Air Breathing Propulsion Systems Integration Technical Committee

47th AIAA/ASME/SAE/ASEE Joint Propulsion Conference & Exhibit San Diego, California31 July - 3 August 2011

August 1, 2011Jeff Flamm

2

Agenda for JPC 11

• Introductions/Guests• Goals• Sub-committee vacancies• Liasons• PAW – Chen Chuck• GARTEUR (Group of Aeronautical Research and Technology in Europe,

http://www.garteur.eu/) - Thomas Berens• H&A• AIAA Conference Reorganization• Hand out Shirts!

3

Goals for tonight

Succession Plan for sub-committees AIAA conference reorganization ABPSI position Increase Liaison Activities

ABPSITC New Members Demographics

4

Name Affiliation Background Years Experience

Segment

Christopher Hughes

NASA Propulsion Airframe Acoustics

32 Govt.

Neal Herring UTRC Thermal Management 4 Industry

Angela Scribben

AFRL Airframe Propulsion Integration

8 Govt.

Tim Warlick Raytheon Engines and Fuels 34 Industry

5

ABPSITC Current Membership# First Last Description AIAA Member Grade Organization1 Charles Beard Member Senior Member Boeing2 Dyna Benchergui International Senior Member Bombardier3 Thomas M. Berens International Senior Member EADS Military Air Systems4 Raymond Best Member Associate Fellow Hawker Beechcraft Corporation5 Norbert Bissinger International Associate Fellow EADS?6 Keith Blodgett Member Associate Fellow GE Aviation7 Jay Carskaden Member Senior Member The Boeing Company8 Clarence Chenault Member Associate Fellow Aerospace Business Development Associates (ABDA)9 Chen Chuck Member Associate Fellow The Boeing Company

10 Roderick Daebelliehn Member Senior Member Aerojet11 Anne-Laure DeLot International Senior Member ONERA12 Vance F. Dippold, III Member Senior Member NASA Glenn Research Center13 Jeffrey Flamm Chair Associate Fellow NASA Langley Research Center14 David Forliti Member Senior Member The State University of New York at Buffalo15 Ian Halliwell Member Associate Fellow AVETEC Inc16 Jeffrey Hamstra Member Fellow Lockheed Martin17 Neil Herring Associate   UTRC18 Christopher Hughes Member Associate Fellow NASA GLENN RESEARCH CENTER19 Stephen Johnson Member Senior Member Northrop Grumman20 John Kelly Member Senior Member 717th Test Squadron Arnold AFB21 Douglas Kisling Member Associate Fellow Belcan Corp.22 Jonathan Litt Member Senior Member NASA Glenn Research Center23 Eric Loth Member Associate Fellow University of Illinois24 Donald J. Malloy Member Associate Fellow Aerospace Testing Alliance, Inc.25 Dave Mayer Member Associate Fellow Boeing26 Bruce McKay Member Senior Member Lockheed Martin Aeronautics27 Michelle McMillian Member Senior Member SynGenics Corporation28 Angela Scribben Member   AFRL29 David Wang Member Member Air Force Flight Test Center, Edwards AFB30 Tim Warlick Member   Raytheon Missile Systems31 William Westphal Member Associate Fellow Rolls-Royce Corporation32 Bryan Westra Member Member Northrop Grumman

6

JPC 11 Attendance# First Last Description AIAA Member Grade Organization1 Thomas M. Berens International Senior Member EADS Military Air Systems2 Keith Blodgett Member Associate Fellow GE Aviation3 Chen Chuck Member Associate Fellow The Boeing Company4 Roderick Daebelliehn Member Senior Member Aerojet5 Anne-Laure DeLot International Senior Member ONERA6 Vance F. Dippold, III Member Senior Member NASA Glenn Research Center7 Jeffrey Flamm Chair Associate Fellow NASA Langley Research Center8 Ian Halliwell Member Associate Fellow AVETEC Inc9 Jeffrey Hamstra Member Fellow Lockheed Martin

