American Medicine Readings

8/3/2019 American Medicine Readings

1/6

American medical education: anthropological approaches (towards a reading list).Updated: March 23, 2009

! "!

!"#$%&'($(%)$&*+,(-*'.("+(/0)%*1$+(0)&*1$-()&21$.*"+(

!#$%&'()!*+!#+!,-(!,-(!.+!/+!0,-!12$3+!4"5556+!!"#$%&'()#($'*+$,"#$%-(.#/$0#'/1$!"#$2-/3,$

4'.'56$768'*$%9/:#6*$;682;!LA2!*,-FK,F2!&H!/,>2!1'2>2-3,3E&-+!?69/*'($6@$>#'(,"$'*+$%6&-'($0#"'.-6/!M54NOPQNPO6++!!

!

#3:E->&-)!1+!4"55O6+!=#+-&'($!'(A$'*+$=#+-&'($76/A1$!"#$B-,9/:C$6@$,"#$;(-*-&+!*&-(&-;!D,F2!1KR$E@,3E&->!*3(+!

!QQQQQQQQQ!4"5CC6+!JE>@&K'>2)!J2>@'E?3E&->!,-(!JE,F-&>2>;!B2?'&(K@E-F!7&'=,$!

I2(E@E-2+!S-!I+!*&@:!,-(!J+!T&'(&-)!2(>+)!0-68#+-&-*#$DE'8-*#++!J&'('2@A3;!U$K82'!

#@,(2=E@!1KR$E>A2'>+!!

36!-2K3',$!?,3E2-3>+!%6&-'($%&-#*$F$=#+-&-*#!O";"MONQXO+!!

E3G!1'2>>+!!

:)!/+!4"5P56+!26/:-.#$'*+$T#8#8>+!!

>2$$)!^+!4"55"6+!DE)#&,#+$=-/'&(#31$%9/:#6*3$',$76/A+!1AE$,(2$?AE,;!L2=?$2!_-E%2'>E3G!1'2>>)!

!

QQQQQQQQQ!4"55C6+!!"#$768'*$-*$,"#$%9/:#6*V3$06+C+!/,=R'E(F2;!Y,'%,'(!_-E%2'>E3G!1'2>>+!

!/A'E>3,:E>)!J+!#+!,-(!/+!a2K(3-2'!4"55N6+!.3AE@>!E-!,!DA&'3!\AE32!/&,3;!!LA2!.3AE@,$!

JE$2==,>!3A,3!I2(E@,$!D3K(2-3>!/&-H'&-3+!G&'+#8-&!=#+-&-*#!XC;M`5QMO`+!

!


2/6


! M!

QQQQQQQQQ!4"55P6+!L2=?&','G!I,332'>;!LA2!.3AE@,$!/&->2bK2-@2>!&H!L',->E2-3!D&@E,$!

B2$,3E&->AE?>!E-!I2(E@,$!L',E-E-F+!?69/*'($6@$,"#$G8#/-&'*$=#+-&'($G336&-',-6*!MPC;!PN5QP`N+!

!/$,':2!23!,$+!4MVVN6+!@E2-3EHE@!L',->H&'=,3E&->!&H!Y2,$3A)!

S$$-2>>)!,-(!_+D+!)!,-(!TE'&Kc+!

!

/&-',()!1+!4"5CC6+!*2,'-E-F!3&!J&@3&';!B2H$2@3E&->!&-!B2@2-3!#@@&K-3>!&H!3A2!I2(E@,$!D@A&&$!92,'>+!?69/*'($6@$>#'(,"$'*+$%6&-'($0#"'.-6/!M54`6;NMNQNNM+!

!J,%2-?&'3)!>E-F!,-(!3A2!I2(E@,$!T,W2;!Y&8!I2(E@,$!D3K(2-3>!

*2,'-!3&!D22!,3!,!a'22!/$E-E@!H&'!3A2!Y&=2$2>>+!=#+-&'($G*,"/6)6(6:C$U9'/,#/(C!"`4N6;!

N"VQNMP+!!

J,%E>Qa$&G()!B+!4"55M6+!0-/,"$G3$G*$G8#/-&'*$T-,#$6@$I'33':#+!E3G!&H!/,$EH&'-E,!1'2>>+!!

