1
Adaptive Behavior and Psychiatric Symptoms using the Behavior Assessment System for Children – Version 3: Results from the ABC-CT Feasibility Study Evaluations of school-aged children with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) include both core symptoms (e.g. social communication) and co-occurring behaviors (e.g. adaptive behavior (1) and psychiatric symptoms (3)). Assessing multiple domains of behavior often requires individualized standardized assessments which can be burdensome on families (4). The Behavior Assessment System for Children- Version 3 (BASC-3) is a comprehensive rating scale that assays multiple domains of behavior (2). We asked whether the BASC-3 can differentiate ASD from typically-developing (TD) school-aged children and whether it demonstrates convergence with more commonly-used measures of adaptive functioning and psychiatric symptoms. 1) Investigate group differences in adaptive behavior and psychiatric symptoms in children with ASD and TD using the BASC-3 composite scores. Hypothesis: Children with ASD will show decreased adaptive behavior and Increased psychiatric symptoms compared to TD. 2) Examine convergent validity of the BASC-3 in children with ASD by comparing this measure to the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales, Second Edition (VABS-II) parent interview and the Child and Adolescent Symptom Inventory-5 (CASI-5)/Early Childhood Inventory-5 (ECI-5). Hypothesis: The BASC-3 domains will correlate to corresponding VABS-II, CASI-5/ECI-5 domains. Participants: Enrolled in the Autism Biomarkers Consortium for Clinical Trials Study (ABC-CT), a multi-site feasibility study including behavioral and experimental measures Eligibility: - ASD met criteria on the Autism Diagnostic Observation Schedule-II Module 1, 2, or 3 (ADOS-II), Autism Diagnostic Interview-Revised (ADI-R) - TD screened negative for psychiatric disorders - Participants included in this sample completed the BASC-3, CASI-5/ECI-5 and VABS-II measures Questionnaires and Interviews: BASC-3: parent rating scale to evaluate adaptive and challenging social and emotional behaviors across community and home settings (2) - Comprehensive scoring includes: composite scales (i.e. internalizing problems), clinical scales (i.e. depression) adaptive scales (i.e. social skills), content scales (i.e. executive functioning) and clinical indices (i.e. Autism probability) - 10-20 minutes - 175 questions CASI-5/ECI-5: parent rating scale based in DSM-5-to assess symptoms related to various psychiatric disorders - 10-20 minutes - 173 questions VABS-II (Survey Interview Form): parent interview to assess adaptive behaviors across the lifespan - 30-60 minutes Statistical Plan: Aim 1: Independent sample t-tests to examine group differences Aim 2: Correlations to examine convergent validity Summary of Results: The following BASC-3 domains within the ASC positively correlated with corresponding VABS-II domains: Functional Communication (BASC-3) & Communication (VABS-II) Daily Living Skills (BASC-3) & Activities of Daily Living (VABS-II) • The Social Skills domain of the BASC-3 did not correlate with the Socialization domain of the VABS-II. However, the BASC-3 Adaptability domain was positively related to the VABS-II Coping Skills sub- domain. • The following BASC-3 psychiatric symptom domains positively correlated with corresponding CASI- 5/ECI-5 domains: • Anxiety (BASC-3) & Generalized Anxiety (CASI-5/ECI-5) • Depression (BASC-3) & Dysthymic (CASI-5/ECI-5) • Attention Problems (BASC-3) & Inattentive (CASI-5/ECI-5) • Hyperactivity (BASC-3) & Hyperactive-Impulsive (CASI-5/ECI-5) Conclusions: The BASC-3 differentiated children with ASD compared to TD across all Composite scores. The BASC-3 Adaptive Skills Composite domains demonstrate convergent validity with the VABS-II, with the exception of Social Skills. BASC-3 Social Skills may be representing a more narrow set of behaviors than VABS-II Socialization, which is an important consideration when using this measure in ASD. In settings where multiple domains need to be assessed in a time-efficient manner, the BASC-3 may be an appropriate alternative to individualized assessments. Introduction Objectives Methods Conclusions 1. Kanne, S. M., Gerber, A. J., Quirmbach, L. M., Sparrow, S. S., Cicchetti, D. V., & Saulnier, C. A. (2010). The Role of Adaptive Behavior in Autism Spectrum Disorders: Implications for Functional Outcome. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders,41(8), 1007-1018. doi:10.1007/s10803-010-1126-4 2. Reynolds, C. R., & Kamphaus, R. W. (2015). BASC3: Behavior assessment system for children: Manual. Bloomington, MN: PsychCorp. 