Upload
enforcement-defense
View
36
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Alleged mortgage fraud regarding investment properties, etc..
Citation preview
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
FRANKLIN COUNTY, OHIO
MARCIA GARCIA
Plaintiff,
v.
RODNEY BREWER, et al.,
Defendants,
UNITED MIDWEST SAVINGS BANK,
Third Party Plaintiff
v.
GENEROSA SIA, et al.,
Third Party Defendants.
AGREED JUDGMENT ENTRY AND ORDER OF FORECLOSURE
CASE NO. 11CV-12-15529
JUDGE K. COCROFT
This cause came before the Court on the Complaint ofPlaintiff, the Answer,
Counterclaim and Third Party Complaint ofDefendant, United Midwest Savings Bank, the
Answer and Disclaimer of Interest of Third Party Defendants, Deutche Bank National Trust and
Lomas Mortgage, USA, the Answer of Search2close, and the Appearance ofThird Party
Defendant, Generoso Sia, Jr..
The Court, having considered the pleadings, motions, the parties agreement, and the
evidence adduced, finds as follows:
1. Plaintiffand all Third Party Defendant have been properly served with summons and a
copy of the Counterclaim and Third Party Complaint ofDefendant, United Midwest Savings
Bank;
2. All parties necessary for a complete adjudication of this matter, Defendant, United
Midwest Savings Bank's, Counterclaim and Third Party Complaint are properly before this
Court;
3. Defendant, Deutche Bank National Trust, has, through its Answer to the Third Party
Complaint denied and expressly disclaimed any right, title and interest in and to the subject
property known as 67 E. Weber Road, Columbus, Ohio 43202. Furthermore, said Defendant has
been dismissed from the Third Party Complaint, via Notice of Dismissal of Third Party
Defendant, Deutche Bank National Trust, filed by Defendant, United Midwest Savings Bank, on
or about May 30,2012;
4. Defendant, Lomas Mortgage has been dismissed from the Third Party Complaint, via
Notice ofDismissal ofThird Party Defendant, Lomas Mortgage, filed by Defendant, United
Midwest Savings Bank, on April 16, 2012.
5. In entering into this Agreed Judgment Entry and Order of Foreclosure, Plaintiff and
Third-party Defendant, Generoso Sia, a.k.a. Generosa T. Sia, Jr., a.k.a. Generoso T. Sia, Jr., state
and affirm to the Court that they are not married. Accordingly, Third Party Defendants,
Unknown Spouse, if any ofMarcia Garcia, and Unknown Spouse, if any of Generosa Sia, are
hereby dismissed from the Third Party Complaint;
6. Plaintiff, Marcia Garcia, a.k.a Marcia M. Garcia, and Third Party Defendant, Generoso
Sia, have agreed to and consent to the entry ofjudgment for foreclosure of the subject property
known as 67 E. Weber Road, Columbus, Ohio 43202 (PN: 010-016448-00) and described
more particularly as:
Situated in the State of Ohio, County ofFranklin and in the City of Columbus, to-wit:
Being part of Lot Number Two Hundred Four (204) and part of the east one-halfof LotNumber Two Hundred Five (205) of CRESTVIEW ADDITION TO THE CITY OFCOLUMBUS, as the same are numbered and delineated upon the recorded plat thereof,ofrecord in Plat Book 8, Pages 11A and 1IB, Recorder's Office, Franklin County, Ohioand more particularly described as follows:
Beginning at a point in the south line of Weber Road, and the northeast corner of LotNumber Two Hundred Four (204); then in a southerly direction along the east line of LotNo. 204, 94.20 feet to a point; thence in a westerly direction and at right angles 37.50 feetto a point in Lot No. 205; thence in a northerly direction and parallel with the east line ofLot No. 205, 76.95 feet to a point in the south line of Weber Road; thence in a easterlydirection along the south line ofWeber Road, to the place ofbeginning.
Excepting, reservations, conditions, restrictions and easements, if any, of record.
