35
An Analysis of LRS VHF/UHF Contest Antenna Systems Brian Howie GM4DIJ

An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    4

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

An Analysis of LRS

VHF/UHF Contest Antenna

SystemsBrian Howie

GM4DIJ

Page 2: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

Current Antennas

• 50 MHz

– Homebrew 9 element Wide Spaced 15m boom

• 70 MHz

– Homebrew 11 element Wide Spaced 15m boom

• 144 MHz

– 4 x M2 19 element

• 432 MHz

– 2 x M2 38 element

• 23cm

– 4x 55element Tonna

Page 3: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

50MHz

Page 4: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

70MHz

Page 5: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

144MHz

Page 6: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

144MHz

later that night

Page 7: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

70cm

Page 8: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

23cm

Page 9: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

How do they perform ?

• Antenna beam pattern

– Horizontal – to determine footpint

– Vertical –including ground effects

• Map pattern to show area coverage

• Show Stations worked form Gatehouse

– Shadows and preferred beam direction

Page 10: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

50MHz

Page 11: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

50MHz

15m agl

Page 12: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

Ground Slope

Page 13: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

View from Gatehouse

Page 14: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

View from Mull of Galloway

Page 15: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

50MHz

Page 16: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

50MHz

Page 17: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

70MHz

Page 18: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

70MHz

Page 19: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

70MHz

Page 20: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

70MHz

Page 21: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

144MHz

Page 22: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

144MHz

Page 23: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

144MHz

Page 24: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

144MHz

Page 25: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

70cm

Page 26: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

70cm

Page 27: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

70cm

Page 28: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

70cm

Page 29: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

23cm

Page 30: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

23cm

Page 31: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

23cm

Page 32: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

Summary

Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB

50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98

70MHz 11 element Yagi 15.98 24.5 30 9.2

144MHz 4 x 17 element Yagi 22.37 13.6 13.6 18.45

432MHz 2 x 38 element Yagi 23.7 17 9 26.6

1296MHz 4 x 55 element Yagi 27.83 6 6 31.78

Band Antenna gain dBi Lobe deg

50MHz 9 element Yagi 20.56 5.4

70MHz 11 element Yagi 21.52 3.8

144MHz 4 x 17 element Yagi 28.24 1.2

432MHz 2 x 38 element Yagi 28.98 2

1296MHz 4 x 55 element Yagi 33.38 1.1

Free space

Real ground ( experimenting with tilt might improve performance)

Page 33: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

Summary

• 6m beam

– Can be parked at 145 deg +/- 10 most of time

for UK

– Has to be turned if Es encountered

• 4m beam

– Can be parked at 145 +/- 10 deg most of time

for UK

– Has to be turned if Es encountered (rare)

Page 34: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

Summary

• 2m beam

– Has to be frequently turned in between 120deg

and 190 deg for UK in ~ 5 deg steps ,80 deg –

120deg for Mainland Europe

• 70cm beam

– Has to be frequently turned in between 120deg

and 190 deg for UK in ~ 8 deg steps ,80 deg –

120deg for Mainland Europe

Page 35: An Analysis of GM3HAM - Lothians Radio Society · 2016-09-12 · Summary Band Antenna gain dBi BW H deg BW V deg F/B dB 50MHz 9 element Yagi 15.22 32 34 13.98 70MHz 11 element Yagi

Summary

• 23cm

– Has to be frequently turned in between 120deg

and 190 deg for UK in ~ 3 deg steps ,80 deg –

120deg for Mainland Europe

– THIS ANTENNA IS SHARP