19
Introduction Ion Pump Baking and Testing EIGB Design and Testing Conclusions An Improved Vacuum System for Storing Highly Charged Ions in a Penning Trap Damien Robertson - TITAN Summer 2011 August 24, 2011 Damien Robertson - TITAN Summer 2011 An Improved Vacuum System

An Improved Vacuum System - for Storing Highly Charged Ions in … › intern › documents › presentation_D... · 2011-08-25 · Introduction Ion Pump Baking and Testing EIGB Design

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: An Improved Vacuum System - for Storing Highly Charged Ions in … › intern › documents › presentation_D... · 2011-08-25 · Introduction Ion Pump Baking and Testing EIGB Design

IntroductionIon Pump Baking and Testing

EIGB Design and TestingConclusions

An Improved Vacuum System

for Storing Highly Charged Ions in a Penning Trap

Damien Robertson - TITAN Summer 2011

August 24, 2011

Damien Robertson - TITAN Summer 2011 An Improved Vacuum System

Page 2: An Improved Vacuum System - for Storing Highly Charged Ions in … › intern › documents › presentation_D... · 2011-08-25 · Introduction Ion Pump Baking and Testing EIGB Design

IntroductionIon Pump Baking and Testing

EIGB Design and TestingConclusions

Agenda

Introduction

Ion Pump Baking and Testing

EIGB Design and Testing

Conclusions

Damien Robertson - TITAN Summer 2011 An Improved Vacuum System

Page 3: An Improved Vacuum System - for Storing Highly Charged Ions in … › intern › documents › presentation_D... · 2011-08-25 · Introduction Ion Pump Baking and Testing EIGB Design

IntroductionIon Pump Baking and Testing

EIGB Design and TestingConclusions

The Motivation

Motivation

Gave valves providesafety in event ofvacuum failure.

Interlocks - gave valvesclose, high voltage powershut off.

Compartments rely onionization and convectiongauges.

Convection gaugeoperates in mtorr range.

Ion gauge interferes withMCP.

MPET

IonPump

MCP

Turbo Pump

Turbo Pump

GV1

GV2 GV3

IG1

IG2

GVM

Damien Robertson - TITAN Summer 2011 An Improved Vacuum System

Page 4: An Improved Vacuum System - for Storing Highly Charged Ions in … › intern › documents › presentation_D... · 2011-08-25 · Introduction Ion Pump Baking and Testing EIGB Design

IntroductionIon Pump Baking and Testing

EIGB Design and TestingConclusions

The Motivation

Ion Gauge Interference

Damien Robertson - TITAN Summer 2011 An Improved Vacuum System

Page 5: An Improved Vacuum System - for Storing Highly Charged Ions in … › intern › documents › presentation_D... · 2011-08-25 · Introduction Ion Pump Baking and Testing EIGB Design

IntroductionIon Pump Baking and Testing

EIGB Design and TestingConclusions

The Motivation

Charge Exchange

Higher pressure translates into greater likelihood that ionsmay interact with stray molecules.

Changing the charge state of ions is problematic especially forHCI.

Low vacuum and ion gauges can contribute to chargeexchange by making the vacuum worse.

Critical that UHV is achieved for mass measurement, MPET.

Damien Robertson - TITAN Summer 2011 An Improved Vacuum System

Page 6: An Improved Vacuum System - for Storing Highly Charged Ions in … › intern › documents › presentation_D... · 2011-08-25 · Introduction Ion Pump Baking and Testing EIGB Design

IntroductionIon Pump Baking and Testing

EIGB Design and TestingConclusions

Ion Pump BakingIon Pump Testing

Ion Pump Baking Preparation

Damien Robertson - TITAN Summer 2011 An Improved Vacuum System

Page 7: An Improved Vacuum System - for Storing Highly Charged Ions in … › intern › documents › presentation_D... · 2011-08-25 · Introduction Ion Pump Baking and Testing EIGB Design

IntroductionIon Pump Baking and Testing

EIGB Design and TestingConclusions

Ion Pump BakingIon Pump Testing

Ion Pump Baking

Start pressure 1.78 × 10−10 torr, end pressure 5.43 × 10−11

torr.

