20
AIMS AMP CAPITAL Publication The Straits Times Date 1 September 2016 Headline Reit sector unfazed by tech disruption By Marissa Lee More consumers are going online to look for value buys but famous shopping strips like London's Bond Street, Tokyo's Ginza and New York's Fifth Avenue are not disappearing either. The brick-and-mortar endorsement came yesterday from Mr Ho Sing, chief executive of YTL Starhill Global Reit Management, who told a forum the threat of e-commerce to Orchard Road is "overrated". He was one of four Reit managers who gave their views on the challenges faced by the different real estate investment trust (Reit) sub-sectors in Singapore. E-commerce is widely expected to have a disruptive impact on retail landlords, but Mr Ho is less concerned. He said: "When we try to mitigate this online shopping thing, actually we don't need to do much... It's the value shopper that goes online most of the time." He noted that necessity spending will continue to prop up suburban malls, and people tend to buy higher-value items online only if they cannot be found in Singapore. In fact, online shopping has boosted retail overall, said Mr Ho, because it has educated the consumer. Mr Koh Wee Lih, chief executive of Aims AMP Capital Industrial Reit, told the event hosted by Macquarie Securities: "Whether you buy from a retail outlet or online, the fulfilment is probably cleared out by a warehouse, so we benefit regardless." Meanwhile, the rising popularity of Airbnb and other room-rental booking sites has put pressure on the hospitality sector. But Mr Ronald Tay, chief executive of Ascott Residence Trust Management, feels the effect on his Reit is less immediate for now. "Airbnb is a disruptor, we acknowledge that. But Ascott Reit is more focused on corporate travel vis-a- vis leisure travel," he said, noting that 85 per cent of the Reit's business in Asia comes from corporate travel, and corporates typically do not book rooms on Airbnb. Airbnb and Ascott's serviced apartments are competing on different price points as well, he added.

AIMS AMP CAPITAL Septemb… · AIMS AMP CAPITAL Publication The Straits Times Date 1 September 2016 Headline Reit ... "Airbnb is a disruptor, we acknowledge that. But Ascott Reit

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    4

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: AIMS AMP CAPITAL Septemb… · AIMS AMP CAPITAL Publication The Straits Times Date 1 September 2016 Headline Reit ... "Airbnb is a disruptor, we acknowledge that. But Ascott Reit

AIMS AMP CAPITAL

Publication The Straits Times

Date 1 September 2016

Headline Reit sector unfazed by tech disruption

By Marissa Lee

More consumers are going online to look for value

buys but famous shopping strips like London's

Bond Street, Tokyo's Ginza and New York's Fifth

Avenue are not disappearing either.

The brick-and-mortar endorsement came

yesterday from Mr Ho Sing, chief executive of YTL

Starhill Global Reit Management, who told a forum

the threat of e-commerce to Orchard Road is

"overrated".

He was one of four Reit managers who gave their

views on the challenges faced by the different real

estate investment trust (Reit) sub-sectors in

Singapore.

E-commerce is widely expected to have a

disruptive impact on retail landlords, but Mr Ho is

less concerned. He said: "When we try to mitigate

this online shopping thing, actually we don't need

to do much... It's the value shopper that goes

online most of the time."

He noted that necessity spending will continue to

prop up suburban malls, and people tend to buy

higher-value items online only if they cannot be

found in Singapore. In fact, online shopping has

boosted retail overall, said Mr Ho, because it has

educated the consumer.

Mr Koh Wee Lih, chief executive of Aims AMP Capital Industrial Reit, told the event hosted by Macquarie

Securities: "Whether you buy from a retail outlet or online, the fulfilment is probably cleared out by a

warehouse, so we benefit regardless."

Meanwhile, the rising popularity of Airbnb and other room-rental booking sites has put pressure on the

hospitality sector.

But Mr Ronald Tay, chief executive of Ascott Residence Trust Management, feels the effect on his Reit

is less immediate for now.

"Airbnb is a disruptor, we acknowledge that. But Ascott Reit is more focused on corporate travel vis-a-

vis leisure travel," he said, noting that 85 per cent of the Reit's business in Asia comes from corporate

travel, and corporates typically do not book rooms on Airbnb.

Airbnb and Ascott's serviced apartments are competing on different price points as well, he added.

