46
http://ier.sagepub.com/ Review Indian Economic & Social History http://ier.sagepub.com/content/49/2/151 The online version of this article can be found at: DOI: 10.1177/001946461204900201 2012 49: 151 Indian Economic Social History Review Muzaffar Alam Strategy and imagination in a Mughal Sufi story of creation Published by: http://www.sagepublications.com can be found at: Indian Economic & Social History Review Additional services and information for http://ier.sagepub.com/cgi/alerts Email Alerts: http://ier.sagepub.com/subscriptions Subscriptions: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsReprints.nav Reprints: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav Permissions: http://ier.sagepub.com/content/49/2/151.refs.html Citations: What is This? - Jun 18, 2012 Version of Record >> by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014 ier.sagepub.com Downloaded from by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014 ier.sagepub.com Downloaded from

Alam-strategy & Imagination in a Mughal Story of Creation-ieshr2012

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

dbdbbd

Citation preview

  • http://ier.sagepub.com/Review

    Indian Economic & Social History

    http://ier.sagepub.com/content/49/2/151The online version of this article can be found at:

    DOI: 10.1177/001946461204900201

    2012 49: 151Indian Economic Social History ReviewMuzaffar Alam

    Strategy and imagination in a Mughal Sufi story of creation

    Published by:

    http://www.sagepublications.com

    can be found at:Indian Economic & Social History ReviewAdditional services and information for

    http://ier.sagepub.com/cgi/alertsEmail Alerts:

    http://ier.sagepub.com/subscriptionsSubscriptions:

    http://www.sagepub.com/journalsReprints.navReprints:

    http://www.sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.navPermissions:

    http://ier.sagepub.com/content/49/2/151.refs.htmlCitations:

    What is This?

    - Jun 18, 2012Version of Record >>

    by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from

    http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/content/49/2/151http://ier.sagepub.com/content/49/2/151http://www.sagepublications.comhttp://www.sagepublications.comhttp://ier.sagepub.com/cgi/alertshttp://ier.sagepub.com/cgi/alertshttp://ier.sagepub.com/subscriptionshttp://ier.sagepub.com/subscriptionshttp://www.sagepub.com/journalsReprints.navhttp://www.sagepub.com/journalsReprints.navhttp://www.sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.navhttp://www.sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.navhttp://ier.sagepub.com/content/49/2/151.refs.htmlhttp://ier.sagepub.com/content/49/2/151.refs.htmlhttp://ier.sagepub.com/content/49/2/151.full.pdfhttp://ier.sagepub.com/content/49/2/151.full.pdfhttp://online.sagepub.com/site/sphelp/vorhelp.xhtmlhttp://online.sagepub.com/site/sphelp/vorhelp.xhtmlhttp://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/

  • !"#$%#

    & ! #

    '()

    !"#$"%

    & ' ("')("

    $" ""$"*+'"

    !

    !" "#$""%%##"&'('(")#'#)#"

    ( ,''- ."-$ #"/01"

    '"#0#2''

    )')"''+

    1+3#'-"&'

    #"4"5%678977:*+ ) *(#

    /''(""&$0/'"$

    #""2'*

    by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from

    http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/

  • ;J#"&-.

    1("*9>%>GJ&

  • !;

    &*">:99769?6@6%:@

    +(%@ (')"* ( ' 3')"$" )("

    )" *

    ("2.%+(%#*&*&*.D &*.D" "#&2".) '" .%+(%0'")""*,'/*&*1D

    "# ("))32 H "

    GJ/#0&"2"*'1'($H2 (1)F

    J" 424"* ("-'

    42-*655G*&

    '''

    '"42*

    )'2"" "')''" &2".

    " 8/%".%(%.(*EH"4)'4*C#F-"*/=0& ''""

    322"*H"="2"2

    &2".*G@9%@>*5.DK*6*6>*.D2"'2'.%+(%

    ))

    .DK*9*G:E*.D2'"2

    "'3.' **.#$1(((*67G>*

    by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from

    http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/

  • ;
  • !;

    &*">:99769?6@6%:@

    $'2 ''"

    '2)")'*$)?

