‘Allowing beef exports not plan panel’s view’ - Abhishek Kadyan

8/2/2019 Allowing beef exports not plan panels view - Abhishek Kadyan

1/13

To: Home Minister of India, Prime Minister of India (Hon'ble Sardar Manmohan Sngh),Shri Rahul Gandhi, MP, Vice President of India (Hon'ble Shri Hamid Ansari), LawMinister of India, Representative of OIPA in India (Naresh Kadyan), Minister ofEnvironment and Forest (Smt. Jayanthi Natrajan), Chairperson, NAC (Smt. SoniaGandhi), President of India, New Delhi (HE Smt. Pratibha Devisingh Patil),Secretary (Shri Prabeer Kumar Basu), Dr. Charan Das Mahant, PlanningCommission of India (Adviser), Shri Rajiv Pratap Rudy, MP, Shri Ram Lal (G.S.Org), Shri Vijay Goel, Ex-MP, Shri Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi, MP, Shri Vinay Katiyar,MP, Shri Kalraj Mishra, MP, Shri Nitin Gadkari, Dr. Praveen Bhai Togadia, DirectorGeneral (Animal Husbndry), Directorate of Animal Husbandry, Haryana. (Dr. K. S.Dangi), Vice-Chancellor, Guru Angad Dev Veterinary & Animal Science University,GADVASU, Ludhiana. (Dr. V. K. Taneja), Director, National Dairy ResearchInstitute, , Karnal (Dr. A. K. Shrivastava), and Deputy Chairman, PlanningCommission (Montek Singh Ahluwalia)

Subject: Don't allow beef export from India - Sukanya Kadyan

Letter: Greetings,

The UN affiliated International Organisation for Animal Protection - OIPA chapter inIndia along with the People for Animals (PFA) Haryana have objected to theworking group report on animal husbandry and dairying for the 12th five-year plan,which includes recommendations to lift the ban on beef exports from India. BothNGO's has demanded that the government withdraw its report to the Planning

Commission and apologize to the nation before "religious and nationalist people"came out on the streets in protest."Export of beef will not only butcher our mother and its family but it will amount to amurder of the Constitution and dharma of the country," Media Adviser of OIPA'sAbhishek Kadyan said.The animal husbandry and dairying department under the agriculture ministry senta report to the Planning Commission recommending lifting the ban on beefexports. "There is an existing ban on beef exports; therefore it is necessary torevise the EXIM policy to allow beef exports," OIPA's Event Director in India MissSukanya Kadyan quoted from the report. This report was more inclined toslaughtering of animals rather then protecting them, she added.

Quoting directive principals under Article 48 of the Constitution, founder Chairman,People for Animals Haryana Naresh Kadyan, Representative of OIPA in India said,"These directives clearly prohibit the slaughter of cows and calves and other milchand draught cattle. We cannot tolerate slaughter of cows or its family at any cost.Our agriculture ministry is supposed to protect and promote cows instead ofslaughtering it."Matter has been taken up with the HE the President of India's office vide No.PRSEC/E/2012/02261and with the Planning Commission of India No.DPLNG/E/2012/00040.The Times of India reporting:NAGPUR: The United Nations (UN) affiliated International Organisation for Animal


2/13

Protection (OIPA) in India along with People for Animals (PFA) and NGOs workingfor animal welfare have slammed the working group report on animal husbandryand dairying for the 12th Five Year Plan, which includes recommendations to lift aban on beef exports from India.The working group on animal husbandry and dairying (2012-17) recently submitteda report to the Planning Commission on present performance of livestock sectorand its contributing factors including development programmes and policiespursued in the recent past. It suggested a road map for achieving the targeted rate

