Against Our Will_UK CAT Shadow Report_speakoutagainstpsychiatry

8/12/2019 Against Our Will_UK CAT Shadow Report_speakoutagainstpsychiatry

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/against-our-willuk-cat-shadow-reportspeakoutagainstpsychiatry 1/26

!

Against Our Will

Our experience of

compulsory psychiatric treatment in the community

as torture and inhuman treatment

(UK)

Speak Out Against Psychiatry

2013

Contact:

Cheryl Prax

[email protected]

Report writer: Anne"Laure Donskoy " [email protected]





@

Table of Contents

8-9$/:+'53'7'$.) ;

8<<('&%*.%/$) ;=$.(/5>-.%/$ ?

@*(. A$'B C4' -/$.'D.

E C4' #F G/$&'$.%/$ /$ .4' 2%34.) /0 @'()/$) :%.4 ,%)*<%+%.%') H*$5 %.) AI.%/$*+

@(/./-/+J %$ .4' #K

L

!5!

A''-*9'0 ,7 '%- BC /86-1+*-+' '8 -;2()3- 9-108+0 3.&/+80-3 *-+'&((7

.(( 418* %)*&+ 1./%'0 918'-2'.8+0 )+3-1 '%- BD EF?G

L

!5# C+8<(-3/- 84 '%- E8+6-+'.8+ M

N C4' +'3*+ 0(*7':/(9 M

#5! H-+'&( I-&('% A2' !JK@ L#MMNO M

@*(. C:/B 8$ 'D*7I+' /0 4>7*$ (%34. &%/+*.%/$) %$ .4' -/77>$%.O

P Q>I'(&%)'5 G/77>$%.O C('*.7'$.) ER

@5! E8**)+.'7 $1-&'*-+' P13-10 LE$P0O ER

@5# $-0'.*8+.-0 EE

; K$/:$ %))>') :%.4 GCA) *(' * 5%).(*-.%/$ 0(/7 .4' 7*%$ %))>' EM

Q5! B+(&<4)( 3-'-+'.8+ EM

Q5# R812-3 '1-&'*-+' L9072%8(8/.2&( &+3 9%70.2&( 28+0'1&.+'O &1- .+%)*&+&+3 3-/1&3.+/ NR

Q5@ A %)*.(.&'.+/ 9182-00 NE

Q5Q F-4)0.+/ '1-&'*-+' .0 .*9800.,(- NN

Q5S ?-89(- 8+ E$P0 &1- 6)(+-1&,(- &+3 89-+ '8 &,)0- NN

? S4/ )*0'3>*(5) .4' (%34.) /0 I'/I+' :%.4 5%)*<%+%.%') /$ * 5*O ./ )*O <*)%)T NP

S5! $%- 18(- 84 '%- E&1- T)&(.'7 E8**.00.8+ NP

S5# $%- 18(- 84 U+3-9-+3-+' H-+'&( I-&('% A3682&'-0 NPS5@ $%- 18(- 84 '%- V),28**.''-- 481 '%- ?1-6-+'.8+ 84 $81')1- N;

@*(. C4(''B 2'-/77'$5*.%/$)

U 2'-/77'$5*.%/$) N;

2'0'('$-')

L 2'0'('$-') N?



Q

Acknowledgements

W-&+ E8X-+0: <%8 0'&1'-3 '%.0 9.-2- 84 <81= ,)' <%8: .+ '%- -+3: <&0 +8' &,(- '8 1-0.0' '%-21)0%.+/ 4812- 84 '%- 9072%.&'1.2 070'-*5

V9-&= P)' A/&.+0' ?072%.&'17 LVPA?O *-*,-10: &+3 -6-178+- <%8 28+'1.,)'-3 '%-.1 -;9-1.-+2-0

84 E8**)+.'7 $1-&'*-+' P13-105

G-,1& V%)(=-0: 0)16.681 &+3 &2'.6.0': 481 %-1 <8130 84 <.038* &+3 91&2'.2&( &36.2-5

$.+& H.+=8<.'X: 84 '%- E-+'1- 481 I)*&+ F./%'0 84 B0-10 &+3 V)16.6810 84 ?072%.&'17 LEIFBV?:

D-< Y81=O: 481 -+28)1&/.+/ '%.0 0),*.00.8+5

Abbreviations

G8CB LB+.'-3 D&'.8+0O E8+6-+'.8+ &/&.+0' $81')1-

GVGB E&1- T)&(.'7 E8**.00.8+

G2@,B LB+.'-3 D&'.8+0O E8+6-+'.8+ 8+ '%- F./%'0 84 ?-108+0 <.'% G.0&,.(.'.-0

GCAB E8**)+.'7 $1-&'*-+' P13-1

WGX2B Z)189-&+ E8+6-+'.8+ 84 I)*&+ F./%'0

1X8B H-+'&( I-&('% A2'

QGCB V)9-16.0-3 E8**)+.'7 $1-&'*-+'



S

Introduction

QI'*9 A>. 83*%$). @)O-4%*.(O

V9-&= P)' A/&.+0' ?072%.&'17 LVPA?O .0 & 0*&(( /1&00188'0 /18)9 -0'&,(.0%-3 .+ #M!!5 U' /&'%-10

9-89(- .+ '%- BC <%8 %&6- )0-3 81 &1- 0'.(( )0.+/ 9072%.&'1.2 0-16.2-0: &0 <-(( &0 8)1 41.-+30: 4&*.(7

&+3 &((.-05 P)1 0'&'-3 &.* .0 '8 1&.0- &<&1-+-00 84 '%- &,)0-0 .+%-1-+' .+ 4812-3 9072%.&'17 &+3 '8

0--= 918'-2'.8+ 84 8)1 1./%'0 &+3 41--38*05 [- 38 +8' 91-'-+3 &+7 -;9-1'.0- .+ '%- (&<: ,)' <- &((

%&6- &+ .+'-1-0' .+ %)*&+ 1./%'0 &+3 %8< '%-0- 1./%'0 &99(7 '8 )05 [- &1- &(( -;9-1'0 ,7

-;9-1.-+2- .+ 9072%.&'17 &+3 *-+'&( %-&('% 0-16.2-0: ,7 6.1')- 84 ,-.+/ \8+ '%- 1-2-.6.+/ -+3\5

[%.(- 28-12.6- *-+'&( %-&('% (-/.0(&'.8+0 &1- 8+ '%- .+21-&0- .+ *&+7 28)+'1.-0: '%- 4&2' 1-*&.+0

'%&': .+ 28+'1&0': 082.-'7 38-0 +8' &+3 918,&,(7 <8)(3 +8' '8(-1&'- 28*9)(0.8+ 81 28-12.8+ 481 .'0/-+-1&( %-&('% )0-10 LP]I&/&+: #M!#O5 $%- 3.44-1-+2- .+ %8< )0-10 84 *-+'&( %-&('% &+3

.+'-((-2')&( 3.0&,.(.'.-0 0-16.2-0 &1- '1-&'-3 .0 1-4(-2'.6- 84 '%- *883 &*8+/ *&+7 (-/.0(&'810 &+3

98(.'.2.&+0 &(.=- 481 /1-&'-1 28+'18( 84 989)(&'.8+0 &+3 & <.(( '8 4812- 082.-'&( 28+481*.'75 $%-

2)11-+' 0&6&/- 2)'0 8+ <-(4&1- ,-+-4.'0 .+ '%- BC &1- %./%(7 .(()0'1&'.6- 84 '%.0 *8835 U+3--3: '%-

BC ^86-1+*-+' %&0 1-9-&'-3(7 2(-&1(7 .+3.2&'-3 .'0 <.(( '8 2%&+/- '%- <&7 9-89(- 28+3)2' '%-.1

(.6-0: .+ 9&1'.2)(&1 '%80- (.6.+/ 8+ ,-+-4.'0: .+2()3.+/ '%- 0.2= &+3 '%- 3.0&,(-3: <.'% '%- )0- 84

demonising descriptors (“scroungers”, “feckless”, “lazy” etc.), also repeatedly used .+ '%- 844.2.&(

1%-'81.2 &+3 -2%8-3 .+ '%- 28+0-16&'.6- &+3 989)(.0' press, playing on people’s fears and

41)0'1&'.8+0 .+ & 31&*&'.2 4.+&+2.&( 2(.*&'-5 $%- 0.')&'.8+ .0 4)1'%-1 28*98)+3-3 ,7 & *-+'&(

%-&('% <81=4812- '%&' .0 .+21-&0.+/(7 )+3-1 0'1-00 3)- '8 2)' ,&2=0: (&2= 84 '1&.+.+/: &+3 9-16&0.6-

28+0-16&'.6- 9-109-2'.6-0 8+ 08*- <&130 81 0-16.2-0 &+3 .+ '%- 28**)+.'7 &,8)' 9072%8_082.&(

3.0'1-00 <%.2% &1- +8' 0-(4_1-4(-;.6-5 U+ 4&2' '%-7 '%-*0-(6-0 84'-+ %&6- (.''(- .+0./%' &,8)' '%-

`)&(.'7 L81 (&2= 84O 84 '%-.1 91&2'.2-5

X>7*$ (%34.) %$ .4' #KB C4' +'3*+ -/$.'D.

$%- BD E8+6-+'.8+ &/&.+0' $81')1- LEA$O <&0 1&'.4.-3 ,7 '%- BC .+ !JKK5 A1'.2(- # 84 '%-

28+6-+'.8+ 918%.,.'0 '81')1- &+3 1-`).1-0 0'&'-0 9&1'.-0 '8 '&=- -44-2'.6- *-&0)1-0 '8 91-6-+' .' .+

&+7 '-11.'817 )+3-1 '%-.1 j)1.03.2'.8+5 V'&'-0 9&1'.-0 *)0' 9)' & 0'89 '8 &(( &2'0 <%.2% 28+0'.')'-

21)-(: .+%)*&+ 81 3-/1&3.+/ '1-&'*-+' )+3-1 A1'.2(- !a 84 EA$5

$%-0- 3)'.-0 8+ '%- BC /86-1+*-+' &1- &,08()'- &+3 +8+_3-18/&,(-b +8 -;2-9'.8+&(

2.12)*0'&+2-0 *&7 ,- .+68=-3 '8 >)0'.47 '81')1- 81 .+%)*&+ &+3 3-/1&3.+/ '1-&'*-+'5 $%- EA$

definition of torture includes “a+7 &2' ,7 <%.2% 0-6-1- 9&.+ 81 0)44-1.+/: <%-'%-1 9%70.2&( 81

*-+'&(: .0 .+'-+'.8+&((7 .+4(.2'-3 8+ & 9-108+ 481 0)2% 9)1980-0 … 481 &+7 1-&08+ ,&0-3 8+

3.021.*.+&'.8+ 84 &+7 =.+3: <%-+ 0)2% 9&.+ 81 0)44-1.+/ .0 .+4(.2'-3 ,7 81 &' '%- .+0'./&'.8+ 84 81

<.'% '%- 28+0-+' 81 &2`).-02-+2- 84 & 9),(.2 844.2.&( 81 8'%-1 9-108+ &2'.+/ .+ &+ 844.2.&( 2&9&2.'7”

LA1'.2(- !O5



a

$%- BD V9-2.&( F&9981'-)1 481 $81')1- W)&+ H-+3-X %&0 1-2-+'(7 28**-+'-3 -;9(.2.'(7 8+ '%-

822)11-+2- 84 '81')1- &+3 .+%)*&+ &+3 3-/1&3.+/ '1-&'*-+' .+ '%- 28+'-;' 84 %-&('%2&1- I.0

4.+3.+/0 28+4.1* '%&' '%- B+.'-3 D&'.8+0 E8+6-+'.8+ 8+ '%- F./%'0 84 ?-108+0 <.'% G.0&,.(.'.-0

LEF?GO .0 '%- &)'%81.'&'.6- 41&*-<81= .+ '%- &1-& 84 '81')1- &+3 .(( '1-&'*-+' <.'% 1-/&13 '89-108+0 <.'% 3.0&,.(.'.-05 A99(7.+/ '%- 0'&+3&130 84 '%- EF?G: &0 &1'.2)(&'-3 ,7 '%- EF?G

E8**.''--: %- 1-9-&'0 '%&' “*-3.2&( '1-&'*-+'0 84 &+ .+'1)0.6- &+3 .11-6-10.,(- +&')1- .+'1)0.6-

&+3 .11-6-10.,(- +&')1-: <%-+ '%-7 (&2= & '%-1&9-)'.2 9)1980-: 81 &.* &' 2811-2'.+/ 81 &((-6.&'.+/ &

3.0&,.(.'7: *&7 28+0'.')'- '81')1- 81 .((_'1-&'*-+' <%-+ -+4812-3 81 &3*.+.0'-1-3 <.'%8)' '%- 41--

&+3 .+481*-3 28+0-+' 84 '%- 9-108+ 28+2-1+-3”5 P+ '%.0 ,&0.0: %- 2&((0 481c

)* )#%,-$&' #)* ,* )-- .,(/'" )*" *,*0/,*%'*%$)- 1'"2/)- 2*&'(3'*&2,*% )4)2*%& 5'(%,*%

62&7 "2%)#2-2&2'%8 2*/-$"2*4 &7' *,*0/,*%'*%$)- )"12*2%&()&2,* ,. 5%9/7,%$(4'(98

'-'/&(,%7,/: )*" 12*"0)-&'(2*4 "($4% %$/7 )% *'$(,-'5&2/%8 &7' $%' ,. ('%&()2*& )*" %,-2&)(9

/,*.2*'1'*&8 .,( #,&7 -,*40 )*" %7,(&0 &'(1 )55-2/)&2,*5 LHd+3-X: #M!@O5

I- &(08 3-*&+30 '%&' 0'&'-0 9&1'.-0 1-9-&( &+7 (-/&( 9186.0.8+0 '%&' &((8< 28+4.+-*-+' 81

28*9)(0817 '1-&'*-+' .+ *-+'&( %-&('% 0-''.+/0: .+0.0'.+/ '%&' '%-7 *)0'c

;).'4$)(" .('' )*" 2*.,(1'" /,*%'*& ,* )* '<$)- #)%2% .,( )-- 2*"232"$)-% 62&7,$& )*9

'=/'5&2,*8 &7(,$47 -'4)- .()1'6,(: )*" >$"2/2)- )*" )"12*2%&()&23' 1'/7)*2%1%8 2*/-$"2*4

&7(,$47 5,-2/2'% )*" 5()/&2/'% &, 5(,&'/& )4)2*%& )#$%'%? !*9 -'4)- 5(,32%2,*% &, &7'

/,*&()(98 %$/7 )% 5(,32%2,*% )--,62*4 /,*.2*'1'*& ,( /,15$-%,(9 &(')&1'*& 2* 1'*&)-

7')-&7 %'&&2*4%8 2*/-$"2*4 &7(,$47 4$)("2)*%725 )*" ,&7'( %$#%&2&$&'" "'/2%2,*01):2*48

1$%& #' ('32%'"? !",5& 5,-2/2'% )*" 5(,&,/,-% &7)& $57,-" )$&,*,198 %'-.0"'&'(12*)&2,*

)*" 7$1)* "24*2&9 … @*%&)*/'% ,. &(')&1'*& 62&7,$& 2*.,(1'" /,*%'*& %7,$-" #'

2*3'%&24)&'"A ('"('%% &, 32/&21% ,. %$/7 &(')&1'*& %7,$-" #' 5(,32"'" 5 LHd+3-X: #M!@: 9&1&KSL-OO

$%- BD E8+6-+'.8+ 8+ '%- F./%'0 84 ?-108+0 <.'% G.0&,.(.'.-0 LEF?GO <&0 1&'.4.-3 ,7 '%- BC .+

#MMK5 G-09.'- '%.0 /18)+3,1-&=.+/ &36&+2-*-+' .+ '%-.1 %)*&+ 1./%'0: 9-108+0 3.&/+80-3 <.'%

*-+'&( .((+-00 81 0.*9(7 .+ 28+'&2' <.'% *-+'&( %-&('% 0-16.2-0 %&6- 28+'.+)-3 '8 ,- '1-&'-3 )+3-1