J,%E>Qa$&G()!B+!,-(!/+!D,'F2-3+!!4"55 6+!S-3'&(K@3E&-;!LA2!D&@E,$!1'&(K@3E&-!&H!#K3A&'E3,3E%2!U-&8$2(F2+!!=#+-&'($G*,"/6)6(6:C$U9'/,#/(C!"V4M6;MNPQMX5+!

!

J,%E>Qa$&G()!B+!,-(!T+!D3+!^&A-+!4"5556+!2/68$Y6&,6/$,6$>#'(#/1$!"#$!/'*3@6/8',-.#$?69/*#C+!728!!_-E%2'>E3G!1'2>>+!

!JK-@,-)!J,%E(!.+!4"55X6+!T#3-+#*,31$!"#$I#/-(3$'*+$I/68-3#$6@$D+9&',-*:$Z69*:$

Y6&,6/3+!728!9&':;!D@'ER-2'+!

!.%,'(>>&-!23!,$+!4MVVN6+!\,'(!#3=&>?A2'2>!&H!Y&''&'!,-(!Y2,$E-F+!>#'(,"!P4`6;!

NPPdN5X!

!a2'W,@@,)!D+!4MVVV6+!e#@3K,$$G)!S!J&-f3!a22$!LA,3!!,-(!3A2!

/$E-E@,$!.-@&K-32'+!=#+-&'($G*,"/6)6(6:C$U9'/,#/(C!"`4"6;MCQOV+!!

a2K(3-2')!/+!,-(!J+!#+!/A'E>3,:E>!4"55`6+!I,:E-F!LA2!B&K-(>;!!LA2!.3AE@,$!

J2%2$&?=2-3!&H!I2(E@,$!D3K(2-3>!E-!3A2!/&-32c3!&H!/$E-E@,$!B&3,3E&->+!>'3,-*:3$;#*,#/$T#)6/,!M`;XQ"M+!

!

a2K(3-2')!/+!J+!#+!/A'E>3,:E>)!,-(!7+!#+!/A'E>3,:E>!4"55`6+!J&!/$E-E@,$!/$2':>!DKHH2'!.3AE@,$!.'&>E&-h!!D3K(2-3>]!12'@2?3E&->!&H!LA2E'!.3AE@,$!.-%E'&-=2-3!,-(!12'>&-,$!

J2%2$&?=2-3+!G&'+#8-&$=#+-&-*#!X5;XPVQXP5+!!

a&c)!B+!/+!4"5OP6+!L',E-E-F!H&'!_-@2'3,E-3G+!S-;!I2'3&-!23!,$+)!2(>+!!"#$%,9+#*,Q

I"C3-&-'*1$H*,/6+9&,6/C$%,9+-#3$-*$,"#$%6&-6(6:C$6@$=#+-&'($D+9&',-6*+!/,=R'E(F2;!Y,'%,'(!_-E%2'>E3G!1'2>>;!MVPQ`"+!

!


3/6


! N!

QQQQQQQQQ!4"5PP6+!LA2!I2(E@,$EW,3E&-!,-(!J2=2(E@,$EW,3E&-!&H!#=2'E@,-!D&@E23G+!

Y'#+'(93!"VX4"6;!5QMM)!!

QQQQQQQQQ!4"5CC!Z"5P5[6+!D33'C3$-*$=#+-&'($%6&-6(6:C1$?69/*#C3$-*,6$,"#$2-#(+)!M-(!2(+!728!,@3E&-!1KR$E>A2'+!

!QQQQQQQQQ!4"55C!Z"5O5[6+!DE)#/-8#*,$I#/-(6931$I"C3-&-'*3$'*+$I',-#*,3$2'&-*:$,"#$L*A*6W*+!728!,@3E&-!1KR$E>A2'>+!

!

QQQQQQQQQ!4"5556+!>!I2(E@,$!.(K@,3E&-!#>:E-F!L&&!IK@A!&H!h!Y'#+'(93!"MC4`6;!"QMO+!

!T,8,-(2)!#+!4MVVM6+!;68)(-&',-6*31$G$%9/:#6*V3$46,#3$6*$'*$H8)#/@#&,$%&-#*+!728!

9&':;!I23'&?&$E3,-!+!

!QQQQQQQQQ!4MVVP6+!0#,,#/1$G$%9/:#6*V3$46,#3$6*$I#/@6/8'*+!728!9&':;!I23'&?&$E3,-!

+!!T&&()!+)![*6W(#+:#J$I6W#/J$'*+$I/'&,-$,"#$G*,"/6)6(6:C$6@$=#+-&-*#$'*+$D.#/C+'C$B-@#+!