of growth during the 12th plan while ensuring its sustainability and inclusiveness.Sukanya Kadyan, OIPA's event director in India, flayed the recommendation in thereport which says, "There is an existing ban on beef exports. Therefore, it isnecessary to revise the EXIM policy to allow beef exports."The OIPA and even local NGOs like Sukrut Nirman Charitable Trust and People forAnimals (PFA), Nagpur, have demanded the report be withdrawn and governmentshould apologize to the nation before 'religious and nationalist people' pour out intothe streets in protest."Export of beef will not only butcher cows but will also amount to murder of theConstitution and dharma, on which country's foundation has been based," saidNaresh Kadyan, India's OIPA representative. The report was more inclined to

slaughtering animals rather than protecting them. The matter has been taken upwith the President and plan panel, he added.Quoting directive principles under Article 48 of the Constitution, Kadyan said theseclearly prohibit slaughter of cows and calves and other milch and draught cattle."We cannot tolerate slaughter of cows or its family at any cost," he remarked.Kannubhai Savadia, chairman of Sukrut, said his NGO has been sendingrepresentations to the Planning Commission for the past four years against meatexports, but strong lobby of traders backed by politicians appears to have prevailedupon the government.Meat exports were basically to boost foreign exchange but now that the countryhas sufficient forex reserves, why promote such exports, Savadia asked.

"Allowing beef export would lead to massive slaughter of cows, which is alreadybeing carried out clandestinely. Our agriculture ministry is supposed to protect andpromote cows instead of slaughtering them," Savadia added."The government should stop playing with the religious sentiments of the people.The recommendation exposes double standards. On one hand, cows are reveredand students are taught about its importance and protection, while on the otherpromotion of beef exports is spoken about," said Karishma Galani, city chief ofPFA.Allowing beef exports would lead to farm and food crisis. As per the cattle censusconducted in 2007, cattle population has already dwindled. "So why is a needbeing felt to promote beef exports?" Galani asked.

VHP letter:Sub.: Request for outright rejection of the recommendations of the Working Groupon Animal Husbandry & Dairying given to the Planning Commission for the 12thFive Year Plan (2012-17) to revise the EXIM policy to allow beef export!(1) The GOI Working Group on Animal Husbandry & Dairying 12thFive Year Plan (2012-17) has submitted a report to the Planning Commission,Government of India. The Report at Page 73, Paragraph 12.3.1 under the headingStrategies and programs for 12th Plan under Chapter 12 Meat and Abattoirs,audaciously asks for pan-Bharatiya permission for cow massacre in these words:There is an existing ban on beef exports; therefore it is necessary to revise the


3/13

EXIM policy to allow beef export

(2) Being a son of Maa Bhaarati Your Excellency would be wellappreciative of the central status of cow and the bull-power as the driving forces ofour ethos of sustainable agriculture since pristine times, stable economy, nationalhealth and mass employment in terms of White Revolution, Green Revolution,pastoral transportation, irrigation, biogas, manure and bio-fertilizers in theagricultural country Bharat. Cow is Complete Ecology and Altruist. It is, therefore,

not for nothing that the Rishi-KrishiTradition acknowledges, celebrates and protectsCow as: Gaavo Vishwasya Maatarah!(Cow is Mother of the World!). A cowsperson is revered as hosting millions of deities. A question in the Yaksha Gita ofthe Mahabharata asks: Kim Amritam? (What is Ambrosia/Panacea/Nectar?).Yudhisthir replies: Gavaamritam!- Cows milk is Ambrosia/Panacea! On planetearth, milk of the earthly cousins of the Kaamdhenus is virtual Amrit. TheBharatiya indigenous non-hybrid varieties feeding on their natural fodder, grassand herbs top the list in the world in purity and potency. According to GolokKhand, one was designated Upnand who owned 500,000 cows, Nand was onewho maintained 900,000 cows, Vrishbhaanu was one who maintained 1,000,000cows, Vrishbhaanuvar was one who maintained 5,000,000 cows, Nand Raja was

