31
Alternatives for vitamin E Theo van Kempen

Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

Alternatives for vitamin ETheo van Kempen

Life a balancing act between oxidizing and being (per)oxidized

The essence of lifeminus Converting the energy in food into growth and labor

minus Nothing is perfectminus Radicals are co-produced

minus Dangerous if not neutralized

CHx + O2

H2O+ CO2

ATP O2 H2O2 OH Tissue damage

bull Lipidsbull Proteinsbull DNA

MDA

Balance exposuredefense critical

Increasing oxidative stress either through increased exposure andor weakened defenses leads to disease

Kothari 2010 After Blumberg and Lekkesfeldt

ADG

GSH

GSS

G

Oxi

dat

ive

stre

ssO

2

OH

H

2O

2

Normal Inflammation(NF-κB)

Impaired cellfunction Apoptosis

AntioxidantDefense

Damagedmolecules

Toxicity

Necrosis

Oxidative stress influences production performance

Oxidative stress influences fertility

Fertility in poultry Radwan 2008

Oxidative stress influences parturition

Parturition in cattle Bernabucci 2002

Oxidative stress influences stress susceptibility

Heat stress in poultry Altan 2003

Oxidative stress influences meat quality

Meat quality in lambs Nieto 2010

Multiple defense mechanisms in place

Membranes

After Surai

Multiple defense mechanisms in place

And 3 catabolism of damaged molecules

GSH Lipoic acid

Vitamin E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODVitamin Ecarotenoidsubiquinols

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Vitamin CPolyphenols

PH-GSH-Px

After Surai

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

bull α-Tocopherol lsquoto carry a pregnancyrsquo

Vit E polyphenol wersquove come to depend on

Anti-oxidant Lipophilic

Key player in antioxidant cascade

1000x more reactive to

H2O2 than PUFA

Vit E prevents

formation of dangerous

peroxidation products

Part of reaction

cascade also involving

Vit C and thiols

Rimbach 2010

Role evolving from AO to gene regulator

Evolving role of Vit E

Zingg 2007Rimbach 2010

Basal vit E requirements sound basis

Poultry 1994 NRC

Swineminus 2012 NRC refers to 1998 NRCminus 1998 NRC refers to 1981 review by Ullrey and ARC

minus Focus is on 40-50 year old literature

Havenstein 2003 Ross 2012

1957 strain

2001 strain

Vit E requirement affected by Stress level Growth rate Meat quality

bull Example for poultry (modified)

AO Requirement depends on health status

Winterbourn 2008

Radicals are also a double-

edged sword for fighting

infections

Intake of 175 mg or 62 ppm saturates muscle

Muscle level of 34 ugg saturates AO effect

Meta-analysis confirms limits

Meta-analysis for swine meat qualityminus 90 of the improvement in TBARS occurs at a tissue level of 34 ugg

tocopherol which is obtained with a dose of 90 mgdayminus Optimum dose of Vit E for meat quality is 30-35 ppm

Sales 2011

Vit E bio-availability poor

Pharmacokinetics trial with swine

minus Bio-efficacy oral 54

minus Elimination half-life 26h

minus Plasma level ~3 microM

Cause

minus Low-fat diet (6)

minus Poor hydrolysis of acetate ester

minus Use of stereo-isomers

minus High dose vs requirement

Vit E one of many antioxidants in nature

Plants contain an array of antioxidants besides Vit Eminus Some plants have a very strong anti-oxidant protection

Apak 2007

Polyphenols a colorful tree

Potent AO alternatives to Vit E

Similar phenolic structure as Vit Eminus Often more hydroxy groups than Vit E

minus More anti-oxidant capacity per moleminus But typically smaller molecules

minus Much more anti-oxidant capacity per gram

Tabart 2009

Naringenin (272)

Caffeic acid (180)

α-tocopherol (472)

Vit P again

1939 Polyphenols were considered as vitaminsminus Cured some diseases linked to

oxidative stress

2006 lsquoLifespan essentialrsquo(Williamson)

Like all-rac Vit E not all polyphenols equal

Polyphenol bio-availability varies from 0 to gt80minus But fermentation can yield digestible fragments

minus Eg proanthocyanidinsminus Too large to be absorbed in small intestines

bull Digestibility = 0minus Can be fermented

bull Key product is hydroxyphenyl acetic acidbull Mass recovery is only 08

Sauro 2010

Polyphenol selectionminus Ruminant bypass or polyphenols which are fermented into potent

anti-oxidants minus Monogastrics digestible with high ORAC (dORAC)

Bio-availability critical in product formulation

Manach 2005 tocopherol = Michiels 2013

AO-mix adapted to species

Components selected for high bio-availability

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications swine

Both Vit E and AO-mix prevented an increase in lipid peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed piglets

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

Control 11 ppm Vit E 80 PPM 11E+69 AO mix

Mal

on

dia

ldeh

yde

(MD

A) MDA pre-stress MDA post-stress

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

Both Vit E and Selko AOmix prevented an increase in peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed broilers

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

AOmix resulted in a lower SOD (ns) in heat-stressed birds

minus MDA and SOD positively correlated

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications poultry

Heat stressed broilers in Asia

minus AO-mix improved BW FI and cellular immunity while reducing MDA

Rama Rao

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 2: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

Life a balancing act between oxidizing and being (per)oxidized

The essence of lifeminus Converting the energy in food into growth and labor

minus Nothing is perfectminus Radicals are co-produced

minus Dangerous if not neutralized

CHx + O2

H2O+ CO2

ATP O2 H2O2 OH Tissue damage

bull Lipidsbull Proteinsbull DNA

MDA

Balance exposuredefense critical

Increasing oxidative stress either through increased exposure andor weakened defenses leads to disease

Kothari 2010 After Blumberg and Lekkesfeldt

ADG

GSH

GSS

G

Oxi

dat

ive

stre

ssO

2

OH

H

2O

2

Normal Inflammation(NF-κB)

Impaired cellfunction Apoptosis

AntioxidantDefense

Damagedmolecules

Toxicity

Necrosis

Oxidative stress influences production performance

Oxidative stress influences fertility

Fertility in poultry Radwan 2008

Oxidative stress influences parturition

Parturition in cattle Bernabucci 2002

Oxidative stress influences stress susceptibility

Heat stress in poultry Altan 2003

Oxidative stress influences meat quality

Meat quality in lambs Nieto 2010

Multiple defense mechanisms in place

Membranes

After Surai

Multiple defense mechanisms in place

And 3 catabolism of damaged molecules

GSH Lipoic acid

Vitamin E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODVitamin Ecarotenoidsubiquinols

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Vitamin CPolyphenols

PH-GSH-Px

After Surai

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

bull α-Tocopherol lsquoto carry a pregnancyrsquo

Vit E polyphenol wersquove come to depend on

Anti-oxidant Lipophilic

Key player in antioxidant cascade

1000x more reactive to

H2O2 than PUFA

Vit E prevents

formation of dangerous

peroxidation products

Part of reaction

cascade also involving

Vit C and thiols

Rimbach 2010

Role evolving from AO to gene regulator

Evolving role of Vit E

Zingg 2007Rimbach 2010

Basal vit E requirements sound basis

Poultry 1994 NRC

Swineminus 2012 NRC refers to 1998 NRCminus 1998 NRC refers to 1981 review by Ullrey and ARC

minus Focus is on 40-50 year old literature

Havenstein 2003 Ross 2012

1957 strain

2001 strain

Vit E requirement affected by Stress level Growth rate Meat quality

bull Example for poultry (modified)

AO Requirement depends on health status

Winterbourn 2008

Radicals are also a double-

edged sword for fighting

infections

Intake of 175 mg or 62 ppm saturates muscle

Muscle level of 34 ugg saturates AO effect

Meta-analysis confirms limits

Meta-analysis for swine meat qualityminus 90 of the improvement in TBARS occurs at a tissue level of 34 ugg

tocopherol which is obtained with a dose of 90 mgdayminus Optimum dose of Vit E for meat quality is 30-35 ppm

Sales 2011

Vit E bio-availability poor

Pharmacokinetics trial with swine

minus Bio-efficacy oral 54

minus Elimination half-life 26h

minus Plasma level ~3 microM

Cause

minus Low-fat diet (6)

minus Poor hydrolysis of acetate ester

minus Use of stereo-isomers

minus High dose vs requirement

Vit E one of many antioxidants in nature

Plants contain an array of antioxidants besides Vit Eminus Some plants have a very strong anti-oxidant protection

Apak 2007

Polyphenols a colorful tree

Potent AO alternatives to Vit E

Similar phenolic structure as Vit Eminus Often more hydroxy groups than Vit E

minus More anti-oxidant capacity per moleminus But typically smaller molecules

minus Much more anti-oxidant capacity per gram

Tabart 2009

Naringenin (272)

Caffeic acid (180)

α-tocopherol (472)

Vit P again

1939 Polyphenols were considered as vitaminsminus Cured some diseases linked to

oxidative stress

2006 lsquoLifespan essentialrsquo(Williamson)

Like all-rac Vit E not all polyphenols equal

Polyphenol bio-availability varies from 0 to gt80minus But fermentation can yield digestible fragments

minus Eg proanthocyanidinsminus Too large to be absorbed in small intestines

bull Digestibility = 0minus Can be fermented

bull Key product is hydroxyphenyl acetic acidbull Mass recovery is only 08

Sauro 2010

Polyphenol selectionminus Ruminant bypass or polyphenols which are fermented into potent

anti-oxidants minus Monogastrics digestible with high ORAC (dORAC)

Bio-availability critical in product formulation

Manach 2005 tocopherol = Michiels 2013

AO-mix adapted to species

Components selected for high bio-availability

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications swine

Both Vit E and AO-mix prevented an increase in lipid peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed piglets