    )''"2')""* "*''")" ' '""*

    ")&28 P, 0Q ") P'Q

    +0*+2" ') 0 "'""'

    *69+I"))"'"2'' )"6G****+",%.(2&22P '"' AQ &28)

    #) 8" &" )

    8)+****(+2"",%.6>

    " ,% '' %*6@

    69+2"*:990 %/'3"' (2"")+2"''&"**&2

    8"28+2%/"++ "*"&2,D

    (2K* 6 * 56%:7 ( / ' ) - 20"RF"' )"

    ")"2 "SIE?6G7/"'))) 0*

    '*&28"28+2=% 1% ./0?.%"*&2"

    2&2"+K*:*@@:%E9*#K*6>'

    (""'0"3')I@6?@E*( '/)(" "$""""

    '0*ID#&

    "*6567/,/ * 96C%65* ,ID#&

    I"+&

    A .D ! !,/,3$$=*@@5%CG*

    6G . )% (% ( % +*+

    ) B'"" '"""*I6@?9E"6@?9C*

    6>$3)' "

    ) )"+2"%

    "2")'*#'+2"",%.) '2)2"""+2*$" 2

    %)'22'(%%'*

    B) "',% +2%/

    "*'*%/"++K*6*:%57*",%."''"'''')'))

    '2)"'

    0'T """'**"2

    #"F/))"/)""*6>:5%/",%.) "'2 &22A)DK*6*97%96H 2H*.""*

    ,*,*&2K*(*GE%G5*6@.%+(%*9G:2J''",%.*GE%G5"

    $"" "#"K" )''

    )

    )36'*K$%**C9G%G65G>%GC*

    by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from

    http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/

  • ;G9777*+")'"66>6&$)A"""""

    >CG6/0 ****() 0 "

    2".+*+")/ 2!""'"''" *F "2'")"%"2 '"" F"*P#2

    Q!"'"" ')

    "*6E

    &2".2'2)''

    ('2&")"""

    "' )'

    $"*6C,#"))

    2))""3"'2 " &"* 2 )

    2"

    '

    3' )$"*$)"'"

    '*$" "''" "2&"*./"

    &0"'')&"*$)''

    ***")"'"&2&"*

    .'""" +"))"'"

    )"#0 *""#0 "2

    ))'"22!")"*

    )'" +"%"""%)&")'")""F) *& /"&0)' "'"&" PKQ

    '" .08"*.08""+ "

    2' ''/)=

    6E.%+(%*9>7*6C'*",%.*97%96*&''" (2&20"""2'

    )" 3 " 2 ' "*+) )

    ' " **F(2&2

    !-+%/K*9"*-U"2(2"*9CE%5E*

    by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from

    http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/

  • !;

    &*">:99769?6@6%:@

    .08"*('/"&0&""'""''$""0" /**+ 65)

    '"*)' /)/"

    '

    0 22*+) '

    $"&""'")"*+0

    ""*6:

    $ """3"

    )") '")F+2 $2$" "

    " ")0'2# ?

    "0)"2)')'

    2'"'*$)"')

    !"/")"" "'*+I'(""'0"3')97

    " 0*()/@%/2' AF"0)"

    "' *&"

    A))2'"****(2

    *+ # )"

    " " ")"/''*+ /A) ""0')""*96

    +&2".)"

    '" '&"" " ('

    65H"'.%&2".)'

    %.+%/" +/"" """*.%+(%*9G52*

    6:.%+(%*9>72*,//"/ ))

    "2/"//"..$" "K

    $%**G59%5G>97%9:EG6%>7*97%(.).

    %+*I@6?@E*96.%+(%*9>6*+",%%%'"#3

    (DDF"2&/%%%:%"*(/2

    "".DD /*956J#"-%+%+ &%/*9G7*& #' I/@%/2&21.

    2"*&'2/"-A2'

    42A/"&2"""*#!A$:1-A2'42AK*N(K*6669*

  • ;
  • !;!

    &*">:99769?6@6%:@

    $&2".2

    ')"%A''"))"

    K")"# !"

