18
ADVERTISEMENT 1 Question from Members Please note: Duplicate questions have been removed. One question has been removed as containing inappropriate content. Three others have been edited to remove some inappropriate content. No Theme Question 1 GPs in Training How do you plan to support the current GP registrars due to sit exams in October? The lack of information is causing increased stress in an already stressful environment. The college should exist for its’ members – especially the most vulnerable. Registrars have been impacted most by the reduction in patient numbers in general practice and many are reliant on jobkeeper. I would make sure registrars are not charged to learn how to sit a new exam. I would look to allowing registrars who fail examinations in October to resit in 2021 at no fee as well as extending their training if needed. 2 GPs in Training A lot of registrars have felt let down by the RACGP on various topics for a long time. What will you try to achieve for GP Registrars if you become elected RACGP President? The main issues that affect registrars are the same as those that affect fellows – poor remuneration relative to other specialties with high training fees. Some of these fees are needed – e.g. The high personnel requirement for our old OSCE format. I would make sure that the RACGP is cost neutral on fees charged to registrars. I will reduce membership fees of the RACGP by 10%. I would look to lobbying for the federal government to directly fund the examination costs of registrars as another way of encouraging doctors into general practice 3 GPs in Training What are the main issues affecting GPs in training and what will you do to improve them as RACGP president? High fees – decrease them where possible Lobby for federally funded maternity and paternity leave as well as study leave Lobby for federal government to pay registrar examination fees 4 GPs in Training How do you see yourselves closing the gap between GP supervisors and registrars when it comes to remuneration in a way that both parties are happy? Are you satisfied that the fellowship exams in their current format are helping the purpose of producing an independent GP who may practice anywhere in Australia? Do you see that RTOs (in the current set up) are delivering similar training programs across Australia?

ADVERTISEMENT Question from Members€¦ · 4 No Theme Question 11 IMGs The current training programs discriminate between local graduate and overseas graduate IMGs. Local graduates

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: ADVERTISEMENT Question from Members€¦ · 4 No Theme Question 11 IMGs The current training programs discriminate between local graduate and overseas graduate IMGs. Local graduates

ADVERTISEMENT

1

Question from Members

Please note: Duplicate questions have been removed. One question has been removed as containing

inappropriate content. Three others have been edited to remove some inappropriate content.

No Theme Question

1 GPs in Training

How do you plan to support the current GP registrars due to sit exams in October? The lack of information is causing increased stress in an already stressful environment. The college should exist for its’ members – especially the most vulnerable. Registrars have been impacted most by the reduction in patient numbers in general practice and many are reliant on jobkeeper. I would make sure registrars are not charged to learn how to sit a new exam. I would look to allowing registrars who fail examinations in October to resit in 2021 at no fee as well as extending their training if needed.

2 GPs in Training

A lot of registrars have felt let down by the RACGP on various topics for a long time. What will you try to achieve for GP Registrars if you become elected RACGP President? The main issues that affect registrars are the same as those that affect fellows – poor remuneration relative to other specialties with high training fees. Some of these fees are needed – e.g. The high personnel requirement for our old OSCE format. I would make sure that the RACGP is cost neutral on fees charged to registrars. I will reduce membership fees of the RACGP by 10%. I would look to lobbying for the federal government to directly fund the examination costs of registrars as another way of encouraging doctors into general practice

3 GPs in Training

What are the main issues affecting GPs in training and what will you do to improve them as RACGP president? High fees – decrease them where possible Lobby for federally funded maternity and paternity leave as well as study leave Lobby for federal government to pay registrar examination fees

4 GPs in Training

How do you see yourselves closing the gap between GP supervisors and registrars when it comes to remuneration in a way that both parties are happy? Are you satisfied that the fellowship exams in their current format are helping the purpose of producing an independent GP who may practice anywhere in Australia? Do you see that RTOs (in the current set up) are delivering similar training programs across Australia?

Page 2: ADVERTISEMENT Question from Members€¦ · 4 No Theme Question 11 IMGs The current training programs discriminate between local graduate and overseas graduate IMGs. Local graduates

ADVERTISEMENT

2

The main differences between GPT4 pay and fellow pay is because of their employment status – payroll tax, worker compensation insurance, sick leave, annual leave, and superannuation cause significant costs that result in registrars costing practices far more in ‘hidden costs’ than contractors The actual “take home entitlements” for an equivalently booked senior registrar is not too much lower than a contractor on 65%. Therefore, the main way to increase GP registrar remuneration is to increase the Medicare rebates for GP consultations – we had a lost decade in Medicare freeze in which rebates are down by 25% if they had just kept up with inflation over that time. Our patients deserve that rebate back and we need an effective lobby organisation to take the government on to do so.