one who maintained 1 crore (10 million) cows. During the times of BhagwanMahavir over 2,500 years ago, Jain Shraavaks (mendicants/monks) maintained 53Gokuls in the periphery of Shravasti city. A Gokul was defined as a place thathoused 10,000 cows. Anand a millionaire received vows of Shraavakhood fromLord Mahavir, and one of the Shraavakhood oaths was to maintain 8 Gokuls. Thecause of Gow, Garib and Dharma (Gow=Cow & its progeny, Garib=Meek &Underprivileged, and Dharma=Righteousness) has also been the triple agenda ofthe entire Sikh history principally the Khalsa history under the ministry of GuruGobind Singhji Maharaj. The Marathas under Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj and hissuccessors had also this triple agenda. In Parsi tradition, a milky white bull iscelebrated as Varsiyaji. Parsis greatly revere a Varsiyaji and make a daily offering

of fruits to it. Varsiyaji is spotlessly milky white from tip to toe (including evenhorns, brows, nails, etc.). One can have its glimpse at a Parsi temple [e.g., Udwara(Surat), Lalbagh and Kama Bagh (Mumbai)]. Cow is considered to be the crowningglory of the animal kingdom and in the evolutionary scale precedes mankind only.Thousands of names of places, persons and things and other words in our countryBharat, e,g., Gopuri, Gauhati, Gorakhpur, Goa, Godhra, Gondiya, Gopuram,Gopal, Govind, Godavari, Govardhan, Gautam, Gaumul, Gomukh, Gokarna,Godhaam, Golok, Gokhroo, Godha, Goyal, Gochar, Gorochan, Goraj, Godhuli,Godaan, Gograas, etc., having been prefixed by the term Go/Gow, signify thedeep reverence and high ground reserved for the cow & progeny in our culture.Your learned-self is also aware of the post-independence history of movements to

stop slaughter of cow & its progeny by means of signature campaigns, massmovements and hunger strikes undertaken by the leading lights of society. Underthe circumstances the said recommendations made by the Working Group onAnimal Husbandry & Dairying Department of Government of Indiais shameless,mindless, audacious and sad. Only one who is not a son of a man can say thatcow is doing a thankless job and therefore deserves to be wolved up. In fact, theGovernments plans and programmes to fight poverty in the country ought also toinclude booster projects for cow rearing by every rural family and reclamation ofGochar Bhoomi (meadow/grazing land) and its maintenance by the Panchayats.Holistic management and use of Jal (water), Jungle (plant kingdom), Zameen(land) and Jaanwar (animal kingdom) would make the Janata (mankind) happy,


4/13

healthy and blessed.(3) Speaking about animal laws, the Constitution of India clearlyunderlines the importance of cow and its protection. Its PART-IV DIRECTIVEPRINCIPLES OF STATE POLICY ARTICLE 48: ORGANIZATION OFAGRICULTURE AND ANIMAL HUSBANDRY reads: The State shall endeavourto organize agriculture and animal husbandry on modern and scientific lines andshall, in particular, take steps for preserving and improving the breeds, andprohibiting the slaughter, of cows and calves and other milch and draught cattle.

(4) And again, ARTICLE 48A PROTECTION AND IMPROVEMENTOF ENVIRONMENT AND SAFEGUARDING OF FORESTS AND WILD LIFE reads: The State shall endeavour to protect and improve the environment and tosafeguard the forests and wildlife of the country.

(5) PART IVA FUNDAMENTAL DUTIES Article 51A of theConstitution says. It shall be the duty of every citizen of India ..(g) toprotect and improve the natural environment including forests, lakes, rivers, andwildlife, and to have compassion for living creatures

(6) Also the Honble Supreme Court on 26.10.2005 in Civil Appeals

No. 4937-4940 of 1998 State of Gujrat & other Vs Mirzapur Moti Kureshi KassabJamat & others has said in Paragraph 67(8) of its order: Finally, the Central Govt.is directed to review the meat export policy, in the light of the Directive Principles ofState Policy under the Constitution of India, and also in the light of the policyspotentially harmful effects on livestock population, and therefore on the economy ofthe country.(7) The Indic Tradition gives cow the status of Mother. MahatmaGandhiji looked up to cow as a picture of piety and the representative of the mutecreation. The Namdhari community sacrificed its lives to uphold the reverence andlife of Mother Cow. Cow protection is advocated in all major schools of theHimalayan tradition. The Omkar Parivarschools, viz., Hinduism, Jainism, Sikhism,