3. Rosen, T. E., Mazefsky, C. A., Vasa, R. A., & Lerner, M. D. (2018). Co-occurring psychiatric conditions in autism spectrum disorder. International Review of Psychiatry. doi:10.1080/09540261.2018.1450229 4. Sikora, D. M., Hall, T. A., Hartley, S. L., Gerrard-Morris, A. E., & Cagle, S. (2007). Does Parent Report of Behavior Differ Across ADOS-G Classifications: Analysis of Scores from the CBCL and GARS. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders,38(3), 440-448. doi:10.1007/s10803-007-0407-z We thank the National Institute of Health for funding this study. Grant NIMH# 1U19MH108206-01, PI: McPartland. We greatly appreciate all of the families who participated in this research across study sites (Yale University, University of Washington, Boston Children’s Hospital, Duke University). References Acknowledgements Results Aim 1 cont. Emily Pompan 1 , Elizabeth Baker 1 , Patricia Renno, Ph.D. 1 , Sara Webb, Ph.D. 5 , Frederick Shic, Ph.D. 5 , Adam Naples, Ph.D. 2 , Catherine Sugar, Ph.D. 1 , Michael Murias, Ph.D. 4 , Raphael Bernier, Ph.D. 5 , Geraldine Dawson, Ph.D. 4 , Charles Nelson, Ph.D. 3 , James McPartland, Ph.D. 2 , and Shafali Jeste, M.D. 1 University of California, Los Angeles 1 , Yale University 2 , Boston Children’s Hospital 3 , Duke University 4 , and the University of Washington 5 ASC Domain Group Differences (t-test) Social Skills t(47)=6.166, p=<.001 Activities of Daily Living t(47)=9.425, p=<.001 Functional Communication t(40.99)=11.453, p=<.001 Adaptability t(47)=5.684, p<.001 Results Aim 2b Question Sample A. Generalized Anxiety/Anxiety B. Dysthymic/Depression C. Inattentive/Attention Problems D.Hyperactive-Impulsive/ Hyperactivity CASI-5/ECI-5 -Cannot get distressing thoughts out of his/her mind. -Talks about death or suicide -Has little confidence, feels inferior to others, or is very self-conscious. -Is easily distracted by other things going on. -Does not pay attention to close details or makes careless mistakes. -Interrupts or intrudes on other people’s activities. -Is “on the go” or acts as if “driven by a motor.” BASC-3 -Worries about making mistakes. -Says “I want to die” or “I wish I were dead.” -Seems lonely. -Is easily distracted. -Has trouble concentrating. -Interrupts others when they are speaking. -Is in constant motion. BASC-3 Adaptive Skills Composite (ASC) Domain Scores in ASD Compared to TD C. D. r=.878, p=<.001 r=.431, p=.045 r=.798, p=<.001 Enrolled in ABC-CT Included in Sample Gender Age (years) M(SD) Best IQ - Full Scale or Ratio Differential Abilities Scales-II M(SD) ADOS-II Severity Score M(SD) ASD n=25 n=22 17 male (77%), 5 female (23%) 8.03(2.28) 93.09(19.41) 14.82 (4.54) TD n=26 n=26 17 male (65%), 9 female (35%) 6.58 (1.98) 114.08(9.34) N/A A. B. Results Aim 1 BASC-3 Composite Group Differences (t-test) Externalizing t(30.834)=-5.788, p=<.001 Internalizing t(47)=-3.775, p=<.001 Behavioral Symptoms Index (BSI) t(47)=-11.965, p=<.001 Adaptive Skills Composite (ASC) t(47)=10.558, p=<.001 BASC-3 Composite Scores in ASD and TD Groups Question Sample (VABS-II/BASC-3) A. Communication/Functional Communication B. Daily Living Skills/ Activities of Daily Living C. Socialization/ Social Skills VABS-II -Tells about everyday experiences (i.e., routine) in detail -Identifies all alphabet letters -Understands what to do in dangerous situations -Does at least two simple household chores -Avoids being manipulated, dominated or taken advantage of by others -Controls anger or hurt feelings when given constructive criticism. BASC-3 -Is clear when telling about personal experiences -Says all letters of the alphabet when asked -Acts in a safe manner -Organizes chores and tasks well -Shows interest in others’ ideas. -Begins conversations appropriately Question Sample (VABS-II/BASC-3) D. Coping Skills Sub- Domain/Adaptability VABS-II -Handles changes in routine without becoming overly distressed -Recovers quickly from a minor setback or disappointment BASC-3 -Adjusts well to changes in routine. -Recovers quickly from a setback The BASC-3 includes an Adaptability domain within the ASC that qualitatively overlaps with the Coping Skills sub-domain within VABS-II Socialization domain. Hypothesis: The BASC-3 Adaptability domain will correlate with VABS-II Coping Skills sub-domain. r=.677, p=<.001 r=.580, p=.004 A. B. C. Results Aim 2a 20 30 40 50 60 70 6 8 10 12 14 16 BASC Adaptability t-score VABS Coping Skills v-scale D. r=.612, p=<.001 40 50 60 70 80 90 40 60 80 100 BASC Depression t-scores CASI/ECI Dysthymic t-scores r=.767, p=<.001 20 30 40 50 40 60 80 100 BASC Social Skills t-scores VABS Socialization Standard Scores r=.308, p=.152

