Afghan National

Defence Journal Pakistan (May 2014)

http://www.defencejournal.com

1

Afghan National Army - A Truly National Army for A Countrys Defence or A Militia

on Steroids

Haris Khan

AFGHAN NATIONAL ARMY - A TRULY NATIONAL ARMY FOR A

COUNTRYS DEFENSE OR A MILITIA ON STEROIDS

Haris Khan

With the US/ISAF- Afghanistan retrograde on track there are some apparently intractable

issues that remain when looking at the military-political strategy for Afghanistan and its

surrounding areas.

A new American intelligence assessment on the Afghan war predicts that the gains the United

States and its allies have made during the past three years are likely to have been significantly

eroded by 2017, even if Washington leaves behind a few thousand troops and continues

bankrolling the impoverished nation, according to officials familiar with the report.*

This article is geared to shed light on the Afghanistan National Armys (ANA) and Afghan

National Army Air Corps (ANAAC) capacity to deal with the security of the country post-

2014 withdrawal of the ISAF apparatus. It will shed light on the structure of ANA, the

manpower it consists of and its training, order of battle (Orbat), and military balance

equipment.

Ill leave the Afghan National Security Forces (ANSF) for some other time to be explained in

depth about its modes operandi. For the record the ANSF constitute the following;

Afghan National Police (ANP)

Afghan Border Police (ABP)

Afghan Local Police (ALP)

Afghan Public Protection Force (APPF)

Afghan National Civil Order Police (ANCOP)

Counter Narcotics Police of Afghanistan (CNPA)

The effectiveness of the ANA is only one element of securing peace and stability in

Afghanistan. But the composition of the ANA is of critical importance in providing lasting

security and stability and denying Afghanistan as a future base for international terrorism and

extremism, since Afghanistan is still at war and will probably be at war long after 2014.

More than a decade of Western intervention has not produced a strong and viable central

government, an economy that can function without massive outside aid, or effective Afghan

security forces. There are few signs that insurgents are being pushed towards defeat or will

lose their sanctuaries in neighbouring countries.

Efforts to rebuild the ANA have been going on for about six years, and judgments about its

progress have been mixed. In November 2009 the NATO Training Mission-Afghanistan

(NTM-A) was established as a multinational military organization. After being activated the

NTM-A was tasked with providing a higher-level training for the ANA and AAFC.



2


on Steroids

Haris Khan

Being that Afghanistan is a multi-ethnic and multi-lingual country, this posed the first and

foremost hurdle that the trainers were faced with. Uncertainty as to which language the

instructional training should occur in was a problem. It was decided it should be in English.

The main focus for NTM-A was that security means that the Afghans handle the violence, not

the ISAF. The Afghans themselves have to manage their districts and cities while the on-

going insurgency is occurring.

The known weaknesses of recent efforts in Afghanistan in creating the ANA are (1) lack of

modern-style professionalism, greatly caused by illiteracy and lack of education, (2) high

desertion rates/poor retention rate of soldiers, and (3) lack of equally-distributed proportional

representation by all the major communities, with some of the predominantly Pathan

(Pushtoon or Pakhtoon) areas such as Kandahar and Helmand contributing less than the Farsi

(Dari) speaking Tajiks and Hazaras.

After a somewhat rocky start, institutional training appears to have progressed well. The

programs of instruction appear sound and attuned to the needs of the Afghan army. More

problematic is the unit-level training, which depends in large part on the efforts of embedded

training teams. It was relatively easier for the officer corps to be instructed in English;

however, at the lower ranks enlistments this caused significant problems. It was observed by

some NATO trainers that after the class was dismissed the enlisted men gravitated towards

their own lingual comrades and stayed with them most of the time and conversed in their

ethnic languages.

In 2003, the collation (ISAF) had set a quota of 40 per cent Pashtoons and 25 per cent Tajiks

for the ANA. Instead, the Tajiks, along with Uzbeks and Hazare, filled the ranks, with very

few southern Pashtoons signing up. The attitude amongst the ANA troops we should not go

out on patrol and stay at respected units base. It appeared to imply units, which have non-

Pushtoons in them, were unwilling to patrol Pushtoon areas and vice versa regarding

Pushtoon units in non-Pushtoon areas.

The latest report by the Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction (SIGAR)

states: In ANA Tajiks, which represent 25% of the population, now account for 41% of all

troops who have been trained, and that only 30% of the troops are now Pushtoon, 12 per cent

Hazari and 10 per cent Uzbek, with the rest made up of smaller ethnic groups, which is

approximately the percentages of these communities in the Afghan population.