'%- H-+'&( I-&('% A2' !JK@ L&*-+3-3 .+ #MMNO <%.2% +-.'%-1 28+481*0 +81 1-09-2'0 '%- EF?G5

$%.0 &,)0- %&0 ,--+ <.3-091-&3 &+3 28**8+9(&2-5

U+ '%.0 1-981': <- %./%(./%' & 9&1'.2)(&1 &09-2' 84 '%- .+28*9&'.,.(.'7 84 '%.0 (-/.0(&'.8+ <.'% '%-,.+3.+/ 8,(./&'.8+0 8+ '%- BC )+3-1 '%- EF?G: '%&' 84 4812-3 '1-&'*-+' .+ '%- 28**)+.'75

A(( '%- '-0'.*8+.-0 .+ '%.0 1-981' 28*- 418* /18)9 *-*,-10 <%8 2&*- 481<&13 '8 28+'1.,)'- '8

'%.0 1-981'5 U' <&0 +8' 3.44.2)(' '8 28((-2' '%-*b &(*80' -6-178+- <%8 %&0 -;9-1.-+2-3 '%- 4)(( 4812-

84 '1-&'*-+'0 <.'%8)' 41-- &+3 .+481*-3 28+0-+' %&0 91848)+3 *.0/.6.+/0 &,8)' .'5 A(( 84 )0 <%8

%&6- )0-3 9072%.&'1.2 0-16.2-0 )+3-10'&+3 '%&' 8)1 1./%'0 &1- 91848)+3(7 &+3 18)'.+-(7 6.8(&'-3 ,7

(-/.0(&'.8+ '%&' 4(8)'0 %)*&+ 1./%'05

e.*.'&'.8+0 84 '%.0 1-981'c '%.0 382)*-+' 3-&(0 8+(7 <.'% Z+/(&+3 &+3 [&(-05



N

PART ONE: The context

EY The UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (and its Optional

Protocol): Current situation in the UK

EYE 8..'7I.) <O .4' #K 3/&'($7'$. ./ 'D-+>5' I'()/$) 5%*3$/)'5 7'$.*++O %++ 0(/7 4>7*$

(%34.) I(/.'-.%/$) >$5'( .4' #F G2@,

$%-1- %&0 ,--+ 28+'186-107 .+ '%- BC &18)+3 <%-'%-1 9-108+0 3.&/+80-3 <.'% *-+'&( .((+-00-0 81

)0.+/ *-+'&( %-&('% 0-16.2-0 0%8)(3 ,- 3-4.+-3 &0 3.0&,(-3 &+3 ,- .+2()3-3 &0 9-108+0 <.'%

3.0&,.(.'.-0 )+3-1 '%- BDEF?G5 $%.0 .0 .+ 28*9(-'- 28+'1&3.2'.8+ <.'% '%- #M!M Z`)&(.'7 A2'! <%.2%

3-4.+-0 3.0&,.(.'7 '%)0c

“A person (P) has a disability if—

B)C D 7)% ) 579%2/)- ,( 1'*&)- 215)2(1'*&8 )*"

B#C &7' 215)2(1'*& 7)% ) %$#%&)*&2)- )*" -,*40term adverse effect on P’s ability to

/)((9 ,$& *,(1)- ")90&,0day activities”

$%- BC Government’s 980.'.8+ ./+81-0 &+3 28+'1&3.2'0 '%- 31&4'.+/ &+3 +-/8'.&'.8+ %.0'817 84 '%-

EF?G .+ <%.2% )0-1f0)16.681 81/&+.0&'.8+0 <-1- 918*.+-+' &+3 '%- 6.-<0 84 '%- EF?G E8**.''--

&+3 '%- V9-2.&( F&9981'-)1 481 $81')1- <%8 %8(3 '%&' '%- EF?G .0 '%- ,.+3.+/ %)*&+ 1./%'0

0'&+3&13 .+ '%- 28+'-;' 84 *-+'&( %-&('%5

The UK Government’s position also contradicts the welfare legislation which %&0 08 4&1 1-28/+.0-3

*-+'&( .((+-00 &0 & 28+3.'.8+ '%&' 2&+ /.6- 1.0- '8 3.0&,.(.'7 9&7*-+'05 $%- 2%&+/-0 '8 '%- ,-+-4.'0

system however, coming into force in April 2013, sees the disappearance of “disability benefits” '8

,- 1-9(&2-3 ,7 & ?-108+&( U+3-9-+3-+2- ?&7*-+' L?U?O &+3 & B+.6-10&( E1-3.' 070'-*5 A0 '%-

words “disabled”, “disability” are removed from the rhetoric and discourse on disability, therefore

8+ &22-9'&+2- 84 3.6-10.'7 .+ 082.-'7: '%- +-< 1%-'81.2 -+28)1&/-0 & 2%&+/- .+ people’s attitudes

'%&' -*,1&2-0 & 3.44-1-+' 082.-'&( *83-( ,&0-3 8+ 9183)2'.6.'75 $%.0 *86- .0 9)1-(7 .3-8(8/.2&(:

<.0%.+/ '8 0'1-00 '%&' 9-89(- 2&+ 4)+2'.8+ .11-09-2'.6- 84 '%-.1 3.0&,.(.'7 L.5-5 &0 9183)2'.6-

.+3.6.3)&(0 <%8 9&7 '&;-0 &+3 &1- +8' 1-(.&+' 8+ 082.-'7b -*9(87*-+' ,-.+/ '%- 91.*- 8,>-2'.6-O5

$%.0 <.(( %&6- 31&0'.2 28+0-`)-+2-0 481 &+78+- <.'% & 3.0&,.(.'7: &+3 9800.,(7 /1-&'-1 481 9-108+0

<.'% 9072%8_082.&( 3.0&,.(.'.-0 <%8 %&6- &(1-&37 0'&1'-3 '8 (80- '%-.1 ,-+-4.'0 )+3-1 '%- 1-2-+'

2%&+/-0 '8 '%- <&7 '%-7 &1- &00-00-35 U+ '%.0 9&1'.2)(&1 1-09-2': '%- <&7 '%- BC ^86-1+*-+' .0

9182--3.+/ .0 28*9(-'-(7 28)+'-1 '8 .'0 8,(./&'.8+0 '8<&130 )0-10f0)16.6810 )+3-1 '%- EF?G5 U+ (.+-

<.'% '%- 082.&( *83-( 84 3.0&,.(.'7 918*8'-3 ,7 '%- EF?G: '%- ^86-1+*-+' 0%8)(3 -+0)1- '%&'

)0-10 &+3 0)16.6810 %&6- '%- 0)9981' '%-7 +--3 '8 (.6- .+3-9-+3-+'(7 &+3 ,- 4)((7 .+2()3-3 .+ '%-

28**)+.'7 L&1' !JO &+3 %&6- %8)0.+/ 0-2)1.'7 &+3 &+ &3-`)&'- 0'&+3&13 84 (.6.+/ L&1' #KO5

! %''9cff<<<5(-/.0(&'.8+5/865)=f)=9/&f#M!Mf!Sf9340f)=9/&g#M!MMM!Sg-+5934



K

EYN K$/:+'53' *$5 *II+%-*.%/$ /0 .4' G/$&'$.%/$B

A('%8)/% '%- BD E8+6-+'.8+ 8+ '%- F./%'0 84 ?-108+0 <.'% G.0&,.(.'.-0 LEF?GO L&+3 .'0 P9'.8+&(

?18'828(O <&0 1&'.4.-3 ,7 '%- BC .+ #MMK: .' 1-*&.+0 (&1/-(7 )+=+8<+ &*8+/ '%- 0-16.2- )0-1 &+30)16.681 28**)+.'7 81 '%-.1 2&1-10 L481*&( &+3 .+481*&(O5 $%- EF?G &(08 1-*&.+0 (&1/-(7 )+=+8<+

'8 *-+'&( %-&('% 9184-00.8+&(0: .+2()3.+/ '%80- 91-0.3.+/ .+ *-+'&( %-&('% '1.,)+&(0 L(-/&(

&3*.+.0'1&'.6- &)'%81.'.-0O <%8 &1- '1&.+-3 '8 9-1481* '%-.1 3)'.-0 <.'%.+ '%- 0'1.2' 1-*.' 84 '%-

H-+'&( I-&('% A2': '8 '%.+= '%&' '%- A2' .0 '%- 8+(7 (-/&( 1-4-1-+2- &+3 '%&': ,-2&)0- .' .0 0&.3 '8

28+481* '8 BC I)*&+ F./%'0 (-/.0(&'.8+: .0 0)44.2.-+' '8 0&4-/)&13 '%- 1./%'0 84 )0-10 &+3 0)16.68105

$%)0 '%- EF?G .0 &' '%- 6-17 (-&0' ./+81-3: .4 +8' 3.0*.00-3 ,7 9184-00.8+&(05

$%- BC /86-1+*-+' .0 8,(./-3 '8 1&.0- &<&1-+-00 &,8)' 1./%'0 &+3 3./+.'7 )+3-1 '%- EF?G

&22813.+/ '8 .'0 A1'.2(- K5 U' %&0 '%-1-481- 4&.(-3 '8 8,0-16- '%.0 8,(./&'.8+ &0 <-(( &0 '%80- )+3-1

A1'.2(- !M 84 '%- EA$:

E0 F)/7 ;&)&' D)(&9 %7)-- '*%$(' &7)& '"$/)&2,* )*" 2*.,(1)&2,* ('4)("2*4 &7' 5(,72#2&2,*

)4)2*%& &,(&$(' )(' .$--9 2*/-$"'" 2* &7' &()2*2*4 ,. -)6 '*.,(/'1'*& 5'(%,**'-8 /232- ,(

12-2&)(98 1'"2/)- 5'(%,**'-8 5$#-2/ ,..2/2)-% )*" ,&7'( 5'(%,*% 67, 1)9 #' 2*3,-3'" 2* &7'

/$%&,"98 2*&'((,4)&2,* ,( &(')&1'*& ,. )*9 2*"232"$)- %$#>'/&'" &, )*9 .,(1 ,. )(('%&8

"'&'*&2,* ,( 215(2%,*1'*&?

G0 F)/7 ;&)&' D)(&9 %7)-- 2*/-$"' &72% 5(,72#2&2,* 2* &7' ($-'% ,( 2*%&($/&2,*% 2%%$'" 2* ('4)("

&, &7' "$&2'% )*" .$*/&2,*% ,. )*9 %$/7 5'(%,*%5LBD: !JKQO

$%-1- .0 +8 -6.3-+2- '%&' &+7'%.+/ %&0 08 4&1 ,--+ 81/&+.0-3 '8 -3)2&'- '%-0- 3.44-1-+' /18)90

&,8)' '%- EF?G &+3 .'0 .*9(.2&'.8+0 481 %)*&+ 1./%'0 &+3 '%- H-+'&( I-&('% A2'5 U+481*.+/ &+3

-3)2&'.+/ )0-10 &,8)' '%- EF?G '%)0 (&1/-(7 0'.(( 1-0.3-0 <.'% & %&+34)( 84 )0-1 &2'.6.0'0 <%8 %&6-

(.''(- *-&+0 84 1-&2%.+/ 8)' '8 & <.3- 02&(- 84 4-((8< )0-10 &+3 0)16.6810: 81 '8 9184-00.8+&(05

NY C4' 5/7').%- +'3*+ 0(*7':/(9

NYE C4' 1'$.*+ X'*+.4 8-. EZMP

$%- H-+'&( I-&('% A2' !JK@ L0),0'&+'.&((7 &*-+3-3 .+ #MMNO LGI: !JK@: GI: #MMNO .0 '%- (&< .+

Z+/(&+3 &+3 Wales that allows people with a ‘mental disorder’ to be admitted to hospital )+3-1

3.44-1-+' 0-2'.8+0 84 '%- A2': &+3 3-'&.+-3 &+3 '1-&'-3 <.'%8)' '%-.1 28+0-+' – -.'%-1 481 '%-.1 8<+

%-&('% &+3 0&4-'7: 81 481 '%- 918'-2'.8+ 84 8'%-1 9-89(- LV28'(&+3 &+3 D81'%-1+ U1-(&+3 %&6- '%-.1

own laws about compulsory treatment for mental ill health.). The term ‘sectioned’ is used to

3-021.,- & 28*9)(0817 &3*.00.8+ '8 %809.'&(5 ?-89(- <%8 &1- 28*9)(081.(7 &3*.''-3 '8 %809.'&(

are called ‘formal’ or 'involuntary' patie+'05 VPA? 8,0-16-0 '%&' ,8'% '%- $81')1- F&9981'-)1 &+3



J

'%- EF?G E8**.''-- %&6- 2&((-3 481 '%- 1-9-&( 84 *-+'&( %-&('% (&<0 84 '%.0 =.+3 # : .5-5 (&<0 '%&'

&((8< 481 28*9)(0817 &3*.00.8+ &+3 '1-&'*-+' 8+ '%- ,&0.0 '%&' '%-7 6.8(&'- '%- EF?G5

$%- I)*&+ F./%'0 A2' !JJK .+281981&'-0 *80' 84 '%- Z)189-&+ E8+6-+'.8+ 8+ I)*&+ F./%'0

LZEIFO .+'8 BC (&<5 $%- A2' &99(.-0 '8 &(( 28)1'0 &+3 '1.,)+&(0: .+2()3.+/ *-+'&( %-&('% '1.,)+&(0:&+3 &(( BC (-/.0(&'.8+ .0 -;9-2'-3 '8 ,- 28*9&'.,(- <.'% '%- A2'5 $%.0 %&0 ,--+ *&3- -6.3-+' <.'%

'%- &36-+' 84 '%- H-+'&( E&9&2.'7 A2' #MMS &+3 '%- H-+'&( I-&('% A2' !JK@ L#MMNO: &0 '%-

1-09-2'.6- E83-0 84 ?1&2'.2- 3-021.,- %)*&+ 1./%'0 &09-2'0 .+ '%- .*9(-*-+'&'.8+ 84 ,8'% A2'05

I8<-6-1: '%-1- .0 +8 *-+'.8+ 84 '%- BD EF?G .+ '%- E83-0 84 ?1&2'.2-5 V8*- ^86-1+*-+'

*.+.0'-10 <-1- 1-,)=-3 481 2&((.+/ '%- EF?G “soft law” by the Government’s own I)*&+ F./%'0

E8**.''-- <%8 stressed that the CRPD is “hard law” (legally binding) and in no way “soft law”

L/).3&+2-O5 G1 I7<-( R1&+2.0 H?: E%&.1 84 '%- E8**.''--: 0&.3:

H' )(' /,*/'(*'" &, -')(* &7)& &7' (247& ,. "2%)#-'" 5',5-' &, 2*"'5'*"'*& -232*4 1)9 #' )&

(2%: &7(,$47 &7' /$1$-)&23' 215)/& ,. /$(('*& ('.,(1%? F3'* &7,$47 &7' IJ ()&2.2'" &7'IKLDMN 2* GOOP 62&7 /(,%%05)(&9 %$55,(&8 &7' Q,3'(*1'*& 2% $*)#-' &, "'1,*%&()&' &7)&

%$..2/2'*& ('4)(" 7)% #''* 5)2" &, &7' L,*3'*&2,* 2* &7' "'3'-,51'*& ,. 5,-2/9 62&7 "2('/&

('-'3)*/' &, &7' -23'% ,. "2%)#-'" 5',5-'? R7' (247& &, 2*"'5'*"'*& -232*4 2* IJ -)6 1)9

*''" &, #' %&('*4&7'*'" .$(&7'(8 )*" 6' /)-- ,* &7' Q,3'(*1'*& )*" ,&7'( 2*&'('%&'"

,(4)*2%)&2,*% &, /,*%2"'( &7' *''" .,( ) .(''%&)*"2*4 (247& &, 2*"'5'*"'*& -232*4 2* IJ -)6?