Adaptive Behavior and Psychiatric Symptoms using the ......• Evaluations of school-aged children with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) include both core symptoms (e.g. social communication)

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Adaptive Behavior and Psychiatric Symptoms using the ......• Evaluations of school-aged children with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) include both core symptoms (e.g. social communication)

AdaptiveBehaviorandPsychiatricSymptomsusingthe BehaviorAssessmentSystemforChildren– Version3:ResultsfromtheABC-CTFeasibilityStudy

• Evaluationsofschool-agedchildrenwithautismspectrumdisorder(ASD)includebothcoresymptoms(e.g.socialcommunication)andco-occurringbehaviors(e.g.adaptivebehavior(1)andpsychiatricsymptoms(3)).

• Assessingmultipledomainsofbehavioroftenrequiresindividualizedstandardizedassessmentswhichcanbeburdensomeonfamilies(4).

• TheBehaviorAssessmentSystemforChildren- Version3 (BASC-3)isacomprehensiveratingscalethatassaysmultipledomainsofbehavior(2).

• WeaskedwhethertheBASC-3candifferentiateASDfromtypically-developing(TD)school-agedchildrenandwhetheritdemonstratesconvergencewithmorecommonly-usedmeasuresofadaptivefunctioningandpsychiatricsymptoms.

1) InvestigategroupdifferencesinadaptivebehaviorandpsychiatricsymptomsinchildrenwithASDandTDusingtheBASC-3 compositescores.Hypothesis:ChildrenwithASDwillshowdecreasedadaptivebehaviorandIncreasedpsychiatricsymptomscomparedtoTD.

2) ExamineconvergentvalidityoftheBASC-3 inchildrenwithASDbycomparingthismeasuretotheVinelandAdaptiveBehaviorScales,SecondEdition(VABS-II)parentinterviewandtheChildandAdolescentSymptomInventory-5(CASI-5)/EarlyChildhoodInventory-5(ECI-5).Hypothesis:TheBASC-3 domainswillcorrelatetocorrespondingVABS-II,CASI-5/ECI-5 domains.

Participants:• EnrolledintheAutismBiomarkersConsortiumforClinicalTrialsStudy(ABC-CT),amulti-site

feasibilitystudyincludingbehavioralandexperimentalmeasures• Eligibility:

- ASDmetcriteriaontheAutismDiagnosticObservationSchedule-IIModule1,2,or3(ADOS-II),AutismDiagnosticInterview-Revised(ADI-R)- TDscreenednegativeforpsychiatricdisorders- ParticipantsincludedinthissamplecompletedtheBASC-3,CASI-5/ECI-5 andVABS-IImeasures

QuestionnairesandInterviews:• BASC-3:parentratingscaletoevaluateadaptiveandchallengingsocialandemotionalbehaviors

acrosscommunityandhomesettings(2)- Comprehensivescoringincludes:compositescales(i.e.internalizingproblems),clinicalscales(i.e.depression)adaptivescales(i.e.socialskills),contentscales(i.e.executivefunctioning)andclinicalindices(i.e.Autismprobability)- 10-20minutes- 175questions

• CASI-5/ECI-5: parentratingscalebasedin DSM-5-toassesssymptomsrelatedtovariouspsychiatricdisorders

