34
Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developments A Case Study of 1175 Lee Hill Boulder, Colorado

Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    5

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developments

A Case Study of 1175 Lee Hill

Boulder, Colorado

Page 2: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

Presenters

Shannon Cox Baker

Boulder Housing Partners

Greg Harms

Boulder Shelter for the Homeless

Introductions

Page 3: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

9:45-10:15 Presentation

10:15-10:30 Q&A and Discussion

Agenda

Page 4: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

Colorado

Page 5: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

City of Boulder located in Boulder County County population of about 300,000 Home of Colorado University Liberal community Population bifurcated based on income 14% live in poverty, 26% have graduate degrees Median housing price over $500,000 2,600 homeless in the last PIT

Boulder County Facts

Page 6: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

Boulder, Colorado

Page 7: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

31, one-bedroom units

Chronically homeless adults

Partnership between

Boulder Housing Partners

The Boulder Shelter for the Homeless

Part of Boulder County’s 10-Year Plan

Across from BHP and adjacent to the Shelter

1175 Lee Hill Project Description

Page 8: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

Local Map

Page 9: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

Building Perspective

Page 10: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

Timeline of Project

BHP bought Lee Hill Site

March 2010

Neighborhood Meeting

September 2011

City Council

Vote

April 2012

Statement of

Operations Completed

Start of Construction

October 2013

Project Completion

September 2014

February 2013

Page 11: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

Based on pre-application meetings

What is Housing First?

What are the Impacts of this use?

Perception of NoBo & Location of Services

Alternatives Site Analysis

Encouraged Outreach

Initial City Staff Reaction

Page 12: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

Not covered in current land use guidelines

Use “by right” or administrative review

Fair Housing Issues

Outreach / Management = Very Important

Regulatory Issues Raised

Page 13: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

February-July: Create outreach plan

March-June: Concept design and programming

September: Neighborhood meeting

Initial Outreach 2011

Page 14: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

Hire communications consultant

Gather feedback from leaders

Identify organizational spokespersons

Garner support of allies

Roll out neighborhood meeting and design, operations plan simultaneously

Initial Outreach Strategy

Page 15: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

“Leaders” represent the masses

It’s about the building

Facts trump emotion

Support of City, allies

Communications versus public relations

Assumptions and Biases

Page 16: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

Timeline of Project

BHP bought Lee Hill Site

March 2010

Neighborhood Meeting

September 2011

City Council

Vote

April 2012

Statement of

Operations Completed

Start of Construction

October 2013

Project Completion

September 2014

February 2013

Page 17: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

Community Meeting

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HgTK4mxJnkM&feature=youtu.be

Page 18: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

Many concerns were raised

Some driven by fear

Some driven by lack of control of process

Formed the North Boulder Alliance

Neighborhood Reaction

Page 19: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First
Page 20: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

November 2011

Page 21: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

Put project on hold for 6 months

Requested Council’s support

Hired PR firm

Galvanized supporters

Offered some control to neighbors

Mid-Course Correction

Page 22: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

Community meetings

H.O.A. visits

One-on-one meetings

Reconstitution of the Shelter/Neighbor group

Statement of Operations

Building design meetings

Efforts to Reach Out

Page 23: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

Timeline of Project

BHP bought Lee Hill Site

March 2010

Neighborhood Meeting

September 2011

City Council

Vote

April 2012

Statement of

Operations Completed

Start of Construction

October 2013

Project Completion

September 2014

February 2013

Page 24: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

Requested voluntary outreach

Requested a Statement of Operations/minutes be submitted with application

Emphasis on good management & communications

8:1 Council vote in support

City Council Actions

Page 25: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

Timeline of Project

BHP bought Lee Hill Site

March 2010

Neighborhood Meeting

September 2011

City Council

Vote

April 2012

Statement of

Operations Completed

Start of Construction

October 2013

Project Completion

September 2014

February 2013

Page 26: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

Citizen committee with staff support

Outside facilitator

Balance of pro and con on committee

Met eight times to create 10 page document

Approved by BHP board of commissioners

Reviewable on an annual basis

Statement of Operations

Page 27: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

Preamble, purpose, guiding principles

Community engagement/communications

Building design

Housing First program

Lease agreement

Property management

Monitoring

Statement of Operations

Page 28: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

Timeline of Project

BHP bought Lee Hill Site

March 2010

Neighborhood Meeting

September 2011

City Council

Vote

April 2012

Statement of

Operations Completed

Start of Construction

October 2013

Project Completion

September 2014

February 2013

Page 29: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

October, 2013 Groundbreaking

Page 30: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

Current Status

Page 31: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

Be prepared for extra time and expense

Start early, years early if possible (land use)

Use small meetings, not one large one

Reach out early

Establish relationships with elected officials

Have pro bono legal council on board

Lessons Learned

Page 32: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

Offer elected officials ways to lend support

Use Fair Housing laws if needed

Offer some control to neighbors

Have alternative sites vetted

Patience and persistence

Lessons Learned

Page 33: Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First Developmentsstatic.squarespace.com/static/513e08bfe4b0b5df0ec24cda/t/533d99… · Addressing Community Opposition to Housing First

Discussion, Questions and Answers