Page 2: AIMS AMP CAPITAL Septemb… · AIMS AMP CAPITAL Publication The Straits Times Date 1 September 2016 Headline Reit ... "Airbnb is a disruptor, we acknowledge that. But Ascott Reit

Singapore is the third-biggest Reit market in the Asia-Pacific region after Japan and Australia, with S-

Reits trading at an average yield of 6 per cent, offering the highest yield spread in developed Asia.

But the Singapore Reit, or S-Reit, sector has slowed down since the first Reit was listed in 2002.

"From 2002 to 2007, you probably saw about 7 per cent to 8 per cent growth in distribution per unit

(DPU) and 4 per cent growth after the great financial crisis," said Mr Tuck Yin Soong, executive director

of Macquarie Securities Singapore. Macquarie is forecasting DPU growth of about 0.2 per cent per

annum in the next two years.

And competition is brewing - the Philippines, Indonesia and India are pushing towards establishing their

own Reit regimes.

But Ms Ng Hsueh Ling, chief executive of Keppel Reit Management, pointed out that it takes time to

build a Reit market.

"Good laws and regulations, no capital controls, no cash trap... these are things that make or break a

Reit market," she said.

Separately, market talk has been that mergers and acquisitions could be a trend to watch in the S-Reits

sector.

Mr Tay said: "I think consolidation is something that is going to be inevitable. A lot of institutional

investors look at (trading) liquidity and size, and some (Reits) are not quite there. Consolidation is not

necessarily a bad thing from an industry point of view."

Page 3: AIMS AMP CAPITAL Septemb… · AIMS AMP CAPITAL Publication The Straits Times Date 1 September 2016 Headline Reit ... "Airbnb is a disruptor, we acknowledge that. But Ascott Reit

Publication The Straits Times

Date 1 September 2016

Headline Reit sector unfazed by tech disruption

By Marissa Lee

URL http://www.straitstimes.com/business/reit-sector-unfazed-by-tech-disruption

E-commerce threat to Orchard Road and suburban malls overrated, says one manager

More consumers are going online to look for value buys

but famous shopping strips like London's Bond Street,

Tokyo's Ginza and New York's Fifth Avenue are not

disappearing either.

The brick-and-mortar endorsement came yesterday

from Mr Ho Sing, chief executive of YTL Starhill Global

Reit Management, who told a forum the threat of e-

commerce to Orchard Road

is "overrated".

He was one of four Reit managers who gave their views

on the challenges faced by the different real estate

investment trust (Reit) sub-sectors in Singapore.

E-commerce is widely expected to have a disruptive

impact on retail landlords, but Mr Ho is less concerned.

He said: "When we try to mitigate this online shopping

thing, actually we don't need to do much... It's the value

shopper that goes online most of the time."

He noted that necessity spending will continue to prop

up suburban malls, and people tend to buy higher-value

items online only if they cannot be found in Singapore.

In fact, online shopping has boosted retail overall, said

Mr Ho, because it has educated the consumer.

Mr Koh Wee Lih, chief executive of Aims AMP Capital

Industrial Reit, told the event hosted by Macquarie

Securities: "Whether you buy from a retail outlet or

online, the fulfilment is probably cleared out by a

warehouse, so we benefit regardless."

Meanwhile, the rising popularity of Airbnb and other

room-rental booking sites has put pressure on the

hospitality sector.

But Mr Ronald Tay, chief executive of Ascott Residence

Trust Management, feels the effect on his Reit is less

immediate for now.

"Airbnb is a disruptor, we acknowledge that. But Ascott

Reit is more focused on corporate travel vis-a-vis leisure

Page 4: AIMS AMP CAPITAL Septemb… · AIMS AMP CAPITAL Publication The Straits Times Date 1 September 2016 Headline Reit ... "Airbnb is a disruptor, we acknowledge that. But Ascott Reit

travel," he said, noting that 85 per cent of the Reit's business in Asia comes from corporate travel, and

corporates typically do not book rooms on Airbnb.

Airbnb and Ascott's serviced apartments are competing on different price points as well, he added.

Singapore is the third-biggest Reit market in the Asia-Pacific region after Japan and Australia, with S-

Reits trading at an average yield of 6 per cent, offering the highest yield spread in developed Asia.

But the Singapore Reit, or S-Reit, sector has slowed down since the first Reit was listed in 2002.

