View
214
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
1/61
!"# %&'()*
+! ,-.
"#$%&'& ()#%* )+ *,& -./*&0 "*1*&2
/!+,.0 1,2,.1 34 2 5.6+72 8 !" $%&8
'!"("()*!+,8 -&
1,2,. 34 ,.9218 !" $%&.
/!,0)*1!*",# :::::::::
!" $ %&' !( )*%'&!%+%& '! ',* -"&'*. /'+'*/
)!-%' !( + 00*+1/ (!% ',* (&(', )&%)-&'
2%&*( (!% +3&)& )-%&+* ',* 3+4!%/ !(
"*$ 4!%56 1!/ +"7*1*/6 +'1+"'+6 +-/'&"6
2&%3&"7,+36 889 +..&'&!"+1 3+4!%/6
)!-"'4 *:*)-'&;*/6 +". 1!)+1&'&*/6 ',*
-"&'*. /'+'*/ )!"(*%*")* !( 3+4!%/6
+". ',* "+'&!"+1 1*+7-* !( )&'&*/ &"
/-00!%' !( 0*'&'&!"*%/
; 27-26< =# 7 26,.6
2)+0)+$"()* 2)3*,!% )4 "5!2("6 )4 7!8 9)+:
6+7-260 0.26+!>?
7.7.@+2 7-2!>
A.6.5< =# 1-=.0.6
.552 >6/!B.6>
!CD
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
2/61
'+21* !( )!"'*"'/
0
,2B@. 34 73!,.!,1 ############################################ G
,2B@. 34 2/,-36+,+.1 #################################### GG
+!,.6.1, 34 25+7+ 7/6+2. ############################## %
1/5526< 34 ,-. 26>/5.!, ######################### *
26>/5.!, ############################################################# (
+# ,OC >PGVJMQC [E"HCQH] @"MW]HJMVGMW @"QJY
+MHCEC]H]8 JMV .M^"GMGMW HOC >PGVJMQC
+LK"]C] +LLCVGJHC -JEL] "M @"QJYGHGC]# ########## (
++# 2 1GMWYC [YJGMHG__`] 7YJGL "_ 4PHPEC
2VLGMG]HEJHGZC 7"]H] 0"C] !"H 1PKK"EH
1HJMVGMW _"E J !JHG"MDGVC +M^PMQHG"M HOJH
+M_YGQH] =GVC]KECJV @"QJY -JEL] ##################### %a
73!7@/1+3! ######################################################## U%
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
3/61
GG
'+21* !( +-',!%&'&*/
0?@A
)@
2%$00!+ -& ;>*!,"6 F*"G% HI;8
%UU 1# 7H# %%Ua RSN%UT ####################################### S)
@$(>%!+25+6,%!+ 2)+0& -& 23*)8
&*) /#1# UUS RSNN(T ########################################### SN
@$-(, -& JC2 8
&&* /#1# )S* RSNNaT ########################################### S)
J+(!*1, )4 "5! C$+"5. F*?& -& A$(1%$8
C*-"%& I!+-,& KLM2N. F*?&8
&Sa /#1# %() RSNNNT ########################################### SN
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
4/61
GGG
P(*"!+ -& 7/@2. F*?#8
&&& /#1# ) RSNNaT ########################################### &8 SN
/B@
/12 [2,6+3, 2QH "_ SNN%8 [Pc# @# !"#%N)'&(8 %%& 1HJH# S)S ######################################### %N
!BD>E +CBDFEGBG>@
;>!*1>!*", ") "5! F>>(B+$"()* /!4)+>
$*1 2)*"+)% ;?" )4 STUVW X!$+(*B
=!4)+! "5! I3Q?)>>& )* F>>(B+$"()*.
/!43B!!,. $*1 F*"G% A$8 )4 "5! X&
2)>>& )* "5! Y31(?($+68 %N%]H 7"MW#
R%babT ################################################################### a
2PVECI 1GMWCE CH JY#8 $" =+)):(*B,. A)?$% F*,(B5",
J+)> @;2; 4)+ F>0%!>!*"(*B J3"3+!
'+)B+$>, 4)+ H*$3"5)+(O!1
F>>(B+$*", RAPMC SN%&T #################################### %%
2P]HGM ["YGQC 0CKJEHLCMH8 /)QQ!+6
'+!-!*"()* Z F>>(B+$*" M3"+!$?5
KX(,0$*(?N8 OHHKdeecGH#YIe%65>%fJ RYJ]H
ZG]GHCV 5JE# *8 SN%(T# ######################################### %U
BCEMJEV =CGMEJPc8 I"$"! @!0"& /!-!+,!,
')%(?6 )* C"5()0($* C[(%!, (* H&I&8 !#
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
5/61
GZ
7GHI "_ 2YcPhPCEhPC 6C]"YPHG"M !"# SNN*'
N)N RAPMC )8 SNN*T ############################################# %U
7GHI "_ 2P]HGM 6C]"YPHG"M RAJM# UN8 %bb)T ############# %U
7GHI "_ B"]H"M8 5JI"E`] 3__GQC "_ !CDB"]H"MGJM]8 OHHKdeecGH#YIe%>_OSS2 RYJ]H
ZG]GHCV 5JE# *8 SN%(T ######################################### %&
7GHI "_ 7OGQJW"8 3__GQC "_ !CD 2LCEGQJM]8
25(?$B) 7!8 ;>!+(?$*, '%$*W
=3(%1(*B $ L5+(-(*B $*1 P!%?)>(*B
2("6 R0CQ# SN%ST ################################################# %S
2)*"(*3(*B M-!+,(B5" )4 "5! F>>(B+$"()*
/!4)+> $*1 2)*"+)% ;?" )4 STUVW
X!$+(*B =!4)+! "5! I3Q?)>>& )*F>>(B+$"()*. /!43B!!,. $*1 F*"G% A$8.
X& 2)>>& )* "5! Y31(?($+68 %NNHO
7"MW# R%ba)T ######################################################## a
0CKJEHLCMH "_ -"LCYJMV 1CQPEGHI8 H $*1
L \(,$ A$8 C*4)+?!>!*" /!,)3+?!
D3(1! 4)+ J!1!+$%. I"$"!. A)?$%. L+(Q$%
$*1 L!++(")+($% A$8 C*4)+?!>!*"8
'+),!?3")+,. Y31B!,. $*1 M"5!+
D)-!+*>!*" ;B!*?(!, RAJM# *8 SN%(T ########### %N8 %%
.EGQ 1QOLGHH8 2%(*")* C[0!?"!1 ") I0$+!
X$("($*, 4+)> @!0)+"$"()*8 !#
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
6/61
Z
X$("($* @!"!*"()* $*1 F*"!+1(?"()*W
X!$+(*B =!4)+! "5! I3Q?)>>& )*
F>>(B+$"()*. /!43B!!,. $*1 F*"G% A$8
)4 "5! X& 2)>>& )* "5! Y31(?($+68
%N%]H 7"MW# R%babT ############################################### b
-"P]H"M +LLGWEJMH @CWJY 1CEZGQC]
7"YYJc"EJHGZC8
OHHKdeeDDD#QGHGfCM]OGKQ"EMCE#"EW RYJ]H
ZG]GHCV 5JE# *8 SN%(T ########################################## %&
F>>(B+$"()* /!4)+> $*1 2)*"+)% ;?" )4
STU]W Y)(*" X!$+(*B, =!4)+! "5!
I3Q?)>>& )* F>>(B+$"()*. /!43B!!,.
$*1 F*"!+*$"()*$% A$8 )4 "5! I& 2)>>&
)* "5! Y31(?($+68 b)HO 7"MW# R%baST #################### )
F>0%!>!*"$"()* )4 F>>(B+$"()* /!4)+>W
X!$+(*B =!4)+! "5! I3Q?)>>& )*
F>>(B+$"()* $*1 /!43B!! ;44$(+, )4 "5!
I& 2)>>& )* "5! Y31(?($+68 %NNHO
7"MW# R%baaT ######################################################### a
A"JMMJ 0ECcI8 X)8 L)1$6G, F>>(B+$"()*
C*4)+?!>!*" ')%(?(!, F>0$?" 25(%1+!*.
J$>(%(!,. $*1 2)>>3*("(!,8 7CMHCE _"E
2LCEGQJM [E"WEC]] R2PW# SN%ST ######################## %)
A"EWC @# 7JEE"8 Q)%(,> )+ F>0+)0!+ @(?"$"!,^8 %(
[CKK# @# 6CZ# Sb) R%babT###################################### b
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
7/61
ZG
@G]J 7OEG]HCM]CM >CC CH JY#8
H*1)?3>!*"!1 F>>(B+$*",G I"$"! Z
A)?$% L$[ 2)*"+(Q3"()*,8 ,OC +M]H# "_
,JiJHG"M j .Q"M"LGQ ["YGQI R4Cc# S*8
SN%(T ################################################## (8 %(8 SS8 SU
@Gf 6"ccGM]8 7!8 9)+: ") ;(1 F>>(B+$*",
;>(1 I"$%%!1 7$"()*$% /!4)+>,8 !#
5JEZGMC -"DC8 F&7&I& /3%(*B =!*!4(",
F%%!B$% F>>(B+$*" 25(%1+!*8 !#!+(?$*
?5(%1+!*8 =J]O# ["]H8 5JE# *8 SN%& ################## %)
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
8/61
ZGG
!JH`Y +LLGWEJHG"M @JD 7CMHCE8
F>>(B+$"()*R(*?%3,(-! I"$"! $*1 A)?$%
')%(?(!, >(B+$"()* I"$"3, RC__CQHGZC 4Cc# Sa8
SN%(T ################################################################### %*
!CD >(B+$*" F*"!B+$"()*8 /17 0"EM]G_C
7CMHCE _"E HOC 1HPVI "_ +LLGWEJMH
+MHCWEJHG"M R0CQ# %&8 SN%&T########################## %S8 %U
M-!+,(B5" )4 "5! ;1>(*(,"+$"()*G,
!*"
')%(?(!,W C[$>(*(*B "5! F>0$?" )*
'3Q%(? I$4!"6 $*1 X)*)+(*B "5!
