1
Last June a little plane bumped me down in Blantyre, Malawi. A ragged 4-WD took me into town. I got the luggage off my back, shook hands with the guys (I have been part of a group investigating susceptibility to bacterial lung infections for several years now) and e-mailed home — “Africa is still the only place for a scientist!”. What? Sub-saharan Africa — even the name is evocative — appeals at many levels. It is a vast continent of stark physical contrasts. Scorching heat in the Namib and breathless chill on Kilimanjaro. Everywhere awesome at times and yet the awful never far away, but part of the draw. That awfulness most often turns out to be a face of the HIV global pandemic. This disease, for clinicians and scientists poses the greatest challenge of our generation. Highlighted as never before by the recent Durban conference, the HIV virus has infected 22.5 million people in sub-saharan Africa in only two decades. Mean life expectancy among Malawians is now back below 40 for the first time in 50 years. More deaths are expected in the sub- saharan region in the next few years than in the whole 14th century plague epidemic in Europe, and these deaths will be in the young and upwardly mobile. 1300 teachers died in Zambia in the first 10 months of 1998. 200 000 AIDS orphans were found in one small area of Tanzania, and the worst is yet to come. On and on it goes — all just numbers but deep down we know that this is the big one. For the clinician, HIV is the backdrop to all of hospital practice in Africa. It means new symptoms, signs, diagnoses, and (sometimes) treatments. As I write, the ‘Principles of Medicine in Africa’ are quite literally being re-written as three- quarters of inpatients are HIV positive. Today in Africa, doctors must learn this new book, embrace the challenge of a new ‘extreme medicine’ and live with a new expectation of failure. Everywhere awesome at times, but the awful never far away For the scientists standing in their thousands world-wide to face this pandemic, Africa is the crucible. Here in the mass of tragically infected people are also found the selected few who by naturally resisting the infection provide a lead in the search for an end to all of it. Africa is the epicentre of AIDS and also the furnace from which will surely emerge the solution. The scientific and other imperatives exerted by this epidemic have been recognised. Multiple sources of funding are accessible to investigators in Africa and their collaborators in the USA and Europe. A particularly good source is the Wellcome Trust Tropical Medicine Programme. On good days, like the one with which I began, I cannot imagine working anywhere else but there are problems. First, the land of physical contrast can break anything. ‘A.W.A.’ we say (‘Africa wins again’) as the freezer melt spreads a year of collected isolates over the floor. Or again, ‘the Malawi rule of two’ which states that in order to have anything working all the time, two must be kept ready — be it fluorescent microscope or flat iron, PCR block or plumbing wrench. People break too, and some very quickly — like the surgeon I remember years ago in Uganda who spent his first African night operating on an injured young woman. She later died in the ward for lack of a blood transfusion and he went home on the next planeA.W.A. Second, the awful is often more immediate than the awesome. There are days when we spend and spend and spend in the laboratory while the patients die and die and die only yards away for lack of medical support. The awesome and elusive scientific answer seems somehow shabby and unworthy beside the immediate suffering. Never was this more stark than when my tissue incubator and microscope occupied an isolation ward while patients lay on the floor outside. Thirdly, Africa is remote. Not in the physical sense that the name evokes either — more like when you find the library shut when you need that journal today. The library is shut in Africa every day. Work hard here and get fewer results for more effort. Come home ill-informed, de-skilled and underconfident. In return, though, Africa will give you more physical and intellectual space, more freedom, more life. I’m going to drive down from England to spend four more years with alveolar macrophages, AIDS and Africa. Maybe we won’t meet there — but I will be in the right place. Address: Division of Genomic Medicine, University of Sheffield, Sheffield, S10 4FA, UK. R4 Current Biology Vol 11 No 1 Feature Africa wins again Clinician and immunologist, Stephen Gordon, can’t imagine working anywhere else but the African infrastructure and HIV pandemic present a massive challenge for researchers, he says.

