1
209 MEAN SERU,A-IIAMUNGGLOBULINS (mg/dl) IN 19 PATIENTS WITH RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS BEFORE AND AFTER LEVAMISOLE TREATMENT stimulation of skin delayed-hypersensitivity tests was associated with depression of serum-immunoglobulins. This observation is consistent with the findings of Huskisson et al.3 A late de- crease in antibody titres was observed by Renoux et al. in elderly levamisole-treated patients immunised with influenza vaccine. Levamisole should therefore be considered rather as an immunomodulating agent than as a general immunostimu- lant. Yaron et al. gave an indication that levamisole can have an anti-inflammatory action independent of its effect on the immune system. We are tempted to suggest that further com- parisons between the clinical effects of levamisole and im- munoreactivity and intensity of inflammatory process in R.A. would make it possible to select patients who could benefit from this drug. H. SZPILMAN S. LUFT D. GLIŃSKA-URBAN W. FISCHER M. PLACHECKA Institute of Rheumatology, Spartańska 1, 02-637 Warsaw, Poland ALPHA-FETOPROTEIN ASSAY IN ALL AMNIOCENTESIS SAMPLES SIR,-We envy Broch and Scrimgeour’s false-positive rate of zero,8 and suspect we understand the reason. They regard an amniotic-fluid sample containing fetal blood as unusable, while our results9 simply reflect a total experience without prior sample selection. We do not feel that a sample contami- nated with fetal blood should be discarded since some 47% of fluids derived from pregnancies where the fetus had anen- cephaly contained fetal hoemoglobin.10 Since fetal blood seems to be present so often in these particular cases, repeat amnio- centeses may be of no avail. We have lately been able to modify our assay, which is now more sensitive. Over 800 samples have been re-assayed, includ- ing the 15 (0-4) reported as "definite" false positives out of the 3536 cases studied.2 With the modified assay, only 5 of these now remain with A.F.P. values >3 S.D. above the mean. This suggests a very similar false-positive rate z 1%) to that reported in the European Medical Research Council report." Since we have not re-assayed all 3536 cases, our exact rate cannot now be stated, but it is clearly in the range where routine A.F.P. assays of all amniotic fluids would be justified. Even by declaring samples with fetal haemoglobin unusable, we predict that a zero false-positive rate will not be main- tained. We offer ultrasound and amniographic studies as addi- tional approaches when faced with borderline elevations of A.F.P., and do not rely solely on the A.F.P. value. Eunice Kennedy Shriver Center, W altham, and Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts, U S A AUBREY MILUNSKY MARGARET E. KIMBALL 6 Renoux, G . Renoux, M., Morand, P., Dartigues, P. Rev. med. Tours, 1973, 7, 797. 7 Yaron, M. Yaron, I., Herzberg, M Lancer, Feb. 14, 1976, p. 369 8 Brock, D J H., Scrimgeour, J. B Lancet, 1976, i, 1404. 9 Milunsky, A . Alpert, E. ibid. 1976, i, 1015. 10 Milunsky, A.. Alpert, E Obstet Gynec. in the press . 11 Lindsten, J, Zetterstrom, R., Ferguson-Smith, M. in Prenatal Diagnosis of Genetic Disorders of the Fœtus. I N.S.E R.M., Paris, 1976. THE HEPARIN-THROMBIN CLOTTING-TIME SIR,-The heparin-thrombin clotting-time (H.T.C.T.) is referred to in your exemplary editorial’ about antithrombin and the diagnosis of prethrombotic states. In case there’could be any confusion, I write to emphasise that this H.T.c.T. test is not influenced by antithrombin levels. Since we use the pa- tient’s plasma as substrate, theoretically such an influence is possible; however, we accept an H.T.c.T. result only if a dilute- thrombin clotting-time is strictly normal. You refer to this test as possibly useful in distinguishing between a diagnosis of acute myocardial infarction and "non- specific chest pain". We continue to find the H.T.c.T. valuable in this situation, but the most striking abnormality in true in- farction may not develop for two to four days. (The original studies were "between the first and the seventh day".) I think the H.T.c.T. may have greater value in detecting a prethrombotic state; the test has twice shown significantly shorter clotting-times in groups of patients studied long after various kinds of thrombosis who presumably are at greater risk than normal of further trouble_2 3 You do not mention that we think this test measures platelet factor 4 released from platelets and so reflects the degree of platelet activation. Portsmouth and South East Hampshire District Pathology Service, St. Mary’s Hospital, Portmouth PO3 6AG J. R. O’BRIEN LEVAMISOLE AS ADJUNCT TO DAPSONE IN LEPROSY SIR,-Levamisole has a stimulatory effect on some aspects of the cellular immunity mechanism of the host. The mechan- ism of action is unclear. It has been suggested that levamisole has a immunostimulatory effect in leprosy patients with depressed cell-mediated immunity.5 6 We have tried to find out if levamisole would affect the course of the disease in patients with lepromatous and dimorphic leprosy treated with dapsone. Patients with nodular lepromatous or nodular dimorphic leprosy took part in the study. These patients were receiving- dapsone, by mouth or by injection. Patients were evaluated monthly for clinical lesions and reactions. Clinical lesions were graded zero or 1-4, 4 being a nodular lesion and zero being a totally flat lesion (macule). The same observer graded these lesions every time but the treatment was unknown to the observer. Smears were read and graded by the same laboratory personnel who did not know the patient’s name or treatment. Sixteen patients were treated with dapsone 25mg by mouth every day and four received 450mg acedapsone intramuscu- larly once every two months. These patients were advised to take an additional pill, which was either levamisole (150 mg) or placebo, one pill every two weeks. At the end of six months of therapy, 12 patients finished the trial from the 20 who had started. All 12 had been clinical grade 4 at the start. The 6 who had been on levamisole in addition to their dapsone (or acedapsone) had lesions of 1+ or zero at the end of the trial. Of the 6 patients taking placebo 4 ended as -3 and 2 as 0. This is what one would expect to see with dapsone alone. 1 Lancet, 1976, i. 1333 2. O’Brien, J. R, Etherington, M. D., Jamieson, S, Klaber, M. R . Lincoln, S. V Thromb Diath. Hœmorrh 1974, 31, 279 3 O’Brien, J R., Etherington, M. D., Jamieson, S., Lawford, P., Lincoln, S V. Alkjaersig, N J ibid 1975, 34, 483. 4 Symoens, J. in Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Modula- tion of Host Resistance in the Prevention or Treatment of Induced Neo- plasias Bethesda, 1975 edited by M A Chirigos U S Government Printing Office in the press 5 Cardama, J E., Gatti, J. C., Balina, I. H . Cabrera, H N, Fliess, L L Int. J Leprosy, 1973, 41, 567. 6 Saint-Andre, P., Louvet, M. Med Arm. 1976, 4, 223.

