22
AGENDA Saturday, October 18, 2014 Chicago O’Hare Hilton Room 2029 Central Standard Time - CST Council Members Present: Anne Agur, Brion Benninger, Philip Fabrizio, Anne Gilroy, Noelle Granger, Sarah Keim, H. Wayne Lambert, Lisa Lee, Carol Lomneth, Marios Loukas, Brian MacPherson, Shanan Atkinson (ex officio), Neil Norton, Rebecca Pratt, Brandi Schmitt, and Shane Tubbs (ex officio). Council Members Absent: Rob Spinner Guests Present: David Porta Breakfast: 8:00 a.m. 1. CALL TO ORDER - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 8:36 a.m. 2. APPROVAL OF AGENDA - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 8:37 a.m. The agenda was approved at 8:37 a.m. 3. APPROVAL OF MINUTES - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 8:38 a.m. Wayne distributed the minutes from the two recent Council meetings at the 2013 AACA Annual Meeting after the Orlando meeting. Several Council members shared some editorial suggestions prior to this meeting, and Lisa Lee shared one additional correction in the New Council Minutes. The minutes were approved at 8:40 a.m. 4. PRESIDENTIAL UPDATE - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- 8:40 a.m. a. Presidential speaker honorarium – Francine Netter will be invited to be the presidential speaker; however, we are still working out the honorarium that will be given to her. b. Paper Journal Costs to Members – Ian Whitmore mentioned that he shouldn’t have to pay the full $125 for the paper version of the

Agenda - clinical-anatomy.orgclinical-anatomy.org/images/...Meeting_in_Chicago.docx  · Web viewAPPROVAL OF AGENDA ... Francine Netter ... Bob Acland was proposing a Wednesday evening

  • Upload
    dangnhi

  • View
    217

  • Download
    1

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Agenda - clinical-anatomy.orgclinical-anatomy.org/images/...Meeting_in_Chicago.docx  · Web viewAPPROVAL OF AGENDA ... Francine Netter ... Bob Acland was proposing a Wednesday evening

AGENDASaturday, October 18, 2014

Chicago O’Hare HiltonRoom 2029

Central Standard Time - CST

Council Members Present: Anne Agur, Brion Benninger, Philip Fabrizio, Anne Gilroy, Noelle Granger, Sarah Keim, H. Wayne Lambert, Lisa Lee, Carol Lomneth, Marios Loukas, Brian MacPherson, Shanan Atkinson (ex officio), Neil Norton, Rebecca Pratt, Brandi Schmitt, and Shane Tubbs (ex officio).

Council Members Absent: Rob Spinner

Guests Present: David Porta

Breakfast: 8:00 a.m.

1. CALL TO ORDER - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 8:36 a.m.

2. APPROVAL OF AGENDA - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 8:37 a.m.The agenda was approved at 8:37 a.m.

3. APPROVAL OF MINUTES - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 8:38 a.m.Wayne distributed the minutes from the two recent Council meetings at the 2013 AACA Annual Meeting after the Orlando meeting. Several Council members shared some editorial suggestions prior to this meeting, and Lisa Lee shared one additional correction in the New Council Minutes. The minutes were approved at 8:40 a.m.

4. PRESIDENTIAL UPDATE - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- 8:40 a.m.a. Presidential speaker honorarium – Francine Netter will be invited to be the presidential speaker;

however, we are still working out the honorarium that will be given to her.b. Paper Journal Costs to Members – Ian Whitmore mentioned that he shouldn’t have to pay the

full $125 for the paper version of the journal. He prefers to pay the difference between the online and paper versions, and members of the Journal Committee agreed to let Ian only pay the $73 difference. Discussion followed as to whether this case was unique or all members should be able to pursue this option. Neil, the Chair of the Journal Committee, will have a discussion with Tiffany McKerahan. Brian and Shane Tubbs also reminded Council members that they can go to the Clinical Anatomy website to sign up for the RSS feed to receive subscription and content reminders.

MOTION (Tubbs, Norton): To give the paper version of the Clinical Anatomy subscription to AACA Honored Members, when it is requested, at a discounted rate. The motion passed unanimously.

c. Standing Rules and Procedures Vote: The AACA Standing Rules and Procedures were presented by Sarah Keim for a Council vote. Discussion also centered on the AACA Past President being charged with monitoring the AACA Standing Rules and Procedures in the future, which led to the following motions.

MOTION (Tubbs, Keim): To approve the Standard Rules and Procedures as amended at the Interim Council Meeting on October 18, 2014. The motion passed unanimously.MOTION (Agur, MacPherson): To place the Past-President in charge of updating the Standard Rules and Procedures document. The motion passed unanimously.

Page 2: Agenda - clinical-anatomy.orgclinical-anatomy.org/images/...Meeting_in_Chicago.docx  · Web viewAPPROVAL OF AGENDA ... Francine Netter ... Bob Acland was proposing a Wednesday evening

5. REPORTS

a. Educational Affairs - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - {9:07 a.m.} Chair's Report (Burgoon)

Composition of Committee: Jennifer Burgoon (Chair), Erin Fillmore, April Richardson-Hatcher, Ann Poznanski, Lonnie Salkowski, Vaughn Lee

The Educational Affairs Committee (EAC) has met twice since the AACA Annual Meeting in Orlando to address the business of the committee.