5 GPs in Training

Employment conditions for GPiT are atrocious and enrolment numbers have been dropping over recent years. The pandemic has exacerbated and highlighted these challenges with many registrars either losing their jobs or having their hours cut. What is your plan to address the gross inequities in entitlements and pay compared to our hospital counterparts, with a view to attracting more doctors to the specialty and whilst supporting practices to take on registrars? The main way we encourage more doctors into our field is by increasing our professional reputation from medical school and the positive exposure of junior doctors to our field as well as increasing remuneration for all GPs. I think there may be a role for a federally funded GPT1 on a salary corresponding to the equivalent hospital registrar. This would allow new GP registrars to focus on learning the ropes instead of Medicare and worrying about income. I think registrars should have access to federally funded maternity, paternity and study leave and we should try to make part time learning more readily available. In many cases though many GPT3/4 earn far more than their equivalent hospital counterparts because they are on a percentage of billings and I would not want to harm this.

6 GPs in Training

What do you intend to do about the financial impositions being placed on general practitioners in training by the RACGP's refusal to reduce the cost of exams and its charges for practice exams in a year when registrar incomes have been, in many cases significantly reduced? I think the RACGP should exist for its members and not the other way around. I would look to do everything I could to reduce the costs on registrars including making sure any exam fees raised only covered the direct costs of the exams themselves as well as looking to allow registrars who fail examinations during the pandemic to resit next year at no additional cost.

7 GPs in Training

What are your thoughts on paid maternity/paternity leave for GPs in Training? How would you support practices with this?

Page 3: ADVERTISEMENT Question from Members€¦ · 4 No Theme Question 11 IMGs The current training programs discriminate between local graduate and overseas graduate IMGs. Local graduates

ADVERTISEMENT

3

I support it. It needs to be federally funded and we need an effective GP lobby/union organisation to effectively lobby government on changes like this.

8 GPs in Training

How do you plan to fix the widening pay and condition disparity between GP registrars and hospital registrars? See my previous answers specifically questions 4,5,6 and 7

9 IMGs IMGs are poorly represented at all levels of RACGP, AHPRA and medical

boards...etc, what is your plan to improve their representation?

What is your plan to end discrimination in payments to trainee GPs (item 53 v

23)?

I find the moratorium and VR vs non-VR divide abhorrent and a stain on our

profession. Either a GP is an expert in primary care (or training to be one) and

should be recognised as such, or they should not be practising primary care.

If we accept that we are either all experts or experts in training, then there is

absolutely no reason to divide our brothers and sisters.

We need to be united, we need to ensure that all “non VR” are incorporated

into the training program and become fellows, and we need to adequately

address the push and pull factors of rural practice (i.e. massively increase

remuneration and the social factors).

10 IMGs Considering a big proportion of GP workforce are IMGs, what measures is the

RACGP going to take to address the unfair moratorium restrictions on RACGP

fellows (i.e. Medicare restrictions 19AB and 19 AA) even if they are trained in

Australian hospitals and completed the fellowship via an RACGP training

provider?

We need to have an effective professional lobby/GP union group to

effectively lobby the government.

Experts in any other profession are not conscripted to the bush – engineers or

miners for example. It is recognised you need to adequately address the push

and pull. Remuneration needs to be massively increased, and the government

needs to work on showcasing the excellent social and cultural capital of our

rural centres that make these places such a great place to live and work.

If this were addressed properly, there would be no need for a moratorium

which I adamantly oppose.

Page 4: ADVERTISEMENT Question from Members€¦ · 4 No Theme Question 11 IMGs The current training programs discriminate between local graduate and overseas graduate IMGs. Local graduates

ADVERTISEMENT

4

No Theme Question

11 IMGs The current training programs discriminate between local graduate and

overseas graduate IMGs. Local graduates are issued with provider numbers

which allow them to practice anywhere in Australia. IMG provider numbers

allow them to practice in MMM2-7 only. Also IMGs have to spend 10 years

in the Bush before they are allowed to practice in Metropolitan areas. What

steps are you going to take to stop this institutional discrimination?