\(?"(>,8 X!$+(*B =!4)+! "5! I& 2)>>&
)* "5! Y31(?($+68 %%*HO 7"MW# RAPYI S%8SN%&T ################################################################### %a
[CD 7OJEGHJcYC ,EP]H]8 F>>(B+$"()* $*1
A!B$%(O$"()*W /)%!, $*1
/!,0)*,(Q(%("(!, )4 I"$"!, $*1 A)?$%("(!,
R2KE# SN%*T ##################################################### a8 %%
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
9/61
ZGGG
[EC]] 6CYCJ]C8 ,OC 7"PMQGY "_ HOC 7GHI "_
!CD JEQCHHG 2MM"PMQC] !JHG"MDGVC
2QHG"M] J] 7"PEH -CJEGMW] [E"QCCV "M
3cJLJ`] +LLGWEJHG"M 6C_"EL] R2KE#
%)8 SN%&T ############################################################ %&
[EC]] 6CYCJ]C8 !CD (? =!*!4(", )4 C[0$*1(*B "5! @+!$>W
@;'; $*1 @;2; F>0$?", )* A),
;*B!%!, $*1 2$%(4)+*($8 /7@2 !"EHO
2LCEGQJM +MHCWEJHG"M j 0CZCY"KLCMH
7CMHCE RAJM# S(8 SN%&T ###################################### S*
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
10/61
Gi
6CcCQQJ 1# 7JE]"M8 /!$16 )+ 7)"^ D$3B(*B
>(B+$"()*8 ,OC 7OGQJW"
7"PMQGY "M >Y"cJY 2__JGE] R5JE# SN%&T ######## %S8 %&
6PHO 5GYFLJM CH JY#8 P$B! L5!4" $*1P)+:0%$?! \()%$"()*, (* A), ;*B!%!,8
/7@2 +M]HGHPHC _"E 6C]CJEQO "M @Jc"E
JMV .LKY"ILCMH RSN%*T #################################### %*
/17+18 F*"!+(> /!%(!4 4)+ 2!+"$(* J)+!(B*
;?$1!>(? I"31!*", ;1-!+,!%6 ;44!?"!1
Q6 X3++(?$*! E$"+(*$W J+!b3!*"%6
;,:!1 c3!,"()*, KJ;cN R!"Z# S&8 SNN&T ############ %N
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
11/61
&"'*%*/' !( +3&)& )-%&+*8
2LGQG ECKEC]CMH J cE"JV Q"JYGHG"M "_ Y"QJY
W"ZCEMLCMH]# 3MC OPMVECV JMV CGWOHCCM QGHGC]8
Q"PMHGC]8 JMV Y"QJY W"ZCEMLCMH "__GQGJY] OJZC ^"GMCV
HOG] cEGC_ J] DCYY J] ,OC /#1# 7"M_CECMQC "_ 5JI"E]8J M"MKJEHG]JM WE"PK ECKEC]CMHGMW LJI"E] "_ "ZCE
%8*NN QGHGC]8 JMV HOC !JHG"MJY @CJWPC "_ 7GHGC]8
DOGQO ECKEC]CMH] L"EC HOJM %b8NNN LPMGQGKJY
W"ZCEMLCMH] MJHG"MDGVC#
2LGQG JEC O"LC H" ]"LC "_ HOC YJEWC]H
GLLGWEJMH Q"LLPMGHGC] GM HOC /MGHCV 1HJHC]# 5"EC
HOJM %#& LGYYG"M QOGYVECM JMV KJECMH] K"HCMHGJYYI
CYGWGcYC _"E ECYGC_ PMVCE HOC CM^"GMCV CiCQPHGZC
WPGVJMQC YGZC GM "PE QGHGC] JMV H"DM]# 2LGQG ]PcLGH
HOG] cEGC_ H" CiKYJGM DOI HOC MJHG"MDGVC GM^PMQHG"MGM HOG] QJ]ClJMV HOC M"ZCY HOC"EI "_ ]HJMVGMW
J]]CEHCV H" ]PKK"EH GHlGLKE"KCEYI GWM"EC] HOC
GEECKJEJcYC OJEL H" "PE EC]GVCMH] _E"L VCMIGMW
OPLJMGHJEGJM VC_CEECV JQHG"M ECYGC_#
% !" Q"PM]CY _"E J KJEHI JPHO"ECV HOG] cEGC_ GM DO"YC "E GM
KJEH8 JMV M" KJEHI "E Q"PM]CY _"E J KJEHI LJVC J L"MCHJEI
Q"MHEGcPHG"M GMHCMVCV H" _PMV HOC KECKJEJHG"M "E ]PcLG]]G"M"_ HOG] cEGC_# !" KCE]"M "HOCE HOJM JLGQG "E HOCGE Q"PM]CY LJVC
J L"MCHJEI Q"MHEGcPHG"M H" HOG] cEGC_`] KECKJEJHG"M "E
]PcLG]]G"M# 2YY Q"PM]CY "_ ECQ"EV KE"ZGVCV cYJMFCH Q"M]CMH _"E
HOC _GYGMW "_ JLGQP] cEGC_] "E ECQCGZCV HGLCYI M"HGQC JMV
Q"M]CMHCV H" HOC _GYGMW "_ HOG] cEGC_#
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
12/61
S
2] JLGQG OJZC CiKYJGMCV JH CZCEI ]HJWC "_ HOG]
YGHGWJHG"Md cCQJP]C PMV"QPLCMHCV GLLGWEJMH] JEC
GMHCWEJY LCLcCE] "_ "PE Q"LLPMGHGC]8 HOC CM^"GMCV
VC_CEECV JQHG"M KE"WEJL] KE"HCQH ZGHJY Y"QJY
GMHCEC]H]# =GHO"PH HOC WPGVJMQC8 LGYYG"M] "_ _JLGYGC]
GM "PE QGHGC] JMV Q"PMHGC] _JQC HOC HOECJH "_VCK"EHJHG"M8 VC]HJcGYGfGMW "PE Q"LLPMGHGC] JMV
^C"KJEVGfGMW HOC DCY_JEC "_ _JLGYGC] JMV QOGYVECM#
,OC MJHG"MDGVC GM^PMQHG"M JY]" PMVCELGMC] HOC
JcGYGHI "_ JLGQG`] K"YGQC VCKJEHLCMH] H" KE"HCQH JMV
]CEZC JYY "_ "PE EC]GVCMH]# 4GMJYYI8 HOC GM^PMQHG"M
GLK"]C] CiHCM]GZC CQ"M"LGQ OJEL "M JLGQG#
/MV"QPLCMHCV GLLGWEJMH] QPEECMHYI Q"MHEGcPHC
OPMVECV] "_ LGYYG"M] "_ V"YYJE] GM HJi ECZCMPC] JMV
"HOCE CQ"M"LGQ cCMC_GH] H" Y"QJY Q"LLPMGHGC] CZCEI
ICJE# ,OC VC_CEECV JQHG"M KE"WEJL] DGYY Q"MHEGcPHC
"ZCE maNN LGYYG"M GM JVVGHG"MJY CQ"M"LGQ cCMC_GH] H"
]HJHC JMV Y"QJY W"ZCEMLCMH] JMMPJYYI# !CD
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
13/61
U
MJHG"MDGVC# 4"EHI'_"PE JLGQG JEC Y"QJHCV GM KYJGMHG__
]HJHC] "E ]HJHC] HOJH OJZC ^"GMCV JLGQP] cEGC_]
]PKK"EHGMW KYJGMHG__]# 4"E CiJLKYC8 JLGQG GMQYPVC
0JYYJ] 7"PMHI8 ,EJZG] 7"PMHI8 JMV .Y [J]" 7"PMHI8
J] DCYY J] 2P]HGM8 -"P]H"M8 BE"DM]ZGYYC8 JMV
.VGMcPEW8 Y"QJY W"ZCEMLCMH] HOJH Q"YYCQHGZCYIECKEC]CMH "ZCE HDCMHI']Gi KCEQCMH "_ ,CiJ]`]
K"KPYJHG"M# 3HOCE JLGQG Y"QJHCV "PH]GVC KYJGMHG__
]HJHC] ECKEC]CMH "ZCE *S LGYYG"M Y"QJY EC]GVCMH]# ,OC
GMHCEC]H] "_ $%% "_ JLGQG`] EC]GVCMH] DCEC GWM"ECV cI
HOC Q"PEH] cCY"D GM JPHO"EGfGMW J MJHG"MDGVC
GM^PMQHG"M#
+_ HOC E"YC "_ Y"QJY W"ZCEMLCMH] G] H" cC
EC]KCQHCV8 Q"PEH] LP]H CM]PEC HOJH HOC Q"EC
EChPGECLCMH] "_ ]HJMVGMW JEC ]JHG]_GCV cC_"EC HOC
G]]PJMQC "_ J MJHG"MDGVC GM^PMQHG"M OJELGMW
Y"MW]HJMVGMW Y"QJY GMHCEC]H]# 2LGQG ]PcLGH HOG]
cEGC_ H" CiKYJGM HOC Y"QJY GLKJQH "_ _CVCEJY
GLLGWEJHG"M LCJ]PEC]8 JMV H" K"GMH "PH HOC YCWJY
JMV KEJQHGQJY KE"cYCL] GM G]]PGMW J MJHG"MDGVC
GM^PMQHG"M DGHO"PH Q"M]GVCEGMW HOC MJHG"MDGVC
OJEL] H" Y"QJY W"ZCEMLCMH] JMV HOCGE EC]GVCMH]#
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
14/61
*
/-33+%4 !( ',* +%7-3*"'
,OG] cEGC_ JVVEC]]C] HOC _GE]H hPC]HG"M GM HOC
KCHGHG"Md DOCHOCE KYJGMHG__ ]HJHC] OJZC ]HJMVGMW H"
cEGMW HOG] JQHG"M# 2LGQG Y"QJY W"ZCEMLCMH] _"QP] "M
JM GLK"EHJMH CYCLCMH "_ ]HJMVGMWd KYJGMHG__]` KE""_"_ ]HJMVGMW _"E CJQO _"EL "_ ECYGC_ ]"PWOH# -CEC8
]CZCEJY _JQH"E] VCL"M]HEJHC DOI KYJGMHG__]` QYJGL "_
]HJMVGMW H" "cHJGM J MJHG"MDGVC GM^PMQHG"M G]
"ZCEcE"JV#
%# +LLGWEJHG"M LCJ]PEC]8 YGFC HOC WPGVJMQC GM
HOG] QJ]C8 VGECQHYI GLKYGQJHC ]GWMG_GQJMH Y"QJY
GMHCEC]H]# 4"E HOG] ECJ]"M8 Y"QJY W"ZCEMLCMH] OJZC
cCCM JQHGZC _"E VCQJVC] GM ]PKK"EHGMW VC_CEECV
JQHG"M JMV HJFGMW "HOCE ]HCK] H" KE"HCQH GLLGWEJMH
EC]GVCMH] JMV HOCGE _JLGYGC]# 4CVCEJY OPLJMGHJEGJMJQHG"M] H" VC_CE VCK"EHJHG"M _"E YJD'JcGVGMW Y"QJY
EC]GVCMH]8 KJEHGQPYJEYI KJECMH] JMV QOGYVECM8 OJZC
_JE'ECJQOGMW ]"QGJY JMV _GMJMQGJY cCMC_GH] _"E
Y"QJYGHGC]# =GHOO"YVGMW JMV VCYJIGMW VC_CEECV
JQHG"M8 cI Q"MHEJ]H8 HOECJHCM] GEECKJEJcYC Y"QJY
OJEL] _"E JYY "_ JLGQG`] EC]GVCMH]#
S# 0C]KGHC HOC ]GWMG_GQJMH Y"QJY GLKJQH8 M" Q"PEH
cCY"D Q"M]GVCECV Y"QJY OJEL]8 GMQYPVGMW DOCHOCE
Y"QJY OJEL] ZJ]HYI CiQCCV HOC ]"YC ]HJMVGMW GM^PEIKE"ZCM cI ,CiJ]8 cC_"EC CM^"GMGMW HOC WPGVJMQC
MJHG"MDGVC# !" VCQG]G"M "_ HOG] 7"PEH PKO"YV] ]PQO
J ]DCCKGMW ]HJMVGMW HOC"EI# ," HOC Q"MHEJEI8 HOG]
7"PEH OJ] LJVC QYCJE HOJH J KJEHI ]CCFGMW J
KECYGLGMJEI GM^PMQHG"M LP]H C]HJcYG]O GEECKJEJcYC
OJEL JMV nHOJH JM GM^PMQHG"M G] GM HOC KPcYGQ
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
15/61
&
GMHCEC]H#o P(*"!+ -& 7/@2. F*?#8 &&& /#1# )8 SN
RSNNaT# 6ChPGEGMW KYJGMHG__] H" C]HJcYG]O ]HJMVGMW
GM^PEI ]P__GQGCMH H" ^P]HG_I HOC WC"WEJKOGQ ]Q"KC "_
^PVGQGJY ECYGC_ O"M"E] HOG] 7"PEH`] DJEMGMW HOJH
Q"PEH] LP]H DCGWO nQ"LKCHGMW QYJGL] "_ GM^PEIo JMV