1. Creation of Listservs from 2014 EAC Breakfast Business Meeting: At the 2014 EAC Breakfast Business Meeting, four discussions were undertaken and groups formed around the topics of: 1) Educational Technology in Anatomy Education; 2) Educational Research Methods; 3) Humanities and Anatomy Education; and 4) Post-Graduate Course. These lists (i.e., members of groups and their emails) have been sent to Caitlin Hyatt to test the new AACA listserv features on Google, starting with the smaller groups. Members of the EAC have been assigned to each listserv: 1) Lonnie Salkowski and April Richardson-Hatcher to Educational Technology in Anatomy Education; 2) Erin Fillmore and Jennifer Burgoon to Educational Research Methods; 3) Ann Poznanski to Humanities and Anatomy Education; and 4) Vaughan Lee to Post-Graduate Course. These individuals will send out an introductory email to the listserv, re-start the discussions begun at the 2014 Annual AACA meeting and monitor the discussions to bring information back to the full EAC group. The committee is currently waiting to hear back from Caitlin about her progress in setting up these listservs so that introductory emails can be sent. 3. Organization of the 2015 EAC Breakfast Business Meeting: At the past two EAC Breakfast Business Meetings at the Annual AACA Meetings, the breakfasts have included an opportunity for attendees to demonstrate how to teach difficult topics using ordinary and inexpensive items or demonstrations. The EAC has decided to brainstorm on new ideas for the 2015 EAC Breakfast Business Meeting. To do this, a Google Doc has been created where ideas can be posted for discussion at the November 2014 EAC meeting. 4. Organization of the 2016 EAC Symposium: During the previous year, the EAC initially attempted to have the focus for the 2014 EAC Symposium on ultrasound, bringing in speakers (speakers selected, but not invited) for the symposium and then holding small hands-on ultrasound sessions during the remainder of the 2014 Annual AACA conference. However, it was determined during the Winter of 2014, that not enough time remained to plan the ultrasound symposium and (especially) the related activities and, therefore, the topic of the 2014 symposium was changed to “Integrating Anatomy into New Curricular Designs”, also a very timely topic. The decision of the EAC was to use the ultrasound planning already completed and to carry the ultrasound topic to the 2016 EAC Symposium. However, the committee was informed at the 2014 Annual AACA conference that the Post-Graduate Course for the 2015 Annual Meeting may want to focus on ultrasound. Therefore, although the ultrasound topic was still of interest, the EAC decided in September 2014 that other potential topics needed to be discussed. Therefore, a Google Doc was created where ideas can be posted by EAC members for discussion at the November 2014 EAC meeting. However, with the recent decision by the AMC (10/15/14) that there will not be a post-graduate course at the 2014 Annual AACA Meeting primarily due to a lack of a true local host, the additional ideas may not be necessary. This decision by the AMC and the 2016 EAC Symposium will be a significant focus at the November 2014 EAC Meeting.

Page 3: Agenda - clinical-anatomy.orgclinical-anatomy.org/images/...Meeting_in_Chicago.docx  · Web viewAPPROVAL OF AGENDA ... Francine Netter ... Bob Acland was proposing a Wednesday evening

5. Other EAC Activities: Through monthly teleconferences, email, and the annual meetings, the EAC members will discuss pressing educational topics and/or concerns and what other activities the EAC should endeavor to accomplish to address these topics and/or concerns.

b. Clinical Anatomical Terminology (CAT) Committee - - - - - - - - - - - {9:42 a.m.} Chair's Report (Downie via Lambert)

Composition of Committee: Brion Benninger, Sherry Downie (Chair), Tom Gest, O. Paul Gobee, Brad Martin, Anthony Olinger, Rebecca Pratt, Alan Richards, Rob Spinner (ex officio), Ian Whitmore

The Clinical Anatomical Terminology (CAT) Committee has met monthly since the AACA Annual Meeting in Orlando to address the business of the committee.

1. Program for Las Vegas Annual Meeting symposium. Professor John Fraher of Cork Ireland, the new Chairman of the Federative International Program for Anatomical Terminology (FIPAT), will be our guest and speak on the present and future of Anatomical Terminology. Following Professor Fraher’s talk we would like to have a panel, including some AACA members (not currently invited), join him and answer questions from the audience. CAT Committee members are currently refining this program and working on a description of the event to be posted on the AACA website.

2. CAT members attend IFAA. Three members of the CAT Committee, O.Paul Gobee, Tom Gest and Brion Benninger, attended the 18th Congress of the International Federation of Associations of Anatomists (IFAA) in Beijing last August. Through their participation, ideas about the CAT symposium and new thoughts about development of AnatomicalTerms.Info.

3. New feature on CAT page of AACA website. We have developed a feature on the Clinical Anatomical Terminology webpage of the AACA website that presents the latest published abstracts and citations of articles concerning Anatomical Terminology. The subjects of these articles range from position papers to historical perspectives to proposals for changes in terminological use. The page will be updated quarterly.

4. AnatomicalTerms.Info. Prior to the IFAA meeting in August, the committee completed production of “Patterns and Guidelines for Developing Definitions for Anatomical Concepts”. This document defines the standards we use for writing concept definitions for AnatomicalTerms.info. Work continues on AT.I.

