Upload
others
View
6
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
1
2
3
4
5
6
A B C D E F
Lawsuits vs Carnival (from 10/11/17 through 10/12/18) Incident Date Lawsuit Date Ship Alleged Neligence Class
KATHLEEN KRYGOWSKI (suit dade is amended) August 23, 2017, 7/30/2018 l Breeze
Excursion ‐ Mayan Princess excursion in Honduras; disembark in an area of the vessel that did not have an adequate ladder and/or handrails, withoutadequate assistance from the tour guide(s). As Plaintiff was preparing to disembark in the areadesignated by the tour guide(s), Plaintiff was unable to maintain her balance due to rough seas. As a result, Plaintiff fell into the shallow water and suffered severe injuries. dream
Arroyo, Doreen 12‐Jul‐17 6/21/2018 Sunshine exiting hot tub, grabbed railing to step over hot tub when railing shifted causing her to slip and fall; railing was loose and defective
Sunshine
SONJA KING September 23, 2016, 1/19/2018 splendor
Lido Deck that was slippery due to the presence of a wet or slipperyforeign substance, slipped, and fell splendor
MATTHEW STONEBERGER October 21, 2017 10/12/2018 freedomstruck in the righteye by a golf ball conquest
Diaz 17‐Oct‐17 10/12/2018 victory
Deck 12 at a Carnival Jacuzzi/spa (steps were wet, also unreasonably slippery when wet) triumph
1
A B C D E F
Lawsuits vs Carnival (from 10/11/17 through 10/12/18) Incident Date Lawsuit Date Ship Alleged Neligence Class
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
TERESA EIDSON 10/10/2017 10/9/2018 Miracle
struck the raised threshold and wasviolently thrown to the deck. Deck 9 spirit
Morales, as Parent and Natural Guardian of J.H., a Minor November 9, 2017 10/5/2018 Vista
embarking the vessel,he walked toward the table to get water and tripped over the uneven, slippery, and/or irregularsurface of the gangway Vista
Christy Lopez‐Flores f/k/a/ Christy Carollo 10/15/2017 10/4/2018 Splendor
12th deck to 11th deck; slip and fall transient substance pooled below bottom stair splendor
Shelba Nesmith and Thomas Nesmith 10/31/2017 10/3/2018 Elation
sprayed with ash, dust, dirt, water, oil, metal, and debris; ran and fell the "ELATION's" smoke stack; ran and fellsuddenly erupted. fantasy
Ryan Friend 9/29/2017 9/28/2018 Victory
attacked by this unknown passenger with a glass bottle that was shattered on his head. Then attacked for 20 mins triumph
Geoffrey Cylwik 1/5/2018 9/26/2018 triumph
Excessive force; security guard put pressure on claimant's humerus with a spiral (Corkscrew fracture) destiny
SANDRA SIMPSON 10/8/2017 9/26/2018 Fascination
automatic doors leading to the “Lido Deck”, at the very aft of the ship, on the port side, unexpectedly and without warning closed directly upon the Plaintiff as she walked through the threshold fantasy
1
A B C D E F
Lawsuits vs Carnival (from 10/11/17 through 10/12/18) Incident Date Lawsuit Date Ship Alleged Neligence Class
14
15
16
1718
19
2021
22
23
2425
Calvin Adams 10/4/2017 9/21/2018 valorpassenger area on liquid or water conquest
CAROL NASH, 8‐Nov‐17 9/20/2018 triumphtripped on photo equipment while looking at phot gallery destiny
DIONE SANDERSON 11‐May‐18 18‐Sep‐18 victory
walking through the outdoor stairways from Deck 11 to Deck 10 of the vessel, when she slipped on a wet surface on said stairway triumph
BRETT COHN 15‐Oct‐17 17‐Sep‐18 Conquest
slipped and fellon water as he entered the restroom on the Lido Deck. conquest
DIONE SANDERSON, 9/14/2018 victory triumphGREGORY RICHARDSand CHARLENE RICHARDS 9/21/2017 9/12/2018 Magic Fumes dream