CM]PEC HOJH KYJGMHG__] JEC M"H ]CCFGMW "ZCEcE"JVECYGC_ cC_"EC G]]PGMW JM GM^PMQHG"M# I!! P!(*Q!+B!+
-& /)>!+)R=$+?!%)8 *&( /#1# UN&8 U%S R%baST#
U# BPH OCEC HOC Y"DCE Q"PEH] VGV M"H DCGWO
Q"LKCHGMW QYJGL] "_ OJEL8 cCQJP]C HOCI HECJHCV
KYJGMHG__ ]HJHC]` KE"^CQHG"M] Jc"PH GMQECJ]CV VEGZCE`]
YGQCM]C JVLGMG]HEJHG"M Q"]H]l]"YCYI GM ,CiJ]lJ]
"ZCEEGVGMW HCM] "_ LGYYG"M] "_ V"YYJE] "_ Y"]H ECZCMPC
JMV CiHCM]GZC ]"QGJY JMV YJD CM_"EQCLCMH OJEL] _"E
Y"QJY W"ZCEMLCMH] GM ,CiJ] JMV GM "HOCE ]HJHC]#
*# ,OG] 7"PEH ]O"PYV M"H JPHO"EGfC J ]HJMVGMW
EPYC _"E MJHG"MDGVC GM^PMQHG"M] HOJH C__CQHGZCYI
WGZC] "c^CQHGMW KJEHGC] HOC EGWOH H" ZCH" _CVCEJY
K"YGQGC] GM CZCEI Y"QJYGHI GM HOC Q"PMHEI8 DOGYC
VG]ECWJEVGMW HOC OJEL H" HO"P]JMV] "_ Y"QJY
W"ZCEMLCMH] JQE"]] HOC MJHG"M# ,OJH "ZCEcE"JV
Q"MQCKH "_ ]HJMVGMW D"PYV GMZGHC KJEHGC] H" YGHGWJHC
"ZCE K"YGHGQJY VG]KPHC] JMV ]CHHYC GLK"EHJMH KPcYGQ
hPC]HG"M]8 J] GM HOG] QJ]C8 cI ]HEJHCWGQ YGHGWJHG"M JMV
]DCCKGMW GM^PMQHG"M] HOJH cCJE YGHHYC ECYJHG"M H" HOCMJEE"D OJEL] J]]CEHCV#
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
16/61
(
+%7-3*"'
&H 'D> 7CGI 0EFB>KB@ 1FJ=@B@B@6 7CGI
&NOF@>@ &NN>IG ,CC !" $%&8
H*1)?3>!*"!1 F>>(B+$*",G I"$"! Z A)?$% L$[ 2)*"+(Q3"()*,8
,OC +M]H# "_ ,JiJHG"M j .Q"M"LGQ ["YGQI8 U R4Cc# S*8 SN%(T8
OHHKdeecGH#YIeS%E[P2V#
http://bit.ly/21rPuAdhttp://bit.ly/21rPuAd
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
17/61
)
Q"LLPMGHGC]# ,OC GM^PMQHG"M GLK"]C] GLLCVGJHC
OJEL] "M JYY Y"QJY EC]GVCMH] cI HOECJHCMGMW KPcYGQ
OCJYHO JMV ]J_CHI8 VC]HJcGYGfGMW _JLGYGC]8 JMV
OJELGMW HOC ]"QGJY JMV CQ"M"LGQ DCYY'cCGMW "_ "PE
Q"LLPMGHGC] J] J DO"YC#
%# @"QJY W"ZCEMLCMH] OJZC Y"MW ECQ"WMGfCV HOJH
KE"L"HGMW HOC GMHCWEJHG"M "_ GLLGWEJMH EC]GVCMH] G]
C]]CMHGJY H" HOC ]PQQC]] "_ Y"QJY Q"LLPMGHGC]8 JMV
HOJH YJQF "_ GMHCWEJHG"M GLK"]C] ]GWMG_GQJMH Y"QJY
OJEL# ,OC VCKHO "_ Y"QJY Q"MQCEM GM HOG] JECJ G]
VCL"M]HEJHCV cI Y"QJY W"ZCEMLCMH]` VCQJVC]'Y"MW
GMZC]HLCMH GM c"HO _CVCEJY JMV Y"QJY K"YGQGC] HOJH
JVZJMQC GLLGWEJMH GMHCWEJHG"M# ,OG] GMZC]HLCMH
ECJQOC] cJQF H" Y"QJY ]PKK"EH _"E HOC YCWJYGfJHG"M
KE"ZG]G"M] "_ HOC %ba( +LLGWEJHG"M 6CYGC_ JMV
7"MHE"Y 2QH R+672T8 DGHO HOC @"] 2MWCYC] 7"PMHI]PKCEZG]"E HC]HG_IGMW cC_"EC 7"MWEC]] HOJH
YCWJYGfJHG"M D"PYV KE"L"HC GMHCWEJHG"M JMV JYY"D
PMV"QPLCMHCV GLLGWEJMH] H" cCQ"LC KE"VPQHGZC
LCLcCE] "_ HOC Q"LLPMGHI#4 @"QJY W"ZCEMLCMH]l
JYHO"PWO M"H EChPGECV H" V" ]"lKYJICV J FCI E"YC GM
* F>>(B+$"()* /!4)+> $*1 2)*"+)% ;?" )4 STU]W Y)(*"
X!$+(*B, =!4)+! "5! I3Q?)>>& )* F>>(B+$"()*. /!43B!!,. $*1
F*"!+*$"()*$% A$8 )4 "5! I& 2)>>& )* "5! Y31(?($+68 b)HO
7"MW# *Ua R%baST R]HJHCLCMH "_ 0CJMC 0JMJ8 1PKCEZG]"E8 @"]
2MWCYC] 7"PMHIT#
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
18/61
a
GLKYCLCMHGMW HOC +672 YCWJYGfJHG"M KE"WEJL8
EJG]GMW JKKYGQJHG"M EJHC] GM HOCGE Q"LLPMGHGC]#5
4"YY"DGMW +672`] KJ]]JWC8 Y"QJY YCJVCE] JMV
ECKEC]CMHJHGZC] Y"ccGCV _"E VC_CEECV JQHG"M K"YGQGC]8
YJHCE CMJQHCV GMH" YJD8 H" JVVEC]] HOC ]"QGJY JMVOPLJMGHJEGJM Q"]H "_ n]KYGH'CYGWGcGYGHI _JLGYGC]od
_JLGYGC] DOCEC ]"LC LCLcCE] OJV YCWJY ]HJHP] JMV
"HOCE] YGZCV PMVCE HOC HOECJH "_ VCK"EHJHG"M#6 +M
%baa8 Y"QJY KEC]]PEC8 KE"LKHCV cI OPLJMGHJEGJM
Q"MQCEM]8 YCV H" J QOJMWC GM ECWPYJHG"M] H" JYY"D
PMV"QPLCMHCV GLLGWEJMH QOGYVECM GM _"]HCE QJEC H"
hPJYG_I _"E YCWJY ]HJHP] PMVCE +672#7
&
I!! [CD 7OJEGHJcYC ,EP]H]8 F>>(B+$"()* $*1 A!B$%(O$"()*W/)%!, $*1 /!,0)*,(Q(%("(!, )4 I"$"!, $*1 A)?$%("(!,8 %S R2KE#
SN%*T8 OHHKdeecGH#YIe%,Z!\k9#
( F>0%!>!*"$"()* )4 F>>(B+$"()* /!4)+>W X!$+(*B =!4)+! "5!
I3Q?)>>& )* F>>(B+$"()* $*1 /!43B!! ;44$(+, )4 "5! I&
2)>>& )* "5! Y31(?($+68 %NNHO 7"MW# %bN R%baaT R]HJHCLCMH "_
.VDJEV +# \"QO8 5JI"E8 7GHI "_ !CD >(B+$"()* /!4)+> $*1 2)*"+)% ;?" )4 STUVW
X!$+(*B =!4)+! "5! I3Q?)>>& )* F>>(B+$"()*. /!43B!!,. $*1
F*"G% A$8. X& 2)>>& )* "5! Y31(?($+68 %NNHO 7"MW# %%%'%%&
R%ba)T R]HJHCLCMH] "_ 6CK# -JLGYH"M 4G]O8 AE## JMV 6CK#
-"DJEV @# BCELJM8 5CLcCE]8 1PcQ"LL# "M +LLGWEJHG"M8
6C_PWCC]8 JMV +MH`Y @JDT#
) 5JEZGMC -"DC8 F&7&I& /3%(*B =!*!4(", F%%!B$% F>>(B+$*"
25(%1+!*8 !#!*1>!*", ")
"5! F>>(B+$"()* /!4)+> $*1 2)*"+)% ;?" )4 STUVW X!$+(*B
=!4)+! "5! I3Q?)>>& )* F>>(B+$"()*. /!43B!!,. $*1 F*"G% A$8
)4 "5! X& 2)>>& )* "5! Y31(?($+68 %N%]H 7"MW# %*('%&b R%babT
http://bit.ly/1TvNKVXhttp://bit.ly/1TvNKVX
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
19/61
b
S# +M HOC ICJE] ]PEE"PMVGMW +6728 Y"QJYGHGC] JY]"
EC]K"MVCV H" HOCGE EC]GVCMH]` _CJE] "_ K"YGHGQJY ]HEG_C
JMV KCE]CQPHG"M GM HOCGE O"LC Q"PMHEGC] cI
]PKK"EHGMW "HOCE _CVCEJY VC_CEECV JQHG"M KE"WEJL]#
4"E CiJLKYC8 Q"MWEC]]G"MJY ECKEC]CMHJHGZC] JMV
Y"QJY W"ZCEMLCMH YCJVCE] _E"L @"] 2MWCYC] JMV5GJLGlQCMHCE] "_ GLLGWEJHG"M _E"L .HOG"KGJ JMV
-JGHG8 EC]KCQHGZCYIl]PKK"EHCV VC_CEECV JQHG"M
KE"WEJL] GM HOC %baN] JMV %bbN] _"E HO"]C WE"PK]#8
2H YCJ]H HDCYZC LPMGQGKJYGHGC] "__GQGJYYI WJZC HOCGE
]PKK"EH H" _CVCEJY VC_CEECV JQHG"M _"E 1JYZJV"EJM
JMV >PJHCLJYJM EC_PWCC] GM HOC %baN]#9 5"EC
ECQCMHYI8 VC_CEECV JQHG"M KE"WEJL] OJZC KE"ZGVCV
OPLJMGHJEGJM ECYGC_ H" GMVGZGVPJY] J__CQHCV cI
ECWG"MJY VG]J]HCE] GM HOC /MGHCV 1HJHC]8 ]PQO J]
R1HJHCLCMH] "_ A"OM .# 3KKCMOCGL8 2]]H# 0GE# _"E 4GMJMQC JMV
2VLGMG]HEJHG"M8 0CK`H "_ 1"QGJY 1CEZGQC]8 1JMHJ 7YJEJ 7"PMHI8
JMV 7JEY"] 5# 1"]J8 2]]H# 0GE#8 0CK`H "_ 7OGYVECM`] 1CEZGQC] "_
@"] 2MWCYC] 7"PMHIT#
a BCEMJEV =CGMEJPc8 I"$"! @!0"& /!-!+,!, ')%(?6 )* C"5()0($*
C[(%!, (* H&I&8 !# @!0)+"$"()*8 !#>& )* F>>(B+$"()*. /!43B!!,. $*1 F*"G% A$8
)4 "5! X& 2)>>& )* "5! Y31(?($+68 %N%]H 7"MW# )b'a% R%babT
R1HJHCLCMH "_ BJEcJEJ 7JECI8 7"LLG]]G"MCE8 0JVC 7"PMHI85GJLGT#
b A"EWC @# 7JEE"8 Q)%(,> )+ F>0+)0!+ @(?"$"!,^8 %(
[CKK# @# 6CZ# Sb)8 U%% R%babT#
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
20/61
%N
-PEEGQJMC \JHEGMJ JMV HOC 1CKHCLcCE %% HCEE"EG]H
JHHJQF]#10
U# /MVCE]Q"EGMW HOC ]HECMWHO "_ Y"QJY GMHCEC]H GM
HOG] JECJ8 Y"QJYGHGC] OJZC Z"YPMHJEGYI CLcEJQCV HOCGE
E"YC GM _CVCEJY ECYGC_ KE"WEJL] _"E PMV"QPLCMHCVZGQHGL] "_ QEGLC# 4"E CiJLKYC8 HOC / JMV , ZG]J
KE"WEJL]8 QECJHCV GM SNNN8 JYY"D ZGQHGL] "_ QEGLC]
]PQO J] V"LC]HGQ ZG"YCMQC JMV OPLJM HEJ__GQFGMW H"
ECQCGZC HCLK"EJEI ]HJHP] G_ HOCI Q""KCEJHC DGHO YJD
CM_"EQCLCMH GMZC]HGWJHG"M]#11 ,OC]C KE"WEJL]
JVVEC]] Y"QJY GMHCEC]H] cI CMQ"PEJWGMW ZGQHGL] H"
Q"LC _"EDJEV JMV Q""KCEJHC DGHO YJD CM_"EQCLCMH#
+M HPEM8 H" GMQECJ]C HEP]H JMV Q"YYJc"EJHG"M cCHDCCM
Y"QJYGHGC] JMV GLLGWEJMH Q"LLPMGHGC]8 LJMI Y"QJY
K"YGQC VCKJEHLCMH]8 KE"]CQPH"E]` "__GQC]8 _JLGYI
KE"HCQHGZC ]CEZGQC]8 JMV "HOCE JWCMQGC] OJZC QO"]CMH" GMZC]H EC]"PEQC] H"DJEV] GVCMHG_IGMW K"HCMHGJY
%N /17+18 F*"!+(> /!%(!4 4)+ 2!+"$(* J)+!(B* ;?$1!>(?