and some Buddhists, etc., consider beef a taboo food and hence eschew itsconsumption. Even some Mughal rulers made cow slaughter a punishable offence.Many Sant-Mahatmas and Gobhaktas(Cow Devotees) have sacrificed their livesfor the cause of cow protection. Under the circumstances, the beef exportsuggestion made by the GOI Department of Animal Husbandry & Dairying is ahostility perpetrated against the Dharmic, spiritual, holistic, altruistic and syncreticworldview of the country.(8) It is, therefore, requested that in view of the provisions of theConstitution of India, pronouncements by the Honble Courts of Law, the obviousnegative impacts on national economy and the deference for popular faith andreverence for cow, Your Excellency ought to shot down forthwith the shameless

proposals made by the Animal Husbandry & Dairying Department of GOI that seekto (i) remove the existing Ban on beef exports and (ii) revise the Export-ImportPolicy (Foreign Trade Policy) to allow beef export!

(9) Action on our above requests and acknowledgment of thiscommunication would be highly appreciated!

Save Cows! Vande Gow Maataram!

Yours in the service ofMaa Bhaarati and Dharma,


5/13

Sd/- (ASHOK SINGHALl, Patron, VHP (IntL)

The Tribune report:The recommendations made by the working group report on animal husbandryand dairying for the 12th Five-Year Plan, which includes recommendations to liftthe ban on beef exports from India, has not gone down well with the UN-affiliatedInternational Organisation for Animal Protection (OIPA) chapter in India along withthe People for Animals (PFA) Haryana, who have raised objections against the

recommendations.

Both NGOs have demanded that the government should withdraw the report andapologise to the nation for hurting the religious sentiments.

Abhishek Kadyan, a representative of the OIPA, said export of beef could result inwidespread butchering of cows, which are considered sacred by the Hindus acrossthe nation. He said the Animal Husbandry and Dairying Department under theAgriculture Ministry had recently sent a report to the Planning Commission inwhich lifting the ban on beef exports had been recommended.

OPIA Director Sukanya Kadyan said the suggestion made in the report was moreinclined to slaughtering of the animals rather than protecting them.

Naresh Kadyan, founder chairman of PFA Haryana and Indian representative ofthe OPIA, said the directive principals under Article 48 of the Constitution of Indiaprohibit the slaughter of cows and calves and other milch and draught cattle. Hesaid the Union Agriculture Ministry was supposed to protect and promote cowsinstead of slaughtering them.

He said the NGOs had already taken up the matter with the President of Indiaalong with the Director-General (Animal Husbandry), Directorate of Animal

Husbandry, Haryana, and the Director, NDRI, Karnal.


6/13

SignaturesName Location Date

Director Events OIPA India Delhi, India 2012-02-13

Paola Ghidotti Vigevano, Italy 2012-02-13

Naresh Kadyan Rep. OIPA in India Delhi, India 2012-02-13Karen Eisenlord Studio City, United States Minor Outlying

Islands2012-02-13

Naresh Kadyan, Representative ofOIPA in India

Delhi, IN 2012-02-13

Filomena Viana melksham, NY 2012-02-13

JOHN RICHARD YOUNG-HIGGINS

East Norriton Township / Norristown, PA 2012-02-13

LENE HANSEN 2400, DE 2012-02-13

lisa salazar Foster City, CA 2012-02-13

Joel Finley Ogdensburg, NY 2012-02-13

Alison Arnold Dagenham, United Kingdom 2012-02-13

nicolette ludolphi bremen, DE 2012-02-13

Nancy Roussy Ste-Florence, Canada 2012-02-13

Ewa Piasecka Warsaw, Poland 2012-02-13andrea dunbar workington cumbria, United Kingdom 2012-02-13

