Upload
others
View
1
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
1
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
AFNeT & ProSTEP iViP
STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 Presentation
By Kevin Le TutourBenchmark Project Manager, AFNeT
April 19 & 20, 2017 STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - Paris
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
2
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
The last step before operational solutions for the industries
August 2014
2nd CAD Benchmark
1st PDM Benchmark
April 19 & 20, 2017 STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - Paris
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
3
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
To provide a public status of STEP AP242 functionalities available for operational use
n ISO STEP AP242 Ed1 is available for the Automotive and Aerospace industries as well as many other branches of the manufacturing industry as a unique product data standard
n Complete & neutral quality control of AP242 based implementations on the market
n Functionalities & systems to be benchmarked are given by the user communitiesn Based on test criteria:
§ formal correctness of the file§ fulfilment of end-to-end validation properties§ end-user validation
April 19 & 20, 2017 STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - Paris
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
4
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
Agenda
nBenchmark #2 CAD test casesnBenchmark #2 PDM test case
For both work packages:§Test models, test cases and test procedure§Functionalities scope §Tests Results Report
April 19 & 20, 2017 STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - Paris
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
5
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
Benchmark #2 CAD test cases
April 19 & 20, 2017 STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - Paris
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
6
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
Test cases and related test models TC# Test case name Criteria overview Example of test modelTC1 3D exact geometry • Solid, surface, curve conversion
• Geometry Presentation (color, …)• Geometric validation properties• Transparency, invisibility• User defined attributes
TC2 3D tessellated geometry • Solid, surface, curve conversion• Geometry Presentation (color, …)• Validation properties
TC3b PMI graphic tessellated (3D exact geometry) • PMI graphic presentation• Saved views• Cross highlight• PMI Validation properties
TC3c PMI semantic link with graphic (3D exact geometry)
• PMI semantic representation• Saved views• Cross highlight • PMI Validation properties
TC4 PMI graphic tessellated (3D tess geometry) • PMI graphic presentation• Saved views• Cross highlight • PMI Validation properties
TC6c CAD assembly BOM XML ext ref assembly STEP tessellated geometry compressed
• Assembly structure• Assembly Validation properties• External reference to geometry
TC6d CAD assembly AIM P21 Nested assembly STEP exact geometry
• Assembly structure• Assembly Validation properties• External reference to geometry
April 19 & 20, 2017 STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - Paris
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
7
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
Testing procedure
April 19 & 20, 2017 STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - Paris
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
8
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
Participating solutions and formats in scope
Vendors Solution name
Autodesk Inventor Professional 2017CoreTechnologie 3DEvolution 4.0
3DAnalyzer 4.0Dassault Systèmes CATIA V5R26
3DEXPERIENCE R2016xDatakit CrossManager 16.2Elysium ASFALIS X7.0Kisters 3DViewStation 2016.0TechSoft3D Tetra4D 2016.1
Native format in scope
CATIA V5
Creo
NX
Inventor
SolidWorks
3D PDF only from STEP to 3D PDF
April 19 & 20, 2017 STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - Paris
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
9
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
Publication in May 2016
n Short report will be officially available:http://benchmark.ap242.org/
n Long version of Benchmark only for AFNeT Associations Members and participating vendors
http://www.afnet.fr/dotank/sps/ap242benchmar/
April 19 & 20, 2017 STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - Paris
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
10
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
Benchmark #2 PDM test case
STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - ParisApril 19 & 20, 2017
September 2016 to March 2017
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
11
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
Participating Vendors and Testing sites
April 19 & 20, 2017 STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - Paris
Windchill 11.0 M020
COMPDM 2.0 OpenPDM 8
ASFALIS EX7.1.12 3DEXPERIENCE R2017x
CrossManager v17.1 3D_Evolution 4.1
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
12
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
Test modeln Nominal Test model: AP242 BO Model XML + AP242 P21 Geometryn Test model: AS1 (defined in ISO 10303-44)n Test model and test scope have been tested before in the PDM IF
See http://www.cax-if.de/library/
April 19 & 20, 2017 STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - Paris
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
13
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
Tested functionalities in scopen Exchange of PDM Information using AP242 BO Model XML
n Transfer of PDM-relevant information § Part number, Version, Life cycle status, document management information, etc.