I"31!*", ;1-!+,!%6 ;44!?"!1 Q6 X3++(?$*! E$"+(*$W J+!b3!*"%6
;,:!1 c3!,"()*, KJ;cN JH % R!"Z# S&8 SNN&T8
OHHKdee%#P]J#W"Ze%,Z3N.hp /12 [2,6+3, 2QH "_ SNN%8 [Pc# @#
!"# %N)'&(8 q *SURcT8 %%& 1HJH# S)S8 U(%#
%% 0CKJEHLCMH "_ -"LCYJMV 1CQPEGHI8 H $*1 L \(,$ A$8
C*4)+?!>!*" /!,)3+?! D3(1! 4)+ J!1!+$%. I"$"!. A)?$%. L+(Q$%
$*1 L!++(")+($% A$8 C*4)+?!>!*"8 '+),!?3")+,. Y31B!,. $*1
M"5!+ D)-!+*>!*" ;B!*?(!,8 *8 b RAJM# *8 SN%(T8
OHHKdee%#P]J#W"ZeS%!P&1L#
http://1.usa.gov/1TvO0Eqhttp://1.usa.gov/21Nu5Smhttp://1.usa.gov/21Nu5Smhttp://1.usa.gov/1TvO0Eq
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
21/61
%%
JKKYGQJMH] JMV KE"ZGVGMW HOCL DGHO V"QPLCMHJHG"M
H" c"Y]HCE HOCGE JKKYGQJHG"M] _"E _CVCEJY ECYGC_#12
*# @"QJYGHGC] Q"MHGMPCV HOCGE _E"MHYGMC
GLKYCLCMHJHG"M E"YC VPEGMW HOC SN%S 0C_CEECV
2QHG"M _"E 7OGYVO""V 2EEGZJY] R0272T GMGHGJHGZC#!CD
=+)):(*B,. A)?$% F*,(B5", J+)> @;2; 4)+ F>0%!>!*"(*B
J3"3+! '+)B+$>, 4)+ H*$3"5)+(O!1 F>>(B+$*", %N8 %* RAPMC
SN%&T8 OHHKdeecE""F#W]e%MYZ\%3#
http://on.nyc.gov/1Qqptwyhttp://on.nyc.gov/1L7mWIEhttp://brook.gs/1nlvK1Ohttp://brook.gs/1nlvK1Ohttp://on.nyc.gov/1L7mWIEhttp://on.nyc.gov/1Qqptwy
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
22/61
%S
_JQGYGHJHCV JQQC]] H" KPcYGQ V"QPLCMH] HOJH
JKKYGQJMH] D"PYV MCCVp KJEHMCECV DGHO KPcYGQ
YGcEJEGC] H" O"YV "PHECJQO ]C]]G"M]p JMV CM]PECV
HOJH EC]GVCMH] DCEC M"H LG]YCV cI QEJQFGMW V"DM "M
PMhPJYG_GCV GMVGZGVPJY] "__CEGMW _EJPVPYCMH YCWJY
]CEZGQC] H" GLLGWEJMH]#16
+M JVVGHG"M H" ]PKK"EHGMW _CVCEJY GLLGWEJHG"M
ECYGC_ KE"WEJL]8 Y"QJYGHGC] OJZC JY]" GLKYCLCMHCV
GMM"ZJHGZC Y"QJY K"YGQGC] H" KE"L"HC GLLGWEJMH
GMHCWEJHG"M# ,OCEC JEC QPEECMHYI ]GiHI'HOECC "__GQC]
KE"L"HGMW GLLGWEJMH GMHCWEJHG"M JH HOC LPMGQGKJY
YCZCY JQE"]] HOC Q"PMHEI8 JMV HO"]C MPLcCE] JEC
WE"DGMW#17 1HJEHGMW GM HOC %baN]8 QGHGC] GMQYPVGMW
!CD >(B+$"()*8 ,OC
7OGQJW" 7"PMQGY "M >Y"cJY 2__JGE]8 a R5JE# SN%&T8
OHHKdeecGH#YIe%K*g(%Q#
%) M0!*(*B >3*("(!,W
2("(!, A!$1(*B 4)+ F>>(B+$*" F*"!B+$"()*8 /17 0"EM]G_C7CMHCE _"E HOC 1HPVI "_ +LLGWEJMH +MHCWEJHG"M8 & R0CQ# %&8
SN%&T8 OHHKdeecGH#YIe%gI)VGh#
%a 7GHI "_ 7OGQJW"8 3__GQC "_ !CD 2LCEGQJM]8 25(?$B) 7!8
;>!+(?$*, '%$*W =3(%1(*B $ L5+(-(*B $*1 P!%?)>(*B 2("68 UU
R0CQ# SN%ST8 OHHKdeecGH#YIe%3kW&W_p !CD
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
23/61
%U
GMM"ZJHG"M] YGFC LPMGQGKJY GVCMHG_GQJHG"M QJEV]l
C]HJcYG]OCV cI JH YCJ]H ]CZCMHCCM Y"QJYGHGC]8 _E"L
@"] 2MWCYC] H" 5GYDJPFCC 7"PMHI8 =G]Q"M]GMl
_PEHOCE CiKJMV JQQC]] H" Y"QJY ]CEZGQC]#19 3HOCE
Y"QJYGHGC] OJZC YJPMQOCV OCJYHO QJEC KE"WEJL] _"E
PMV"QPLCMHCV EC]GVCMH]#20
," cPGYV HEP]H cCHDCCMYJD CM_"EQCLCMH JMV GLLGWEJMH Q"LLPMGHGC]8
K"YGQC VCKJEHLCMH] _E"L LCHE"K"YGHJM QCMHCE] JMV
]LJYYCE QGHGC] OJZC GMHE"VPQCV GLLGWEJHG"M ]HJHP]
Q"M_GVCMHGJYGHI K"YGQGC]8 ]KCQGJY O"HYGMC]8 JMV
Q"LLPMGHI CVPQJHG"M KE"WEJL]#21 @"QJY "__GQGJY]
!"# %S* R2PW# )8 %babTp !CD C"EWGJTp 5JEGC [EGQC8 2("(!, P!%?)>(*B F>>(B+$*",W A)?$%I"+$"!B(!, ") ;""+$?" $*1 /!"$(* F>>(B+$*", (* H&I&
%U R0CQ# SN%*T8 OHHKdeecGH#YIe%g9,&.k RVC]QEGcGMW !CD >(B+$*"
M3"+!$?5 KX(,0$*(?N8 OHHKdeecGH#YIe%65>%fJ RYJ]H ZG]GHCV 5JE#
http://bit.ly/1QXSRh0http://bit.ly/1QXT5EVhttp://bit.ly/1RMG1zahttp://bit.ly/1RMG1zahttp://bit.ly/1QXT5EVhttp://bit.ly/1QXSRh0
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
24/61
%*
OJZC JY]" KE"]CQPHCV CLKY"ICE] DO" CMWJWC GM
DJWC HOC_H JMV "HOCE JcP]C] H"DJEV]
PMV"QPLCMHCV D"EFCE]#22
(# ,OC SN%* CiCQPHGZC WPGVJMQC KE"HCQH] HOC]C
DCYY'C]HJcYG]OCV Y"QJY GMHCEC]H]# ,OC WPGVJMQCCiHCMV] OPLJMGHJEGJM ECYGC_ H" HOC ]JLC QJHCW"EI "_
n]KYGH'CYGWGcGYGHI _JLGYGC]o HOJH Y"QJY YCJVCE] OJV
Y"MW ]"PWOH ECYGC_ _"E# 2MV cI "__CEGMW VC_CEECV
JQHG"M ECYGC_ H" JM C]HGLJHCV U#a LGYYG"M Y"QJY
EC]GVCMH]8 HOC WPGVJMQC OCYK] KE"L"HC Y"QJY
W"ZCEMLCMH]` CiG]HGMW GMHCWEJHG"M C__"EH]#
BCQJP]C HOC GLKJQH "_ HOC WPGVJMQC G] L"]H
GLLCVGJHC JH HOC Y"QJY YCZCY8 Y"QJY W"ZCEMLCMH]
KE"ZGVCV CJEYI JMV CiHCM]GZC ]PKK"EH _"E GH]
GLKYCLCMHJHG"M# !CD
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
25/61
%&
Q"LLPMGHI WE"PK] _"E GLKYCLCMHJHG"M "_ HOC
WPGVJMQC#23 @"] 2MWCYC] EJG]CV m* LGYYG"M _"E GH]
SN%& QJLKJGWM H" OCYK @"] 2MWCYC] EC]GVCMH] JKKYI
_"E VC_CEECV JQHG"M#24 4E"L -"P]H"M H" +MVGJMJK"YG]
H" B"]H"M JMV cCI"MV8 Y"QJYGHGC] OJZC Q"MZCMCV
]HJFCO"YVCE] H" LJFC KYJM]8 KE"ZGVC GM_"ELJHG"M H"GLLGWEJMH EC]GVCMH]8 JMV CM]PEC JQQC]] H" hPJYGHI
YCWJY ]CEZGQC] H" OCYK EC]GVCMH] DGHO HOCGE
JKKYGQJHG"M]#25 +MVCCV8 DCCF] J_HCE HOC SN%*
WPGVJMQC DJ] JMM"PMQCV8 J MJHG"MJY Q"JYGHG"M "_
LJI"E] JMV Q"PMHI YCJVCE] QJLC H"WCHOCE H"
]PKK"EH HOC WPGVJMQC JMV ]OJEC cC]H KEJQHGQC] _"E
GLKYCLCMHJHG"M# ,OG] Q"JYGHG"M M"D GMQYPVC] "ZCE
%NN LJI"E] JMV Q"PMHI YCJVCE]#26
)# >GZCM HOC Y"QJY GMHCEC]H] JH ]HJFC8 Y"QJY
W"ZCEMLCMH] OJZC JY]" LJVC JM CiHEJ"EVGMJEI
SU @Gf 6"ccGM]8 7!8 9)+: ") ;(1 F>>(B+$*", ;>(1 I"$%%!1
7$"()*$% /!4)+>,8 !#JEQCHHG
2MM"PMQC] !JHG"MDGVC 2QHG"M] J] 7"PEH -CJEGMW] [E"QCCV "M
3cJLJ`] +LLGWEJHG"M 6C_"EL] R2KE# %)8 SN%&T8
OHHKdeecGH#YIe%K*6KNJ#
S& -"P]H"M +LLGWEJMH @CWJY 1CEZGQC] 7"YYJc"EJHGZC8
OHHKdeeDDD#QGHGfCM]OGKQ"EMCE#"EW RYJ]H ZG]GHCV 5JE# *8 SN%(Tp
7JE]"M8 ,30+$ M"HC %( JH ap 7GHI "_ B"]H"M8 5JI"E`] 3__GQC "_!CD B"]H"MGJM]8 OHHKdeecGH#YIe%>_OSS2 RYJ]H ZG]GHCV 5JE# *8
SN%(T#
S( 7GHGC] _"E 2QHG"M8 OHHKdeecGH#YIe%gI6hf< RYJ]H ZG]GHCV 5JE# *8
SN%(T#
http://bit.ly/1p4Rp0ahttp://bit.ly/1Gfh22Ahttp://bit.ly/1Gfh22Ahttp://bit.ly/1p4Rp0a
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
26/61
%(
C__"EH H" GM_"EL HOC Q"PEH] cCY"D DOI J MJHG"MDGVC
GM^PMQHG"M ]O"PYV M"H G]]PC# 2LGQG OJZC _GYCV
JLGQP] cEGC_] JH CZCEI ]HJWC "_ HOG] YGHGWJHG"M
CiKYJGMGMW DOI J MJHG"MDGVC GM^PMQHG"M cY"QFGMW
GLKYCLCMHJHG"M "_ HOC WPGVJMQC GLK"]C] GLLCVGJHC
OJEL] "M JLGQG`] EC]GVCMH]#
2] JLGQG OJZC CiKYJGMCV8 HOC GM^PMQHG"M OJEL]
Y"QJY CQ"M"LGC]# [ECZCMHGMW EC]GVCMH] _E"L D"EFGMW
YCWJYYI VCKEGZC] Y"QJYGHGC] "_ HJi ECZCMPC8 FCCK]
_JLGYGC] GM K"ZCEHI8 JMV YCJZC] PMV"QPLCMHCV
EC]GVCMH] ZPYMCEJcYC H" CLKY"ICE CiKY"GHJHG"M JMV
JcP]C# ,OC WPGVJMQC G] C]HGLJHCV H" GMQECJ]C HOC
GMQ"LC "_ _JLGYGC] DGHO JH YCJ]H "MC CYGWGcYC KJECMH
cI Jc"PH HCM KCEQCMH#27 !JHG"MDGVC8 GH G] C]HGLJHCV
HOJH HOC SN%S JMV SN%* VC_CEECV'JQHG"M GMGHGJHGZC]
D"PYV GMQECJ]C ]HJHC JMV Y"QJY HJi Q"MHEGcPHG"M] cImaN& LGYYG"M KCE ICJElm&b LGYYG"M _"E ,CiJ]
JY"MC#28 ,OC GM^PMQHG"M Q"]H] Y"QJY W"ZCEMLCMH]
OPMVECV] "_ HO"P]JMV] "_ V"YYJE] CJQO VJI GH
ECLJGM] GM C__CQH#
2LGQG OJZC JY]" CiKYJGMCV HOJH HOC GM^PMQHG"M
GLK"]C] GEECKJEJcYC ]"QGJY OJEL]# ,OC CM^"GMCV
WPGVJMQC KE"HCQH] QOGYVECM JMV KJECMH]8
S) 6JMVI 7JKK] !" $%&8 @!4!++!1 ;?"()* 4)+ H*$3"5)+(O!1F>>(B+$*" '$+!*",W ;*$%6,(, )4 @;';G, ')"!*"($% C44!?", )*
J$>(%(!, $*1 25(%1+!*8 5GWEJHG"M ["YGQI +M]HGHPHC8 %) R4Cc#
SN%(T8 OHHKdeecGH#YIe%/!Y-g6#
Sa >CC8 ,30+$ M"HC U JH
http://bit.ly/1UNlHQRhttp://bit.ly/1UNlHQR
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