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

Control 11 ppm Vit E 80 PPM 11E+69 AO mix

Mal

on

dia

ldeh

yde

(MD

A) MDA pre-stress MDA post-stress

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

Both Vit E and Selko AOmix prevented an increase in peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed broilers

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

AOmix resulted in a lower SOD (ns) in heat-stressed birds

minus MDA and SOD positively correlated

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications poultry

Heat stressed broilers in Asia

minus AO-mix improved BW FI and cellular immunity while reducing MDA

Rama Rao

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 3: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

Balance exposuredefense critical

Increasing oxidative stress either through increased exposure andor weakened defenses leads to disease

Kothari 2010 After Blumberg and Lekkesfeldt

ADG

GSH

GSS

G

Oxi

dat

ive

stre

ssO

2

OH

H

2O

2

Normal Inflammation(NF-κB)

Impaired cellfunction Apoptosis

AntioxidantDefense

Damagedmolecules

Toxicity

Necrosis

Oxidative stress influences production performance

Oxidative stress influences fertility

Fertility in poultry Radwan 2008

Oxidative stress influences parturition

Parturition in cattle Bernabucci 2002

Oxidative stress influences stress susceptibility

Heat stress in poultry Altan 2003

Oxidative stress influences meat quality

Meat quality in lambs Nieto 2010

Multiple defense mechanisms in place

Membranes

After Surai

Multiple defense mechanisms in place

And 3 catabolism of damaged molecules

GSH Lipoic acid

Vitamin E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODVitamin Ecarotenoidsubiquinols

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Vitamin CPolyphenols

PH-GSH-Px

After Surai

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

bull α-Tocopherol lsquoto carry a pregnancyrsquo

Vit E polyphenol wersquove come to depend on

Anti-oxidant Lipophilic

Key player in antioxidant cascade

1000x more reactive to

H2O2 than PUFA

Vit E prevents

formation of dangerous

peroxidation products

Part of reaction

cascade also involving

Vit C and thiols

Rimbach 2010

Role evolving from AO to gene regulator

Evolving role of Vit E

Zingg 2007Rimbach 2010

Basal vit E requirements sound basis

Poultry 1994 NRC

Swineminus 2012 NRC refers to 1998 NRCminus 1998 NRC refers to 1981 review by Ullrey and ARC

minus Focus is on 40-50 year old literature

Havenstein 2003 Ross 2012

1957 strain

2001 strain

Vit E requirement affected by Stress level Growth rate Meat quality

bull Example for poultry (modified)

AO Requirement depends on health status

Winterbourn 2008

Radicals are also a double-

edged sword for fighting

infections

Intake of 175 mg or 62 ppm saturates muscle

Muscle level of 34 ugg saturates AO effect

Meta-analysis confirms limits

Meta-analysis for swine meat qualityminus 90 of the improvement in TBARS occurs at a tissue level of 34 ugg

tocopherol which is obtained with a dose of 90 mgdayminus Optimum dose of Vit E for meat quality is 30-35 ppm

Sales 2011

Vit E bio-availability poor

Pharmacokinetics trial with swine

minus Bio-efficacy oral 54

minus Elimination half-life 26h

minus Plasma level ~3 microM

Cause

minus Low-fat diet (6)

minus Poor hydrolysis of acetate ester

minus Use of stereo-isomers

minus High dose vs requirement

Vit E one of many antioxidants in nature

Plants contain an array of antioxidants besides Vit Eminus Some plants have a very strong anti-oxidant protection

Apak 2007

Polyphenols a colorful tree

Potent AO alternatives to Vit E

Similar phenolic structure as Vit Eminus Often more hydroxy groups than Vit E

minus More anti-oxidant capacity per moleminus But typically smaller molecules

minus Much more anti-oxidant capacity per gram

Tabart 2009

Naringenin (272)

Caffeic acid (180)

α-tocopherol (472)

Vit P again

1939 Polyphenols were considered as vitaminsminus Cured some diseases linked to

oxidative stress

2006 lsquoLifespan essentialrsquo(Williamson)

Like all-rac Vit E not all polyphenols equal

Polyphenol bio-availability varies from 0 to gt80minus But fermentation can yield digestible fragments

minus Eg proanthocyanidinsminus Too large to be absorbed in small intestines

bull Digestibility = 0minus Can be fermented

bull Key product is hydroxyphenyl acetic acidbull Mass recovery is only 08

Sauro 2010

Polyphenol selectionminus Ruminant bypass or polyphenols which are fermented into potent

anti-oxidants minus Monogastrics digestible with high ORAC (dORAC)

Bio-availability critical in product formulation

Manach 2005 tocopherol = Michiels 2013

AO-mix adapted to species

Components selected for high bio-availability

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications swine

Both Vit E and AO-mix prevented an increase in lipid peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed piglets

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

Control 11 ppm Vit E 80 PPM 11E+69 AO mix

Mal

on

dia

ldeh

yde

(MD

A) MDA pre-stress MDA post-stress

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

Both Vit E and Selko AOmix prevented an increase in peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed broilers

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

AOmix resulted in a lower SOD (ns) in heat-stressed birds

minus MDA and SOD positively correlated

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications poultry

Heat stressed broilers in Asia

minus AO-mix improved BW FI and cellular immunity while reducing MDA

Rama Rao

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 4: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

Oxidative stress influences production performance

Oxidative stress influences fertility

Fertility in poultry Radwan 2008

Oxidative stress influences parturition

Parturition in cattle Bernabucci 2002

Oxidative stress influences stress susceptibility

Heat stress in poultry Altan 2003

Oxidative stress influences meat quality

Meat quality in lambs Nieto 2010

Multiple defense mechanisms in place

Membranes

After Surai

Multiple defense mechanisms in place

And 3 catabolism of damaged molecules

GSH Lipoic acid

Vitamin E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODVitamin Ecarotenoidsubiquinols

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Vitamin CPolyphenols

PH-GSH-Px

After Surai

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

bull α-Tocopherol lsquoto carry a pregnancyrsquo

Vit E polyphenol wersquove come to depend on

Anti-oxidant Lipophilic

Key player in antioxidant cascade

1000x more reactive to

H2O2 than PUFA

Vit E prevents

formation of dangerous

peroxidation products

Part of reaction

cascade also involving

Vit C and thiols

Rimbach 2010

Role evolving from AO to gene regulator

Evolving role of Vit E

Zingg 2007Rimbach 2010

Basal vit E requirements sound basis

Poultry 1994 NRC

Swineminus 2012 NRC refers to 1998 NRCminus 1998 NRC refers to 1981 review by Ullrey and ARC

minus Focus is on 40-50 year old literature

Havenstein 2003 Ross 2012

1957 strain

2001 strain

Vit E requirement affected by Stress level Growth rate Meat quality

bull Example for poultry (modified)

AO Requirement depends on health status

Winterbourn 2008

Radicals are also a double-

edged sword for fighting

infections

Intake of 175 mg or 62 ppm saturates muscle

Muscle level of 34 ugg saturates AO effect

Meta-analysis confirms limits

Meta-analysis for swine meat qualityminus 90 of the improvement in TBARS occurs at a tissue level of 34 ugg

tocopherol which is obtained with a dose of 90 mgdayminus Optimum dose of Vit E for meat quality is 30-35 ppm

Sales 2011

Vit E bio-availability poor

Pharmacokinetics trial with swine

minus Bio-efficacy oral 54

minus Elimination half-life 26h

minus Plasma level ~3 microM

Cause

minus Low-fat diet (6)

minus Poor hydrolysis of acetate ester

minus Use of stereo-isomers

minus High dose vs requirement

Vit E one of many antioxidants in nature

Plants contain an array of antioxidants besides Vit Eminus Some plants have a very strong anti-oxidant protection

Apak 2007

Polyphenols a colorful tree

Potent AO alternatives to Vit E

Similar phenolic structure as Vit Eminus Often more hydroxy groups than Vit E

minus More anti-oxidant capacity per moleminus But typically smaller molecules

minus Much more anti-oxidant capacity per gram

Tabart 2009

Naringenin (272)

Caffeic acid (180)

α-tocopherol (472)

Vit P again

1939 Polyphenols were considered as vitaminsminus Cured some diseases linked to

oxidative stress

2006 lsquoLifespan essentialrsquo(Williamson)

Like all-rac Vit E not all polyphenols equal

Polyphenol bio-availability varies from 0 to gt80minus But fermentation can yield digestible fragments

minus Eg proanthocyanidinsminus Too large to be absorbed in small intestines

bull Digestibility = 0minus Can be fermented

bull Key product is hydroxyphenyl acetic acidbull Mass recovery is only 08

Sauro 2010

Polyphenol selectionminus Ruminant bypass or polyphenols which are fermented into potent

anti-oxidants minus Monogastrics digestible with high ORAC (dORAC)

Bio-availability critical in product formulation

Manach 2005 tocopherol = Michiels 2013

AO-mix adapted to species

Components selected for high bio-availability

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications swine

Both Vit E and AO-mix prevented an increase in lipid peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed piglets

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

Control 11 ppm Vit E 80 PPM 11E+69 AO mix

Mal

on

dia

ldeh

yde

(MD

A) MDA pre-stress MDA post-stress

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

Both Vit E and Selko AOmix prevented an increase in peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed broilers

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

AOmix resulted in a lower SOD (ns) in heat-stressed birds

minus MDA and SOD positively correlated

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications poultry

Heat stressed broilers in Asia

minus AO-mix improved BW FI and cellular immunity while reducing MDA

Rama Rao

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 5: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