E3G!&H!/,$EH&'-E,!1'2>>+!!

QQQQQQQQQ!4MVVN!ZMVVV[6+!/$E-E@,$!7,'',3E%2>!,-(!3A2!D3K(G!&H!/&-32=?&','G!J&@3&'Q

1,3E2-3!B2$,3E&->AE?>+!S-!#$R'2@A3!23!,$+)!2(>+)!>'*+6W$Y6&,6/3$!"-*A+!3&-;!Y&KFA3&-!IEHH$E-!/&+!

!

Y,HH2'3G)!a'2(2'E@!\+!4"55"6+!S-3&!3A2!0,$$2G;!J2,3A!,-(!3A2!D&@E,$EW,3E&-!&H!I2(E@,$!D3K(2-3>+!728!Y,%2-;!9,$2!_-E%2'>E3G!1'2>>+!

!

Y,HH2'3G!a+!\+!,-(!B+!a',-:>!4"55C6+!!4"5CO6+!I"C3-&-'*3$6@$7#3,#/*$=#+-&-*#1$G*,"/6)6(6:-&'($

G))/6'&"#3$,6$!"#6/C$'*+$I/'&,-+!!J&'('2@A3;!J+!B2E(2$!1KR+!/&+!$

!Y,''E>&-)!IE@A2$$2!4"5CM6+!G$768'*$-*$T#3-+#*+!!728!9&':;!B,-(&=!Y&K>2!

!


4/6


! `!

Y&'-2)!J+!4"55V6+!B2,@3E&->!&H!aE'>3Q92,'!I2(E@,$!D3K(2-3>!3&!3A2!LA2E'!S-E3E,$!

.-@&K-32'!8E3A!,!/,(,%2'!E-!3A2!JE>>2@3E-F!B&&=+!G&'+#8-&$=#+-&-*#!XO4"V6++!!!

Y&82$$)!^&2$!J+!4"55O6+!!#&"*6(6:C$-*$,"#$>63)-,'(1$!/'*3@6/8-*:$I',-#*,$;'/#$-*$,"#$D'/(C$!W#*,-#,"$;#*,9/C\$>+!

!U,3W)!1+!4"5556+!!"#$%&'()#(V3$D+:#1$!"#$;9(,9/#$6@$%9/:#6*3+!3&-;!#$$G-!,-(!6W$G8#/-&'*$>63)-,'(3$%"')#$,"#$

D*+$6@$B-@#+!728!9&':;!D@'ER-2'+!!

U$2E-=,-)!#+!4"5PC6+!/&-@2?3>!,-(!,!I&(2$!H&'!3A2!/&=?,'E>&-!&H!I2(E@,$!DG>32=>!,>!/K$3K',$!DG>32=>+!!%6&-'($%&-#*$'*+$=#+-&-*#!"M;COQ5N+!

!

QQQQQQQQQ!4"5CV6+!I',-#*,3$'*+$>#'(#/3$-*$,"#$;6*,#E,$6@$;9(,9/#1$G*$DE)(6/',-6*$6@$,"#$06/+#/('*+$0#,W##*$G*,"/6)6(6:CJ$=#+-&-*#J$'*+$I3C&"-',/C+!!E3G!&H!

/,$EH&'-E,!1'2>>+!!QQQQQQQQQ!4"55O6+!7/-,-*:$',$,"#$='/:-*$1$Y-3&69/3#$0#,W##*$G*,"/6)6(6:C$'*+$

=#+-&-*#+!!E3G!&H!/,$EH&'-E,!1'2>>+!!

U$2E-=,-!23!,$+!4"5PC6+!/K$3K'2)!S$$-2>>)!,-(!/,'2;!/$E-E@,$!*2>>&->!H'&=!

#-3A'&?&$&FE@!,-(!/'&>>!/K$3K',$!B2>2,'@A+!!G**'(3$6@$H*,#/*'($=#+-&-*#!CC;MO"QMOC+!!

U&A-)!#+!4MVVV6+!eS=?2'H2@3!#-F2$>g;!7,'',3E%2!i.=?$&3=2-3i!E-!3A2!I2(E@,$!I,-,F2=2-3!&H!/AE$('2-!8E3A!/',-E&H,@E,$!#-&=,$E2>+!=#+-&'($G*,"/6)6(6:C$

U9'/,#/(C!"`4M6;MVMQM"N+!