Africa wins again

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Africa wins again

Last June a little plane bumped medown in Blantyre, Malawi. A ragged4-WD took me into town. I got theluggage off my back, shook handswith the guys (I have been part of agroup investigating susceptibility tobacterial lung infections for severalyears now) and e-mailedhome — “Africa is still the only placefor a scientist!”. What?

Sub-saharan Africa — even thename is evocative — appeals at manylevels. It is a vast continent of starkphysical contrasts. Scorching heat inthe Namib and breathless chill onKilimanjaro. Everywhere awesome attimes and yet the awful never faraway, but part of the draw.

That awfulness most often turnsout to be a face of the HIV globalpandemic. This disease, for cliniciansand scientists poses the greatestchallenge of our generation.Highlighted as never before by therecent Durban conference, the HIVvirus has infected 22.5 million peoplein sub-saharan Africa in onlytwo decades. Mean life expectancyamong Malawians is now back below40 for the first time in 50 years. Moredeaths are expected in the sub-saharan region in the next few yearsthan in the whole 14th centuryplague epidemic in Europe, andthese deaths will be in the young andupwardly mobile. 1300 teachers diedin Zambia in the first 10 months of1998. 200 000 AIDS orphans werefound in one small area of Tanzania,and the worst is yet to come. On andon it goes — all just numbers butdeep down we know that this is thebig one.

For the clinician, HIV is thebackdrop to all of hospital practice in

Africa. It means new symptoms,signs, diagnoses, and (sometimes)treatments. As I write, the ‘Principlesof Medicine in Africa’ are quiteliterally being re-written as three-quarters of inpatients are HIVpositive. Today in Africa, doctorsmust learn this new book, embracethe challenge of a new ‘extrememedicine’ and live with a newexpectation of failure.

Everywhere awesome at times,but the awful never far away

For the scientists standing intheir thousands world-wide to facethis pandemic, Africa is the crucible.Here in the mass of tragicallyinfected people are also found theselected few who by naturallyresisting the infection provide a leadin the search for an end to all of it.Africa is the epicentre of AIDS andalso the furnace from which willsurely emerge the solution.

The scientific and otherimperatives exerted by this epidemichave been recognised. Multiplesources of funding are accessible toinvestigators in Africa and theircollaborators in the USA and Europe.A particularly good source is theWellcome Trust Tropical MedicineProgramme. On good days, like theone with which I began, I cannotimagine working anywhere else butthere are problems.

First, the land of physicalcontrast can break anything. ‘A.W.A.’we say (‘Africa wins again’) as thefreezer melt spreads a year of

collected isolates over the floor. Oragain, ‘the Malawi rule of two’ whichstates that in order to have anythingworking all the time, two must bekept ready — be it fluorescentmicroscope or flat iron, PCR block orplumbing wrench. People break too,and some very quickly — like thesurgeon I remember years ago inUganda who spent his first Africannight operating on an injured youngwoman. She later died in the wardfor lack of a blood transfusion and hewent home on the nextplane…A.W.A.

Second, the awful is often moreimmediate than the awesome. Thereare days when we spend and spendand spend in the laboratory while thepatients die and die and die onlyyards away for lack of medicalsupport. The awesome and elusivescientific answer seems somehowshabby and unworthy beside theimmediate suffering. Never was thismore stark than when my tissueincubator and microscope occupiedan isolation ward while patients layon the floor outside.

Thirdly, Africa is remote. Not inthe physical sense that the nameevokes either — more like when youfind the library shut when you needthat journal today. The library is shutin Africa every day. Work hard hereand get fewer results for more effort.Come home ill-informed, de-skilledand underconfident.

In return, though, Africa willgive you more physical andintellectual space, more freedom,more life. I’m going to drive downfrom England to spend four moreyears with alveolar macrophages,AIDS and Africa. Maybe we won’tmeet there — but I will be in theright place.

Address: Division of Genomic Medicine,University of Sheffield, Sheffield, S10 4FA, UK.

R4 Current Biology Vol 11 No 1

Feature

Africa wins again

Clinician and immunologist, Stephen Gordon, can’t imagine workinganywhere else but the African infrastructure and HIV pandemicpresent a massive challenge for researchers, he says.