    A*$))""

    2) 2 /

    "*#'""")(%

    "*# "#)) ' 1 " ( ) % + % ,% %%,1(/9@ )'"*(

    ("""''"'

    22'2"'""( P Q"'*+

    2""")"'/

    *9E

    &2" . ' " '))

    "''" "A?

    -A)

    ")

    22

    '*$

    )

    2 2 /+ )J ')

    2

    " "

    *-A))")"

    " "'2 &")"2

    "")

    2*(2

    #,"F&P"*'69G7Q)?

    8+,%()+0%)+

    9@##"#?#)"'K)$%"

    %%"'"#"2"11""'#J4".'$%*@G%@:6E6*&2

    ,D)11)'"'2 )

    "'

    "1%" "2)' " )'' " "

    ))'"'*0./!/"*#"&"/*G9CH *8"*8"#*65G*

    9E.%+(%*9>72*&2".'?.

    )' '#)" 2

    2* ( '" # ' " "

    2*+2""2'A

    ' ' &2".")#

    ") ) " 8/ .% (%.(* * ."'K A( " A")#'.'K

    &2".B)

    2))#'3*

    by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from

    http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/

  • ";
  • !;

    &*">:99769?6@6%:@

    )

    "'"'""

    2 )""'*G6

    &2". ))) 2&"2

    2 ) 2 )" "

    2"$""*A""

    ))'"2'""'" '2

    2" S"""

    -A))

    2'"")

    2

    2")

    2"DD " )

    22

    3" *&")

    20 *#)

    2'2)****+ )" " 2)" A "

    ")'"()

    2

    / 0*

    "'?

    -A)

    22)

    2'

    "")

    2 ")

    '*+)

    2"

    ))

    2" *" ''"2))

    &"PQ*B)

    2"" " ' )"*&'"

    &")

    2"$)

    22"

    0")

    2"*B)"2)

    2

    " %*&" )

    2" ))

    2

    "" $*+"&")

    2"

    F ")

    2 )

    '' " ")

    '

    "*B

    '))

    2)

    *&")

    '*$)

    " )""

    *&")

    2""*,(/'')

    2"')

    '

    )

    %"*$)

    '

    '%)2'2*$)

    " )'"'

    )

    22"")

    2 )/.*-A ' &")

    2" " ))

    )*(

    )

    2)")" "

    ) )

    ') ' "

    )')

    2

    "*+ )

    G6.%+(%*9>9*

    by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from

    http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/

  • ;
  • !;

    &*">:99769?6@6%:@

    '&2".*$2

    )2 KG>%%" $% )

    )K ''

    ) " "2 3" 2

    #"# " *&2".

    )?

    #"#"P/0Q)2'

    ))" "12"

    % "? '" 1 P " Q)')

    %))

    2")"")''" #0 "+"=)F)*+& )"' 2))"''''" !1*+'!1+)

    2"2&"""'"*+)')

    '2

    "2'(+

    1)

    2''"22*()

    "))

    2*/0)

    "

    !1'"%*

  • ;
  • !;

    &*">:99769?6@6%:@

    '"*GC$

    ' "'" A ")

    2

    " ()

    )"2"*+A)

    "

    *&

    "")

    2 )FB

    *+)

    )

    "FFJ)

    "

    "*&"A)

    2

    '%,%)

    0")

    2"" "* +

    )

    2 " """0'"2/")"%*(

    )""A'

    )

    '*!"

    )

    0")

    '

    " A " "'" " )*G5

    )2"$"

    9>%9@J&F&:, ;

    %/!(%! %"*#$"##)#

    K* 66 * E77* &2" . / '" % % /%*('"')"%%/"%!%*

    G5.%+(%*9>@*G:.%+(%*9>@2*

    by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from

    http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/

  • ;6+'

    /&2".)

    '/"2

  • !;

    &*">:99769?6@6%:@

    2 ) 2&" '''J

    )')

    )(%))

    ""* ) &2"

    .""$"0

    ))')0'

    $

    '"/0 *& !")