%''9cff<<<5-+.(5-)f+-<0f-+.(_+-<0(-''-1_8+_'%-_>8.+'_28**.''--_8+_%)*&+_1./%'0_

1-981'_8+_.+3-9-+3-+'_(.6.+/_&+3_)+2139fO

V)2% *.01-91-0-+'&'.8+ 84 '%- (-/&( 0'&')0 84 '%- EF?G %&0 '%- 98'-+'.&( '8 -;2()3- 9-89(- <.'%9072%8_082.&( 3.0&,.(.'.-0 418* '%- %./%-0' 0'&+3&13 84 %)*&+ 1./%'0 918'-2'.8+ 481 9-108+0 <.'%

3.0&,.(.'.-05 $%.0 .0 ./+81&+' &+3 %./%(7 9-1+.2.8)05

U+ 9&1'.2)(&1: A1'.2(- ! 84 '%- EF?G 0'&'-0 '%&' '%- 9)1980- 84 '%- E8+6-+'.8+ .0 '8 918'-2' &+3

918*8'- &(( %)*&+ 1./%'0 &+3 4)+3&*-+'&( 41--38*0 84 &(( 9-108+0 <.'% 3.0&,.(.'.-05 $%- ?1-&*,(- 84

'%- '1-&'7 &(08 *&=-0 2(-&1 '%&' 3.0&,.(.'7 .0 &+ “-68(6.+/ 28+2-9'” &+3 '%&' '%- -;9-1.-+2- 84 3.0&,.(.'7

.0 '%- 1-0)(' 84 &''.')3.+&( &+3 -+6.18+*-+'&( ,&11.-10 L.5-5 3.021.*.+&'.8+O '%&' %.+3-1 2-1'&.+ 9-89(-

418* 9&1'.2.9&'.+/ .+ 082.-'7 8+ &+ -`)&( ,&0.0 <.'% 8'%-105 $%.0 481*)(&'.8+ 2(-&1(7 .+2()3-0 )0-10 &+3

0)16.6810 84 9072%.&'17: <%8 <-1- &2'.6- .+ '%- 31&4'.+/ &+3 +-/8'.&'.8+ 84 '%.0 %)*&+ 1./%'0 '1-&'75

# EF?G E8**.''-- E8+2()3.+/ P,0-16&'.8+0 8+ $)+.0.& LEF?GfEf$BDfEPf!: !@ H&7 #M!!: 9&1& #SO: V9&.+LEF?GfEfZV?fEPf!: !J P2'8,-1 #M!!: 9&1& @aO: ?-1) LEF?GfEf?ZFfEPf!: J H&7 #M!#: 9&1& #JO5



!M

@82C CSAB 8$ 'D*7I+' /0 4>7*$ (%34. &%/+*.%/$) %$ .4' -/77>$%.O >$5'( .4'

7'$.*+ 4'*+.4 *-.

PY Q>I'(&%)'5 G/77>$%.O C('*.7'$.)

PYE G/77>$%.O C('*.7'$. A(5'()

U+ P2'8,-1 #MMK &*-+3*-+'0 '8 '%- H-+'&( I-&('% A2' !JK@ LGI: !JK@O 2&*- .+'8 -44-2' 6.& '%-

V)9-16.0-3 E8**)+.'7 $1-&'*-+' LVE$O 9186.0.8+0 84 '%- H-+'&( I-&('% A2' #MMN LGI: #MMNO5 VE$

-+&,(-3 2(.+.2.&+0 .+ Z+/(&+3 &+3 [&(-0 '8 *&=- & 28**)+.'7 '1-&'*-+' 813-1 LE$PO )+3-1 <%.2%

'%-7 28)(3 1-`).1- 2-1'&.+ 9&'.-+'0 '8 &22-9' '1-&'*-+' .+ '%- 28**)+.'7 48((8<.+/ 3.02%&1/-

418* 28*9)(0817 3-'-+'.8+ .+ %809.'&(5 $%- +-< 0-2'.8+0 '%)0 .+'183)2- '%- 3-4.+.'.8+ ]28**)+.'7

9&'.-+'] '8 1-4-1 '8 & 9-108+ <%8 .0 0),>-2' '8 & E$P5 VE$ .0 3.02)00-3 .+ 2%&9'-1 #K 84 '%- G1&4'1-6.0-3 H-+'&( I-&('% A2' !JK@ E83- 84 ?1&2'.2- 481 Z+/(&+3 L\'%- 31&4' E83- 481 Z+/(&+3\O &+3

2%&9'-1 #a 84 '%- 31&4' E83- 481 [&(-05

$%- (&'-0' 3&'& 481 #M!!f!# L481 Z+/(&+3O 0)//-0' '%&' '%- +)*,-1 84 9-89(- 0),>-2' '8 3-'-+'.8+

)+3-1 '%- H-+'&( I-&('% A2' 28+'.+)-0 '8 1.0-5 $%-1- .0 .+21-&0.+/ )0- 84 E8**)+.'7 $1-&'*-+'

P13-10 LE$P0O <.'% +-&1(7 %&(4 -+3.+/ <.'% '%- 1-.+0'&'-*-+' 84 '%- )+3-1(7.+/ 3-'-+'.8+ V-2'.8+5

LIVEUE: #M!#O5 R./)1-0 481 Z+/(&+3 481 #M!!f#M!# L(&'-0'O 0%8< '%&'c

P+ '%- @!0' H&12% L#M!#O: ##:#aN 9-89(- <-1- 0),>-2' '8 3-'-+'.8+ 81 E$P 1-0'1.2'.8+0

)+3-1 $%- A2' .+ DIV &+3 .+3-9-+3-+' 0-2'81 %809.'&(05 $%.0 1-91-0-+'0 & a 9-1 2-+'

.+21-&0- 0.+2- '%- 91-6.8)0 7-&1 &+3 .+2()3-0 !N:SM@ 9-89(- <-1- 3-'&.+-3 .+ %809.'&( &+3Q:NaQ 9-89(- 0),>-2' '8 & E$P5

$%-1- <-1- & '8'&( 84 QK:a@! 3-'-+'.8+0 .+ DIV &+3 .+3-9-+3-+' %809.'&(0 3)1.+/ #M!!f!#5

$%.0 +)*,-1 <&0 S 9-1 2-+' L#:#K@O /1-&'-1 '%&+ 3)1.+/ '%- #M!Mf!! 1-981'.+/ 9-1.835

$8'&( 3-'-+'.8+0 .+ .+3-9-+3-+' 0-2'81 %809.'&(0 .+21-&0-3 ,7 #! 9-1 2-+'b & (&1/-

918981'.8+ 84 '%.0 .+21-&0- <&0 &''1.,)'&,(- '8 & QS 9-1 2-+' .+21-&0- .+ )0-0 84 V-2'.8+ #5

$%-1- <-1- Q:##M E$P0 *&3- 3)1.+/ #M!!f!#: &+ .+21-&0- 84 @Ka L!M 9-1 2-+'O 0.+2-

#M!Mf!!5 $%- +)*,-1 84 E$P 1-2&((0 .+21-&0-3 ,7 @M 9-1 2-+' &+3 .' .0 -0'.*&'-3 '%&'

&18)+3 NM 9-1 2-+' -+3-3 .+ & 1-682&'.8+ L&+ .+21-&0- 84 &9918;.*&'-(7 !M 9-12-+'&/-

98.+'0 0.+2- (&0' 7-&1O5 $%- 1.0- .+ E$P 1-2&((0 &+3 1-682&'.8+0 *&7 ,- (.+=-3 '8 '%- a 9-1

2-+' 1-3)2'.8+ LQN@O .+ )0-0 84 ?&1' UU V-2'.8+ @ 84 $%- A2'5LIVEUE: #M!#O



!!

PYN C').%7/$%') B

*Y X*O:*(5[) )/$ :*) *((').'5 <O .4' I/+%-' 0/( 0*%+%$3 ./ -/7I+O :%.4 4%) GCAY

S)%2/)--9 &7'9 &,,: 721 )6)9 2* 7)*"/$..%8 #'/)$%' &7'9 %$%5'/&'" 7' 6)% *,& &):2*4 &7'2(

"($4%???&7'9 4,& 7218 5$& 721 2* 5,-2/' 3)*8 7' 6)2&'" 8 7)*"/$..'"8 .,( ,3'( G 7(%8 1)9#'

&7(''8 .,( ) T7,%52&)- #'"T 5 LA+.'& I&7<&13: #M!#: 9-108+&( 28**)+.2&'.8+O

<Y Jean’s account of being on a CTO: “A danger and a nuisance” ! #$%& '( )*+ ,-

@& #'4)* )-1,%& )% %,,* )% &7' K'6 U)#,$( 4,3'(*1'*& &,,: 5,6'( 2* EPPV? R7'(' 6'('

($1,$(% ,. ) *'6 W'*&)- X')-&7 !/&8 &, ('5lace the one brought in by Margaret Thatcher’s

government in 1983. Users and survivors understood it wouldn’t be the Mental Health Act

we wanted when Frank Dobson, then Minister for Health, famously pronounced that “the

mentally ill” were “a danger and a nuisance”.

R7' Y2&, R($%& 7)" #''* -,##92*4 .,( ) /7)*4' 2* &7' -)6 .,( %,1' &21'? R72% ,(4)*2%)&2,*

6)% %'& $5 #9 &7' 62",6 ,. Z,*)&7)* Y2&,8 ) -)69'(8 67, 7)" #''* ()*",1-9 %&)##'" &,

"')&7 #9 L7(2%&,57'( L-$*2%8 ) #-)/: 1)* 62&7 ) "2)4*,%2% ,. %/72[,57('*2)? H72-' @ 7)3'

'3'(9 %915)&79 62&7 Z)9*' Y2&,8 @ 7)3' &, %)9 &7)& 5,%%2#-9 7'( ,(4)*2%)&2,* "2" *,&

('5('%'*& &7' 1,%& #)-)*/'" 32'6 ,* &7' %$#>'/& ,. /,15$-%2,* 2* 1'*&)- 7')-&7?

R7' Q,3'(*1'*& -,,:'" &, &7' I;!8 67'(' %,1' %&)&'% 7)" )-(')"9 %'& $5 @*3,-$*&)(9

\$&5)&2'*& L,112&1'*& D(,4()1%? @& /,*%$-&'" 62&7 5%9/72)&(2%&%8 67, ,. /,$(%' &,-" &7'1

that the problem was that people weren’t taking their medication. If only people would

&):' &7'2( 1'"2/)&2,*8 &7'9 6,$-" #' %).' &, -23' 2* &7' /,11$*2& y, they wouldn’t have to

#' (')"12&&'"8 #'" ,//$5)*/9 ()&'% 6,$-" .)--8 )*" %, ,*? R7' Q,3'(*1'*& 5(,5,%'"

L,11$*2&9 R(')&1'*& \("'(%8 )-%, :*,6* )% ;$5'(32%'" L,11$*2&9 R(')&1'*&? D',5-'

6,$-" #' .,(/'" &, &):' 1'"2/)&2,* 672-' &7'9 6'(' -232*4 2* &7'2( own homes. “Non0

compliance is not an option.” thundered another minister.

I%'(% )*" %$(323,(% )*" ,$( )--2'% 1,#2-2['"? H' "'1,*%&()&'"8 6' 5'&2&2,*'"8 6' -,##2'"8

we came out to the media, we made music and art and books and films. “Recovery begins

62&7 *,*0compliance” said one placard. We were broadly against coercion and force. We

6'(' /,*/'(*'" &7)& &7' -)6 6,$-" #' )55-2'" 62"'-9 &, &7,$%)*"% ,. 2**,/'*& 5',5-'?

The Government just wouldn’t listen to us. I remember going to see my MP, a Labour MP.

He wouldn’t let me speak, and it was clear to me that he didn’t understand the issues at all,

he kept talking about “squaring the circle”, whatever that means. His mind was entirely

focused on dangerousness. What he couldn’t recognise was that in front of 721 6)% ) %1)--

12""-'0)4'" 6,1)* 67, 6,(:'" )% ) -2#()(9 )%%2%&)*&8 ) 1,&7'( ,. ) &''*)4' ")$47&'(8

who’d always voted Labour, had never hurt a soul, and that as someone with a history of

5%9/72)&(2/ )"12%%2,*% @ 6)% )& (2%: ,. .)--2*4 $*"'( &72% -'42%-)&2,*?

@ %)& $5%&)2(% 2* &7' X,$%' ,. U,("% 672-' &7'9 "'#)&'" &7' 2%%$'? S9 &72% &21' &7' "'#)&'

7)" 1,3'" ,* .(,1 ()*",1 %&)##2*4% )*" @ 7)" &, -2%&'* &, &7'1 &)-: ,. &7,%' 5,,(



!#

5)&7'&2/ %,$-% 67, #'/)1' ('3,-32*4 ",,( 5)&2'*&% 62&7 ('5')&'" 7,%52&)- )"12%%2,*%

because they didn’t understand how important it was to take the medication which was so

4,," .,( &7'1? R72% -'42%-)&2,* 6,$-" 7'-5 &7'18 &7'9 )4(''"8 "(2552*4 62&7 /,15)%%2,*?

](,1 GOO^02009, I became a revolving door patient. I don’t actually :*,6 7,6 1)*9

7,%52&)- )"12%%2,*% @ 7)" )% 2& )-- #'/)1' ) #2& ,. ) #-$(? R7'9 6,$-" 5$& 1' 2* 7,%52&)-8

.,(/' 1' &, &):' &7' 1'"2/)&2,*8 -'& 1' ,$& ).&'( ) .'6 6'':%8 @ 6,$-" %&,5 &):2*4 &7'

1'"2/)&2,*8 &7'9 6,$-" ,#%'(3' 1' 2* &7' ')(-9 %&)4'% ,. 62&7"()6)-8 %)9 @ 6)% %'-.0

*'4-'/&2*4 )*" 5$& 1' #)/: 2* 7,%52&)- )4)2*? @& 6)% 5('&&9 &()$1)&2/? R7' 1'*&)- 7')-&7

%'(32/'% ('.$%' &, ('/,4*2%' &7'2( /'*&()- (,-' 2* /)$%2*4 &7' &()$1)?

@* GOOV the new legislation was passed. They didn’t make a new Mental Heal &7 !/&8 &7'9

>$%& )1'*"'" &7' ,-" ,*'?

@* GOOP @ 6)% 5$& ,* ) L,11$*2&9 R(')&1'*& \("'(? R7' &'(1% ,. &7' ,("'( )('_

R, ('%2"' )& 19 /$(('*& )""('%%

R, :''5 )55,2*&1'*&% 62&7 /)(' /,0,("2*)&,( B $%$)--9 ) *$(%' ,( %,/2)- 6,(:'(C

R, :''5 )55,2*&1'*&% 62&7 5%9/72)&(2%&

R, /,15-9 62&7 1'"2/)&2,*

@. @ ", *,& :''5 &7'%' /,*"2&2,*% @ /)* #' ('/)--'" &, 7,%52&)-? @ /)* #' ('/)--'" &, 7,%52&)-

'3'* 2. @ ", :''5 )-- &7' /,*"2&2,*% 2. &7'(' )(' /,*/'(*% )#,$& 19 1'*&)- 7')-&7?

@ 7)3' #''* ('/)--'" ,*/'? R7' ",/&,( %'*& 1' ) -'&&'( 2*%&($/&2*4 1' &, ('5,(& &, 7,%52&)-?

@ 24*,('" 2&? W9 %,/2)- 6,(:'( 4,& &7' :'9% &, 19 .-)& .(,1 19 '=07$%#)*"8 -'& 7'(%'-. 2*

)//,15)*2'" #9 5,-2/' )*" @ 6)% &()*%5,(&'" #)/: &, 7,%52&)- 2* )* )1#$-)*/'? R7' LR\

6)% ('3,:'" )*" @ 6)% 7'-" 2* 7,%52&)- )*" &(')&'" )4)2*%& 19 62-- $*"'( &7' W'*&)- X')-&7

!/& .,( &7('' 6'':%? R7'* &7'9 ('-')%'" 1' $*"'( ) LR\ )4)2*?

!.&'( &7)& @ 6)% 5$& ,* "'5,& 1'"2/)&2,*? @ 7)3' &, 4, &, &7' /-2*2/ ('4$-)(-9 &, #' 2*>'/&'"

2* &7' #)/:%2"'? @& 2% "''5-9 7$12-2)&2*4? @ 6,$-" *'3'( )4('' &, &72% ,. 19 ,6* .('' 62--?

H7'* @ 6)% .2(%& ,* &7' "'5,&8 @ >$%& $%'" &, -2' 2* #'" )-- ")9? R7' 1'"2/)&2,* 1)"' 1' .''-

&,&)--9 [,*:'" ,$& )*" "'1,&23)&'"? @ )-%, .'-& "'4()"'" )*" "'1,()-2%'" #'/)$%' @ 6)% ,*

&7' LR\? H7'* @ "2" 4'& $5 @ >$%& %-$15'" 2* .(,*& ,. &7' R̀ ? @ %&,55'" (')"2*4 #'/)$%' @

just couldn’t take it in. I have always read and I have always been an active and creative

5'(%,*?