27/61
%)
PMV"QPLCMHCV GLLGWEJMH] DGHO _JLGYI Q"MMCQHG"M]
H" HOC /MGHCV 1HJHC] JMV Y"QJY Q"LLPMGHGC]#29
=GHOO"YVGMW VC_CEECV JQHG"M KYJQC] LGYYG"M] "_
_JLGYGC] GM "PE QGHGC] JMV Q"PMHGC] JH CQ"M"LGQ JMV
KCE]"MJY EG]FlPMJcYC H" YCWJYYI ]PKK"EH HOCGE
_JLGYGC] JMV J_EJGV JMV ECYPQHJMH H" W" H" HOC K"YGQC8]CCF OCJYHO QJEC8 "E HJFC JVZJMHJWC "_ W"ZCEMLCMH
]CEZGQC] H" JGV HOCL]CYZC] JMV HOCGE QOGYVECM8 _"E
_CJE "_ ECZCJYGMW HOC PMV"QPLCMHCV ]HJHP] "_ J
_JLGYI LCLcCE# ,OC]C OJEL] CiHCMV cCI"MV HOC
K"HCMHGJY JKKYGQJMH] HOCL]CYZC]d QOGYVECM "_
PMV"QPLCMHCV KJECMH] RGMQYPVGMW LJMI QOGYVECM
DO" JEC QGHGfCM] "_ HOG] Q"PMHEIT ]P__CE "MW"GMW
]"QGJY JMV K]IQO"Y"WGQJY OJEL] VPC H" _CJE "_
]CKJEJHG"M _E"L KJECMH]8 ]GcYGMW]8 JMV "HOCE Y"ZCV
"MC]#30 2MV HOC ]J_CHI "_ JYY EC]GVCMH] G] HOECJHCMCV
Sb 7JKK]8 ,30+$ M"HC S) JH &8 ) RM"HGMW HOJH L"EC HOJM HD"'
HOGEV] "_ KJECMH] K"HCMHGJYYI CYGWGcYC _"E ECYGC_ PMVCE HOC
WPGVJMQC OJZC YGZCV GM HOC /MGHCV 1HJHC] _"E JH YCJ]H HCM
ICJE]8 JMV CGWOHI'_GZC KCEQCMH "_ HOCGE LGM"E QOGYVECM JEC /#1#
QGHGfCM]T#
UN I!! 5Ji .OECM_EPCMV8 X)8 5$-(*B $* 3*1)?3>!*"!1 0$+!*" 53+", ;>!+(?$* ?5(%1+!*8 =J]O# ["]H8 5JE# *8 SN%&p
A"JMMJ 0ECcI8 X)8 L)1$6G, F>>(B+$"()* C*4)+?!>!*"
')%(?(!, F>0$?" 25(%1+!*. J$>(%(!,. $*1 2)>>3*("(!,8 7CMHCE
_"E 2LCEGQJM [E"WEC]]8 b R2PW# SN%ST8 OHHKdeeJLKE#W]e%MYi7E7p
7JKK]8 ,30+$ M"HC S) JH %b'SN#
http://ampr.gs/1nlxCrChttp://ampr.gs/1nlxCrC
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
28/61
%a
DOCM Q"LLPMGHI LCLcCE] JEC J_EJGV H" ]CCF OCYK
_E"L HOC K"YGQC#31
2LGQG ECYI "M HOC Q"MHEGcPHG"M "_ JYY EC]GVCMH]8
JMV OJEL H" JMI ]GWMG_GQJMH K"EHG"M "_ "PE EC]GVCMH]
JMV _JLGYGC] J__CQH] HOC DGVCE Q"LLPMGHI# 2] J!CD 0L@ "FB /COOFEB/B>(B+$"()* C*4)+?!>!*" ')%(?(!,W C[$>(*(*B "5! F>0$?" )*
'3Q%(? I$4!"6 $*1 X)*)+(*B "5! \(?"(>,8 X!$+(*B =!4)+! "5! I&
2)>>& )* "5! Y31(?($+68 %%*HO 7"MW# RAPYI S%8 SN%&TR]HJHCLCMH "_ ,"L 5JMWCE8 5J^"E 7GHGC] 7OGC_] 2]]"QGJHG"MT8
JZJGYJcYC JH OHHKdeecGH#YIe%@.1LKB#
US 5JEZGMC -"DC8 L5! /!B()*W H*1!+ "5! 7!8 A$8. F%%!B$%
;%(!*, I344!+
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
29/61
%b
QGEQPGHGMW Q"M]GVCEJHG"M "_ HOC KPcYGQ GMHCEC]H GM
CM^"GMGMW W"ZCEMLCMH JQHG"M# -CEC8 HOC Q"PEH]
cCY"D _JGYCV H" CM]PEC HOJH KYJGMHG__]` KE"ZCM
]HJMVGMW GM^PEI ^P]HG_GCV JM CiKJM]GZC MJHG"MDGVC
GM^PMQHG"M# ,OJH ]HJMVGMW CEE"E OJV KE"_"PMV
KEJQHGQJY Q"M]ChPCMQC] _"E JLGQG# +H LCJMH HOJH M"Q"PEH cCY"D Q"M]GVCECV HOC OJEL] H" Y"QJY
Q"LLPMGHGC] JMV Y"QJY EC]GVCMH] cC_"EC G]]PGMW JM
GM^PMQHG"M cGMVGMW GM JLGQG`] O"LC ^PEG]VGQHG"M]#
%# -CEC8 JYHO"PWO HDCMHI']Gi ]HJHC] _GYCV ]PGH8
HOC VG]HEGQH Q"PEH Q"MQYPVCV HOJH KYJGMHG__] OJV
C]HJcYG]OCV "MYI "MC Q"MQECHC _"EL "_ GM^PEId33 HOJH
,CiJ] D"PYV JYYCWCVYI GMQPE n]CZCEJY LGYYG"M
V"YYJE]o GM _PHPEC JVLGMG]HEJHGZC Q"]H]8 KE"QC]]GMW
VEGZCE`] YGQCM]C JKKYGQJHG"M] _E"L EC]GVCMH] DO"
LGWOH hPJYG_I _"E VC_CEECV JQHG"M PMVCE HOC
WPGVJMQC R[CH# 2KK# S%JT#34
UU ,OC VG]HEGQH Q"PEH VGV M"H QECVGH HOC "HOCE Q"MQYP]"EI
JYYCWJHG"M] "_ GM^PEI LJVC cI KYJGMHG__]# 5JMI "_ KYJGMHG__]`
JYYCWCV nGM^PEGC]o GM _JQH EC]HCV "M PMKE"ZCM QYJGL] Jc"PH
GMQECJ]CV %)?$% _G]QJY cPEVCM R6C]K"MVCMH]` BE# GM 3KK# H"
[CHGHG"M _"E J =EGH "_ 7CEHG"EJEG JH %S8 %) R!"# %&'()*TT# BPH
KYJGMHG__] V" M"H KPEK"EH H" ECKEC]CMH Y"QJY W"ZCEMLCMH] GM
HOCGE ^PEG]VGQHG"M]8 JMV QJMM"H n]CCF H" CM^"GMo HOC SN%*
WPGVJMQC n"M HOC WE"PMV HOJH GH LGWOH QJP]C OJEL H" "HOCEKJEHGC]#o I!! ,8 &(% /#1#
%Ub8 %(U RSN%NT#
U* ,OC /MGHCV 1HJHC] M"HC] HOJH ,CiJ] G] QYJGLGMW OJEL _E"L
J Z"YPMHJEI ]HJHC ]Pc]GVI cCQJP]C ,CiJ] Q"PYV ]OG_H HOC Q"]H "_
KE"QC]]GMW YGQCM]C JKKYGQJHG"M] H" JKKYGQJMH] R[CH`E]` BE# JH
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
30/61
SN
BPH HOG] 7"PEH OJ] LJVC QYCJE HOJH n]HJMVGMW G]
M"H VG]KCM]CV GM WE"]]8o JMV8 J] J EC]PYH8 JMI
GM^PMQHGZC ECYGC_ LP]H cC HJGY"ECV H" nHOC GM^PEI GM
_JQH HOJH HOC KYJGMHG__ OJ] C]HJcYG]OCV#o
@$(>%!+25+6,%!+ 2)+0& -& 23*)8 &*) /#1# UUS8 U&URSNN(T RQGHJHG"M JMV hP"HJHG"M LJEF] "LGHHCVT# ,"
^P]HG_I HOC ]Q"KC "_ HOC KECYGLGMJEI GM^PMQHG"M8
KYJGMHG__] OJV H" C]HJcYG]O GM^PEI ]P__GQGCMH H" CM^"GM
HOC WPGVJMQC *$"()*8(1!# I!! J+(!*1, )4 "5! C$+"5.
F*?& -& A$(1%$8 C*-"%& I!+-,& KLM2N. F*?&8 &Sa /#1#
%()8 %a& RSNNNT RKJEHGC] LP]H C]HJcYG]O ]HJMVGMW _"E
CJQO _"EL "_ ECYGC_ ]"PWOH8 GMQYPVGMW ]HJMVGMW H"
"cHJGM JM GM^PMQHG"MT#
S# 7Y"]C JHHCMHG"M H" ]HJMVGMW GM HOC GM^PMQHG"M
Q"MHCiH KE"HCQH] HOGEV KJEHGC]8 ]PQO J] JLGQG JMV
HOCGE EC]GVCMH]8 Q!4)+! J cE"JV GM^PMQHG"M G] GLK"]CV
HOJH OJEL] Jc]CMH KJEHGC]# ,OG] 7"PEH OJ] DJEMCV
HOJH Q"PEH] LP]H DCGWO Q"LKCHGMW QYJGL] "_ GM^PEI
JMV KE"HCQH HOC KPcYGQ GMHCEC]H cC_"EC G]]PGMW JM
GM^PMQHG"M# I!!. !&B&. P(*"!+8 &&& /#1# JH SNp
P!(*Q!+B!+8 *&( /#1# JH U%U# +_ HOC]C VPHGC] JEC M"H
_"YY"DCV8 HOCEC G] J ]CEG"P] EG]F HOJH "ZCEcE"JV
GM^PMQHG"M] DGYY ]CEZC J] nGM]HEPLCMHr]s "_ DE"MW#o
I$%$O$+ -& =3)*)8 &&b /#1# )NN8 )%*'%& RSN%NT
RQGHJHG"M JMV hP"HJHG"M LJEF] "LGHHCVTp ,!! $%,) P!(*Q!+B!+8 *&( /#1# JH U%S RDJEMGMW Q"PEH] H" nKJI
S(T# 2LGQG EJG]C ]HJMVGMW "c^CQHG"M] HOJH D"PYV JKKYI
GMVCKCMVCMHYI "_ JMI Z"YPMHJEI ]Pc]GVI OPEVYC#
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
31/61
S%
KJEHGQPYJE ECWJEV _"E HOC KPcYGQ Q"M]ChPCMQC] GM
CLKY"IGMW HOC CiHEJ"EVGMJEI ECLCVI "_
GM^PMQHG"MoT# 1HJMVGMW G] HOC ]HJEHGMW K"GMH _"E HOC]C
HOEC]O"YV GMhPGEGC]# 7"PEH] QJMM"H Q"OCECMHYI HJGY"E
GM^PMQHG"M] H" JZ"GV KPcYGQ OJEL] PMYC]] HOC ]Q"KC
"_ ECYGC_ J KYJGMHG__ G] CMHGHYCV H" G] QYCJE _E"L HOC"PH]CH#
2H CZCEI ]HJWC "_ HOG] YGHGWJHG"M8 JLGQG Y"QJY
W"ZCEMLCMH] OJZC CMVCJZ"ECV H" CiKYJGM HOC
CiHCM]GZC OJEL] GLK"]CV JMV QEPQGJY cCMC_GH] Y"]H
cI CM^"GMGMW HOC WPGVJMQC GM HO"P]JMV] "_ Y"QJY
Q"LLPMGHGC] JQE"]] HOC MJHG"M# ,OC HOC"EI "_
]HJMVGMW JQQCKHCV cI HOC Y"DCE Q"PEH]8 O"DCZCE8
GLKE"KCEYI GWM"ECV HO"]C GMHCEC]H]lJQQCKHGMW J
VG]QECHC JMV MJEE"D QYJGL "_ nGM^PEIo H" J ]GMWYC
KYJGMHG__lJ] Q"M_CEEGMW ]HJMVGMW H" CM^"GM HOC
WPGVJMQC CZCEIDOCEC8 ECWJEVYC]] "_ OJEL_PY Y"QJY
GLKJQH# BPH HOC ]HJMVGMW GM^PEI QYJGLCV V"C] M"H
LJHQO HOC CiKJM]GZC ECYGC_ HOJH DJ] "EVCECV#
-CEC8 KYJGMHG__] C]HJcYG]OCV "MYI "MC _"EL "_
JYYCWCV ]HJMVGMW GM^PEId HOJH ,CiJ] LJI _JQC
JVVGHG"MJY JVLGMG]HEJHGZC CiKCMVGHPEC] _E"L
GMQECJ]CV VEGZCE`] YGQCM]C JKKYGQJHG"M] G_ HOC SN%*
WPGVJMQC W"C] GMH" C__CQH# [YJGMHG__] VGV M"H CZCM
C]HJcYG]O HOJH HOC GMQECJ]CV CiKCMVGHPEC]Q"M]HGHPHCV nOJELo "E nGM^PEIo GM HOC "EVGMJEI
LCJMGMW "_ HO"]C HCEL]# BI WEJMHGMW D"EF
JPHO"EGfJHG"M JMV ECQ"WMGfGMW HOC CQ"M"LGQ
Q"MHEGcPHG"M "_ Y"MWHCEL PMV"QPLCMHCV EC]GVCMH]8
HOC WPGVJMQC KE"ZGVC] OPMVECV] "_ LGYYG"M] "_
V"YYJE] GM CQ"M"LGQ cCMC_GH] H" ]HJHC] JMV
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
32/61
SS
Y"QJYGHGC]#35 [YJGMHG__] VGV M"H VG]KE"ZC HOC]C
cCMC_GH]p HOCI "MYI QYJGLCV HOJH HOC cCMC_GH] DCEC
GEECYCZJMH CZCM G_ ,CiJ] JMV "HOCE KYJGMHG__] JEC MCH
CQ"M"LGQ JMV _G]QJY cCMC_GQGJEGC] PMVCE HOC
