Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Journal of Materials Sciences and Applications
2015; 1(2): 65-69
Published online April 10, 2015 (http://www.aascit.org/journal/jmsa)
Keywords Experimental Study,
Kevlar/Epoxy,
Composite Materials and
Internal Pressure Loading
Received: February 28, 2015
Revised: March 18, 2015
Accepted: March 19, 2015
An Experimental Study of Hybrid/Epoxy Composite Cylinders Under Internal Pressure Loading
A. A. Ramadhan
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Al-Hawija Technical Institute, Foundation of technical
education Kirkuk, Iraq
Email address [email protected]
Citation A. A. Ramadhan. An Experimental Study of Hybrid/Epoxy Composite Cylinders Under Internal
Pressure Loading. Journal of Materials Sciences and Applications. Vol. 1, No. 2, 2015, pp. 65-69.
Abstract An experimental study of Kevlar-29/epoxy composite thin wall cylinders under internal
pressure loading has been investigated in this work. Kevlar/epoxy composite specimens
have been fabricated and tested. All of these specimens were tested by using the
hydraulic pump and it were subjected to a uniformed internal pressure loading. The
results that were obtained from this work to find the (PIR) and derived the failure load
with comparison have been presented. The comparison was done and at last the more
strength material using for fabricating a thin wall composite pressure vessel was
specified. The efficient and effective composite cylinder have been presented
experimentally and provided considerable advantage for using woven roving fibers in
pressure vessels applications.
1. Introduction
The ever-increasing use of pressure vessel can been seen widely in civilian industries
such as for liquid petroleum gas tank, fire extinguisher, oxygen gas tank and the power
generation under different conditions of pressure, temperature, and environment.
Therefore, it have given special emphasis to analytical and experimental methods for
determining new materials to undergo a certain high working with an appropriate safety
factor and low maintenance cost [1-2].
The important modern materials that use in a lot of engineering applications are the
composite materials. The aim in this study to fabricate one of the composite materials
that are used for the pressure vessels to make pressure vessels that will be more safety
and more light than before. [3]
A great deal of attention is being concentrated on reducing the weight of pressure
vessels and fuel tanks by 10% to 20%. Most efforts are focused at the use of new lighter
weight to high strength materials to achieve this goal. [4].For instance, many researchers
have studied the manufacturing and designing aspects of laminated composite pressure
vessels [5-6]. Recently, a number of researchers have studied the optimal design of
laminated composite pressure vessels to reduce the weight and possible maintenance
costs and to investigate the laminate failures. But must of these studies were about
filament winding. For example, Chang R.[7] studied experimentally and theoretically the
first- ply failure of laminated composite pressure vessels, for reliability assurance, an
accurate prediction of the internal load failure process of laminated composite structures
and the maximum loads that the structures can withstand before failure occurs and the
effect of the number of layers on the ratio of increase in pressure, that has become an
66 A. A. Ramadhan: An Experimental Study of Hybrid/Epoxy Composite Cylinders Under Internal Pressure Loading
important topic of research. Hose D.R and his associates [8]
used a woven roving glass reinforced composite to made
mixed wall pipes fabricated and subjected to internal a
pressure to measure the strain in inner surface. Adali et al. [9]
gave another method on the optimization of multi-layered
composite pressure vessels using an exact elasticity solution.
A three dimensional theory for anisotropic thick composite
cylinders subjected to axis symmetrical loading conditions
was derived. The three dimensional interactive Tsai-Wu
failure criterion was employed to predict the maximum burst
pressure. The optimization of pressure vessels show that the
stacking sequence can be employed effectively to maximum
burst pressure. However Adali’s results were not compared
with experimental testing and the stiffness degradation was
not considered during analysis.
Sayman [10] studied analysis of multi-layered composite
cylinders under hygrothermal loading. Mackerle [11] gives a
bibliographical review of finite element methods applied for
the analysis of pressure vessel structures and piping from the
theoretical as well as practical points of view. Xia et al. [12]
studied multi-layered filament-wound composite pipes under
internal pressure. Xia et al. (2001) presented an exact
solution for multi-layered filament-wound composite pipes
with resin core under pure bending. Rao and Sinha [13]
studied the effects of temperature and moisture on the free
vibration and transient response of multidirectional
composites. A three-dimensional finite element analysis is
developed for the solution.
The effect of number of layers of composite pressure
vessels on the pressure increase ratio (PIR) is studied
experimentally in this work.
Experimental investigation of pressure increase ratio in
composite pressure vessel subjected to internal pressure load
in performed by using manual pump. A comparison between
test results was made to demonstrate the suitability of the
composite materials in pressure vessels fabrication.
2. Experimental Work
2.1. Materials Selection and Specimen
Fabrication
Materials selection was done after several surveys of
previous studies and thesis recommendations had make a
study about composite pressure vessels from reinforcement
and resin. Woven roving Kevlar-29 fiber with epoxy resin
(EP-A215C1) and hardener resin (EP-B215) had been
selected to fabricate the composite specimens in this paper.