"From 2002 to 2007, you probably saw about 7 per cent to 8 per cent growth in distribution per unit

(DPU) and 4 per cent growth after the great financial crisis," said Mr Tuck Yin Soong, executive director

of Macquarie Securities Singapore. Macquarie is forecasting DPU growth of about 0.2 per cent per

annum in the next two years.

And competition is brewing - the Philippines, Indonesia and India are pushing towards establishing their

own Reit regimes.

But Ms Ng Hsueh Ling, chief executive of Keppel Reit Management, pointed out that it takes time to

build a Reit market.

"Good laws and regulations, no capital controls, no cash trap... these are things that make or break a

Reit market," she said.

Separately, market talk has been that mergers and acquisitions could be a trend to watch in the S-Reits

sector.

Mr Tay said: "I think consolidation is something that is going to be inevitable. A lot of institutional

investors look at (trading) liquidity and size, and some (Reits) are not quite there. Consolidation is not

necessarily a bad thing from an industry point of view."

Page 5: AIMS AMP CAPITAL Septemb… · AIMS AMP CAPITAL Publication The Straits Times Date 1 September 2016 Headline Reit ... "Airbnb is a disruptor, we acknowledge that. But Ascott Reit

Publication The Business Times

Date 1 September 2016

Headline Singapore Reits hitting their limit over compliance rules

By Lee Meixian

Singapore real estate investment trust (Reit)

managers believe the stricter rules that kicked in

for the sector this year have raised the Republic's

Reit hub status. But they are quick to add that a

breather is needed on compliance rules.

Any more, and it will be too painful to bear, and

may even result in a "diminishing returns"

situation, they say.

At a roundtable discussion organised by

Macquarie Securities on Wednesday, Reit

managers were asked for their wish list: what

changes they would like to see in the Reit code

that governs them.

Ho Sing, CEO of the manager for Starhill Global

Reit, said that the rule changes - which mostly

focus on improving disclosures, prudence and

aligning managers' interests with unitholders' -

have been "very positive" in boosting the faith that

external investors and credit ratings agencies

have in the system.

"But going forward, we do see a very significant increase in compliance costs from a legal perspective

and regulatory perspective. I have not seen it approach that point yet, but I do hope that they will not

keep adding up the compliance regime such that you get diminishing returns.

"In fact, when it goes into diminishing returns, that's when you see Reits delisting, because it is easier

to keep the yield private and enjoy it even without the tax-free (benefits) . . . my wish list is that I hope

that they monitor it to the extent that it doesn't reach that diminishing returns point."

His view was shared by the other three managers, from Keppel Reit, Ascott Residence Trust and AIMS

AMP Capital Industrial Reit, on the panel.

Ng Hsueh Ling, CEO of the manager for Keppel Reit, also took issue with the fact that Reits are put in

the same compliance and regulatory ranks as financial institutions (FIs) by the Monetary Authority of

Singapore (MAS), which again increases compliance expenses.

Banks and Reits are the only listed companies that have to abide by both MAS and Singapore Exchange

(SGX) guidelines; most others need only adhere to rules enacted by the latter.

These MAS guidelines deal with a whole gamut of issues from how Reits treat information, to how they

outsource business processes, or ensure that their service providers meet certain recovery standards.

The thinking behind this is that Reits, like banks and insurers, are deemed to be financial products as

they deal with a lot of "mom-and-pop" money, thus necessitating the added layer of protection.

Page 6: AIMS AMP CAPITAL Septemb… · AIMS AMP CAPITAL Publication The Straits Times Date 1 September 2016 Headline Reit ... "Airbnb is a disruptor, we acknowledge that. But Ascott Reit

Furthermore, SGX's push towards sustainability initiatives could pile on more compliance costs for S-

Reits, said Ms Ng. "My wish list is that we can make it a good environment to attract global capital, but

don't make it so prescriptive that the Reits can't breathe or move."

Ronald Tay, CEO of the manager for Ascott Residence Trust, agreed. "I really think that Reits shouldn't

be viewed in the same light as FIs. The requirements for anti-money laundering kind of compliance . . .

We don't lend money.

"Just because we all have the same licence that we are governed by, the same compliance standard,

that to me could be a little bit punishing. I don't know whether it's possible to look into slightly different

kinds of compliance that will allow us more breathing space."

Other wishes mentioned include a reinstating of the stamp duties remission for local property purchases,

vacancy rebates (such that Reits are not taxed on the vacant portion of their new buildings), and more

transparency on how taxation on overseas investments and tax structures for international investors will

move, going forward.