Oxidative stress influences fertility

Fertility in poultry Radwan 2008

Oxidative stress influences parturition

Parturition in cattle Bernabucci 2002

Oxidative stress influences stress susceptibility

Heat stress in poultry Altan 2003

Oxidative stress influences meat quality

Meat quality in lambs Nieto 2010

Multiple defense mechanisms in place

Membranes

After Surai

Multiple defense mechanisms in place

And 3 catabolism of damaged molecules

GSH Lipoic acid

Vitamin E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODVitamin Ecarotenoidsubiquinols

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Vitamin CPolyphenols

PH-GSH-Px

After Surai

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

bull α-Tocopherol lsquoto carry a pregnancyrsquo

Vit E polyphenol wersquove come to depend on

Anti-oxidant Lipophilic

Key player in antioxidant cascade

1000x more reactive to

H2O2 than PUFA

Vit E prevents

formation of dangerous

peroxidation products

Part of reaction

cascade also involving

Vit C and thiols

Rimbach 2010

Role evolving from AO to gene regulator

Evolving role of Vit E

Zingg 2007Rimbach 2010

Basal vit E requirements sound basis

Poultry 1994 NRC

Swineminus 2012 NRC refers to 1998 NRCminus 1998 NRC refers to 1981 review by Ullrey and ARC

minus Focus is on 40-50 year old literature

Havenstein 2003 Ross 2012

1957 strain

2001 strain

Vit E requirement affected by Stress level Growth rate Meat quality

bull Example for poultry (modified)

AO Requirement depends on health status

Winterbourn 2008

Radicals are also a double-

edged sword for fighting

infections

Intake of 175 mg or 62 ppm saturates muscle

Muscle level of 34 ugg saturates AO effect

Meta-analysis confirms limits

Meta-analysis for swine meat qualityminus 90 of the improvement in TBARS occurs at a tissue level of 34 ugg

tocopherol which is obtained with a dose of 90 mgdayminus Optimum dose of Vit E for meat quality is 30-35 ppm

Sales 2011

Vit E bio-availability poor

Pharmacokinetics trial with swine

minus Bio-efficacy oral 54

minus Elimination half-life 26h

minus Plasma level ~3 microM

Cause

minus Low-fat diet (6)

minus Poor hydrolysis of acetate ester

minus Use of stereo-isomers

minus High dose vs requirement

Vit E one of many antioxidants in nature

Plants contain an array of antioxidants besides Vit Eminus Some plants have a very strong anti-oxidant protection

Apak 2007

Polyphenols a colorful tree

Potent AO alternatives to Vit E

Similar phenolic structure as Vit Eminus Often more hydroxy groups than Vit E

minus More anti-oxidant capacity per moleminus But typically smaller molecules

minus Much more anti-oxidant capacity per gram

Tabart 2009

Naringenin (272)

Caffeic acid (180)

α-tocopherol (472)

Vit P again

1939 Polyphenols were considered as vitaminsminus Cured some diseases linked to

oxidative stress

2006 lsquoLifespan essentialrsquo(Williamson)

Like all-rac Vit E not all polyphenols equal

Polyphenol bio-availability varies from 0 to gt80minus But fermentation can yield digestible fragments

minus Eg proanthocyanidinsminus Too large to be absorbed in small intestines

bull Digestibility = 0minus Can be fermented

bull Key product is hydroxyphenyl acetic acidbull Mass recovery is only 08

Sauro 2010

Polyphenol selectionminus Ruminant bypass or polyphenols which are fermented into potent

anti-oxidants minus Monogastrics digestible with high ORAC (dORAC)

Bio-availability critical in product formulation

Manach 2005 tocopherol = Michiels 2013

AO-mix adapted to species

Components selected for high bio-availability

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications swine

Both Vit E and AO-mix prevented an increase in lipid peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed piglets

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

Control 11 ppm Vit E 80 PPM 11E+69 AO mix

Mal

on

dia

ldeh

yde

(MD

A) MDA pre-stress MDA post-stress

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

Both Vit E and Selko AOmix prevented an increase in peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed broilers

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

AOmix resulted in a lower SOD (ns) in heat-stressed birds

minus MDA and SOD positively correlated

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications poultry

Heat stressed broilers in Asia

minus AO-mix improved BW FI and cellular immunity while reducing MDA

Rama Rao

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 6: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

Oxidative stress influences parturition

Parturition in cattle Bernabucci 2002

Oxidative stress influences stress susceptibility

Heat stress in poultry Altan 2003

Oxidative stress influences meat quality

Meat quality in lambs Nieto 2010

Multiple defense mechanisms in place

Membranes

After Surai

Multiple defense mechanisms in place

And 3 catabolism of damaged molecules

GSH Lipoic acid

Vitamin E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODVitamin Ecarotenoidsubiquinols

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Vitamin CPolyphenols

PH-GSH-Px

After Surai

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

bull α-Tocopherol lsquoto carry a pregnancyrsquo

Vit E polyphenol wersquove come to depend on

Anti-oxidant Lipophilic

Key player in antioxidant cascade

1000x more reactive to

H2O2 than PUFA

Vit E prevents

formation of dangerous

peroxidation products

Part of reaction

cascade also involving

Vit C and thiols

Rimbach 2010

Role evolving from AO to gene regulator

Evolving role of Vit E

Zingg 2007Rimbach 2010

Basal vit E requirements sound basis

Poultry 1994 NRC

Swineminus 2012 NRC refers to 1998 NRCminus 1998 NRC refers to 1981 review by Ullrey and ARC

minus Focus is on 40-50 year old literature

Havenstein 2003 Ross 2012

1957 strain

2001 strain

Vit E requirement affected by Stress level Growth rate Meat quality

bull Example for poultry (modified)

AO Requirement depends on health status

Winterbourn 2008

Radicals are also a double-

edged sword for fighting

infections

Intake of 175 mg or 62 ppm saturates muscle

Muscle level of 34 ugg saturates AO effect

Meta-analysis confirms limits

Meta-analysis for swine meat qualityminus 90 of the improvement in TBARS occurs at a tissue level of 34 ugg

tocopherol which is obtained with a dose of 90 mgdayminus Optimum dose of Vit E for meat quality is 30-35 ppm

Sales 2011

Vit E bio-availability poor

Pharmacokinetics trial with swine

minus Bio-efficacy oral 54

minus Elimination half-life 26h

minus Plasma level ~3 microM

Cause

minus Low-fat diet (6)

minus Poor hydrolysis of acetate ester

minus Use of stereo-isomers

minus High dose vs requirement

Vit E one of many antioxidants in nature

Plants contain an array of antioxidants besides Vit Eminus Some plants have a very strong anti-oxidant protection

Apak 2007

Polyphenols a colorful tree

Potent AO alternatives to Vit E

Similar phenolic structure as Vit Eminus Often more hydroxy groups than Vit E

minus More anti-oxidant capacity per moleminus But typically smaller molecules

minus Much more anti-oxidant capacity per gram

Tabart 2009

Naringenin (272)

Caffeic acid (180)

α-tocopherol (472)

Vit P again

1939 Polyphenols were considered as vitaminsminus Cured some diseases linked to

oxidative stress

2006 lsquoLifespan essentialrsquo(Williamson)

Like all-rac Vit E not all polyphenols equal

Polyphenol bio-availability varies from 0 to gt80minus But fermentation can yield digestible fragments

minus Eg proanthocyanidinsminus Too large to be absorbed in small intestines

bull Digestibility = 0minus Can be fermented

bull Key product is hydroxyphenyl acetic acidbull Mass recovery is only 08

Sauro 2010

Polyphenol selectionminus Ruminant bypass or polyphenols which are fermented into potent

anti-oxidants minus Monogastrics digestible with high ORAC (dORAC)

Bio-availability critical in product formulation

Manach 2005 tocopherol = Michiels 2013

AO-mix adapted to species

Components selected for high bio-availability

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications swine

Both Vit E and AO-mix prevented an increase in lipid peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed piglets

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

Control 11 ppm Vit E 80 PPM 11E+69 AO mix

Mal

on

dia

ldeh

yde

(MD

A) MDA pre-stress MDA post-stress

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

Both Vit E and Selko AOmix prevented an increase in peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed broilers

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

AOmix resulted in a lower SOD (ns) in heat-stressed birds

minus MDA and SOD positively correlated

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications poultry

Heat stressed broilers in Asia

minus AO-mix improved BW FI and cellular immunity while reducing MDA

Rama Rao

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 7: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

Oxidative stress influences stress susceptibility

Heat stress in poultry Altan 2003

Oxidative stress influences meat quality

Meat quality in lambs Nieto 2010

Multiple defense mechanisms in place

Membranes

After Surai

Multiple defense mechanisms in place

And 3 catabolism of damaged molecules

GSH Lipoic acid

Vitamin E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODVitamin Ecarotenoidsubiquinols

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Vitamin CPolyphenols

PH-GSH-Px

After Surai

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

bull α-Tocopherol lsquoto carry a pregnancyrsquo

Vit E polyphenol wersquove come to depend on

Anti-oxidant Lipophilic

Key player in antioxidant cascade

1000x more reactive to

H2O2 than PUFA

Vit E prevents

formation of dangerous

peroxidation products

Part of reaction

cascade also involving

Vit C and thiols

Rimbach 2010

Role evolving from AO to gene regulator

Evolving role of Vit E

Zingg 2007Rimbach 2010

Basal vit E requirements sound basis

Poultry 1994 NRC

Swineminus 2012 NRC refers to 1998 NRCminus 1998 NRC refers to 1981 review by Ullrey and ARC

minus Focus is on 40-50 year old literature

Havenstein 2003 Ross 2012

1957 strain

2001 strain

Vit E requirement affected by Stress level Growth rate Meat quality

bull Example for poultry (modified)