Following Wayne’s presentation of Sherry Downie’s report, Brian asked Brion Benninger about the current direction of the committee. Brion explained that the committee has decided not to create own path, but is asking FIPAT what can they do to help with the goals of the IFAA. Brian felt the direction of this committee needs to be defined because it seems the committee reports the same activities at each interim meeting. Rebecca Pratt suggested reaching out to AACA members who are interested in CAT, to help obtain a new direction. Marios Loukas, who is currently serving on FIPAT explained his FIPAT position is purely an academic job. He stated that when there is a gap in anatomical terminology, the committee tries to fill it, which involves backing up new additions with the literature. Finally, this new information is presented to the whole FIPAT committee. The CAT committee could pursue specific tasks with regard to anatomical regions and complete meta-analysis within the published literature. Marios has been tasked with working within the

Page 4: Agenda - clinical-anatomy.orgclinical-anatomy.org/images/...Meeting_in_Chicago.docx  · Web viewAPPROVAL OF AGENDA ... Francine Netter ... Bob Acland was proposing a Wednesday evening

thorax and abdomen for FIPAT. Members of the CAT committee could be tasked with the historical literature and give the committee specific targets. The general consensus derived from this discussion was that the CAT committee needs to improve their communication with FIPAT to see how they can assist their mission..

After hearing the conversation and determining that the AACA contains FIPAT members and direct links to the IFAA, Brion proposed an ad hoc committee (composed of Brion, Shane, Marios, and Rebecca) to determine the direction of this committee in the future.

c. Career Development - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - {10:06 am}Chair's Report (Wisco)

Composition of Committee: Dolgar Bataar, Alan Detton, Sarah Greene, Nirusha Lachman, Tony Olinger, Gib Willett, Jonathan Wisco (Chair)

The Career Development Committee (CDC) has met monthly since the AACA Annual Meeting in Orlando to address the business of the committee.

1. CDC symposium: The symposium topic for the 2015 meeting will be “Changing Paradigm of Academics”. The intention of this symposium is to expose our membership to non-traditional (i.e. non-academic) careers in clinical anatomy. Three talks will be 25 minutes in length, followed by a 15 minute panel discussion at the end of the session.The CDC has identified the following speakers:1) Andrew Cawrse (anatomytools.com) – will address the role of clinical anatomy in

medical illustration, visual arts, and film making.2) Alan Detton (Stanford University; Anatomage) – will discuss how to become

involved with consulting for translational education companies.3) Frank Daly (University of New England) (not yet confirmed) – will speak about

directing a donated body program that is involved with surgical simulation as part of its service to medical schools.

2. Mentorship reception: With the success of the Mentorship Reception the previous two years, the CDC will continue the tradition of serving refreshments for mentors and mentees and the textbook give-away. This year the CDC will utilize color nametags that will designate career level, and include information about academic interest(s), which will allow for quicker identification of natural mentor and mentee relationships. Last year the CDC included a small poster session with posters focused on mentoring, and they plan to continue this activity during their off-cycle for the symposium.

3. Organize judging of student platform and poster presentations: The CDC members will recruit judges from the entire membership, and assign them to posters and platform presentations. The CDC is working with the MOPP and Annual Meeting Planning Committee (AMPC) to streamline the abstract submission/registration/judging process. They will also continue the judges’ meeting to provide orientation

4. Special projects: The CDC has organized their committee into sub-committees. Each sub-committee has established a project that will be published on the association website to help our members with their career development and advancement. Each Special Topic subcommittee

Page 5: Agenda - clinical-anatomy.orgclinical-anatomy.org/images/...Meeting_in_Chicago.docx  · Web viewAPPROVAL OF AGENDA ... Francine Netter ... Bob Acland was proposing a Wednesday evening

Brian wanted to know if we could give the mentees some time away from the mentors because he remembered a comment from the AACA survey requesting this opportunity. Noelle will check the survey results. The CDC is hoping to get more judges and move the judging online with a paper backup; however, the Wifi problems at Green Valley Ranch may hamper this progression. The CDC also has two subcommittees that were mentioned, including one on translational anatomy. Marios Loukas is charged as Editor-in-Chief of a new journal on this topic, and he is hoping this subcommittee can help people who want to transition from being a traditional anatomist to a clinical anatomist.

d. Publicity Committee Establishment - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - {10:20 a.m.}Chair's Report (Wisco)

Composition of Committee: Jon Wisco (Interim Chair) and to be determined

Establishment of the committee: Since the Annual Council meeting in Orlando, FL, Jon Wisco (former Publicity ad hoc Committee Chair) and Peter Ward (former Membership ad hoc Committee Chair) drafted the following description for the role of this new committee (still being edited). We are awaiting by-laws diction from Neil Norton.