Page 7: AIMS AMP CAPITAL Septemb… · AIMS AMP CAPITAL Publication The Straits Times Date 1 September 2016 Headline Reit ... "Airbnb is a disruptor, we acknowledge that. But Ascott Reit

Publication The Business Times

Date 1 September 2016

Headline Singapore Reits hitting their limit over compliance rules

By Lee Meixian

URL http://www.businesstimes.com.sg/real-estate/singapore-reits-hitting-their-limit-over-

compliance-rules

Singapore real estate investment trust (Reit) managers believe the stricter rules that kicked in for the

sector this year have raised the Republic's Reit hub status. But they are quick to add that a breather is

needed on compliance rules.

Any more, and it will be too painful to bear, and may

even result in a "diminishing returns" situation, they

say.

At a roundtable discussion organised by Macquarie

Securities on Wednesday, Reit managers were

asked for their wish list: what changes they would

like to see in the Reit code that governs them.

Ho Sing, CEO of the manager for Starhill Global

Reit, said that the rule changes - which mostly focus

on improving disclosures, prudence and aligning

managers' interests with unitholders' - have been

"very positive" in boosting the faith that external

investors and credit ratings agencies have in the

system.

"But going forward, we do see a very significant

increase in compliance costs from a legal

perspective and regulatory perspective. I have not

seen it approach that point yet, but I do hope that

they will not keep adding up the compliance regime

such that you get diminishing returns.

"In fact, when it goes into diminishing returns, that's

when you see Reits delisting, because it is easier to

keep the yield private and enjoy it even without the

tax-free (benefits) . . . my wish list is that I hope that

they monitor it to the extent that it doesn't reach that

diminishing returns point."

His view was shared by the other three managers,

from Keppel Reit, Ascott Residence Trust and AIMS

AMP Capital Industrial Reit, on the panel.

Ng Hsueh Ling, CEO of the manager for Keppel

Reit, also took issue with the fact that Reits are put

in the same compliance and regulatory ranks as

financial institutions (FIs) by the Monetary Authority

of Singapore (MAS), which again increases

compliance expenses.

Page 8: AIMS AMP CAPITAL Septemb… · AIMS AMP CAPITAL Publication The Straits Times Date 1 September 2016 Headline Reit ... "Airbnb is a disruptor, we acknowledge that. But Ascott Reit

Banks and Reits are the only listed companies that have to abide by both MAS and Singapore Exchange

(SGX) guidelines; most others need only adhere to rules enacted by the latter.

These MAS guidelines deal with a whole gamut of issues from how Reits treat information, to how they

outsource business processes, or ensure that their service providers meet certain recovery standards.

The thinking behind this is that Reits, like banks and insurers, are deemed to be financial products as

they deal with a lot of "mom-and-pop" money, thus necessitating the added layer of protection.

Furthermore, SGX's push towards sustainability initiatives could pile on more compliance costs for S-

Reits, said Ms Ng. "My wish list is that we can make it a good environment to attract global capital, but

don't make it so prescriptive that the Reits can't breathe or move."

Ronald Tay, CEO of the manager for Ascott Residence Trust, agreed. "I really think that Reits shouldn't

be viewed in the same light as FIs. The requirements for anti-money laundering kind of compliance . . .

We don't lend money.

"Just because we all have the same licence that we are governed by, the same compliance standard,

that to me could be a little bit punishing. I don't know whether it's possible to look into slightly different

kinds of compliance that will allow us more breathing space."

Other wishes mentioned include a reinstating of the stamp duties remission for local property purchases,

vacancy rebates (such that Reits are not taxed on the vacant portion of their new buildings), and more

transparency on how taxation on overseas investments and tax structures for international investors will

move, going forward.

Page 9: AIMS AMP CAPITAL Septemb… · AIMS AMP CAPITAL Publication The Straits Times Date 1 September 2016 Headline Reit ... "Airbnb is a disruptor, we acknowledge that. But Ascott Reit

Publication The Business Times

Date 1 September 2016

Headline Partnering competitors - Reits find ways around disruption

By Lee Meixian

Real estate investment trusts (Reits) have their ways of

dealing with competition from disruptors such as Airbnb and

e-commerce, whose consumers tend to be more price-

sensitive, they say.

One way is by working with the competition. The other is by

changing their product range to not cross paths with their

disruptors'.