AMANDA WILOTH 11‐Oct‐17 9/10/2018 Panel fell from ceilingDoline 9/7/2018
KEYAMA JACKSON 10/19/2017 9/5/2018 glory
entrance of the dining room which was wet due to water leaking from theceiling conquest
PATRICIA STROM,f/k/a PATRICIA SILVA, andEDWARD STROM 12/26/2017 8/30/2018 vista
improperly constructed staircase at or near the pool deck ‐ SLIPPERY vista
Carlos Czarnik 8/31/2017 8/29/2018 valor
s at or near the wheel chair ramp on deck 10, when she slipped in water or on some other slippery substance on the ground at or near this area conquest
Broderick, Aaron 6/28/2018 8/29/2018 sensation medmal Fantasy
1
A B C D E F
Lawsuits vs Carnival (from 10/11/17 through 10/12/18) Incident Date Lawsuit Date Ship Alleged Neligence Class
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
Rhonda Millington 9/4/2017 8/28/2018 Freedomtripped while lights were dimly lit at comedy show conquest
Iliana Batista 9/16/2017 8/28/2018 conquest slip on laminated menu conquest
Joshua Wendtas Survivors, and on behalf of the Estate, of 28‐Aug‐18 Liberty food allergy conquest
FELIPE RAMOS, JR 7/26/2018 8/27/2018 valorslip and fall while walking on the Lido Deck conquest
MARIE LEFEVRE 7/28/2018 8/27/2018 victory
deck four by the glass elevator, when she slipped on a wet, foreign or transitorysubstance triumph
Linda Dudley 2/12/2018 8/24/2018 Valor
traversed the Shogun Club Casino on the Promenade deck (deck 5) of the Carnival Valor, she tripped over protruding and uneven carpeting conquest
KATRENIA WILLIAMS 5‐Jul‐17 8/20/2018 victory EXCURSION ‐ operating the catamaran at a high rate of speedand/or racing another vessel. The captain ultimately crashed into the dock,and the catamaran didnot have an adequate method for passengers to secure themselves to theirseat.
triumph
Naomi Dean 1/12/2018 8/18/2018 Paradise
movement of the ship caused her to lose her balance and fall in the midship starboard hallway. There were no handrails or other devices fantasy
TAMMY JOSIAS, 10/9/2017 8/15/2018 Breezeon Deck 11, s/f on water or substance dream
1
A B C D E F
Lawsuits vs Carnival (from 10/11/17 through 10/12/18) Incident Date Lawsuit Date Ship Alleged Neligence Class
35
36
37
TARYN SERRA‐CRUZ, 17‐Aug‐17 15‐Aug‐18 splendor
attempting to navigate over therough, uneven and/or steep terrain, Plaintiff crashed, she was thrown off the ATV, and the ATVlanded on top of her. As a result, Plaintiff suffered severe injuries. splendor
JENNIFER APRIL CENTER 1‐Aug‐17 8/14/2018 conquest
walking on the tiled surface in the Monet restaurant as directed by Defendant CARNIVAL’s restaurant when she was suddenly caused to slip and fall hard to the ground when she walked over clear liquids that were spilled on the surface. conquest
Lillian Haroun, Michael Haroun, A.Z. by andthrough his mother Lillian Haroun, J.Z. by and through his mother Lillian Haroun, Hany Haroun, Christine Haroun, E.H. by and through her fatherHany Haroun, and Joseph Haroun, 14‐Aug‐17 8/13/2018 paradise false imprisonement fantasy
1
A B C D E F
Lawsuits vs Carnival (from 10/11/17 through 10/12/18) Incident Date Lawsuit Date Ship Alleged Neligence Class
38
39
40
HAWKS, RHONDA 4/3/2018 8/7/2018 Dream
fell on amisshapen/shortened step; s located on the exterior weather deck between deck 14and 12; stairway, the steps, as well as the area surrounding thestairway, was unreasonably dangerous, risk‐creating, defective, outdated, improperly designed,improperly installed, and/or otherwise unsafe Dream