WPGVJMQC#
U# ,OG] Q"MQCKH "_ ]HJMVGMW M"H "MYI "ZCEY""F]
HOC YJQF "_ Q"MQECHC _GMJMQGJY GM^PEI H" ,CiJ]8 GH JY]"
GWM"EC] HOC OJEL] HOJH J MJHG"MDGVC GM^PMQHG"M
GLK"]C] "M Y"QJYGHGC]# ,OC Q"PEH] cCY"D MCZCE
CZJYPJHCV DOI ,CiJ]`] QYJGL "_ GMQECJ]CV
JVLGMG]HEJHGZC Q"]H] R]"YCYI GM ,CiJ]T DJEEJMHCV
CM^"GMGMW HOC WPGVJMQC JQE"]] HOC /MGHCV 1HJHC]#
4JGYPEC H" JVOCEC H" HOEC]O"YV ]HJMVGMW
EChPGECLCMH] LCJMH GM C__CQH HOJH HOC ECJY D"EYV
Q"MQCEM] "_ LGYYG"M] "_ Y"QJY EC]GVCMH] DCEC
"ZCEY""FCV#
+M Q"MHEJ]H H" ,CiJ]`] MJEE"D QYJGL "_ GM^PEI
_E"L _PHPEC CiKCMVGHPEC]8 cY"QFGMW GLKYCLCMHJHG"M
"_ HOC WPGVJMQC GLK"]C] CiHCM]GZC Y"QJY OJEL]lJYY
"_ DOGQO HOC Q"PEH] cCY"D VG]ECWJEVCV cCQJP]C HOCI
JQQCKHCV HOJH ,CiJ] OJV ]HJMVGMW H" CM^"GM HOC
WPGVJMQC MJHG"MDGVCd
• @"QJY OJEL] DGHOGM ,CiJ]# @"QJY
W"ZCEMLCMH] DGHOGM KYJGMHG__ ]HJHC] DGYY]P__CE OJEL G_ HOC WPGVJMQC G] VCYJICV# ,OC
U& >CC8 ,30+$ M"HC U JH
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
33/61
SU
SN%S JMV SN%* VC_CEECV'JQHG"M GMGHGJHGZC]
D"PYV YGFCYI YCJV H" LGYYG"M] "_ GMQECJ]CV
Y"QJY HJi Q"MHEGcPHG"M]l"MC C]HGLJHC G] HOJH
HOC ]HJHC "_ ,CiJ] JMV GH] Y"QJY W"ZCEMLCMH]
Q"PYV ECQCGZC m&b LGYYG"M J ICJE _E"L HOC
GMGHGJHGZC]#36 +M _JQH8 JLGQG _E"L ,CiJ]8
ECKEC]CMHGMW (#) LGYYG"M ,CiJ] EC]GVCMH]8
"KK"]C HOC KECYGLGMJEI GM^PMQHG"M JMV
Q"M_GEL HOJH HOC GM^PMQHG"M DGYY OJEL HOCGE
EC]GVCMH]8 Q"LLPMGHGC]8 JMV Y"QJY
W"ZCEMLCMH]#
• @"QJY OJEL] "PH]GVC ,CiJ]# @GFCDG]C8 DOGYC
KYJGMHG__] KE"ZCV M" OJEL )3",(1! "_ ,CiJ]8
Y"QJY W"ZCEMLCMH] JMV LGYYG"M] "_ Y"QJY
EC]GVCMH] GM "HOCE ]HJHC] JEC OJELCV cI HOC
KECYGLGMJEI GM^PMQHG"M# 2] JLGQG OJZC
CiKYJGMCV8 CZCM G_ Q"M_GMCV H" _GMJMQGJY
GLKJQH JY"MC8 HOC _GMJMQGJY OJEL H" Y"QJY
W"ZCEMLCMH] GM "HOCE ]HJHC] _JE CiQCCV]
,CiJ]`] QYJGL "_ GM^PEI# !CD
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
34/61
S*
!CD (? =!*!4(", )4 C[0$*1(*B"5! @+!$>W @;'; $*1 @;2; F>0$?", )* A), ;*B!%!, $*1
2$%(4)+*($8 /7@2 !"EHO 2LCEGQJM +MHCWEJHG"M j
0CZCY"KLCMH 7CMHCE8 % RAJM# S(8 SN%&T8 OHHKdeecGH#YIe%,C+i6@#
http://bit.ly/1TeIxRLhttp://bit.ly/1TeIxRL
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
35/61
S&
_JLGYI ]HJcGYGHI JMV GM^PEC] QOGYVECM# ,O"]C
OJEL] HEPYI JEC GEECKJEJcYCp HOCI QJMM"H cC
PMV"MC CZCM G_ HOC GM^PMQHG"M G] YJHCE YG_HCV#
*# =OGYC HOC Y"DCE Q"PEH] ECYGCV "M
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
36/61
S(
]HJHC] GM HOCGE ]"ZCECGWM QJKJQGHI M"E QYCJEYI
GEECKJEJcYC GM ]Q"KC#
,OC Y"DCE Q"PEH]` JMJYI]G] OGWOYGWOH] HOC
"ZCEcECJVHO GM KYJGMHG__]` ]HJMVGMW HOC"EI# @GFC
JYL"]H JYY W"ZCEMLCMH JQHG"M]8 HOC CiCQPHGZCWPGVJMQC cJYJMQC] ]O"EH'HCEL Q"]H] JMV Y"MW'HCEL
cCMC_GH]lOCEC8 HOC cCMC_GH] H" Y"QJY Q"LLPMGHGC] cI
JYY"DGMW QCEHJGM YJD'JcGVGMW JMV Y"MW]HJMVGMW
EC]GVCMH] H" JKKYI _"E VC_CEECV JQHG"M ECYGC_# +H
D"PYV cC JYL"]H GLK"]]GcYC H" GLKYCLCMH JMI
cCMC_GQGJY W"ZCEMLCMH JQHG"M8 KJEHGQPYJEYI JQHG"M
HOJH JGV] JMV KE"HCQH] J YJEWC MPLcCE "_
GMVGZGVPJY]8 DGHO"PH ,)>! 0$+"6 OJZGMW H" LJFC
,)>! _PHPEC JVLGMG]HEJHGZC CiKCMVGHPEC]#
,OC HIKC "_ JVLGMG]HEJHGZC Q"]H] HOJH ,CiJ]
J]]CEH] JEC Q"LL"M H" JMI MPLcCE "_ KJEHGC]8
GMQYPVGMW M"M'W"ZCEMLCMHJY KJEHGC] YGFC GM]PEJMQC
Q"LKJMGC]8 CLKY"ICE]8 JMV "HOCE cP]GMC]]C] HOJH
LGWOH OJZC H" KE"QC]] JVVGHG"MJY JKKYGQJHG"M] "E
KJKCED"EF J] J EC]PYH "_ J QOJYYCMWCV W"ZCEMLCMH
WPGVJMQC "E JQHG"M# +H LJFC] YGHHYC ]CM]C H" G]]PC
MJHG"MDGVC GM^PMQHG"M] H" KJEHGC] DO" QYJGL
]HJMVGMW cJ]CV "M JMHGQGKJHCV JVLGMG]HEJHGZC Q"]H]
DGHO"PH Q"M]GVCEGMW HOC KPcYGQ cCMC_GH] J]]"QGJHCV
DGHO HOC QOJYYCMWCV W"ZCEMLCMH JQHG"M JMV DGHO"PHQ"M]GVCEGMW DOCHOCE HOC KYJGMHG__ CZCM ]P__CE] J MCH
L"MCHJEI Y"]]#
,OC cECJVHO "_ HOC ]HJMVGMW HOC"EI GM HOG] QJ]C
G] Q"LK"PMVCV cI HOC QGEQPGH LJ^"EGHI`] EJHG"MJYC
_"E J MJHG"MDGVC GM^PMQHG"M# ,OC HD"'^PVWC LJ^"EGHI
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
37/61
S)
^P]HG_GCV J MJHG"MDGVC GM^PMQHG"M cI KEC]PLGMW HOJH
J WC"WEJKOGQJYYI YGLGHCV GM^PMQHG"M D"PYV cC
GMC__CQHGZC cCQJP]C CYGWGcYC cCMC_GQGJEGC] "_ HOC
CiCQPHGZC WPGVJMQC Q"PYV K"HCMHGJYYI ECY"QJHC H"
,CiJ] _E"L "HOCE JECJ] R[CH# 2KK# abJT# BPH
_ECCV"L "_ HEJZCY G] J cJ]GQ _JQH "_ YG_C GM HOC /MGHCV1HJHC]# ,OC K"HCMHGJY _"E GMVGZGVPJY] H" L"ZC H" J
KJEHGQPYJE Y"QJHG"M _E"L "HOCE JECJ] CiG]H] GM
JYL"]H JMI QJ]C#
+_ HOJH K"HCMHGJY JY"MC JPHO"EGfCV ]HJMVGMW H"
"cHJGM J MJHG"MDGVC GM^PMQHG"M40 M"HDGHO]HJMVGMW
DGVC]KECJV Y"QJY OJEL] CY]CDOCEC8 Y"QJY
W"ZCEMLCMH] D"PYV cC _JQCV DGHO JM PMD"EFJcYC
]HJMVGMW EPYC HOJH KYJQCV HOC GMHCEC]H] "_ HOCGE
EC]GVCMH] JH EG]F# 2 _PMVJLCMHJY HEJGH "_ 2LCEGQJM
YG_ClPMEC]HEGQHCV HEJZCYlD"PYV JPHO"EGfC
MJHG"MDGVC GM^PMQHG"M] J] J LJHHCE "_ Q"PE]C GM
YGHGWJHG"M QOJYYCMWGMW _CVCEJY JQHG"M]# ,OC
nLGWEJHG"Mo HOC"EI "_ MJHG"MDGVC GM^PMQHG"M] JY]"
VG]ECWJEV] HOC GLLCVGJHC C__CQH] "_ ]PQO
GM^PMQHG"M] "M LGYYG"M] "_ GMVGZGVPJY] GM HOCGE
QPEECMH Q"LLPMGHGC]# +H VG]]CEZC] HOC KPcYGQ
40 2YHO"PWO HOG] 7"PEH OJ] EChPGECV HOJH HOECJHCMCV GM^PEI cC
nECJY8 GLLCVGJHC8 JMV VGECQHo J] DCYY J] nQCEHJGMYI GLKCMVGMWo
H" ]PKK"EH ]HJMVGMW8 @$-(, -& JC2 8 &&* /#1# )S*8 )U* RSNNaTp2%$00!+ -& ;>*!,"6 F*"G% HI;8 %UU 1# 7H# %%Ua8 %%*U RSN%UT8
KYJGMHG__] MCZCE KE"ZCV HOJH HOC"EGfCV LGWEJHG"M GMH" ,CiJ]
DJ] ECJY JMV GLLGMCMH8 "E CZCM YGFCYI H" GMQECJ]C HOC MPLcCE
"_ _PHPEC VEGZCE`] YGQCM]C JKKYGQJHG"M]8 WGZCM HOC K"HCMHGJY _"E
]GLPYHJMC"P] LGWEJHG"M "_ GMVGZGVPJY] JMV _JLGYGC] "PH "_
,CiJ]#
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
38/61
Sa
GMHCEC]H H" G]]PC CiKJM]GZC ECYGC_ cJ]CV "M HOC
HOC"ECHGQJY K"]]GcGYGHI "_ GMVGZGVPJY] ECY"QJHGMW JH
]"LC _PHPEC K"GMH8 DOGYC GWM"EGMW KEC]CMH'VJI
OJEL] H" LGYYG"M] "_ Y"QJY EC]GVCMH] GM HOC QGHGC] JMV
Q"PMHGC] DOCEC HOCI EC]GVC +(B5" *)8#
(# 2QQCKHGMW ]PQO J cE"JV ]HJMVGMW HOC"EI JY]"
HOECJHCM] H" L"ZC WCMCEJYGfCV K"YGHGQJY VG]KPHC]
GMH" _CVCEJY Q"PEH]8 WGZGMW KYJGMHG__] DGHO MJEE"D
JMV Q"M_GMCV GM^PEGC] J LCQOJMG]L H" "cHJGM
MJHG"MDGVC GM^PMQHG"M]# ,OC L"]H K"YGHGQJYYI
Q"MHE"ZCE]GJY ]Pc^CQH] JEC JY]" HO"]C L"]H YGFCYI H"
J__CQH HOC VJGYI YGZC] "_ GMVGZGVPJY]# @"QJY
W"ZCEMLCMH] JEC C]KCQGJYYI ZPYMCEJcYC cCQJP]C
HOCI KE"ZGVC _E"MHYGMC ]CEZGQC] JMV VGECQHYI
CiKCEGCMQC HOC GLKJQH DOCM EC]GVCMH] JEC VCKEGZCV
"_ C]]CMHGJY ]CEZGQC]8 KE"HCQHG"M]8 JMV ECLCVGC]
cCQJP]C "_ J ^PVGQGJY GM^PMQHG"M#
2WJGM8 HOC Q"EC Q"LK"MCMH] "_ KYJGMHG__]` QYJGLCV
]HJMVGMWlKE"^CQHCV _PHPEC JVLGMG]HEJHGZC Q"]H]
KYP] HOC K"]]GcGYGHI "_ GMVGZGVPJY] HEJZCYGMWlQ"PYV
cC J]]CEHCV cI J DGVC JEEJI "_ KJEHGC] c"HO KPcYGQ
JMV KEGZJHC# >GZGMW J ]GMWYC ]HJHC R"E J ]GMWYC KJEHIT
]HJMVGMW H" C__CQHGZCYI ZCH" _CVCEJY JQHG"M
MJHG"MDGVC "M ]PQO MJEE"D KE""_ "_ GM^PEI W"C] _JE
cCI"MV HOC CiG]HGMW ]HJMVGMW KEGMQGKYC] ECQ"WMGfCVcI HOG] 7"PEH#41
*% 1HJMVGMW HOC"EGC] HOJH ECJVGYI JYY"D ]GMWYC'Q"PEH
MJHG"MDGVC GM^PMQHG"M] JY]" KYJQC QEPQGJY KPcYGQ G]]PC] GM HOC
OJMV] "_ "MC ^PVWClQ"PMHCELJMVGMW HOG] 7"PEH`] QJPHG"M HOJH