All specimens have same geometry but with different
numbers of fiber layers. The length of the specimen are 320
mm and the active length that make from 2, 4, 6 layers and it
will carry the internal pressure load of the test until burst will
be in the middle of the specimen and have a length of 100
mm only, the remained inactive length will be in both
specimen sides and it will be inside the test equipment with
different geometrical shape according to the test equipment
in measurement and geometrical shape in order to make sure
that the specimens will seat fit in the test equipment without
any gap, Figure 1 shows the geometry of the specimen.
Figure 1. The geometry of the specimen (all the dimensions in mms)
For accuracy reasons, three specimens were fabricated for
each number of layers which means 9 specimens will needed,
i.e. three for each 2, 4 and 6 layers of Kevlar-29 fibers.
Comparison between the different number of layers should
be investigated, so 3(number of specimens) times 3(number
of layers) the total will be 9 specimens each tube after cutting
and finishing will produce one specimens only. Therefore,
the results were represented from the average of three
specimens under the same condition and as a result, 3 results
will be ready for analyzing and discussion, representing all
the layers and the kinds of specimens.
Hand lay-up method has been used to fabricate all the
specimens. Woven roving Kevlar-29 fiber is winding
manually in the open mold, and epoxy resin brushed over and
into the woven roving fiber. Entrapped air is removed
manually with a roller. As shown in Figure 2.
Journal of Materials Sciences and Applications 2015; 1(2): 65-69 67
Figure 2. Typical Photograph, Hand Lay-Up Process
After preparing all the materials, first step in fabrication
start with cutting woven roving fiber manually into suitable
parts. After finding circumference of each mandrel, the
length of each piece of fiber can be found by multiplying the
circumference times the number of layers. The diameter of
the mandrel is 48 mm; the circumference of the circular cross
sectional area can be obtained by multiplying the diameter (D)
by (π ).
By multiplying the circumference by the number of layers
(N) for each category of tubes 2, 4 and 6 and the length of the
piece of fiber can be obtained from equation:
The length (m) = Circumference × N
According to equation above the length of fiber can be
obtained. Till this step all the pieces of woven roving fiber
are ready to start fabricated.
Next step is preparing the mixture 20 parts by volume of
epoxy hardener from Leco Corporation USA was used for the
matrix per 100 parts by volume of epoxy resin, After the
mixture become ready, by using suitable brush the mixture
will distribute on the fiber of the active area, rolling the fiber
on the mandrel should be done in the same time to ensure the
equal distribution of the mixture between the fiber and the
layers that will produce balanced specimens and symmetrical
dimension for all parts of the specimens. The composite tube
curried out at room temperature 32 Cº and leaved behind for
72 hours to provide optimum blend.
After finishing from the fabrication processes and by using
turning machine (XL 1880) at 320 rpm in the work shop the
finishing and cutting processes should be done. The Final
specimens of Kevlar-29/epoxy composite material are shown
in Figure 3.
Figure 3. Typical Photograph of Kevlar-29/epoxy Specimens
2.2. Testing of Composite Tubes
Burst pressures were measured by applying pressurized oil
to the specimens of pressure vessels and slowly increasing
the pressure until each vessel failed. At First the specimen is
prepared via fixing among two plugs as shown in Figure4,
each plug contains three slots as a place for washers, and also
each plug must be exposed to silicon glue to make it safer
against leakage. Secondly the specimen should be fixing
from each side by the flanges, in order to ensure holding the
plugs tightly inside the specimen during pressurized process.
The third step is connecting the pump with specimen by
using a high pressure pipe between them. After that the
specimen become ready to testing and by put it above
suitable stand, pressurized oil process starting manually by
using the pump until failure done as shown in Figure 5.
68 A. A. Ramadhan: An Experimental Study of Hybrid/Epoxy Composite Cylinders Under Internal Pressure Loading
Figure 4. Typical Photograph, plugs fixing process
Figure 5. Connecting and Pressurized process until failure occurred
3. Results and Discussion
Table 1. The Burst Pressure and Average Pressure for Kevlar-29/Epoxy
Specimens
Average of Max.
Pressure (bar)
The Max.
Pressure (bar)
No. of
Specimens
No. of
Layers
96
91 Specimen 1
2 97 Specimen 2
100 Specimen 3
227
220 Specimen 1
4 236 Specimen 2
225 Specimen 3
339
331 Specimen 1
6 339 Specimen 2
348 Specimen 3
The burst pressure test applied for the three specimen sets
and the test result will discuss below and according to
average burst pressure for number of layers and by using
composite pro other relations and parameters will find and
discuss. To make a comparison for a maximum (burst)
pressure of specimens according to the number of layers a
chart include all of them has been donning and Table1 shows
the average of burst pressure for each number of layers for all
specimens
Figure 6. Average of Burst Pressure for Each Number of Layers for All
Specimens
Figure 6 illustrates the bar chart of the Pmax average for the
all specimens with different numbers of layers. From this
Figure, the value of Pmax increased gradually from the lowest
pressure in Kevlar-29/epoxy specimens depending on the
number of layers. The maximum pressure (burst pressure) is
proportional to the number of layers or the thickness of the
specimen wall. And also the specimens that have six layers
(6L) always can carry the highest Pmax and highest internal
load comparing with other specimens that made from two
layers (2L) and four layers (4L).