10 Neil Herring Associate UTRC11 Stephen Johnson Member Senior Member Northrop Grumman12 Jonathan Litt Member Senior Member NASA Glenn Research Center13 Donald J. Malloy Member Associate Fellow Aerospace Testing Alliance, Inc.14 Dave Mayer Member Associate Fellow Boeing15 Bruce McKay Member Senior Member Lockheed Martin Aeronautics16 Michelle McMillian Member Senior Member SynGenics Corporation17 David Wang Member Member Air Force Flight Test Center, Edwards AFB18 Tim Warlick Member Raytheon Missile Systems19 William Westphal Member Associate Fellow Rolls-Royce Corporation2021 Guests22 Bob Nichols AEDC/Air Force23 Reginold Floyd AEDC/Air Force24 David Young Raytheon2526272829303132

7

Air Breathing Propulsion System Integration TC – Office Holders

TC ChairmanJeff Flamm

Vice ChairMichelle McMillan

Past ChairRaymond Best

Joint Propulsion ConferenceRod Daebeliehen

Aerospace Sciences MeetingVance Dippold

CommunicationsNeal Herring

Honors & AwardsKeith Blodgett

EducationRod Daebelliehn

MembershipKeith Blodgett

Integrated Aero Performance

Thomas Berens

Subsystem, Performance, Optimization Bruce Mckay

Propellers/Pistons/

Turboprops Vacant

Requirements Verification,

Certification and Testing Bob Nichols

Service Subcommittees

Technical Subcommittees

Conference Subcommittees

8

Systems Integration Technical Areas and population

Integrated Aero Performance (10 members)– Thomas Berens – Chair, Vice Chair Chris Hughes

Subsystem, Performance, Optimization (8 members)-Chair Bruce McKay

Propellers/Pistons/Turboprops (3 members)– ??? Chair, Charles Beard Vice Chair

Requirements Verification, Certification and Testing (3 members)

– Bob Nichols Chair, Dave Wang, Vice Chair ABPSI Steering (8 members)

99

Systems Integration – Member Positions and population

• TC Chair – Jeff Flamm Vice Chair – Michelle McMillin

• Membership – Keith Blodgett Applications & Data Recruiting Member Upgrades

• Communications – Neal Herring Sub comm. Vice Chair -?? Year in Review Article- Dyna Benchergui Newsletter - Website – Anne-Laure Delot

• Education – Rod Daebelliehn Sub comm Vice Chair Chen

Chuck Student Design Competition

– Bill Westphal– Neal Herring

Outreach – Chen Chuck

Short Courses– Chen Chuck

• Honors and Awards – Keith Blodgett Sub Comm Vice Chair Vance

Dippold Propulsion Award Packages -

EVERYBODY Student Award - Vance Dippold Best Paper Awards - Bryan

Westra

1010

Systems Integration – Member Positions and population

• ASM - 5 ASM 09 Jeff Flamm (Orlando) ASM 10 Vance Dippold (Orlando) ASM 11 –Don Malloy (Orlando) ASM 12 – Vance Dippold (Nashville) ASM 13 – Dyna Benchergui (Dallas) ASM 14 – Need Volunteer Washington DC ASM 15 – Need Volunteer Orlando

• JPC – 5 JPC 09 Doug Kisling (Denver) JPC 10 Don Malloy (Nashville) JPC 11 Rod Daebelliehn (San Diego) JPC 12 – Michelle McMillan (Atlanta) JPC 13 – Bruce McKay (San Jose) JPC 14 – Chris Hughes (Cleveland) JPC 15 (New Orleans?)