Randall Noon as PR of Karen Noon 7/7/2017 8/3/2018 Sensation
shortness of breath respiratory distress; Carnival gave passenger oxygen tank; Carnival didn't let passenger keep the oxygen tank or provide ambulance to hospital; passenger went into respiratory arrest; emergency services finally called fantasy
JAMES MCCHRISTIAN, August 20, 2017 7/31/2018 Inspiration
slipped and felldue to a wet and slippery foreign substance Fantasy
1
A B C D E F
Lawsuits vs Carnival (from 10/11/17 through 10/12/18) Incident Date Lawsuit Date Ship Alleged Neligence Class
41
42
43
Dase, Bertha 2/22/2017 7/30/2018 triumph
ship experienced a list, causing the entrance door of Club Hollywood which wasimproperly secured to swing out, slamming and crushing her right thumb in her dominanthand. Consequently, her thumb was severely lacerated, suffering an open fracture resultingin surgery with the placement of hardware. destiny
LINDA ADCOX, 18‐22002‐CIV‐Ungaro May 23, 2017 7/20/2018 Conquest
Stair issues AND Medmal; walking downthe stairs from the fifth (5th) deck to the fourth (4th) deck approximately 8:10 pm when her right foot slipped out from under her and she slippedand fell, after traversing the second step, – while descending the stairwell. conquest
CELIA VASQUEZ 8/19/2017 7/18/2018 Magic
slipped and fell in her stateroom bathroom, whichcaused her to suffer injuries, including but not limited to a fractured ankle.
1
A B C D E F
Lawsuits vs Carnival (from 10/11/17 through 10/12/18) Incident Date Lawsuit Date Ship Alleged Neligence Class
4445
46
47
48
49
50
51
Sheena Martin and A.M a minor 7/22/2017 7/16/2018 Magic
descending steps near waterpark on vessel (slipped and fell on wet, loose or raised steps) ; A.M. hurt, and mom zone danger dream
Cleveland Winfield 8/23/2017 7/13/2018 Sunshine Medical Malpractice sunshineSean Ashwell v Carnival and Steiner ‐ Case 1:18cv22738 7/7/2018 imagination slip/fall lido deck
fantasyElise Doline 8‐Jul‐17 7/6/2018 glory walking from the outside
pool deck to the inside, on the Lido Deck(Deck 9) conquest
LAWRENCE FOWLER 6/5/2017 7/3/2018 glory
walking down a staircase prior todisembarking from the ship. tripped and fell on an unmarked, visually confusing and obscured step conquest
RAINEKA WATSON and SHAVADO SMITH, ZION SMITH, their deceased minor child
October 14, 2017, 7/3/2018 glory tumbled over the railing and tragically fell several stories to her death. conquest
SHERRI LAWRENCE 10/29/2017 6/27/2018 Vista,
Lido deck on the Carnival Vista, she lost her footing on awet surface that was not objectively perceivable Vista
Chakmakian, Nicole 14‐Jul‐17 6/21/2018 Sunshine exisint ladies room deck 5 by casino across from bar; liquid substance on the floor, by entrance of ladies room caused slip an fall Sunshine
1
A B C D E F
Lawsuits vs Carnival (from 10/11/17 through 10/12/18) Incident Date Lawsuit Date Ship Alleged Neligence Class
52
53
54
55
56
57
Bollinger November 1, 2017 6/19/2018 Ecstasy descending a stairwell aboard the Carnival Ecstasy from Deck 8 toDeck 7 when her shoe got caught in the metal strip lining the edge of the stair and caused her tofall
MARY L. MACK, 27‐Jun‐17 6/19/2018 VICTORY unreasonably slippery bathroom cabin floor.
Judy Castille Case 1:18‐cv‐22405‐CMA 6/14/2017 6/15/2018 Spirit LegendFELISIA WILLIAMS 5‐Aug‐17 6/15/2018 Splendor just adjacent to the Pizza
Pirate restaurant/buffet stand on the Lidodeck of CARNIVAL Splendor.
