™ AMERICAN ECCLESIASTICAL

REVIEW A MONTHLY PUBLICATION FOR THE CLERGY

Cum Approbatione Superiorum

VOL. CLIV JANUARY-JUNE, 1966

'Ei» ivl Tvebfiari, fuq. ifwxfi avvaffhovvTCS r% vlara rod diayyeklov

Phil. 1:27

Published by

THE CATHOLIC UNIVERSITY OF AMERICA PRESS

CONTENTS FOR VOLUME CLIV

JANUARY

Articles

An Interview—Robert McAfee Brown: The Ecumenical Venture Dom Patrick Granfield 1 Collegial Responsibility for the Needy Churches Eugene Burke, C.S.P. 20 A "Piety Void"? Daniel L. Lowery, C.SS.R. 31 The Great Challenge to Church Musicians Johannes Somary 39

In Review 48

Answers to Questions Francis J. Connell, CSS.R.

Interest on Stipends S3 Capital Punishment S3 Misuse of Headlines 54

Boo\ Reviews

Personal Faith, by Carlos Cirne-Lima Translated by G. Richard Dimler, SJ. 57 Enciclopedia de orientacion bibliografica. Vols I and II. Director Thomas Zamarriego, SJ. 58 Philippine Duchesne: 1769-1852, by Louise Callan, R.S.C.J. 59 The Benedictine Nun, by Hubert van Zeller, O.S.B. 59 Christianity and Social Progress, by John F. Cronin, S.S. 60 Moral Philosophy, by Jacques Maritain 61 A World to Win, by Joseph A. Grassi, MM. 62 The Modern Mission Apostolate, edited by William J. Richardson, MM. 62 Steps to Christian Unity, edited by John A. O'Brien 63 The Mother of God. Her Physical Maternity: A Reappraisal, by Cletus Wessels, O.P. 64 The Catholic Church and Nazi Germany, 631 Guenter Lewy 65 Catholicism in English-Speaking Lands, by Mother Peter Carthy, OS.U. 66 The Art of the Canterbury Tales, by Paul G. Ruggiers 67 Lexikon fur Theologie und Kirche. 2nd Edition. Vol. 9. Edited by Josef Hojer and Karl Rahner 68

Boo\s Received 70

in

iv Contents for Volume CLIV

FEBRUARY

Articles

The Church and the Dispossessed John J. Harmon 73 What Is the Kerygmatic Approach? Francis A. Brunner, CSS.R. 84 "Nova et Vetera": The Middle Road of Paul VI T. L. Bouscaren, S.J. 92 Eastern Orthodoxy: Primacy and Reunion James Likoudis 104 The Sister at the City's Gates Sister M. Terese Avila Brown, O.SJF. 117

In Review 12S

Answers to Questions Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R.

Satisfying Obligation with Unworthy Mass 133 The Sacrament of Penance as Reconciliation with the Church 134 Transubstantiation and the Hylomorphic Theory 134 How Far Can Acting Go? 135

Boo\ Reviews

Our Lady of Ephesus, by Bernard F. Deutsch 136 Sacraments of Initiation: Baptism and Confirmation, by Charles Davis 137 Baptism and Confirmation, by Burkhard Neunheuser, O.S~B. Translated by John Jay Hughes 137 The Priestly Amen, by Roy Rhin 137 The Preacher's Encyclopedia. Vol. I—Lent and Eastertide. Edited under the supervision of Cardinal Angel Herrera. Translated and edited by David Greenstock. 138 The Moral Teaching of the New Testament, by Rudolph Schnackenburg 139 Power and Poverty in the Church, by Yves Congar 140 Rome and Reunion, by Frederick C. Grant 141

Boo\s Received 143

r \ i

Contents jor Volume CLIV

MARCH

=> Articles

A Ministry of Presence Jonathan Daniels 14S The Papal Program for Latin America John J. Considine, MM. 153 Some Thoughts About Religious Obedience Francis N. Korth, SJ. 170 The Priest and Convert Work Louis F. Miltenberger 183

In Review 196

Documentation 202

Answers to Questions Francis J. Cornell, C.SS.R.