In addition, all member are expected to be session chairs and conduct abstract reviews for our conferences

11

Air Breathing Propulsion Systems Integration TC Scope & Charter

Scope• The application of mechanical design, fluid mechanics and thermodynamics to the

science and technology of air vehicle propulsion and power systems integration, including: Installed performance and controls (SPO, PPT) Propulsion aerodynamics; inlet and nozzle systems (IE) Power and thermal management (SPO, PPT) All aspects of propulsion system / air vehicle interface and certification (RVCT)

Charter: Advance air breathing propulsion integration technology by: • Developing and sponsoring technical sessions at ASM, JPC and other conferences of interest • Working effectively with AIAA TCs and PCs and other technical societies to organize and

promote joint sessions and activities • Providing for technical communications and reviews, educational activities, and honors and

awards• Providing the Institute with authoritative technical opinions and public policy recommendations

Near Goal: Update the Short Course to include certificationLong term is a book on the same subject.Mid Term Goal Develop a workshop ala DPW or High Lift – work with A/C Design or

Flow Control Committees

12

Chair – Bruce Mckay – Lockheed Martin

• Charter: • Promote & Facilitate Communication in support of Efficient Interaction, And

Performance Of Air Breathing Propulsion SystemsScope:• Exploit Synergies in Aeropropulsion, Thermal And Power Subsystems• Performance Modeling And Validation• Cognizance in the contributions of Advanced Materials, Sensing, Controls, Maintenance• New Challenges In Green Aircraft – Operations, Emissions, Noise • Foster Discussions And Ideas - New Energy Sources, and synergies with alternate

energy being developed for ground based energy.

• Outline established for Technology Advocacy Paper examining auxiliary electric concepts

Subsystem, Performance, Optimization Technical Area Scope & Charter

13

Propellers/Pistons/Turboprops (Rotors) Technical Area Scope & Charter

Chair - VacantScope

Create the focal point for concepts and issue resolution related to the airframe integration of propellers, pistons and turboprop engines

CharterTo provide a forum for the design, development and certification of powerplant installations for piston and turboprop aircraft.

Topics for consideration Propellers

– Un-ducted fans (rotor burst, noise and icing protection) Pistons

– Avgas and Diesel FADEC Engines– Elimination of Leaded AV Gas

Turboprops– 300 – 500 SHP engines for light GA Aircraft

14

Chair - Thomas Berens, EADSScope

Focus on the development and Performance of aircraft inlets, nozzles and exhaust systems.

CharterEmphasis on both computational and experimental results (including sub-scale and flight components), component optimization, inlet and exhaust system design techniques, propulsion test techniques at speeds ranging from subsonic through hypersonic.

Topics for consideration

Integrated Aero Performance Technical Area Scope & Charter

STOVLJet EffectsThrust vectoringArea controlSurvivabilityThrust reversersNacelle/wing interactionUnducted fan

Flow control application including scaling effectsAircraft performanceStructural integration of inlets and exhaust systemsReal world operation environmental issues (ice, sand, rain, FOD, bugs, etc…)Acoustics

Acoustic treatments Affect of inlet and nozzle on sonic boom

High Speed Applications

Name Changed from Inlets & Nozzles to better reflect Scope

15

Requirements Verification, Certification and Testing Technical Area Scope & Charter

Chair – Donald J. Malloy, Aerospace Testing Alliance, Bob Nichols to take over for Don, TN Vice Chair Dave Wang

ScopeAll aspects of air breathing propulsion integration certification and testing

including:Installed performance and controlsPropulsion aerodynamics; inlet, nozzle and systemsPower and thermal management

Charter Advance air breathing propulsion integration testing technology by:

• Developing and sponsoring technical sessions at the IGTI Turbo Expo in collaboration with ASME IGTI Aircraft Engine TC

• Develop and Sponsoring Technical Sessions at the ASM, JPC and other conferences of interest in collaboration with the SAE S-16 Engine Inlet Flow Distortion TC

• Working effectively with the ABPSI Inlets/Exhausts and SPO technical areas and other technical societies to organize and promote joint sessions and actives