Splendor
Linda Heald 9/9/2017 6/8/2018 Breezepushed down stairs by passenger dream
MICHELLE BALGOBIND 1/27/2018 6/8/2018 Imagination
Deck 10 (“Lido Deck”) near a stage, her foot slipped onliquid on the floor Fantasy
1
A B C D E F
Lawsuits vs Carnival (from 10/11/17 through 10/12/18) Incident Date Lawsuit Date Ship Alleged Neligence Class
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
Beverly White 5‐Aug‐17 6/4/2018 Splendor
adjacent to the Pizza Pirate restaurant/buffet stand on the Lido Splendor
BRITTANY THOMPSON Case 1:18‐cv‐22216‐KMW 4‐Nov‐17 6/4/2018 TriumphLido Deck (vicinity of Guy Fieri’s Burger Joint) Destiny
Linda Carter 28‐May‐17 6/1/2018 Breeze
stepped on a slippery metal plate on the floor as she was entering the buffet area on the LidoDeck causing her foot to slip and then catch on the carpet pitching her forward and causingher to fall injuring her right knee dream
KIM GRIFFIN 6/4/2017 6/1/2018 conquest
while walking from comfort kitchen to seafood shack slipped in liquid on the floor conquest
GIULIANA FLORIN June 15, 201+A3+B34 5/30/2018 magic
Lido Deck and as she entered one of the restaurants, she tripped over an uneven‐protruding metal grate (presumably covering a gutter or like drainage canal) dream
DEBORA HUTCHINSON 7/22/2017 5/29/2018 Freedom
elevator area of the Lido deck on the M/V Carnival Freedom, Plaintiff tripped over a raised threshold conquest
JACQUELINE COPPOLA, 25‐May‐17 5/25/2018 splendor Lido Deck (Deck 9) o splendor
1
A B C D E F
Lawsuits vs Carnival (from 10/11/17 through 10/12/18) Incident Date Lawsuit Date Ship Alleged Neligence Class
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
EMMA GONZALEZ 5/18/2018 Victorywet stairs ‐ sky deck (deck 14) leading triumph
KAREN BURNEY 8/1/2017 5/15/2018 VICTORY
ZIPLINE failed to signal to her to slow down and brake as he was supposed to. 33. When Burney tried to stop herself, her leg hit a metal beam that was part of the platform, triumph
CHARLENE MAJOR, 5/20/2017 5/14/2018 Imagination
def overserved fellow passenger who then assaulted plaintiff fantasy
CORTNEE WRIGHT, 5/13/2017 5/11/2018 Fantasy
a glass automatic elevator on deck 11, the door abruptly closed on her
MARY STEWARt 1:18‐cv‐21898‐CMA 6‐Jun‐17 5/11/2018 Pride SpiritPAULETTE HOWARD BUNCH 24‐Jul‐17 5/10/2018 Glory Fitness Center Conquest
NANCY ENG, February 28, 2018 5/4/2018 Magic
n indoor portion of the Lido (10th) Deck, she slipped and fell as a result ofa wet, slippery, dangerous and/or hazardous flooring surface Dream
1
A B C D E F
Lawsuits vs Carnival (from 10/11/17 through 10/12/18) Incident Date Lawsuit Date Ship Alleged Neligence Class
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
Tonia Falkner 5/7/2017 5/3/2018 triumphslip puddle water (dirt, sand, debris) on deck destiny
CHARLES RYAN,DOLORES RYAN 5/4/2017 5/2/2018 triumph cabin flooded ‐ ptsd destiny
Raul Hernandez 7/30/2017 4/26/2018 liberty
slip on slippery flooring inside stateroom floor inside/outside of shower stall conquest
SARAH WILLIAMS June 4, 2017. 4/25/2018 Liberty,
outdoor portion of the Lido deck including the area where this fall occurred to accumulate water and remain in a wet and unsafe condition. The wet area accumulated near a utility cart placed on the Lido deck by CARNIVAL.; Carnival allowed its utility cart used to store ice to malfunction and/or leak water and/or condensate onto the Lido deck floor. Conquest
Eric Ewing 1/25/2018 4/25/2018 ecstasy
top bunk unexpectedly deployed strikinghim violently on the top of his head
Patrcicia McFarlin 4/27/2017 4/24/2018 Fantasy
housekeeping cart hit her ankle and rolled over her foot by a member of the ship’s crew, Fantasy
LORI LEVIN 5‐Sep‐17 4/17/2018 pride
slippery floor surface in a cafeteria area near the Serenity Lounge.