Danuta Watola Kalety, Poland 2012-02-13

Mervi Rantala Tampere, Finland 2012-02-13

De Zustergroepen Tisselt, NE 2012-02-13

Jordan Kasteler Sandy, UT 2012-02-13

Beth Animal Protector galt, CA 2012-02-13

Beatriz Fernandes So Paulo, Brazil 2012-02-13

Jackie Tryggeseth Sauk City, WI 2012-02-13

R B Escondido, CA 2012-02-13

Tatjana Plieschke Beckum, DE 2012-02-13

Sheryl Winkler Fredericksburg, VA 2012-02-13

Chantal Buslot Hasselt, Belgium 2012-02-13


7/13

Name Location Date

Bobbie Murray Raleigh, NC 2012-02-14

Peggy Acosta Womelsdorf, PA 2012-02-14

loreli dejac blasdell, NY 2012-02-14

ANTONINI Claudine bagnolet, NY 2012-02-14

Sky Tilley New Haven, KY 2012-02-14

Deneen Tokich Schererville, IN 2012-02-14

Charlotte Vardan Los Angeles, CA 2012-02-14

Ellen G Sussex, WI 2012-02-14

dolores paddock cheshire, CT 2012-02-14

Jon Spinac New York, NY 2012-02-14

Craig Geiger Olympia, WA 2012-02-14

Abhishek Kadyan Delhi, India 2012-02-14

Sukanya Kadyan Delhi, India 2012-02-14

Sharda Kadyan Delhi, India 2012-02-14

Saba Alemayehue Bellingham, WA 2012-02-14

Magdalena Mazurek Marco Island, FL 2012-02-14

Sami Signorino Kokomo, IN 2012-02-14

Jacqui Trevillian Melton West, Australia 2012-02-14

JiYoung _ Chung Bundang, Korea, Republic of 2012-02-14

Maria Karlsson Gteborg, Sweden 2012-02-14

Irene Broeit Herford, OR 2012-02-14

Maria Schneider Munich, Germany 2012-02-14

Ana Mesner Ljubljana, Slovenia 2012-02-14

Isabella Nicolaides Coatesville, PA 2012-02-14

isabel esteve Castelloli, Spain 2012-02-14

carolyn hayton evandale, Australia 2012-02-14

Hana Copinga Invercargill, New Zealand 2012-02-14

Darlene Davis Detroit, MI 2012-02-14

Irmgard Gutersohn Asperg, Germany 2012-02-14


8/13

Name Location Date

Theodore Spachidakis piraeus, Greece 2012-02-14

marcus ferguson london, United Kingdom 2012-02-14

Andrea Nemec Osijek, Croatia 2012-02-14

Axel Ritt Darmstadt, Germany 2012-02-14

Joanna Attard bahar ic-caghaq, Malta 2012-02-14

elisabetta rossi savona, Italy 2012-02-14

Amy Bernett Centerville, OH 2012-02-14

Sandra Seia Aveiro, Portugal 2012-02-14

Nadezhda Peneva Karlsruhe, Germany 2012-02-14

Irma Fleischeuer Sittard, Netherlands 2012-02-14

Susan Esposito Staten Island, NY 2012-02-14

Monique Angela Buijs De Weere, Netherlands 2012-02-14

dennis van elslans Amsterdam, Netherlands 2012-02-14

Dario Frankie Sunny Catania, Italy 2012-02-14

Julie Goldman Chesterfield, MO 2012-02-14

Manuela arioli Milano, Italy 2012-02-14

Ginger Geronimo Birmingham, AL 2012-02-14

Kanika Pruthi Hisar, India 2012-02-14

C D Bangor, ME 2012-02-14

T C Kitamoto-shi, Japan 2012-02-14

Jasmina Cuk Solna, Sweden 2012-02-14

Elisabeth Bechmann St. Plten, Austria 2012-02-14

Dorota Wi_niewska Wroc_aw, Poland 2012-02-14

Lena Rehberger Grebenhain, Germany 2012-02-14

caspa ceacas norwich, United Kingdom 2012-02-14