The Omission of "Deicide" 205 The Use of Must for Mass 206 The Possibility of Divorce 207

Boo\ Reviews

Images of Hope. Imagination as Healer of the Hopeless, by William F. Lynch, SJ. 209 Maturity in the Religious Life, by John J. Evoy, S.J., and Van F. Christoph, SJ. 210 Nature, Grace and Religious Development, by Barry McLoughlin, SJ. 210 Minor Seminary Conference: Academic Program of the Minor Seminary, edited by Cornelius M. Cuyler, S.S. 211 Great Heresies and Church Councils, by Jean Guitton. Translated by F. D. Wieck 212 Philosophy in a Technological Culture, edited by George F. McLean, O.M.I. 213 Le Frere Andre (1845-1937) et l'Oratoire Saint-Joseph du Mont-Royal, by Etienne Catta 214 Cross and Crucifix in Mission, by Norman A. Homer 215

Boo\s Received 216

vi Contents for Volume CL1V

APRIL

Articles

The Constitution On Divine Revelation In Ecumenical Perspective Avery Dulles, SJ. 217 Authority is Service John A. Weaver 232 Theological Consensus: The Present Dilemma George Malone 2A2 The Divine Office: Why Vocalize? Joseph B. Tremonti, CSV. 257

Documentation

Pope Paul VI Marriage-Family-Children 263

In Review 271

Answers to Questions Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R.

Buying and Selling Votes 279 The Sterilization of a Retarded Girl 280 The Pope's Mass Pro Populo 282

Boo\ Reviews

The Church in an Age of Revolution: 1789-1870, by H. Damel-Rops 283 The Preaching Word, by Otto Semmelroth, S.J. 284 The Unreformed Church, by Robert E. McNally, SJ. 285 The Pastor as Counselor, by Andre Godin, SJ. 285 The Heart of Newman, A Synthesis arranged by E. Przywara, SJ. 286 Ecumenical Experiences, ed. by Luis V. Romeu 287

Contents for Volume CLIV vii

MAY

Articles

Protestant Reaction to the Role of Mary in Vatican II Eatnon R. Carroll, 0. Carm. 289 Let's Keep Our Minor Seminaries Melvin L. Farrell, S.S. 302 Significant Ecumenism Robert M. Balkam 312 The Future of the Parish Mission Henry Drury Noyes, C.S.P. 320 Religious Profile of a Class of Catholic College Women Sister Consuelo Maria, S.S.J. 328

In Review 334

Documentation

Pope Paul VI—Priestly Ministry 340

Answers to Questions Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R.

Participation in the Arms Race 345 The Church's Coercive Power 346 Length of Time for a Low Mass 347

Boo\ Reviews

John Courtney Murray: Contemporary Church-State Theory, by Thomas T. Love 348 Renewal in Dogma. Volume I. Theology Today, edited by Johannes Feiner, et al. Translated by Peter White and Raymond H. Kelly 349 A Guide to Catholic College Administration, by Edward V. Stanford, O.SA 349 The Power of Life or Death, by Michael V. Di Salle 350 A Short History of Lebanon, by Philip K. Hitti 351 Writings of Fermin Francisco de Lasuen. 2 vols., edited and translated by Finbar Kenneally, OJ'.M. 352 Church and State in Social Welfare, by Bernard J. Coughlin, S.J. 353 Born for Friendship. The Spirit of Sir Thomas More, by Bernard Basset, SJ. 354 Utopia. The Yale Edition of The Complete Works of S t Thomas More. Volume 4, edited by Edward Surts, S.J., and J. H. Hexter 354 Christian Sacraments and Christian Personality, by Bernard J. Cooke, SJ. 355 Bishops at Large, by Peter F. Anson 357

Boo\s Received 359

viii Contents jor Volume CLIV

JUNE Articles

Old Testament Horizon of 1966 Robert North, SJ. 361 National Conferences of Bishops: A Look at the Past Henry Bischoff, SJ. 384 Instant Cana: A Program for Every Parish Urban G. Steinmets 397 An Interview—Archbishop Denis Hurley and Priestly Training

Joseph O'Donoghue 405

In Review 410

Documentation Pope Paul VI— The Mystery of the Church 416

The Church—House of God 418 Answers to Questions

Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R. Publication of Church Donations 421 The Blow on the Cheek 421 Imposing our Religious Vows on Others 422

Boo\ Reviews The Life of John Lancaster Spalding: First Bishop of Peoria, 1840-1916, by David P. Sweeney, O.F.M. 424 The Genius of the Apostolate: Personal Growth in the Candidate, the Seminarian and Priest, by Paul F. D'Arcy, MM., and Eugene C. Kennedy, MM. 425 The Ovulation Method, 631 John Billings, M.D. 426 Social Ethics. Natural Law in the Western World, by Johannes Messner 427 Catherine of Siena, by J. M. Perrin, O.P. 427 Mary in the Gospel, by Jean Galot, SJ. 428 A Theology of Mary, by Cyril Vollert, SJ. 428 Psaumes et priere chretienne. Collection de Pastorale Liturgique. Paroisse et Liturgie. No. 66, by A. Rose 429 Actes et documents du Saint Siege relatifs a la seconde guerre mondiale. Le Saint Siege et la guerre en Europe (Mars 1939—Aoiit 1940) 430 Foundations of Biblical Spirituality, translated by Joseph A. Grispino, SM. 430 Treizieme Dimanche apres la Pentecote. Assemblies du Seigneur. Catechese des dimanches et des fetes. No. 67 iy M. Cornil, E. Charpentier, et al. 431