    "F8"

    )"0',)"'

    ' * &2" . 2

    )'"' ?('%"'"P"Q )'

    ')

    *>9

    +)2"2))' '

    ''2&2".K)"

    "*$$"22 K)

    * 8)"""')A

    "'""'"

    &2".

    *(#"#

    " '""" ')

    A2 )"&"))"'

    ''')"?

    #"#"?U))""2)"

    &"J2"2"'"'

    '*B

    ")""'

    )"''S"?U"("

    )""

    "

    )" %%*+

    )2',+%%*B"'%""""""2")""S>G

    &""")(''*,K

    ""? -")"") J "

    )))# **%*B'"''2S>>K2''#"

    #*$

    2""")

    ' ''1""' )"

    &"""'"*K'

    '

    >9.%+(%*9>@*>G.%+(%*9>E*>>.%+(%*9>E2*%22

    4+,)'''" 2"2$)''"2)2!"*

    by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from

    http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/

  • ;
  • !;!

    &*">:99769?6@6%:@

    (K)"4"#)))

    "'"2&"2 "*

    ))4"/) ""'

    &""'" ("*"/&"

    ""$

    " "2

    2 2 " " *& " "

    )2$"""&2".

    ) " 2 %% A" /&04"/"'/"

    8""4"/"*+

    $""))'()

    )"''" A

    $"3

    '*+

    22""'"A"'

    )) " ' " *>C+

    )"2))'4"/"A"

    )'"")&")2

    )2 "0")4"/

    )" ' """ "1"*

    &2".2 " 2K'

    %%*K""'#"#)""0' &"

    "'"*("''2 K

    &2". ' $"" "

    ''3''))'"*(

    "" &2".) ) 0"

    K )""'"*+

    '

    '"#"

    #"'1"""')"

    )

    '" ")" 7"FB

    *#"# """"*+"

    /0 )

    "'"))

    *0

    )"3*>5#"/##"8""))2 ""

    )

    '" *"("

    $""&""'"))2'

    ' '" "*1" 2"

    "$""!"*K''"

    *() 0' !"'"/*K

    " "''

    )?

    >C&"#255*G:E%>95"

    ')'"*>5.%+(%*9>5*

    by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from

    http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/

  • ";
  • !;

    &*">:99769?6@6%:@

    "/" "2 " ) !"*&")

    "" "*/)" *$

    " )" "" " *& A"

    '2" )'"

    " ''" *&2 "

    .0A" ""

    2'J""&""'")

    "" " *+) )"2"*#"

    '")"

    "2"")"2'

    (""" 0"2""P

    'QI0"I2*F"2

    &"2'" 0""1*&"")'"''

    02 2"'")'""

    "'"&"""'"*

    + "" " PQ 2"

    )"'"'&""'"*B!"""

    2'*+ )!""&

    ")$

    )"$'")$"*@6

    #

    (2))".%!%&2". '3"'$"'

    *

    ""'"""''

    ))"*+.%+(%'2"'") )

    .%!%"')" '""2)" 2*+

    )?

    +("")''3

    ''")P3

    1% Q*&)!"$ "")"""")

    )""2

    ")2'2) !"*

    /"")""

    @6

    %%%" /I6>?9C"@?6*.% +(%*9>:%9@7*&0A"2)'

    22J

  • ;G97777* "

    ")''

    ")6C95777)"*+

    ")677777*+"

    '"")''

    "%)69:E777)"*+")67777*+"

    "'

    "%)J"5E>777)"*+")6777*+"

    ")''

    ")>G9777)"*+"677*+)'

    "/"%,%''%*+"""/0 J )*

    B " " )' " / 0 '"

    "2'")")*+'

    ""2'"B"#" %%*$"""*B

    ) " ) "

    2 ''*()GE7""

    '"J'""

    '*B2'""""J'

    )"")*+'

    "%*+!"$ )$)"")'"

    ' ' 3' ) " " 2*+ P

    ("Q2)6777"2'

    "*+ @7""*+("

    ")2 2 2

    ')2D"*@9

    &2" . $" '' &"

    ) ' """"$3'''""'2''')

    ')'T)'"2")

    2 2)T

    2 .%+(%?