n Transfer of Assembly Validation Properties
n References to geometry (STEP Part 21 files / CAD models)
n References to non-CAD documents (PDF, JPG)
n Management of changes (new versions, updated life cycle status)
April 19 & 20, 2017 STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - Paris
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
14
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
Verified properties and business rules in scopen Properties
§ Resolved product structure without configuration information§ Part properties (number, name, description etc.)§ 3D positioning matrix§ Instance name of part usage§ CAD or non-CAD Document properties
(number, name, version, creator etc.)§ External file properties
(name, creator and creation date, last modifier and Date)§ Life cycle status (released, in work, etc.)
n Business rules§ CAx-IF Recommended Practices for STEP AP242 BO Model XML Product and
Assembly Structure v1.1
April 19 & 20, 2017 STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - Paris
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
15
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
Testing procedure
PDM Sys. B
BenchmarkTestEnv.
Export modifiedData
ExportData
STEP files check
Import DataEnd-user checks
Import DataManage ChangesEnd-user checks
3
4a
5
6
7
8
Re-Import sameSample DataEnd-user check
ImportSample Data
End-user check1 2
Sample STEP-XML
PDM Sys. A
Phas
e 1
Phas
e 2
Base
d on
Ste
p 1
Compare to Sample XML
STEP filescheck
Phas
e 3
Afte
r STE
P fil
e se
lect
ion
4b
April 19 & 20, 2017 STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - Paris
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
16
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
Results Overview by tools (Short Version)
April 19 & 20, 2017 STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - Paris
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
17
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
Results by PDM functionalities
April 19 & 20, 2017 STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - Paris
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
18
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
Results by STEP conformity criteria
April 19 & 20, 2017 STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - Paris
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
19
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
Summary
n Good level of STEP AP242 BO XML implementation for PDM product structure exchange
n Most of in-scope PDM functionalities robustly supported, except for the transfer of the benchmarked assembly validation properties
n Concerning conformity tests of produced STEP files, most results are positive
n As the Recommended Practices become more and more stable over time, it is expected that the results will also be improved in this area
n Next AFNeT & ProSTEP iViP benchmark with tests of extended functionalities to be planned in 2018
April 19 & 20, 2017 STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - Paris
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
20
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
Publicationn Short report is officially available:
http://benchmark.ap242.org/
n Long version of Benchmark only for Associations Members and participating vendors:§ Detailed results of tested software§ Precise results tables of every
executed step§ Precise table of every criterion
n Websites§ http://www.afnet.fr/dotank/sps/ap242
benchmar/§ http://www.prostep.org/en/medialibra
ry/publications/benchmarks.html
Content
1 Introduction2 References and terms
2.1 Reference documents2.2 Terms
3 Test methodology3.1 Functionalities tested in this Benchmark3.2 Testing Strategy3.3 Synthetic Test Case Specifications: PDM Assembly with 3D Geometry3.4 List of tested applications3.5 STEP file selected as reference for phase
4 Test Results4.1 Overview of the Test Results4.2 Overall Test Results
5 Summary6 Publication of the Long Report of PDM test case7 Acknowledgements
April 19 & 20, 2017 STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - Paris
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
21
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
Conclusionn Since PLM vendors and CAD integrators constantly enhance the functionalities
and robustness of their STEP AP242 interfaces, the results of this benchmark provide a snapshot of the functionalities tested at a certain moment in time for a specific version of the vendors solutions.
n New editions of this Benchmark report will be published, addressing additional software & functionalities.
n The use of international open standards for 3D Model Based interoperability is seen as a key enabler to support global engineering and manufacturing of complex products within the extended enterprise.
n It also contributes to ensure a better independence regarding PLM vendor’s proprietary formats, and long-term preservation of 3D Model Based design.
n The availability of COTS STEP AP242 solutions for PDM data interoperability contributes to answer to this challenge.