At a roundtable organised by Macquarie Securities on

Wednesday, CEO of the manager of Ascott Residence Trust,

Ronald Tay, said the trust has tried listing its properties on

Airbnb to see if they would garner any booking. "So far the

result is nil, zero," he said.

He believes this is because of the price point - people who

book accommodation on Airbnb tend to be leisure travellers

and bargain hunters, quite different from Ascott Reit's profile

of corporate travellers for its serviced residences.

"At this point in time, as a disruptor to our business, I would say (Airbnb) is fairly insignificant, but it is

not something we are not concerned about," Mr Tay said.

Its sponsor Ascott last year bought a minority stake in Tujia.com - dubbed China's Airbnb and the

country's largest online apartment sharing platform equivalent - to better understand how disruptors

work.

"There are ways and means that we can collaborate with them, and tap their database and business

model to also increase our business profile globally as well," he said.

Addressing the e-commerce threat, Ho Sing, CEO of the manager of Starhill Global Reit and himself an

avid online shopper, said the trust has side-stepped offerings on shopping websites by adding and

improving the food and beverage options in its malls.

"We are not selling mass market things; we are not selling S$5 burgers. Things are a little bit more

artisanal: Japanese concepts, modern concepts, even for the food court itself, we emphasise quality,"

he said.

He noted that electronics stores such as Best Denki have evolved into selling white goods and home

theatre appliances, big items that would not have been easy to transport from overseas. Being

expensive, buyers would also prefer to inspect their features in person before committing their

purchases. This is a space e-commerce will find it difficult to get into.

On the resurgence of vinyl, as people have recently begun to appreciate the quality of music again,

more are now buying vinyl records from retail stores. "They don't take the risk of the thing coming

cracked in three pieces when they buy online, so the vinyl stores have come back," he said.

Page 10: AIMS AMP CAPITAL Septemb… · AIMS AMP CAPITAL Publication The Straits Times Date 1 September 2016 Headline Reit ... "Airbnb is a disruptor, we acknowledge that. But Ascott Reit

At this, Koh Wee Lih, CEO of the manager of AIMS AMP Capital Industrial Reit, could not help but add:

"I'm pleased to know that whether you buy from Orchard Road or you buy from online, the fulfilment is

probably carried out by warehouses, so we'll benefit regardless."

He added that a lot of the pick-up in demand for logistics space recently has come from local companies

dealing with local deliveries of food and everyday products to retail stores and hotels. "We have actually

seen the local boys picking up the business, asking for more space from us, versus maybe the

international players," he said.

The trust has nine warehouses island-wide and is adding one more in 2017.

Page 11: AIMS AMP CAPITAL Septemb… · AIMS AMP CAPITAL Publication The Straits Times Date 1 September 2016 Headline Reit ... "Airbnb is a disruptor, we acknowledge that. But Ascott Reit

Publication The Business Times

Date 1 September 2016

Headline Partnering competitors - Reits find ways around disruption

By Lee Meixian

URL http://www.businesstimes.com.sg/real-estate/partnering-competitors-reits-find-ways-

around-disruption

Real estate investment trusts (Reits) have their ways of

dealing with competition from disruptors such as Airbnb and

e-commerce, whose consumers tend to be more price-

sensitive, they say.

One way is by working with the competition. The other is by

changing their product range to not cross paths with their

disruptors'.

At a roundtable organised by Macquarie Securities on

Wednesday, CEO of the manager of Ascott Residence

Trust, Ronald Tay, said the trust has tried listing its

properties on Airbnb to see if they would garner any

booking. "So far the result is nil, zero," he said.

He believes this is because of the price point - people who

book accommodation on Airbnb tend to be leisure travellers

and bargain hunters, quite different from Ascott Reit's profile

of corporate travellers for its serviced residences.

"At this point in time, as a disruptor to our business, I would

say (Airbnb) is fairly insignificant, but it is not something we

are not concerned about," Mr Tay said.

Its sponsor Ascott last year bought a minority stake in

Tujia.com - dubbed China's Airbnb and the country's largest

online apartment sharing platform equivalent - to better

understand how disruptors work.

"There are ways and means that we can collaborate with

them, and tap their database and business model to also

increase our business profile globally as well," he said.

Addressing the e-commerce threat, Ho Sing, CEO of the

manager of Starhill Global Reit and himself an avid online

shopper, said the trust has side-stepped offerings on

shopping websites by adding and improving the food and

beverage options in its malls.