Damien Robertson - TITAN Summer 2011 An Improved Vacuum System

Page 8: An Improved Vacuum System - for Storing Highly Charged Ions in … › intern › documents › presentation_D... · 2011-08-25 · Introduction Ion Pump Baking and Testing EIGB Design

IntroductionIon Pump Baking and Testing

EIGB Design and TestingConclusions

Ion Pump BakingIon Pump Testing

Ion Pump Operation

Large permanent magnets,HV cathode plates.

Honeycombed cylindersmaintain plasma that ionizesair molecules.

Ions are accelerated towardscathode plates, are buried orsputter.

Ion pump has three HVsettings, 3 kV, 5 kV and 7kV.

Damien Robertson - TITAN Summer 2011 An Improved Vacuum System

Page 9: An Improved Vacuum System - for Storing Highly Charged Ions in … › intern › documents › presentation_D... · 2011-08-25 · Introduction Ion Pump Baking and Testing EIGB Design

IntroductionIon Pump Baking and Testing

EIGB Design and TestingConclusions

Ion Pump BakingIon Pump Testing

Testing Procedure

Ion Pump had not been activated for two years.

Correct starting procedure was observed.

All three settings were tried while manual gate valve was bothopen and closed.

Pressure allowed to stabilize after setting changed andrecorded.

Ran through twice to ensure reproducibility.

Damien Robertson - TITAN Summer 2011 An Improved Vacuum System

Page 10: An Improved Vacuum System - for Storing Highly Charged Ions in … › intern › documents › presentation_D... · 2011-08-25 · Introduction Ion Pump Baking and Testing EIGB Design

IntroductionIon Pump Baking and Testing

EIGB Design and TestingConclusions

Ion Pump BakingIon Pump Testing

Testing Results

Gate valve open (torr) Gate valve closed (torr)

7 kV 1.0 ± 0.1 × 10−10 1.1 ± 0.1 × 10−10

5 kV 5.4 ± 0.2 × 10−11 9.2 ± 0.3 × 10−11

3 kV 3.8 ± 0.1 × 10−11 7.2 ± 0.2 × 10−11

All trials showed ion pump performed better with manual gatevalve open.

Based on present test, optimum setting is: Manual gate valveopen, HV set to 3 kV.

Optimum setting was used and allowed to pump a further twodays, pressure went off scale, < 1.0 × 10−11 torr.

Damien Robertson - TITAN Summer 2011 An Improved Vacuum System

Page 11: An Improved Vacuum System - for Storing Highly Charged Ions in … › intern › documents › presentation_D... · 2011-08-25 · Introduction Ion Pump Baking and Testing EIGB Design

IntroductionIon Pump Baking and Testing

EIGB Design and TestingConclusions

Concept and DesignTesting

Theory

Ion gauge produces chargedparticles

Through the use ofelectrostatic barrier, chargedparticles can be contained.

IonGauge

+V

-V

Front Screen

Mid ScreenGround Screen

A+

e-

Damien Robertson - TITAN Summer 2011 An Improved Vacuum System

Page 12: An Improved Vacuum System - for Storing Highly Charged Ions in … › intern › documents › presentation_D... · 2011-08-25 · Introduction Ion Pump Baking and Testing EIGB Design

IntroductionIon Pump Baking and Testing

EIGB Design and TestingConclusions

Concept and DesignTesting

Design

Floating voltage rings

Ceramic washers

Conductive screens

Grounded ringBalSeal spring

Insulating spheres

SHV feedthrough

Ion gauge void

SolidWorks design (EIGB) Electrostatic Ion Gauge Barrier.Conductive screens act as electrostatic barrier.Insulating spheres, BalSeal spring maintain electricalcontinuity.

Damien Robertson - TITAN Summer 2011 An Improved Vacuum System

Page 13: An Improved Vacuum System - for Storing Highly Charged Ions in … › intern › documents › presentation_D... · 2011-08-25 · Introduction Ion Pump Baking and Testing EIGB Design

IntroductionIon Pump Baking and Testing

EIGB Design and TestingConclusions

Concept and DesignTesting

Design

Damien Robertson - TITAN Summer 2011 An Improved Vacuum System

Page 14: An Improved Vacuum System - for Storing Highly Charged Ions in … › intern › documents › presentation_D... · 2011-08-25 · Introduction Ion Pump Baking and Testing EIGB Design

IntroductionIon Pump Baking and Testing

EIGB Design and TestingConclusions

Concept and DesignTesting

Test Setup and Procedure

Intended to test in baking station in ISAC 1 Hall.