AO Requirement depends on health status

Winterbourn 2008

Radicals are also a double-

edged sword for fighting

infections

Intake of 175 mg or 62 ppm saturates muscle

Muscle level of 34 ugg saturates AO effect

Meta-analysis confirms limits

Meta-analysis for swine meat qualityminus 90 of the improvement in TBARS occurs at a tissue level of 34 ugg

tocopherol which is obtained with a dose of 90 mgdayminus Optimum dose of Vit E for meat quality is 30-35 ppm

Sales 2011

Vit E bio-availability poor

Pharmacokinetics trial with swine

minus Bio-efficacy oral 54

minus Elimination half-life 26h

minus Plasma level ~3 microM

Cause

minus Low-fat diet (6)

minus Poor hydrolysis of acetate ester

minus Use of stereo-isomers

minus High dose vs requirement

Vit E one of many antioxidants in nature

Plants contain an array of antioxidants besides Vit Eminus Some plants have a very strong anti-oxidant protection

Apak 2007

Polyphenols a colorful tree

Potent AO alternatives to Vit E

Similar phenolic structure as Vit Eminus Often more hydroxy groups than Vit E

minus More anti-oxidant capacity per moleminus But typically smaller molecules

minus Much more anti-oxidant capacity per gram

Tabart 2009

Naringenin (272)

Caffeic acid (180)

α-tocopherol (472)

Vit P again

1939 Polyphenols were considered as vitaminsminus Cured some diseases linked to

oxidative stress

2006 lsquoLifespan essentialrsquo(Williamson)

Like all-rac Vit E not all polyphenols equal

Polyphenol bio-availability varies from 0 to gt80minus But fermentation can yield digestible fragments

minus Eg proanthocyanidinsminus Too large to be absorbed in small intestines

bull Digestibility = 0minus Can be fermented

bull Key product is hydroxyphenyl acetic acidbull Mass recovery is only 08

Sauro 2010

Polyphenol selectionminus Ruminant bypass or polyphenols which are fermented into potent

anti-oxidants minus Monogastrics digestible with high ORAC (dORAC)

Bio-availability critical in product formulation

Manach 2005 tocopherol = Michiels 2013

AO-mix adapted to species

Components selected for high bio-availability

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications swine

Both Vit E and AO-mix prevented an increase in lipid peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed piglets

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

Control 11 ppm Vit E 80 PPM 11E+69 AO mix

Mal

on

dia

ldeh

yde

(MD

A) MDA pre-stress MDA post-stress

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

Both Vit E and Selko AOmix prevented an increase in peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed broilers

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

AOmix resulted in a lower SOD (ns) in heat-stressed birds

minus MDA and SOD positively correlated

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications poultry

Heat stressed broilers in Asia

minus AO-mix improved BW FI and cellular immunity while reducing MDA

Rama Rao

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 8: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

Oxidative stress influences meat quality

Meat quality in lambs Nieto 2010

Multiple defense mechanisms in place

Membranes

After Surai

Multiple defense mechanisms in place

And 3 catabolism of damaged molecules

GSH Lipoic acid

Vitamin E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODVitamin Ecarotenoidsubiquinols

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Vitamin CPolyphenols

PH-GSH-Px

After Surai

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

bull α-Tocopherol lsquoto carry a pregnancyrsquo

Vit E polyphenol wersquove come to depend on

Anti-oxidant Lipophilic

Key player in antioxidant cascade

1000x more reactive to

H2O2 than PUFA

Vit E prevents

formation of dangerous

peroxidation products

Part of reaction

cascade also involving

Vit C and thiols

Rimbach 2010

Role evolving from AO to gene regulator

Evolving role of Vit E

Zingg 2007Rimbach 2010

Basal vit E requirements sound basis

Poultry 1994 NRC

Swineminus 2012 NRC refers to 1998 NRCminus 1998 NRC refers to 1981 review by Ullrey and ARC

minus Focus is on 40-50 year old literature

Havenstein 2003 Ross 2012

1957 strain

2001 strain

Vit E requirement affected by Stress level Growth rate Meat quality

bull Example for poultry (modified)

AO Requirement depends on health status

Winterbourn 2008

Radicals are also a double-

edged sword for fighting

infections

Intake of 175 mg or 62 ppm saturates muscle

Muscle level of 34 ugg saturates AO effect

Meta-analysis confirms limits

Meta-analysis for swine meat qualityminus 90 of the improvement in TBARS occurs at a tissue level of 34 ugg

tocopherol which is obtained with a dose of 90 mgdayminus Optimum dose of Vit E for meat quality is 30-35 ppm

Sales 2011

Vit E bio-availability poor

Pharmacokinetics trial with swine

minus Bio-efficacy oral 54

minus Elimination half-life 26h

minus Plasma level ~3 microM

Cause

minus Low-fat diet (6)

minus Poor hydrolysis of acetate ester

minus Use of stereo-isomers

minus High dose vs requirement

Vit E one of many antioxidants in nature

Plants contain an array of antioxidants besides Vit Eminus Some plants have a very strong anti-oxidant protection

Apak 2007

Polyphenols a colorful tree

Potent AO alternatives to Vit E

Similar phenolic structure as Vit Eminus Often more hydroxy groups than Vit E

minus More anti-oxidant capacity per moleminus But typically smaller molecules

minus Much more anti-oxidant capacity per gram

Tabart 2009

Naringenin (272)

Caffeic acid (180)

α-tocopherol (472)

Vit P again

1939 Polyphenols were considered as vitaminsminus Cured some diseases linked to

oxidative stress

2006 lsquoLifespan essentialrsquo(Williamson)

Like all-rac Vit E not all polyphenols equal

Polyphenol bio-availability varies from 0 to gt80minus But fermentation can yield digestible fragments

minus Eg proanthocyanidinsminus Too large to be absorbed in small intestines

bull Digestibility = 0minus Can be fermented

bull Key product is hydroxyphenyl acetic acidbull Mass recovery is only 08

Sauro 2010

Polyphenol selectionminus Ruminant bypass or polyphenols which are fermented into potent

anti-oxidants minus Monogastrics digestible with high ORAC (dORAC)

Bio-availability critical in product formulation

Manach 2005 tocopherol = Michiels 2013

AO-mix adapted to species

Components selected for high bio-availability

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications swine

Both Vit E and AO-mix prevented an increase in lipid peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed piglets

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

Control 11 ppm Vit E 80 PPM 11E+69 AO mix

Mal

on

dia

ldeh

yde

(MD

A) MDA pre-stress MDA post-stress

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

Both Vit E and Selko AOmix prevented an increase in peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed broilers

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

AOmix resulted in a lower SOD (ns) in heat-stressed birds

minus MDA and SOD positively correlated

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications poultry

Heat stressed broilers in Asia

minus AO-mix improved BW FI and cellular immunity while reducing MDA

Rama Rao

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 9: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

Multiple defense mechanisms in place

Membranes

After Surai

Multiple defense mechanisms in place

And 3 catabolism of damaged molecules

GSH Lipoic acid

Vitamin E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODVitamin Ecarotenoidsubiquinols

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Vitamin CPolyphenols

PH-GSH-Px

After Surai

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

bull α-Tocopherol lsquoto carry a pregnancyrsquo

Vit E polyphenol wersquove come to depend on

Anti-oxidant Lipophilic

Key player in antioxidant cascade

1000x more reactive to

H2O2 than PUFA

Vit E prevents

formation of dangerous

peroxidation products

Part of reaction

cascade also involving

Vit C and thiols

Rimbach 2010

Role evolving from AO to gene regulator

Evolving role of Vit E

Zingg 2007Rimbach 2010

Basal vit E requirements sound basis

Poultry 1994 NRC

Swineminus 2012 NRC refers to 1998 NRCminus 1998 NRC refers to 1981 review by Ullrey and ARC

minus Focus is on 40-50 year old literature

Havenstein 2003 Ross 2012

1957 strain

2001 strain

Vit E requirement affected by Stress level Growth rate Meat quality

bull Example for poultry (modified)

AO Requirement depends on health status

Winterbourn 2008

Radicals are also a double-

edged sword for fighting

infections

Intake of 175 mg or 62 ppm saturates muscle

Muscle level of 34 ugg saturates AO effect

Meta-analysis confirms limits

Meta-analysis for swine meat qualityminus 90 of the improvement in TBARS occurs at a tissue level of 34 ugg

tocopherol which is obtained with a dose of 90 mgdayminus Optimum dose of Vit E for meat quality is 30-35 ppm

Sales 2011

Vit E bio-availability poor

Pharmacokinetics trial with swine

minus Bio-efficacy oral 54

minus Elimination half-life 26h

minus Plasma level ~3 microM

Cause

minus Low-fat diet (6)

minus Poor hydrolysis of acetate ester

minus Use of stereo-isomers

minus High dose vs requirement

Vit E one of many antioxidants in nature

Plants contain an array of antioxidants besides Vit Eminus Some plants have a very strong anti-oxidant protection

Apak 2007

Polyphenols a colorful tree

Potent AO alternatives to Vit E

Similar phenolic structure as Vit Eminus Often more hydroxy groups than Vit E

minus More anti-oxidant capacity per moleminus But typically smaller molecules

minus Much more anti-oxidant capacity per gram

Tabart 2009

Naringenin (272)

Caffeic acid (180)

α-tocopherol (472)

Vit P again

1939 Polyphenols were considered as vitaminsminus Cured some diseases linked to

oxidative stress

2006 lsquoLifespan essentialrsquo(Williamson)