See my answers to 9 and 10. GPs need to unify and the first part of this is

treating each GP regardless of their origin with equal dignity and respect.

We need to address the rural shortage issues with approaches other than

what in my view amounts to conscription. We need to massively increase

remuneration and the social aspects of rural life so that it is an attractive

proposition to all GPs.

12 IMGs What is your view on the 10 year moratorium for overseas trained GPs?

If you are elected president, what advocacy will you participate in for

overseas trained doctors who are subject to the 10-year moratorium?

See my previous answers. I am against the moratorium.

We need to address the push and pull factors. We need to massively

increase remuneration for rural work. This will not be possible without

effective GP advocacy which is why one of my core ideas is to create a

professional lobby group for general practice.

13 Membership

Engagement

How do you feel your past experience with involvement/activity in the

College will shape your presidency and how will you ensure our Board does

not make mistakes which might alienate its members?

I want to create positive change at the RACGP. I want to be part of an

RACGP that exists for its’ members. Too many of us feel it is the other way

around.

A big part of the change I would like to see is transparency – many

members feel alienated because they are disconnected and do not

understand why the RACGP makes the decisions it does. I would hold

monthly “by the fire” webinar catch ups to explain what is going on to

members as well as seek member opinions on important problems.

14 Membership

Engagement

How will the College ensure that its history is well documented via its own

Archives to better inform its future leaders?

15 Membership

Engagement

Why should I vote at all? The college feels so far removed from my day to

day reality as a coal face GP. If not for some I would not know much about

anyone even on my state RACGP board or national board or their values. It

seems I pay a fee to RACGP so some GPs can make a career out of clinical

governance and unfortunately based on my education and training (

Page 5: ADVERTISEMENT Question from Members€¦ · 4 No Theme Question 11 IMGs The current training programs discriminate between local graduate and overseas graduate IMGs. Local graduates

ADVERTISEMENT

5

overseas ) I won’t even stand a chance to be noticed when they do their

succession planning ( as RACGP last campaign showcased).

Because we can change the RACGP together.

I am just like you. I am a coal face GP who feels disenfranchised by our

college. I made the choice to engage and try to change it from within. I am

genuinely concerned that if the RACGP does not change general practice

will be left with no chance of ever having effective advocacy.

I beg you and everyone who shares this view to give the RACGP another

chance, watch my video and let us try to change the RACGP through

engagement together.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TIH6gp668NQ

16 Membership

Engagement

Why is the annual subscription so high?

Are you aware of the struggle of the current COVID circumstances?

AHPRA has waived the necessity for CME this year!!

Are there specific reasons?

One of my core messages is that I will reduce the annual subscription

“fees” by 10%. The college should exist for its members.

17 Membership

Engagement

Do you think there should be a GP (Doctor) advocacy group just as we have

patient advocacy group to assist members when they run into problems with

AHPRA or any other body for just cause? If so how would you go about it?

If not, why do you think it is unnecessary?

I agree with this completely – this is one of my core messages. Please

watch my video and join my Facebook page. We can change General

Practice for the better together.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TIH6gp668NQ

drchrisirwin.com.au

18 Membership

Engagement

Is there any plan to support SOLO GPs networking?

I believe we are a dying breed with little support on the professional and

financial aspects. All funds for any projects go to big clinics? Little attention

from all organizations including PHN!!!"

I think we should look to encouraging the formation of local GP networks

for support and social interaction.

Page 6: ADVERTISEMENT Question from Members€¦ · 4 No Theme Question 11 IMGs The current training programs discriminate between local graduate and overseas graduate IMGs. Local graduates

ADVERTISEMENT

6

19 Membership

Engagement

How do you think the RACGP should support the mental health of its

members, especially in regard to the recent extreme stresses of bushfires

and COVID?

Page 7: ADVERTISEMENT Question from Members€¦ · 4 No Theme Question 11 IMGs The current training programs discriminate between local graduate and overseas graduate IMGs. Local graduates

ADVERTISEMENT

7

No Theme Question

20 Membership

Engagement

What plan do you have to defend GP rights when it comes to Bullying tactics by

DOH compliance department such as the “nudge letter campaigns “?

You will not find a stronger supporter of GPs against the PSR/DOH than me.

We need an effective GP union/ lobby group to stand up for our members.