Boo\s Received 433

Index to Volume CLIV 435

Boo\s Reviewed 438

™ AMERICAN ECCLESIASTICAL

REVIEW A MONTHLY PUBLICATION FOR THE CLERGY

Cum Approbation Superiorum

VOL. CLV JULY-DECEMBER, 1966

avvaJdXovvTes T% irLarei rod ebayyeXLov

Phil. 1:27

Published by

THE CATHOLIC UNIVERSITY OF AMERICA PRESS

CONTENTS FOR VOLUME CLV

JULY

Articles

The Church—My Mother Henri de Lubac 1

Pornography Paul J. Murphy, SJ. 11

Father Paul James Francis of the Society of the Atonement Edmund Delaney, S.A. 18

New Testament Horizon of 1966 Robert North, SJ. 33

In Review S3

Documentation

Pastoral Letter of the Archbishop of Washington 58

Answers to Questions

Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R.

The Use of Torture to Extort Confessions 60 The Right of a Catholic to Leave the Catholic Church 62

Boo\ Reviews

The Church in the New Testament, by Rudolf Schnackenburg.

Translated by W. J. O'Hara 65

Sacraments, the Gestures of Christ, edited by Denis O'Callaghan 66

Conscience and Confession, by Dom Claude Jean-Nesmy. Translated by Malachy Carroll 67 Seminary Education in a Time of Change, by John Tracy Ellis, George G. Hagmaier, C.S.P., John L. McKensie, SJ., et al. Edited by James Michael Lee and Louis J. Putz, C.S.C. 68

Historical Problems of Church Renewal (Church History). Volume 7. Concilium, edited by Roger Aubert. By Brian Tierney, Hilaire Marot, O.S.B., August Franzen, et al. 69

Boo\s Received 71

IV Contents for Volume CLV

AUGUST Articles

Ecumenical Activities in 1965: A Chronicle Thomas E. Ambrogi, SJ. 73 The Death and Resurrection of the Priest-Workers Joseph N. Moody 35 Bishop John England and the Laity Thomas R. Ryan, C.PP.S. 97 The Church University in Megalopolis Robert G. Howes 104 Liturgy in the Seminary Curriculum Christopher Kiesling, O.P. 109

In Review jjg

Documentation Pope Paul VI—Who Belongs to the Church? 122

The Church is the Mystical Body 125

Answers to Questions Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R.

Three Dots in Denzinger 128 A Grave Violation of the Friday Abstinence 129 Obscene Literature in Catholic Schools 130

Boo\ Reviews

The Cross in the Sand, by Michael V. Gannon 133 The Epistle to the Romans. Theological Meditations, by Karl Hermann Schelkle. Translated by Brian Thompson 133 Introduction to the New Testament, by A. Robert and A. Feuillet. Trans, by P. W. Skehan, E. P. Arbes, S.S., et al. 134 Israel's Sacred Songs, by Harvey H. Guthrie, Jr. 135 COCU—Consultation on Church Union 136 Man and Sin (A Theological View), by Piet Schoonenberg, SJ. Translated by Joseph Donceel, SJ. 137 The Mass in the West, by Lancelot C. Sheppard 137 The Thought of Teilhard de Chardin, by Michael H. Murray 138 Tensions and Change: The Problems of Religious Orders Today, by Gerard Huyghe, Bishop of Arras. Translated by Sr. Marie Florette, S.C.H. 138 Religious Life: A Living Liturgy, by Paul Hinnebusch, O.P. 139 Age of Faith, by Ann Fremantle & Editors of Time-Life Books 140 Family Pastoral Care, by Russell J. Becker 141

Books Received 143

Contents for Volume CLV v

SEPTEMBER

Articles

American Contributions to the Decree on the Ministry and Life of Priests Vincent A. Yzermans 145 Depression in Priests and Religious Austin McCawley, M.D. 164 Episcopal Appointments in the U.S.A. Francis J. Weber 178

In Review 192

Documentation

Pope Paul VI—The Church—a City 195 The Church—Bride and Mother 197

Answers to Questions Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R.