vanessa allen Beaverton, OR 2012-02-14

Michele Bowes Statesville, NC 2012-02-14

Nicole Weber Pasadena, MD 2012-02-14

Lesley Ann McArthur Lincoln, United Kingdom 2012-02-14


9/13

Name Location Date

christine curien saint jean la vetre, France 2012-02-14

Devindra Maharaj California, Trinidad and Tobago 2012-02-14

Valerie Hildebrand Winnipeg, MB., Canada 2012-02-14

Bea Calzada San Luis Potosi, Mexico 2012-02-14

tina horowitz philadelphia, PA 2012-02-14

Pearl Carter Denver, CO 2012-02-14

june bullied toronto, CA 2012-02-14

Gaby Seabra Anadia, Portugal 2012-02-14

Maria Lozano Valencia, Spain 2012-02-14

Melissa Geno Brentwood, TN 2012-02-14

Fight Right Ulm, DE 2012-02-14

Carin Zellerman Stockholm, Sweden 2012-02-14

Annika Pettersson Boden, NY 2012-02-14

Katharina Hdl Hainburg, Austria 2012-02-14

Lilo Prinz Au/ZH, AL 2012-02-14

Mike Rigoli Chicago, IL 2012-02-15

James Walker janesville, WI 2012-02-15

JOANN BROWN COLUMBUS, OH 2012-02-15

Carmen Ortiz New York, NY 2012-02-15

Constance Franklin Los Angeles, CA 2012-02-15

PFA Haryana Palwal, India 2012-02-15

preetiranjan raut baroda, India 2012-02-15

Kenny Vaher NYC, NY 2012-02-15

Mary Bemis St George, UT 2012-02-15

Alison Nieuwoudt Pta, South Africa 2012-02-15

Kunal Shah kolkata, India 2012-02-15

amit sanghvi anjar, India 2012-02-15

Judith Abel Basel, Switzerland 2012-02-15

Bettina Lorenz Rhede, Germany 2012-02-15


10/13

Name Location Date

Graciela Patrn Mederos Len, Spain 2012-02-15

Lindsay Jagneaux Mamou, LA 2012-02-15

kelly grimm davie, FL 2012-02-15

Navari Elysium Bergen, Norway 2012-02-15

Vitboxer Agneta Tingsryd, Sweden 2012-02-15

POIGNON Aurelie NANCY, NY 2012-02-15

MacKenzie Serpe Everett, WA 2012-02-15

Margaret Rigsby Hazel Green, AL 2012-02-15

Christopher Evans Near Byton Hand, United Kingdom 2012-02-15

barbara ito monterotondo scalo, Italy 2012-02-15

Angela Tomic Novi Sad, United Kingdom 2012-02-15

Linda Scott Santa Fe, NM 2012-02-16

jazmine ganado cebu city, Philippines 2012-02-16

emilia ruia albacete, Spain 2012-02-16

Melissa Wise Benbrook, TX 2012-02-16

Maria F. Verona, Italy 2012-02-16

Beth Dowless Carlisle, PA 2012-02-16

Marina La Placenta GLASGOW, United Kingdom 2012-02-16

Lloyd MacNeal Largo, FL 2012-02-16

Toni Adisano Brooklyn, NY 2012-02-16

Vanditta Diwakar Suva, HI 2012-02-16

Rebecca Moule southend, United Kingdom 2012-02-17

Helene Beck Aarhus, Denmark 2012-02-17

Nina Rauball Heidelberg, Germany 2012-02-17

Kitty Autumn Catopia, United Kingdom 2012-02-17

S Voltolin Loganville, GA 2012-02-17

Sarah-Jane Marr durham, United Kingdom 2012-02-17

margaret lamontagne milllinocket, ME 2012-02-18

Garry Lough Wylie, TX 2012-02-18


11/13

Name Location Date

Jessica Nyquist Colton, OR 2012-02-18

Nafsika Tentokali Thessaloniki, Greece 2012-02-18