This proposed, yet unnamed, committee is responsible for

The promotion and maintenance of strategic initiatives, which include:

Providing oversight of regional meeting proposals and selecting hosts, in conjunction with the MOPP committee; and providing logistical support in conjunction with the AACA’s professional management service;

Establishing a promotional and collaborative presence with other professional organizations with complementary missions (particularly those involved with initiatives related to clinical anatomy research and educational scholarship);

Maintaining and updating the AACA website and social media outlets to reflect current events, connect members, and seamlessly tie the efforts of the standing committees together in order to unify the public presentation (I KNOW there’s a better word but it is not coming to my mind…) of the Association;

Soliciting information from the membership and monitoring current trends and emerging issues in the field of clinical anatomy to determine how AACA can best meet members’ needs; this information will be communicated with the standing Committees and Council;

Soliciting information from the membership regarding their perception of: events at the annual meeting, interface of the Society’s social media outlets, events that would benefit the Association in the future;

Interacting with media on behalf of the Association and directing inquiries to an appropriate member or member of Council;

Selectively promoting products or services offered by or endorsed by the Association;

Working with each of the standing committees to promote their initiatives to the public and other stakeholders;

Recommending further suggestions, as needed, to Council to improve promotion of AACA as a clinically oriented, scientific and educational scholarly institution.

The committee shall consist of five members. The President shall appoint three members, with the approval of the Council, and designate one nominee as the Committee's Chair. Two

Page 6: Agenda - clinical-anatomy.orgclinical-anatomy.org/images/...Meeting_in_Chicago.docx  · Web viewAPPROVAL OF AGENDA ... Francine Netter ... Bob Acland was proposing a Wednesday evening

members shall be nominated and elected by the membership at the Annual Business Meeting.

Regional meeting planning: Jon Wisco has been working with ASG and Noelle Granger to plan the first AACA Regional Meeting. University of Utah School of Medicine and School of Dentistry (Salt Lake City, UT) was selected as the first host for October 17, 2015. University of North Carolina School of Medicine was tentatively selected as the host for 2016. The intent of choosing the University of Utah as the first host was to ensure that a member of the Marketing Committee (currently Jon Wisco is the only member) would be able to work with ASG to plan and learn from the experience, which will inform future hosts. As a reminder, the Marketing Committee is planning the Regional Meeting with the following non-binding guidelines that were approved by Council at the Denver meeting:

Regional Meeting Guidelines

The MOPP committee will work with ASG to implement the following guidelines (subject to being updated for official program launch) for hosting a regional meeting:

1. Interested faculty should contact ASG at least one year in advance of desired regional conference date. ASG will manage the regional conference and assist hosting faculty with administrative tasks and hotel arrangements.

2. Members or teams of members submit a proposal to Council to host a regional meeting at their university or universities. Proposals will include the following information:

a. Title and theme of the conferenceb. Date(s) of the conference

i. We recommend a one-day conference to be held Fall, Winter or Spring months

c. Brief description of the hosting facultyd. Brief description of student involvemente. Brief description of the hosting university and available facilitiesf. Letter of support from the hosting department or college dean outlining the

contribution and commitment of the hosting department or college with regards to meeting space and/or other financially equivalent support.

g. Support letter from ASG regardingi. Housing options for registrants

ii. Cateringiii. Technology needs

h. Fee structure for registrantsi. We recommend $40-50 registration, no cost for abstract submissions

(this will likely increase)i. Program proposal that outlines the activities for participants (e.g. speaker

topics, poster sessions, plenary sessions, post-grad mini-course, etc.)j. Detailed budget, including any request for supplementary support from

AACA up to $1000

Brion asked Jon if we can develop an infrastructure that enables our students who are presenting to get feedback for their review of the work.

{BREAK 10:30 a.m.}

Page 7: Agenda - clinical-anatomy.orgclinical-anatomy.org/images/...Meeting_in_Chicago.docx  · Web viewAPPROVAL OF AGENDA ... Francine Netter ... Bob Acland was proposing a Wednesday evening

e. Anatomical Services - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - {10:50 a.m.}Chair's Report (Schmitt)

Composition of Committee: Brion Benninger, Andrew Corson, Quentin Fogg, Todd Hoagland (Academic Co-Chair), Jennifer Mark, Angela McArthur, Brandi Schmitt (Technical Co-Chair)

1. The Anatomical Services Committee (ASC) has met monthly since the AACA Annual Meeting in Orlando to address the business of the committee. Meeting synopses included:o Agenda: 2014 Symposium, meeting re-cap and survey, 2015 meeting discussion,

ASC award, Vendor policy use and appendix, Federal Bill in House of Representatives on body donation - HR 5318 https://beta.congress.gov/bill/113th-congress/house-bill/5318/text Agenda: 2015 meeting discussion, Vendor policy appendix, ASC budget, ASC award, interim council meeting report, ASC regional meeting, IFAA report-out, Vesalius report-out.

2. Current items Vendor policy process clarification & draft appendix ASC poster session and award

3. ASC Agenda for 2014/2015:a. Plan the 2015 ASC Breakfast meeting & develop an outline for 2016 (symposium

and possible post-grad course participation).1) 2015 - 90 minute meeting will be split to cover topical discussions and to perform

the business of the committee and SIG (elections, future symposium topics, etc.). The topical discussions will be on pertinent laws and lessons learned with ASC members and other participants sharing their expertise by recounting legislative experiences as well as how their program or institution encountered and resolved a donor program problem. Legislative topics include UAGA, HR 5318 (see link above), other applicable health and safety codes and business and professions codes; lesson learned topics include how to prepare and deal with emergencies and disasters (sewage leak, power outages, chemical spill, social media postings, etc.). Funding: ASC will submit projected expenses to AACA council in early 2015

2) 2016 - San Francisco, ASC Symposia topic – Tagging, Tracking and Oversight of Human Anatomical Specimens.