Like all-rac Vit E not all polyphenols equal

Polyphenol bio-availability varies from 0 to gt80minus But fermentation can yield digestible fragments

minus Eg proanthocyanidinsminus Too large to be absorbed in small intestines

bull Digestibility = 0minus Can be fermented

bull Key product is hydroxyphenyl acetic acidbull Mass recovery is only 08

Sauro 2010

Polyphenol selectionminus Ruminant bypass or polyphenols which are fermented into potent

anti-oxidants minus Monogastrics digestible with high ORAC (dORAC)

Bio-availability critical in product formulation

Manach 2005 tocopherol = Michiels 2013

AO-mix adapted to species

Components selected for high bio-availability

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications swine

Both Vit E and AO-mix prevented an increase in lipid peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed piglets

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

Control 11 ppm Vit E 80 PPM 11E+69 AO mix

Mal

on

dia

ldeh

yde

(MD

A) MDA pre-stress MDA post-stress

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

Both Vit E and Selko AOmix prevented an increase in peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed broilers

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

AOmix resulted in a lower SOD (ns) in heat-stressed birds

minus MDA and SOD positively correlated

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications poultry

Heat stressed broilers in Asia

minus AO-mix improved BW FI and cellular immunity while reducing MDA

Rama Rao

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 10: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

Multiple defense mechanisms in place

And 3 catabolism of damaged molecules

GSH Lipoic acid

Vitamin E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODVitamin Ecarotenoidsubiquinols

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Vitamin CPolyphenols

PH-GSH-Px

After Surai

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

bull α-Tocopherol lsquoto carry a pregnancyrsquo

Vit E polyphenol wersquove come to depend on

Anti-oxidant Lipophilic

Key player in antioxidant cascade

1000x more reactive to

H2O2 than PUFA

Vit E prevents

formation of dangerous

peroxidation products

Part of reaction

cascade also involving

Vit C and thiols

Rimbach 2010

Role evolving from AO to gene regulator

Evolving role of Vit E

Zingg 2007Rimbach 2010

Basal vit E requirements sound basis

Poultry 1994 NRC

Swineminus 2012 NRC refers to 1998 NRCminus 1998 NRC refers to 1981 review by Ullrey and ARC

minus Focus is on 40-50 year old literature

Havenstein 2003 Ross 2012

1957 strain

2001 strain

Vit E requirement affected by Stress level Growth rate Meat quality

bull Example for poultry (modified)

AO Requirement depends on health status

Winterbourn 2008

Radicals are also a double-

edged sword for fighting

infections

Intake of 175 mg or 62 ppm saturates muscle

Muscle level of 34 ugg saturates AO effect

Meta-analysis confirms limits

Meta-analysis for swine meat qualityminus 90 of the improvement in TBARS occurs at a tissue level of 34 ugg

tocopherol which is obtained with a dose of 90 mgdayminus Optimum dose of Vit E for meat quality is 30-35 ppm

Sales 2011

Vit E bio-availability poor

Pharmacokinetics trial with swine

minus Bio-efficacy oral 54

minus Elimination half-life 26h

minus Plasma level ~3 microM

Cause

minus Low-fat diet (6)

minus Poor hydrolysis of acetate ester

minus Use of stereo-isomers

minus High dose vs requirement

Vit E one of many antioxidants in nature

Plants contain an array of antioxidants besides Vit Eminus Some plants have a very strong anti-oxidant protection

Apak 2007

Polyphenols a colorful tree

Potent AO alternatives to Vit E

Similar phenolic structure as Vit Eminus Often more hydroxy groups than Vit E

minus More anti-oxidant capacity per moleminus But typically smaller molecules

minus Much more anti-oxidant capacity per gram

Tabart 2009

Naringenin (272)

Caffeic acid (180)

α-tocopherol (472)

Vit P again

1939 Polyphenols were considered as vitaminsminus Cured some diseases linked to

oxidative stress

2006 lsquoLifespan essentialrsquo(Williamson)

Like all-rac Vit E not all polyphenols equal

Polyphenol bio-availability varies from 0 to gt80minus But fermentation can yield digestible fragments

minus Eg proanthocyanidinsminus Too large to be absorbed in small intestines

bull Digestibility = 0minus Can be fermented

bull Key product is hydroxyphenyl acetic acidbull Mass recovery is only 08

Sauro 2010

Polyphenol selectionminus Ruminant bypass or polyphenols which are fermented into potent

anti-oxidants minus Monogastrics digestible with high ORAC (dORAC)

Bio-availability critical in product formulation

Manach 2005 tocopherol = Michiels 2013

AO-mix adapted to species

Components selected for high bio-availability

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications swine

Both Vit E and AO-mix prevented an increase in lipid peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed piglets

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

Control 11 ppm Vit E 80 PPM 11E+69 AO mix

Mal

on

dia

ldeh

yde

(MD

A) MDA pre-stress MDA post-stress

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

Both Vit E and Selko AOmix prevented an increase in peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed broilers

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

AOmix resulted in a lower SOD (ns) in heat-stressed birds

minus MDA and SOD positively correlated

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications poultry

Heat stressed broilers in Asia

minus AO-mix improved BW FI and cellular immunity while reducing MDA

Rama Rao

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 11: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

bull α-Tocopherol lsquoto carry a pregnancyrsquo

Vit E polyphenol wersquove come to depend on

Anti-oxidant Lipophilic

Key player in antioxidant cascade

1000x more reactive to

H2O2 than PUFA

Vit E prevents

formation of dangerous

peroxidation products

Part of reaction

cascade also involving

Vit C and thiols

Rimbach 2010

Role evolving from AO to gene regulator

Evolving role of Vit E

Zingg 2007Rimbach 2010

Basal vit E requirements sound basis

Poultry 1994 NRC

Swineminus 2012 NRC refers to 1998 NRCminus 1998 NRC refers to 1981 review by Ullrey and ARC

minus Focus is on 40-50 year old literature

Havenstein 2003 Ross 2012

1957 strain

2001 strain

Vit E requirement affected by Stress level Growth rate Meat quality

bull Example for poultry (modified)

AO Requirement depends on health status

Winterbourn 2008

Radicals are also a double-

edged sword for fighting

infections

Intake of 175 mg or 62 ppm saturates muscle

Muscle level of 34 ugg saturates AO effect

Meta-analysis confirms limits

Meta-analysis for swine meat qualityminus 90 of the improvement in TBARS occurs at a tissue level of 34 ugg

tocopherol which is obtained with a dose of 90 mgdayminus Optimum dose of Vit E for meat quality is 30-35 ppm

Sales 2011

Vit E bio-availability poor

Pharmacokinetics trial with swine

minus Bio-efficacy oral 54

minus Elimination half-life 26h

minus Plasma level ~3 microM

Cause

minus Low-fat diet (6)

minus Poor hydrolysis of acetate ester

minus Use of stereo-isomers

minus High dose vs requirement

Vit E one of many antioxidants in nature

Plants contain an array of antioxidants besides Vit Eminus Some plants have a very strong anti-oxidant protection

Apak 2007

Polyphenols a colorful tree

Potent AO alternatives to Vit E

Similar phenolic structure as Vit Eminus Often more hydroxy groups than Vit E

minus More anti-oxidant capacity per moleminus But typically smaller molecules

minus Much more anti-oxidant capacity per gram

Tabart 2009

Naringenin (272)

Caffeic acid (180)

α-tocopherol (472)

Vit P again

1939 Polyphenols were considered as vitaminsminus Cured some diseases linked to

oxidative stress

2006 lsquoLifespan essentialrsquo(Williamson)

Like all-rac Vit E not all polyphenols equal

Polyphenol bio-availability varies from 0 to gt80minus But fermentation can yield digestible fragments

minus Eg proanthocyanidinsminus Too large to be absorbed in small intestines

bull Digestibility = 0minus Can be fermented

bull Key product is hydroxyphenyl acetic acidbull Mass recovery is only 08

Sauro 2010

Polyphenol selectionminus Ruminant bypass or polyphenols which are fermented into potent

anti-oxidants minus Monogastrics digestible with high ORAC (dORAC)

Bio-availability critical in product formulation

Manach 2005 tocopherol = Michiels 2013

AO-mix adapted to species

Components selected for high bio-availability

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications swine

Both Vit E and AO-mix prevented an increase in lipid peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed piglets

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

Control 11 ppm Vit E 80 PPM 11E+69 AO mix

Mal

on

dia

ldeh

yde

(MD

A) MDA pre-stress MDA post-stress

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

Both Vit E and Selko AOmix prevented an increase in peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed broilers

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

AOmix resulted in a lower SOD (ns) in heat-stressed birds

minus MDA and SOD positively correlated

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications poultry

Heat stressed broilers in Asia

minus AO-mix improved BW FI and cellular immunity while reducing MDA

Rama Rao

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 12: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

Key player in antioxidant cascade

1000x more reactive to

H2O2 than PUFA

Vit E prevents

formation of dangerous

peroxidation products

Part of reaction

cascade also involving

Vit C and thiols

Rimbach 2010

Role evolving from AO to gene regulator

Evolving role of Vit E

Zingg 2007Rimbach 2010

Basal vit E requirements sound basis

Poultry 1994 NRC

Swineminus 2012 NRC refers to 1998 NRCminus 1998 NRC refers to 1981 review by Ullrey and ARC

minus Focus is on 40-50 year old literature

Havenstein 2003 Ross 2012

1957 strain

2001 strain

Vit E requirement affected by Stress level Growth rate Meat quality

bull Example for poultry (modified)

AO Requirement depends on health status

Winterbourn 2008

Radicals are also a double-

edged sword for fighting

infections

Intake of 175 mg or 62 ppm saturates muscle

Muscle level of 34 ugg saturates AO effect

Meta-analysis confirms limits

Meta-analysis for swine meat qualityminus 90 of the improvement in TBARS occurs at a tissue level of 34 ugg

tocopherol which is obtained with a dose of 90 mgdayminus Optimum dose of Vit E for meat quality is 30-35 ppm