Now at its biggest size yet, 214,000 soldiers, the ANA is so plagued with desertions and low

re-enlistment rates that it has to replace a third of its entire force every year, according to

SIGAR. The desertion rate amongst the Pashtoon is the highest. The attrition strikes at the

core of Americas exit strategy in Afghanistan: to ensure that the ANA that can take over the

war and allow the United States and NATO forces to withdraw by the end of 2014.



3


on Steroids

Haris Khan

According to USCENTCOM, on the day the retrograde is completed the total combined

forces of ANA and ANSF should reach its planned strength of 394,000 troops, assuming that

there is no large scale Pashtoon desertion.

On the line is also the critical status of the Bilateral Security Agreement (BSA) between the

USA and Afghanistan. With the effect (BSA) at least ANA & ANSF would not be left

themselves to deal with the inevitable and impending frontal onslaught by the insurgents

(Taliban and other groups).

BSA will assure the region that the United States will remain engaged and will not abandon

Afghanistan as the US once did in 1989 after the Soviet withdrawal. The BSA is also the

keystone of a much wider international commitment of several countries involving over years

of ready to provide economic and security assistance to Afghanistan beyond 2015.

Afghanistans regional neighbours, with the exception of Iran and India, also understand the

importance of the BSA. President Putin of Russia, President Xi of China, and Prime

Minister/Foreign Minister Sharif of Pakistan has all personally urged President Karzai to

conclude the bilateral security agreement.

According to some estimates the insurgencies are running at less than 50% of its capacity. It

took the US and its NATO partners eight years to realize that Afghanistan is not large-scale

combat; instead its a war of intimidation - brief fights and heavy field and aerial bombing

intended to instil fear, causing the insurgence to pull back and go into hiding. General John

N. Abrams son of famous Gen Creighton W Abrams Jr (Chief of Staff of the United States

Army during Vietnam War) said in 2003, that dont let war in Afghanistan become

Afghanization war of attrition; alas this is what this war has become. To build and maintain

the spirit of ANA has become the central theme of US-Afghan war policy since 2009. The

Americans have put all their chips on the ANA so at least they [ANA] can control and keep

open the cities and highways, otherwise, if there are superficial cracks in ANA while fighting

the insurgences the Americans can always provide heavy air support to breach the attack and

spirit of the Taliban (Pashtoons) for the time being. Some months ago Gen. (R) Stanley

MacCrystal said that if there are problems in Afghanistan they flow into Pakistan like

river Kabul.

For Pakistan the BSA is something which ought to happen for its security in Afghanistan. As

long as the US has a visible footprint in Afghanistan, which entails giving air support to ANA

and training ANA troops, Pakistans security parameters are more or less guaranteed.

Pakistan is currently fighting a major internal insurgency (with one of its hands and legs tied)

with the so-called Pakistani Pashtoon aka almost 55 groups who call themselves Tehreek-e-

Taliban Pakistan (TTP). Presently there is a hodgepodge effort to deal with this insurgency

that is bent on destroying the Constitution of the country and wish to impose its own brand of

perverted understanding of Islam, which is of Khawarij mind-set. For some odd reason if any



4


on Steroids

Haris Khan

faction of the Pushtoon Taliban return to Kabul post 2014 things likely will become difficult

for the elected government in Islamabad and other provisional capitals, hence, the possibility

of popular military take over becomes very imminent with mass approval of the populace.

However if there is no BSA the situation in Pakistans FATA and more or less most of

Afghanistan will be open and hostile to Pakistans sovereignty and national security. What if

there is an attack on the mainland USA and the postage stamps points straight to FATA or

any area in Afghanistan? The USA will not ask the Pakistanis to do more or try to talk some

sense in Kabuls regimes but rather theyll use air assets to bomb the area mercilessly for its

attack at the mainland USA. Even the talk of US pull-out has started having its impact.

Pakistan has started to receive more Afghan refugees than before, said Pakistans

Ambassador to the US Jalil Abbas Jilani. This shows that the people of Afghanistan too

have fears, Said Jalil Abbas Jilani Pakistans new ambassador to the United States. In case

the bulk of the troops withdraw, the major responsibility would lie on our shoulders. Security

responsibilities, previously being shared by others, then exclusively become Pakistans

responsibility. It is certainly going to be a big challenge, he said. It should also be noted here

that if for some reasons the backflow of Afghan civil war into Pakistan the country will be

very susceptible for a military take over because of the securities concerns of Pakistan

nuclear weapons and its program.