UCOP Anatomical Services & UC Anatomical Donation Programs are likely to sponsor the post-grad specimens at no charge to the association, there will be an anatomical services specific tour & possibly a poster/presentation session (as interest & schedule allows)

3) 2017 - TBDb. Discussion and planning for an AACA ASC regional meetingc. Discuss and develop an ASC award system for members who present posters at

annual meeting. Brandi would like to see a poster category specific to technical projects involved with the anatomical services. Brandi will involve David Porta with this process and will need to submit names of appropriate judges for these posters. , We may want to have ASC members check a box to specify their project is related to anatomical services.

Page 8: Agenda - clinical-anatomy.orgclinical-anatomy.org/images/...Meeting_in_Chicago.docx  · Web viewAPPROVAL OF AGENDA ... Francine Netter ... Bob Acland was proposing a Wednesday evening

d. Assist the new AACA association management group with development of webpage & newsletter items pertinent to the ASC

e. Write a viewpoint article for the Journal of Clinical Anatomy on the AACA's Best Practices for Anatomical Donation Programs document

f. Respond to inquiries and items of topical interest to the ASC when warranted

Brandi also talked about the vendor policy. Brian asked how many Council members have viewed the vender package given out from meetings. Shanan will send it to the members to view.

Brandi mentioned the importance of a one-day registration for anatomical services members. The AACA has not pushed this effort as they want AS members to attend the entire meeting.

Brion commended Brandi on the initiative to thank the donors in scholarly papers. Many journals have adopted this policy, and it is evidence as her impact as the Chair of this very important AACA committee. Brian and the entire Council echoed these sentiments.

f. Membership Committee - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - {11:01 a.m.}Chair's Report (Norton)

Neil discussed the new membership application process, which enables members to join the AACA after paying their dues, unless the Membership Committee sees a problem with the application. This approved change has streamlined the process, and Neil has noted that we currently have 1,239 AACA members (at the end of September). This number shows that the AACA has doubled its membership from a year ago.

g. AAA-AACA Liaison Sub Committee Reports - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - {11:11 a.m.} (Agur)

Anne discussed some recent conversations with AAA concerning regional meetings, and she asked Brian to follow up with Kimberly Topp to help with the direction of these regional meetings. It seems the AAA was unaware that the AACA wanted to work with them to co-host a regional meeting. The AACA also needs a liaison to work with the AAA to avoid regional meeting conflicts. If we hosted a joint meeting, the AACA would expect a 50-50 split in revenue. We also need to be aware of the AAA pricing for the regional meeting, so the AACA can offer a competitive price for the Utah meeting scheduled for 2015. Anne will look into this information further.

h. ad hoc Committee for CME - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - {11:15 a.m.} (Tubbs, Fabrizio, Spinner, Loukas)

Shane discussed investigating the feasibility for offering CMEs (or their equivalent) at future meetings for physicians (CMEs), as well as occupational and physical therapists (CEUs). He stated the committee has found it may be more affordable than initially thought. Marios discussed the Medical Foundation of Alabama, which is a non-profit (503B) organization that could potentially partner with us to offer CMEs, if we fill out the appropriate forms. The form starts the cost is $750, but the AACA is trying to figure out what this $750 represents and how it applies to our situation. Philip discussed the costs involved with offering CEUs for occupational and physical therapists, where we would need to partner with a state association. The costs were more expensive ($3,000),

Page 9: Agenda - clinical-anatomy.orgclinical-anatomy.org/images/...Meeting_in_Chicago.docx  · Web viewAPPROVAL OF AGENDA ... Francine Netter ... Bob Acland was proposing a Wednesday evening

but the payments may cover CEUs from the AACA for a 5-year period. The application process is involved and takes around 3-4 months to complete. After the initial discussion, Brian stated it may not be realistic to have this process in place for the Las Vegas meeting. However, we should make a conscious effort to have it in place before the Minneapolis meeting in 2016. Marios stated that they will continue to pursue these topics and may have more information for the MOPP committee around December. There may be a presidential appointee to the MOPP committee tohandle CMEs and CEUs.

i. ad hoc Sponsorship Committee (vendor/member) - - - - - - - - - - - - - {11:55 a.m.} (Agur)

Anne distributed two documents regarding corporate and membership sponsorship opportunities composed by this committee. Anne went over the “Value of corporate sponsorship opportunities” document, which was a document composed by Anne with feedback by Marios Loukas, Rob Spinner, Brian MacPherson, and Neil Norton. The purpose of this document is to generate endowment funds for faculty and student awards, which will not go to our daily operating costs. Platinum corporate sponsors would have ads that could run in a loop in the meeting auditorium before and after presentations. The Council members were generally in support of this initiative. Next, Anne covered the “Membership sponsorship” document, which was also a document composed by Anne with feedback by Marios Loukas, Rob Spinner, Brian MacPherson, and Neil Norton. Pins would be provided to members depending on their level of donation (Sapphire, Ruby, Emerald, Diamond), and these designations would last for one year. Discussion ensued concerning the cost of the pins and the feasibility to ordering a pin with the AACA logo and the associated year of the donation. This committee will have to see if they can order these pins in very specific numbers based upon the number of donors. Brian stated this committee has had a great start.