I didn’t have the energy or the will to argue with the professionals any 1,('? R7'9 &7,$47&

&72% 6)% )* 215(,3'1'*&?

W,(' ('/'*&-9 19 5%9/72)&(2%& 7)% #''* 5'(%$)"'" &, ('"$/' &7' ",%'? @ )1 )#-' &, ", ) #2&

1,(' )*" @ 7)3' 1,(' '*'(498 #$& &7' 5(2*/25-' ('1)2*% &7' %)1'? @ 7)3' *, /7,2/' )#,$&

67)& 4,'% 2*&, 19 ,6* 12*" )*" #,"9? R72% 2% ) 7$1)* (247&% 2%%$'?

I*"'( ) LR\ &7' ('-)&2,*%725 #'&6''* ",/&,( )*" 5)&2'*& #'/,1'% &7)& ,. 1)%&'( )*"

%-)3'?



!@

@ ", 7)3' %,1' (247&%? @ 7)3' &7' (247& &, )55')- &, ) R(2#$*)- ,*/' ) 9')(? R7' R(2#$*)-

/,*%2%&% ,. &7('' 5',5-' 67, 7)3' *'3'( 1'& 1' )*" 19 %,-2/2&,( 7)% )#,$& )* 7,$( &,

/,*32*/' &7'1 &7)& 19 5%9/72)&(2%& 2% 6(,*4 )*" @ %7,$-" *,& #' &(')&'" &72% 6)9? W,%& ,.

this hour is taken up with the psychiatrist’s evidence. At the end I get about five minutes to#'4 .,( 19 .(''",1?

;&$"2'% 7)3' %7,6* &7)& S-)/: )*" 12*,(2&9 '&7*2/ 5',5-' )(' ,3'(0('5('%'*&'" 2* &7'

*$1#'(% ,. 5',5-' %$#>'/& &, 1'*&)- 7')-&7 -'42%-)&2,*? @ -,,: )(,$*" &7' 6)2&2*4 (,,1 )&

&7' "'5,& /-2*2/ )*" 6' )(' '=/-$%23'-9 5,,( )*" 6,(:2*4 /-)%%?

!//,("2*4 & o the Guardian, over 6000 CTO’s were issued in the UK up to 2011. This is ten

&21'% &7' ,(242*)- Q,3'(*1'*& '%&21)&'?

I put this figure to a senior psychiatrist at the hospital. “That’s 6000 people who would

otherwise be being treated in hospital,” he said, “It’s the least restrictive option.”

Maybe it’s 6000 people who would otherwise be free to make their own treatment

"'/2%2,*%8 -2:' )*9 ,&7'( 1'1#'( ,. %,/2'&9?

L%''9cff<<<5/)&13.&+5285)=f082.-'7f#M!!f*&1f!Sf*-+'&(_%-&('%_9&'.-+'0_4812-3_

3-'-+'.8+O

-Y 8 &%5'/ <O * QA8@ 7'7<'( :4/ 4*) 'DI'(%'$-'5 GCA) %) *&*%+*<+' 4'('B

%''9cff09-&=8)'&/&.+0'9072%.&'17581/f3-98'_.+>-2'.8+_18,0_&1'.0'_84_%-1_21-&'.6.'7f

5Y [1O G/77>$%.O C('*.7'$. A(5'( :*) .4' 7'$.*+ 4'*+.4 '\>%&*+'$. /0 4*&%$3 * .*3[

%''9cff<<<5.+3-9-+3-+'5285)=f(.4-_0'7(-f%-&('%_&+3_4&*.(.-0f%-&('%_+-<0f9072%.&'1.2_

&0,80_<-1-_&+_-1181_0&70_=-7_&36.081_KSN#!@K5%'*(

D)$- L7)51)* 7)" >$%& 4,& 1)((2'" 67'* 7' 6)% .2(%& 5-)/'" ,* ) L,11$*2&9 R(')&1'*&

\("'( BLR\C 2* GOOP? X' 7)" ) 72%&,(9 ,. 1'*&)- 2--*'%% )*" 7)" #''* )"12&&'" &, 7,%52&)-

%,1' G^ &21'% %2*/' .2(%& #'2*4 "2)4*,%'" 62&7 #25,-)( "2%,("'( )*" ,&7'( .,(1% ,.

5%9/7,%2% 2* EPPE?

\* &72% ,//)%2,*8 7' 7)" #''* %'/&2,*'" &, ) 5%9/72)&(2/ 6)(" ).&'( 7' #'4)* 7')(2*4 3,2/'%

)*" 72% 5%9/7,&2/ '52%,"'% ('024*2&'"? !.&'( 7' )#%/,*"'" .(,1 &7' 6)("8 72% 62.'

5'(%$)"'" &7' 7,%52&)- &7)& 7' 6,$-" #' #'&&'( /)('" .,( )& 7,1'8 %, 7' 6)% "2%/7)(4'" ,*

&7' LR\?

X,6'3'(8 D)$-8 .(,1 S(244 2* U2*/,-*%72('8 %)9% 67)& 7)" .2(%& %''1'" -2:' )* )&&()/&23'

,5&2,* &$(*'" 2*&, %,1'&72*4 -'%% 5,%2&23'? R7' ab09')(0,-" "'%/(2#'% 7,6 #'2*4 5$& ,* )

LR\ /7)*4'" 72% ('-)&2,*%725 62&7 72% .)12-9 )*" /)('(_ ()&7'( &7)* #'2*4 #)%'" ,*

'15)&798 2& #'/)1' ) 1$/7 1,(' -'4)-2%&2/ )(()*4'1'*&?

c@*%&')" ,. &7'1 #'2*4 /,*/'(*'" ,$& ,. /)(' )*" /,15)%%2,* .,( &7' 5(,#-'1 @ 6)% 7)32*48

&7'(' 6)% (')%,* .,( &7'1 &, #' ('%5,*%2#-' )*" 7)3' )$&7,(2&9 ,3'( 1'8c 7' %)9%?

c@ &72*: @ 7)" &, #' %''* #9 19 %5'/2)-2%& /)(' 6,(:'( ,*/' ) .,(&*247& )*" &7'(' 6)% )

-,/:",6* ,* 1'"2/)&2,* – &7'(' 6)% *, 1'%%2*4 62&7 19 1'"2/)&2,*? @& 6)% &7' 1'*&)-



!Q

7')-&7 '<$23)-'*& ,. 7)32*4 ) &)4? @. @ #'/)1' $*6'-- )4)2* ,( %&,55'" &):2*4 19

1'"2/)&2,* – -2:' ('0,..'*"2*4 – @ 6,$-" 7)3' 4,*' %&()247& #)/: 2*&, 7,%52&)-?c

!.&'( ) .'6 1,*&7%8 7' 2*<$2('" )#,$& #'2*4 &):'* ,.. &7' LR\ #$& 6)% &$(*'" ",6*_ c@ .'-&

%&241)&2%'" #9 2&? S'/)$%' ,. &7' *)&$(' ,. 19 /,*"2&2,*8 @ .'-& ,&7'( 5',5-' 1247& :*,6 )*"

&72*:8 TX' 1$%& #' #)"8 7'T% ,* ) LR\T?c

'Y 8 7/.4'( /0 .:/ 5*>34.'() :%.4 'DI'(%'$-' /0 GCA)] )*O)

H'-- 19 ")$47&'(% 7)3' #,&7 #''* %'/&2,*'"? R7' 9,$*4'( ,*' 6)% "($44'" )% ) /72-"? !

LR\ 2% )-- )#,$& .,(/'" "($442*4 )*" 19 '-"'( ")$47&'( 2% ,* ) LR\ (247& *,6 $*"'( 5(23)&'

%'/&,( )*" 2% /7(,*2/ &(')&1'*& ('%2%&)*&?

D(,. d 5(,12%'" ) "($4 .('' 5'(2," )*" %7' 6)% ) 3,-$*&)(9 5)&2'*& &, %&)(& ,.. 62&7 )*"

&7'* '*"'" $5 ,* ) LR\ 672/7 2% /,*&2*$2*4 (247& *,6? @ )1 2* &,$/7 62&7 1)*9 ,&7'(1,&7'(% 67, )-%, 7)3' %,*%e")$47&'(% ,* LR\% "($44'" $5 &, &7'2( *'/:% 0 ,*' 1,&7'( 7)%

7'( %,* ,* EfOO 14 ,. "($4% )*" 7' /)* 7)("-9 1,3'? S9 &7' 6)9 &7' "($4 #'2*4 423'* ,*

&72% LR\ 2% /)--'" W'&.,(12*' .,( "2)#'&'% ÔO14 )*" 9'& 2% #'2*4 423'* ,.. -)#'- .,( 6'247&

-,%% )*" ,* &,5 ,. &72% 2% &7' L-,[)52*' fOO14? W9 ")$47&'( %5,:' ,. %&).. 6)&/72*4 7'(

'3'(9 1,3'8 ,. %&).. %7,$&2*4? ;7' 2% ,* ) LR\ )*" #'2*4 .,(/'" &, &):' &7'%' "($4%?

W9 9,$*4'%&8 ) #$--92*4 32/&21 6)% 423'* M2%52(2")- )% ) /72-" )*" %'/&2,*'"? ;$5'(32%'"

57,*' /)--%e'%/,(&'" -')3' )% ) ('%$-& ,. '*.,(/'" LR\5

0Y C4' 7/(*+ -*(''( /0 * I*.%'$. >$5'( GCA

A+ U+3-9-+3-+' H-+'&( I-&('% A3682&'- 3-021.,-0 <%&' %- 2&((0 '%- '79.2&( “moral career”

84 '%- E$P 9&'.-+'c *)('.9(- &3*.00.8+0 &0082.&'-3 <.'% +8' '&=.+/ *-3.2&'.8+ &+3 >)0' +8'

,-.+/ (.0'-+-3 '88 <%-+ '%-7 1&.0- 28+2-1+0 &,8)' *-3.2&'.8+ &+3 0.3- -44-2'05

L-2'*& $*"'( LR\_ ;/'*)(2,_

! &6'*&9 .23' 9')( ,-" 1)-' 67, 7)" #''* "'&)2*'" #9 5,-2/' $*"'( ;'/&2,* Efb ,. &7' WX

Act while behaving in a way considered to be “odd” and distressed to police officers. After a

EG 7,$( 6)2& 2* ) 5,-2/' %&)&2,* 7' 6)% )%%'%%'" #9 ) "$&9 5%9/72)&(2%& 67, &7,$47& 7' 6)%

suffering from a “bipolar episode” and needed an acute admission. After a three month

)"12%%2,* &, ) -,/)- 7,%52&)-8 "$(2*4 672/7 7' ()2%'% /,*/'(*% )#,$& %2"' '..'/&%8 &7' /-2'*&

)4(''" &, &):' 1'"2/)&2,* )*" 6)% "2%/7)(4'" 7,1'? R7('' 6'':% -)&'(8 7)32*4 )55)('*&-9

%&,55'" &):2*48 1'"2/)&2,* 7' 2% "'&)2*'" )4)2* #9 5,-2/' )*" 5-)/'" 2* &7' %'/$(' 6)(" ,.

) -,/)- 5%9/72)&(2/ 7,%52&)-? ! 1,*&7 -)&'( "'%52&' 72% ,#>'/&2,*% &, &7' 1'"2/)&2,* 7' 2%

"2%/7)(4'" .(,1 7,%52&)- #$& &72% &21' 7' 7)% &, )4('' &, )&&'*" ) -,/)- ")9 7,%52&)- .,(

"'5,& 2*>'/&2,*%? H2&72* &6, 6'':% 7' 7)% %&,55'" )&&'*"2*4 &7' ")9 7,%52&)- )*" 7'*/'

accepting the depot injections. Friends say they haven’t seen him for a week but that he

7)" /,15-)2*'" ,. 1'"2/)&2,* %2"' '..'/&% 672/7 &7'9 %)9 7' 7)" ()2%'" 62&7 72%

Community Nurse but which, they say, hadn’t resulted in any changes to his medication.



!S

The Mental Health Team decide that they cannot do anything because he isn’t subject to

&7' W'*&)- X')-&7 !/&? R6, 6'':% -)&'( &7' W'*&)- X')-&7 R')1 )(' /)--'" &, )* 2*/2"'*&

)& 72% .-)& )*" "'&)2* 721 $*"'( ;'/&2,* f ,. &7' W'*&)- X')-&7 !/&?

N$(2*4 72% )"12%%2,* &7' /-2'*& '=5('%%'% /,*%&)*& /,*/'(*% )#,$& 1'"2/)&2,* )*" 62-- ,*-9

)4('' &, &):' 2& ,()--9? K, /7)*4'% )(' 1)"' &, &7' 1'"2/)&2,* )*" 7' 2% '3'*&$)--9

.,(/'.$--9 423'* ) "'5,& 2*>'/&2,* ,. 1'"2/)&2,*? ]2*)--9 f 1,*&7% 2*&, &7' )"12%%2,* 7'

)4(''% &, )//'5& "'5,& )*" )55')(% 1,(' '*4)42*4 )*" /,,5'()&23' &, &7' %'(32/'%?

X,6'3'(8 )& &7' .2*)- LD! 5(2,( &, "2%/7)(4' 7' 2% &,-" &7)& &7'9 2*&'*" &, 5-)/' 721 ,* )

L,11$*2&9 R(')&1'*& \("'( BLR\C )*" ,*' ,. &7' /,*"2&2,*% ,. 72% "2%/7)(4' 62-- #' &7)&

7' )4(''% &, )&&'*" &7' ")9 7,%52&)-? X' ,#>'/&% #$& .2*)--9 "'/2"'% &7)& )4(''2*4 &, &72% 2%

#'&&'( &7)* %&)92*4 2* 7,%52&)-?

! 1,*&7 ).&'( #'2*4 "2%/7)(4'" 7' 2% &,-" #9 )*,&7'( '= 05)&2'*& &7)& 7' /)* )55')- )4)2*%&

&7' LR\? X' /,*&)/&% 72% -,/)- @*"'5'*"'*& W'*&)- X')-&7 !"3,/)/9 ;'(32/' 67, 7'-5 721%&)(& )* )55')-% 5(,/'%% 62&7 ('4)(" &, &7' LR\? X,6'3'(8 "$(2*4 &7' 5(,/'%% &7' W'*&)-

Health team argue that because of the “nature” of his illness, it is likely that it will return if

/,*"2&2,*% )(' *,& 2* 5-)/' &, '*%$(' 7' 62-- /,*&2*$' 72% "'5,& 2*>'/&2,*%?

L?&)( $)1+-1: 9-108+&( 28**)+.2&'.8+: #M!@O

3Y Q.*.'7'$. 0(/7 *$/.4'( =$5'I'$5'$. 1'$.*+ X'*+.4 85&/-*.'’s 'DI'(%'$-' /0

:/(9%$3 :%.4 GCA I*.%'$.)

H,(:2*4 )% )* @*"'5'*"'*& W'*&)- X')-&7 !"3,/)&' B@WX!C @ 1''& ) -,& ,. /-2'*&% 67, )('

%$#>'/& &, LR\%? H7)& @ 7)3' %''* ,* %'3'()- ,//)%2,*% 2% &7' 5(,.'%%2,*)-% &'-- &7' 5)&2'*&

&7)& &7'9 1$%& &):' &7' 1'"2/)&2,* #'/)$%' ,. &7' LR\8 )*" 2. &7'9 ", *,& &7'9 62-- #'

&):'* %&()247& #)/: &, 7,%52&)-? !% 1)*9 5)&2'*&% .2*" 7,%52&)- &, #' ) "2%&('%%2*4

'*32(,*1'*&8 &72% /)$%'% &7'1 &, /,15-9 62&7 &7' &(')&1'*& ,$& ,. .')( ,. #'2*4 &):'*

#)/: 2*?

I believe this is incorrect practice and not what CTO’s were created for.

! LR\ 2% %$55,%'" &, '*%$(' &7)& ) 5)&2'*& /)* #' ')%2-9 (')"12&&'" &, 7,%52&)- 2* &7' '3'*&

&7'9 #'/,1' $*6'--8 )*" 2% *,& "'%24*'" %215-9 &, #' ) 6)9 ,. /,'(/2*4 &7'1 &, &):'

1'"2/)&2,*? L,15-92*4 62&7 &(')&1'*& 1)9 #' ,*' ,. &7' /,*"2&2,*% ,. &7' LR\8 #$&

#('):2*4 &72% /,*"2&2,* ",'% *,& 1')* &7' 5)&2'*& 2% )$&,1)&2/)--9 &):'* #)/: &, 7,%52&)-?