"We are not selling mass market things; we are not selling

S$5 burgers. Things are a little bit more artisanal: Japanese

concepts, modern concepts, even for the food court itself,

we emphasise quality," he said.

He noted that electronics stores such as Best Denki have

evolved into selling white goods and home theatre

Page 12: AIMS AMP CAPITAL Septemb… · AIMS AMP CAPITAL Publication The Straits Times Date 1 September 2016 Headline Reit ... "Airbnb is a disruptor, we acknowledge that. But Ascott Reit

appliances, big items that would not have been easy to transport from overseas. Being expensive,

buyers would also prefer to inspect their features in person before committing their purchases. This is a

space e-commerce will find it difficult to get into.

On the resurgence of vinyl, as people have recently begun to appreciate the quality of music again,

more are now buying vinyl records from retail stores. "They don't take the risk of the thing coming

cracked in three pieces when they buy online, so the vinyl stores have come back," he said.

At this, Koh Wee Lih, CEO of the manager of AIMS AMP Capital Industrial Reit, could not help but add:

"I'm pleased to know that whether you buy from Orchard Road or you buy from online, the fulfilment is

probably carried out by warehouses, so we'll benefit regardless."

He added that a lot of the pick-up in demand for logistics space recently has come from local companies

dealing with local deliveries of food and everyday products to retail stores and hotels. "We have actually

seen the local boys picking up the business, asking for more space from us, versus maybe the

international players," he said.

The trust has nine warehouses island-wide and is adding one more in 2017.

Page 13: AIMS AMP CAPITAL Septemb… · AIMS AMP CAPITAL Publication The Straits Times Date 1 September 2016 Headline Reit ... "Airbnb is a disruptor, we acknowledge that. But Ascott Reit

Publication ReitsWeek

Date 1 September 2016

Headline Singapore REITs well-poised to weather downturn in economy, say CEOs

By Ridzwan Rahmat

URL http://www.reitsweek.com/2016/09/singapore-reits-well-poised-to-weather-downturn-

in-economy-say-ceos.html

Amid a slowing economy, Singapore REITs are generally

well-positioned to weather the downturn and adapt to

industry disruptors across sectors that they operate in,

said the CEOs of four REIT managers during a media

roundtable hosted by Macquarie Securities on 31 August.

The session was attended by Koh Wee Lih, Ronald Tay,

Ho Sing and Ng Hsueh Ling, CEOs of the managers for

AIMS AMP Capital Industrial REIT, Ascott Residence

Trust (Ascott REIT), Starhill Global REIT, and Keppel

REIT respectively.

On the industrial front, the drop in global commodities

meant some multinationals had reduced their space

needs in Singapore but there is rising demand from

Singapore companies, said Koh.

“Growing trends such as online retail has also created

new opportunities for the industrial REIT sector. Whether

you buy from Orchard Road or online, the fulfilment is

carried out by warehouses so it will benefit the industrial

sector, particularly the warehouse and logistics segment”,

he added.

Stahilll Global REIT too has said that it remains unfazed

on the growing popularity of online retail. “We remain

strong because of our prime locations and tenant mix

while catering to a differentiated segment of retail”, said

Ho.

“In fact, online shopping has actually helped Singapore retail by educating consumers on new brands

overseas, so that ups the game for retail and increases the opportunities where we can push for better

shopping experiences and new tenant mix”, he added.

With regards to demand for hospitality properties and the effects of disruptors, Ascott REIT commented

that it targets a different market segment than those who use services such as Airbnb.

“As a majority of Ascott REIT’s business is from corporate travellers, we do not see a significant impact

on our business by sharing economy providers that appeal more to leisure travellers”, said Tay, adding

that the REIT’s sponsor has also embraced the effect of disruptions by investing in Tujia, China’s largest

online apartment sharing platform.

However compliance costs remain a challenge for Singapore REITs and the CEOs have reiterated the

call for REITs to be differentiated from financial institutions in terms of scrutiny.

Page 14: AIMS AMP CAPITAL Septemb… · AIMS AMP CAPITAL Publication The Straits Times Date 1 September 2016 Headline Reit ... "Airbnb is a disruptor, we acknowledge that. But Ascott Reit

“I hope we maintain a good regulatory and compliance environment for attracting global capital into

Singapore REITs”, said Ng, who added that Keppel REIT remains in good stead despite the slowing

demand in office space due to a strategy of adopting forward renewals and lease extensions for existing

tenants.