j. Sushruta-Guha Award/Lectureship - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - {12:00 a.m.} (Agur)

This new proposed award will be called the “Sushruta-Guha Outstanding Clinician Lectureship Award in Clinical Anatomy”, and it will be awarded annually, contingent upon funding, to an outstanding clinician who has demonstrated scholarship in clinical anatomy by applying anatomic principals to clinical practice through original research and publication. The winner of this award will attend the AACA Annual meeting and give a one hour platform presentation of their work. The value of this global award is $1,500. This award will replace the former award, and the winner of this award will be invited to the meeting to share their research and scholarly endeavors. The nominees could be provided by any AACA regular member. After discussion, it was determined that this award may support the travel for the Presidential Speaker, but it may not be given annually to this speaker.

WORKING LUNCH - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - {12:08 p.m.}

6. MEETINGS - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - {12:35 p.m.}a. Program Secretary/MOPP Committee Chair's Report (Granger)In regards to the 2015 AACA Annual Meeting in Henderson, Nevada, some of our members received a communication warning of a union strike against the Green Valley Ranch (GVR), which will occur during the time we are scheduled to be there in June. It threatened

Page 10: Agenda - clinical-anatomy.orgclinical-anatomy.org/images/...Meeting_in_Chicago.docx  · Web viewAPPROVAL OF AGENDA ... Francine Netter ... Bob Acland was proposing a Wednesday evening

difficulty for guests coming to the GVR at that time and requested that we move our meeting elsewhere, which we will not do. The GVR is privately owned, so the strikers may not be on the property and Shanan advised everyone not to respond to the emails, which were used illegally.

It has been decided not to have a post graduate course in Las Vegas. Several road blocks occurred during the planning stages and given that the annual meeting survey revealed that the respondents were quite satisfied not to have a course after every meeting, the MOPP committee endorsed this decision. The MOPP Committee approved the creation of a survey to ask members about content for the post graduate course, in order to make it more organized and less ‘hit-and-miss” in terms of topics and to find topics that the members would find interesting.

Bob Acland will not be able to participate in the organization and presentation of the first night social hour, which was on art and anatomy, so the activities for that evening will need to be revisited.

Noelle will be handing out a statement of the proposed guidelines for honoraria and reimbursement of speakers that has been discussed by the committee. There has been a discussion of registration fees. It was decided to have an a la carte price list for the social events for accompanying persons at registration: first evening social, breakfasts, and the banquet. Caitlin is preparing this document for our next meeting. As per the results of the survey, the banquet fee will be wrapped into the registration fee for members. A small increase was included in the registration fee this year. On the basis of comments from the participants at the Orlando meeting, the banquet dinner will now be a buffet on a regular basis. Finally, it was decided that the Council might want to take up the issue of when to hold the meeting banquet – the penultimate or last day of the meeting (Friday). The responses to the annual meeting survey were all over the place, but Council members were hoping the banquet could be earlier in the day, so members could still catch flights out of Las Vegas.

b. 2014 Annual Meeting Report (Porta/Atkinson)David Porta presented a PowerPoint presentation, which is enclosed. He proposed a future change to the organization of the abstract for a research paper, which will be an item for the next MOPP committee meeting. For the 2014 AACA Annual Meeting, the AACA received 139 abstracts (76 Regular and 66 Associate). There was instituted a 2-stage review process for formatting then content. Unfortunately, 62% (or 86) of the abstracts had formatting errors, with 66 abstracts having minor errors and 20 returned to authors for major corrections. These latter abstracts were fixed and returned in one week. The 139 abstracts went to three reviewers for blind content review and were judged on a 20-point scale. 29 abstracts were accepted for platform presentations with their abstracts to be published in Clinical Anatomy. 82 posters were accepted with abstracts to be published in Clinical Anatomy. 17 posters were accepted, but their abstracts will not be published. 5 abstracts were rejected. Late breaking abstracts totaled 27 (17 Regular and 10 Associate), but these abstracts were not eligible for platform presentations, student awards, and publication. Despite some minor formatting problems, all 27 late-breaking abstracts were accepted for poster presentations. With approximately 120 posters in Orlando with only 30 poster boards, the abstracts were rotated so each poster hung for 1.5 days with 1 hour presentation times varying based upon the poster number. It was a problem to get all of the student awards judged before the banquet. Approximately a dozen posters were withdrawn prior to the meeting. Another dozen were not presented at the meeting (with 9 of these posters being

Page 11: Agenda - clinical-anatomy.orgclinical-anatomy.org/images/...Meeting_in_Chicago.docx  · Web viewAPPROVAL OF AGENDA ... Francine Netter ... Bob Acland was proposing a Wednesday evening

presented on Friday). 4 of these posters were accepted for publication in Clinical Anatomy, but the authors were informed their abstracts will not be published.