mini kaushik delhi, India 2012-02-18

Kay HelpSaveAnimals Sax., Germany 2012-02-18

pamela keen simi valley, CA 2012-02-18

Esther Chalaby Dallas, TX 2012-02-18

Jerilyn Capaccione Aliquippa, PA 2012-02-18

Drahomra Rudolsk Nejdek, Czech Republic 2012-02-18

Lesley Dove London, UK, NY 2012-02-18

M S Coeymans, NY 2012-02-18

Morgan Bender Tomah, WI 2012-02-19

Danielle Mawson Suwanee, GA 2012-02-19

carolyne tivey swadlincote, United Kingdom 2012-02-19

lynn willis swansea, United Kingdom 2012-02-19

Sari Faber Heemstede, Netherlands 2012-02-19

Deborah Shillam Keighley, United Kingdom 2012-02-19

Cynthia Scalici New Baltimore, MI 2012-02-19

Fiona Dunne Lisburn, United Kingdom 2012-02-19

Charles Procter Strathmore, Canada 2012-02-19

Lacey Levitt Shrewsbury, MA 2012-02-20

Kristina Golemanova Gabrovo, Bulgaria 2012-02-20

Tony Menechella Frankfort, KY 2012-02-20

nick dalzell Owensboro, KY 2012-02-20

Elizabeth And Family Ontario, Canada 2012-02-20

S and B Stephens Ontario, Canada 2012-02-20

nuno miguel vocals lisboa, Portugal 2012-02-20

CRISTINA FERREIRA Rio de Janeiro, RI 2012-02-20

kathleen wissenz warminster, PA 2012-02-20

rosane agnoleto Cascavel, MS 2012-02-20


12/13

Name Location Date

Beate Michl Nandlstadt, DE 2012-02-20

Edit Vakarcs Budapest, Hungary 2012-02-20

clarissa boico campinas, Brazil 2012-02-20

Maria Ralha Braga, Portugal 2012-02-20

Diane MacArthur Brighton, Canada 2012-02-20

Lexy Johnson Uniontown, PA 2012-02-20

sandra sheehy Dublin., IL 2012-02-21

monica ghoodjani toronto, Canada 2012-02-21

Jill Barrett Auckland, AK 2012-02-21

Olivia Gunawan Jakarta, ID 2012-02-21

Cathie Penalagan London, Canada 2012-02-21

vijay pinjarkar pinjarkar Nagpur, MH 2012-02-21

Ginger Neimo Adelaide, Australia 2012-02-21

savannah van dongen merksplas, Belgium 2012-02-21

Pamela Case Pmb, South Africa 2012-02-21

Samantha Wilde Shropshire, United Kingdom 2012-02-21

Sarah Dutch Mountains Sliedrecht, Netherlands 2012-02-21

Tudorache Adriana Bucharest, Romania 2012-02-21

Susan Griffiths Klagenfurt, Austria 2012-02-22

Dr.Shenita Etwaroo New York, NY 2012-02-22

Natalia Klasa Gdansk, Poland 2012-02-22

Wendy Douglas DUNDEE, United Kingdom 2012-02-23

Sylvie Bermannov Prague, Czech Republic 2012-02-23

VIRVE HILVERVIK Molltorp, Sweden 2012-02-23

poonam khilnani New Delhi, IN 2012-02-24

Rahul Sharma valsad, India 2012-02-24

Savita Upadhyay valsad, India 2012-02-24

Catherine Turley Orange, CA 2012-02-24

Teresa Rozenga Olsztyn, Poland 2012-02-24


13/13

Name Location Date

Maria Bernardo Atlantic Beach, FL 2012-02-25

Sidney Vaghela Valsad, India 2012-02-25

Olga Gorovits Brooklyn, NY 2012-02-25

Tanwi Sandelwood Onbekend, Belgium 2012-02-25

lucia acua buenos aires, AR 2012-02-26

Documents

‘Allowing beef exports not plan panel’s view’ - Abhishek Kadyan