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
39/61
Sb
)# 4GMJYYI8 G_ ]HJMVGMW H" "cHJGM J MJHG"MDGVC
GM^PMQHG"M G] PKOCYV cJ]CV "M KE"^CQHCV
JVLGMG]HEJHGZC CiKCMVGHPEC] KYP] HOC K"]]GcGYGHI "_
GMVGZGVPJY] HEJZCYGMW8 J OPWC ]DJHO "_ _CVCEJY
JQHG"M] DGHO QEGHGQJY C__CQH] "M Y"QJY EC]GVCMH] D"PYVcC ]Pc^CQH H" ]DCCKGMW GM^PMQHGZC QOJYYCMWC] GM
JYL"]H JMI VG]HEGQH Q"PEH GM HOC MJHG"M# 4E"L J
KEJQHGQJY KCE]KCQHGZC8 GM "EVCE H" KE"HCQH LPMGQGKJY
GMHCEC]H]8 Y"QJY JPHO"EGHGC] D"PYV OJZC H" HEJQF
YJD]PGH] JE"PMV HOC Q"PMHEI JMV ]CCF H" _GYC JLGQP]
cEGC_]8 "E CZCM GMHCEZCMC8 H" DJEV "__ OJEL_PY
GM^PMQHG"M] GM HOCGE O"LC ^PEG]VGQHG"M]#42
7GHI JMV Q"PMHI JHH"EMCI] JQQP]H"LCV H"
KEJQHGQGMW "MYI GM HOCGE Y"QJY Q"PEH] D"PYV OJZC H"
JKKCJE GM _JEJDJI _CVCEJY Q"PEH] JMV JHHCLKH H"
KEC]CMH CZGVCMQC "_ Y"QJY OJEL] GM YGHGWJHG"M
GMZ"YZGMW "HOCE KJEHGC]# kCEI _CD LPMGQGKJY YJD
"__GQC] OJZC HOC]C QJKJcGYGHGC]8 KJEHGQPYJEYI _"E
KECYGLGMJEI GM^PMQHG"M KE"QCCVGMW] J] GM HOG] QJ]C8
DOCM W"ZCEMLCMH JQHG"M G] JH ]HJFC8 Q"PEH] ]O"PYV M"H
nHODJEH HOC VCZCY"KLCMH "_ GLK"EHJMH hPC]HG"M] "_ YJD cI
_ECCfGMW HOC _GE]H _GMJY VCQG]G"M ECMVCECV "M J KJEHGQPYJE YCWJY
G]]PC#o H*("!1 I"$"!, -&
*S BI VGZ"EQGMW HOC ]Q"KC "_ HOC GM^PMQHG"M _E"L KE"ZCM GM^PEI8HOC ]HJMVGMW HOC"EI GM HOG] QJ]C CMQ"PEJWC] KYJGMHG__] H"
]HEJHCWGQJYYI _"EPL ]O"K JMV H" VCYGcCEJHCYI QO""]C Q"PEH] GM
_"EPL] DOCEC HOC OJEL] "_ J cE"JV GM^PMQHG"M DGYY M"H cC
"cZG"P] "E JKKJECMH8 JMV DOCEC GH DGYY cC VG__GQPYH _"E
JVZCE]CYI J__CQHCV KJEHGC]8 YGFC Y"QJY W"ZCEMLCMH]8 H" JKKCJE#
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
40/61
UN
DOGQO HJFC KYJQC "M JM CiKCVGHCV HGLC_EJLC# 4"E
JYY HOC]C ECJ]"M]8 VCZ"HGMW ]QJEQC EC]"PEQC] H" ]HJZC
"__ "ZCEcE"JV GM^PMQHG"M] GM _JE'_YPMW ^PEG]VGQHG"M]
G] GLKEJQHGQJY8 G_ M"H GLK"]]GcYC8 _"E HOC ZJ]H
LJ^"EGHI "_ HOC JLGQG QGHGC] JMV Q"PMHGC]#
? ? ? ?
+M HOG] QJ]C8 M" Q"PEH cCY"D Q"M]GVCECV HOC OJEL
H" LGYYG"M] "_ KC"KYC JQE"]] HO"P]JMV] "_ Y"QJY
^PEG]VGQHG"M] cC_"EC G]]PGMW J MJHG"MDGVC GM^PMQHG"M
cY"QFGMW HOC WPGVJMQC# ,OG] 7"PEH ]O"PYV ZJQJHC
HOC GM^PMQHG"M cCQJP]C KYJGMHG__] _JGYCV H" C]HJcYG]O
]HJMVGMW H" ^P]HG_I HOC ]Q"KC "_ HOC GM^PMQHG"M8 "E
KE"ZC HOJH HOC GM^PMQHG"M ]CEZCV HOC KPcYGQ GMHCEC]H
JMV DJ] MCQC]]JEI H" ECLCVI Q"WMGfJcYC OJEL H",CiJ]#
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
41/61
U%
)!")1-/&!"
,OC ^PVWLCMH "_ HOC 7"PEH "_ 2KKCJY] ]O"PYV cC
ECZCE]CV#
6C]KCQH_PYYI ]PcLGHHCV8
; 27-26< =# 7 26,.6 5+7-2.@ !# 4./.6
2)+0)+$"()* 2)3*,!% )4 2("6 ;"")+*!6 )4 "5!
"5! 2("6 )4 7!8 9)+:. 2("6 )4 A), ;*B!%!,.
;"")+*!6 4)+ "5! 2("6 )4 ;"")+*!6 4)+ "5! 2("6 )4
7!8 9)+: $*1 /!!1. ;"")+*!6 4)+ P(%%($>
. ;%$Q$>$
2 !!. @# 536>2!
2("6 ;"")+*!6.
;"")+*!6 4)+ I"!-! ;1%!+
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
42/61
!"
#$%%& () *+,-.,/
0$1%23 0$1%4,. 5$/ 26, 0$1%23 $5 7.&8,9&
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& +#,%"' #) !-./&0.1 +.-2)#$%2.
:2,;6,%
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
43/61
!!
:2,;6,% 7) K&CL4&&C
0$1%23 722$/%,3
+#,%:&- )#$ "*& +#,%"' D#.$0
#) !$-2%3"#% +#,%"'1 A2$32%2.
M,$/-, 7) J+.4$%?&.2+8$/, 0+23 :$.+C+2$/
!""#$%&' )#$ 6.'#$ 9"&E*.%2& F.5-2%3:GD-.@&
.8"2%3 #% >&*.-) #) "*& 6.'#$
.%0 +2"' +#,%82- #) D.-"2/#$&
#&I+9 =) 7.,46+/,
0+23 722$/%,3
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& +2"' #) D&--1 +.-2)#$%2.
H6+.+;;& K) M126/+,
0$/;$/&2+$% 0$1%4,.
+#,%:&- )#$ "*& +2"' #) D-##/2%3"#%1 H%02.%.
6.'#$ I#*% J./2-"#%
($N,/2 ?) >1C,
0+23 722$/%,3
0+23 $5 ?$+4,
!""#$%&' )#$ K.L20 J= D2&"&$1
6.'#$ #) "*& +2"' #) D#2:&1 H0.*#
E1-,%, >) BOP.&6,/230$/;$/&2+$% 0$1%4,.
0+23 $5 ?$42$% >&G #,;&/28,%2
!""#$%&' )#$ 6.$"2% I= M.-:*
6.'#$ #) "*& +2"' #) D#:"#%1 6.::.8*,:&"":
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
44/61
!Q
() 06/+42$;6,/ K,3,/
0+23 722$/%,3 5$/ 26, 0+23 $5 ?/+9-,;$/2
!""#$%&' #% >&*.-) #) "*& J#%#$.>-& I#:&E* C=
;.%2/1 6.'#$ #) "*& +2"' #) D$203&E#$"1
+#%%&8"28,"
K&/@ :$44+
0+23 722$/%,3
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& +2"' #) D$#5%:L2--&1 N&7.:
6.'#$ N#%' 6.$"2%&O
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
45/61
!T
06,/3. F&24$% P+46,/
0+23 :$.+C+2$/ $5 26, 0+23 $5 06,.4,&
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& +2"' #) +*&-:&.1 6.::.8*,:&"":
.%0 +2"' 6.%.3&$ N*#/.: ;= !/>$#:2%#
:2,;6,% () H&22$%0$/;$/&2+$% 0$1%4,.
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& +2"' #) +*28.3#1 H--2%#2:
.%0 6.'#$ F.*/ B/.%,&-
($4, K) F+%@,.,/
#,;123 0$1%23 722$/%,3
0$C$%+%$ 0$1%23 722$/%,34 B55+C,
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& +#8#%2%# +#,%"'1 !$2O#%.
D#.$0 #) 9,E&$L2:#$:
(+C6&/9 0) H5,+55,/A =/)
0+23 722$/%,3
0+23 $5 0$.18N14
+#,%:&- )#$ !%0$&5 ;2%"*&$1
6.'#$ #) "*& +2"' #) +#-,/>,:1 R*2#
7%+2& 7.I&/,S
:2&2,O4 722$/%,3
#$%&.9 =) H,C6$14
H&1. 7) 0&42+-.+$%,
744+42&%2 :2&2,O4 722$/%,34 !""#$%&': )#$ +##@ +#,%"'1 H--2%#2:
F,%93 >) E.42$%
0+23 722$/%,3
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& +2"' #) +$&"&1 4&>$.:@.
6.'#$ F#3&$ Q#:"&$
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
46/61
!U
K$%+C& >+/& ?/&I$
>+/& ?/&I$ >&GA H>>0
!""#$%&' )#$ K.--.: +#,%"'1 N&7.:1
.%0 +-.' P&52: I&%@2%:1
+#,%"' I,03& #) K.--.: +#,%"'
R&//+,2 7) :2,+%,/
0+23 722$/%,3
?,42 ?,42 V W/+,-,/ >>H
!""#$%&' )#$ K.% M#-@1
6.'#$ #) "*& +2"' #) K.L2:1 +.-2)#$%2.
=$6% 0) K142$
744+42&%2 0+23 722$/%,3
0+23 $5 #&32$%A B6+$
#,;&/28,%2 $5 >&G
!""#$%&' )#$ +2"' #) K.'"#%1 R*2#
.%0 4.% M*.-&'1 6.'#$ #) "*& +2"' #) K.'"#%1 R*2#
#) :C$22 K&/2+%,S
0+23 722$/%,3
!""#$%&' )#$ 628*.&- D= J.%8#8@
6.'#$ #) "*& +2"' S +#,%"' #) K&%L&$
=$6% ?) K1/;6,3
($4,%26&.A K1/;6,3A 0$N.,%2S V #$%&61,
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& A2--.3& #) K#-"#%1 H--2%#2:.%0 6.'#$ F2-&' J= F#3&$:
H&2/+C@ F) ?&@,/
+2"' !""#$%&' )#$ "*& +2"' #)
K,$*./1 4#$"* +.$#-2%.
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
47/61
!X
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
48/61
!Z
J+[1,.., 7..,% F+%5/,3
0$/;$/&2+$% 0$1%4,. $5 26, 0+23 $5 M&/3A L%9+&%&
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& +2"' #) ;.$'1 H%02.%. .%0
6.'#$ >H
!""#$%&' )#$ 4.%8' F= F#"&$2%3
6.'#$ #) "*& +2"' #) J23*-.%0 C.$@1 H--2%#2:
7.34+& K) H/$@$A E4[)
L%2,/+8 0$/;$/&2+$% 0$1%4,.
0+23 $5 R$N$@,%
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& 6.'#$ .%0
+2"' #) J#>#@&%1 4&5 I&$:&'
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
49/61
!_
W&/& >&8N 01%6&
744+42&%2 0+23 :$.+C+2$/
!""#$%&' )#$ !-&7 D= 6#$:&1
6.'#$ #) J#-'#@&1 6.::.8*,:&"":
#$%%& >) E981%94$%0+23 722$/%,3
=19+26 (&84,3
06+,5A M,%,/&. >+2+-&2+$% :,C2+$%
0+23 $5 R$142$% >,-&. #,;&/28,%2
!""#$%&' )#$ 9'-L&:"&$ N,$%&$1
6.'#$ #) J#,:"#%
:C$22 7) #&8/$%
0+23 722$/%,3 $5 26, 0+23 $5
R1%2+%-2$%A F,42 ]+/-+%+&
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& +2"' #) J,%"2%3"#%1 M&:" A2$32%2.