Concerning the actual meeting itself, there were big problems with a lack of food venues close to the meeting, so many members missed part of the meeting during meals. David also mentioned he felt the scientific aspect of the meeting seems to be improving. Also, the buffet style banquet was well-received. The post graduate course was also very strong.

c. 2015 Annual Meeting Committee Report (Porta)For the 2015 AACA Annual Meeting in Henderson, the Green Valley Ranch will be visited by David and Shanan in March to examin logistics. The meeting co-chairs will be Sherry Downie and David. David also proposed instituting a $20 resubmission fee for any abstracts that do not pass the format review, based upon his experiences with the 2014 Orlando meeting. Bob Acland was proposing a Wednesday evening social to discuss the Hischfield and Leveille “Nevrologie” Atlas of 1853, which is often considered the highpoint of anatomical art. Proposed speakers include Jerzy Gieliecki, Carlos Machado, and Bob Acland, and the AACA would provide food. Unfortunately, Bob has recently been diagnosed with biliary cancer that has metastasized to his liver. You can keep up with Bob’s journey by going to www.caringbridge.org and visiting Robert Acland’s site. Currently, the 2015 meeting has no local host, which has made planning a post graduate course difficult, so the proposed ultrasound course will be scheduled for the Oakland meeting in 2016. David also presented another reason to push the banquet to Friday (beside keeping AACA members at the meeting for its entirety), which was giving the judges more time to complete their decisions on the student awards. The discussion led to several action items for the Annual Meeting and MOPP committees, which included: 1) Neil Norton proposed to move the banquet and the business meeting to Friday, and Anne Gilroy suggested moving it to earlier in the day. Having it earlier would allow some AACA member to catch “red eye” flights back to the east coast. 2) Brion Benninger suggested changing abstract headings to match our journal. 3) Marios Loukas suggested finding a way to determine a way to identify paid Regular Members who are actually still students, so they can still be considered for the student awards. 4) Brandi Schmitt wanted to identify technical posters specific to the anatomical services and have them present at the same day and same time.

d. 2016 and 2017 Annual Meetings (Granger/Atkinson)Noelle and the Executive Committee have agreed to pull out of and cease attempts to have a co-located meeting with AMI in San Antonio in 2017. After two years of sluggish progress and much dithering on the part of AMI, the cost of the hotel rooms had risen to an unsupportable level (over $200 a night). Noelle wrote the President of AMI, who agreed with the decision. The Memorandum of Understanding with regard to co-location of the two organizations will remain for some future date. We recently received an updated version from AMI.

The 2017 meeting has been moved to Minneapolis. The Annual Meeting Chair for that year will be Jennifer Burgoon, co-chaired by Rebecca Pratt. Tony Weinhaus at the University of Minnesota Medical School will be the local host and run the post-graduate course.

There was a request from Minnesota that CME credit be offered, and the ad hoc Committee for CME will be involved as Noelle sent Marios their contact information to see if CMEs and CEUs could be in place for 2017.

e. Future Meetings (Granger/Atkinson)

Page 12: Agenda - clinical-anatomy.orgclinical-anatomy.org/images/...Meeting_in_Chicago.docx  · Web viewAPPROVAL OF AGENDA ... Francine Netter ... Bob Acland was proposing a Wednesday evening

The 2018 meeting will be held in Charlotte, as a joint meeting with BACA. Noelle contacted Brian and Neil to ask them if they could approach BACA with the idea. We do not have an AMC chair for the meeting planned for Charlotte in 2018, and Noelle plans to contact someone in the Surgery Department at Carolinas Medical Center as a possible local host for a post graduate course and appoint a AMC chair for that meeting.

f. Changes to Exhibitor package (Atkinson)There was a discussion of increasing the costs for the exhibitors at our annual meeting, and we are looking at increasing their cost for the first time in many years. This topic has been met with support from the AACA Executive Committee.

7. POSITIONS FOR 2014 ELECTION (Lambert/MacPherson) - - - - - - - {1:58 p.m.}Rebecca Lufter is currently serving as Chair of the Nominating Committee for the 2015 AACA Election, and Wayne has been working with her to get nominations for the five spots that will be open on the AACA Council. Wayne announced the following positions will need to be filled in the 2015 AACA Election. These positions are:a. President-Elect (2015-2017)b. Program Secretary (2015-2018)c. 2 Councilor-at-Large positions (2015-2018)d. Anatomical Services – Special Councilor (2015-2018)

8. AWARDS (Lambert/MacPherson) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - {2:03 p.m.}Wayne sent the AACA Council members the nomination packets for these two prestigious awards. As discussed previously, all nominees, that do not win these awards at this meeting, will be considered for 2 more years.a. AACA Honored Member Award - Three nominees were presented to Council. After

a vote, Dr. Carol Scott-Conner of the University of Iowa College of Medicine in Iowa City, Iowa was elected as the 2015 AACA Honored Member.

b. R. Benton Atkins, Jr. Distinguished Service Award - Three nominees were presented to Council. After a vote, Dr. Lawrence “Larry” Ross of the University of Texas – Houston Medical School was elected as the 2015 R. Benton Atkins, Jr. Distinguished Service Award recipient.

c. Blue Box Award - Members of Selection Committee will determine the winner of this award at a future date.