Page 15: AIMS AMP CAPITAL Septemb… · AIMS AMP CAPITAL Publication The Straits Times Date 1 September 2016 Headline Reit ... "Airbnb is a disruptor, we acknowledge that. But Ascott Reit

Publication TODAY

Date 1 September 2016

Headline Opening of flagship stores highlight Orchard Road’s appeal

By Lee Yen Nee

URL http://www.todayonline.com/business/opening-flagship-stores-highlight-orchard-roads-

appeal

The rise of suburban malls and e-commerce may

have affected retailers on Orchard Road, but the

opening of flagship stores by international brands

here is testament that the shopping belt has not

totally lost its sheen, said the chief executive of

Starhill Global Reit.

“We will not see things like the first flagship stores

opening in suburbs. I don’t think that’s the trend …

the first landing point for most retail (brands), in any

city in the world, is the core downtown. So, the

location strength can’t change,” said Mr Ho Sing, who

was one of the panellists at a roundtable discussing

the challenges and outlook for Singapore’s real

estate investment trusts (Reits).

Japanese retailer Uniqlo will open its first South-east

Asian global flagship store at Orchard Central

tomorrow. Several others, including US lingerie

brand Victoria’s Secret, fashion house Michael Kors

and Apple, are also adding their flagship stores to the

belt.

Mr Ho said amid the challenging retail landscape,

tenant mix is key to maintaining an edge and the Reit

has been working on introducing new-to-market

brands at its malls. Starhill Global Reit’s portfolio

includes Wisma Atria and Ngee Ann City on Orchard

Road.

He added that while e-commerce has attracted

shoppers looking for value buys, many still prefer to

purchase higher value items in store. Therefore,

premium shopping destinations such as London’s

Bond Street, Japan’s Ginza and New York’s Fifth

Avenue will continue to attract traffic.

The Reit sector in Singapore, or S-Reits, has held up

despite the increasingly challenging economic

environment with a year-to-date gain of 11 per cent,

outperforming the benchmark Straits Times Index’s 2

per cent loss, noted Mr Soong Tuck Yin, executive

director of Macquarie Securities Singapore, who was

the moderator at yesterday’s roundtable.

Page 16: AIMS AMP CAPITAL Septemb… · AIMS AMP CAPITAL Publication The Straits Times Date 1 September 2016 Headline Reit ... "Airbnb is a disruptor, we acknowledge that. But Ascott Reit

“Since the inception of Reits from 2002 till now, the growth rates have slowed … so the environment

has been a little bit more challenging. However, S-Reits’ yield of 6.1 per cent offers the highest yield

spread in developed Asia relative to Hong Kong, Australia and Japan. Organic growth is a big challenge

(for S-Reits), so overseas expansion is a key trend in the last three to four years,” he said.

“There’s still a group of investors out there chasing yields. Secondly, post-Brexit, there’s some money

flowing from European real estate investments into Asia due to concerns over what will happen in

Europe due to the uncertainties.”

Page 17: AIMS AMP CAPITAL Septemb… · AIMS AMP CAPITAL Publication The Straits Times Date 1 September 2016 Headline Reit ... "Airbnb is a disruptor, we acknowledge that. But Ascott Reit

Publication ReitsWeek

Date 1 September 2016

Headline Starhill Global REIT allays concerns over popularity of online shops, suburban malls

By Ridzwan Rahmat

URL http://www.reitsweek.com/2016/08/starhill-global-reit-allays-concerns-over-popularity-

of-online-shops-suburban-malls.html

Despite the growing popularity of online shopping and

suburban malls, the manager of Starhill Global REIT

remains confident about its prospects for the years ahead,

citing the REIT’s quality of properties and tenant mix.

These remarks come amid concerns that Orchard Road,

where Starhill Global REIT’s two Singapore properties are

located, may have lost its lustre as the republic’s premier

shopping destination.

Starhill Global REIT derives 61.9% of its revenue for its 4Q

2016 from its Singapore properties.

“The key things have not changed”, said Ho Sing, CEO of

Starhill Global REIT’s manager, in reference to shopper’s

habits. “We will continue to leverage on our quality and

location strength, and our tenant mix as key drivers for the

markets that we operate in”, he added.

Ho was speaking with three other Singapore REITs at a

media roundtable organised by Macquarie Securities in

Singapore on 31 August.

