28
AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER

AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs

AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER

Page 2: AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs

Lilliwaup Main House

Page 3: AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs

Tail race returning water from the powerhouse to pool beneath falls

Page 4: AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs

Flow of water in Lilliwaup Creek changes dramatically with the Season.

Our permit requires that we shut down if flow is less than 5 CFS

Page 5: AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs

Creek flow in late summer & autumn

Page 6: AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs

Late spring early summer

Page 7: AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs

Winter Flow

Page 8: AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs

But the falls get even bigger

Page 9: AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs

The powerhouse has seven gensets, each rated at 200kW.

Turbines, supplied by Cornell in 1984, require 11 cfs anda head of 275 ft (119psi) to operate at capacity.

When the 42” penstock enters the powerhouse, a manifold pipes it into seven 12” pipes to each turbine.

The turbine floor is compact to a fault.

Page 10: AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs

Turbines and Generators in Power House

Page 11: AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs

In 2002 a landslide under-mined the flume which conveys water from Gate-house to Screen House.

It was necessary to build a truss to support the flume.

Page 12: AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs

Truss to support concrete flume after landslide

Page 13: AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs

We operated successfully until late December 2005, when another more serious slide occurred.

Page 14: AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs

Jan. 2006 After the devastating slide

Page 15: AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs
Page 16: AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs

Fallen Truss

Page 17: AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs

It was a very demoralizing event.

And a costly one.

For six years I did nothing.

Then the FERC called:

“Rebuild or the permit to operate your hydro plant will be cancelled”.

Page 18: AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs
Page 19: AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs
Page 20: AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs
Page 21: AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs

Installing the 48” HDPE Flume

Page 22: AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs

Inserting the Flume into the Screen House

Page 23: AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs

FPI Screen being installed

Page 24: AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs

Earthworks above MSI Wall

Page 25: AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs

View of MSI Wall from below

Page 26: AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs

Another view of the completed wall with water flowing from the gate house

Page 27: AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs

View from the top

Page 28: AN AMATEUR’S INVOLVEMENT IN HYDRO POWER falls... · 2018-08-06 · expensive to justify the investment on economics. - $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs

End result:- An excellent rebuild but much too expensive to justify the investment on economics.- $0.033 per kWh too low for small hydro with high fixed costs.- In 2016, Revenue $200,000 at 49% capacity factor.- Annual Return on Investment = 2%- But: Psychic Return: HUGE