1616

Conference Paper Statistics

JPC ‘10

ASM ‘11

JPC ‘11

CoNA ‘11

ASM ‘12

Abs. Received: 11 12 26 26 18

Abs. Accepted: 8 10 25 26 16

Sessions: 3 3 5 55

(3w/AP)

Withdraw/No-Show: 1/0 2/0 6/- - -

17

Website

Webmaster – Anne-Laure Delot anne-laure.delot@onera.fr https://info.aiaa.org/tac/PEG/ABPSITC/default.aspx

18

ABPSITC Membership Profile – ASM 2011

Government 8

Industry 21

Academia 2

Total 32

ABPSI has room to grow (max is 35)

Members 26

Associate 1

International 4

* Dual 2

Everyone should be at least a Senior Member!

ASM '09 JPC '09 ASM '10 JPC '10 ASM ‘11 JPC ‘11Fellow 0 0 0 0 1

A. Fellow 11 12 12 13 13Senior 8 11 12 16 18

Member 9 8 7 7 4GPA 2.07 2.13 2.16 2.17 2.31

Committee Member TypeOccupation Distribution

AIAA Membership Grade & GPA

19

How do we increase ABPSI TC member attendance at conferences

13 of 32 members present at JPC 11 (3 guests)• 13 of 36 members present at ASM 11 ( RSVP 8 yes, 9 no)• 16 of 36 Members present at JPC 10 (17 RSVP yes, 4 No)• 14 of 31 Members present at ASM 10• 16 of 31 Members present at JPC 09• 17 of 29 Members present at ASM 09• 20 of 29 Members present at JPC 08• Bad Trend

20

Minimum Expectations of TC members

Attend at least 1 meeting preferably two a year Review papers Chair sessions Serve on at least two sub committees 1 service and 1

technical– Take a leading role for a function of at least 1 sub-committee

Other Suggestions

What is the role of a Tech sub-committee

• At minimum Help define call for papers - assure relevance and timeliness of the call Support conferences by organizing special topic sessions/panels

• Expanding White papers Position papers Develop Short course or module in a short course Liason with other TC’s and societies Text books Standards definitions Workshops

21

What do want to do as a TC beyond conferences?

• Workshop– Workshops collaborate with Aircraft Design TC also Flow Control TC (aggressive

serpentine inlet or supersonic inlet)» UHB» Open Rotor» Optimization of vehicle-next gen fighter/uav» Thermal management

• Books• White papers• Special sessions

4 Panel sessions – 1 for each Tech area at JPC 12

• Invited sessions• Short course

22

Liasions• Other AIAA TC’s/PC’s

Fluids Dynamics TC - Flamm contributed to Flow Control Book Ground Test – Keith Blodgett Aerodynamics – Eric Loth Joint Session at ASM ‘12 Potential joint panel session with GTTC for JPC ‘12 Joint technical sessions HSABP and GTTC for JPC ‘12

• Other Societies ASME propulsion committee Don Malloy/David Wang/Chris Hughes

– Sponsoring technical sessions at the IGTI Turbo Expo in collaboration with ASME IGTI Aircraft Engine TC – Propulsion Integration Panel discussion

– IECE Joint Panel on Horse Power Extraction – Need Panelist (Bruce McKay volunteered)• Local Sections

Hampton Roads Section – Jeff Flamm Tennessee Section – Maloy Northern Ohio Section - Litt

• Other ICC - Ice Crystal Consortium coordinated with AIA – Ray Best PPSA – Jeff Flamm

• Ground Test Committee – DOE Focus Group David Wang

23

ABP Best Paper Awards

Session Chairs please email best paper selections to

Bryan Westra bryan.westra@ngc.com

Dave Mayer David.W.Mayer@boeing.com

Awarded for the best technical paper presented in an Air Breathing Propulsion Session at the 2011 Joint Propulsion Conference or