1
A B C D E F
Lawsuits vs Carnival (from 10/11/17 through 10/12/18) Incident Date Lawsuit Date Ship Alleged Neligence Class
79
80
81
82
83
84
CHRISTINE CIGAINERO 5/12/2017 4/10/2018 Conquest
crossing from the portside of theM/V “CONQUEST” towards amidships to access an elevator. CARNIVAL employee mopping the area, and realized that the floor that she was walking upon was wet; no warning signs Conquest
MABLE BREVARD 7/5/2017 3/29/2018 paradise
f slipped and fell on a wet, slippery and hazardousflooring surface in front of an elevator and injured her right shoulder and wrist requiring surgery Fantasy
Alicia Hall 4/21/2017 3/28/2018 glorywalking up staiway (trip fall due to uneven surface) conquest
ANN GUZMAN HICKMAN 5/6/2017 3/27/2018 paradise
walking past the buffet area she slipped and fell due to theexistence of a liquid substance on the floor Fantasy
CHARLES RUDOLPH 10‐May‐17 3/27/2018 victory TRIUMPH
EVELYN ENOGIERU 4/13/2017 3/23/2018 sensation
descending an exterior staircase locatedbetween deck 10 and 11 aboard the vessel, when she slipped and fell on a wet, slipperyand/or hazardous flooring surface and/or steps fantasy
1
A B C D E F
Lawsuits vs Carnival (from 10/11/17 through 10/12/18) Incident Date Lawsuit Date Ship Alleged Neligence Class
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
PATRICIA FULLER, 5/20/2017 3/20/2018 glory
slipped and felldue to a wet and slippery foreign substance while walking on deck 9 conquest
HANNAH KARTAGENER 22‐Jan‐18 3/15/2018 Paradise
slipped on a wet, foreign or transitorysubstance inside an elevator Fantasy
RUBY SOSA Freedom 3/14/2018 conquest
entering the buffet area, Plaintiff slipped and fell due to a largepuddle of water on the floor Conquest
Helen Caldwell 3/17/2017 3/9/2018 magicwalking to pizzeria sliped in large puddle water dream
Jessica L. Carter 4/20/2017 3/7/2018 Magicslipped and fell in large pooling of water deck 11 Dream
KAREN LAVANDOWSKI, December 6th, 2016 3/5/2018 Pride
descending stairs from the water slide area, a stair shifted and moved, causing her to lose her balance and fall Spirit
KATHLEEN KENNEDY, individually,as PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVEof THE ESTATE OF JOHN ANTHONY,VALANTIEJUS‐RIGGLE deceased,for and on behalf of THE ESTATE,and the Survivors 7/6/2017 3/5/2018 freedom
location where he jumped was shallow, although this was not obvious toDecedent as the water was murky, and Decedent had not been warned of the danger. Decedentstruck his head and neck on the ocean floor below, causing severe injuries. conquest
DELORIS BENTLEY‐MITCHELL, 17‐Jul‐17 3/1/2018 triumph
walking through the ship’s casino, Plaintiff fell after stepping on a loose tile and tile grout making up the flooring destiny
1
A B C D E F
Lawsuits vs Carnival (from 10/11/17 through 10/12/18) Incident Date Lawsuit Date Ship Alleged Neligence Class
93
94
95
96
9798
FRANCENIA THOMPSON, 4/9/2017 2/26/2018 splendor
CARNIVALcrewmember dropped the heavy tub of silverware onto Plaintiff’s left shoulder, causingserious injuries to Plaintiff’s shoulder and neck splendor
CAROLYN THIBODEAUX 12/12/2016 2/23/2018 FREEDOM
slip and fall in one of the publicbathrooms aboard said cruise ship. That one of the toilets had overflowed and the Plaintiff fellon the wet floor Conquest
SHEKEITHA NELSON f November 21, 2016 2/21/2018 victory
theattendant lost control of the wheelchair, causing Nelson to be expelled from the chair andsustaining injuries to her knees, hip and back. triumph
KYOUNGSOON YOO 2/21/2017 2/20/2018 vista
bobsled excursion, when she was bounced within the bobsled and/or the seatbelt restraintfailed to hold Plaintiff to the seat during the bobsled ride. Vista
CHANEL HARRIS 1/15/2017 2/7/2018 sensation
Kaleidoscope Room, when sheslipped on a wet, foreign or transitory substance on the floor and fell fantasy
Karen Cabico 1‐Feb‐17 1/30/2018 sunshine lido deck slip
1
A B C D E F
Lawsuits vs Carnival (from 10/11/17 through 10/12/18) Incident Date Lawsuit Date Ship Alleged Neligence Class
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
PAMELA FOSTER 1/29/2017 1/29/2018