{BREAK 2:10 p.m.}

9. ASG REPORT (Atkinson) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - {2:20 - 15 min}Shanan reviewed the ASG daily activities in the form of hours of work submitted. She submitted a form which reported 876.74 hours worked by ASG from January 1, 2014 to September 30, 2014. 596.41 hours were reported for work directed toward the current and future annual meetings.

10. JOURNAL COMMITTEE (Norton/Tubbs) - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - {2:25 - 40 min}Neil reported our new journal contract is benefitting the AACA, and he mentioned they will be meeting with Wiley to discuss journal based CME and ask for an increase in the office support for the journal.

Shane presented a PowerPoint presented. He reported the Clinical Anatomy impact factor for 2013 was 1.159, which was equal to the 2012 report. These numbers reflect the 2011 and 2012 journal content. This number is calculated by the number of citations to articles in Clinical Anatomy divided by the total number of “citable items” in the journal. The current impact factor references work done by Stephen Carmichael and future impact factors will

Page 13: Agenda - clinical-anatomy.orgclinical-anatomy.org/images/...Meeting_in_Chicago.docx  · Web viewAPPROVAL OF AGENDA ... Francine Netter ... Bob Acland was proposing a Wednesday evening

start to reflect the work Shane has done with the journal. He reported the submission to decision time has been cut to 12.9 days. His editorial board and staff has also cut the revision to early view process to less than 15 days. Shane reported the survey concerning the journal only had 34 respondents, which was disappointing. However, based upon these 34 responses, Shane cited the “most read” sections as original studies, reviews, and letters to the editor. Survey respondents mentioned that authors that it was important for the journal to have a strong impact factor and quick turnaround for publication. They also cited the strengths of the journal as being its reputation, quality, and relevance. Shane shared future paper of interests and future special issues, including cardiac anatomy part II, clinical anatomy of sex, advances in plastic surgery, cosmetic/dermatologic surgery, etc., that will be published by the journal. He also reported improvements to the journal, such as publishing alerts (RSS feeds, e-mail blasts, etc.), video highlights, YouTube, CME, Best Paper Award, a new app, etc. He also showed Wiley’s new journal app service, the iOS newsstand, which shows the most recent journal cover and pushes new articles to users so they can have the most recent content on their computer or hand-held device. The 2nd annual Wiley symposium is called “Anatomy of the New Millennium”, including Susan Standring and other TBA speakers. He discussed the most downloaded articles, highlighted by the 64,000 downloaded views of the review article on female external genitalia and orgasm. He also discussed the altmetric score for scholarly articles, which is derived from: 1) Volume = score rises as more people mention it, 2) Sources = each category of mention contributes toa different base amount of the final score, and 3) Authors = how often the author of each mention talks about the scholarly articles influencing the contribution of the mention. Shane finished his presentation by mentioning that he has worked to improve the communication between editors of member societies.

11. TREASURER’S REPORT (Lomneth) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - {2:50 p.m.}Carol presented what may be the shortest Treasurer’s Report in the AACA history, in which she showed the 2014 AACA Annual Meeting currently has a profit of $35,780. It should be noted that there may be additional expenses that have not be reported, but these numbers represent an improvement over past meetings. She also reported that our associations funds are starting to increase due to the restructuring of the journal contract and membership dues. We have also seen an increase in royalties derived from the journal.

Carol also discussed honoraria provided by the AACA. The AACA currently pays for travel, hotel, and offers a $500 honorarium to Presidential Speakers, though a larger honorarium may be considered for desirable speakers. If the Presidential Speaker is an AACA member, the honorarium will be $300. Speakers at SIG committee symposia will not receive an honorarium if they are AACA member, but $300 will be given for non-AACA members. All of these recommendations are flexible based upon the situation.

12. LISTSERV (Atkinson/MacPherson) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - {3:00 p.m.}Shanan discussed moving the listserv to Google Platform earlier in the meeting, and we in the process of completing this transition. It is important to move forward with this proposal as the Council voted at the annual meeting to discontinue use of our current listserv, hosted at Albert Einstein, when a viable option was identified.

13. OLD BUSINESS - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - {4:00 – 5 min}Carol went over the new AACA Travel Policy, which she distributed to Council. Adoption of a new travel policy is needed to make it clear as to what will be reimbursed by the AACA following travel for our professional association. Carol emphasized timely submission of an itemized list with original receipts. Every expense over $10 needs a receipt, and the

Page 14: Agenda - clinical-anatomy.orgclinical-anatomy.org/images/...Meeting_in_Chicago.docx  · Web viewAPPROVAL OF AGENDA ... Francine Netter ... Bob Acland was proposing a Wednesday evening

submission process will go through ASG. The AACA will not pay for the travel of a spouse. Carol emphasized that AACA members should be economical when they travel. They can stay over an extra night if the flight out of their location is less expensive. After discussion, it was determined that internet access is a business expense.

MOTION (Norton, Benninger): To approve the new AACA Travel Policy and it incorporated into the Standard Rules and Procedures document. The motion passed unanimously-.

14. NEW BUSINESS - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - {3:14 – 5 min}None

ADJOURNMENT: 3:15 p.m.

Respectfully submitted,H. Wayne Lambert, Ph.D., AACA Secretary