Please watch my video and read my policies on my website drchrisirwin.com.au

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TIH6gp668NQ

21 Membership

Engagement

So there is a great debate about the RACGP’s role and its obligations to its

members. The College is a professional body for education, standards of education

and quality assurance in General practice or it is also a lobby group for

representation of General Practice in Australia. We are keen to find out if you will

settle this issue once and for all. In your view what is the best way forward and

what change you will bring which will satisfy many members who feel

disenfranchised?

My position on this is clear

We need effective and professional lobbying to rival the pharmacy guild and

other forces out there

Please watch my video and read my policies on my website drchrisirwin.com.au

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TIH6gp668NQ

22 Membership

Engagement

How do you plan to change the perception of general practice - in the community,

in other medical professions (including specialists, hospitals and junior doctors

considering GP as a career) and with government?

There is no easy fix. We have a profession held in low regard by politicians and unfortunately many of our subspecialist colleagues. The remuneration compared to any other specialty is poor, and we are gradually being forced into increased bureaucratic oversight. The solutions must address these problems. - effective advocacy by a professional lobby group for GPs to win the hearts and minds of politicians and the public.

Page 8: ADVERTISEMENT Question from Members€¦ · 4 No Theme Question 11 IMGs The current training programs discriminate between local graduate and overseas graduate IMGs. Local graduates

ADVERTISEMENT

8

- general practice should be a much larger component of medical education and we need our best and brightest advocating for our profession to medical students. Increase GP remuneration and change how, to allow longer consultations. Increased time spent with patients and increased collegiate discussions will increase the opinion of non-GP specialists of our profession. Remember that junior doctors are heavily influenced by non-GP specialists because they are the people with whom they spend their time.

23 Membership Engagement

Engagement of members within the College is increasingly important. What is your strategy to change the narrative from the commonly used 'The College', to 'My College'? My core mantra is that I want the college to exist for members and not the other way around. We do this through

- Cutting fees - Creating an effective professional GP lobby /union group - Transparency - Pursuing goals that benefit the coal face GP instead of those within the

RACGP

24 Membership engagement

GPs who specialise in aged care have a unique set of issues and challenges facing them on a daily basis. What do you see as the main areas that need attention with regard to helping and supporting these GPs, and do you have a plan for this? If so, what are the main elements of this plan?

25 Advocacy Financial viability is a major stress for practice owners. Can you please discuss your plans to ensure GP clinics remain financially viable. I believe this is the most important issue at the moment. Do you agree? I completely agree. I am a practice owner of two clinics. The primary way we increase practice profitability is through increasing the service fees gained (by lobbying for increased rebates) and through ensuring the room rental agreements small businesses have entered into with multi billion dollar organisations are not interfered with by government (i.e. protecting fair room rental agreements from pathology and others) We need a powerful and effective lobby organisation to do this – this is why I want to create a professional GP lobby/union group Please watch this webinar from the 14th minute to hear more about my ideas https://australiangpalliance.com.au/2020/08/12/meet-the-candidates/?fbclid=IwAR1TxQyWI3_4JimIn9UArbM2poiye9c00yvquFlRA8zfpfmQO-rhis2QD7c

Page 9: ADVERTISEMENT Question from Members€¦ · 4 No Theme Question 11 IMGs The current training programs discriminate between local graduate and overseas graduate IMGs. Local graduates

ADVERTISEMENT

9

26 Advocacy I would be interested in the candidate's opinions about reform to the payment arrangements within Australian general practice. Is a payment system based on fee for service non-negotiable? Or does the candidate have a willingness see the RACGP exploring new payment models as have been introduced in a variety of international models of the patient centred medical home? I have nothing against other models in principle. The problem is that both sides have government have shown we cannot trust that they will act in the best interests of patients. Any changes to capitation or block funding will in my view only be with a view to further cut costs to the government and to increase bureaucratic control. I would have no problem supporting a capitated system in which the funding levers were removed from government control and handled by an independent body with the sole remit of providing world class quality primary care. But this would never happen as the only point of moving to capitation from a government’s point of view is cutting costs and increasing control.

27 Advocacy Is the Medicare system fixable for GPs? If so, how would you go about making changes and what main areas of Medicare for GPs would you target? If not, then how would you propose to radicalise the broken Medicare system? Fee for service must be enshrined. We have lost 25% of our Medicare rebate as the RACGP sat in the tent with a decade of Medicare freeze and not keeping up with inflation. We need an effective and professional GP lobby group to get the rebates back that our patients deserve.