!U&--2')!I+!4"5CP6+!+)!0-68#+-&-*#$DE'8-*#++!J&'('2@A3;!U$K82'!#@,(2=E@!1KR$E>A2'>+!

!

*&@:)!I,'F,'23!I+!,-(!J2R&',A!T&'(&-)!2(>+!4"5CC6+!0-68#+-&-*#$DE'8-*#++!J&'('2@A;!U$K82'!#@,(2=E@!1KR$E>A2'>+!

!

*K(=2'2')!U+!I+!4"5556+!!-8#$,6$>#'(1$G8#/-&'*$=#+-&'($D+9&',-6*$@/68$,"#$!9/*$6@$,"#$;#*,9/C$,6$,"#$D/'$6@$='*':#+$;'/#+!jcH&'(;!jcH&'(!_-E%2'>E3G!1'2>>+!

!*KA'=,--)!L+!I+!4MVVV6+!X@$!W6$=-*+31$,"#$K/6W-*:$Y-36/+#/$-*$G8#/-&'*$I3C&"-',/C+!

728!9&':;!U-&?H+!

!*K:2)!Y+!4MVVN6+!=#+-&'($D+9&',-6*$'*+$%6&-6(6:C$6@$=#+-&'($>'+!


5/6


! O!

I,'E&-)!B+!4"5C56+!"#$H*,#/*$0(9#31$,"#$I/-.',#$X/+#'(3$6@$!"/##$Z69*:$Y6&,6/3+!728!

9&':;!I&''&8+!!

I,'3E-)!.=E$G!!4"55M!Z"5CP[6+!!"#$768'*$-*$,"#$06+C1$G$;9(,9/'($G*'(C3-3$6@$T#)/6+9&,-6*+!3&-)!>+!

!I2'3&-)!B+!23!,$+)!2(>+!4"5OP6+!!"#$%,9+#*,QI"C3-&-'*1$H*,/6+9&,6/C$%,9+-#3$-*$,"#$

%6&-6(6:C$6@$=#+-&'($D+9&',-6*+!/,=R'E(F2;!Y,'%,'(!_-E%2'>E3G!1'2>>+!!IEW',AE)!L2''G!4"5CX6+!K#,,-*:$T-+$6@$I',-#*,31$;6*,/'+-&,-6*3$-*$,"#$%6&-'(-_',-6*$6@$

I"C3-&-'*3+!728!!_-E%2'>E3G!1'2>>+!!

IK$$2')!^2>>E@,!Y+!4"55M6+!DA,(2>!&H!!RG!

I2(E@,$!B2>E(2-3>+!%6&-'($%&-#*$F$=#+-&-*#+!C;!CCOQC5C+!!

1&$$&@:)!J&-,$(!4"55X6+!L',E-E-F!L,$2>;!_+D+!I2(E@,$!#K3&RE&F',?AG+!;9(,9/'($G*,"/6)6(6:C!""4N6;NN5QNX"+!

!

B,E-2')!^+!U+!4"5CP6+!2-/3,$Y6$46$>'/81$T#@(#&,-6*3$6*$0#&68-*:$'$0/'-*$%9/:#6*+!!728!9&':;!\E$$,'(!+!

!

B,??)!B+!4"5556+!!#3,-*:$768#*J$!#3,-*:$,"#$2#,931$,"#$%6&-'($H8)'&,$6@$G8*-6*,#3-3$-*$G8#/-&'+!728!9&':;!B&K3$2(F2+!

!BA&(2>)!*&'-,!#+!!4"55X6+!D3K(GE-F!!,!/K$3K',$!DG>32=+!S-!D,'F2-3!,-(!

^&A->&-)!2(>+)!=#+-&'($G*,"/6)6(6:C1$;6*,#8)6/'/C$!"#6/C$'*+$=#,"6++!\2>3?&'3)!

/L;!1',2F2'+!!

B&>2-R2'F)!/+!4"5CP6+!!"#$;'/#$6@$%,/'*:#/31$!"#$T-3#$6@$G8#/-&'`3$>63)-,'($%C3,#8\$

728!9&':;!E@!+!!

B&3A=,-)!.+!4"5556+!7"-,#$;6',1$0#&68-*:$'$Y6&,6/$',$>'/.'/+$=#+-&'($%&"66(+!728!9&':;!\+!I&''&8+!

!