Below is the chart of the military equipment that the US and its allies have given to ANA and

ANSF. This chart doesnt include small arms (assault rifles, rocket launchers, pistols, motor

rockets and its launchers, communication equipment etc)



5


on Steroids

Haris Khan



6


on Steroids

Haris Khan



7


on Steroids

Haris Khan

Command echelons include Corps (15,000 - 20,000 troops), a Division (approx. 10,000

troops), Brigade (3,000 - 4,000 troops), kandak (battalion - about 600 troops) of four toli (a

company-sized unit of rather more than 100 troops, toli being the Urdu word for troop). Most

of these units are numbered sequentially, as in the 4th Toli, of the 3rd Kandak, of the 1st

Brigade, of the 201st Corps [4th Toli, 3rd Kandak, 1st Brigade, 201st Corps], and cannot be

uniquely identified without reference to their upper echelons. But others have identifiers such

as Weapons Toli or 201st Combat Logistics Kandak.

The US will have three CV (Nuclear powered aircraft carriers) groups at the northern Arabian

sea, plus tactical air wings at Al Udeid Air Base Doha, Al Dharfa, UAE, plus a strategic base



8


on Steroids

Haris Khan

at Diego Garcia. This entails close to 350+ fighter aircrafts plus bombers and hundreds of

stand-off missiles. This leaves the USA enough airpower to dominate Pakistani airspace in 40

minutes and Indian Air space in 70 minutes according to recent estimates. As I have written,

it will not take them [US] long to start bombing without any repercussions if needed in

Afghanistan. The main concern is what has Pakistan planned for this scenarios occurrence. If

things go wrong in Afghanistan they will flow into Pakistan just as they did during Nov-Dec

2001 and Jan-Feb 02. These notions of do more will turn into you are the culprits and well

take care of our problem inside your country. Pakistans armed forces neither have the

capability nor the capacity to sustain this type of assault.

On the other hand, the Indians planners wish that the Afghans would refrain from signing the

BSA. If the BSA is not signed the Indians will try to establish themselves as the main power

provider for the Kabul regime. This will cause a lot of problems for Islamabad, Beijing and

Washington DC. Recently, when President Karzai visited New Delhi his Defence Minister

tabled a long weapons wish list to their counterpart. This wish list shows a dramatic shift

from the type of weaponry that the USA and NATO have assigned to ANA and ANSF. This

wish list included 120 pieces of 105mm medium artillery, 150 T-72 heavy tanks, 24 Mi-17

Hip assault Helicopter, 24 Mi-35 Hind gunship helicopters. If for some reason India is able to

provide these weapons the face of the ANA will change from being mainly a counter

insurgency and defensive force into an offensive force which will definitely threatened

Pakistan.

Indian hawks, in their army and Ministry of external affairs, have a mind-set which

encourages taking a robust and possibly even a military role in Afghanistan. They wish to fill

the security vacuum left by the US withdrawal, force Karzai not to sign BSA, advance its

regional interest, and compete with China rivals for a permanent influence in Afghanistan.

They wish to thwart their Pakistani enemies at the same time.

Historically the trust deficits between the majority Pashtoon and Tajik plus Uzbek have never

been reconciled. Since the majority of ANA and ANSF is of Tajik and Uzbek groups it is

inevitable that after some time these two groups will turn their guns towards the Pashtoon. If

this happens more than likely the Pashtoon will fall back towards the east and the fighting

will be eventually be at Pakistans border. With the ANA weaponry and added arms from

India, there is a good possibility that Pakistan will be dragged directly in Afghanistans ethnic

civil war.

The choices for Pakistan are very well defined. Pakistan should make sure that Afghanistan

signs BSA with USA, hence, making sure that the USA is engaged for 10 more years and the

funding to sustain ANA and ANSF continues unabated. Pakistan needs to make sure that

Afghan refugees return to their homeland plus at some critical points the border needs to be

secured with birded wire fence and landmines, even if this security measure requires Pakistan

erect this fence within its own border. There ought to be fool proof flight cargo manifesto for



9


on Steroids

Haris Khan

all the Indian flights, which use Pakistani air space to and from India to Afghanistan to

determine if illegal arms are being moved without Pakistans permission.

President Karzai has views about Pakistan which do not sit well with the defence managers of

Pakistan and USA. He informed one of the US Army officers of the following Everyday

ANA are getting stronger. No government in Kabul can have a good relationship with

Islamabad unless there are no hostile material and slogans from Pakistan. He blames

everyone from Pakistans ISI, religious scholars, traders/businessmen for any problems in

Afghanistan. On the other hand, he often refuses to acknowledge that the drug problem is one

of the main incubators of insurgency in his country. If we come to know that Pakistan is

being used against us we will make sure we take out these camps with our ANA, we are very

strong and can teach Pakistanis a lesson in a very short time, said President Karzai.