!//,("2*4 &, &7' W'*&)- X')-&7 !/& L,"' ,. 5()/&2/'_

“Appropriate action wil - *''" &, #' &):'* 2. &7' 5)&2'*& #'/,1'% $*6'--8 '*4)4'% 2* 72470

(2%: #'7)32,$( )% ) ('%$-& ,. 1'*&)- "2%,("'( ,( 62&7"()6% /,*%'*& &, &(')&1'*& B,( #'42*%

&, ,#>'/& &, 2&C? R7' ML %7,$-" /,*%2"'(8 62&7 &7' 5)&2'*& B)*" ,&7'(% 67'(' )55(,5(2)&'C8

&7' (')%,*% .,( &72% )*" 67)& &7' *'=& %&'5% %7,$-" #'? @. &7' 5)&2'*& ('.$%'% /($/2)-

&(')&1'*&8 )* $(4'*& ('32'6 ,. &7' %2&$)&2,* 62-- #' *''"'"8 )*" ('/)--2*4 &7' 5)&2'*& &,

7,%52&)- 62-- #' )* ,5&2,* 2. &7' (2%: >$%&2.2'% 2&? @. %$2&)#-' )-&'(*)&23' &(')&1'*& 2% )3)2-)#-'

672/7 6,$-" )--,6 ;LR &, /,*&2*$' %).'-9 )*" 672/7 &7' 5)&2'*& 6,$-" )//'5&8 &7' ML



!a

%7,$-" /,*%2"'( %$/7 &(')&1'*& 2. &72% /)* #' ,..'('"? @. %,8 &7' &(')&1'*& 5-)*8 )*" 2.

necessary the conditions of the CTO, should be varied accordingly.”

;, 2. ) 5)&2'*& 2% *,& )4(''2*4 62&7 &7' 1'"2/)&2,* ,( )*,&7'( /,*"2&2,* ,. &7' LR\8 &7'('

%7,$-" #' ) "2%/$%%2,* 62&7 &7' 5)&2'*& )*" )-&'(*)&23'% %7,$-" #' /,*%2"'('"? @* (')-2&9 @

7)3' *,& %''* &72% '=5-)2*'" &, 5)&2'*&%8 &7'9 )(' %215-9 &,-" &7'9 1$%& /,15-9 ,( &7'9 62--

#' &):'* #)/: &, 7,%52&)-? @* (')-2&9 *,#,"9 /)* #' .,(/'" &, &):' 1'"2/)&2,* 2* &7'

/,11$*2&98 ,*-9 $*"'( ) %'/&2,* 2* 7,%52&)-? H7)& @ .''- 2% 7)55'*2*4 62&7 LR\% 2%

5(,.'%%2,*)-% )(' $%2*4 &7'1 &, 4'& (,$*" &72% #9 .(247&'*2*4 5',5-' 2*&, /,15-92*4 62&7

1'"2/)&2,*?

W)*9 5)&2'*&% @ 7)3' %5,:'* &, 7)3' &,-" 1' &7)& &7' LR\ 1):'% &7'1 .''- -2:' &7'9 /)**,&

#' &($%&'" &, &):' /)(' ,. &7'1%'-3'%8 )*" &7)& &7'9 62-- *'3'( #' .('' .(,1 1'*&)- 7')-&7

%'(32/'%?

@ 7)3' %''* 1)*9 5)&2'*&% )55-9 &, &7' &(2#$*)- &, &(9 &, )55')- &7' LR\8 #$& *'3'(%$//'%%.$--9? @. &7' 5)&2'*& 2% ",2*4 6'--8 &72% 2% ,.&'* %''* )% 5(,,. &7' LR\ 2% 6,(:2*4 %,

&7'9 )(' :'5& ,* 2&8 2. &7'9 )(' ",2*4 #)"-9 )*" )(' ,.&'* #'2*4 (')"12&&'" &, 7,%52&)- &7'*

&7' LR\ 62-- #' %''* )% *'/'%%)(9? R72% /(')&'% ) /)&/70GG %2&$)&2,* 67'(' &7' 5)&2'*& /)*

#' %$#>'/& &, &7' ,("'( .,( 9')(%? @ ", *,& &72*: 5(,.'%%2,*)-% 4'*'()--9 )55('/2)&' 7,6 2&

.''-% &, #' -232*4 62&7 &7' /,*%&)*& &7(')& ,. #'2*4 &):'* #)/: &, 7,%52&)-8 )*" &7' '..'/& &72%

7)% ,* 5',5-'%T 1'*&)- 7')-&7?

LW&=- V-,&0'.&+: 9-108+&( 28**)+.2&'.8+: #M!@O

4Y 1'$.*+ 4'*+.4 I*.%'$.) -/7I+*%$ /0 [^/7<%0%-*.%/$[ "WD-'))%&' >)' /0 0/(-'5 5'.'$.%/$

*$5 -/'(-'5 .('*.7'$. <O .4' FXQ 7'*$) I*.%'$.) 4*&' +%..+' -/$.(/+ /&'( .4'%(

.('*.7'$." 1*(9 _/>+5] C4' _>*(5%*$] C>')5*O E ? 1*(-4 N REE

c@ #'/)1' T[,1#2.2'"T .,( *')(-9 EG 1,*&7% 67'* @ 6)% .,(/'" &, &):' 1,," %&)#2-2%'(% )*"

)*&25%9/7,&2/ 1'"2/)&2,*8c %)9% M':) J(2'4? R7' fO09')(0,-" 7)% #25,-)( "2%,("'(8 %, 7)%

5'(2,"% ,. 1)*2/ )/&232&9 )*" 5%9/7,&2/ '52%,"'%8 672/7 -'" &, 7'( #'2*4 .,(/2#-9 "'&)2*'"

)*" &(')&'" 2* 7,%52&)- 2* GOOP?

J(2'4T% /)%' '='15-2.2'% &7' /(2%2% 2* KX; 5%9/72)&(2/ /)('8 672/7 2% ('%$-&2*4 2* '=/'%%23' $%'

,. /,'(/23' "'&'*&2,* )*" &(')&1'*& ,. 5',5-' 62&7 1'*&)- 2--*'%%? U)&'%& %&)&2%&2/% ('-')%'"

2* Z)*$)(9 %7,6 ) EV?^g (2%' 2* &7' *$1#'( ,. 5',5-' #'2*4 c%'/&2,*'"c – $*"'( &7' W'*&)-

X')-&7 !/& BWX!C – .(,1 fG8baP 2* GOOh‑

OP &, fh8fbP 2* GOOP0EO? R72% 1')*% &7)& *')(-9

aOg ,. 5)&2'*&% 2* KX; 5%9/72)&(2/ $*2&% )(' &7'(' $*"'( -'4)- "$('%%?

i')(% ,. "()%&2/ #'" /$&% 1')* 6)("% )(' .$-- ,. ,*-9 &7' 1,%& $*6'-- 5)&2'*&% – &7,%' %''*

&, #' ) ")*4'( &, &7'1%'-3'% ,( ,&7'(%? R72% 2*/-$"'% (2%2*4 *$1#'(% /,12*4 2*&, 7,%52&)-

32) &7' >$"2/2)- %9%&'1? F247& 7$*"('" )*" &72(&9 6,1'* "'&)2*'" $*"'( &7' WX! /)1' 2*&,

7,%52&)- 32) 5(2%,* ,( &7' /,$(&% -)%& 9')(8 ) (2%' ,. 1,(' &7)* h^g8 672-' &7' *$1#'( ,.

1'* (,%' #9 ahg8 .(,1 E8PhG &, G8Pf^?

R7' $%' ,. /,11$*2&9 &(')&1'*& ,("'(% BLR\%C 7)% )-%, (,/:'&'"? ;2*/' &7'9 6'('

2*&(,"$/'" 2* GOOh8 1,(' &7)* b8GOO 7)3' #''* %'(3'" – EO &21'% &7' '=5'/&'" *$1#'(?

I*"'( ) LR\8 5)&2'*&% )(' ('-')%'" .(,1 "'&'*&2,*8 #$& /)* #' .,(/2#-9 ('&$(*'" &, 7,%52&)-



!N

2. &7'9 .)2- &, &):' &7'2( 1'"2/)&2,* ,( ,&7'( &(')&1'*&? X,6'3'(8 5)&2'*&% /,15-)2* &7)&

,*/' 423'* ) LR\8 2& &):'% &7'1 &,, -,*4 &, 4'& 2& ('1,3'"8 ,#-242*4 &7'1 &, %&2/: 62&7

1'"2/)&2,* &7'9 #'-2'3' &7'9 *, -,*4'( *''"?

LR\% )(' c) /,15-'&' 6)%&' ,. 1,*'98c %)9% J(2'4? c@ 7)" ) 72%&,(9 ,. ('5')& 7,%52&)-)"12%%2,*8 #$& @ 6)% #'&&'( 67'* &7'9 "'/2"'" &, 215,%' &7' LR\8 672/7 @ 7)&'"? @ .'-& @ 7)"

*, /,*&(,- ,3'( 19 7$1)* (247&%?c ;7' 6)% .2*)--9 ('-')%'" .(,1 &7' LR\ ).&'( &6, )55')-%

62&7 &7' 7'-5 ,. ) %5'/2)-2%& -)69'(?

!*" 2& %''1% &7)& LR\% 7)3' *,& ')%'" &7' 5('%%$(' ,* 5%9/72)&(2/ 6)("%? U)%& K,3'1#'(8

&7' L)(' j$)-2&9 L,112%%2,*8 672/7 ,3'(%''% 5)&2'*&% "'&)2*'" $*"'( &7' WX!8 .,$*" &7)&

%,1' 7,%52&)-% 6'(' ('5,(&2*4 EG^g #'" ,//$5)*/9 ()&'%8 )*" *')(-9 ) &72(" ,. &7' ahb

-,/:'" KX; 6)("% 2* F*4-)*" )*" H)-'% 7)" ,//$5)*/9 ()&'% ,. EOOg ,( 1,('8 1')*2*4

&7'9 6'(' .,(/'" &, %'*" 5)&2'*&% 7,1' ')(-9 &, )//,11,")&' *'6 )((23)-%?

W'*&)- 7')-&7 /7)(2&2'% )*" %'*2,( 5%9/72)&(2%&% %)9 &7' %2&$)&2,* 2% )55)--2*48 )*" &7'9 )('

-,##92*4 .,( /7)*4'% &, &7' 7')-&7 )*" %,/2)- /)(' #2-- /$(('*&-9 4,2*4 &7(,$47 5)(-2)1'*&8

&, 1):' 2& 7)("'( &, 215,%' /,15$-%,(9 &(')&1'*&?

R,*9 Y241,*"8 &7' M,9)- L,--'4' ,. D%9/72)&(2%&%T -')" ,* 1'*&)- 7')-&7 -)68 %)9% &7'

%2&$)&2,* 2% c) "2%4()/'c? X' .')(% %,1' 1'*&)- 7')-&7 %'(32/'% )(' #'/,12*4 %, .,/$%'" ,*

&7' (2%: ,. 5)&2'*&% 7)(12*4 &7'1%'-3'% ,( ,&7'(% &7)& &7'9 1):' '=/'%%23' $%' ,.

/,15$-%2,* )*" /,'(/2,*? X' "'%/(2#'% "'&'*&2,* $*"'( 1'*&)- 7')-&7 -)6 )% c) -,#%&'( 5,&

– ')%9 &, 4'& 2*&, #$& 7)(" &, 4'& ,$&c? X2% /,--'4' )*" &7' W'*&)- X')-&7 !--2)*/'8 )*

$1#('--) 4(,$5 ,. /7)(2&2'%8 /232- -2#'(&2'% ,(4)*2%)&2,*% )*" -)69'(%8 )(' -,##92*4 WD% &,

)1'*" &7' 7')-&7 )*" %,/2)- /)(' #2-- &, 1):' 2& 7)("'( &, 215,%' LR\%? \&7'(62%'8 7' .')(%

&7' $%' ,. LR\% /,$-" %52()- ,$& ,. /,*&(,-? cR7' &,5 -2*' 2% &7)& LR\% 7)3' 2*/(')%'" &7'

*$1#'( ,. "'&'*&2,*%8c 7' %)9%? c@* '..'/&8 &7'9 )(' 5(2%,*% 62&7,$& 6)--% %, &7' *$1#'(% ,*

&7'1 /,$-" #' -212&-'%%?c

D)$- ])(1'(8 /72'. '='/$&23' ,. 1'*&)- 7')-&7 /7)(2&9 W2*"8 %)9% 7' 2% c'=&('1'-9 6,((2'"c

)#,$& &7' (2%' 2* LR\%8 c'%5'/2)--9 )% fOg ,. &7'1 )(' #'2*4 215,%'" ,* 5',5-' 67, 7)3'

*, 72%&,(9 ,. *,& /,0,5'()&2*4 62&7 &(')&1'*&c? X' )""%_ cLR\% )(' ) -,,12*4 &7(')& ,.

(')"12%%2,* 7)*42*4 ,3'( &7' 7')"% ,. 5',5-' 67, )(' &(92*4 &, ('#$2-" &7'2( -23'% )*"

2*"'5'*"'*/'?c

U'' W2-*'(8 aE8 7)% %/72[,)..'/&23' "2%,("'(8 672/7 ('%$-&% 2* '52%,"'% ,. '-)&2,* ,(

"'5('%%2,* /,$5-'" 62&7 7)--$/2*)&2,*%? ! 3,-$*&''( )*" /)15)24*'( 62&7 1'*&)- 7')-&7

/7)(2&9 M'&72*:8 U'' 7)% 7)" '=&'*%23' '=5'(2'*/' ,. "'&'*&2,* 2* 7,%52&)- %2*/' EPPG 67'*8

.,--,62*4 &7' %$2/2"' ,. 72% .)&7'(8 7' &(2'" &, %'& .2(' &, &7' .)12-9 7,1'? X' 6)% -)%&

%'/&2,*'" 2* GOEO )*" )4(''% &7)& 7,%52&)-% )(' 5)/:'" 62&7 ,*-9 &7' 1,%& %'(2,$% /)%'%?

cR7' 6)(" 6)% -2:' #'2*4 2* &7' ")(: )4'%? X,6 &7' *$(%'% <$)-2.2'" @ *'3'( :*,6 ??? H7'* @&(2'" &, &)-: &, &7' /,*%$-&)*& )#,$& %52(2&$)-2&98 7' >$%& )%:'" 2. @ 6)*&'" 1,(' 1'"2/)&2,*?c

Y241,*" 6)*&% ) 1,(' /,*%'*%$)- )55(,)/7 &, &(')&1'*&8 )*" 1,(' %5)/' %'& )%2"' 2*

7,%52&)-% .,( 5)&2'*&% &, $%' )% %)*/&$)(2'% 2* &21'% ,. /(2%2%? cH79 *,& 423' 5)&2'*&% &7'

,5&2,* ,. /,12*4 ,.. 1'"2/)&2,* )*" #'2*4 )#-' &, /,1' 2*&, 7,%52&)- 2. &7'9 *''" &,kc 7'

%)9%?

D)$- S$(%&,68 /)(' %'(32/'% 12*2%&'(8 ('/,4*2%'% &7' *''" .,( /)$&2,*? @* ,55,%2&2,*8 7'

6)(*'" &7)& LR\% 6'(' )* ,3'(-9 /,'(/23' 2*%&($1'*& 67,%' ('12& 6)% &,, 62"'? K,6

S$(%&,6 %)9% &7)& ,..2/2)-% )(' :''52*4 ) /-,%' 6)&/7 ,* &7' (2%2*4 ()&'% ,. LR\%? cD',5-'

67, *''" /,15$-%,(9 &(')&1'*t … should be treated fairly, and mental health services )('



!K

('%5,*%2#-' .,( 1):2*4 %$(' &7)& &7'9 $%' &7' 5,6'(% 2* &7' W'*&)- X')-&7 !/&

)55(,5(2)&'-98c 7' %)9%?