.%0 6.'#$ 9"&L& M2--2./:
7&/$% B) >&I+%,
0$/;$/&2+$% 0$1%4,.
!""#$%&' )#$ 9L.%"& P= 6'$28@A
6.'#$ #) H"*.8.1 4&5 ?#$@
K$%+C& #&I+4 =$+%,/
0+23 722$/%,3
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& +2"' #) I.8@:#%1 62::2::2EE26.'#$ N#%' ?.$>&$
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
50/61
Q`
=,/,83 P&//,..
0$/;$/&2+$% 0$1%4,.
0+23 $5 =,/4,3 0+23
!""#$%&' )#$ 9"&L&% 6= Q,-#E1
6.'#$ #) "*& +2"' #) I&$:&' +2"'1 4&5 I&$:&'
F+..+&8 #) M,&/3
0+23 722$/%,3
!""#$%&' )#$ 9'-L&:"&$ T9-'U I./&:1
6.'#$ #) "*& +2"' #) +I+%-42$%
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& +2"' #) P2L2%3:"#%1 +.-2)#$%2. .%0
6.'#$ F#0$23# B:E2%#O.
06&/.,4 H&/@+%
0+23 722$/%,3
!""#$%&' )#$ F#>&$" ;.$82.
6.'#$ #) P#%3 D&.8*1 +.-2)#$%2.
K&/3 0) F+C@6&80$1%23 0$1%4,.
!""#$%&' )#$ P#: !%3&-&: +#,%"'1 +.-2)#$%2.
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
51/61
Qa
=1.+& ?&2,4
>1C&4 0$1%23 H/$4,C12$/
?3 :2,I,% =) H&;&9+8$4
P+/42 744+42&%2A >1C&4 0$1%23 H/$4,C12$/b4 B55+C,
!""#$%&' )#$ D#.$0 #) P,8.: +#,%"'1 R*2#1
+#//2::2#%&$:1 N2%. 9@&-0#% M#O%2.@1 C&"&;&$@&%1 .%0 +.$#- +#%"$.0.
K+C6&,. H) K&3
0+23 722$/%,3
!""#$%&' )#$ C.,- F= 9#3-2%1
6.'#$ #) 6.02:#%1 M2:8#%:2%
:2,I,% F$$94+9,
0$1%23 0$1%4,.
+#,%:&- )#$ "*& +#,%"' #) 6.$2%1 +.-2)#$%2.
W$/+
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
52/61
Q"
K&/C H) R&%4,%
0$1%23 722$/%,3
!""#$%&' )#$ 6#%"3#/&$' +#,%"'1 6.$'-.%0
=$6% ($4,A =/)
7C2+%- 0$/;$/&2+$% 0$1%4,. !""#$%&' )#$ N#%2 4= J.$E1
6.'#$ #) 4&5 J.L&%1 +#%%&8"28,"
=,55/,3 $%9/,-&%
0$/;$/&2+$% 0$1%4,.
$5 26, 0+23 $5 J,G >$%9$%
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& +2"' #) 4&5 P#%0#%1 +#%%&8"28,"
.%0 6.'#$ 628*.&- B= C.::&$#
(,N,CC& #+,2S
0+23 722$/%,3
0+23 $5 J,G B/.,&%4
!""#$%&' )#$ 62"8* P.%0$2&,
6.'#$ #) "*& +2"' #) 4&5 R$-&.%:1 P#,2:2.%.
W&26.,,% E) M+..A E4[)
06+,5 $5 :2&55 5$/ H$.+C3 &%9 M$I,/%8,%2 755&+/4c
0$/;$/&2+$% 0$1%4,.
0+23 $5 J,G ($C6,..,
!""#$%&' )#$ 6.'#$ D$./:#% .%0
"*& +2"' #) 4&5 F#8*&--&1 4&5 ?#$@
F+..+, >) H&/@,/A E4[)
0$/;$/&2+$% 0$1%4,.
0+23 $5 J,G&/@A #,;&/28,%2 $5 >&G
!""#$%&' )#$ F.: I= [email protected]
6.'#$ #) "*& +2"' #) 4&5.$@1 4&5 I&$:&'
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
53/61
Q!
#$%%&.3% ?) >3%C6 W&6%
0+23 :$.+C+2$/
0+23 $5 J,G2$%
!""#$%&' )#$ 9&""2 K= M.$$&%
6.'#$ #) "*& +2"' #) 4&5"#%1 6.::.8*,:&"":
0/&+- R) =$6%4$%
0$/;$/&2+$% 0$1%4,.
!""#$%&' )#$ C.,- != K':"&$1
6.'#$ #) 42.3.$. Q.--:1 4&5 ?#$@
?&/N&/& =) H&/@,/
0+23 722$/%,3 5$/ 26,
0+23 $5 B&@.&%9
!""#$%&' )#$ 6.'#$ P2>>' 98*..)
.%0 "*& +2"' #) R.@-.%0
#$8,%+C@ :2&8;$%,A E4[)
0$/;$/&2+$% 0$1%4,. 5$/ 26, 0+23 $5 H&2,/4$%
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& +2"' #) C."&$:#%1 4&5 I&$:&'
.%0 6.'#$ I#:& TV#&'U N#$$&:
:&81,. :) M$/,%A E4[)
0+23 722$/%,3
0+23 $5 H,8N/$@, H+%,4
+2"' !""#$%&' )#$ C&/>$#@& C2%&:1 Q-#$20.
:$S+ H,9/$ &G #,;&/28,%2
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& +2"' #) C*2-.0&-E*2. .%0
6.'#$ I./&: Q=
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
54/61
>$1/9,4 :&%C6,S (+9-,
0+23 :$.+C+2$/
06+,5 >,-&. B55+C,/
!""#$%&' )#$ M2--2./ C&0,"#1
6.'#$ #) C2"":>,$3*
#&I+9 >) K+%C6,..$
0$/;$/&2+$% 0$1%4,.
!""#$%&' )#$ !0$2.% R= 6.EE1
6.'#$ #) C-.2%)2&-01 4&5 I&$:&'
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
55/61
QT
?/1C, (,,9 M$$98+..,/
0+23 722$/%,3
0+23 $5 (+C68$%9
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& +2"' #) F28*/#%0
.%0 6.'#$ N#/ D,""1 +2"' #) F28*/#%01 +.-2)#$%2.
?/+&% P) 01//&%
0$/;$/&2+$% 0$1%4,.
>&G #,;&/28,%2
0+23 $5 ($C6,42,/
!""#$%&' )#$ P#L&-' M.$$&%1
6.'#$ #) "*& +2"' #) F#8*&:"&$1 4&5 ?#$@
(&C6,. K) 0&/14$
?$/$1-6 722$/%,3
?$/$1-6 $5 ($4,..,
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& D#$#,3* #) F#:&--&1 4&5 I&$:&'
6.'#$ +*$2:"2%& K.%:&$&.,
=&8,4 :&%C6,S
0+23 722$/%,3
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& +2"' +#,%82-1
9.8$./&%"#1 +.-2)#$%2.
K&/-&/,2 #) H.&%,
:&.2 >&@, 0+23 722$/%,3
:&.2 >&@, 0+23 0$/;$/&2+$% !""#$%&' )#$ 9.-" P.@& +2"'
.%0 6.'#$ I.8@2& D2:@,E:@2
(+C@ () B.+I&/,S
0+23 722$/%,3
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& +2"' #) 9.% Q&$%.%0#1 +.-2)#$%2.
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
56/61
QU
#,%%+4 =) R,//,/&
:&% P/&%C+4C$ 0+23 722$/%,3
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& +2"' .%0 +#,%"' #) 9.% Q$.%82:8#
.%0 6.'#$ B052% 6= P&&
(+C6&/9 #$3.,0+23 722$/%,3
!""#$%&' )#$ 6.'#$ 9./ P288.$0#
.%0 "*& +2"' #) 9.% I#:&1 +.-2)#$%2.
=$6% 0) ?,+,/4
0$1%23 0$1%4,.
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& +#,%"' #) 9.% 6." +.-2)#$%2.
:$%+& () 0&/I&.6$
0+23 722$/%,3
0+23 $5 :&%2& 7%&
+2"' !""#$%&' )#$ "*& +2"' #) 9.%". !%.A +.-2)#$%2.
623,&- C,-20#1 6.'#$
B//3 H) W$/N
0$1%23 0$1%4,.
0$1%23 $5 :&%2& 0.&/&
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& +#,%"' #) 9.%". +-.$.1 +.-2)#$%2.
06&/.,%, >&;.&%2,
06+,5 0+I+. #,;123:&%2& 0/1S 0$1%23 722$/%,3
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& D#.$0 #) 9,E&$L2:#$:
9.%". +$,O +#,%"'1 !$2O#%.
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
57/61
QX
W,..,3 7) ?/,%%&%
0+23 722$/%,3
0+23 $5 :&%2& P,
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& +2"' #) 9.%". Q&
I.L2&$ 6= ;#%O.-&:1 6.'#$
K&/46& =$%,4 K$12/+,
0+23 722$/%,3
0+23 $5 :&%2& K$%+C&
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& +2"' #) 9.%". 6#%28.1 +.-2)#$%2.1
6.'#$ !%"#%2# A.OX,&O
0&/. M) P&.$2+C$
0$/;$/&2+$% 0$1%4,.
!""#$%&' )#$ ;.$' F= 68+.$"*'1
6.'#$ #) 98*&%&8".0'1 4&5 ?#$@
L&% F&/%,/
>,-&. 0$1%4,. 2$ 26, K&3$/ $5 :,&22.,
+#,%:&- )#$ B05.$0 D= 6,$$.'1 6.'#$ #) 9&.""-&
P/&%C+4 d) F/+-62A =/)
0+23 :$.+C+2$/
0+23 $5 :$8,/I+..,
!: .""#$%&' )#$ I#:&E* != +,$"."#%&1
.: 6.'#$ #) 9#/&$L2--&1 6.::.8*,:&"":
?/1C, M$.942,+%
0$1%23 0$1%4,.
7.,-/+& #, >& 0/1S
#,;123 0$1%23 0$1%4,.
0$1%23 $5 :$%$8&
!""#$%&': )#$ 9#%#/. +#,%"'1 +.-2)#$%2.
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
58/61
QZ
0/+42&. 0) ?/+4C$
0$/;$/&2+$% 0$1%4,. $5 26, 0+23 $5 :$126 ?,%9
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& +2"' #) 9#,"* D&%01 H%02.%.
.%0 6.'#$ C&"& D,""232&3
K+C6&,. 7) M&/I+%0+23 0$1%4,.$/
!""#$%&' )#$ Q$.%82: ;= 9-.'1
6.'#$ #) "*& +2"' #) 9"= P#,2:
:&81,. =) 0.&/@
0+23 722$/%,3
!""#$%&' )#$ 6.'#$ +*$2: +#-&/.%
9.2%" C.,-1 62%%&:#".
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
59/61
Q_
E.+S&N,26 7) H&1.+
0+23 $5 D,8@*#$%1
6.'#$ #) "*& +2"' #) N./E.1 Q-#$20.
#&I+9 7) E4C&8+..&
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
60/61
T`
E.+S&N,26 7) 0&I,%9+46
M,%,/&. 0$1%4,.
K&3$/ K1/+,. ?$G4,/
!""#$%&' )#$ 6.'#$ 6,$2&- D#5:&$1
M.:*2%3"#%1 K=+=
K+C6&,. =,%@+%4
0+23 722$/%,3
=,%@+%4 V R$-+%A >>H
!""#$%&' )#$ P2%0:&' C= J#$L."*1
6.'#$ #) M&:" J#--'5##01 +.-2)#$%2.
P/&%@ 0$%4$.$
>&G #+/,C2$/
+#,%:&- )#$ 6.'#$ +*.$-&: B= 9/2"* .%0
N*& A2--.3& #) M##0/&$&1 R*2#
H6+.+; =) H$-.,9+C6
0$1%23 0$1%4,.
0$1%23 $5 Y$.$
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& +#,%"' #) ?#-#1 +.-2)#$%2.
K+C6&,. ]) 01/2+A E4[)
0$/;$/&2+$% 0$1%4,.
0+23 $5 Y$%@,/4
!""#$%&' )#$ 62@& 9E.%#1
6.'#$ #) "*& +2"' #) ?#%@&$:1 4&5 ?#$@
=&4$% () :&N$.A E4[)
744+42&%2 :$.+C+2$/ $5 26, 0+23 $5 Y$/@A
H,%%43.I&%+&
!""#$%&' )#$ "*& +2"' #) ?#$@1 C&%%:'-L.%2.
.%0 6.'#$ +=
8/19/2019 Amicus Brief filed by 118 cities in U.S. v. Texas
61/61
Ta
0&/$.3% 0$.,8&%A E4[)
#+/,C2$/A P,9,/&. 79I$C&C3
J&2+$%&. >,&-1, $5 0+2+,4
!""#$%&' )#$ 4."2#%.- P&.3,& #) +2"2&:
=$6% #&%+,. (,&I,4M,%,/&. 0$1%4,.