slip and fall while exiting the Carnival vessel on a gangwayowned by Brevard County; water which was leaking into the gangway due to leaks in the gangway
Laura Trotmon 10/9/2016 1/29/2018 conquest
fellwhile walking into a night club, “Henri’s Dance Club,” used as a teen/kids game arcadeand social gathering venue, which was not well lit Conquest
Elizabeth Amy, parent of Wesleigh Amy 6/13/2016 1/26/2018 liberty
minor climbed over and/or passed through the railing and fell 9 feet to hard deck below factured skull conquest
Samel Ramic 5/28/2013 1/22/2018 glory
shoulder fatigue while working but never given light duty conquest
JENNIFER HEINRICH, 2/12/2017 1/18/2018 breeze
suffered injuries during an “Ionithermie”Procedure
Keith Mills 1/24/2017 1/17/2018 fantasy
sat on chair in casino‐ chair fell backward. Chair wasn't attached as it was designed to be attached. Piece of chair was missing
BRANDI WELLONS, Individually and as personal representative of the Estate of KEVIN WELLONS, deceased, February 13, 2017 1/12/2018 elation
fell overboard; not enough lifeboats fantasy
1
A B C D E F
Lawsuits vs Carnival (from 10/11/17 through 10/12/18) Incident Date Lawsuit Date Ship Alleged Neligence Class
106
107
108
109
110
111
Marita FREY 1/13/2017 1/12/2018
Defendant’s crew came out of aservice door and struck the left side of Plaintiff’s body, injuring her left hand and left fifthfinger with the door and door handle.
Roy Friedlos 1/15/2017 1/1/2018 splendor
foot struck protruding base of colomn, hidden by croward; at liquor tasting near duty free shops splendor
Pamela Burt and Tommy Braziel 12/31/2016 12/22/2017 Fantasy
allowed an unreasonably large andextremely dangerous hole to remain in the wood decking of the Lido Deck for a prolongedperiod of time; slip
Richard Ward January 21, 2017. 12/20/2017 Conquest Conquest
Paul Mendelsohn 1/30/2017 12/18/2017 sensation
door in mens bathroom separated from hinges cut leg and back injury
Lachelle Jones 12/19/2016 12/14/2017 splendor
walking towards the pool, through an eating area, she slipped and fell splendor
1
A B C D E F
Lawsuits vs Carnival (from 10/11/17 through 10/12/18) Incident Date Lawsuit Date Ship Alleged Neligence Class
112
113
114
115
12/12/2016 12/11/2017 magic
walking up thestairs from the fourth to fifth deck. When he reached Deck 5, he turned to his left andhis left leg struck the metallic base of the glass railing which was protruding out frombottom of the glass railing, and tripped and fell to the deck dream
Ward, David 12/11/2016 12/7/2017 Conquest
slipped on transient substnace on the floor while walking into the Lido Deck restaurant Conquest
Lis, James January 17, 2017 12/7/2017 Miracle
wetting the area or allowing the area to be wet, choosing the areato host the second game, not cleaning and drying the flooring before the game, making the secondgame a race, the Plaintiff slipped and fell and suffered a displaced/unstable ankle fracture thatultimately required surgery on January 31, 2017. The surgery involved the insertion of a plate andscrews in his ankle Spirit
Zack Carusso 7/29/2017 12/1/2017 fantasyloose lip/threshold in stateroom fantasy
1
A B C D E F
Lawsuits vs Carnival (from 10/11/17 through 10/12/18) Incident Date Lawsuit Date Ship Alleged Neligence Class
116
117
118
119120
Farris, Norma 2/25/2017 12/1/2017 Breeze
stretched power cord across public corridor in passenger space on ship, like a trip wire; passenger tripped on cord; (complaint contains Carnival's 2 minute training) dream
Mahingostar, Iraj 2/24/2017 11/22/2017 INspiration order to board the ship, Defendants directed passengers, including the Plaintiff, to utilize an escalator (“the subject escalator”) leading up to the gangway. Passengers were also directed to check their luggage at an area at the top ofthe subject escalator.as directed by the Defendants, the Plaintiff was on thesubject escalator with his luggage when suddenly, and without warning, it malfunctioned andjolted. The Plaintiff was caused to lose his balance, fall backwards down the subject escalator,strike his head and suffer severe injuries
Gaines, KELVIN April 4, 2017, 11/15/2017 Dream slipped/tripped andfell on a step.