Sales 2011

Vit E bio-availability poor

Pharmacokinetics trial with swine

minus Bio-efficacy oral 54

minus Elimination half-life 26h

minus Plasma level ~3 microM

Cause

minus Low-fat diet (6)

minus Poor hydrolysis of acetate ester

minus Use of stereo-isomers

minus High dose vs requirement

Vit E one of many antioxidants in nature

Plants contain an array of antioxidants besides Vit Eminus Some plants have a very strong anti-oxidant protection

Apak 2007

Polyphenols a colorful tree

Potent AO alternatives to Vit E

Similar phenolic structure as Vit Eminus Often more hydroxy groups than Vit E

minus More anti-oxidant capacity per moleminus But typically smaller molecules

minus Much more anti-oxidant capacity per gram

Tabart 2009

Naringenin (272)

Caffeic acid (180)

α-tocopherol (472)

Vit P again

1939 Polyphenols were considered as vitaminsminus Cured some diseases linked to

oxidative stress

2006 lsquoLifespan essentialrsquo(Williamson)

Like all-rac Vit E not all polyphenols equal

Polyphenol bio-availability varies from 0 to gt80minus But fermentation can yield digestible fragments

minus Eg proanthocyanidinsminus Too large to be absorbed in small intestines

bull Digestibility = 0minus Can be fermented

bull Key product is hydroxyphenyl acetic acidbull Mass recovery is only 08

Sauro 2010

Polyphenol selectionminus Ruminant bypass or polyphenols which are fermented into potent

anti-oxidants minus Monogastrics digestible with high ORAC (dORAC)

Bio-availability critical in product formulation

Manach 2005 tocopherol = Michiels 2013

AO-mix adapted to species

Components selected for high bio-availability

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications swine

Both Vit E and AO-mix prevented an increase in lipid peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed piglets

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

Control 11 ppm Vit E 80 PPM 11E+69 AO mix

Mal

on

dia

ldeh

yde

(MD

A) MDA pre-stress MDA post-stress

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

Both Vit E and Selko AOmix prevented an increase in peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed broilers

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

AOmix resulted in a lower SOD (ns) in heat-stressed birds

minus MDA and SOD positively correlated

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications poultry

Heat stressed broilers in Asia

minus AO-mix improved BW FI and cellular immunity while reducing MDA

Rama Rao

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 13: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

Role evolving from AO to gene regulator

Evolving role of Vit E

Zingg 2007Rimbach 2010

Basal vit E requirements sound basis

Poultry 1994 NRC

Swineminus 2012 NRC refers to 1998 NRCminus 1998 NRC refers to 1981 review by Ullrey and ARC

minus Focus is on 40-50 year old literature

Havenstein 2003 Ross 2012

1957 strain

2001 strain

Vit E requirement affected by Stress level Growth rate Meat quality

bull Example for poultry (modified)

AO Requirement depends on health status

Winterbourn 2008

Radicals are also a double-

edged sword for fighting

infections

Intake of 175 mg or 62 ppm saturates muscle

Muscle level of 34 ugg saturates AO effect

Meta-analysis confirms limits

Meta-analysis for swine meat qualityminus 90 of the improvement in TBARS occurs at a tissue level of 34 ugg

tocopherol which is obtained with a dose of 90 mgdayminus Optimum dose of Vit E for meat quality is 30-35 ppm

Sales 2011

Vit E bio-availability poor

Pharmacokinetics trial with swine

minus Bio-efficacy oral 54

minus Elimination half-life 26h

minus Plasma level ~3 microM

Cause

minus Low-fat diet (6)

minus Poor hydrolysis of acetate ester

minus Use of stereo-isomers

minus High dose vs requirement

Vit E one of many antioxidants in nature

Plants contain an array of antioxidants besides Vit Eminus Some plants have a very strong anti-oxidant protection

Apak 2007

Polyphenols a colorful tree

Potent AO alternatives to Vit E

Similar phenolic structure as Vit Eminus Often more hydroxy groups than Vit E

minus More anti-oxidant capacity per moleminus But typically smaller molecules

minus Much more anti-oxidant capacity per gram

Tabart 2009

Naringenin (272)

Caffeic acid (180)

α-tocopherol (472)

Vit P again

1939 Polyphenols were considered as vitaminsminus Cured some diseases linked to

oxidative stress

2006 lsquoLifespan essentialrsquo(Williamson)

Like all-rac Vit E not all polyphenols equal

Polyphenol bio-availability varies from 0 to gt80minus But fermentation can yield digestible fragments

minus Eg proanthocyanidinsminus Too large to be absorbed in small intestines

bull Digestibility = 0minus Can be fermented

bull Key product is hydroxyphenyl acetic acidbull Mass recovery is only 08

Sauro 2010

Polyphenol selectionminus Ruminant bypass or polyphenols which are fermented into potent

anti-oxidants minus Monogastrics digestible with high ORAC (dORAC)

Bio-availability critical in product formulation

Manach 2005 tocopherol = Michiels 2013

AO-mix adapted to species

Components selected for high bio-availability

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications swine

Both Vit E and AO-mix prevented an increase in lipid peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed piglets

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

Control 11 ppm Vit E 80 PPM 11E+69 AO mix

Mal

on

dia

ldeh

yde

(MD

A) MDA pre-stress MDA post-stress

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

Both Vit E and Selko AOmix prevented an increase in peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed broilers

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

AOmix resulted in a lower SOD (ns) in heat-stressed birds

minus MDA and SOD positively correlated

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications poultry

Heat stressed broilers in Asia

minus AO-mix improved BW FI and cellular immunity while reducing MDA

Rama Rao

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 14: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

Basal vit E requirements sound basis

Poultry 1994 NRC

Swineminus 2012 NRC refers to 1998 NRCminus 1998 NRC refers to 1981 review by Ullrey and ARC

minus Focus is on 40-50 year old literature

Havenstein 2003 Ross 2012

1957 strain

2001 strain

Vit E requirement affected by Stress level Growth rate Meat quality

bull Example for poultry (modified)

AO Requirement depends on health status

Winterbourn 2008

Radicals are also a double-

edged sword for fighting

infections

Intake of 175 mg or 62 ppm saturates muscle

Muscle level of 34 ugg saturates AO effect

Meta-analysis confirms limits

Meta-analysis for swine meat qualityminus 90 of the improvement in TBARS occurs at a tissue level of 34 ugg

tocopherol which is obtained with a dose of 90 mgdayminus Optimum dose of Vit E for meat quality is 30-35 ppm

Sales 2011

Vit E bio-availability poor

Pharmacokinetics trial with swine

minus Bio-efficacy oral 54

minus Elimination half-life 26h

minus Plasma level ~3 microM

Cause

minus Low-fat diet (6)

minus Poor hydrolysis of acetate ester

minus Use of stereo-isomers

minus High dose vs requirement

Vit E one of many antioxidants in nature

Plants contain an array of antioxidants besides Vit Eminus Some plants have a very strong anti-oxidant protection

Apak 2007

Polyphenols a colorful tree

Potent AO alternatives to Vit E

Similar phenolic structure as Vit Eminus Often more hydroxy groups than Vit E

minus More anti-oxidant capacity per moleminus But typically smaller molecules

minus Much more anti-oxidant capacity per gram

Tabart 2009

Naringenin (272)

Caffeic acid (180)

α-tocopherol (472)

Vit P again

1939 Polyphenols were considered as vitaminsminus Cured some diseases linked to

oxidative stress

2006 lsquoLifespan essentialrsquo(Williamson)

Like all-rac Vit E not all polyphenols equal

Polyphenol bio-availability varies from 0 to gt80minus But fermentation can yield digestible fragments

minus Eg proanthocyanidinsminus Too large to be absorbed in small intestines

bull Digestibility = 0minus Can be fermented

bull Key product is hydroxyphenyl acetic acidbull Mass recovery is only 08

Sauro 2010

Polyphenol selectionminus Ruminant bypass or polyphenols which are fermented into potent

anti-oxidants minus Monogastrics digestible with high ORAC (dORAC)

Bio-availability critical in product formulation

Manach 2005 tocopherol = Michiels 2013

AO-mix adapted to species

Components selected for high bio-availability

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications swine

Both Vit E and AO-mix prevented an increase in lipid peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed piglets

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

Control 11 ppm Vit E 80 PPM 11E+69 AO mix

Mal

on

dia

ldeh

yde

(MD

A) MDA pre-stress MDA post-stress

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

Both Vit E and Selko AOmix prevented an increase in peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed broilers

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

AOmix resulted in a lower SOD (ns) in heat-stressed birds

minus MDA and SOD positively correlated

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications poultry

Heat stressed broilers in Asia

minus AO-mix improved BW FI and cellular immunity while reducing MDA

Rama Rao

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 15: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

Vit E requirement affected by Stress level Growth rate Meat quality

bull Example for poultry (modified)

AO Requirement depends on health status

Winterbourn 2008

Radicals are also a double-

edged sword for fighting

infections

Intake of 175 mg or 62 ppm saturates muscle

Muscle level of 34 ugg saturates AO effect

Meta-analysis confirms limits

Meta-analysis for swine meat qualityminus 90 of the improvement in TBARS occurs at a tissue level of 34 ugg

tocopherol which is obtained with a dose of 90 mgdayminus Optimum dose of Vit E for meat quality is 30-35 ppm

Sales 2011

Vit E bio-availability poor

Pharmacokinetics trial with swine

minus Bio-efficacy oral 54

minus Elimination half-life 26h

minus Plasma level ~3 microM

Cause

minus Low-fat diet (6)

minus Poor hydrolysis of acetate ester

minus Use of stereo-isomers

minus High dose vs requirement

Vit E one of many antioxidants in nature

Plants contain an array of antioxidants besides Vit Eminus Some plants have a very strong anti-oxidant protection