28 Advocacy How do you defend GPs against financial loss caused by pharmacies, Medicare? How you can protect our profession against other professions trying to take financial advantage? Pharmacies administer flu vaccine and in some states children’s vaccinations. How you can protect prescribing in a GP’s job and not allow others to take it? We need effective advocacy. We need a professional GP lobby /union group. This is a core goal of my presidency. Our college is eight times larger than the pharmacy guild. Imagine the good we could achieve for our patients if we just hit back? Please see my website and videos for more information

29 Advocacy The government won't change any strategy until BB rates drop. How would you go about organising the College to advise its members to drop their BB rates, essentially as a tactical show of power?

Page 10: ADVERTISEMENT Question from Members€¦ · 4 No Theme Question 11 IMGs The current training programs discriminate between local graduate and overseas graduate IMGs. Local graduates

ADVERTISEMENT

10

If most health expenditure is wasted in/on hospitals, what role do you see the College having in talking to State governments to get this money diverted to GPs, who as we know, from copious amounts of data, do a more efficient job? I disagree that the only way forwards is through BB rates dropping. The pharmacy guild won a 9% increase in dispensing fees this year (during the covid recession) for their members. Dispensing fees are essentially their “bulk billed” equivalent to our consults. Not only that the pharmacists have even been guaranteed their dispensing income regardless if their script volumes drop because of covid. So, I argue we do not necessarily need BB rates to drop, we need an effective voice to the public and to the politicians for change.

No Theme Question

30 Advocacy Some candidates advocated to increase GPs’ remuneration from Medicare. This is unlikely to be fruitful, given the economic reality of Covid-19. Some of the candidates however are also practice owners who charge GPs a service fee of 30-40% before tax which leaves many GPs struggling. Would you advocate limiting the service fee to 20% as a way of helping GPs to have a decent income? We need greater transparency in our profession. I run two medical clinics. I know the numbers. The truth is that depending on the amount of ancillary support provided and location, costs of running a medium sized clinic are in the region of 35-40% of turnover. A well running practice might make 5% of the total income generated as profit. 20% is just not realistic. We need to promote GP owned general practice.

31 Advocacy GPs across Australia have embraced Telehealth and the flexibility that it gives us in providing patient centred care. I have found that Telehealth is a wonderful tool to provide care for my patients with disability as one example. What will you do as RACGP president to advocate for the continuation of Telehealth item numbers for general practice post COVID-19? I would make it a priority and make sure that the rebate for an equivalent telehealth consult remains the same as a face to face consult. To do this we need an effective and professional GP lobby/union group

32 Advocacy The COVID19 Pandemic has really highlighted the problems GPs have working within a state based healthcare system, and yet being federally funded. We are following the guidance of our state based chief health officers, but we are often forgotten in state based planning. I would love to know the candidates’ thoughts on this, and their suggestions for a solution.

33 Advocacy Is the RACGP's 'Vision for general practice and a sustainable healthcare system' (https://www.racgp.org.au/advocacy/advocacy-resources/the-vision-for-general-practice) still relevant, appropriate and useful? Do you believe that it should be the basis for the RACGP's discussions and negotiations with government and other third party funders of health care? If you think that it needs to be changed or updated, in what ways should it be changed or updated?

34 Advocacy Why are we called "" just GPs"" but AHPRA register us as Specialists? Why are we not called Family Medicine Specialists?

Page 11: ADVERTISEMENT Question from Members€¦ · 4 No Theme Question 11 IMGs The current training programs discriminate between local graduate and overseas graduate IMGs. Local graduates

ADVERTISEMENT

11

I believe websites of medical centres should change the title of fellows to Specialist Family Medicine Physician or Specialist Generalist Physician and non Fellows should be classified as Family Medicine Physician Registrar or Generalist Registrars while those not training should be called Career Medical Officers - our integrity is down. What are your thoughts? I agree that GPs have a branding problem. I think we need to advocate for better funding, and we need to financially incentivise longer consults first, to create an environment for specialist GPs to thrive before changing our name.

35 Advocacy Regional and country practices are being subjected to new restrictions in recruiting and training new doctors and facing immediate workforce shortages. How do the candidates address the shortages and improve the distributions of GPs? We need to encourage doctors to work rurally through much larger financial incentives as well as maximising the ‘social and cultural pull’ of rural Australia.