Sanders, Judith May 4, 2017 11/15/2017 Elationslipped and fell on a wet dance floor. Fantasy
Reeves 11/14/2017
1
A B C D E F
Lawsuits vs Carnival (from 10/11/17 through 10/12/18) Incident Date Lawsuit Date Ship Alleged Neligence Class
121
122
123
124
125
ANDRE OW BULAND, 11/15/2016 11/14/2017 PEARL medmal NORWEGIAN
REBECCA SOTO December 10, 2016 (10 p 11/10/2017 Magic
just outside the Showtime theater. slip and fall in the area of vomit Dream
Bougere, SHIRLEY 10/30/2016 11/9/2017 Triumph
Lido deck by the buffet line on the vessel, when she slipped on a wet, foreign or transitory substance on the floor and fell and sustained tibia fracture which wassurgically repaired via open reduction internal fixation Destiny
Ward, Lorie December 5, 2016. 11/7/2017 Conquest
Ward put her foot on the raised shiny metal threshold which looked dry before she stepped on it. But the shiny metal threshold was wet and unreasonably slippery when wet.Ward’s foot slipped out from under her and caused her to fall backward Conquest
Meree, Susan April 2, 2017 11/2/2017 Ecstasy
injured by shards that shot out of the air conditioning vent (“A/C vent”) above her bed. Plaintiff’s injuriesinclude, but are not limited to, severely damaged retinas and limited visibility. Fantasy
1
A B C D E F
Lawsuits vs Carnival (from 10/11/17 through 10/12/18) Incident Date Lawsuit Date Ship Alleged Neligence Class
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
Kraft, Joy 5/6/2017 11/2/2017 Inspiration
slipped and/ortripped over a threshold, subdural hematoma, Medmal Fantasy
Progen, Susan 7‐Dec‐16 11/1/2017 Sunshine
in a restroom on or around the lido deck, a heavy wall‐panel suddenly fell out of the restroom wall Sunshine
Ward,Tracy 2‐Feb‐17 11/1/2017 Gloryslipped and fell on a wet floor Conquest
Printiss Jackson‐Davis, individuallyand as Personal Representative of theEstate of Brenda Jackson, November 13, 2016. 11/1/2017 Dream Medmal dream
OCTOBIA LEWIS 4‐Nov‐16 10/31/2017 Glory
Lido deck slipped and fell on a puddle of water which contained dirt, sand, and/or other debris Conquest
KAREN FORD October 30, 2016 10/30/2017 SENSATION
slipped and fell on Deck 10 (Lido) of the vessel just after entering the dining area. A portion of the deck was wet and slippery as a result of liquid on the floor Fantasy
JAMES CHATMAN 29‐Aug‐16 10/27/2017 Splendor
tripped and fell entering a Lido deckbathroom, caused by a threshold that was difficult to visualize, along with the action of the closingdoor which forced him to the ground
Splendor
1
A B C D E F
Lawsuits vs Carnival (from 10/11/17 through 10/12/18) Incident Date Lawsuit Date Ship Alleged Neligence Class
133
134
135
136
137
138
JESSIE FINE, as mother of BRADY FINE,a minor, 13‐Jun‐16 10/26/2017 DREAM
swimming atthe swimming pool when his foot struck a sharp object believed to be glass, sustaining severe injuries
DREAM
Hornsby, JONNELLA June 29, 2017 10/25/2017 Breeze
at or around the “WaterWorks” attraction aboard the Carnival Breeze when she was hit by over 300‐gallons of water without warning, and knocked down stairs. As a result of the fall, the Plaintiff fractured her right hand,
dream
BILLY PRUITT, 29‐Oct‐16 10/25/2017 DREAM
failing to equipthe shower in Plaintiff’s passenger cabin with a non‐slip mat dream
Strong‐Polin,MARY 25‐Aug‐17 10/20/2017 Ecstasy
reached for the door and entered the gazebo, she fell and hit her head with a metal baseboard. Threshold and other issues.