R7' N'5)(&1'*& ,. X')-&7 %)9% &7)& &7' WX! /,*&)2*% -'4)- %).'4$)("% .,( 5',5-' ,* &7'%'

&(')&1'*& ,("'(%8 2*/-$"2*4 &7' (247& &, )55')- )*" &, 7)3' )* )"3,/)&'? S$&8 )%5,:'%6,1)* %)9%8 /-2*2/2)*% )(' #'%& 5-)/'" &, :*,6 2. ) LR\ 1')*% 5)&2'*&% 4'&

)55(,5(2)&' &(')&1'*&?

W)(>,(2' H)--)/'8 /72'. '='/$&23' )*" .,$*"'( ,. 1'*&)- 7')-&7 /7)(2&9 ;)*'8 %)9% &7)&

67'* %7' %'& $5 &7' /7)(2&9 G^ 9')(% )4,8 1,(' &7)* POg ,. 5%9/72)&(2/ 2*5)&2'*&% 6'('

&7'(' 3,-$*&)(2-9? ;7' %)9% &7' KX; *''"% 1,(' #'"%_ cD',5-' 67, )(' 2* /(2%2% &'-- $% &7'9

7)3' *,67'(' &, 4,? H' )(' &,-" &7)& 2& 2% 7)("'( &, )"12& 5',5-' 3,-$*&)(2-9 &7)* 2& ,*/'

6)%8 )*"8 .,( &7,%' 67, ", .2*" )* 2*5)&2'*& #'"8 ,$( '=5'(2'*/' 2% &7)& 5%9/72)&(2/ 6)("%

,..'( 3'(9 -2&&-' %)*/&$)(98 62&7 ,3'(6,(:'" %&).. )*" .'6 &7'()5'$&2/ %'(32/'%?c

S$& ;21,* U)6&,*0;12&78 7')" ,. 5,-2/9 )& &7' W'*&)- X')-&7 ],$*")&2,*8 .')(% KX;

5%9/72)&(9 2% c1,32*4 2* &7' 6(,*4 "2('/&2,*c? X' 6)*&% 5',5-' &, .''- )#-' &, '*4)4'

3,-$*&)(2-9 62&7 ",/&,(% #'.,(' &7'9 #'/,1' (')--9 $*6'--? cH' *''" &7' lW'*&)- X')-&7m)/& 67'* 5',5-' )(' ) ")*4'( &, &7'1%'-3'% ,( ,&7'(%8 #$& 6' 6)*& ) %9%&'1 67'(' 2&T%

$%'" -'%% )*" -'%%8 *,& 1,(' )*" 1,('?c

;Y K$/:$ %))>') :%.4 GCA) *(' * 5%).(*-.%/$ 0(/7 .4' 7*%$ I/%$.

$%-1- &1- +8' 8+(7 *&+7 .00)-0 <.'% E$P0 ,)' &(08 <.'% '%- &2&3-*.2 &+3 9184-00.8+&( 9-109-2'.6-

8+ '%- '89.2: &0 <-(( &0 <%&' 2&+ ,- 48)+3 .+ '%- *-3.& L-5/5 '%- ^)&13.&+ &1'.2(-O5 U+3--3: '%-

(.'-1&')1- 8+ E$P0 *80'(7 482)0-0 8+ '%- 4&.(.+/0 84 9182-3)1&( 0&4-/)&130 &+3 (&2= 84 -44.2&27 84

E$P0 Lh)1+0 -' &(5: #M!@: E)1'.2- -' &(5: #M!!: ?&'-( -' &(5: #M!!: $&7(81 -' &(5: #M!@O <%.2% &1- '%-+

-2%8-3 .+ '%- 91-005 $%- 38*.+&+' '%-*- 2&+ ,- 1-0)*-3 &0c E$P0 38 +8' <81= ,-2&)0- '%-7 &1-

+8' .*9(-*-+'-3 9189-1(75

$%- 4&2' '%&' E$P0 %&6- *&+7 .+%-1-+' .00)-0 .0 0-28+3&175 V)2% 0')3.-0 &+3 &1'.2(-0 *.00 '%-

98.+'c '%- 4&2' '%&' E$P0 &1- 4.10' &+3 481-*80' )+(&<4)( .+ 1-(&'.8+ '8 '%- %./%-0' %)*&+ 1./%'0

0'&+3&13 481 9-108+0 <.'% 3.0&,.(.'.-0: '%- BD EF?G5 Z'%.2&( 28+2-1+0 &,8)' E$P0 &+3 '%- 2)1'&.(.+/

84 %)*&+ 1./%'0 )0)&((7 28*- (8< 38<+ '%- (.0' 84 &1/)*-+'0 &/&.+0' E$P05 A/&.+: '%-7 &1- 8+(7

*-+'.8+-3 &0 &+ 8)'28*- 84 .+-44.2.-+' 81 9881(7 &3*.+.0'-1-3 E$P0: +8' .+ '%-.1 8<+ 1./%'5

I)*&+ 1./%'0: <- &1/)-: 0%8)(3 ,- '%- 91.*&17 28+2-1+ 1&'%-1 '17.+/ '8 4.+3 <&70 84 .*9186.+/

E$P0 81 '%-.1 .*9(-*-+'&'.8+: &+ &9918&2% <%.2% 3.0'1&2'0 418* '%- *&.+ .00)-: &+3 +-)'1&(.0-0

&+7 9800.,.(.'7 481 &('-1+&'.6-05

C4' ('*+ %))>') *('B

;YE C4' 5'.'$.%/$ /0 I'()/$) %$ .4' -/77>$%.O %) >$+*:0>+ %$ ('3*(5 ./ .4' #F G2@,B

Effectively until 2008 in the UK users of mental health services were “only” 3-'&.+-3 4812.,(7

within the walls of psychiatric institutions. Now they can be forcibly “legally” detained in the

28**)+.'7 &0 9-1 '%- '-1*0 84 &+ )+(&<4)( &2': '%- HIA5 U' .0 '%&' 3-'-+'.8+ 0'&')0 '%&' &((8<0

4812-3 '1-&'*-+'05 Z44-2'.6-(7 '%- BC: &0 0'&'- 9&1'7 V'&'- ?&1'7 '8 '%- '1-&'7: 38-0 +8' 1-09-2' .'0

(-/&( 8,(./&'.8+ '8 -+0)1- '%&' +&'.8+&( (&<0 *--' '%- '-1*0 84 '%- EF?G5



!J

I8<-6-1 '%- E83- 84 ?1&2'.2- 481 '%- HIA 8+(7 1-4-10 '8 '%- BC I)*&+ F./%'0 A2' !JKK <%.2%

.+281981&'-0 *80' 84 '%- &+3 '%- ZEIF LGI: #MMKO: 0'1-00.+/ '%&' *)2% 84 .' .0 &,8)'

“proportionality” and balance of decision LE)1'.2- -' &(5: #M!!O5 ?18981'.8+&(.'7 .+ -44-2' +8' 8+(7

clearly supports a risk averse culture but also the curtailing of people’s hum&+ 1./%'0 .+ '%-interest of society or of the person’s “best interests”. $%- .00)- %-1- .0 '%&' .' 0%8)(3 1-4(-2'

91.+2.9&((7 '%- EF?G &0 '%- %./%-0' %)*&+ 1./%'0 0'&+3&13 481 9-108+0 <.'% 3.0&,.(.'.-0 &+3 +8' '%-

ZEIF <%.2% -2%8-0 *)2% 84 '%- 8)'3&'-3 &+3 -;'1-*-(7 28+0-16&'.6- H-+'&( I-&('% E&1-

?1.+2.9(-0: .+ 9&1'.2)(&1 .+0.0'.+/ 8+ '%- .00)- 84 (&2= 84 2&9&2.'7 '8 >)0'.47 3-'-+'.8+ &+3 4812-3

'1-&'*-+'5

@& 2% &7'('.,(' *'/'%%)(9 &, (')..2(1 &7)& &7' L,*3'*&2,* ,* &7' M247&% ,. D'(%,*% 62&7

N2%)#2-2&2'% ,..'(% &7' 1,%& /,15('7'*%23' %'& ,. %&)*")("% ,* &7' (247&% ,. 5'(%,*% 62&7

"2%)#2-2&2'%8 2*&'( )-2)8 2* &7' /,*&'=& ,. 7')-&7 /)('8 67'(' /7,2/'% #9 5',5-' 62&7 "2%)#2-2&2'%

are often overridden based on their supposed “best interests”, and where serio$% 32,-)&2,*%

and discrimination against persons with disabilities may be masked as “good intentions” of

7')-&7 5(,.'%%2,*)-% B!ebfeEV^8 5)()? aPC?LHd+3-X: #M!@O

E$P0 L&+3 &(( 4812-3 '1-&'*-+' &+3 3-'-+'.8+O 6.8(&'- &1'.2(- S 84 '%- EF?G &0 <-(( LZ`)&(.'7 &+3

+8+_3.021.*.+&'.8+O5

$%- E8+6-+'.8+ 1&3.2&((7 3-9&1'0 418* '%.0 &9918&2% ,7 481,.33.+/ 3-91.6&'.8+ 84 (.,-1'7 ,&0-3 8+

'%- -;.0'-+2- 84 &+7 L9-12-.6-3O 3.0&,.(.'7: .+2()3.+/ *-+'&( 81 .+'-((-2')&(: &0 3.021.*.+&'8175

Article 14, paragraph 1 (b), of the Convention unambiguously states that “the existence of a

disability shall in no case justify a deprivation of liberty”. HC4'7*.%- ).>5O /0 .4' X%34

G/77%))%/$'( 0/( X>7*$ 2%34.) /$ %7I+'7'$.*.%/$ /$ 9'O +'3*+ 7'*)>(') 0/( .4' (*.%0%-*.%/$

*$5 %7I+'7'$.*.%/$ /0 .4' G/$&'$.%/$ /$ .4' 2%34.) /0 @'()/$) :%.4 ,%)*<%+%.%')] 8`X2GÈR`;M]

I*(* ;MJY

F&9981'-)1 Hd+3-X 0&70:

@15,(&)*& 2*&'(5('&)&23' )*" 4$2"2*4 5(2*/25-'% %$/7 )% -'4)- /)5)/2&98 2*.,(1'" /,*%'*&8 )*"

the doctrine of “medical necessity” as well as the concept of stigmatized identities provide

$%'.$- 4$2")*/' 2* $*"'(%&)*"2*4 &7' #(')"&7 ,. &7' 5(,#-'1 )*" &7' $*"'(-92*4 /)$%'% &7)&

)(' 5)()1,$*& &, 1,%& ,. &7'%' )#$%23' 5()/&2/'%?LHd+3-X: #M!@O

B+3-1 0)9-16.0-3 28**)+.'7 '1-&'*-+': 9&'.-+'0 28*9)(081.(7 3-'&.+-3 .+ %809.'&( )+3-1 V-2'.8+

@ 84 '%- HIA L28*9)(0817 '1-&'*-+'O *&7 ,- 3.02%&1/-3 8+'8 & E$P 1-`).1.+/ '%-* '8 28*9(7

<.'% 2-1'&.+ 28+3.'.8+0: .+2()3.+/ '&=.+/ '%-.1 *-3.2&'.8+5 Effectively the “community” becomes

&+ -;'-+0.8+ 84 9072%.&'1.2 0-''.+/0 ,7 6.1')- 84 '%- 28+0'1&.+'0 <%.2% &1- 9)' 8+ 9-89(- '8 1-09-2'

'%- (-/&( '-1*0 84 '%-.1 3-'-+'.8+ &+3 4812-3 '1-&'*-+' .+ 0&.3 28**)+.'75 A0 '%- '-0'.*8+.-0

0%8<: 9-89(- 4-(' (.=- prisoners in the community (the GPS bracelet/ “tag” effect), where space for

+-/8'.&'.8+ &+3 1-4)0&( 84 '1-&'*-+' %&6- +8 9(&2- <%&'08-6-15 $%.0 0.')&'.8+ .0 9800.,(7 -6-+

<810- '%&+ 481 91.08+-10 )+3-1 (.2-+2- 81 918,&'.8+ and the issue of “medical necessity” invoked

,7 E$P0 .0 & L)+(&<4)(O 1-3_%-11.+/5 B+(.=- -;.0'.+/ 0)9-16.0-3 &4'-12&1- 98<-10: E$P0 .+2()3- '%-



#M

0&+2'.8+ 84 28+6-7.+/ & +8+28*9(.&+' 9&'.-+' '8 %809.'&( 481 28*9)(0817 '1-&'*-+' <.'%8)' '%-

+-2-00.'7 84 481*&( 1-&3*.00.8+5

B+3-1 E$P0: .+3.6.3)&(0 +8' 8+(7 (80- '%-.1 &/-+27 ,)' &(08 '%- 4)(( -+>87*-+' 84 '%-.1 %)*&+

1./%'0 8+ &+ -`)&( ,&0.0 <.'% 8'%-1 *-*,-10 84 082.-'75 U+ %-1 &228)+' .+ '%- ^)&13.&+: C1.-/ 0&700%- %&3 “+8 28+'18( 86-1 %-1 %)*&+ 1./%'0”, she felt “violated”5

R812-3 9072%.&'1.2 '1-&'*-+' .+ '%- 28**)+.'7 .0 & 6.8(&'.8+ 84 ,8'% '%- 09.1.' &+3 '%- (-''-1 84 '%-

EF?G5 $%.0 91&2'.2- 4(8)'0 &(( 91.+2.9(-0 0-' 8)' .+ A1'.2(- @ 84 '%- EF?G 0)2% &0 1-09-2' 481 .+%-1-+'

3./+.'7: .+3.6.3)&( &)'8+8*7: .+3-9-+3-+2- 84 9-108+0 &+3 +8+_3.021.*.+&'.8+5 U' 2(-&1(7 ,1-&2%-0

9186.0.8+0 84 '%- '1-&'7: .+2()3.+/ A1'.2(-0 !# LZ`)&( 1-28/+.'.8+ ,-481- '%- (&<O: A1'.2(- !S

LR1--38* 418* '81')1- 81 21)-(: .+%)*&+ 81 3-/1&3.+/ '1-&'*-+' 81 9)+.0%*-+'O &+3 A1'.2(- !N

L?18'-2'.+/ '%- .+'-/1.'7 84 '%- 9-108+O &+3 A1'.2(- #S LI-&('%O5

;YN 6/(-'5 .('*.7'$.) HI)O-4/+/3%-*+ *$5 I4O)%-*+ -/$).(*%$.J *(' %$4>7*$ *$5 5'3(*5%$3B

?-108+0 )+3-1 E$P0 &/1-- '8 )+3-1'&=- '1-&'*-+' &0 9-1 '%- '-1*0 84 '%- HIA5 $%-0-

.+'-16-+'.8+0 '79.2&((7 .+2()3- '%- '&=.+/ 84 *.+3_&('-1.+/ 31)/0: 0)2% &0 +-)18(-9'.205 U+ '%- ?&'-(

-' &( 0')37 L#M!!O: 6.1')&((7 &(( 9&1'.2.9&+'0 8+ E$P0 LJJiO <-1- /.6-+ &+'.9072%8'.20 &0 '%- *&.+

medication and “Of the total sample 7.2% had antipsychotic (combined) doses exceeding 100%

hDR@ (.*.'0 &+3 J5Ni <-1- 91-021.,-3 '<8 &+'.9072%8'.205

R812-3 '1-&'*-+' <.'% +-)18(-9'.2 L&+'._9072%8'.2O 31)/0 .0 28+'1&17 '8 A1'.2(- !S 84 '%- EF?G &+3

%&0 ,--+ 1-28/+.0-3 &0 '81')1- ,7 H&+41-3 D8<&=: '%- '%-+ BD V9-2.&( F&9981'-)1 481 $81')1-5

U+ #MMK %- <18'-c

@*%2"' 2*%&2&$&2,*%8 )% 6'-- )% 2* &7' /,*&'=& ,. .,(/'" ,$&5)&2'*& &(')&1'*&8 5%9/72)&(2/

1'"2/)&2,*8 2*/-$"2*4 *'$(,-'5&2/% )*" ,&7'( 12*"0)-&'(2*4 "($4%8 1)9 #' )"12*2%&'('" &,

5'(%,*% 62&7 1'*&)- "2%)#2-2&2'% 62&7,$& &7'2( .('' )*" 2*.,(1'" /,*%'*& ,( )4)2*%& &7'2(

62--8 $*"'( /,'(/2,* ,( )% ) .,(1 ,. 5$*2%71'*&? R7' )"12*2%&()&2,* 2* "'&'*&2,* )*"

5%9/72)&(2/ 2*%&2&$&2,*% ,. "($4%8 2*/-$"2*4 *'$(,-'5&2/% &7)& /)$%' &('1#-2*48 %723'(2*4 )*"

/,*&()/&2,*% )*" 1):' &7' %$#>'/& )5)&7'&2/ )*" "$-- 72% ,( 7'( 2*&'--24'*/'8 7)% #''*

('/,4*2%'" )% ) .,(1 ,. &,(&$('?B D8<&= 8 GOOhC

I.0 0)22-0081: F&9981'-)1 W)&+ Hd+3-X &(08 1-28**-+3-3 & ,&+ 8+ 4812-3 9072%.&'1.2 31)//.+/

&+3 '%- 1-9-&( 84 (&<0 &((8<.+/ 28*9)(0817 *-+'&( %-&('% '1-&'*-+' LHd+3-X: #M!@O5

?072%.&'1.0' G1 ?-'-1 h1-//.+ <1.'-0 84 '%- -44-2' 84 +-)18(-9'.2 31)/0c

H72-' &7' *'$(,-'5&2/% )(' &,=2/ &, 1,%& #()2* .$*/&2,*%8 "2%($5&2*4 *')(-9 )-- ,. &7'18 &7'9

7)3' )* '%5'/2)--9 6'--0",/$1'*&'" 215)/& ,* &7' ",5)12*' *'$(,&()*%12&&'( %9%&'1? !%

)*9 5%9/72)&(2/ &'=&#,,: 62-- /,*.2(18 ",5)12*' *'$(,&()*%12&&'(% 5(,32"' &7' 1)>,( *'(3'

5)&76)9% .(,1 &7' "''5'( #()2* &, &7' .(,*&)- -,#'% )*" -21#2/ %9%&'1 0 &7' 3'(9 %)1'

@ British National Formulary, the medication ‘bible’ for all doctors .+ '%- BC



#!