- 10-20minutes- 173questions

• VABS-II(SurveyInterviewForm):parentinterviewtoassessadaptivebehaviorsacrossthelifespan- 30-60minutes

StatisticalPlan:• Aim1:Independentsamplet-teststoexaminegroupdifferences• Aim2:Correlationstoexamineconvergentvalidity

SummaryofResults:• ThefollowingBASC-3 domainswithintheASCpositivelycorrelatedwithcorrespondingVABS-II

domains:• FunctionalCommunication(BASC-3)&Communication(VABS-II)• DailyLivingSkills(BASC-3)&ActivitiesofDailyLiving(VABS-II)

• TheSocialSkillsdomainoftheBASC-3 didnotcorrelatewiththeSocializationdomainoftheVABS-II.However,theBASC-3AdaptabilitydomainwaspositivelyrelatedtotheVABS-II CopingSkillssub-domain.

• ThefollowingBASC-3 psychiatricsymptomdomainspositivelycorrelatedwithcorrespondingCASI-5/ECI-5 domains:

• Anxiety(BASC-3)&GeneralizedAnxiety(CASI-5/ECI-5)• Depression(BASC-3)&Dysthymic(CASI-5/ECI-5)• AttentionProblems(BASC-3)&Inattentive(CASI-5/ECI-5)• Hyperactivity(BASC-3)&Hyperactive-Impulsive(CASI-5/ECI-5)

Conclusions:• TheBASC-3 differentiatedchildrenwithASDcomparedtoTDacrossallCompositescores.• TheBASC-3 AdaptiveSkillsCompositedomainsdemonstrateconvergentvaliditywiththeVABS-II,

withtheexceptionofSocialSkills.BASC-3 SocialSkillsmayberepresentingamorenarrowsetofbehaviorsthanVABS-IISocialization,whichisanimportantconsiderationwhenusingthismeasureinASD.

• Insettingswheremultipledomainsneedtobeassessedinatime-efficientmanner,theBASC-3maybeanappropriatealternativetoindividualizedassessments.

Introduction

Objectives

Methods

Conclusions

1. Kanne,S.M.,Gerber,A.J.,Quirmbach,L.M.,Sparrow,S.S.,Cicchetti,D.V.,&Saulnier,C.A.(2010).TheRoleofAdaptiveBehaviorinAutismSpectrumDisorders:ImplicationsforFunctionalOutcome. JournalofAutismandDevelopmentalDisorders,41(8),1007-1018.doi:10.1007/s10803-010-1126-42. Reynolds,C.R.,&Kamphaus,R.W.(2015).BASC3:Behaviorassessmentsystemforchildren:Manual.Bloomington,MN:PsychCorp.3. Rosen,T.E.,Mazefsky,C.A.,Vasa,R.A.,&Lerner,M.D.(2018).Co-occurringpsychiatricconditionsinautismspectrumdisorder. InternationalReviewofPsychiatry.doi:10.1080/09540261.2018.14502294. Sikora,D.M.,Hall,T.A.,Hartley,S.L.,Gerrard-Morris,A.E.,&Cagle,S.(2007).DoesParentReportofBehaviorDifferAcrossADOS-GClassifications:AnalysisofScoresfromtheCBCLandGARS.JournalofAutismandDevelopmentalDisorders,38(3),440-448.doi:10.1007/s10803-007-0407-z

WethanktheNationalInstituteofHealthforfundingthisstudy.GrantNIMH#1U19MH108206-01,PI:McPartland.Wegreatlyappreciateallofthefamilieswhoparticipatedinthisresearchacrossstudysites(YaleUniversity,UniversityofWashington,BostonChildren’sHospital,DukeUniversity).

References

Acknowledgements

ResultsAim1cont.

EmilyPompan1,ElizabethBaker1,PatriciaRenno,Ph.D. 1,SaraWebb,Ph.D.5,FrederickShic,Ph.D.5,AdamNaples,Ph.D.2,CatherineSugar,Ph.D.1,MichaelMurias,Ph.D. 4,RaphaelBernier,Ph.D. 5,GeraldineDawson,Ph.D. 4,CharlesNelson,Ph.D. 3,JamesMcPartland,Ph.D. 2,andShafaliJeste,M.D. 1

UniversityofCalifornia,LosAngeles1,YaleUniversity2,BostonChildren’sHospital3,DukeUniversity4,andtheUniversityofWashington5

ASCDomain GroupDifferences(t-test)

SocialSkills t(47)=6.166,p=<.001

ActivitiesofDailyLiving t(47)=9.425,p=<.001

FunctionalCommunication t(40.99)=11.453,p=<.001

Adaptability t(47)=5.684,p<.001

ResultsAim2bQuestionSample

A.GeneralizedAnxiety/Anxiety

B.Dysthymic/Depression C.Inattentive/AttentionProblems

D.Hyperactive-Impulsive/Hyperactivity

CASI-5/ECI-5

-Cannotgetdistressingthoughtsoutofhis/hermind.