Apak 2007

Polyphenols a colorful tree

Potent AO alternatives to Vit E

Similar phenolic structure as Vit Eminus Often more hydroxy groups than Vit E

minus More anti-oxidant capacity per moleminus But typically smaller molecules

minus Much more anti-oxidant capacity per gram

Tabart 2009

Naringenin (272)

Caffeic acid (180)

α-tocopherol (472)

Vit P again

1939 Polyphenols were considered as vitaminsminus Cured some diseases linked to

oxidative stress

2006 lsquoLifespan essentialrsquo(Williamson)

Like all-rac Vit E not all polyphenols equal

Polyphenol bio-availability varies from 0 to gt80minus But fermentation can yield digestible fragments

minus Eg proanthocyanidinsminus Too large to be absorbed in small intestines

bull Digestibility = 0minus Can be fermented

bull Key product is hydroxyphenyl acetic acidbull Mass recovery is only 08

Sauro 2010

Polyphenol selectionminus Ruminant bypass or polyphenols which are fermented into potent

anti-oxidants minus Monogastrics digestible with high ORAC (dORAC)

Bio-availability critical in product formulation

Manach 2005 tocopherol = Michiels 2013

AO-mix adapted to species

Components selected for high bio-availability

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications swine

Both Vit E and AO-mix prevented an increase in lipid peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed piglets

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

Control 11 ppm Vit E 80 PPM 11E+69 AO mix

Mal

on

dia

ldeh

yde

(MD

A) MDA pre-stress MDA post-stress

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

Both Vit E and Selko AOmix prevented an increase in peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed broilers

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

AOmix resulted in a lower SOD (ns) in heat-stressed birds

minus MDA and SOD positively correlated

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications poultry

Heat stressed broilers in Asia

minus AO-mix improved BW FI and cellular immunity while reducing MDA

Rama Rao

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 16: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

Intake of 175 mg or 62 ppm saturates muscle

Muscle level of 34 ugg saturates AO effect

Meta-analysis confirms limits

Meta-analysis for swine meat qualityminus 90 of the improvement in TBARS occurs at a tissue level of 34 ugg

tocopherol which is obtained with a dose of 90 mgdayminus Optimum dose of Vit E for meat quality is 30-35 ppm

Sales 2011

Vit E bio-availability poor

Pharmacokinetics trial with swine

minus Bio-efficacy oral 54

minus Elimination half-life 26h

minus Plasma level ~3 microM

Cause

minus Low-fat diet (6)

minus Poor hydrolysis of acetate ester

minus Use of stereo-isomers

minus High dose vs requirement

Vit E one of many antioxidants in nature

Plants contain an array of antioxidants besides Vit Eminus Some plants have a very strong anti-oxidant protection

Apak 2007

Polyphenols a colorful tree

Potent AO alternatives to Vit E

Similar phenolic structure as Vit Eminus Often more hydroxy groups than Vit E

minus More anti-oxidant capacity per moleminus But typically smaller molecules

minus Much more anti-oxidant capacity per gram

Tabart 2009

Naringenin (272)

Caffeic acid (180)

α-tocopherol (472)

Vit P again

1939 Polyphenols were considered as vitaminsminus Cured some diseases linked to

oxidative stress

2006 lsquoLifespan essentialrsquo(Williamson)

Like all-rac Vit E not all polyphenols equal

Polyphenol bio-availability varies from 0 to gt80minus But fermentation can yield digestible fragments

minus Eg proanthocyanidinsminus Too large to be absorbed in small intestines

bull Digestibility = 0minus Can be fermented

bull Key product is hydroxyphenyl acetic acidbull Mass recovery is only 08

Sauro 2010

Polyphenol selectionminus Ruminant bypass or polyphenols which are fermented into potent

anti-oxidants minus Monogastrics digestible with high ORAC (dORAC)

Bio-availability critical in product formulation

Manach 2005 tocopherol = Michiels 2013

AO-mix adapted to species

Components selected for high bio-availability

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications swine

Both Vit E and AO-mix prevented an increase in lipid peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed piglets

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

Control 11 ppm Vit E 80 PPM 11E+69 AO mix

Mal

on

dia

ldeh

yde

(MD

A) MDA pre-stress MDA post-stress

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

Both Vit E and Selko AOmix prevented an increase in peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed broilers

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

AOmix resulted in a lower SOD (ns) in heat-stressed birds

minus MDA and SOD positively correlated

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications poultry

Heat stressed broilers in Asia

minus AO-mix improved BW FI and cellular immunity while reducing MDA

Rama Rao

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 17: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

Vit E bio-availability poor

Pharmacokinetics trial with swine

minus Bio-efficacy oral 54

minus Elimination half-life 26h

minus Plasma level ~3 microM

Cause

minus Low-fat diet (6)

minus Poor hydrolysis of acetate ester

minus Use of stereo-isomers

minus High dose vs requirement

Vit E one of many antioxidants in nature

Plants contain an array of antioxidants besides Vit Eminus Some plants have a very strong anti-oxidant protection

Apak 2007

Polyphenols a colorful tree

Potent AO alternatives to Vit E

Similar phenolic structure as Vit Eminus Often more hydroxy groups than Vit E

minus More anti-oxidant capacity per moleminus But typically smaller molecules

minus Much more anti-oxidant capacity per gram

Tabart 2009

Naringenin (272)

Caffeic acid (180)

α-tocopherol (472)

Vit P again

1939 Polyphenols were considered as vitaminsminus Cured some diseases linked to

oxidative stress

2006 lsquoLifespan essentialrsquo(Williamson)

Like all-rac Vit E not all polyphenols equal

Polyphenol bio-availability varies from 0 to gt80minus But fermentation can yield digestible fragments

minus Eg proanthocyanidinsminus Too large to be absorbed in small intestines

bull Digestibility = 0minus Can be fermented

bull Key product is hydroxyphenyl acetic acidbull Mass recovery is only 08

Sauro 2010

Polyphenol selectionminus Ruminant bypass or polyphenols which are fermented into potent

anti-oxidants minus Monogastrics digestible with high ORAC (dORAC)

Bio-availability critical in product formulation

Manach 2005 tocopherol = Michiels 2013

AO-mix adapted to species

Components selected for high bio-availability

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications swine

Both Vit E and AO-mix prevented an increase in lipid peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed piglets

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

Control 11 ppm Vit E 80 PPM 11E+69 AO mix

Mal

on

dia

ldeh

yde

(MD

A) MDA pre-stress MDA post-stress

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

Both Vit E and Selko AOmix prevented an increase in peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed broilers

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

AOmix resulted in a lower SOD (ns) in heat-stressed birds

minus MDA and SOD positively correlated

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications poultry

Heat stressed broilers in Asia

minus AO-mix improved BW FI and cellular immunity while reducing MDA

Rama Rao

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 18: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

Vit E one of many antioxidants in nature

Plants contain an array of antioxidants besides Vit Eminus Some plants have a very strong anti-oxidant protection

Apak 2007

Polyphenols a colorful tree

Potent AO alternatives to Vit E

Similar phenolic structure as Vit Eminus Often more hydroxy groups than Vit E

minus More anti-oxidant capacity per moleminus But typically smaller molecules

minus Much more anti-oxidant capacity per gram

Tabart 2009

Naringenin (272)

Caffeic acid (180)

α-tocopherol (472)

Vit P again

1939 Polyphenols were considered as vitaminsminus Cured some diseases linked to

oxidative stress

2006 lsquoLifespan essentialrsquo(Williamson)

Like all-rac Vit E not all polyphenols equal

Polyphenol bio-availability varies from 0 to gt80minus But fermentation can yield digestible fragments

minus Eg proanthocyanidinsminus Too large to be absorbed in small intestines

bull Digestibility = 0minus Can be fermented

bull Key product is hydroxyphenyl acetic acidbull Mass recovery is only 08

Sauro 2010

Polyphenol selectionminus Ruminant bypass or polyphenols which are fermented into potent

anti-oxidants minus Monogastrics digestible with high ORAC (dORAC)

Bio-availability critical in product formulation

Manach 2005 tocopherol = Michiels 2013

AO-mix adapted to species

Components selected for high bio-availability

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications swine

Both Vit E and AO-mix prevented an increase in lipid peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed piglets

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

Control 11 ppm Vit E 80 PPM 11E+69 AO mix

Mal

on

dia

ldeh

yde

(MD

A) MDA pre-stress MDA post-stress

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

Both Vit E and Selko AOmix prevented an increase in peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed broilers

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

AOmix resulted in a lower SOD (ns) in heat-stressed birds

minus MDA and SOD positively correlated

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications poultry

Heat stressed broilers in Asia

minus AO-mix improved BW FI and cellular immunity while reducing MDA

Rama Rao

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 19: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

Polyphenols a colorful tree

Potent AO alternatives to Vit E

Similar phenolic structure as Vit Eminus Often more hydroxy groups than Vit E

minus More anti-oxidant capacity per moleminus But typically smaller molecules

minus Much more anti-oxidant capacity per gram

Tabart 2009

Naringenin (272)

Caffeic acid (180)

α-tocopherol (472)

Vit P again

1939 Polyphenols were considered as vitaminsminus Cured some diseases linked to

oxidative stress

2006 lsquoLifespan essentialrsquo(Williamson)