    @9.%!%42*-*96E*9>>*

    by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from

    http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/

  • !;

    &*">:99769?6@6%:@

    , ') 0"'

    )0"'217)G777 % ) - 2 3"''

    "

    F20P2)Q**&"*$ )" !"%%2"

    2')" )% +2 '

    %("'+*$)'2"""''")

    22")))

    2 "

    ")*

    (" '"&" )'

    )

    2")3!"(%/)

    " "'")) 2!")

    20'

    '0*#)

    '%*& 2)

    2"))

    22")")

    2'"2"!"$ *$)

    ''*!"

    ')

    )'" "0

    '0)

    2'"*()

    ))

    ' '"' )

    " "2 ("

    ')" '*+)! )

    ""$")

    2HB*&

    /)

    ''")"")

    "

    2'2""2 )

    *

    ()

    )

    ""

    ")

    2' *1))

    "

    "

    2 )

    *,)")

    2"

    """ " )*& 2''")

    ))" %(%")

    '

    ' +%/ )'*,))")

    ""2'

    ""

    2 )

    ''

    %/)%+'-)

    )"%% ''"')PQ""")

    ' A" $

    "

    '2) %" *B'')""'"!"$ 2 2 ')""2*

    +)2)'(%"?0/)')"J'" /)')''"J

    by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from

    http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/

  • ;7*

    #$%

    &2".)# )3)

    $")"2"")"('

    *+'''"'" "3'*&2

    #"#) '/ )'/ "' "F2) 2'(' (2"

    *$" "$"2"

    '2 " A" " ))

    *#"#))3*$)

    "2$" "."/2'

    "")&2'")

    )""

    *#'"'"")3'

    *@>#') 2"" ()

    2''" '' "*@@ &2".

    )"'

    " #'/&''" '/

    72 ")"$"*!"10

    ***K"'"2 "K#

    "$

    )""2'%" "'

    @G.%!%42*-*96E*9>>%9>@2*@>*.*+"1GHIH9GJKL!2*6:5%99@J,''$

    A*6:9%975*@@&.&1*

    by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from

    http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/

  • !;

    &*">:99769?6@6%:@

    )"K" ? ) " 3*#10""'

    K""2""" '

    '*

    #/2!" "

    # (2 " " " '* #"

    #1" *$"(2)

    " )

    2 ")*@E&2".''

    $")"2D '*

    $"' $" ""

    *(''72 "$")"7) 'I*

    B'"')&2"..%+(%)'"*B)' $"S&"3&2".

    "

    ''$"+% 3*&))

    2) 0 &2"

    . $") "

    "'"&"*B)'"%)'")"'&2".

    """'$"'" )'" )

    *+%) '"'') ' 7*) 2"A' '7)"2'' 2*BA'3

    )3'"2'''*(''

    )"2'''H3

    'A'?

    (657@,'B""3')"

    A"' $%*+A"))B")" " 3') )"*+

    A")B") (JA"' ") '"*$ '" ) ) ' "

    2 % 1%% )'

    "

    ' )' ")" B"*

    @E,''$A*

    by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from

    http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/

  • ;:%@9*.' ' ' 3 " )'""'"2"'' H

    (")

    *6@6%@>*-'31$%""9)

    $"2#.#&')''"''F

    " &2*@5+)2)))*D';;'* ' 6> * CG:

    %$%J'2

  • !;

    &*">:99769?6@6%:@

    B'".%+(%"''' A(2 )&""

    '' ))$"' *(

    ''"))""2&2".

    )2)")*B

    ) 2)")""' "%*B"2"''''

    ")(''*&"'")2% "'' *+2&"

    'A" "($*

    +''"'

    )"2 ')

    22 "*/&"""$

    )"2"

    "))"*+$"")

    "J$"!"'""3"*

    +$"!"

    " )

    2")"&"*+'' 2&"*+

    ")""" 'K"

    $"

    ' "?"