2012 Aerospace Sciences Conference

Best Paper AwardsSelection Process

• Each TC (ABPSI, HSABP, GTE) selects a best paper from their respective sessions at the prior year JPC and current year ASM Session chairs identify best paper from their respective technical sessions The best paper focal forms a selection team Selection follows a judging process and selection criteria each TC develops their own process, for example

The best of the best papers is then selected• Award presented at the current year JPC

Scoring CriteriaWeighting

Factor(A)

RATING (B)

SCORE (AxB)

Excellent Poor

5 4 3 2 1

Technical Content 5

Relevance 4

Completeness 3

Writing Quality 2

ABPSI Best Paper Awards

ABPSI Best Paper 2010/2011 Powered Model Wind Tunnel Test of a High Offset Subsonic Turoprop Intake AIAA-2010-6502 Luis P. Ruiz-Calavera, David E. Funes-Sebastian, and David Perdones-Diaz, AIRBUS MILITARY, Getafe (Madrid), 28906, Spain

Judges: Bryan Westra, Jeff Flamm, Keith Blodgett, Norbert Bissinger, Neal Herring, Dave Mayer

Awarded for the best technical paper presented in an Air Breathing Propulsion Session at the 2009 Joint Propulsion Conference or

2010 Aerospace Sciences Conference

27

Logo Shirt purchase Status

• Purchased shirts with TAC funds• Shirts delivered at JPC 11• Setup fee is paid and logo is available for

purchase on your own from LandsEnd Business outfitters

• http://ocs.landsend.com/cd/frontdoor?store_name=corpsales&store_type=1

• Ph 800-587-1541• Logo#: 0941796w• Logo embroidery cost is $10.50 normally• Note they often run specials for free logo (up

to $8.50)

28

AIAA Conference reorganization

Suggest poll of AIAA general membership before going ahead with final changesAIAA has high conference fees – Concern that reorg may not improve high fee structure Defense Forum is in direct competition with JANNAF

Do we really want to do that?What value/differences do we add?May have to stick it out a few years to draw participationConcern about classified as too expensive/difficult – stick with ITAR alone

General feeling that focused conferences have a place in addition to the larger onesWas how the TC’s Map to conferences considered?

ABPSI possibly has to support 3 of the 4 proposedTC’s organized by discipline, proposed conferences organized by product – Since TC’s support conferences they may need to be reorganized in the same wayJPC 2nd biggest AIAA conference and money maker

Why break it up?Aviation conferences are close coupled time wise – 3 months apart – concern that is too close. Current 6 month interval liked sbetter

29

Accomplishments from JPC 10

• Vice Chair candidate identified• List of potential new TC members developed• Additional Liaison activities/opportunities identified• Conference planners identified for JPC ‘12 and ’13• TC Members to canvas peers for paper submissions• Game plan for purchasing logo shirts

30

Accomplishments from ASM 11

• Additional sub-committee and conference leads identified• POC for Centennial of Naval Aviation – ?• Supersonic Inlets Special Joint Session w/ Applied Aero

planned for ASM ’12 (Loth and Babinsky) • 6th Edition of the AIAA Aerospace Design Engineers Guide

Book – update (Rockensies)• Website Updated• YIR article – Dyna Benchergui• 5 new member applicants• Additional Liaison activities/opportunities identified• Game plan for purchasing logo shirts – Really!

31

Accomplishments from JPC 11

• New sub-committee leads identified Blodgett H&A, Mckay SPO, Nichols RVCT

• Identified additional Liasons

• Held Kick-off meeting for Propulsion Aerodynamics Workshop (PAW)

• Seek potential invited session ‘13/’14: GARTEUR (Group of Aeronautical Research and Technology in Europe, http://www.garteur.eu/) - Thomas Berens

• Potential joint panel session with GTTC for JPC ’12 McMillan• Joint technical sessions HSABP and GTTC for JPC ’12 McMillan• YIR article – Dyna Benchergui

• 4 new members

• logo shirts – delivered!

Backup

32