Like all-rac Vit E not all polyphenols equal

Polyphenol bio-availability varies from 0 to gt80minus But fermentation can yield digestible fragments

minus Eg proanthocyanidinsminus Too large to be absorbed in small intestines

bull Digestibility = 0minus Can be fermented

bull Key product is hydroxyphenyl acetic acidbull Mass recovery is only 08

Sauro 2010

Polyphenol selectionminus Ruminant bypass or polyphenols which are fermented into potent

anti-oxidants minus Monogastrics digestible with high ORAC (dORAC)

Bio-availability critical in product formulation

Manach 2005 tocopherol = Michiels 2013

AO-mix adapted to species

Components selected for high bio-availability

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications swine

Both Vit E and AO-mix prevented an increase in lipid peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed piglets

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

Control 11 ppm Vit E 80 PPM 11E+69 AO mix

Mal

on

dia

ldeh

yde

(MD

A) MDA pre-stress MDA post-stress

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

Both Vit E and Selko AOmix prevented an increase in peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed broilers

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

AOmix resulted in a lower SOD (ns) in heat-stressed birds

minus MDA and SOD positively correlated

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications poultry

Heat stressed broilers in Asia

minus AO-mix improved BW FI and cellular immunity while reducing MDA

Rama Rao

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 20: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

Potent AO alternatives to Vit E

Similar phenolic structure as Vit Eminus Often more hydroxy groups than Vit E

minus More anti-oxidant capacity per moleminus But typically smaller molecules

minus Much more anti-oxidant capacity per gram

Tabart 2009

Naringenin (272)

Caffeic acid (180)

α-tocopherol (472)

Vit P again

1939 Polyphenols were considered as vitaminsminus Cured some diseases linked to

oxidative stress

2006 lsquoLifespan essentialrsquo(Williamson)

Like all-rac Vit E not all polyphenols equal

Polyphenol bio-availability varies from 0 to gt80minus But fermentation can yield digestible fragments

minus Eg proanthocyanidinsminus Too large to be absorbed in small intestines

bull Digestibility = 0minus Can be fermented

bull Key product is hydroxyphenyl acetic acidbull Mass recovery is only 08

Sauro 2010

Polyphenol selectionminus Ruminant bypass or polyphenols which are fermented into potent

anti-oxidants minus Monogastrics digestible with high ORAC (dORAC)

Bio-availability critical in product formulation

Manach 2005 tocopherol = Michiels 2013

AO-mix adapted to species

Components selected for high bio-availability

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications swine

Both Vit E and AO-mix prevented an increase in lipid peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed piglets

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

Control 11 ppm Vit E 80 PPM 11E+69 AO mix

Mal

on

dia

ldeh

yde

(MD

A) MDA pre-stress MDA post-stress

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

Both Vit E and Selko AOmix prevented an increase in peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed broilers

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

AOmix resulted in a lower SOD (ns) in heat-stressed birds

minus MDA and SOD positively correlated

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications poultry

Heat stressed broilers in Asia

minus AO-mix improved BW FI and cellular immunity while reducing MDA

Rama Rao

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 21: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

Vit P again

1939 Polyphenols were considered as vitaminsminus Cured some diseases linked to

oxidative stress

2006 lsquoLifespan essentialrsquo(Williamson)

Like all-rac Vit E not all polyphenols equal

Polyphenol bio-availability varies from 0 to gt80minus But fermentation can yield digestible fragments

minus Eg proanthocyanidinsminus Too large to be absorbed in small intestines

bull Digestibility = 0minus Can be fermented

bull Key product is hydroxyphenyl acetic acidbull Mass recovery is only 08

Sauro 2010

Polyphenol selectionminus Ruminant bypass or polyphenols which are fermented into potent

anti-oxidants minus Monogastrics digestible with high ORAC (dORAC)

Bio-availability critical in product formulation

Manach 2005 tocopherol = Michiels 2013

AO-mix adapted to species

Components selected for high bio-availability

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications swine

Both Vit E and AO-mix prevented an increase in lipid peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed piglets

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

Control 11 ppm Vit E 80 PPM 11E+69 AO mix

Mal

on

dia

ldeh

yde

(MD

A) MDA pre-stress MDA post-stress

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

Both Vit E and Selko AOmix prevented an increase in peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed broilers

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

AOmix resulted in a lower SOD (ns) in heat-stressed birds

minus MDA and SOD positively correlated

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications poultry

Heat stressed broilers in Asia

minus AO-mix improved BW FI and cellular immunity while reducing MDA

Rama Rao

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 22: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

Like all-rac Vit E not all polyphenols equal

Polyphenol bio-availability varies from 0 to gt80minus But fermentation can yield digestible fragments

minus Eg proanthocyanidinsminus Too large to be absorbed in small intestines

bull Digestibility = 0minus Can be fermented

bull Key product is hydroxyphenyl acetic acidbull Mass recovery is only 08

Sauro 2010

Polyphenol selectionminus Ruminant bypass or polyphenols which are fermented into potent

anti-oxidants minus Monogastrics digestible with high ORAC (dORAC)

Bio-availability critical in product formulation

Manach 2005 tocopherol = Michiels 2013

AO-mix adapted to species

Components selected for high bio-availability

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications swine

Both Vit E and AO-mix prevented an increase in lipid peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed piglets

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

Control 11 ppm Vit E 80 PPM 11E+69 AO mix

Mal

on

dia

ldeh

yde

(MD

A) MDA pre-stress MDA post-stress

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

Both Vit E and Selko AOmix prevented an increase in peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed broilers

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

AOmix resulted in a lower SOD (ns) in heat-stressed birds

minus MDA and SOD positively correlated

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications poultry

Heat stressed broilers in Asia

minus AO-mix improved BW FI and cellular immunity while reducing MDA

Rama Rao

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 23: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

Polyphenol selectionminus Ruminant bypass or polyphenols which are fermented into potent

anti-oxidants minus Monogastrics digestible with high ORAC (dORAC)

Bio-availability critical in product formulation

Manach 2005 tocopherol = Michiels 2013

AO-mix adapted to species

Components selected for high bio-availability

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications swine

Both Vit E and AO-mix prevented an increase in lipid peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed piglets

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

Control 11 ppm Vit E 80 PPM 11E+69 AO mix

Mal

on

dia

ldeh

yde

(MD

A) MDA pre-stress MDA post-stress

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

Both Vit E and Selko AOmix prevented an increase in peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed broilers

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

AOmix resulted in a lower SOD (ns) in heat-stressed birds

minus MDA and SOD positively correlated

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications poultry

Heat stressed broilers in Asia

minus AO-mix improved BW FI and cellular immunity while reducing MDA

Rama Rao

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 24: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

AO-mix adapted to species

Components selected for high bio-availability

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications swine

Both Vit E and AO-mix prevented an increase in lipid peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed piglets

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

Control 11 ppm Vit E 80 PPM 11E+69 AO mix

Mal

on

dia

ldeh

yde

(MD

A) MDA pre-stress MDA post-stress

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

Both Vit E and Selko AOmix prevented an increase in peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed broilers

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

AOmix resulted in a lower SOD (ns) in heat-stressed birds

minus MDA and SOD positively correlated

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications poultry

Heat stressed broilers in Asia

minus AO-mix improved BW FI and cellular immunity while reducing MDA

Rama Rao

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 25: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications swine

Both Vit E and AO-mix prevented an increase in lipid peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed piglets

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

Control 11 ppm Vit E 80 PPM 11E+69 AO mix

Mal

on

dia

ldeh

yde

(MD

A) MDA pre-stress MDA post-stress

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

Both Vit E and Selko AOmix prevented an increase in peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed broilers

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

AOmix resulted in a lower SOD (ns) in heat-stressed birds

minus MDA and SOD positively correlated

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications poultry

Heat stressed broilers in Asia

minus AO-mix improved BW FI and cellular immunity while reducing MDA

Rama Rao

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 26: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

Both Vit E and Selko AOmix prevented an increase in peroxidation (measured as MDA) in heat-stressed broilers

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

AOmix resulted in a lower SOD (ns) in heat-stressed birds

minus MDA and SOD positively correlated

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications poultry

Heat stressed broilers in Asia

minus AO-mix improved BW FI and cellular immunity while reducing MDA

Rama Rao

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 27: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

AOmix prevents heat stress complications poultry

AOmix resulted in a lower SOD (ns) in heat-stressed birds

minus MDA and SOD positively correlated

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications poultry

Heat stressed broilers in Asia

minus AO-mix improved BW FI and cellular immunity while reducing MDA

Rama Rao

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 28: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

AO-mix prevents heat-stress complications poultry

Heat stressed broilers in Asia

minus AO-mix improved BW FI and cellular immunity while reducing MDA

Rama Rao

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 29: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

Field experience in South Africa confirms benefits

5 barns treated 5 barns control

minus Interim results

minus Heavier carcasses amp breasts

minus Less breasts with oxidation problems (day 28 data only)

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 30: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

AO-mix amp Vit E polyvalent defense

Rosmarinic and others

Curcumin vit E

CuZn-SOD

Membranes

Polyphenols

Catalase

Mn-SODCarnosic acid vit E

GSH-Px (Se)GSH-Px (Se)

Rosmarinic and others

PH-GSH-Px

1 Enzymes2 Antioxidants

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality

Page 31: Alternatives for vitamin E - Home | AFMA Forum 2020 · − Vit. E potent antioxidants but with limits − AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit. E 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20

AO-mix boosts antioxidant defenses

Conclusions

minus Oxidative stress a challenge in health and even more so in disease or high metabolic activity

minus Vit E potent antioxidants but with limits

minus AO-mix can boost AO defenses beyond Vit E

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 50 100

dO

RA

C

Vit

E

IU

kg

Weight kg

Vit E requirement

AO mod Growthhealth

AO low healthhigh growth

Meat quality