)(')% %&($/: #9 %$(42/)- -,#,&,19? W,%& 5%9/7,%$(4'(9 /$&% &7' *'(3' /,**'/&2,*% &, )*"

.(,1 &7' .(,*&)- -,#'% )*" -21#2/ %9%&'1A /7'12/)- -,#,&,19 -)(4'-9 2*&'("2/&% &7' *'(3'

/,**'/&2,*% &, &7' %)1' ('42,*%? F2&7'( 6)98 /,12*4 ,( 4,2*48 it’s a lobotomy effect. Thus

&7' 1'/7)*2%1 ,. )/&2,* ,. &7' *'$(,-'5&2/% 2% *, 19%&'(9_ /-2*2/)--9 &7' "($4% 5(,"$/' )-,#,&,19 )*" *'$(,-,42/)--9 &7' "($4% 5(,"$/' ) -,#,&,19 5Lh1-//.+: !JJ@O

$%- )0- 84 9072%.&'1.2 *-3.2&'.8+0: 9&1'.2)(&1(7 +-)18(-9'.20: .0 &(08 &0082.&'-3 <.'% & 0%81'-+.+/

84 '%- (.4- 09&+5 ?-89(- <%8 )0- 9072%.&'1.2 *-3.2&'.8+0 *&7 -;9-1.-+2- & +)*,-1 84 %-&('%

918,(-*0 &0 &36-10- -44-2'0 84 '%-0- *-3.2&'.8+0: .+2()3.+/ 918,(-*0 84 '%- +-)18(8/.2&(:

-+3821.+-: *-'&,8(.2: &+3 2&13.86&02)(&1 070'-*0 &+3 28/+.'.6- 3.44.2)('.-0:

&7'(' 2% ) 5('5,*"'()*/' ,. '32"'*/' %7,62*4 &7)& %&)*")(" *'$(,-'5&2/%8 ,3'( &7'

-,*4&'(18 2*/(')%' &7' -2:'-27,," &7)& ) 5'(%,* 62-- #'/,1' /7(,*2/)--9 2--? R72% ,$&/,1' 2%

5)(&2/$-)(-9 5(,#-'1)&2/ 67'* ,*' /,*%2"'(% &7)& &7' "($4% )-%, /)$%' ) 62"' ()*4' ,.&(,$#-2*4 %2"' '..'/&%8 2*/-$"2*4 *'$(,-'5&2/ 1)-24*)*& %9*"(,1'8 D)(:2*%,*2)* %915&,1%8

)*" &)("23' "9%:2*'%2)? D)&2'*&% 1)2*&)2*'" ,* %&)*")(" *'$(,-'5&2/% )-%, 7)3' &, 6,((9

)#,$& #-2*"*'%%8 .)&)- #-,," /-,&%8 7')& %&(,:'8 %6,--'* #(')%&%8 -'):2*4 #(')%&%8 215,&'*/'8

,#'%2&98 %'=$)- "9%.$*/&2,*8 #-,," "2%,("'(%8 5)2*.$- %:2* ()%7'%8 %'2[$('%8 "2)#'&'%8 )*"

')(-9 "')&78 L[%.'&=-1: #MMQO5

$%- (8+/ '-1* )0- 84 +-)18(-9'.20 .0 &(08 9186-+ '8 2&)0- &'189%7 84 '%- ,1&.+:

@* ) %'(2'% ,. BWM@C %&$"2'% .(,1 EPPa &, EPPh8 2*3'%&24)&,(% ('5,(&'" &7)& &7' "($4% /)$%'"

#)%)- 4)*4-2,* %&($/&$('% )*" &7' &7)-)1$% &, %6'--8 )*" &7' .(,*&)- -,#'% &, %7(2*:8 62&7these changes in volumes “dose related” 5 L[%.'&=-1: #M!MO

U+ &+.*&( 0')3.-0 .+ '%- (&0' 4-< 7-&10: -6.3-+2- 84 1-3)2'.8+ .+ ,1&.+ '.00)- 68()*- <&0 1-981'-3

.+ *8+=-70 /.6-+ P(&+X&9.+- &+3 I&(89-1.38( L28**8+(7_)0-3 +-)18(-9'.2 31)/0O 86-1 & 9-1.83 84

'<8 7-&10: -5/5 G819% -' &(: L#MMSO5

;YP 8 4>7%+%*.%$3 I(/-'))B

e8+/_&2'.+/ 3-98' 481*0 84 +-)18(-9'.20 &1- 28**8+(7 )0-3 8+ 9-89(- 8+ E$P05 ?-89(- &''-+3 &

2(.+.2 1-/)(&1(7: )0)&((7 -6-17 '<8 81 48)1 <--=0: '8 ,- /.6-+ '%- .+>-2'.8+ .+ '%- ,)''82=5 e.=- 2&''(-

waiting to be slaughtered at the abattoir, Jean’s video testimony recalls how people were confined

'8 & <&.'.+/ 188* '8 ,- .+>-2'-3: 8+- ,7 8+-5 U' .0 3-/1&3.+/ &+3 .+'1)0.6- '8 %&6- & 31)/

&3*.+.0'-1-3 .+ '%.0 <&75 D8 &*8)+' 84 '.+=-1.+/ <.'% '%- <&7 31)/0 &1- &3*.+.0'-1-3 .0 /8.+/ '8

*&=- .' -.'%-1 ,-''-1 81 (&<4)(5

?.& C%&+: & 0-16.2- )0-1 0&70:

@ ('1'1#'( &7'9 6'(' .,(/2*4 1' &, 7)3' 1'"2/)&2,*? @ .'-& 32,-)&'"? @ ('1'1#'( #'2*4

.,(/'" 2*&, ) %1)-- (,,1 ,* 19 ,6*8 &7'(' 6)% *, #'"? R7'9 5$%7'" 1' 2*&, 2&? R7'9 7'-"



##

1' ",6* )*" .,(/'" 1'"2/)&2,* ,* 1'? @ )1 ) "212*$&23' ^TEc )*" &7'9 6'(' )-- #244'(

&7)* 1'?

F-=& C1.-/: & 0-16.2- )0-1 0&70 L^)&13.&+O:

@ #'/)1' [,1#2.2'" .,( *')(-9 EG 1,*&7% 67'* @ 6)% .,(/'" &, &):' 1,," %&)#2-2['(% )*"

)*&205%9/7,&2/ 1'"2/)&2,*

W-&+ E8X-+0: 481*-1 (.,1&17 &00.0'&+' &+3 *8'%-1c

W9 %2%&'( 7)" /,1' &, 32%2&? @ 6)% )*4(9 #'/)$%' %7' 7)" ) &6, 7,$( >,$(*'9 )*" 7)" #''*

:'5& 6)2&2*4 ,$&%2"' &7' 6)(" #'/)$%' 2& 6)% *,& 32%2&2*4 &21' 9'&? @ /,15-)2*'" &, &7'

*$(%'%? @ "2"*& %6')(8 @ 6)%*& )#$%23'8 @ >$%& /,15-)2*'"? K'=& &72*4 @ :*'68 19 %2%&'( 6)%

#$*"-'" ,$& &7' ",,( )*" &,-" &, 4, 7,1'? @ 6)% &):'* &, 19 (,,18 .,(/'" &, -2' .)/' ",6*

,* &7' #'"8 )*" 2*>'/&'" 62&7 %,1'&72*4 &7)& :*,/:'" 1' ,$& .,( 7,$(%? @ 7)" #($2%2*4 &,

19 #)/:?

;Y; 2'0>)%$3 .('*.7'$. %) %7I/))%<+'B

A('%8)/% .+ 91.+2.9(-: 9-89(- &1- &((8<-3: <%-'%-1 '%-7 &1- 68()+'&17 81 .+68()+'&17 9atients’, to

1-4)0- '1-&'*-+': '%- 1-&(.'7 .0 `).'- 3.44-1-+'5 U' 0--*0 '%&' .+ *-+'&( %-&('%: 9881 28*9(.&+2- 81

refusal of treatment are often considered a symptom of the person’s ‘illness’ or evidence of ‘lack

of insight’. This allows coercive measures '8 ,- )0-3 '8 4812- %809.'&( &3*.00.8+ &+3 '1-&'*-+' 8+

9-89(-: &0 <-(( &0 '8 4812- '1-&'*-+' .+ '%- 28**)+.'75 V-2'.8+ #@5@N 84 '%- HIA E83- 84

?1&2'.2-: 0'.9)(&'-0 '%&'c

!-&7,$47 &7' WX! 5'(12&% %,1' 1'"2/)- &(')&1'*& .,( 1'*&)- "2%,("'( &, #' 423'* 62&7,$&consent, the patient’s consent should still be sought before treatment, wherever

practicable. The patient’s consent or refusal should be recorded in their notes, as should the

treating clinician’s assessment of the patient’s capacity to consent.

U+ 4&2': &22813.+/ '8 V-2'.8+ #@5QM 84 '%- E83-: 28*9)(0817 '1-&'*-+' '%&' *&7 8'%-1<.0- ,-

3--*-3 .+%)*&+- 2&+ &(08 ,- >)0'.4.-3 &+3 +8' 2&((-3 “.+%)*&+-” 81 “3-/1&3.+/” when it “is

28+6.+2.+/(7 0%8<+ '8 ,- 84 '%-1&9-)'.2 +-2-00.'7 418* '%- 98.+' 84 6.-< 84 -0'&,(.0%-3

principles of medicine”.

;Y? @'()/$) >$5'( GCA) *(' &>+$'(*<+' *$5 /I'$ ./ *<>)'B

?&)( 1-2&((0 LU+3-9-+3-+' &1'.2(-O %8< %- %&3 +8' 8+(7 (80' '%- 4)(( -+>87*-+' 84 %.0 &/-+27: %-

<&0 &(08 9)' .+ & 0.')&'.8+ 84 6)(+-1&,.(.'7 <.'%.+ %.0 8<+ 4&*.(7 481 <%8* %- %&3 ,-28*- & 084'

'&1/-'5

R7' 1,%& %'(2,$% 32,-)&2,* ,. &7' 7$1)* (247& &, 5'(%,*)- 2*&'4(2&9 )*" "24*2&98 5('%$55,%'%

) %2&$)&2,* ,. 5,6'(-'%%*'%%8 67'('#9 &7' 32/&21 2% $*"'( &7' &,&)- /,*&(,- ,. )*,&7'(

5'(%,*? D'(%,*% 62&7 "2%)#2-2&2'% ,.&'* .2*" &7'1%'-3'% 2* %$/7 %2&$)&2,*%8 .,( 2*%&)*/' 67'*

&7'9 )(' "'5(23'" ,. &7'2( -2#'(&9 2* 5(2%,*% ,( ,&7'( 5-)/'%8 ,( 67'* &7'9 )(' $*"'( &7'

/,*&(,- ,. &7'2( /)('423'(% ,( -'4)- 4$)("2)*%? @* ) 423'* /,*&'=&8 &7' 5)(&2/$-)( "2%)#2-2&9 ,.



#@

)* 2*"232"$)- 1)9 ('*"'( 721 ,( 7'( 1,(' -2:'-9 &, #' 2* ) "'5'*")*& %2&$)&2,* )*" 1):'

721 ,( 7'( )* ')%2'( &)(4'& ,. )#$%'? X,6'3'(8 2& 2% ,.&'* /2(/$1%&)*/'% '=&'(*)- &, &7'

individual that render them “powerless”, such as when one’s exercise of decision01):2*4

)*" -'4)- /)5)/2&9 2% &):'* )6)9 #9 "2%/(212*)&,(9 -)6% ,( 5()/&2/'% )*" 423'* &, ,&7'(%? HQI'-%*+ 2*II/(.'>( /$ C/(.>('] 8ÙPÈL?] I*(* ?RJ

?-108+0 )+3-1 E$P0 &1- &(08 89-+ '8 9072%8(8/.2&( &,)0- ,7 '%- 070'-* .'0-(4:

K,#,"9 &)-:'" &, 1' )% ) 7$1)* #'2*48 2&T% .,(/'8 .,(/' )-- &7' 6)9? @&T% ,*-9 67'* 9,$

%$#"$' 9,$( %52(2&8 )*" 9,$ ",*T& %&($44-' )*91,('8 &7)& &7'9T(' 7)559 &, ('-')%' 9,$? BD2)

J7)*8 5'(%,*)- &'%&21,*98 GOEGC?

?Y S4/ )*0'3>*(5) Ieople’s fundamental rights %$ .4' #K /$ * 5*O ./ 5*O <*)%)T

?YE C4' (/+' /0 .4' G*(' V>*+%.O G/77%))%/$

$%- E&1- T)&(.'7 E8**.00.8+ LETEO .0 & /86-1+*-+'&( &/-+27 1-098+0.,(- 481 918'-2'.+/ '%-

.+'-1-0'0 84 9-89(- 3-'&.+-3 &+3 '1-&'-3 )+3-1 '%- H-+'&( I-&('% A2' .+ Z+/(&+3: 481 *&=.+/ 0)1-

'%-7 &1- 2&1-3 481 9189-1(7: &+3 481 -+0)1.+/ '%- H-+'&( I-&('% A2' .0 )0-3 2811-2'(75

U+ [&(-0: '%- I-&('%2&1- U+09-2'81&'- [&(-0]0 F-6.-< V-16.2- 481 H-+'&( I-&('% .0 1-098+0.,(- 481

*8+.'81.+/ '%- H-+'&( I-&('% A2'5

L%''9cff<<<5*-+'&(%-&('%2&1-581/5)=f*-+'&(g%-&('%g&2'jE8*9)(0817g'1-&'*-+'O

$%- 18(- &+3 1-*.' 84 '%- ETE .0 0-' '8 .+21-&0- LBC ̂ 86-1+*-+': #M!#O '8 -;9(81e “%8< ,-0' '8

&(./+ .'0 1-/)(&'817 &+3 0'&')'817 *8+.'81.+/ 4)+2'.8+0 .+ 1-(&'.8+ '8 *-+'&( %-&('%: .+2()3.+/

“e;'-+3.+/ H-+'&( I-&('% A2' *8+.'81.+/ '8 .+2()3- &00-00*-+' &+3 &3*.00.8+: 0)9-16.0-3

28**)+.'7 '1-&'*-+': `)&(.'7 84 &22-00 '8 '1-&'*-+' &+3 &4'-12&1-”5

I8<-6-1 .' .0 2(-&1 &0 481 &0 (8+/ &0 .' 28+'.+)-0 '8 <81= 8+(7 <.'%.+ '%- '-1*0 84 '%- HIA: ./+81-0

&+3 38-0 +8' *--' '%- EF?G 0'&+3&130: '%- ETE 2&++8' 2(&.* '%&' .' .0 “918'-2'.+/ '%- .+'-1-0'0 84

9-89(- 3-'&.+-3 &+3 '1-&'-3 )+3-1 '%- H-+'&( I-&('% A2' .+ Z+/(&+3” as it has to which does not

28+481* '8 '%- BD EF?G5

$%.0 (-&6-0 )0-10 &+3 0)16.6810 &1- (-4' .+ & 6-17 6)(+-1&,(- 980.'.8+ <%-+ '%- 844.2.&( ,837 '%&' .0

*-&+' '8 *8+.'81 <%&' .0 %&99-+.+/ <.'%.+ *-+'&( %-&('% 0-16.2-0 .0 +8' & 980.'.8+ '8 1-4-1 '8 '%-EF?G .+ .'0 <81=5

?YN C4' (/+' /0 7'$.*+ 4'*+.4 *5&/-*.')