-Talksaboutdeathorsuicide-Haslittleconfidence,feelsinferiortoothers,orisveryself-conscious.

-Iseasilydistractedbyotherthingsgoingon.-Doesnotpayattentiontoclosedetailsormakescarelessmistakes.

-Interruptsorintrudesonotherpeople’sactivities.-Is“onthego”oractsasif“drivenbyamotor.”

BASC-3 -Worriesaboutmakingmistakes.

-Says“Iwanttodie”or“IwishIweredead.”-Seemslonely.

-Iseasilydistracted.-Hastroubleconcentrating.

-Interruptsotherswhentheyarespeaking.-Isinconstantmotion.

BASC-3 AdaptiveSkillsComposite(ASC)DomainScoresinASDComparedtoTD

C. D.

r=.878,p=<.001

r=.431,p=.045 r=.798,p=<.001

EnrolledinABC-CT

IncludedinSample Gender Age(years)

M(SD)

BestIQ- FullScaleorRatioDifferentialAbilitiesScales-II

M(SD)

ADOS-II SeverityScoreM(SD)

ASD n=25 n=22 17male(77%),5female(23%) 8.03(2.28) 93.09(19.41) 14.82(4.54)

TD n=26 n=26 17male(65%),9female(35%) 6.58(1.98) 114.08(9.34) N/A

A. B.

ResultsAim1

BASC-3 Composite GroupDifferences(t-test)

Externalizing t(30.834)=-5.788,p=<.001

Internalizing t(47)=-3.775,p=<.001

BehavioralSymptomsIndex

(BSI)t(47)=-11.965,p=<.001

AdaptiveSkillsComposite(ASC) t(47)=10.558,p=<.001

BASC-3 CompositeScoresinASDandTDGroups

QuestionSample(VABS-II/BASC-3)

A. Communication/FunctionalCommunication

B.DailyLivingSkills/ActivitiesofDailyLiving

C.Socialization/SocialSkills

VABS-II

-Tellsabouteverydayexperiences(i.e.,routine)indetail-Identifiesallalphabetletters

-Understandswhattodoindangeroussituations-Doesatleasttwosimplehouseholdchores

-Avoidsbeingmanipulated,dominatedortakenadvantageofbyothers-Controlsangerorhurtfeelingswhengivenconstructivecriticism.

BASC-3

-Isclearwhentellingaboutpersonalexperiences-Saysalllettersofthealphabetwhenasked

-Actsinasafemanner-Organizeschoresandtaskswell

-Showsinterestinothers’ideas.-Beginsconversationsappropriately

QuestionSample(VABS-II/BASC-3)

D.CopingSkills Sub-Domain/Adaptability

VABS-II

-Handleschangesinroutinewithoutbecomingoverlydistressed-Recoversquicklyfromaminorsetbackordisappointment

BASC-3-Adjustswelltochangesinroutine.-Recoversquicklyfromasetback

TheBASC-3 includesanAdaptabilitydomainwithintheASCthatqualitativelyoverlapswiththeCopingSkillssub-domainwithinVABS-IISocializationdomain.Hypothesis:TheBASC-3 AdaptabilitydomainwillcorrelatewithVABS-II CopingSkillssub-domain.

r=.677,p=<.001r=.580,p=.004A. B.

C.

ResultsAim2a

20 30 40 50 60 70

6

8

10

12

14

16

BASC Adaptability t-score

VAB

S C

opin

g S

kills

v-s

cale

D.

r=.612,p=<.001

40 50 60 70 80 90

40

60

80

100

BASC Depression t-scores

CA

SI/E

CI D

ysth

ymic

t-sc

ores

r=.767,p=<.001

20 30 40 5040

60

80

100

BASC Social Skills t-scores

VAB

S S

ocia

lizat

ion

Sta

ndar

d S

core

s

r=.308,p=.152