B&3A>32E-)!\+!T+!4"5CP6+!G8#/-&'*$=#+-&'($%&"66(3$'*+$,"#$I/'&,-$6@$=#+-&-*#1$G$>-3,6/C+!jcH&'(;!jcH&'(!_-E%2'>E3G!1'2>>+!

!


6/6


! X!

D,-3E,F&QS'EW,''G!0+!4"55X6+!/K$3K'2!,>!@K'2+!;9(,9/'($G*,"/6)6(6:C+!"";NQM`+!

!DE-@$,E')!D+!4"55P6+!='A-*:$Y6&,6/31$G*$H*3,-,9,-6*'($G))/#*,-"-)+!728!9&':;!+!G*,"/6)6(6:C$F$=#+-&-*#!

P4"6;!""OQ"N`+!!QQQQQQQQQ!4MVV`6+!.%E(2-@2QR,>2(!=2(E@E-2;!#!728!BE3K,$!E-!I2(E@,$!L2,@AE-F+! 0/-,-3"$

=#+-&'($09((#,-* !X54"6;"P5Q"5X+!

!D&R&)!.+!4MVV56+!;9(,9/#$'*+$=#'*-*:$-*$>#'(,"$%#/.-$T#3#'/&"1$G$I/'&,-&'($2-#(+$

K9-+#+!\,$-K3!/'22:)!/#;!*2H3!/&,>3!1'2>>+!!!

D&R&)!.+!k!1+!UK'3E-!4MVVN6+!0,'E,3E&-!E-!?AG>E@E,->]!(2HE-E3E&->!&H!3A2!@&=?232-3!

?,'2-3!,-(!&3A2'!R,''E2'>!3&!FKE(2$E-2!,(A2'2-@2;!3A2!@,>2!&H!?2(E,3'E@!=E-&'!A2,(!E-lK'G!=,-,F2=2-3+!%6&-'($%&-#*$F$=#+-&-*#+!OX4"M6;M`P5QM`5"+!

!D3,'')!1+!4"5CM6+!!"#$%6&-'($!/'*3@6/8',-6*$6@$G8#/-&'*$=#+-&-*#+!728!9&':;!E@!+!

!D32E-)!Y+!4"55V6+!G8#/-&'*$=#+-&-*#$'3$;9(,9/#+!>+!

!

D32E-2')!^+!4MVVO6+!LA2!_>2!&H!D3&'E2>!E-!/$E-E@,$!B2>2,'@A!,-(!Y2,$3A!1&$E@G+!?69/*'($6@$,"#$G8#/-&'*$=#+-&'($G336&-',-6*!M5`4MM6+!4J2@2=R2'!"`)!MVVO6;!M5V"QM5V`+!

!D32?A2-!D3'E@:$,-(!4"5P"6+!S-32F',3E&-!&H!I2(E@,$!B2>2,'@A!,-(!Y2,$3A!1&$E@E2>+!

%&-#*!"PN;!"V5NQ""VN+!!

!L,G$&')!^+!4MVVN,6+!/&-H'&-3E-F!i/K$3K'2i!E-!I2(E@E-2f>!i/K$3K'2!&H!7&!/K$3K'2i+!

G&'+#8-&$=#+-&-*#!PC4X6;!OOOQOO5+!

!QQQQQQQQQ!4MVVNR6+!LA2!>3&'G!@,3@A2>!G&K!,-(!G&K!H,$$!(&8-;!3',F2(G)!23A-&F',?AG)!,-(!

mm@K$3K',$!@&=?232-@2+]]!=#+-&'($G*,"/6)6(6:C$U9'/,#/(C!"P;"O5dC"+!!

LK'R2>!D+!23!,$+!4MVVM6+!LA2!AE((2-!@K''E@K$K=!E-!=K$3E@K$3K',$!=2(E@,$!2(K@,3E&-;!

3A2!'&$2!&H!@,>2!2c,=?$2>+!G&'+#8-&$=#+-&-*#!PP;!MV5d"X+!!

0&-!TK-32-)!/+!a+)!,-(!J+!*K?K!4MVV 6+!J2%2$&?=2-3!&H!,!I2(E@,$!DKR>?2@E,$3G!E-!

1,$$E,3E%2!I2(E@E-2;!1'&F'2>>!B2?&'3+!!?69/*'($6@$I'((-',-.#$=#+-&-*#!P4M6;MV5QM"5+!!

^&K'-,$;!#@,(2=E@!I2(E@E-2!

Documents

American Medicine Readings