A22-00 '8 *-+'&( %-&('% &3682&27 %&0 ,-28*- & 1./%' 481 0-16.2- )0-10 3-'&.+-3 )+3-1 '%- HIA

0.+2- #MMJ &0 & 1-0)(' 84 '%- 2%&+/-0 .+ #MMN '8 '%- HIA !JK@5 $%- 18(- 84 '%- U+3-9-+3-+'

H-+'&( I-&('% A3682&'- LUHIAO .0 3-021.,-3 .+ 2%&9'-1 #M 84 '%- HIA E83- 84 ?1&2'.2- &+3 <&0

set up as “an additional safeguard for patients who are subject to the Act”.



#Q

UHIA0 %-(9 9-89(- &22-00 '%-.1 1./%'0 )+3-1 '%- H-+'&( I-&('% A2' &+3 )+3-10'&+3 '%- 98<-10 84

'%- 0-16.2- 9186.3-105 $%.0 .+2()3-0 9-89(- 0),>-2' '8 V)9-16.0-3 E8**)+.'7 $1-&'*-+'5 UHIA0

%&6- 2-1'&.+ 1./%'0 &+3 3)'.-0 .+2()3.+/ & 3)'7 '8 1-098+3 '8 1-&08+&,(- 1-`)-0'0 481 &3682&27 &+3

'%- 98<-1 '8 .+'-16.-< &+7 9184-00.8+&(0 28+2-1+-3 <.'% '%- 2&1- 84 '%- 0-16.2- )0-1: &22-000-16.2- )0-10 &+3 &22-00 *-3.2&( 1-281305

A *-+'&( %-&('% &3682&'- 0&70:

People do have rights but don’t (can’t) enforce them – for example I’ve only 7)" ,*' 5'(%,*

/,1' &, 1' )#,$& &7'2( LR\ 2* &7' -)%& EG 1,*&7%? \&7'( 5',5-' ,* &7' &')1 7)3' %''* ,*'

,( &6, #$& &7' /,*&)/& 62&7 LR\ /-2'*&% 2% 3'(9 -,6? L?&)( $)1+-1: 9-108+&( 28**)+.2&'.8+:

#M!@O

$%.0 *-&+0 '%&' )+(-00 0-16.2- )0-10 &1- &<&1- 84 '%-.1 1./%'0 &+3 *-+'&( %-&('% &3682&27 .0

9189-1(7 &36-1'.0-3 &+3 0)9981'-3: '%-7 &1- -6-+ (-00 &,(- '8 -+>87 '%-.1 4)(( %)*&+ 1./%'0 <%-+

3-'&.+-35

?YP C4' (/+' /0 .4' Q><-/77%..'' 0/( .4' @('&'$.%/$ /$ C/(.>('

A0 '%- BC %&0 +8' 8+(7 1&'.4.-3 '%- EF?G ,)' &(08 '%- P?EA$: '%.0 <%.2% *-&+0 '%&' '%-

V),28**.''-- 481 '%- ?1-6-+'.8+ 84 $81')1- LV?$O 0%8)(3 38 .+09-2'.8+0 '885

@82C CX2WWBUY 2'-/77'$5*.%/$)

$%- BC 0%8)(3 +8' ,- 1-/&13-3 &0 & *83-( 84 /883 91&2'.2- .+ '-1*0 84 %)*&+ 1./%'0 0.+2- %)*&+

1./%'0 6.8(&'.8+0 28**.''-3 &/&.+0' 9-108+0 <.'% 3.0&,.(.'.-0 &1- <.3-091-&35 $%.0 0%8)(3 ,- ,81+-

.+ *.+3 <%-+ considering the UK’s influence over what happens elsewhere in the world.

[%.(- '%- BC .0 &,(- '8 844-1 & 6-+--1 84 1-09-2'&,.(.'7 &+3 2)(')1&( 6&(.3.'7 '%18)/% .'0 9182-3)1&(

070'-*0: '%-0- 38 +8' 0-16- '%- .+'-1-0' 84 )0-10 &+3 0)16.6810 84 9072%.&'175 U+3--3: +8 &*8)+' 84

‘solid’ 9182-3)1- 2&+ 1-+3-1 4812-3 3-'-+'.8+ &+3 4812-3 '1-&'*-+'0 ,-''-1 81 (&<4)( .+ 1-/&13 '8

'%- EF?G .+ 9&1'.2)(&1: &+3 %)*&+ 1./%'0 .+ /-+-1&(5$8 %&6- &+7 *-&+.+/ .+ '%- BC: '%- EF?G *)0' ,- 4)((7 .+'-/1&'-3 <.'%.+ 38*-0'.2 (&<0: &+3 4)((7

.*9(-*-+'-3: 481 &(( 84 )0 '8 4--( '%-1- .0 &+7 %89- '%&' '%.+/0 2&+ .+3--3 2%&+/- &+3 '%&' 4812-3

9072%.&'17 2&+ 28*- '8 &+ -+35

$%-1- .0 '%-1-481- & +--3 '8c

U*9(-*-+' '%- 4.+3.+/0 from Rapporteur Mendez’ report LHd+3-X: #M!@Oc

U**-3.&'-(7 1-9-&( &(( (-/&( 9186.0.8+0 &((8<.+/ 481 4812-3 9072%.&'1.2 3-'-+'.8+ 81 4812-3

9072%.&'1.2 '1-&'*-+': .+2()3.+/ E$P0 &0 )+(&<4)( <.'% 1-/&130 '8 '%- '-1*0 84 '%- BD

EF?G: .+ 9&1'.2)(&1 &1'.2(-0 !Q &+3 !S



#S

A1'.2(- Q5!L&O &+3 L,O 84 '%- EF?G 1-`).1-0 0'&'-0 '8 '&=- (-/.0(&'.6- *-&0)1-0 '8 /.6- -44-2'

'8 '%- 1./%'0: &+3 '8 1-9-&( (&<0 '%&' 3.021.*.+&'- &/&.+0' 9-108+0 <.'% 3.0&,.(.'.-05

R1-- &+3 .+481*-3 28+0-+' 0%8)(3 ,- 0&4-/)&13-3 8+ &+ -`)&( ,&0.0 481 &(( .+3.6.3)&(0

<.'%8)' &+7 -;2-9'.8+: '%18)/% '%- (-/&( 41&*-<81= &+3 >)3.2.&( &+3 &3*.+.0'1&'.6-*-2%&+.0*0: .+2()3.+/ '%18)/% 98(.2.-0 &+3 91&2'.2-0 '8 918'-2' &/&.+0' &,)0-05 A+7 (-/&(9186.0.8+0 '8 '%- 28+'1&17: 0)2% &0 9186.0.8+0 &((8<.+/ 28+4.+-*-+' 81 28*9)(0817'1-&'*-+' .+ *-+'&( %-&('% 0-''.+/0: .+2()3.+/ '%18)/% /)&13.&+0%.9 &+3 8'%-1 0),0'.')'-33-2.0.8+_*&=.+/: *)0' ,- 1-9-&(-35

A(08c

$%- ETE 0%8)(3 ,- *&3- '8 <81= <.'%.+ '%- '-1*0 84 '%- EF?G: &+3 +8' 8+(7 <.'%.+ '%-1-*.' 84 '%- HIA <%.2% 38-0 +8' 1-09-2' '%- EF?G5

Z+0)1- '%&' &22-00 '8 *-+'&( %-&('% &3682&'-0 .0 *&3- -&07 481 &(( 0-16.2- )0-10: .+9&1'.2)(&1 '%80- 3-'&.+-3 )+3-1 '%- HIA5 $%.0 *-&+0 '%&' &3682&27 0-16.2-0 *)0' ,-9189-1(7 &36-1'.0-3 8+ <&130: .+ ^? 0)1/-1.-0: .+ 9),(.2 9(&2-0 L-5/5 9),(.2 (.,1&1.-0O -'25

$%- BC ^86-1+*-+' 0%8)(3 9186.3- 4)+3.+/ 84 &('-1+&'.6- 481*0 84 0)9981' '%&' 1-09-2''%- &)'8+8*7: <.(( &+3 91-4-1-+2-0: 3./+.'7 &+3 91.6&27 84 '%- 9-108+ 28+2-1+-3 L&01-`).1-3 ,7 '%- EF?G E8**.''--O5

$%-1- 0%8)(3 ,- 0)9981' 481 .+3-9-+3-+' (.6.+/ .+ '%- 28**)+.'7: .+2()3.+/ &+ &3-`)&'-0'&+3&13 84 (.6.+/ &+3 0-2)1- %8)0.+/ L&22813.+/ '8 &1'0 !J &+3 # 84 '%- EF?GO5

A22-00 '8 1-9&1&'.8+0f28*9-+0&'.8+ 481 6.2'.*0 84 9072%.&'1.2 '81')1- &+3 .+%)*&+ &+33-/1&3.+/ '1-&'*-+' L)+3-1 &1'.2(- !Q 84 EA$O5

LY 2'0'('$-')

hFZ^ÛD: ?5 !JJ@5 R,=2/ D%9/72)&(9_ H79 R7'()598 F15)&79 )*" U,3' W$%& M'5-)/' &7' N($4%8

F-'/&(,%7,/: )*" S2,/7'12/)- R7',(2'% ,. &7' K'6 D%9/72)&(98 e8+38+: I&19-1E8((.+05hBFDV: $5: FB^CkVA: W5: HPePGYDVCU: A5: GA[VPD: W5: CVZDUWA: Y5: lAmTBZm_HPD$ZV: H5:

lPYVZY: H5: VUDEeAUF: W5 n ?FUZhZ: V5 #M!@5 E8**)+.'7 '1-&'*-+' 813-10 481 9&'.-+'0 <.'%9072%80.0 LPE$Z$Oc & 1&+38*.0-3 28+'18((-3 '1.&(5 R7' U)*/'& oP+(.+-p5 oA22-00-3 J A91.(#M!@p5

EBF$UEZ: H5: hAVIUF: R5: CIBFHU: V5: EFPEPHhZ: W5: IA[CUDV: $5 n Zq[PF$IY: $5 #M!!5 $%-918981'.8+&(.'7 91.+2.9(- &+3 <%&' .' *-&+0 .+ 91&2'.2-5 R7' D%9/72)&(2%& oP+(.+-p: @S5

A6&.(&,(-c %''9cff9,5129072%581/f28+'-+'f@Sf@f!!!jhUhe5GI !JK@5 H-+'&( I-&('% A2' !JK@5 @*_ ^PlZFDHZD$: I5 L-35O5 e8+38+5GI #MMN5 H-+'&( I-&('% A2' #MMN5 @*_ IZAe$I: G5 P5 L-35O5 e8+38+5GI #MMK5 E83- 84 ?1&2'.2- H-+'&( I-&('% A2' !JK@5 @*_ GI L-35O5 e8+38+c $VP5GPF?I_?Z$ZFVZD: C5: ?UZFFU: W5: ?ZFZe: W5: VBD: m5: VAH?VPD: A5 n eZ[UV GA #MMS5 $%- .+4()-+2-

84 2%18+.2 -;980)1- '8 &+'.9072%8'.2 *-3.2&'.8+0 8+ ,1&.+ 0.X- ,-481- &+3 &4'-1 '.00)-4.;&'.8+c & 28*9&1.08+ 84 %&(89-1.38( &+3 8(&+X&9.+- .+ *&2&`)- *8+=-705K'$(,5%9/7,57)(1)/,-,498 @M] !aQJ_a!5

IVEUE5 #M!#5 @*5)&2'*&% ],(1)--9 N'&)2*'" 2* X,%52&)-% I*"'( &7' W'*&)- X')-&7 !/& EPhf )*"

D)&2'*&% ;$#>'/& &, ;$5'(32%'" L,11$*2&9 R(')&1'*& 0 F*4-)*"8 GOEE0GOEG8 !**$)- .24$('%



#a

oP+(.+-p5 I-&('% &+3 V82.&( E&1- U+481*&'.8+ E-+'1-5 A6&.(&,(-c%''9cff<<<5%02.25/865)=f2&'&(8/)-f?BhMKMKS oA22-00-3 !a A91.( #M!@ #M!@p5

HrDGZm: W5: Z5: #M!@5 ##+3 0-00.8+ 84 '%- I)*&+ F./%'0 E8)+2.( A/-+3& U'-* @5 ^-+-6&c I)*&+F./%'0 E8)+2.(5

DP[AC: H5 #MMK5 $81')1- &+3 8'%-1 21)-(: .+%)*&+ 81 3-/1&3.+/ '1-&'*-+' 81 9)+.0%*-+'5 D-<Y81=c B+.'-3 D&'.8+05

P]IAÂD: H5 #M!#5 U'4)- /,'(/2,*_ &7' '-'57)*& 2* &7' ('/,3'(9 (,,1 oP+(.+-p5 V28'.0% F-286-17D-'<81=5 A6&.(&,(-c %''9cff<<<5028''.0%1-286-175+-'fe&'-0'_+-<0f(-/&(_28-1-286-17_12.8+_'%-_-(-9%&+'_.+_'%-_188*5%'*(5

?A$Ze: H5 q5: HA$PDIPGmZ: W5: hAU^: H5 C5: ÛeeZZD: W5: hPYGZee: W5: IPeeP[AY: R5: $AYePF: G5:VmHBCeZF: ^5: eAHhZF$: $5 n GAlUG: A5 V5 #M!!5 U+21-&0-3 )0- 84 &+'.9072%8'.2 (8+/_&2'.+/.+>-2'.8+0 <.'% 28**)+.'7 '1-&'*-+' 813-105 R7'()5'$&2/ !"3)*/'% 2*

D%9/7,57)(1)/,-,498 !] @N_QS5$AYePF: A5: eA[$PD_VHU$I: V5 n hBeeHPFZ: I5 #M!@5 V)9-16.0-3 28**)+.'7 '1-&'*-+'c 38-0 .'

4&2.(.'&'- 082.&( .+2()0.8+s A 9-109-2'.6- 418* &99186-3 *-+'&( %-&('% 9184-00.8+&(0

LAHI?0O5 W'*&)- X')-&7 )*" ;,/2)- @*/-$%2,*8 !N] Q@_QK5BC ^PlZFDHZD$ #M!#5 D8 I-&('% [.'%8)' H-+'&( I-&('%c U*9(-*-+'&'.8+ R1&*-<81=5 e8+38+c

E18<+5BD !JKQ5 BD E8+6-+'.8+ &/&.+0' $81')1- &+3 P'%-1 E1)-(: U+%)*&+ 81 G-/1&3.+/ $1-&'*-+' 81

?)+.0%*-+'5 @*_ DA$UPDV: B5 L-35O5 D-< Y81=5[IU$ACZF: F5 #MMQ5 $%- 2&0- &/&.+0' &+'.9072%8'.2 31)/0c & SM_7-&1 1-2813 84 38.+/ *81- %&1*

'%&+ /8835 W'"2/)- X9,&7'%'%8 a#] S_!@5[IU$ACZF: F5 #M!M5 !*)&,19 ,. )* F52"'12/8 D-< Y81=: E18<+ ?),(.0%-105

Documents

Against Our Will_UK CAT Shadow Report_speakoutagainstpsychiatry