7. Plaintiff, Marcia Garcia, and Third Party Defendant, Generoso Sia, executed the Note
described in the Counterclaim and Third Party Complaint now owned and held by Defendant,
United Midwest Savings Bank;
8. The Note was not paid according to its terms, and as a consequence, there is due and
owing to Defendant, United Midwest Savings Bank, on the debt secured by the Mortgage, the
sum ofTwo Hundred, Forty-two Thousand, Three Hundred, Seventy-one Dollars and Seventy-
eight Cents ($242,371.78) with interest at the rate of 5.125% per annum from and after July 1,
2008, plus late fees and costs necessary to preserve the subject property;
9. Plaintiff, Marcia Garcia, unmarried, and Third Party Defendant, Generoso Sia,
unmarried, are the owners of record of the subject property;
10. In order to secure payment of the Note, Plaintiff, Marcia Garcia, and Third Party
Defendant, Generoso Sia, executed and delivered a Mortgage, as set for the in the Second Count
ofDefendant, United Midwest Savings Bank's, Counterclaim and Third Party Complaint,
thereby conveying the subject property to Defendant, United Midwest Savings Bank, its
successors and assigns;
11. The Mortgage was duly recorded in the Office of the Recorder of Franklin County, Ohio
on December 28, 2007 as Instrument Number 200712280220886 and thereby became and is a
valid first mortgage lien on the subject property;
12. The conditions of the Mortgage have been broken and the same has become absolute.
Accordingly, Defendant, United Midwest Savings Bank, is entitled to have the equity of
redemption and dower, if any, of all parties, to this Agreed Entry, in and to the subject property
foreclosed;
13. In order to further secure payment of the Note, Plaintiff, Marcia Garcia, executed and
delivered a UCC Financing Statement, as set for the in the Third Count ofDefendant, United
Midwest Savings Bank's, Counterclaim and Third Party Complaint, thereby conveying the
personal property, fixtures, inventory which are raw materials, work in progress, or materials
which may be used in the construction or improvement of the subject property, which may or
may not be found at the subject property;
14. The UCC Financing Statement was duly recorded in the Office of the Recorder of
Franklin County, Ohio on December 28, 2007 as Instrument Number 200712280220912 and
thereby provided Defendant, United Midwest Savings Bank, with a security interest in the
personal property described therein;
15. In consideration for the agreement ofPlaintiff, Marcia Garcia, and Third Party
Defendant, Generoso Sia, to the entry ofjudgment and order of foreclosure contained herein,
Defendant, United Midwest Savings Bank, has agreed to waive any and all rights to any
deficiency judgment against Plaintiff, Marcia Garcia, and Third Party Defendant, Generoso Sia,
and upon confirmation of any judicial sale held on connection with this action, the obligations
evidenced by the Note and Mortgage shall be deemed satisfied in full;
16. The Parties to this Agreed Entry desire to release and discharge one and other from any
and all rights, claims, causes of action, counterclaims, demands, actions, suits, damages, debts,
losses, executions and liabilities of whatever kind or nature which the Parties now have against
one another, ever had or may have in the future against one another, including but not limited to
past, present, and future claims, either legal or equitable, whether known or unknown, for
contractual, extra-contractual, tortuous, compensatory, and punitive damages, commissions,
interest, attorneys' fees and costs arising from the events and circumstances contained in the case
at bar, including but not limited to all claims, rights, or causes of actions which were or might
have been asserted in the present case or applicable to the subject property.
17. There is due and owing to Third Party Defendant, Franklin County Treasurer, taxes
accrued taxes, assessments and penalties on the subject property, as shown on the Franklin
County Treasurer's tax duplicate, the exact amount being undetermined at the present time, but
which amount will be ascertainable at the time of sale, which is a valid and subsisting lien
thereon for that amount so owing; and finally
18. There is no just reason for delay in the entry of final judgment as to the matters addressed
herein.