    '&"

    '"K'"'" *'

    &"2&"""*+'

    "*+)' )

    '" 2

    '"&" ''"2'")

    "

    "*('"'' " "'

    """ )' 2*+

    I7'"2%*+ '/ "I"" ' "'('3))"$"'*

    &2".""'$"' ('

    ")

    *$''A&2"

    2&22

    "')""'

    I&2 8 2 8+2 " )'

    'I/@%/$)I'"/*$'"""" 4"/) ))2

    !" 0' " *" "4"/2

    " )"")''"

    &""'"("*

    B)/"" "#"&)"

    ')''*+"&)"

    "8$%'" 3":%

    by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from

    http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/

  • ;
  • !;!

    &*">:99769?6@6%:@

    '' )"

    PQ*+"' "'""""'

    "" "2) )'F"*!"T23"T"?&*P$)Q""2

    "P"Q

    2'2 2 3'

    )" *$'? $)'"'2)"'""'2

    2')

    *+ !"T23"T

    '?

    *#')

    )"'2")"*#3' )2"

    ) P$Q2 "

    *&$D(PQ,?

    4;B"S

    B2;(2 2)'

    + )" "$ ;$)'$"2'

    "S

    ,';$(

    PQ*

    !"T$23"T"?58&8&$

    '$) *A2'PQ")

    )))"* ( ) " )

    *+

    )"" 2*4

    (2''*#'32

    (2**#'(2'

    2")S

    ,"2"P2QP"Q)" "

    '*$D"T!""'2T

    ) *$'? & ! .*$'23"2*!""?5&*B)"'22S+ ))" "'

    ' *+ )

    ")*""

    *#'2)S$D

    /)0$D"PQ'' ?

    +"

    )" '*

    by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from

    http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/

  • ";
  • !;

    &*">:99769?6@6%:@

    22*&

    ))" 2 "2

    1%&)"'1% ' # )

    ) ) S")

    2) 2)#"A3S+

    )"2 )' % '" 1%%) " /2 " " %%" # ) " "

    3"2""'%%

    "(J"'")'&2".)")"

    ") )('""'

    *

    %&%'((

    H) '0' '""'

    &2".) )2"2 )'

    3)"""""'*+"2'"2

    )"*+)

    "') *()"

    ('" &2' J2 0

    " " ) )' '"! "

    .A")"2)

    "" " 2(*EG''"

    ) ") ""

    2('*('"'A

    %%"2 #&2

    ,D 20' %%))2")")C777C")2''')"" / %%%*E>&2".2 "

    '

    ""2'*+"')'

    )") '".%+(%2

    EG"++ "A('("-!

    &*+)("'&2'2

    )3)2 ("*#'

    &2="&"2#:%1.%/""2**$K*9*6>E%>C*,"''3/"+& '

    ,('$ *,

    ''"(')

    )"10F.D%&%"*"&.9%

    )+%*GC%:C*&''" 3'+

    /)3"'"

    0''*

    E>%%A#&2,D"'*65%6:*

    by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from

    http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/

  • ;
  • !;

    &*">:99769?6@6%:@

    ('!#?B''2

    /2()"B"#" %% )''2 /2)2(""

    ' D*

  • ;C*C7 ) %. + / %(% /

    IC7?>*C6.%!%42**9>G%9>>*

    by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from

    http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/

  • !;

    &*">:99769?6@6%:@

    )"3 2'"2'"

    ('"2' *C9

    B''"&2".)'"2

    '' ("'"('""

    )#"22")

    )"*+#'2""

    '2 "? " ("'' "2 "/"' "#"#'(' *B) &2".

    ) 2 )"&"*'

    )#&"#"'"677777&"

    "(2&2"B"#

    " %%")"*CG

    )()

    +'23)'&2".

    3"')"'"*B

    """)"(""2"")"

    ""'2 '"'

    "'2" "''*C>(&2".

    "")" (" " " "" '

    #2"') 2%" 12")')" 22""

    )("*')2"

    )

    " 2"") "'

    $" "'$""*

    () '' " )) ""

    12") "' ,( " " "*C@+)&2".