In his elaboration, Ho highlighted that established

international brands will usually select a downtown

location, such as Orchard Road, to launch a flagship store

when first entering a particular market.

“You will not see a flagship store opening in the suburbs”,

said Ho, citing Apple, which will be launching its first official

retail outlet in Singapore on Orchard Road, as an example.

“Decentralisation to suburban malls happen for mass market brands. The first landing point for a more

premium brand is always the core downtown area, just like Tokyo’s Shinjuku and Ginza”, he said, adding

that Starhill Global REIT targets a similar premium market segment when selecting its tenants.

Ho also posits that Singapore is still behind shopping other destinations such as Hong Kong and Tokyo

in terms of variety in the choice of premium international brands.

“We see a lot of headroom for international brands to come in to Singapore”, he said, adding that Starhill

Global REIT’s properties, Wisma Atria and Ngee Ann City, are well positioned to tap on this demand.

Besides Singapore, Starhill Global REIT currently has a portfolio of 12 primarily retail properties in

Australia, China, Japan and Malaysia.

Page 18: AIMS AMP CAPITAL Septemb… · AIMS AMP CAPITAL Publication The Straits Times Date 1 September 2016 Headline Reit ... "Airbnb is a disruptor, we acknowledge that. But Ascott Reit

Units of Starhill Global REIT finished the trading day unchanged from its previous close on the

Singapore Exchange at SGD0.805.

Page 19: AIMS AMP CAPITAL Septemb… · AIMS AMP CAPITAL Publication The Straits Times Date 1 September 2016 Headline Reit ... "Airbnb is a disruptor, we acknowledge that. But Ascott Reit

Publication Malay Mail Online

Date 1 September 2016

Headline Opening of flagship stores highlight Orchard Road’s appeal

URL http://www.themalaymailonline.com/money/article/opening-of-flagship-stores-in-

singapore-highlights-orchard-roads-appeal

The rise of suburban malls and e-commerce may have

affected retailers on Orchard Road, but the opening of

flagship stores by international brands here is

testament that the shopping belt has not totally lost its

sheen, said the chief executive of Starhill Global Reit.

“We will not see things like the first flagship stores

opening in suburbs. I don’t think that’s the trend … the

first landing point for most retail (brands), in any city in

the world, is the core downtown. So, the location

strength can’t change,” said Mr Ho Sing, who was one

of the panellists at a roundtable discussing the

challenges and outlook for Singapore’s real estate

investment trusts (Reits).

Japanese retailer Uniqlo will open its first South-east

Asian global flagship store at Orchard Central

tomorrow. Several others, including US lingerie brand

Victoria’s Secret, fashion house Michael Kors and

Apple, are also adding their flagship stores to the belt.

Mr Ho said amid the challenging retail landscape,

tenant mix is key to maintaining an edge and the Reit

has been working on introducing new-to-market brands

at its malls. Starhill Global Reit’s portfolio includes

Wisma Atria and Ngee Ann City on Orchard Road.

He added that while e-commerce has attracted

shoppers looking for value buys, many still prefer to

purchase higher value items in store. Therefore,

premium shopping destinations such as London’s

Bond Street, Japan’s Ginza and New York’s Fifth

Avenue will continue to attract traffic.

The Reit sector in Singapore, or S-Reits, has held up

despite the increasingly challenging economic

environment with a year-to-date gain of 11 per cent,

outperforming the benchmark Straits Times Index’s 2

per cent loss, noted Mr Soong Tuck Yin, executive

director of Macquarie Securities Singapore, who was

the moderator at yesterday’s roundtable.

“Since the inception of Reits from 2002 till now, the

growth rates have slowed … so the environment has

been a little bit more challenging. However, S-Reits’

yield of 6.1 per cent offers the highest yield spread in

Page 20: AIMS AMP CAPITAL Septemb… · AIMS AMP CAPITAL Publication The Straits Times Date 1 September 2016 Headline Reit ... "Airbnb is a disruptor, we acknowledge that. But Ascott Reit

developed Asia relative to Hong Kong, Australia and Japan. Organic growth is a big challenge (for S-

Reits), so overseas expansion is a key trend in the last three to four years,” he said.

“There’s still a group of investors out there chasing yields. Secondly, post-Brexit, there’s some money

flowing from European real estate investments into Asia due to concerns over what will happen in

Europe due to the uncertainties.”