April 19 & 20, 2017 STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - Paris
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
22
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
Related web sites, contacts and Acknowledgements
n AP242 project: http://www.ap242.org/
n AP242 Benchmark: http://benchmark.ap242.org/
n PDM-IF: http://www.pdm-if.org/
n CAx-IF: http://www.cax-if.org
n Private website: http://plmtf.sharepoint.com/benchmark
Related web sites Testing Team Contactsn AFNeT
Pierre Duchier, Frédéric Darré, Aminata Mbengue Kevin Le Tutour, Gaël Diquelou
AFNeT
30 rue de Miromesnil 75008 Paris
Tel.: +33 (0) 144 568 750
n ProSTEP iViP
Jochen Boy, Felix Klier
ProSTEP iViP
Dolivostraße 11 D-64293 Darmstadt
Tel.: +49 6151 9287 440
April 19 & 20, 2017 STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - Paris
n Thanks to the applications Vendors who provided their COTS applications for the
Benchmark testing, for their support in the installation, and for the analysis of the test
results.
n Thanks the CAx-IF and the PDM-IF for the STEP Recommended Practices and the test
case.
n Thanks Airbus, Dassault Aviation, Daimler, Daher, MBDA, Liebherr, Zodiac Aerospace,
ASD-SSG, GALIA, GIFAS, PFA, VDA, AFNeT & ProSTEP iViP Members for their funding
and orientations.
Acknowledgements
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
23
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
AP242 on a page
April 19 & 20, 2017 STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - Paris
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
24
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
New in AP242: Business Object Model XML
BM-Scope
MotivationAs designated backbone for data exchange in the manufacturing industry, the capability to exchange PDM data in XML format is a key factor.
Scopen General Administrative Datan Part and Document Managementn Propertiesn Assembly Structuren Requirementsn Configuration, Effectivityn Compositesn Kinematicsn External References
April 19 & 20, 2017 STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - Paris
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
25
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
Phas
e 1
Sam
ple
STEP
impo
rt
Test scenario, procedure and methodology
PDM Sys. B
BenchmarkTestEnv.
Export modifiedData
ExportData
STEP files check
Import DataEnd-user checks
Import DataManage ChangesEnd-user checks
3
4a
5
6
7
8
Re-Import sameSample DataEnd-user check
ImportSample Data
End-user check1 2
Sample STEP
dataset
PDM Sys. A
Phas
e 2
STEP
exp
ort a
nd c
heck
Compare to Sample XML
STEP filescheck
Phas
e 3
Impo
rt fro
m s
elec
ted
STEP
file
s
4b n The test scenario:
§ New import
§ Re-import (allow to see how the tool behave: overwrite, duplicate, etc.)
§ Export data and export modified data
§ Import changes (modification of description attributes, geometry, part position, etc.),
§ Interpret revision numbers,
§ Import life cycle status.n STEP files checks
§ XML files will be checked for syntax and structures (XSD conformity)
§ compliance with business rules will be checked using Schematron
§ Check visually XML content + compare to initial file
n End-user checks
§ Check for completeness and
§ correctness of product structure and attributes
n STEP file selection
§ Select the best STEP file out of 4.
§ Select the best STEP file out of 7.
April 19 & 20, 2017 STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - Paris
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
26
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
Procedure for 3DEvolution
AllPDM Sys.
BenchmarkTestEnv.
ExportData
Import DataEnd-user checks
2
4a
5
1
Sample STEP-XML
Compare to Sample XML
STEP filescheck
4b
3DEvolution
ImportSample Data
End-user checkPhas
e 1
Sam
ple
STEP
impo
rt
Phas
e 2
STEP
exp
ort a
nd c
heck
Phas
e 3
Impo
rt fro
m s
elec
ted
STEP
file
s
April 19 & 20, 2017 STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - Paris
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
27
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
Procedure for CrossManager
BenchmarkTestEnv.
Import DataEnd-user checks
Import DataEnd-user checks5bis 8bis
Sample STEP-XML
CrossManager 3D PDF
3DGeometryreview
Phas
e 1
Sam
ple
STEP
impo
rt
Phas
e 2
STEP
exp
ort a
nd c
heck
Phas
e 3
Impo
rt fro
m s
elec
ted
STEP
file
s
April 19 & 20, 2017 STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - Paris
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
28
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
Overview of the AS1 assembly structure, including indication of changes
April 19 & 20, 2017 STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - Paris
DIESAR Direction Internationale de l’Evaluation, de la Sécurité et des Affaires Réglementaires
29
AFNeT Standardization Days 2017
List of tested applications
April 19 & 20, 2017 STEP AP242 Benchmark #2 - AFNeT Standardization Days 2017 - Paris