    ' ) 2

    "" ,*B '" " ' "

    '''"('2''2

    ''"*+ ''"'

    " 2 "*

    C9*/1 / #22 D*-* ,* 9>5 * >6J/%"+ 2/% !4/1))2DD

    42&

    * 6C5@*" 2 &2" =(% /1%!%/ !"*"#22 *C7E*

    CG#&"#"+%K*9*>9%>>*C>&+ ##",&2F*6EE%CG*C@#&+"2)?' )"'

    ("*

    by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from

    http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/

  • ;
  • !;

    &*">:99769?6@6%:@

    "2)2 ''*B

    ')"'2)' '

    S$2 )')'"

    " "2""

    ')2

    "

    *C:

    ,&2".2''"

    '%)')*U #"#"K

    %"))2'"2 )*#'"''"2)' '' "

    *$2)'""'

    20'2 "!")

    2*57

    & &2" . ' ' 5J

    $*!*1#"K*97%9EJ&*4*$("+"'?

    #".0((*6*G9%GE*9E@%56J*/*#+"'*

    by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from

    http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/

  • ;@2%9>E*59- '"'!" K"AK

    1+A$"3**

    $$"*6C:%:6*

    5GK))&;$*6>%6E6:%G@*5>.%+(%*9>E*

    by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from

    http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/

  • !; !

    &*">:99769?6@6%:@

    +))

    *A)!*5@&2"

    . ''" .%+(%) *$) $" &""'" 2

    ' '")*

    ("" ) ' ' 0*

    +") " '*5E

    *+(%,

    +'#&2"."! '

    ' '

    ")'' ' " ''* (

    )"'

    ' """""

    2"

    )" ""

    """")'3 "

    '' ("*$" ''')

    ''2""*'&"

    22""?%(&2!"J!"$/'") '2/!"

    *

    ") .%+(% " 22 $"" """

    "'2 '2)""

    "*+2")2'"'"'2)

    ) '2''

    ''"*B' ) ' &2"

    . ) '* () " '

    '))"

    "

    ) 2 " '

    (' "*

    &2" . ' ) ' " '""

    2 )" "*$"

    5@B)&2".'" (""

    '')')'*+

    ' (" A#''''

    **8'4'#.2 2)#'"("

    &3@G*9>C%EG*(''"(""!

    " "' )""*,3#)"

    A(

    '"'A "A'

    ""*#8B2" 5*3$B * C:* # " '" (" " 'A "')""("*#AH*B

    +F''(*96:*66999*5E.%+(%*9>:2*

    by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from

    http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/

  • !";
  • !;!

    &*">:99769?6@6%:@

    "''' ) 2)

    $")"("*+"

    3''" '3

    *$)''*$""

    2D(' ")"'"

    *&0' )")&"'

    )")""""&""

    " *+H )" 2 '

    '')"'" 1)

    B"3 )" 2)"')"

    '

    ' ""'' *+)"'"

    20 H

    " *55) &2" .

    ""' '"

    $"))"")''"

    )" &"H"2"2

    32"")"*5:

    ( 2" ' 2'

    ' " '"'1)B"

    2 *B"2"

    2"'2).

    ""3"')

    ("''")'

    ) "

    *B &2".) )

    ''("'2"2'

    '")

    "

    '")"' ''

    ' *(')"

    '2"""'3

    )

    ') )*

    #%

    &222/""*2%!%?):%%+""&$&2""& 6:@>*1)F

    6::C*

    &2,D 220./!/#"&"/"* *& 977@JH *

    $*#*8"*8"#*F

    9775*

    55&A "-

    '3!&B#**67%6>9C%@EJ."VA WVY"W?4'NK( O' "

    Y' '

    'YY YYY

    FY'Y&&*5:4 !.!*67:%977*

    by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from

    http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/

  • !;*

    TTT*+F2B?. 4)"A'

    ("."-$"F"B2""#*

    &3'$4"9766*5%G:*

    &D"#0#2*551)U9766*

    &K))*;$F

    6:5@*

    "-.