Pressure Increase Ratio (PIR)
The pressure increase ratio (PIR) is the ratio between the
maximum average pressures in the same type of specimens
has a different number of layers.
This can be obtained from equation:
(High No. of Layers) (Low No. of Layers)
(Low No. of Layers)
Max Max
Max
P PPIR
P
−= (1)
Where, (PMax) will be the average maximum pressure for a
different number of layers in the same type of specimens.
This parameter is very important to study the behavior of
composite materials in pressure vessels design when internal
load apply in of the specimens.
By applied (equation1) on the average maximum pressure
shown in Table 1 the pressure increase ratio for Kevlar-
29/Epoxy specimens found as schematic diagram as shown in
Figure 7 and the chart in Figure 8
Journal of Materials Sciences and Applications 2015; 1(2): 65-69 69
Figure 7. Schematic Diagram, Increase Ratio for KE specimens
Figure 8. The bar chart of Pressure Increase Ratio for KE Specimens
Figure 8 illustrates the variation of PIR in Kevlar-29/epoxy
specimens between different numbers of layers, the ratio
decrease from (137.76%) in two numbers of layers to four
numbers of layers into (49.26%) between four numbers of
layers to six numbers of layers that mean the total decrease is
(88.5%). While the PIR between the two numbers of layers
and six numbers of layers is (254.90%). That also means the
PIR for Kevlar-29/Epoxy specimens decrease as much as the
numbers of layers increase but the specimens have the best
ratio of reduce in PIR that mean in any design application it
requires less internal load.
The summery of pressure Increase Ratio of the result are
showed in figures (7 and 8) according to the number of layers.
The PIR for four layers to six layers it can clearly noticed
that the lower gain in Kevlar-29/epoxy specimens so by
increasing the number of layers in specimen it can carry more
internal load for the industrial applications. The highest PIR
for two layers to six layers can be noted during the test.
4. Conclusion
In this paper, the pressure increase ratio (PIR) of
composite cylinders were investigated and tested under
internal pressure at various numbers of the layers. The results
of the composite cylinders were presented; it was found that
PIR for Kevlar-29/Epoxy Specimens increased with
increasing number of layers from 2L to 4L. The results also
identified that the pressure increase ratio (PIR) of
Kevlar/epoxy composite cylinders was highest ratio from the
others cylinders.
References
[1] John Case, Lord Chilver, Carl T.F. Ross (1999). Strength of Materials and Structures, Fourth Edition, a member of the Hodder headline group London - Sydney Auckland co-published in north, central and south America By John Wiley & sons inc., New York Toronto.
[2] Fukunaga H, Chou TW. Simplified design techniques for laminated cylindrical pressure vessels under stiffness and strength constraints. J Comp Mater 1988;22:1157-69.
[3] Salah M. Ali. Experimental Study of Composite Cylinders under Internal Pressure Loading. Dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of master of engineering, MI: University of Malaya Press, 2009.
[4] Robert J. Setlock, Jr. Hydrostatic Pressure Retainment. June 2004
[5] Perugini P. Application and extensu=ion of filament winding process to general shape structures, M.Sc. Thesis in aeronautical Engineering. Roma: Universita 'La Sapienza',1990 (in Italian
[6] Eckold GC. A design method for filament wound GRP vessels and pipework. Composite 1985;16:41-7
[7] R.R. Chang Experimental and Theoretical analyses of first-ply failure of laminated composite pressure vessels. Composite Structure 49(2000)237-243.
[8] D. R. Hose and R. Kitching. Glass Reinforced Composite of Mixed Wall Construction. In. J. Pres. Ves. & Piping 27-305-323
[9] Adali, S., Verijenko, V. E. et al.(1995). Optimization of multilayered composite pressure vessels using exact elasticity solution, Composites for the Pressure Vessels Industry, PVP V302,ASME,203-312.
[10] Sayman, O. (2005). Analysis of Multi-Layered Composite Cylinders Under Hygrothermal Loading, Composites Part A, 1-11.
[11] Mackerle, J. (2002). Finite Elements in the Analysis of Pressure Vessels and Piping, an Addendum: a Bibliography (1998-2001), International Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping, 79, 1-26.
[12] Xia, M., Takayanagi, H. & Kemmochi, K. (2001). Analysis of Multi-Layered Filament- Wound Composite Pipes under Internal Pressure, Composite Structures, 53, 483-491.
[13] Rao, V. V. S. & Sinha, P. K. (2004). Dynamic Response of Multidirectional Composites in Hygrothermal Environments, Composite Structures, 64, 329-338.