IT IS THEREFORE, ORDERED, ADJUDICATED and DECREED that in rem judgment
is entered in favor ofDefendant, United Midwest Savings Bank in the amount of Two Hundred,
Forty-two Thousand, Three Hundred, Seventy-one Dollars and Seventy-eight Cents
($242,371.78) with interest at the rate of 5.125% per annum from and after July 1, 2008, plus late
fees and costs necessary to preserve the subject property, together with the costs of this action,
including the sum of $1,039.00, for the Preliminaryand Final Judicial Reports.
IT IS FURTHER, ORDERED, ADJUDICATED and DECREED that upon confirmation
of any judicial sale held in connection with this matter, the obligations evidencedby the Note
and Mortgage shall be deemed satisfied in foil and no personaljudgment shall be rendered
against Plaintiff, Marcia Garcia, and Third Party Defendant, Generoso Sia.
IT IS FURTHER, ORDERED, ADJUDICATED and DECREED that Defendant, United
Midwest Saving Bank, be entitled to any and all its statutory rights in and to the goods which are
or were to become fixtures, inventory which are raw materials, work in process, or materials
which may be used in the construction of the dwelling located at 67 E. Weber Road, Columbus,
Ohio 43202 or that may situated therein.
IT IS FURTHER, ORDERED, ADJUDICATED and DECREED that unless the sums
hereinabove found due, together with the costs of this action, be folly paid within three (3) days
from the date of the entry of this Judgment, the equity of redemption and dower of all
Defendants, Third Party Defendants, and Plaintiff, in and to the subject property shall be
foreclosed, and the property sold; that upon the issuance of a Praecipe for Order of Sale by
Defendant, United Midwest Savings Bank, an Order of Sale shall thereafter be issued to the
Sheriffof Franklin County, Ohio, directing him to appraise, advertise in a paper of general
circulation with the County, and sell the subject property as upon execution and according to
law, free and clear of the interests of all parties to this action.
IT IS FURTHER, ORDERED, ADJUDICATED and DECREED that after the sale has
been completed, the Sheriff ofFranklin County shall convey to the purchaser of the Property a
Sheriffs Deed and that a Writ ofPossession of the Property shall be issued.
IT IS FURTHER, ORDERED, ADJUDICATED and DECREED that in the event that
Defendant, United Midwest Savings Bank, is the successful bidder at the Sheriff Sale, the
amount of the deposits made herein by Defendant, United Midwest Savings Bank, and the costs
of the Preliminary and Final Judicial Reports, in the sum of $1,039.00, shall be deducted from
the total amount of court costs otherwise payable herein.
IT IS FURTHER, ORDERED, ADJUDICATED and DECREED that Defendant, United
Midwest Savings Bank be authorized to credit bid at the Sheriff Sale.
IT IS FURTHER, ORDERED, ADJUDICATED and DECREED, that all claims of the
Parties to this agreement, excluding those specifically addressed in this Agreed Entry, are hereby
dismissed with prejudice.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
Date Judge K. Cocroft
The undersigned, being all the parties associated with Defendant, United Midwest SavingsBank's, Counterclaim and Third Party Complaint APPROVE the foregoing Agreed JudgmentEntry/ind Orderof Foreclosure:
landa'Baird (0071482)Baird Law Offices, LLCAttorneyfor PlaintiffMarcia Garcia
Charles R. Griffith (0031388)Matthew J. Roda (0061985)Griffith Law OfficesAttorneysfor Defendant, CounterclaimantAnd Third Party Plaintiff,United Midwest Savings Bank
Jerry L. Kaltenbach (0075065)Kaltenbach Law, LLCAttorneyfor Third Party DefendantGeneroso Sia, Jr.
Steven E. Elder (0009066)Michelle L. Polly-Murphy (0072091)STEVEN E. ELDER CO., L.P.A.Attorneyfor DefendantSearch2Close
Mary E. Johnson (0037623)Adria L. Fields (0064399)Assistant Prosecuting AttorneysAttorneys for DefendantFranklin County Treasurer