36 Advocacy The RACGP lacks a national online members-only forum in which members can discuss issues among themselves. The Faculty Facebook groups go only a little way towards this. The GPs Down Under closed Facebook group with 7 837 members is the de facto national discussion forum for members of the RACGP. Are you satisfied with this situation? If not, how do you propose that the RACGP should enable members nationally to discuss issues among themselves?

Page 12: ADVERTISEMENT Question from Members€¦ · 4 No Theme Question 11 IMGs The current training programs discriminate between local graduate and overseas graduate IMGs. Local graduates

ADVERTISEMENT

12

No Theme Question

37 Advocacy If elected as president of RACGP what measures you will take to make the Govt understand the importance of GPs in primary healthcare as GP specialists and improve the Medicare rebate and improve the quality of service as GPs we are offering to community? Improved access for allied health services for chronic medical conditions instead of 5 visits per year and to make it as 10 visits per year. We need an effective professional GP lobby/union group.

38 Advocacy There has been a lot of talk by one candidate in particular - about GPs needing a lobby group akin to the pharmacy guild. What are your feelings on this and the ethics of general practice using tactics like “pay for play”? (Donations to all political parties) I think we are doing our patients harm by allowing legal and effective lobbyists from the guild and the pathologists to change the healthcare landscape in a way that increases costs to patients and taxpayer, fragments care and in my view encourages lower quality care than effective GP lead advocacy. I do not agree with political lobbying and I wish it did not exist. It does, we have a choice to ignore it and harm our patients as a result or engage to advocate for positive change in primary care and save the lives of Australians by doing so.

39 Advocacy Considering the success of other groups who use professional lobbyists (e.g. Pharmacy Guild, NRA, etc) in achieving their advocacy goals, would you consider the same approach to be suitable for the RACGP? Why or why not? The central message of my candidacy is we need an effective professional GP lobby/union to counter the pharmacy guild and other players, and promote excellent GP led primary healthcare.

40 Advocacy The evidence that a strong primary health care sector leads to better outcomes and reduced overall costs is well known, but general practice continues to be the poor cousin of the Australian health system, both metaphorically and literally. How will you convince government of our critical role and secure a meaningful increase in funding of Australian general practice? We need to have an effective lobby group. We need to have the ear of politicians and the ear of the public. Imagine how much good we could do together? Please watch my video or join my page https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TIH6gp668NQ drchrisirwin.com.au Or join my Facebook page https://www.facebook.com/groups/578850982830966/

41 Advocacy We believe the Australian Primary Care Physician is facing the greatest challenge ever now. There are many examples from other countries when they did not rise to the challenge general practice became a dying profession

Page 13: ADVERTISEMENT Question from Members€¦ · 4 No Theme Question 11 IMGs The current training programs discriminate between local graduate and overseas graduate IMGs. Local graduates

ADVERTISEMENT

13

or a mere referral and prescription platform. We are being constantly challenged by Pharmacists, Nurse Practitioners and even certain other specialists. (Pharmacy led prescriptions is an example) Young GPs are being exploited by big corporates who puts profit before care. They are being forced to work for lower percentage seeing higher number of patients per day. This leads to significant reduction in quality of care and less confidence in people of their GP. Most of us still believe small family practices are the essence of primary care. But they are struggling to survive when facing giant corporates. When compared to other Specialist colleges, the majority of membership feels RACGP has less control over their training programme AGPT, which may need a touch of redesigning. Could each candidate please explain to members their plans and vision to these challenges. I am passionate about GP lead primary care. Every single study shows we are more effective, cost less and in my opinion provide better care. Primary care should primarily exist in medium sized GP owned general practice in my opinion, because this allows GPs to control care. I would do everything in my power to build up general practice as a profession and increase our standing as well as helping our most vulnerable members. I believe the main way we do this is to have an effective GP union and lobby group to take care of our members and advocate strongly to politicians and the public.

42 Advocacy Why have AHPRA fees risen when for the most part the income of GPs has fallen and the cost of running a GP business has increased?

43 Advocacy Primary Health Networks offer tens of thousands of dollars to General

Practices to obtain patient clinical data. It is called QIPIP. Our PHN installs

software onto our computers to extract data. We have no oversight or

control. PHN contractors are supposed to de-identify the data. Has your

practice signed up for this Project? Does this Data extraction worry you?

What position should the RACGP have regarding this multimillion-dollar

National Government Project?

This is one of the many reasons I am wary of block funding and capitation.

