I need to do my job well

    Strongly Agree Agree

    Disagree Strongly Disagree

    Signature: ______________

    THANK YOU FOR GIVING YOUR VALUABLE TIME