Fantasy
Russell, MICHELLE June 29, 2017 10/20/2017 Vista
walking near the pool aboard when she slipped on the wet floor of the ship deck causing injuries. Vista
Dimpfel, STARR August 22, 2016, 10/20/2017 TRIUMPH
slip and fall on a wet deck while walking intothe Lido Buffet from the pool deck.
1
A B C D E F
Lawsuits vs Carnival (from 10/11/17 through 10/12/18) Incident Date Lawsuit Date Ship Alleged Neligence Class
139
140
141
142
143
144
Johanna Curry November 4, 2016 10/18/2017 Miracle
afternoon CARNIVAL began cleaning an area of the its Lido buffet floor, but left aslick area on floor without properly warning or blocking off the area being cleaned; slick cleaning liquid
spirit
Badura, ANGELA January 23, 2017 10/16/2017 Inspiration
fell on a step in a dimly lit and crowded room during the emergency boat drill & mandatory safety briefing Fantasy
Mordhorst,ERIC October 15, 2016, 10/13/2017 SUNSHINE
walking on a passenger stairs of the CARNIVALSUNSHINE going from Deck 14 to Deck 12 wet and unreasonably slippery passenger stairs. SUNSHINE
Siplin, ZELMA 12/18/2016 10/12/2017 Victory
immediately after entering the buffet area from the Lido deck, Plaintiff slipped and fell in a large puddle of water on the floor, Triumph
IRIS NATHANS 11/30/2016 10/9/2017 Pride
grading on the surface of the floor that had negligently been permitted to remain, and become loose and unsecured. . . Spirit
SHELLIE GRICE 11/11/2017 8/14/2017 Victory
slipped and fell due to a wet and slippery foreign substance while walking on the deck triumph
1
A B C D E F
Lawsuits vs Carnival (from 10/11/17 through 10/12/18) Incident Date Lawsuit Date Ship Alleged Neligence Class
145146
147148
149
150151152
153
154
155
156
Jessica Gibson, individuallyand as personal representativeof the estate of MarshaBoekeloo, deceased; BrandonBoekeloo and Terry Boekeloo
9/22/2016 breeze
Marsha Boekeloo’s harness seperated out of the harness on the zipline just a few feet from the starting point of the line and she fell approximately 25‐40 feet down a cliff, ausing massive internal injuries which led to her death later that day. dream
Baker, CAROLYN 12/17/2016 12/6/2007 Magic Medmal Dream
Linda Wieters 1/1/2016 2016 FascinationAtrium Bar, Wieters fell and broke her tibia.
David Carideo v Carnival, Whet Travel, 2016 Inspiration
Sampson 10/24/2014 Inspiration Fantasy***MENTIONED IN ANOTHER CASE*** Zarr v. Carnival Corporation, Case No. 17‐CIV20312‐CMA
SOMETIME 2017 trip, slip and fall on a piece of flooring or wooden
MCGREGOR, JOYCE June 6, 2017 10/20/2017 Magic
protruding metal stripon the floor caused her to fall. dream
Michelle Prince‐Bowers 6/24/2017 inspirationslip in bathroom (shower flooded bathroom) fantasy
Susan Fallon Perryman, Personal Representative of the Estate of Walter Lamar Perryman, deceased. 7/1/2017 Sensation Medmal Wrongful Death
Sara Heisler 5/31/2016
mentioned in Iris Nathans response to MSJ