The main point (in my opinion) of such funding systems is increased

bureaucratic control (e.g. of our data).

I own two practices. I have not signed up and as a consequence lose many

thousands of dollars in funding every year because of these concerns.

Page 14: ADVERTISEMENT Question from Members€¦ · 4 No Theme Question 11 IMGs The current training programs discriminate between local graduate and overseas graduate IMGs. Local graduates

ADVERTISEMENT

14

The RACGP should advocate for a primary care system run by GPs and not

bureaucrats.

Page 15: ADVERTISEMENT Question from Members€¦ · 4 No Theme Question 11 IMGs The current training programs discriminate between local graduate and overseas graduate IMGs. Local graduates

ADVERTISEMENT

15

No Theme Question

44 Advocacy Characterising patients as "consumers" has eroded the doctor-patient

alliance, causing loss of respect for doctors, unrealistic expectations of care,

less patient responsibility for their health, more defensive practice, rising

complaints and an attitude by complaints authorities that doctors are guilty

until proven innocent. Will you promote abandoning the consumer model

restoring the concept of joint responsibility through the principle of the

doctor-patient alliance?

45 Advocacy How do you propose to lobby government and make changes to the current

situation of GPs being forced to bulk bill certain Telehealth MBS items? The

government does not force specialists to do this, so why target the frontline

primary care physician? Imagine spending an hour of your time drawing up a

Mental Health Care Plan for a patient you are concerned about, putting

safety precautions in place to protect that patient and get paid all of $138

for your efforts.

We need an effective lobby organisation, because if politicians do not

respect or fear us (or better – both) we will face a worsening situation as

we are increasingly defunded despite being the most efficient part of the

health system. We need to stand up for our patients and positive change

Please watch my video or join my page https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TIH6gp668NQ drchrisirwin.com.au Or join my Facebook page

https://www.facebook.com/groups/578850982830966/

46 Climate Change

Do you feel the RACGP should play a more active role in Environmental health issues for the well-being and health of our patients? If so, how? The RACGP should advocate for GPs and their patients. We know that climate change is significantly impacting our patients and thus we have a moral imperative to act. As president I would work closely with experts and groups such as ‘Doctors for the Environment Australia’ We can be leaders in simple ways such as

- Reduce the carbon footprint of the college - Promote webinar meetings instead of travel based on fossil fuels -

saving the college money at the same time.

47 Climate Change

Climate change has been recognised as the greatest health challenge for the 21st century. How will you ensure that the GP workforce is prepared to face this challenge? The recent bushfire emergency showed a glimpse of the serious climate emergencies we will increasingly face. It also unfortunately highlighted how disconnected general practice is from emergency management.

Page 16: ADVERTISEMENT Question from Members€¦ · 4 No Theme Question 11 IMGs The current training programs discriminate between local graduate and overseas graduate IMGs. Local graduates

ADVERTISEMENT

16

We need to form an effective GP lobby group to give us better access to those in power and integrate GPs effectively into emergency management at a local level.

48 Climate Change

COVID-19 has demonstrated the enormous disruption and health impacts caused by a global emergency. The climate emergency effects are arguably more profound. The catastrophic bush fires of 2019-2020 saw lives lost, communities destroyed and GPs put on the front line of action. How will you as RACGP president lead primary care to mitigate against, but also prepare for the impacts of climate change on the health of the Australian people? Let us put things in perspective – COVID19 has horrifically claimed the lives of over 200 Australians this year. Just the pollution from fossil fuels kills 2,500 Australians every year. Climate change through fires, increasing particulate matter or heat stress is known to significantly impact one of our largest causes of mortality – cardiovascular disease. It also of course severely impacts many with respiratory illnesses in the long term to an extent we are still not entirely sure of. Therefore, we need to be leaders in effective advocacy and preventative health. We need a GP lobby group to effectively get this message, as well as many others, across to politicians and the public.