Intelligence estimates give various figures as to what type of weaponry that was in possession

with Taliban till October 2001. These weapons are still not being accounted for or have been

destroyed by the ISAF. Since estimates say that the insurgencies are working at 50% of their

capacity and presently are only fighting the ISAF and ANA with small to medium arms plus

IED. When the US completes its withdrawal their heavy weaponry might reappear in

insurgencies hands and this would change the battlefield equation dramatically. Some of the

heavy artillery like ex-Soviet M-46 130 mm and multi rocket launchers BM-21 122 mm plus

the famous Brazilian SS-30 ASTROS (Artillery Saturation Rocket System) with a maximum

range of 30 km which were purchased by Saudi Arabia and passed on to Afghan Mujahedeen

forces in 1986 are unaccounted for. The same rockets were confiscated by Pakistans FC

from Baloch Liberation Army arms cache in 2011.

Afghan President Karzai has complained to Secy. of Defence Hagel about Pakistans Haft IX

Nasr SRBFBM because he feels after post 2014 Pakistan might use these missiles against

ANA. Also, one of the reasons that Karzai is refusing to sign BSA with the USA is to insert

provisions that the ANA could enter into Pakistan territory and attack suspected militant

camps. The US refused his request completely and said they will not be party of anything of

this nature. If Afghanistan deteriorates into a chaotic civil war after the US leaves, it would

be bad for Afghanistan but a royal disaster for Pakistan.

Afghanistan has been in a perpetual state of Buzkashi game. What is earnestly needed is that

the Afghans sort out their own affairs without any outside advice or mediation. The only two

countries, which have permanent, interest in what happens in Afghanistan, are Iran and

Pakistan. However, they should honestly keep their hands off when the Afghans are sorting

out their affairs. Other countries have interest in Afghanistan (USA, Russia, China, India,

Japan, and Saudi Arabia) but have no permanent interest in Afghanistan and they should be

told to keep their hands off. Yes, if the situation takes a turn for the worst these

aforementioned countries will eventually feel the repercussions.



10


on Steroids

Haris Khan

However, it would be very difficult to keep the above-mentioned countries out of

Afghanistans affairs because Afghanistan as a country cant stand on its own but requires

massive amount of external aid to run its affairs. At this junction it would be very prudent for

these later countries to help Afghanistan but keep a very strict check into how and where their

aid money has been spent.

For Pakistan, a stable and normal Afghanistan is critical for its prosperity and development.

Since 2002, more than 70,000 Pakistanis have died because of the overflow of violence from

Afghanistan and it has caused economic losses estimating close to $100 billion.

The safe havens in North Waziristan Agency ought to be destroyed and cleared from the

militants (both locals and foreign) who are fighting the State of Pakistan. This is also the

areas in which are several individuals who are kidnapped and held by their kidnappers, who

the US intelligence agencies have described as high value sensitive liabilities (HVSL). The

elected members need to make sure that the hub of insurgency in FATA becomes an integral

part of Constitutional Pakistan. The main threat to Pakistan territorial integrity, survival, and

sovereignty is clearly from India, which should not be given any leverage to establish a

permanent base in Afghanistan at the expense of Pakistan.

Works Cited

Askarson, Katterina. Prospect for a Crisis in Post-2014 Afghanistan, Civil-Military Fusion

Centre, 2013.

Author. Informal Conversation with retired US Army Major-General Stanley McChrystal.

Washington. DC, 2013.

Dalrymple, William. A Deadly Triangle: Afghanistan, Pakistan, and India,. A Deadly

Triangle: Afghanistan, Pakistan and India. June 2013.

Defence, U.S. Department of. Report on Progress towards Security and Stability in

Afghanistan. 2012. U.S. Department of Defence, n.d.

Jilani, Jalil Abbas. Pakistans Ambassador to USA Anwar Iqbal. Dawn Newspaper, 2 January

2014.

National Intelligence Council, 2030.

About the Author

Haris Khan is a native of Karachi, Pakistan and has been living in the USA for almost 29

years. He owns and operates couple of businesses in the USA. Beside his business he works

in matters of Homeland Security and is a Defence analyst with acumen on South Asia,

Nuclear and Missile Weaponization, and the Arabia Gulf countries. He tweets at

haris_n_Khan plus is an administrator at PakDef Military Consortium website which has

more than 4,500 members. He can be reached at [email protected] or [email protected]

Documents

Afghan National