ALPHA-FETOPROTEIN ASSAY IN ALL AMNIOCENTESIS SAMPLES

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: ALPHA-FETOPROTEIN ASSAY IN ALL AMNIOCENTESIS SAMPLES

209

MEAN SERU,A-IIAMUNGGLOBULINS (mg/dl) IN 19 PATIENTS WITHRHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS BEFORE AND AFTER LEVAMISOLE TREATMENT

stimulation of skin delayed-hypersensitivity tests was associatedwith depression of serum-immunoglobulins. This observationis consistent with the findings of Huskisson et al.3 A late de-crease in antibody titres was observed by Renoux et al. inelderly levamisole-treated patients immunised with influenzavaccine. Levamisole should therefore be considered rather asan immunomodulating agent than as a general immunostimu-lant. Yaron et al. gave an indication that levamisole can havean anti-inflammatory action independent of its effect on theimmune system. We are tempted to suggest that further com-parisons between the clinical effects of levamisole and im-

munoreactivity and intensity of inflammatory process in R.A.would make it possible to select patients who could benefitfrom this drug. H. SZPILMAN

S. LUFTD. GLIŃSKA-URBANW. FISCHERM. PLACHECKA

Institute of Rheumatology,Spartańska 1,02-637 Warsaw, Poland

ALPHA-FETOPROTEIN ASSAY IN ALLAMNIOCENTESIS SAMPLES

SIR,-We envy Broch and Scrimgeour’s false-positive rateof zero,8 and suspect we understand the reason. They regardan amniotic-fluid sample containing fetal blood as unusable,while our results9 simply reflect a total experience withoutprior sample selection. We do not feel that a sample contami-nated with fetal blood should be discarded since some 47% offluids derived from pregnancies where the fetus had anen-cephaly contained fetal hoemoglobin.10 Since fetal blood seemsto be present so often in these particular cases, repeat amnio-centeses may be of no avail.We have lately been able to modify our assay, which is now

more sensitive. Over 800 samples have been re-assayed, includ-ing the 15 (0-4) reported as "definite" false positives out ofthe 3536 cases studied.2 With the modified assay, only 5 ofthese now remain with A.F.P. values >3 S.D. above the mean.This suggests a very similar false-positive rate z 1%) to thatreported in the European Medical Research Council report."Since we have not re-assayed all 3536 cases, our exact ratecannot now be stated, but it is clearly in the range whereroutine A.F.P. assays of all amniotic fluids would be justified.Even by declaring samples with fetal haemoglobin unusable,

we predict that a zero false-positive rate will not be main-tained. We offer ultrasound and amniographic studies as addi-tional approaches when faced with borderline elevations ofA.F.P., and do not rely solely on the A.F.P. value.Eunice Kennedy Shriver Center,W altham, and MassachusettsGeneral Hospital,Boston, Massachusetts, U S A