    1("A0"&0

    !"$F

    9779*9>%>G*

    TTT**

    &,"F*;+'%""*+6:E6*

    TTT*/'%1K"*+6::>*

    TTT*!%'%".D#/""*+977:*

    "L&2" I" %/) "' 2+ $* #2

    K*9+9776*

    &2="&"2#*:%1.%/"*Y$

    A6:76*

    1%$%A2",D,D#(-('6@>>"(-('

    >@9& "&'

    ' - " ("-'

    '+

    424"*

    ','*$A?&('K)$"!"#"#'

    7A)$"("*,"

    F6:::*6:9%975*

    1$%)$" 2 #.#

    *

    F&$#0D*-%-.%4')655@J *'4)'1)U

    6::9*

    HB*"'*4)'41)U9779*

    HY$*#$ &B-3"

    6:7G*

    by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from

    http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/

  • !;!

    &*">:99769?6@6%:@

    ,1*.*&3*2&

    2"977E*

    ,"I$"#*%/-%"*".D&K*6+

    977:*

    !"&*#&")."*1

    #?.%4"

    977E*G@7%E6*

    $8*2345'6:@G*

    $&$*/% &%/#""+2"*+6::9*

    $%(-('6CCC&"&'

    '-"("-'

    '+424"*

    $D.**;%&7;%'6:@5*

    $&*4* ("+"'?#".0 ((*6*G9%GE$

    *5K*96G6:C6*9E@%56*

    (2&2F*!-+%/-U"*"2(2"

    "A6:C9*

    (.D* !3 & -# /'

    9779*

    8'2$*=+$O?*

    "/"&2"*"*#!A$:1

    -A2'42AK*N(K*A6:C7*

    1$*!*#"K+/1

    2#

    "

    &6C6:@@*97%9E*

    -,''*8:%%?&"F""H

    #&"&'#"2

  • !;5#22D*

    #)F"2&2".*!!)%/"

    ("(2"*."6::C*

    #)F"*%$%H 42#F A"

    1)F

    6:C7*

    / % "+ . /% ! 4/# * ,* 6C5@ 1))2

    D

    42& *

    #"&@%C@*

    KK" A* 1+ A K" AK "*

    $"3**$$"

    4')977@*6C:%:6*

    K."'*A( " A"A*F*"

    #'-"&'#"4"6:55*

    K*$%**F

    6::5*

  • !;!

    &*">:99769?6@6%:@

    BAH*+F''(B*$

    "F"*4

    "&$#=!4"6::6*96:%G5*="* &2". F*F "*1

    &F

    6:57*G@9%@>*

    =&"2&2"*(%1%!%/ !"#22 "6:59*

    by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from

    http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/

    /ColorImageDict > /JPEG2000ColorACSImageDict > /JPEG2000ColorImageDict > /AntiAliasGrayImages false /DownsampleGrayImages true /GrayImageDownsampleType /Bicubic /GrayImageResolution 300 /GrayImageDepth -1 /GrayImageDownsampleThreshold 1.50000 /EncodeGrayImages true /GrayImageFilter /DCTEncode /AutoFilterGrayImages true /GrayImageAutoFilterStrategy /JPEG /GrayACSImageDict > /GrayImageDict > /JPEG2000GrayACSImageDict > /JPEG2000GrayImageDict > /AntiAliasMonoImages false /DownsampleMonoImages true /MonoImageDownsampleType /Bicubic /MonoImageResolution 1200 /MonoImageDepth -1 /MonoImageDownsampleThreshold 1.50000 /EncodeMonoImages true /MonoImageFilter /CCITTFaxEncode /MonoImageDict > /AllowPSXObjects false /PDFX1aCheck false /PDFX3Check false /PDFXCompliantPDFOnly false /PDFXNoTrimBoxError true /PDFXTrimBoxToMediaBoxOffset [ 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 ] /PDFXSetBleedBoxToMediaBox true /PDFXBleedBoxToTrimBoxOffset [ 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 ] /PDFXOutputIntentProfile () /PDFXOutputCondition () /PDFXRegistryName (http://www.color.org) /PDFXTrapped /Unknown

    /Description >>> setdistillerparams> setpagedevice