Test setup would involve multiple scenarios involving iongauge placement and an MCP.

The EIGB and ion gauge would be within line of sight of eachother, and multiple scenarios in which they would not bewithin line of sight of each other.

Aim would determine if EIGB is necessary to create barrier forions or if simply placing the ion gauge around a simple bend,thus eliminating line of sight, would tame the unwantedbackground noise on the MCP.

Time did not allow such tests.

Damien Robertson - TITAN Summer 2011 An Improved Vacuum System

Page 15: An Improved Vacuum System - for Storing Highly Charged Ions in … › intern › documents › presentation_D... · 2011-08-25 · Introduction Ion Pump Baking and Testing EIGB Design

IntroductionIon Pump Baking and Testing

EIGB Design and TestingConclusions

Concept and DesignTesting

Testing EIGB in MPET

MCP biased to ≈ 1950 V.

Various scenarios using barrier voltage from 0 − 3000 V.

MCP count rate (Hz)

Ion gauge in original position ≈15000Ion gauge in EIGB, barrier potentials off ≈ 450Ion gauge in EIGB, barrier potentials on ≈ 300

Barriers set to ±500 V.

EIGB’s best performance; middle screen biased to 200 V orhigher, front screen biased to −150 V or lower.

Strange phenomena at 150 V.

Damien Robertson - TITAN Summer 2011 An Improved Vacuum System

Page 16: An Improved Vacuum System - for Storing Highly Charged Ions in … › intern › documents › presentation_D... · 2011-08-25 · Introduction Ion Pump Baking and Testing EIGB Design

IntroductionIon Pump Baking and Testing

EIGB Design and TestingConclusions

Concept and DesignTesting

Results of EIGB in MPET

Performance of EIGB wasnot as expected but newphenomena discovered.

Testing found that ionpump/IG1 can contribute toMCP interference as well.

This interference wasthought to be unavoidablebackground noise.

Raises new questions aboutfiltering interference.

Proper test setup shouldidentify new problems.

Damien Robertson - TITAN Summer 2011 An Improved Vacuum System

Page 17: An Improved Vacuum System - for Storing Highly Charged Ions in … › intern › documents › presentation_D... · 2011-08-25 · Introduction Ion Pump Baking and Testing EIGB Design

IntroductionIon Pump Baking and Testing

EIGB Design and TestingConclusions

Ion PumpElectrostatic Ion Gauge BarrierClosing

Ion Pump Implementation

Given the success of theion pump, second pumpshould be added, shownin light grey.

May provide the lowestpressure for the MPET.

Ion gauge, IG3, added tomonitor pressure inMPET, outside of magfield.

MPET

IonPump

MCP

Turbo Pump

Turbo Pump

GV1

GV2 GV3

IG1

IG2

GVM

GV4

IonPump

IG4

IG3

Turbo Pump

GVM

Damien Robertson - TITAN Summer 2011 An Improved Vacuum System

Page 18: An Improved Vacuum System - for Storing Highly Charged Ions in … › intern › documents › presentation_D... · 2011-08-25 · Introduction Ion Pump Baking and Testing EIGB Design

IntroductionIon Pump Baking and Testing

EIGB Design and TestingConclusions

Ion PumpElectrostatic Ion Gauge BarrierClosing

Limitations

Removing ion gauge from line of sight showed improvementby a factor of ≈33.

Activating EIGB showed improvement by a factor of ≈1.3.

May be other effects of charged particle creation from iongauge EIGB is missing.

Possible that EIGB is missing charged particles due to convexconductive screens.

Further study needed to improve design of EIGB to activateIG2.

Damien Robertson - TITAN Summer 2011 An Improved Vacuum System

Page 19: An Improved Vacuum System - for Storing Highly Charged Ions in … › intern › documents › presentation_D... · 2011-08-25 · Introduction Ion Pump Baking and Testing EIGB Design

IntroductionIon Pump Baking and Testing

EIGB Design and TestingConclusions

Ion PumpElectrostatic Ion Gauge BarrierClosing

Closing

A challenging, time consuming project.

Very interesting, found myself trying to work out newapproaches to problems.

Thank you to Stephan Ettenauer, Usman Chowdhury and MelGood for their help and the rest of the TITAN team forallowing me to ”try” stuff out on MPET.

Damien Robertson - TITAN Summer 2011 An Improved Vacuum System