Divine and Human Laws on Mixed Marriages 201

Boo\ Reviews

Spiritual Exercises, by Karl Rahner, SJ. 206 The Eucharist in the Primitive Church, by Edward J. Kilmartin, SJ. 207 Histoire Spirituelle de la France 208 New Testament Essays, by Raymond E. Brown, S.S. 209 Twentieth-Century Thinkers: Studies in the Work of Seventeen Modern Philosophers, edited by John K. Ryan 209 Christ Teaches Today, by Mark J. Link, SJ. 210 We Live in Christ, by Mark J. Link, SJ. 210 The First Six Hundred Years, by Jean Danielou and Henri Marrou. Translated by Vincent Cronin 211 The Pope and the World, by Anton Heme 213 More Answers to Today's Moral Problems, by Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R. Edited by Eugene J. Weitsel, C.S.V. 213

Boo\s Received 215

vi Contents jor Volume CLV

OCTOBER

Articles Theology in the Council Yves Congar, O.P. 217 The Uncomfortable Christ Maurice Ouellet, S.S£. 231 The Rosary and the Liturgy Thomas O'Flym, CM. 234 The Seminary College Course John L. Murphy 242 The Two-Eyed Priest Regis Appel, O.C.S.O. 258

Documentation

Pastoral Letter of the South African Bishops 263

In Review 271

Answers to Questions Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R.

Keep Your Latin Missals 276 An Invalid Election 277 Mary, Mediatress 277 Some Recent Statements on the Sacrament of Penance 278

Boo\ Reviews

Handbook for Special Preaching, edited by Anatole 0. Baillargeon, OM.I. 281 The Holy Spirit and the Priest, by Clement Dillenschneider, C.SS.R. Trans, by Sister M. Renelle, S.S.N.D. 282 Freedom in Education: Federal Aid for All Children, by Virgil C. Blum, SJ. 283 The Pastor as Counselor, 631 Andre Godin, SJ. 283 Mysticism and Ecumenism, by Robley Edward Whitson 284 From the Housetops: A Pastor Speaks to Adults, 631 Edouard Stevens. Trans, by Mary Ilford. 285 Christianity in World History, by Arend Th. van Leeuwen 285

Boo\s Received 2&7

Contents for Volume CLV vii

NOVEMBER

Articles An Interview with Jaroslav Pelikan Dom Patrick Granfield 289 Confidentiality and the Right to Know Joseph T. Alves 307 Calvin on Christ's True Presence in the Lord's Supper Joseph N. Tylenda, S.J. 321

In Review 334

Documentation

Bishop Wright on Family Life 341

Answers to Questions Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R.

Academic Freedom in a Catholic College 349 Satisfying One's Obligation in an Orthodox Church 349 Would the Consecration be Valid ? 3S0 Genuflecting in an Episcopalian Church 351

Bool( Reviews

St. Madeleine Sophie: Her Life and Letters, by Margaret Williams, R.S.CJ. 352 Learning to Worship, by Theodor Filthaut 353 A Challenge to the Church, by Leon Arthur Elchinger, Marc Boegner et al. 354 Sin in the Orthodox Church, by V. Palachovsky, and in the Protestant Churches, by C. Vogel 354 Saints: Their Place in the Church, by Paul Molinari, SJ. 355

Booths Received 357

vm Contents jor Volume CLV

DECEMBER Articles

Transubstantiation and Eucharistic Theology Clarence McAuliffe, S.J. 361 "Father, I've Got a Problem . . ." Robert V. Monticello 374 The Background of American Catholic Unity Thomas T. McAvoy, C.S.C. 384 The Growing Literature on Franz Stock Robert J. Dionne, S.M. 393 The Man with the Oils Patrick A. Magnier, C.SS.R. 399

Documentation

Pope's Address to Theologians 403

In Review 408

Answers to Questions Francis J. Connell, C.SS.R.

The Reception of a Jewish Convert 413 May Smoking Be Permitted? 413 How Frequently Should the Devout Confess? 414 Stipends for Concelebrated High Mass 415

Boo\ Reviews

Catholics in Colonial America, by John Tracy Ellis 416 With the Eyes of Faith, by John L. Murphy 417 California's First Archbishop. The Life of Joseph Sadoc Alemany, O.P., 1814-1888, by John Bernard McGloin, SJ. 418 The Eucharistic Words of Jesus, by Joachim Jeremias. Translated from the German by Norman Ferrin 419 Towards a Theology of Religions, by Heinz Robert Schlette 420 The English Church and the Papacy in the Middle Ages, edited by C. H. Lawrence, with a Foreword by David Knowles 421 Torah and Gospel: Jewish and Catholic Theology in Dialogue, edited by Philip Scharper 422 The Inspired Word: Scripture in the Light of Language and Literature, by Luis Alonzo Schbkel, SJ. Translated by Francis Martin, O.C.S.O. 423

Boo\s Received 425

Index to Volume CLV 427

Boo^s Reviewed and Noticed 430