AUBREY MILUNSKYMARGARET E. KIMBALL

6 Renoux, G . Renoux, M., Morand, P., Dartigues, P. Rev. med. Tours, 1973,7, 797.

7 Yaron, M. Yaron, I., Herzberg, M Lancer, Feb. 14, 1976, p. 3698 Brock, D J H., Scrimgeour, J. B Lancet, 1976, i, 1404.9 Milunsky, A . Alpert, E. ibid. 1976, i, 1015.10 Milunsky, A.. Alpert, E Obstet Gynec. in the press .11 Lindsten, J, Zetterstrom, R., Ferguson-Smith, M. in Prenatal Diagnosis of

Genetic Disorders of the Fœtus. I N.S.E R.M., Paris, 1976.

THE HEPARIN-THROMBIN CLOTTING-TIME

SIR,-The heparin-thrombin clotting-time (H.T.C.T.) isreferred to in your exemplary editorial’ about antithrombinand the diagnosis of prethrombotic states. In case there’couldbe any confusion, I write to emphasise that this H.T.c.T. testis not influenced by antithrombin levels. Since we use the pa-tient’s plasma as substrate, theoretically such an influence ispossible; however, we accept an H.T.c.T. result only if a dilute-thrombin clotting-time is strictly normal.You refer to this test as possibly useful in distinguishing

between a diagnosis of acute myocardial infarction and "non-specific chest pain". We continue to find the H.T.c.T. valuablein this situation, but the most striking abnormality in true in-farction may not develop for two to four days. (The originalstudies were "between the first and the seventh day".)

I think the H.T.c.T. may have greater value in detecting aprethrombotic state; the test has twice shown significantlyshorter clotting-times in groups of patients studied long aftervarious kinds of thrombosis who presumably are at greater riskthan normal of further trouble_2 3

You do not mention that we think this test measures plateletfactor 4 released from platelets and so reflects the degree ofplatelet activation.

Portsmouth and South East HampshireDistrict Pathology Service,St. Mary’s Hospital, Portmouth PO3 6AG J. R. O’BRIEN

LEVAMISOLE AS ADJUNCT TO DAPSONE INLEPROSY

SIR,-Levamisole has a stimulatory effect on some aspectsof the cellular immunity mechanism of the host. The mechan-ism of action is unclear. It has been suggested that levamisolehas a immunostimulatory effect in leprosy patients with

depressed cell-mediated immunity.5 6 We have tried to find outif levamisole would affect the course of the disease in patientswith lepromatous and dimorphic leprosy treated with dapsone.

Patients with nodular lepromatous or nodular dimorphicleprosy took part in the study. These patients were receiving-dapsone, by mouth or by injection. Patients were evaluatedmonthly for clinical lesions and reactions. Clinical lesions weregraded zero or 1-4, 4 being a nodular lesion and zero beinga totally flat lesion (macule). The same observer graded theselesions every time but the treatment was unknown to theobserver. Smears were read and graded by the same laboratorypersonnel who did not know the patient’s name or treatment.Sixteen patients were treated with dapsone 25mg by mouthevery day and four received 450mg acedapsone intramuscu-larly once every two months. These patients were advised totake an additional pill, which was either levamisole (150 mg)or placebo, one pill every two weeks.

At the end of six months of therapy, 12 patients finished thetrial from the 20 who had started. All 12 had been clinical

grade 4 at the start. The 6 who had been on levamisole inaddition to their dapsone (or acedapsone) had lesions of 1+ orzero at the end of the trial. Of the 6 patients taking placebo4 ended as -3 and 2 as 0. This is what one would expect tosee with dapsone alone.

1 Lancet, 1976, i. 13332. O’Brien, J. R, Etherington, M. D., Jamieson, S, Klaber, M. R . Lincoln,

S. V Thromb Diath. Hœmorrh 1974, 31, 2793 O’Brien, J R., Etherington, M. D., Jamieson, S., Lawford, P., Lincoln,

S V. Alkjaersig, N J ibid 1975, 34, 483.4 Symoens, J. in Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Modula-

tion of Host Resistance in the Prevention or Treatment of Induced Neo-

plasias Bethesda, 1975 edited by M A Chirigos U S Government

Printing Office in the press5 Cardama, J E., Gatti, J. C., Balina, I. H . Cabrera, H N, Fliess, L L Int.

J Leprosy, 1973, 41, 567.6 Saint-Andre, P., Louvet, M. Med Arm. 1976, 4, 223.