49 Climate Change

How can RACGP better prepare for and mitigate climate change, the public health threat of our time? What are our international responsibilities as communities face increasing frequency and severity of extreme weather events?" We can take steps to reduce our carbon emissions We can encourage online webinars over face to face meetings causing fossil fuel burn We can try to encourage our members to take action in their own lives which also benefit their health – bicycling to work where appropriate, increased use of public transport, changing to diets less based on red meat consumption

50 Climate Change

Climate change has been recognised as the greatest health challenge for the 21st century. How will you ensure that the general practice workforce is prepared to face this challenge? Same question as number 47

51 Climate Change

Congratulations to each of the candidates and I wish you all the very best in the upcoming presidential elections. There is a growing body of scientific evidence demonstrating pollution, such as air pollution, impacts human health. This includes the health of our patients. What role does the RACGP play and what can you do to help address this global issue? There needs to be planetary wide action. Every single member of humanity needs to play a part, this includes the RACGP We can take steps to reduce our carbon emissions We can encourage online webinars over face to face meetings causing fossil fuel burn

Page 17: ADVERTISEMENT Question from Members€¦ · 4 No Theme Question 11 IMGs The current training programs discriminate between local graduate and overseas graduate IMGs. Local graduates

ADVERTISEMENT

17

We can try to encourage our members to take action in their own lives which also benefit their health – bicycling to work where appropriate, increased use of public transport, changing to diets less based on red meat consumption

52 Issue Specific Obesity societies globally recognize obesity as a chronic Progressive disease. Why has the RACGP been the only learned medical college in Australia to reverse the unanimous vote of the college presidents? I know the reason. A total lack knowledge of this disease process within college academic circles. Weight stigma is pervasive and without addressing it we cannot progress prevention and management of this global pandemic. How will you address this?

53 Issue Specific How do you see the RACGP and ACRRM working better together into the future that respects rural and city-based GP practice really are different? ACCRM is a fantastic organisation dedicated to their GPs. I would work as closely as I could with ACCRM on the core issues that affect us both and look to increased teamwork.

No Theme Question

54 Issue Specific What is the first issue you will work on once you are elected? Creating a GP lobby/union group to rival the pharmacy guild – this is the best chance general practice has of continuing to exist as an effective part of the health care system in my opinion Please watch my video or join my page https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TIH6gp668NQ drchrisirwin.com.au Or join my Facebook page https://www.facebook.com/groups/578850982830966/

55 Issue Specific The barriers to implementing fax-free General Practice appears to be politically driven. There is a lot of commercial interests that act as a barrier (companies already invested money in various platforms). They lobby for an ongoing profit stream. Already implemented, government funded platforms such as CDA/My Health Record platform can be a "not-for-profit" alternative. This supports the HL7 standards and CDA used for interactions between providers. Could each candidate provide a specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound policy in collaboration with non-GP specialists to implement a Fax-free workplace by the end of your term? Let us start with provider-provider communications. This is a complex discussion outside the bounds of a 150-word limit. I’m very happy to talk more on this issue – please message me on Facebook or join my Facebook group https://www.facebook.com/groups/578850982830966/

56 Issue Specific General practice research, led by GPs, can help to generate the evidence that can be used to guide the development of our profession and the models of care in which we work. I would like to ask the candidates their (a) vision for

Page 18: ADVERTISEMENT Question from Members€¦ · 4 No Theme Question 11 IMGs The current training programs discriminate between local graduate and overseas graduate IMGs. Local graduates

ADVERTISEMENT

18

building the academic general practice workforce, (b) how to engage and enable clinical GPs to generate research questions and participate in research and (3) how we can facilitate a network of practice based research networks across the country.

57 Issue Specific In what ways do you believe social media realistically and potentially hurts and harms our profession and how can the RACGP do it better? I think social media is generally a force for good and the RACGP should embrace it more and encourage more transparency - for example I would look to using social media for monthly “fireside chats” where I as president would talk with members and seek their opinion.

58 Issue Specific I want representation for AMDS GPs. I feel like we have been sidelined as if we are not college trainees/not working towards the fellowship. If the criticism is for the doctors who come from different specialities and work in AMDS then maybe this should be brought up at higher level to restrict those doctors from working in an after-hours setup.

59 Issue Specific Will you support the new President if you are not successful? Loyalty? First and foremost, I see my role as an advocate for the coal face GP. I think it is important that we all respect the result of the election and allow the new president time to learn the ropes and enact positive change. I still think part of any effective democracy though is ensuring that you remain a passionate advocate for those you represent, and I would continue to stand up for those GPs who feel the RACGP is not listening to them.

60 Issue Specific If you are NOT successful in your presidential campaign, how will you continue to demonstrate your commitment to the values and aims you have highlighted in your campaign? I would look to building and strengthening relationships in general practice and with politicians to be a more effective advocate for the “coal face” and look at the viability of creating a GP union/lobby group without RACGP funding or support.